+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet...

Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet...

Date post: 30-Apr-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 16 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
45
NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC, Spain Collaborators: L. Roca, E. Oset, M. J. Vicente Vacas, V. Magas Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.1/45
Transcript
Page 1: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Dynamically Generated

Resonances from BaryonDecuplet-Meson Octet Interaction

Sourav Sarkar

Universidad de Valencia-IFIC, SpainCollaborators:

L. Roca, E. Oset, M. J. Vicente Vacas, V. Magas

Dynamically Generated

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.1/45

Page 2: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Plan

I. General discussion on dynamically generated resonances S.S., E. Oset, M.J. Vicente Vacas, NPA 750 (2005) 294 andEur.Phys.J.A24 (2005) 287

IntroductionUnitary coupled channel formalismResonances observed in different channels

II. Detailed study of the resonance S.S., E. Oset,

M.J.Vicente Vacas, PRC72 (2005) 015206 and L.Roca, S.S., V.K.Magas, E Oset (inpreparation)

Improvements; addition of extra channels, etc.Determination of unknown parameters and couplingsPredictions and comparison with experimental data

Dynamically Generated

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.2/45

Page 3: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Introduction

Chiral Dynamics + Unitary Coupled Channels Successful prediction of s-wave baryon resonances.s-wave scattering of the pion octet with the nucleonoctet

Dynamical generation of baryonresonances

!" #$ !&% " ' ($ !&% ) '* $ !+ '* $ !

D. Jido et al, NPA 725(03)181;

C. Garcia Recio et al, PLB 582(04)49;

M.F.M. Lutz et al, NPA 700(02)193;

E. Oset et al, NPA 635(98)99

N. Kaiser et al; T. Inoue et al ; etc...

Dynamically Generated

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.3/45

Page 4: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

IntroductionWhat about d-wave baryon resonances?,- , in d-wave has too many unknown terms in .PT

No predictivity!But, these d-wave resonances couple in s-wave to the

baryons decuplet and the mesons octet. Ifthese s-wave channels are dominant the resonancescould appear in the s-wave scattering of the baryonsdecuplet and the mesons octet.

s-wave implies .PT is more predictive!

In fact some of these d-wave resonances( / 0 1 / 0 2 1 3 2 ) have large decaybranching ratios to /54 4 channels even when 4 / isfavoured by phase space!

Kolomeitsev and Lutz, PLB 585(04)243

Dynamically Generated

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.4/45

Page 5: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Formulation

Lowest order chiral Lagrangian (Decuplet - Octet interaction)6 7 8 9;: <= : <

: <> ?A@ the baryons decuplet and B C the covariant derivative

= C : < > ?@ D C : <> ?A@ E F C G > : <G ?@ E F C G? : <> G@ E F C G@ : <> ? G

F C H I J D C J K E J K D C J ML J I N O P Q I R ST

with a single coupling constant U

E. Jenkins et al, PLB 259 (91) 353

We write : < :WV < whereXZY[\] ^ _ `a ba c dfe eg !ih Yij % d ! Xij % e !

Dynamically Generated

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.5/45

Page 6: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Formulation

We will consider only the k-wave part of the interaction andthe non-relativistic limit, so thatl Xj m% e m !in o Xj % e ! [ p o q p ^ ^ r s t uv j uwx !

\ r] ^ r\] ^ _ `a ba c d m e m eg !h Yij my% d m ! _ ` a ba c de eg !h Yj % d ! p ^ ^ r [z s t u v j u awx a !&

6 8 :W| 9~: : F f

l ! [] l c o [ # a o z o !

` ` ` [ , ` ` a [ ` b

, ` a a [ ` b q , a a a [ , ` ` b [ ` b )

, ` a b [ ` ) q , a a b [ ` b ) , ` b b [ ` b + q , a b b [ ` b + , b b b [ .

Dynamically Generated

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.6/45

Page 7: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Formulation

For a meson of incoming (outgoing) momenta we getfor the k- O transition amplitudes,

P 7 U I P E This is used as kernel of a coupled channels BetheSalpeter equation : 7 ¡ H £¢

= +T V G TV

Dynamically Generated

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.7/45

Page 8: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Formulation

¡¥¤ 8 ¤ ¦ §©¨ 4 § ª 7 ¨ I7 I¤ E 8¬«

¨ I7 ­ I¤ E 8¬«

Using dimensional regularization

¡¥¤ HH®°¯ a ¤ ²± E ³µ´ ¶ a¸·< a E ¹ a · ¶ a · »ºI º ³ ´ ¹ a ·¶ a · E¼ ·Qº ½ ³ ´ k7 I¤ 7 ­ I¤ E ¨ ¤ k E ³ ´ k E I¤ 7 ­ I¤ E ¨ ¤ k 7³µ´ 7 k E I¤ 7 ­ I¤ E ¨ ¤ k 7 ³ ´ 7 k7 I¤ 7 ­ I¤ E ¨ ¤ k ¾¿ 1

with unknown parameters ÀÁ for which the ‘natural size‘ is ÂÃ Ä

corresponding to a cut-off of  700 MeV.

Dynamically Generated

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.8/45

Page 9: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Formulation

Å N decomposition: , - ,Æ Æ 2Æ Projection on to Å N basis: ÈÇ É PËÊ

Ì 81 Í Î P ÌÏ 1 Ð Î

Strength is proportional to: Ç É ¦ 8Ñ Ò 1 1 1 7

strong attraction in octet, followed by decupletweak attraction in 27, repulsion in 35

We then solve the BS equation and look for poles in thecomplex plane. In the Å N limit we get two poles, oneeach for the octet and decuplet representations

Dynamically Generated

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.9/45

Page 10: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Results: Trajectories of Poles in the Complex Plane

Two bound states in the Å N limit

1350 1500 1650 1800 1950 2100 Re zR (MeV)

0

50

100

150

200

−Im

zR (M

eV)

S=0, I=1/2S=−1, I=1S=−1, I=0S=−2, I=1/2

Octet

? (1673)

M0=1382 MeVm0=368 MeV

1350 1500 1650 1800 1950 2100 Re zR (MeV)

0

50

100

150

200

−Im

zR (M

eV)

S=0, I=3/2S=−1, I=1S=−2, I=1/2S=−3, I=0

Decuplet

?

(1738)

M0=1382 MeVm0=368 MeV

Break ÓÔ !

symmetry graduallyx Õ iÖ ! [ x q s Ö x Õz x q !× aÕ iÖ ! [ × a q s Ö × aÕ z × a q !$Ø Ö Ø Close to the pole

iÙÚ !

ÕÛ Ù ! [ Ü Õ ÜÛÙ z ÙÚ

residue Ý couplings Ü Õ

Dynamically Generated

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.10/45

Page 11: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Poles in the Complex Plane

1300 1400 1500 1600 1700 1800 1900 2000 2100 2200-50

0

50

100

150

200

S=0, I=1/2Þ ßàáâãäæå çè é

1300 1400 1500 1600 1700 1800 1900 2000 2100 2200-50

0

50

100

150

200

S=0, I=3/2êàá çëìå áí è éàá ìî ëå áä ì é

1300 1400 1500 1600 1700 1800 1900 2000 2100 2200-50

0

50

100

150

200

S=-1, I=0ïàá è èäæå í ë é

1300 1400 1500 1600 1700 1800 1900 2000 2100 2200-50

0

50

100

150

200

S=-1, I=1ðàá í â îå á è é

àá í ì ëå á ë ì éàîä î áå çè é

1300 1400 1500 1600 1700 1800 1900 2000 2100 2200-50

0

50

100

150

200

S=-2, I=1/2ñ àá ì â îå á ìî é àáã îäæå áâ ë éàî á í îå áã é

1400 1500 1600 1700 1800 1900 2000 2100 2200-50

0

50

100

150

200

S=-3, I=0ò

àî á çáå â ì é

Dynamically Generated

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.11/45

Page 12: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

ª ó 7 Resonances

1300 1500 1700 1900 2100ECM (MeV)

0

0.01

0.02

0.03

0.04

0.05

0.06

|T|2 (1

/MeV

2 )

∆πΣ*K∆π (with width)Σ*K (with width)

(S,I)=(0,1/2)

N*(1520)

1300 1500 1700 1900 2100ECM (MeV)

0

0.001

0.002

0.003

0.004

0.005

|T|2 (1

/MeV

2 )

∆πΣ*K∆η

(S,I)=(0,3/2)

∆(1700)

∆ (?)

1300 1500 1700 1900 2100ECM (MeV)

0

0.005

0.01

0.015

0.02

0.025

|T|2 (1

/MeV

2 )

Σ∗πΞ*K

(S,I)=(−1,0)

Λ(1520)

1300 1500 1700 1900 2100ECM (MeV)

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

|T|2 (1

/MeV

2 )

∆KΣ∗πΣ∗ηΞ*K

(S,I)=(−1,1) −

Σ(1670)

Σ(1940)

1300 1500 1700 1900 2100ECM (MeV)

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

|T|2 (1

/MeV

2 )

Σ*KΞ∗πΞ∗ηΩK

(S,I)=(−2,1/2)

Ξ(1820)

Ξ (?)

1300 1500 1700 1900 2100ECM (MeV)

0

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

|T|2 (1

/MeV

2 )

Ξ*KΩη

(S,I)=(−3,0)

Ω (?)

Dynamically Generated

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.12/45

Page 13: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

ôöõ÷ øù ú

In our treatment so far with the 4 û 0 and üý 0 in coupledchannels the is generated dynamically with alarge coupling to the 4 û 0 channel.

It appears about MeV higher in mass and is about

times broader than the nominal width which is ¢ Ò MeV.

This large width is a consequence of the fact that thepole appears above the 4 û 0 threshold.

However, the width of the comes essentiallyfrom the decay into

9 ü / ( %) and 4 û ( %)

It is mandatory to add these channels to our scheme

Dynamically Generated

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.13/45

Page 14: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

ôöõ÷ øù ú

Other channels like þ and üý could also contributebut their influence will be in the mass and not the width.In any case the position (mass) can be fine tunedthrough the subtraction constants.

The lowest partial wave in which the channels

9 ü / and4 û can couple to spin parity is ÿ .

We will couple these channels in ¦-wave to the 4 û 0

channel and not to the ü ý 0 which is far away from theregion of influenceWe will also introduce the û 0 width in the meson baryonloop function since the 4 û 0 threshold is very close tothe peak of the

Dynamically Generated

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.14/45

Page 15: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Coupling of -wave channels:K

Σ∗

π

d−wave s−wavek

N (1/2,m) (3/2,M)

à à ! " # $% %

where

&' ( Ä ) * + ( Ä, - . !+ ( Ä Ä ' ( Ä0/ , 1 ) # & ' ( Ä + ( Ä -

so that

à à . ! 2 Ä 3 / , 4 )à , # 65 78 9 ! " # !à + # 9 8 7 :;=<

Dynamically Generated

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.15/45

Page 16: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

K

Σ∗ Σ∗

ππ

N(3/2,M) (1/2,m) (3/2,M´)

a [ > ? @BA* C ! @ DE FHGI # C

n GI E uv A u aJ _ w* * w* c ×%x mz × !K a] J L r MA ! z ! L r J

n GI E uv A u a _ w* * w* c ×%x z × ! K a] J L MA ! z ! L J

Angular integration of the two K z Ý p L L r

Orthogonality of the Clebsch Gordan coefficientsOn-shell factorization of vertex a [ Nn GI E APOQ R aTS D GI E [ UWV X Y GI E DGI E UGI E Y V X

Dynamically Generated

Z []\ ^_ `

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.16/45

Page 17: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

a

With the b matrix given by

b cdcecfcdcecfcdcecfcdcg 2 2 ! % 2 h % 2 # g 2 ! % 2 h % # 2 3 i 3 2 j i jg 2 ! % h % 2 # g ! % h % # k k

2 3 i 3 k 3 3 i j3 3 j i 3 i j

2 j i j k 3 j i 3 i j j j i jjcdcecfcdcecfcdcecfcdc

where g 2 2 ; , g ' and g 2 g 2 Ã :l

A Õ [ mn oe Ne z px Õ s × Õ q a R Ne z px Õz × Õ q a R

r qÕ [ e z x aÕ s × aÕn oe

we can continue with the formalism as in ordinary s-wave scattering.

Dynamically Generated

Z []\ ^_ `

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.17/45

Page 18: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

a

To take the t û u width into account we fold ¡ with thespectral function of the û u :

D V X p oe=v x X v × V q Ý Lxw a yzL|w a yz ? oe m z mC Im

moe mz x X s > X pe m qw n~

S D V X p oe=v oe mv × V qwhere

X pe m q [ q A p= v x v × V q

A p Xv v × V q p o z z × V q

m n A p v Xv × V q

A p Xv Xv × V q p o z X z × V q v

Dynamically Generated

Z []\ ^_ `

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.18/45

Page 19: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

a

Using b as the kernel and the loop function we use the coupled channelBS equation to get the amplitudes for

and <

From a fit to the experimental amplitudes

we find the unknownparameters 2 3 , 2 j, 3 3 , 3 j, j j in the b matrix and the subtractionconstants % , in

P p o q z AC o A C o p o q

¡ ¡ ¢£ p o ¤¥¦ § ¨ q

We get the following values

©§ © ª¥ p

MeV « q ª¥ @ pMeV « q ª p

MeV «¦ q ª @ @ p

MeV «¦ q ª @ p

MeV «¦ qz m z m ¬ S m « ­ m mS m « ­ z m ®S m « ¥ z ®S m « ¥ z m mS m « ¥

Dynamically Generated

Z []\ ^_ `

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.19/45

Page 20: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

¯ a 1450 1475 1500 1525 1550 1575 1600

-0.2

-0.1

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

Re T~

1450 1475 1500 1525 1550 1575 1600

-0.2

-0.1

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

1450 1475 1500 1525 1550 1575 1600√__ s (MeV)

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

Im T~

1450 1475 1500 1525 1550 1575 1600√__ s (MeV)

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

K_

N K_

N K_

N πΣ

Fit to the experimental amplitudes. Left column:

°²±³ ´ °²±³ ; right column:

°²±³ ´ C µ.Experimental data from G. P. Gopal et al. NPB119 (1977) 362 and M. Alston-Garnjost et al.PRD18 (1978) 182

Dynamically Generated

Z []\ ^_ `

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.20/45

Page 21: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

¯·¶ a ¸ ¹

1450 1500 1550 1600

-0.06

-0.04

-0.02

0

0.02Re

T (

MeV

-1)

1450 1500 1550 1600-0.03-0.02-0.01

00.010.020.03

1450 1500 1550 1600-0.03-0.02-0.01

00.010.020.03

1450 1500 1550 1600-0.1

-0.08

-0.06

-0.04

-0.02

0

Im T

(M

eV-1

)

1450 1500 1550 16000

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

1450 1500 1550 16000

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

1450 1500 1550 16000

0.002

0.004

0.006

0.008

0.01

|T|2 (

MeV

-2)

1450 1500 1550 1600

√_ s (MeV)

0

0.002

0.004

0.006

0.008

0.01

1450 1500 1550 16000

0.002

0.004

0.006

0.008

0.01

πΣ∗ πΣ∗ πΣ∗ Κ_

Ν πΣ∗ πΣ

From left to right: Unitary amplitudes for º µ ´ º µ , º µ ´ °²±³ and º µ ´ º µ.Dynamically Generated

Z []\ ^_ `

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.21/45

Page 22: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

¯·¶ a ¸ ¹

Close to the peak of the » ¼½¾ ¿À Á the amplitudes are givenby p o q  Âo z ¤¥ ¦ § ¨ à ¡ ¤¥ ¦ § ¨ Ä nfrom where we calculate the couplings of the » ¼½¾ ¿À Á to thedifferent channels:

  z ¡ ¤¥ ¦ § ¨n Å p ¤¥ ¦ § ¨ q Å ¢£ Æ p ¤¥ ¦ § ¨ qÇv

We get Â¥    @ ¬ m z n¬ z È z È

The partial decay widths can be obtained from¡ Â nPº

¤¥ ¦ § ¨ É

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.22/45

Page 23: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

¯·¶ a ¸ ¹

Predictions:

The reaction ÐÒÑ Ó Ô t Õ×Ö u Õ ¼ ½Ø Ù¾ Á Ô t Õ t Õ » ¼ ½ ½ ½Ú ÁK−

πo p1( ) p

2( )πo

Σ∗op

(k)

(1/2,m) (3/2,M) Λ (1/2,m´)

z ÃÛ pÜÞÝ ¥v ÜÝ q z Ã=ßà áâã äåæ çè é äåã Ä £ã êz äå à ¡ äå ë ê ì Ä èíïî

ðz è Ý Òñ £ ò Ä è

Ý Òó ÃÝ Òô £ z ò Ä èõïö

÷

Symmetrize the amplitude three-body phase space cross-section

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.23/45

Page 24: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

¯·¶ ø ¸ ¹

We also add the following conventional diagrams

p1( )πo

p2( )

K− πo

(1/2,m)p Λ (1/2,m´)p

(k)πo p

2( )

Σ∗ο

p1( )πo

K−

Λ (1/2,m´)p(1/2,m) p

(k)

(a) (b)

K− πo p2( )

πo p1( )

K−πo p

2( )

πo p1( )

(k)

(1/2,m´)Λp(1/2,m) (1/2,m)pΛ (1/2,m´)

(a) (b)

K

(k)

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.24/45

Page 25: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

¯·¶ ø ¸ ¹

350 400 450 500 550 600 650 700q (MeV)

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2

σ(K

- p

π0 π0 Λ)

(mb)

ÐÒÑ Ó Ôù Õù Õ » cross section (mb) vs ÓúÞû ü (MeV) of Ð Ñ

Experimental data from S. Prakhov et al., PRC69 (2004) 042202

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.25/45

Page 26: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

¯·¶ ø ¸ ¹

300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460q (MeV)

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

σ(K

- p

π+ π− Λ)

(mb)

ÐÒÑ Ó Ôù ýù Ñ » cross section (mb) vs ÓúÞû ü (MeV) of Ð Ñ

Experimental data from T. S. Mast et al., PRD7 (1973) 5

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.26/45

Page 27: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

¯·¶ ø ¸ ¹1460 1480 1500 1520 1540 1560 1580 1600 1620 1640

MK-p (MeV)

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

dσ/d

MK

- p (a

rbitr

ary

units

)

ÐÒÑ Ó invariant mass distribution for the þ Ó Ô Ð ý Ð Ñ Ó

reaction with photons in the range ÿ ¿ Ù Ù

GeV.Experimental data from D. P. Barber et al., Z. Phys. C7 (1980) 17

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.27/45

Page 28: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

¯·¶ ø ¸ ¹1450 1500 1550 1600 1650

MK-p (MeV)0

10

20

30

40

50dσ

/dM

K- p

(arb

itrar

y un

its)

1450 1500 1550 1600 1650MK-p (MeV)

0

5

10

15

20

25

30pπ− = 1.6-2.4 GeV/c pπ− = 2.9-3.3 GeV/c

ÐÒÑ Ó invariant mass distribution for theù Ñ Ó Ô Ð Õ ÐÒÑ Ó

reaction. Left: pions in the range Ó « ½ Ú ¿

GeV/c; right:Ó « ¿ Ø Ø GeV/c.Experimental data from O. I. Dahl et al., Phys. Rev. 163 (1967) 1377

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.28/45

Page 29: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Summary: resonances

Systematic study of the interaction of the baryondecuplet with the meson octet taking the lowest orderchiral Lagrangian (Weinberg Tomozawa term) Ø ¿ Ñ resonances

Poles associated to established resonances: ¼ ½¾ ¿ À Á , ¼ ½ À À Á , » ¼ ½¾ ¿À Á ,Ö ¼ ½Ú À Á ,Ö ¼ ½ À Á , ¼ ½ Ù ¿À Á , ¼ ¿ ¿¾ À Á

Prediction of couplings of these resonances to themeson baryon decay channels partial widthsPrediction of extra resonances not yet observed: ¼ ¿½Ú À Á with a width of 40 MeV, and some others toobroad e.g. 1550 MeV.

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.29/45

Page 30: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Summary:

Phenomenological introduction of the !channels

" Ð andù Ö into the coupled channel scheme

Introduction of the Ö width in theù Ö loop functionWe find that the » ¼½¾ ¿À Á couples strongly to theù Ö

channel though the branching ratios to the

" Ð andù Ö

channels are much larger

Prediction of amplitudes and couplings of the » ¼ ½¾ ¿ À Á toall the channelsWe obtain good agreement with experimental data inthe reactions Ð Ñ Ó Ô »ù ù , þ Ó Ô Ð ý Ð Ñ Ó andù Ñ Ó Ô Ð Õ Ð Ñ Ó at energies close to and above the» ¼ ½¾ ¿À Á region.

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.30/45

Page 31: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Extras

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.31/45

Page 32: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Results: # $ # ( %)

States: ù and Ö Ð.

1300 1500 1700 1900 2100ECM (MeV)

0

0.01

0.02

0.03

0.04

0.05

0.06

|T|2 (1

/MeV

2 )

∆πΣ*K∆π (with width)Σ*K (with width)

(S,I)=(0,1/2)

N*(1520)

Pole at ½Ø ¿ & ¿À MeVwith strong coupling to ù

channel.PDG ¼½¾ ¿À Á , ' ½ ¿À

MeVThe peak at 1877 MeV isa threshold effect.

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.32/45

Page 33: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Results: # $ # ( )

States: ù , Ö Ð and )( .Two poles in the complex plane

1300 1500 1700 1900 2100ECM (MeV)

0

0.001

0.002

0.003

0.004

0.005

|T|2 (1

/MeV

2 )

∆πΣ*K∆η

(S,I)=(0,3/2)

∆(1700)

∆ (?)

Pole at ½ Ù & ½Ú ¾ MeVwith strong coupling to ù

channel.No counterpart in PDG.Missing resonance ?

Pole at ½ Ù ¿ & ½ À Ù MeVwith strong coupling toÖ Ð channel.PDG ¼ ½ À À Á , ' Ø À À

MeV

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.33/45

Page 34: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Couplings of to various channels

*,+ ½ Ù & ½Ú ¾ ½ Ù ¿ & ½ À Ù

-. / -. / -. / -. /

ù ¿ À & ½ ¿ Ù À ¾ 0 & À Ù ½ ÀÖ Ð ½ Ú & ½ Ú ¿Ø Ø Ø 0 & À Ø

( À Ø & À ½ À Ø ½ & ½ ¿ ¿

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.34/45

Page 35: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Results: # 1 $ # ( )

States: Ö ù and Ð.

1300 1500 1700 1900 2100ECM (MeV)

0

0.005

0.01

0.015

0.02

0.025

|T|2 (1

/MeV

2 )

Σ∗πΞ*K

(S,I)=(−1,0)

Λ(1520)

Pole at ½¾ ¾ À &Ú MeVcouples strongly to Ö ù

channel.PDG » ¼ ½¾ ¿ À Á

The peak around 2000MeV is a threshold effect.

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.35/45

Page 36: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Couplings of various to channels

*,+ ½¾ ¾ À &Ú

-. / -. /

Ö ù ¿ À & ½ ¾ ¿¾ Ð À & À Ù ½ ¿

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.36/45

Page 37: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Results: # 1 $ # ( )

States: " Ð, Ö ù , Ö ( and Ð.We find three poles in the complex energy plane

1300 1500 1700 1900 2100ECM (MeV)

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

|T|2 (1

/MeV

2 )

∆KΣ∗πΣ∗ηΞ*K

(S,I)=(−1,1) −

Σ(1670)

Σ(1940)

Pole at ½Ú Ø ¿ & ½¾ MeVwith strong coupling to " Ð channel.PDG: Ö ¼ ½Ú À Á , ' Ú À

MeVPole at ò23 ®54 Ã ò ®3 MeV. Too broad !

Pole at ¿À ¿½ & ¾ is asso-ciated to Ö ¼ ½ À Á with ' ¿ ¿À MeV in the PDG

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.37/45

Page 38: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Couplings of to various channels

*+ ½Ú Ø ¿ & ½¾ ½Ú Ù & ½ Ù ¿ À ¿½ & ¾

-. / -. / -. / -. / -. / -. /

Ð Ø & À ÀØ Ø À & ½ ½ Ù À & À ¾ À ÚÖ ù ½ ½ 0 & À ½ ½ ¿ ¿ & ¿ À Ø À À Ø 0 & À Ù À Ù

Ö ( ½ Ù & À Ø ½ ½ 0 & À Ú ½ ½ À & À ½ ¿

Ð À Ø 0 & À ¾ À Ú ¿ & ½ Ø À ¿¾ 0 & ½ À ¿

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.38/45

Page 39: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Results: # 1 $ # ( )

States:Ö " Ð, ù , ( and Ð.We find four poles in the complex energy plane

1300 1500 1700 1900 2100ECM (MeV)

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

|T|2 (1

/MeV

2 )

Σ*KΞ∗πΞ∗ηΩK

(S,I)=(−2,1/2)

Ξ(1820)

Ξ (?)

The pole at ½ Ù & ½¾

MeV is associated withthe ¼ ½ Ù ¿À Á which has ' ¿ ý 67Ñ 6 Õ MeVwidth (on real axis) appears reduced dueto Flatt 8:9 effect

Poles at ò3 æ è 4 Ã ò3 è and ò ¬ è; 4 Ã ò æ ®

MeV are too broad to show up

Pole at ¿½Ú ¿ & ½ MeV couples strongly to Ð Ô

quasibound state !Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.39/45

Page 40: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Couplings of to various channels

< ê ò3 2 æ 4 Ã ò ë>= ; ¬ ì ò3 æ è 4 Ã ò3 è ò ¬ è; 4 Ã ò æ ® è ò 2 è 4 Ã ò ¬

 Š Š Š Š Š Š Š Å

µ ? ± ò ¬@ Ã; ® è ; ò 3 4 Ã ò ò è ò ò ò @ Ã; ò ò ò ; æ 4 Ã; ; È

A ? º ; È @ Ã; ¬ ò ò è æ 4 Ã ò 3 è ¬ ò ò 4 Ã ò ® è ; ; è @ Ã; ® ; ®

A ?:B è È @ Ã; è è 2 ò @ Ã ò æ ò ¬ æ È @ Ã ò ® æ 3 ; 4 Ã; æ ; È

C ± ; ò 4 Ã; ® ; ® è æ 4 Ã; ¬ è ò 2 4 Ã; ò ® è ò @ Ã; ¬ è æ

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.40/45

Page 41: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Results: # 1 , # ( )

States: " Ð and ( .

1300 1500 1700 1900 2100ECM (MeV)

0

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

|T|2 (1

/MeV

2 )

Ξ*KΩη

(S,I)=(−3,0)

Ω (?)

We find a pole at ¿½ ½ &Ø Ù MeVCould be associated tothe ¼ ¿ ¿¾ À Á (***), ' ¾ ¾ D

½ Ù MeV in PDG

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.41/45

Page 42: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Couplings of to various channels

*,+ ¿½ ½ &Ø Ù

-. / -. /

Ð ½ ½ & À Ù ½

( Ø Ø 0 & À Ø

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.42/45

Page 43: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

Formulation

Example: E 4 ò , F ;

G H ± H G I ±J µ ?J º I µ ? H º H µ ? HB µ ? I ºJ A ?J ± I A ? H ± H

G H ± H è è 4 ò ò 4 ç æ ; ; ;

G I ±J è ; 4 ò 4 ç æ 4 ò ; ;

µ ?J º I è è ; ; è ;

µ ? H º H ; ; 4 è ò 4 ò

µ ? HB ; ; ç æ ç æ

µ ? I ºJ è ; è

A ?J ± I è 4 ò

A ? H ± H è

Å µ ? º KML ; N L OP Å µ ? I ºJ N 4 O P Å µ ? H º H N 4 O P Å µ ?J º I N

;Å A ?Q KML ; N L OR Å A ? HQ H N 4 OR Å A ?J Q I N

to finally get for KML ;

µ ? º A ? Q

µ ? º S ç2

A ? Q æ

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.43/45

Page 44: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

N/D Method

Unitarity states that, above threshold,

TU V W4 ò ¼X ÁY ÃZ [ Ã Ãù X

\ ÃZ U V ] ¼X Á

Using a subtracted dispersion relation

W4 ò ¼X Á ] ¼X Á 0 ^4 ò ¼X Á

where ] ¼_ Á

contains an arbitrary subtraction constant and^4 ò

accounts for contact terms which remain at tree levelwhen ] À .The above equation can be cast as

W T½ ^ ]Y 4 ò ^ 0 ^ ] W

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.44/45

Page 45: Dynamically Generated Resonances from Baryon Decuplet ...hadron.physics.fsu.edu/nstar/TALKS/Saturday/sarkar.pdf · Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction Sourav Sarkar Universidad de Valencia-IFIC,

NSTAR05, Oct 12-15, Tallahassee

`·¶ a ø ¸ ¹

The actual amplitudes are given by

Ûã äå âã äå L bã äå âã äåÛà cå â à cå L bà cå â à cåÛßà áâã äå L bßà áâã äå d ë O R è PR e f>g h 4 f ìi R)j kJ l ë m:n ì ë4 ò ì lJ k ç S º

Ûã ä â ã äå L bã ä âã äå d ë O R è PR e fg h 4 f ìi R)j kJ l ë m:n ì ë4 ò ì lJ k ç S º

Ûß à áâ ßà á L bßà áâ ßà á ld ë OR è PR e f>g h 4 f ìi R j kJ l ë m n ìpo

o d ë O R è PR e f q g h 4 f q ìi ?R)j k rJ l ë msn q ì ë4 ò ì k rJ k S º

Dynamically Generated

Ê Ë]Ì ÍÎ Ï

Resonances from Baryon Decuplet-Meson Octet Interaction – p.45/45


Recommended