Directorate General of Medical Education & Research...

Sr No. Case No. Case Title Concern Branch

and Branch Officer

of the cases.

Date of

Institution/

Receiving

Date in the

Department

Previous

date of

Hearing

Next date of

Hearing

Case Concern Remarks & Status Most Urgent/

Urgent.

1

CWP-15453

2015

Pawan singh @

pawan singh v/s

state of haryana and

ors.

Branch-SHKM, Govt.

Medical College,

Nalhar (Mewat).

Branch Officer- Smt.

Malti (MO) (A).

4/9/2015 28/04/2016 25/05/2016 As per the order of the Hon'ble High Court "The petitioner

submits that he was at sr. no. 1 in waiting list and one of the

candidate namely Rajinder Parshad not joined his duties

therefore he has a right to be considered on that post but still

his claim has been rejected. (Post of Technical Assistant /

Labortary Technician) in Mewat."

Reply filed by Director SHKM

GMC, Nalhar, Mewat.

Fixed for hearing on 25/5/2016

Most Urgent

2

CWP No.

6930 of 2016

Divya Savy V/s

Union of India and

ors.

Branch - Medical

Branch.

Branch Officer - Smt.

Jyoti Kaushal Mo (M)

20/4/2016 29/04/2016 25/5/2016 MBBS Admission (Gold Field Medical College). No draft of reply has been

supplied for vetting by the

Branch Officer.

Fixed for 25/5/2016.Most Urgent

3

CWP No.

6325 of 2016

Parvesh & ors. V/s

Union of India and

ors.

Branch - Medical

Branch.





Branch Officer.


4

CWP No.

6683 of 2016

Anjali Ahuja V/s

Union of India and

ors.

Branch - Medical

Branch.





Branch Officer.


5

CWP No.

5681 of 2016

Anmol Kaur Gill V/s

Union of India and

ors.

Branch - Medical

Branch.





Branch Officer.


Directorate General of Medical Education & Research Haryana, Case pending before the Hon'ble High Court / Supreme Court

6

CWP No.

8488 of 2016

Sumit Singh and ors.

V/s Union of India

and ors.

Branch - Medical

Branch.





Branch Officer.


7

CWP No.

6452 of 2016

Shuaib Muneer V/s

State of Haryana and

ors.

Branch - Dental

Branch


Sheeba (SDS)

12/4/2016 13/5/2016 26/5/2016 BDS Course in Swami Devi Dayal Dental College. No draft of reply has been


Branch Officer.


8

CWP No.

4635 of 2016

Dr. R.B Jain V/s Pt.

B.D. Sharma

University Health

Sciences, Rohtak &

ors.

Branch- Pt. B.D.

Sharma University

Health Sciences

Rohtak.


Jyoti Kaushal (MO)

(M).

31/03/2016 23/04/2016 27/05/2016 Service Matter No draft of reply has been


Branch Officer.

Fixed for 27/05/2016.Urgent

9

CWP No.

4151 of 2016

heard

alongwith

CWP No.

939 of 2012

Mahesh Kumar V/s

State of Haryana.

Branch- SHKM GMC,

Nalhar Mewat.


Malti (MO) (A).

15/03/2016 14/03/2016 27/05/2016 Order of the Hon'ble High Court is stated here:- "Petitioner is

seeking direction to the respondents to relieve him to enable

him to join SHKM, Mewat. In the mean time, Petitioner be

relieved subject to decision of the writ petition."

No draft of reply has been


Branch Officer.

Fixed for 27/5/2016. Urgent

10

CWP No.

1632 of 2014

Gaur Barahmin

Ayurvedic College &

Hospital

Barahmanwas V/s

Union of India &

Others

Branch-BAMS


Sheeba (SDS)

16/04/2014 12/2/2016 4/7/2016 BAMS Course (Session 2011-12) Letter sent to Advocate

General, Haryana. Government

of Haryana has been impleaded

as formal party and Union of

India and CCIM are the main

contesting party. This

Directorate is not party in this

case.

Fixed for hearing on

04/07/2016.

Urgent

11

CWP No.

10250 of

2015

Dr. Devinder Kumar

V/s Director Medical

Education and

Research, Haryana

and Ors.

Branch-BPS Govt.

Medical College,

Khanpur kalan,

Sonepat.

Branch Officer-Smt.

Malti (MO) (A).

12/8/2015 11/4/2016 11/7/2016 Phychiatric Social Worker. Government Service (Hry) in BPS

GMC Khanpur Kalan.

Reply filed by Director, BPS

GMC, Khanpur Kalan.

Fixed for 11/07/2016.

Urgent

12

CWP No.

3683 of 2014

Anil Kumar V/s State

of Haryana &

Others.

Branch-SHKM, Govt.

Medical College,

Nalhar (Mewat)

Branch Officer-

Smt. Malti (MO) (A).

25/03/2014 25/01/2016 11/7/2016 Post of Nursing Sister in SHKM GMC, Nalhar. He has not been

allowed to join on the post of Nursing Sister on the ground

that he is not medically fit as he is color blind.

Reply filed by Director SHKM

GMC, Nalhar.


11/07/2016. Urgent

13

CWP No.

4716 of 2015

Bibhava

Vikramaditya & ors.

V/s Financial

Commissioner and

ors.

Branch-BPS Govt.

Medical College,

Khanpur kalan,

Sonepat.


Malti (MO) (A).

5/2/2016 14/1/2016 11/7/2016 Order of the Hon'ble High Court is reproduced here:- "The

Petitioners contends that as per the appointment letter (P-2)

petitioner No. 1 was granted the pay scale along with NPA.

However, vide impugned order dated 05.01.2015, NPA was

withdrawn from the pay structure by making reference to

instruction dated 20.02.2009 (P-13) but as per these

instructions, the doctors working in various department of

the State are entitled for grant of NPA at the uniform rate of

25% of the basic pay w.e.f. 01.01.2006 i.e. revisions of pay

scales and therefore, the petitioners who are also working

under the Health and Medical Education Department of this

State, are fully entitled for the NPA."



Branch Officer.

Fixed for 11/07/2016.

Urgent

14

CWP No.

25089 of

2014

Shri Ram Krishan

Paramhans Shiksha

Parishad Vs. State of

Haryana and others

Branch-Nursing

Branch


Savita Mandhar

13/2/2015 29/04/2016 11/7/2016 Seeking NOC to run the courses of ANM & GNM training

schools (Admission and Examination) without having

permission from INC, and HNRC.

Reply filed.

Fixed for 11/7/2016.

Most Urgent

15

CWP No.

4142 of 2015

Monika Kumari and

ors Vs. State of

Haryana and ors.

Branch-BPS Govt.

Medical College,

Khanpur kalan,

Sonepat.

Branch Officer-Smt.

Malti (MO) (A).

19/3/2015 25/1/2016 12/7/2016 Post of Staff Nurse on Contract basis in BPS GMC, Khanpur

Kalan, Sonepat.

Reply filed by Director BPS

GMC, Khanpur Kalan.

Fixed for argument on

12/07/2016. Urgent

16

CWP No.

6462 of 2015

Rajesh Kumar and

ors. Vs State of

Haryana and ors

Branch-BPS Govt.

Medical College,

Khanpur kalan,

Sonepat.


Malti (MO) (A).

22/4/2015 16/02/2016 12/7/2016 Post of Lab Technician on contract basis in BPS GMC, Khanpur

Kalan, Sonepat

Reply filed by Director BPS

GMC, Khanpur Kalan.


12/07/2016 Urgent

17

CM - 13600

of 2015 in

CWP-20407-

2015

Kapisthal Charitable

Soceity & Others V/s

State of Haryana &

others.

Branch-Nursing

Branch


Savita Mandhar

8/3/2016 15/7/2016 Order of the Hon'ble High Court is reproduced here :-

"Petitioner seeks permission to be part of the counselling for

admission for ANM & GNM courses for the petitioner

institute for the acadamic session 2015-16.

Though there might be a dispute inter se the members of the

Society, but the petitioner institute cannot be put to a lose

on account of the scuffle which is inter se the members. It is

also pertinent to mention that the representations of the

petitioner annexure P-9 and P-10 have not been decided by

the respondent no. 1 and have been refered for legal advice

to Advocate General Office and matter is still pending for

consideration.

Accordingly, the petitioner institute is allowed to admit

students provisionaly for the acadamic sesssion 2015-16 for

ANM and GNM courses. It is, however, made clear that this

order is purely provisional and does not create any right to

the petitioner and shall be subject to final outcome of the

writ petition. The respondent will include the name of the

petitioner institute for admission on the website with a note

regarding pendency of the litigation and with regard to

interim order passed by this Court today on 29.09.2015."

Affidavit filed.

Fixed for 15/7/2016

Most Urgent

18

CWP

No.6183 of

2014

Smt. Kamla Devi V/s

State of Haryana

Branch - Rohtak


Malti MO (A)



Branch Officer.

Fixed for 18/07/2016Urgent

19

CWP No.

5459 of

2016.

Joginder Singh V/s


anr.

Branch - PGIMS,

Rohtak


Malti (MO) (A)

8/4/2016 17/5/2016 21/7/2016 Order of the Hon'ble High Court is reproduced here:-

"Learned counsel for the petitioner is directed to produce the

applicable service rules and apprise the Court with regard to

the fact so as to how many sanctioned posts of Analytical

Psychologists are there out of which one post is to be filled

up through the impugned advertisement.

Adjourned to 02.05.2016"



Branch Officer.


20

CWP No.

2993 of 2016

Dr. Naresh Kumar

V/s State of

Haryana.

Branch- SHKM,

Mewat.


Malti (MO) (A).

15/03/2016 15/2/2016 21/07/2016 Order of the Hon'ble High Court is reproduced here:- "In this

case Counsel of the petitioner contends that after rendering

four years service of Assistant Professor, the petitioner was

re-designated as Associate Professor w.e.f. 23.01.2014, vide

order dated 28.07.2014/08.08.2014 (Annexure P-3). The said

order has been withdrawn by the respondent department

vide order dated 12.01.2016/01.02.2016 (Annexure P-4)

without issuing any show cause notice to the petitioner. Ld.

Counsel for petitioner further contends that as per Govt.

Notification dated 25.01.2007, the petitioner has requisite

experience of four years of service as Assistant Professor and

the impugned order (Annexure P-4) is liable to be quashed. In

the mean time, the operation of impugned order (Annexure P-

4) shall remain stayed."



Branch Officer.

Fixed for 21/07/2016

Most Urgent

21

CWP No.

2954 of 2016

Dr. Sibadatta Dass

V/s State of

Haryana.

Branch- SHKM,

Mewat.


Malti (MO) (A).

15/02/2016 21/07/2016

As above.



Branch Officer.

Fixed for 21/07/2016Most Urgent

22

CWP No.

24399 of

2015

Gaur Barahmin

Vidya Parcharini

Sabha (Regd) V/s

Union of India &

Others

Branch-Ayurvedic

Branch


Sheeba (SDS).

5/1/2016 17/3/2016 22/7/2016 Seeking permission to admit students upto 60 seats for the

session 2015-16



Branch Officer.

Fixed for 22/7/2016Most Urgent

23

CRM-M-

19820-2011

Rajpal @ Labh Singh

& ANR. V/S State of

Haryana

Branch-Medical

Branch.


Jyoti Kaushal (MO)

(M).

23/04/2016 23/07/2016 uploading MLR/PMR on the web based portal Affidavit filed by this office on

the behalf of all Haryana Govt.

Medical College.

Fixed for hearing on 23/07/2016 Most Urgent

24

CWP No.

26148 of

2014

Sarita Kumari and

anothers Vs. State of

Haryana and others

Branch-BPS Govt.

Medical College,

Khanpur kalan,

Sonepat.


Malti (MO) (A).

16/02/2016 26/07/2016 Order of the Hon'ble High Court is reproduced here:- "Ld.

Counsel for the petitioners contents that no criteria for

selection of Staff Nurse was ever disclosed either in the

adverstisement or on the website. It was disclosed

subsequently at the time of appointment only. He further

contents that higher marks were awarded in interview to the

candidates who had secured lesser marks in the written test.

He further contents that more marks were alloted for the

interview then those permissible as per the decision of the

Hon'ble Supreme Court in Ashok Kumar Yadav and ors. V/s

State of Haryana and ors, AIR 1987 Supreme Court, 454 (1). "



Branch Officer.

Director, BPS, Khanpur Kalan,

Sonepat is the main contesting

party and this department has

been impleaded as formal party.

Fixed for 26/07/2016.

Urgent

25

CWP No.

1779 of 2015

Court on its Own

Motion Vs. Union of

India and others

Branch-PGIMS Rohtak

Branch Officer-Smt.

Jyoti Kaushal (MO)

(M).

22/5/2015 28/04/2016 28/07/2016 Fungal infections rampant in intensive care units (ICU's) Affidavit has been filed by this

office. Union of India

(Respontent No. 1), Medical

Council of India (Respontent No.

2), Department of Health and

Family Welfare, Government of

Punjab (Respontent No. 3),

PGIMER, Chandigarh

(Respontent No. 4 and 5) and

PGIMER, Rohtak (Respontent

No. 6).


28/07/2016.

Urgent

26

CWP No.

6979 of 2014

Jai Kumar and

others Vs. State of

Haryana and others

Branch-Kalpana

Chawla Medical

College, Karnal

Branch Officer-

Smt. Malti (MO) (A).

23/05/2014 8/3/2016 4/8/2016 Order of the Hon'ble High Court is reproduced here:-"Counsel

for the petitioner contends that initially the position, as

stated in the impugned order, would be correct but on

complition of 10 years of service, the petitioners are also

getting a grade pay of Rs. 32,00 which is the same as that of

lab technician and therefore, the said ground of rejection of

the claim of the petitioner that they are getting a lower grade

pay than the cost, for which they have applied is not

sustainable.

The selection, in persuance to the advertisement dated

06/01/2013 (Annexure P-1) on the post of lab technician shall

be subject to the decision of the writ petition."

An intimation letter has been

sent to Director Kalpana Chawla

Govt. Medical College to file a

joint reply on behalf of

Respondent No. 1 (State of

Haryana), Respondent No. 2 (

DGMER) and send same copy of

reply to this office.

Fixed for hearing on 4/08/2016.

Urgent

27

CWP No.

5737 of 2016

Jagbir Singh and ors.

V/s District and

Sessions Judge,

Panchkula and anr.

Branch -

Branch Officer -



Branch Officer.


28

CWP No.

9576 of 2015

Ravinder Kumar V/s

State of Haryana

Branch-SHKM, Govt.

Medical College,

Nalhar (Mewat)


Malti (MO) (A).

14/03/2016 9/8/2016 petitioner contends that as per the written test, the

petitioner was found to be excellent but yet after interview

conducted after 11 months of the written test, the petitioner

was not selected, and his name was figuring at sr. no. 4 in the

waiting list. As per annexure P-3, the information provided

by the respondents, it reveals that no reason, much less,

criteria has been given as to how much marks have been

allocated in the interview. (Post of Driver) in Mewat.

Affidavit filed.


09/08/2016.

Urgent

29

CWP No.

26413 of

2015

connected

with 11073

of 2015 and

17497 of

2015

Meeta Rani & ors.

V/s State of Haryana

& ors.

Branch - Admin.


Malti MO (A)

7/1/2016 11/8/2016 Service Matter No draft of reply has been


Branch Officer.

Fixed for 11/8/2016

Urgent

30

CWP No.

14977 of

2013

Rakesh Kumar Goyal

V/s State of

Haryana.

Branch- PT. B.D.

Sharma UHS, Rohtak.


Malti (MO) (A).

15/03/2016 21/04/2016 23/08/2016 As per the order of the Hon'ble High Court "To release the

scales to the petitioners as prescribed by AICTE w.e.f.

01.01.2006 and as per decision of the Executive Council of

the respondent university vide decision dated 08.03.2011 (P-

4) and all arears be released with market rate interest."



Branch Officer.

Govt. of Haryana MER

(respondent No. 1)

Fixed for 23/08/2016.

Most Urgent

31

CWP No.

3043 of 2016

Baljeet Singh V/s


ors.

Branch - Pt B.D.

Sharma UHS, Rohtak.


Malti (MO) (A).

23/04/2016 27/08/2016 Order dt. 16/3/2016 of the Hon'ble High Court is reproduced

here:- "In the

mean time, the petitioner shall not be evicted from the

premises alloted to him by the PGIMS, Rohtak."



Branch Officer.


32

CWP No.

12235 of

2014

Director Medical

Education &

Research Haryana,

Vs. Presiding Officer

Labour Court (Mohit

Mishra)

Branch-Admn. Branch

(DMER)


Malti (MO) (A).

30/06/2014 25/04/2016 29/08/2016 As per the order of the Hon'ble High Court:-

"There was a service agreement inter se the petitioner

department and respondent workman whereby, the

engagement was for the period not exceeding 6 months.

However, the workman has worked from 16/08/2010 to

13/09/2012 and the engagement was extended. It is

submitted that in such circumstances, the exception provided

under section 2 (oo) (bb) of the industrial dispute 1947 would

come into play and therefore there would be no retrachment

and voilation of section 25F of the act.

In the mean time, operation of the award shall remain

stayed."

CWP filed.


29/08/2016.

Urgent

33

CWP No.

18304 of

2014

DMER v/s POLC

(Munish Kumar)

Branch-Admn.

(DMER)


Malti (MO) (A).

5/8/2014 10/12/2015 29/08/2016 As per the order of the Hon'ble High Court:-

"The respondent workman was initially appointed on

contract basis as a peon for a period of 6 months or till the

joining of a person on regular basis vide appointment letter

appended with the written statement. The service agreement

was also entered into and thereafter he was relieved on

06/03/2012 w.e.f. 04/03/2012 after noticing that his work

and conduct was not satisfactory. It is submitted that the

Labour Court was not justified in directing reinstatement of

the workman along with back wages.

It is submitted that rather the case would be covered under

the observations made by the Apex Court in Muncipal

Council, samrala V/s rajkumar Supreme Court Case it was the

case of contractual employment and section 2 (oo)(bb) of the

Industrial dispute Act 1947 would come into play. In the

mean time operation of the impugned award shall remain

stayed."

CWP Filed.

Fixed for hearing on 29/8/2016.

Urgent

34

CWP No.

2822 of 2016

Omveer and ors. V/s

State of Haryana &

ors.

Branch-SHKM GMC,

Nalhar, Mewat.


Malti (MO) (A).

14/03/2016 23/04/2016 30/08/2016 Contractual employees through outsourcing agency. No draft of reply has been


Branch Officer.

Fixed for 30/08/2016. Most Urgent

35

CWP No.

10678 of

2015

Sh. Mohammad Arif

Khan Vs. State of

Haryana and Others

Branch-SHKM, Govt.

Medical College,

Nalhar (Mewat)

BranchOfficer- Smt.

Malti (MO) (A).

25/5/2015 1/3/2016 5/9/2016 Order of the Hon'ble High Court is reproduced here:-

"Petitioner submits that the advertisement for filling up four

vacancies out of six vacancies for General Category was

published in pursuance to the process of selection and he

was kept at sr. no. 1 in the waiting list. Yet he has not been

issued appointment letter and later on, acquired that one

post out of the four posts has been reserved for economically

backward class."

Reply is yet to be filed by the

Director SHKM GMC Nalhar,

Mewat.

Fixed for 5/09/2016Urgent

36

CWP No.

10140 of

2015 to be

heard

alongwith

223 of 2015

Dayanand Sheokand

Vs. State of Haryana

and another

Branch -BPS Govt.

Medical College,

Khanpur kalan,

Sonepat.


Malti (MO) (A).

24/12/2015 6/9/2016 Post of Administrative Officer on contract basis in BPS GMC,

Khanpur Kalana, Sonepat.



Branch Officer.


37

CWP No. 522

of 2015 to be

heard along

with CWP

No. 223 of

2015 titled as

"Charanjeet

Singh Vs.

State of

Haryana and

others"

Satish Kumar Vs.


another

Branch-BPS Govt.

Medical College,

Khanpur kalan,

Sonepat.

Branch Officer-Smt.

Malti (MO) (A).

10/3/2015 6/10/2015 6/9/2016 Govt. Service, Haryana (post of accountant on contract basis)

in BPS Kanpur Kalan College.



Branch Officer.

Fixed for 6/9/2016.

Urgent

38

CWP-

7845/2015

heard along

with CWP

No. 223 of

2015.

Ram Mehar Attri

and ANR V/S State of

Haryana and Anr.

Branch-BPS Govt.

Medical College,

Khanpur kalan,

Sonepat.


Malti (MO) (A).



Branch Officer.


39

CWP No.

9269/2013

Dr. Shamsher Singh

Lohchab V/s State of

Haryana & Others

Branch-PGIMS,

Rohtak


Malti (MO) (A).

15/05/2013 29/4/2016 14/9/2016 Cardiac Anesthesia Services & Surgical Facilities to the

Department of Cardiac Surgery in LSL super Specility Center,

PGIMS Rohtak

Reply filed. Pt. BD Sharma UHS,

Rohtak is the main contesting

party.


14/09/2016.

Urgent

40

CWP No.

23544 of

2014

Neeraj Kumar Vs.

State of Haryana &

Ors.

Branch-BPS Govt.

Medical College,

Khanpur kalan,

Sonepat.

Branch Officer-Smt.

Malti (MO) (A).

30/12/2014 12/2/2016 23/9/2016 Govt. Service (Haryana) in BPS, Govt. Medical College

Khanpur Kalan, Sonepat

Letter sent to BPS,Khanpur

Kalan,Sonepat for filing reply

on behalf of respondent no. 1

(ACS,MER) and Responent No. 2

(DGMER).


23/09/2016.

Urgent

41

CM No.

16540 of

2015 in CWP

No. 21243 of

2015

Adesh Welfare

Society (Regd.) V/s

State of Haryana &

Ors.

Branch-Medical

Branch


Jyoti Kaushal (MO)

(M).

10/5/2016 18/5/2016 Seeking NOC to run the Medical College, Kurukshetra.

In this case an amended writ petition has been filed by the

petitioner.

Order Reserved on 18/5/2016

by the Hon'ble High Court.

Affidavit and reply has been

filed.

Fixed for 18/05/2016.

Most Urgent

Date post:	02-May-2018
Category:	Documents
Upload:	trinhhanh
View:	217 times
Download:	2 times

Directorate General of Medical Education & Research...

Documents