The audio portion of the conference may be accessed via the telephone or by using your computer's
speakers. Please refer to the instructions emailed to registrants for additional information. If you
have any questions, please contact Customer Service at 1-800-926-7926 ext. 10.
Presenting a live 90-minute webinar with interactive Q&A
Equity Rollovers in M&A:
Bridging the Finance and Valuation Gap Negotiating and Structuring Rollovers; Tax Considerations for Buyers and Sellers
Today’s faculty features:
1pm Eastern | 12pm Central | 11am Mountain | 10am Pacific
WEDNESDAY, JUNE 7, 2017
David R. Hardy, Partner, Osler Hoskin & Harcourt, New York
George H. Wang, Partner, Barton, New York
Tips for Optimal Quality
Sound Quality
If you are listening via your computer speakers, please note that the quality
of your sound will vary depending on the speed and quality of your internet
connection.
If the sound quality is not satisfactory, you may listen via the phone: dial
1-888-450-9970 and enter your PIN when prompted. Otherwise, please
send us a chat or e-mail [email protected] immediately so we can
address the problem.
If you dialed in and have any difficulties during the call, press *0 for assistance.
Viewing Quality
To maximize your screen, press the F11 key on your keyboard. To exit full screen,
press the F11 key again.
FOR LIVE EVENT ONLY
Continuing Education Credits
In order for us to process your continuing education credit, you must confirm your
participation in this webinar by completing and submitting the Attendance
Affirmation/Evaluation after the webinar.
A link to the Attendance Affirmation/Evaluation will be in the thank you email
that you will receive immediately following the program.
For additional information about continuing education, call us at 1-800-926-7926
ext. 35.
FOR LIVE EVENT ONLY
Program Materials
If you have not printed the conference materials for this program, please
complete the following steps:
• Click on the ^ symbol next to “Conference Materials” in the middle of the left-
hand column on your screen.
• Click on the tab labeled “Handouts” that appears, and there you will see a
PDF of the slides for today's program.
• Double click on the PDF and a separate page will open.
• Print the slides by clicking on the printer icon.
FOR LIVE EVENT ONLY
Financial vs. strategic buyers
Non-control, post-closing equity participation by seller’s management
team/founders Non-control
○ Typically 10 - 40%
Up to 49%
Type of security ○ Equity
Same rights as buyer or junior in rights
○ Debt - subordinated Seller Note
Anchor Investment vs. Tag-on portfolio acquisition
Objectives – Defer tax gain to rollover participants; step up to buyer
6
Example 1
8-12% of the equity post transaction allocated/reserved for senior management
Example 2
Pursuant to a merger, or other mutually agreeable form of transaction, (x) one or more Investor(s) will acquire all of the equity of Target currently held by Old PE Fund, (y) the Phantom Equity (defined below) of Target will be redeemed by Target so that it is no longer outstanding and (z) substantially all of the equity currently held by the management team and management companies owned by the management team (the “Management Companies”) will be “rolled forward” so that the management team and the Management Companies will remain equity holders in Target post-Transaction. (20% pre-closing management participation)
Example 3
Seller Note: If the Company's ratio of indebtedness divided by LTM EBITDA will be less than 4.5 immediately as of the closing, then the Seller, or an affiliate of the Seller, will lend to the Company an amount in cash equal to the amount required to cause such ratio to equal 4.5. The definition of LTM EBITDA will be mutually agreed between the parties. Such loan shall be made pursuant to a promissory note on terms and conditions to be mutually agreed by the parties and will be subordinated to all other debt of the Company, and will be subject to a subordination agreement satisfactory to the lenders.
Seller Co-Investment: Due to the importance of the Seller to Target, Seller has the option to co-invest up to 49% of the closing equity value of the Target in order to share in the future equity appreciation.
7
Incentivizes on-going management
Management participation in future appreciation Subsequent PE exit, IPO or sale
Aligns management with acquirer
Bridges financing and valuation gaps
8
Representative deal terms from a recent PE term sheet:
Enterprise valuation = 6.1 x LTM historic EBITDA + 6.1 x post-closing
annualized, normalized quarterly EBITDA
Debt financing
○ Senior or mezzanine debt – up to 4.5 x LTM EBITDA
○ Seller note = shortfall of senior/mezz debt to 4.5 x multiple
Equity roll – co-invest up to 49% of closing equity value
9
Potential conflicts of interest Fiduciary duty of rolling persons
Decision by conflicted members of board
Alignment with buyer vs. seller
○ Use Rep and Warranty Insurance to mitigate issue?
Selection of only certain rollover participants
Complication of negotiations Rights of the rolling management vs. buyer.
Equity vs. non-equity members of management
Equity of buyer and founders may not be of same class
10
Type of equity Common vs. participating preferred (PIK dividends)
Tax considerations Stock vs. asset deal
Buyer’s basis step up vs. taxable roll-over parties
Ability to convert corporation to pass-through structure
○ Delaware vs New York entity
Acquisition at holdco or subsidiary level
Domestic vs. cross-border considerations e.g. Luxembourg CPEC structure
11
Maintain percentage of equity
Maintain percentage of debt equal to equity percentage
Exceptions: Options and incentive plans to directors, employees and consultants
Redemption from majority shareholder (not to exceed 10%) for resale to new investors
Minority may not have financial wherewithal to buy
12
Priority of Payment to Rollover participants Pari passu
Preferred return to PE fund/Fund and management ○ On IPO, Fund typically receives preferred return
“Promote” style compensation to management?
Liquidation preference to preferred?
Example 1 First, PE fund receives return of equity investment without any return on capital
Second, co-investors receive return of co-investment (based on closing value) without return of capital
Third, distributions pro rata
Example 2 First, PE fund and co-investors receive pro rata distributions until capital and deemed capital is
returned
Second, PE fund and co-investors receive distributions equal to 10.1% IRR
Third, co-investors receive a promote of 17.5% and PE fund and co-investors share pro rata in 82.5% balance
Example 3 Pro rata distributions to PE fund and management
13
Tag along with debt or equity – pro rata Substantially all deals
Bear pro rata price adjustment, indemnity obligations
Exceptions to Tag-Along Sale to shareholders,
less than 10% Equity or Debt,
per registered offer
Drag along on sale of company or substantially all assets Any minimum price to require drag
Rights of first refusal / first negotiation More limited than Tag along/ drag along
Possible lock-up period
○ Three years, except for Permitted Transfers, vs. immediate right to sell
Board/Observer Seats 14
S-1 Demand Number
By whom
When – anytime, after qualified IPO
Piggyback Against whom – anyone, issuer only
Proper notice
Priority
S-3
15
Voting Rights Board seat
Supramajority rights
○ Amend charter or capital structure
○ Change business
○ Change auditors or accounting principles
○ Make non cash distributions of profits
○ Merger or sale of business
○ Enter contracts or capital expenditures in excess of $
Veto rights
○ Wind-up or liquidate
Merger or sale of business
Dividends Rarely paid currently, accumulated and paid at liquidity event
Voting with majority on transfers of assets, acquisitions, election of Board
16
Vesting – say three years
Permitted transfers
Right to initiate sale, including engage advisors and require rollover to participate in marketing efforts
Right to force partial sale of a development project
Rights regarding corporate opportunities: Side by side fund
Non-compete and customer/employee non-solicit covenants Term following rollover equity no longer having securities
Buyer having de minimus amount (10%)
Rights of redemption
Equity transfer restrictions
Access to financial statements and other information and personnel
17
Subordination Fully subordinate vs. pari passu
Secured Second lien
Unsecured note
Acceleration on sale or change of control
“AHYDO” (accelerated high yield discount obligations) interest provisions Avoid adverse tax effect
18
Mechanism for Fund to charge fees to target
Term – ten years, thereafter automatic renewal but terminable by PE fund
Advisory fee – 2% EBITDA or annual minimum
Expense requirement including counsel and auditor fees
Transaction fees – 1% of consideration for refinancing’s, equity or debt
offering, dividends recaps
Fees violative of financing agreements will accrue and be payable when
allowable
19
Mechanism for Fund to charge fees to Letter of Intent
Rollover Agreement
Securityholders’ Agreement
Registration Rights Agreement
Certificate of Incorporation Rights, Preferences and Designations
Seller Note Non-solicit and non-competes
○ 3-4 year average non-compete
Advisory Agreement for Fund 20
George H. Wang is a corporate transactions attorney who focuses his
practice on mergers, acquisitions, joint ventures, investments and broad-
scope business transactions on behalf of clients in North America, Asia and
Europe. He has represented domestic and multinational clients on numerous
domestic and cross-border merger and acquisition, private equity, venture
capital and related transactions.
George has led several large cross-border private equity and merger and
acquisition transactions, including a transaction which was awarded 2013
Domestic Deal of the Year by LatinFinance.
George has represented strategics, private equity funds, their portfolio
companies and family offices in acquiring North American, Asian and
European targets, completing serial acquisitions, multi-continent M&A
transactions, acquisitions of United States public companies and “going
private” transactions and joint ventures.
George was recently named Cornell Asian Alumni Association Honoree of the
Year by his alma mater, Cornell University (B.S.) and The Cornell Law School
(JD). For more than a decade, George served as an Educational Counselor to
the Admissions Committee of The Massachusetts Institute of Technology
(S.M. in Engineering). He is the immediate past Board Chair of the Asian
American Federation, the leading pan-Asian Advocacy organization in the
New York metropolitan area working to advance the civic voice of Asian
Americans.
413906.1
21
Seller Equity Rollovers in M&A
Tax Considerations
David R. Hardy, Partner
Osler, Hoskin & Harcourt LLP
New York City
Stafford Webinar June 7, 2017
LEGAL_1: 44339532.1
Tax Considerations Agenda
1. Deal Objectives
2. Basic Tax Consequences of Middle Market Acquisition Transactions
3. Requirements for Stepped-Up Basis to Buyer
4. Requirements for Tax-Free Rollover to Sellers
5. Restructuring Opportunities to Harmonize Buyer and Sellers Objectives
Equity Rollovers Tax Considerations
23
Stafford Webinar June 7, 2017
a. Buyer’s Objectives
• Acquire Control
• Maximize After-Tax Returns – Stepped-Up Asset Basis
• Minimize Fiduciary Complexities or Impediments to Resale
• Preserve Historic Licenses Without Tax Contingencies
• Retain Key Management Personnel
b. Seller’s Objectives
• Achieve Liquidity Event
• Maximize After-Tax Proceeds – One Level of Tax
• To Retain a Participation in Post-Transaction Appreciation
24
Stafford Webinar June 7, 2017
1. Deal Objectives
1. Deal Objectives (con’t.)
c. Structuring Tax Free Rollovers – With Basis Step-Up
• For Partnerships and Flow Through Entities
• For S Corporations
• For C Corporations
25
Stafford Webinar June 7, 2017
2. Basic Tax Consequences
a. Share Sale of Taxable C Corporation
• Seller’s Sell Shares – Realize a Capital Gain on Shares Taxed 20% Rate – One Level of Tax
• Buyer Buys Shares – Obtains a Cost Basis in Shares. Share Investment is not Depreciable; Share Basis Will Only Produce a Tax Benefit When Resold.
b. Sale of C Corporation’s Assets
• Selling Corporation Pay Tax on Asset Gains at 35%; then Distributes Cash to Shareholder Who Pay Tax on Their Share Gains at 20% – Two Levels of Tax (But Consider Shareholder Goodwill and Non-Competes)
• Buyer Get Stepped Up Asset Basis, Including Goodwill and Going Concern Value Amortizable Over 15 Years; Avoids Historic and Contingent Liabilities.
26
Stafford Webinar June 7, 2017
2. Basic Tax Consequences (con’t.)
c. Sale of Partnerships, Branches, or Disregarded Entities
• All Transparent or Flow-Through Entities.
• Buyer May Buy Ownership Interest or Assets; Purchase Price Treated as Paid for Assets. Stepped-Up Asset Basis Increases Depreciation and Amortization Allowing Tax Sheltered Cash Flow to Pay Down Acquisition Debt.
• Sellers Sell Assets or Ownership Interests in the Entity. Sellers Realize a Capital Gain on Assets – One Level of Tax at 20% Rate (Except Depreciation Recapture Taxed at Ordinary Rates).
d. S Corporation – Treated as Modified Flow Through.
• Sale of Assets Gives Buyer Stepped Up Asset Basis – Selling Shareholders One to Level of Tax (Asset Gains May Flow Through at Ordinary Rates for Receivables and Depreciable Assets).
27
Stafford Webinar June 7, 2017
2. Basic Tax Consequences (con’t.)
• Consider §1374 Entity Level Tax for S Corporations That Have Converted From C Corporations During the Prior 5 Years.
• Sale of Shares Gives Buyer a High Share Basis, No Asset Step-Up; Sellers have one Level of Tax.
e. Section 338 Election (Similar Results May Exist Under 336(e))
• 338(g) Allows Sale of Shares to Be Treated as an Asset Sale by the Target Company (Tax Obligation Retained in the Entity).
• 338(h)(10) Allows Shares Sale to be Treated as an Asset Sale But Asset Gains are Taxed to Selling Consolidated Group or Selling S Corp Shareholders (Tax Thrown Back to Sellers).
28
Stafford Webinar June 7, 2017
3. Requirements for Step-Up
a. Buyer’s Asset Step-Up Requires
• Asset Purchase
• A Constructive Asset Purchase – Purchase of Transparent Entity (Partnership, Branch or Disregard Entity)
• Deemed Asset Purchase Under Section 338
b. Asset Purchase is Prohibitively Expensive if:
• Seller is a C Corp. with Substantial Asset Gains (Self Created Goodwill Has a Zero Basis)
• Seller is a C Corp. without a Large NOL
29
Stafford Webinar June 7, 2017
3. Requirements for Step-Up (con’t.)
c. Section 338 Requirements
• Buyer Acquires 80% of Vote and Value of Shares
• Share Acquisition Obtained by Purchase (Not Non-Taxable Share Contribution or Tax-Free Reorganization)
• Share Acquisition Must Occur Within a 12-Month Acquisition Period
• Buyer Election 338(g) (Basic 338) or Mutual Election by Buyer and Seller Under 338(h)(10) with Agreed Upon Purchase Price Allocation (i.e., Tax Thrown Back to Sellers)
• Difficult for Tax Free Rollover Because All Target’s Assets Have Been Sold All Selling Shareholders Will Recognize Proportionate Share of Taxable Gain
30
Stafford Webinar June 7, 2017
4. Requirement for Tax Free Rollover
a. Generally All Sellers Will Be Taxable on Cash Received for Target Equity
b. Compensatory Shares Will Generate Ordinary Income to Employees. Post Closing Vesting Requirements are Inconsistent with Rollover Treatment
c. Sellers Either: (i) Don’t Sell (Some or all Sellers Retain Some or all Equity), or (ii) Exchange Old Equity for New Equity in a Tax Free Incorporation Transaction
31
Stafford Webinar June 7, 2017
4. Requirement for Tax Free Rollover (con’t.)
d. Consistency with Buyer’s Asset Step-Up Objectives
• Target Partnerships are Most Consistent with Competing Objectives – Sellers One Level of Tax with Rollover Opportunity and Buyers Step-Up
• Sellers Retaining Equity in Excess of 20% can Prevent §338(h)(10) Election
• For Target S Corporations and C Corporations – Certain Structures Exist
32
Stafford Webinar June 7, 2017
5. Harmonizing Buyer and Seller Objectives
a. Flow Through Targets
• Partnerships, LLC Treated as Partnership, and Disregarded Entities are not Taxed as Entities. Taxable Income Follows Through to Owners
• Flow Through Entities Most Easily Accommodate Harmonization of Buyer’s Stepped-Up Basis with Seller Rollover Opportunity
• Seller Rollover Can Be Proportionate or Disproportionate
33
Stafford Webinar June 7, 2017
5. Harmonizing Buyer and Seller Objectives
b. Flow Throughs
34
Stafford Webinar June 7, 2017
Shareholders
Private
Equity
Partnership
Target
Management
70%
• Example
• Buyer obtains a
Basis Step-Up in
Partnership Assets
for its Purchase
Price (§§754 and
743)
• Sellers Retained
Rollover Shares can
be Proportionate or
Disproportionate
• Introducing New
Holdco Can
Complicate
Analysis. (See
§§708 and Rev.
Rul. 99-6)
Cash
5. Harmonizing Buyer and Seller Objectives (con’t.)
c. C Corporation Target – Rollover and Step-Up Together are Difficult
35
Stafford Webinar June 7, 2017
Shareholders
Target
Private
Equity
Holdco
New
Target
• Rollover Without Step-
Up – Shareholders Sell
Some Shares to P.E. in
Taxable Transaction;
Shareholders Retain (or
Contribute to Holdco)
Rollover Equity
• No Tax Basis Step-Up to
Buyer or Holdco!!
(Might Consider Interest
Expense on Acquisition
Debt at Holdco Offset or
Shareholder Level
Goodwill)
• Rollover can be
Proportionate or
Disproportionate
5. Harmonizing Buyer and Seller Objectives (con’t.)
d. C Corporation Target – Basis Step-Up But With Two Levels of Tax
36
Stafford Webinar June 7, 2017
Private
Equity
Shareholders
Target
Target
Assets
• Part Sale / Part Retained
Ownership. Say P.E.
Fund Contributes Cash
for 70% of Targets
Assets
• P.E. Fund Buyer Gets
Asset Step-Up for Its
Benefit Only (§743)
• Selling Shareholders
Have Two Levels of Tax
on Cash Portion of the
Transaction
5. Harmonizing Buyer and Seller Objectives (con’t.)
e. S Corporation Target
• Section 338(h)(10) Election Available to Treat Stock Sale as an Asset Purchase (Buyer Gets Step-Up)
• Buyer Must Acquire 80%; All Assets Deemed Sold
• S Corp.’s Taxable Gain Allocated to Selling Shareholder’s – Pro-Rata. (Target Sellers Seeking Rollover will be Taxable)
• Buyer Acquires Historic Entity with any Tax Contingencies
f. F Reorganization Structure – Preserves Historic Licenses,
but Buyer Avoids Historic Tax Contingencies 37
Stafford Webinar June 7, 2017
5. Harmonizing Buyer and Seller Objectives (con’t.)
38
Stafford Webinar June 7, 2017
Private
Equity
Shareholders
Target
Target
LLC
• F Reorganization Steps:
• Seller’s Drop Target S
Corp. into New
Holdco and Elect Q
Sub Status – Tax Free
• §368(a)(1)(F)
• Sellers – Merge Target into
LLC
• Buyers Purchase all or
Most of LLC. Not a 338,
but a Partnership Purchase
(Can Acquire Less than
80%)
• Buyer gets Stepped Basis;
Sellers gets One Level of
tax and Proportionate
Rollover Opportunity.
Holdco C
New S
Cash
Target LLC
Units
Bio
David’s practice focuses on corporate and international tax including the tax issues affecting corporations in the energy industry. He has been involved in cross-border merger transactions, including public company stock acquisitions, joint ventures, project financings, cross-border security issuances, inbound and outbound securities, real estate and private equity partnerships. David is the past President of the International Tax Institute in New York, past chair of the Taxation Committee of the International Bar Association and a long time member of the Executive Committee of the NYS Bar Tax Section. In addition, he is a frequent speaker at tax conferences and frequently writes on various topics. He has been the principal author of a number of NYS Bar Tax Section reports on subjects including the anti-double dip finance provisions, the anti-hybrid provisions of the U.S.-Canada treaty, the non-recognition rules regarding the outbound transfers of intangible property, and the consistency principle in tax treaty interpretation.
39