Date post: | 10-Sep-2014 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | kshitish-purohit |
View: | 116 times |
Download: | 0 times |
DriverCognition&the
Sense of Time
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
2
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
3
ForewordThis project was proposed owing to sheer fascination with the concept of time, and an interest to experiment. ‘WHAT???’ was one question, ‘how do I incorporate this fascination of time with transportation design?’ was another. I had nothing more than a vague answer to these questions while starting, and I knew that I was signing up for a tough task.
From the moment of commencement of the project, I knew there was a huge amount of literature study required. Firstly, I wanted to get a clear textbook under-standing of driver cognition. I soon realized what I had read during Ergonomics & System Design projects was just a meagre percentage of what I had signed up for. Second, I realized it was extremely necessary for me to get hold of philosophical as well as psychological aspects of ‘time’. Textbooks, hence, had to be supplemented with discussions with batch mates, seniors and peers. Third, the project deliverables under the Ford Foundation funding scheme included two research papers, publish-able in design journal(s). This meant that my theoretical foundation had no excuse for lapses. Lastly, I wanted to understand methods used in design research and felt the need to work around marrying qualitative, quantitative and simulative research tech-niques. At the end of a rather prolonged literature study phase, I was proud of myself on two accounts: a) for managing to get a grip on the above mentioned points and b) for spending more time in the library than my two years at NID combined!
Mid-way into the literature phase, it was agreed upon between me and my project guide that my first paper could be a complete review of literature followed by a pilot study to set a research framework. The second paper could, then, be in-depth research and analysis concluding into design blueprints, which were the other deliver-ables for my project.
The pilot studies were carried out in three parts. The first one was to get an understanding of how different drivers perceived time. What ‘time’ meant to them, had a direct bearing on their driving behaviour, and this helped me select a user group for further detailed study. The second part was a market study, where the
current Indian four-wheeler market was studied with respect to safety features/inter-faces available. The aim of this study was not to analyze vehicle safety, but instead, to understand the average perception of safety amongst the Indian population. Also, this study would give the threshold level that any new design should meet, and take off from. The third study was a road study, where the four most accident-prone road stretches of Ahmedabad were studied and analyzed as to what factors contributed to accidents on Indian roads.
Combined, the three pilot studies gave a picture of ’whom to design for’, ‘what to design up from’, and ‘where to design for’. In other words, this helped de-fine a broad context for further detailed studies to be carried on.
Henceforth, the task was getting clearer. I figured that to reach a conclusion, all I needed to do was follow the research, and narrow down the context at every step. So this time, I started with the vehicle – selecting what type of vehicle was a slightly confusing task, but once the vehicle was selected, the driver would automati-cally fit in. The options were passenger car, bus and truck. Going ahead with a truck would mean social weight in the project, but the logistics involved were many and too difficult to control – at least alone. The final call was between the passenger car and the bus, and attractiveness bias got the better of me and the passenger car was selected as my vehicle for further study. This automatically gave me my user group – the cab driver.
The detailed study was carried from a pure systems perspective. The first aspect of study was a cab agency. The sub-system was built around the most com-mon task at a cab agency – booking a cab. At each node, informational needs were mapped. As support case studies, a hierarchy of cab services was made and higher end services (Meru) were studied for comparisons and possible design interventions.
The next aspect of study was the vehicles employed by the cab agencies. The most commonly used cabs in Ahmedabad were selected and made to go through an anthropometric and interface audit. Again, as a support case, the Tata Indica was
studied as to how it revolutionized the taxi scene in India.
Finally, it was the most important component of any driving system – the driver. Now that everything had narrowed down at each step, it was the driver’s turn. The third aspect of my studies involved extensive research on the driver’s mental models, ‘day in the life of’ study, awareness towards safety/technology, perception of their profession etc.
Through this, I was able to narrow my entire research down to a certain Wan-jibhai Parmar, 32, who drives a Tata Indica for RR Travels, an Ahmedabad-based cab agency. Wanjibhai is the average user for my research, and is the persona for whom the guidelines have been designed.
Kshitish PurohitTransportation & Automobile Design
PGDPD ‘07, National Institute of Design
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
4
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
5
AcknowledgementThroughout the duration of the project, I’ve had immense amount of cooperation and support from my guide, Dr. Bibhudutta Baral, who, despite being constrained by geographical locations, was always present to assist me, and despite not being an automobile design expert, made sure he was always a step ahead of me so that he could guide me at each step. Such is the attitude students need from their guides and I feel fortunate to have had this throughout the project.
Dr. Prabir Mukhopadhyay, an expert in Ergonomics made sure in the beginning that I don’t fall lax and gave me enough impetus to be able to read more and get my basics right. This project could’ve gone without a logical element had it not been for Dr. Prabir in the beginning.
A word of gratitude to Mr. Praveen Nahar, ex-coordinator, Transportation & Auto-mobile Design and guide for my System Design project, for guiding me on Wayfind-ing – the project that made me select this topic. Also, Mr. Bhaskar Bhatt gets a vote of thanks for putting me in touch with the cab agency, and for helping me at certain crossroads in the beginning and at many other stages of the project.
Then there were people who helped in any-which-way possible. Some formed a part of the pilot studies (Vikramsinh Ji, Sagar Bhai, Bharat Bhai, Narainsinh Ji, Malav Sanghvi, Hiren Rana, Prassun Saha), while some just made me reflect upon what I was doing and where I was headed (Aditya ‘what IS your project all about’ Narayan). A special word of gratitude goes to the bunch at Mediashala@NDBI (Himanshu Khatri, Nalin Avasthi, Sumiran Pandya, Adithya Ananth, Kiran Pandya & Deepak Singh) for giving me space to work from and work smooth.
This project would’ve never got the human element had it not been for my peers. From the early discussions with Jaikar ‘Lump’ Marur, Kanishk ‘iKeny’ Gajjar, Ameya ‘Batman’ Nabar to the assistance and discussions I got from Hrishikesh Neve on the pilot studies, I was guaranteed enjoyment working. And no Transportation De-sign project is complete without mentioning TAD ’07 – Neeraj Pathak, Sunil Kharat, Imlisashi Aier, Sudarshan Rathod, Harsha Raju, Sanjay Urikoth & Nikhil Sharma.
Of course, Transportation & Automobile Design itself is not complete without the inclusion of Shradha Jain, Anuj Sharma, Poornima Garg, Pratyusha Reddy, San-gram Soni and Malhar Salil.
No journey would ever be complete without the real pillars of support – my parents. From the moment I decided to do a self-driven project within the walls of NID to the time I finished, Smt. Pramila Raghavendran and Sh. P.S.Raghavendran gave me nothing but support and limitless love. The one very special person, my grandmother Smt. Malati Rao, for making me want to finish fast and come home for food, and my aunt Smt. Nirmala Rao and uncle Sh. Vasudeva Rao – for taking care of grandma and being really cool people, my brother Anand Purohit – I owe one to all.
Finally, with so many people to thank for little things, there is just one person to thank for so many things – my real reality check, Kavita Myles, for showering endless amounts of love and support since forever, for constantly making me realize who I am, and for making me live one dream and work towards another.
This page has been intentionally left blank.Please turn over for the next section.
6
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
7
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Contents
National Institute of Design
Transportation & Automobile Design
Ford Foundation
Project Brief
The Driving Task
Time - The Fourth Dimension
Factors Affecting Perceived Time
Time and Cognition
Microstrategies and Recognition
Driver Behaviour
Vehicular Interfaces
Interface Design
How do Drivers Perceive Time?
Safety Trends
Where do Accidents Occur?
Conclusion
Introduction
The Cab Agency
Case Study: Meru Cabs
Case Study: Tata Indica
The Vehicle Space
The Driver: Mental Models
Persona: Wanjibhai Parmar
Information Structure
Concept
Guidelines
Summary
Dashboard Integration
Relevance of the Design
Project Reflection
Future Scope
Bibliography
introduction8
framework32
research & analysis 48
design74
conclusion12216
literature study
INTRODUCTION8
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
INTRODUCTION 9
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
The National Institute of Design (NID) is internationally acclaimed as one of the foremost multi-disciplinary institutions in the field of design education and research. The Business Week, USA has listed NID as one of the top 25 European & Asian programmes in the world. The institute functions as an autonomous body under the department of Industrial Policy & Promotion, Ministry of Commerce & Industry, Government of India. NID is recognised by the Dept. of Scientific & Industrial Research (DSIR) under Ministry of Science & Technology, Government of India, as a scientific and industrial design research organisation.
NID has been a pioneer in industrial design education after Bauhaus and Ulm in Germany and is known for its pursuit of design excellence to make Designed in India, Made for the World a reality. NID’s graduates have made a mark in key sectors of commerce, industry and social development by taking role of catalysts and through thought leadership.
NID Gandhinagar is situated in the city of Gandhinagar, in Gujarat. As part of expansion plan, NID has started building a new postgraduate campus at Gandhina-gar, the capital of Gujarat State.
Commerce and Industry Minister Kamal Nath laid the foundation stone for this campus. The upcoming campus will be spread over 11,362 square meters and the building will cost around Rs 195 million. The campus has been proposed to consist of a jewellery and automobile design centre along with Lifestyle Accessory Design, New Media Design, Toy and Game Design, Strategic Design Management, Transportation and Information Design centres.
NID’s R&D Campus at Bangalore was set up as a joint initiative of and funding from the Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion (DIPP), Ministry of Com-merce and Industry and the Ministry of Information Technology, Government of India and was inaugurated in March 2006. The R&D Campus commenced two research intensive PG Programmes namely Design for Retail Experience and Design for Digital Experience, from the academic year 2007-2008. From the academic year 2008-2009,
introductionNational Institute of Design
Transportation & Automobile Design
Ford Foundation
Project Brief
8
National Institute of Design
9
11
12
13
INTRODUCTION10
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
INTRODUCTION 11
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
the campus has also commenced one more research intensive PG Programme, namely Information and Interface Design. NID’s Research & Development Campus addresses the immediate need for an exclusive Design Research centre in the country, by foster-ing the creative design spirit and sighting new opportunities and frontiers through NID’s design acumen nurtured over the four decades of intense teaching-learning process.
Having entered the 5th decade of design excellence, NID has been active as an autonomous institute under the aegis of the Department of Industrial Policy & Promo-tion, Ministry of Commerce & Industry, Government of India; in education, applied research, service and advanced training in Industrial, Communication, Textile, and I.T. Integrated (Experiential) Design. NID offers a wide spectrum of design domains while encouraging transdisciplinary design projects. NID is a unique institution with many problem-solving capabilities, depths of intellect and a time-tested, creative educa-tional culture in promoting design competencies and setting standards of design education. The rigorous development of the designer’s skills and knowledge through a process of ‘hands on minds on’ is what makes the difference.
The overall structure of NID’s programme is a combination of theory, skills, de-sign projects, and field experiences supported by cutting edge design studios, skill & innovation labs and the Knowledge Management Centre. Sponsored design projects are brought into the classroom to provide professional experience. Interdisciplinary design studies in Science and Liberal Arts widen the students’ horizons and increase general awareness of contemporary issues.
A unique feature of NID’s design education programme is the openness of its educational culture and environment, where students from different faculties and de-sign domains interact with each other in a seamless manner. The benefit of learning in such a trans-disciplinary context is immeasurable.
Transportation is an indispensable need of humanity and the basic power of any economy, and is essential for survival today. Transportation as understood at NID in-cludes not only cars and other vehicles or off road vehicles but also vehicles on tracks, water vessels and other mobility devices and equipments. In India, where there is still a value base for resource conservation and adopting one product for multipurpose use, transportation of both people and goods has many co-existing modes.
Transportation in India so far has been technologically driven with minimum or little attention paid to the users’ needs in terms of comfort, safety, information and even the considerations of cultural sensitivities and preferences. In the context of an emerging market economy in India, it is essential to strengthen basic infrastructure facilities. Transportation is one of the most important links towards this end.
Designers have a very important contribution to make towards the way they make objects in our environment work, and in turn, influence our perception towards them. This course seeks to establish a credible relationship of products and ser-vices with the user, technology and environment. The course aims to train young professionals with a thorough grounding in the systems approach to holistic problem solving processes, a sensitivity of concerns towards the environment and needs of dif-ferent user groups.
The objectives of this Programme are to develop an understanding of the field of Transportation Design with respect to the discipline of Industrial Design and to de-velop skills in analysis, concept generation, formulation of design strategies, problem solving, product detailing, communication and teamwork.
Transportation & Automobile Design
INTRODUCTION12
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
INTRODUCTION 13
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
The Ford Foundation is an independent, nonprofit grant-making organization. For more than half a century it has worked with courageous people on the frontlines of social change worldwide, guided by its mission to strengthen democratic values, reduce poverty and injustice, promote international cooperation, and advance human achievement. With headquarters in New York, the foundation has offices in Latin America, Africa, the Middle East, and Asia.
The Ford Foundation was established on Jan. 15, 1936 by Edsel Ford, whose father Henry, founded the Ford Motor Company. During its early years, the founda-tion operated in Michigan under the leadership of Ford family members. Since the founding charter stated that resources should be used “for scientific, educational and charitable purposes, all for the public welfare,” the foundation made grants to many kinds of organizations.
Edsel’s son, Henry Ford II, was a key figure in the foundation from 1943 to 1976. Serving variously as president, chairman and member of the board of trust-ees, he oversaw its transformation from a local Detroit foundation to a national and international organization. Today, the Ford Foundation, led by Luis Ubiñas, remains committed to advancing human welfare. Headquartered in New York City, Ford Foundation makes grants in all 50 states and, through 10 regional offices around the world, supports programs in more than 50 countries.
The Ford Foundation supports visionary leaders and organizations working on the frontlines of social change worldwide, with a goal to:
• Strengthen democratic values
• Reduce poverty and injustice
• Promote international cooperation
• Advance human achievement
The Ford Foundation works mainly by making grants or loans that build knowledge
and strengthen organizations and networks. The Ford Foundation diploma/research funding scheme at the National Institute of Design has, over the years, become a cru-cial component that assures in-house funding for diploma projects for students and also for faculties, and supports research-based projects that go in-line with the Ford Foundation ideology.
“A research based study on driver behaviour and cognition, with a focus on temporal orientation, aiming to improve vehicle safety.”
To reach any destination, one needs to know three basic things – Where am I?, Where do I have to go? and How to get there? In the bigger picture, the answers to these questions form the basis of any mobility task.
The kind of information that acts as indicator may be architectural, graphic, auditory, olfactory or even astronomical. However, how the human mind interprets this information, is purely psychological & rooted deep down the Hippocampal sec-tion of the brain. Mobility, from a wayfinding perspective, can be considered as a spatial problem solving technique. The information provided at each node & land-mark act as cues that help reach the destination with minimal loss of time and with maximum safety, thus, most efficiently.
For proper processing, the information needs to be provided at the right place & in the right amount, so that necessary action can be taken at the right time. This is essential for safety & other critical functions. The design of any human-machine interface is based on these principles of information processing.
However, in addition to the three basic questions regarding mobility, there is another aspect that is often taken for granted. The question how much time will it take?, even if not expressed explicitly, always has an estimated answer to it. The hu-man mind has the tendency and the capacity to automatically estimate the time dura-tion for a particular event. This aspect of information processing is called temporal orientation – orientation with respect to time. We, as humans, inadvertently expect and measure the changes that occur from start to finish, and ‘guess’ the expected time, for time is the measure of change. This ‘body clock’ is what dictates our behav-ioral patterns and that’s how we ‘move with the times’.
In the field of vehicular design, research is underway & a lot of assistive inter-faces are already prominent in the market. Technologies like Adaptive Cruise Control,
Lane Departure Warning, Collision Warning Devices, Adaptive Headlamps etc. are already available in cars abroad. The primary aim of these interfaces is to assist the driver in case of uncontrollable conditions and provide a safe solution to escape any obstacles or aberrations on the road. These technologies, however, are based on spa-tial & behavioral pattern recognitions and little has been done in the field of temporal orientation.
This project is aimed at studying the behaviour of the driver from a temporal perspective, and how these principles of cognition can be applied to vehicular safety.
The total number of accidents reported by all the States/ Union Territories (UTs) in India in the year 2005 were 4,39,255 of which 19% were fatal; the number of persons killed in the accidents were 94,968 (i.e. an average of one fatality per 4.6 accidents) and; the number of persons injured at 4,65,282 exceeded total number of accidents (4,39,255) in 2005.
Furthermore, 80% of all the road accidents have been attributed to the driver’s negligence/fault. The so-called human element of error could be due to in-hospitable conditions (e.g. heavy vehicles), time of day, or sheer negligence, but most importantly, it is due to insufficient information provided to the user on how to tackle the problem and the user having to rely upon his/her limited mental functions.
In Ahmedabad, over 2600 cases of road accidents have been reported in the year 2001 alone, with about 160 to 200 persons getting killed.
India, being a country run mostly according to one’s own free will, cannot rely solely on training programmes and policies. Nor can it rely on technology alone. Thus, considering mobility as one of today’s most basic needs, and considering safety as today’s biggest concern, design needs to go hand-in-hand with knowledge-based methods if vehicular safety is to be strengthened.
Project BriefFord Foundation
INTRODUCTION14
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
INTRODUCTION 15
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
The Driving Task SystemThe initial set of guidelines in the form of the driving task system model.
This page has been intentionally left blank.Please turn over for the next section.
LITERATURE STUDY16
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
LITERATURE STUDY 17
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
The Driving Task
Time - The Fourth Dimension
Factors Affecting Perceived Time
Time and Cognition
Microstrategies and Recognition
Driver Behaviour
Vehicular Interfaces
Interface Design
Driving is a multi-sensory task. While driving, we see, we hear, we smell, we touch. Most importantly, we experience and we remember. The sights we see, the sounds we hear, the smells we smell, the road bumps we feel - all register in our memory as experiences that help us plan our next drive.
As the saying goes, “you never forget how to drive!” Driving in an environ-ment requires not only physical skill, but also involves highly complex strategies (or micro strategies) that dictate the action(s) being taken. Driving, thus, requires con-tinuous processing of information - information that comes in the form of space and time.
The driving system is made of interactions that happen at three different levels. The first level of interaction is that between the driver and the vehicle. This includes various information displays and controls primarily within the vehicle. The displays are in the form of indications regarding speed, fuel, gear markings etc. and the controls are primarily in the form of steering, accelerator & braking. This forms the control component of the driving task.
The next level of interaction is that between the vehicle and the road. Road geometries, surfaces, the transportation networks etc. help the driver in negotiating a route and thus, form the guidance aspect of driving. Guidance also includes interac-tion between different vehicles.
The third level is the interaction between the road and the driver. From a psy-chological standpoint, this is an important level of interaction, as the traffic signs and landmarks encountered en route shape the driver’s perception of the next journey. At the same time, these are informational cues that help the driver plan his/her route. This forms the navigational aspect of the driving task.
The outermost layer is the environment, which does not directly interact with the elements of the driving task system, but aids in the different levels of interaction. For example, ambient illumination directly affects visual perception, thus modify-
ing the way some displays are read. On the same lines, a rainy day might change a person’s driving plans, without necessarily directly interfering with his/her driving capabilities.
literature study
16
The Driving Task
17
19
21
22
24
27
30
31
LITERATURE STUDY18
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
LITERATURE STUDY 19
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Navigation
Environment
ControlGuidance
DrivingTask
The Driving TaskThe driving task system at the macro level, as the interaction between control, guidance & navigation, and the share of environmental inputs.
Time has different definitions based on different interpretations. In the shortest pos-sible definition, time is the measure of change. “Change in what?”, if someone asks - time is a measure of change in events, an event being anything having a spatial and a temporal presence.
Mathematically, time is a first-order derivative of any event. Time is the con-stant in the universe with respect to which, we measure everything else. The phrase “passage of time” could merely translate to “a perception of changes in events around us”.
Why do we measure time? Why do we look at the clock for everything? With technology, we’ve given in to the need for measuring time to the very second (and millisecond in case of racers). Is it technology that is dictating our perception of time? Or is it our need to measure precise time durations that’s driving technology? What seems as a chicken-egg analogy led to another question - if the clock weren’t there, what would we measure against? We would probably revert to seasons (or larger frames of reference) but again, seasons prove as being a clock of sorts. This argument, then, modified the discourse to if we didn’t have a constant reference of change, how would events be measured?
The human body has definitive cycles: sleep cycles, hunger, menstrual cycles etc. These patterns constitute a certain rhythm, called Circadian rhythm (circa - around, diem - day). The human body tends to adjust to the environmental change patterns and in ways, we can assert that the circadian rhythm is an adaptation to the environment. This body clock is what makes us move with the times and repeats itself in a uniformly fashion. The human body, thus, is a metronome.
This led to the argument that if the clock really weren’t there, would there actually be a need to measure events?
The answer to the question above lies in ‘the perception of time’ - what ex-actly it is that we feel passing. Lexically, there can be sense made out of time in man
ways:
• Duration sense (time is passing)
• Event sense (5 minutes from time)
• Moment sense (now is the time)
• Instance sense (5 times in a row)
• Agentative sense (time heals)
• Measurement-system sense (standard time)
• Commodity sense (time is money)
• Matrix sense (time is eternal)
Time perception is an experience (as it involves a sense) and time can be con-sidered as the space occupied by the mind (as it is purely psychological).
Time - The Fourth Dimension
LITERATURE STUDY20
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
LITERATURE STUDY 21
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
The Unified Field TheoryA famous 1930 comic strip on Albert Einstein by Sidney ‘George’ Strube. This strip has been cited in a number of time-perception studies.
Characteristics of the time period. These include the du-ration and size of the stimulus, and also the activities between two stimuli.
Age. Age has a direct relation with information processing capacity of the brain and hence, affects perception.
Gender. Males have superior prospective duration judgements while females are better at retro-spective judgements.
Psychological Loads. Stressors prolong information processing while motivators reduce informa-tion processing.
Factors Affecting Psychological Time
LITERATURE STUDY22
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
LITERATURE STUDY 23
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Information processing takes place in the human brain in stages. These stages of information processing, in turn, register in the memory as experiences, and shape future situations. How does one define “future situations?” A situation is defined in terms of a number of factors. These include the surrounding environment, goals, the system, the crew, the available human/physical resources etc.
Sensation and perception occur in the human brain in terms of space (landmarks, signage etc.) and time (speed, environmental time etc.). Furthermore, sensation could be in terms of different types of sensory input (visual, auditory, tactile etc.). The interpretation of this spatial and temporal information, and the projection of this interpre-tation onto the immediate future, decides the course of action for the user performing a task. Also, the action(s) taken by the user are stored in the memory as experiences that help in the next cycle of information processing.
The most important link in the cycle of information processing is of expectancies and estimations.
Estimations are essentially calculations made in the mind about certain events that are about to happen. These have a cyclic relation with expectancies, which are “beliefs about the future”. Based on what to expect, the human mind makes calculations in terms of space and time. These could be the field of safe travel, time to impact, speed of the vehicle in front, traffic speed etc.
Experienced time (prospective and retrospective durations) and cognitive time (semantic and episodic expe-
Situation AwarenessRepresentation showing the stages of in-formation processing and their analogous situation awareness stages.
riences) are based on expectancies that help make estima-tions regarding situations. Psychological time is, hence, an important ingredient of situation awareness.
Driving as a Memory ProcessFlowchart model showing the components of the driving task and the associated memory processes. At each level, there is a cyclic relation be-tween expectancies and estimations, which translate into actions.
Time and Cognition
LITERATURE STUDY24
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
LITERATURE STUDY 25
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
The driver is the human component of the vehicle system, which is responsible for maintaining vehicle path and speed while in motion. This is achieved through an interaction between the driver’s visual, cognitive & psychomotor actions (which form the constituents of the driving task system).
The task is accomplished at three different adaptation levels – strategic, tactical & operational. While the task at the strategic level involves route planning and other navigational aspects, tactical and operational levels directly involve the driver’s visual, cognitive and psychomotor abilities. Tactical sub-tasks involve negotiating speed limits, maintaining time-headway etc (control). Operational sub-tasks are concerned with the driver’s cognitive abilities such as seeking information at traffic intersections, increased attention while taking turns etc (guidance). At each of the three levels, the driving task involves formation of microstrategies, involving the driver’s aforemen-tioned abilities. Microstrategies are information processing activities at the cardinal level, i.e, when the time required for an action is of the order of 1-100 ms.
Consider a rather complicated scenario where a driver has to take a detour through a residential road, where while taking a U-turn, a child comes in the way to catch his football. Taking the detour involves planning an alternate route that’ll take the driver to his/her destination with minimal delay. Driving through the residential neighbourhood is a tactical task as the driver needs to negotiate speeds and time-headways owing to the population distribution (vehicular as well as human) on the residential road. While taking the U-turn, the task demands increased attention (seek-ing road extremity, watching out for intervening traffic etc) in addition to the reduced speed.
The child appearing in front of the car suddenly is a hazard to both the driver and the child. This requires the driver to first perceive the situation as a hazard, and apply brakes immediately at a safe gap from the child. Also, the driver needs to make sure that his/her sudden braking does not put the traffic behind his/her vehicle to an abrupt stop (which in most cases is inevitable) and that there is no damage to any
entity on the road.
At each level of the above-mentioned scenario, the driver is confronted with situations that need not necessarily conform to his/her expectancies. In such cases, the perception of events (in space and time) imposes a greater load on the driver’s information processing activities and hence, demands greater attention. In turn, this increased load on information processing increases the driver’s reaction time.
The driving task, hence, is a task that involves continuous strategy formation – essentially to optimize time – and in cases of impulse situations as the one consid-ered above, immediate action to optimize safety in the situation.
The behavior of a driver in different situations can be explained through the Recognition-Primed Decision Making (RPD) model. The model defines “typicality” in terms of expectancies, courses of action, goals and relevant cues in the environment. In case of routine activities, the situation is recognized as typical, and the course of action is, generally, obvious to the user.
DrivingTask
Navigation
Strategic
Operational
TacticalEnvironment
ControlGuidance
The Driving Task - Level 2The driving task system showing operational, tactical & strategic components.
Microstrategies and Recognition
LITERATURE STUDY26
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
LITERATURE STUDY 27
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Situation Assessment
Take Action
Situation Typical?
Expectancies
Relevant Cues
Goals
Typical Action
Encountered Simi-lar Situation?
Situation Recognizable
Situation Not Recognizable
The flowchart shows the RPD model applied to each deci-sion node in the adjoining scenario.
Risk
Analogy/Story-building
RecognitionExpected ‘course of action’.
SituationA rather unforeseen one.
Micro-strategiesTackling unfamiliar situations.
Driver behaviour can be defined as the actions a driver takes in order to main-tain a safe travel path. These actions not only depend on external factors, but also rely heavily on psychological factors. E.g., a woman driving to meet her hospitalized mother would “behave” completely differently as compared to a man dropping his son to school, who in turn, would have different behaviour as that of a truck driver.
The primary actions - steering, accelerator and brake - are those that are performed continuously and are necessary to maintain a safe path while driving. Ac-tions like pressing the clutch lever, shifting gear etc. can be considered as secondary functions that supplement the primary actions. Other actions like rolling down the window, horn etc. are tertiary functions that are not required throughout the driving task.
Driver behaviour is affected by a number of psychological and physiologi-cal factors. The first of these is distraction. A distracting activity could be anything from wandering thoughts to billboards, or a flash of light at the corner of the eye, or changing the song on the car-stereo.
Another psychological factor that affects driver behaviour is motivation. A high motivation level increases the mental well-being of a driver and affects the pri-mary actions. Motivation also has an inverse relation with perceived duration. Highly motivated journeys (or journeys towards a certain goal), thus, seem to pass quickly. Emotions also play a major role as an internal factor. Segregative emotions (anger, hatred etc.) generally tend to make a driver behave in a rash and erratic way, while intergrative emotions (love, friendship, reunion etc.) tend to calm the driver down. For example, driving to the hospital to meet her ill mother would tend to make a woman drive without much control.
The driving task is derived of the driver’s visual, cognitive and psychomotor abilities – human characteristics that depend on a variety of factors. Age is an obvious such factor. With age, there is a proven decline in visual and physical abilities. Older drivers have problems while negotiating turnings, intersections, crowds etc. Vision
deterioration resulting in a failure to read/understand traffic dynamics only adds to their woes. The same vision problems give them a higher degree of field dependence as they are unable to separate relevant visual cues from the overall picture. Attention span gets affected, and so does memory capability. All this lead to a decline in spatial problem solving and wayfinding abilities, hence directly affecting their driving behav-iour.
Although gender does not have any direct relation to how people drive, gen-der differences do have an impact on certain underlying principles of cognition and behaviour. Where motor skills are concerned, males have been known to be better at movements that involve larger amplitude (e.g. throwing a ball, stopping/catching a moving object, aiming etc). Females, on the other hand, are adept at finer move-ments (e.g. manipulating hand shapes, finger movements etc).
Men and women are known to show different spatial abilities as well. While men find it easier to visualize an object in different orientations (mental rotation), women have memory to their advantage. This leads to a major difference between the sexes when it comes to wayfinding – men’s mental rotation ability makes it easy for them to visualize directions egocentrically. Men find it easier to break down a journey into directions and segments. Women, on the other hand, use landmarks as reference, owing to their memory ability.
Although there are differences between the abilities of the sexes, there is no answer to which one is better, or more specifically, who the better driver is. Driving, as a task, relies as much on mental rotation as it does on memorizing landmarks. The fact that there are more male drivers in India than female drivers is not because of capability, but because of social conditioning, and should not be taken as indicating one gender being superior/inferior to the other.
Driver fatigue is a human factor that is largely responsible for accidents. Seen mostly in extreme driving conditions (e.g, truck drivers), fatigue is the feeling of tired-ness resulting from long hours of work, long periods since sleep, and also from the
Driver Behaviour
LITERATURE STUDY28
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
LITERATURE STUDY 29
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
time of the day. Fatigue usually results in a decline in the driver’s appraisal of his own capabilities, and hence, affects driving behaviour, resulting in accidents in extreme cases.
DrivingTask
Navigation
Strategic
Operational
TacticalEnvironment
ControlGuidance
Secondary
Clutch
Gear
Horn
Headlamp
Turn Indicator
Primary
Brake
Acceleration
Steering
Tertiary
A/C
Wiper
Window
Ignition
Gender
Driver Behaviour
EventsColourDetail
InattentionSudden Change
DistractionSalience
Attention
Situational Blindness
Vision DeteriorationField Dependence
WayfindingInformation ProcessingSpatial Problem Solving
Cognitive
Psychomotor
Visual
Age Medicinal Dependence
Decline in Abilities
Temporary Impairments
AlcoholDrugs
MedicationStress/Anger
MotivationIntegrative
Segregative
GoalsEmotion
Spatial TasksMemory TasksRisk PerceptionMotor Skills
Fatigue Time of DayTime since SleepHours of Work
Factors affecting driver behaviourVarious factors contributing to driving behaviour.
LITERATURE STUDY30
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
LITERATURE STUDY 31
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
An interface is defined as a platform on which interaction between human and the machine takes place. An interface, thus, consists of controls to operate the machine and displays to show relevant information. In the field of vehicular design, interfaces range from the simple dashboard/instrument panel to more advanced as-sistive interfaces. Technologies like Adaptive Cruise Control, Lane Departure Warn-ing, Collision Warning Devices, Adaptive Headlamps etc. are already equipped onto vehicles. The primary aim of these interfaces is to assist the driver in case of uncon-trollable conditions and provide a safe solution to escape any obstacles or aberrations on the road.
Vehicular safety systems can be grouped into in-built, information, warning and assistive systems, with each type of system having a different degree of operator control. In-built systems, e.g anti-lock braking, traction control, adaptive highbeam, autonomous cruise control etc. are mostly fully automated and require almost no op-erator control. In-built systems are integrated to the vehicle speed and trajectory and regulate any deviating trends in vehicle movement.
Information systems, or in-vehicle navigation systems, are satellite-based route guidance systems. As an interface, these systems give route information from a survey perspective (top-view, north-up) or a route perspective (first person, heads-up).
Warning and assistive systems are automated to the extent of not interfering with operator control, and let the operator decide the best action based on the in-formation output. Feedback is given in the form of visual indications, auditory signals and/or in some cases, tactile feedback.
While standard vehicular interfaces adhere to guidelines deviced on the prin-ciples of cognition, most new technologies work on spatial & behavioral pattern rec-ognitions of the drivers. The difficulties in “measuring” psychological time has made technology rely on distance and speed calculations to include the dynamics of driving.
A little thought can be given to the efficacy of the existing assistive interfaces
owing to the different degrees of distraction that they offer. Visual feedback is mostly concentrated within the interface, which forces the driver to look for and look at the incoming signal. Auditory feedback may not always be salient and may tend to get subdued in the loud and chaotic environment, especially in a country like India.
In terms of research underway, active safety is taking the spotlight. Active safety is the term being used for interfaces that adapt to the driver’s characteristics and drive conditions. The question is, however, what level of safety do vehicles in India really require? Subsequently, are the safety features equipped to automobiles today sufficient? In other words, this could even spawn a debate over the need for advanced safety systems for India.
Concerns• Can technology “measure” psychological time?
• Can experiential design mitigate errors?
• How efficient are the interfaces?
• How distracting are the interfaces?
• What level of safety is required in India?
• What level of safety is available in India?
• Can an alternative to active safety be proposed for India?
Vehicular Interfaces Interface Design
An interface is considered ‘humane’ if it is responsive to human needs and consider-ate to human frailties. In other words, an interface should understand a) the scope of the user in the system, and, b) the user’s conscious and unconscious triggers that invoke a response or an action.
Going by the pedagogy that information should be present at the right place, right time and in the right amount, an interface can be considered as that informa-tion system which takes into account the user’s information needs and presents the required information in a form that is easy for the user to read, comprehend and act upon. In case of the driving task, this is essentially in the form of control, guidance and navigational information (which has been discussed in detail throughout the document, and especially in the Design section).
Since driving is a task where information acquisition happens while on the move, there are limitations to providing information inside as well as outside the vehicle. User-centered design of automobile interfaces, hence, focuses majorly on information presentation as well as information hierarchy. The following guidelines are followed while designing any information system:
• Keep systems simple.
• Provide visual and auditory information in emergency situations.
• Provide as much control to operator as possible.
• Use special-purpose lighting to make low-contrast targets more visible.
• Use colour and shape coding.
• Provide illustrated instructions.
• Minimize small print.
Various legibility scales can be used for graphics and type and generally as a guideline, high-contrast colours are used. However, while choosing colours, care
should be taken as driving is a task that is carried out in different light conditions and after-image formation poses a serious cognitive threat to drivers.
For deciding the information structure, an abstraction hierarchy is followed for which, it become mandatory to know what the functional meaning of different informational parameters is (e.g., time means sensing change, speed means sensing movement etc.).
Deciding the physical form is usually the last stage of user-centered design, where the user’s mental models are used for designing graphics, text messages and even colours. Following the abstraction hierarchy, the physical form should map to the functional meaning in order for the interface to be more efficient and hence, more usable.
FRAMEWORK32
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
FRAMEWORK 33
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
How do Drivers Perceive Time?
Safety Trends
Where do Accidents Occur?
Conclusion
Methodology9 male participants in Ahmedabad were interviewed, with questions based on a questionnaire. The 9 participants included 6 professional drivers, and 3 personal car drivers. The professional drivers, in turn, consisted of taxi drivers as well as drivers employed for personal service. The questionnaire aimed at understanding the driver’s perception of time and what importance time actually held as part of his driving pro-fession/task. The questions were slotted according to the following:
• The driver’s profile - age, experience, type of service/vehicle.
• The driver’s daily activity pattern – distance/trips per day and activities in-between trips.
• Familiarity and attention – how does the driver familiarize with a route, how he remembers the same route, and how sudden changes are encountered.
• Time-behaviour study – what ‘time’ means to the driver and how does that dictate his behaviour.
Certain indicators that were identified were discomfort in different parts of the body, the driver’s manner of presenting himself (indicating to what degree he achieves his primary driving goal) and speed, which was considered as the primary indicator of driving behaviour.
Personal Information• Age
• Vehicle
• Experience
• Shift/Drive Hours
• Distance/Trips per day
• Rest between trips?
• Activities between trips?
• Route (constant/variable)
• How familiar are you with the route?
• How long did it take for you to familiarize?
• Can you explain the route you take?
the area.
• How do you encounter sudden changes to the route?
• How do you tackle sudden obstructions on the route?
Time• What is your primary goal? • Reaching on time
• Reaching safe• Least vehicle damage• Other (specify)
• What are the implications of losing time?
• How do you make up for lost time?
Behaviour• When/where do you speed up?
• Why do you speed up?
• Does it ache after a drive?
SAMPLE
framework
32
How do Drivers Perceive Time?
33
37
39
46
FRAMEWORK34
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
FRAMEWORK 35
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
temporal behavioral
RESPECThigh self-esteem
well-spokenlevel-headed
cautiousclientelle
FREEDOMenjoys stature
free speechpanics often
temperamentalthrill
SAFETYhigh self-esteem
well-spokenpanics often
cautiousenjoys driving
MONEYlow self-esteem
anxietypanics often
temperamentallivelihood
COMMITMENTrespects others
over-confidentlevel-headed
selflessprofession
PEACE of MINDcasual
well-spokenpractical
temperamentalprofession
the clientelle he serves indicates his standing as a professional. he can’t afford to lose punctuality and maintains upto 30 minutes buffer time.
driving is a very func-tional and occasionally recreational activity for him. safety is always his priority and he maintains buffers upto 30 minutes to avoid any panic.
driving is his only source of livelihood and he sees time as a commodity that has a monetary equivalent. he has to keep track of time as that is essential to his service & money and often needs to make up for lost time.
he loves the thrill of driving, and also his own stature on the road. his daily commute requires coordinating with a standard timing and that coordination dictates his behaviour.
delivery of service and his commitments is his prime objective. his confidence and familiarity with the routes he takes gives him a high degree of freedom and very less anxiety about time. occasionally, he tries to make up for lost time.
even though he has professional demands to be met, he prefers having complete peace of mind. he maintains time buffers upto 15 minutes and does not feel the need to hurry up.
time buffer keeps track of time
loses time does not speed up
speeds up occasionally
speeds up often
due to his low temporal demand, he never speeds up and almost always, reaches his destination on time.
he speeds up only on recreational drives. he generally keeps low temporal demands and does not speed up to make up lost time.
time is money for him and he always has an urgency to reach his destination. he often speeds up to reach his clients/destination.
speeds up often on empty roads. also, he takes advan-tage of his stature and tries to dominate subordinate traffic.
he is committed to the delivery of his service and often speeds up to ensure quality. however, his confi-dence makes him adept at handling speeds.
he likes to drive with complete peace of mind. getting late by a few minutes is acceptable to him as long as it ensures a peaceful commute.
safety indicator
HeadFatigue
Stress
EyesVision
IlluminationFatigue
ShouldersFatigue
ElbowsFatigue
Lower BackFatigue
Discomfort
HandsGrips
KneesFatigue
Over-usage of components
FeetFatiguePosture
Over-usage of components
Left - ClutchRight - Accelerator, Brake
Left - Gearshift, SteerRight - Steer
physiological
pain/discomfort in body
personalityFigure 2. Personae building and behavioral and physiological implications of temporal orientation
9 -a
The findings of the survey were con-solidated and analysed by building six different personae based on their driv-ing goals. As per the literature review, perceived time is the rate of achieve-ment of a goal. Hence, it has been as-sumed that how a driver perceives time is his ultimate goal for which he drives a vehicle. moderate
high
low
yes
no
maintain speed
track time
destination?
speed upurgency?
start
end
GoalMotivationExperience
Temporal OrientationSense of Duration
Timing DeviceCoordinate with Timing System
Temporal DemandCombination of goal and
temporal orientation
Spatial OrientationSpatial Confirmation
Behaviour
AchievementPersonal
ProfessionalPsychological
Intuition, Body Clock, Traffic etc.ClockMusic, Train Timings etc.
Clientelle, Livelihood, ThrillFamiliarity, Confidence
Accelerator, Brake, SteeringHorn, Gearshift, Clutch
Panic, Temperament
Destination
Safety, LivelihoodMoney, Respect, Commitment, ServicePeace of Mind, Freedom
behaviour loop personalityindicators
What came across as interesting was how the par-ticipants of the interview regulated their temporal loads by keeping track of time in different ways. For some service drivers (cab, taxi etc.), reminders from clients served as a track of time. The most in-teresting case was one participant who used music and song durations to estimate time.
A comprehensive flow model was built for analy-sis, showing the link between driver behaviour and safety.
FRAMEWORK36
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
FRAMEWORK 37
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Trac
k of
Tim
e Distances Travelled
Music
Speed
Instinct
Standard Timing
Timing Device
Traffic
Calls from Clients
Expected Distance/Time
Rhythm
Song Duration
No. of Songs Played
Intuition
Body Clock
Experience
Familiarity with Place
Train Timing
Siren
Rush Hour
Traffic Speed
Wrist Watch
Dashboard Clock
Environmental Time
Phone Calls
Messages
Attention
Semantic Memory
Episodic Memory
Expectancy/Estimation
In retrospect, it is worthy to think about how this inter-nal time-keeping affects temporal loads of drivers. All the driver groups kept track of time, and the efficiency of their individual time-keeping techniques could de-pend upon a variety of factors. For example, a phone call from a client means immediate distraction, which could, in turn, cause a lot of safety issues while driving.
An analysis was done for the temporal orientation of the driver groups. It can be established that extrinsic time-measures are often attention-demanding, while intrinsic time-measures come across as and with expe-rience.
MethodologyThe four-wheeler market of India was studied with respect to safety features in the vehicles available. Showroom brochures and official websites of four-wheeler manu-facturers were referred for this part of the study. The aim of this part of the study was to understand the average safety level of the traffic in India, and to generalize that into the average safety requirement of the Indian driver.
0 30 60 90 120 150
Structural
Airbags
ABS
Brake Assist
TCS
Reverse Assist
Stability Control
ABS w/ EBD
SummaryThe 9 major automobile brands available in India were compared. The number of car models currently available from these manufacturers is 54 (excluding phased out models), with the total number of variants amounting to 162. All the 162 variants provide structural safety, in terms of child lock, collapsible steering column, crumple zones etc. This is the mandatory level of safety that is required by ARAI standards.
47 variants provide airbags. Dual airbags are optional in certain cars, but driver side airbag is provided. Anti-lock braking (ABS) is available across 62 variants out of which, 25 provide ABS with Electronic Brakeforce Distribution (EBD). Advanced features such as brake assist, traction control (TCS), reverse assist and stability control are available only on higher range models.
Automobile models studied using showroom brochures, internet information etc.
Safety Trends
FRAMEWORK38
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
FRAMEWORK 39
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
This study opened up a discussion as to what the average safety level in the Indian traffic scenario is. A quick comparison to the global market would surely mean Indian automobiles are lagging far behind, but the question is, what is the safety require-ment for vehicles in India?
Rugged terrains and the average maintenance level of roads in India make structural stabil`ity a must for any vehicle. Airbags may not be deemed extremely necessary as most traffic in India is bumper-to-bumper and high speeds are attained mostly on highways and at rare times on empty city roads.
Features like ABS and traction control may be considered required owing to pertinent slippery/kaccha road conditions in India, while those such as reverse assist are upcoming trends owing to the increased number of parking spaces, urban land use patterns etc.
The safety features available in the Indian automobile market today are all passive. The question would now move on to whether India needs active safety at all? Or is there a scope for dynamic information interfaces to make their way into the market, complimenting the passive features that are already available?
Methodology4 road stretches of Ahmedabad were identified with the highest accident rate per km and taken for study of road, traffic and other factors contributing to the high acci-dent rates. Observations were made and informal interviews were conducted with the local population of these areas, regarding:
• Road characteristics - road profile, length, obstructions on the road stretch, rush hour timings etc.
• Traffic characteristics - traffic speed, traffic direction, vehicle distribution etc.
• Accident characteristics - nature and time of accidents, accident-prone zones on the stretch, impact on surrounding traffic, cause of accidents. ?
Vasna - Sarkhej: 261
Parimal Garden - Mithakali: 221
Income Tax - Commerce College: 296
Mirzapur - Vijali Ghar: 348
SummaryAccident rates on each of the 4 segments and the overall vehicle distribution between these segments. The grey sectors indicate the share of each vehicle type and the yellow area indicates proneness to accidents for each vehicle type.
Where do Accidents Occur?
FRAMEWORK40
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
FRAMEWORK 41
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
AccidentFrequency - highNature/damage - mild - moderateCritical zones - triangular intersections, school/court crossing, other intersectionsTime - mostly during rush hours, school timing Effect on traffic - hold-ups for 15-20 minsReason - speeding, overtaking on narrow lanes, buses negotiating blind curves
RoadLength - 1 km (approx.)Type - city road, no lanesHigh traffic hours - 10 am - 12 pm, 4 pm - 8 pmOther - busy bus route, vehicles parked on road, buses take up entire road width, school/court on road
TrafficDirection - both sidesType - mixedSpeed - 30 km/h (approx)
Mirzapur - Vijali Ghar
AccidentFrequency - highNature/damage - mild - moderateCritical zones - intersections, school crossing, construction siteTime - mostly during rush hours,school timingEffect on traffic - mild hold-upsReason - speeding, absense of speed-bumps
RoadLength - 2 km (approx.)Type - city road, 3/3 lane on Ashram Road, no lanes otherwiseHigh traffic hours - 8 am - 8 pmOther - busy bus route, CG Road in-tersection, railway crossing on route, vehicles parked on road
TrafficDirection - commercial areas on both ends, school/college towards Com-merce CollegeType - mixedSpeed - 50 km/h (approx)
Income Tax - Commerce College
FRAMEWORK42
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
FRAMEWORK 43
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
AccidentFrequency - highNature/damage - mild - highCritical zones - signalsTime - mostly during rush hours, night time on empty roadEffect on traffic - mild hold-upsReason - speeding, jumping traffic signals
RoadLength - 1.5 km (approx.)Type - city road, 2/2 laneHigh traffic hours - 8-11 am, 6-8 pmOther - vehicles parked on road, no bus-stops, traffic signals/circles at ev-ery intersection, shopping area lights/billboards
TrafficDirection - equal, slightly towards Parimal Garden in eveningType - mixedSpeed - 50 km/h (approx) Parimal Garden - Mithakali
AccidentFrequency - highNature/damage - mild - moderateCritical zones - intersectionsTime - mostly during rush hours,school timingEffect on traffic - mild hold-upsReason - speeding, blind intersections, absense of speedbumps,absence of traffic signal on the stretch
RoadLength - 3.5 km (approx.)Type - city road, 2/2 laneHigh traffic hours - 8-11 am, 6-8 pmOther - 4 bus-stands on the stretch
TrafficDirection - towards Sarkhej in morning, towards Vasna in eveningType - mixedSpeed - 50 km/h (approx)
Vasna - Sarkhej
FRAMEWORK44
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
FRAMEWORK 45
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Vasna - Sarkhej
Parimal Gdn - Mithakali
Income Tax - Commerce College
Mirzapur - Vijali Ghar
No traffic signal on entire stretchAbsent/misplaced speed bumpsBusy bus routeConnection to highway
Well-developed roadsTraffic circles at intersectionsSignage well-placedBusy bus route
No speed bumpsCertain segments are without lanesBusy bus route
Triangular intersectionsBuses overtaking on narrow lanesBusy bus route
Mor
ning
rush
8 - 1
1 AM
Afte
rnoo
n ru
sh2
- 3 P
M
Even
ing
rush
6 - 8
PM
Time(hrs)
8 10 12 14 16 18 20
School crossingBlind intersections
Traffic signals
School crossingsItnersectionsConstruction site
School crossingOvertakingIntersections
Road
Ch
arac
teri
stic
s
Caus
es/
Criti
cal Z
ones
AnalysisAn analysis of road characteristics, accident times and critical zones. The road characteristics were observed while accident times were found out from interviews/conversations with locals. The causes and critical zones are a result of analysis of all factors.
Except the Mirzapur - Vijali Ghar segment, all segments have end points in com-mercial areas and/or residential areas. This could lead to one possibility that rush hour accidents are caused by temporal urgency regarding reaching workplace and/or returning home. While reaching workplace is a case of pure urgency, returning home is more motivational and regressive.
Another possibility for a high accident rate on these stretches is that each of these segments falls on a busy bus route. The Vasna - Sarkhej segment has 4 bus-stands over a length of 3.5 km, and timing clashes between buses is a common scenario. On the Mirzapur - Vijali Ghar stretch, which is a transit edge, the roads are not laned and there are 3 traffic intersections on the 0.75 km stretch of road. Buses overtake each other on these narrow roads which is not only a risky endeavour, but also proves hazardous for other traffic.
Erratic behaviour by bus drivers could be attributed to a number of psychologi-cal factors. Firstly, since buses ply on routes, there is a high degree of familiarity with the routes that the drivers hold. This often leads to over-confidence while negotiating tricky maneuvers and situations while driving.
Also, bus drivers live on very low perks professionally. This makes time-based incentives extremely important for them (the number of trips made per day directly contributes to any additional income they get). This leads to competition between bus drivers plying the same route due to which they overspeed and try to out-do each other.
As per the vehicle distribution, buses constitute only 10% of the traffic on these roads, but carry a good 60% of Ahmedabad’s population. Erratic behaviour by bus drivers poses a threat not only to vehicle safety, but also proves as a public safety issue.
All segments fall on busy bus routes• Speeding
• Overtaking
• Speeding/overtaking on turns
• Bus-stand placement
• Competition between buses
Possible reasons for erratic behaviour• Familiarity with route
• Over-confidence
• Time-based incentives
• Low perks on job
• Feeling of driving a big vehicle
FRAMEWORK46
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
FRAMEWORK 47
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Driving was understood as an interaction between the driver, road and vehicle, and the driver’s psychology with respect to time was studied as the core aspect of this research. The studies were carried out to realize the literature review findings and models in the Indian context, more specifically, in the context of Ahmedabad, and to propose a framework for research on psychological time and the driving task.
The overall conclusion from the literature review and the pilot studies is that there is an urgent need for automobile manufacturers to understand the psychology of the driver before arriving at design solutions. While structural safety and spatial information systems are pre-requisites in any vehicle, it is considered extremely important that the dynamics of the driving task are tackled using a driver-centered approach. Especially in a country like India where active safety and ADAS have not yet made their foray, there is tremendous op-portunity for introduction of systems that combine the static and dynamic aspects of in-vehicle information, rather than blindly going for the hi-tech systems avail-able abroad. At the same time, traffic conditions in India are highly random and mostly disorganized due to which, introducing new design solutions needs to be dealt with tactfully. As the causes of road accidents are also random, the efficacy of design solutions being implemented abroad can be deemed questionable in the Indian context.
Before arriving at a design direction, one needs to consider certain basic points about vehicular interfaces. The primary purpose of an interface is to provide information to the user regarding the current situation, and give enough cues to ease the user’s decision-making process, which are enacted through the controls.
The question is - how much information is required? Before that, what information is required? Certain displays in a vehicle are used only while starting (engine temperature, oil temperature, battery etc), while certain displays need to be continuously monitored (speed, fuel level etc). A complete task analysis of a car
Vehicle Safety
Damage to human lifeDamage to vehicleDamage to infrastructureOther damage
Faul
ty/u
nfor
esee
n co
nditi
ons
Hum
an er
ror
Miscalculations
Con
trol e
lemen
ts
PrimarySteeringSpeed
Secondary Inattention/distraction
StructuralActivePassive Inappropriate information
Stresses
Tem
pora
l
Cog
nitiv
e
Information overload
Phys
ical
Workspace
FatigueLong driving hoursNo sleep/rest
Urgency SpeedHorn
prev
ent a
ccid
ents
caused by
com
pone
nts
caus
ed b
y
panic
DriverPhys
ical
Skill
Age
Fitness
Psyc
holo
gica
l
Experience
Familiarity
Attention/memory
4-wheeler
CarVanMUV/cabMini-bus Controls Pr
imar
y
SteeringAceleratorBrake
Seco
ndar
y
ClutchGearshiftHorn
Terti
ary
StereoA/CWindow
Display
Speedometer
Odometer
Tachometer
Gauges FuelTemperatureOilBattery
Personal CommuteRecreational
Professional Personal cab serviceCab service for company/organization
Road
Surfa
ce
Geo
met
ry
EdgesIntersectionsRoutes
Info
rmat
ion
SignageSignals
Landmarks
City
LanedNo lanes
Hig
hway
NationalState
Express
SafetyRespect
CommitmentMoney
Peace of mindFreedom Time
Intrinsic
Body clockIntuition
ExtrinsicDirect
Siren/alertsCalls/messages
Clock
EstimativeMusicSpeedEnvironmental timeCoordinative time
drivesattributes has
onfo
r
goal
type
has
HumanVehicular
PavedKaccha
Animal/other
rate of achievement
track
ing
controls
navigation/planning
to achieve
are equipped with
could cause erratic usage
too much could cause
could cause
causes
lowers
is/causes
coul
d ca
use
Vehicle Safety
Damage to human lifeDamage to vehicleDamage to infrastructureOther damage
Faul
ty/u
nfor
esee
n co
nditi
ons
Hum
an er
ror
Miscalculations
Con
trol e
lemen
ts
PrimarySteeringSpeed
Secondary Inattention/distraction
StructuralActivePassive Inappropriate information
Stresses
Tem
pora
l
Cog
nitiv
e
Information overload
Phys
ical
Workspace
FatigueLong driving hoursNo sleep/rest
Urgency SpeedHorn
prev
ent a
ccid
ents
caused by
com
pone
nts
caus
ed b
y
panic
DriverPhys
ical
Skill
Age
Fitness
Psyc
holo
gica
l
Experience
Familiarity
Attention/memory
4-wheeler
CarVanMUV/cabMini-bus Controls Pr
imar
y
SteeringAceleratorBrake
Seco
ndar
y
ClutchGearshiftHorn
Terti
ary
StereoA/CWindow
Display
Speedometer
Odometer
Tachometer
Gauges FuelTemperatureOilBattery
Personal CommuteRecreational
Professional Personal cab serviceCab service for company/organization
Road
Surfa
ce
Geo
met
ry
EdgesIntersectionsRoutes
Info
rmat
ion
SignageSignals
Landmarks
City
LanedNo lanes
Hig
hway
NationalState
Express
SafetyRespect
CommitmentMoney
Peace of mindFreedom Time
Intrinsic
Body clockIntuition
ExtrinsicDirect
Siren/alertsCalls/messages
Clock
EstimativeMusicSpeedEnvironmental timeCoordinative time
drivesattributes has
onfo
r
goal
type
has
HumanVehicular
PavedKaccha
Animal/other
rate of achievement
track
ing
controls
navigation/planning
to achieve
are equipped with
could cause erratic usage
too much could cause
could cause
causes
lowers
is/causes
coul
d ca
use
display/control system forms the central framework for detailed research and analysis.
Also forming the framework is, based on the user groups studied, an in-depth study of the driver. The pilot study gave an indication of the different ways time is perceived in, and the chal-lenge was, now, to select one particular group and do a complete system study for that group.
FrameworkA complete model of the driving task. Values in red denote the framework for detailed research.
Conclusion
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS48
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS 49
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Introduction
The Cab Agency
Case Study: Meru Cabs
Case Study: Tata Indica
The Vehicle Space
The Driver: Mental Models
Persona: Wanjibhai Parmar
The research framework that followed the literature review suggested a direction in the form of “drivers who drive for money”. It was suggested that this driver group is more susceptible to systemic lapses and hence, more prone to human error.
The vehicles identified as falling under this user segment were trucks, buses & cabs. The truck was understood to be a very huge topic, not feasible to be studied alone. The bus, generally, does not have a design and it is extremely challenging to standardize any design. For this reason, considering marketability and standardization as factors alongwith an attractiveness bias, the cab segment was chosen for detailed study.
The taxi has had its own journey in India. Started in 1910 as a replacement for horse-driven carriages, the taxis that became the most popular in the 1980s were the black and yellow Hindustan Ambassadors and Premier Padminis. These were state run and metered, and were available to the public on a non-sharing basis, thus giving the comfort of an owned vehicle.
The taxi business didn’t take off until 2000, when a certain flaw with the newly released Tata Indica triggered off a revolution. A whole new segment - the luxury cab - spawned off, that came off as extremely interesting for business-minded individuals. The Indica became an instant favourite amongst tour operators as it gave a mugh higher comfort and luxury as compared to the passé Ambassadors and Pad-minis. The Indica was, overall, a much better designed vehicle, and had the “designed for India” tag attached. The line between a personal car and a taxi had began to blur.
Soon, vehicles like the Maruti Esteem, Ford Ikon etc. followed suit and the word “taxi” had become obsolete. By 2005, the cab business had already seen its next demand. In September 2006, the Dial-a-Cab service was started, which was a radio taxi service. These agencies (Dial-a-Cab, EasyCabs, Wings Radio Cabs, Forsche etc.) used latest technology to run and track their service, and were the first to em-ploy a formal driver training programme.
The year 2007 saw another revolutionary business model - the Meru cab service - that promised to deliver world-class service and maintain higher standards of driver behaviour and etiquette. Meru formalized the driver selection process even more by including health and background checkups, as opposed to the word-of-mouth selection criteria earlier.
The line between personal car and a cab has blurred even more now. The number of taxis plying on Indian roads is approximately 2,35,000. The business along with the industry has become much more organized, efficient and rewarding with many new car rental services popping up in the industry, which has also given a rea-son for the unorganized cab agent to seek.
For the purpose of this project, an Ahmedabad based travel agency, Ashapura Travels, has been studied. Also, case studies have been done on Meru and the Tata Indica.
research & analysis
48
Introduction
49
50
52
54
56
70
72
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS50
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS 51
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
The cab service agency operates through a network or branches or friends/other operators. The clientelle is usually regular, and vehicles are always made available for the clients. In case of non-availability, other operators/branches are contacted and vehicle booked accordingly.
Night travel is usually avoided, except in emergencies and in case of receiving someone from the airport. Driving shift starts at 5 AM and goes on till midnight, while office begins at 10:30 AM through 6:30 PM. In case of reporting time earlier than office timings, the memo is prepared the previous night, and its the driver’s responsibility to report on time. Drivers usually reach well before reporting time, and are most often made to wait.
The agency requires a minimum driving experience of 2 years. This, they require so that the driver is already familiar with Gujarat and outer roads before commencement of service. No special skill is required, but a taxi license is mandatory.
Billing shifts are of 80 km/8 hr or 100 km/12 hr. In case of drop-alone shifts, billing is done according to the 8 hr period. In case of trips exceeding the 12 hr shifts, over-billing is done as per the 8 hr period. However, a margin of 1-1.5 hrs is allowed in such cases, depending on how much distance has been travelled.
The agency maintains strict rules and follows a code of conduct. Drivers are motivated through a uniform, giving them a degree of self-esteem. There is an informal training programme before vehicle dispatch, where the drivers are instructed on what kind of etiquette/manners are expected out of them.
Vehicle tracking is done through a GPS-based web interface, which gives the vehicle number and its geographic location on a map at intervals of every 20-25 km. Speed is monitored with respect to mileage, and is
BOOKING
Flee
t
Driv
erD
ispat
ch MONITORING
BILLING
Che
ck
8 cabs, dieselIndica x 2Indigo x 2Qualis x 2Sumo x 1Innova x 11 driver per cab
CorporatesDelegatesFamilies
- +
Cab available?
Contactother branch
Y
N
Battery
Oil levels
Tyre pressure
Mechanicals
Min. driving experience2 yrs requiredDrivers trainedEtiquettesMannerismsTimelinessDriver UniformAvg. 200 km per day Pi
ck-u
p po
int
Home
Other
Home
Other
Site
Clie
nt
Dro
p-po
int
SpeedEmergency
Tracking
Speed maintained below 80 km/hMonitored by checking mileage
GPS-basedTracks position
Updates every 15-20 km Call sent Near tobreakdownlocation?
Transfer tonearest branch
Replacementavailable?
Transfer toother branch
Dispatch
Repairable?
Halt/repair
Replacement?
Service centre
Y N
NN
N Y Y
Y
80 km/8 hr shift
100 km/12 hr shift
Drop charges
Full trip charges
Overtime charges
margin of ~1 hr allowed
memo prepared
OFFICE TRIP RETURN
Check fuelCheck batteryCheck other components
Reach site safelyReach site on timeWait at site
Reach client on timeWait for client
Drop client to drop-pointPrepare billCollect money
Wait at siteRestEat/smoke/tea etc.
Leave vehicleDeposit money
DestinationClient details
Directions to site Vehicle statusFuel, battery,water etc.
Directions to pick-up pointDistance to pick-up pointTime required
Directions to drop-pointWithin shift?Billing information
TasksInformationrequired
BOOKING
Flee
t
Driv
erD
ispat
ch MONITORING
BILLING
Che
ck
8 cabs, dieselIndica x 2Indigo x 2Qualis x 2Sumo x 1Innova x 11 driver per cab
CorporatesDelegatesFamilies
- +
Cab available?
Contactother branch
Y
N
Battery
Oil levels
Tyre pressure
Mechanicals
Min. driving experience2 yrs requiredDrivers trainedEtiquettesMannerismsTimelinessDriver UniformAvg. 200 km per day Pi
ck-u
p po
int
Home
Other
Home
Other
Site
Clie
nt
Dro
p-po
int
SpeedEmergency
Tracking
Speed maintained below 80 km/hMonitored by checking mileage
GPS-basedTracks position
Updates every 15-20 km Call sent Near tobreakdownlocation?
Transfer tonearest branch
Replacementavailable?
Transfer toother branch
Dispatch
Repairable?
Halt/repair
Replacement?
Service centre
Y N
NN
N Y Y
Y
80 km/8 hr shift
100 km/12 hr shift
Drop charges
Full trip charges
Overtime charges
margin of ~1 hr allowed
memo prepared
OFFICE TRIP RETURN
Check fuelCheck batteryCheck other components
Reach site safelyReach site on timeWait at site
Reach client on timeWait for client
Drop client to drop-pointPrepare billCollect money
Wait at siteRestEat/smoke/tea etc.
Leave vehicleDeposit money
DestinationClient details
Directions to site Vehicle statusFuel, battery,water etc.
Directions to pick-up pointDistance to pick-up pointTime required
Directions to drop-pointWithin shift?Billing information
TasksInformationrequired
capped at 80 km/hr. In case of emergencies, depending on the severity or the breakdown, replacement cabs are sent.
The Cab AgencyThe schematic is representative of Ashapura Travels, an Ahmedabad-based travel agent, but can be con-sidered as a general representation of a cab service system.
The Cab Agency
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS52
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS 53
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
MeruThe Meru cab service was started in April 2007, with a fleet growing to 150 in January 2008. In the past 2 years, Meru has grown across 4 cities, with a GPS-tracked fleet of 3500 vehicles.
Service
Driver Fleet
TechnologyVehicle
Availability
• Pays a refundable deposit amount to Meru.• Is put through a series of medical tests.• Pays daily fees to Meru for the use of the cab.• Makes around 4-6 trips at the maximum (in and around
the city, airport to-fro trips).• Typically earns about Rs. 2500-3500 per day.• Pays for all the diesel used by him.• Takes home the entire earned amount, after paying the
daily fee.• Is free to make private arrangements with any patrons.• There are no scheduled leaves for the driver.
The
Dri
ver
at M
eru
• Selection based on driving experience and background check
• Medical checkup & formal training• Versed in Hindi, English & regional lan-
guage of State• Trained in customer service, safe driving
& hygiene
Dri
ver
• Operates in Delhi, Mumbai, Hyderabad & Bangalore
• ~3500 cabs all over India• Maruti Esteem, Mahindra Logan, Tata
Indigo cabs• 1 cab shared between 2-3 driversFl
eet
• System does not indicate weather & traffic conditions.• No map/voice on GPS device.• No multilingual support. The current system only
works in English & Hindi.
Dra
wb
acks
• Client can make a booking anytime.• ‘Lost & found’ tracking system helps track missed/left out
luggage in the vehicle.• Driver’s ID and printed receipt help report any complaints
efficiently.• Has to pay toll, parking etc. charges in addition to the
fares.
The
Clie
nt
The Meru SystemObservations and insights about the Meru service. Although Meru has received excel-lent reviews in the 3 years of functioning and there have been very few accidents/misbehaviours reported, there are clear indications of human factors issues regard-ing the driver at Meru.
• Air-conditioned• GPS-based metering unit• Speed alert alarm system• First aid kitV
ehic
le
• 24-hr cab booking facility• Door-to-door pickup/drop• Fares based on State regulations• Credit & prepaid card payment • GPS-based vehicle tracking• GPS-based fleet management• Vehicle can be flagged down if vacant
Serv
ice
Case Study: Meru Cabs
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS54
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS 55
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
In the year 1996, Ratan Tata envisioned a small car ‘that would look good in black’. In the year 1998, this was realized in the form of the Tata Indica, a car which would soon become a favourite amongst the Indian middle class, and at the same time, revolutionize the public transport scene in the country.
The launch of the Indica was amidst competition from the existing small cars, the Maruti Zen and the Fiat Uno. The Uno, highly overpriced and riding only on the Fiat brand name, would soon see the end of its stint on the Indian roads, while the Zen, even though providing good ride quality and comfort, was a little too inacces-sible to the Indian middle-class pocket. Tata Motors, hence, had their task cut out clearly in terms of on-road competitors.
However, the threats were many. The Indica was Tata Motors’ (then Telco Motors) first venture into the passenger car segment. Known for building trucks and buses, entering the car market at a price lower than that of the Zen and the Uno only meant a tough challenge. But perhaps the bigger threat was in the form of other car models slated for release in the same year. Hyundai, Maruti, Daewoo and Fiat were all looking at the newly created B segment with their announced cars, the Santro, the WagonR, the Matiz and the Palio, respectively. Also, the fact that the Indica’s release date was 30th December, it just meant that the marketing team had to do their job with pin-point accuracy.
And there it was - the Indica (abbreviated from INDIan CAr). Clever print ads, followed by TV commercials promising ‘more dreams per car’ had made the Indica enter into the Indian hearts, warranting 11,500 bookings in the very first week of its release. At a starting price of Rs. 2.59 lakhs, the Indica offered superb mileage, a tough body, a good ride, high stability, a rugged car, and heaps of space and com-fort. The higher end Indica variants also featured A/c and power windows (at Rs. 2.9 lakhs), which were available only in up-market imports till then.
The Tata Indica became an instant favourite and remained that way until Tata Motors started receiving complaints on ride quality and horsepower issues on the
Indica. The 1999-2000 period saw a huge dip in sales of the Indica after Tata Motors decided to call back all the models for necessary repairs - and this was the time when mobility in India took a turn towards minimizing the divide between owned and shared transport.
At a meagre price of Rs. 2.6 lakhs, the Indica had created a whole new seg-ment - that of the ‘Big...Small Car’. The Indica was offering comfort at a level higher than any other car in the B-segment. Also, the fact that the Indica was ‘designed for India’ made it suitable on a variety of road conditions. Options in petrol and diesel meant that the car could be used for long-distance travels as easily. Moreover, the Indica was aesthetically a well balanced design. These factors, along with the sup-posed ‘failure’ of the Indica as a driver’s car, meant a huge opportunity for taxi opera-tors, who were at the most, concerned only with costs and passenger comfort - and the Indica was alredy winning on those fronts. Capitalizing on these factors, a new system of transport emerged on the Indian roads - the shared cab. Taxis, which used to be black and yellow state-run Hindustan Ambassadors and Premier Padminis, soon found themselves a competitor, a car that would become synonymous with the word ‘taxi’ in India and knock them off the roads.
By the time Tata Motors released the Indica V2 in 2001 after rectifying the errors in the first edition, the Indica had already revolutionized the taxi scene in India. From the middle class to high officials in corporates, here was now a car that would give them the comfort of a luxury car, at the on-demand service of a taxi. The Indica soon started gaining popularity over the existing taxis and became the ideal ‘hired vehicle’ for corporates as well as families going on long trips. The release of the Indica V2 was accompanied by a CNG variant to add to the fleet. This further strengthened the taxi operators’ faith in the Indica, as CNG proved to be cheaper than petrol or diesel. By now, the Indica had begun its journey again on the Indian roads - as a pas-senger car and as a cab.
Advertising the IndicaThe very first print ads for the Indica sporting a clever ‘designed in India’ slogan that promised ‘more car per car’.
More car per car
Case Study: Tata Indica
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS56
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS 57
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
One could broadly divide human factors into physical and cognitive components. While physical factors contribute to fatigue and discomfort in different parts of the body, cognitive factors could cause information overloading and hence, psychological stresses. Errors in information acquisition could also cause physical stresses (e.g vis-ibility issues in the night), and more often than not, distractions.
Inter/intra-state cab drivers are faced with both types of the above-stated fac-tors. Having to drive 200-250 km sometimes, fatigue is very common in cab drivers. In many cases, these journeys could be overnight, in rain, on slippery roads, in dusty conditions etc. The workspace of these vehicles, thus, needs to incorporate human factors seriously and go much beyond comfort and stylish interiors.
The needs of the driver were divided into work zone and informational, and the vehicles most commonly used as cabs in Ahmedabad (and India) were audited with respect to these.
Working Zone Needs: Anthropometrics
The primary physical requirement for any work is comfort. In the case of driving, comfort is achieved through good seat design, accessibility of control components (primary, secondary and tertiary), and an overall friendly atmosphere in the working zone. This “friendly” atmosphere could include lighting, smell, sound-dampening etc., all of which contribute to a “comfortable” workspace.
Informational Needs: Interface
In today’s scenario, vehicles are offering all the information ranging from vehicle speed to what the air-conditioner level is. Vehicular interfaces are designed to give all necessary information that would aid the driver in his task. However, it is important to analyze to what detail can the information be deemed as relevant and to what extent these information agent act as distractors. The driver’s information needs can be ar-
ranged hierarchically into primary (distance, speed), secondary (battery level, fuel level etc.) and tertiary (on-road information, directions, signage etc.). In addition, time is the information that the driver can measure his rate of achievement of goals against. Ignition
Insert key Key slot location
Rotate key clockwise Gear markings
Check levels Icons on dashboard
Check neutral Neutral position Gear markings, gear lever play
Ignition ON Engine sound, vibra-tion
Move vehicle
Press clutch Clutch position
Change gear to 1 Gear positions Gear markings
Release parking brake Parking brake location Parking brake indi-cator
Accelerate Pedal movement Smooth motion, engine sound
Monitor
Task Knowledge required Feedback
Speed Speedometer, traffic This constitutes dynamic mental models, as ex-plained later in this section.
Time Clock, instinct
Direction Road, safe travel path
Stop vehicle
Press clutch Clutch position
Press brake Brake position
Release brake Vehicle motion
Change gear to neutral Neutral position Gear markings
Ignition OFF
Rotate key Two-step rotation Engine sound off
Remove key
Task Knowledge required Feedback
Hierarchical Task Analysis: The Driving TaskA hierarchical task model was made for the driving task before doing a detailed interface audit.
The Vehicle Space
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS58
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS 59
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
ClutchBrake
Accelerator
Instrument PanelAuxilliary Panel
Gearshift Lever
Auxilliary Lever
Parking Brake
Ignition Switch
Turn Indicator
Steering Wheel
Link AnalysisA link diagram based on the hierarchical task model. The combined task flow was broken down for further detailed analysis. The dotted nodes show the monitoring elements.
Workspace SchematicGeneral schematic for a 4-wheeler interface. A detailed link analysis was carried out for the same.
Start the vehicleStarting the vehicle mainly needs static mental models and training knowledge of the driving task.
MonitorMonitoring is the task that requires judgements and dy-namic mental models. The yellow shaded triangle shows the monitoring area and the lines show the actions as-sociated with the monitoring task.
Stop the vehicleStopping the vehicle also needs training knowledge on when to press the brakes and by what amounts.
Repeated component usage is a major cause of fatigue and bodily pain/discomfort.
The auxilliary panel (clock etc.) are often outside the cone of vision.
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS60
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS 61
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
The vehicle space was divided into the anthropometric workspace and the interface. A complete work-space audit was carried out for the vehicles selected and a benchmark was decided, based on the Indian anthropometric dimensions. This benchmark was considered to be the minimum requirement for any design intervention.
Anthropometric StudyValues in green are conforming dimensions while those in red are on-conforming dimensions. Values in bold are take-off points from the Indian anthropometric data.
Seat heightSeat widthSeat angleSeat pan depthFoot pedal - seat edgeFoot pedal lengthFoot pedal angleClutch - brake pedalBrake - acc. pedal
Backrest heightBackrest widthBackrest angle
Headrest lengthHeadrest widthHeadrest angleSteering wheel dia.Steering grip dia.Steering angleSteering wheel heightGear lever - H-pointGear gripFloor height (ground)Head clearanceWindow clearanceDashboard clearancecle
aran
ces
gear
steer
ing
head
rest
peda
lsse
atba
ckre
st
Tata
Indi
go
620 mm425 mm13 deg310 mm435 mm9 deg470 mm400 mm65 mm28 deg75 mm75 mm180 mm210 mm13 deg330 mm25 mm28 deg550 mm500 mm55 mm190 mm120 mm385 mm635 mm
Toyo
ta Q
ualis
600 mm510 mm13 deg270 mm420 mm19 deg470 mm370 mm60 mm33 deg90 mm90 mm180 mm260 mm13 deg320 mm30 mm30 deg470 mm550 mm50 mm480 mm110 mm345 mm690 mm
Toyo
ta In
nova
600 mm520 mm13 deg310 mm450 mm8 deg460 mm460 mm60 mm33 deg85 mm75 mm180 mm210 mm13 deg320 mm30 mm27 deg500 mm570 mm50 mm400 mm120 mm330 mm750 mm
Che
vrol
et T
aver
a
570 mm470 mm16 deg310 mm470 mm6 deg490 mm420 mm55 mm53 deg75 mm75 mm200 mm220 mm16 deg345 mm30 mm24 deg500 mm650 mm60 mm500 mm110 mm330 mm710 mm
Land
mar
k
PoplitealHip breadth-Buttock-poplitealMid-patellaFoot length-Ball of footFoot breadth
AcromionBi-deltoid-
Neck length max.Head circumference-Elbow-elbow closedGrip inside dia. max.-
Mid thigh breadth relaxedPalm lengthMid-patella-Span akimboButtock-knee length
5th
%ile
484 mm379 mm-380 mm272 mm-399 mm418 mm227 mm-299 mm83 mm94 mm520 mm-346 mm42 mm-530 mm289 mm92 mm419 mm-774 mm489 mm
-
-
50th
%ile
551 mm426 mm-425 mm331 mm
455 mm464 mm248 mm
324 mm94 mm134 mm544 mm-409 mm49 mm-587 mm369 mm103 mm464 mm-859 mm558 mm
-
-
95th
%ile
608 mm482 mm-471 mm405 mm
512 mm517 mm274 mm
354 mm106 mm162 mm574 mm-489 mm56 mm-644 mm449 mm114 mm517 mm-959 mm615 mm
± To
leran
ces
clothing, adjustibility etc.(50 mm)
-
-
interpolate w/95th Bi-acromion (422 mm)-clothing (5-10 mm)clothing (5-10 mm), extra (10-15 mm each side)
clothing (5-10 mm), calf clearance (100 mm)clothing (5-10 mm), footwear (10-25 mm)footwear (10-25 mm each side), min. 1/3rd area
radius 52 mm, footwear (15 mm), clearance (30-40 mm)footwear (10-25 mm), clearance (50 mm)adjustibiilty (50 mm)diameter 174 mm, adjustibility (50 mm)-steering cover (10 mm), gloves (5-10 mm)steering cover (10 mm), gloves (5-10 mm)-clothing (5-10 mm), footwear (10-25 mm)centre of palm (80 mm)interpolate w/5th Hand breadth with thumb (86 mm)footwear (10-25 mm)-1/2 span (480 mm), resting clearance (25-40 mm)clothing (5-10 mm), at knee (5-10 mm)
Acc
eptib
le ra
nge
590 - 610 mm390 - 410 mm17 deg360 - 380 mm420 - 440 mm7 - 10 deg290 - 300 mm400 - 420 mm95 - 100 mm30 deg100 - 120 mm110 - 130 mm150 - 200 mm200 - 250 mm17 deg270 - 300 mm25 - 30 mm25 deg630 - 650 mm550 - 650 mm85 - 95 mm390 - 410 mm100 - 130 mm420 - 440 mm590 - 610 mm
Ana
lysis
minimum acromion is taken as the landmark, but the backrest usually extends till the mid-shoulder.minimum bi-deltoid is taken as the landmark, but the backrest extends till the shoulders.
Acceptible seating angle is 17 deg. However, backrests are reclineable over a range of -10 to 175 deg.recumbent seating, a further tolerance of 50 mm can be accepted.
Seat cushioningSeat pan depth should be able to accommodate calf clearance, and too deep a seat will cause friction under the knee and cause a 5%ile to recline more.
Minimum surface contact should be 1/3rd of the foot length. However, only the underside of the toe is in contact with the pedal.Acceptible footrest angle is 30 deg, and a little amount of play is always provided in the pedals.
bi-malleolars touch each other in closed seating.right foot to access while being pivoted on one point.
Headrest lengths are adjustible by ±80-100 mm.Headrest should be wide enough too accommodate the head, but also not constrain head movement.Headrests are not reclineable, but have an acceptible angle of 10 deg w.r.t backrest plane.Steering posture should be an interpolation between a relaxed 5%ile and a closed 95%ile elbow-elbow distance.
25 deg steering angle gives a comfortable posture and a good viewing angle for pasenger cars.in between the legs and hence, these values are acceptible.
maximum range and was derived using seat pan depth, half seat width and 95%ile mid-thigh overhang.
A head clearance of 100 - 130 mm is required to accommodate bumps.
localized trim at the driver’s thigh location.
Contact points
primary
secondary
tertiary
Seat heightSeat widthSeat angleSeat pan depthFoot pedal - seat edgeFoot pedal lengthFoot pedal angleClutch - brake pedalBrake - acc. pedal
Backrest heightBackrest widthBackrest angle
Headrest lengthHeadrest widthHeadrest angleSteering wheel dia.Steering grip dia.Steering angleSteering wheel heightGear lever - H-pointGear gripFloor height (ground)Head clearanceWindow clearanceDashboard clearancecle
aran
ces
gear
steer
ing
head
rest
peda
lsse
atba
ckre
st
Tata
Indi
go
620 mm425 mm13 deg310 mm435 mm9 deg470 mm400 mm65 mm28 deg75 mm75 mm180 mm210 mm13 deg330 mm25 mm28 deg550 mm500 mm55 mm190 mm120 mm385 mm635 mm
Toyo
ta Q
ualis
600 mm510 mm13 deg270 mm420 mm19 deg470 mm370 mm60 mm33 deg90 mm90 mm180 mm260 mm13 deg320 mm30 mm30 deg470 mm550 mm50 mm480 mm110 mm345 mm690 mm
Toyo
ta In
nova
600 mm520 mm13 deg310 mm450 mm8 deg460 mm460 mm60 mm33 deg85 mm75 mm180 mm210 mm13 deg320 mm30 mm27 deg500 mm570 mm50 mm400 mm120 mm330 mm750 mm
Che
vrol
et T
aver
a
570 mm470 mm16 deg310 mm470 mm6 deg490 mm420 mm55 mm53 deg75 mm75 mm200 mm220 mm16 deg345 mm30 mm24 deg500 mm650 mm60 mm500 mm110 mm330 mm710 mm
Land
mar
k
PoplitealHip breadth-Buttock-poplitealMid-patellaFoot length-Ball of footFoot breadth
AcromionBi-deltoid-
Neck length max.Head circumference-Elbow-elbow closedGrip inside dia. max.-
Mid thigh breadth relaxedPalm lengthMid-patella-Span akimboButtock-knee length
5th
%ile
484 mm379 mm-380 mm272 mm-399 mm418 mm227 mm-299 mm83 mm94 mm520 mm-346 mm42 mm-530 mm289 mm92 mm419 mm-774 mm489 mm
-
-
50th
%ile
551 mm426 mm-425 mm331 mm
455 mm464 mm248 mm
324 mm94 mm134 mm544 mm-409 mm49 mm-587 mm369 mm103 mm464 mm-859 mm558 mm
-
-
95th
%ile
608 mm482 mm-471 mm405 mm
512 mm517 mm274 mm
354 mm106 mm162 mm574 mm-489 mm56 mm-644 mm449 mm114 mm517 mm-959 mm615 mm
± To
leran
ces
clothing, adjustibility etc.(50 mm)
-
-
interpolate w/95th Bi-acromion (422 mm)-clothing (5-10 mm)clothing (5-10 mm), extra (10-15 mm each side)
clothing (5-10 mm), calf clearance (100 mm)clothing (5-10 mm), footwear (10-25 mm)footwear (10-25 mm each side), min. 1/3rd area
radius 52 mm, footwear (15 mm), clearance (30-40 mm)footwear (10-25 mm), clearance (50 mm)adjustibiilty (50 mm)diameter 174 mm, adjustibility (50 mm)-steering cover (10 mm), gloves (5-10 mm)steering cover (10 mm), gloves (5-10 mm)-clothing (5-10 mm), footwear (10-25 mm)centre of palm (80 mm)interpolate w/5th Hand breadth with thumb (86 mm)footwear (10-25 mm)-1/2 span (480 mm), resting clearance (25-40 mm)clothing (5-10 mm), at knee (5-10 mm)
Acc
eptib
le ra
nge
590 - 610 mm390 - 410 mm17 deg360 - 380 mm420 - 440 mm7 - 10 deg290 - 300 mm400 - 420 mm95 - 100 mm30 deg100 - 120 mm110 - 130 mm150 - 200 mm200 - 250 mm17 deg270 - 300 mm25 - 30 mm25 deg630 - 650 mm550 - 650 mm85 - 95 mm390 - 410 mm100 - 130 mm420 - 440 mm590 - 610 mm
Ana
lysis
minimum acromion is taken as the landmark, but the backrest usually extends till the mid-shoulder.minimum bi-deltoid is taken as the landmark, but the backrest extends till the shoulders.
Acceptible seating angle is 17 deg. However, backrests are reclineable over a range of -10 to 175 deg.recumbent seating, a further tolerance of 50 mm can be accepted.
Seat cushioningSeat pan depth should be able to accommodate calf clearance, and too deep a seat will cause friction under the knee and cause a 5%ile to recline more.
Minimum surface contact should be 1/3rd of the foot length. However, only the underside of the toe is in contact with the pedal.Acceptible footrest angle is 30 deg, and a little amount of play is always provided in the pedals.
bi-malleolars touch each other in closed seating.right foot to access while being pivoted on one point.
Headrest lengths are adjustible by ±80-100 mm.Headrest should be wide enough too accommodate the head, but also not constrain head movement.Headrests are not reclineable, but have an acceptible angle of 10 deg w.r.t backrest plane.Steering posture should be an interpolation between a relaxed 5%ile and a closed 95%ile elbow-elbow distance.
25 deg steering angle gives a comfortable posture and a good viewing angle for pasenger cars.in between the legs and hence, these values are acceptible.
maximum range and was derived using seat pan depth, half seat width and 95%ile mid-thigh overhang.
A head clearance of 100 - 130 mm is required to accommodate bumps.
localized trim at the driver’s thigh location.
Contact points
primary
secondary
tertiary
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS62
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS 63
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Display
Control
Display
Control
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS64
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS 65
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Display
Control
Display
Control
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS66
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS 67
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
- +
RPM
km/h
Display Panel AnalysisAn analysis of display parameters used in vehicles.
Controls AnalysisAn analysis of controls used in vehicles.
Pedals
Function Form Detail Mental Model Remarks Criticality
Speed Dial Gradations of 5 km/h Red zone for unsafe speeds
New models have LED for critical speed feedback.
Very high
Engine RPM Dial Gradations of 1000 rpm Red zone for high engine speeds
_____ Critical for engine safety
Fuel Level Icon on dial Empty, full, reserve & mid-way markings
Red zone for reserve tank
_____ High
Turn Indicator Blinking icon Left/Right arrow Direction of motion to activate appropri-ate indicator
Turn indicators are the only means of communicating with traffic (other than horn).
High
Engine Check Icon 15mm X 15mm Engine silhouette Cab drivers don’t understand all icons/functions. However, due to their experience, they know that these icons glow only dur-ing ignition check. Anomalies are detected in the form of the icon not glowing off.
Critical for pre-driving checks. Even though the icons are not able to com-municate the function on their own, drivers under-stand the functioning of the icons.
Battery Check Icon 15mm X 15mm Battery icon, +/- signs
Engine Tempera-ture
Icon on dial Cold, hot markings Red zone for critical temperature
Oil Pressure Icon 15mm X 15mm Oil can icon
Water Level Icon 15mm X 15mm Water pump icon
Parking Brake Icon 15mm X 15mm _____
Headlamp Beam Icon 15mm X 15mm Beam icon Glows only when on high beam Critical for driving etiquette and visual comfort for traffic coming from opposite direc-tions.
Function Form Detail Mental Model Remarks Criticality
Hazard Switch
Icon on switch Colour/shape coded Triangle is the univer-sal warning sign.
New models have LED for critical speed feedback.
Very critical in case of emergen-cies
Ignition Key slot Text instructions Screw rotation Key slot is always kept unreach-able as accidental operation would switch off the engine.
One time operation
Gear Mark-ings
Numbers Engraved Location of numbers conforms to the gear stick movement.
_____ High
Air-condi-tioner
Icon on switch, sliders
_____ Universal snow symbol
Auxilliary control, but pre-fitted in most cars today.
Important feature for passenger comfort, but could act as a dis-tractor from primary tasks.
Wiper Icon on selector Markings for high, low & intermediate
_____ _____ Useful only in rainy conditions
Headlamp Icon on selector Markings for beam & parking lights
Bulb icon _____ _____
Horn Icon on steering wheel
_____ _____ Means of communicating with other traffic. The horn is one of the most frequently used controls and is hence placed centrally.
Critical for the driving task, but often a source of auditory dis-comfort.
Motion control
_____ _____ The C-B-A is the stan-dard model for Indian vehicles.
_____ Primary operations along with steering.
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS68
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS 69
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
DiscussionThe aim of the ergonomic study was to identify thresholds for design intervention. This study was done with the belief that there would be a lot of scope for design intervention.
However, the anthropometric workspace was observed to conform to er-gonomic standards, barring a few anomalies that are overcome with adjustibility in design.
The control/display interface was also observed to conform to ergonomic standards of feedback, functionality and information details. Also, the drivers’ mental models regarding the currently used system only validated the existing designs. The Toyota Qualis, which is out of production but still used widely across India, was the only vehicle found to be employing text messages rather than complete iconic indica-tion. However, these were messages that were not found to be critical while driving.
The question is, how to arrive at a design solution based on this.
Worthy of discussion, in this scenario, are the dynamic mental models. These expectancies are highly contextual as they depend on policies, rules, and behavioral patterns of the population. The dynamic mental models, hence, were believed to provide opportunities for design intervention.
This page has been intentionally left blank.Please turn over for the next section.
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS70
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS 71
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Mental models are the users’ representations of the task at hand. These expec-tancies are built with experience and help the user in familiarizing with unforeseen situations. For cab drivers, there are clearly defined goals - to deliver punctual service. This goal is perceived by different drivers in various ways. However, in order for the travel agency to follow codes of conduct, drivers are trained in developing the goal-based mental models.
Navigational mental models are knowledge-based. These are often not con-textual, and are purely built over time, with experience (semantic expectancy). These allow for planning the next journey effectively.
Guidance mental models are rule-based and highly contextual. These expec-tancies (episodic) are functions of traffic behaviour, and include tasks such as start-ing/stopping a car, safe headway, traffic speed, knowing when to activate certain controls etc.
Control mental models are skill-based and are functions of driver behaviour (in terms of vehicular displays and controls). These include the functional aspects of driving sub-tasks and are most important for monitoring a safe drive.
left turn free
before turningindicate
high gearsnot good in city
road changeslow down
give way
signal greenchange to red
rush hourleave early
rainy daywill get stuck
construction sitewill get stuck
before startcheck mirrors
if not familiarask
check seatbelts
area unsafe at nighttrouble
reach clientbe on time
be on timejob well done
client requiresbe present
when road clearspeed up
safe speed
not safebefore ignition on
engine startdon’t press accelerator
take vehicle
while at halt
tailgatenot safe
before overtakeblow horn
abnormal weatherdrive slow
heavy vehiclelet it pass
foot on clutchemergency situation
Goal Navigation Guidance Control
Goal
-bas
ed
Know
ledg
e-ba
sed
Rule
-bas
ed
Skill
-bas
ed
Planning/preparation
Driving
Monitoring
Dynamic Mental ModelsA cause-effect representation of mental models based on Rasmussen’s classification.
The Driver: Mental Models
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS72
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
RESEARCH & ANALYSIS 73
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Wanjibhai Parmar, 32, works at RR Travels as a driver. He has been driving for 3 years and has been with RR Travels, an Ahmedabad based cab agent, for 1.5 years. He has a Tata Indica (diesel variant) assigned to him by the agency, and has driven a Toyota Qualis prior to this. His job demands him to commute clients from one city to another (e.g. Ahmedabad to Surat), and occasionally, from Gujarat to Rajasthan or Madhya Pradesh. Within the city, his commute involves reaching the client, and then reaching the highway.
Having started driving at the age of 28, he took close to a year familiarizing with the main roads of Gujarat. At the moment, he is familiar with all highways and all major centres of Gujarat.
Wanjibhai reports to duty at 7:00 AM everyday. More often than not, his daily duty is ready by the time he arrives for work. However, in case of pickings before 7:00 AM, he takes his Indica with him the previous night so that he is able to reach the client directly, without having to pick up his vehicle.
Wanjibhai has not undergone any formal training regarding behaviour and etiquette. RR Travels selects drivers purely based on driving experience (minimum 2 years required). However, for the first 3 months of his service, he was under proba-tion where before each trip, he used to be given instructions regarding the kind of behaviour and etiquette expected of him.
Wanjibhai has had basic primary education, and can not understand English. He finds it difficult to read specific instructions and/or symbols in his vehicle. He is, however, comfortable with icons, but needs instructions to understand the icons. For this purpose, he carries a service manual with him. He also considers distance, fuel and engine information as the most important.
Wanjibhai earns Rs. 7500 a month, which is just about enough to support his family (wife and 10 yr-old daughter in a Govt. school). Timely service is, hence, of utmost importance as that alone earns him a major chunk of his salary.
As far as driving is concerned, Wanjibhai maintains a safe driving behaviour. He can negotiate most traffic and obstructions comfortably. However, errors due to fatigue and urgency can not be ruled out. Although he has maintained a safe record till present, the value of time and the need for money make him prone to accidents, thus posing a threat to both his and his clients’ lives.
ProfileAge 32 yrs
3 yrs experienceAt current service for 1.5 yrs
Is aware of new technologies
LivelihoodHas had primary educationEarns Rs. 7500 a monthLives with his wife & daughter
TIME IS MONEY• Driving is my source of livelihood• I have to support my family• I have to reach client on time• I have to always be available to the client• My timely delivery of service will reap me rewards• I have to maintain etiquette with client
I CAN DRIVE 150 km AT A STRETCH• I have driven many vehicles before• I maintain speed limits• I don’t tailgate• I judge speed by traffic• I can drive as well in the city as on the highway
I AM EXPERIENCED• I’m highly familiar with highways• I asks for directions if unsure of routes• I know basic repair/maintenance knowledge
of my vehicle• I know all the functions on my vehicle• I know features on other cars as well
SPEED LIMITS ARE MOST ESSENTIAL• Engine temperature & fuel levels are important to me• I always do vehicle checks before starting my duty• Steering and brakes should be functioning properly• I carry a service manual
Persona: Wanjibhai Parmar
DESIGN74
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 75
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Information Structure
Concept
Guidelines
Summary
Dashboard Integration
Relevance of the Design
OFFICE TRIP RETURN
NAVIGATION
GUIDANCE
CONTROL
OTHER
Mandatory informationDestination
Client detailsReporting time
Cautionary informationFuel levelsOil levelsWater levelsElectricals/mechanicals
Emergency informationService numbersEmergency contacts
Breakdown managementVehicle repair knowledge
Road rules
LandmarksSignage
Distance markersDirection markers
In-vehicle informationDisplay/controls
SpeedTime
Distance metersEngine RPM
Monitoring informationSpeedDistanceFuel/oil/water levelEngine temperatureBattery
Billing informationDistance travelledTime travelled forBilling charges
Pre-driving task Driving task
Informational NeedsThe entire research findings were synthesized into infor-mational needs. These needs were grouped according to navigational, guidance and control needs, and also, informa-tional needs pertaining to the driver’s knowledge of the task at hand.design
74
Information Structure
75
86
96
109
111
118
DESIGN76
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 77
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
DrivingTask
Where to go?
Navigation
Directional
ExactDestination
Distance
Time
Time of day
Day of week
Traffic
Weather
Other factors Public gatherings
Constructions
Diversions
Railway crossings
How long will it take?
Which route to take? Shorter route
Easier route
Faster route
Alternate route
Navigational information needs for the driver.
DrivingTask
Directions en routeDistance to destination
Directional markers
LandmarksNatural
Signage
Architectural
Left/right?
Turn allowed?
Intersecting traffic
Intersections
Weather
Safe gap
Day/night?
Traffic speed
Rain
Traffic direction
Fog
Non-vehicular traffic
Windy
Human
Animal
Obstructions
When/where to turn?
Communication with traffic
Environment
Guidance
Guidance information needs for the driver.
DESIGN78
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 79
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
DrivingTask
How fast am I going?
How long have I been driving for?
How much distance have I travelled?
How much fuel is left?
Time
Interface Display
Controls When to accelerate?
Can information be read?
When to use clutch?
How sufficient is the information?
When to change gear?
Is the information necessary?
Is the information in the right amount?
Is it indicating critical points appropriately?
When to put brakes?
Where are other con-trols located?
Control
Control information needs for the driver.
DrivingTask
BreakdownsBasic repair
Service numbers
Distance travelled
Maintenance
Emergency contacts
Time travelled forTime driven for
Time waited for
Billing charges
Road rules
Emergency
Billing
OtherKnowledge
Other information needs for the driver.
DESIGN80
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 81
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
PlanStart LocationDestinationDistanceEstimated Time
MaintenanceVehicle InformationRecommended LevelsBasic Repair Tips
BillingMeteringDistance TravelledTime Travelled forBilling CycleUnit FareAmount
GuidanceLandmarkDirection to LandmarkDistance to LandmarkEstimated Time to Landmark
VehicleFuel LevelEstimated Distance on FuelTemperatures/Other Checks
MonitoringDistance TravelledSpeedFuel LevelVehicle ChecksTrafficEnvironment
Information to be handled by the information system
Information to be handled by the monitoring system
The information needs were further refined and grouped into functions and functional components. A system architecture is proposed for the cab system. The proposed system is a simulation of real-world activities and has a back-end as analogous to the cab agency. The back-end shall administer various activities, e.g., cab booking, fleet management, vehicle tracking, reports etc. The vehicular interface is the simulation of the driver and will have functions that are relevant only to the driver.
This system aims at the cab agents who run the so-called “unorganized” cab service. This system has been proposed with the understanding that the existing system needs to be streamlined. Also, the market component has been considered here, focusing on two main points, a) India still does not have an in-vehicle information and monitoring system and new systems need to be designed for the Indian con-text, and, b) introduction of a new system would give a competitive edge to the unorganized cab sector and elevate them to the level of “organized” services like Meru.
ActivityPhysical space where all agency activities shall be performed.
Back-endBack-end application for manag-ing agency services, fleet man-agement, tracking, reports etc.
InterfaceSynchronized monitoring and information systems.
DatabaseCommon database for the interface as well as back-end, based on GPS.
NetworkThe network space binding the digital elements.
InteractionVehicle space housing the driver-vehicle inter-actions.
System ArchitectureA macro-view of the proposed system
DESIGN82
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 83
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Information ArchitectureComplete map for the information system interface.
Task Sub-task Parameter L0 Parameter L1 Data Input Data Display
Navigation Plan Start Location Text, sync. with back-end ---
Destination Text, sync. with back-end ---
Estimated Distance --- Calculated using GPS data
Estimated Time --- Calculated using GPS data
Guide Map --- GPS/Google Maps sync.
Meter Distance Travelled --- Sync. with vehicle odometer
Metered Amount --- On-board calculation
Active Signage Next Landmark --- Direction & landmark, GPS
Distance --- GPS/Google Maps sync.
Estimated Time --- Calculated using GPS data
Vehicle Status Running Speed --- Sync. with speedometer
Fuel Level --- Sync. with fuel gauge
Distance on Fuel --- Calculated using GPS data
Engine Temp. --- Sync. with temp. gauge
Oil, Battery etc. --- Sync. with vehicle
Bill Client Text, sync. with back-end ---
Distance Travelled --- Odometer, GPS
Time Travelled for --- GPS sync.
Amount Billing Cycle Database ---
Information ArchitectureA hierarchical analysis of input/output modes
DESIGN84
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 85
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Task Sub-task Parameter L0 Parameter L1 Data Input Data Display
Unit Fare --- ---
Tools Maintenance Service Information Last Service Database Date, km reading
Next Service Database Date, km reading
Vehicle Information km Reading --- Sync. with odometer
Fuel Levels --- Sync. with fuel gauge
Tire Pressure --- Sync. with tire monitor
Temperature --- Sync. with temp. gauge
Oil, Battery etc. --- Sync. with vehicle
Service Manual Vehicle Information Make Database Text, brand
Year Database Text, year
Maintenance Tips --- Instructions
Component Info. --- Infographics
Driver Details Personal Details Photograph Database Image
Name Database Text
Employee Code Database Text
Age Database Text
Date of Birth Database Text
Address Database Text
License Details License No. Database Text
Information ArchitectureA hierarchical analysis of input/output modes
Task Sub-task Parameter L0 Parameter L1 Data Input Data Display
Issue Date Database Text
Expiry Date Database Text
Issuing Authority Database Text
Emergency Call One-touch call button ---
Map --- GPS/Google Maps sync.
Information ArchitectureA hierarchical analysis of input/output modes
DESIGN86
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 87
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Dashboard/Home Screen
WireframesFor the information system interface, wireframes were made, first on paper, and then detailed out digitally, and based on the information architecture decided. The conceptual layout thus gave the information structure as applicable in the digital world, and the wireframes helped realize information flow and screen-to-screen navigation.
Tasks PanelFor tasks received through the cab agency
Navigation PaneFor planning and executing a trip
Map View SnippetFor current position orientation
Tools PanelFor non-task activities
Trip Planner
Concept
DESIGN88
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 89
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Task Summary
Active Guidance
Bill Generation & Printing
DESIGN90
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 91
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Tools: Maintenance
Colour-coded for alerts
Tools: Driver Details
Tools: Service Manual
DESIGN92
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 93
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Event MonitorThe event monitor has been conceptualized keeping in mind the Indian drivers’ mental models. The event monitoring system will use a combination of sensors and actuators to map out behaviour triggers and behavioral actions.
SpeedometerAnalog moving-pointer, fixed-dial type speedometer.
Icon ClusterThe icon cluster shall house the standard icons. These icons are on/off type and are activated only in case of anomalies in the vehicle. All these icons display a similar functional be-haviour and hence, were best perceived as a cluster.
OdometerStandard digital odometer with trip features. Synchronization with the in-formation system shall add a trip-meter reset feature, setting the value to 0 for easy metering/billing.
The System DynamicsThe monitoring system shall continu-ously interact with the information system and the server/database.
Timer/Fatigue WarningDigital clock with trip features. The trip-timer shall be set to 0 (synchronized with the infor-mation system), for easy metering/billing.
The fatigue warning alarm shall make use of the trip-timer feature and give a feedback to the driver in case of continuous driving for more than a set amount of time.
Event Monitor: Internal EventsInternal events are the primary actions performed by the driver, and can be ‘sensed’ using instrumented accel-erator, steering & brake. These sensors are available in varied sensitivities, and can be hooked to microprocessor-based interpolation tables to detect realtime anomalies.
Brake pedal motion sensorResolution +/- 0.1 inch
Last 10 pedal movement values
Standard deviation
11th value
Deviation
Accelerator pedal motion sensorResolution +/- 0.1 inch
Last 10 pedal movement values
Standard deviation
11th value
Deviation
Steering wheel motion sensorResolution +/- 1 degree
Last 10 wheel movement values
Standard deviation
11th value
Deviation
mean
deviation
non-critical alert
critical alert
alert
data
val
ue
data received every 0.1 seconds
σ
σ
σ
σd 6σd
6σd
DESIGN94
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 95
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Event Monitor: External EventsExternal events are events that trigger a specific action from the driver. These are real-world events (e.g. approaching danger, overtaking vehicles etc.).
Side Collision Sensing (S)Low-range proximity sensor to detect probable collisions from the side.
Rear-end Sensing (R1, R2)High-range ultrasonic proxim-ity sensor to detect probable collisions from behind/warn against overtaking vehicles.
non-critical alert
critical alert
S/R1/R2 active
(S+R1)/(R1+R2) active
- +
F
E
F
E
Dashboard: SchematicThe conceptual layout for the dashboard with the icon cluster, speedometer, fuel gauge and the event monitor.
DESIGN96
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 97
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
25o
25o
20o
600
mm
180
mm
360 mm
640
mm
400 mm
220 mm
300 mm
440 mm
630 mm
300 mm
10o
The Driver SpaceErgonomically acceptible dimensions of workspace elements. The dashboard is shown in cyan in the side view and shows the orientation w.r.t the driver.
Dashboard LocationThe location of the dashboard monitor w.r.t. eye quadrants in mean and heads down positions.
- +
F
E
F
E
horizonI
i
IV
iv
II
ii
III
iii
horizonheads down
- +
F
E
Cruise Range: 40-60 km/hColour-coded to white shaded zone.
Startup Speed: 0-40 km/hColour-coded to white bordered zone.
Speed Limits: 60-80 km/hColour-coded to red shaded zone. The speed limits have been thought of accord-ing to varied limits (60 km/h in city, 80 km/h on highways). Also, these are not regulated speed limits, but are safe speeds on the roads.
Dial:Type: Analog, moving pointer, fixed dialViewing Distance: 630 mm (2 ft.)Viewing Angle: 15o
Diameter: 75 mm (3 in.)
Pointer:Length: 35 mmThickness: 4 mm at baseDeflection: 255o
Colours:Back Colour: Gray (#6d6e71)Cruise: Gray (#e6e7e8)Higher Speeds: Red (#ed1c24)Pointer Colour: Orange (#f26922)
High Speed: > 80 km/hColour-coded to red shaded sector. Sectors demand immediate attention and speeds greater than 80 km/h are dangerous.
35 mm
4 mm
8 mm
colo
ur
pal
ette
Speedometer
Guidelines
DESIGN98
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 99
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
- +
F
E
30 mm
12 m
mOdometer
Clock
Trip meter
Height-width = 2:1Thickness = 0.5 mmItalic = 10o
Height-width = 2:1Thickness = 1 mm
Timer
4 m
m
10 m
m
Display:Type: Digital, segment displayViewing Distance: 630 mm (2 ft.)Viewing Angle: 15o
Dimensions: 30 x 12 mm
Alerts:Trip: 150 km from last haltTimer: 75 min from last halt
Colours:Back Colour: Gray (#939598)Font: Black (#000000)Alert: Orange (#f37032) co
lou
r p
alet
te
Font Details:
Alerts:
Counters- +
F
E
40 mm
25 mm15 mm
30 m
m
22 m
m
30 m
m
Warning IndicatorIndicator for warnings based on internal and external events.
External Events MonitorIndicator for external events and probable collision areas.
Display:Type: Digital, iconic, segmentedViewing Distance: 630 mm (2 ft.)Viewing Angle: 15o
Dimensions:Warning Indicator: 40 x 30 mmSymbol: 25 x 22 mmEvent Monitor: 15 x 30 mm
Colours:Back Colour: Gray (#333132)Critical (Inactive): Gray (#d1d3d4)Critical (Active): Red (#ed1c24)Symbol Back: Yellow (#fff200)
Display States: Event Monitor
Display States:Warning Indicator
colo
ur
pal
ette
25 mm
8 m
m
2.5 mm
0.5
mm
Event Monitor
DESIGN100
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 101
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
- +
F
E
- +
- +
45 mm
50 m
m
Display:Type: Digital, iconicViewing Distance: 630 mm (2 ft.)Viewing Angle: 15o
Dimensions: 45 x 50 mm
Icons:Number of Icons: 8Size: encl. 12 x 12 mm
Colours:Back Colour: Gray (#333132)Icons: Yellow Chrome (#ffc22c)Beam Icon: Blue (#1b75bc)Parking Icon: Red (#ed1c24)
Inactive State:
Icon Sample:
colo
ur
pal
ette
12 mm
Icon Cluster- +
F
E
F
E
40 m
m
4 m
m
10 mm
8 mm
Display:Type: Analog, moving pointer, fixed barViewing Distance: 630 mm (2 ft.)Viewing Angle: 15o
Dimensions: 10 x 40 mm
Colours:Back Colour: Gray (#686e71)Level Zones: Gray (#e6e7e8)Reserve: Red (#ed1c24)Pointer: Orange (#f26922)
Pointer Details:
colo
ur
pal
ette
Level Indicator
Half-way
Reserve
Fuel Gauge
Moving PointerPointer in the ‘reserve’ zone to gen-erate the ‘low fuel’ alert in the icon cluster.
DESIGN102
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 103
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
The TRIPPER in-vehicle navigator and information system has been conceptualized as a systemic aid to the cab service. The TRIPPER is a touch-based interface that will assist the driver in activities relevant to the driving task, and his job as a taxi service employ-ee.
TRIPPER follows a hierarchy which is similar to that of the real-world cab agent-driver hierarchy. TRIPPER is the interface-level counterpart of the real-world driver, and the functions of TRIPPER have been designed keeping in mind the tasks and responsibilities of a cab driver.
TRIPPER has the following components:• Interface: touch-based simulation of the real-world relation between the agency,
vehicle and the driver.• Database: a record of the last 10 tasks executed by the current driver. This can be
thought of as the semantic memory counterpart of the driver’s memory.• Intelligence: GPS-based assistive aid for the driver, in terms of traffic/weather moni-
toring.• Assistance: GPS-based active guidance for en-route information.
Guidelines: Dashboard ElementsThis section shows guidelines regarding appearance of ele-ments on the home screen (dashboard) of TRIPPER.
Layout:Dimensions: 576 x 432 px
Colours:Background: #ffffffHeader: #578fb5Body: grad. #ffffff - #e2e2e2Header Text: #e2e2e2 co
lou
r p
alet
te
DESIGN104
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 105
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Function: Tasks Function: Navigation
Task AlertColour-coded alert for new task received from the agency.
Task Description1-line description (source-destination) of the received task. Plan BillGuidance
15 mm 10 mm
8 mm
8 m
m
15 m
m
Colours:Inactive: #7b95af, #485f77Active: #f4646f, #b04449Symbol: #e2e2e2
Colours:Background: #7b95af, #485f77Symbol: #e2e2e2
Display States: colour palette Details: colour palette
30 m
m30 mm
15 mm
15 m
m
Function: Tools Functions: Position Map
MaintenanceDriver Details
Task History
Emergency Call
Current Position Marker
Service Manual
5 mm
Colours:Background: #7b95af, #485f77Symbol: #e2e2e2
Map:Level: DistrictType: North-up
Colours:Marker: #ff000000
Details:
Details:
colour palette
colour palette
20 m
m
20 mm
10 mm
10 m
m
DESIGN106
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 107
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Presentation: Active Signage
Next Landmark on route
Distance to Landmark
Time to Landmark
Direction to Landmark
35 m
m
20 m
m
15 mm
8 mm
colour palette
Colours:Signage: #415469
Sign Variations:
Presentation: Vehicle Running Information
Engine Temp. Alert
Running Speed
Estimated Distance on Remaining Fuel
Running Fuel Level
Colour Details: colour palette
Fuel: Temp:
#00ff00 #bf0700
#00ff00 #00ff00
#bf0700 #bf0700
Hot
Cold
Mid
Full
Mid
Reserve
Symbol: #ff0000
25 m
m
32 mm
DESIGN108
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 109
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Data Input: On-screen Keyboard
Type:QWERTY Touch-screen Keypad
Keys:Number: 40 keysNumbers: 0-9Characters: A-ZSpecial: Back, Space, Cancel, OK
Presentation: Tracker Map
Map:Level: DistrictType: Moving-up
Colours:Best Route: #f37032Alternate Route: #00a79dMinor Routes: #a7a9acTracker: #ff0000Map Background: #282829
Details:
colo
ur
pal
ette
TrackerMinor Routes
Alternate Route
Best Route
Summary
The Driver SpaceThe workspace has been proposed keeping in view anthropometric data for the In-dian male. However, since most components are adjustible these days, the proposed dimensions are merely guidelines and not strict blueprints.
• Backrest. The backrest should provide support to the bi-deltoid protrusions. The backrest width should be enough to support a 95th percentile Indian male driver, and also not give much movement space for a 5th percentile Indian male driver. The backrest should be reclinable upto 17o for postural adjustments and lumbar support.
• Seat. The seat should provide support to the buttocks and to the thighs. In auto-mobile seats, however, the posture need not demand thigh support, but ergo-nomically, the seat pan should be deep enough to support the buttock-popliteal length of a 95th percentile male driver, and also not so deep that the seat fowls with the 5th percentile popliteal. The seat width should be enough to support the hip-breadth of the 95th percentile male, and also not give much movement space for the 5th percentile male. The seat height should keep the driver’s popliteal height as close to the vertical as possible. The seat should have a 10o incline w.r.t. the horizontal for efficient foot movement.
• Pedals. The pedal dimensions should be enough to accommodate 1/3rd of the corresponding foot dimensions. Also, the distance between the pedals should accommodate foot movement keeping the heel fixed, and also non-interference of the two feet.
• Headrest. The headrest should provide support to the driver’s head and also maintain a horizontal line of vision for the driver (or a 5o eyellipse). The headrest width should be enough to support a 95th percentile male and also not give much movement space to the 5th percentile male. The headrest height should be adjustable and should be fixed w.r.t. the backrest, so that the headrest reclines
only with the backrest.
• Steering. The steering wheel diameter should accommodate the elbows in a closed/relaxed position. Also, the steering wheel should be placed such that the right elbow doesn’t collide with the door while manoeuvring the vehicle. The steering grip diameter should conform to the human grip inside diameter.
• Gear. The gear lever should be within the secondary zone in its maximum posi-tion and provide enough clearance between the left elbow and the rest of the body in its minimum position.
• Clearances. While driving the vehicle, there should be mandatory head clear-ance, clearance between the knee and the dashboard and clearance between the elbow and the window. Also, for easy ingress/egress, there should be adequate ground clearance.
• General. For accessibility, dimensions should be taken off from the lower percen-tile and extrapolated to the higher percentile. For clearance, dimensions should be taken off from the higher percentile and extrapolated to the lower percentile. All tertiary controls (stereo, A/C etc.) should be placed between the secondary and tertiary zones so that they don’t pose a distraction while driving the vehicle.
For dimensional values, refer to page no. 96.
DESIGN110
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 111
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Present current position on the main screen. Present all functionalities in the least number of interface screens. Wherever possible, use collapsible components instead of adding a new screen. All screens should be navigable directly to and from the home screen. Provide confirmation screens before critical tasks, e.g., starting the billing cycle.
• Colour coding. Use minimum number of colours for information presentation. Use contrasting colours for presenting important information. Use colour-coded alerts. Wherever possible, show alerts on the home screen. The following colour convention has been followed for a comfortable viewing stress:
• Background: White to blue gradient.
• Alerts: Red.
For more details on individual components, refer to page no. 104-108.
The InterfaceThe interface has been divided into two components:
• The monitor - for monitoring on-the-task events and giving relevant informa-tion to the driver.
• The TRIPPER information system - for meeting the informational needs of the cab driver, including navigation, guidance & billing functions.
The MonitorThe following guidelines have been followed for the design of the monitor:
• Layout. Arrange the most critical information (speedometer and event monitor) in the first and second visual quadrants. The fatigue warning should be placed in the third quadrant and the icon cluster in the fourth quadrant. This layout has been proposed considering the various degrees of criticality of the functionalities.
• Presentation of information. Present speed information in terms of safe, regu-latory and critical limits. Present distance information in terms of total as well as trip distance. Present time information in terms of clock and trip time.
• Colour-coding. Use the least number of colours to display the desired informa-tion. The colours should be contrasted with the background and should not be visible when the icons are in a deactivated state. The following colour conven-tions have been used:
• Background: 90% grey.
• Safe values: 10% grey.
• Non-critical warnings: Chrome yellow.
• Critical warnings: Red.
• Driver response indications: Orange.
• Symbol sizes. Symbols in the icon cluster have been restricted to a 12x12 mm square. Variable stroke sizes have been used to enhance legibility of the icons for a viewing distance of 600 mm. The event monitor icons have been restricted to a 30 mm height and a proportional width.
• Alerts. Generate an alert whenever a reading exceeds an acceptable value. Alert the driver and demand driver’s attention whenever critical events are recorded outside the driver’s cone of vision. Use multisensory modality in case of critical events.
For more details on individual components, refer to page no. 97-103.
The TRIPPER Information SystemThe following guidelines have been followed for designing the TRIPPER information system interface:
• Functional grouping. Function allocation to the TRIPPER system should be within the scope of the functions of the real-world driver. Group the functional-ities according to tasks and tools. The tasks are the primary planning and billing tasks, while the tools are extra information that may be required for breakdown maintenance, servicing etc.
• Presentation of information. The TRIPPER should use a combination of textual and graphical information. Present map information as north-up on the home screen (spatial orientation confirmation) and as moving-up on the guidance screen (spatial movement confirmation).
• Screen content and navigation. Present all functionalities on the main screen.
DESIGN112
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 113
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
As a future vision, the design guidelines were conceptually integrated with the vehicle dash-board. These concepts were divided into three levels of integration.
The first one was based on the simple two-module configuration for the instrument panel and the Tripper system. The functionalities and sub-modules of the two interface components remain the same as proposed in the guidelines. However, colour treatment was changed in line with aesthetics.
The other concepts aimed at futuristic integration of the interfaces in terms of form and layout.
Dashboard Integration: IA rather pessimistic scenario considering the inte-gration of the interfaces on the current dashboard (ref. Tata Indica/Indigo).
Dashboard Integration
DESIGN114
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 115
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
DESIGN116
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 117
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Dashboard Integration: IIA BAU scenario considering the integration of the interfaces on the current dashboard.
Auxilliary controls (ste-reo, A/C etc.)
Instrument cluster
Instrument cluster detail
Information system
DESIGN118
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 119
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Relevance of the Design
Dashboard Integration: IIIAn optimistic scenario considering the integra-tion of the interfaces into a single panel.
Navigation screen
Integrated interaction panel
Interaction panel detail
Information system functions
Adaptation of the information system guidelines to other vehicle segments/marketsThe guidelines for the vehicle space, instrument cluster and the information system have been designed based on human cognition and general workspace related needs. While the instrument cluster and the seating space can be generalized as ‘ergonomically designed’ for both personal as well as passenger cars, the information system guidelines can be viewed as being specific to the cab system. This, however, can be generalized across the taxi market in India and could also be extended to trucks, buses and other fleet vehicles.
Logistics Freight management
Fuel management
Tolling
Passenger management
Scheduling
Route management
Ticketing
Navigation
Vehicular performance management
Public transport
Personal transport
Information system guidelines
For whom to adapt
What to adapt
DESIGN120
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
DESIGN 121
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Complete process simulation
Simulation of the real-world sytem and its hierarchies helps in identifying human frailties at different levels, and also manage the tasks at these levels. The scope of the information system is same as the real-world driver and thus, defines his roles and responsibili-ties.
Spatial information presentation
The presentation of spatial information in terms of maps helps in wayfinding, navigation and planning.
Dynamic/temporal information presentation
The presentation of dynamic information such as vehicular information, realtime change of contextual information etc. adds to the spatal informatin processing capabilities and helps carry out the driving task with greater efficiency.
Vehicle maintenance information
Vehicle maintenance information and the service manual has been considered necessary in cases of breakdowns on the highway/remote areas, as well as for regular vehicle checks.
Benefits of the information system guidelines
Reduced visual load
The usage of high-contrast and minimum number of colours is aimed at reducing the visual load while trying to read the messages. In addition, the message icons have been kept in accordance with the drivers’ existing mental model set.
Reduced information processing time
Display of numbers and quantitative information in case of primary information has been kept minimal. All warnings have been kept as on-off type warnings with their states indicating the functional state of the corresponding vehicular function.
Behaviour feedback
Feedback is important in any cognitive task. While most modern displays provide visual and/or auditory feedback for critical values, behavioral feedback is present only in expensive ADAS (e.g., lane-departure warning etc.). Here, behaviour feedback has been pre-sented as another simple on-off type warning, thus indicating to the drier to review his actions in terms of steering, speed & brake controls.
Collision warning
The external event monitor gives warnings against probable collisions and also indicates which side the threat is from. This also indi-cates the driver to review his actions in terms of driving path and speed.
Fatigue warning
The fatigue warning system has been conceptualized, based on the average distance & average time that the selected user group drove for comfortably without taking a break. Following the fatigue warning would ensure proper rests during a journey and reduce the risk of fatigue-related errors.
Benefits of the instrument panel design guidelines
CONCLUSION122
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
CONCLUSION 123
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Project Reflection
Future Scope
Bibliography
122
conclusion123
125
128
When the project was started, I had absolutely no idea how or where it would end. The brief I had chosen was extremely open \-ended and gave me a lot to explore in terms of cognitive psychology, time perception, vehicular information etc. The only thing that I was sure of was that the link between time perception and driving behav-iour would give the project a solid direction.
The literature review helped its bit as I was able to ‘measure’ how the sense of time affected driving, in terms of fatigue and situation awareness. This, however, did require fieldwork and the framework research helped in that. It was oly through those three pilot studies that I could arrive at a context.
The task was only about to get more challenging now. So I had a context, but then what? Again, even at this time, I didn’t know how or where the project would go. It could’ve very well turned to a futuristic interior design project, or it could’ve just ended at workpace anthropometrics. Detailed research, hence, had to ensue.
It was interesting, rather surprising, how the focus of the project just changed from safety/accident prevention to interface usability. This was mainly due to, a) the fact that accidents and road safety follow a very random pattern in India, and, b) the understanding that what is more usable is what is safer. In retrospect, it can very well be said that the road study was quite irrelevant! However, looking at a brighter side, accident analysis on Ahmedabad roads could be quite a challenging project!
In terms of methodologies followed, I tried to maintain a highly non-intrusive method. Interviews were conducted wherever required, but most of the research was observational. This was due to the understanding that in order to study human cogni-tion, the subject (for lack of politically correct words) should always be made to feel comfortable and not interfered with while carrying out his/her task. In such a scenar-io, one could question the efficacy of the methods followed as its more than natural to form a bias. I managed to maintain an unbiased method throughout the project, as there wasn’t much to be biased for or biased against, except for a little attractive-ness bias which made me choose the taxi over the truck.
Of course, there were crossroads, there were stalemates, there were stand-points, and there were straight passages throughout the project. Once again, I would like to thank all the people who helped me get through. Your names have already been mentioned in detail in the acknowledgements section, so I won’t repeat.
To end this part, I would summarize my learnings as follow:
• Read a lot. How much is too much? It never is.
• Always make notes. It helps a lot to write what you read and helps retain it longer and faster.
• Being clueless helps. This is rather debatable, but the innocent explorer is always more successful than the expectant one, e.g., Christopher Columbus discovering America while expecting India.
• Know your limits. If you can’t do something on your own, don’t be afraid to accept it. I would’ve done this project for a truck had I been a superhero, but I knew I wasn’t and I accepted it.
• Observation is the best method. Ekalavya is a fine example to that. What’s more important is what to observe and how much to absorb.
• Automobile design is not all about styling. This is one of the myths that a lot of people often believe. Automobile design is a clear case of hardcore systems approach and I, for some reason, always wanted this to be a state-ment to those who think sketching a car beautifully is all there is to automo-bile design.
• Self-initiated projects can and will get delayed. Its just too relaxing.
• Be human. You can’t do a project without discussing with peers, seniors and the layman. If a layman asks ‘why?’ to a research project, you’ll end up either, a) arguing incessantly, b) without a reply, or, in rare cases, c) in a
Project Reflection
CONCLUSION124
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
CONCLUSION 125
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
fistfight. But, its all human.
So the above was quite a humorous touch to some things I learnt during the course of the project.These aren’t the typical management class pointers, but actual first-hand experiences. On a serious note, I actually learnt how to incorporate hard-
core research, ergonomics, interface design and interior styling into one single proj-ect. Also, some of the tools I learnt (Microsoft Expression Blend) are industry-standard tools and are bound to help me in my future endeavours.
Perception of time
Situation awareness
Events and information processing
Vehicular interfaces & safety
Driver behaviour
Final user group
Final driver persona
Competitor & market specification
Anthropometric & interface requirements
System & vehicle type
Basic links - behaviour & safety
Terminologies
The driving task model
Driver personae
Links - temporal & physiological behaviour
Vehicular safety levels in India
Probable accident causes
Workspace guidelines
Instrument panel guidelines
Information system guidelines
Dashboard integration concepts
Stakeholder identification
Process SummaryDiagram showing key findings in the dif-ferent stages of the project.
future scope
The outcome of this project has opened up a lot of opportunities in industrial, visual as well as technical design. As the project concluded in guidelines and directions, these can be realized in independent projects and/or subset projects spanning across various disciplines. The opportunities can be listed as follows:
Industrial DesignErgonomics. Workspace design including seating, lighting, passenger interaction.
Automobile Design. Vehicle packaging, design of a ‘standard’ taxi.
Styling. Exterior and interior aesthetics, use of colour to reduce mental loads.
Materials. Optimization for dust-proofing, tamper-proofing etc. for the touch-screen interface.
Interaction & Experiential DesignAesthetics. Adaptive interiors for enhancing driver cognition.
Interface Design. Design of the dashboard to meet futuristic trends, interaction methods for human-machine interaction, interface design for the back-end.
Graphic DesignInstrument Panel. Alternative icons for dashboard.
Information System. Branding, interface skinning.
Technical DesignDevelopment. Programming, integration with real-time data.
Integration. Integration with on-board computer(s), sensor integration, integration of GPS/GPRS systems.
Design ResearchUser Testing. Testing of the concept before implementation, prototyping.
Standardization. Cross-platform standardization and generalization of interfaces.
Contextualization. Realization of the system in different contexts of use, e.g., area-wise, demographically etc.
Accident Research & Analysis. Understanding contributors to accidents in Ahmed-abad, accident studies, prevention etc.
Future Scope
CONCLUSION126
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
CONCLUSION 127
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Opportunity/Stakeholder MapThe future opportunities can be considered as stakeholders in the future scope of the project. Mapping was done as a modified influence-interest map to identify and analyze cross-links between the various stakeholders in the different stages of the project.
How to read the map
The three columns on the left represent the three stages of the project, and the coloured cells represent overlaps/relevant stages for the stakeholders (column 4).
Column 4 and beyond are shown as a distance matrix, representing the inter-links that each stakeholder would share with other stakeholders. The coloured cells show the affected stakeholder domains.
Research Domain
Ergonomics
Ergonomics
Graphic
Design
Graphic
Design
Vehicle
Design
Vehicle
Design
Branding
Branding
Styling
Styling
Development
Development
Aesthetics for
Experience
Aesthetics for
Experience
Standardization
Standardization
Interaction/
Interface
Design
Interaction/
Interface
Design
Contextualization
Stakeholder
Contextualization
will affect
Influence
Design Development
Future Scope
Interest
CONCLUSION128
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
CONCLUSION 129
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
1. Accidental Deaths in India (2007). National Crime Records Bureau. Re-trieved September 12, 2009, from http://ncrb.nic.in/ADSI2007/Accident07.pdf
2. Advanced Driver Assistance Systems. Retrieved October 7, 2009, from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Driver_Assistance_Systems
3. Ahmedabad City Development Plan (2006-2012). AMC, AUDA, CEPT University. Jawaharlal Nehru Urban Renewal Mission.
4. Annual Report (2008-2009). Ministry of Road Transport & Highways. Gov-ernment of India.
5. Ayers, R. (n.d.). Retrieved September 23, 2009, from http://www.usq.edu.au/users/ayers/tengmod10.htm
6. Beishon, J., Peters, G. (1972). Systems Behaviour. London: Open University Press.
7. Block, Richard A. (l996). Psychological Time and Memory Systems of the Brain. In Fraser, J.T., & Soulsby, M.P. (Eds.), Dimensions of Time and Life: The Study of Time VIII (pp 61-76). Madison: International Universities Press, Inc.
8. Block, Richard A. (1998). Psychological Time and the Processing of Spatial Information. In Egenhofer, Max J., Golledge, Reginald G. (Eds.), Spatial and Temporal Reasoning in Geographic Information Systems (pp 119-130). New York: Oxford University Press.
9. Castro, C. (2009). Models of Driving Information Acquisition. In Castro, C. (Ed.), Human Factors of Visual & Cognitive Performance in Driving (pp 1-31). Florida: CRC Press.
10. Chengalur, Somadeepti N., Rodgers, Suzanne H., Bernard, Thomas E. (2004). Kodak’s Ergonomic Design for People at Work (2nd ed.). New Jersey:
John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
11. Cyber Media Press Release: October 25 (2007). Retrieve March 20, 2010, from http://www.cybermedia.co.in/press/pressrelease67.html
12. Dewar, Robert E., Olson, Paul L. (2001). Human Factors in Traffic Safety. Arizona: Lawyers & Judges Publishing Company Inc.
13. Dingus, Thomas A., Gellatly, Andrew W., Reinach, Stephen J. (1997). Human Computer Interaction Applications for Intelligent Transportation Systems. In Helander, M., Landauer, Thomas, K., Prabhu, Prasad, V. (Eds.), Handbook of Human Computer Interaction (pp 1259-1282). Amsterdam: Elsevier Science BV.
14. Dingus, T., Hulse, M., Jahns, S., Alves-Foss, J., Confer, S., Rice, A., Rob-erts, I, Hanowski, R., Sorenson, D. (1996). Development of Human Fac-tors Guidelines for Advanced Traveller Information Systems and Commercial Vehicle Operations: Literature Review (Tech. Rep. No. FHWA-RD-95-153). Federal Highway Administration.
15. Eby, David W., Molnar, Lisa J., Kartje, Paula S. (2008). Maintaining Safe Mobility in an Aging Society. Florida: CRC Press.
16. Endsley, Mica R., Bolte, B., Jones, Debra G. (2003). Designing for Situa-tion Awareness: An Approach to User-centered Design. Philadelphia: Taylor & Francis.
17. Engeström, Y. (2006). Activity Theory and Expansive Design. In Bagnara, S., Smith, Gillian C. (Eds.), Theories and Practice in Interaction Design (pp 3-24). Philadelphia: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 2006.
18. European Road Safety Observatory (2006) Fatigue. Retrieved May 9, 2008 from http://www.erso.eu
Bibliography
19. Evans, V. (2007). How we Conceptualise Time: Language, Meaning and Temporal Cognition. In Evans, V., Berger, Benjamin K., Zinken, J. (Eds.), The Cognitive Linguistics Reader (pp 733-765). London: Equinox Publishing.
20. Fairchild R.G., Brake, J.F., Thorpe, N., Birrell, S., Stewart, A., Young, M., Felstead, Tim, J., Fowkes, M. (2009). Using On-board Driver Feedback Systems to Encourage Safe, Ecological and Efficient Driving: The Foot-LITE Project. Retrieved March 16, 2010, from http://www.aisb.org.uk/convention/aisb09/Proceedings/PERSUASIVE/FILES/FairchildR.pdf
21. Forgus, Ronald H. (1966). Perception. New York: McGraw Hill.
22. Goodrich, Michael A., Boer, Erwin R. (1998). Semiotics and Mental Mod-els: Modeling Automobile Driver Behavior. In Proceedings of the IEEE ISIC/CIRA/ISAS Joint Conference (pp 771-776).
23. Gruber, Ronald P., Wagner, Lawrence F., Block, Richard A. (2004). Relationships between Subjective Time and Information Processed. In Harris, Paul A., Crawford, M. (Eds.), Time and Uncertainty (pp 188-203). Boston: Brill Leiden.
24. Guastello, Stephen J. (2006). Human Factors Engineering and Ergonomics. New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers.
25. Gugerty, L. (in press) Situation Awareness in Driving. In Lee, J., Rizzo, M., Fisher, D. , Caird, J. (Eds.), Handbook for Driving Simulation in Engineering, Medicine and Psychology. Florida: CRC Press.
26. Halpern, Diane F. (2000). Sex Differences in Cognitive Abilities (3rd Ed.). Mahwah: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
27. Hancock, Peter A. (1999). Human Performance and Ergonomics. London: Academic Press.
28. Helander, M. (2006). A Guide to Human Factors and Ergonomics (2nd ed.). Florida: CRC Press.
29. Hines, M. (2005). Brain Gender. New York: Oxford University Press.
30. Ho, C., Spence, C. (2008). The Multisensory Driver: Implications for Ergo-nomics Car Interface Design. Vermont: Ashgate Publishing Ltd.
31. Johnson-Laird, P. N. (1980). Mental Models in Cognitive Science. In Col-lins, A. (Ed.). Cognitive Science Journal Vol.4 (pp 71-115). Cognitive Science Society.
32. Journey of Taxi-Cabs in India (n.d.). Retrieved March 24, 2010, from http://www.carazoo.com/article/3006200803/Journey-of-Taxi-Cabs-in-India
33. Kappa effect. Retrieved October 7, 2009, from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kappa_effect
34. Kimura, D. (2000). Sex and Cognition, Boston: MIT Press.
35. Lees, Monica N., Lee, John D. (2009). Enhancing Safety by Augmenting In-formation Acquisition in Driving. In Castro, C. (Ed.), Human Factors of Visual & Cognitive Performance in Driving (pp 167-186). Florida: CRC Press.
36. Majumdar, D. (2006). Human Factors in Transportation Safety. In Chaturve-di, P. (Ed.), Challenges of Occupational Safety and Health (pp 105-109). New Delhi: Concept Publishing Co.
37. McDonald, N. (1984). Fatigue, Safety & the Truck Driver. Philadelphia: Taylor & Francis.
38. Meru Cabs (n.d.). Retrieved March 20, 2010, from http://www.merucabs.com
39. Meru Cabs: Technology on Wheels (n.d.). Retrieved March 20, 2010, from
CONCLUSION130
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
CONCLUSION 131
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
http://www.geospatialtoday.com/gst/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=93%3Ameru-cabs&catid=48%3Aarticles&Itemid=84
40. Mohan, D. (2000). Injury Control and Safety Promotion: Ethics, Science and Practice. In Mohan, D., Tiwari, G. (Eds.), Injury Prevention and Control (pp 1-12). London: Taylor & Francis.
41. National Road Transport Policy (n.d.). Road Safety and Traffic Manage-ment. Retrieved April 30, 2009, from http://morth.nic.in/writereaddata/sub-linkimages/ROAD_TRANSPORT_POLICY7406816237.htm
42. OECD/ECMT Transport Research Centre (2006). Young Drivers – The Road to Safety. Paris: OECD Publishing.
43. Poidevin, Robin Le (2003). Travels in Four Dimensions: The Enigmas of Space and Time. New York: Oxford University Press.
44. Raskin, J. (2000). The Human Interface: New Directions for Designing Inter-active Systems. Massachusetts: Addison Wesley Longman Inc.
45. Regan, Michael A., Lee, John D., Young, Kristie L. (2009). Driver Distrac-tion: Theory, Effects & Mitigation. Florida: CRC Press.
46. Road Transport Yearbook (2009). Transport Research Wing. Ministry of Shipping, Road Transport and Highways, Government of India.
47. Roese, Neal J., Sherman, Jeffrey W. (2007) . Expectancy. In Kruglanski, A. W., Higgins, E.T. (Eds.), Social psychology: Handbook of basic principles (Vol. 2). New York: Guilford.
48. Rousseau, R., Tremblay, S., Breton, R. (2006). Defining and Modeling Situation Awareness: A Critical Review. In Banbury, S., Tremblay, S. (Ed.), A Cognitive Approach to Situation Awareness: Theory and Application (pp 3-21). Hampshire: Ashgate Publishing Ltd.
49. Salvucci, D., Boer, E., and Liu, A. (2001). Toward an Integrated Model of Driver Behavior in a Cognitive Architecture. In Transportation Research Re-cord (pp 1779:9-16).
50. Schindhelm, R., Gelau, C., Keinath, A., Bengler, K., Kussmann, H., Kompfner, P., Cacciabue, Carlo P., Martinetto, M. (2004). Report on the Review of the Available Guidelines and Standards (Tech. Rep. No. IST-1-507674-IP). Information Society Technologies Programme.
51. Schlesinger, George N. (1980). Aspects of Time (2nd ed.). Indianapolis: Cambridge.
52. St-Cyr, O. (2002). An Ecological Approach to Mental Models: Towards Assessing Ecological Compatibility. In Human Systems in Systems Design Engineering (Tech. Rep. No. HSSD-02-01). Department of Systems Design Engineering. University of Waterloo.
53. Sträter, O. (2005). Cognition and Safety: An Integrated Approach to Systems Design and Assessment. Hampshire: Ashgate Publishing.
54. Tiwari, G. (2000). Traffic Flow and Safety: Need for new Models for Heter-ogenous Traffic. In Mohan, D., Tiwari, G. (Eds.), Injury Prevention and Control (pp 71-88). London: Taylor & Francis.
55. Warwick, W., McIlwaine, S., McDermott, Patricia L., & Stanard, T., Hutton, Robert J. B. (n.d.). Retrieved October 29, 2009, from http://ppc.uiowa.edu/driving-assessment/2001/Summaries/Driving%20Assessment%20Papers/65_stand.pdf
56. Wochinger, K., Binder, S., Traube, E., Band, D., Foley, J. (2008). Human Factors Forum on Advanced Vehicle Safety Technologies: Summary and Pro-ceedings (Tech. Rep. No. DOT HS 810 918). National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
57. Woods, David, D. (1988). Coping with Complexity: The Psychology of Human Behaviour in Complex Systems. In Goodstein, Len, P., Andersen, Henning, B., Olsen, Svend, E. (Eds.), Tasks, Errors and Mental Models (pp 128-148). Philadelphia: Taylor & Francis.
58. Woodson, W., Conover, D. (1964). Human Engineering Guide for Equip-ment Designers. California: University of California Press.
59. Zakay, D., Levin, I. (1989). Experiencing and Remembering Time: Affor-dances, Context, and Cognition. In Block, Richard A. (Ed.), Time and Human Cognition (pp 333-363). North Holland: Elsevier Science Publishers BV.
CONCLUSION132
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
CONCLUSION 133
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
This project is dedicated to my grandmother (late) Smt. Malati Rao, who passed away the day I finished writing the project document.
APPENDICES134
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
APPENDICES 135
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
However, by the time the project neared completion, there were a few stones that remained left unturned. Certain links between the start and the finish could not be resolved. One of them is the significance of ‘time’ that got lost somewhere along the way. Even though time perception dictated who the final user was for me, I feel time could’ve been included in the final outcome in a more explicit way.
There were certain decision that I, as a designer, took entirely out of gut in-stinct and/or seeming misinterpretation of research data, e.g., removing the numbers from the Speedometer. However, in defence of such a move, Chris Bangle did not design the BMW Gina considering peoples’ acceptance.
Then there were other open issues like driver feedback on the Tripper system. An attempt has been made to gather critique from the cab driver on the Tripper inter-face and a user feedback is shown in the next few pages.
There were critiques like not referring to international standards, and other UI-related queries. International standards were referred (ATIS CVO, NavMan, TomTom etc.) and insights from those were applied to the design of the Tripper UI. However, as a context, the Indian cab scenario (or specifically, Ahmedabad) was studied as standalone and as representative of the national demographic. Certain miscalcula-tions based on assumptions are but inevitable in such cases. Other points of concern were the studies on Meru & Tata Indica. The Tata Indica study, like the road study, did not bear any results. The study on Meru, on the other hand, did give a benchmark for the proposed system design, but since the service is not available in Ahmedabad and travelling was not feasible, I had to resort to an extensive internet research, the verac-ity of which could be questioned.
The learning was immense in this project. Coming from a different back-ground altogether, there was a steep learning curve for me and touching upon Cog-nitive Ergonomics, Systems Design, UI - all at once - was indeed a challenge - some-thing that I’m proud of having accomplished!
End Note
End Note
User Feedback
134
appendices135
136
APPENDICES136
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
APPENDICES 137
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Feedback Remarks
Task summary lets me prepare for my task ac-cordingly.
Zooming in/out not pos-sible.
This should be included in the position orientation map.
‘Plan’ icon not under-standable.
Icons currently used are generalized symbols for respective tasks. Refine-ment of icons and graph-ics has been proposed as a future opportunity.
‘Maintenance’ and ‘Ser-vice Manual’ are good features. ‘Tasks’ need not be repeated in the Tools panel as it is already pres-ent as a separate panel.
‘Tasks’ should be removed from the Tools panel.
1
2
3
4
User Feedback
MethodologyThe Tripper UI prototype was shown to a prospective cab driver who fit in the demographic of Wanjibhai Parmar’s persona. With each screen of the UI, the driver’s feedback was noted. Correspondingly shown are remarks on the same feedback.
To minimize the learning curve, the UI functionalities were first explained as in the user manual before conducting the feedback session.
APPENDICES138
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
APPENDICES 139
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
1
3
4
2
Feedback Remarks
Automatic starting loca-tion is good. I don’t need to enter my current loca-tion.
QWERTY keypad could be a possible learning curve for the driver. However, for best ease of alphanu-meric data, the QWERTY arrangement shall be retained.
Estimations are good. I can plan my speed and time accordingly.
This button takes me to an unfamiliar screen. I don’t know what to do there.
Navigation to the ‘Tasks’ screen needs to be re-moved. Instead, this but-ton should directly take the user to the ‘Guidance’ screen.
1
3
4
2
Feedback Remarks
Metering is good. It would’ve been better if it gave the fare as well.
Fare depends on billing cycles. Also, fare does not fit in the context of guid-ance, and is not informa-tion that is required while driving.
Will the signage change? The signage would change as per realtime data. Due to the proto-typic nature of this UI, the change could not be implemented.
Zooming in/out not pos-sible.
Tracker map need not have zooming enabled as it is only giving movement orientation.
Speed is better indicated through a dial.
The Tripper is not in-tended to be used as a vehicle monitor, but as an information/assistance system. For best indication of speed, the dashboard display should be consid-ered.
APPENDICES140
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
APPENDICES 141
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
1
3
2
Feedback Remarks
Can I modify the billing cycle? What happens when the billing rates change?
The billing cycle is auto-matically calculated based on booking and start time of journey. Also, billing rates need to be modified at the back end.
Why are there two ‘print’ buttons?
The idea was to give a print command for the current bill, and a sepa-rate print button for previ-ous bills. The two could be incorporated into one in the future iterations of the UI.
The previous bill details are useful but I can’t contact the client in case there’s some problem/error.
There should be client in-formation (at least contact number) in this section for cases of discrepancy of any kind.
2
1
Feedback Remarks
Can I edit my details? What if I change my phone number or ad-dress?
For good practice and to maintain a hierarchy, driv-er details have been made editable only through the back-end. Also, since Tripper does not work on a login-password basis, editable details could be a security threat as well.
Shouldn’t my details be printed and permanently displayed and shown to the client?
There could be a print op-tion for this.
APPENDICES142
National Institute of DesignDriver Cognition and the Sense of Time
APPENDICES 143
Kshitish Purohit Transportation & Automobile Design PGDPD 07
Feedback Remarks
There is no indication of ‘start’ or ‘end’ of journey. How will I know when billing has started?
The ‘next’ button on the ‘Plan’ screen indicates start of journey. However, since this is not intuitive, there needs to be a direct indication to start metering the trip.
History is a helpful feature as I can keep a record of my performance, vehicle perfor-mance and bills, and also be able to contact the concerned person if needed.
The English used throughout the application is very friendly and easy to understand. It feels like the application is talking to me.
‘Maintenance’ and ‘Service Manual’ are extremely useful features in cases of emergen-cies and general monitoring of the vehicle.
Colours used are very pleasing to the eye. This session could not be conducted in low illumination condition and also, since the simulation was shown on a laptop LCD screen, the interface was always lit up. Howev-er, a neutral background was used in order to minimize after-images in light and dark.
Is there backup power for this? What happens if the battery is dead? For this, there needs to be an alternate power source or an in-built battery, in which case, there needs to be an indication of the same.
End of Document