+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED...

Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED...

Date post: 08-Oct-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
18
IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR '.:'HE BAS'I'ERK DIS':'RICT 07' PEKNSYLVnNIA RE; ASBESTOS PRODUCTS LIABE,ITY LITIGATION {No. Vt) Consolidated Undey MDL COCKE':' NO. 875 CERTAIN PLA:NTI FrS v. Cases 'Transferred from Various Districts thal were L. Magistra:e Judge CERTAIN DEFENDA'HS M. Faith Angell for Conferences C:lr:d Pretrial Management Q .. R DE R AND NOW, this 7th day of January, it is OlUJERED Lha:- ora _ arg...::nent on all pend-=-nq motions, including motions for summary judg:nent, in ;;;::e cases lis,,::-ed -=--n Exhibit "AIt, attached, will be held on Tuesday, January 25th t 2011 al 10:00 a.m. in Cc:.:rtroom l1A, Jarres A. 3yr::e Uniled States Cc::rtho::..se, 601 Market Street, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19106 before the HOnQrable Eduardo C. Robreno. The cases WiJu:e previously beill.Q handled by Magistrate Ml Faith Anqel.l. I but are np}! befo:+.e .1u.dge iobren9. A list of t:::e opposed nctlons to be heard is listed in Exhi.bit "B f " attached. This Order supcrcedcs any previously entered Order concernir:g ::.he date t!":e head ng ... .'1.11 be held and provides for a protocol to be followed by Plai ntiffs i counsel prior to this -,",.ear'inq. 1 i= any of these cases are suhJcct to a scheduling '.lraer. in which ':he for motions not yet passed, please i nforrr: ;:.he CourL ';:1nd the case will be removed frou the lIst. Case 2:07-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 01/11/11 Page 1 of 18
Transcript
Page 1: Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR '.:'HE BAS'I'ERK DIS':'RICT 07' PEKNSYLVnNIA ~N . RE; ASBESTOS

IN ]E UNlED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR HE BASIERK DISRICT 07 PEKNSYLVnNIA

~N RE ASBESTOS PRODUCTS LIABEITY LITIGATION No Vt) Consolidated Undey

MDL COCKE NO 875 CERTAIN PLANTI FrS

v Cases Transferred from Various Districts thal were

bullL bull Refer~ed ~o Magistrae Judge CERTAIN DEFENDAHS M Faith Angell for

Sett~emcnt Conferences Clrd Pretrial Management

Q R DE R

AND NOW this 7th day of January 201~ it is he~eby

OlUJERED Lha- ora _ argnent on all pend-=-nq Op~LQged motions

including motions for summary judgnent in e cases lis-ed -=--n

Exhibit AIt attached will be held on Tuesday January 25th t

2011 al 1000 am in Ccrtroom l1A Jarres A 3yre Uniled

States Ccrthose 601 Market Street Philadelphia Pennsylvania

19106 before the HOnQrable Eduardo C Robreno The list~d cases

WiJue previously beillQ handled by Magistrate Ml Faith Anqell I but

are np befo+e 1udge iobren9 A list of te opposed nctlons to

be heard is listed in Exhibit B f attached This Order

supcrcedcs any previously entered Order concernirg he date

whi~h te head ng 111 be held and provides for a protocol to be

followed by Plai ntiffs i counsel prior to this -earinq 1

~Qwever i= any of these cases are suhJcct to a scheduling lraer in which he ~irre for dlsposit~ive motions ~iiS

not yet passed please i nforrr he CourL 1nd the case will be removed frou the lIst

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 1 of 18

It is futthcY ORDERED that this conference constiutes

he final pre r~maBd confizece in each of hese cases

rerefOB prior to the hear

status of the case wich [Ltst fall

into one of the folowing three categoies

(1) Case should be diswi ssed 0 the bankruptcy on1y

docket and a proposed order has been filod

(2) Case has been sQttlad and a proposed order has

been filed

(3) The case complies with the factors set forth in

A~~inistrative Order 182 and the case is ready to be

remanded to the trans ree court

It is further ORDERED that if the case is ceady to be

remanded to the transeree court Platr~ Ofs counse- shal

provide to ~he Court pr~or to the hea~i~g date a lst 0= a~l remaining viab~e defrndats to be pUYucd at trial T-c Court

will dismiss all other viable defendants and stay p~ccccdings

aqainst bankrup~ defendants

It is further ORDERED that if there are no pending motions

2 Administrative Order 18 is available at httDjwwwpaeduscQurtsgovdocumentsMDLMDL87S8dministrative Qrder=18 pdf

2

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 2 of 18

renaining it the case and counsel infoTrP-s the Court as to the

s-atus of tre case prio to the date of the hearing 2ppcarance

at thC headng ~s excused Faillre to appear at the hearing

without a prior status update may result in the dism$~al of the

case

AND IT IS SO ORDERED

q~ -

EDUARDO C ROBRENO r J

3

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 3 of 18

Exhibit A

07-60062 SC 0-60063 SC 07-60066 SC 07-60069 SC

-shy 07-60070 SC 07-60074 SC 07-60080 SC 07-60084 SC 07-60092 SC 07-60097 SC 07-60107 SC 07-60254 SC 07-60256 SC 07-60267 SC 07-60268 SC 07middotmiddot60322 SC 07-60330 SC 07-60341 SC

07-60351 SC

07-6035S SC

07-60363 SC 07-60365 SC 07-60367 SC

07-60372 SC

07-60383 SC

07-60384 SC 07-60392 SC 07-60400 SC 0]middot60403 SC 07-60410 SC Q7-60412 SC 07-60415 SC 07-60416 SC 07-6]423 SC 07-60429 SC 07-60431 SC 07-60434 SC 07-60438 SC 07-60439 SC 07-60442 SC 07-60447 SC 07-60448 SC 01-60450 SC 01-60453 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 4 of 18

01~60454

07~60456

07-60457

07-60468 07-60470 07~60471

07~60474 07-60477 07-60478 07-60479

07-60481 07-60486 07-60488 07-60490 07-60493 07-60494

07-60495 07-60496 07-60501

07-60505 07-60510

07-60512 07~60515

07~60519

07-60520 07~60524

07-60525 07-60526

07~60527

07-60529 07-60530 07-60531 07-60534

07-60555 07-60559

07-60561 07middot60565

07-60566

07-60568 07-60571 07-60596 07-60597 07-60608 07-60610 07-60613

07-60615 07-60616

SC SC SC SC I

SC SC

SC SC SC

SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC sc

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 5 of 18

07-60632

07-60637 07-60641 07-60642 07-60645 07-60646

07-60649 07-60650

07-60658 07-60659

07-60660 07-60662

07-60663

07-60664 07-60666 07-60669 07-60670 07-60672 07-60673

07-60674 07-60675

07-60677 07-60682 07-60685

07-60686 07-60688 07-60689 07-60694

07-60696

07-60703 07-60704

07-60707 07-60709 07-607

07-607 07-60 07-60721

07-60725 07-60727 07-60732 07-60733

07-60740 07-607 07-60744

07-60745 07-60761 07-60762

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Be se se sc sc sc sc SC SC SC

i

I

I

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 6 of 18

07-60769 07-60770 07(0777 07-60784 07middot60785 07-60795 07-60797 01middot60802

07middot60808 0760810

07middot60812 07-60813 07-60815 07-60817 0760818

OH0819

i 07-60822 0760824

07-60826 07-60830 07-60833 0760836 0760837 0760838 0760839

07-60841 07-60842 07-60844 0760845

0760846 07-60849 07-60855 07-60859 0760860 n7~60863

07middot60865 07middot60868 0760872

060875 07middot60876

_M 0760877

t17middot60878 07middot60881 07-60883 07-60887 07-60894 07middot60896

se I SC

se se

SC

sc sc sc SC Be

SC

SC

SC

SC I sc

sc SC

SC

sc SC

se se SC

SC I

SC

sc

SC I SC I SC SC

SC

SC SC SC I SC SC

SC I

SC

sc

SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 7 of 18

07middot60899 SC 07middot60900 SC 07middot60901 SC 07middot60903 SC 07middot60905 SC 01middot60907 SC 01-60908 SC 07-lti0912 SC

07middot60917 SC 07~60918 SC 07-lti0919 SC

07-60922 SC I 07middot60925 SC I

07middot60926 SC

07middot60927 SC 07-60928 SC

I 07-lti0930 SC I OH0933 SC

07-60937 SC

07middot60945 SC

0760947 SC )7~60955 SC 07middot60957 SC

07middot60958 SC I 0760963 SC

07-lti0965 SC 0760968 SC 07-60973 SC

07-lti0976 SC i 07-60977 SC I 07-60979 SC

07middot60986 SC 07middot60990 SC 07middot60995 SC

07middot60996 SC I 07middot61010 SC

07middot61011 SC

07~61014 SC 07-ltil015 SC 07-61016 SC OHI017 SC 07-lti1018 SC

07-61021 SC 07middot61022 SC 07middot61026 SC 07middot61030 SC 07middot61031 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 8 of 18

07-61032 07middot61033 07-61034 07-61035 07middot61037 07middot61038 07middot6L041 07-61042

07-61043 07-61044

07-61045 07-61048 07-61049 07-61052 07-61055 07middot61062 07-61064

07-61068 07-61069 07-61010 07-61071 07-61072 07-61073 07-61081 07-61083

07-61084 07-61085 07-6101(1 07-61091 07-61093 07-61094 07-61095 07-61096 07-61098 07-61099 07-61102 07-61108 07middot61109 07middot6111 0 07-61113 07-61115 07-61116 07middot61118 07-61120 07-61121 07-61122 07-61124

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC-SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC sc SC sc sec SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 9 of 18

i

i

07-61125 07-6) 126 07-6)[29

07middot61 no 07middot6113l

07~61l32

07-61136

07-61137 OJ-GI139

07middot61140 07middot6) 143

07-61144 rshy 07-61146 L bullbullbull

07middot6) 147 07middot6) 148

07-61149 07-61150 07-6)[52 07-6)[54 07middot6) 155

07middot61158 07middot61159 07-61160 07-61161 07middot61162 0761163

07-61165 07middot61166 07middot61167 07-6l168 07-61169 07-61170 07-61171

07-61172

07middot61173

07middot61174 07-61176 07-61177

07middot61179 07middot61180

07-6118)

07middot61182 07middot61183

07-6Jl34 07-61185 07middot6) )86

07middot61187

se se SC sc se se SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC sc sc sc sc se SC SC SC se SC sc se SC sc sc SC sc SC se se SC se sc SC SC SC SC SC

-

I

I

i

I

I

i

I

I

I

I

I i

I

7

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 10 of 18

07-61188 SC 07-61189 SC 07-61190 SC 07-61191 SC 07-61192 SC 07-61193 SC 07-61194 SC 07-61196 SC 07-61197 sc 07-61198 SC 07-61201 SC 07-61203 SC 07-61205 SC 07-61206 SC 07-61209 SC 07-61210 SC 07-61213 sc 07-61215 SC 07-61216 SC 07-61217 SC 07-61219 SC 07-61220 SC 07-61223 SC 07-61225 SC 07-61226 SC 07-61227 SC 07-61228 SC 07-61233 SC 07-61404 SC 07-61412 SC 07-61413 SC 07-61429 SC 07-61432 SC 07-61434 SC 07-61435 SC 07-61438 SC 07-61439 SC 07-61442 SC 07-61443 SC 07-61445 SC 07-61448 SC 07-61457 SC 07-61459 SC 07-61460 SC 07-61461 SC 07-61474 SC 07-61475 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 11 of 18

I

07-61477 07-61478 07-61479 07-61485 07-51486 07-61487 07-61488 07-61489 07-61491

Q7-61493 07-51496 07-61498 07-61503 07-61504 07-61505 07~61506

07-61507 07-61508 07-61509 07middot61510 07-61512 07-61513

07middot61514 07middot61515 07-61516

07-61518 L sc

07-61523 07-61526 07-61534 07-61536 07-61539 07-61541

07-61543

07-62972 07-62973 07middot62974 07middot62975 07-62976 07-62977 07-62979 07-63756 07middot63757 07middot63760 07-63761 07middot63762 0763763

07-63769

SC Be

Be se Be Be se

se se se se se

se

se se se se se se

sc sc Be se se Be

se se sc sc se

se Be Be Be Be Be se se Be se se se se se se Be

shy

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 12 of 18

07middot63770 SC 07-63771 SC 07middot63774 SC 07middot63778 SC 07middot63779 SC I 07-64649 SC

07-64650 SC

07middot64655 SC 07middot64664 SC 07middot64671 SC 07middot64674 SC 07-64678 SC 07middot64682 SC 07middot65979 SC

07middot65982 SC

07middot65984 SC 07middot65985 SC I 07middot65989 SC

07middot67408 SC 07-67411 SC 07-67413 SC 07-69159 SC 07-69162 SC 07-69163 SC 07middot69167 SC 07-69168 SC 07-69169 SC 07-69170 SC

07-69179 SC i 07-69182 SC 07-69183 SC

07-70506 SC 07-73476 SC

07-73478 SC 07-73499 SC 07middot73501 SC 07middot74185 SC 08middot67063 SC 08-67066 SC 08-70866 NCmiddotW 08-70886 SC

08-70894 SC

I 08-70895 SC 08-768gt2 NCmiddotW

08middot76849 SC

08middot76850 SC -I 0S-76851 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 13 of 18

08-76853 08-76855 08-76856 08-76857 08-76862 08-76865 08-79838 08-79848

08-79850 08-83125 08-83127 08-83129 08-83131

08-83568 08-83571

08-83575 08-83577 08-83579 08-84578

08-84581 08-84586 08-87194

08-87198

I 08-87205 08-88797

08-88801

08-88803 08-88804

08-88809 08-88810 08-88817

08-89202

08-89203 08-89204 08-89207

08-89209 08-89215 08-90395

08-90396 08-90399 08-90400 08-90403 08-90404 08-90406

08-90413 08-90414

08-90416

se se se se se se se

se se He He se se se se se se se se se se He He se sc se se se se se se

He se

se I se

se sc

He

se se se He He se se se He

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 14 of 18

I 09middot6(1076 09-6(1080

09-60083 09-60084 09-60088

09-60100

09middot60102 09-60104 09-60109 09(0117 09-60119

09-60122 09-60124 09-62649 09-62650

09-62658 IN-65538

09-65541 09middot65549

09middot65551 09-65552 09middot66138 09middot66142

I 09-66147 09middot67138 09-67139

09-67144 01-67146 09-70165 09-70172 09-70173

01middot74445 09-74773 09middot74776 09-80061

09middot80063 09-80075 09-80103

09-90845

09-90846 09-90847 09-90amp48

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

GA-S

Sc SC

SC SC SC UT SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 15 of 18

IIxbjbjj B

1 MCAnany at a1 v Owens-Corning Fiberglas Corporation et al 207~cv-605euroB (S2)

a Nolion for Suwmary Judgment by Bayer cropscience Inc

2 Jirel v ACampS Ino at al 207-cv-61116 ISC)

a Motion fol Summary Judgment by Noland Company Inc

3 Christian v Owens-Illinois et al 207-cv-61187 (SC)

~ ~otion for Su~ary Judqme~~ by Daniel International Corporation

b Motion for Summary Judgment by Flour Daniel Corporation

4 Smoak v Owens-Illinois t et al 207-cv-61217 (SC)

a gtlotion for Sunmary Judgnet by Aventis Cropsclenc USA Ine

5 Kitt v Owens-Illinois at al 207-cv-61220 (SC)

a Motion for Summary JudgmenL by Aventis Cropscienoe USA Inc

6 Johnson v Aventis Crapsoience et a1 207-cv-61223 (SC)

a Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Crane Co

McDaniel v Owens-Illinois I at a~ 207-cv-61225 (SC)

1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 16 of 18

a t-lotion fc SUflnary JJdgrrent by Crane Co

8 Blackmon v Owens-Illinois et al 207middotmiddotcv-6297J (SC)

a Motion for SUfrJllaquo1Y Judgment by Crane Co

o ~ A1bereson v Bayer Cropscience et al

207-cv-63761 (SC)

a Motion for Suuunary Judgment by Bayer Cropscienoe Inc

10 Campbell v Bayer Cropsoienoe et a1 gt07-cv-63763 (Sc)

a Motio~ for Su~~a~y Judgment by Bayer Cropecience Ino

11 Fritz v Bayer Cropsc1ence et al 207-cv-65982 (SC

lt1 Xotion -or Stmnary Judgme by Crane Co

12 WQaver v Owens Illinois Inc et al 20B-cv-90416 ISC)

a Motion fo SUhlmary Judgment by Bayer Cropscience Inc Certainteed Ino and Union Carbide Inc (same motion)

b Xotion or Summary Judgme-t by Crane Co

13 Anderson v Hamilton M1nerals et al 20Q-cv-H0103 IUtah)

a Motim for SrrJlnry Judgmen cy Rapid-American

b Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Georgia Pacific

c Motion -=or Summary Judgme-t by Union Carhide

2

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 17 of 18

MAILED ALGERNON SOLOMONS AlLAN SHACKELFOR ALLAN SLOAN BRENT BOYD BRUCE MtLLER C DRAKE CAREY AVrR CARl PIERCE CHRLES NORRIS CHRJSTOPHER 1AUHlELLO CHR1STOPHER Me cnOl CRAVENS RAVrNI-J DANIEL WHITE DAID CLEVELAND DAVlD LYLE DAVlD MORRISON

DAVD SLOUGH ERIC ElGLEBARDT GIIfILUPS

E-MAlLED~ ADDU R1E A1DREW SHAW ANTIlONY HAYES BRIAN CLARK

C EVERT CARLPIERCH CARTER LA1BfTl CASE DAM CATHERINE JASONS CHARLES SlEueL CHARLES SPRINKIlo CHRISTOPHER SANTORO CLARE MAISASO DAVIDLAMM DAVID TRAYLOR DEME nuns ZACHAROPOU EDWARD SIAUGHTER

BRlN 5110VNEI

FALDRIDGE FRANCES ZACHER FRANK (JORDON GEORGE lNABINET GEORGE TANKARD GtSSUAREZ OUYGLzIER HARRY DAVIS HOWARD BOWERS

Certificate of Service

GEOROE OKELLrV HOMER TISDALE JACKSON BARWICK JAiES KEhEDY JAMES PRESSLEY JEA~ELYLES

JEFFREY fiARNWELL JEFFREY EDDY

JOHNBRYAfT JOSEPH KIJIN

JOSEPH WiLSOr- KEVIN KAUER LAURA EVANS LEE WILSON MARYHILL NATCY MONTI

PAUL DOMlNICK PHILUP FERDERIGOS R SllAW

lVAK G1)STAFS()N

JAMES ElJJUIT JAMES OANDY JAMES KEYNEDY JANET BLACK JE1NlFER TECIIMAN JOHANNA FOWIER JOHN GARDNhR JOHN SLOSSON JOSEPH RHODES JOSEPHINE HICKS JOSHUA BENNEIT KELLY JONES KENNETHKYRE KEVlt OBRIEN K1RK WARNER

LAURA VEE LINDSAY PEED LOREN JACOBSON LOUIS HERNS

MARK THOMAS MARK WALL

MICHAEL COLE

MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI MOFFATT MCDONALD MONA WALLACE

RALPH DAVIES RlCHAAD BURKE RICHARD LUTZEL ROBERT BROWN ROBERT CARPENT[R ROBERT VARNADO

ROLFE MARTlf SHARON WjlLlAM~ THOMAS KEAVENY THOMAS wnl-S TIMOTHY BOlCI TODD SMYTH TRUDY ROBERmOfshyTYNIKA ADAMS VALERIE WILLIAMS WILLIAM HANAHAN WILLIAM LYLpoundS

NATHANIEL HOSIO OLLIE HARlOJI RICHARD RADCLIfFE

RonERTHOOD llOBERT LOVETT ROBERT MLRIWE fHER

ROBERTSHAW

RONALD cox SAfUEL CARR1NGTON SCOTT FRICK $H~ K4CHMAR

STEPHANIE FLYhN STEVEN OUZTS STEVEN PUGH TIIOMAS DOUGAU

TIMOT11Y HO)CH

TIMOTHY PF(K TRACY TOM1lN

v BEVON V1LLlAM COLLINS WILLlAM CONNER WLLlAM DAVIES WILLIAM DAVIS

WILLtM GR1HAM WILLIAM SM1TH WILLlAM STARR

1 of 1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 18 of 18

Page 2: Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR '.:'HE BAS'I'ERK DIS':'RICT 07' PEKNSYLVnNIA ~N . RE; ASBESTOS

It is futthcY ORDERED that this conference constiutes

he final pre r~maBd confizece in each of hese cases

rerefOB prior to the hear

status of the case wich [Ltst fall

into one of the folowing three categoies

(1) Case should be diswi ssed 0 the bankruptcy on1y

docket and a proposed order has been filod

(2) Case has been sQttlad and a proposed order has

been filed

(3) The case complies with the factors set forth in

A~~inistrative Order 182 and the case is ready to be

remanded to the trans ree court

It is further ORDERED that if the case is ceady to be

remanded to the transeree court Platr~ Ofs counse- shal

provide to ~he Court pr~or to the hea~i~g date a lst 0= a~l remaining viab~e defrndats to be pUYucd at trial T-c Court

will dismiss all other viable defendants and stay p~ccccdings

aqainst bankrup~ defendants

It is further ORDERED that if there are no pending motions

2 Administrative Order 18 is available at httDjwwwpaeduscQurtsgovdocumentsMDLMDL87S8dministrative Qrder=18 pdf

2

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 2 of 18

renaining it the case and counsel infoTrP-s the Court as to the

s-atus of tre case prio to the date of the hearing 2ppcarance

at thC headng ~s excused Faillre to appear at the hearing

without a prior status update may result in the dism$~al of the

case

AND IT IS SO ORDERED

q~ -

EDUARDO C ROBRENO r J

3

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 3 of 18

Exhibit A

07-60062 SC 0-60063 SC 07-60066 SC 07-60069 SC

-shy 07-60070 SC 07-60074 SC 07-60080 SC 07-60084 SC 07-60092 SC 07-60097 SC 07-60107 SC 07-60254 SC 07-60256 SC 07-60267 SC 07-60268 SC 07middotmiddot60322 SC 07-60330 SC 07-60341 SC

07-60351 SC

07-6035S SC

07-60363 SC 07-60365 SC 07-60367 SC

07-60372 SC

07-60383 SC

07-60384 SC 07-60392 SC 07-60400 SC 0]middot60403 SC 07-60410 SC Q7-60412 SC 07-60415 SC 07-60416 SC 07-6]423 SC 07-60429 SC 07-60431 SC 07-60434 SC 07-60438 SC 07-60439 SC 07-60442 SC 07-60447 SC 07-60448 SC 01-60450 SC 01-60453 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 4 of 18

01~60454

07~60456

07-60457

07-60468 07-60470 07~60471

07~60474 07-60477 07-60478 07-60479

07-60481 07-60486 07-60488 07-60490 07-60493 07-60494

07-60495 07-60496 07-60501

07-60505 07-60510

07-60512 07~60515

07~60519

07-60520 07~60524

07-60525 07-60526

07~60527

07-60529 07-60530 07-60531 07-60534

07-60555 07-60559

07-60561 07middot60565

07-60566

07-60568 07-60571 07-60596 07-60597 07-60608 07-60610 07-60613

07-60615 07-60616

SC SC SC SC I

SC SC

SC SC SC

SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC sc

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 5 of 18

07-60632

07-60637 07-60641 07-60642 07-60645 07-60646

07-60649 07-60650

07-60658 07-60659

07-60660 07-60662

07-60663

07-60664 07-60666 07-60669 07-60670 07-60672 07-60673

07-60674 07-60675

07-60677 07-60682 07-60685

07-60686 07-60688 07-60689 07-60694

07-60696

07-60703 07-60704

07-60707 07-60709 07-607

07-607 07-60 07-60721

07-60725 07-60727 07-60732 07-60733

07-60740 07-607 07-60744

07-60745 07-60761 07-60762

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Be se se sc sc sc sc SC SC SC

i

I

I

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 6 of 18

07-60769 07-60770 07(0777 07-60784 07middot60785 07-60795 07-60797 01middot60802

07middot60808 0760810

07middot60812 07-60813 07-60815 07-60817 0760818

OH0819

i 07-60822 0760824

07-60826 07-60830 07-60833 0760836 0760837 0760838 0760839

07-60841 07-60842 07-60844 0760845

0760846 07-60849 07-60855 07-60859 0760860 n7~60863

07middot60865 07middot60868 0760872

060875 07middot60876

_M 0760877

t17middot60878 07middot60881 07-60883 07-60887 07-60894 07middot60896

se I SC

se se

SC

sc sc sc SC Be

SC

SC

SC

SC I sc

sc SC

SC

sc SC

se se SC

SC I

SC

sc

SC I SC I SC SC

SC

SC SC SC I SC SC

SC I

SC

sc

SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 7 of 18

07middot60899 SC 07middot60900 SC 07middot60901 SC 07middot60903 SC 07middot60905 SC 01middot60907 SC 01-60908 SC 07-lti0912 SC

07middot60917 SC 07~60918 SC 07-lti0919 SC

07-60922 SC I 07middot60925 SC I

07middot60926 SC

07middot60927 SC 07-60928 SC

I 07-lti0930 SC I OH0933 SC

07-60937 SC

07middot60945 SC

0760947 SC )7~60955 SC 07middot60957 SC

07middot60958 SC I 0760963 SC

07-lti0965 SC 0760968 SC 07-60973 SC

07-lti0976 SC i 07-60977 SC I 07-60979 SC

07middot60986 SC 07middot60990 SC 07middot60995 SC

07middot60996 SC I 07middot61010 SC

07middot61011 SC

07~61014 SC 07-ltil015 SC 07-61016 SC OHI017 SC 07-lti1018 SC

07-61021 SC 07middot61022 SC 07middot61026 SC 07middot61030 SC 07middot61031 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 8 of 18

07-61032 07middot61033 07-61034 07-61035 07middot61037 07middot61038 07middot6L041 07-61042

07-61043 07-61044

07-61045 07-61048 07-61049 07-61052 07-61055 07middot61062 07-61064

07-61068 07-61069 07-61010 07-61071 07-61072 07-61073 07-61081 07-61083

07-61084 07-61085 07-6101(1 07-61091 07-61093 07-61094 07-61095 07-61096 07-61098 07-61099 07-61102 07-61108 07middot61109 07middot6111 0 07-61113 07-61115 07-61116 07middot61118 07-61120 07-61121 07-61122 07-61124

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC-SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC sc SC sc sec SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 9 of 18

i

i

07-61125 07-6) 126 07-6)[29

07middot61 no 07middot6113l

07~61l32

07-61136

07-61137 OJ-GI139

07middot61140 07middot6) 143

07-61144 rshy 07-61146 L bullbullbull

07middot6) 147 07middot6) 148

07-61149 07-61150 07-6)[52 07-6)[54 07middot6) 155

07middot61158 07middot61159 07-61160 07-61161 07middot61162 0761163

07-61165 07middot61166 07middot61167 07-6l168 07-61169 07-61170 07-61171

07-61172

07middot61173

07middot61174 07-61176 07-61177

07middot61179 07middot61180

07-6118)

07middot61182 07middot61183

07-6Jl34 07-61185 07middot6) )86

07middot61187

se se SC sc se se SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC sc sc sc sc se SC SC SC se SC sc se SC sc sc SC sc SC se se SC se sc SC SC SC SC SC

-

I

I

i

I

I

i

I

I

I

I

I i

I

7

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 10 of 18

07-61188 SC 07-61189 SC 07-61190 SC 07-61191 SC 07-61192 SC 07-61193 SC 07-61194 SC 07-61196 SC 07-61197 sc 07-61198 SC 07-61201 SC 07-61203 SC 07-61205 SC 07-61206 SC 07-61209 SC 07-61210 SC 07-61213 sc 07-61215 SC 07-61216 SC 07-61217 SC 07-61219 SC 07-61220 SC 07-61223 SC 07-61225 SC 07-61226 SC 07-61227 SC 07-61228 SC 07-61233 SC 07-61404 SC 07-61412 SC 07-61413 SC 07-61429 SC 07-61432 SC 07-61434 SC 07-61435 SC 07-61438 SC 07-61439 SC 07-61442 SC 07-61443 SC 07-61445 SC 07-61448 SC 07-61457 SC 07-61459 SC 07-61460 SC 07-61461 SC 07-61474 SC 07-61475 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 11 of 18

I

07-61477 07-61478 07-61479 07-61485 07-51486 07-61487 07-61488 07-61489 07-61491

Q7-61493 07-51496 07-61498 07-61503 07-61504 07-61505 07~61506

07-61507 07-61508 07-61509 07middot61510 07-61512 07-61513

07middot61514 07middot61515 07-61516

07-61518 L sc

07-61523 07-61526 07-61534 07-61536 07-61539 07-61541

07-61543

07-62972 07-62973 07middot62974 07middot62975 07-62976 07-62977 07-62979 07-63756 07middot63757 07middot63760 07-63761 07middot63762 0763763

07-63769

SC Be

Be se Be Be se

se se se se se

se

se se se se se se

sc sc Be se se Be

se se sc sc se

se Be Be Be Be Be se se Be se se se se se se Be

shy

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 12 of 18

07middot63770 SC 07-63771 SC 07middot63774 SC 07middot63778 SC 07middot63779 SC I 07-64649 SC

07-64650 SC

07middot64655 SC 07middot64664 SC 07middot64671 SC 07middot64674 SC 07-64678 SC 07middot64682 SC 07middot65979 SC

07middot65982 SC

07middot65984 SC 07middot65985 SC I 07middot65989 SC

07middot67408 SC 07-67411 SC 07-67413 SC 07-69159 SC 07-69162 SC 07-69163 SC 07middot69167 SC 07-69168 SC 07-69169 SC 07-69170 SC

07-69179 SC i 07-69182 SC 07-69183 SC

07-70506 SC 07-73476 SC

07-73478 SC 07-73499 SC 07middot73501 SC 07middot74185 SC 08middot67063 SC 08-67066 SC 08-70866 NCmiddotW 08-70886 SC

08-70894 SC

I 08-70895 SC 08-768gt2 NCmiddotW

08middot76849 SC

08middot76850 SC -I 0S-76851 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 13 of 18

08-76853 08-76855 08-76856 08-76857 08-76862 08-76865 08-79838 08-79848

08-79850 08-83125 08-83127 08-83129 08-83131

08-83568 08-83571

08-83575 08-83577 08-83579 08-84578

08-84581 08-84586 08-87194

08-87198

I 08-87205 08-88797

08-88801

08-88803 08-88804

08-88809 08-88810 08-88817

08-89202

08-89203 08-89204 08-89207

08-89209 08-89215 08-90395

08-90396 08-90399 08-90400 08-90403 08-90404 08-90406

08-90413 08-90414

08-90416

se se se se se se se

se se He He se se se se se se se se se se He He se sc se se se se se se

He se

se I se

se sc

He

se se se He He se se se He

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 14 of 18

I 09middot6(1076 09-6(1080

09-60083 09-60084 09-60088

09-60100

09middot60102 09-60104 09-60109 09(0117 09-60119

09-60122 09-60124 09-62649 09-62650

09-62658 IN-65538

09-65541 09middot65549

09middot65551 09-65552 09middot66138 09middot66142

I 09-66147 09middot67138 09-67139

09-67144 01-67146 09-70165 09-70172 09-70173

01middot74445 09-74773 09middot74776 09-80061

09middot80063 09-80075 09-80103

09-90845

09-90846 09-90847 09-90amp48

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

GA-S

Sc SC

SC SC SC UT SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 15 of 18

IIxbjbjj B

1 MCAnany at a1 v Owens-Corning Fiberglas Corporation et al 207~cv-605euroB (S2)

a Nolion for Suwmary Judgment by Bayer cropscience Inc

2 Jirel v ACampS Ino at al 207-cv-61116 ISC)

a Motion fol Summary Judgment by Noland Company Inc

3 Christian v Owens-Illinois et al 207-cv-61187 (SC)

~ ~otion for Su~ary Judqme~~ by Daniel International Corporation

b Motion for Summary Judgment by Flour Daniel Corporation

4 Smoak v Owens-Illinois t et al 207-cv-61217 (SC)

a gtlotion for Sunmary Judgnet by Aventis Cropsclenc USA Ine

5 Kitt v Owens-Illinois at al 207-cv-61220 (SC)

a Motion for Summary JudgmenL by Aventis Cropscienoe USA Inc

6 Johnson v Aventis Crapsoience et a1 207-cv-61223 (SC)

a Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Crane Co

McDaniel v Owens-Illinois I at a~ 207-cv-61225 (SC)

1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 16 of 18

a t-lotion fc SUflnary JJdgrrent by Crane Co

8 Blackmon v Owens-Illinois et al 207middotmiddotcv-6297J (SC)

a Motion for SUfrJllaquo1Y Judgment by Crane Co

o ~ A1bereson v Bayer Cropscience et al

207-cv-63761 (SC)

a Motion for Suuunary Judgment by Bayer Cropscienoe Inc

10 Campbell v Bayer Cropsoienoe et a1 gt07-cv-63763 (Sc)

a Motio~ for Su~~a~y Judgment by Bayer Cropecience Ino

11 Fritz v Bayer Cropsc1ence et al 207-cv-65982 (SC

lt1 Xotion -or Stmnary Judgme by Crane Co

12 WQaver v Owens Illinois Inc et al 20B-cv-90416 ISC)

a Motion fo SUhlmary Judgment by Bayer Cropscience Inc Certainteed Ino and Union Carbide Inc (same motion)

b Xotion or Summary Judgme-t by Crane Co

13 Anderson v Hamilton M1nerals et al 20Q-cv-H0103 IUtah)

a Motim for SrrJlnry Judgmen cy Rapid-American

b Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Georgia Pacific

c Motion -=or Summary Judgme-t by Union Carhide

2

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 17 of 18

MAILED ALGERNON SOLOMONS AlLAN SHACKELFOR ALLAN SLOAN BRENT BOYD BRUCE MtLLER C DRAKE CAREY AVrR CARl PIERCE CHRLES NORRIS CHRJSTOPHER 1AUHlELLO CHR1STOPHER Me cnOl CRAVENS RAVrNI-J DANIEL WHITE DAID CLEVELAND DAVlD LYLE DAVlD MORRISON

DAVD SLOUGH ERIC ElGLEBARDT GIIfILUPS

E-MAlLED~ ADDU R1E A1DREW SHAW ANTIlONY HAYES BRIAN CLARK

C EVERT CARLPIERCH CARTER LA1BfTl CASE DAM CATHERINE JASONS CHARLES SlEueL CHARLES SPRINKIlo CHRISTOPHER SANTORO CLARE MAISASO DAVIDLAMM DAVID TRAYLOR DEME nuns ZACHAROPOU EDWARD SIAUGHTER

BRlN 5110VNEI

FALDRIDGE FRANCES ZACHER FRANK (JORDON GEORGE lNABINET GEORGE TANKARD GtSSUAREZ OUYGLzIER HARRY DAVIS HOWARD BOWERS

Certificate of Service

GEOROE OKELLrV HOMER TISDALE JACKSON BARWICK JAiES KEhEDY JAMES PRESSLEY JEA~ELYLES

JEFFREY fiARNWELL JEFFREY EDDY

JOHNBRYAfT JOSEPH KIJIN

JOSEPH WiLSOr- KEVIN KAUER LAURA EVANS LEE WILSON MARYHILL NATCY MONTI

PAUL DOMlNICK PHILUP FERDERIGOS R SllAW

lVAK G1)STAFS()N

JAMES ElJJUIT JAMES OANDY JAMES KEYNEDY JANET BLACK JE1NlFER TECIIMAN JOHANNA FOWIER JOHN GARDNhR JOHN SLOSSON JOSEPH RHODES JOSEPHINE HICKS JOSHUA BENNEIT KELLY JONES KENNETHKYRE KEVlt OBRIEN K1RK WARNER

LAURA VEE LINDSAY PEED LOREN JACOBSON LOUIS HERNS

MARK THOMAS MARK WALL

MICHAEL COLE

MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI MOFFATT MCDONALD MONA WALLACE

RALPH DAVIES RlCHAAD BURKE RICHARD LUTZEL ROBERT BROWN ROBERT CARPENT[R ROBERT VARNADO

ROLFE MARTlf SHARON WjlLlAM~ THOMAS KEAVENY THOMAS wnl-S TIMOTHY BOlCI TODD SMYTH TRUDY ROBERmOfshyTYNIKA ADAMS VALERIE WILLIAMS WILLIAM HANAHAN WILLIAM LYLpoundS

NATHANIEL HOSIO OLLIE HARlOJI RICHARD RADCLIfFE

RonERTHOOD llOBERT LOVETT ROBERT MLRIWE fHER

ROBERTSHAW

RONALD cox SAfUEL CARR1NGTON SCOTT FRICK $H~ K4CHMAR

STEPHANIE FLYhN STEVEN OUZTS STEVEN PUGH TIIOMAS DOUGAU

TIMOT11Y HO)CH

TIMOTHY PF(K TRACY TOM1lN

v BEVON V1LLlAM COLLINS WILLlAM CONNER WLLlAM DAVIES WILLIAM DAVIS

WILLtM GR1HAM WILLIAM SM1TH WILLlAM STARR

1 of 1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 18 of 18

Page 3: Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR '.:'HE BAS'I'ERK DIS':'RICT 07' PEKNSYLVnNIA ~N . RE; ASBESTOS

renaining it the case and counsel infoTrP-s the Court as to the

s-atus of tre case prio to the date of the hearing 2ppcarance

at thC headng ~s excused Faillre to appear at the hearing

without a prior status update may result in the dism$~al of the

case

AND IT IS SO ORDERED

q~ -

EDUARDO C ROBRENO r J

3

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 3 of 18

Exhibit A

07-60062 SC 0-60063 SC 07-60066 SC 07-60069 SC

-shy 07-60070 SC 07-60074 SC 07-60080 SC 07-60084 SC 07-60092 SC 07-60097 SC 07-60107 SC 07-60254 SC 07-60256 SC 07-60267 SC 07-60268 SC 07middotmiddot60322 SC 07-60330 SC 07-60341 SC

07-60351 SC

07-6035S SC

07-60363 SC 07-60365 SC 07-60367 SC

07-60372 SC

07-60383 SC

07-60384 SC 07-60392 SC 07-60400 SC 0]middot60403 SC 07-60410 SC Q7-60412 SC 07-60415 SC 07-60416 SC 07-6]423 SC 07-60429 SC 07-60431 SC 07-60434 SC 07-60438 SC 07-60439 SC 07-60442 SC 07-60447 SC 07-60448 SC 01-60450 SC 01-60453 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 4 of 18

01~60454

07~60456

07-60457

07-60468 07-60470 07~60471

07~60474 07-60477 07-60478 07-60479

07-60481 07-60486 07-60488 07-60490 07-60493 07-60494

07-60495 07-60496 07-60501

07-60505 07-60510

07-60512 07~60515

07~60519

07-60520 07~60524

07-60525 07-60526

07~60527

07-60529 07-60530 07-60531 07-60534

07-60555 07-60559

07-60561 07middot60565

07-60566

07-60568 07-60571 07-60596 07-60597 07-60608 07-60610 07-60613

07-60615 07-60616

SC SC SC SC I

SC SC

SC SC SC

SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC sc

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 5 of 18

07-60632

07-60637 07-60641 07-60642 07-60645 07-60646

07-60649 07-60650

07-60658 07-60659

07-60660 07-60662

07-60663

07-60664 07-60666 07-60669 07-60670 07-60672 07-60673

07-60674 07-60675

07-60677 07-60682 07-60685

07-60686 07-60688 07-60689 07-60694

07-60696

07-60703 07-60704

07-60707 07-60709 07-607

07-607 07-60 07-60721

07-60725 07-60727 07-60732 07-60733

07-60740 07-607 07-60744

07-60745 07-60761 07-60762

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Be se se sc sc sc sc SC SC SC

i

I

I

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 6 of 18

07-60769 07-60770 07(0777 07-60784 07middot60785 07-60795 07-60797 01middot60802

07middot60808 0760810

07middot60812 07-60813 07-60815 07-60817 0760818

OH0819

i 07-60822 0760824

07-60826 07-60830 07-60833 0760836 0760837 0760838 0760839

07-60841 07-60842 07-60844 0760845

0760846 07-60849 07-60855 07-60859 0760860 n7~60863

07middot60865 07middot60868 0760872

060875 07middot60876

_M 0760877

t17middot60878 07middot60881 07-60883 07-60887 07-60894 07middot60896

se I SC

se se

SC

sc sc sc SC Be

SC

SC

SC

SC I sc

sc SC

SC

sc SC

se se SC

SC I

SC

sc

SC I SC I SC SC

SC

SC SC SC I SC SC

SC I

SC

sc

SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 7 of 18

07middot60899 SC 07middot60900 SC 07middot60901 SC 07middot60903 SC 07middot60905 SC 01middot60907 SC 01-60908 SC 07-lti0912 SC

07middot60917 SC 07~60918 SC 07-lti0919 SC

07-60922 SC I 07middot60925 SC I

07middot60926 SC

07middot60927 SC 07-60928 SC

I 07-lti0930 SC I OH0933 SC

07-60937 SC

07middot60945 SC

0760947 SC )7~60955 SC 07middot60957 SC

07middot60958 SC I 0760963 SC

07-lti0965 SC 0760968 SC 07-60973 SC

07-lti0976 SC i 07-60977 SC I 07-60979 SC

07middot60986 SC 07middot60990 SC 07middot60995 SC

07middot60996 SC I 07middot61010 SC

07middot61011 SC

07~61014 SC 07-ltil015 SC 07-61016 SC OHI017 SC 07-lti1018 SC

07-61021 SC 07middot61022 SC 07middot61026 SC 07middot61030 SC 07middot61031 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 8 of 18

07-61032 07middot61033 07-61034 07-61035 07middot61037 07middot61038 07middot6L041 07-61042

07-61043 07-61044

07-61045 07-61048 07-61049 07-61052 07-61055 07middot61062 07-61064

07-61068 07-61069 07-61010 07-61071 07-61072 07-61073 07-61081 07-61083

07-61084 07-61085 07-6101(1 07-61091 07-61093 07-61094 07-61095 07-61096 07-61098 07-61099 07-61102 07-61108 07middot61109 07middot6111 0 07-61113 07-61115 07-61116 07middot61118 07-61120 07-61121 07-61122 07-61124

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC-SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC sc SC sc sec SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 9 of 18

i

i

07-61125 07-6) 126 07-6)[29

07middot61 no 07middot6113l

07~61l32

07-61136

07-61137 OJ-GI139

07middot61140 07middot6) 143

07-61144 rshy 07-61146 L bullbullbull

07middot6) 147 07middot6) 148

07-61149 07-61150 07-6)[52 07-6)[54 07middot6) 155

07middot61158 07middot61159 07-61160 07-61161 07middot61162 0761163

07-61165 07middot61166 07middot61167 07-6l168 07-61169 07-61170 07-61171

07-61172

07middot61173

07middot61174 07-61176 07-61177

07middot61179 07middot61180

07-6118)

07middot61182 07middot61183

07-6Jl34 07-61185 07middot6) )86

07middot61187

se se SC sc se se SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC sc sc sc sc se SC SC SC se SC sc se SC sc sc SC sc SC se se SC se sc SC SC SC SC SC

-

I

I

i

I

I

i

I

I

I

I

I i

I

7

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 10 of 18

07-61188 SC 07-61189 SC 07-61190 SC 07-61191 SC 07-61192 SC 07-61193 SC 07-61194 SC 07-61196 SC 07-61197 sc 07-61198 SC 07-61201 SC 07-61203 SC 07-61205 SC 07-61206 SC 07-61209 SC 07-61210 SC 07-61213 sc 07-61215 SC 07-61216 SC 07-61217 SC 07-61219 SC 07-61220 SC 07-61223 SC 07-61225 SC 07-61226 SC 07-61227 SC 07-61228 SC 07-61233 SC 07-61404 SC 07-61412 SC 07-61413 SC 07-61429 SC 07-61432 SC 07-61434 SC 07-61435 SC 07-61438 SC 07-61439 SC 07-61442 SC 07-61443 SC 07-61445 SC 07-61448 SC 07-61457 SC 07-61459 SC 07-61460 SC 07-61461 SC 07-61474 SC 07-61475 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 11 of 18

I

07-61477 07-61478 07-61479 07-61485 07-51486 07-61487 07-61488 07-61489 07-61491

Q7-61493 07-51496 07-61498 07-61503 07-61504 07-61505 07~61506

07-61507 07-61508 07-61509 07middot61510 07-61512 07-61513

07middot61514 07middot61515 07-61516

07-61518 L sc

07-61523 07-61526 07-61534 07-61536 07-61539 07-61541

07-61543

07-62972 07-62973 07middot62974 07middot62975 07-62976 07-62977 07-62979 07-63756 07middot63757 07middot63760 07-63761 07middot63762 0763763

07-63769

SC Be

Be se Be Be se

se se se se se

se

se se se se se se

sc sc Be se se Be

se se sc sc se

se Be Be Be Be Be se se Be se se se se se se Be

shy

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 12 of 18

07middot63770 SC 07-63771 SC 07middot63774 SC 07middot63778 SC 07middot63779 SC I 07-64649 SC

07-64650 SC

07middot64655 SC 07middot64664 SC 07middot64671 SC 07middot64674 SC 07-64678 SC 07middot64682 SC 07middot65979 SC

07middot65982 SC

07middot65984 SC 07middot65985 SC I 07middot65989 SC

07middot67408 SC 07-67411 SC 07-67413 SC 07-69159 SC 07-69162 SC 07-69163 SC 07middot69167 SC 07-69168 SC 07-69169 SC 07-69170 SC

07-69179 SC i 07-69182 SC 07-69183 SC

07-70506 SC 07-73476 SC

07-73478 SC 07-73499 SC 07middot73501 SC 07middot74185 SC 08middot67063 SC 08-67066 SC 08-70866 NCmiddotW 08-70886 SC

08-70894 SC

I 08-70895 SC 08-768gt2 NCmiddotW

08middot76849 SC

08middot76850 SC -I 0S-76851 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 13 of 18

08-76853 08-76855 08-76856 08-76857 08-76862 08-76865 08-79838 08-79848

08-79850 08-83125 08-83127 08-83129 08-83131

08-83568 08-83571

08-83575 08-83577 08-83579 08-84578

08-84581 08-84586 08-87194

08-87198

I 08-87205 08-88797

08-88801

08-88803 08-88804

08-88809 08-88810 08-88817

08-89202

08-89203 08-89204 08-89207

08-89209 08-89215 08-90395

08-90396 08-90399 08-90400 08-90403 08-90404 08-90406

08-90413 08-90414

08-90416

se se se se se se se

se se He He se se se se se se se se se se He He se sc se se se se se se

He se

se I se

se sc

He

se se se He He se se se He

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 14 of 18

I 09middot6(1076 09-6(1080

09-60083 09-60084 09-60088

09-60100

09middot60102 09-60104 09-60109 09(0117 09-60119

09-60122 09-60124 09-62649 09-62650

09-62658 IN-65538

09-65541 09middot65549

09middot65551 09-65552 09middot66138 09middot66142

I 09-66147 09middot67138 09-67139

09-67144 01-67146 09-70165 09-70172 09-70173

01middot74445 09-74773 09middot74776 09-80061

09middot80063 09-80075 09-80103

09-90845

09-90846 09-90847 09-90amp48

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

GA-S

Sc SC

SC SC SC UT SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 15 of 18

IIxbjbjj B

1 MCAnany at a1 v Owens-Corning Fiberglas Corporation et al 207~cv-605euroB (S2)

a Nolion for Suwmary Judgment by Bayer cropscience Inc

2 Jirel v ACampS Ino at al 207-cv-61116 ISC)

a Motion fol Summary Judgment by Noland Company Inc

3 Christian v Owens-Illinois et al 207-cv-61187 (SC)

~ ~otion for Su~ary Judqme~~ by Daniel International Corporation

b Motion for Summary Judgment by Flour Daniel Corporation

4 Smoak v Owens-Illinois t et al 207-cv-61217 (SC)

a gtlotion for Sunmary Judgnet by Aventis Cropsclenc USA Ine

5 Kitt v Owens-Illinois at al 207-cv-61220 (SC)

a Motion for Summary JudgmenL by Aventis Cropscienoe USA Inc

6 Johnson v Aventis Crapsoience et a1 207-cv-61223 (SC)

a Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Crane Co

McDaniel v Owens-Illinois I at a~ 207-cv-61225 (SC)

1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 16 of 18

a t-lotion fc SUflnary JJdgrrent by Crane Co

8 Blackmon v Owens-Illinois et al 207middotmiddotcv-6297J (SC)

a Motion for SUfrJllaquo1Y Judgment by Crane Co

o ~ A1bereson v Bayer Cropscience et al

207-cv-63761 (SC)

a Motion for Suuunary Judgment by Bayer Cropscienoe Inc

10 Campbell v Bayer Cropsoienoe et a1 gt07-cv-63763 (Sc)

a Motio~ for Su~~a~y Judgment by Bayer Cropecience Ino

11 Fritz v Bayer Cropsc1ence et al 207-cv-65982 (SC

lt1 Xotion -or Stmnary Judgme by Crane Co

12 WQaver v Owens Illinois Inc et al 20B-cv-90416 ISC)

a Motion fo SUhlmary Judgment by Bayer Cropscience Inc Certainteed Ino and Union Carbide Inc (same motion)

b Xotion or Summary Judgme-t by Crane Co

13 Anderson v Hamilton M1nerals et al 20Q-cv-H0103 IUtah)

a Motim for SrrJlnry Judgmen cy Rapid-American

b Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Georgia Pacific

c Motion -=or Summary Judgme-t by Union Carhide

2

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 17 of 18

MAILED ALGERNON SOLOMONS AlLAN SHACKELFOR ALLAN SLOAN BRENT BOYD BRUCE MtLLER C DRAKE CAREY AVrR CARl PIERCE CHRLES NORRIS CHRJSTOPHER 1AUHlELLO CHR1STOPHER Me cnOl CRAVENS RAVrNI-J DANIEL WHITE DAID CLEVELAND DAVlD LYLE DAVlD MORRISON

DAVD SLOUGH ERIC ElGLEBARDT GIIfILUPS

E-MAlLED~ ADDU R1E A1DREW SHAW ANTIlONY HAYES BRIAN CLARK

C EVERT CARLPIERCH CARTER LA1BfTl CASE DAM CATHERINE JASONS CHARLES SlEueL CHARLES SPRINKIlo CHRISTOPHER SANTORO CLARE MAISASO DAVIDLAMM DAVID TRAYLOR DEME nuns ZACHAROPOU EDWARD SIAUGHTER

BRlN 5110VNEI

FALDRIDGE FRANCES ZACHER FRANK (JORDON GEORGE lNABINET GEORGE TANKARD GtSSUAREZ OUYGLzIER HARRY DAVIS HOWARD BOWERS

Certificate of Service

GEOROE OKELLrV HOMER TISDALE JACKSON BARWICK JAiES KEhEDY JAMES PRESSLEY JEA~ELYLES

JEFFREY fiARNWELL JEFFREY EDDY

JOHNBRYAfT JOSEPH KIJIN

JOSEPH WiLSOr- KEVIN KAUER LAURA EVANS LEE WILSON MARYHILL NATCY MONTI

PAUL DOMlNICK PHILUP FERDERIGOS R SllAW

lVAK G1)STAFS()N

JAMES ElJJUIT JAMES OANDY JAMES KEYNEDY JANET BLACK JE1NlFER TECIIMAN JOHANNA FOWIER JOHN GARDNhR JOHN SLOSSON JOSEPH RHODES JOSEPHINE HICKS JOSHUA BENNEIT KELLY JONES KENNETHKYRE KEVlt OBRIEN K1RK WARNER

LAURA VEE LINDSAY PEED LOREN JACOBSON LOUIS HERNS

MARK THOMAS MARK WALL

MICHAEL COLE

MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI MOFFATT MCDONALD MONA WALLACE

RALPH DAVIES RlCHAAD BURKE RICHARD LUTZEL ROBERT BROWN ROBERT CARPENT[R ROBERT VARNADO

ROLFE MARTlf SHARON WjlLlAM~ THOMAS KEAVENY THOMAS wnl-S TIMOTHY BOlCI TODD SMYTH TRUDY ROBERmOfshyTYNIKA ADAMS VALERIE WILLIAMS WILLIAM HANAHAN WILLIAM LYLpoundS

NATHANIEL HOSIO OLLIE HARlOJI RICHARD RADCLIfFE

RonERTHOOD llOBERT LOVETT ROBERT MLRIWE fHER

ROBERTSHAW

RONALD cox SAfUEL CARR1NGTON SCOTT FRICK $H~ K4CHMAR

STEPHANIE FLYhN STEVEN OUZTS STEVEN PUGH TIIOMAS DOUGAU

TIMOT11Y HO)CH

TIMOTHY PF(K TRACY TOM1lN

v BEVON V1LLlAM COLLINS WILLlAM CONNER WLLlAM DAVIES WILLIAM DAVIS

WILLtM GR1HAM WILLIAM SM1TH WILLlAM STARR

1 of 1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 18 of 18

Page 4: Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR '.:'HE BAS'I'ERK DIS':'RICT 07' PEKNSYLVnNIA ~N . RE; ASBESTOS

Exhibit A

07-60062 SC 0-60063 SC 07-60066 SC 07-60069 SC

-shy 07-60070 SC 07-60074 SC 07-60080 SC 07-60084 SC 07-60092 SC 07-60097 SC 07-60107 SC 07-60254 SC 07-60256 SC 07-60267 SC 07-60268 SC 07middotmiddot60322 SC 07-60330 SC 07-60341 SC

07-60351 SC

07-6035S SC

07-60363 SC 07-60365 SC 07-60367 SC

07-60372 SC

07-60383 SC

07-60384 SC 07-60392 SC 07-60400 SC 0]middot60403 SC 07-60410 SC Q7-60412 SC 07-60415 SC 07-60416 SC 07-6]423 SC 07-60429 SC 07-60431 SC 07-60434 SC 07-60438 SC 07-60439 SC 07-60442 SC 07-60447 SC 07-60448 SC 01-60450 SC 01-60453 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 4 of 18

01~60454

07~60456

07-60457

07-60468 07-60470 07~60471

07~60474 07-60477 07-60478 07-60479

07-60481 07-60486 07-60488 07-60490 07-60493 07-60494

07-60495 07-60496 07-60501

07-60505 07-60510

07-60512 07~60515

07~60519

07-60520 07~60524

07-60525 07-60526

07~60527

07-60529 07-60530 07-60531 07-60534

07-60555 07-60559

07-60561 07middot60565

07-60566

07-60568 07-60571 07-60596 07-60597 07-60608 07-60610 07-60613

07-60615 07-60616

SC SC SC SC I

SC SC

SC SC SC

SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC sc

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 5 of 18

07-60632

07-60637 07-60641 07-60642 07-60645 07-60646

07-60649 07-60650

07-60658 07-60659

07-60660 07-60662

07-60663

07-60664 07-60666 07-60669 07-60670 07-60672 07-60673

07-60674 07-60675

07-60677 07-60682 07-60685

07-60686 07-60688 07-60689 07-60694

07-60696

07-60703 07-60704

07-60707 07-60709 07-607

07-607 07-60 07-60721

07-60725 07-60727 07-60732 07-60733

07-60740 07-607 07-60744

07-60745 07-60761 07-60762

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Be se se sc sc sc sc SC SC SC

i

I

I

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 6 of 18

07-60769 07-60770 07(0777 07-60784 07middot60785 07-60795 07-60797 01middot60802

07middot60808 0760810

07middot60812 07-60813 07-60815 07-60817 0760818

OH0819

i 07-60822 0760824

07-60826 07-60830 07-60833 0760836 0760837 0760838 0760839

07-60841 07-60842 07-60844 0760845

0760846 07-60849 07-60855 07-60859 0760860 n7~60863

07middot60865 07middot60868 0760872

060875 07middot60876

_M 0760877

t17middot60878 07middot60881 07-60883 07-60887 07-60894 07middot60896

se I SC

se se

SC

sc sc sc SC Be

SC

SC

SC

SC I sc

sc SC

SC

sc SC

se se SC

SC I

SC

sc

SC I SC I SC SC

SC

SC SC SC I SC SC

SC I

SC

sc

SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 7 of 18

07middot60899 SC 07middot60900 SC 07middot60901 SC 07middot60903 SC 07middot60905 SC 01middot60907 SC 01-60908 SC 07-lti0912 SC

07middot60917 SC 07~60918 SC 07-lti0919 SC

07-60922 SC I 07middot60925 SC I

07middot60926 SC

07middot60927 SC 07-60928 SC

I 07-lti0930 SC I OH0933 SC

07-60937 SC

07middot60945 SC

0760947 SC )7~60955 SC 07middot60957 SC

07middot60958 SC I 0760963 SC

07-lti0965 SC 0760968 SC 07-60973 SC

07-lti0976 SC i 07-60977 SC I 07-60979 SC

07middot60986 SC 07middot60990 SC 07middot60995 SC

07middot60996 SC I 07middot61010 SC

07middot61011 SC

07~61014 SC 07-ltil015 SC 07-61016 SC OHI017 SC 07-lti1018 SC

07-61021 SC 07middot61022 SC 07middot61026 SC 07middot61030 SC 07middot61031 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 8 of 18

07-61032 07middot61033 07-61034 07-61035 07middot61037 07middot61038 07middot6L041 07-61042

07-61043 07-61044

07-61045 07-61048 07-61049 07-61052 07-61055 07middot61062 07-61064

07-61068 07-61069 07-61010 07-61071 07-61072 07-61073 07-61081 07-61083

07-61084 07-61085 07-6101(1 07-61091 07-61093 07-61094 07-61095 07-61096 07-61098 07-61099 07-61102 07-61108 07middot61109 07middot6111 0 07-61113 07-61115 07-61116 07middot61118 07-61120 07-61121 07-61122 07-61124

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC-SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC sc SC sc sec SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 9 of 18

i

i

07-61125 07-6) 126 07-6)[29

07middot61 no 07middot6113l

07~61l32

07-61136

07-61137 OJ-GI139

07middot61140 07middot6) 143

07-61144 rshy 07-61146 L bullbullbull

07middot6) 147 07middot6) 148

07-61149 07-61150 07-6)[52 07-6)[54 07middot6) 155

07middot61158 07middot61159 07-61160 07-61161 07middot61162 0761163

07-61165 07middot61166 07middot61167 07-6l168 07-61169 07-61170 07-61171

07-61172

07middot61173

07middot61174 07-61176 07-61177

07middot61179 07middot61180

07-6118)

07middot61182 07middot61183

07-6Jl34 07-61185 07middot6) )86

07middot61187

se se SC sc se se SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC sc sc sc sc se SC SC SC se SC sc se SC sc sc SC sc SC se se SC se sc SC SC SC SC SC

-

I

I

i

I

I

i

I

I

I

I

I i

I

7

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 10 of 18

07-61188 SC 07-61189 SC 07-61190 SC 07-61191 SC 07-61192 SC 07-61193 SC 07-61194 SC 07-61196 SC 07-61197 sc 07-61198 SC 07-61201 SC 07-61203 SC 07-61205 SC 07-61206 SC 07-61209 SC 07-61210 SC 07-61213 sc 07-61215 SC 07-61216 SC 07-61217 SC 07-61219 SC 07-61220 SC 07-61223 SC 07-61225 SC 07-61226 SC 07-61227 SC 07-61228 SC 07-61233 SC 07-61404 SC 07-61412 SC 07-61413 SC 07-61429 SC 07-61432 SC 07-61434 SC 07-61435 SC 07-61438 SC 07-61439 SC 07-61442 SC 07-61443 SC 07-61445 SC 07-61448 SC 07-61457 SC 07-61459 SC 07-61460 SC 07-61461 SC 07-61474 SC 07-61475 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 11 of 18

I

07-61477 07-61478 07-61479 07-61485 07-51486 07-61487 07-61488 07-61489 07-61491

Q7-61493 07-51496 07-61498 07-61503 07-61504 07-61505 07~61506

07-61507 07-61508 07-61509 07middot61510 07-61512 07-61513

07middot61514 07middot61515 07-61516

07-61518 L sc

07-61523 07-61526 07-61534 07-61536 07-61539 07-61541

07-61543

07-62972 07-62973 07middot62974 07middot62975 07-62976 07-62977 07-62979 07-63756 07middot63757 07middot63760 07-63761 07middot63762 0763763

07-63769

SC Be

Be se Be Be se

se se se se se

se

se se se se se se

sc sc Be se se Be

se se sc sc se

se Be Be Be Be Be se se Be se se se se se se Be

shy

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 12 of 18

07middot63770 SC 07-63771 SC 07middot63774 SC 07middot63778 SC 07middot63779 SC I 07-64649 SC

07-64650 SC

07middot64655 SC 07middot64664 SC 07middot64671 SC 07middot64674 SC 07-64678 SC 07middot64682 SC 07middot65979 SC

07middot65982 SC

07middot65984 SC 07middot65985 SC I 07middot65989 SC

07middot67408 SC 07-67411 SC 07-67413 SC 07-69159 SC 07-69162 SC 07-69163 SC 07middot69167 SC 07-69168 SC 07-69169 SC 07-69170 SC

07-69179 SC i 07-69182 SC 07-69183 SC

07-70506 SC 07-73476 SC

07-73478 SC 07-73499 SC 07middot73501 SC 07middot74185 SC 08middot67063 SC 08-67066 SC 08-70866 NCmiddotW 08-70886 SC

08-70894 SC

I 08-70895 SC 08-768gt2 NCmiddotW

08middot76849 SC

08middot76850 SC -I 0S-76851 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 13 of 18

08-76853 08-76855 08-76856 08-76857 08-76862 08-76865 08-79838 08-79848

08-79850 08-83125 08-83127 08-83129 08-83131

08-83568 08-83571

08-83575 08-83577 08-83579 08-84578

08-84581 08-84586 08-87194

08-87198

I 08-87205 08-88797

08-88801

08-88803 08-88804

08-88809 08-88810 08-88817

08-89202

08-89203 08-89204 08-89207

08-89209 08-89215 08-90395

08-90396 08-90399 08-90400 08-90403 08-90404 08-90406

08-90413 08-90414

08-90416

se se se se se se se

se se He He se se se se se se se se se se He He se sc se se se se se se

He se

se I se

se sc

He

se se se He He se se se He

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 14 of 18

I 09middot6(1076 09-6(1080

09-60083 09-60084 09-60088

09-60100

09middot60102 09-60104 09-60109 09(0117 09-60119

09-60122 09-60124 09-62649 09-62650

09-62658 IN-65538

09-65541 09middot65549

09middot65551 09-65552 09middot66138 09middot66142

I 09-66147 09middot67138 09-67139

09-67144 01-67146 09-70165 09-70172 09-70173

01middot74445 09-74773 09middot74776 09-80061

09middot80063 09-80075 09-80103

09-90845

09-90846 09-90847 09-90amp48

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

GA-S

Sc SC

SC SC SC UT SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 15 of 18

IIxbjbjj B

1 MCAnany at a1 v Owens-Corning Fiberglas Corporation et al 207~cv-605euroB (S2)

a Nolion for Suwmary Judgment by Bayer cropscience Inc

2 Jirel v ACampS Ino at al 207-cv-61116 ISC)

a Motion fol Summary Judgment by Noland Company Inc

3 Christian v Owens-Illinois et al 207-cv-61187 (SC)

~ ~otion for Su~ary Judqme~~ by Daniel International Corporation

b Motion for Summary Judgment by Flour Daniel Corporation

4 Smoak v Owens-Illinois t et al 207-cv-61217 (SC)

a gtlotion for Sunmary Judgnet by Aventis Cropsclenc USA Ine

5 Kitt v Owens-Illinois at al 207-cv-61220 (SC)

a Motion for Summary JudgmenL by Aventis Cropscienoe USA Inc

6 Johnson v Aventis Crapsoience et a1 207-cv-61223 (SC)

a Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Crane Co

McDaniel v Owens-Illinois I at a~ 207-cv-61225 (SC)

1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 16 of 18

a t-lotion fc SUflnary JJdgrrent by Crane Co

8 Blackmon v Owens-Illinois et al 207middotmiddotcv-6297J (SC)

a Motion for SUfrJllaquo1Y Judgment by Crane Co

o ~ A1bereson v Bayer Cropscience et al

207-cv-63761 (SC)

a Motion for Suuunary Judgment by Bayer Cropscienoe Inc

10 Campbell v Bayer Cropsoienoe et a1 gt07-cv-63763 (Sc)

a Motio~ for Su~~a~y Judgment by Bayer Cropecience Ino

11 Fritz v Bayer Cropsc1ence et al 207-cv-65982 (SC

lt1 Xotion -or Stmnary Judgme by Crane Co

12 WQaver v Owens Illinois Inc et al 20B-cv-90416 ISC)

a Motion fo SUhlmary Judgment by Bayer Cropscience Inc Certainteed Ino and Union Carbide Inc (same motion)

b Xotion or Summary Judgme-t by Crane Co

13 Anderson v Hamilton M1nerals et al 20Q-cv-H0103 IUtah)

a Motim for SrrJlnry Judgmen cy Rapid-American

b Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Georgia Pacific

c Motion -=or Summary Judgme-t by Union Carhide

2

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 17 of 18

MAILED ALGERNON SOLOMONS AlLAN SHACKELFOR ALLAN SLOAN BRENT BOYD BRUCE MtLLER C DRAKE CAREY AVrR CARl PIERCE CHRLES NORRIS CHRJSTOPHER 1AUHlELLO CHR1STOPHER Me cnOl CRAVENS RAVrNI-J DANIEL WHITE DAID CLEVELAND DAVlD LYLE DAVlD MORRISON

DAVD SLOUGH ERIC ElGLEBARDT GIIfILUPS

E-MAlLED~ ADDU R1E A1DREW SHAW ANTIlONY HAYES BRIAN CLARK

C EVERT CARLPIERCH CARTER LA1BfTl CASE DAM CATHERINE JASONS CHARLES SlEueL CHARLES SPRINKIlo CHRISTOPHER SANTORO CLARE MAISASO DAVIDLAMM DAVID TRAYLOR DEME nuns ZACHAROPOU EDWARD SIAUGHTER

BRlN 5110VNEI

FALDRIDGE FRANCES ZACHER FRANK (JORDON GEORGE lNABINET GEORGE TANKARD GtSSUAREZ OUYGLzIER HARRY DAVIS HOWARD BOWERS

Certificate of Service

GEOROE OKELLrV HOMER TISDALE JACKSON BARWICK JAiES KEhEDY JAMES PRESSLEY JEA~ELYLES

JEFFREY fiARNWELL JEFFREY EDDY

JOHNBRYAfT JOSEPH KIJIN

JOSEPH WiLSOr- KEVIN KAUER LAURA EVANS LEE WILSON MARYHILL NATCY MONTI

PAUL DOMlNICK PHILUP FERDERIGOS R SllAW

lVAK G1)STAFS()N

JAMES ElJJUIT JAMES OANDY JAMES KEYNEDY JANET BLACK JE1NlFER TECIIMAN JOHANNA FOWIER JOHN GARDNhR JOHN SLOSSON JOSEPH RHODES JOSEPHINE HICKS JOSHUA BENNEIT KELLY JONES KENNETHKYRE KEVlt OBRIEN K1RK WARNER

LAURA VEE LINDSAY PEED LOREN JACOBSON LOUIS HERNS

MARK THOMAS MARK WALL

MICHAEL COLE

MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI MOFFATT MCDONALD MONA WALLACE

RALPH DAVIES RlCHAAD BURKE RICHARD LUTZEL ROBERT BROWN ROBERT CARPENT[R ROBERT VARNADO

ROLFE MARTlf SHARON WjlLlAM~ THOMAS KEAVENY THOMAS wnl-S TIMOTHY BOlCI TODD SMYTH TRUDY ROBERmOfshyTYNIKA ADAMS VALERIE WILLIAMS WILLIAM HANAHAN WILLIAM LYLpoundS

NATHANIEL HOSIO OLLIE HARlOJI RICHARD RADCLIfFE

RonERTHOOD llOBERT LOVETT ROBERT MLRIWE fHER

ROBERTSHAW

RONALD cox SAfUEL CARR1NGTON SCOTT FRICK $H~ K4CHMAR

STEPHANIE FLYhN STEVEN OUZTS STEVEN PUGH TIIOMAS DOUGAU

TIMOT11Y HO)CH

TIMOTHY PF(K TRACY TOM1lN

v BEVON V1LLlAM COLLINS WILLlAM CONNER WLLlAM DAVIES WILLIAM DAVIS

WILLtM GR1HAM WILLIAM SM1TH WILLlAM STARR

1 of 1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 18 of 18

Page 5: Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR '.:'HE BAS'I'ERK DIS':'RICT 07' PEKNSYLVnNIA ~N . RE; ASBESTOS

01~60454

07~60456

07-60457

07-60468 07-60470 07~60471

07~60474 07-60477 07-60478 07-60479

07-60481 07-60486 07-60488 07-60490 07-60493 07-60494

07-60495 07-60496 07-60501

07-60505 07-60510

07-60512 07~60515

07~60519

07-60520 07~60524

07-60525 07-60526

07~60527

07-60529 07-60530 07-60531 07-60534

07-60555 07-60559

07-60561 07middot60565

07-60566

07-60568 07-60571 07-60596 07-60597 07-60608 07-60610 07-60613

07-60615 07-60616

SC SC SC SC I

SC SC

SC SC SC

SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC sc

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 5 of 18

07-60632

07-60637 07-60641 07-60642 07-60645 07-60646

07-60649 07-60650

07-60658 07-60659

07-60660 07-60662

07-60663

07-60664 07-60666 07-60669 07-60670 07-60672 07-60673

07-60674 07-60675

07-60677 07-60682 07-60685

07-60686 07-60688 07-60689 07-60694

07-60696

07-60703 07-60704

07-60707 07-60709 07-607

07-607 07-60 07-60721

07-60725 07-60727 07-60732 07-60733

07-60740 07-607 07-60744

07-60745 07-60761 07-60762

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Be se se sc sc sc sc SC SC SC

i

I

I

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 6 of 18

07-60769 07-60770 07(0777 07-60784 07middot60785 07-60795 07-60797 01middot60802

07middot60808 0760810

07middot60812 07-60813 07-60815 07-60817 0760818

OH0819

i 07-60822 0760824

07-60826 07-60830 07-60833 0760836 0760837 0760838 0760839

07-60841 07-60842 07-60844 0760845

0760846 07-60849 07-60855 07-60859 0760860 n7~60863

07middot60865 07middot60868 0760872

060875 07middot60876

_M 0760877

t17middot60878 07middot60881 07-60883 07-60887 07-60894 07middot60896

se I SC

se se

SC

sc sc sc SC Be

SC

SC

SC

SC I sc

sc SC

SC

sc SC

se se SC

SC I

SC

sc

SC I SC I SC SC

SC

SC SC SC I SC SC

SC I

SC

sc

SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 7 of 18

07middot60899 SC 07middot60900 SC 07middot60901 SC 07middot60903 SC 07middot60905 SC 01middot60907 SC 01-60908 SC 07-lti0912 SC

07middot60917 SC 07~60918 SC 07-lti0919 SC

07-60922 SC I 07middot60925 SC I

07middot60926 SC

07middot60927 SC 07-60928 SC

I 07-lti0930 SC I OH0933 SC

07-60937 SC

07middot60945 SC

0760947 SC )7~60955 SC 07middot60957 SC

07middot60958 SC I 0760963 SC

07-lti0965 SC 0760968 SC 07-60973 SC

07-lti0976 SC i 07-60977 SC I 07-60979 SC

07middot60986 SC 07middot60990 SC 07middot60995 SC

07middot60996 SC I 07middot61010 SC

07middot61011 SC

07~61014 SC 07-ltil015 SC 07-61016 SC OHI017 SC 07-lti1018 SC

07-61021 SC 07middot61022 SC 07middot61026 SC 07middot61030 SC 07middot61031 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 8 of 18

07-61032 07middot61033 07-61034 07-61035 07middot61037 07middot61038 07middot6L041 07-61042

07-61043 07-61044

07-61045 07-61048 07-61049 07-61052 07-61055 07middot61062 07-61064

07-61068 07-61069 07-61010 07-61071 07-61072 07-61073 07-61081 07-61083

07-61084 07-61085 07-6101(1 07-61091 07-61093 07-61094 07-61095 07-61096 07-61098 07-61099 07-61102 07-61108 07middot61109 07middot6111 0 07-61113 07-61115 07-61116 07middot61118 07-61120 07-61121 07-61122 07-61124

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC-SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC sc SC sc sec SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 9 of 18

i

i

07-61125 07-6) 126 07-6)[29

07middot61 no 07middot6113l

07~61l32

07-61136

07-61137 OJ-GI139

07middot61140 07middot6) 143

07-61144 rshy 07-61146 L bullbullbull

07middot6) 147 07middot6) 148

07-61149 07-61150 07-6)[52 07-6)[54 07middot6) 155

07middot61158 07middot61159 07-61160 07-61161 07middot61162 0761163

07-61165 07middot61166 07middot61167 07-6l168 07-61169 07-61170 07-61171

07-61172

07middot61173

07middot61174 07-61176 07-61177

07middot61179 07middot61180

07-6118)

07middot61182 07middot61183

07-6Jl34 07-61185 07middot6) )86

07middot61187

se se SC sc se se SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC sc sc sc sc se SC SC SC se SC sc se SC sc sc SC sc SC se se SC se sc SC SC SC SC SC

-

I

I

i

I

I

i

I

I

I

I

I i

I

7

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 10 of 18

07-61188 SC 07-61189 SC 07-61190 SC 07-61191 SC 07-61192 SC 07-61193 SC 07-61194 SC 07-61196 SC 07-61197 sc 07-61198 SC 07-61201 SC 07-61203 SC 07-61205 SC 07-61206 SC 07-61209 SC 07-61210 SC 07-61213 sc 07-61215 SC 07-61216 SC 07-61217 SC 07-61219 SC 07-61220 SC 07-61223 SC 07-61225 SC 07-61226 SC 07-61227 SC 07-61228 SC 07-61233 SC 07-61404 SC 07-61412 SC 07-61413 SC 07-61429 SC 07-61432 SC 07-61434 SC 07-61435 SC 07-61438 SC 07-61439 SC 07-61442 SC 07-61443 SC 07-61445 SC 07-61448 SC 07-61457 SC 07-61459 SC 07-61460 SC 07-61461 SC 07-61474 SC 07-61475 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 11 of 18

I

07-61477 07-61478 07-61479 07-61485 07-51486 07-61487 07-61488 07-61489 07-61491

Q7-61493 07-51496 07-61498 07-61503 07-61504 07-61505 07~61506

07-61507 07-61508 07-61509 07middot61510 07-61512 07-61513

07middot61514 07middot61515 07-61516

07-61518 L sc

07-61523 07-61526 07-61534 07-61536 07-61539 07-61541

07-61543

07-62972 07-62973 07middot62974 07middot62975 07-62976 07-62977 07-62979 07-63756 07middot63757 07middot63760 07-63761 07middot63762 0763763

07-63769

SC Be

Be se Be Be se

se se se se se

se

se se se se se se

sc sc Be se se Be

se se sc sc se

se Be Be Be Be Be se se Be se se se se se se Be

shy

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 12 of 18

07middot63770 SC 07-63771 SC 07middot63774 SC 07middot63778 SC 07middot63779 SC I 07-64649 SC

07-64650 SC

07middot64655 SC 07middot64664 SC 07middot64671 SC 07middot64674 SC 07-64678 SC 07middot64682 SC 07middot65979 SC

07middot65982 SC

07middot65984 SC 07middot65985 SC I 07middot65989 SC

07middot67408 SC 07-67411 SC 07-67413 SC 07-69159 SC 07-69162 SC 07-69163 SC 07middot69167 SC 07-69168 SC 07-69169 SC 07-69170 SC

07-69179 SC i 07-69182 SC 07-69183 SC

07-70506 SC 07-73476 SC

07-73478 SC 07-73499 SC 07middot73501 SC 07middot74185 SC 08middot67063 SC 08-67066 SC 08-70866 NCmiddotW 08-70886 SC

08-70894 SC

I 08-70895 SC 08-768gt2 NCmiddotW

08middot76849 SC

08middot76850 SC -I 0S-76851 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 13 of 18

08-76853 08-76855 08-76856 08-76857 08-76862 08-76865 08-79838 08-79848

08-79850 08-83125 08-83127 08-83129 08-83131

08-83568 08-83571

08-83575 08-83577 08-83579 08-84578

08-84581 08-84586 08-87194

08-87198

I 08-87205 08-88797

08-88801

08-88803 08-88804

08-88809 08-88810 08-88817

08-89202

08-89203 08-89204 08-89207

08-89209 08-89215 08-90395

08-90396 08-90399 08-90400 08-90403 08-90404 08-90406

08-90413 08-90414

08-90416

se se se se se se se

se se He He se se se se se se se se se se He He se sc se se se se se se

He se

se I se

se sc

He

se se se He He se se se He

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 14 of 18

I 09middot6(1076 09-6(1080

09-60083 09-60084 09-60088

09-60100

09middot60102 09-60104 09-60109 09(0117 09-60119

09-60122 09-60124 09-62649 09-62650

09-62658 IN-65538

09-65541 09middot65549

09middot65551 09-65552 09middot66138 09middot66142

I 09-66147 09middot67138 09-67139

09-67144 01-67146 09-70165 09-70172 09-70173

01middot74445 09-74773 09middot74776 09-80061

09middot80063 09-80075 09-80103

09-90845

09-90846 09-90847 09-90amp48

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

GA-S

Sc SC

SC SC SC UT SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 15 of 18

IIxbjbjj B

1 MCAnany at a1 v Owens-Corning Fiberglas Corporation et al 207~cv-605euroB (S2)

a Nolion for Suwmary Judgment by Bayer cropscience Inc

2 Jirel v ACampS Ino at al 207-cv-61116 ISC)

a Motion fol Summary Judgment by Noland Company Inc

3 Christian v Owens-Illinois et al 207-cv-61187 (SC)

~ ~otion for Su~ary Judqme~~ by Daniel International Corporation

b Motion for Summary Judgment by Flour Daniel Corporation

4 Smoak v Owens-Illinois t et al 207-cv-61217 (SC)

a gtlotion for Sunmary Judgnet by Aventis Cropsclenc USA Ine

5 Kitt v Owens-Illinois at al 207-cv-61220 (SC)

a Motion for Summary JudgmenL by Aventis Cropscienoe USA Inc

6 Johnson v Aventis Crapsoience et a1 207-cv-61223 (SC)

a Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Crane Co

McDaniel v Owens-Illinois I at a~ 207-cv-61225 (SC)

1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 16 of 18

a t-lotion fc SUflnary JJdgrrent by Crane Co

8 Blackmon v Owens-Illinois et al 207middotmiddotcv-6297J (SC)

a Motion for SUfrJllaquo1Y Judgment by Crane Co

o ~ A1bereson v Bayer Cropscience et al

207-cv-63761 (SC)

a Motion for Suuunary Judgment by Bayer Cropscienoe Inc

10 Campbell v Bayer Cropsoienoe et a1 gt07-cv-63763 (Sc)

a Motio~ for Su~~a~y Judgment by Bayer Cropecience Ino

11 Fritz v Bayer Cropsc1ence et al 207-cv-65982 (SC

lt1 Xotion -or Stmnary Judgme by Crane Co

12 WQaver v Owens Illinois Inc et al 20B-cv-90416 ISC)

a Motion fo SUhlmary Judgment by Bayer Cropscience Inc Certainteed Ino and Union Carbide Inc (same motion)

b Xotion or Summary Judgme-t by Crane Co

13 Anderson v Hamilton M1nerals et al 20Q-cv-H0103 IUtah)

a Motim for SrrJlnry Judgmen cy Rapid-American

b Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Georgia Pacific

c Motion -=or Summary Judgme-t by Union Carhide

2

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 17 of 18

MAILED ALGERNON SOLOMONS AlLAN SHACKELFOR ALLAN SLOAN BRENT BOYD BRUCE MtLLER C DRAKE CAREY AVrR CARl PIERCE CHRLES NORRIS CHRJSTOPHER 1AUHlELLO CHR1STOPHER Me cnOl CRAVENS RAVrNI-J DANIEL WHITE DAID CLEVELAND DAVlD LYLE DAVlD MORRISON

DAVD SLOUGH ERIC ElGLEBARDT GIIfILUPS

E-MAlLED~ ADDU R1E A1DREW SHAW ANTIlONY HAYES BRIAN CLARK

C EVERT CARLPIERCH CARTER LA1BfTl CASE DAM CATHERINE JASONS CHARLES SlEueL CHARLES SPRINKIlo CHRISTOPHER SANTORO CLARE MAISASO DAVIDLAMM DAVID TRAYLOR DEME nuns ZACHAROPOU EDWARD SIAUGHTER

BRlN 5110VNEI

FALDRIDGE FRANCES ZACHER FRANK (JORDON GEORGE lNABINET GEORGE TANKARD GtSSUAREZ OUYGLzIER HARRY DAVIS HOWARD BOWERS

Certificate of Service

GEOROE OKELLrV HOMER TISDALE JACKSON BARWICK JAiES KEhEDY JAMES PRESSLEY JEA~ELYLES

JEFFREY fiARNWELL JEFFREY EDDY

JOHNBRYAfT JOSEPH KIJIN

JOSEPH WiLSOr- KEVIN KAUER LAURA EVANS LEE WILSON MARYHILL NATCY MONTI

PAUL DOMlNICK PHILUP FERDERIGOS R SllAW

lVAK G1)STAFS()N

JAMES ElJJUIT JAMES OANDY JAMES KEYNEDY JANET BLACK JE1NlFER TECIIMAN JOHANNA FOWIER JOHN GARDNhR JOHN SLOSSON JOSEPH RHODES JOSEPHINE HICKS JOSHUA BENNEIT KELLY JONES KENNETHKYRE KEVlt OBRIEN K1RK WARNER

LAURA VEE LINDSAY PEED LOREN JACOBSON LOUIS HERNS

MARK THOMAS MARK WALL

MICHAEL COLE

MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI MOFFATT MCDONALD MONA WALLACE

RALPH DAVIES RlCHAAD BURKE RICHARD LUTZEL ROBERT BROWN ROBERT CARPENT[R ROBERT VARNADO

ROLFE MARTlf SHARON WjlLlAM~ THOMAS KEAVENY THOMAS wnl-S TIMOTHY BOlCI TODD SMYTH TRUDY ROBERmOfshyTYNIKA ADAMS VALERIE WILLIAMS WILLIAM HANAHAN WILLIAM LYLpoundS

NATHANIEL HOSIO OLLIE HARlOJI RICHARD RADCLIfFE

RonERTHOOD llOBERT LOVETT ROBERT MLRIWE fHER

ROBERTSHAW

RONALD cox SAfUEL CARR1NGTON SCOTT FRICK $H~ K4CHMAR

STEPHANIE FLYhN STEVEN OUZTS STEVEN PUGH TIIOMAS DOUGAU

TIMOT11Y HO)CH

TIMOTHY PF(K TRACY TOM1lN

v BEVON V1LLlAM COLLINS WILLlAM CONNER WLLlAM DAVIES WILLIAM DAVIS

WILLtM GR1HAM WILLIAM SM1TH WILLlAM STARR

1 of 1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 18 of 18

Page 6: Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR '.:'HE BAS'I'ERK DIS':'RICT 07' PEKNSYLVnNIA ~N . RE; ASBESTOS

07-60632

07-60637 07-60641 07-60642 07-60645 07-60646

07-60649 07-60650

07-60658 07-60659

07-60660 07-60662

07-60663

07-60664 07-60666 07-60669 07-60670 07-60672 07-60673

07-60674 07-60675

07-60677 07-60682 07-60685

07-60686 07-60688 07-60689 07-60694

07-60696

07-60703 07-60704

07-60707 07-60709 07-607

07-607 07-60 07-60721

07-60725 07-60727 07-60732 07-60733

07-60740 07-607 07-60744

07-60745 07-60761 07-60762

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Be se se sc sc sc sc SC SC SC

i

I

I

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 6 of 18

07-60769 07-60770 07(0777 07-60784 07middot60785 07-60795 07-60797 01middot60802

07middot60808 0760810

07middot60812 07-60813 07-60815 07-60817 0760818

OH0819

i 07-60822 0760824

07-60826 07-60830 07-60833 0760836 0760837 0760838 0760839

07-60841 07-60842 07-60844 0760845

0760846 07-60849 07-60855 07-60859 0760860 n7~60863

07middot60865 07middot60868 0760872

060875 07middot60876

_M 0760877

t17middot60878 07middot60881 07-60883 07-60887 07-60894 07middot60896

se I SC

se se

SC

sc sc sc SC Be

SC

SC

SC

SC I sc

sc SC

SC

sc SC

se se SC

SC I

SC

sc

SC I SC I SC SC

SC

SC SC SC I SC SC

SC I

SC

sc

SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 7 of 18

07middot60899 SC 07middot60900 SC 07middot60901 SC 07middot60903 SC 07middot60905 SC 01middot60907 SC 01-60908 SC 07-lti0912 SC

07middot60917 SC 07~60918 SC 07-lti0919 SC

07-60922 SC I 07middot60925 SC I

07middot60926 SC

07middot60927 SC 07-60928 SC

I 07-lti0930 SC I OH0933 SC

07-60937 SC

07middot60945 SC

0760947 SC )7~60955 SC 07middot60957 SC

07middot60958 SC I 0760963 SC

07-lti0965 SC 0760968 SC 07-60973 SC

07-lti0976 SC i 07-60977 SC I 07-60979 SC

07middot60986 SC 07middot60990 SC 07middot60995 SC

07middot60996 SC I 07middot61010 SC

07middot61011 SC

07~61014 SC 07-ltil015 SC 07-61016 SC OHI017 SC 07-lti1018 SC

07-61021 SC 07middot61022 SC 07middot61026 SC 07middot61030 SC 07middot61031 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 8 of 18

07-61032 07middot61033 07-61034 07-61035 07middot61037 07middot61038 07middot6L041 07-61042

07-61043 07-61044

07-61045 07-61048 07-61049 07-61052 07-61055 07middot61062 07-61064

07-61068 07-61069 07-61010 07-61071 07-61072 07-61073 07-61081 07-61083

07-61084 07-61085 07-6101(1 07-61091 07-61093 07-61094 07-61095 07-61096 07-61098 07-61099 07-61102 07-61108 07middot61109 07middot6111 0 07-61113 07-61115 07-61116 07middot61118 07-61120 07-61121 07-61122 07-61124

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC-SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC sc SC sc sec SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 9 of 18

i

i

07-61125 07-6) 126 07-6)[29

07middot61 no 07middot6113l

07~61l32

07-61136

07-61137 OJ-GI139

07middot61140 07middot6) 143

07-61144 rshy 07-61146 L bullbullbull

07middot6) 147 07middot6) 148

07-61149 07-61150 07-6)[52 07-6)[54 07middot6) 155

07middot61158 07middot61159 07-61160 07-61161 07middot61162 0761163

07-61165 07middot61166 07middot61167 07-6l168 07-61169 07-61170 07-61171

07-61172

07middot61173

07middot61174 07-61176 07-61177

07middot61179 07middot61180

07-6118)

07middot61182 07middot61183

07-6Jl34 07-61185 07middot6) )86

07middot61187

se se SC sc se se SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC sc sc sc sc se SC SC SC se SC sc se SC sc sc SC sc SC se se SC se sc SC SC SC SC SC

-

I

I

i

I

I

i

I

I

I

I

I i

I

7

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 10 of 18

07-61188 SC 07-61189 SC 07-61190 SC 07-61191 SC 07-61192 SC 07-61193 SC 07-61194 SC 07-61196 SC 07-61197 sc 07-61198 SC 07-61201 SC 07-61203 SC 07-61205 SC 07-61206 SC 07-61209 SC 07-61210 SC 07-61213 sc 07-61215 SC 07-61216 SC 07-61217 SC 07-61219 SC 07-61220 SC 07-61223 SC 07-61225 SC 07-61226 SC 07-61227 SC 07-61228 SC 07-61233 SC 07-61404 SC 07-61412 SC 07-61413 SC 07-61429 SC 07-61432 SC 07-61434 SC 07-61435 SC 07-61438 SC 07-61439 SC 07-61442 SC 07-61443 SC 07-61445 SC 07-61448 SC 07-61457 SC 07-61459 SC 07-61460 SC 07-61461 SC 07-61474 SC 07-61475 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 11 of 18

I

07-61477 07-61478 07-61479 07-61485 07-51486 07-61487 07-61488 07-61489 07-61491

Q7-61493 07-51496 07-61498 07-61503 07-61504 07-61505 07~61506

07-61507 07-61508 07-61509 07middot61510 07-61512 07-61513

07middot61514 07middot61515 07-61516

07-61518 L sc

07-61523 07-61526 07-61534 07-61536 07-61539 07-61541

07-61543

07-62972 07-62973 07middot62974 07middot62975 07-62976 07-62977 07-62979 07-63756 07middot63757 07middot63760 07-63761 07middot63762 0763763

07-63769

SC Be

Be se Be Be se

se se se se se

se

se se se se se se

sc sc Be se se Be

se se sc sc se

se Be Be Be Be Be se se Be se se se se se se Be

shy

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 12 of 18

07middot63770 SC 07-63771 SC 07middot63774 SC 07middot63778 SC 07middot63779 SC I 07-64649 SC

07-64650 SC

07middot64655 SC 07middot64664 SC 07middot64671 SC 07middot64674 SC 07-64678 SC 07middot64682 SC 07middot65979 SC

07middot65982 SC

07middot65984 SC 07middot65985 SC I 07middot65989 SC

07middot67408 SC 07-67411 SC 07-67413 SC 07-69159 SC 07-69162 SC 07-69163 SC 07middot69167 SC 07-69168 SC 07-69169 SC 07-69170 SC

07-69179 SC i 07-69182 SC 07-69183 SC

07-70506 SC 07-73476 SC

07-73478 SC 07-73499 SC 07middot73501 SC 07middot74185 SC 08middot67063 SC 08-67066 SC 08-70866 NCmiddotW 08-70886 SC

08-70894 SC

I 08-70895 SC 08-768gt2 NCmiddotW

08middot76849 SC

08middot76850 SC -I 0S-76851 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 13 of 18

08-76853 08-76855 08-76856 08-76857 08-76862 08-76865 08-79838 08-79848

08-79850 08-83125 08-83127 08-83129 08-83131

08-83568 08-83571

08-83575 08-83577 08-83579 08-84578

08-84581 08-84586 08-87194

08-87198

I 08-87205 08-88797

08-88801

08-88803 08-88804

08-88809 08-88810 08-88817

08-89202

08-89203 08-89204 08-89207

08-89209 08-89215 08-90395

08-90396 08-90399 08-90400 08-90403 08-90404 08-90406

08-90413 08-90414

08-90416

se se se se se se se

se se He He se se se se se se se se se se He He se sc se se se se se se

He se

se I se

se sc

He

se se se He He se se se He

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 14 of 18

I 09middot6(1076 09-6(1080

09-60083 09-60084 09-60088

09-60100

09middot60102 09-60104 09-60109 09(0117 09-60119

09-60122 09-60124 09-62649 09-62650

09-62658 IN-65538

09-65541 09middot65549

09middot65551 09-65552 09middot66138 09middot66142

I 09-66147 09middot67138 09-67139

09-67144 01-67146 09-70165 09-70172 09-70173

01middot74445 09-74773 09middot74776 09-80061

09middot80063 09-80075 09-80103

09-90845

09-90846 09-90847 09-90amp48

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

GA-S

Sc SC

SC SC SC UT SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 15 of 18

IIxbjbjj B

1 MCAnany at a1 v Owens-Corning Fiberglas Corporation et al 207~cv-605euroB (S2)

a Nolion for Suwmary Judgment by Bayer cropscience Inc

2 Jirel v ACampS Ino at al 207-cv-61116 ISC)

a Motion fol Summary Judgment by Noland Company Inc

3 Christian v Owens-Illinois et al 207-cv-61187 (SC)

~ ~otion for Su~ary Judqme~~ by Daniel International Corporation

b Motion for Summary Judgment by Flour Daniel Corporation

4 Smoak v Owens-Illinois t et al 207-cv-61217 (SC)

a gtlotion for Sunmary Judgnet by Aventis Cropsclenc USA Ine

5 Kitt v Owens-Illinois at al 207-cv-61220 (SC)

a Motion for Summary JudgmenL by Aventis Cropscienoe USA Inc

6 Johnson v Aventis Crapsoience et a1 207-cv-61223 (SC)

a Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Crane Co

McDaniel v Owens-Illinois I at a~ 207-cv-61225 (SC)

1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 16 of 18

a t-lotion fc SUflnary JJdgrrent by Crane Co

8 Blackmon v Owens-Illinois et al 207middotmiddotcv-6297J (SC)

a Motion for SUfrJllaquo1Y Judgment by Crane Co

o ~ A1bereson v Bayer Cropscience et al

207-cv-63761 (SC)

a Motion for Suuunary Judgment by Bayer Cropscienoe Inc

10 Campbell v Bayer Cropsoienoe et a1 gt07-cv-63763 (Sc)

a Motio~ for Su~~a~y Judgment by Bayer Cropecience Ino

11 Fritz v Bayer Cropsc1ence et al 207-cv-65982 (SC

lt1 Xotion -or Stmnary Judgme by Crane Co

12 WQaver v Owens Illinois Inc et al 20B-cv-90416 ISC)

a Motion fo SUhlmary Judgment by Bayer Cropscience Inc Certainteed Ino and Union Carbide Inc (same motion)

b Xotion or Summary Judgme-t by Crane Co

13 Anderson v Hamilton M1nerals et al 20Q-cv-H0103 IUtah)

a Motim for SrrJlnry Judgmen cy Rapid-American

b Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Georgia Pacific

c Motion -=or Summary Judgme-t by Union Carhide

2

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 17 of 18

MAILED ALGERNON SOLOMONS AlLAN SHACKELFOR ALLAN SLOAN BRENT BOYD BRUCE MtLLER C DRAKE CAREY AVrR CARl PIERCE CHRLES NORRIS CHRJSTOPHER 1AUHlELLO CHR1STOPHER Me cnOl CRAVENS RAVrNI-J DANIEL WHITE DAID CLEVELAND DAVlD LYLE DAVlD MORRISON

DAVD SLOUGH ERIC ElGLEBARDT GIIfILUPS

E-MAlLED~ ADDU R1E A1DREW SHAW ANTIlONY HAYES BRIAN CLARK

C EVERT CARLPIERCH CARTER LA1BfTl CASE DAM CATHERINE JASONS CHARLES SlEueL CHARLES SPRINKIlo CHRISTOPHER SANTORO CLARE MAISASO DAVIDLAMM DAVID TRAYLOR DEME nuns ZACHAROPOU EDWARD SIAUGHTER

BRlN 5110VNEI

FALDRIDGE FRANCES ZACHER FRANK (JORDON GEORGE lNABINET GEORGE TANKARD GtSSUAREZ OUYGLzIER HARRY DAVIS HOWARD BOWERS

Certificate of Service

GEOROE OKELLrV HOMER TISDALE JACKSON BARWICK JAiES KEhEDY JAMES PRESSLEY JEA~ELYLES

JEFFREY fiARNWELL JEFFREY EDDY

JOHNBRYAfT JOSEPH KIJIN

JOSEPH WiLSOr- KEVIN KAUER LAURA EVANS LEE WILSON MARYHILL NATCY MONTI

PAUL DOMlNICK PHILUP FERDERIGOS R SllAW

lVAK G1)STAFS()N

JAMES ElJJUIT JAMES OANDY JAMES KEYNEDY JANET BLACK JE1NlFER TECIIMAN JOHANNA FOWIER JOHN GARDNhR JOHN SLOSSON JOSEPH RHODES JOSEPHINE HICKS JOSHUA BENNEIT KELLY JONES KENNETHKYRE KEVlt OBRIEN K1RK WARNER

LAURA VEE LINDSAY PEED LOREN JACOBSON LOUIS HERNS

MARK THOMAS MARK WALL

MICHAEL COLE

MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI MOFFATT MCDONALD MONA WALLACE

RALPH DAVIES RlCHAAD BURKE RICHARD LUTZEL ROBERT BROWN ROBERT CARPENT[R ROBERT VARNADO

ROLFE MARTlf SHARON WjlLlAM~ THOMAS KEAVENY THOMAS wnl-S TIMOTHY BOlCI TODD SMYTH TRUDY ROBERmOfshyTYNIKA ADAMS VALERIE WILLIAMS WILLIAM HANAHAN WILLIAM LYLpoundS

NATHANIEL HOSIO OLLIE HARlOJI RICHARD RADCLIfFE

RonERTHOOD llOBERT LOVETT ROBERT MLRIWE fHER

ROBERTSHAW

RONALD cox SAfUEL CARR1NGTON SCOTT FRICK $H~ K4CHMAR

STEPHANIE FLYhN STEVEN OUZTS STEVEN PUGH TIIOMAS DOUGAU

TIMOT11Y HO)CH

TIMOTHY PF(K TRACY TOM1lN

v BEVON V1LLlAM COLLINS WILLlAM CONNER WLLlAM DAVIES WILLIAM DAVIS

WILLtM GR1HAM WILLIAM SM1TH WILLlAM STARR

1 of 1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 18 of 18

Page 7: Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR '.:'HE BAS'I'ERK DIS':'RICT 07' PEKNSYLVnNIA ~N . RE; ASBESTOS

07-60769 07-60770 07(0777 07-60784 07middot60785 07-60795 07-60797 01middot60802

07middot60808 0760810

07middot60812 07-60813 07-60815 07-60817 0760818

OH0819

i 07-60822 0760824

07-60826 07-60830 07-60833 0760836 0760837 0760838 0760839

07-60841 07-60842 07-60844 0760845

0760846 07-60849 07-60855 07-60859 0760860 n7~60863

07middot60865 07middot60868 0760872

060875 07middot60876

_M 0760877

t17middot60878 07middot60881 07-60883 07-60887 07-60894 07middot60896

se I SC

se se

SC

sc sc sc SC Be

SC

SC

SC

SC I sc

sc SC

SC

sc SC

se se SC

SC I

SC

sc

SC I SC I SC SC

SC

SC SC SC I SC SC

SC I

SC

sc

SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 7 of 18

07middot60899 SC 07middot60900 SC 07middot60901 SC 07middot60903 SC 07middot60905 SC 01middot60907 SC 01-60908 SC 07-lti0912 SC

07middot60917 SC 07~60918 SC 07-lti0919 SC

07-60922 SC I 07middot60925 SC I

07middot60926 SC

07middot60927 SC 07-60928 SC

I 07-lti0930 SC I OH0933 SC

07-60937 SC

07middot60945 SC

0760947 SC )7~60955 SC 07middot60957 SC

07middot60958 SC I 0760963 SC

07-lti0965 SC 0760968 SC 07-60973 SC

07-lti0976 SC i 07-60977 SC I 07-60979 SC

07middot60986 SC 07middot60990 SC 07middot60995 SC

07middot60996 SC I 07middot61010 SC

07middot61011 SC

07~61014 SC 07-ltil015 SC 07-61016 SC OHI017 SC 07-lti1018 SC

07-61021 SC 07middot61022 SC 07middot61026 SC 07middot61030 SC 07middot61031 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 8 of 18

07-61032 07middot61033 07-61034 07-61035 07middot61037 07middot61038 07middot6L041 07-61042

07-61043 07-61044

07-61045 07-61048 07-61049 07-61052 07-61055 07middot61062 07-61064

07-61068 07-61069 07-61010 07-61071 07-61072 07-61073 07-61081 07-61083

07-61084 07-61085 07-6101(1 07-61091 07-61093 07-61094 07-61095 07-61096 07-61098 07-61099 07-61102 07-61108 07middot61109 07middot6111 0 07-61113 07-61115 07-61116 07middot61118 07-61120 07-61121 07-61122 07-61124

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC-SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC sc SC sc sec SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 9 of 18

i

i

07-61125 07-6) 126 07-6)[29

07middot61 no 07middot6113l

07~61l32

07-61136

07-61137 OJ-GI139

07middot61140 07middot6) 143

07-61144 rshy 07-61146 L bullbullbull

07middot6) 147 07middot6) 148

07-61149 07-61150 07-6)[52 07-6)[54 07middot6) 155

07middot61158 07middot61159 07-61160 07-61161 07middot61162 0761163

07-61165 07middot61166 07middot61167 07-6l168 07-61169 07-61170 07-61171

07-61172

07middot61173

07middot61174 07-61176 07-61177

07middot61179 07middot61180

07-6118)

07middot61182 07middot61183

07-6Jl34 07-61185 07middot6) )86

07middot61187

se se SC sc se se SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC sc sc sc sc se SC SC SC se SC sc se SC sc sc SC sc SC se se SC se sc SC SC SC SC SC

-

I

I

i

I

I

i

I

I

I

I

I i

I

7

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 10 of 18

07-61188 SC 07-61189 SC 07-61190 SC 07-61191 SC 07-61192 SC 07-61193 SC 07-61194 SC 07-61196 SC 07-61197 sc 07-61198 SC 07-61201 SC 07-61203 SC 07-61205 SC 07-61206 SC 07-61209 SC 07-61210 SC 07-61213 sc 07-61215 SC 07-61216 SC 07-61217 SC 07-61219 SC 07-61220 SC 07-61223 SC 07-61225 SC 07-61226 SC 07-61227 SC 07-61228 SC 07-61233 SC 07-61404 SC 07-61412 SC 07-61413 SC 07-61429 SC 07-61432 SC 07-61434 SC 07-61435 SC 07-61438 SC 07-61439 SC 07-61442 SC 07-61443 SC 07-61445 SC 07-61448 SC 07-61457 SC 07-61459 SC 07-61460 SC 07-61461 SC 07-61474 SC 07-61475 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 11 of 18

I

07-61477 07-61478 07-61479 07-61485 07-51486 07-61487 07-61488 07-61489 07-61491

Q7-61493 07-51496 07-61498 07-61503 07-61504 07-61505 07~61506

07-61507 07-61508 07-61509 07middot61510 07-61512 07-61513

07middot61514 07middot61515 07-61516

07-61518 L sc

07-61523 07-61526 07-61534 07-61536 07-61539 07-61541

07-61543

07-62972 07-62973 07middot62974 07middot62975 07-62976 07-62977 07-62979 07-63756 07middot63757 07middot63760 07-63761 07middot63762 0763763

07-63769

SC Be

Be se Be Be se

se se se se se

se

se se se se se se

sc sc Be se se Be

se se sc sc se

se Be Be Be Be Be se se Be se se se se se se Be

shy

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 12 of 18

07middot63770 SC 07-63771 SC 07middot63774 SC 07middot63778 SC 07middot63779 SC I 07-64649 SC

07-64650 SC

07middot64655 SC 07middot64664 SC 07middot64671 SC 07middot64674 SC 07-64678 SC 07middot64682 SC 07middot65979 SC

07middot65982 SC

07middot65984 SC 07middot65985 SC I 07middot65989 SC

07middot67408 SC 07-67411 SC 07-67413 SC 07-69159 SC 07-69162 SC 07-69163 SC 07middot69167 SC 07-69168 SC 07-69169 SC 07-69170 SC

07-69179 SC i 07-69182 SC 07-69183 SC

07-70506 SC 07-73476 SC

07-73478 SC 07-73499 SC 07middot73501 SC 07middot74185 SC 08middot67063 SC 08-67066 SC 08-70866 NCmiddotW 08-70886 SC

08-70894 SC

I 08-70895 SC 08-768gt2 NCmiddotW

08middot76849 SC

08middot76850 SC -I 0S-76851 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 13 of 18

08-76853 08-76855 08-76856 08-76857 08-76862 08-76865 08-79838 08-79848

08-79850 08-83125 08-83127 08-83129 08-83131

08-83568 08-83571

08-83575 08-83577 08-83579 08-84578

08-84581 08-84586 08-87194

08-87198

I 08-87205 08-88797

08-88801

08-88803 08-88804

08-88809 08-88810 08-88817

08-89202

08-89203 08-89204 08-89207

08-89209 08-89215 08-90395

08-90396 08-90399 08-90400 08-90403 08-90404 08-90406

08-90413 08-90414

08-90416

se se se se se se se

se se He He se se se se se se se se se se He He se sc se se se se se se

He se

se I se

se sc

He

se se se He He se se se He

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 14 of 18

I 09middot6(1076 09-6(1080

09-60083 09-60084 09-60088

09-60100

09middot60102 09-60104 09-60109 09(0117 09-60119

09-60122 09-60124 09-62649 09-62650

09-62658 IN-65538

09-65541 09middot65549

09middot65551 09-65552 09middot66138 09middot66142

I 09-66147 09middot67138 09-67139

09-67144 01-67146 09-70165 09-70172 09-70173

01middot74445 09-74773 09middot74776 09-80061

09middot80063 09-80075 09-80103

09-90845

09-90846 09-90847 09-90amp48

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

GA-S

Sc SC

SC SC SC UT SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 15 of 18

IIxbjbjj B

1 MCAnany at a1 v Owens-Corning Fiberglas Corporation et al 207~cv-605euroB (S2)

a Nolion for Suwmary Judgment by Bayer cropscience Inc

2 Jirel v ACampS Ino at al 207-cv-61116 ISC)

a Motion fol Summary Judgment by Noland Company Inc

3 Christian v Owens-Illinois et al 207-cv-61187 (SC)

~ ~otion for Su~ary Judqme~~ by Daniel International Corporation

b Motion for Summary Judgment by Flour Daniel Corporation

4 Smoak v Owens-Illinois t et al 207-cv-61217 (SC)

a gtlotion for Sunmary Judgnet by Aventis Cropsclenc USA Ine

5 Kitt v Owens-Illinois at al 207-cv-61220 (SC)

a Motion for Summary JudgmenL by Aventis Cropscienoe USA Inc

6 Johnson v Aventis Crapsoience et a1 207-cv-61223 (SC)

a Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Crane Co

McDaniel v Owens-Illinois I at a~ 207-cv-61225 (SC)

1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 16 of 18

a t-lotion fc SUflnary JJdgrrent by Crane Co

8 Blackmon v Owens-Illinois et al 207middotmiddotcv-6297J (SC)

a Motion for SUfrJllaquo1Y Judgment by Crane Co

o ~ A1bereson v Bayer Cropscience et al

207-cv-63761 (SC)

a Motion for Suuunary Judgment by Bayer Cropscienoe Inc

10 Campbell v Bayer Cropsoienoe et a1 gt07-cv-63763 (Sc)

a Motio~ for Su~~a~y Judgment by Bayer Cropecience Ino

11 Fritz v Bayer Cropsc1ence et al 207-cv-65982 (SC

lt1 Xotion -or Stmnary Judgme by Crane Co

12 WQaver v Owens Illinois Inc et al 20B-cv-90416 ISC)

a Motion fo SUhlmary Judgment by Bayer Cropscience Inc Certainteed Ino and Union Carbide Inc (same motion)

b Xotion or Summary Judgme-t by Crane Co

13 Anderson v Hamilton M1nerals et al 20Q-cv-H0103 IUtah)

a Motim for SrrJlnry Judgmen cy Rapid-American

b Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Georgia Pacific

c Motion -=or Summary Judgme-t by Union Carhide

2

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 17 of 18

MAILED ALGERNON SOLOMONS AlLAN SHACKELFOR ALLAN SLOAN BRENT BOYD BRUCE MtLLER C DRAKE CAREY AVrR CARl PIERCE CHRLES NORRIS CHRJSTOPHER 1AUHlELLO CHR1STOPHER Me cnOl CRAVENS RAVrNI-J DANIEL WHITE DAID CLEVELAND DAVlD LYLE DAVlD MORRISON

DAVD SLOUGH ERIC ElGLEBARDT GIIfILUPS

E-MAlLED~ ADDU R1E A1DREW SHAW ANTIlONY HAYES BRIAN CLARK

C EVERT CARLPIERCH CARTER LA1BfTl CASE DAM CATHERINE JASONS CHARLES SlEueL CHARLES SPRINKIlo CHRISTOPHER SANTORO CLARE MAISASO DAVIDLAMM DAVID TRAYLOR DEME nuns ZACHAROPOU EDWARD SIAUGHTER

BRlN 5110VNEI

FALDRIDGE FRANCES ZACHER FRANK (JORDON GEORGE lNABINET GEORGE TANKARD GtSSUAREZ OUYGLzIER HARRY DAVIS HOWARD BOWERS

Certificate of Service

GEOROE OKELLrV HOMER TISDALE JACKSON BARWICK JAiES KEhEDY JAMES PRESSLEY JEA~ELYLES

JEFFREY fiARNWELL JEFFREY EDDY

JOHNBRYAfT JOSEPH KIJIN

JOSEPH WiLSOr- KEVIN KAUER LAURA EVANS LEE WILSON MARYHILL NATCY MONTI

PAUL DOMlNICK PHILUP FERDERIGOS R SllAW

lVAK G1)STAFS()N

JAMES ElJJUIT JAMES OANDY JAMES KEYNEDY JANET BLACK JE1NlFER TECIIMAN JOHANNA FOWIER JOHN GARDNhR JOHN SLOSSON JOSEPH RHODES JOSEPHINE HICKS JOSHUA BENNEIT KELLY JONES KENNETHKYRE KEVlt OBRIEN K1RK WARNER

LAURA VEE LINDSAY PEED LOREN JACOBSON LOUIS HERNS

MARK THOMAS MARK WALL

MICHAEL COLE

MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI MOFFATT MCDONALD MONA WALLACE

RALPH DAVIES RlCHAAD BURKE RICHARD LUTZEL ROBERT BROWN ROBERT CARPENT[R ROBERT VARNADO

ROLFE MARTlf SHARON WjlLlAM~ THOMAS KEAVENY THOMAS wnl-S TIMOTHY BOlCI TODD SMYTH TRUDY ROBERmOfshyTYNIKA ADAMS VALERIE WILLIAMS WILLIAM HANAHAN WILLIAM LYLpoundS

NATHANIEL HOSIO OLLIE HARlOJI RICHARD RADCLIfFE

RonERTHOOD llOBERT LOVETT ROBERT MLRIWE fHER

ROBERTSHAW

RONALD cox SAfUEL CARR1NGTON SCOTT FRICK $H~ K4CHMAR

STEPHANIE FLYhN STEVEN OUZTS STEVEN PUGH TIIOMAS DOUGAU

TIMOT11Y HO)CH

TIMOTHY PF(K TRACY TOM1lN

v BEVON V1LLlAM COLLINS WILLlAM CONNER WLLlAM DAVIES WILLIAM DAVIS

WILLtM GR1HAM WILLIAM SM1TH WILLlAM STARR

1 of 1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 18 of 18

Page 8: Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR '.:'HE BAS'I'ERK DIS':'RICT 07' PEKNSYLVnNIA ~N . RE; ASBESTOS

07middot60899 SC 07middot60900 SC 07middot60901 SC 07middot60903 SC 07middot60905 SC 01middot60907 SC 01-60908 SC 07-lti0912 SC

07middot60917 SC 07~60918 SC 07-lti0919 SC

07-60922 SC I 07middot60925 SC I

07middot60926 SC

07middot60927 SC 07-60928 SC

I 07-lti0930 SC I OH0933 SC

07-60937 SC

07middot60945 SC

0760947 SC )7~60955 SC 07middot60957 SC

07middot60958 SC I 0760963 SC

07-lti0965 SC 0760968 SC 07-60973 SC

07-lti0976 SC i 07-60977 SC I 07-60979 SC

07middot60986 SC 07middot60990 SC 07middot60995 SC

07middot60996 SC I 07middot61010 SC

07middot61011 SC

07~61014 SC 07-ltil015 SC 07-61016 SC OHI017 SC 07-lti1018 SC

07-61021 SC 07middot61022 SC 07middot61026 SC 07middot61030 SC 07middot61031 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 8 of 18

07-61032 07middot61033 07-61034 07-61035 07middot61037 07middot61038 07middot6L041 07-61042

07-61043 07-61044

07-61045 07-61048 07-61049 07-61052 07-61055 07middot61062 07-61064

07-61068 07-61069 07-61010 07-61071 07-61072 07-61073 07-61081 07-61083

07-61084 07-61085 07-6101(1 07-61091 07-61093 07-61094 07-61095 07-61096 07-61098 07-61099 07-61102 07-61108 07middot61109 07middot6111 0 07-61113 07-61115 07-61116 07middot61118 07-61120 07-61121 07-61122 07-61124

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC-SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC sc SC sc sec SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 9 of 18

i

i

07-61125 07-6) 126 07-6)[29

07middot61 no 07middot6113l

07~61l32

07-61136

07-61137 OJ-GI139

07middot61140 07middot6) 143

07-61144 rshy 07-61146 L bullbullbull

07middot6) 147 07middot6) 148

07-61149 07-61150 07-6)[52 07-6)[54 07middot6) 155

07middot61158 07middot61159 07-61160 07-61161 07middot61162 0761163

07-61165 07middot61166 07middot61167 07-6l168 07-61169 07-61170 07-61171

07-61172

07middot61173

07middot61174 07-61176 07-61177

07middot61179 07middot61180

07-6118)

07middot61182 07middot61183

07-6Jl34 07-61185 07middot6) )86

07middot61187

se se SC sc se se SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC sc sc sc sc se SC SC SC se SC sc se SC sc sc SC sc SC se se SC se sc SC SC SC SC SC

-

I

I

i

I

I

i

I

I

I

I

I i

I

7

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 10 of 18

07-61188 SC 07-61189 SC 07-61190 SC 07-61191 SC 07-61192 SC 07-61193 SC 07-61194 SC 07-61196 SC 07-61197 sc 07-61198 SC 07-61201 SC 07-61203 SC 07-61205 SC 07-61206 SC 07-61209 SC 07-61210 SC 07-61213 sc 07-61215 SC 07-61216 SC 07-61217 SC 07-61219 SC 07-61220 SC 07-61223 SC 07-61225 SC 07-61226 SC 07-61227 SC 07-61228 SC 07-61233 SC 07-61404 SC 07-61412 SC 07-61413 SC 07-61429 SC 07-61432 SC 07-61434 SC 07-61435 SC 07-61438 SC 07-61439 SC 07-61442 SC 07-61443 SC 07-61445 SC 07-61448 SC 07-61457 SC 07-61459 SC 07-61460 SC 07-61461 SC 07-61474 SC 07-61475 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 11 of 18

I

07-61477 07-61478 07-61479 07-61485 07-51486 07-61487 07-61488 07-61489 07-61491

Q7-61493 07-51496 07-61498 07-61503 07-61504 07-61505 07~61506

07-61507 07-61508 07-61509 07middot61510 07-61512 07-61513

07middot61514 07middot61515 07-61516

07-61518 L sc

07-61523 07-61526 07-61534 07-61536 07-61539 07-61541

07-61543

07-62972 07-62973 07middot62974 07middot62975 07-62976 07-62977 07-62979 07-63756 07middot63757 07middot63760 07-63761 07middot63762 0763763

07-63769

SC Be

Be se Be Be se

se se se se se

se

se se se se se se

sc sc Be se se Be

se se sc sc se

se Be Be Be Be Be se se Be se se se se se se Be

shy

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 12 of 18

07middot63770 SC 07-63771 SC 07middot63774 SC 07middot63778 SC 07middot63779 SC I 07-64649 SC

07-64650 SC

07middot64655 SC 07middot64664 SC 07middot64671 SC 07middot64674 SC 07-64678 SC 07middot64682 SC 07middot65979 SC

07middot65982 SC

07middot65984 SC 07middot65985 SC I 07middot65989 SC

07middot67408 SC 07-67411 SC 07-67413 SC 07-69159 SC 07-69162 SC 07-69163 SC 07middot69167 SC 07-69168 SC 07-69169 SC 07-69170 SC

07-69179 SC i 07-69182 SC 07-69183 SC

07-70506 SC 07-73476 SC

07-73478 SC 07-73499 SC 07middot73501 SC 07middot74185 SC 08middot67063 SC 08-67066 SC 08-70866 NCmiddotW 08-70886 SC

08-70894 SC

I 08-70895 SC 08-768gt2 NCmiddotW

08middot76849 SC

08middot76850 SC -I 0S-76851 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 13 of 18

08-76853 08-76855 08-76856 08-76857 08-76862 08-76865 08-79838 08-79848

08-79850 08-83125 08-83127 08-83129 08-83131

08-83568 08-83571

08-83575 08-83577 08-83579 08-84578

08-84581 08-84586 08-87194

08-87198

I 08-87205 08-88797

08-88801

08-88803 08-88804

08-88809 08-88810 08-88817

08-89202

08-89203 08-89204 08-89207

08-89209 08-89215 08-90395

08-90396 08-90399 08-90400 08-90403 08-90404 08-90406

08-90413 08-90414

08-90416

se se se se se se se

se se He He se se se se se se se se se se He He se sc se se se se se se

He se

se I se

se sc

He

se se se He He se se se He

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 14 of 18

I 09middot6(1076 09-6(1080

09-60083 09-60084 09-60088

09-60100

09middot60102 09-60104 09-60109 09(0117 09-60119

09-60122 09-60124 09-62649 09-62650

09-62658 IN-65538

09-65541 09middot65549

09middot65551 09-65552 09middot66138 09middot66142

I 09-66147 09middot67138 09-67139

09-67144 01-67146 09-70165 09-70172 09-70173

01middot74445 09-74773 09middot74776 09-80061

09middot80063 09-80075 09-80103

09-90845

09-90846 09-90847 09-90amp48

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

GA-S

Sc SC

SC SC SC UT SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 15 of 18

IIxbjbjj B

1 MCAnany at a1 v Owens-Corning Fiberglas Corporation et al 207~cv-605euroB (S2)

a Nolion for Suwmary Judgment by Bayer cropscience Inc

2 Jirel v ACampS Ino at al 207-cv-61116 ISC)

a Motion fol Summary Judgment by Noland Company Inc

3 Christian v Owens-Illinois et al 207-cv-61187 (SC)

~ ~otion for Su~ary Judqme~~ by Daniel International Corporation

b Motion for Summary Judgment by Flour Daniel Corporation

4 Smoak v Owens-Illinois t et al 207-cv-61217 (SC)

a gtlotion for Sunmary Judgnet by Aventis Cropsclenc USA Ine

5 Kitt v Owens-Illinois at al 207-cv-61220 (SC)

a Motion for Summary JudgmenL by Aventis Cropscienoe USA Inc

6 Johnson v Aventis Crapsoience et a1 207-cv-61223 (SC)

a Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Crane Co

McDaniel v Owens-Illinois I at a~ 207-cv-61225 (SC)

1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 16 of 18

a t-lotion fc SUflnary JJdgrrent by Crane Co

8 Blackmon v Owens-Illinois et al 207middotmiddotcv-6297J (SC)

a Motion for SUfrJllaquo1Y Judgment by Crane Co

o ~ A1bereson v Bayer Cropscience et al

207-cv-63761 (SC)

a Motion for Suuunary Judgment by Bayer Cropscienoe Inc

10 Campbell v Bayer Cropsoienoe et a1 gt07-cv-63763 (Sc)

a Motio~ for Su~~a~y Judgment by Bayer Cropecience Ino

11 Fritz v Bayer Cropsc1ence et al 207-cv-65982 (SC

lt1 Xotion -or Stmnary Judgme by Crane Co

12 WQaver v Owens Illinois Inc et al 20B-cv-90416 ISC)

a Motion fo SUhlmary Judgment by Bayer Cropscience Inc Certainteed Ino and Union Carbide Inc (same motion)

b Xotion or Summary Judgme-t by Crane Co

13 Anderson v Hamilton M1nerals et al 20Q-cv-H0103 IUtah)

a Motim for SrrJlnry Judgmen cy Rapid-American

b Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Georgia Pacific

c Motion -=or Summary Judgme-t by Union Carhide

2

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 17 of 18

MAILED ALGERNON SOLOMONS AlLAN SHACKELFOR ALLAN SLOAN BRENT BOYD BRUCE MtLLER C DRAKE CAREY AVrR CARl PIERCE CHRLES NORRIS CHRJSTOPHER 1AUHlELLO CHR1STOPHER Me cnOl CRAVENS RAVrNI-J DANIEL WHITE DAID CLEVELAND DAVlD LYLE DAVlD MORRISON

DAVD SLOUGH ERIC ElGLEBARDT GIIfILUPS

E-MAlLED~ ADDU R1E A1DREW SHAW ANTIlONY HAYES BRIAN CLARK

C EVERT CARLPIERCH CARTER LA1BfTl CASE DAM CATHERINE JASONS CHARLES SlEueL CHARLES SPRINKIlo CHRISTOPHER SANTORO CLARE MAISASO DAVIDLAMM DAVID TRAYLOR DEME nuns ZACHAROPOU EDWARD SIAUGHTER

BRlN 5110VNEI

FALDRIDGE FRANCES ZACHER FRANK (JORDON GEORGE lNABINET GEORGE TANKARD GtSSUAREZ OUYGLzIER HARRY DAVIS HOWARD BOWERS

Certificate of Service

GEOROE OKELLrV HOMER TISDALE JACKSON BARWICK JAiES KEhEDY JAMES PRESSLEY JEA~ELYLES

JEFFREY fiARNWELL JEFFREY EDDY

JOHNBRYAfT JOSEPH KIJIN

JOSEPH WiLSOr- KEVIN KAUER LAURA EVANS LEE WILSON MARYHILL NATCY MONTI

PAUL DOMlNICK PHILUP FERDERIGOS R SllAW

lVAK G1)STAFS()N

JAMES ElJJUIT JAMES OANDY JAMES KEYNEDY JANET BLACK JE1NlFER TECIIMAN JOHANNA FOWIER JOHN GARDNhR JOHN SLOSSON JOSEPH RHODES JOSEPHINE HICKS JOSHUA BENNEIT KELLY JONES KENNETHKYRE KEVlt OBRIEN K1RK WARNER

LAURA VEE LINDSAY PEED LOREN JACOBSON LOUIS HERNS

MARK THOMAS MARK WALL

MICHAEL COLE

MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI MOFFATT MCDONALD MONA WALLACE

RALPH DAVIES RlCHAAD BURKE RICHARD LUTZEL ROBERT BROWN ROBERT CARPENT[R ROBERT VARNADO

ROLFE MARTlf SHARON WjlLlAM~ THOMAS KEAVENY THOMAS wnl-S TIMOTHY BOlCI TODD SMYTH TRUDY ROBERmOfshyTYNIKA ADAMS VALERIE WILLIAMS WILLIAM HANAHAN WILLIAM LYLpoundS

NATHANIEL HOSIO OLLIE HARlOJI RICHARD RADCLIfFE

RonERTHOOD llOBERT LOVETT ROBERT MLRIWE fHER

ROBERTSHAW

RONALD cox SAfUEL CARR1NGTON SCOTT FRICK $H~ K4CHMAR

STEPHANIE FLYhN STEVEN OUZTS STEVEN PUGH TIIOMAS DOUGAU

TIMOT11Y HO)CH

TIMOTHY PF(K TRACY TOM1lN

v BEVON V1LLlAM COLLINS WILLlAM CONNER WLLlAM DAVIES WILLIAM DAVIS

WILLtM GR1HAM WILLIAM SM1TH WILLlAM STARR

1 of 1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 18 of 18

Page 9: Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR '.:'HE BAS'I'ERK DIS':'RICT 07' PEKNSYLVnNIA ~N . RE; ASBESTOS

07-61032 07middot61033 07-61034 07-61035 07middot61037 07middot61038 07middot6L041 07-61042

07-61043 07-61044

07-61045 07-61048 07-61049 07-61052 07-61055 07middot61062 07-61064

07-61068 07-61069 07-61010 07-61071 07-61072 07-61073 07-61081 07-61083

07-61084 07-61085 07-6101(1 07-61091 07-61093 07-61094 07-61095 07-61096 07-61098 07-61099 07-61102 07-61108 07middot61109 07middot6111 0 07-61113 07-61115 07-61116 07middot61118 07-61120 07-61121 07-61122 07-61124

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC-SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC sc SC sc sec SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 9 of 18

i

i

07-61125 07-6) 126 07-6)[29

07middot61 no 07middot6113l

07~61l32

07-61136

07-61137 OJ-GI139

07middot61140 07middot6) 143

07-61144 rshy 07-61146 L bullbullbull

07middot6) 147 07middot6) 148

07-61149 07-61150 07-6)[52 07-6)[54 07middot6) 155

07middot61158 07middot61159 07-61160 07-61161 07middot61162 0761163

07-61165 07middot61166 07middot61167 07-6l168 07-61169 07-61170 07-61171

07-61172

07middot61173

07middot61174 07-61176 07-61177

07middot61179 07middot61180

07-6118)

07middot61182 07middot61183

07-6Jl34 07-61185 07middot6) )86

07middot61187

se se SC sc se se SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC sc sc sc sc se SC SC SC se SC sc se SC sc sc SC sc SC se se SC se sc SC SC SC SC SC

-

I

I

i

I

I

i

I

I

I

I

I i

I

7

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 10 of 18

07-61188 SC 07-61189 SC 07-61190 SC 07-61191 SC 07-61192 SC 07-61193 SC 07-61194 SC 07-61196 SC 07-61197 sc 07-61198 SC 07-61201 SC 07-61203 SC 07-61205 SC 07-61206 SC 07-61209 SC 07-61210 SC 07-61213 sc 07-61215 SC 07-61216 SC 07-61217 SC 07-61219 SC 07-61220 SC 07-61223 SC 07-61225 SC 07-61226 SC 07-61227 SC 07-61228 SC 07-61233 SC 07-61404 SC 07-61412 SC 07-61413 SC 07-61429 SC 07-61432 SC 07-61434 SC 07-61435 SC 07-61438 SC 07-61439 SC 07-61442 SC 07-61443 SC 07-61445 SC 07-61448 SC 07-61457 SC 07-61459 SC 07-61460 SC 07-61461 SC 07-61474 SC 07-61475 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 11 of 18

I

07-61477 07-61478 07-61479 07-61485 07-51486 07-61487 07-61488 07-61489 07-61491

Q7-61493 07-51496 07-61498 07-61503 07-61504 07-61505 07~61506

07-61507 07-61508 07-61509 07middot61510 07-61512 07-61513

07middot61514 07middot61515 07-61516

07-61518 L sc

07-61523 07-61526 07-61534 07-61536 07-61539 07-61541

07-61543

07-62972 07-62973 07middot62974 07middot62975 07-62976 07-62977 07-62979 07-63756 07middot63757 07middot63760 07-63761 07middot63762 0763763

07-63769

SC Be

Be se Be Be se

se se se se se

se

se se se se se se

sc sc Be se se Be

se se sc sc se

se Be Be Be Be Be se se Be se se se se se se Be

shy

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 12 of 18

07middot63770 SC 07-63771 SC 07middot63774 SC 07middot63778 SC 07middot63779 SC I 07-64649 SC

07-64650 SC

07middot64655 SC 07middot64664 SC 07middot64671 SC 07middot64674 SC 07-64678 SC 07middot64682 SC 07middot65979 SC

07middot65982 SC

07middot65984 SC 07middot65985 SC I 07middot65989 SC

07middot67408 SC 07-67411 SC 07-67413 SC 07-69159 SC 07-69162 SC 07-69163 SC 07middot69167 SC 07-69168 SC 07-69169 SC 07-69170 SC

07-69179 SC i 07-69182 SC 07-69183 SC

07-70506 SC 07-73476 SC

07-73478 SC 07-73499 SC 07middot73501 SC 07middot74185 SC 08middot67063 SC 08-67066 SC 08-70866 NCmiddotW 08-70886 SC

08-70894 SC

I 08-70895 SC 08-768gt2 NCmiddotW

08middot76849 SC

08middot76850 SC -I 0S-76851 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 13 of 18

08-76853 08-76855 08-76856 08-76857 08-76862 08-76865 08-79838 08-79848

08-79850 08-83125 08-83127 08-83129 08-83131

08-83568 08-83571

08-83575 08-83577 08-83579 08-84578

08-84581 08-84586 08-87194

08-87198

I 08-87205 08-88797

08-88801

08-88803 08-88804

08-88809 08-88810 08-88817

08-89202

08-89203 08-89204 08-89207

08-89209 08-89215 08-90395

08-90396 08-90399 08-90400 08-90403 08-90404 08-90406

08-90413 08-90414

08-90416

se se se se se se se

se se He He se se se se se se se se se se He He se sc se se se se se se

He se

se I se

se sc

He

se se se He He se se se He

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 14 of 18

I 09middot6(1076 09-6(1080

09-60083 09-60084 09-60088

09-60100

09middot60102 09-60104 09-60109 09(0117 09-60119

09-60122 09-60124 09-62649 09-62650

09-62658 IN-65538

09-65541 09middot65549

09middot65551 09-65552 09middot66138 09middot66142

I 09-66147 09middot67138 09-67139

09-67144 01-67146 09-70165 09-70172 09-70173

01middot74445 09-74773 09middot74776 09-80061

09middot80063 09-80075 09-80103

09-90845

09-90846 09-90847 09-90amp48

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

GA-S

Sc SC

SC SC SC UT SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 15 of 18

IIxbjbjj B

1 MCAnany at a1 v Owens-Corning Fiberglas Corporation et al 207~cv-605euroB (S2)

a Nolion for Suwmary Judgment by Bayer cropscience Inc

2 Jirel v ACampS Ino at al 207-cv-61116 ISC)

a Motion fol Summary Judgment by Noland Company Inc

3 Christian v Owens-Illinois et al 207-cv-61187 (SC)

~ ~otion for Su~ary Judqme~~ by Daniel International Corporation

b Motion for Summary Judgment by Flour Daniel Corporation

4 Smoak v Owens-Illinois t et al 207-cv-61217 (SC)

a gtlotion for Sunmary Judgnet by Aventis Cropsclenc USA Ine

5 Kitt v Owens-Illinois at al 207-cv-61220 (SC)

a Motion for Summary JudgmenL by Aventis Cropscienoe USA Inc

6 Johnson v Aventis Crapsoience et a1 207-cv-61223 (SC)

a Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Crane Co

McDaniel v Owens-Illinois I at a~ 207-cv-61225 (SC)

1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 16 of 18

a t-lotion fc SUflnary JJdgrrent by Crane Co

8 Blackmon v Owens-Illinois et al 207middotmiddotcv-6297J (SC)

a Motion for SUfrJllaquo1Y Judgment by Crane Co

o ~ A1bereson v Bayer Cropscience et al

207-cv-63761 (SC)

a Motion for Suuunary Judgment by Bayer Cropscienoe Inc

10 Campbell v Bayer Cropsoienoe et a1 gt07-cv-63763 (Sc)

a Motio~ for Su~~a~y Judgment by Bayer Cropecience Ino

11 Fritz v Bayer Cropsc1ence et al 207-cv-65982 (SC

lt1 Xotion -or Stmnary Judgme by Crane Co

12 WQaver v Owens Illinois Inc et al 20B-cv-90416 ISC)

a Motion fo SUhlmary Judgment by Bayer Cropscience Inc Certainteed Ino and Union Carbide Inc (same motion)

b Xotion or Summary Judgme-t by Crane Co

13 Anderson v Hamilton M1nerals et al 20Q-cv-H0103 IUtah)

a Motim for SrrJlnry Judgmen cy Rapid-American

b Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Georgia Pacific

c Motion -=or Summary Judgme-t by Union Carhide

2

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 17 of 18

MAILED ALGERNON SOLOMONS AlLAN SHACKELFOR ALLAN SLOAN BRENT BOYD BRUCE MtLLER C DRAKE CAREY AVrR CARl PIERCE CHRLES NORRIS CHRJSTOPHER 1AUHlELLO CHR1STOPHER Me cnOl CRAVENS RAVrNI-J DANIEL WHITE DAID CLEVELAND DAVlD LYLE DAVlD MORRISON

DAVD SLOUGH ERIC ElGLEBARDT GIIfILUPS

E-MAlLED~ ADDU R1E A1DREW SHAW ANTIlONY HAYES BRIAN CLARK

C EVERT CARLPIERCH CARTER LA1BfTl CASE DAM CATHERINE JASONS CHARLES SlEueL CHARLES SPRINKIlo CHRISTOPHER SANTORO CLARE MAISASO DAVIDLAMM DAVID TRAYLOR DEME nuns ZACHAROPOU EDWARD SIAUGHTER

BRlN 5110VNEI

FALDRIDGE FRANCES ZACHER FRANK (JORDON GEORGE lNABINET GEORGE TANKARD GtSSUAREZ OUYGLzIER HARRY DAVIS HOWARD BOWERS

Certificate of Service

GEOROE OKELLrV HOMER TISDALE JACKSON BARWICK JAiES KEhEDY JAMES PRESSLEY JEA~ELYLES

JEFFREY fiARNWELL JEFFREY EDDY

JOHNBRYAfT JOSEPH KIJIN

JOSEPH WiLSOr- KEVIN KAUER LAURA EVANS LEE WILSON MARYHILL NATCY MONTI

PAUL DOMlNICK PHILUP FERDERIGOS R SllAW

lVAK G1)STAFS()N

JAMES ElJJUIT JAMES OANDY JAMES KEYNEDY JANET BLACK JE1NlFER TECIIMAN JOHANNA FOWIER JOHN GARDNhR JOHN SLOSSON JOSEPH RHODES JOSEPHINE HICKS JOSHUA BENNEIT KELLY JONES KENNETHKYRE KEVlt OBRIEN K1RK WARNER

LAURA VEE LINDSAY PEED LOREN JACOBSON LOUIS HERNS

MARK THOMAS MARK WALL

MICHAEL COLE

MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI MOFFATT MCDONALD MONA WALLACE

RALPH DAVIES RlCHAAD BURKE RICHARD LUTZEL ROBERT BROWN ROBERT CARPENT[R ROBERT VARNADO

ROLFE MARTlf SHARON WjlLlAM~ THOMAS KEAVENY THOMAS wnl-S TIMOTHY BOlCI TODD SMYTH TRUDY ROBERmOfshyTYNIKA ADAMS VALERIE WILLIAMS WILLIAM HANAHAN WILLIAM LYLpoundS

NATHANIEL HOSIO OLLIE HARlOJI RICHARD RADCLIfFE

RonERTHOOD llOBERT LOVETT ROBERT MLRIWE fHER

ROBERTSHAW

RONALD cox SAfUEL CARR1NGTON SCOTT FRICK $H~ K4CHMAR

STEPHANIE FLYhN STEVEN OUZTS STEVEN PUGH TIIOMAS DOUGAU

TIMOT11Y HO)CH

TIMOTHY PF(K TRACY TOM1lN

v BEVON V1LLlAM COLLINS WILLlAM CONNER WLLlAM DAVIES WILLIAM DAVIS

WILLtM GR1HAM WILLIAM SM1TH WILLlAM STARR

1 of 1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 18 of 18

Page 10: Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR '.:'HE BAS'I'ERK DIS':'RICT 07' PEKNSYLVnNIA ~N . RE; ASBESTOS

i

i

07-61125 07-6) 126 07-6)[29

07middot61 no 07middot6113l

07~61l32

07-61136

07-61137 OJ-GI139

07middot61140 07middot6) 143

07-61144 rshy 07-61146 L bullbullbull

07middot6) 147 07middot6) 148

07-61149 07-61150 07-6)[52 07-6)[54 07middot6) 155

07middot61158 07middot61159 07-61160 07-61161 07middot61162 0761163

07-61165 07middot61166 07middot61167 07-6l168 07-61169 07-61170 07-61171

07-61172

07middot61173

07middot61174 07-61176 07-61177

07middot61179 07middot61180

07-6118)

07middot61182 07middot61183

07-6Jl34 07-61185 07middot6) )86

07middot61187

se se SC sc se se SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC SC sc SC sc sc sc sc se SC SC SC se SC sc se SC sc sc SC sc SC se se SC se sc SC SC SC SC SC

-

I

I

i

I

I

i

I

I

I

I

I i

I

7

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 10 of 18

07-61188 SC 07-61189 SC 07-61190 SC 07-61191 SC 07-61192 SC 07-61193 SC 07-61194 SC 07-61196 SC 07-61197 sc 07-61198 SC 07-61201 SC 07-61203 SC 07-61205 SC 07-61206 SC 07-61209 SC 07-61210 SC 07-61213 sc 07-61215 SC 07-61216 SC 07-61217 SC 07-61219 SC 07-61220 SC 07-61223 SC 07-61225 SC 07-61226 SC 07-61227 SC 07-61228 SC 07-61233 SC 07-61404 SC 07-61412 SC 07-61413 SC 07-61429 SC 07-61432 SC 07-61434 SC 07-61435 SC 07-61438 SC 07-61439 SC 07-61442 SC 07-61443 SC 07-61445 SC 07-61448 SC 07-61457 SC 07-61459 SC 07-61460 SC 07-61461 SC 07-61474 SC 07-61475 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 11 of 18

I

07-61477 07-61478 07-61479 07-61485 07-51486 07-61487 07-61488 07-61489 07-61491

Q7-61493 07-51496 07-61498 07-61503 07-61504 07-61505 07~61506

07-61507 07-61508 07-61509 07middot61510 07-61512 07-61513

07middot61514 07middot61515 07-61516

07-61518 L sc

07-61523 07-61526 07-61534 07-61536 07-61539 07-61541

07-61543

07-62972 07-62973 07middot62974 07middot62975 07-62976 07-62977 07-62979 07-63756 07middot63757 07middot63760 07-63761 07middot63762 0763763

07-63769

SC Be

Be se Be Be se

se se se se se

se

se se se se se se

sc sc Be se se Be

se se sc sc se

se Be Be Be Be Be se se Be se se se se se se Be

shy

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 12 of 18

07middot63770 SC 07-63771 SC 07middot63774 SC 07middot63778 SC 07middot63779 SC I 07-64649 SC

07-64650 SC

07middot64655 SC 07middot64664 SC 07middot64671 SC 07middot64674 SC 07-64678 SC 07middot64682 SC 07middot65979 SC

07middot65982 SC

07middot65984 SC 07middot65985 SC I 07middot65989 SC

07middot67408 SC 07-67411 SC 07-67413 SC 07-69159 SC 07-69162 SC 07-69163 SC 07middot69167 SC 07-69168 SC 07-69169 SC 07-69170 SC

07-69179 SC i 07-69182 SC 07-69183 SC

07-70506 SC 07-73476 SC

07-73478 SC 07-73499 SC 07middot73501 SC 07middot74185 SC 08middot67063 SC 08-67066 SC 08-70866 NCmiddotW 08-70886 SC

08-70894 SC

I 08-70895 SC 08-768gt2 NCmiddotW

08middot76849 SC

08middot76850 SC -I 0S-76851 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 13 of 18

08-76853 08-76855 08-76856 08-76857 08-76862 08-76865 08-79838 08-79848

08-79850 08-83125 08-83127 08-83129 08-83131

08-83568 08-83571

08-83575 08-83577 08-83579 08-84578

08-84581 08-84586 08-87194

08-87198

I 08-87205 08-88797

08-88801

08-88803 08-88804

08-88809 08-88810 08-88817

08-89202

08-89203 08-89204 08-89207

08-89209 08-89215 08-90395

08-90396 08-90399 08-90400 08-90403 08-90404 08-90406

08-90413 08-90414

08-90416

se se se se se se se

se se He He se se se se se se se se se se He He se sc se se se se se se

He se

se I se

se sc

He

se se se He He se se se He

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 14 of 18

I 09middot6(1076 09-6(1080

09-60083 09-60084 09-60088

09-60100

09middot60102 09-60104 09-60109 09(0117 09-60119

09-60122 09-60124 09-62649 09-62650

09-62658 IN-65538

09-65541 09middot65549

09middot65551 09-65552 09middot66138 09middot66142

I 09-66147 09middot67138 09-67139

09-67144 01-67146 09-70165 09-70172 09-70173

01middot74445 09-74773 09middot74776 09-80061

09middot80063 09-80075 09-80103

09-90845

09-90846 09-90847 09-90amp48

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

GA-S

Sc SC

SC SC SC UT SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 15 of 18

IIxbjbjj B

1 MCAnany at a1 v Owens-Corning Fiberglas Corporation et al 207~cv-605euroB (S2)

a Nolion for Suwmary Judgment by Bayer cropscience Inc

2 Jirel v ACampS Ino at al 207-cv-61116 ISC)

a Motion fol Summary Judgment by Noland Company Inc

3 Christian v Owens-Illinois et al 207-cv-61187 (SC)

~ ~otion for Su~ary Judqme~~ by Daniel International Corporation

b Motion for Summary Judgment by Flour Daniel Corporation

4 Smoak v Owens-Illinois t et al 207-cv-61217 (SC)

a gtlotion for Sunmary Judgnet by Aventis Cropsclenc USA Ine

5 Kitt v Owens-Illinois at al 207-cv-61220 (SC)

a Motion for Summary JudgmenL by Aventis Cropscienoe USA Inc

6 Johnson v Aventis Crapsoience et a1 207-cv-61223 (SC)

a Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Crane Co

McDaniel v Owens-Illinois I at a~ 207-cv-61225 (SC)

1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 16 of 18

a t-lotion fc SUflnary JJdgrrent by Crane Co

8 Blackmon v Owens-Illinois et al 207middotmiddotcv-6297J (SC)

a Motion for SUfrJllaquo1Y Judgment by Crane Co

o ~ A1bereson v Bayer Cropscience et al

207-cv-63761 (SC)

a Motion for Suuunary Judgment by Bayer Cropscienoe Inc

10 Campbell v Bayer Cropsoienoe et a1 gt07-cv-63763 (Sc)

a Motio~ for Su~~a~y Judgment by Bayer Cropecience Ino

11 Fritz v Bayer Cropsc1ence et al 207-cv-65982 (SC

lt1 Xotion -or Stmnary Judgme by Crane Co

12 WQaver v Owens Illinois Inc et al 20B-cv-90416 ISC)

a Motion fo SUhlmary Judgment by Bayer Cropscience Inc Certainteed Ino and Union Carbide Inc (same motion)

b Xotion or Summary Judgme-t by Crane Co

13 Anderson v Hamilton M1nerals et al 20Q-cv-H0103 IUtah)

a Motim for SrrJlnry Judgmen cy Rapid-American

b Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Georgia Pacific

c Motion -=or Summary Judgme-t by Union Carhide

2

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 17 of 18

MAILED ALGERNON SOLOMONS AlLAN SHACKELFOR ALLAN SLOAN BRENT BOYD BRUCE MtLLER C DRAKE CAREY AVrR CARl PIERCE CHRLES NORRIS CHRJSTOPHER 1AUHlELLO CHR1STOPHER Me cnOl CRAVENS RAVrNI-J DANIEL WHITE DAID CLEVELAND DAVlD LYLE DAVlD MORRISON

DAVD SLOUGH ERIC ElGLEBARDT GIIfILUPS

E-MAlLED~ ADDU R1E A1DREW SHAW ANTIlONY HAYES BRIAN CLARK

C EVERT CARLPIERCH CARTER LA1BfTl CASE DAM CATHERINE JASONS CHARLES SlEueL CHARLES SPRINKIlo CHRISTOPHER SANTORO CLARE MAISASO DAVIDLAMM DAVID TRAYLOR DEME nuns ZACHAROPOU EDWARD SIAUGHTER

BRlN 5110VNEI

FALDRIDGE FRANCES ZACHER FRANK (JORDON GEORGE lNABINET GEORGE TANKARD GtSSUAREZ OUYGLzIER HARRY DAVIS HOWARD BOWERS

Certificate of Service

GEOROE OKELLrV HOMER TISDALE JACKSON BARWICK JAiES KEhEDY JAMES PRESSLEY JEA~ELYLES

JEFFREY fiARNWELL JEFFREY EDDY

JOHNBRYAfT JOSEPH KIJIN

JOSEPH WiLSOr- KEVIN KAUER LAURA EVANS LEE WILSON MARYHILL NATCY MONTI

PAUL DOMlNICK PHILUP FERDERIGOS R SllAW

lVAK G1)STAFS()N

JAMES ElJJUIT JAMES OANDY JAMES KEYNEDY JANET BLACK JE1NlFER TECIIMAN JOHANNA FOWIER JOHN GARDNhR JOHN SLOSSON JOSEPH RHODES JOSEPHINE HICKS JOSHUA BENNEIT KELLY JONES KENNETHKYRE KEVlt OBRIEN K1RK WARNER

LAURA VEE LINDSAY PEED LOREN JACOBSON LOUIS HERNS

MARK THOMAS MARK WALL

MICHAEL COLE

MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI MOFFATT MCDONALD MONA WALLACE

RALPH DAVIES RlCHAAD BURKE RICHARD LUTZEL ROBERT BROWN ROBERT CARPENT[R ROBERT VARNADO

ROLFE MARTlf SHARON WjlLlAM~ THOMAS KEAVENY THOMAS wnl-S TIMOTHY BOlCI TODD SMYTH TRUDY ROBERmOfshyTYNIKA ADAMS VALERIE WILLIAMS WILLIAM HANAHAN WILLIAM LYLpoundS

NATHANIEL HOSIO OLLIE HARlOJI RICHARD RADCLIfFE

RonERTHOOD llOBERT LOVETT ROBERT MLRIWE fHER

ROBERTSHAW

RONALD cox SAfUEL CARR1NGTON SCOTT FRICK $H~ K4CHMAR

STEPHANIE FLYhN STEVEN OUZTS STEVEN PUGH TIIOMAS DOUGAU

TIMOT11Y HO)CH

TIMOTHY PF(K TRACY TOM1lN

v BEVON V1LLlAM COLLINS WILLlAM CONNER WLLlAM DAVIES WILLIAM DAVIS

WILLtM GR1HAM WILLIAM SM1TH WILLlAM STARR

1 of 1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 18 of 18

Page 11: Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR '.:'HE BAS'I'ERK DIS':'RICT 07' PEKNSYLVnNIA ~N . RE; ASBESTOS

07-61188 SC 07-61189 SC 07-61190 SC 07-61191 SC 07-61192 SC 07-61193 SC 07-61194 SC 07-61196 SC 07-61197 sc 07-61198 SC 07-61201 SC 07-61203 SC 07-61205 SC 07-61206 SC 07-61209 SC 07-61210 SC 07-61213 sc 07-61215 SC 07-61216 SC 07-61217 SC 07-61219 SC 07-61220 SC 07-61223 SC 07-61225 SC 07-61226 SC 07-61227 SC 07-61228 SC 07-61233 SC 07-61404 SC 07-61412 SC 07-61413 SC 07-61429 SC 07-61432 SC 07-61434 SC 07-61435 SC 07-61438 SC 07-61439 SC 07-61442 SC 07-61443 SC 07-61445 SC 07-61448 SC 07-61457 SC 07-61459 SC 07-61460 SC 07-61461 SC 07-61474 SC 07-61475 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 11 of 18

I

07-61477 07-61478 07-61479 07-61485 07-51486 07-61487 07-61488 07-61489 07-61491

Q7-61493 07-51496 07-61498 07-61503 07-61504 07-61505 07~61506

07-61507 07-61508 07-61509 07middot61510 07-61512 07-61513

07middot61514 07middot61515 07-61516

07-61518 L sc

07-61523 07-61526 07-61534 07-61536 07-61539 07-61541

07-61543

07-62972 07-62973 07middot62974 07middot62975 07-62976 07-62977 07-62979 07-63756 07middot63757 07middot63760 07-63761 07middot63762 0763763

07-63769

SC Be

Be se Be Be se

se se se se se

se

se se se se se se

sc sc Be se se Be

se se sc sc se

se Be Be Be Be Be se se Be se se se se se se Be

shy

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 12 of 18

07middot63770 SC 07-63771 SC 07middot63774 SC 07middot63778 SC 07middot63779 SC I 07-64649 SC

07-64650 SC

07middot64655 SC 07middot64664 SC 07middot64671 SC 07middot64674 SC 07-64678 SC 07middot64682 SC 07middot65979 SC

07middot65982 SC

07middot65984 SC 07middot65985 SC I 07middot65989 SC

07middot67408 SC 07-67411 SC 07-67413 SC 07-69159 SC 07-69162 SC 07-69163 SC 07middot69167 SC 07-69168 SC 07-69169 SC 07-69170 SC

07-69179 SC i 07-69182 SC 07-69183 SC

07-70506 SC 07-73476 SC

07-73478 SC 07-73499 SC 07middot73501 SC 07middot74185 SC 08middot67063 SC 08-67066 SC 08-70866 NCmiddotW 08-70886 SC

08-70894 SC

I 08-70895 SC 08-768gt2 NCmiddotW

08middot76849 SC

08middot76850 SC -I 0S-76851 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 13 of 18

08-76853 08-76855 08-76856 08-76857 08-76862 08-76865 08-79838 08-79848

08-79850 08-83125 08-83127 08-83129 08-83131

08-83568 08-83571

08-83575 08-83577 08-83579 08-84578

08-84581 08-84586 08-87194

08-87198

I 08-87205 08-88797

08-88801

08-88803 08-88804

08-88809 08-88810 08-88817

08-89202

08-89203 08-89204 08-89207

08-89209 08-89215 08-90395

08-90396 08-90399 08-90400 08-90403 08-90404 08-90406

08-90413 08-90414

08-90416

se se se se se se se

se se He He se se se se se se se se se se He He se sc se se se se se se

He se

se I se

se sc

He

se se se He He se se se He

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 14 of 18

I 09middot6(1076 09-6(1080

09-60083 09-60084 09-60088

09-60100

09middot60102 09-60104 09-60109 09(0117 09-60119

09-60122 09-60124 09-62649 09-62650

09-62658 IN-65538

09-65541 09middot65549

09middot65551 09-65552 09middot66138 09middot66142

I 09-66147 09middot67138 09-67139

09-67144 01-67146 09-70165 09-70172 09-70173

01middot74445 09-74773 09middot74776 09-80061

09middot80063 09-80075 09-80103

09-90845

09-90846 09-90847 09-90amp48

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

GA-S

Sc SC

SC SC SC UT SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 15 of 18

IIxbjbjj B

1 MCAnany at a1 v Owens-Corning Fiberglas Corporation et al 207~cv-605euroB (S2)

a Nolion for Suwmary Judgment by Bayer cropscience Inc

2 Jirel v ACampS Ino at al 207-cv-61116 ISC)

a Motion fol Summary Judgment by Noland Company Inc

3 Christian v Owens-Illinois et al 207-cv-61187 (SC)

~ ~otion for Su~ary Judqme~~ by Daniel International Corporation

b Motion for Summary Judgment by Flour Daniel Corporation

4 Smoak v Owens-Illinois t et al 207-cv-61217 (SC)

a gtlotion for Sunmary Judgnet by Aventis Cropsclenc USA Ine

5 Kitt v Owens-Illinois at al 207-cv-61220 (SC)

a Motion for Summary JudgmenL by Aventis Cropscienoe USA Inc

6 Johnson v Aventis Crapsoience et a1 207-cv-61223 (SC)

a Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Crane Co

McDaniel v Owens-Illinois I at a~ 207-cv-61225 (SC)

1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 16 of 18

a t-lotion fc SUflnary JJdgrrent by Crane Co

8 Blackmon v Owens-Illinois et al 207middotmiddotcv-6297J (SC)

a Motion for SUfrJllaquo1Y Judgment by Crane Co

o ~ A1bereson v Bayer Cropscience et al

207-cv-63761 (SC)

a Motion for Suuunary Judgment by Bayer Cropscienoe Inc

10 Campbell v Bayer Cropsoienoe et a1 gt07-cv-63763 (Sc)

a Motio~ for Su~~a~y Judgment by Bayer Cropecience Ino

11 Fritz v Bayer Cropsc1ence et al 207-cv-65982 (SC

lt1 Xotion -or Stmnary Judgme by Crane Co

12 WQaver v Owens Illinois Inc et al 20B-cv-90416 ISC)

a Motion fo SUhlmary Judgment by Bayer Cropscience Inc Certainteed Ino and Union Carbide Inc (same motion)

b Xotion or Summary Judgme-t by Crane Co

13 Anderson v Hamilton M1nerals et al 20Q-cv-H0103 IUtah)

a Motim for SrrJlnry Judgmen cy Rapid-American

b Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Georgia Pacific

c Motion -=or Summary Judgme-t by Union Carhide

2

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 17 of 18

MAILED ALGERNON SOLOMONS AlLAN SHACKELFOR ALLAN SLOAN BRENT BOYD BRUCE MtLLER C DRAKE CAREY AVrR CARl PIERCE CHRLES NORRIS CHRJSTOPHER 1AUHlELLO CHR1STOPHER Me cnOl CRAVENS RAVrNI-J DANIEL WHITE DAID CLEVELAND DAVlD LYLE DAVlD MORRISON

DAVD SLOUGH ERIC ElGLEBARDT GIIfILUPS

E-MAlLED~ ADDU R1E A1DREW SHAW ANTIlONY HAYES BRIAN CLARK

C EVERT CARLPIERCH CARTER LA1BfTl CASE DAM CATHERINE JASONS CHARLES SlEueL CHARLES SPRINKIlo CHRISTOPHER SANTORO CLARE MAISASO DAVIDLAMM DAVID TRAYLOR DEME nuns ZACHAROPOU EDWARD SIAUGHTER

BRlN 5110VNEI

FALDRIDGE FRANCES ZACHER FRANK (JORDON GEORGE lNABINET GEORGE TANKARD GtSSUAREZ OUYGLzIER HARRY DAVIS HOWARD BOWERS

Certificate of Service

GEOROE OKELLrV HOMER TISDALE JACKSON BARWICK JAiES KEhEDY JAMES PRESSLEY JEA~ELYLES

JEFFREY fiARNWELL JEFFREY EDDY

JOHNBRYAfT JOSEPH KIJIN

JOSEPH WiLSOr- KEVIN KAUER LAURA EVANS LEE WILSON MARYHILL NATCY MONTI

PAUL DOMlNICK PHILUP FERDERIGOS R SllAW

lVAK G1)STAFS()N

JAMES ElJJUIT JAMES OANDY JAMES KEYNEDY JANET BLACK JE1NlFER TECIIMAN JOHANNA FOWIER JOHN GARDNhR JOHN SLOSSON JOSEPH RHODES JOSEPHINE HICKS JOSHUA BENNEIT KELLY JONES KENNETHKYRE KEVlt OBRIEN K1RK WARNER

LAURA VEE LINDSAY PEED LOREN JACOBSON LOUIS HERNS

MARK THOMAS MARK WALL

MICHAEL COLE

MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI MOFFATT MCDONALD MONA WALLACE

RALPH DAVIES RlCHAAD BURKE RICHARD LUTZEL ROBERT BROWN ROBERT CARPENT[R ROBERT VARNADO

ROLFE MARTlf SHARON WjlLlAM~ THOMAS KEAVENY THOMAS wnl-S TIMOTHY BOlCI TODD SMYTH TRUDY ROBERmOfshyTYNIKA ADAMS VALERIE WILLIAMS WILLIAM HANAHAN WILLIAM LYLpoundS

NATHANIEL HOSIO OLLIE HARlOJI RICHARD RADCLIfFE

RonERTHOOD llOBERT LOVETT ROBERT MLRIWE fHER

ROBERTSHAW

RONALD cox SAfUEL CARR1NGTON SCOTT FRICK $H~ K4CHMAR

STEPHANIE FLYhN STEVEN OUZTS STEVEN PUGH TIIOMAS DOUGAU

TIMOT11Y HO)CH

TIMOTHY PF(K TRACY TOM1lN

v BEVON V1LLlAM COLLINS WILLlAM CONNER WLLlAM DAVIES WILLIAM DAVIS

WILLtM GR1HAM WILLIAM SM1TH WILLlAM STARR

1 of 1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 18 of 18

Page 12: Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR '.:'HE BAS'I'ERK DIS':'RICT 07' PEKNSYLVnNIA ~N . RE; ASBESTOS

I

07-61477 07-61478 07-61479 07-61485 07-51486 07-61487 07-61488 07-61489 07-61491

Q7-61493 07-51496 07-61498 07-61503 07-61504 07-61505 07~61506

07-61507 07-61508 07-61509 07middot61510 07-61512 07-61513

07middot61514 07middot61515 07-61516

07-61518 L sc

07-61523 07-61526 07-61534 07-61536 07-61539 07-61541

07-61543

07-62972 07-62973 07middot62974 07middot62975 07-62976 07-62977 07-62979 07-63756 07middot63757 07middot63760 07-63761 07middot63762 0763763

07-63769

SC Be

Be se Be Be se

se se se se se

se

se se se se se se

sc sc Be se se Be

se se sc sc se

se Be Be Be Be Be se se Be se se se se se se Be

shy

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 12 of 18

07middot63770 SC 07-63771 SC 07middot63774 SC 07middot63778 SC 07middot63779 SC I 07-64649 SC

07-64650 SC

07middot64655 SC 07middot64664 SC 07middot64671 SC 07middot64674 SC 07-64678 SC 07middot64682 SC 07middot65979 SC

07middot65982 SC

07middot65984 SC 07middot65985 SC I 07middot65989 SC

07middot67408 SC 07-67411 SC 07-67413 SC 07-69159 SC 07-69162 SC 07-69163 SC 07middot69167 SC 07-69168 SC 07-69169 SC 07-69170 SC

07-69179 SC i 07-69182 SC 07-69183 SC

07-70506 SC 07-73476 SC

07-73478 SC 07-73499 SC 07middot73501 SC 07middot74185 SC 08middot67063 SC 08-67066 SC 08-70866 NCmiddotW 08-70886 SC

08-70894 SC

I 08-70895 SC 08-768gt2 NCmiddotW

08middot76849 SC

08middot76850 SC -I 0S-76851 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 13 of 18

08-76853 08-76855 08-76856 08-76857 08-76862 08-76865 08-79838 08-79848

08-79850 08-83125 08-83127 08-83129 08-83131

08-83568 08-83571

08-83575 08-83577 08-83579 08-84578

08-84581 08-84586 08-87194

08-87198

I 08-87205 08-88797

08-88801

08-88803 08-88804

08-88809 08-88810 08-88817

08-89202

08-89203 08-89204 08-89207

08-89209 08-89215 08-90395

08-90396 08-90399 08-90400 08-90403 08-90404 08-90406

08-90413 08-90414

08-90416

se se se se se se se

se se He He se se se se se se se se se se He He se sc se se se se se se

He se

se I se

se sc

He

se se se He He se se se He

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 14 of 18

I 09middot6(1076 09-6(1080

09-60083 09-60084 09-60088

09-60100

09middot60102 09-60104 09-60109 09(0117 09-60119

09-60122 09-60124 09-62649 09-62650

09-62658 IN-65538

09-65541 09middot65549

09middot65551 09-65552 09middot66138 09middot66142

I 09-66147 09middot67138 09-67139

09-67144 01-67146 09-70165 09-70172 09-70173

01middot74445 09-74773 09middot74776 09-80061

09middot80063 09-80075 09-80103

09-90845

09-90846 09-90847 09-90amp48

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

GA-S

Sc SC

SC SC SC UT SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 15 of 18

IIxbjbjj B

1 MCAnany at a1 v Owens-Corning Fiberglas Corporation et al 207~cv-605euroB (S2)

a Nolion for Suwmary Judgment by Bayer cropscience Inc

2 Jirel v ACampS Ino at al 207-cv-61116 ISC)

a Motion fol Summary Judgment by Noland Company Inc

3 Christian v Owens-Illinois et al 207-cv-61187 (SC)

~ ~otion for Su~ary Judqme~~ by Daniel International Corporation

b Motion for Summary Judgment by Flour Daniel Corporation

4 Smoak v Owens-Illinois t et al 207-cv-61217 (SC)

a gtlotion for Sunmary Judgnet by Aventis Cropsclenc USA Ine

5 Kitt v Owens-Illinois at al 207-cv-61220 (SC)

a Motion for Summary JudgmenL by Aventis Cropscienoe USA Inc

6 Johnson v Aventis Crapsoience et a1 207-cv-61223 (SC)

a Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Crane Co

McDaniel v Owens-Illinois I at a~ 207-cv-61225 (SC)

1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 16 of 18

a t-lotion fc SUflnary JJdgrrent by Crane Co

8 Blackmon v Owens-Illinois et al 207middotmiddotcv-6297J (SC)

a Motion for SUfrJllaquo1Y Judgment by Crane Co

o ~ A1bereson v Bayer Cropscience et al

207-cv-63761 (SC)

a Motion for Suuunary Judgment by Bayer Cropscienoe Inc

10 Campbell v Bayer Cropsoienoe et a1 gt07-cv-63763 (Sc)

a Motio~ for Su~~a~y Judgment by Bayer Cropecience Ino

11 Fritz v Bayer Cropsc1ence et al 207-cv-65982 (SC

lt1 Xotion -or Stmnary Judgme by Crane Co

12 WQaver v Owens Illinois Inc et al 20B-cv-90416 ISC)

a Motion fo SUhlmary Judgment by Bayer Cropscience Inc Certainteed Ino and Union Carbide Inc (same motion)

b Xotion or Summary Judgme-t by Crane Co

13 Anderson v Hamilton M1nerals et al 20Q-cv-H0103 IUtah)

a Motim for SrrJlnry Judgmen cy Rapid-American

b Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Georgia Pacific

c Motion -=or Summary Judgme-t by Union Carhide

2

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 17 of 18

MAILED ALGERNON SOLOMONS AlLAN SHACKELFOR ALLAN SLOAN BRENT BOYD BRUCE MtLLER C DRAKE CAREY AVrR CARl PIERCE CHRLES NORRIS CHRJSTOPHER 1AUHlELLO CHR1STOPHER Me cnOl CRAVENS RAVrNI-J DANIEL WHITE DAID CLEVELAND DAVlD LYLE DAVlD MORRISON

DAVD SLOUGH ERIC ElGLEBARDT GIIfILUPS

E-MAlLED~ ADDU R1E A1DREW SHAW ANTIlONY HAYES BRIAN CLARK

C EVERT CARLPIERCH CARTER LA1BfTl CASE DAM CATHERINE JASONS CHARLES SlEueL CHARLES SPRINKIlo CHRISTOPHER SANTORO CLARE MAISASO DAVIDLAMM DAVID TRAYLOR DEME nuns ZACHAROPOU EDWARD SIAUGHTER

BRlN 5110VNEI

FALDRIDGE FRANCES ZACHER FRANK (JORDON GEORGE lNABINET GEORGE TANKARD GtSSUAREZ OUYGLzIER HARRY DAVIS HOWARD BOWERS

Certificate of Service

GEOROE OKELLrV HOMER TISDALE JACKSON BARWICK JAiES KEhEDY JAMES PRESSLEY JEA~ELYLES

JEFFREY fiARNWELL JEFFREY EDDY

JOHNBRYAfT JOSEPH KIJIN

JOSEPH WiLSOr- KEVIN KAUER LAURA EVANS LEE WILSON MARYHILL NATCY MONTI

PAUL DOMlNICK PHILUP FERDERIGOS R SllAW

lVAK G1)STAFS()N

JAMES ElJJUIT JAMES OANDY JAMES KEYNEDY JANET BLACK JE1NlFER TECIIMAN JOHANNA FOWIER JOHN GARDNhR JOHN SLOSSON JOSEPH RHODES JOSEPHINE HICKS JOSHUA BENNEIT KELLY JONES KENNETHKYRE KEVlt OBRIEN K1RK WARNER

LAURA VEE LINDSAY PEED LOREN JACOBSON LOUIS HERNS

MARK THOMAS MARK WALL

MICHAEL COLE

MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI MOFFATT MCDONALD MONA WALLACE

RALPH DAVIES RlCHAAD BURKE RICHARD LUTZEL ROBERT BROWN ROBERT CARPENT[R ROBERT VARNADO

ROLFE MARTlf SHARON WjlLlAM~ THOMAS KEAVENY THOMAS wnl-S TIMOTHY BOlCI TODD SMYTH TRUDY ROBERmOfshyTYNIKA ADAMS VALERIE WILLIAMS WILLIAM HANAHAN WILLIAM LYLpoundS

NATHANIEL HOSIO OLLIE HARlOJI RICHARD RADCLIfFE

RonERTHOOD llOBERT LOVETT ROBERT MLRIWE fHER

ROBERTSHAW

RONALD cox SAfUEL CARR1NGTON SCOTT FRICK $H~ K4CHMAR

STEPHANIE FLYhN STEVEN OUZTS STEVEN PUGH TIIOMAS DOUGAU

TIMOT11Y HO)CH

TIMOTHY PF(K TRACY TOM1lN

v BEVON V1LLlAM COLLINS WILLlAM CONNER WLLlAM DAVIES WILLIAM DAVIS

WILLtM GR1HAM WILLIAM SM1TH WILLlAM STARR

1 of 1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 18 of 18

Page 13: Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR '.:'HE BAS'I'ERK DIS':'RICT 07' PEKNSYLVnNIA ~N . RE; ASBESTOS

07middot63770 SC 07-63771 SC 07middot63774 SC 07middot63778 SC 07middot63779 SC I 07-64649 SC

07-64650 SC

07middot64655 SC 07middot64664 SC 07middot64671 SC 07middot64674 SC 07-64678 SC 07middot64682 SC 07middot65979 SC

07middot65982 SC

07middot65984 SC 07middot65985 SC I 07middot65989 SC

07middot67408 SC 07-67411 SC 07-67413 SC 07-69159 SC 07-69162 SC 07-69163 SC 07middot69167 SC 07-69168 SC 07-69169 SC 07-69170 SC

07-69179 SC i 07-69182 SC 07-69183 SC

07-70506 SC 07-73476 SC

07-73478 SC 07-73499 SC 07middot73501 SC 07middot74185 SC 08middot67063 SC 08-67066 SC 08-70866 NCmiddotW 08-70886 SC

08-70894 SC

I 08-70895 SC 08-768gt2 NCmiddotW

08middot76849 SC

08middot76850 SC -I 0S-76851 SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 13 of 18

08-76853 08-76855 08-76856 08-76857 08-76862 08-76865 08-79838 08-79848

08-79850 08-83125 08-83127 08-83129 08-83131

08-83568 08-83571

08-83575 08-83577 08-83579 08-84578

08-84581 08-84586 08-87194

08-87198

I 08-87205 08-88797

08-88801

08-88803 08-88804

08-88809 08-88810 08-88817

08-89202

08-89203 08-89204 08-89207

08-89209 08-89215 08-90395

08-90396 08-90399 08-90400 08-90403 08-90404 08-90406

08-90413 08-90414

08-90416

se se se se se se se

se se He He se se se se se se se se se se He He se sc se se se se se se

He se

se I se

se sc

He

se se se He He se se se He

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 14 of 18

I 09middot6(1076 09-6(1080

09-60083 09-60084 09-60088

09-60100

09middot60102 09-60104 09-60109 09(0117 09-60119

09-60122 09-60124 09-62649 09-62650

09-62658 IN-65538

09-65541 09middot65549

09middot65551 09-65552 09middot66138 09middot66142

I 09-66147 09middot67138 09-67139

09-67144 01-67146 09-70165 09-70172 09-70173

01middot74445 09-74773 09middot74776 09-80061

09middot80063 09-80075 09-80103

09-90845

09-90846 09-90847 09-90amp48

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

GA-S

Sc SC

SC SC SC UT SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 15 of 18

IIxbjbjj B

1 MCAnany at a1 v Owens-Corning Fiberglas Corporation et al 207~cv-605euroB (S2)

a Nolion for Suwmary Judgment by Bayer cropscience Inc

2 Jirel v ACampS Ino at al 207-cv-61116 ISC)

a Motion fol Summary Judgment by Noland Company Inc

3 Christian v Owens-Illinois et al 207-cv-61187 (SC)

~ ~otion for Su~ary Judqme~~ by Daniel International Corporation

b Motion for Summary Judgment by Flour Daniel Corporation

4 Smoak v Owens-Illinois t et al 207-cv-61217 (SC)

a gtlotion for Sunmary Judgnet by Aventis Cropsclenc USA Ine

5 Kitt v Owens-Illinois at al 207-cv-61220 (SC)

a Motion for Summary JudgmenL by Aventis Cropscienoe USA Inc

6 Johnson v Aventis Crapsoience et a1 207-cv-61223 (SC)

a Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Crane Co

McDaniel v Owens-Illinois I at a~ 207-cv-61225 (SC)

1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 16 of 18

a t-lotion fc SUflnary JJdgrrent by Crane Co

8 Blackmon v Owens-Illinois et al 207middotmiddotcv-6297J (SC)

a Motion for SUfrJllaquo1Y Judgment by Crane Co

o ~ A1bereson v Bayer Cropscience et al

207-cv-63761 (SC)

a Motion for Suuunary Judgment by Bayer Cropscienoe Inc

10 Campbell v Bayer Cropsoienoe et a1 gt07-cv-63763 (Sc)

a Motio~ for Su~~a~y Judgment by Bayer Cropecience Ino

11 Fritz v Bayer Cropsc1ence et al 207-cv-65982 (SC

lt1 Xotion -or Stmnary Judgme by Crane Co

12 WQaver v Owens Illinois Inc et al 20B-cv-90416 ISC)

a Motion fo SUhlmary Judgment by Bayer Cropscience Inc Certainteed Ino and Union Carbide Inc (same motion)

b Xotion or Summary Judgme-t by Crane Co

13 Anderson v Hamilton M1nerals et al 20Q-cv-H0103 IUtah)

a Motim for SrrJlnry Judgmen cy Rapid-American

b Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Georgia Pacific

c Motion -=or Summary Judgme-t by Union Carhide

2

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 17 of 18

MAILED ALGERNON SOLOMONS AlLAN SHACKELFOR ALLAN SLOAN BRENT BOYD BRUCE MtLLER C DRAKE CAREY AVrR CARl PIERCE CHRLES NORRIS CHRJSTOPHER 1AUHlELLO CHR1STOPHER Me cnOl CRAVENS RAVrNI-J DANIEL WHITE DAID CLEVELAND DAVlD LYLE DAVlD MORRISON

DAVD SLOUGH ERIC ElGLEBARDT GIIfILUPS

E-MAlLED~ ADDU R1E A1DREW SHAW ANTIlONY HAYES BRIAN CLARK

C EVERT CARLPIERCH CARTER LA1BfTl CASE DAM CATHERINE JASONS CHARLES SlEueL CHARLES SPRINKIlo CHRISTOPHER SANTORO CLARE MAISASO DAVIDLAMM DAVID TRAYLOR DEME nuns ZACHAROPOU EDWARD SIAUGHTER

BRlN 5110VNEI

FALDRIDGE FRANCES ZACHER FRANK (JORDON GEORGE lNABINET GEORGE TANKARD GtSSUAREZ OUYGLzIER HARRY DAVIS HOWARD BOWERS

Certificate of Service

GEOROE OKELLrV HOMER TISDALE JACKSON BARWICK JAiES KEhEDY JAMES PRESSLEY JEA~ELYLES

JEFFREY fiARNWELL JEFFREY EDDY

JOHNBRYAfT JOSEPH KIJIN

JOSEPH WiLSOr- KEVIN KAUER LAURA EVANS LEE WILSON MARYHILL NATCY MONTI

PAUL DOMlNICK PHILUP FERDERIGOS R SllAW

lVAK G1)STAFS()N

JAMES ElJJUIT JAMES OANDY JAMES KEYNEDY JANET BLACK JE1NlFER TECIIMAN JOHANNA FOWIER JOHN GARDNhR JOHN SLOSSON JOSEPH RHODES JOSEPHINE HICKS JOSHUA BENNEIT KELLY JONES KENNETHKYRE KEVlt OBRIEN K1RK WARNER

LAURA VEE LINDSAY PEED LOREN JACOBSON LOUIS HERNS

MARK THOMAS MARK WALL

MICHAEL COLE

MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI MOFFATT MCDONALD MONA WALLACE

RALPH DAVIES RlCHAAD BURKE RICHARD LUTZEL ROBERT BROWN ROBERT CARPENT[R ROBERT VARNADO

ROLFE MARTlf SHARON WjlLlAM~ THOMAS KEAVENY THOMAS wnl-S TIMOTHY BOlCI TODD SMYTH TRUDY ROBERmOfshyTYNIKA ADAMS VALERIE WILLIAMS WILLIAM HANAHAN WILLIAM LYLpoundS

NATHANIEL HOSIO OLLIE HARlOJI RICHARD RADCLIfFE

RonERTHOOD llOBERT LOVETT ROBERT MLRIWE fHER

ROBERTSHAW

RONALD cox SAfUEL CARR1NGTON SCOTT FRICK $H~ K4CHMAR

STEPHANIE FLYhN STEVEN OUZTS STEVEN PUGH TIIOMAS DOUGAU

TIMOT11Y HO)CH

TIMOTHY PF(K TRACY TOM1lN

v BEVON V1LLlAM COLLINS WILLlAM CONNER WLLlAM DAVIES WILLIAM DAVIS

WILLtM GR1HAM WILLIAM SM1TH WILLlAM STARR

1 of 1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 18 of 18

Page 14: Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR '.:'HE BAS'I'ERK DIS':'RICT 07' PEKNSYLVnNIA ~N . RE; ASBESTOS

08-76853 08-76855 08-76856 08-76857 08-76862 08-76865 08-79838 08-79848

08-79850 08-83125 08-83127 08-83129 08-83131

08-83568 08-83571

08-83575 08-83577 08-83579 08-84578

08-84581 08-84586 08-87194

08-87198

I 08-87205 08-88797

08-88801

08-88803 08-88804

08-88809 08-88810 08-88817

08-89202

08-89203 08-89204 08-89207

08-89209 08-89215 08-90395

08-90396 08-90399 08-90400 08-90403 08-90404 08-90406

08-90413 08-90414

08-90416

se se se se se se se

se se He He se se se se se se se se se se He He se sc se se se se se se

He se

se I se

se sc

He

se se se He He se se se He

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 14 of 18

I 09middot6(1076 09-6(1080

09-60083 09-60084 09-60088

09-60100

09middot60102 09-60104 09-60109 09(0117 09-60119

09-60122 09-60124 09-62649 09-62650

09-62658 IN-65538

09-65541 09middot65549

09middot65551 09-65552 09middot66138 09middot66142

I 09-66147 09middot67138 09-67139

09-67144 01-67146 09-70165 09-70172 09-70173

01middot74445 09-74773 09middot74776 09-80061

09middot80063 09-80075 09-80103

09-90845

09-90846 09-90847 09-90amp48

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

GA-S

Sc SC

SC SC SC UT SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 15 of 18

IIxbjbjj B

1 MCAnany at a1 v Owens-Corning Fiberglas Corporation et al 207~cv-605euroB (S2)

a Nolion for Suwmary Judgment by Bayer cropscience Inc

2 Jirel v ACampS Ino at al 207-cv-61116 ISC)

a Motion fol Summary Judgment by Noland Company Inc

3 Christian v Owens-Illinois et al 207-cv-61187 (SC)

~ ~otion for Su~ary Judqme~~ by Daniel International Corporation

b Motion for Summary Judgment by Flour Daniel Corporation

4 Smoak v Owens-Illinois t et al 207-cv-61217 (SC)

a gtlotion for Sunmary Judgnet by Aventis Cropsclenc USA Ine

5 Kitt v Owens-Illinois at al 207-cv-61220 (SC)

a Motion for Summary JudgmenL by Aventis Cropscienoe USA Inc

6 Johnson v Aventis Crapsoience et a1 207-cv-61223 (SC)

a Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Crane Co

McDaniel v Owens-Illinois I at a~ 207-cv-61225 (SC)

1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 16 of 18

a t-lotion fc SUflnary JJdgrrent by Crane Co

8 Blackmon v Owens-Illinois et al 207middotmiddotcv-6297J (SC)

a Motion for SUfrJllaquo1Y Judgment by Crane Co

o ~ A1bereson v Bayer Cropscience et al

207-cv-63761 (SC)

a Motion for Suuunary Judgment by Bayer Cropscienoe Inc

10 Campbell v Bayer Cropsoienoe et a1 gt07-cv-63763 (Sc)

a Motio~ for Su~~a~y Judgment by Bayer Cropecience Ino

11 Fritz v Bayer Cropsc1ence et al 207-cv-65982 (SC

lt1 Xotion -or Stmnary Judgme by Crane Co

12 WQaver v Owens Illinois Inc et al 20B-cv-90416 ISC)

a Motion fo SUhlmary Judgment by Bayer Cropscience Inc Certainteed Ino and Union Carbide Inc (same motion)

b Xotion or Summary Judgme-t by Crane Co

13 Anderson v Hamilton M1nerals et al 20Q-cv-H0103 IUtah)

a Motim for SrrJlnry Judgmen cy Rapid-American

b Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Georgia Pacific

c Motion -=or Summary Judgme-t by Union Carhide

2

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 17 of 18

MAILED ALGERNON SOLOMONS AlLAN SHACKELFOR ALLAN SLOAN BRENT BOYD BRUCE MtLLER C DRAKE CAREY AVrR CARl PIERCE CHRLES NORRIS CHRJSTOPHER 1AUHlELLO CHR1STOPHER Me cnOl CRAVENS RAVrNI-J DANIEL WHITE DAID CLEVELAND DAVlD LYLE DAVlD MORRISON

DAVD SLOUGH ERIC ElGLEBARDT GIIfILUPS

E-MAlLED~ ADDU R1E A1DREW SHAW ANTIlONY HAYES BRIAN CLARK

C EVERT CARLPIERCH CARTER LA1BfTl CASE DAM CATHERINE JASONS CHARLES SlEueL CHARLES SPRINKIlo CHRISTOPHER SANTORO CLARE MAISASO DAVIDLAMM DAVID TRAYLOR DEME nuns ZACHAROPOU EDWARD SIAUGHTER

BRlN 5110VNEI

FALDRIDGE FRANCES ZACHER FRANK (JORDON GEORGE lNABINET GEORGE TANKARD GtSSUAREZ OUYGLzIER HARRY DAVIS HOWARD BOWERS

Certificate of Service

GEOROE OKELLrV HOMER TISDALE JACKSON BARWICK JAiES KEhEDY JAMES PRESSLEY JEA~ELYLES

JEFFREY fiARNWELL JEFFREY EDDY

JOHNBRYAfT JOSEPH KIJIN

JOSEPH WiLSOr- KEVIN KAUER LAURA EVANS LEE WILSON MARYHILL NATCY MONTI

PAUL DOMlNICK PHILUP FERDERIGOS R SllAW

lVAK G1)STAFS()N

JAMES ElJJUIT JAMES OANDY JAMES KEYNEDY JANET BLACK JE1NlFER TECIIMAN JOHANNA FOWIER JOHN GARDNhR JOHN SLOSSON JOSEPH RHODES JOSEPHINE HICKS JOSHUA BENNEIT KELLY JONES KENNETHKYRE KEVlt OBRIEN K1RK WARNER

LAURA VEE LINDSAY PEED LOREN JACOBSON LOUIS HERNS

MARK THOMAS MARK WALL

MICHAEL COLE

MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI MOFFATT MCDONALD MONA WALLACE

RALPH DAVIES RlCHAAD BURKE RICHARD LUTZEL ROBERT BROWN ROBERT CARPENT[R ROBERT VARNADO

ROLFE MARTlf SHARON WjlLlAM~ THOMAS KEAVENY THOMAS wnl-S TIMOTHY BOlCI TODD SMYTH TRUDY ROBERmOfshyTYNIKA ADAMS VALERIE WILLIAMS WILLIAM HANAHAN WILLIAM LYLpoundS

NATHANIEL HOSIO OLLIE HARlOJI RICHARD RADCLIfFE

RonERTHOOD llOBERT LOVETT ROBERT MLRIWE fHER

ROBERTSHAW

RONALD cox SAfUEL CARR1NGTON SCOTT FRICK $H~ K4CHMAR

STEPHANIE FLYhN STEVEN OUZTS STEVEN PUGH TIIOMAS DOUGAU

TIMOT11Y HO)CH

TIMOTHY PF(K TRACY TOM1lN

v BEVON V1LLlAM COLLINS WILLlAM CONNER WLLlAM DAVIES WILLIAM DAVIS

WILLtM GR1HAM WILLIAM SM1TH WILLlAM STARR

1 of 1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 18 of 18

Page 15: Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR '.:'HE BAS'I'ERK DIS':'RICT 07' PEKNSYLVnNIA ~N . RE; ASBESTOS

I 09middot6(1076 09-6(1080

09-60083 09-60084 09-60088

09-60100

09middot60102 09-60104 09-60109 09(0117 09-60119

09-60122 09-60124 09-62649 09-62650

09-62658 IN-65538

09-65541 09middot65549

09middot65551 09-65552 09middot66138 09middot66142

I 09-66147 09middot67138 09-67139

09-67144 01-67146 09-70165 09-70172 09-70173

01middot74445 09-74773 09middot74776 09-80061

09middot80063 09-80075 09-80103

09-90845

09-90846 09-90847 09-90amp48

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC SC

GA-S

Sc SC

SC SC SC UT SC SC SC SC

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 15 of 18

IIxbjbjj B

1 MCAnany at a1 v Owens-Corning Fiberglas Corporation et al 207~cv-605euroB (S2)

a Nolion for Suwmary Judgment by Bayer cropscience Inc

2 Jirel v ACampS Ino at al 207-cv-61116 ISC)

a Motion fol Summary Judgment by Noland Company Inc

3 Christian v Owens-Illinois et al 207-cv-61187 (SC)

~ ~otion for Su~ary Judqme~~ by Daniel International Corporation

b Motion for Summary Judgment by Flour Daniel Corporation

4 Smoak v Owens-Illinois t et al 207-cv-61217 (SC)

a gtlotion for Sunmary Judgnet by Aventis Cropsclenc USA Ine

5 Kitt v Owens-Illinois at al 207-cv-61220 (SC)

a Motion for Summary JudgmenL by Aventis Cropscienoe USA Inc

6 Johnson v Aventis Crapsoience et a1 207-cv-61223 (SC)

a Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Crane Co

McDaniel v Owens-Illinois I at a~ 207-cv-61225 (SC)

1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 16 of 18

a t-lotion fc SUflnary JJdgrrent by Crane Co

8 Blackmon v Owens-Illinois et al 207middotmiddotcv-6297J (SC)

a Motion for SUfrJllaquo1Y Judgment by Crane Co

o ~ A1bereson v Bayer Cropscience et al

207-cv-63761 (SC)

a Motion for Suuunary Judgment by Bayer Cropscienoe Inc

10 Campbell v Bayer Cropsoienoe et a1 gt07-cv-63763 (Sc)

a Motio~ for Su~~a~y Judgment by Bayer Cropecience Ino

11 Fritz v Bayer Cropsc1ence et al 207-cv-65982 (SC

lt1 Xotion -or Stmnary Judgme by Crane Co

12 WQaver v Owens Illinois Inc et al 20B-cv-90416 ISC)

a Motion fo SUhlmary Judgment by Bayer Cropscience Inc Certainteed Ino and Union Carbide Inc (same motion)

b Xotion or Summary Judgme-t by Crane Co

13 Anderson v Hamilton M1nerals et al 20Q-cv-H0103 IUtah)

a Motim for SrrJlnry Judgmen cy Rapid-American

b Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Georgia Pacific

c Motion -=or Summary Judgme-t by Union Carhide

2

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 17 of 18

MAILED ALGERNON SOLOMONS AlLAN SHACKELFOR ALLAN SLOAN BRENT BOYD BRUCE MtLLER C DRAKE CAREY AVrR CARl PIERCE CHRLES NORRIS CHRJSTOPHER 1AUHlELLO CHR1STOPHER Me cnOl CRAVENS RAVrNI-J DANIEL WHITE DAID CLEVELAND DAVlD LYLE DAVlD MORRISON

DAVD SLOUGH ERIC ElGLEBARDT GIIfILUPS

E-MAlLED~ ADDU R1E A1DREW SHAW ANTIlONY HAYES BRIAN CLARK

C EVERT CARLPIERCH CARTER LA1BfTl CASE DAM CATHERINE JASONS CHARLES SlEueL CHARLES SPRINKIlo CHRISTOPHER SANTORO CLARE MAISASO DAVIDLAMM DAVID TRAYLOR DEME nuns ZACHAROPOU EDWARD SIAUGHTER

BRlN 5110VNEI

FALDRIDGE FRANCES ZACHER FRANK (JORDON GEORGE lNABINET GEORGE TANKARD GtSSUAREZ OUYGLzIER HARRY DAVIS HOWARD BOWERS

Certificate of Service

GEOROE OKELLrV HOMER TISDALE JACKSON BARWICK JAiES KEhEDY JAMES PRESSLEY JEA~ELYLES

JEFFREY fiARNWELL JEFFREY EDDY

JOHNBRYAfT JOSEPH KIJIN

JOSEPH WiLSOr- KEVIN KAUER LAURA EVANS LEE WILSON MARYHILL NATCY MONTI

PAUL DOMlNICK PHILUP FERDERIGOS R SllAW

lVAK G1)STAFS()N

JAMES ElJJUIT JAMES OANDY JAMES KEYNEDY JANET BLACK JE1NlFER TECIIMAN JOHANNA FOWIER JOHN GARDNhR JOHN SLOSSON JOSEPH RHODES JOSEPHINE HICKS JOSHUA BENNEIT KELLY JONES KENNETHKYRE KEVlt OBRIEN K1RK WARNER

LAURA VEE LINDSAY PEED LOREN JACOBSON LOUIS HERNS

MARK THOMAS MARK WALL

MICHAEL COLE

MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI MOFFATT MCDONALD MONA WALLACE

RALPH DAVIES RlCHAAD BURKE RICHARD LUTZEL ROBERT BROWN ROBERT CARPENT[R ROBERT VARNADO

ROLFE MARTlf SHARON WjlLlAM~ THOMAS KEAVENY THOMAS wnl-S TIMOTHY BOlCI TODD SMYTH TRUDY ROBERmOfshyTYNIKA ADAMS VALERIE WILLIAMS WILLIAM HANAHAN WILLIAM LYLpoundS

NATHANIEL HOSIO OLLIE HARlOJI RICHARD RADCLIfFE

RonERTHOOD llOBERT LOVETT ROBERT MLRIWE fHER

ROBERTSHAW

RONALD cox SAfUEL CARR1NGTON SCOTT FRICK $H~ K4CHMAR

STEPHANIE FLYhN STEVEN OUZTS STEVEN PUGH TIIOMAS DOUGAU

TIMOT11Y HO)CH

TIMOTHY PF(K TRACY TOM1lN

v BEVON V1LLlAM COLLINS WILLlAM CONNER WLLlAM DAVIES WILLIAM DAVIS

WILLtM GR1HAM WILLIAM SM1TH WILLlAM STARR

1 of 1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 18 of 18

Page 16: Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR '.:'HE BAS'I'ERK DIS':'RICT 07' PEKNSYLVnNIA ~N . RE; ASBESTOS

IIxbjbjj B

1 MCAnany at a1 v Owens-Corning Fiberglas Corporation et al 207~cv-605euroB (S2)

a Nolion for Suwmary Judgment by Bayer cropscience Inc

2 Jirel v ACampS Ino at al 207-cv-61116 ISC)

a Motion fol Summary Judgment by Noland Company Inc

3 Christian v Owens-Illinois et al 207-cv-61187 (SC)

~ ~otion for Su~ary Judqme~~ by Daniel International Corporation

b Motion for Summary Judgment by Flour Daniel Corporation

4 Smoak v Owens-Illinois t et al 207-cv-61217 (SC)

a gtlotion for Sunmary Judgnet by Aventis Cropsclenc USA Ine

5 Kitt v Owens-Illinois at al 207-cv-61220 (SC)

a Motion for Summary JudgmenL by Aventis Cropscienoe USA Inc

6 Johnson v Aventis Crapsoience et a1 207-cv-61223 (SC)

a Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Crane Co

McDaniel v Owens-Illinois I at a~ 207-cv-61225 (SC)

1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 16 of 18

a t-lotion fc SUflnary JJdgrrent by Crane Co

8 Blackmon v Owens-Illinois et al 207middotmiddotcv-6297J (SC)

a Motion for SUfrJllaquo1Y Judgment by Crane Co

o ~ A1bereson v Bayer Cropscience et al

207-cv-63761 (SC)

a Motion for Suuunary Judgment by Bayer Cropscienoe Inc

10 Campbell v Bayer Cropsoienoe et a1 gt07-cv-63763 (Sc)

a Motio~ for Su~~a~y Judgment by Bayer Cropecience Ino

11 Fritz v Bayer Cropsc1ence et al 207-cv-65982 (SC

lt1 Xotion -or Stmnary Judgme by Crane Co

12 WQaver v Owens Illinois Inc et al 20B-cv-90416 ISC)

a Motion fo SUhlmary Judgment by Bayer Cropscience Inc Certainteed Ino and Union Carbide Inc (same motion)

b Xotion or Summary Judgme-t by Crane Co

13 Anderson v Hamilton M1nerals et al 20Q-cv-H0103 IUtah)

a Motim for SrrJlnry Judgmen cy Rapid-American

b Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Georgia Pacific

c Motion -=or Summary Judgme-t by Union Carhide

2

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 17 of 18

MAILED ALGERNON SOLOMONS AlLAN SHACKELFOR ALLAN SLOAN BRENT BOYD BRUCE MtLLER C DRAKE CAREY AVrR CARl PIERCE CHRLES NORRIS CHRJSTOPHER 1AUHlELLO CHR1STOPHER Me cnOl CRAVENS RAVrNI-J DANIEL WHITE DAID CLEVELAND DAVlD LYLE DAVlD MORRISON

DAVD SLOUGH ERIC ElGLEBARDT GIIfILUPS

E-MAlLED~ ADDU R1E A1DREW SHAW ANTIlONY HAYES BRIAN CLARK

C EVERT CARLPIERCH CARTER LA1BfTl CASE DAM CATHERINE JASONS CHARLES SlEueL CHARLES SPRINKIlo CHRISTOPHER SANTORO CLARE MAISASO DAVIDLAMM DAVID TRAYLOR DEME nuns ZACHAROPOU EDWARD SIAUGHTER

BRlN 5110VNEI

FALDRIDGE FRANCES ZACHER FRANK (JORDON GEORGE lNABINET GEORGE TANKARD GtSSUAREZ OUYGLzIER HARRY DAVIS HOWARD BOWERS

Certificate of Service

GEOROE OKELLrV HOMER TISDALE JACKSON BARWICK JAiES KEhEDY JAMES PRESSLEY JEA~ELYLES

JEFFREY fiARNWELL JEFFREY EDDY

JOHNBRYAfT JOSEPH KIJIN

JOSEPH WiLSOr- KEVIN KAUER LAURA EVANS LEE WILSON MARYHILL NATCY MONTI

PAUL DOMlNICK PHILUP FERDERIGOS R SllAW

lVAK G1)STAFS()N

JAMES ElJJUIT JAMES OANDY JAMES KEYNEDY JANET BLACK JE1NlFER TECIIMAN JOHANNA FOWIER JOHN GARDNhR JOHN SLOSSON JOSEPH RHODES JOSEPHINE HICKS JOSHUA BENNEIT KELLY JONES KENNETHKYRE KEVlt OBRIEN K1RK WARNER

LAURA VEE LINDSAY PEED LOREN JACOBSON LOUIS HERNS

MARK THOMAS MARK WALL

MICHAEL COLE

MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI MOFFATT MCDONALD MONA WALLACE

RALPH DAVIES RlCHAAD BURKE RICHARD LUTZEL ROBERT BROWN ROBERT CARPENT[R ROBERT VARNADO

ROLFE MARTlf SHARON WjlLlAM~ THOMAS KEAVENY THOMAS wnl-S TIMOTHY BOlCI TODD SMYTH TRUDY ROBERmOfshyTYNIKA ADAMS VALERIE WILLIAMS WILLIAM HANAHAN WILLIAM LYLpoundS

NATHANIEL HOSIO OLLIE HARlOJI RICHARD RADCLIfFE

RonERTHOOD llOBERT LOVETT ROBERT MLRIWE fHER

ROBERTSHAW

RONALD cox SAfUEL CARR1NGTON SCOTT FRICK $H~ K4CHMAR

STEPHANIE FLYhN STEVEN OUZTS STEVEN PUGH TIIOMAS DOUGAU

TIMOT11Y HO)CH

TIMOTHY PF(K TRACY TOM1lN

v BEVON V1LLlAM COLLINS WILLlAM CONNER WLLlAM DAVIES WILLIAM DAVIS

WILLtM GR1HAM WILLIAM SM1TH WILLlAM STARR

1 of 1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 18 of 18

Page 17: Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR '.:'HE BAS'I'ERK DIS':'RICT 07' PEKNSYLVnNIA ~N . RE; ASBESTOS

a t-lotion fc SUflnary JJdgrrent by Crane Co

8 Blackmon v Owens-Illinois et al 207middotmiddotcv-6297J (SC)

a Motion for SUfrJllaquo1Y Judgment by Crane Co

o ~ A1bereson v Bayer Cropscience et al

207-cv-63761 (SC)

a Motion for Suuunary Judgment by Bayer Cropscienoe Inc

10 Campbell v Bayer Cropsoienoe et a1 gt07-cv-63763 (Sc)

a Motio~ for Su~~a~y Judgment by Bayer Cropecience Ino

11 Fritz v Bayer Cropsc1ence et al 207-cv-65982 (SC

lt1 Xotion -or Stmnary Judgme by Crane Co

12 WQaver v Owens Illinois Inc et al 20B-cv-90416 ISC)

a Motion fo SUhlmary Judgment by Bayer Cropscience Inc Certainteed Ino and Union Carbide Inc (same motion)

b Xotion or Summary Judgme-t by Crane Co

13 Anderson v Hamilton M1nerals et al 20Q-cv-H0103 IUtah)

a Motim for SrrJlnry Judgmen cy Rapid-American

b Motion for Sumrnary Judgment by Georgia Pacific

c Motion -=or Summary Judgme-t by Union Carhide

2

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 17 of 18

MAILED ALGERNON SOLOMONS AlLAN SHACKELFOR ALLAN SLOAN BRENT BOYD BRUCE MtLLER C DRAKE CAREY AVrR CARl PIERCE CHRLES NORRIS CHRJSTOPHER 1AUHlELLO CHR1STOPHER Me cnOl CRAVENS RAVrNI-J DANIEL WHITE DAID CLEVELAND DAVlD LYLE DAVlD MORRISON

DAVD SLOUGH ERIC ElGLEBARDT GIIfILUPS

E-MAlLED~ ADDU R1E A1DREW SHAW ANTIlONY HAYES BRIAN CLARK

C EVERT CARLPIERCH CARTER LA1BfTl CASE DAM CATHERINE JASONS CHARLES SlEueL CHARLES SPRINKIlo CHRISTOPHER SANTORO CLARE MAISASO DAVIDLAMM DAVID TRAYLOR DEME nuns ZACHAROPOU EDWARD SIAUGHTER

BRlN 5110VNEI

FALDRIDGE FRANCES ZACHER FRANK (JORDON GEORGE lNABINET GEORGE TANKARD GtSSUAREZ OUYGLzIER HARRY DAVIS HOWARD BOWERS

Certificate of Service

GEOROE OKELLrV HOMER TISDALE JACKSON BARWICK JAiES KEhEDY JAMES PRESSLEY JEA~ELYLES

JEFFREY fiARNWELL JEFFREY EDDY

JOHNBRYAfT JOSEPH KIJIN

JOSEPH WiLSOr- KEVIN KAUER LAURA EVANS LEE WILSON MARYHILL NATCY MONTI

PAUL DOMlNICK PHILUP FERDERIGOS R SllAW

lVAK G1)STAFS()N

JAMES ElJJUIT JAMES OANDY JAMES KEYNEDY JANET BLACK JE1NlFER TECIIMAN JOHANNA FOWIER JOHN GARDNhR JOHN SLOSSON JOSEPH RHODES JOSEPHINE HICKS JOSHUA BENNEIT KELLY JONES KENNETHKYRE KEVlt OBRIEN K1RK WARNER

LAURA VEE LINDSAY PEED LOREN JACOBSON LOUIS HERNS

MARK THOMAS MARK WALL

MICHAEL COLE

MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI MOFFATT MCDONALD MONA WALLACE

RALPH DAVIES RlCHAAD BURKE RICHARD LUTZEL ROBERT BROWN ROBERT CARPENT[R ROBERT VARNADO

ROLFE MARTlf SHARON WjlLlAM~ THOMAS KEAVENY THOMAS wnl-S TIMOTHY BOlCI TODD SMYTH TRUDY ROBERmOfshyTYNIKA ADAMS VALERIE WILLIAMS WILLIAM HANAHAN WILLIAM LYLpoundS

NATHANIEL HOSIO OLLIE HARlOJI RICHARD RADCLIfFE

RonERTHOOD llOBERT LOVETT ROBERT MLRIWE fHER

ROBERTSHAW

RONALD cox SAfUEL CARR1NGTON SCOTT FRICK $H~ K4CHMAR

STEPHANIE FLYhN STEVEN OUZTS STEVEN PUGH TIIOMAS DOUGAU

TIMOT11Y HO)CH

TIMOTHY PF(K TRACY TOM1lN

v BEVON V1LLlAM COLLINS WILLlAM CONNER WLLlAM DAVIES WILLIAM DAVIS

WILLtM GR1HAM WILLIAM SM1TH WILLlAM STARR

1 of 1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 18 of 18

Page 18: Eastern District of Pennsylvania | United States District ... Judg… · IN ']';{E UN:::'l'ED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR '.:'HE BAS'I'ERK DIS':'RICT 07' PEKNSYLVnNIA ~N . RE; ASBESTOS

MAILED ALGERNON SOLOMONS AlLAN SHACKELFOR ALLAN SLOAN BRENT BOYD BRUCE MtLLER C DRAKE CAREY AVrR CARl PIERCE CHRLES NORRIS CHRJSTOPHER 1AUHlELLO CHR1STOPHER Me cnOl CRAVENS RAVrNI-J DANIEL WHITE DAID CLEVELAND DAVlD LYLE DAVlD MORRISON

DAVD SLOUGH ERIC ElGLEBARDT GIIfILUPS

E-MAlLED~ ADDU R1E A1DREW SHAW ANTIlONY HAYES BRIAN CLARK

C EVERT CARLPIERCH CARTER LA1BfTl CASE DAM CATHERINE JASONS CHARLES SlEueL CHARLES SPRINKIlo CHRISTOPHER SANTORO CLARE MAISASO DAVIDLAMM DAVID TRAYLOR DEME nuns ZACHAROPOU EDWARD SIAUGHTER

BRlN 5110VNEI

FALDRIDGE FRANCES ZACHER FRANK (JORDON GEORGE lNABINET GEORGE TANKARD GtSSUAREZ OUYGLzIER HARRY DAVIS HOWARD BOWERS

Certificate of Service

GEOROE OKELLrV HOMER TISDALE JACKSON BARWICK JAiES KEhEDY JAMES PRESSLEY JEA~ELYLES

JEFFREY fiARNWELL JEFFREY EDDY

JOHNBRYAfT JOSEPH KIJIN

JOSEPH WiLSOr- KEVIN KAUER LAURA EVANS LEE WILSON MARYHILL NATCY MONTI

PAUL DOMlNICK PHILUP FERDERIGOS R SllAW

lVAK G1)STAFS()N

JAMES ElJJUIT JAMES OANDY JAMES KEYNEDY JANET BLACK JE1NlFER TECIIMAN JOHANNA FOWIER JOHN GARDNhR JOHN SLOSSON JOSEPH RHODES JOSEPHINE HICKS JOSHUA BENNEIT KELLY JONES KENNETHKYRE KEVlt OBRIEN K1RK WARNER

LAURA VEE LINDSAY PEED LOREN JACOBSON LOUIS HERNS

MARK THOMAS MARK WALL

MICHAEL COLE

MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI MOFFATT MCDONALD MONA WALLACE

RALPH DAVIES RlCHAAD BURKE RICHARD LUTZEL ROBERT BROWN ROBERT CARPENT[R ROBERT VARNADO

ROLFE MARTlf SHARON WjlLlAM~ THOMAS KEAVENY THOMAS wnl-S TIMOTHY BOlCI TODD SMYTH TRUDY ROBERmOfshyTYNIKA ADAMS VALERIE WILLIAMS WILLIAM HANAHAN WILLIAM LYLpoundS

NATHANIEL HOSIO OLLIE HARlOJI RICHARD RADCLIfFE

RonERTHOOD llOBERT LOVETT ROBERT MLRIWE fHER

ROBERTSHAW

RONALD cox SAfUEL CARR1NGTON SCOTT FRICK $H~ K4CHMAR

STEPHANIE FLYhN STEVEN OUZTS STEVEN PUGH TIIOMAS DOUGAU

TIMOT11Y HO)CH

TIMOTHY PF(K TRACY TOM1lN

v BEVON V1LLlAM COLLINS WILLlAM CONNER WLLlAM DAVIES WILLIAM DAVIS

WILLtM GR1HAM WILLIAM SM1TH WILLlAM STARR

1 of 1

Case 207-cv-60568-ER Document 35 Filed 011111 Page 18 of 18


Recommended