1
ELECTRICAL SAFETY FIRST:IMPROVING ELECTRICAL SAFETY AND PREVENTING FIRES IN WALES
2
Electrical Safety First
London Office45 Great Guildford StreetLondon SE1 0ES
Telephone: +44(0)203 463 5100Email: [email protected]
CONTENTS01. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 3
02. RECOMMENDATIONS 4
03. CONTEXT OF ESF’S POLICY AND LOBBYING WORK IN WALES 6
04. PUTTING THE RECOMMENDATIONS INTOPRACTICE–TRAININGAND FUNDING ISSUES 8
05. HOUSING IN SOUTH WALES 9
06. GRANTS FOR ELECTRICAL SAFETY IN WALES 11
07. CARE & REPAIR AUTHORITIES GRANT FUNDING-CASESTUDY 12
08. SOUTH WALES FIRE AND RESCUE SERVICE–WORKINGINPARTNERSHIP 15
09. ESF CONCLUSION & DISCUSSION POINTS 16
10. ANNEXES 18
32
EXECUTIVE SUMMARYIn July 2018, the Welsh Government produced a report entitled: Electrical Fires in Wales: A Review of the Evidencei, which Electrical Safety First (ESF) welcomed as a step forward in ascertaining which electrical sourcesofignitionremainathigherlevelsinWales,andinparticulartheSouthWalesFireandRescueServicearea.This paper documents ESF’s response and discusses resulting policy issues which will focus our work with stakeholders in Wales.
The Welsh Government report identifies the overall number of accidental dwelling fires in Wales is in sustained decline, but fires with an electrical distribution source have continued to rise in the last 15 years. The South Wales Fire and Rescue Service area has had the greatest increaseii.TheGovernmentgoesontosuggestthattheyfoundthattheincreaserelatestoelectricaldistributionfiresratherthanelectricalappliancesormobiledevices.Furthermore,theGovernmentwasunabletoidentifythecauseofthe increasesiii.
WhilstESFwelcomedtheGovernment’swillingnesstoundertakethisreview,webelievethattheresearchtodateraisesadditionalquestionsandhighlightsthefactthatfurthersafetyawarenessworkandbettersystems may need to be put in place to protect the Welsh publiciv.
ESFremainsconcernedaboutelectricalsafetyinWalesandthefirescausedbyelectricaldistribution.WebelievethattherecommendationsfoundintheGovernment’sreportneedtobefullyfunded,workableandadaptabletoensurefiresarereducedthroughanationalstrategyinvolvingtheFireandRescueAuthoritiesinWales.
ESFbelievesmoreresearchneedstobeundertakenintoelectricaldistributionfiresinSouthWalesduetotheageofthehousingstock,particularlyintheSouthWalesvalleysarea.Thepotentialageofinstallationsisofparticularinterest;howeverthereisalackofdataavailabletosupportthistheoryastheIncidentReportingSystemdoesnotrecordageofproperties.
ConsiderationoftheageofhousingissupportedbyanecdotalevidencethatESFhasobtainedduringvariousoutreacheventsinSouthWalesandinourdiscussionswithstakeholders,wherebyhome-ownersreportproblemstotheCharityabouttheageofelectricalinstallationsandtheirinabilitytoaffordelectricalimprovementsorrepairs.TheredonotappeartobeanysystemsinplaceorsustainablefundingmechanismstoassistthemostvulnerableWelshhomeownerswhohavebeenidentifiedasneedingelectricalimprovementsintheirhomes.ThispotentiallyunderminestheWelshGovernment’srecommendationtoreducefirescausedbyelectricalsourcesofignition.
ThisdocumentfocussesontheSouthWalesFireandRescueServiceregion,itsolderhousingstockandtheproactiveworkbeingundertakenbystakeholderstoreducefires.ItalsolooksatthepolicyproblemsthatneedaddressingtoprotecttheWelshpublicintheirhomes.
i https://gweddill.gov.wales/docs/dsjlg/publications/fire/180716-electrical-fires-in-wales-en.pdfii Ibid p6 iii Ibid p2 iv https://gov.wales/newsroom/people-and-communities/2018/new-report-on-electrical-fires-released/?lang=en
01.Im
pro
ving electrical safety an
d p
reventing fires in W
ales
4
RECOMMENDATIONSCommunicatingwiththeWelshPublic 2.1 TheWelshGovernmentshouldhelpco-ordinateacampaignonelectricalsafety,supportedbyWelsh
FRAsandtheCharity,followingtheexampleoftheHomeOffice’s‘FireKills’initiative.We would recommend a specific week of activities, similar to ‘Electrical Fire Safety Week’ but dedicated
to Wales.
2.2 National media advertising on electrical dangers, such as the straight-forward campaign undertaken by the Home Office recently, needs to be put in place by Welsh Governmentv. Other WelshGovernmentnationaladvertisingonsmoking,organdonationandchildcarealreadyexistsinWales,buttherestillexistsastrongneedforaco-ordinatedapproachonelectricaldangers,ledbytheWelshGovernment.
2.3 Onalocallevel,theCharitywillworkinpartnershipwithSouthWalesFireandRescueServicetoreducefirescausedbyelectricity,byraisingawarenessthroughsupportingsubject-basedcampaigns(i.e.whitegoodssafety)jointcommunications,researchinitiativesandappropriateoutreachevents.
2.4 TheCharitywillcontinuetobuildnewrelationshipswithNorth,MidandWestWalesFireServices,supportingtheircommunicationsworkonelectricalsafetyissuesandpreventionoffires.
POLICY IMPROVEMENTS2.5 Welsh Government should provide a specific grant to improve electrical safety in South Wales
for the most vulnerable owner-occupiers who cannot afford electrical safety improvements that have been identified as part of a Fire and Rescue Service Home Safety Visit. The Charity will help provide ring-fenced funding through its ‘Fire Safety Fund’ for use in the South Wales FRS area to improve the electrical safety of owner-occupiers in most need. A pilot area with the greatest need forimprovementsindomesticelectricalsafetycouldbechosen.WhilstelectricaldistributionhasbeenidentifiedinSouthWalesasakeysourceofelectricalfires,thereneedstobeacombinedapproachtoreducingelectricalfiresinWalesthroughtheworkoftheCharity,WelshGovernment,SouthWalesFireandRescueServiceandCare&RepairCymru.
2.6 Electrical safety checks should be provided for all Welsh households with a person over the age of 80.Thecostofthisinitiativewouldbe£5mmaximumperyear,asdetailedinourSwansea
Universityreportvi.
v https://www.gov.uk/government/news/new-campaign-warns-it-only-takes-one-accident-to-start-a-firevi https://www.electricalsafetyfirst.org.uk/media-centre/press-releases/2017/11/older-people-in-wales-are-more-at-risk-of-electrical-fires-and-
accidents/
02.El
ectr
ical
Saf
ety
Firs
t
54
PARTNERSHIPS2.7 The Charity will work with the Welsh Government and FRAs to ensure that electrical safety
problems are identified and referrals are actioned in order to support the Government’s recommendations.Atpresent,itisunderstoodthatidentifiedelectricalsafetyissuesarenotalwaysreferredcorrectlyandiftheyare,budgetsmaynotallowimprovementstobemade.Withanimprovedgrantscheme,betterguidanceneedstobedrafted.
2.8 The Charity will help train Fire Officers to improve their electrical safety knowledge in the South Wales Fire and Rescue Service area.WhilsttheWelshGovernmenthasrightlyidentifiedthatFireOfficersarenotelectricians,basicawarenessofelectricalhazardsandimprovingdatacaptureareessential.
IMPROVED DATA CAPTURE AND RESEARCH 2.9 TheCharitybelievesthat,whilsttheWelshGovernment’sanalysiscorrectlyidentifieselectrical
distributionasaprobleminSouthWales,weshouldnotneglectotherissues.Theseincludethemisuseofelectricity,productsafetyfailures,theincreasednumberofappliancesinhomes,andincreasedchargingofproducts,oftencombinedwitholderhousingstockandwiring.More research needs to be undertaken to fully understand the wider issues with electrical use in South Wales. We will aim to work with South Wales Fire and Rescue Service on potential research and future-proofing of data.
2.10 Thereisapotential,giventheageofpropertiesinSouthWalesthathomeownerscouldbelivinginpropertiesill-equippedtodealwithmodernliving.A lack of hard data makes this issue difficult to accurately determine which properties and people are at risk of fires caused by electricity and we would encourage further policy research between the Charity and the Welsh Government, to allow for informed Government and stakeholder-led consumer awareness campaigns.
2.11 ItisunknownhowmanypropertiesinWalesmayneedare-wire,orhaveunsafeelectricalinstallations,asdatafromStatisticsWalesdoesnotprovidesufficientinformation.Consideration should be given to surveying South Wales properties to determine the extent of the problem.
2.12 Welsh Government should report annually to the Senedd on electrical safety policy across Wales and progress being made to reduce electrical fires in Wales.
Imp
rovin
g electrical safety and
preventin
g fires in Wales
6
CONTEXT OF ESF’S POLICY AND LOBBYING WORK IN WALES 3.1 Since2016,therehavebeenthreemainissuesofconcerninWalesfortheCharity,aroundwhichwe
haveconcentratedourdiscussionswithMembersoftheNationalAssemblyforWales(AMs)andtheWelshGovernment,theseare:
•Firescausedbyelectricaldistribution,misuseofappliancesandlackofinformationonfirescausedbyelectricalitemsthatrequirecharging.
•Safetyoftenantswholiveintheprivateandsocialrentedsectors.
•Thesaleofelectricalgoods(counterfeit,substandardandsecond-hand)toWelshcitizens,oftenonline,whichcanbeunsafeorillegal.(ThelatterbeingamatterfortheUKGovernment).
3.2 TheCharityhasmadeprogressinimprovingconsumerprotectioninWalesforpeoplelivingintheprivateandsocialrentedsectors.ButacontinuingkeypriorityistheneedtounderstandwhymorefiresarecausedbyelectricalsourcesofignitioninWalesthananywhereelseintheUK.
3.3 OurlobbyingduringthepassageoftheRentingHomes(Wales)Bill,(nowtheRentingHomes(Wales)Act),sawtheWelshGovernmentacknowledgetheneedtoprotecttenantsinWalesbystatingitsintentiontointroducemandatoryelectricalsafetychecksintheprivateandsocialrentedsectors.Previously,theWelshGovernmentrejectedtheneedforfurtherregulationoftherespectivesectors.Thispolicywillhaveasignificantimpactonprotectingpeoplelivinginthosesectorsfromelectricalaccidentsandfires.
3.4 DiscussionsledbytheCharityandlobbyingbyAssemblyMembersresultedintheWelshGovernmentagreeingtolookincloserdetailatfirescausedbyelectricityinWelshhomes.ThisledtosignificantresearchandconsequentpublicationofthereportbytheWelshGovernment,‘Electrical Fires in Wales–AReviewofEvidence’vii.
viihttps://gweddill.gov.wales/docs/dsjlg/publications/fire/180716-electrical-fires-in-wales-en.pdf
03.
6
Elec
tric
al S
afet
y Fi
rst
76
PRIVATE RENTED SECTORINWALES–POLICY PROGRESS3.5 DuringthepassageoftheRentingHomes(Wales)BilltheCharitywasabletoensurethatourpolicy
ask-ensuringmandatoryelectricalsafetychecksintheprivaterentedsectorinWales-cametofruition.Initially,theWelshGovernmentdisagreedthattherewasaneedtoimproveregulations.
3.6 AsaresultofassistancefromNationalAssemblyMembers,theCharitylobbiedtoensuretheinclusionofmandatoryelectricalsafetychecksaspartoftheBill’sFitnessforHumanHabitationrequirements.
3.7 MuchofourconcernrelatedtopoorerqualityhousingstockintheprivaterentedsectorinWales,particularlyinSouthWales.Thisareahasahighconcentrationofterracedhousingdatingfromthemid-1850sonwards.
3.8 Atthetimeofwriting,theCharityisawaitingaWelshGovernmentannouncementonthewayforward.ButatameetingoftheRentingHomes(Wales)ActimplementationgroupinSeptember2018,confirmationwasgivenoftheGovernment’sintentiontogoforwardwithmandatorychecks,howeveranimplementationdateisyettobeannounced.
REDUCING FIRES CAUSED BYELECTRICITYINWALES–POLICY PROGRESS3.9 ElectricitycausesmorethanhalfofhousefiresinWalesperyearand42%ofaccidentalhousefires
caused by a faulty fuel supply in Welsh homes were ignited by an electrical sourceviii.Since2015,theCharityhascalledforaWelshGovernmentstrategytoreducethenumberofaccidentaldomesticelectricalfiresbytenpercent,overthenextfiveyears.
3.10 Followingsuccessfulcross-partylobbyingofNationalAssemblypoliticians,wesecuredinterestinadebate by Dawn Bowden AM (Labour,MerthyrTydfilandRhymney) in the Assembly on Electrical Fires inMay2017.
3.11 DuringthedebateMs.BowdenAMcalledforconsiderationofaregulatoryregimeforelectricaltestingintheprivaterentedsector,furtherresearchintothecausesoffiresandapublicawarenesscampaignsupportedbytheWelshGovernmentonelectricalfireprevention.ThelatterisakeyexpectationoftheCharityontheWelshGovernment,whichisrelevanttoprotectingpeopleacrossWalesandnotjustinSouthWales.
viiihttp://gov.wales/docs/statistics/2016/160727-fire-statistics-2015-16-en.pdf
Imp
rovin
g electrical safety and
preventin
g fires in Wales
8
04.
Elec
tric
al S
afet
y Fi
rst
THE KEY FINDINGS OF THE WELSH GOVERNMENT REPORT ARE Ix: •IthasdeterminedthattheincreaseinelectricalfiresrelatestoelectricaldistributioninSouthWales,
asopposedtoelectricalappliancesormobiledevices.
•ThisincreaseseemstobeaparticularissueintheSouthWalesRegion.Fromthedataanalysed,theredoesnotappeartobeasimilartrendinScotland,EnglandorotherpartsofWales.
•ThereportbelievesFireandRescueAuthoritiesinWales(FRAs)haveakeyroletoplayinpreventingfirescausedbyelectricaldistribution,bysharingtheCharity’sadvicex.Weagreewiththisapproach,asfireofficersrepresentatrustedpublicservice–perhapsmoresothanindividualelectricalinstallers.
•Thereport’sreviewofevidencementionstheageofhousingxiandelectricalfiresoccurpredominantlyinelectricalinstallationsratherthanappliances.WeviewthisassignificantgivensomeoftheanecdotalevidencewehavereceivedduringoutreacheventsinSouthWales,wheremembersofthepublichaveinformedusoftheirconcernsabouttheageoftheirwiringandtheirinabilitytoaffordelectricalimprovementsorrepairs.
PUTTING THE RECOMMENDATIONS INTO PRACTICE–TRAININGANDFUNDING ISSUES4.1 IntheirreporttheWelshGovernmentmadeanumberofrecommendationsforFireandRescue
Services,includingre-invigoratingtheirelectricalfiresafetymessagingandstatingthatallhouseholdsexperiencinganelectricaldistributionfireshouldreceiveafollowupSafeandWellvisit.TheCharitysupportsthis,asFRAsarethe‘trusted’servicetoundertakethiswork.
ix https://gweddill.gov.wales/docs/dsjlg/publications/fire/180716-electrical-fires-in-wales-en.pdfx https://www.electricalsafetyfirst.org.uk/guidance/safety-around-the-home/xi https://gweddill.gov.wales/docs/dsjlg/publications/fire/180716-electrical-fires-in-wales-en.pdfp12
8 9
05.
Imp
rovin
g electrical safety and
preventin
g fires in Wales
4.2 WhilsttheWelshGovernmentsayselectricalsafetyinWalesisapriorityxii,thereisnospecificgrantavailablefromtheWelshGovernmentprioritisingelectricalsafetyforthemostvulnerableinsociety.Thisisofparticularconcernforhomeownerswhoareunabletoaffordelectricalimprovements.
4.3 ThereferralssystemfromHomeSafetyVisitsneedsfurtherattentionandappearstoneedtobeimprovedsignificantly.IfFRAsidentifysafetyissuesindomesticpropertiesthatneedelectricalwork,whoarepeoplereferredto?Whatifthehomeownercannotaffordtomaketherecommendedimprovements?ThiscouldresultinreferralprocessesnotworkingcorrectlyandthereforetherecommendationssuggestedintheWelshGovernmentreportfallingatthefirsthurdle.
4.4 Care&Repairagenciesoftendonotidentifyelectricalworkrequireduntilanassessmentofotherworkhasbeenundertaken-i.e.electricalworkmayneedtobeundertakenbeforeotherbuildingworkscancommence.Thiscancreateproblemswithbudgets,asmajorelectricalworkcanoftenconsumetheentirebudget.
4.5 ThereisaneedtotrainFireOfficerstoidentifyelectricalsafetyrisksduringHomeSafetyVisits.TheCharity’sviewisthattheremaybeacorrelationbetweenelectricaldistributionfiresandtheageoftheproperty,aselectricalinstallationswilldeteriorateovertime.
4.6 TheelectricalsafetyelementofaHomeSafetyVisitonlycoversvisualchecksandmustcompetewithotherissues,suchastrips,slipsandfallsetc.Ifaconsumerunit,forexample,isinacupboardthiswillnotusuallybeapartoftheassessment.
HOUSING IN SOUTH WALES5.1 TheCharitybelievesthattheWelshGovernmentshouldfurtherinvestigateahypothesisthatold
housingstock,coupledwithpoorwiringandalackof‘futureproofing’,couldpotentiallycauseelectricaldistributionfires.
5.2 SouthWaleshasasignificantamountofolder,inter-connectedhousingstock,withopenatticspaces,wherefirescouldeasilyspread.Furthermore,electricalinfrastructureinhousingstockinSouthWalesisexpectedtoundertakemoderndaytasksthatitwasnotpotentiallydesignedfor.TheCharity,inpartnershipwiththeFireandRescueServices,particularlyinSouthWales,coulddevelopinitiativestoreducethisrisk.
5.3 AccordingtotheMinistryofHousing,CommunitiesandLocalGovernment,housingconstructedbefore1919isatgreaterriskoffires.InWales,26%ofhousingwasbuiltbefore1919,whereasinScotlandthisis20%and21.2%inEngland.LookingatolderpropertiesingeneralacrosstheUK,36%overallpredates1945,andofthose,34%werereportedtohaveacategory1HHSRShazardxiii.
xii https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-north-east-wales-42077549xiiihttps://gov.wales/statistics-and-research/welsh-housing-conditions-survey/?lang=en
10
5.4 LookingmorecloselyatthehousingagetheoryinrelationtoSouthWales,atenthofhousingpredates1875andathirdwasbuiltbeforetheendoftheFirstWorldWar.TheWelshHousingConditionsSurvey2017/18foundthat28%ofallhouseholdsinWaleslivedinaterracedhousexiv.
5.5 Fromthe2011censusRhonddaCynonTaf,CardiffandCaerphillyhavethehighestnumberofterracedhousesrespectivelyofthe10LocalAuthorityareasinSouthWales.By population, Blaenau Gwent, Rhondda Cynon Taf and Merthyr Tydfil respectively have the highest proportion of terraced housing. [Annex A]
5.6 Domesticelectricalinstallations,whichwereinstalledinthe1950-60sandarenowexpectedtomeetmodernhouseholdusage,areofconcern.Whatisdifficulttoascertainisthebreakdownoffiresbytenure.OnthebasisthatpeoplelivingintheprivateandsocialrentedsectorsinSouthWaleswillreceiveelectricalsafetychecksshortly,itislikelythoselivingintheowner-occupiedsectorintheregionwillbethemostvulnerable,giventhatanolderdemographicandhomeownershipcouldequalalackofrepairsduetotheownerbeing‘assetrichandcashpoor’.
5.7 ThestateofexistingelectricalinstallationsacrossWalesshouldalsobeconsideredfromtheviewpointoffuture-proofing.ThewayinwhichpeopleuseelectricityintheirhomeshaschangeddramaticallysincethemajorityofWelshhomesweredesignedandconstructedandtechnologicaldevelopmentsmeanthiscanonlyaccelerate.
5.8 Electricalinstallationsdesignedandinstalledbeforethemasstakeupofdomesticelectricalappliancesmayalreadybeinadequatetodealwithcurrentusagepatterns.Anindicationofthisistheprevalenceofextensionleadsinmanyhouseholdswherethereareinsufficientplugsockets.ThiswillbeexacerbatedifandwhenpersonalElectricVehicles(EVs)becomecommonplace.Theinstallationofsolarpanelsandindividualhouseholdenergystorageunitsisalsoaforeseeabletrendthatwillpresentproblems-evenforexistingelectricalinstallationsthatareingoodcondition.Asthiswilloccurinadditiontotheever-increasingnumberofelectricalappliancespeoplewillseeasnecessaryformodernliving.
5.9 Homesthatarenotonlywithoutamodernelectricalinstallationbutarealsoinastateofdisrepairwillbeparticularlydifficultandexpensivetobringuptoaminimumstandardneededtokeeppacewithfuturedevelopments.Failingtotakeactionnowwillresultinincreasedcostsanddisruptioninthefuture-perhapsevenresultingina‘drageffect’onlargequantitiesofexistinghousingstockandassociatedlocaleconomies.Housingmustbesafe,warmandsecure,butitisalsoakeydriverfortheeconomy.Failingtoequiphomeswiththenecessaryinfrastructureforthefuturecanonlyhaveadetrimentaleffect.
5.10 Assumingthatpovertyimpactsontheabilitytopayforelectricalhomeimprovements,unemploymentratesandthenumberofbenefitclaimantsinlocalauthorityareaswereconsidered,todeterminewherethehighestdeprivationinSouthWalesmaybe.AccordingtotheOfficeforNationalStatistics,CaerphillyandRhonddaCynonTafhavethehighestunemploymentratesrespectively.Similarly,BlaenauGwent,MerthyrTydfilandCaerphillyhavethehighestnumberofoutofworkbenefitclaimants.
5.11 Takingtheaboveintoaccount,(1)RhonddaCynonTaffand(2)CaerphillyarethemostvulnerableareasinSouthWales,followedby(3)BlaenauGwent,(4)MerthyrTydfiland(5)Cardiff.
xiv Ibid
Elec
tric
al S
afet
y Fi
rst
10 11
06.GRANTS FOR ELECTRICAL SAFETY IN WALES6.1 TheWelshGovernmenthasnodedicatedgrantsavailableforelectricalsafetyinWales.Only£67.5mis
availablefromHousesintoHomes,andHomeImprovementandTownCentreLoanSchemesxv.Soanyelectricalsafetyworkwouldhavetobepaidoutoftheseschemes.
6.2 Thebudgetrepresents£3.06mperlocalauthorityinWales,or£30.68mintheSouthWalesFRSarea.Therefore,electricalsafetywouldhavetocompetewithotherbuildingimprovementsfromthisbudget.Only £139 is potentially available per terraced household in the South Wales FRS area for electrical safety improvements from current grantsxvi.TheCharitybelievesthisiswoefullyinadequate.
6.3 Furthermore,theWelshGovernmentsaysthat1-2%ofhousesareataboveaverageorextremeriskinterms of electrical safetyxvii,consequentlyaround5,000terracedhousesmayneedre-wiringinSouthWales.ItappearsthatgrantsforelectricalsafetyworksthroughcurrentWelshGovernmentfundingdonotsupportdealingwithmajorelectricalworksforthosewithlimitedresources,thereforethisneedstobelookedatingreaterdetail.
6.4 ToascertaintowhatextentlocalauthoritiesinSouthWaleswerehelpingtofundelectricalhomeimprovements,wesentanumberofFreedomofInformationrequestsregardingHomeImprovementLoansandtheHousesintoHomesscheme.
6.5 CouncilssettheirowneligibilitycriteriaforHomeImprovementLoansandanyonecanapplyfortheHousesintoHomesscheme.OnlytwoCouncilshaveprovidedanyHomeImprovementLoans.Mosthave,however,providedsomeHousesintoHomesloans.However,formostinstances,itisnotknownwhetherthismoneyhasgonetowardselectricalimprovements.
6.6 FromAnnexes B & CitcanbeseenthatundertheHomeImprovementGrantonlytwolocalauthoritiesprovidedagrantforelectricalsafetyrepairs-CaerphillyandValeofGlamorgan.Thiscouldincludenewwiring,consumerunitsandinstallations.However,nofurtherdetailonthemoniesavailableviathesegrantsforelectricalsafetywasforthcoming.Noneofthelocalauthoritieswereabletoadvisehowmuchwasactuallyspentinthesecases.
xv http://cofnod.cynulliad.cymru/WrittenQuestion/77251xviMethodology:£67.5m/22=£30.6mx10=£30.68m/220259(numberofterracedhousingstockin10localauthorityareas)=£139xviiInformationreceivedfromStatisticsWales–ElectricalConditionandHousingSurvey–“fromthesurveyresultsisthatunderHHSRS,only
1%-2%ofpropertiesinWalesposedasignificantlyhigherthanaverageorextremeriskduetoelectricalsafety,andthatitwasasimilarpictureacrossthethreeFire&RescueServiceregions.”
Imp
rovin
g electrical safety and
preventin
g fires in Wales
12
HOUSES INTO HOMES6.7 TheCharityaskedlocalauthoritiesintheSouthWalesFireandRescueServiceareaforinformationon
electricalsafetygrantsavailablethroughtheHousesintoHomesandTownsScheme.From Annex D, below,onlythreelocalauthoritieswereabletoconfirmthatelectricalworkcouldtakeplace.Alltheothersfailedtoprovideanyinformation.OnlyBridgendCouncilsaiditcouldcoverre-wiring.
6.8 ItisclearthatlocalauthoritiesdonothavetheresourcestoimproveelectricalsafetyinhomesintheSouthWalesFRSareaiftheowner-occupierhasnoresourcestoundertakethiswork.TheWelshGovernmentmustlookatthisissuemorecloselyandprioritiseanelectricalimprovementsgrant,startinginSouthWales,whichhashadthemostsignificantnumberofelectricaldistributionfires.
CARE & REPAIR AUTHORITIES GRANTFUNDING-CASESTUDY7.1 GiventhattherearenograntsavailablefromtheWelshGovernmentorLocalAuthoritiesspecifically
forelectricalsafety,theonlyalternativeforthosewhocannotaffordimprovementsistobereferredtoCare&Repair.Atpresent,theCharityunderstandsthatHomeSafetyVisitsundertakenbySouthWalesFRShaveresultedinnoreferralstoCare&RepairAgencies.
7.2 TheCharityhashadapartnershipapproachwithC&RCsince2015.C&RChasdistributedtheCharity’sfunding,totalling£20ktodate,acrossWalesviacaseworkerstopeopleinneedofelectricalimprovements.ThisissomethingtheCharitywouldwishtoseesupportedbytheWelshGovernment,throughapilotschemeofelectricalgrantsinadesignatedlocalauthorityarea.
ACHIEVEMENTS OF THE PARTNERSHIP •C&RChasreceived39clientreferralsanddistributedESFfundsto38clients.
•Theaveragefundingawardedtoclientshasbeen£263.16.
•Nineofthe13Care&Repairagencieshaveappliedforfundingonbehalfofclients.ThelargestnumberofapplicationsreceivedwasfromCardiff,andNeathPortTalbot.
07.
Elec
tric
al S
afet
y Fi
rst
12 13
•Themajorityofworkcompletedhasinvolvedtheupgradingofearthing,bondingandconsumerunitsandtheinstallationofRCDs.Thelatterisanessentialsafetydevice,whichcutsofftheelectriccurrenttopreventanelectricshock.
7.3 AccordingtoC&RC,“TheElectricalSafetyFirstschemehassuccessfullyhelpedtoprovidemuchneededfundstooldervulnerableclientsacrossWales,allowingthemtokeeptheirhomessafe.C&RCadministrationhasallowedagencycaseworkerstosecureotherfundingneededmuchquicker,whichmeansthedesiredoutcomefortheclientisalsoachievedmuchmorequickly.”
7.4 C&RCprovidedcasestudiesofclientshighlightingthechallengestoimprovingelectricalsafetyarisingfromalackoffunding.Theseexamplesrepresentanongoingproblemaroundfundinganddemonstratethatthepoorestowner-occupiersmaynotbeabletoaffordelectricalimprovements.The Charity believes the Welsh Government must consider how electrical repairs could be better funded, as this in turn will help prevent fires caused by electrical distribution in people’s homes in Wales and, in this instance, South Wales.
Case study 1 Catherine,age62,owneroccupier,livesalone.
Catherinehasfibromyalgia,memoryandbackproblemsandhashadakneereplacement.HeronlyincomeisEmploymentandSupportAllowance(ESA)of£146perfortnightandshehasnosavings.
CatherinewasreferredtoherlocalC&RAgencybyalocaladviceagencyaftershehadcontactedthemforhelp.Shehadanoldlean-toatthebackofherhousethatwasinapoorstateofrepair.Waterwascomingthroughwhenitrained,andshewasworriedabouttheelectrics.Thelean-tohousedherwashingmachine,whichalongwiththelightinginthelean-towasrunningofftrailingwiresandextensionleadsfromthekitchen.Allthewiresweregettingwetwhenitrainedandshealsohadanumberofbrokensocketsinvariousroomsthroughoutthehouse.
Care&Repairobtainedaquotefromaqualifiedelectriciantomaketheelectricssafe.Thisincludedreplacingthedamagedsocketsanddisconnectingandmakingsafetheelectricsinthelean-to,whichamountedto£698.Catherinehadnosavingsandlivedonaverylowincome,soCare&Repairhadtoapplyforcharitable/benevolentfundstoraisethemoney,forrepairs,beforethenecessaryworkwasabletogoahead.
AsCatherinehadnorelevantworkhistoryandnoservicehistory,fundraisingprovedverydifficultandittookoversixmonthsbeforeanapplicationtothePerryFundwassuccessful.FollowingcompletionoftheworkoutlinedabovetheelectricsinCatherine’shomearenowsafe.
Imp
rovin
g electrical safety and
preventin
g fires in Wales
14
Case study 2 Valerie,aged77,owneroccupier,liveswithherhusband.
Valeriehaspoormobility,osteoporosisandahistoryoffalls.ShewasreferredtoherlocalC&RAgencybyaworriedrelative.Valeriehadanumberofissueswithherhomebutwasveryworriedaboutherelectrics.Shehadoldstylecircularsocketsplusanoldconsumerunitwithnotripswitch.
ValeriehadrecentlybeenassessedbyanOccupationalTherapist.TheyhadadvisedthatsheneededalevelaccessshowerandreferredhertothelocalauthorityforaDisabledFacilityGrant(DFG).Theworks,however,wereunabletogoaheadduetotheconditionoftheelectricsintheproperty.
Valeriealsohadnocentralheatingandwasrelyingongasfirestoheatherhome.ShehadbeenawardedagrantfromNest(theWelshGovernment’sfundedfuelpovertyscheme)fortheinstallationoffullcentralheating.Butagain,theseworkscouldnotgoaheadduetothestateoftheelectrics.A full rewire was advised.
Valerie’spartnerhadservedintheforcessofundraisingwaslookedatasanoptiontopayfortheworks.However,duetothelengthofthetimethiswouldtakeandhowworriedValerieandherpartnerwereabouttheseworks,theydecidedtopursueaCouncilHomeRepairLoan.UndertheCouncilloanafullrewirewascompleted,theNestgrantthenwentaheadtofitfullgascentralheatingandtheDisabledFacilityGrantalsowentaheadtofitalevelaccessshower.
7.6 TheCharityhaslongheldthepolicypositionofsupportingtheintroductionofelectricalsafetychecksforhomeownerswithonepersonagedover80inWales;thiswasakeyrecommendationinourreportproducedbySwanseaUniversity.SouthWalesFireandRescueServiceplaysacrucialroleinidentifyingelectricalfaultsbutC&Rplaysakeyroleinhelpingtopayforelectricalimprovements,oftenwithverylimitedbudgets.TheCharitywouldrecommendtheWelshGovernmentlookscloselyathowsecurefundingcanbeprovidedtoensureelectricalproblemsinpeople’shomesaredealtwithaftertheyhavebeenidentified;andwhathappensifreferralshavebeenmadebutnoresourceexiststoundertakethework.
Elec
tric
al S
afet
y Fi
rst
14 15
SOUTH WALES FIRE AND RESCUESERVICE–WORKINGIN PARTNERSHIP8.1 TheCharityhasdevelopedakeypartnershipwithSouthWalesFireandRescueServiceoveranumber
ofyears.Thishasincludedsupportingcommunications,outreachevents,provisionofgrantmoniesforcommunitysafetyandadviceonelectricalsafetymatters.WithrecentattendanceattheCommunityRiskReductionCommittee,theCharitywantstoexpanditspartnershipworkingthroughoutWales.However,forthebasisofourreportSouthWalesisseenasapriorityintermsofworkingtoreducefirescausedbyelectricity.
8.2 OneofthekeyrecommendationsoftheWelshGovernment’sreportisthat“FRAs should include adviceontheneedforelectricalsafetychecksintheirSafeandWellvisitsasamatterofcourse.”WhilsttheCharitysupportsandagreeswiththisrecommendation,anumberofconcernsexistaboutthesevisitsastheystand,whichhavepreviouslybeenreferredto.Forexample:
•FireOfficersarenottrainedtofullyidentifypotentialelectricaldangersinthehomebuttheyshould,asnotedintheWelshGovernment’sreport,beabletoundertakebasicchecks.Theelectricalchecksatpresentareonlyvisualandifthedangerishidden,i.e.inacupboardorbehindwalls,itwillnotbenoticed.
•SouthWalesFireandRescueService’sHomeSafetyvisits.In 2017/18: 17,396 Home Safety Visits occurred and 1,028 electrical issues were identifiedxviii.Thisequatestoonly6%oftheseHomeSafetyvisitsleadingtotheidentificationofanelectricalproblem.Itshouldbenotedthatelectricalchecksarein‘competition’withotherimportantinitiativesduringthesevisits,suchastrips,slipsandfallsetc.andthereforeitisnotclearwhetherthereweremoreelectricalissuesduringthesevisitsthatwerenotidentifiedastherewaseitheralackofknowledgeortheissuewashiddenawayfromview.
•AlthoughFireOfficersareresponsibleforarangeoftasks,theyarethetrustedorganisationtoundertakethesevisits.If,liketheCharity,theWelshGovernmentwantsthistobeapriority,thereneedstobeareprioritisationsoelectricalchecksarepartofthisactivity.FireOfficerswillneedadditionalbasictrainingtohelpthemtoidentifyelectricalrisksandalsotoofferadviceonfuture-proofinginordertoincreasetheeffectivenessofthesevisits.
•Therearenotedproblemswithsignpostingandreferrals,especiallyiftheoccupierneedsanelectrician.FireOfficersarenotpermittedtorecommendanelectrician,forexample.Furthermore,referralstoCRCmaynotoccurandwhentheydo,budgetmaybeunavailable.This needs to be fully reviewed, costed and funded by Welsh Government.
xviiiDatareceivedfromSouthWalesFireandRescueService–March2019
08.Im
pro
ving electrical safety an
d p
reventing fires in W
ales
16
FUTURE-PROOFING8.3 ItappearsthatsomepreparationsarebeingundertakenbylocalauthoritiesinWalestoassistWelsh
consumersonfuture-proofing,i.e.readinessforchargingelectricvehicles,howeverthisismakingslowprogress.
8.4 FollowingFreedomofInformationrequestsundertakenbytheCharity,wefoundthatofthesevenlocalauthoritiesoutofnineintheSouthWalesareathatresponded,mostoftheseareonlyatthestudyorplanningstagesforpublicchargingpoints.Averylownumberofchargingpointsexistinstreetsalreadyintheseareas.ThisraisespotentialimplicationsofthereadinessinSouthWalesforchargingvehiclesandtheimpactondomesticelectricalinstallationsandwiringinpropertiesxix.
ESF CONCLUSION & DISCUSSION POINTS9.1 GivenwhatresearchdataisavailableandfollowingconversationswithstakeholdersinWales,ESF
concludes that:
•ThereisaneedfornationalcoordinationbetweenGovernment,theFRAsandtheCharitytounderstandthedangersassociatedwithelectricalusageindomesticpropertiesinWalesandhowtopreventfires.
•TheWelshGovernmentiscommittedtointroducingmandatoryelectricalsafetychecksintheprivateandsocialrentedsectorswhichwillbetheresponsibilityoflandlordsandlettingagents.Thiswillimprovesafetyandhopefullyreducefirescausedbyelectricalsourcesofignition.However,theowner-occupiedsectorneedstobeconsidered,especiallythosewhoarevulnerableandrelyonCareandRepairAgencysupport.
•TherecommendationsoftheWelshGovernmentreportrightlypointatFRAstoworktohelpreducefirescausedbyelectricalsourcesofignitioninWales.Howeverwebelievetheseneedtobefullycostedandthoughtthrough.ItappearstherearepotentialpolicyblackholeswithregardstoHomeSafetyVisitsandelectricalsafety,fundingofrepairs,advicegiventohomeownersandreferralprocesses.
xixhttps://www.electricalsafetyfirst.org.uk/media-centre/press-releases/2019/5/driven-to-danger-electric-vehicle-drivers-charging-dangerously-due-to-lack-of-public-infrastructure/
09.
Elec
tric
al S
afet
y Fi
rst
16 17
•Giventheevidenceonbudgetconstraintsforelectricalsafetyandthelackofgrantsavailable,thereneedstobeafocusonfundingrepairsforthemostvulnerablehomeowners.Considerationshouldbegiventograntstorepairandrenewelectricalinstallationsandwiring.
•Thereisalackofinformationanddataonfireswithregardstotenure,housingageandrequiredrepairs.TheWelshGovernmentwasnotabletogivesubstantialinformationonthenumbersofpropertiesthatneedre-wiringinSouthWales.Thisneedstobeconsideredasapriorityworkstrand.
•FireofficersneedtrainingintheprovisionofbasicelectricalsafetyadviceandelectricaladviceduringHomeSafetyvisitsshouldbeseenasapriority.
•ThereislimitedworkbeingdonewiththeWelshpubliconfuture-proofingandrisks,thiscouldleadtoincreaseddomesticchargingwithinstallationsthatarenotappropriateforthesetasks.
Improvin
gelectricalsafetyandpreventin
gfiresin Wales
18
10.ANNEX AEl
ectr
ical
Saf
ety
Firs
t
Local Authority Area Population(1) Number of Terraced Houses (2)
Percentage of terraced houses by population
Unemployment Rate % (3)
Out of work benefit claimants % (4)
Blaenau Gwent 69,609 15749 23% 5.6 16.7
Bridgend 144,208 15401 11% 5 12.7
Caerphilly 180,795 26526 15% 6 13.5
Cardiff 362,756 43612 12% 5.7 10.4
Merthyr Tydfil 59,953 12020 20% 5.5 15.7
Monmouthshire 93,590 6515 7% 3.4 7.7
Newport 151,485 20265 13% 5.4 12.6
Rhondda Cynon Taf 239,127 49322 21% 5.8 15
Torfaen 92,264 16359 18% 5.2 12.8
Vale of Glamorgan 130,690 14490 11% 3.6 9.7
Ref: (1) StatsWales.PopulationMid2017.(2) NOMIS (based on 2011 census) Published June 2014 (3) OfficeforNationalStatistics-June-July2018(4) StatsWales-2016
ANNEX BHome Improvement Grants – FOIs to Local Authorities in the South Wales area1.Howmanyhomeimprovementgrantshavebeenissuedinthelocalauthorityareainthelastfiveyears?2.Whatestimateorfiguresarethereforthenumberofterracedhousingstockinthelocalauthorityarea
regardlessoftenure.3.Dothesegrantscoverelectricalsafetyimprovementsinhousing?4.Ifyesto3,whatdidthesecover?Forexample-rewiring,replacingsockets,changingafusebox/consumerunit5.Whatisthelocalauthority’sbudgettocoverHomeImprovementgrantsinyourarea?6.Howmanyofthesegrantswenttoolderpeopleover65–whatfiguresareavailable?
Question 1 Question 2 Question 3 Question 4 Question 5 Question 6
Blaenau Gwent None 52% No N/A N/A N/A
Bridgend None N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
Caerphilly 534 26,700 Yes Mayincludefullrewire,renewingthefusebox,earthingandbonding,renewingsocketsandswitches
2018/19is£1,140,938
Informationnot recorded
Cardiff None Info not held
N/A N/A N/A N/A
Merthyr Tydfil None 12,600 No grants issued in ten years
N/A None N/A
Monmouthshire Notprovided No answer N/A N/A N/A N/A
Newport No answer 38.50% No answer No answer No answer No answer
Rhondda Cynon Taf Grant not yet operational
63015 N/A N/A 15 N/A
Torfaen 9 16,359 No N/A £1,060,552 N/A
Vale of Glamorgan 5 N/A Workhasinvolvedcompletely new electricalinstallationsincluding new fuse boxetc.
N/A £1,626,594 N/A
18 19
Improvin
gelectricalsafetyandpreventin
gfiresin Wales
ANNEX C1.Howmanya)HowmanyHousesintoHomesloanshttps://gov.wales/topics/housing-and-regeneration/housing-
supply/empty-homes/houses-into-homes/?lang=enandb)TownCentreLoanschemeshavebeenissuedbythelocalauthorityinthelastfiveyears?
2.Whatbudgetisavailablefora)andb)?3.Whatelectricalsafetyimprovementstohousinginthelocalauthorityareawereallocatedfromtheabovegrants?4.Ifyes,whatdidthesecover?Forexample-rewiring,replacingsockets,changingafusebox/consumerunit?
Question 1 Question 2 Question 3 Question 4
Blaenau Gwent a)32Now replaced with Land Lord loansb)7
a)£865,466b)£764,286
N/A N/A
Bridgend a)23 b)26 a)£900,000b)no set budget
Mayincludeelectricalwork could include rewiring
Caerphilly No response
Cardiff a)56b)N/A a)£3.39m Info not recorded N/A
Merthyr Tydfil a)11 b)1 a)£717,520.35b)£1,000,000
Not answered Noinfoavailable
Monmouthshire a)3 b)1 a)£1.2mb)£42.5k Includedrewiringwork N/A
Newport a)32b)N/A a)£884,496 Info not recorded N/A
Rhondda Cynon Taf
Torfaen a)28lastfiveyearsb)7lastthreeyears
a)£1,073,525b)£200,000
Info not recorded N/A
Vale of Glamorgan a)21 b)2 a)£1626594b)£1,045,665
a)Workhasinvolvedcompletelynewelectricalinstallationsincludingnewfuseboxetc.
N/A
ANNEX DVale of GlamorganLocal Authority What preparations are you
undertaking as a council to prepare for Electric Vehicle charging in your area?
Are you planning or commencing work on installing on-street charging points in your area?
If yes to 3, how many charging points have been installed to date?
Rhondda Cynon Taf Lookingintoit Yes One
Blaenau Gwent Haveinstalledchargingpoints,butissueswithlowuse/vandalism–nocorporatepolicy.
No 6
Monmouthshire Lookingatsuitablepotentiallocations,technology,funding
Yes None
Merthyr Tydfil None No 0
Bridgend Lookingatassessingpotentialfor EV locally
No None
Newport Lookingatsuitablesites Yes 4
Vale of Glamorgan Setupworkinggroup No N/A
Cardiff Been awarded funding Yes -
Torfaen Part of a regional study Yes Five
Arbenigwyr diogelwch trydanol y DU