+ All Categories
Home > Documents > EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation....

EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation....

Date post: 27-Jul-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 2 times
Download: 5 times
Share this document with a friend
38
EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN OVERVIEW Prasanta Kalita, Rabin Bhattarai Department of Agricultural and Biological Engineering University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Transcript
Page 1: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN OVERVIEW

Prasanta Kalita, Rabin BhattaraiDepartment of Agricultural and Biological Engineering

University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

Page 2: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Erosion Control Research and Training Centero Established in 2010 to conduct research and education on erosion

and sediment control Training Research

Page 3: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Training Activitieso Module I: Fundamentals of Storm Water Pollution and Erosion and Sediment

Controlo Module II: Erosion and Sediment Control Planning and Designo Module III: Inspection of Erosion and Sediment Control Best Management

Practices (BMPS)

Page 4: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Hydrologic Cycle

Page 5: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Runoff and Infiltration

Page 6: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Soil Erosion

http://www.nrcs.usda.gov/wps/portal/nrcs/main/national/landuse/crops/erosion/

o Breakdown, transport, and redistribution of soil particles by the forces of water or wind.

o Understanding and managing these processes has important long term implications.

o Land area globally affected: o 1094 million ha by water erosion,

549 million ha by wind erosion (Lal, 2003)

o Significant economic burden US - 44 billion dollars/year (Pimentel

et al., 1995). EU - 38 billion euros/year

(Montanarella, 2007)

Page 7: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Soil Erosion

EPA (2007) National Water Quality Inventory

Page 8: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Soil Erosion

http://www.epa.gov/owow/NPS/MMGI/Chapter4/ch4-3a.html

Page 9: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Consequences of Soil ErosionLoss of soil health

Depletion of nutrients and organic matterAggregate instabilityReduced plant vigor and health

Environmental degradationWater quality

Point and Non-point source pollutionImpacts to plant and animal life

Aquatic & TerrestrialAir quality

Point and Non-point source pollutionImpacts to human health and safety

Economic impactNotice of Violation (NOV) $$$$$$$$$

It takes 100-600 years to form an inch of topsoil

Page 10: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Types of Soil Erosion

Water erosiono Splash/raindrop erosiono Sheet erosiono Rill erosiono Gully erosion

Wind erosiono Suspensiono Saltationo Creep

Page 11: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Water Erosion

Page 12: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Erosion and Sediment Estimation

1. Measure for the real world conditions

Page 13: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Factors Affecting Soil Erosion

Rainfall – intensity and duration

Soil type (soil amendments)Slope lengthSteepnessLand cover – grass, mulch, etc.Conservation practices

What factors can the designers/contractors change for a construction site?

Page 14: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Research Activitieso Evaluation of various erosion and sediment control products for IDOT

o Ditch checkso Inlet protection deviceso Perimeter barrier products

Page 15: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

o Test vegetation establishment under 5 cover practices (one bare)

o Document growth of vegetation and erosion patternso Collect biomass samples of vegetation

Vegetation Cover Evaluation

Hydroseed-Mulch Hydroseed Compost Mulch

Page 16: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

2011-03-04 (Hydroseed-Mulch, Hydroseed, Compost, Mulch, Bare)

Page 17: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

2011-05-12 (Hydroseed-Mulch, Hydroseed, Compost, Mulch, Bare)

Page 18: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

2011-05-31 (Hydroseed-Mulch, Hydroseed, Compost, Mulch, Bare)

Page 19: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Vegetation Cover Evaluation

Page 20: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Four 3H:1V plots, 35’ long by 8’ wide Three cover materials and one control

Mushroom compost Screened garden compost Premium shredded hardwood mulch Bare soil (control)

Compost Covers for Rill Erosion Protection

Page 21: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Bare soil

Compost Covers for Rill Erosion Protection

Page 22: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Screened garden compost

Compost Covers for Rill Erosion Protection

Page 23: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Shredded hardwood mulch

Compost Covers for Rill Erosion Protection

Page 24: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Mushroom compost

Compost Covers for Rill Erosion Protection

Page 25: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

1. Bare plot

3. Mulch

2. Garden compost

4. Mushroom compost

1. Bare plot

2. Garden compost

3. Mulch

4. Mushroom compost

Page 26: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Bhattarai et al. (2011)

Bhattarai et al. (2011)

Compost Cover for Erosion Control

Page 27: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation

Test ECBs under 4 in/hr rainfall intensity for 30 minutes and compare to control condition (bare plot)

Record runoff rates, sediment concentrations, and erosion patterns

Determine overall soil loss

Page 28: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation

Page 29: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Curlex I DS-75 SC-150Control plot

Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation

Page 30: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Ditch Check Evaluation Test ditch checks under 3 flow conditions (5, 7.5, and

10 L/s) Record erosion patterns and sediment accumulation Collect the water samples for turbidity and sediment

concentration measurement

Page 31: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Ditch Check EvaluationAverage testing channel soil loss under 10 L s-1 flow rate.

Page 32: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Ditch Check Evaluation

Bulnes Garcia et al. (2015)

Page 33: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Inlet Protection Product Evaluation

Test inlet protection products under two flow conditions (5 and 10 L/s)

Record channel disturbance and observe any performance issues/failures

Collect water samples for turbidity and sediment concentration measurement

Silt Fence Welded wire with woven fabric

Page 34: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

05

10152025303540455055

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80

5 L/s 10 L/s

NTU

s

Time (min)

Welded Wire (Around Grate)

05

10152025303540455055

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120

5 L/s 10 L/s

NTU

s

Time (min)

Silt Fence

05

10152025303540455055

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120

5 L/s 10 L/s

NTU

sTime (min)

Welded Wire (Around Concrete)

Inlet Protection Product Evaluation

Bhattarai et al. (2016)

Page 35: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Sediment Control Product Evaluation

Evaluation of curb and gutter inlet protection products

Evaluation of flared-end inlet protection products

Frame & Grate Dandy Curb Sack Erosion Eel SediGuard

Page 36: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

ERTEC ProWattle (HDPE)

woven monofilament geotextile

compost log (Filtrexx Siltsoxx)

Evaluation of Perimeter Barrier Products

Page 37: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Evaluation of Perimeter Barrier Products

Curlex Sediment Log (Aspen Excelsior) coconut coir log (Coir Fiber)

Siltworm (Dried Hardwood)

Page 38: EROSION CONTROL RESEAECH AND TRAINING CENTER – AN … · Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Control plot . Curlex I. DS-75. SC-150. Erosion Control Blanket Evaluation. Ditch Check

Questions??


Recommended