Enel Green Power Latin America
II Congreso del FuturoCiencia, tecnología Humanidades y ciudadanía
Santiago 17th January 2013
Uso: Aziendale
The Energy Mix Strategy to address Country and business risk
Risk
Energy Mix
Financial Energy Security Regulatory Competitive
Fossil fuel- based energy prices
increasing as global demographics and economic growth boost demand
The Fukushima disaster and political turmoil in the Middle East highlight energy-
availability risk
Regulation tightens as stakeholders demand that
companies do more to mitigate the
environmental impact
Operational efficiency becomes a key differentiator in the economic downturn
A diversified energy matrix as an instrument to mitigate
business & country risk
Uso: Aziendale
The Renewable Energies Market Renewables’ Response to the Energy Trilemma
Renewable Energies
Supply Independency
Increasing Global Energy
Demand
More renewables in the mix help mitigate the risk profile of the Energy system
• Renewable energy is a key element of a balanced primary energy mix at affordable costs and improving energy security and independence
• Short time to market and modularcharacteristic allows wind and solarto adapt very well to changingenergy demand scenarios
Uso: Aziendale
5.0%
Min Max
7% 16%
7% 8%
5% 9%
4% 9%
2% 7%
Expected GrowthCAGR ‘11-’20
8.7%
2020 Max
110
1,000
1,030
550
330
(GW)
3,020
2020 Min
53
921
655
371
207
(GW)
~2,206
Installed base
27+2%
513+11%
460+10%
252
+6%
173+3%
2011 (GW)
~1,4255.0%
Min Max
13% 24%
7% 11%
10% 15%
2% 2%
5% 24%
8.7%
Investments
~113
~2
~65
~58
~13
2011 (€bn)
~€250bn+112
‘10-11 (GW) %
+31 78%
+0.2 2%
+41 21%
+29 3%
+11 17%
Delta capacity
8.5%
Installed base
~71
~11
~238
~1,034
~71
2011 (GW)
~1,425
Installed base
Source: EPIA, GWEC, EER (2011); WEO 2011 New Policies scenario (2020 min); industry reports/McKinsey (2020 max); BNEF, EGP estimates
Note: Investments estimated based on BNEF figures and assuming an fx of 1.3 €/$. Large Hydro investments estimated assuming 29GW of new installations and 2.0M€/MW capex.
Renewable energy investments: a growing industryExpected worldwide growth
TOTAL
Solar
Geothermal
Wind
Hydro
Biomass
Technology
TOTAL
Africa
Asia
Europe
North America
Latin America
Area
By technology By geography
Expected Growth
CAGR 2011-20
~40
~11
~197
~1,005
~60
2010 (GW)
~1,313
Installed base
26
461
419
239
168
2010 (GW)
~1,313
Uso: Aziendale
233383 419 460
746185
231 239 252
486
132
162 168173
301
219
428461
513
1,070
22
25
2627
84
792
1,2301,313
1,425
2,687
2000 2009 2010 2011 2020
Latin America
Africa
Europe
Asia
North America
Fonti: Enerdata, WEO 2011 (World Energy Outlook pubblicato annualmente dall’International Energy Agency), EER (Emerging Energy Research), GWEC (Global Wind Energy Council), EWEA (European Wind Energy Association), EPIA (European Photovoltaic Industry Association), NREAPs (National Renewable Energy Action Plans), REN 21, target nazionali, stime EGP
Renewable Market Forecast – EGP view 2000 – 2020 Installed Capacity by Area
CAGR:+5,0%
YoY:+6,8%
YoY:+8,5%
CAGR:+7,3%
Renewable Energy growth involves all continents
GW
Uso: Aziendale
745
979 1,005 1,034
1,33917
159197
238
767
428
68 71
82
153
792
1,2301,313
1,425
2,687
2000 2009 2010 2011 2020
Others
Wind
Hydro
CAGR:+5,0%
YoY:+6,8%
YoY:+8,5%
CAGR:+7,3%
Renewable Market Forecast- EGP view2000 – 2020 Installed Capacity by Technology
Source: Enerdata, WEO 2011, EER, GWEC, EWEA, EPIA, NREAPs, REN 21, National targets, EGP estimate
Wind and Solar PV the technologies that will contribute most significantly to the projected growth
Solar
GW
Uso: Aziendale
The renewable energy marketStrengths and opportunities
Predictable
• EU experience shows RES integration closer to real time markets
• Spain: unbalances management
• Italy: RES participation in the unbalancing market from 2013
• Progressive integration of regional markets
• Grid support and progressive integration of distributed generationReliable
• Renewable energy proved to be competitive in terms of pricing
• Capex reductions do to competition, economy of scale and efficiency
• Progressive integration of intermittent production in competitive markets
Competitive
Uso: Aziendale
Paradigm shift in the energy supply of the future
Future
Past Supply DemandFollows
Supply Demandinterdependent
Smart Homes, Smart grids and storage are some examples of elements that are and will guide the transition
Uso: Aziendale
Chile: Trends and market scenarios
7 7.8 8 8.4 8.9
12.232.7 34.8 36.7 37.3 39.2
52
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2022
Capacity (GW) Production (TWh)
CAGR Capacity 2013-2017:6,3%
CAGR Production 2013-2017:4,6%
A single technology can not cover the
increasing demand. A more balanced
energy mix is needed
Nuclear issues: acceptance (Fukushima);
significant costs; time to market
Hydro: high reliance on Hydropower expose
systems to the risk of droughts (Brazil)
Thermal- based power: essential but affects the
carbon footprint of the economy
Renewables play an important role in the matrix differentiation
Uso: Aziendale
Chile: main issues at stake
Upcoming challenges in the renewable energy market will shape the context in which investors are called to participate
Transmission
ENRC debate
Permitting
Energy Supply
Bottlenecks force to use inefficient local generation and cause risky operations. Black Out risks
Current ERNC quota set at 10% 2024 does not provide correct market signals
Transparent rules to favor interested players to boost investments in the Country
• Long term energy selling mechanism and increasing recourse to tenders
Uso: Aziendale
Strategy and opportunities for public acceptance of low carbon investments
Enel Green Power is strongly committed at
making renewable sources not only
sustainable, but also increasingly competitive
with traditional generation technologies,
increasing their efficiency and reliability
Corporate Social responsibility
Enel’s mission is to generate and distribute value in theinternational energy market, to the benefit of our
competitiveness and the requirements of our customers, theinvestments of our shareholders and the expectations of
everyone who works with us.Enel acts in the service of communities, respecting the
environment with the intention of ensuring a better world tocoming generation
Enel Green Power enacts its CSR activities
based on the following four principles:
� Responsible growth
� Climate change combat
� Transparent and continuous mutual communication with local communities
� Promotion of human rights
Social responsibility as an opportunity to competitive success - Porter
11
12
• More efficient regulation in mature markets
• Increasing recourse to tenders
• Market design to increase flexibility
• Innovation, scale and competition driving down technology costs, especially in wind and solar
1
1 2
• Significant growth of all main technologies in all geographical areas
• Several new markets opening quickly
4
• Large variety of new industrial and financial players entering at regional and global level
3Market Scenario
CompetitiveScenario
RegulatoryFramework
Cost of Technology
New Challenges in the Renewable Energies MarketThe Industry’s Circle of Technology, Regulation, Competition and Market
Uso: Riservato Aziendale
13
Thank you for your attention
Maurizio Bezzeccheri
Enel Green PowerHead of Iberia and Latin America
Uso: Riservato Aziendale
14
BACK UP
Uso: Aziendale
CSR- a concrete example
Barefoot college
� Enel Green Power SpA and the Barefoot College have initiated a partnership to establish Community Empowerment Centres (CECs) in five countries in Latin America.
� The Centres will also serve as Rural Electronic Workshops to support the solar electrification of remote, rural villages in Guatemala, Chile, Brazil, Peru and Colombia.
Established in 1972, the Barefoot
College is a non-government
organization that has been
providing basic services and
solutions to problems in rural
communities, with the objective
of making them self-sufficient
and sustainable.
The partnership with EGP The approach
� The Barefoot Approach: women from these rural communities will be trained as Barefoot Solar Engineers. After 6 months of training at the Barefoot College in India, they will return to their countries to solar electrify their own communities.
� These women will then become trainers themselves and train other women at the CECs in each country
Society and corporate performance: an integrated, essential approach
15
Uso: Aziendale
EGP presence
North America
Operating 1,010 MW
Production 2.92 TWh
Iberia e Latin America
Operating 2,486 MW
Production 6,97 TWh
Italy and Europe
Operating 3,583 MW
Production 12,58 TWh
Enel Green Power
Operating 7,079 MW
Production 22.48 TWh
Installed capacity by technologyFY 2011
Production by technologyFY 2011
EGP Number and figures– FY2011Geographical diversification and multi-technological approach
Total = 7.1 GW
3%11%
36%
50%
Total = 22.48 TWh
3%25%
45%
27%
16
16 Countries across all main renewable technologies
Uso: Riservato Aziendale
17
Agenda
1. EGP Latin America
− EGP presence at a glace
2. Chile
− The Institutional environment
− General framework and market design
− Selling mechanism and nodal prices
− RES: renewable incentive mechanism
3. Mexico
− The Institutional environment
− Market functioning
− Regulatory developments
4. Brazil
− The Institutional environment
− The Brazilian power system
− Auction based scheme: the Brazilian experience
5. Panama, Costa, Rica Guatemala, El Salvador and Cross Issues
Regulatory Affairs - LATAM
EGP Business Plan: flexibility in capital allocation
17
Uso: Riservato Aziendale
Technology cost reduction - Wind
Note: wind plant cost estimation is based on a standard onshore 50 MW plant, equipped with 2 MW wind turbines (HH=80m, D=90m)Source: McKinsey, May 2012; BNEF, Wind turbine price index, July 2012.
WTG capitalcost
reduction
Innovation (materials, control
systems)
Supply chain cost improvements
Competition
Cost estimation – Wind plant 2012-2022 (€/W)
1.2
1.1
0.9
0.9
0.7
0.5
0.8
1.1
1.4
2012 2017 2022
Base Case Low Case
Economies of scale
Uso: Riservato Aziendale
Technology cost reduction - PV
Note: cost estimates refer to c-si PV modulesSource: McKinsey, May 2012; Photon Consulting, The true cost of solar power, July 2012; PV Insight, Sept 2012
PV modules cost
reduction
Economies of scale
Throughput efficiency
Innovation (materials, efficiency)
Competition
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
Jan 20121110092008
Cost estimation - PV plant 2012-2022 (€/W)
1.4
1.2
1.0
1.0
0.8
0.5
0.8
1.1
1.4
1.7
2012 2017 2022
Base Case Low Case
PV modules spot market price ($/W)
Wind energy cost – Recent data
Brazil – 2011 A-3 tender
Brazil – 2011 A-5 tender (*)
Mexico – 2012 Oaxaca wind tender
(Sureste I – Phase II)
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
2014
2016
2018
2020
2022
2024
2026
2028
2030
2032
Expected CFE
tariff (USD/MWh)
CFE Bid offer
(USD/MWh)
0 BRL/MWh
20 BRL/MWh
40 BRL/MWh
60 BRL/MWh
80 BRL/MWh
100 BRL/MWh
120 BRL/MWh
2011 A-3 2011 A-5
Natural Gas
Hydro
Wind
(*) mainly large hydro projects expansion