of 30
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
1/30
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
2/30
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Project DescriptionNeighborhood Context
1. MASTER PLAN
2. PLAZA
3. MASSING
4. CHARACTER STRUCTURE
5. FACADES
6. LANDSCAPING
7. SOLIDWASTE RECYCLABLE MATERIALSSTORAGE ANDACCESS
8. DESIGN DEPARTURE REQUESTS
9. DESIGN REVIEW GUIDELINESANDRESPONSES
11th AND E PIKE
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
3/30
NC3P-65
PIKE/PINE URBANCENTER VILLAGE
PIKE/PINE CONSERVATION CORE
PIKE/PINE CONSERVATION OVERLAY
H
A
I B
C
D
E
F J
G
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc4 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
Pacic SupplyCo.to Agneslotsalong 12thAvenue.All
ourbuildingsare owned by Dunn &Hobbesand con-nect to one mid-block courtyard.
NEIGHBORHOOD CONTEXT
The existing site orthe proposed project remains asan unriendly missing toothin the abric o the block,and on anavenue that hasbee n identied asan important pede strian connection and a Green Street in the neighborhood plan.
AgnesLots and 1111 East Pike along southside o
Pike between 11thAvenue and 12thAvenue
The Trace Lotsat the cornero 12th and Madison withone storyFerraribuilding in oreground
BakerLinen building on cornero 11thand East Pike
KEY
A - Project Site:1424 11thAvenueB - AgnesLotsC- Piston &Ring Building
D- Manhattan BuildingE - Pacic SupplyCo.
PROJECT SITE
F - Ferrari
G- Union ArtsCoopH- BakerLinenI - 1111 East Pike
J - Trace Lots
5
5
CONTEXT
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
4/30
CHARACTER BUILDINGSTRUCTUREACCESS POINTS & PATHWAYSURBANSHELTER PROPERTIESTAX LOTPEDESTRIANENTRYCAR ENTRY
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc6 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
The Mews
1424 11th Avenue
The Mews is envisioned asan open airconnectorbetween 11th Avenue and theCourtyard .Fronted byretail and restaurantstoreronts,it is intended to eel like aclassic pedestrian alley,a respite romthebusystreets o Capitol Hill. Itssecondaryunction isto allow space orlight and airtoneighboring buildings.In a previousversiono the MasterPlan,the Chophouse buildingwasto be demolished in orderto constructthe Mews. In the current MasterPlan, theChophouse isretained,and the Mewsliveswithin itseroded structural rame. Secondoor joists are re-purposed into a trellis,and the concrete rame islet asa ruin thatormstable tops,planters, lighting mounts,etc.This matches the eroded structuralrame at the existing Piston &Ring plaza.Fortunately,the bay spacing o the oldbuilding aligns perectlywith the Mewswidth.
The current proposal represents the lastmajorpiece o the masterplan. It includesretail and restaurant usesat street level,withocesand 3-4 apartmentsabove. Anearlierversion o the MasterPlan called orabout 60apartmentsabove, but given therecent highlevel o apartment constructionin the neighborhood,oceswere includedin orderto maintain a balance o usesandday& night activityor Pike/Pine.
MASTERPLAN
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
5/30
CHARACTER BUILDINGSTRUCTUREACCESS POINTS & PATHWAYSURBANSHELTER PROPERTIESTAX LOTPEDESTRIANENTRYCAR ENTRY
PettiRosso
ELEVATOR
CupcakeRoyale
BoomNoodle
Plum
LaSpiga
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc8 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
The mid-block courtyard can be accessed
rom 7 diferent buildings, including twobuildingsowned by others. The roughlydozen pathsto reachthe courtyard are
varied,and multi-leveled,or example,onecould walk throughCupcake Royale romE.Pike,out the back dooro the Pacic Supply
hardware store,or take the main pathalong the Mewswhich connectsto 12thAvenue via a corridorand stairwaythrough
the Piston & Ring Building. ADA accessrom11thto12thAvenue isprovided bytheelevatorsin the AgnesLots building.
The courtyard and Mews, along with acontiguous easement just to the north,serve asthe secondaryexiting systemor all
seven buildings.
Automobile and service entrances or
AgnesLots, Piston &Ring, Manhattan,andthe current project have been consolidatedto a single 18wide curb cub on 11thAvenue.
At the EarlyDesign Guidance meeting,this
question was posed,and the answerroma building planning standpoint has to dowiththe location o ourcore. Placing the
new structural/staircore within the retainedcharacterstructure on the northh al o thesite did not make sense because it impacted
the characterstructure and the open-nessothe nearbymews.Thisleavesthe southhalo the site,and the best place on the south
side isalong the southpartywall, in ordertoallow ora unctional garage layout. Froman urban design standpoint, locating themicro-retail space to the southo the garage
helps extend the retail rontage urthersouthon 11thAvenue,in orderto lessen thegap ormed by the vacant lot next door,
and connect withuture development thatmight occuron that lot in the uture.
CIRCULATION
CURB CUT & TRAFFIC
WHY CENTER CURB CUT?
MASTERPLAN
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
6/30
Plaza (public/private):a. Designand integratethe courtyardplaza levels toaddress privacy issues orexistingand proposedcommercial andresidential uses whilereinorcingopportu-nities orlight,air andventilation(B-5,C-3, D-1,&E-2).
EARLY DESIGN GUIDANCE
DOUBLE
HEIGHT
SPACE
DOUBLE
HEIGHT
SPACE
GATELOCATIONCLOSES OVERNIGHT
This page shows the proposed layout o the mid-block courtyardand mews.
The mews are ramed by the eroded structural rame o the Chop-house building, highlighted in yellow. At the north ace o the mews,connections to Cupcake Royale and Petti Rosso restaurant arehighlighted. The south ace o the mews is aced with retail store-ronts.
Double height spaces occupy the our corners o the building, andopen onto the mews, the courtyard, and 11th Avenue. The court-yard itsel is ringed by shops, oces, restaurants, and the main entryto 1124 buidling.
The mews and courtyard will be closed overnight with a steel andwood gate with card key access. No trash/recycle/compost will be
stored or transported through the mews/courtyard.
PLAZA
PLAZA
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
7/30
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc12 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
VIEW AT MEWS LOOKING EAST TOWARDS PISTON & RING BUILDING
The Mews is dened by the eroded structural rame o the Chop-house building: existing roo joists orm a trellis above, supportedby the existing concrete rame on the north.
The south wall is comprised o transparent storeront combinedwith panels made o wood salvaged rom the Chophouse.
THE MEWS
Entry gate to the Mews - using steel at bars and wire mesh withreclaimed wood rom the Chophouse
PLAZA
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
8/30
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc14 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
LIGHTING DESIGN
PROJECT SITE
FA
FD
FC
FD
FD FDEXISTING FATOREMAIN
FA FA FA
FA
FBFBFBFBFB
LIGHTING
The lighting plan uses jelly jar xtures mountedto existing concrete character structure walls, withmodern canopy downlights at new structure entries.
Catenary lights,one perbay,are installed inmews,similarto aclassic alley setting.
EXISTING FATOREMAIN
PLAZA
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
9/30
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc16 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
At EDG,the board directed the architect topursue alternative #,which reducesmass rom the street,sets back rom adjacent buildingsto the north,and createsan openair pedestrianwalkway connecting thAvenue withthemidblock courtyard,as wasenvisioned inthe masterplan.
EARLY DESIGN GUIDANCE
Smallscale developmentthis unique developmentsite isonly 7 wide,6,000s ootprint
Setbacksat nd foor,thfoor and 5thfoor toreducemass
thfoor setback alignswithscale o adjacent BakerLinenBuilding
Residentialfooris set back urtherrom street
Roo angled downward romsouthto northto respectneighboring building
Decksare included at all westacing setbacks
Building isset back 0 rom northproperty line,orming a to5 mewsbetween buildings
EDG PREFERRED OPTION - ALTERNATIVE #3
MASSING
BaPikePine Neighborhood Scale and Proportion
BaPikePine Neighborhood Scale and Proportion
Bb PikePine Neighborhood Scale and Proportionrelate to exist
Bc PikePine Neigborhood Scale and Proportionupper story ht.
A5Respect oradjacent sites
AHuman Activity
A5Respect oradjacent sites,A HumanActivity
Massing:a.(Preerred)Alternative3 visually reduces themassing rom a street perspectivewhilealsoemphasizing thepedestriancirculationpathway interiortothe devel-opment.Thedesign responds well tothe adjacent (north)structures mass.TheBoarddirectedthearchitect todevelopthe preerredoptionorthe recommen-dationmeetingwith theollowingguidance(B-1).
MASSING
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
10/30
Character Structures:a. TheBoardrequestedclaricationon howthedevelopment standards arebeingmet toachieveadditional height ormaintaining theCharacter Structure. TheBoarddoes not want toset a precedent o allowinga designwithout properdocu-mentationo presentationo theCharacterStructureper SMC23.041.
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc18 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
PRESERVATION OF CHARACTER STRUCTURE
PRESERVATION OF CHARACTER STRUCTURE
B Integrationo CharacterStructuresin New Development
BaDevelop aDesignConcept
Be B7c AlignFeatures
Bd Emphasize the Streetscape
Bd Emphasize the Streetscape
Bd Emphasize the Streetscape,Human Activity
B AnchorNew Structure to Streetscape
Bb Donot overpowerthe characterstructure
Bb Donot overpowerthe characterstructure
A5Respect oradjacent sites,AHuman Activity
Bc Expressrelationship o new toold
Bc Expressrelationship o new toold
B7aMaintain Architecturalintegrity o characterstructure
B7aMaintain Architecturalintegrity o characterstructure
B7aMaintain Architecturalintegrity o characterstructure
CharacterStructure
Cleardierentiationo new vs.historic architecture
Floorheights o new structure alignwithexisting
Remove T,restore existing upperwindows
Gateway entry tomewsalignswith minorbay oexisting building
New operable windowsadded at retail rontage
Overhead canopy provided at new portiono building
New structure isset back above characterstructure
Chop House isopened up toMews,with twostoryexpressed volume spacesat Eand W ends
Building isset back 0 romnorthproperty line,orming a to5 mewsbetween buildings
Flooring materialschangesrom concrete new towood old
Salvaged wood rom demolished portionso existingbuilding isused asnish at mews
Existing concrete rame is eroded and planted withlandscape along mews
Wood columns,cardecking,and concrete rame ismaintained ulllengtho existing building
New structure and seismic bracing iswoven throughexisting structure
EARLY DESIGN GUIDANCE
Early drawingsby architect E.R.Sonnichsenaround 90indicate that the building wasoriginally intended asaourstory structure. This givesus the opportunity tomaintainthe existing roo structure and use it asthe second foor inthe new project.
An image o the building rom the 9housing anAutoPartsstore. The storehad already beensignicantly altered the originalplan.The center medallipainted on. Note the trim highlightsthe projecting signat the location o
CH
ARACTERSTRUCTURE
E
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
11/30
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc20 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
CHOPHOUSE: EXISTING SECTION & FLOOR FRAMING P LANS
DEMO
Crosssection throughthe existing building showing concrete rame,clay tile inll, and heavy timberstructure. CROSSSECTION
1ST FLOOR FRAMIING
2NDFLOOR FRAMIING
ROOF FRAMIING
Existing raming planso the Chophouse building,with portionsto be demolishedshaded. Note that heavy timberraming is tobe salvaged and reused in the newproject,most notably onexteriorwallsuraces inside the Mews.
CHARACTERSTRUCTURE
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
12/30
StreetLevelFaade:a.TheBoardwouldliketo seeclaricationonthe locationandreadability o pe-destrianentries;mews, entry intobuildingand parkingaccess alongstreet-levelstreet acingaade(A-4,C-3,& D-1).
b.Detaileddocumentationresolvingpedestriancirculationandvehicularaccess isrequiredat thenext Boardmeeting. Pedestrianaccess to retail andlobby shouldbe emphasizedwhile simultaneously minimizingvehicular access (C-3,C-4, &D-11).
c.Theopening tothemews is a gateway throughthedevelopment siteandshouldbedesigned tocreate a saedeensible spaceor pedestrians accessing11th and12thavenues throughthemid-block connection(B-5,D-1, &D-7).
Interior LotFaade:a.Providemore detail onlocationanddesign o theadjacent residential structuretothe north. Clariy upperlevel setbacks depths,locationo roo topdecks o theabuttingstructures tothe north(A-5,B-2).
b.Designnorthaade tomaximizeprivacy orexistingresidents by providingsu-cient setback andlocatingwindows tominimizedirect lineo site betweenexist-ingandproposed residential units (A-5).
c.Use materials tocreatea dynamicaadetreatment, 3-D element i possible,tominimize theappearanceo a blank wall acinganadjacent suraceparkinglot(A-5,D-2).
N
PANORAMA OF 11TH AVE WITH PROPOSED PROJECT
E.PIKE UNIO
Baker Linen Building Chophouse Union Arts CoopFuture Development
1424 11th Avenueyear | 2014
designer | SKLarchitects& GBAmixed-use
EARLY DESIGN GUIDANCE
FACADES
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
13/30
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc24 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
WEST ELEVATION
WESTFACADE
The west aade isbrokendowninto ourdistinct zones:
. CharacterStructure. See previoussectionoradescriptiono the Character Structure aade.
. Street Face. The new street ace o the building isaced with SwissPearl integrally colored panels,andis intended toread asa solid block,scaled tomatchthe adjacent building tothe north. A large glazedopening, vertically proportioned,is the centerpiece.At the street level,asimple steelcanopy overhangsthesidewalk,withdownlights. The garage dooris asimple,painted,rollup door,in characterwith the straightorward,industrial history o the neighborhood,and tobeconsistent withother service doorson the block innewand existing buildings E.Pike and the BakerLinenBuilding,pictured below.A glazed microretailstore
ront sits at the southend o the street ront,underneaththe canopy.. Backdrop 5 setback:The backdrop to the Street
Face and the Characterstructure is a simple griddedmetalpanel aade,with large sliding doorsat thfoordeck.
. Residential5th Floor:The residentialace is set backanother8 to create decksand reduce building mass.The roo o the residential units is sloped downromsouthtonorthto allow betterdaylight toneighboringroo decks.
NORTHFACADE
The northaade hasa clearseparation at the roo line othe CharacterStructure. Below this line,a combinationostoreront and reclaimed wood siding acesontothe Mews.Above thisline, the aade isorganized intoa regularcompositiono aluminum clad wood windows and painted panels. The window spacing ispurposely set inan opposingpatternto the neighboring E. Pike building,in ordertomaintainbetter privacy betweenthe buildingssee diagramonpage 9.
SEECHARACTERSTRUCTURESECTION
FOR DETAILS
KEYPLAN
N
FACADES
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
14/30
KEYPLAN
N
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc26 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
EAST ELEVATION
EASTFAADE
The east aade isintended asa refectiono the west,withapaneled backdrop accentuated by aprojecting metalgridbay window.Double height storeront windowswithgaragedoorsand sliding doorsacesonto the courtyard.
SOUTHFAADE
The southaade is a property line wall that isgivenDrelie by the insertiono verticalsteel channelsrelated tothe roo scape,along witha recessed slot window at the thfoorcoee bar. Decksat the residentiallevel are set backtoallow southlight to the unitsand tobreak up the massothe southaade. SwissPearlintegrally colored panelsareused at the returnleg o the street ront mass,then paintedpanelsrom there eastward.
FACADES
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
15/30
POTENTIAL ARTWORK AT SOUTH FACADE - NOT CURRENTLY FUNDED
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc28 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
The artwork shown here isnot currently unded inthe project budget.It is includedhere ordesignreview to conrm acceptability incase unding becomesavailable.Seeprevioussheet orproposed southacade.
FACADES
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
16/30
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc30 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
ALUMINUM-CLAD WOOD WINDOWS
SWISS PEARL CARATSL SAPPHIREINTEGRALLY COLORED SIDING
CLAY TILEINFILL
PRE-CASTCONCRETEPAVERS
CONCRETEFRAME
CHARACTERSTRUCTURE
PAINTCOLORS
METAL WALL PANELSALUMINUM/FIBERGLASS STOREFRONTRECLAIMED WOOD SIDING
HARDI
TRIM
ACCENT
METAL
FACADES
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
17/30
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc32 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
GROUND LE
LARGETREE24 MIN.SOILDEPTH
TRELLIS FROM EXISTINGROOF JOISTS
LARGETREE24 MIN.SOIL DEPTH
HANGING PLANTERSAND VEGETATED WALL
ON EXISTING CON-CRETESTRUCTURE
LANDSCAPING
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
18/30
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc34 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
SolidWaste Recyclable MaterialsStorage andAccessa.At theRecommendationmeetingthe Boardwouldlike tothe applicant presentmaterials todemonstratehow thesolid wastematerials will bemanaged;loca-tiono storage,pick-updays,etc. orthe proposeddevelopment andorthe entiredevelopment site(D-6).
BASEMENT LEVEL (SEE FULL PLAN IN APPENDIX)
LEVEL 1
EARLY DESIGN GUIDANCE
SOLID WASTE
Solid waste orocesand residenceso the new project,Agnes Lots,and thePiston and Ring Building willbe consolidated ina trash room located inthegarage. Trash,recycle,and compost willthen be carted up the ramp in yardcontainersandortotes toa curb pickup areaat the top o the ramp,just insidethe garage door. Pick up scheduleswillbe arranged toalternate daily betweentrashand recycle.
Restaurant waste rom the new project willbe gathered intotes ina smallroomonthe rst foor,thenpicked up rom thAvenue viathe corridorat the southwest cornero the building.
Restaurant waste orthe existing restaurantson thAvenue and Pike StreetsBoom Noodle,Plum,La Spiga,and Manhattan willcontinue tobe picked upcurbside at thAvenue.
Nowaste rom Dunnand Hobbes projectswillbe stored orcarted throughtheMews,althoughthe existing trashcans located inthe plazawillremain tomanage waste generated directly by public use o the plaza.
WASTE
STORAGEANDACCESS
S
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
19/30
SMC 23.73.014B2a/cRETENTION OF FACADE ANDFLOOR LEV-EL OF CHARACTER STRUCTURE
STANDARD
B. Height exception orlotsthat include a characterstructure. In zoneswitha 65-oot mapped height limit,or with a 40-oot mapped height limit withprovisionsallowing or additional height up to 65 eet according to subsec-
tion 23.47A.012.A,the Directormay permit the height o a structure to ex-ceed the height limit o the zone by10 eet,subject to the ollowing:1. The lot includesa characterstructure.
2. I a project incorporates a character structure on the lot,the projectmeets the ollowing conditions:
2a. All street-acing acadeso the character structure shall be re
tained;2c. The original oor-to-ceiling height o the ground storyshall bemaintained.
DEPARTURE
Per2a, ourproposal is to maintain the street-acing acade o the characterstructure.However,th e norththird will not have interioroor space behind it.Instead,it will serve asa gatewayto the mews.
Per2c, the original oorto ceiling height o the ground storywill be main-tained, except that the second oor will be removed at the east and westends o the building to create double height spacesacing 4thAvenue and
the courtyard.
WHYTHIS DEPARTURE BETTER MEETSTHE INTENT OF THEDESIGN GUIDELINES
(2a)Allowing the open-airmew sto overlap withthe north third o the char-
acters tructure creates an outdoormid-block connection to the plaza.T hisconnection,occuring within the eroded structural rame o the building,willbe a unique and attractive pedestrian amenityor the Pike/Pine neighbor-
hood.
(2c) Removal o portionso the existing second oorat the east and west
endso the character structure will result in grand double height spacesac-ing 11thAvenue and the Mid-Block courtyard.What was beore a somewhatnon-descript wood rame structure now takes on the unique urban character-
isticsaforded by double height retail/restaurant space withopen mezzaninesabove. This correspondswith the intent o the Pike Pine Design guidelines,whichpromote stall street level storeront retail spaces.
BASEMENT
STREET LEVEL
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc36 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
DESIGN DEPARTURE REQUEST #2
DESIGNREQUESTS
TS
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
20/30
SMC 23.47A2b/cSTREET LEVEL DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS
STANDARD
60% o the street acing aade between 2and 8eet above the sidewalk shall
be transparent.
DEPARTURE
53 % o the street acing aade between 2 and 8eet above th e sidewalk isto be transparent.
WHYTHIS DEPARTURE BETTER MEETSTHE INTENT OF THEDESIGN GUIDELINES
This isa narrow aade on a small scale project that incorporatesa characterstructure,a garage doorthat is necessaryto serve the building and othersonthe block,and a required exit passage door. Everything else isglazed retail/
restaurant storeront,whichme etsthe intent o the design guidelines.
DESIGN DEPARTURE REQUEST #3
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc38 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
DESIGN DEPARTURE REQUES
DESIGNREQUESTS
EARLYDESIGN GUIDANCE
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
21/30
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc40 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
A-2 Streetscape CompatibilityThesiting o buildings shouldacknowledgeandreinorcetheexistingdesirable spatial characteris-tics o theright-o-way.
Along 11thAvenue, the building isorganized into 4 distinct zonesthat are intended to reinorce the existing streetscape:Zone 1:Chop House: At the northhal o the site,the existingChop House aade will be renovated,with itsnorthern 1/3 bay
becoming the entrance to the throughblock pedestrian alleyenvisioned in the original long-termmulti-site maste rplan. Newportionso the building will be set back above the Chop House,
allowing ora large second oorroo deck overlooking 11th Av-enue.Zone 2:New Street Front:At the southhal o the site,the street
aade o the new building risesto about 55,similar in scale to theadjacent BakerLinen Building.Solid cornersand parapetsmatchthe solid eel o adjacent buildings. The building setsback above
Zone 2,allowing a second roo deck overlooking 11th Avenue atthe ourthoor level.Zone 3:Back Drop:The L shaped backdropportion o the build-
ing readsas a light glassand steel backdrop to Zones1 and 2,setback 15 eet romthe s treet lot line.
Zone 4:Top FloorResidential: The top (th)oor isset backanother8 to distinguishthe residential level and to allow orresi-dential decksoverlooking 11thAvenue.
See Part 3 o thisdocument ormore details.
A-4 Human ActivityNewdevelopment shouldbe sitedanddesignedto encouragehumanactivity onthestreet.
Glazed street level retail and restaurantsring the building, withacesonto 11th Avenue,the pedestrian alley,and the courtyard.The through-block connection to 12thAvenue envisioned by
the original urban design ramework iscompleted bythis build-ing witha pedestrian alley and enlarged courtyard. The curb at11thAvenue is bulbed out and landscaped asthe rst step in an
improved urban streetscape along 11thAvenue between Pike St.and Union St.
A-5 Respect or AdjacentSitesBuildings shouldrespect adjacent properties bybeinglocatedon theirsites tominimizedisruptiono theprivacy andoutdooractivities o residents inadjacent buildings.
Particularcare wastaken in addressing the neighboring condo-miniumbuilding to the north,1111 E.Pike St. No setback isrequiredalong the northpropertyline, however,the new building isset back10,which,when added to 1111s5 setback,yieldsa 15distance
between buildings,similar to a standard alleywidth. No setback isrequired along the east propertyline, however,the new building isset back approximately15 romthe east lot line,allowing orbetter
light and views,especiallyrom the east third o the neighboringbuilding. The solid/void pattern o the northaade isplanned tocorrespond in reverse to 1111 E.Pikessouth aade,so that windows
do not look directlyacross the pedestrian alleyat otherwindows,thushelp ing withprivacyissues. The top oorresidential unitsareset back at the NEand NW cornerso the building to allow orbe t-
terlight and views to adjacent roo decksat 1111 E.Pike St.See Part 3 o thisdocument ormore details.
A-8 Parkingand Vehicle AccessSitingshouldminimizethe impact o automobileparkinganddriveways onthepedestrian environ-ment,adjacent properties andpedestriansaety.
Given the goal o incorporating the Chop House on the north halo the site,vehicle access,drive aisles,and new building coresare alllocated on the southhal o the lot. A choice was made to locate
the vehicle entryat mid-block,next to the Chop House,rather thanat the southedge o the site. This wasthe most efective plan-ning strategyin order to allow ora unctional parking arrangement
(given the Chop House oundation line at mid-site), and allow oropen,transparent oce oors above bymoving the circulation coreto the southwall.
Reduced drivewaywidth and reduction o sight trianglesis pro-posed via Design Departure in orderto reduce the impact o thedrivewayon the pe destrian environment and increase retail street
rontage. Forped estrian saety,we are proposing motion-activatedwarning lightsin lieu o sight triangles. We are also proposing thatthe drivewayrunsat or5as it entersthe building,beore begin-
ning itsdescent,in order to allow a relativelyat approachto thesidewalk rominside the garage.
A. Site Planning
Guideline Response Guideline Response
EARLY DESIGN GUIDANCE
Design review Guidelinesrom Early Design Guidance Packetand Responses
GUIDELINES
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
22/30
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc42 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
B-5Through-Block Developmenta)Avoidmonolithicdevelopment onthroughlots.
b)On blocks boundedby designatedprincipal
pedestrianstreets,take advantageo opportunitiestoincludethrough-block connections
c)Capitalizeon opportunities toprovideutilityunctions in through-block development.
Instead o a monolithic development, the new project isproposed
onlyor the west hal o the throughlot-buildings on the east halare maintained,with a courtyard in between.
See a)above.
Original oorto ceiling heightsare maintained. Portions o thesecond oorare removed at the east and west endso the build-ing to allow ordouble height spaces within the building.
See B-3b)above.
C-1 ArchitecturalContextThePike/Pinevernaculararchitectureis char-acterizedby thehistoricauto rowandwarehouseindustrial buildings eaturing highground-foorceilings,articulatedground-foorcommercial space,display windows,detailedcorniceandrieze work,andtrim detailing.
Extra highground oorcommercial space iscreated bysetting
the second ooro the new building at about 20above streetand courtyard level and re-classiying the second ooro theChop House asa mezzanine. We have purposelychosen to
design a modern,well proportioned building,w ithout corniceand rieze work,as a contrast to the retained aade o the ChopHouse.
B-7. Conservation oCharacter Structures(Supplementalguidance especially orpropertieslocatedin the Pike/Pine Conserva-tion Overlay District)a)Maintainthe architectural integrity o thecharacterstructure
b)MaintainCharacter-DeningElements
c)Recognizethe priority ormaintainingtheoriginalfoor-to-ceilingheights in characterstructures,espe-cially orthe groundfoorandor eatures visibleromtheexterior.
d)Sensitively locateadditions sothey donot domi-natethe appearanceo thecharacterstructure.
Existing Chop House aade will be stripped o add-ons like T-111 ply-wood,with new windowsadded. Wood structure will be carried backthroughbuilding, withstee l seismic bracing added.
The through-block connection envisioned in the original urban
design ramework orthe block isrealized withthis project.
Curb cuts,trashalcoves, etc., at connected buildingshave beenavoided bycoordinated development,and connected garagesto
the new building.
C-2 ArchitecturalConceptandConsistencyBuildingdesignelements,details andmassingshouldcreatea well-proportionedanduniedbuildingorm andexhibit an overall architecturalconcept. Buildings shouldexhibit orm andea-tures identiyingthe unctions withinthebuild-ing. Ingeneral,theroofineor topo thestructureshouldbeclearly distinguishedrom its acade
walls.
See A-2above or discussion o massing and materialsstrategy.
C-3 Human ScaleInorderto achievegoodhumanscale, theexistingneighborhoodcontext encourages buildingentranc-
es inproportionwith neighboringstoreront develop-ments.Inaddition tothe CitywideDesignGuide-lines,developments shouldsuccessully contributetothe vitality o thestreet level andpedestrianscalerelationships tothe right-o-way. Thus,thedesigno thegroundfooro new developments shouldinclude: Pedestrian-orientedarchitectural elements. Gatesto pedestrian alley,a large mid-block plaza withseating,
opening windowsand garage doors to retail/restaurant estab-lishments,planters, curb bulbs,alley trellisrom old Chop Houseraming,are all pedestrian oriented architectural elements
included in the project.
C. ArchitecturalElements andMaterials
Guideline Response Guideline Response
EARLY DESIGN GUIDANCE: Design review Guidelinesrom Early Design Guidance PacketandResponses
GUIDELINES
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
23/30
D-9 CommercialSignageSigns shouldaddinterest to thestreet ront environ-ment andshouldbe appropriateorthescale andcharacterdesiredinthe area.
D-10 CommercialLightingAppropriatelevels o lightingshouldbe providedinordertopromote visual interest anda senseo secu-rity orpeoplein commercial districts duringeveninghours.Lightingmay be providedby incorporationintothe buildingaade,theundersideo overheadweatherprotection,onand aroundstreet urniture,inmerchandisingdisplay windows,inlandscapedareas,
and/oronsignage
D-11 CommercialTransparencyCommercial storeronts shouldbe transparent,allowingora direct visual connectionbetweenpedestrians onthesidewalk andthe activities occur-ringonthe interioro a building.Blank walls shouldbeavoided.
See D-1 above orlighting discussion.
E-1 Landscapingto Reinorce Design Conti-nuity with AdjacentSitesWherepossible,and wherethereis not anotheroverridingconcern,landscapingshouldreinorcethecharactero neighboringproperties andabut-tingstreetscape.
E-2 Landscapingto Enhance the Buildingand/or SiteThecreationo small gardens andart withinthestreet right-o-way is encouragedin thePike/Pineneighborhoodin ordertoenhanceand energizethepedestrianexperience.This is especially desirableorresidential andmixeduse developments as wellas a means to distinguishcommercial areas rominstitutional areas.Providingvertical landscaping,trellises orwindowboxes orplants is alsodesirable.Street greeningis specically recommendedalongtheollowingstreets: Avenues betweenUnion andPike Streets,fromMinorAvenueonthewest toHarvardAvenueon
theeast; AlongBellevue, Summit,Belmont, andBoylston
(except rom PiketoPine) UnionStreet from BorentoBroadway Avenues betweenPike andOlive Streets from
11thAve.ontheeast to14thAve.onthewestincludingPinefrom 14thand15thandOlivefrom
11thto 15th(except along14thAve. rom PinetoPike).
Thisproject is the rst new streetscape improvement on 11thAvenue between Pike and Union streets,and the ownerhas
worked withSDOT to coordinate improvementswith a longertermvision or a coherent urban streetscape on thisblock,withsubsequent projectsexpected to ollow the same pattern.
See D-1 above orlighting discussion
Plantershave been strategicallyplaced at multiple levelsin andaround the pedestrian alley,plaza,and Chop House roo deckto enhance and energize the pedestrian experience. Please
reerto the Landscape Plan.
Project isringed on three sidesby transparent commercial
storeronts.
E. Landscaping
Note that the pedestrian alley and plaza will be closed at nightrom1AM to 7AM,accessible onlybycard keyto building oc-
cupants. This will be accomplished bylocking gatesat the 11thAvenue entrypassage.
Lightinginstalledorpedestrians shouldbehoodedordirectedto pathways leadingtowards buildings.a).Promotethe pedestrianenvironmentb).Refect the special neighborhoodcharacter
D-7 PersonalSaety andSecurityProject designshouldconsideropportunities orenhancingpersonal saety andsecurity inthe envi-ronment underreview.
See signage page in part 5 o thisdocument orapprovedsignage examples
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc44 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
Guideline Response Guideline Response
EARLY DESIGN GUIDANCE: Design review Guidelinesrom Early Design Guidance PacketandResponses
GUIDELINES
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
24/30
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc46 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
SITE ANALYSIS: summer solstice
( e) Ba ke r Li ne n ( e) 11 11 P ik e ( e) S tr uc t ur e ( e) Ag ne s Lo ft s
(e)Piston &Ring
Building
12THA
VENUE
11THA
VENUE
EASTPIKE STREET
EASTUNIONSTREET
(e)Manhattan
1419 12th Ave.
(e)Pacific Hardware
1417 12th Ave
(e)FerrariDealership
(e)Union Building
3:00 pm
parking
( e) Ba ke r Li ne n ( e) 11 11 P ik e ( e) St r uc t ur e ( e) Ag ne s Lo ft s
(e)Piston &Ring
Building
12THA
VENUE
11THA
VENUE
EASTPIKE STREET
EASTUNIONSTREET
(e)Manhattan
1419 12th Ave.
(e)Pacific Hardware
1417 12th Ave
(e)FerrariDealership
(e)Union Building
3:00 pm
parking
WITH PROJECTJune 22, 3:00 PM
WITHOUT PROJECTJune 22, 3:00 PM
APPENDIX
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
25/30
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc48 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
SITE ANALYSIS: summer solstice
( e) Ba ke r Li ne n ( e) 11 11 P ik e ( e) S tr uc t ur e ( e) Ag ne s Lo ft s
(e)Piston &Ring
Building
12THA
VENUE
11THA
VENUE
EASTPIKE STREET
EASTUNIONSTREET
(e)Manhattan1419 12th Ave.
(e)Pacific Hardware
1417 12th Ave
(e)FerrariDealership
(e)Union Building
3:00 pm
parking
( e) Ba ke r Li ne n ( e) 11 11 P ik e ( e) St r uc t ur e ( e) Ag ne s Lo ft s
(e)Piston &Ring
Building
12THA
VENUE
11THA
VENUE
EASTPIKE STREET
EASTUNIONSTREET
(e)Manhattan1419 12th Ave.
(e)Pacific Hardware
1417 12th Ave
(e)FerrariDealership
(e)Union Building
3:00 pm
parking
WITH PROJECTDecember22, 3:00 PM
WITHOUT PROJECTDecember 22, 3:00 PM
APPENDIX
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
26/30
VIEW SOUTH FROM 1111 E. PIKE ROOF DECK
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc50 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
APPENDIX
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
27/30
The rst foorincludesrestaurant and retailspace with storeront and garage doorsthat openonto the Mews,ontothe midblock Courtyard,and ontothAvenue. Double height spacesare located at the ourcorners o the building tocreate exceptionalurban spaceslinked tothe Courtyard, Mews,and thAvenue reerto retailmezzanine planollowing. The garage entry islocated onth Avenue nearthe middle o the building orreasonsnoted at the basement plan. Thisresults ina microretailspace at the southend o the building that isintended toextend the thAvenue urbanretailstreetront southward asar aspossible.
The mainentry orthe ocesand residencesis o o the courtyard at the SEcornero the building,identied by acanopy. This ispurposeul, andintended tomake the Courtyard intoaorecourt similarto classic courtyard buildingsin Europeancitiesor like the Innat the Market inSeattle.
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc52 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
STREET LEVEL PLAN
E EASEMENTTOREMAIN
11thAVENUE
THEMEWS
DRIVEWAY COURTYARD
E COURTYARD
RETAIL
DOUBLEHEIGHTSPACE
DOUBLEHEIGHTSPACE
APPENDIX
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
28/30
The second foorcontainsoce space,and isaligned with the existingroo structure o the Chophouse,which wasdesigned orfoor loading see originaldrawing withadditionalfoorsin CharacterStructuresectiono thisdocument. The second fooropensonto aroo deckwhichsits ontop o the Chophouse,and overlooksthAvenue.
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc54 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
SECOND FLOOR PLAN
OFFICES
DECK
APPENDIX
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
29/30
The third foormezzanine containsoce space,and haslarge doubleheight spacesopento the third foorbelow unshaded areas.
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc56 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
THIRD FLOOR MEZZANINE PLAN
OFFICES
OPENTOBELOW
OPENTOBELOW
APPENDIX
7/29/2019 Dr Proposal 3014325 Agenda Id 4291
30/30
The th foorcontains three residentialunits, each one bedroom,and eachwith large decks. A small,commongardenspace islocatedonthe southwall.
1424 11th Avenue | Design Review | Marc58 Sundberg Kennedy Ly-AuYoung Architects | Graham BabaArchitects
FIFTH FLOOR (RESIDENTIAL LEVEL) PLAN
DECKBELOW
DECK
DECK
DECK
RESIDENTIALUNIT# RESIDENTIAL
UNIT#
RESIDENTIALUNIT#
GREENROOF
GREENROOF
APPENDIX