Energy and Environmental Security:Energy and Environmental Security:
Leveraging Human Ingenuity in an Age of ConsequencesLeveraging Human Ingenuity in an Age of Consequences
Carol DumaineDeputy Director
Energy & Environmental Security DirectorateOffice of Intelligence and Counterintelligence
US Department of Energy
GOV 2.0 SummitRAPID FIRE: Setting the Stage
Washington, DCWashington, DC9 September 20099 September 2009
We live in an age of consequences that remain largely unexamined in so far as they relate to energy and environmental security. This is because energy and environmental impacts on societies have not traditionally been considered security issues.
1
What Are the Risks of Not Planning for Worst-Case Scenarios?
2
The climate crisis alone contains the potential for catastrophic impacts on factors such as water and food security and rising temperatures and sea levels. Although these issues are thoroughly integrated, the institutions meant to tackle them are not.
2
3
3
Strategic Surprise - Bolt out of the Blue
Antarctica Ice Shelf Collapse
During the Cold War, we spared no effort preparing for a high impact – low probability event: a surprise nuclear attack. Today, we’re less invested in contingency planning on energy and environmental issues-like a catastrophic acceleration of ice sheet discharge that could raise sea levels enormously.
Images: Baikonur / Kazakhstan SOVIET Launch; Nevada Nuclear Test Explosion, NNSA, Nevada Office
4
Plato, Book VII of The RepublicThe Allegory of the Cave 4
Plato’s CaveSeeing Beyond the Shadows of Present-day Concerns
This image of the Allegory of Plato’s cave—where the audience, able to see only reflected shadows of the real world--Capture our challenge today in confronting the new security realities.
4
5
Intelligence, n. Knowledge and foreknowledge of the world around us—the prelude to decision and action …
Consumer Guide to Intelligence, 1999 5
Foresight and Warning
Foresight and warning is about escaping the cave and immersing ourselves in all that we do not understand. Sometimes, in the cave, it’s difficult to identify issues of emerging security significance. It’s hard to see them in the shadows posed by present-day concerns.
5
Source: Evolution’s Edge, Graeme Taylor, New Society Publishing, Canada. 20086
Overcoming Barriers to Foresight and Risk Assessment
In this regard, for example, demographic considerations are critical. What are the implications of expected population growth to over 9 billion within forty years’ time?
6
What are the Implications of…?
Tibetan Glacier Melt
Black Stem Rust
Extreme Weather Events
Abrupt Climate Change
7
We need to consider the implications of such factors as:
The decline of glaciers on the Tibetan plateau
An epidemic of black stem rust affecting wheat crops in the Middle East
Extreme weather events affecting energy infrastructure and fuel production capacity
[As of April this year, The Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) of the United Nations asked Pakistan and Afghanistan to be on high alert, following a report that Ug99 black wheat stem rust has moved to major wheat-growing areas including Iran. Wheat stem rust is a potential threat to regional food security. (http://islamabad.usembassy.gov/pr-09081303.html)]
8
8
Dormant, But For How Much Longer?
Our work to date has emphasized that climate change will not be gradual, uniform or benign. Under these conditions, preparedness and resiliency are paramount.
Image: Colima Volcano, NASA Terra Satellite, Advanced Spaceborne Thermal Emission and Reflection Radiometer (ASTER
What interactions lie beneath the “volcano”…?
9Understanding Dynamic Feedbacks and Connections
EnergyEnergyScarcityScarcity
Climate Climate ChangeChange
SecuritySecurityand Riskand Risk
SocialSystems
BehaviouralNorms
GovernanceErosion
DisruptedState
Authority
OrganisedCrime
ResourceNationalism
Statecollapse
Terrorism
DistressedMigration Resource
Conflicts
Disaffection
BoostingRadicalisation
TradeDisruption
EconomicVolatility
SocialDistress
GlobalPopulation
Growth
PhysicalInfrastructure
Threats
DisruptedAgriculture& Transport
FoodDisruption
HeatStress
Spread ofDisease
Amplifying Inequity and Grievance
Disrupting Fragile Systems
PhysicalSystems
IncreasedTemperatures
BiodiversityLoss
EnvironmentalDegradation
Extreme WeatherEvents
ST
RE
SS
ES
RE
SP
ON
SE
S
David Robson, Scottish Government, 2009
Governments lack knowledge of how energy and environmental dynamics affect security. There are many underlying currents of change that have security consequences. We can think of them as seismic forces beneath a quiet volcano. What underlying forces are we not taking into consideration?
9
EnergyEnergyScarcityScarcity
Climate Climate ChangeChange
SecuritySecurityand Riskand Risk
SocialSystems
BehaviouralNorms
GovernanceErosion
DisruptedState
Authority
OrganisedCrime
ResourceNationalism
Statecollapse
Terrorism
DistressedMigration Resource
Conflicts
Disaffection
BoostingRadicalisation
TradeDisruption
EconomicVolatility
SocialDistress
GlobalPopulation
Growth
PhysicalInfrastructure
Threats
DisruptedAgriculture& Transport
FoodDisruption
HeatStress
Spread ofDisease
Amplifying inequity and grievance
Disrupting Fragile systems
PhysicalSystems
IncreasedTemperatures
BiodiversityLoss
EnvironmentalDegradation
Extreme WeatherEvents
AbruptClimateChange
IncreasedTemperatures
10
…and What Will Cause the Eruption?
Understanding Dynamic Feedbacks and ConnectionsDavid Robson, Scottish Government, 2009
What underlying forces are we not thinking about? Probably a great many.
Many of these are global problems, whose effects multiply quickly and unpredictably in a complex system.
10
11
Glacier Melt and Polar Ice Loss
11
Gangotri Glacier Himalayas
Melting polar ice is the proverbial canary in the coal mine for planetary health.
In the last two years alone, developments not anticipated by the world’s most respected climate change scientists have occurred, including far faster-than-expected ice melting in the Arctic and other regions.
12
Multiple – Unexpected – Systemic - Interconnected threats
Traditional approaches to analysis and collection are insufficient
DisruptedDisruptedAgricultureAgriculture
New DiseaseNew DiseasePatternsPatterns
StressedStressedMigrationMigration
SocialSocialTurmoilTurmoil
EnergyEnergyScarcityScarcity
TradeTradeDisruptionDisruption
EconomicEconomicVolatilityVolatility
BoostBoostGrievancesGrievances
BoostingBoostingRadicalisationRadicalisation
Rising SeaRising SeaLevelsLevels
PhysicalPhysicalInfrastructureInfrastructureThreatsThreats
IncreasedIncreasedtemperaturestemperaturesClimateClimate
ChangeChange
ResourceResourceconflictsconflicts
OrganisedOrganisedCrimeCrime
BiodiversityBiodiversityLossLoss
FoodFoodshortagesshortages
DisruptedDisruptedStateStateAuthorityAuthority
Energy and Environmental Security . . . a Global security challenge
Food riots in Haiti
Afghanistan ... UN food aid
ChallengeWater Scarcity, Food Security, and Conflict
Drought, food, water scarcity, conflict and high prices do not happen in isolation. They reinforce each other in non-linear, unexpected ways. Their interconnectedness can lead to widespread consequences in the wake of systems failures.
12
Understanding risks and potential consequences:
Key to adaptability and foresight
13
Imagine for a moment what your life would be like if you did not know what a “red light” meant at an intersection. What’s our equivalent for understanding the visual symbols related to energy and environmental consequences?
13
14
Global & co-evolutionary
Recombinant international networks
“Bottom-up” organization
Collaborative foresight techniques
Public sphere
Principles:
International partnership - US initiated
On-line platform and face-to-face
Participants from many nations
Projects emphasizing how to factor risks and uncertainties into assessments
Unclassified, open, multidisciplinary
Implementation So Far:
Deploying Systems For Open Global Engagement:Connecting Across Boundaries
14
14
We’re working to develop new capacities for a globally interdependent world. We’re creating new communities of strategic insight and expertise, working to translate the best of science into security-related consequences and opportunities.
15
President Obama Calls for New Capacities
15
Earlier this year, President Obama said we need “to understand the world as it is to develop the capacities that we need to confront emerging danger and to act with purpose and pragmatism to turn this moment of peril into one of promise.”
Source: Speech at National Defense University in early 2009
http://www.flickr.com/photos/whitehouse/3594694575/sizes/l/in/set-72157619416255803/
White House Official Flickr Photostream
Resiliency and Foresight: New Capacities for Energy and Environmental Security
Re-perceiving security within a global framework
Networking globally and collaboratively as a first resort
Assembling diversity of talent globally
Visualizing the “whole” for enhanced resilience
Overcoming cognitive/organizational barriers to foresight and risk assessment
Deploying systems for open global engagement
16
There is structure beneath the chaos. Our work requires developing new capacities for a radically changed security paradigm the outlines of which are not yet clear, let alone broadly shared and accepted as reality.
Image: Rubber bands, Getty Images
16
Global Concerns, Global ResponsesGlobal Responsibility
17
Beta-testing New Capacities for GlobalStrategic Foresight and Action
These challenges must be considered through a global lens, not a usual perspective applied by traditional national security organizations. They require new capacities for connecting across boundaries—national, organizational, generational, and disciplinary boundaries.
17
18
“A turkey is fed for a 1000 days - every day confirms to its statistical department that the human race cares about its welfare ‘with increased statistical significance’. On the 1001st day, the turkey has a surprise.”
Nassim Nicholas Taleb ‘The Fourth Quadrant, a map of the limits of statistics’, The Edge, 15 SEP 2008
-120
-100
-80
-60
-40
-20
0
20
40
Anatomy of a Blow-up
18
Risk Models Masking Risk: A Common Problem
Another area of focus for us is the challenge of communicating about risks of abrupt change in systems. Inputs to risk models tend to be based on past experience and can induce a false sense of security about the future, as exemplified by Taleb’s example of a turkey’s abrupt ending.
[Climate models don’t incorporate poorly understood feedback mechanisms, like methane release from thawing permafrost, for instance.]
18
19
19
Resiliency in Advance of Disaster
It’s what we least expect that can be most threatening to our national and global security. Diversity of participation in government and non-government partnerships is key to enhanced societal resiliency.
Images: Midwest Floods - NASA MODIS; France Riot – AP; CA Fires – NASA; Hurricane Andrew Damage – NOAA; Mudslide/boulder – NY Times; Ship and Storm – Unknown; Hurricane – NOAA; al Shabab – AP Photo; Iraqi Oil Fire – International Business Times;
http://globaleese.org/20
Deploying Systems For Open Global Engagement
Connect to people: discussion forum with links to articles and documents
Synthesize assessments: ability to ‘rate’ posted documents and articles
Generate insights: threaded conversations
On 24/7 - RSS feeds to your homepage
Coming soon: Library/ Bibliography and a 'Question Stream'
Connect to people: discussion forum with links to articles and documents
Synthesize assessments: ability to ‘rate’ posted documents and articles
Generate insights: threaded conversations
On 24/7 - RSS feeds to your homepage
Coming soon: Library/ Bibliography and a 'Question Stream'
In response to these challenges, we’re beta-testing an online forum complementing face-to-face meetings. We call this an “ecosystem” : it emphasizes diversity of participation and talent. I hope our vision of a global foresight common, is large enough to match the scale of the challenges we’re facing. Thank you.
20