Date post: | 02-Apr-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | darin-selby |
View: | 213 times |
Download: | 0 times |
7/27/2019 Energy Water Collision
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/energy-water-collision 1/9
IEEE.org | IEEE Xplore Digital Library | IEEE Standards | IEEE Spectrum | More Sites
Follow on:
Energywise Energy Fossil Fuels
Collision Between Water and Energy IsCollision Between Water and Energy IsUnderway, and WorseningUnderway, and WorseningBy Katherine Tweed
Posted 18 Jul 2013 | 18:32 GMT
Share | Email | Print
When a heat wave spread across the Midwest in the summer of 2012, the
Powerton coal plant in central Illinois had to temporarily shut down a
generator when its water supply became too warm to effectively cool the plant.
Although 2012 was a year of severe drought in the U.S., the problems seen at
various coal, nuclear, and hydropower facilities last summer are only likely to
increase in coming years unless the power sector quickly changes its way of
doing business, according to a new study from the Union of Concerned
Scientists (UCS) [PDF]. The problem is that the power sector is not known for
moving quickly.
Related StoriesRelated Stories
Topics
Reports
Blogs
Multimedia
Magazine
Resources
Search
EnergywiseEnergywise
IEEE Spectrum’s energy, power, and
green tech blog, featuring news and
analysis about the future of energy,
climate, and the smart grid.
ContributorsContributors
Newsletter Sign UpNewsletter Sign Up
Sign up for the EnergyWise
newsletter and get biweekly news on
the power & energy industry, green
technology, and conservation
delivered directly to your inbox.
EditorEditor
Bill Sweet
New York City, USA
ContributorContributor
Dave Levitan
New York City, USA
ContributorContributor
Peter Fairley
British Columbia,
Canada
Sign UpSign Up
Advertisement
converted by Web2PDFConvert.com
7/27/2019 Energy Water Collision
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/energy-water-collision 2/9
Power generation in the United States relies heavily on water. For some
plants, like the ones that run on coal or nuclear power, the water is needed for
cooling, while hydro directly uses water for energy production. More than 40
percent of fresh water used in the United States is withdrawn to cool power
plants. Renewable energy generally uses far less water, but there are glaring
exceptions, such as geothermal and concentrating solar.
The report, part of UCS’s Energy and Water in a Warming World Initiative,
noted that even though the oldest and most water-hungry, coal-fired power
plants are being retired, the shift to cleaner energy isn’t happening fast
enough to overcome increasing water shortages.
“We set electricity and water on a collision course years ago. Now we must
build a power system hard-wired not for risk, but for resilience,” Peter
Frumhoff, UCS's director of science and policy and chair of the project’sScientific Advisory Committee, said in a statement.
The report found that although coal use would drop significantly through
2050, the change would not significantly reduce the power sector’s carbon
emissions because demand would rise and natural gas would mostly replace
coal. Other estimates find coal use dropping more quickly. With the looming
mercury and air toxic standards (MATS) rule from the U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency, Black &Veatch recently estimated that nearly 60 gigawatts
of coal generation will retire by 2020.
As coal use plummets, there could be serious water savings under a business-as-usual scenario, because most new power plants would use recirculated or
dry cooling and gas-fired power plants require less cooling. The study
estimates freshwater withdrawals could drop more than 80 percent by 2050
and water consumption would go down by more than 40 percent. The savings
would not be same across the country, however, and water use for power
could even rise in some areas, such as the Great Lakes region.
There also could be even further complications. Even though gas-fired power
plants use less water than coal or nuclear, the process of extracting gas by
hydrofracking requires far more water than conventional drilling.
Also, even though some newer plants might use far less water, they could find
that there’s far less water available as water temperatures go up and water
flows go down. Another study found that nearly half of 423 U.S. plants were at
risk of lower power output during droughts because their intake pipes for
water were less than 3 meters below the surface.
Wind Now Cost CompetitiveWind Now Cost CompetitiveWith Coal in IndiaWith Coal in India
Lower need for water and falling pricesmake renewables more attractive23 Jul
Energy
Minnesota Nuclear PlantMinnesota Nuclear PlantUpgrade Is $267 Million OverUpgrade Is $267 Million OverBudgetBudgetA nuclear plant's 20-year extension
comes at a high cost16 Jul
Energy
Can Wastewater Injection fromCan Wastewater Injection fromFracking Cause Earthquakes?Fracking Cause Earthquakes?A scientific study suggests so, which is
bound to complicate regulation11 Jul
Energy
converted by Web2PDFConvert.com
7/27/2019 Energy Water Collision
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/energy-water-collision 3/9
Although the business-as-usual scenario could be bleak, there is another way
forward, according to the report. A mix of energy efficiency and renewable
energy could vastly from the water needed to keep the lights on.
First, the UCS sees energy efficiency offsetting what would otherwise be
increased levels of energy use. That is already happening, with electricity use
levels nearly flatlining from 1978 to 2005.
The second part of the scenario, with renewables producing 80 percent of energy demand, is a tough target. If the aggressive renewable target could be
achieved (California and Hawaii have the most aggressive renewable portfolio
standards in the country, at 33 and 40 percent, respectively), water
consumption would drop by 85 percent and water withdrawals would be 97
percent lower.
The study argues that the renewables-and-efficiency scenario would free up
water for the agricultural sector, which is already fighting with power projects
for the right to constrained water resources.
Although 80 percent renewable energy is a stretch across most of the United
States at this time, the study notes several ways that we can get closer to the
renewables-and-efficiency scenario, rather than business as usual. Plants
could use non-potable wastewater instead of freshwater for cooling and states
can strengthen energy efficiency resource standards and renewable energy
portfolio standards.
Of course, the water industry also uses a significant amount of energy and
more efficient wastewater treatment plants and more efficiency in municipal
water systems will also be critical in coming years.
“We can untangle the production of electricity from our water supply to a
much greater degree, and we can build a low-carbon electricity system,” study
authors wrote. “But we cannot wait, nor do either in isolation, without
compromising both. We must get this right.”
Photo: iStockphoto
Learn More drought energy production power plants renewable energy water
efficiency water power water shortage water-energy nexus
125 23
ShareShare
Share | Email | Print196
Like
CommentsComments Comment Policy
Advertisement
Netherlands Builds NationwideNetherlands Builds NationwideEV Fast-Charging Network EV Fast-Charging Network Start your (electric vehicle) engines10 Jul
Green Tech
North China Pollution Cuts LifeNorth China Pollution Cuts LifeEx ectanc b More than FiveEx ectanc b More than Five
Energy
converted by Web2PDFConvert.com
7/27/2019 Energy Water Collision
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/energy-water-collision 4/9
7 comments
Leave a message...
Best Community
Ghung •
“We set electricity and water on a collision course yearsago. Now we must build a power system hard-wired not for risk, but for resilience,”
Ya think?! The AME has been warning about this stuff for years but we're not very go
who rode reactors for the Navy and spent a chunk of his life mapping and designing p
keeps the PV clean, then goes about it's business.
This year, TVA has been dumping water as fast as they can; a few years ago, lake le
your systems, there isn't much slack for these weather/climate variations. Kind of har3
Tony •
"A mix of energy efficiency and renewable energy could vastly from the water needed
???2
drkennethnoisewater •
Of course, molten-salt reactors (particularly, LFTR ) not only don't need water cooling,
desalination, thus _increasing_ fresh water supplies. Plants that could be powered fro
waste.1
GoodCheer •
Well no power generation technology NEEDs water for cooling, it just makes evUsing air as your final heat dump requires huge cooling infrastructure.1
Uzza •
How hard air cooling is depends on the source that's to be cooled. If th
massive infrastructure. But if the source is high temperature e.g. ~100
something is the faster it radiates energy.
Also a factor in the amount of cooling needed is the thermal efficiency
about 33% thermal efficiency, meaning for every GW generated there'
Modern high efficiency CCGT can reach an efficiency of 60%, reducing
Molten salt reactors are high temperature reactors generally running ab
The high temperature also allows them to use brayton cycle gas turbin
generated by half for every watt compared to current LWRs.
Then there's the use that drkennethnoisewater mentioned, using the w
producer of fresh water.
GoodCheer •
You're kinda double counting. You can't have both high efficienc
limited by the materials properties of turbines and plumbing, so
any other thermal source. And the low end is limited by ambientput into cooling.
Years YearsMore than ever, the People's Republic
desperately needs clean tech10 Jul
Contextualizing Conergy'sContextualizing Conergy'sSolar FailureSolar FailureThe relatively tiny photovoltaics market
is still stabilizing9 Jul
Green Tech
Advertisement
Japan Will Help Kenya Unlock Japan Will Help Kenya Unlock Its Geothermal PotentialIts Geothermal PotentialGeothermal is a big part of Kenya's bold
plans to electrify half the population9 Jul
Energy
converted by Web2PDFConvert.com
7/27/2019 Energy Water Collision
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/energy-water-collision 5/9
erma source s a erma source. a you o w your
separate from the decision to use coal, gas, or LFTR.
Manofsteel11 •
Rating agencies have missed this one, as well as other major risks.
Both water and energy utilities enjoy high ratings, which do not take into account huge
One must wonder who has a complete current quantitive map of what 'water scarcity'
See for example: http://www.ey.com/Publication/...
World's Biggest Offshore WindWorld's Biggest Offshore WindFarm Switched On in BritainFarm Switched On in BritainMassive London Array dwarfs previous
record-holder, can power a half million
homes8 Jul
Green Tech
Obama's $7 Billion for AfricanObama's $7 Billion for AfricanElectricityElectricity
Yes, you guessed it: There's less therethan meets the eye3 Jul
Energy
Spanish Town Taps Sewage toSpanish Town Taps Sewage toMake BiofuelMake BiofuelThe EU hopes wastewater is the secret to
producing algal oils at scale2 Jul
Energy
converted by Web2PDFConvert.com
7/27/2019 Energy Water Collision
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/energy-water-collision 6/9
Project Aims to Make LakeProject Aims to Make LakeGeorge World’s “SmartestGeorge World’s “SmartestLake”Lake”Predictive modeling could help save Lake
George and other threatened waters1 Jul
Energy
U.S. Climate Plan Covers theU.S. Climate Plan Covers theBasesBases
In this particular case, there appears to beno devil in the details29 Jun
Energy
A Cheaper Option to TurnA Cheaper Option to TurnCarbon Dioxide Into SyntheticCarbon Dioxide Into SyntheticFuelFuelMaybe we won't need to bury carbon
dioxide after all27 Jun
Green Tech
converted by Web2PDFConvert.com
7/27/2019 Energy Water Collision
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/energy-water-collision 7/9
Obama Delivers a DefiningObama Delivers a DefiningSpeech on Climate ChangeSpeech on Climate ChangeHe also delivers a comprehensive plan,
but in this case the rhetoric may be more
important than the details25 Jun
Energy
DOE Opens New Smart GridDOE Opens New Smart GridIntegration Testing FacilityIntegration Testing Facility
As renewable penetration goes up, thegrid will need to be far more flexible24 Jun
Energy
Car Battery Swapping Is Dead;Car Battery Swapping Is Dead;Long Live Car BatteryLong Live Car BatterySwappingSwappingTesla resurrects an appealing idea only
just given up for dead22 Jun
Green Tech
converted by Web2PDFConvert.com
7/27/2019 Energy Water Collision
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/energy-water-collision 8/9
Better Home NetworkingBetter Home NetworkingCould Save $330 MillionCould Save $330 MillionRunning a broadband modem and router
all day uses a surprising amount of energy20 Jun
Energy
German Parliament OKs BoldGerman Parliament OKs BoldHVDC Grid UpgradeHVDC Grid UpgradeGermany's parliament and senate
approved a bold grid upgrade that couldchallenge AC power's century-long reign18 Jun
Energy
Advanced Occupancy SensorsAdvanced Occupancy SensorsSlash Energy Bills, KeepSlash Energy Bills, KeepEveryone HappyEveryone HappyForget about lighting, sensors offer far
greater savings when managing airflow18 Jun
Green Tech
converted by Web2PDFConvert.com
7/27/2019 Energy Water Collision
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/energy-water-collision 9/9
TopicsTopics
Aerospace At Work
Biomedical
Computing
Energy
Gadgets
Geek Life
Robotics
Semiconductors
Telecom
ConnectConnect
FacebookTwitter
Google+
RSS
IEEE SpectrumIEEE Spectrum
Contact Us About
Newsletters
Mobile Site
IEEE PartnersIEEE Partners
Advertising &
Media Center
IEEE Job Site
Buyer’s Guide
The MagazineThe Magazine
Subscribe Now
Digital Download
© Copyright 2013 IEEE Spectrum Terms & Conditions |Privacy & Security|Nondiscrimination
Policy
About IEEE
Conferences & Events
Education & Careers
Membership & Services
Publications and Standards
Societies & Communities
China Launches Pilot CarbonChina Launches Pilot CarbonEmissions Trading SystemEmissions Trading SystemWith its usual talent for copying the most
successful, China is starting small18 Jun
Energy