5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

1/10

1

DRAFT

GUIDE FOR EXPERTS

ON

QUALITY ASSESSMENT

Actions managed by

NATIONAL AGENCIES

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

2/10

2

INTRODUCTION

A E+ P .

T N A P C

/

. N A 1

/ . T,

N A.

T G E

E+ P2. I

P

N A.

T G E :

;

;

;

.

2.EE

2.1

T

.

T , ,

, .

T . B '

,

, N A ,

E C.

T

.

1P "" "" G.

2 T E+ P R (EU) N 1288/2013 E

P C 11 D 2013 'E+': U

, , D N 1719/2006/EC, N 1720/2006/EC N 1298/2008/EC/

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

3/10

3

B ' , N A

(. 4).

2.2 A ,

E () , .

T , .

E

N A.

T N A

.

A . T,

.

3

D ,

,

N A. E E+ P

N A.

E 4

. T , N

A

N A (. 6 G). T

.

P

.

W

N A , N A

3 P :

- R (EC) N 45/2001 E P C

E U

;

- ,

.

4 F R A. 57(2):

, ,

, , , .

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

4/10

4

,

.

3.AEEACA

3.1

B , N A

P ,

.

E

O E E T (OEET),

.

B , :

E+ P G

P

;

, ,

. F ,

A 5 G;

(. 3.3);

;

N A.

E .

I :

.

E ,

/

N A.

3.2 A

E O E E T (OEET). T

OEET. E OEET N

A .

T E C

P C

P C. E ,

(. 3.3).

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

5/10

5

O , O

E E T,

.

A ,

. E OEET.

3.3 A

E P G.

T A 14 G, :

A 1: A

A 2: L M5:

o S

o S

o S

o Y

A 3: S P ,

A 4: S M

E

. T

. T

;

.

I

, . T

2 3 , .

W

. T

. E .

I

.

E ,

. A ,

5 A

, E C H E (ECHE).

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

6/10

6

, ,

.,

, .

A 100 . T

N A.

A A

A 1 A 2 A 3

A

M

,

,

S P

S D

R

6

30 30 30 30

Q

7

20 40 20 40

Q

8

20 N.A. 20 N.A.

I

30 30 30 30

TOTAL 100 100 100 100

T ,

,

.

E

20, 30 40 . T

100 OEET

. E

.

W ,

, . T

:

6 C : " "

7 C : "

"

8 C : "

"

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

7/10

7

V

. T

.

G ,

. T .

F , . T

,

.

W

. T ,

.

T

.

40 3440 28 33 20 27 019

30 2630 2125 1520 014

20 1720 1416 1013 09

E , ,

. T

.

A , . I

,

.

A N A ,

,

N A.

A ,

. I ,

. I

, ,

. H, N A

. N.B. E

.

T N A .

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

8/100

8

E , .

3.4

I E+ P,

N A :

60

50% .

3.5

E . I

, N A. T N A

.

A,

,

, N A

.

3.6 C

I ,

.

I ,

. T

. T .

I 30

,

,

. T

NA ,

. I

, N A

.

I 30 ,

N A

9. T

. C

.

9

T .

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

9/100

9

T . I

,

,

, .

4.

A P G, N A

,

.

I N A

.

T .

I , N A

.

A:

1. A

2. A KA1 ,

,

3. A KA2 S P

4. A KA3 S

5. R ,

6. T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

10/1

A 1 A 1 A

10

A 1 A 1 A

AAD CEA E

( 30 )

T :

- A

-

T :

-

-

- EU

HEI

( 20 )

T :

-

,

,

-

- , /

- /

-

- A

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

11/1

A 1 A 1 A

11

AAD CEA E

( 20 )

T ,

, )

T ,

, , ,

T ,

W ,

, E

I ,

( 30 )

T

T :

-

-

, /

T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

12/1

A 2 A 1 ,

A 2.A E

12

A 2.A E

PROPORTIONALITY

I , T .

AAD CEA E

( 30 )

T

:

-

A

T A

P B P G.

T

() , .. .

S

, :

-

, ;

-

;

-

-

;

- E .

-

T

. I

.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

13/1

A 2 A 1 ,

A 2.A E

13

AAD CEA E

T

:

-

T

.

T

-

T

,

I ,

.

( 40 )

T ,

(,

,

)

T

. I

T

T ,

T .

T

T

T ,

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

14/1

A 2 A 1 ,

A 2.A E

14

AAD CEA E

.

T .

T

E D

P

T E D P :

, ,

E , , ,

, )

;

,

/

T

.

T

/

T

,

T

,

T (

) .

T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

15/1

A 2 A 1 ,

A 2.A E

15

AAD CEA E

(, , , ).

T

.

T

T

, , /

T

'

,

E

T

W , E . R

: E..

( 30 )

T

T

. T

.

T

:

T

.

T

, ,

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

16/1

A 2 A 1 ,

A 2.A E

16

AAD CEA E

,

, ,

/ E

). I ,

.

T .

T

T

(). I

, (.

,

, , /

T .

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

17/1

A 2 A 1 , ,

A 2.B E (E)

17

A 2.B E (E)

PROPORTIONALITY

I , T .

AAD CEA E

( 30 )

T

:

A

T A

P B P G.

T

() , .. VET

T

VE

T

:

-

T

VET / .

T

, .

A/: T

-

T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

18/10

A 2 A 1 , ,

A 2.B E (E)

18

AAD CEA E

( 40 )

T ,

(,

,

)

T .

T ,

T .

T

.

T

T

T

.

T ,

.

T .

T

,

T

T

T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

19/10

A 2 A 1 , ,

A 2.B E (E)

19

AAD CEA E

, , /

T

'

,

E

T

.

W , E ECVET E

T

/

T

/ .

T

I ,

,

T

.

I

T

.

T

T

,

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

20/1

A 2 A 1 , ,

A 2.B E (E)

20

AAD CEA E

( 30 )

.

T

:

-

T

.

T

. I

-

, ,

,

/ E

T .

R

T

T

.

T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

21/1

A 2 A 1 , ,

A 2.B E (E)

21

AAD CEA E

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

22/1

A 2 A 1 , ,

A 2.C A E

22

A 2.C A E

PROPORTIONALITY

I , T .

AAD CEA E

( 30 )

T

:

A

T A

P B P G.

T

, .. .

T

.

S

D P).

T

:

-

T

.

T

,

- T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

23/1

A 2 A 1 , ,

A 2.C A E

23

AAD CEA E

( 40 )

T ,

(,

,

)

T

.

T ,

T .

T

.

T

T

.

T ,

.

T .

T

E

D P

T E D P :

, ,

E , ,

, )

;

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

24/1

A 2 A 1 , ,

A 2.C A E

24

AAD CEA E

, ,

/

T

,

T

T

T

, , /

T

'

,

E

T

.

W , E . R

: E.

T

/

T .

T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

25/1

A 2 A 1 , ,

A 2.C A E

25

AAD CEA E

N.B. T .

I ,

,

T

.

I

T

.

( 30 )

T

T

,

.

T

:

-

T

.

T

.

T . I

.

-

T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

26/1

A 2 A 1 , ,

A 2.C A E

26

AAD CEA E

, ,

, / E

.

R

T

T

.

T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

27/1

A 2 A 1 , ,

A 2.D

27

A 2.D

PROPORTIONALITY

I , T .

AAD CEA E

( 30 )

T

:

-

A

-

T

:

-

T A,

" P G. I

V S '

.

T "Y" P G.

I Y E E V S

I" P G.

T

. T

, P

A 1: L ", "W

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

28/10

A 2 A 1 , ,

A 2.D

28

AAD CEA E

-

T

A

T

( 40 )

T ,

(,

,

)

T

T

A I, "M

V S,

T

,

(, , ,

T

.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

29/10

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

30/1

A 2 A 1 , ,

A 2.D

30

AAD CEA E

/

T

,

I E V S,

. T , ,

. T /

. T

.

T

. T

/

. T

B ,

, .

T /

. T

A I "M

T

( ). T

:

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

31/1

A 2 A 1 , ,

A 2.D

31

AAD CEA E

,

T

: . P

, .

I Y E ,

, . T

.

T

,

,

;

;

.

T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

32/1

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

33/1

A 2 A 1 , ,

A 2.D

33

AAD CEA E

P ( ,

, , .)

. T

EVS . T (, , )

, , ).

D

T

,

. D

;

' ,

. D ,

(

(CDR, DVD);

( /TV/ , ,

); (,

), .

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

34/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.A E

34

3. A E

PROPORTIONALITY

I , . T

.

AAD CEA E

C

( 30

)

T

:

-

E

,

T

, ..

E ,

P B P G. P

,

:

,

,

,

;

ICT (I C

T) ,

(OER)

, ICT

T

I

I

D

E

R

P

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

35/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.A E

35

AAD CEA E

C

;

EU

,

.

,

;

E

.

-

A

T P B

P G

A,

:

, ;

ICT

OER

E ;

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

36/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.A E

36

AAD CEA E

C

.

T :

-

T ,

, ,

(),

.

T

.

T

-

,

T

.

T

.

-

,

T

,

. .

-

/

T /

,

,

, ,

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

37/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.A E

37

AAD CEA E

C

.

AND/OR:

I ,

. I

,

.

T

.

-

EU

T

;

.

( 20

T ,

,

,

, ,

T

.

T ,

.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

38/10

A 3 A 2

A 3.A E

38

AAD CEA E

C

) T

.

T

T

.

T

T

.

T /

.

T

,

T

,

,

. T

.

T

T

.

T

.

I ,

:

I ,

,

I

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

39/10

A 3 A 2

A 3.A E

39

AAD CEA E

C

T

'

. T

,

,

.

T , ..

,

,

, ,

, ,

.

T

'

,

E

I , ,

/

E

, : E /

; E

E

.

T

R

( 20

T :

-

T ,

,

.

F S

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

40/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.A E

40

AAD CEA E

C

)

,

T ,

,

.

/

-

T

,

,

.

-

,

, ,

I '

, /

, ,

.

T

, , /

.

-

A

T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

41/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.A E

41

AAD CEA E

C

.

T

,

T .

T

.

I

I ,

P C

(

,

)

T P

C

,

P C.

B:

C '

, ""

( 09 )

"

" .

( 30

T

T

.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

42/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.A E

42

AAD CEA E

C

) T

:

-

,

T

/ .

T

.

-

, , ,

/

E

T

E

.

T ,

, , , / E.

T

:

,

, / E ;

/

;

E+ /

E P.

T

:

T F S

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

43/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.A E

43

AAD CEA E

C

.

A

.

T

,

, / E

.

I

.

I

.

I ,

,

,

I ,

,

.

I ,

.

T

:

T

. I

F S

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

44/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.A E

44

AAD CEA E

C

EU

.

I , /

.

I ,

.

I

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

45/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.B E

45

3. B E

PROPORTIONALITY

I ,

. T

.

AAD CEA E

C

( 30

)

T

:

- E

,

T

, ..

E ,

P B P G. P

,

:

,

, ,

;

ICT (I C

T) ,

(OER)

, ICT

T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

46/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.B E

46

AAD CEA E

C

;

EU

,

.

,

;

E

.

P

-

A

T P B

P G

A,

:

, ;

ICT

OER E

;

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

47/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.B E

47

AAD CEA E

C

.

T :

-

T , , ,

(),

.

T

.

T

E

-

,

T

.

T

.

-

,

T

,

. .

-

/

T

/ ,

,

, ,

.

I

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

48/10

A 3 A 2

A 3.B E

48

AAD CEA E

C

AND/OR:

I ,

. I

,

.

T

.

-

EU

T

;

.

( 20

)

T ,

,

, ,

,

T

.

T ,

.

T .

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

49/10

A 3 A 2

A 3.B E

49

AAD CEA E

C

T

T

.

T

T

.

T /

.

T

,

T

,

, . T

.

T

T

. T

.

I ,

:

T

'

I ,

,

. T ,

,

T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

50/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.B E

50

AAD CEA E

C

.

T , .. ,

,

, ,

, ,

.

T

'

,

E

I ,

,

/

E

, : E /

; E

E

.

T

K

R

E

( 20)

T :

-

,

T

,

,

.

T ,

,

.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

51/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.B E

51

AAD CEA E

C

-

T

,

,

.

-

,

, ,

I '

, /

,

,

.

T

, , /

.

-

A

T

.

T

,

T .

T

.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

52/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.B E

52

AAD CEA E

C

I ,

P C

(

,

)

T P C

,

P C.

B:

C

' ,

"" (

09 )

" " .

( 30

)

T

T

.

T

:

-

,

T

/ .

T

.

T

(

E

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

53/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.B E

53

AAD CEA E

C

-

, , ,

/ E

T

E .

T ,

,

, , / E.

T :

, ,

/ E ;

/

;

E+ / E

P.

T

:

T

.

A

.

T

, ,

/ E

.

I

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

54/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.B E

54

AAD CEA E

C

.

I ,

,

,

I ,

,

.

I ,

.

T

:

EU

T

. I

.

I ,

/

.

I ,

.

T

T

(.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

55/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.C E

55

3.C E

PROPORTIONALITY

I ,

. T

.

AAD CEA E

C

( 30

)

T

:

- E

,

T

, ..

E ,

P B P G. P

, :

,

, ,

;

ICT (I C

T) ,

(OER)

, ICT

T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

56/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.C E

56

AAD CEA E

C

;

EU

,

.

,

;

E

.

P

-

A

T P B

P G

A,

:

, ;

ICT

OER E

;

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

57/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.C E

57

AAD CEA E

C

.

T :

-

T ,

, ,

(),

.

T

.

T

-

,

T

.

T

.

-

,

T

,

. .

-

/

T

/ ,

,

, ,

.

T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

58/10

A 3 A 2

A 3.C E

58

AAD CEA E

C

AND/OR:

I ,

. I

,

.

T

.

-

EU

T

;

.

( 20

)

T ,

,

, ,

,

T

.

T ,

.

T .

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

59/10

A 3 A 2

A 3.C E

59

AAD CEA E

C

T

T

.

T

T

.

T /

.

T

,

T

,

, . T

.

T

T

. T

.

I ,

:

T

'

I ,

,

. T ,

,

T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

60/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.C E

60

AAD CEA E

C

.

T , .. ,

,

, ,

, ,

.

T

'

,

E

I ,

,

/

E

, : E /

; E

E

.

T

K

R

( 20)

T :

-

,

T

,

,

.

T ,

,

.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

61/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.C E

61

AAD CEA E

C

-

T

,

,

.

-

,

, ,

I '

, /

,

,

.

T

, , /

.

-

A

T

.

T

,

T .

T

.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

62/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.C E

62

AAD CEA E

C

I ,

P C

(

,

)

T P C

,

P C.

B:

C

' ,

"" (

09 ) "

" .

( 30

)

T

T

.

T

:

-

,

T

/ .

T

.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

63/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.C E

63

AAD CEA E

C

-

, , ,

/ E

T

E .

T ,

,

, , / E.

T :

, ,

/ E ;

/

;

E+ / E

P.

T

:

T

.

A

.

T , ,

/ E

.

I

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

64/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.C E

64

AAD CEA E

C

.

I ,

,

,

I ,

,

.

I ,

.

T

:

EU

T

. I

.

I ,

/

.

I ,

.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

65/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.D A E

65

3.D A E

PROPORTIONALITY

I ,

. T

.

AAD CEA E

C

( 30

)

T

:

-

E

,

T

, ..

E ,

P B P G. P

, :

,

, ,

;

ICT (I C

T) ,

(OER) , ICT

;

T

P

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

66/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.D A E

66

AAD CEA E

C

EU

,

.

,

;

E

.

T

-

AT P B P G

A,

:

, ;

ICT

OER E

;

.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

67/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.D A E

67

AAD CEA E

C

T :

-

T ,

, ,

(), .

T

.

T

-

,

T

.

T

.

-

,

T

,

. .

-

/

T

/

,

, , ,

.

AND/OR:

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

68/10

A 3 A 2

A 3.D A E

68

AAD CEA E

C

I ,

. I ,

.

T

.

-

EU

T

;

.

( 20)

T ,

,

,

, ,

T

.

T ,

.

T .

T

T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

69/10

A 3 A 2

A 3.D A E

69

AAD CEA E

C

.

T

T

.

T /

.

T

,

T

,

, . T

.

T

T

. T

.

I ,

:

T

'

I ,

,

. T ,

,

.

T , ..

,

I

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

70/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.D A E

70

AAD CEA E

C

,

, , ,

, .

I

T

'

,

E

I , ,

/

E

, : E /

; E

E

.

T

R

( 20

T :

-

T

,

,

.

T ,

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

71/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.D A E

71

AAD CEA E

C

) ,

,

.

-

T

,

,

.

-

,

, ,

I '

, /

,

,

.

T

, , /

.

-

A

T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

72/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.D A E

72

AAD CEA E

C

.

T

,

T

. T

.

I ,

P C

(

,

)

T P C

,

P C.

B:

C

' ,

"" (

09 )

"

" ,

.

( 30

T

T

.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

73/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.D A E

73

AAD CEA E

C

) T

:

-

,

T

/

.

T

.

-

, , ,

/

E

T

E .

T ,

, ,

, / E.

T :

, ,

/ E ;

/

;

E+ / E

P.

T

:

T

.

A

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

74/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.D A E

74

AAD CEA E

C

.

T , ,

/ E

.

I

.

I ,

,

,

I ,

,

.

I ,

.

T

:

EU

T

. I

.

I ,

/

.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

75/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.D A E

75

AAD CEA E

C

I ,

.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

76/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.E

76

3.E

PROPORTIONALITY

I ,

. T

.

AAD CEA E

C

( 30

)

T

:

-

E

,

T

, ..

E , P B P G. P

,

:

,

,

,

;

ICT (I C

T) ,

(OER)

, ICT

T

E

T

E

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

77/1

A 3 A 2

A 3.E

77

AAD CEA E

C

;

EU

,

.

.

P

T

P

-

A

T P B

P G

A,

:

, ;

ICT

OER

E ;

.

T :

-

T ,

, ,

(),

T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

78/10

A 3 A 2

A 3.E

78

AAD CEA E

C

.

T .

-

,

T

.

T

.

-

,

T ,

. .

I

-

/

T

/

,

,

, ,

.

AND/OR:

I ,

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

79/10

A 3 A 2

A 3.E

79

AAD CEA E

C

. I

,

.

T

.

-

EU

T

;

.

( 20

)

T ,

,

,

, ,

T

.

T ,

.

T .

T

T

T

A

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

80/10

A 3 A 2

A 3.E

80

AAD CEA E

C

. "S

.

T

T

.

T /

.

T

T

,

T

,

,

. T

.

T

T

.

T

.

I , :

T

'

I , ,

. T

,

,

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

81/10

A 3 A 2

A 3.E

81

AAD CEA E

C

.

T , ..

,

,

, ,

, ,

.

T

'

, E

I ,

,

/

E

, : E /

; E

E

.

L

( 20

)

T :

-

,

T

,

, .

T ,

,

T

I

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

82/10

A 3 A 2

A 3.E

82

AAD CEA E

C

.

-

T

,

,

.

-

,

, ,

I '

, /

, ,

.

T

, , /

.

- T

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

83/10

A 3 A 2

A 3.E

83

AAD CEA E

C

A

.

T

,

T

.

T

.

I ,

P C

(

,

)

T P

C

,

P C.

B:

C '

,

"" ( 09 )

"

"

, .

( 30

T

T

.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

84/10

A 3 A 2

A 3.E

84

AAD CEA E

C

) T

:

-

,

T

/ .

T

.

-

, , ,

/

E

T

E

.

T ,

, , , / E.

T

:

,

, / E ;

/

;

E+ /

E P.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

85/10

A 3 A 2

A 3.E

85

AAD CEA E

C

T

:

T

.

A

.

T

,

, / E

.

I

.

I ,

,

,

I ,

,

.

I ,

.

T

:

T

. I

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

86/10

A 3 A 2

A 3.E

86

AAD CEA E

C

EU

.

I ,

/

.

I ,

.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

87/10

A 4 A 3 D:

87

A 4 A 3 D:

PROPORTIONALITY

I ,

. T

.

AAD CEA E

( 30 )

T :

-

A

-

T

:

-

-

T

A ( )

T

"W

G.

T

B, "Y" P

T

P A "E I"

T ,

(,

,

)

T

:

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

88/100

A 4 A 3 D:

88

AAD CEA E

( 40 ) T

T ,

T

T

/

I ,

,

()

,

, .).

T

.

A

T ,

. I

T

. T

/

T

.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

89/10

A 4 A 3 D:

89

AAD CEA E

B ,

, .

T

. A

(,

, .)

T

:

,

T

. P

,

,

T

. I , :

,

;

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

90/10

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

91/10

A 4 A 3 D:

91

AAD CEA E

T

SMS ; ,

;

, ,

V P:

W ,

P (

A,

D

T

. D

" "

. O

(,

(CDR, DVD); /TV/ , ,

);

), .

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

92/10

A 5

92

A 5

5.A ,

E 2020 EE 2020

o E 2020 : ://../2020/.

o E 2020 : ://../2020///

o C 2013: ://../2020/

//.

o E T 2020 (ET2020):

://..////.

o R E: I :

http://eur-

lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:52012DC0669:EN:N

OT

o T EU Y :

://..////.

o E: ://../N.?=745884:&=&=745887:,745886:,745885

:,745888:,745883:,745884:,745882:,745804:,745802:,745803:,&

=6&=1&=863&=10&=

o E Q F: ://

../R.?0=&1=&2=&=&=&

RT=RECH&S=S

E :

o "E : A G E":

://..////

//.

o "T G C C E E"

R H L R P E E

D G E I D G E

C: ://..////

//

//.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

93/10

A 5

93

C (C) E (E):

o T F L: N W L N S F J:

://....//EAP/FC.

o O E: ://..///

/.

o O E R E:

://....//EAP/OEREU.

o U C C E

://....//EAP/SCALECCR.

o D C: I E

:

://....//EAP/DIGCOMP.

:

o C S W D: "L C ,

":

://..////372.

o R T W G L J

:

://..///.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

94/10

A 5

94

5.B

I ,

- "C ":

://

../LUS/LUS.?=OJ:C:2011:191:0001:0006:EN:PDF

- C "T : A

E 2020 A":

://

../LUS/LUS.?=COM:2011:0018:FIN:EN:PDF

- F R T W G E S L

link will be provided at a later stage

F :

://..////.

I

- T E F K C:

://.///

/11090.

- "C 26 N 2012 ":

://

../LUS/LUS.?=OJ:C:2012:393:0001:0004:EN:PDF

- F R EU H L G L:

link will be provided at a later stage

- C : "A K C

: P G":

://

../LUS/LUS.?=SWD:2012:0371:FIN:EN:PDF

- "C E

21 ":

://

../LUS/LUS.?=OJ:C:2010:323:0011:0014:EN:PDF

- F :

://..////.

D E C E C

- C : "E C E C: P

":

://

../LUS/LUS.?=COM:2011:0066:FIN:EN:PDF

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

95/10

A 5

95

- "C :

":

://

../LUS/LUS.?=OJ:C:2011:175:0008:0010:EN:PDF

- F E

(ECEC) E:://..////.

R

- C : "S T P

B L O":

://

../LUS/LUS.?=SWD:2012:0374:FIN:EN:PDF

- "C 26 N 2009

":

://

../LUS/LUS.?=OJ:C:2009:302:0006:0009:EN:PDF

- "C ":

://...///////1397

15.

- F :

://..////.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

96/10

A 5

96

5.C

1. T B C E

, 20112020

://..////2011/.

2. "V "

://../LUS/LUS.?=SWD:2012:0375:FIN:EN:PDF

3. "W L E. P "

M :

://..///.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

97/10

A 5

97

5.D

H E M A:

://../LUS/LUS.?=COM:2011:0567:FIN:EN:PDF

M : ://..///

/.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

98/10

A 5

98

5.E

1. E

://..////.

2. T S A S (PIAAC)

://..////.

://.//IP13922.

3. E T M 2013

://..////13.

4. L

S A :

://../LUS/LUS.?=OJ:C:2011:372:0001:0006:EN:PDF

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

99/10

A 5

99

5.

1. C R E

(20102018) EU Y S.

2. D 1 E C.

3. P 2.0 /

E.

5/28/2018 Draft Guide for Experts on Quality Assessment 1

100/

A 6

100

D

E+, C P N XXX, ,

I, ,

(1) A.57 F R :

1. F ,

,

U.

W ,

N A

. W ,

. T N A

.

2. F 1, , 1,

, , ,

.

(2) A. 32 R A

U , , :

() ;

() ;

() .

I 10

I

/

C ,

.

I I

/ , I

N A I

.

F, I I . I

. I .

N:

S:

D:

10I ,

, ,

N A . T N A .