GNWT PMC 2017
Embracing Project Uncertainty
Dr. George Jergeas P.Eng.
Professor and Director of Project Management, University of Calgary
November 22, 2017
Benevolent Dictatorship for Major Capital Projects
A guide for Executives who want to enhance their major project delivery experience LEARN academy™ Jim Lozon [email protected] (403) 466-1449
Amazon.ca Slide 2
Slide 3
Muskrat Falls Project
Major Infrastructure Projects
■ We do not deliver on time and on budget. ■No single actor in control of the vision and
implementation. ■Private and public entities and stakeholders.
●Difficult compromise is needed.
●New players join and demand big changes.
●Changes can affect costs, schedule, and scope.
Slide 4
Too Many Moving Parts
Slide 5
Major Infrastructure Projects
■ The public tends to be fixated on the original promises.
■ The scope keeps evolving but the public is
expecting cost won’t increase. ■ Not easy to explain the new budget isn’t an
overrun driven by incompetence.
Slide 6
7
Major Infrastructure Projects
■ Judged on the gap between initial targets and actual performance.
■50 to 100% cost overruns
Slide 8
9
Slide 10
Blame Culture
Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bovidae#mediaviewer/File:Hausziege_04.jpg
11
Benevolent Dictatorship
A Leader exercises absolute authority over the delivery of a project
but does so for the benefit of all members of
the project in full compliance with
legal, ethical and moral requirements and values
12
Benevolent Dictatorship Approach
1. Understand the project delivery process 2. Embrace uncertainty 3. Establish governance and conduct oversight 4. Improve front-end planning and design 5. Appreciate your contractual and negligence
Obligations 6. Recognize your claims and disputes obligations 7. Build collaborative relationships
13
1. Understand the Project Delivery Process
14
1. Understand the Project Delivery Process
■Must not bypass any decision gate
■Analyze the risks and opportunities at each decision gate
■Final approved budget must be after detailed engineering design is complete
15
2. Embrace Uncertainty
■No project goes exactly as planned
■Become comfortable with uncertainty ■Accept deviations during execution ●Plan for it
Slide 16
Consider the Three Types of Risks
17
Three Buckets
■Project Contingency
■Scope Contingency
■Management Contingency
18
Cost Contingency Drawdown Curves
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Cos
t % o
f Con
tinge
ncy
Time % of Project Schedule
Drawdown Plan
Actual Amount Allotted to Date Time Now
19
20
Risk Allocation
“… the contractor shall not have any claim for compensation for damages against the owner for any stoppage or delay from any cause whatsoever.”
21
Risk Allocation Guidelines
■Accept the risks that are rightfully yours
■Allocate a risk to the best party capable of controlling it and dealing with it
■ If a risk is imposed, contractors add high contingencies
Slide 22
3. Establish Governance and Conduct Oversight
Dictator 1
Dictator 2
Leader
4. Improve Front-End Planning and Design
■Enhance design/engineering quality: ●Consider constructability during design ●Standardize designs and vendors on
repetitive installations ●Maximize modularization and pre-build in
shops to reduce fieldwork ●Reduce the practice of fast tracking ●Apply the 80-100 rule
Slide 23
80-100 rule
Slide 24
Quantity of Change vs. Impact (based on manhours)
-5%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% 50%
Change Hours as % of Base Project Hours
Impa
ct a
s %
of
Tota
l Act
ual
Hou
rs
Productivity Improvement
CII
25
5. Appreciate your Contractual and Negligence Obligations ■ Make the construction site available ■ Timely delivery of owner supplied materials ■ Ensure quality design ■ Provide timely approvals and decisions ■ Do not specify “method of construction” ■ Deliver owner supplied facilities ■ Timely issuance of change orders and payments ■ Disclose all information ■ Apply due diligence
Slide 26
Due Diligence ■Policies and procedures ■Training ■Monitoring ■Reporting ■ Investigation ■Enforcement ■Benchmarking ■Record-keeping – “show your work”
Slide 27
6. Recognize your Claims and Disputes Obligations ■ Clear lines of authority and responsibility ■ Implement collaborative relationships ■ Review scheduling and time requirements ■ Assign representatives of all parties to reside on site ■ Respond to contractor communications ■ Pay invoices in a timely manner ■ Monitor project progress ■ Implement a rigorous change management process ■ Minimize design changes during construction ■ Address claims as they arise
Slide 28
Dispute Prevention vs. Resolution
DISPUTE
CO
NTR
OL
BY
TH
E P
AR
TIE
S
COST TO THE PARTIES
LITIGATION
NEGOTIATION
MEDIATION
THIRD PARTY NEUTRAL EVALUATION
ARBITRATION
Resolution
Pre
vent
ion
29
7. Build Collaborative Relationships
Build a cohesive, co-operative relationship with common goals and established procedures for open and honest communication and issue resolution in a timely manner based on: ●Trust ●Respect
Slide 30
7. Build Collaborative Relationships
1. Common Vision 2. Health Check 3. Issue Resolution Mechanism 4. Ground Rules 5. Roles and Responsibilities
31
We, the YYC Runway Development Program – City of Calgary Airport Trail Tunnel teams will
meet the following milestone dates: ● Zone 1 under runway – Aug 31, 2012 ● Zone 2/3 under Taxiways – October 31, 2012 ● Structure completion – October 31, 2012 ● Zone 4/5 under perimeter roads – June 30,
2013 ●Runway in service – May 2014
32
Health Check 1. difficult, guarded 1 2 3 4 N/A2. restricted 1 2 3 4 N/A3. late 1 2 3 4 N/A4. ineffective 1 2 3 4 N/A
5. Poor, Detached 1 2 3 4 N/A6. ignored 1 2 3 4 N/A7. personal, negative 1 2 3 4 N/A8. ineffectively 1 2 3 4 N/A9. Senior Management 1 2 3 4 N/A
10. Low 1 2 3 4 N/A
11. ignored 1 2 3 4 N/A12. not acceptable 1 2 3 4 N/A13. ignored 1 2 3 4 N/A14. low 1 2 3 4 N/A15. poor 1 2 3 4 N/A16. not acceptable 1 2 3 4 N/A
17. Public Complaints are… frequent 1 2 3 4 N/A18. Client Involvement is… late, unclear, vague 1 2 3 4 N/A
19. Completion of milestones are rewarded / recognized ineffective 1 2 3 4 N/A20. Overall Satisfaction is… dissatisfied 1 2 3 4 N/A
COMMUNICATIONTeam Communications are… open, up-frontInformation flow is… free, openTimeliness of information is… on-timeCommunications / Meetings are… effective
WORKING RELATIONSHIPSCooperation between Project Groups is… good, unreservedIssues and concerns are… dealt with quicklyResponses to issues become… project specificDisputes are addressed… EfficientlyProblems/issues are resolved by… lowest levelLevel of Trust is… High
PROJECT REQUIREMENTSSafety is being… consideredQuality of work is… acceptableEnvironmental requirements are… consideredIs the Project receiving Value for money highSchedule Management is… EffectiveCost Management is… acceptable
effectivesatisfied
STAKEHOLDER & EXTERNAL ISSUESinfrequenttimely/relative
TEAM SATISFACTION
Please list examples for the points above that you rated 1 or 2 __________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________________ 33
Issue Resolution Mechanism
A: Issue requires immediate or quick resolution.
B: Issue can be resolved within 5 days with minimal impact
C: Issue can be resolved in greater than 5 days with minimal impact
Group: A Immediate
B 5 days
C 5+ days
Site Level Site Level
12 HR 1 day 5 days
PM Level PM level 24 HR 2 days 5 days Director Director 24 HR 2 days 5-10
days General Manager CEO
24 HR
34
Ground Rules An example of Ground Rules:
● If response is urgent, say when - if timeline is not possible, say so and establish a reasonable timeline.
● Key decisions – document and share them within 3 days (aids communication and defines future change).
● Meetings – every 3 weeks: agenda provided in advance (2 days); meeting minutes sent out within 1 week by Engineer.
● Open communication – include the PM in project correspondence.
● Respect decisions once made – leave disagreements at the door; trust and personal respect.
● Everyone shares responsibility and celebrates success. ● Don’t let issues fester – speak up.
35
Roles and Responsibilities
Read The Full Contract (RTFC)
36
37
How to Become a Benevolent Dictator?
■Show personal humility ■Act as a Servant Leader ●He who will be Leader is to be Servant
●The right balance: ●The Head - The Vision ●The Hands - Skills ●The Feet - Walk the talk ●The Heart - The Value system
Simplicity
38
39