Date post: | 30-May-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | kzaiusa6978 |
View: | 222 times |
Download: | 0 times |
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 1/40
A Q u a r t e r ly Ma g az in e fo r
B i o p r e n e u r s
Art : Sanjoy Rakshit
Vol.1, No.1, April 2008
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 2/40
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 3/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 3
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
Prologue:
W e know that every business is related to either inventive or innovative products or
services and it must face some ups and downs throughout the phases of its
development. Ultimately, and quite fortunately, a stage usually appears in typical
development that can offer some comfort and satisfaction to participants of most
business ventures. But purists in any field will advocate neither satisfaction, nor
comfort alone, for its own sake. It is dedication, business zeal, will power to prove
proficiency, an d t he u nforgett able love of a product t ha t en tices most people involved
to continue serving business goals. Our focus and our prime concern in this book is
to explore bioventure an d th e jour ney of a bioventurer .
B ioventure represents a microcosm of the world at large concentrated into the small
word of biological venture capital. As far as biopreneurs are concerned we have to
define a scenario with a different kind of light—a light of a different color and
temperature. It is an interesting and exciting a time for people wanting to
appr eciate t he world of bioventu re. And th is is plainly becau se biotechnology, withemergent educational, governmental, and industrial support, is moving toward its
wave crest.
W e can think of bioventure being a sleek aerodynamic car racing on three wheels—
technology, management, and capital. Each wheel is extremely sophisticated, and
must be taken care of appropriately to drive the car to an ultimate and optimal
destination. After spending many years learning and teaching, when I joined the
practiced field of authentic business, I realized the need for the proper
understanding of those three driving wheels. As people from the field of research
work, and management, we may be aware of the greater issues related to our own
unique ar eas of interest, but to be a tr uly successful biopreneur we must h ave a
comm an ding gras p on all thr ee driving wheels in our bio-business.
W hen we look a t t he world of bioventure we find severa l cases wh ere people inten ded
to invest heavily, but due to a lack of suitable knowledge they decided to shy away.
There a re insta nces where compa nies ha ving a potent ial to expand their horizons by
meeting a mere few necessities—such as patenting their ideas, and technology.
Simply having enough information and facts regarding selling intellectual property
or research-based material to pharmaceutical establishments may help some
budding biovent ur es to succeed. But in sufficient informa tion also cau ses compa ra ble
ventu res t o lag behind oth er m ore aggressive compet itors.
W hen these r ealizations stru ck m e, I felt th ere was a lack of one extra ordina ry itemin our imm ediate a rea which could solve our collective problems. Tha t extr aordina ry
item was a qu ality study cur riculum tha t m ight be of assistance to all people in t he
field of bioventure. My intent is that this study material must contain substantial
information for all—upcoming entrepreneurs, people from the field of management,
an d su ited investors. This would not only to serve gettin g people from va rious fields
under the one roof—bioventure—but it would also create a feeling of unanimity
within bioventur e.
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 4/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 4
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
W orking together has always been a fun for people like us. Now we have the means
to create that same fun—multiplied—by networking our talents, invented drugs,
and various other biotechnological products. At the same time there could be an
additional benefit waiting for each of us involved, in the form of earned capital. In
all honesty, that is simply one future that I dream of for bioventure. The best
possible future relies on greater understanding among the people associated with
this business. This will be possible only if we can integrate our knowledge and
experience, and opera te wit hin each oth er’s r espective fields of expert ise. If we can
appreciate the views that those among us want to share, and vice versa, then a
tr easu re t rove in bioventu re is not far off.
~~ Biopreneur Editorial Board
~~~~ *** ~~~~Taft Stett inius & Hollister LLP – www.taftlaw.com
Founded in 1885, Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP continues to focus on the future, offeringsolutions and opportunities in an ever-changing world. Taft has more than 200 attorneys whopractice in a wide range of legal areas and service both U.S. and international clients, from start-up t echnology companies to publicly traded and internat ional corporations.
Medzym – www.medzym.com Medzym, Inc. is a privately held biotechnology company focused on building molecular
therapeutics based on effective platform technologies. Company’s current focus is on Age-related eye disorders- (1) eye-diseases, (2) Anti-Inflammatory/Allergy, and (2) Cardio-vascular.
Nort hern California Polytechnic (NorCal Poly) University (NCPU) is located in Silicon
Valley.California. The mission of NCPU is to provide students with amultidisciplinary and intercultural understanding of the world that enriches theirlives while actively participating in the global marketplace of commerce, culture,and technology. NCPU offers graduate degree programs, general educat ion,services and activities to enhance the academic and personal development of
students.
Technoedits is providing technical writing, editing and copywriting services to the
biotech/high-tech organizations. Biopreneur uses tecnoedits for its selective needs andservices. For more information contact [email protected].
PATRONS
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 5/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 5
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
WHO ARE BIOPRENEURS?Mi yu k i S h ir a t a n i a n d R y a n B a id y a
Cup er t i no , Ca l i fo r n i a
Biopreneurs or bioentrepreneurs are
normally adventurous, innovative,
analytical, problem solvers. PhD
training in any given field gives the
primary skills and core knowledge of
that field. However, there is anotherwhole set of skills and understanding
that is not covered in normal PhD
training. That aspect is the
understanding of entrepreneurship
itself, which makes it easier to
manage and administer the aspects of
a specific business. With bioventure
comes extreme complexity that
requires business knowledge and
understanding. To become an
established and successfulbioentrepreneur no one can avoid the
business aspects of such a venture. A
successful biopreneur must acquire
and command the necessary basic
knowledge of general business
practices. Plan ning a business and t he
execution of that plan to achieve real
success are two completely different
aspects of bionventure, or of any
business. A person may have to go
through an intermediary phase, or
phases—becoming a technicalma na ger—and m ight also have to be a
lead scientist or researcher as well.
The transition from technical
contributor to technical manager is
not easy. Globally, in biotechnology,
scientists are often given the
responsibility for projects and people
without much thought or additional
management training. This is
especially true in the case of
biopreneurs who want to establish a
business without outsideadministrative help. If they transition
perfectly—i.e. they understand the
proper place and roles of
administrative people and mold
themselves in accord with that—
th ey’ll gain t he sa me out come a s
having outside managers brought into
the team. The fact is that some
biopreneurs make the transition
rather well, though many experts
agree that the industry has had arough time in such transitional
phases; it needs improvement. So, to
reach the peak in your business, you
cannot underestimate the need forefficient management styles.
Try to understand what happens
within th e minds of ma ny biopreneur s.
Failure in the transitional stage to
manager occurs because most people
with a PhD in biotechnology, while
chalking out a business plan, focus onth e scientific an d t echnological aspects
of the whole matter. As they consider
their potential product and related
incidentals, they see it only from a
scientist’s point of view. Thus when it
comes t o the adm inistrat ive a spects of
the venture, they believe that
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 6/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 6
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
implementing supervisory skills is
simply a matter of time and gaining
experience. They expect it to be a ba sic
learning situation while they operate
their n ew business.
Sta n Sewitch, a h uma n r esources (HR)
consultant in San Diego, contradicts
that all too common belief saying,
"Management is not an additional set
of responsibilities requ iring n ew skills
to be added to one's professional
repertoire," he continues,
"Management is an entirely different
career from that of the individual
contributor in science." Sewitch,
form er dir ector of hum an resour ces for
Mycogen, San Diego, CA, USA, addsthat technical professionals too often
believe that managing people is a
skill-set to be acquired. In most cases,
they find out t oo late th at th is isn't th e
case. It’s best to take Sewitch’s advice
seriously from the very outset of a
project.
A researcher willing to set up a
business based on h is or h er concept in
biotechnology, known as a biopreneur
in the industry, must achieve several
useful qualities to reach the goal of
becoming a successful businessman.
Along with gaining managerial
awareness it is also advantageous to
know how they themselves are
different from other businessmen. It
surely helps them to smooth out any
pertinent difficulties while adding
indispensable qualities. It is essential
to prospective biopreneurs to prepare
for the future by learning and
planning for their bio-venture. They
must understand, along with otherthings, prior to commencing their
business, their own drawbacks and
weaknesses and how they may
overcome t hem or a t least be pr epared
to face them.
TRAITS OF A RESEARCHER AND A BUSINESSPERSON
RESE ARCHE R BIOPRE NEU R (Science+ Business)
Determinant & Stubborn Determinant
Ambitious Ambitious with rea lism
Pr oblem solver Pr oblem solver & delegat or
Un boun d Explorer Disciplined Explora tion
Risk tak er Risk tak er & hedger
Leader ship (some cases) Leader ship & Team Player
Cheer leader (some cases) Cheer leader
Sales person (some cases) Sales person
Ha rd worker Ha rd worker
From the above chart it is quite clear
that researchers and biopreneurs are
different in fundamental ways. You
can recognize one thing clearly; if you
are willing to become solely a
researcher you may follow one path,
inventing new things day in and day
out. But if your goal is to become a
successful businessman you will have
a somewhat different pa th way to ta ke.
Table 1: Characteristic differences between Researcher and Businessperson
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 7/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 7
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
If fortune is inviting you to become a
biopreneur you must choose a special
lifestyle— one where you must play
both roles—researcher and
businessman. Along with the
characteristics that a researcher
exhibits a biopreneur carries
additional attributes which demand
particular attention. For example, a
researcher’s character-set insists on
being ambitious. In contrast the
character of a biopreneur requires
ambition based on reality. That
“reality” makes an ideal situation
because in bioventure you must work
to promote yourself along with your
compa ny’s br an d. Ther e is n o place for
airy ambition as you are required toma ke a pr ofit for your investors. In th e
case of bioventure, you will be forced
into certain obligations such as:
competitive intelligence, task-
management, finding investors and
funding, tax concerns and monetary
returns for your investors, marketing
strategies, concrete branding—the
future of your brand, reworking
corporate structure etc. These things
will prevent you from exploring new
product-lines without ample concernfor profit in the venture. Thus, still
retaining characteristics of a
researcher, which you truly are, you
will also think and execute things like
a businessman. That means not to
embellish, so that you will become an
ideal biopreneur.
Valuable opinions
Co-founder and Chairman of
Responsys, Inc., Anand Jagannathantalked about the characteristics
required to be an entrepreneur.
Entrepreneurs need to have
determina tion a nd dr ive, the a bility to
face rejection, a nd t hey need t o be risk
takers. They must know their “value
proposition” with respect to customer
“pain points.” Most successful
entrepreneurs, Jagannathan suggests,
have a clear definition of their
personal success that goes beyond
reaching the IPO stage, an ability to
listen an d ada pt to cust omer ’s
requirements, and the ability to
recognize and seize opportunity.
Though it may be easy to read or
listen to this, it’s really very difficult
to follow through. And, to materialize
th e whole concept is even ha rder .
Mr. Bipin Shah, a successful
entrepreneur, now a V.C. in the
Silicon Valley, once presented advice
to the new entrepreneurs:
•• SStt aa rr tt oonn llyy iif f yyoouu aa rr ee ccoomm mm iitt tt eedd f f oorr tt hh ee lloonn gg hh aa uu ll
aa nn dd pp rr eepp aa rr eedd tt oo ggoo tt hh rr oouu gghh
tt hh ee uu ppss aa nn dd dd oowwnn ss ..
•• SStt aa rr tt oonn llyy iif f yyoouu hh aa vvee tt hh ee
ddeeeepp eess tt p paassssiioonn f f oorr wwhh aa tt
yyoouu aa rr ee ggooiinn gg tt oo ddoo..
•• SStt aa rr tt oonn llyy iif f yyoouu aa rr ee
pprr eeppaa rr eedd tt oo ““ f f aa ii ll”” iif f tt hh iinn ggss
ggoo ““ww r r oonn gg”” aa nn dd tt hh eeyy ““d d oo…… ””
•• SStt aa rr tt oonn llyy iif f yyoouu aa rr ee
aa bbssoolluu tt eellyy ccoonn vviinn cceedd tt hh aa tt
yyoouu aa rr ee k k ii lllliinn gg aa r r eeaall p paaiinn
tt hh aa tt eexxiiss tt ss iinn tt hh ee mm aar r k k eet t
t t ood d aa y y ..
Though an old familiar story but
probably novel to new entrepreneurs—
starting anything new always has risk
factors, which could lead to failure. If
you are inclined to stop at this point,
or move on to other tangential visions,
you m ay never retu rn to your dr eam of
establishing a real bio-venture and itwill rema in merely a fant asy. Whether
it’s a n ew, or an est ablished ventu re,
risk is always an innate part of the
game. But you have to stick to your
original choice of acquiring success.
Gururaj “Desh” Deshpande rejected
thoughts of returning to his life as a
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 8/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 8
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
professor and software engineer—Re:
book titled From Financial Flop to
Billionaire. After his first failure,
Desphande stayed the course, always
true to his original vision. Now a very
successful entrepreneur, he relates: “A
manager means doing things (the)
‘right way’ and a leader means doing
the ‘right things.’” If it's something
you really believe in, he asserts,
"…you're going to ma ke it h app en."
Here, before you decide which role fits
you best, you have to know exactly
what right thing and exactly which
right way… Reading theories and
building a business plan, based on
theory alone, is not very hard, maybeeven a little too easy. Your planning
must be based first on reality. After
tha t you ha ve to be prepared to pursue
essential intermediate goals in order
to achieve success. First and foremost,
you m ust consider possible risk factors
tha t you or your compan y may need t o
face. Risks have to be faced; not
succumbing to your fears will make
you an ultimat e winner .
Leader ship—It’s ExpectedOutstanding leaders in business have
the ability to convince others. You
must have the ability to inspire your
peers and to execute things at the
right time. You have to motivate
investors and pa rt ners to have faith in
your abilities and concepts, so that
they do not waver to invest or support
your decisions.
It is particularly true that gainingsomething is frequently easier than
retaining it. Leadership is that same
sort of thing. As a leader you may
ha ve to ma ke decisions with out ha ving
all the information at hand, but your
decisions will have to be a strong
enough so that no one will want to
oppose you afterward. Though only
real experience helps true leaders to
make decisions effectively,
nonetheless, many times intuition,
based on personal and concrete
understanding, is also a great and
positive ass ist.
You have to stick to your decisions
until a time when you find significant
flaws in them. Here you will have to
mindful that as a leader you must not
play the part of a dictator. Good and
generous leaders have their goals
focused on their team’s goals. You
have to be always ready to listen to
your people because they may, in fact,
have better ideas in mind than you.
You mu st bu ild a good team to execut ewhat you think. Thus capable minds
should surround you—their
suggestions, comments and
interpretations will always be helpful.
You should try to remain the center-
point of the team, and so your
communicating skills will keep them
in concert. You have to be strongly
connected to your team-members,
ready to listen to and talk to them as
needed.
It may appear to be the job of
ma na gers but you a lso mu st learn h ow
to separate your inner being—
compartmentalizing yourself as
required for a group venture. You
must know how to gain the qualities
needed to accomplish th e du ties of full
leadership. You have to sanction
yourself with powers like ego-power,
self-power an d agency-power. And it is
your soul-power—the power of yourspirit—that will keep you totally
responsive to all appropriate feedback.
Tha t power will never lead you to feel-
on-top of anyone, nor beneath anyone
either. Also ego, if used positively, can
make you self-aware; it can increase
positive values in your life. But
remember, your ego-power must not
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 9/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 9
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
BIOPRENEUR
become tactless egotism—self-centered
selfishness—optimally it should
lightly touch egoism , i.e. self-interest.
That difference subtlety prevents you
from losing your hu ma nity.
As Deepak Chopra has shared, you as
a leader have to have the ability to
look and listen—not normal looking,
and listening—you must not be
blinded to observing reality. For the
best possible future of your business,
you must not be deaf to free-flowing
ideas and advice from your partners
and your subordinat es.
Interestingly, this vision is not
only for you, but also for the sake of social justice and environmental
responsibility. After all you must be
responsible for any harm caused to
am bient su rr oundings if it’s caused by
your bioventure. So you ought to
cultivate a sense of consciousn ess, an d
social-environmental awareness.
Consciousness differentiates tangled
hierarchies. Consciousness is
necessary to virtually connect with
reality. And so, it is a sense of
consciousness, and awareness, thatevery human being, whether in
business or any field or job, must
possess, for the betterment of society
an d the environmen t in genera l.
A Simple Philosophy
Business is a service for the society
and money is the by-product of that
service. Every time, as you think of
building a new venture, you ought to
remind yourself of that sta tement . Theby-product of the business is your
profit and it is the living blood of your
company, but the service you provide
to society must not be any less than
oxygen. That might be considered yet
an other responsibility, but as a leader
you have to be prepared for such
concepts.
Leadership is dependent on time and
circumstances. You must be prepared
to prove your abilities every time you
are faced with requisite
circumstances. You have to create a
wholly positive environment for
ongoing pr ojects. As a leader you ha ve
to have understand synchronicity—a
sense of co-ordination, and a sense of
harmony within several jobs. A leader
feels, visualizes, takes a risk, and
accomplishes a comm itmen t t o pick u p
broken pieces, as he or she moves
along to meet various goals. A leader
never loses the winning spirit.
Nearing the end of this section, Iwould like to recap and philosophize.
It’s not wrong to say th at leaders, and
followers, co-create each other.
Leaders, followers and environments
co-arise within the same space and
time. It is rule itself th at different iates
the ruler from others. Although there
are several points or characteristics
that may help an entrepreneur to
manage the role of the ruler , there is
nothing that is fixed in any business.
Rules work for business, but businessis never for the sake of rules. Rules or
basic guidelines to prepare your
business are conceived from previous
business experiences.
As a leader you will have to mak e your
own rules. Time will allow such
opportunities. Then why talk about
not-making-rules or avoiding it? Why
listen to other people? It is for a
breakthrough or to invent new orbetter rules, when you will reach new
vantage points of understanding—
newer positions of understanding,
th us m odifying older ru les.
Knowledge is only a stairway that
leads you to a level of success—you
have to become successful first, by
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 10/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 10
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
devising your own strategy. When
your strategy is proven, you will
establish your own rules in which to
rule your business, a s you s ee fit. This
tipping point will be perceived as the
birth of a real industry leader. …Hats
off!
Inside th e Minds of Biopren eur s
Now you know or at least have a
vague n otion of wha t a biopreneur is, a
hint of the managerial aspects of the
job, as well as t he r ole an d th e ways of
a lea der. Now let’s ta ke a brief jour ney
through the mind of a biopreneur.
What they hold in their minds makes
them different from other r esearchers,
as it also makes them known to theworld! What is the inspiring source of
such strong will-power! According to
Mr. Olaf Isachson, the author of
Joining the Entrepreneurial Elite, the
ten most traits of entrepreneurs,
includin g biopreneu rs possess, are:
• They are in charge of their own
destiny. Contradicting this,
anyone can say that every man
is the master of his own
destiny, it is true! But the
winning drive is this: Like
other people, entrepreneurs,
when problems arise, do not
leave their destiny in hands of
an unforeseen circumst ance.
• T hey are non-conform ists, able
to be stand-alone or be with
people. It is their iron mettle
that helps them to face any
situation. They know how to
mold themselves in accordancewith a given situat ion.
• They move beyond the local, the
provincial, the familiar and the
tried and true. In short they
are t rue r isk-takers.
• They avoid time-consuming
trifles and are swift to make
decisions. True leadership is
always a part of their
character. Always, even in the
roughest and hardest
situations, they remain cool
and calm—to make the right
an d best decisions.
• There are no obstacles, only
challenges and temporary
setbacks. The word obstacle
does not exist in the vern acular
of biopreneurs. It is a merely a
challenge, as th ey love to call it,
and obviously it is a challenge
th at m akes them so excited and
charged.
• The harder they work the more
energy they generate. Theygenerally possess nonstop
energy to go on, and on, and
on…
• They love what they do, and
their devotion and passion
allows t hem to move beyond the
confin es of th emselves. Th e
passion and love for what you
are about to do will make its
outcome much better, and of
cour se gen era lly positive.
• They are visionaries and their
biggest competitors are
themselves. It is ultimately
their unique vision and
decisions that make up
responsibilities for t he futu re of
their ventures. Certainly, if
they are wrong, they will
reverse an imminent
catastrophe.
• T hey seldom give up. Failure is
not in their vocabulary. Jus tlike the word obstacle they are
not ready to think of failure. A
small piece of advice here: it is
better to have confidence, not
thinking of failure or obstacles,
but you have to keep your eyes
open for anything of that sort
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 11/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 11
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
too, so that you find yourself
and your people ready to face
it, if it a ppears in t he futur e.
• They firmly believe there are no
sins of commission—only those
of om ission. That may differ
depending on the individuals.
However, it is also a particular
trait tha t biopreneurs possess
quite pr oudly.
Pa ths to success
We always like to know and teach,
especially when we know a lot about
business, leadership, etc., or about a
formula that may bring success. I do
not think there is any generalized
formula or equation that can be usedto define su ccess. However, this does
not prevent us from exploring and
finding a clust er of form ula s, or sets of
characteristics, that may give us a
foreseeable indication of a pathway to
success. In bioventure this information
is quite valuable. It is actually based
on experience as well as the
experiments of others who might
inform us about possible, though not
100% flawless, paths to success. One
th ing might be applicable to X, th ough
it may not equally be applicable to Z,
an d so on. A group of scholar s at
MIT’s Sloan School of Management
did research on this subject for five
years . Accordin g to th eir studies here
is th eir m odel for s uccess:
• Success takes a balance of forces.
Techn ology is not a lways necessar y
an d is almost never su fficient.
•Due to the power of opencommunication by the virtue of the
Internet revolution, the business
model of future company might be
a huge corporation or it might be a
very small enterpr ise.
• Decentralization is key phrase of
th e future. In order to be
successful one must make
decisions based on ones proximity
to the knowledge of his or her
customers.
• True activities, not the corporate
organization charts, will become
the primary building blocks in a
business. Out-sourcing and
alliances will eliminate the need
for huge personnel, and becomes
the enabler of the small
businessperson intent on staying
lean but growing into a big
business.
• Companies large and small will be
both global an d local. They will
need the local touch and all will
face global compet ition.• The most impacting discovery of
this research is regarding the
coming golden era of
m icroenterprises—a vision that is
saturated in the power of Internet.
Given the low cost of
communications, everyone can be
well informed and thus will make
good decisions . The high ly
motivated, the creative and
innovative, the biopreneur, will
convert imparted data and
knowledge into business wisdom,
and build successful companies to
compete with gorilla-corporations.
As I already ha ve ment ioned th ese are
possible ways; it dep ends u pon you, a s
you are the sole responsible agent for
the future of your company. It is
useful and a wise decision for the time
being to read these ideas to
comprehend the right way before youmake any hasty decisions. No one and
nothing in particular will bring
success unless you understand and
decide what is good for you. It is well
said that success is the progressive
realization of a worthy goal. Success
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 12/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 12
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
comes from the ability to feel
compassion.
Success Redefined
Inderjit Singh, founder and CEO of
Infiniti Solutions and also TIE
Singapore, a member of parliament in
Singapore, he has shared the story of
his entr epreneursh ip. Acquiring a
seat in government or joining a
multinational company formerly
defined success in Singapore. This
might resonate with many of us who
have known success in Japan, or have
equated it to signing-up with a
multinational organization, or gaining
a governm ent position. Singh climbed
the ladder of success in Singaporethrough the same means. But then he
attempted something a bit different;
he was able to acquire venture
funding from inside of Singapore, and
from abroad. In doing this he
ultimately realized his
entrepreneurial dream by changing
previously construed, or tacitly
defined, limits.
He said, as a member of par liamen t he
championed the cause of transformingSingapore from a corpora te bas ed
economy into an entr epreneur ial one
by addr essing all concerns,
impediment s, and challenges to
entr epreneur ship—his mission
leaving: “no stone left u nt ur ned.”
Accordin g to him t he k ey
characteristics required to be a
successful entr epren eur ar e as follows:
1) Determination
2) Risk-taking 3) Leadership
4) Number one sales person and
nu mber one cheerleader
5) Problem solver
So you see t he ba sic tra its required to
be a successful entrepreneur stay
sam e. It is only th e met hod of utilizing
these traits that change. Over the
course, methods change with things
such as the mind, time, and
circumstances.
Though not directly connected to
bioventure let us share another
important success story. A well
circulated story, if not well known, is
one in which Ireland was looking to
become a major center for Microsoft
and wanted a major server hub.
Unfortunately, Microsoft’s
investigat ion revealed tha t Irela nd’s
electronic infrastructure could notsupport it because it did not have
enough resident bandwidth. So
everything stopped. What to do now!
There was no looking back and no
crying tears of woe. Ireland took on
the enterprise, implementing the
required bandwidth building it to the
latest specifications in a very short
span of time. The rest is history, thus
establishing Ireland as a global center
of excellence in Internet activity. And
that is how one should be prepared forany forthcoming or unforeseen,
unexpected, problem. Now then two
questions ar ise:
How would an other count ry h ave dealt
with such a challenge?
How are other countries prepared to
participate in similar dynamic and
global marketplaces?
The problem and its solution
will remain at their places we just
have to find them out. Now that we
have enjoyed a little bit of success
kind a thing, let us explore some new
ways to attend success:
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 13/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 13
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
Some Critical Success Fa ctors In Biopr eneu rs
! Str ong Will Power Tha t Ca n Motivate Oth ers.
! Ear ly Conta ct With Successful Ent repreneur s.
! Exposure To Success St ories And Cas e Stu dies.! Gain Practical, Real World Experience Before, During And After
PhDs.
! Be Willing To Be Un usu al/Unconvent iona l.
! Agree To Embr ace Risk, And Possibly Fa ilur e.
! Ready To Leave A Lar ge Compa ny.
! Great Idea To Sta rt With.
! Excellent And P ass iona te Team - Near And Long Term Vision.
! Ability To Chan ge Cour se Mid Strea m.
! Execution, Execution And Execution!!
! Strategic And Marketing Brilliance.
! Fr ugality & Excellent Cash Mana gement.
! Support Network - VCs, Board, Advisory Board And Other Value
Add People.
Though it may look like
bringing the same old line in front
again, I should like to remind you
again that things are not to be
followed strictly. Those are important
yet very flexible ru les. Those tools ar e
for the sake of your business and your
business is not there to prove their
practicality. Every ruler creates
his/her own r ule but it’s only after you
be sure of calling yourself a ruler inbusiness.
Sum up
As someone once said, the best
of us is not what we do but what we
inspire in others. Thus when we sha re
our experience and knowledge it
increases. Whatever the way we
choose or wherever we move to work
the basic knowledge and way will
remain the same. We may face failure
and obstacles only to remember,
“Fa ilure is one of th e ma jor m ilestones
of an entrepreneur and each obstacle
is an opport un ity”. It’s not a th eory, as
a theory is also based on what we
learn out of our failure and
experiment, but our own flaw andfailure will teach us the right way to
success. It will make us winner one
day. Everything is dependant on our
mind as Silicon Valley is not a
geographical location it is just a “state
of mind”. Think as a winner and you
will find yourself as a winner. If you
Tab le 2 : S ucces s F ac to r s i n B ioven tu re
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 14/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 14
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
loose the vigour of your mind you will
be nowhere in near fut ure.
If experiment is the only thing
tha t you ha ve in h an d, do it sincerely,
genuinely and with an inimitable
passion for t hem. With th e hum an life
span longer and the business cycle
shorter, the opportunities are
immense for those with the
motivation, the temperament, a nd t he
guts to do it their way. There was no
one-way, there is no one-way and
there will be no one-way. It was the
biopren eur ’s wa y, it is t he biopren eur ’s
way and it will be the biopreneur’s
way.
(This artilce is taken from a book
titled – Biopreneurs: the Molecular
Millionaires)
M i yu k i S h i r a t a n i currently is in charge of int ernationa l logistic for Devicenet, US A,
Inc. S he ha s over 10 years’ international and m ulticultural experience (J apan, US ,
India) in both IT and biotech in du stries. S he also held responsibilities of
international m arketing com m un ications at S harp E lectronic Corp., Osaka , Japan;
and sale/ custom er relations at J US CO, J apan. S he received h er BA at Kansai
Gaidai Un iversity, Osaka , J apan, and MBA at the S an J ose state University, CA.
Ryan Ba id ya is an entrepreneur a business strategist and who has 12+ years of
experience in biotech. He lau nch ed several biotech an d h igh-tech b usin esses in S ilicon
Valley/ US A, and T okyo/ J apan. He found ed BioZak and B ioZak-Infobase, and
served as one of the foun din g m ana gem ent. Prior to that he was w ith Genprobe, ,
HyseQ; and GeneAsia. He serves as an ad visor to Golden-Em bryo, Pune/ Ind ia; and
KZA IS oft corp., Durgapur/ Ind ia. He gave num erous lectures on life sciences an d bio-
business topics at conferences, primarily in US A, and J apan. He auth ored articles,
patents, and com m entaries. Dr. Baid ya received his MS from IIT Kanp ur, PhD from
the University of California, Santa Cruz and MBA from the San Jose State
Un iversity, CA..
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 15/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 15
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
Bio-bu s ines s – a new Gold R ush :
Bio- business comprises over 10
tr illion d ollars or 30 p ercent of the
global economy. Coun tr ies th roughout
th e world h ave identified new
opportu nities in t he bio-busin ess
ar ena a s the n ext hot technology ar ea
an d ar e investing in tr aining their
scientists, setting up state-of-the-art
life science an d t echn ology kn owledge-
clust ers, esta blishin g viable
biotechnology industries to fuel
growth in bio-business ar eas.
In th e recent year s, there is morewillingness a nd pu sh for cross-
disciplinar y work an d ventu res
between h igh-tech an d biotech.
Professional and business investors
ma y find biotech a s a new Gold Rush
of our t ime. Biotech offers in finite
opportu nities as long as hu ma n beings
reside on t his planet.
It is considered t ha t t he bio-business
is going to be the fast est gr owing
sector of th e world economy dur ingthis centur y. Some even designa te th e
21st centur y as the bio-century . This
work shop is designed t o provide non-
bio professionals a broader
under stan ding of the field, and t he
opportu nities lie with in. Can you
afford be sim ple a spectat or?
P a ra d igm o f Bio -bu s ines s :
The biotech bu siness is witnessed ineveryday life from tooth pas te t o th e
medicine cabinet. I t occupies more of
our persona l economics, an d social
rela tionships, from h appin ess to love
tha n wha t we may realize. With the
recent convergence of IT an d na notech
with biotechnology, th e Bio-field is
growing a nd en abling more economic
opport un ities to be lat ched on t o.
As every discipline goes th rough its
roller-coaster of highs and lows, bio
ha s gone th rough its own high an dlows in th e mid 80s, while th e IT-
dot.com ha d its day in th e late 90s.
During th is roller coaster ride man y
fared well in th e game while
consider able others lost a big chun k of
th eir portfolio net wort h; however, th e
fundam entals remained the same and
th ose who maneu vered with sound
under stan ding of the field far ed th e
best.
C o m m o n S e n s e s n o t c o m m o n
t r a i t s :
Comm on sense of funda ment al
doctr ines in most busines ses is
un ivers al an d applicable all of th e
time—either in a depressed or vibran t
economy. What chiefly differ ar e th e
business and t he intr insic model tha t
follows t he business. Kn owing th e
specifics a nd u ndersta nding th e
un ique-nat ur e of th e field gives oneprofessiona l tools, skills, a nd wit t o
win a r ace of apparen t a mbiguity.
People fail in th eir endea vors n ot just
becau se th ey do not kn ow, but
moreover because of confusion and
lack of confiden ce which a rises from
th e weak u nderst an ding of the
int er linkin g of th e ma ny ‘bio-pa rt s’.
Biotech, by virtue, has its own specific
an d u nique distinction. Ha ving
spher ical kn owledge an dun derst an ding of the field would help
one to mak e pru dent decisions eith er
for bu siness investm ent or for car eer
developmen t with in th e field.
R y a n B a i d y a
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 16/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 16
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
P a t e n t P r o t e ct i on fo r L ife S c ie n c e I n v e n t i on s :
U n i q u e C h a lle n g e s fo r Ap p li ca n t s
Dr . Ade l a i de K . Le i t ze l an d Dav i d A . M an c i no
Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP, Cincinnati, OH, USA
S ynops i s - Life sciences invent ors face a r igorous st an dar d for t he writt en
disclosure in pat ent a pplicat ions. Each pat ent a pplication must provide an
extensive, highly detailed am oun t of tea ching tha t en ables a hypothet ical person of
ordina ry skill in t he a rt to practice a claimed invent ion with even a modera te
am ount of breadth . The United States Pa tent a nd Tradem ar k Office is also very
careful about th e scope of an y invent ion t ha t is claimed in th e paten t ap plicat ion.
For exa mple, if there is an y potentia l for over-reaching of invent ion scope or a
claim ed app licat ion in gene th era py (which th e Pa ten t Office does not yet r ecognize),
th e pat ent a pplican t will face rejections requirin g tha t th e claim scope be
appropriately narr owed. The applicat ion can be strength ened by the appr opriate u seof deposits a nd a claim str at egy focused on th e invention ra th er t ha n th e invention’s
potential
In th e United Stat es, patent
protection can be obta ined for a ny
novel, non-obvious and useful
invent ion tha t is a process, machine,
ma nu factu re, or composition of
ma tt er. Generally, paten t protection
provides a n inventor with a right to a
monopoly on his or her invention for a
limited nu mber of years (or if th einvent or is not pra cticing the
invention, a r ight to a r easonable
royalty for oth ers’ use of the pa ten ted
invention). In excha nge for this
limited monopoly, th e inventor m ust
provide th e public (via th e pat ent
disclosur e) with a clear description of
th e invention an d th e process of
ma king and u sing the invention so
that the public can m ake and u se the
invent ion wh en t he m onopoly expires.This is the fundamental trade-off in
th e pat ent policy – the public, th rough
th e inven tor’s det ailed disclosure of
the invention in the pat ent, obtains
knowledge of the technology, while the
invent or obta ins a limited m onopoly to
the technology.
An inventor obtains paten t
protection by submitt ing a pa tent
application th at distinctly claims an d
describes his or her novel, non-
obvious, an d useful invention. The
application undergoes examination bya Pa tent a nd Tradema rk Office
Exam iner who determines if th e
invention is novel, non-obvious, and
possesses a clear u tility. In addit ion
the P atent Examiner determines if the
pat ent application’s deta iled
disclosure, kn own as th e specificat ion,
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 17/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 17
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
“cont ain[s] a writ ten description of the
invention, an d of the ma nn er an d
process of mak ing and u sing it, in such
full, clear, concise, an d exact ter ms a s
to enable any person skilled in t he ar t
to which it pert ains…to ma ke an d use
th e sa me” (35 U.S.C. §112, 1st
par agraph ). In other words, the
application mus t pr ovide a clear
writt en description of th e invent ion so
th at a h ypoth etical person “skilled in
the art ” would be able to ma ke an d
use th e invent ion (i.e., would be
“ena bled”). Inven tions in r apidly
developing techn ologies such a s t he
life sciences face pa rt icular challenges
with regard to these written
description and enablementrequirements.
The “cla ims” of an y issued
patent ar e the numbered paragraphs
at t he end tha t describe in detail the
exact scope of th e subject m at ter
covered by, or protected by the pat ent .
They are a na logous t o the boun dary
descriptions in a pr operty deed,
describing in deta il the boun dar ies of
th e paten t protection. The claims of a
paten t a pplicat ion are compa red bythe Pa tent a nd Tradema rk Office
Exam iner against th e present stat e-of-
the-art in th e present technological
field (kn own a s “prior ar t” and
including prior patents, publications,
ar ticles, litera tur e, and other
techn ologies in th e pu blic doma in).
Often times, the ma jority of the paten t
exam inat ion pr ocess involve a form al
negotiation between t he pat ent
applicant and the Examiner regardingthe precise langua ge of the pa tent
claims . Not only do th e invent ions
covered by th ese claims need t o be
novel and non-obvious over the prior
ar t, but the claims m ust also be fully
supported by the written description of
th e pat ent specification. In other
words, a patent application cannot
claim an “an ti-gra vity” ma chine if th e
pat ent specification fails to describe
how to make an d use such a ma chine.
Often biotech inventions occur
at t he nexus of hum an ingenuity and
highly complex n at ur al compositions
of ma tt er. The Applican t is faced with
th e challenge of describing a vira l
strain, hybridoma cell line, transgenic
an ima l, or a newly isolat ed gene in
such a wa y tha t it could be made or
used. Scientists routinely write
protocols tha t det ail the wa y
someth ing was m ade or isolated but
would be t he first to acknowledge
na tu ra l var iat ion in biological
ma terials. Where words alone areinsu fficient to describe th e invent ed
biological m at erial, t he P at ent Office
allows deposits of many types of
biological materials with a Patent
Depository such as t he American Type
Cult ur e Collection (ATCC). Referen ce
to an d ident ificat ion of the deposited
ma terials in a paten t application
fulfills t he wr itten descript ion
requiremen t for the deposited
ma ter ials. The benefits of depositin g
ma terial must be weighed against thecost and inconvenience of depositing
the mat erial.
In a ddition to depositing an y
claim ed biological m at erials, pa ten t
app licat ions for life science m at erials
should teach possible alterations
extensively. The Pa tent an d
Tra dema rk Office considers th e art of
biotechnology new and highly
unpr edicta ble, thus general teachingsof how to design variants are usually
not consider ed su fficient ly described to
pr ovide t he scope of coverage m ost
pat entees desire. Suppose an inventor
ha s isolated a novel nu cleotide
sequen ce encoding a high fidelity,
th ermostable polymera se and ha s
crea ted a mut an t form with extremely
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 18/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 18
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
high fidelity an d wishes t o obta in
paten t protection on t he origina l
sequence and the improved sequence.
The inventor claims his sequences and
variants tha t ha ve at least 95%
identity and ar e capable of
synth esizing DNA. In the applicat ion
the inventor sh ould describe an y
variants that he made, any variants
tha t he planned to make, any residues
tha t ar e part icularly crucial, an d any
residues th at he pr edicts could be
altered without impacting the
pr otein’s funct ion. Describe all th e
variant s tha t were made, even the less
successful ones.
These less successful var ian tsindicat e cha nges that can be ma de
without significant ly impa cting
activity and p rovide direct tea ching of
variant s within t he scope of the
invent ion. If th ere is a region of th e
protein t ha t will ha ve less impact on
activity, th e inventor should indicat e
tha t sh e recognizes tha t var iations in
tha t region ar e covered. If ther e are
regions t ha t a re cru cial for a ctivity,
the inventor sh ould describe the
subset of variations tha t m ight beaccepta ble. Alter ing a glycine residue
to alan ine, for example, might be
tolerat ed better t ha n a ltering glycine
to tryptopha n. If mu ltiple var iations
might yield different results, the
inventor should describe the potential
combina tions. Pr ovide at least one
specific functional assay for the
protein and provide a broad range of
resu lts ind icat ive of fun ction.
Deposit, describe, a nd don’t
stret ch. Suppose an inventor has
discovered an assay system t ha t
allows him to rapidly screen numerous
compoun ds for a par ticular a ctivity
th at he hopes will yield a m ulti-
million dollar medication. The
inventor should claim: the assay
system ; any n ovel componen ts of the
assay system; methods of using the
assay system; methods for performing
th e assa y to identify compoun ds with
a s pecific measu ra ble activity; an d
novel compounds tha t ar e in han d. If
th e identified compoun ds sha re well-
defined stru ctura l similarities, the
inventor should try to claim the genus
of str uctur ally similar compounds
with th e act ivity. Avoid “r each -
th rough” claims th at at tempt to cover
compoun ds t ha t could be discovered
using the novel assay.
In a nother exam ple, suppose
an invent or h as developed a n ovel
met hod of assaying a biomar ker forwhich an abnormal level correlates
with a par ticular disease state. The
invent or claims m eth ods of using th e
bioma rker assa y, compar ing the
results to a sta ndard, and
cha ra cterizing th e bioma rker level as
abnormal.
In the current Pa tent and
Trademark Office environment such
broad claims a re likely to face writt en
description rejections (a rejectionbased upon th e examiner’s ar gument
th at t he claims are not support ed by
th e written description of the paten t
app licat ion). Such broad claims will
cau se th e examiner to question
whet her t he invent ion is sufficiently
described to indicat e tha t t he
Applican t wa s in possession of th e
invention. At the very least the
app licat ion sh ould include nar row
claims tha t indicate wheth er anincreased or decreased biomarker level
corr elates with t he par ticular disease
sta te. The specification should
describe data corr elating the altered
bioma rker level with the disease th us
demonstrat ing that t he Applican t was
in possession of th e invent ion.
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 19/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 19
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
BIOPRENEUR
In a similar scenar io, the
invent or, a well-known eyebrow
specialist, h as identified a set of genes
expressed differen tly in diseased
eyebrow sam ples tha n hea lthy
eyebrow sam ples. Recognizing th e
importa nce of early diagnosis in
eyebrow disease, th e specialist invent s
a met hod of detecting eyebrow disease
based on th is differen tial expression.
The specification provides clear
evidence th at differen tial expr ession of
th e gene set occur s in ea ch of th e top
five eyebrow diseases.
The a pplicat ion claims met hods
of detecting eyebrow disease t ha tinclude t he steps of assa ying th e
eyebrow disease relat ed gene set in a
subject, compar ing the r esults t o a
predetermined standar d, and
cha ra cterizing a subject with the
appr opriate increases or decreases in
gene expression levels a s a subject
with eyebrow disease or without
eyebrow disease. Such claims ar e
likely to face a “non-enablemen t”
rejection based on th e exam iner’s
ar gument t ha t the meth od couldidentify arm pit diseases or bigtoe
diseases a s well as eyebrow disease,
thu s th e claims ar e not enabled for
met hods of detecting eyebrow disease.
To reduce the likelihood of
th ese types of non-enablemen t
rejections, include claims th at indicate
the novel method is tissue preferred.
For exam ple, provide claim s with th e
step of providing an eyebrow tissuesam ple from t he subject.
Additionally, methods that rely
on differen tial expr ession of a gene set
face increased scrutiny by th e Pa tent
an d Tradem ar k Office. While not as
firm ly rejected as gene ther apy claims ,
ther e is an increasing concern a bout
the var iability an d
repr oducibility of th e a vailable
differen tial gene expression assa ys,
par ticularly microarr ay based
methods and t he impact t hat
altera tions in th e microarra y ana lysis
softwa re’s un derlying assum ptions
could ha ve on t he a na lysis of
microarray dat a.
It is not clear to what extr eme
th e P aten t Office will tak e th is
concern ; however, it is advisable t o
teach suita ble softwar e progra ms a nd
a r an ge of par am eters th at could be
used in the microarr ay data a na lysis.
If the Pat ent a nd Tra demar k Office
regards microarr ay data a na lysisprogra ms a s a na logous t o sequence
homology progra ms, it ma y become
necessar y to specify a pr eferr ed
microarr ay data a na lysis progra m to
be used with t he invention.
Fin ally, provide claims th at
distinguish the invention from gene
therapy. The Pat ent and Trademark
Office does n ot consider gene t her apy
a viable technology; th erefore, a ny
claim th at could be const ru ed to covergene therapy is considered not enabled
for t he full breadt h of th e claim .
There ar e num erous acceptable
ways to delineat e the claims a nd th e
app ropriat e way of doing th is depends
on th e actu al invention. For instance,
th e Pa ten t Office routinely accepts us e
of th e ter m “isolat ed” tr an sform ed
cells or t issue to distinguish t he
claimed material or methods fromgene ther apy.
In s um ma ry, life sciences
invent ors face a rigorous st an dar d for
written description a nd ena blement in
pat ent applicat ions. Each paten t
application must provide an extensive,
highly detailed am oun t of tea ching to
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 20/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 20
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
provide a wr itten description t ha t
enables a claim with even a moderate
am ount of brea dth . The application
can be strengthened by the
appropriate use of deposits and a
claim str at egy focused on t he
invention r at her tha n t he invention’s
potential.
*****************************
ADELAIDE K. LEIT ZEL is a patent agent in the biotech area and w orks w ith th e
attorneys at T aft S tettinius & Hollister LLP wh o practice in the area of Patent
Prosecution. S he holds a Ph .D. in genetics and m olecular biology from th e University
of North Carolina and received her undergraduate degrees in biology and history
from Davidson College in Davidson, North Carolina. Her research recently was
published in the journa l Yeast . Dr. Leitzel also is a registered patent agent with the
U.S . Patent & T radem ark Office.
DAVID A. MAN CINO is a Partner and Co-Chair of the Intellectual Property
practice of Taft S tettin ius & H ollister LL P. Mr. Man cino’s scope of practice inclu des
patent a nd int ellectual p roperty (“IP”) litigation, paten t preparat ion an d prosecution,
IP opinion work, IP licensing, technology agreements, IP training and client
coun seling as it relates to techn ology, IP protection an d bu siness strategy. Mr. Mancino, a registered patent attorney, litigates and prosecutes patents in many
technical areas including: medical and surgical devices, prosthetics, software,
busin ess m ethods, electrical circuits, compu ter system s, comp ut er netw orks,
semiconductor device technology, and many other mechanical and electro-mechanical
techn ologies. He obtain ed his law degree from th e University of Cincinn ati S chool of
Law in 1994.
T o a u t h o r s : Contributingaut hors a re requested to
submit a short 1-2
par agr aph proposal for
ar ticles relevan t t o th e bio-
business au diences. Em ail:
biomkt [email protected]
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 21/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 21
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
Wh y d o m a n y c a n c e r p a t i e n t s r e l a p s e e ve n a f t e r
r e m o va l of t h e ir t u m o r ?
T h e p r o m i s e o f t a r g e t e d t h e r a p y a g a i n s t c a n c e r s t e m c e lls
An u r a a g S a r a n g iNeu roscience progra m, Vander bilt U niversity, Nas hville, TN, USA.
Why do ma ny can cer pat ients relapse even after r emoval of th eir tum or? How do
these aggressive tum ors spread a nd meta stasize to oth er par ts of the body? Why
has the current treatment regimen of surgery, chemotherapy and radiation therapy
failed to provide long-term su rvival for man y can cer pa tient s? These a re difficult
questions. As a potential answer, the can cer stem cell theory tha t is now at t he
forefront of cancer resea rch offers a n int riguing explana tion.
Cells that make up a patient 's tumor
may be organized in a hierarchical
ma nn er. At the top of this hiera rchy
are malignant cells that behave like
stem cells, being able to divide and
give rise to themselves and to other
tu mor cells. This sma ll subset of cells
may init iate and maintain tumor
growth. Some stu dies ha ve shown
that injecting as few as a 100 of these
cells can grow an aggressive brain
tumor (glioblastoma multiforme) inthe brain of an immunocompromised
mouse. The implicat ions of such a
findin g ar e enorm ous. These cancer
stem cells (CSC) can give rise to a
heterogeneous mix of cells as seen in
the morphology of many aggressive
tumors. If these cancer stem cells
survive the current treatment
regimen, then they may cause the re-
growth of a tum or in a patient. These
cells may invade surrounding normal
tissue or move to another location in
the body an d form a met ast atic tumor.
Current treatment modalit ies treat
the tumor as a bulk enti ty and try to
eliminate as many tumor cells as
possible. However, ta rget ed th era py
against these cancer stem cells can
provide a better means of eliminating
a tum or complet ely. Can we isolate
and eliminate them? How? How do we
spare the normal stem cells in the
body while trying to eliminate the
cancerous ones? Resear chers in
academia and industry are finding
creative approaches in the pursuit of
such a targeted therapy.
It is certainly not easy to isolate these
cells from solid tumors (brain, breast,
prostate tumors, etc.) and maintain
them in culture. However, it ispossible to isolate t hem with t he us e of
distinct cell-surface markers or
modified culture methods that favor
stem cell ma int ena nce. Recent ly,
isolation and characterization of these
cells from many solid tumors have
revealed many interesting findings:
they constitute only a rare population
of cells (between <1-5%) within the
tumor and they utilize inherent
molecular mechanisms that promote
resistan ce to radiation th erapy or drug
tr eatm ents. These findings suggest
that CSC are a hard target to go after.
At the same time, they also provide
clues that can be exploited to develop
therapies based on eliminating them.
Elucidating the molecular
mechanisms thr ough wh ich these cells
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 22/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 22
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
maintain their stem cell state, give
rise to tumor cells, resist standard
therapy, and metastasize will give us
a handle on how to target them
specifically. Resear chers ha ve
identified approaches that can
specifically target CSC or their
microenvironm ent . For exam ple,
Duke university researchers recently
demonstrated that CSC recruit their
own vasculature for nutrient support.
They also showed that preventing the
growth of new blood vessels effectively
reduced CSC nu mbers. Researchers
in Italy have suggested another
approach relying on the signaling
molecule bone morph ogenet ic protein's
(BMP) ability to terminallydifferentiate CSC into tumor cells.
This type of "differentiation therapy"
could render differentiated CSC more
susceptible to existing treatment
modalities.
The biopharma industry is exploring
opportunities to quickly bring to
market therapies based on CSC
eliminat ion. The pace of indu str ial
development in this area is picking up
as companies are generating more
exciting results related to theeffectiveness of th is appr oach. Some
of the key players in this field are
Genentech, Oncomed
Pharmaceuticals, GlaxoSmithKline,
an d Stemline Thera peutics. It may be
a matter of time before such targeted
therapies are on th e market.
Just as normal stem cells rely on
developmental cues and molecular
signaling path ways during th e growth
of an organism, CSC may utilize someof these same pathways in an
unregulated manner to support tumor
growth. Genen tech's app roach relies
on chara cterizing a nd int erfering with
these pathways to promote tumor
regression. In collaboration with
Curis, Genentech is developing
compounds that inhibit the Hedgehog
signaling pathway that is known to
play a role in CSC maintenance,
tumor growth and metastasis in skin,
brain, pancreatic, prostate and
gastrointestinal cancers, among
others . Ph ase I clinical tr ials of a
Hedgehog antagonist are currently
under way along with plans of sta rting
a P ha se II trial by this year.
Oncomed Pharmaceuticals is
employing a screening approach to
identify and develop monoclonal
antibodies that may specifically target
CSC populations. They isolate CSC
from primary human tumors, create
xenograft models of these tumors by
injecting t hese cells into mice, and t est
a panel of antibodies against thesean imal models t o determ ine promising
can didates for furt her testing. This
type of approach may identify a wider
range of potential therapeutic
candidates that can be employed
against specific tumor types.
Init iation of clinical t rials of their lead
candidate is expected to start this
year.
Some of the currently available drugs
may also eliminate CSC.
GlaxoSmithKline's Tykerb is currentlyapproved for patients with advanced
breast cancer that has spread to other
par ts of th e body. Recent ly, in two
independent Phase I clinical trials,
Tykerb was found to reduce CSC
numbers by as much as 50% in some
breast cancer patients when
adm inister ed along with Genen tech’s
Herceptin and slow the spread of the
tumor to the brain in combination
with Roche’s Xeloda . Theseencouraging results have prompted
GSK t o re-position Tykerb for deta iled
stu dies relat ed to its effect on CSC.
SL-401 from Stemline Therapeutics is
also a biologic compound in Phase I
clinical trials currently that has
demonstrated the ability to inhibit
tu mor growth by ta rgeting CSC. SL-
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 23/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 23
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
401 targets Interleukin-3 receptor,
overexpressed in Acute Myeloid
Leukaemia stem cells, and delivers a
toxin to the cells thus eliminating
them . On a very encour aging note,
one of the patients in the study, who
had been refractory to standard
chemotherapy, achieved a complete
response with SL-401 treatment
demonstrating the compound's potent
ant i-tum or activity.
As the cancer stem cell field matures,
we are likely to see more therapies
that are designed specifically against
these malignant cells within cancers.
Many technical challenges remain in
the quest towards targeted therapy
against CSC. But it is now
increasingly clear that surpassing
th ese hur dles will open up a pr omising
new and effective approach to cancer
t reatment
Anuraag Sarangi is currently pursuing a Ph.D. in the Neuroscience program at
Van derbilt Un iversity. His research focuses on th e role of the Hedgehog signa ling
pathway in brain tu m or stem cells. Prior to joining V and erbilt, he com pleted a M.S c.
in Compu ter S cience from Ind iana Un iversity in 2004. An uraag also serves as the
Co-Director of th e Tenn essee Biotechn ology Association S tu den t Ch apter.
Globa l Bu s iness Acce le ra t ion
Thr ough a n a ffiliation with th e Biopren eur
It is simple and easy and effective - ask how
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 24/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 24
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
B I O P R E N E U R S’ B IT E S
B u s in e s s P l a n Tip s F o r Th e E n t r e p r e n e u r o r I n t r a p r e n e u r
Sherr i Dohema nn
Or th o-McNei l Neu r ologics , Inc .
The bottom line - Are you an entr epreneur or Intr apr eneur? Inn ovation an d
customer knowledge should go hand in hand:
If you a re an entr epreneur , then your
customers ar e many and varied and
include pat ients, payers,
doctors/clinicians , r egulators, an dinvestors.
The good news is that you’ll always be
learn ing; a solid ha ndle on inn ovat ing
and knowing your customers and their
needs will put you a hea d of your
competitors.
The following 4 item s a re some
business plan sections r equired to
approach any investor and help you
under stan d your customers, including
lar ge compa nies for exit str at egy
options.
The da ys of winn ing on t hink ing up of
just a h ot technology inn ovat ion a re
over. Ther e is still funding to be ha d,
mer gers to be ma de, and IP O’s,
however answer those questions
before th ey stop you in your tr acks.
1) Detailed an d accur ate a ssessment
of customer or pipeline need
fulfillmen t/complem ent with
technology based on current tr eatm ent
trends.
2) Accurate assessment of any current
organizat ion’s eith er compet itors or
potent ial buyers capability measu red
against disruptive market changes-
Cartesian method.
3) Under sta nd govern an ce of lar ge
organizations tha t m ay be your
corp ora te invest or: who assesses, who
signs off decides, an d why et c.
4) Innovation, why it's now sur vival,
not just growth a nd why it's easier for
small companies to innovate and
perh aps for lar ge compa nies to buy.
L oo k in g a t y o u r c o m p a n y a n d a n y
p a r t n e r la r g e c o m p a n i e s:
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 25/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 25
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
When looking at a compan y part ner or
ass essing your own compa ny, World-
Class Operations and finance-ceteris
par ibus-is th ere t he vision to see
where your science/ technology
innovation fits with t he cust omer ? Do
you a nd your par tner compa ny know
how you'll gain cust omer comm un ity
support for the innovation?
However, you need to know how it fits
th eir pr actice reality in physiological,
pat ient pr ofile, fina ncial, an d pra ctice
deta il-to win funding from invest ors;
th at ’s what t hey’ll ask t o see. Ha ve a
reimbursem ent plan based on a
mar ket a ssessment knowing what
payer will see what value in yourproduct a nd why.
My perspective is tha t th e crea tion of
a plan t o win in th e mar ketplace
sta rts by being able to accur ately
ass ess your organizat ion's capa bility
to move this inn ovat ion forwa rd. Also,
you'd need t o see wha t h as t o be done
to increase that capability and propose
appr opriate governan ce chan ges
su pport ive of th e vision. This
requires th e necessar y comm itment
from the n eeded levels for t he cha nges
an d the right resources. The
comm un icat ion t o reinforce th e
agreement s enables the changes in
roles an d responsibilities to support
th e vision.
It seems critical tha t t he correct
cur rent capabilities and business
environment be accurately perceived
for your business an d your part ner
invest or or co-promoter . This would
be combined with horizon s cann ing
capability for wh ere t he tr ends of th e
ma rket a re going.
Days where large firms can capitalize
on- ways of doing th ings an d
techn ologies to scales u p of th e ma sses
for exten ded periods are sa id to be
over in technology mar kets becau se of
disruptive innovat ion. That is why
innovation seems necessar y for
sur vival, not just growth n ow.
Where ar e some places whereentrepreneurs or intrapreneurs can
learn more and net work?
http://www.FountainBlue.biz Lessons
in Funding
From th e Fount ain Incuba tors’ Pan el:
T ip s o n Wo r k i n g w i t h I n c u b a t o r s
# Incuba tors could be virtua l or
brick a nd m ort ar, a nd will work with you to suit your needs.
# Incubators can support you in
building your strategy,
developing your tech nology,
conn ecting you wit h fun ding
sources, connecting you with
qua lity service providers,
providing a sha redinfra stru ctur e, creat ing a
comm unity of entr epreneur s,
etc.,
# Underst an d t he options for
incubat ing compa nies and t he
value each one provides. Also
under stan d wha t your objectives
are to ensure that they are in
alignment with the
opportu nities pr esented.
T h o u g h t s o n S e c u r i n g F u n d i n g fo r
Ear ly St age L i fe S ci ence S t a r t -Ups
# Bootstrap for as long as
possible, while still making
progress.
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 26/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 26
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
# Understand when and why you
should take money and
resea rch h ow you
# can connect with the right
investors (private? Angel? VC?
Foundat ion) at th e right t ime.
# Understand the value of the
funder beyond the money - will
they provide expertise,
connections, operational
support, coaching, etc.
# When considering funding,
ensure that it will position your
company well for additional
an d futu re funding.
# SBIR gra nt s ar e a good option
for early sta ge drug
development,
however pha se one fundin g is
relatively small and gran t
findings in general
ar e episodic ra ther t ha n
cont inual. In addition, th ere
are restrictions on
how the grant monies can be
applied, although th ere is no
equ ity loss for
the findings.
* Research STTR NIH grant shttp://grants.nih.gov/grants/funding/sbir.htm,
DARPA grants
http://www.darpa.mil/body/off_programs.html,
RAID NIH gran ts
http://dtp.nci.nih.gov/docs/raid/raid_pp.html,
an d other govern ment grant options
http://www.grants.gov/search/search.do?oppId=15474&flag2006=true&mode=VIEW
* Research funding opport un ities fromprivat e foun dat ions on specific
diseases if it is relevant to your star t-
up.
Oth er Th oughts on Bu ilding Your Life
Science Compa ny
* Consider opport un ities for n ew ways
to deliver, pa ckage, and app ly etc.,
kn own dr ugs or deliver plat form s or
devices in other ways.
* The business model may evolve as
you go, with th e developm ent of
your technology, clinical trials, needs
in the m ark et, etc., Str ucture your
funding, partn ership and other
str at egies accordingly.
*Consider corpora te developmentpar tner s, investors, or gran ts (
primarily for institutions-research).
* Out sourcing developmen t m ay be an
efficient option, but choose t o
ret ain developmen t of th e core
technologies.
* Perform dru g/product developmen t
an d business development in
parallel.
* Pr otect your IP wh en work ing with
potent ial part ners, funders, etc.,
* Select your co-found ers care fully,
an d under stan d the role each will
play in t he su ccess of the compa ny.
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 27/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 27
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
* Roles of the co-founders will evolve
as t he compa ny grows. A funding
event will likely impact t he roles of
the founder s.
inform at ion from th e Ventu re Ca pital
Industry: www.nvca.org
Partnering conference information:
www.biowindhover.com.
news, info, lear n a bout la rge compa ny
partners : www.windhover.com
news, event s, an d part nering
information:
http://www.devicelink.com/mx/
Check out th e week's activities at
http://eweek.stanford.edu venture
speed rounds, Biomedical technology
showcase, and more
S h e rr i Do h em a n n is a Senior Sales professional at Ortho-McNeil Neurologics, with
eight years of experience representin g 13 m olecular enti ties to #11 d ifferent specialists
for a ran ge of 6 disease states. S he is a volun teer organizer for th e Foun tain Blu e Life
Sciences Forum, an organization that offers education and networking to life science
entrepreneurs & th eir team s such as staff m embers, advisers, board m em bers, and
investors. S herri completed a BS degree in Com bined S ciences, an in terdisciplinary
natu ral sciences degree from S anta Clara University and a ttended S tanford
Biodesign's Em erging En trepreneurs in B iomedical Techn ology in 2007. .
~~~~ *** ~~~~
for G lo b a l Ma r k e t i n g a n d B r a n d in g s t r a t e g y:
B i o p r e n e u r is a valu e-added option
tell your st or ies, invent ions a nd p rofiles to the global
biopreneurs
be with crowd that drives the engine, not drags it.
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 28/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 28
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
India
Bio
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 29/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 29
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
BioIndia ™ India h as been pr oviding the
developing world comp rise of 2/3 of th eworld’s population with t he n ecessa ry
medicines from common cold to HIV,
from antibiotics to anti-diabetics for
the past severa l decades. Over these
periods India ha s developed a well-
developed drug m an ufactur ing
industry that now poised to compete
with multina tional phar ma ceuticals
compa nies su ch as , Pfizer, Roche,
Merck and GSK globally. Initia l
model of the Bio-indu str y was t oprovide medicine to t he bottom of the
pyram ids emerging as th e model to
provide cost saving options to t he top
of the pyra mid (CK Pr aha lad).
Indian ph arm a an d biotech
corporations have obtained clearance
from F DA to lau nch severa l generics
drug in USA and m any are in th epipelines. More an d more biotech and
phar ma compa nies in India ar e
par tner ing with their count er par ts in
USA for p re-clinical a nd clinical
stu dies – an em erging bio-out sourcing
economy.
India ha s developed a solid
infrastructure for pre-clinical and
clinical stu dies t ha t is approved a ndrecognized by FDA. Recent ly FDA
expressed its intend to house
inspectors and a gents in India to
ass ist India n a nd USA bio-compa nies
in th eir drug development ,
manufacturing and regulatory
processes and compliance protocols –
A step forwa rd for BioIndia .
# Clinical tr ials in India is
growing a t a 60% AAGR# Crossed USD 100 million in
2004.
# By 2010, the indu str y will
spen d USD 300M+ on clinical
tr ials in India.
# 240 inter na tiona l studies
recru iting su bjects = 1.2% of
the total studies worldwide
# 66% of inter na tional clinical
trials are Pha se III
# 207 sites FDA register ed
# 40,000 subjects par ticipat ed inclinical trials to date (<0.02% of
population)
• India compa nies ha ve
ap proxima te sh ar e of 35% in
DMFs an d 25% in ANDAs
filing globally
• Second a nd t hird tier
comp an ies have a ggressively
scaled u p ANDA/DMF filing in
th e US mar ket over th e last 2-3years
In th is section we will bring fort h
what ’s been h appening in th e
biobuiness in In dia.
Biopharma76%
Bioservices8%
Bioindustry
8%
Bioagri6%
Bioinformatics2%
Composition of Indian Biotech Industry
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 30/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 30
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
B IO-B U S I NE S S E S I N I NDIA
Q1-2008
T he E x-P r e s iden t o f In d i a , Mr A.P .J . Abdu l Ka l am ask ed
Bio-ind u s t r y to p r odu ce 40% of wor ld ’s gene r ic d r u gs .
In Mar ch a t Vadodara , while addressing a gath ering here to celebrate t he
cent ena ry function of Alembic Ltd, th e form er P resident of India, Mr A.P.J.
Abdul Kalam said the global production of pha rm aceuticals, bra nded a nd
generics put together is nea rly $550 billion.
The domestic pharm aceuticals indust ry, at present, h as a tur nover of $12.5
billion of gener ics for domestic and export ma rket s a gainst th e production of
$78 billion wort h of gener ics in th e world. He called at ten tion to th e need for
India to cont ribut e 40 per cent of the world’s generic drug pr oduction an d
focus on er adication of diseases such a s ma laria an d tu berculosis.
Re d d y ’s La b o r a t o r i e s is t o a c q u i r e p a r t o f D o wCh em ica l ’s bu s ines s i n UK.
Dr Reddy's Labora tories (Hyderaba d, Ind ia) ent ered into a definitive agr eemen t
with Dow Chem ical Compa ny (USA) to acquire a portion of Dowpha rm a Sm all
Molecules business a ssociat ed with its opera tion in Mirfield an d Cam bridge, UK.
Thr ough th is acquisition Dr . Reddy’s Labora tories will acquire th e ass ociat ed
product-port folio, technologies, intellectu al pr opert y, tra dema rk s, and t he
cust omers. Dr. Reddy's will a lso receive a non-exclusive license to Dow's Pfenex
Expr ession Technology for biocat alysis developmen t. The t ra nsa ction is expected t o
close by the end of April, 2008 pending r egulatory a pproval.
S u v e n a n d E li Li ly s ig n e d S e c on d D r u g d i s co ve r y
C olla b o r a t i o n i n C N S t h e r a p e u t i csSuven Life Sciences Limit ed, (Hyder aba d, India) ann oun ced in Mar ch 2008 tha t it
signed a second collabora tive pre-clinical R&D agr eemen t with Eli Lilly in t hether apeut ic ar ea of centra l nervous system disorders (CNS).
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 31/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 31
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
Under the terms of this agreement Suven will be responsible for identifing and
selectin g dur g candidat es for CNS. Suven will receive up-front pa yment for th e
R&D works an d in add ition t o th at Suven will receive milestone pa yment s for
potent ial dru g can didates in th e ra nge of $19 million t o $23 million per can didat e
molecule. The compa ny is also ent itled to futu re r oyalties on net sa les of an y
products t ha t m ay be su ccessfully comm ercialized from th e collabora tion.
U S p h a r m a c e u t i ca ls in d u s t r y t o a d o p t In d i a n
P h a r m a c o p oe ia s t a n d a r d sAs the US sta ndar d has no monogra phs for an tiretrovira l dru gs, the US drug
ma ker s would follow th e Indian P ha rm acopoeia Commission’s stan dar ds man ua l for
HIV/AIDS drugs. By expan ding th e scope of a coopera tion deal signed in 2006
between t he US P ha rma copoeia and t he Indian Pha rm acopeia comm ission, the US
will be now publishing monogra phs, or a set of referr al sta nda rds, developed by the
Indian Pharmacopeia Commission for about 51 anti-AIDS drugs.
Pha rm acopoeia is the drug stan dards ma nua l for th e pharm aceuticals indust ry
published per iodically by different coun tr ies to help dru g man ufactur ers a s well as
the r egulators to follow the pa ra meters for m aking a st an dard dr ug. Curr ently, the
US P ha rma copoeia an d British Ph ar ma copoeia ar e the two widely referred
pharmacopoeias in the world.
F DA Ap pr oved Na t co ’s AP I fa c i li t i e s i n In d iaIn Ma rch 2008, the US F ood a nd Dr ug Administra tion h as a pproved Nat co Phar ma ’s
Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients (APIs) facility at Mekaguda in Mahaboobnagar
distr ict, Andhr a P ra desh for pr oduction of some a dditiona l products. The appr ovedproducts in clude Ima tinib Mesylat e (medicine for blood can cer), Anast ra zole (brea stcancer), Gra nisetron (nausea ) and Rizat ripan (migraine).
Ac c e n t u r e i s e x p a n d i n g i t s li fe -s c ie n c e s o p e r a t i on
i n I n d iaAccentu re envision high gr owth in t he life-sciences down-str eam processes
out sourcing prima rily becau se of un cont rollable cost an d n eed to expedite lab-to-
ma rket pr ocess. More an d more phar ma compan ies are looking to places where
sta ble, reliable and regulatory compa ra ble infrastr uctures a re in place.
Accent ur e’s life science R&D cent re in Ban galore is its lar gest in t he world with
2,500 employees compr ising doma in expert s such a s clinician s, nu rses, scientists
an d bio-stat istician s apa rt from t echn ology professiona ls. Accentur e is , th erefore,
looking at expan ding th e scope a nd scale of its lifescience opera tions in In dia .
Accent ur e ma y double the n um ber of employees in its R&D centr e and a lso sprea d to
more cities in India to att ra ct t alent.
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 32/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 32
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
S tem C yte , Apo l lo -h osp i t a l an d C ad i l a c r ea t ed a jo in t
ven t u r e fo r s t em-ce ll p r odu c t s
Stem Cyte Inc.( Arcadia, Californ ia) ann ounced the form at ion of a joint ventu re,
StemCyte India Therapeutics Pvt. Ltd., in India with Apollo Hospitals and Cadila
Ph ar ma ceuticals. The joint -vent ur e compa ny will provide stem cell th era pies
derived from u mbilical cord blood to tr eat pat ients with cert ain m alignan t blooddisorders, such as leukemia, lymphoma and myeloma; sickle cell anemia and
tha lassemia; and immun e deficiency diseases. The Stem Cyte India Therapeu tics will
cont ribut e to the clinical st udies t o develop cell th era pies for poten tial diseas es withno possible cure ava ilable at pres ent .
"The joint vent ur e ena bles us to combine StemCyt e's proven cell th era py products
with Apollo and Cadila's expertise in the Indian healthcare arena for the benefit of
one of the world largest pa tient populations," said Kenneth J . Giacin, cha irma n a nd
th e chief execut ive officer of St em Cyte. He ad ded, "Moreover, St emCyte Ind ia
Therapeu tics is a n importa nt part of our global expansion stra tegy.”
Creat ion of New Ventu re, StemCyte In dia, Continu es StemCyte's Intern at iona l
Expan sion a nd Ut ilizes the St ren gths a nd Regiona l Expert ise of Apollo Hospitalsand Cadila Pharmaceuticals
T h e U S i s s e e k i n g a d d i t i o n a l sc ie n t i fi c , r e g u l a t o r y
a n d t e c h n ic a l c olla b o r a t i on w i t h I n d i a a s a m e a n s
t o im p r o ve h e a lt h c a r e o u t c o m e s fo r p a t i e n t s in U S A
a n d a r o u n d t h e w o r ld .
On Ma rch 18 in Wash ington DC, the U.S.-India Busin ess Coun cil (USIBC) hosted
the Mr. Micha el O. Leavitt, Secretar y, U.S. Depart ment of Health a nd H uma n
Services. Secreta ry Leavitt h ighlighted th e need collabora tion as a mean s to
impr ove hea lthcar e outcomes for pa tient s around th e world. Secreta ry Leavitt
sha red a bout his desires for grea ter scient ific, regulat ory and t echnical collaborat ion
between th e U.S. an d India. A centra l goal of th e Coalition for Hea lthy India is to
foster grea ter regulatory har monization between t he U.S. and In dia, resulting in
decreased costs a nd increased pa tient safety.
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 33/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 33
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
B IO -B U S I N E S S E S IN ASIA
Q1-2008
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 34/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 34
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
B I O -B U S I N E S S E S IN & AROUND
J AP AN, S. K O R E A, S I N G A P O R E & C H I N A
Q1-2008
N S B P o s t e c h , I n c a n d F r e d H u t c h i n s o n Ca n c e r R e s e a r c h C e n t e r t o
Co ll abo ra t e on Deve lopm en t o f New Clas s of P r o t eomic Microa r ra ys
In Ma rch NSB P ostech (Sout h Korea) an nounced tha t it has ent ered int o a
collabora tion a greement with Fr ed Hu tchinson Ca ncer Research Center (FHCRC) to
coordin at e th eir effort s an d t o deter min e th e efficacy of the NS B's Nan oCones
sur face technology in creat ing high qua lity proteomic microar ra ys to be used in t he
study of hum an diseases.
NSB is a South Korean biotech company which possesses a proprietary microarraytechn ology and a grea t dea l of expert ise in na no-scale contr olled sur face chemistr y.NSB ha s agreed t o fund th e collaborat ion.
Ant ibody or protein m icroar ra ys ar e glass m icroscope slides ont o which very sm all
am ount s of thousan ds of differen t a nt ibodies or pr oteins h ave been a ffixed at
distinct locations. Ant ibody microar ra ys can be used to simu lta neously deter min e
th e level of each an tibody's specific binding par tn er in complex mixtu res su ch as
blood so th ousan ds of different assa ys can be perform ed with sm all am oun ts of sample.
R A VE N B I O T E C H N O L O G I E S A N D B I O P R O C E S S I N G T E C H N O L O G Y I N S T I T U T E
AN N O U N C E C OL L ABORAT ION T O ADVANCE D ISCOVE R Y OF S T E M C E L L
AN T I B O D I E S
In April Raven biotechnologies, inc.(Singapore), a privately held company focused on
th e discovery a nd development of monoclona l an tibody ther apeu tics (MAbs) for
cancer, a nd th e Bioprocessing Technology Inst itut e (BTI) (Sa n Fr an cisco, CA),
an noun ced a R&D collabora tive agreem ent for th e discovery of novel cancer stem
cell antibodies.
Un der t he t erm s of th is R&D agreem ent , Raven biotechn ologies, Inc will license its
proprieta ry whole cell imm un ization techn ology to BTI for use with BTI's stem cells.Raven will screen th e resu lting an tibodies aga inst it s collection of can cer lines, and
cancer stem cell lines. Raven will ret ain th e right s to th e ant ibodies BTI gener at es
using Raven's immunization technology for use in cancer therapeutics and
diagnostics; an d BTI will ha ve th e rights to the an tibodies it gener at es for a ll oth er
stem cell therapies.
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 35/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 35
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
Masimo PVI(TM) Cleared for Market in Japan
P VI cou ld h e lp c li n i c i ans a s ses s a pa t i en t 's fl u id r e sp ons ivenes s
non invas ive ly , acco rd ing t o a new s tu dy pu b l ished i n 'Anes th es i a &
Analges ia '
In April, J apa nese Ministr y of Hea lth, Labor an d Welfare (MHLW) appr oved
Masim o’s (Irvine, CA) PVI m easu rem ent . PVI is an in dex au toma tically derived
from the Masimo plethysmographic waveform, which has been demonstrated to
noninvasively assess fluid responsiveness in mechanically ventilated patients and
can h elp clinicians a ssess if a pat ient's cardia c function is compr omised.
PVI ma y help clinicians a nd em ergency professiona ls to determ ine if a pa tient is
dehydrated or over-hydrated-enabling more accurate fluid administration decisions-
all by simply referring to the nu mer ical Masimo PVI value th at is continu ouslydisplayed on Ma simo Rainbow SET P ulse CO-Oximeters .
PVI is a dyna mic new indicator of fluid r esponsiveness t ha t does not requir e an
invasive procedure or manual calculation, yet has been demonstrated to be sensitive
to cha nges in preload an d to be an a ccura te pr edictor of fluid r esponsiveness in
mechanically vent ilat ed pa tients
Naglazyme Approved by Japanese Ministry of HealthIn Ma rch, BioMar in Ph ar ma ceutical Inc. (Na sda q: BMRN) (Novato, CA) ann ounced
tha t AnGes MG, Inc. (Osaka, J apan ), BioMar in's ma rket ing and distribution part ner
gran ted appr oval for its Ma rk eting Applicat ion for Na glazyme(R) (galsulfase) fromthe J apa nese Ministry of Health, Labor an d Welfare (MHLW) for t he tr eatm ent of
pat ients with Mu copolysaccha ridosis VI ( MPS VI). Na glazyme was appr oved by the
U.S. Food an d Dru g Administ ra tion (FDA) in May 2005 an d by th e Eur opean
Commission (EC) in January 2006.
As th e first dr ug appr oved for MP S VI treat ment , the F DA and EC both gave
Naglazyme an orphan drug status, conferring seven years of market exclusivity in
the U nited Stat es and 10 years of ma rket exclusivity in the E ur opean U nion.
Naglazyme a lso obtained orphan drug st atu s in J un e 2007 from th e MHLW inJapan .
BioMarin est ablished a ma rketing a nd distribution a greement with AnGes inDecember 2006, th rough which AnGes obta ined exclusive right s to mar ket
Naglazyme in th e Ja panese ma rket. AnGes submitted a m ar keting application to
th e MHLW in August 2007.
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 36/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 36
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
Oncolys BioPharma and Tacere Therapeutics to DevelopHepatitis C cure using RNAi technology
In Ma rch, Oncolys BioPh ar ma , Inc. (Tokyo, Ja pan ) an d Tacere Thera peut ics, Inc.
(San J ose, CA,) an nounced tha t t hey ha ve entered into a str ategic alliance an d
license a greemen t t o develop a nd comm ercialize th roughout Asia, Tacere's RNAinter feren ce (RNAi)-based Hepa titis C virus (HCV) compoun d. This agreem ent
resulted from t he str at egic alliance entered into by Tacere a nd Oncolys in J un e
2007, wher eby Oncolys was gran ted a n option t o acquire t he Asian right s for TT-
033.
Under the terms of the agreement, Oncolys and Tacere will form a joint steering
comm ittee t ha t will work with th e Tacere a nd Pfizer steer ing comm ittee t o overseepreclinical r esear ch a nd developmen t effort s for TT-033/OBP-701.
In add ition t o an up-front paym ent , Tacere will be eligible to receive milestone
payments through successful achievement of development, approval, and
comm ercializat ion m ilestones resu lting in total poten tial pa yment s to Tacere of upto $60 million. Upon commercialization of TT-033/OBP-701, Tacere would be entitled
to receive royalties on net sales by On colys. Fur th er, if Oncolys su blicenses it s r ights
under the stra tegic allian ce to any ma jor ph arm aceutical compa ny, the m ilestone
paym ent s an d sales royalties Oncolys receives will be sha red with Ta cere a t
predeterm ined ra tes based u pon t he sta ge of development at which t he m ilestonesoccur.
Corgenix licensed cardio-inflammation bio-marker from Japan
Corgenix Med ical Corpora tion (BB: CONX) (Denver, Colora do) , a developer of diagnostic test kits, licensed a diagnostic technology for s eru m am yloid protein
(SAP), an important serum bio-marker for cardiovascular inflammation from withthe Okayam a Pr efectur e Industr ial Pr omotion Foundat ion, Ja pan.
This exclusive licensing a greemen t provides corgenix worldwide rights to diagnostictechnology measuring serum bio-marker for cardiovascular inflammation detection.
Pr ofessor E iji Matsu ur a a t th e University of Okaya ma Gra dua te School of Medicine,
Dentistry and Pharmaceutical Sciences invented the technology. Corgenix has had
stra tegic allian ces with the scientists a nd a cademic institu tions in Okayam a, J apan ,
since 2001. The Compan y's earlier product Ather Ox(TM) was a lso developed incollaboration with University of Okayama scientists. Present agreement stren gthens
the collaborative relationship with th e Okayam a Pr efectu re a imed at developing
innovat ive an d important diagnostic products in th e future.
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 37/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 37
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
China Medical Technologies Completed the Developmentof Prostate Cancer FISH Reagent
In April, China Medical Technologies, Inc. (Beijing, China) (NASDAQ:CMED) ,
an noun ced th e complet ion of developmen t of th e Pr osta te Can cer F ISH Det ection
Kit, a pr ostat e cancer-specific molecula r dia gnostic test based on t he F luorescent in
situ Hybridization ("FISH") technology.
The Kit is designed to detect TMPRS S2 an d ETS gene fusions in pr osta te
pat hological t issues. Dysregulat ion of ETS fam ily mem bers t hr ough fusions withTMPRSS2 are implicated as cancer-causing gene rea rra ngements in prostate cancer,
CMED, a leadin g China-based m edical device compan y, develops, ma nu factu res a nd
ma rk ets a dvanced in-vitro diagnostic products an d high int ensity focusedultrasound tum or therapy systems.
Gastric Cancer Drug Market to Triple by 2012 in ChinaDecision Resour ces, one of th e world's leadin g resea rch an d a dvisory firms focusing
on phar ma ceutical an d health car e issues, forecasts in April 2008, tha t t he Chinese
gast ric can cer dru g mar ket will near ly triple between 2007 and 2012. According to
the new Em erging Markets r eport entitled Gastric Cancer in China; this growth will
be fueled by increased a ccess to health insur an ce an d great er pat ient spending
power, leading t o increased u sage of ta rgeted t her apies. Additiona lly, the pr evalence
of gast ric can cer in China is am ong th e highest in th e world. In 2007, approxima tely
392,000 cases were diagn osed in China , and it is forecast ed tha t t he indication
population will grow 2.3 percent p er year between 2007 a nd 2012.
The report a lso finds t hat J iangsu Simcere's Endostar and Merck KGaA's Er bitux
ar e th e ta rgeted th erapies prescribed most often by Chinese physicians for t he
treatment of gastric cancer. These new targeted therapies will be prescribed to a
greater percent age of the eligible population in China tha n in th e past, benefiting
from in crea sed ph ysician familiarity a nd bet ter efficacy an d toxicity profiles th an
conventional chemotherapy agents. More importantly, surveyed physicians
an ticipate th at some t argeted t hera pies will be included in t he Na tional
Reimbur semen t Dr ug List (NRDL) by 2012, significan tly increa sing pat ientaccessibility to th ese dru gs.
Pandemic Influenza H5N1 Vaccineto be launched in China
Sinovac Biotech Ltd. (Beijing/China)(AMEX:SVA) , a lea ding biotech compa ny
developing human vaccines, announced in April 2008, that Panflu, its pandemic
influen za H 5N1 whole viron ina ctivat ed vaccine, received clear an ce to produce a nd
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 38/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 38
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
ma rket in China by the China Sta te Food and Dru g Administra tion (SFDA). Pa nflu
is the first an d only appr oved vaccine available in China aga inst t he H5N 1 influenza
virus.
Per th e production license for P an flu gra nt ed by SFDA, th e vaccine is appr oved for
production s olely to be supp lied to the Ch inese na tional va ccine st ockpiling program
an d will not be sold directly to the m ar ket . The license a lso indicates th at th e
Chinese government has the exclusive right to initiate Panflu vaccinations in anemer gency or in the event of an influen za pa ndem ic.
Sinovac previously a nn ounced positive top-line r esults of a r an domized, double-
blind, P ha se II clinical tria l of its p an demic influenza (H5N1) vaccine a t t he en d of
2007. The Pha se II clinical trial results were subm itted in Febru ary 2008 to the
SFDA. Sinovac commenced th e development of a pa ndem ic influen za vaccine in
2004. In J un e 2006, the P ha se I clinical tr ial result s indicat ed good immu nogenicityan d safety.
AMDL Signs Exclusive Licensing Agreement with Mygenefor Human Papilloma Virus Diagnostic Kit
AMDL, Inc. (AMEX:ADL) , headqu ar ter ed in Tust in, California, with
opera tions in Sh enzhen , Jian gxi, and J ilin, China , is a vert ically integra ted
specialty pha rm aceutical compa ny. In April, AMDL ann ounced tha t it
ent ered int o an exclusive sublicensing (subject t o certa in ter ms a nd
conditions) agreemen t with MyGene Int ern at iona l, Inc. ("MGI," USA) for th e
MyGene H PV Chip Kit for in -vitro genotype test ing of Hu ma n Pa pilloma
Viru s (HP V).
The a greemen t between MGI a nd AMDL is an exclusive sublicense to use t he
paten ts, tra demar k, an d technology in man ufactu ring, promoting, mar keting,
distribut ing, an d selling the MyGene HP V Test Kit in China (includin g Hong
Kong), Taiwan , Singap ore, Malaysia, Thailan d, Cambodia, and Vietn am .
HP V is th e most comm on sexu ally tra nsm itted infection. Globally ther e ar e
appr oximat ely 330 million women presen tly infected with HP V, with 70% of
existing infections in Asian populations.
ProGenTech received $21 Million Series C FinancingApril 2, 2008 /PRNewswire/ -- Pr oGenTech, biotech compa ny ba sed in Sha ngha i,
China an d Em eryville, CA developing a cont am inat ion free, casset te based
automated nucleic acid purification system, announced in April 2008 that it has
closed a $21 m illion Series C finan cing led by Bay City Ca pital (San Fr an cisco) andDT Capital (Shanghai).
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 39/40
N C P U , T a f t l a w M e d z y m , t e c h n o e d i t s Page 39
Copyright © 2008, Biopreneu r. All right s reser ved.
BIOPRENEURwww.b i opr eneur . org
Compa ny also announced its ma na gement chan ges. Trevor H awkins, PhD joined the
compa ny as Cha irma n an d Chief Executive Officer. Dr. Hawk ins was previously the
CEO of Ph ilips Molecular H ealt hcar e business a nd h eld senior executive roles at GE
and MDS. He was also the Director of th e US DOE J oint Genome Institut e, and led
th e DOE's effort s to sequen ce th e Hu ma n genome. Pr oGenTech’s foun der St eve Yu
become COO and presiden t wh ile foun der J esus Ch ing will serve a s Chief Scientificofficer.
The key advant age of ProGenTech's aut oma ted system is tha t it eliminates th e
possibilities of user exposure a nd cross-conta mina tion by virtu e of its u nique
cassett e-based a pproach. The compa ny's initial products ha ve applicat ions in both
research and medical diagnostics.
Ha ve passion to write on busin ess, sciences an d economics topics th at might
relate to and benefited by the biotech/life sciences/investment professionals –
express it, an d n ot hold it long t o avoid high BP .
…….Biopreneur is therapeutics in many respects…….
8/14/2019 E Mag Biopreneur April08
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e-mag-biopreneur-april08 40/40
ACKNOW LEDGEMENTS
Taft Stett inius & Hollister LLP – www.taftlaw.com Founded in 1885, Taft Stett inius & Hollister LLP continues to focus on the future,offering solutions and opportunit ies in an ever-changing world. Taft has more than 200att orneys who practice in a wide range of legal areas and service both U.S. andinternational clients, from start-up technology companies to publicly traded andinternational corporations.
Taft’s Life Sciences practit ioners assist companies, research institutions, incubators, andscientists protect, develop and commercialize their intellectual property in a wide rangeof technical areas, including: genetics, molecular biology, medical and surgical devices,pharmaceuticals, clinical trials, and bioremediation.
Nort hern California Polytechnic (NorCal Poly) University (NCPU) is
located at the heart of high-tech center in Silicon Valley in California.The mission of NorCal Polytechnic University is to provide studentswith a multidisciplinary and intercultural understanding of the worldthat enriches their lives while actively participating in the globalmarketplace of commerce, culture, and t echnology. NCPU offersgraduate degree programs, general education, services and activities to
enhance the academic and personal development of students.
Technoedits is a Silicon Valley based organization that provides technical writing,editing and copywrit ing services to the biotech/hightech organizations. Biopreneuruses tecnoedits for its selective needs and services. For more information [email protected].
Medzym – www.medzym.com Medzym, Inc. is a privately held biotechnology company focused on building moleculartherapeut ics based on effective platform technologies. Company’s current focus is on
Age-related eye disorders- (1) eye-diseases, (2) Anti-Inflammatory/Allergy, and (2)Cardio-vascular.