+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Effectiveness of Ultrasound and Transcutaneous Electrical...

Effectiveness of Ultrasound and Transcutaneous Electrical...

Date post: 02-Jun-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 1 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
5
International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR) ISSN (Online): 2319-7064 Index Copernicus Value (2015): 78.96 | Impact Factor (2015): 6.391 Volume 6 Issue 2, February 2017 www.ijsr.net Licensed Under Creative Commons Attribution CC BY Effectiveness of Ultrasound and Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation in Postnatal Painful Breast Engorgement: A Comparative Study Apurva A. Mahadalkar 1 , S. Anandh 2 1 Intern, Krishna Institute of Medical Sciences Deemed University, Karad 2 Professor, Faculty of Physiotherapy, Krishna Institute of Medical Sciences Deemed University, Karad. Abstract: Introduction: Breast engorgement is a normal biological process that typically occurs within the first 3 to 5 days of postpartum. About 20 % postnatal mothers are affected with breast engorgement. Conventional therapy currently available for this problem are therapeutic massage, application of cold and hot packs, breast squeeze, administration of analgesics and use of binders. Objectives: To study effectiveness of ultrasound in postnatal painful breast engorgement. To study effectiveness of TENS in postnatal painful breast engorgement. To compare effectiveness of ultrasound and TENS in postnatal painful breast engorgement. Methods: Subjects between the ages of 18-35 years diagnosed with breast engorgement of Krishna hospital, Karad were selected for the study. Study was conducted on 30 subjects. Subjects were divided into two groups. Pre consent was taken from each participant. The subjects were divided into group A (TENS with conventional treatment) and group B (Ultrasound with conventional treatment). The interventions were carried out twice a day for 2 days. The outcome measures for the study were subjective which includes VAS scale, 6- point self-rated breast engorgement scale and Wong baker’s faces pain rating scale. Results: The data was statistically analysed using INSTAT software. The present study provide the evidence for the use of TENS and ultrasound along with conventional treatment including hot moist packs and therapeutic massage in the management of pain and tenderness and improving the lactation in painful breast engorgement. Keywords: Breast engorgement, ultrasound, transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation, hot moist packs, therapeutic massage 1. Introduction Breast feeding is the feeding of babies and young children with milk from a women’s breast. [1] health professionals recommend that breastfeeding begins within the first hour of a baby’s life and continue as often and as much as the baby wants. [2][3] during the first week of life babies may nurse roughly every two or three hours. The duration of the feeding is usually ten to fifteen minutes on each breast. [4] Advantages of breastfeeding: [5] 1) Composition: breast milk is ideal food with easy digestion and low osmotic load. It contains carbohydrate, fat, protein, minerals. 2) Protection against infection and deficiency state to baby. 3) Brest milk is a readily available food to the new born at body temperature and without any cost. 4) Natural contraception to mother. 5) Psychological benefit of mother-child bonding. 6) Helps involution of uterus. 7) No risk of allergy. Breast engorgement is a normal biological process that typically occurs within the first 3 to 5 days postpartum. Breast engorgement may result in the breasts becoming swollen, hard, throbbing, aching, tender, and painful. [6] Breast engorgement occurs in 72% [7] to 85% [8] of women. 2. Causes Breast engorgement is due to exaggerated normal venous and lymphatic engorgement of the breasts which precedes lactation. This in turn prevents escape of milk from the lactate system. Generally the onset is third or fourth day postpartum. 3. Symptoms 1) Considerable pain and feeling of tenderness or heaviness in both the breasts. 2) Generalized malaise or even transient rise of temperature. 3) Painful breast feeding. 4. Conventional Therapy 1) Hot moist packs: The application of local heat directly on the engorge breast promotes vasodilatation, and thus increases circulation and consequently the volume of milk in the breast, which physiologically, would lead to an increase in the engorgement. [9] However, no studies aimed at studying the hot compress specifically. It was used in association with massage. [10] 2) Therapeutic massage: Two main principles of therapeutic massage in lactation include mobilization of fluid with massage towards the axilla to facilitate lymph circulation and alternating gentle massage and hand expression to facilitate milk removal. [11] Ultrasound has been a part of clinical practice since sometimes back in the 1950’s. Ultrasound is a form of mechanical energy. Normal human sound range is from 16Hz to 15-20,000Hz. Beyond this upper limit, mechanical vibration is known as ultrasound. The frequencies used in therapy are typically between 1.0 and 3.0MHz. [12] Paper ID: ART2017851 1258
Transcript
Page 1: Effectiveness of Ultrasound and Transcutaneous Electrical ...ijsr.net/archive/v6i2/ART2017851.pdf · treated with therapeutic ultra sound receiving between 1 and 7 treatments (average

International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR) ISSN (Online): 2319-7064

Index Copernicus Value (2015): 78.96 | Impact Factor (2015): 6.391

Volume 6 Issue 2, February 2017 www.ijsr.net

Licensed Under Creative Commons Attribution CC BY

Effectiveness of Ultrasound and Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation in Postnatal Painful

Breast Engorgement: A Comparative Study Apurva A. Mahadalkar1, S. Anandh2

1Intern, Krishna Institute of Medical Sciences Deemed University, Karad

2Professor, Faculty of Physiotherapy, Krishna Institute of Medical Sciences Deemed University, Karad.

Abstract: Introduction: Breast engorgement is a normal biological process that typically occurs within the first 3 to 5 days ofpostpartum. About 20 % postnatal mothers are affected with breast engorgement. Conventional therapy currently available for this problem are therapeutic massage, application of cold and hot packs, breast squeeze, administration of analgesics and use of binders. Objectives: To study effectiveness of ultrasound in postnatal painful breast engorgement. To study effectiveness of TENS in postnatal painful breast engorgement. To compare effectiveness of ultrasound and TENS in postnatal painful breast engorgement. Methods: Subjects between the ages of 18-35 years diagnosed with breast engorgement of Krishna hospital, Karad were selected for the study. Study was conducted on 30 subjects. Subjects were divided into two groups. Pre consent was taken from each participant. The subjects were divided into group A (TENS with conventional treatment) and group B (Ultrasound with conventional treatment). The interventions were carried out twice a day for 2 days. The outcome measures for the study were subjective which includes VAS scale, 6-point self-rated breast engorgement scale and Wong baker’s faces pain rating scale. Results: The data was statistically analysed using INSTAT software. The present study provide the evidence for the use of TENS and ultrasound along with conventional treatment including hot moist packs and therapeutic massage in the management of pain and tenderness and improving the lactation in painful breast engorgement.

Keywords: Breast engorgement, ultrasound, transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation, hot moist packs, therapeutic massage

1. Introduction

Breast feeding is the feeding of babies and young children with milk from a women’s breast.[1] health professionals recommend that breastfeeding begins within the first hour ofa baby’s life and continue as often and as much as the baby wants.[2][3] during the first week of life babies may nurse roughly every two or three hours. The duration of the feeding is usually ten to fifteen minutes on each breast.[4]

Advantages of breastfeeding:[5]

1) Composition: breast milk is ideal food with easy digestion and low osmotic load. It contains carbohydrate, fat, protein, minerals.

2) Protection against infection and deficiency state to baby. 3) Brest milk is a readily available food to the new born at

body temperature and without any cost. 4) Natural contraception to mother. 5) Psychological benefit of mother-child bonding. 6) Helps involution of uterus. 7) No risk of allergy.

Breast engorgement is a normal biological process that typically occurs within the first 3 to 5 days postpartum. Breast engorgement may result in the breasts becoming swollen, hard, throbbing, aching, tender, and painful.[6]Breast engorgement occurs in 72%[7] to 85%[8] ofwomen.

2. Causes

Breast engorgement is due to exaggerated normal venous and lymphatic engorgement of the breasts which precedes

lactation. This in turn prevents escape of milk from the lactate system. Generally the onset is third or fourth day postpartum.

3. Symptoms

1) Considerable pain and feeling of tenderness or heaviness in both the breasts.

2) Generalized malaise or even transient rise of temperature. 3) Painful breast feeding.

4. Conventional Therapy

1) Hot moist packs: The application of local heat directly onthe engorge breast promotes vasodilatation, and thus increases circulation and consequently the volume ofmilk in the breast, which physiologically, would lead toan increase in the engorgement.[9]However, no studies aimed at studying the hot compress specifically. It was used in association with massage.[10]

2) Therapeutic massage: Two main principles of therapeutic massage in lactation include mobilization of fluid with massage towards the axilla to facilitate lymph circulation and alternating gentle massage and hand expression tofacilitate milk removal.[11]

Ultrasound has been a part of clinical practice since sometimes back in the 1950’s. Ultrasound is a form ofmechanical energy. Normal human sound range is from 16Hz to 15-20,000Hz. Beyond this upper limit, mechanical vibration is known as ultrasound. The frequencies used intherapy are typically between 1.0 and 3.0MHz.[12]

Paper ID: ART2017851 1258

painful breast engorgement. compare effectiveness of postnatal painful breast engorgement. Methods: of 18-35 years diagnosed with breast engorgement of Krishna hospital, Karad were selected for the study. of Krishna hospital, Karad were selected for the study. of

30 subjects. Subjects were divided into two groups. Pre consent was taken from each participant. The subjects were divided into group A (TENS with conventional treatment) and group B (Ultrasound with conventional treatment). The interventions were carried out twice a day for 2 days. The outcome measures for the study were subjective which includes day for 2 days. The outcome measures for the study were subjective which includes daypoint self-rated breast engorgement scale and Wong baker’s faces pain rating scale. Results: The data was statistically analysed using INSTAT software. The present study provide the evidence for the use of TENS and ultrasound along with conventional treatment of TENS and ultrasound along with conventional treatment ofincluding hot moist packs and therapeutic massage in the management of pain and tenderness and improving the lactation of pain and tenderness and improving the lactation of

Breast engorgement, ultrasound, transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation, hot moist packs, therapeutic massage

the feeding of babies and young children of babies and young children ofwomen’s breast.[1] health professionals

recommend that breastfeeding begins within the first hour of life and continue as often and as much as the baby

during the first week of life babies may nurse of life babies may nurse of three hours. The duration of the of the of fifteen minutes on each breast.[4]

breastfeeding:[5]

Composition: breast milk is ideal food with easy digestion and low osmotic load. It contains carbohydrate, It contains carbohydrate, It

Protection against infection and deficiency state to baby. a readily available food to the new born at

lactation. This in turn prevents escape in turn prevents escape inlactate system. Generally the onset postpartum.

3. Symptoms

1) Considerable pain and feeling in both the breasts. in both the breasts. in

2) Generalized malaise or even transient rise or even transient rise or3) Painful breast feeding.

4. Conventional Therapy

1) Hot moist packs: The application the engorge breast promotes vasodilatation, and thus increases circulation and consequently the volume

Page 2: Effectiveness of Ultrasound and Transcutaneous Electrical ...ijsr.net/archive/v6i2/ART2017851.pdf · treated with therapeutic ultra sound receiving between 1 and 7 treatments (average

International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR) ISSN (Online): 2319-7064

Index Copernicus Value (2015): 78.96 | Impact Factor (2015): 6.391

Volume 6 Issue 2, February 2017 www.ijsr.net

Licensed Under Creative Commons Attribution CC BY

Ultrasound works on the principle of piezo electric effect caused by vibration of crystals within the head of the probe.

Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) is a commonly used non pharmacological and noninvasive treatment for pain. TENS is the application of electrical current through electrodes placed on the skin for pain control. It can be applied with varying frequency, from low (<10 Hz) to high (>50Hz).[14]Low frequency is also known as acupuncture TENS has a low pulse rate. It acts bystimulating the A-delta nerve fibres to produce endorphins which in turn relieve pain.

5. Review of Literature

Pawar Priyanka, Ramnavr A, Geeta Kurhade, Arvind Kurhade, Rajaram Pawar. In their study of comparative effect of ultrasound therapy with conventional therapy onbreast engorgement in immediate post-partum mothers: a randomized controlled trial concluded that ultrasound therapy added with conventional therapy helps inreduction of pain with tender breast which further helps the post-partum mothers to recover better from discomfort of breast engorgement. This in turn can facilitate better breast feeding.

Valerie Lavigne and brian J. Gleberzon. In their retrospective case series study Ultrasound as a treatment of mammary blocked duct among 25 postpartum lactating women. Twenty – five cases were retrospectively identified of women who presented with a breast lump that was consistent with a blocked duct. Patients had been treated with therapeutic ultra sound receiving between 1 and 7 treatments (average 3.3) to experience improvement in their presenting symptoms. A majority of the patients reported improvement in breastfeeding and symptoms after treatment.no adverse reactions were identified in the patient record.

H. M. Snowden, Mary Josephine Renfrew, Michael Woolridge. In their study of Treatments for breast engorgement during lactation three different studies were identified which used cabbage leaves or cabbage leaves extract; no overall benefit was found. Ultrasound treatment and placebo were equally effective. Use ofDanzen (anti-inflammatory agent) significantly improve the symptoms.

Moumita Manna, Lily Podder, Sujata devi. In this study ofeffectiveness of hot fomentation versus cold compression on breast engorgement among postnatal mothers they concluded that hot fomentation and cold compression both are effective in reducing breast engorgement. Reduction inpain intensity score of cold compression group was significantly higher than that for the hot fomentation group. Reduction in breast engorgement score of cold compression group was not significantly higher than that for hot fomentation group.

Kalpana B., Rabinerson D, Pardo J, Krieser RU, Neri A.In their study of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation as a pain- relief device in obstetrics and gynecology concluded that in obstetrics and gynecology, TENS has been found to be effective in alleviating labour pain and in the treatment of dysmenorrhea. Patients and medical staff should be encourage to try the TENS device

for obstetric and gynecological indications, since it is non- invasive, efficient and easy to use.

6. Material and Methodology

Subjects between the age of 18-35 years diagnosed with breast engorgement of Krishna hospital, Karad were selected for the study. Study was conducted on 30 subjects. Subjects were divided into two groups. Pre consent was taken from each participant. The subjects were divided into group A (TENS with conventional treatment) and group B (Ultrasound with conventional treatment). The interventions were carried out twice a day for 2 days. The outcome measures for the study were subjective which includes VAS scale, 6-point self-rated breast engorgement scale and Wong baker’s faces pain rating scale.

6.1 Outcome Measures

1. Visual analogue scale: The VAS has shown greater sensitivity than discrete points of categorical scale. The pain rating scale allows the subject to visually gauge the amount of pain along a solid 10 cm line. Where 0 represent no pain and 10represent maximum pain.

2. 6-Point self-rated engorgement scale: The scale scoring ranges from 1 to 6. Scring is given by

the patient. 3. Wong bakers faces pain rating scale :

The scale is developed by Donna Wong and Connie Baker. The scale shows series of faces ranging from happy face at 0 “no hurt” to crying face at 10 “ hurts worst”

4. Statistical analysis Statistical analysis was done using 1) INSTAT software. 2) Intra group comparison (within group) using paired t test. 3) Inter group comparison (between group) using unpaired t

test.

7. Results

1. Age distribution: In the present study mean age distribution in group A was 25.13±2.41 and mean age distribution in group B was 24.93±2.89 which showed nostatistical difference in both the groups suggesting mean ageof both the groups were same.

Graph 1: Age distribution in group A and B

Paper ID: ART2017851 1259

randomized controlled trial concluded that ultrasound therapy added with conventional therapy helps in

pain with tender breast which further helps thers to recover better from discomfort

breast engorgement. This in turn can facilitate better can facilitate better can

Valerie Lavigne and brian J. Gleberzon. In their In their Inretrospective case series study Ultrasound as a treatment

mammary blocked duct among 25 postpartum lactating five cases were retrospectively

women who presented with a breast lump that was consistent with a blocked duct. Patients had been treated with therapeutic ultra sound receiving between 1 and 7 treatments (average 3.3) to experience improvement

their presenting symptoms. A majority of the patients of the patients ofreported improvement in breastfeeding and symptoms in breastfeeding and symptoms inafter treatment.no adverse reactions were identified in the in the in

Snowden, Mary Josephine Renfrew, Michael their study of Treatments for breast of Treatments for breast of

engorgement during lactation three different studies were identified which used cabbage leaves or cabbage leaves or cabbage leaves or

overall benefit was found. Ultrasound treatment and placebo were equally effective. Use ofDanzen (anti-inflammatory agent) significantly improve

1. Visual analogue scale: The VAS has shown greater sensitivity than discrete points of categorical scale. The pain rating scale allows of categorical scale. The pain rating scale allows ofthe subject to visually gauge the amount solid 10 cm line. Where 0 represent cm line. Where 0 represent cmrepresent maximum pain.

2. 6-Point self-rated engorgement scale: The scale scoring ranges from 1

the patient. 3. Wong bakers faces pain rating scale :

The scale is developed by Donna Wong and Connie by Donna Wong and Connie byBaker. The scale shows series happy face at 0 at 0 at “no hurt” to crying face worst”

4. Statistical analysis Statistical analysis was done using 1) INSTAT software. 2) Intra group comparison (within group) using paired t test. 3) Inter group comparison (between group) using unpaired t

test.

7. Results

1. Age distribution: In the present study mean age In the present study mean age Indistribution in group A was 25.13±2.41 and mean age in group A was 25.13±2.41 and mean age indistribution in group B was 24.93±2.89 which showed in group B was 24.93±2.89 which showed in

Page 3: Effectiveness of Ultrasound and Transcutaneous Electrical ...ijsr.net/archive/v6i2/ART2017851.pdf · treated with therapeutic ultra sound receiving between 1 and 7 treatments (average

International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR) ISSN (Online): 2319-7064

Index Copernicus Value (2015): 78.96 | Impact Factor (2015): 6.391

Volume 6 Issue 2, February 2017 www.ijsr.net

Licensed Under Creative Commons Attribution CC BY

Table 1: Age distribution in group A and B

Parameter Group A Group B ‘p’ value ‘t’ valueMean SD Mean SDAge 25.13 2.41 24.93 2.89 0.8386 0.2056

2. Outcome measures:

1. Visual analogue scale: In the present study pre interventional mean of Visual analogue scale was 6.49±1.20 in Group A and 6.15±1.33 inGroup B whereas post-interventional mean of Visual analogue scale was 2.27±1.02 in Group A and 2.56±0.99 inGroup B respectively

Graph 2: Comparison of Mean Pre-treatment and post-treatment VAS score of group A and B

Table 2: Comparison of Mean Pre-treatment and post-treatment VAS score of group A and B

GroupsPre-treatment

VAS scorePost-treatment

VAS score ‘p’ value ‘t’value

Mean SD Mean SDTens

(Group A) 6.49 1.20 2.27 1.02 < 0.0001 20.15

Ultrasound(Group B) 6.15 1.33 2.56 0.99 < 0.0001 18.31

2. 6-Point breast engorgement scale In the present study pre interventional mean of 6-Point breast engorgement scale was 4.53±0.99 in Group A and 4±0.92 in Group B whereas post-interventional mean of 6-Point breast engorgement scale was 2.066±0.70 in Group A and 1.66±0.72 in Group B respectively.

Graph 3: Comparison of Mean Pre-treatment and post-treatment 6-point breast engorgement scale score of group A

and B

Table 3: Comparison of Mean Pre-treatment and post-treatment 6-point breast engorgement scale score of group A

and B

Groups

Pre-treatment 6-point breast

engorgementscale score

Post-treatment 6-point breast

engorgementscale score

‘p’value

‘t’value

Mean SD Mean SDTens

(Group A) 4.53 0.99 2.06 0.70 <0.0001 12.85

Ultrasound(Group B) 4 0.92 1.66 0.72 <

0.0001 18.52

3. Wong bakers faces pain rating scale: In the present study pre interventional mean of Wong bakers faces pain rating scale was 6.53±1.76 in Group A and 5.6±1.54 in Group B whereas post-interventional mean ofWong bakers faces pain rating scale was 1.73±1.48in Group A and 1.46±1.4 in Group B respectively.

Groups

Pre-treatmentWong bakers

faces painrating scale

score

Post-treatmentWong bakers

faces pain ratingscale score

‘p’ value ‘t’ value

Mean SD Mean SDTENS

(Group A) 6.53 1.76 1.73 1.48 < 0.0001 18.33

Ultrasound(Group B) 5.6 1.54 1.46 1.4 < 0.0001 13.48

Graph 4: Comparison of Mean Pre-treatment and post-treatment Wong bakers faces pain rating scale score of

group A and B

Table 4: Comparison of Mean Pre-treatment and post-treatment Wong bakers faces pain rating scale score ofgroup A and B

8. Discussion

The study “Effectiveness of ultrasound and TENS with conventional treatment in postnatal painful breast engorgement: A comparative study” was conducted tocompare the two treatments and find out the best treatment method for breast engorgement. Breast engorgement is a normal biological process that typically occurs within the first 3 to 5 days postpartum. Breast engorgement may result in the breasts becoming swollen, hard, throbbing, aching, tender, and painful.

Paper ID: ART2017851 1260

Comparison of Mean Pre-treatment and post-of Mean Pre-treatment and post-oftreatment VAS score of group A and B of group A and B of

of Mean Pre-treatment and post-treatment VAS score of group A and B

treatmentscore

Post-treatmentVAS score ‘p’ value ‘t’

valueSD Mean SD

1.20 2.27 1.02 < 0.0001 20.15

1.33 2.56 0.99 < 0.0001 18.31

6-Point breast engorgement scale the present study pre interventional mean of 6-Point of 6-Point of

breast engorgement scale was 4.53±0.99 in Group A and in Group A and in Group B whereas post-interventional mean of 6-of 6-of

Point breast engorgement scale was 2.066±0.70 in Group A in Group A in Group B respectively.

Groups

Pre-treatmentWong bakers

faces painrating scale

score

Post-treatmentWong

faces painscale

Mean SD MeanTENS

(Group A) 6.53 1.76 1.73

Ultrasound(Group B) 5.6 1.54 1.46

Graph 4: Comparison of Mean Pre-treatment and post-of Mean Pre-treatment and post-oftreatment Wong bakers faces pain rating scale score

group A and B

Page 4: Effectiveness of Ultrasound and Transcutaneous Electrical ...ijsr.net/archive/v6i2/ART2017851.pdf · treated with therapeutic ultra sound receiving between 1 and 7 treatments (average

International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR) ISSN (Online): 2319-7064

Index Copernicus Value (2015): 78.96 | Impact Factor (2015): 6.391

Volume 6 Issue 2, February 2017 www.ijsr.net

Licensed Under Creative Commons Attribution CC BY

Study was conducted on 30 subjects. Subjects were divided into two groups. Pre consent was taken from each participant. The subjects were divided into group A (TENS with conventional treatment) and group B (Ultrasound with conventional treatment). The interventions were carried outtwice a day for 2 days. The outcome measures for the study were subjective which includes VAS scale, 6-point self-rated breast engorgement scale and Wong baker’s faces pain rating scale.

This study shows significant difference in the pre and post treatment values in both the groups. The present study supported null hypothesis which stated that there is nosignificant difference between the effectiveness ofultrasound and TENS in postnatal painful breast engorgement. This was confirmed using statistical analysis by using ‘Paired t- test’ for within group comparison and ‘Unpaired t-test’ for between the group comparisons. In the present study, we found that after intervention there was significant improvement in the outcome of both the groups and both the treatment methods are equally effective to treat painful breast engorgement.

In the present study mean age distribution in group A was 25.13±2.41 and mean age distribution in group B was 24.93±2.89 which showed no statistical difference in both the groups suggesting mean age of both the groups were same.

1) Visual analogue scale In the present study pre interventional mean of Visual analogue scale was 6.49±1.20 in Group A and 6.15±1.33 inGroup B whereas post-interventional mean of Visual analogue scale was 2.27±1.02 in Group A and 2.56±0.99 inGroup B respectively. Pre interventional mean of Visual analogue scale showed no statistical difference in both the groups which suggest that the mean score was same in both the groups. Intra group statistical analysis revealed statistically significant increase in post interventional for both the groups. This was done by using paired t test Group A (t=20.15, p=0.001), Group B (t=18.311, p=0.001)

The pre and post treatment values of visual analogue scale shows extremely significant difference in group A (t=20.15) and group B (t=18.31). Post treatment values of both the groups do not show significant difference.

2) 6-point self-rated breast engorgement scale: In the present study pre interventional mean of 6-Point breast engorgement scale was 4.53±0.99 in Group A and 4±0.92 in Group B whereas post-interventional mean of 6-Point breast engorgement scale was 2.066±0.70 in Group A and 1.66±0.72 in Group B respectively. Pre interventional mean of 6-Point breast engorgement scale showed nostatistical difference in both the groups which suggest that the mean score was same in both the groups. Intra group statistical analysis revealed statistically significant increase in post interventional for both the groups. This was done byusing paired t test Group A (t=12.853, p=0.001), Group B (t=18.520, p=0.001)

The pre and post treatment values of 6-point self-rated breast engorgement scale shows extremely significant difference in

group A (t=12.85) and group B (t=18.52). Post treatment values of both the groups do not show significant difference.

3) Wong bakers faces pain rating scale: In the present study pre interventional mean of Wong bakers faces pain rating scale was 6.53±1.76 in Group A and 5.6±1.54 in Group B whereas post-interventional mean ofWong bakers faces pain rating scale was 1.73±1.48in Group A and 1.46±1.4 in Group B respectively. Pre interventional mean of Wong bakers faces pain rating scale showed nostatistical difference in both the groups which suggest that the mean score was same in both the groups. Intra group statistical analysis revealed statistically significant increase in post interventional for both the groups. This was done byusing paired t test Group A (t=18.330, p=0.001), Group B (t=13.484, p=0.001)

The pre and post treatment values of Wong bakers faces pain rating scale shows extremely significant difference in group A (t=18.33) and group B (t=13.48). Post treatment values ofboth the groups do not show significant difference.

Hence the present study can provide the evidence for the use of TENS and ultrasound along with conventional treatment including hot moist packs and therapeutic massage in the management of pain and tenderness and improving the lactation in painful breast engorgement.

9. Conclusion

In conclusion, the present study provided evidence tosupport the use of both treatments methods i.e. TENS and ultrasound for painful breast engorgement. In addition, result supported that there is no significant difference between effectiveness of ultrasound and TENS with conventional treatment in postnatal painful breast engorgement. Thus the null hypothesis is proved.

10. Further Scope

The Sample size used in this study was relatively small. This makes it difficult to extrapolate the results on general population. This study can be done on larger population.

References

[1] “Breastfeeding and breast milk: condition information.”2013-12-19. Retrieved 27 July 2015.

[2] “Infant and young child feeding fact sheet N.342.”WHO. February 2014. Retrieved February 8, 2015.

[3] American Academy of paediatrics section onbreastfeeding. March 2012 “Breastfeeding and the use of human milk” paediatrics 129(3):827-841.Doi:10.1542/peds2011-3552. PMID 22371471.

[4] “How do I breastfeed? Skip sharing on social media links” 2014-04-14. Retrieved 27 July 2015.

[5] Brest feeding. D C Dutta’s textbook of obstetrics including perinatology and contraception. Enlarged and Revised Reprint of Reventh Edition. November 2013.

[6] Mangesi L. Dowswell T, The Cochrane Collaboration. Treatments for breast engorgement during lactation (review) John Wiley & sons; 2010.

Paper ID: ART2017851 1261

in the outcome of both the groups of both the groups ofand both the treatment methods are equally effective to treat painful breast engorgement.

the present study mean age distribution in group A was in group A was in25.13±2.41 and mean age distribution in group B was in group B was in24.93±2.89 which showed no statistical difference in both in both inthe groups suggesting mean age of both the groups were of both the groups were of

Visual analogue scale the present study pre interventional mean of Visual of Visual of

analogue scale was 6.49±1.20 in Group A and 6.15±1.33 inGroup B whereas post-interventional mean of Visual of Visual ofanalogue scale was 2.27±1.02 in Group A and 2.56±0.99 inGroup B respectively. Pre interventional mean of Visual of Visual of

no statistical difference in both the in both the ingroups which suggest that the mean score was same in both in both inthe groups. Intra group statistical analysis revealed statistically significant increase in post interventional for in post interventional for inboth the groups. This was done by using paired t test Group by using paired t test Group byA (t=20.15, p=0.001), Group B (t=18.311, p=0.001)

The pre and post treatment values of visual analogue scale of visual analogue scale ofshows extremely significant difference in group A (t=20.15) in group A (t=20.15) inand group B (t=18.31). Post treatment values of both the of both the of

A (t=18.33) and group B (t=13.48). Post treatment values both the groups do not show significant difference.

Hence the present study can provide the evidence for the use of TENS and ultrasound along with conventional treatment of TENS and ultrasound along with conventional treatment ofincluding hot moist packs and therapeutic massage management of pain and tenderness and improving the of pain and tenderness and improving the oflactation in painful breast engorgement. in painful breast engorgement. in

9. Conclusion

In conclusion, the present study provided evidence In conclusion, the present study provided evidence Insupport the use of both treatments methods i.e. TENS and of both treatments methods i.e. TENS and ofultrasound for painful breast engorgement. supported that there is no significant difference between effectiveness of ultrasound and TENS with conventional of ultrasound and TENS with conventional oftreatment in postnatal painful breast engorgement. Thus the in postnatal painful breast engorgement. Thus the innull hypothesis is proved.

10. Further Scope

The Sample size used in this study was relatively small. This in this study was relatively small. This inmakes it difficult it difficult it to extrapolate the results population. This study can be done

References

Page 5: Effectiveness of Ultrasound and Transcutaneous Electrical ...ijsr.net/archive/v6i2/ART2017851.pdf · treated with therapeutic ultra sound receiving between 1 and 7 treatments (average

International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR) ISSN (Online): 2319-7064

Index Copernicus Value (2015): 78.96 | Impact Factor (2015): 6.391

Volume 6 Issue 2, February 2017 www.ijsr.net

Licensed Under Creative Commons Attribution CC BY

[7] Hill PD, Humenick SS. The occurrence of breast engorgement. J Hum Lact 1994 10(2):79-86.

[8] Whitley N. preparation of breastfeeding; a one year follow up of 34 nursing mothers. JOGN Nurs 1978:44-48.

[9] Academy of breastfeeding Medicine Protocol Committee; Berens P. ABM clinical protocol #20:Engorgement. Breastfeed Med.2009;4(2):111-3

[10] Chiu JY, Gau ML, Kuo SY, Chang YH, KuoSC,Tu HC. Effects of Gua-Sha Therapy on breast engorgement: a randomized controlled trail. J Nurse Res. 2010;18(1):1-10.

[11] Maya Bolman, Handling the pain:The role oftherapeutic breast massage in lactation.

[12] Tim Watson 2015, therapeutic ultrasound.[13] Ultrasound therapy: Clayton’s Electrotherapy, theory

and practice, eighth edition.[14] Josimari M. De Santana , Deidre M, Walsh, Carol

Vance, Barbara A, Rakel, Kathleena A, Sluka. Effectiveness of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation for treatment of hyperalegesia and pain.15)Mark john .electrical nerve stimulation.

Author Profile

Dr. Apurva A. Mahadalkar:I have done my BPTh, from Krishna college of Physiotherapy, Krishna Institute of Medical Sciences Deemed University, Karad- 415110. District: Satara, State: Maharashtra. I have done my research during graduation course inyear 2016-17 under the guidance of Dr. S. Anandh from Krishna college of Physiotherapy, KIMSU, Karad, and Maharashtra, India.

Dr. S. Anandh.I am physiotherapist Mastered in the field ofcommunity health sciences. Presently I am working as professor inKrishna college of Physiotherapy, Krishna Institute of Medical Sciences Deemed University, Karad.

Paper ID: ART2017851 1262

transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation for treatment of hyperalegesia and pain.of hyperalegesia and pain.of 15)Mark john .electrical nerve stimulation.

Mahadalkar:I have done my BPTh, from Krishna my BPTh, from Krishna my Physiotherapy, Krishna Institute of Medical Sciences

Deemed University, Karad- 415110. District: Satara, State: my research during graduation course my research during graduation course my in

under the guidance of Dr. of Dr. of S. Anandh from Krishna Physiotherapy, KIMSU, Karad, and Maharashtra, India.

physiotherapist Mastered in the field ofcommunity health sciences. Presently I am working as professor in

Physiotherapy, Krishna Institute of Medical of Medical ofSciences Deemed University, Karad.


Recommended