D.M.Reeve: AAPM 2011
1
Breast MRI: Image Quality, Artifacts and Quality ControlBreast MRI: Image Quality,
Artifacts and Quality Control
Donna M. Reeve, MS, DABR, DABMPDonna M. Reeve, MS, DABR, DABMPDepartment of Imaging PhysicsDepartment of Imaging PhysicsDepartment of Imaging PhysicsDepartment of Imaging Physics
Educational ObjectivesEducational Objectives
•• Describe common artifacts and image quality issues Describe common artifacts and image quality issues encountered in clinical breast MR images.encountered in clinical breast MR images.
•• Discuss methods for addressing breast MR image quality Discuss methods for addressing breast MR image quality problems.problems.pp
•• Describe quality control procedures accreditation programs Describe quality control procedures accreditation programs specific to breast MRI.specific to breast MRI.
Challenges:
• Adequate SNR ACR: “not too grainy”
• Good spatial resolution
• 1mm x 1mm in-plane resolution
3 li hi k
Breast MR Image QualityBreast MR Image Quality
• ≤ 3mm slice thickness
• Temporal resolution dynamic series (60-90 sec/phase)
• Absence of (or minimal) artifacts
• Effective, uniform fat suppression
SNRSNRSNRSNRPotential causes of low SNR:
• Low field strength• Poor Coil connection• Coil element failure• Incorrect center frequency selectionIncorrect center frequency selection• Protocol parameters:
- Small voxels (large matrix, small FOV, thin slices)
- trade-offs: speed, SNR, resolution
1 0H s ave
samp
FOV FOVSNR N B f
N N
Spatial resolutionSpatial resolutionSpatial resolutionSpatial resolution
High contrast spatial resolution requires small voxels:• Large matrix• Small FOV• Thin slices
= FOV / N Resolution (frequency-encoding direction
= FOV / N Resolution (phase encoding direction)
slice Resolution (slice
Trade-offs: • Longer scan time if phase matrix is increased
• Reduced SNR improve with 3T imaging
direction)
Tscan = TR Nave N Acquisition time
1.5T 1.5T 3T 3T
3T3T–– trade additional SNR for increased spatial trade additional SNR for increased spatial resolution or faster scan time resolution or faster scan time
FSE T2W w/ fat sat,FSE T2W w/ fat sat,
FOV 220mm, 256x192, 4mmFOV 220mm, 256x192, 4mm
FSE T2W w/ fat sat, FSE T2W w/ fat sat,
FOV 200mm, 320x192, 3mmFOV 200mm, 320x192, 3mm
D.M.Reeve: AAPM 2011
2
Breast MRI ArtifactsBreast MRI Artifacts
Common artifacts in breast MRICommon artifacts in breast MRI
•• MotionMotion
•• Truncation artifactsTruncation artifacts
Out of volume wrapOut of volume wrap•• Out of volume wrapOut of volume wrap
•• SusceptibilitySusceptibility artifactsartifacts
•• Signal nonSignal non--uniformityuniformity
•• Poor or nonPoor or non--uniform fat saturationuniform fat saturation
Motion artifactsMotion artifactsOccur in the phase encoding direction. Caused by cardiac Occur in the phase encoding direction. Caused by cardiac motion, respiration, patient movement. Results in phase motion, respiration, patient movement. Results in phase mismis--mapping in kmapping in k--space due the time delay between space due the time delay between phasephase--encoding and signal readout. encoding and signal readout.
Truncation ArtifactsTruncation ArtifactsTruncation ArtifactsTruncation Artifacts•• Occur at high contrast edges.Occur at high contrast edges.
•• Also Also known known as Gibbs or as Gibbs or “ringing” artifact“ringing” artifact..
•• Can occur in either phase or frequency direction.Can occur in either phase or frequency direction.
•• Minimized Minimized by increasing matrix by increasing matrix sizesizeHi h t t ti l l ti iHi h t t ti l l ti i•• High contrast spatial resolution improvesHigh contrast spatial resolution improves
•• Scan time also increases if phase matrix is increasedScan time also increases if phase matrix is increased
•• SNR reducedSNR reduced
Object profile Measured intensity profile
Truncation ArtifactsTruncation ArtifactsFrequency
Pha
se
Small ACR phantom in 3T GESmall ACR phantom in 3T GE HD Breast array HD Breast array
320x192 matrix320x192 matrix 320x320 matrix320x320 matrix
Aliasing or “WrapAliasing or “Wrap--Around” Around” ArtifactsArtifacts
Aliasing or “WrapAliasing or “Wrap--Around” Around” ArtifactsArtifacts
FOV
Aliased to lower frequencyAliased to
higher
-fmax fmaxf0
gfrequency
Aliased imagef f faliased true Nyquist 2
Phase
Aliasing or “WrapAliasing or “Wrap--Around” Around” ArtifactsArtifacts
•• Increase FOV to include entire Increase FOV to include entire object object -- increase phaseincrease phase--encode encode steps to maintain resolution steps to maintain resolution (trade(trade--off: off: impacts scan time) impacts scan time)
Phase
•• Swap phase and frequencySwap phase and frequency--encoding directions : shorter encoding directions : shorter dimension in phasedimension in phase--encoding encoding directiondirection. (trade-off: motion artifacts)
•• Use “No phase wrap” or “antiUse “No phase wrap” or “anti--aliasing” techniques.aliasing” techniques.
D.M.Reeve: AAPM 2011
3
Peripheral signal artifact(annefact, star artifact)
Peripheral signal artifact(annefact, star artifact)
e
FSE: Star artifact – bright signal close tocenter of images.
FSE: Spine exam using phased arraysurface coil .
Pha
se
Pha
se
Signal originates in region where gradients are nonlinear. FID from 180 pulses not crushed – aliases back into image.
Magnetic Susceptibility ArtifactsMagnetic Susceptibility ArtifactsMagnetic Susceptibility ArtifactsMagnetic Susceptibility Artifacts
Metallic objects can cause distortions of the static and Metallic objects can cause distortions of the static and gradient fields, RF fields, or bothgradient fields, RF fields, or both Ferromagnetic objects Ferromagnetic objects -- distort Bdistort Boo and Band B1 1 fieldsfields
NonNon--ferromagnetic metal objects ferromagnetic metal objects -- distort Bdistort B11 fieldsfields
Typical effects are Typical effects are signal voids signal voids
and and geometric distortionsgeometric distortions..
Most noticeable on GRE (rather thanMost noticeable on GRE (rather than
SE or FSE). Appearance reduced SE or FSE). Appearance reduced
with wider receive BW, shorter TE.with wider receive BW, shorter TE.
Frequency selective fat satFrequency selective fat sat
•• FrequencyFrequency--selective fat or silicone saturation is routinely selective fat or silicone saturation is routinely used in breast imaging. Frequency of saturation pulse must used in breast imaging. Frequency of saturation pulse must match resonant frequency of fat/silicone. match resonant frequency of fat/silicone.
•• Selection of resonant peak usually automated, but may Selection of resonant peak usually automated, but may require manual adjustment require manual adjustment Technologist training Technologist training essential.essential.
•• Uniform saturation dependent on homogeneity of BUniform saturation dependent on homogeneity of B0 0 field field within the imaged volume:within the imaged volume:
•• challenge (breasts off challenge (breasts off isocenterisocenter))
•• shimming is importantshimming is important
Fat/silicone saturation - peak selectionFat/silicone saturation - peak selection
f
~220 Hz ~100 Hz 1.5T
~200 Hz 3T (fat-water separation 3.5 ppm)
~440 Hz
Effective chemicallyEffective chemically--
waterfat
silicone
Increasing frequency
selective fat or silicone selective fat or silicone saturation depends on saturation depends on accurate peak selection. accurate peak selection.
GE: center on water, saturates GE: center on water, saturates fat signal at fat signal at --220Hz 220Hz
Composition of breast tissueComposition of breast tissue
Glandular tissueGlandular tissue SiliconeSilicone Adipose tissueAdipose tissue
Composition of breast tissue (adipose/glandular/silicone) determines Composition of breast tissue (adipose/glandular/silicone) determines appearance of spectrum. Selecting the correct peak to achieve fat or appearance of spectrum. Selecting the correct peak to achieve fat or
silicone saturation can be challenging.silicone saturation can be challenging.
T2 FSE,T2 FSE, fat satfat sat
Left breast Left breast Right breast Right breast
Difference in center frequency 440 Hz (3.5 Difference in center frequency 440 Hz (3.5 ppmppm) ) = 3T difference in = 3T difference in resonant frequency between fatresonant frequency between fat--water. water. CCentered on entered on fat peak fat peak fat sat fat sat failure.failure.
CF 128,173,640 Hz CF 128,173,200 Hz
D.M.Reeve: AAPM 2011
4
3D3D T1 postT1 post--contrast dynamic, fat satcontrast dynamic, fat sat
Left breast Left breast Right breast Right breast
Center frequency = 128,173,593Center frequency = 128,173,593
Good fat saturation achieved on both sidesGood fat saturation achieved on both sides
ShimmingShimming•• Shim volume Shim volume –– useruser prescribes graphicallyprescribes graphically
•• Current in shim coils adjusted to optimize BCurrent in shim coils adjusted to optimize B00 field field uniformity within the volume. Improves uniformity of fat uniformity within the volume. Improves uniformity of fat saturation.saturation.
Saturation failureSaturation failure
•• Bandwidth of the Bandwidth of the sat pulse sat pulse centered on fat sufficient to centered on fat sufficient to saturate both fat and siliconesaturate both fat and siliconesignalsignal –– both appearboth appear dark.dark.
T2W fast spin-echoTR =3500ms / TE =86 ms echo train length = 8122 Hz/pixel bandwidth 256x256 matrix, 200 mm FOV1 averagefat sat
•• Incomplete saturation of fat Incomplete saturation of fat and/or silicone can occur in and/or silicone can occur in regions with large static regions with large static magnetic field magnetic field inhomogeneties. inhomogeneties.
AuroraSUPERSHIMTM
One vendor’s shim coil system is designed to improve fat One vendor’s shim coil system is designed to improve fat suppression suppression in breast MR imaging in breast MR imaging
ShimmingShimming
typical typical MRI MRI Aurora Aurora MRI MRI
Oval shape and positioned more anterior so that bilateral breast Oval shape and positioned more anterior so that bilateral breast tissue is centered within shim volume.tissue is centered within shim volume.
http://www.auroramri.com/mri/index.shtml
Signal uniformity and breast coil design
1.5T 1.5T SentinelleSentinelle coil coil --
axial image of small axial image of small ACR phantomACR phantom
3T GE HD array 3T GE HD array --
axial image of small axial image of small ACR phantomACR phantom
Breast MRI Quality ControlBreast MRI Quality Control
Quality control of MRI systems used for diagnostic breast MR imaging and biopsy guidance
• Is important to ensure production of high quality images by evaluating whether MRI scanner and coils used for breast imaging are performing consistently over timebreast imaging are performing consistently over time.
• Should be part of a comprehensive MRI quality control program.
• May be required to satisfy accreditation program requirements
D.M.Reeve: AAPM 2011
5
ACR Breast MRI Accreditation ProgramACR Breast MRI Accreditation Program
ACR Breast Magnetic Resonance Imaging Accreditation Program ACR Breast Magnetic Resonance Imaging Accreditation Program (BMRAP) launched in May 2010 under breast imaging (BMRAP) launched in May 2010 under breast imaging accreditation programs (mammography, stereotactic breast accreditation programs (mammography, stereotactic breast biopsy, and breast ultrasound).biopsy, and breast ultrasound).
• Separate from the ACR MR Accreditation Program (MRAP)
• Provides accreditation for MR systems used for breast accreditation for MR systems used for breast imagingimaging::
•• Dedicated breast MRI systems orDedicated breast MRI systems or
•• Whole body MRI systems with Whole body MRI systems with
•• detachable tabledetachable table--top breast coiltop breast coil
•• dedicated tables with integrated breast coilsdedicated tables with integrated breast coils
ACR Breast MRI Accreditation ProgramACR Breast MRI Accreditation Program
•• Currently no phantom image submission.Currently no phantom image submission.
•• Clinical cases (bilateral) for each scanner acquired within 2 months* of Clinical cases (bilateral) for each scanner acquired within 2 months* of date on testing memorandum. Cases reviewed by two radiologists.date on testing memorandum. Cases reviewed by two radiologists.
•• BIBI--RADS category 1: negative, or 2: benign findingsRADS category 1: negative, or 2: benign findings
•• BIBI--RADS category 6: known, enhancing, biopsyRADS category 6: known, enhancing, biopsy--proven malignancyproven malignancy
CD/DVD must open in less than 2 minutesCD/DVD must open in less than 2 minutes•• CD/DVD must open in less than 2 minutes.CD/DVD must open in less than 2 minutes.
•• Quality control program and medical physicist involvement essentially the Quality control program and medical physicist involvement essentially the same as MRI Accreditation Program (MRAP)same as MRI Accreditation Program (MRAP)
•• Breast MRIBreast MRI--specific experience/training requirements for technologists specific experience/training requirements for technologists and radiologists.and radiologists.
IntersocietalIntersocietal Accreditation Commission Magnetic Accreditation Commission Magnetic Resonance Lab (ICAMRL) offers a breast MRI Resonance Lab (ICAMRL) offers a breast MRI accreditation option.accreditation option.•• No phantom image review.No phantom image review.
•• Clinical images acquired within the last year submitted for Clinical images acquired within the last year submitted for
ICAMRL Accreditation ProgramICAMRL Accreditation Program
C ca ages acqu ed w t t e ast yea sub tted oC ca ages acqu ed w t t e ast yea sub tted oreview.review.
•• Breast MRIBreast MRI--specific experience/training requirements for specific experience/training requirements for radiologists. radiologists.
•• Cost similar to ACR BMRAP program.Cost similar to ACR BMRAP program.
•• Quality control program established by Quality Assurance Quality control program established by Quality Assurance Committee and/or the Medical Director. Tests performed according Committee and/or the Medical Director. Tests performed according to manufacturer’s performance standards.to manufacturer’s performance standards.
•• Acceptance testing required after installation and major upgrades.Acceptance testing required after installation and major upgrades.
•• Periodic maintenance (PM) requiredPeriodic maintenance (PM) required
ICAMRL Accreditation ProgramICAMRL Accreditation Program
•• QC performed by MR technologist, service engineer, medical QC performed by MR technologist, service engineer, medical physicist or “qualified expert”. physicist or “qualified expert”.
•• Daily and periodic QC required Daily and periodic QC required •• Equipment function and safetyEquipment function and safety
•• Center frequencyCenter frequency
•• SNRSNR
•• UniformityUniformity
•• Artifact assessmentArtifact assessment
Breast MRI QCBreast MRI QC
Physicist:
• MRI system performance evaluation after scanner installation, annually and following major repair or hardware/software upgrade
A l QC f ll RF il (i l di b MRI il )• Annual QC of all RF coils (including breast MRI coils)
Service engineer:
• Periodic/preventative maintenance (PM). Frequency defined in service contract
MRI technologist:
• Daily/weekly phantom scans
Breast RF Coil Quality ControlBreast RF Coil Quality Control
ti ll di lwww.sentinellemedical.com
D.M.Reeve: AAPM 2011
6
Breast RF Coil Quality ControlBreast RF Coil Quality Control
Establish baseline coil performance in order to monitor coil
performance over time.
• Coil inspection
• Signal-to-noise ratio (SNR)
• Signal uniformity• Signal uniformity
• Phased array coils: compare SNR for individual channels
• Artifact evaluation (including ghosting)
• Using QC protocol
• Using clinical protocol
Coil inspection•• Inspect coil, cables, cable insulation, ports and Inspect coil, cables, cable insulation, ports and
connectors for damageconnectors for damage
•• Could present a safety issue or result in low SNR or Could present a safety issue or result in low SNR or image artifactsimage artifacts
Breast RF Coil Quality ControlBreast RF Coil Quality Control
image artifacts.image artifacts.
www.invivocorp.com
Coil testing:•• Important to test coils:
• after installation of new scanner or new coils• at least annually• whenever artifacts or coil problems occur
Breast RF Coil Quality ControlBreast RF Coil Quality Control
•• Manufacturers provide a coil manual for each coil• includes description of clinical use of the coil• may include detailed description of coil test procedure• may include pass/fail limits• may only say “establish baseline and monitor over time”
Coil testing:• Test all available coil configurations.
• Note any error messages.
• In our experience the vendor is more likely to respond
Breast RF Coil Quality ControlBreast RF Coil Quality Control
p y pto coil QC failure when manufacturer’s QC procedure is followed.
Uniformity:• Follow procedure in 2004 ACR MRI QC Manual (min,
max signal intensity within small ROI)
Artifact evaluation•• Evaluate images acquired using QC protocolEvaluate images acquired using QC protocol
•• To troubleshoot artifacts observed on patient images To troubleshoot artifacts observed on patient images may acquire images of homogeneous QC phantom may acquire images of homogeneous QC phantom
Breast RF Coil Quality ControlBreast RF Coil Quality Control
using clinical protocol.using clinical protocol.
Consistent scan/measurement methods: Consistent scan/measurement methods: Identical phantom and positioning within coil
•• Homogeneous phantom (sphere, cylinder, custom)Homogeneous phantom (sphere, cylinder, custom)•• ACR or other phantomACR or other phantom
Identical scan parameters:
Breast RF Coil Quality ControlBreast RF Coil Quality Control
p•• Pulse sequence, timing parameters, slice thickness and position, Pulse sequence, timing parameters, slice thickness and position,
matrix, FOV, receive bandwidth, etcmatrix, FOV, receive bandwidth, etc•• Record center frequency, transmit gain/attenuation, receiver Record center frequency, transmit gain/attenuation, receiver
gainsgains
Identical measurement methods, ROI positions•• SNR, signal uniformity, ghosting, stability testsSNR, signal uniformity, ghosting, stability tests•• Evaluation of channel performanceEvaluation of channel performance
D.M.Reeve: AAPM 2011
7
SNR methodsSNR methods
Signal Signal measured in ROI within magnitude imageSignal measured in ROI within magnitude image
Noise Noise measured in background of signal imageNoise measured in background of signal image NEMA approach: Noise measured in subtractionNEMA approach: Noise measured in subtraction NEMA approach: Noise measured in subtraction NEMA approach: Noise measured in subtraction
image: image: •• 2 images acquired with identical protocols and 2 images acquired with identical protocols and
prescanprescan parameters (center frequency, transmit parameters (center frequency, transmit gain/attenuation, receiver gains)gain/attenuation, receiver gains)
Noise measured in “pure noise” image acquired with Noise measured in “pure noise” image acquired with no RF excitation no RF excitation
Breast RF Coil Quality ControlBreast RF Coil Quality Control
Coronal Sagittal composite image Noise image
Images acquired with individual coil elements
Breast RF Coil Quality ControlBreast RF Coil Quality Control
Unilateral biopsy mode Bilateral imaging mode
• Signal ROI: SE T1, unilateral and bilateral imaging modes
• Noise image (no RF excitation)
Breast RF Coil Quality ControlBreast RF Coil Quality Control
Breast RF Coil Quality ControlBreast RF Coil Quality Control
The small ACR phantom may The small ACR phantom may be utilized for breast coil be utilized for breast coil quality control. Phantom quality control. Phantom contains objects that enable contains objects that enable evaluation of: evaluation of: geometric accuracygeometric accuracy
41
•• geometric accuracy geometric accuracy
•• high contrast spatial resolution high contrast spatial resolution
•• slice thickness accuracy slice thickness accuracy
•• slice position accuracy slice position accuracy
•• image intensity uniformityimage intensity uniformity
•• ghosting ghosting
•• low contrast detectabilitylow contrast detectability
Small ACR phantomsBilateral mode
Breast RF Coil Quality ControlBreast RF Coil Quality Control
SE, Philips Achieva 1.5T, 16 channel breast array
Images courtesy of R. Price, PhD
D.M.Reeve: AAPM 2011
8
SummarySummary
•• High quality breast MR images exhibit adequate SNR and contrast, High quality breast MR images exhibit adequate SNR and contrast, high resolution, absence of artifacts, and uniform fat/silicone high resolution, absence of artifacts, and uniform fat/silicone saturation. Compromises are often necessary to achieve this in saturation. Compromises are often necessary to achieve this in addition to good temporal resolution of the DCE series.addition to good temporal resolution of the DCE series.
•• Effective and uniform fat saturation can be challenging to achieve Effective and uniform fat saturation can be challenging to achieve and can be more consistent with technologist education and use ofand can be more consistent with technologist education and use ofand can be more consistent with technologist education and use of and can be more consistent with technologist education and use of proper shim techniques.proper shim techniques.
•• Two breast MRI accreditation programs are currently available Two breast MRI accreditation programs are currently available (ACR, ICAMRL)(ACR, ICAMRL)
•• A comprehensive quality control program, including testing of breast A comprehensive quality control program, including testing of breast RF coils, is important to ensure optimal performance and image RF coils, is important to ensure optimal performance and image quality of breast MRI systems.quality of breast MRI systems.
ReferencesReferences1. ACR Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) Quality Control Manual, 2004.
(under revision)
2. ACR Technical Standards for Diagnostic Medical Physics Performance Monitoring of MRI Equipment, revision 2009. www.acr.org
3. Breast MRI Accreditation Program Requirements, 7/27/2011. www.acr.org
4. ICAMRL 2010 Standards for Accreditation in Magnetic Resonance Imaging Parts I and II, 9/10.www.icamrl.org
5. Determination of Signal-to-Noise Radio (SNR) in Diagnostic Magnetic Resonance Imaging, NEMA Standards MS 1-2008. www.nema.org