Ethical Leadership
Shoreline Community CollegeOperations Committee
December 1, 2008
Presented by Stephen SmithVice President for
Human Resources and Legal Affairs
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 2
Change and Challenges We are living and working in
extraordinary times, where change is virtually constant. Please check for updates momentarily on:
The World . . . The Country . . .
The Budget . . . The College . . .
Them . . . Us … You .. . Me!
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 3
Supervisory Responsibility Identify issues and risks
When uncertain of correct procedure When perceived as unusual or improper When information is unclear (directives and
responses)
Informed choices Find and understand the facts (investigate!) Comply with all law, contract, policy requirements Human factors (personnel and beyond)
Timely Action
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 4
Ethics - General Definition
The embodiment of those values that the person or organization feels are important…, and spell our proper conduct and appropriate action.
- Webster’s Dictionary
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 5
Sources of Ethical Core Values College Mission Strategic Plan Legal and Contractual Compliance
RCW 42.52 WAC 292-110-010, et. seq. RCW 28B Collective Bargaining Agreements Etc., etc., etc.
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 6
Ethical Awareness
Public sector ethics issues are both practical and political, involving: Public, Media, and Legislative interests Constituent and Labor Relations Audit Findings Employee Morale Public Trust and Confidence
These issues affect enrollment and funding in higher education
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 7
Ethical Choices
Ethical choices are generally not between issues of good and evil, but rather between two goods, such as:
Truth vs. Loyalty
Failing to disclose or address improper conduct
Individual vs. Community
Private or personal benefit
• Short-term vs. Long-term
“Expediency is the opposite of ethics, but …”
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 8
Ethics in State Government Policies, law, and expectations that
define the minimum standards of conduct for state employees to achieve: Public trust in government operations
and cooperation with government authority
Efficient use of public resources to conduct the business of government
Accountability of public employees
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 9
Ethics Context at SCC
Vision We will be a world-class leader in student
success and community engagement
Mission We are dedicated to serving the
educational, workforce and cultural needs of our diverse community.
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 10
Ethical Awareness
Daily ethical choices Words
Actions
Nonverbal
Clearly distinguish and understand “must,” “can” and “should”
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 11
Ethics Law Requirements Ethics law requires that all of our
actions are consistent with the highest principles of public service: Selfless -- without any personal or
private benefit Efficiently and productively doing our
job Serving the public interest as defined
by Leadership through Mission, Strategic Plan, etc.
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 12
Ethics Law Consequences Investigations and audits
State and federal College
Corrective and disciplinary action Grievances, mediation, arbitration
Individual fines and civil penalties
Negative public perception
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 13
Defining Ethical Leadership
From an executive/HR perspective: Consistent, professional behavior
(Leadership by Example) that demonstrates the highest values of official conduct and accountability.
Timely perception and action that fulfills agency business objectives efficiently and respectfully for all parties.
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 14
Ethics Standards
The ethical standards for each employee are defined and reflected in the words and actions of their supervisor … and all other College leaders
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 15
Core Principles of Leadership (Clarity) Decisions, communication and actions are
clear and logical
(Transparency) Actions are consistent with law and core business purpose – and anticipate public disclosure and controversy
(Diversity) Actions are equitable and respectful for all persons
(Productivity) Actions efficiently fulfill formal business objectives and core values
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 16
Key Leadership Issues Power and Perception
Objectivity
Transparency
Confidentiality
Appearance of Impropriety Abuse of Authority or Position
Conflict of Interest
Misuse of state resources
Critical choices: Can vs. Should
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 17
Power and Perception
Ethical behavior is respectful
Treating people with respect … including compassion … is the most productive and efficient use of our (state) resources, time and energy.
More healthy … less downtime Less conflict … reduced liability
Demonstrate respect for individual’s rights and inherent qualities
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 18
Ethical cognitive errors: common rationales for unethical behavior
Deadlines or performance goals
Lack of resources, staff, time
Fear of authority
Career pressures to get the job done
The action “isn’t really” illegal
The action is in an individual’s or organization’s
“best interests”
The action is “unlikely” to be discovered
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 19
Global Ethics Principles
Objectivity
Selflessness
Stewardship
Transparency
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 20
Objectivity
College employees are public employees under the law and must place the public’s interest before any private interest or external obligation. Decisions should be made on the merits of any issue.
• RCW 42.52.020, Activities incompatible with public duties
• RCW 42.52.030, Financial interests in transactions
• RCW 42.52.040, Assisting in transactions
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 21
Selflessness
College employees should not make decisions in order to gain financial or other benefits for themselves, their family, or their friends.•RCW 42.52.070, Special privileges
•RCW 42.52.140, Gifts
•RCW 42.52.150, Limitations on gifts
•RCW 42.52.080, Employment after public service
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 22
Stewardship
College employees have a duty to conserve public resources and funds against misuse and abuse.
• RCW 42.52.070, Special privileges
• RCW 42.52.160, Use of persons, money, or property for private gain
• RCW 42.52.180, Use of public resources for political campaigns
• WAC 292-110-010 – Use of State Resources
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 23
Transparency
College employees must be as open as possible about decisions and actions while also protecting confidential information.
•RCW 42.52.050, Confidential information
•RCW 42.17 Public Disclosure Requirements
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 24
Conflict of Interest
A conflict of interest occurs when you (or a member of your family) have a private interest that may benefit from your official actions, or when a private interest could interfere with official duties
Money or financial
Non-monetary
Most conflict of interests result from the exercise of discretionary (unsupervised) authority … and the supervisor can remain individually liable
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 25
The Appearance of ImproprietyRecognizing Potential Conflict of Interest
Mission
Official Responsibilities
Use of College Resources
Personal Relationships and Activities
Private Employment
Commercial Business and other Private Transactions
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 26
Consider This
“If … you can’t be a good example, then you’ll just have to be a horrible warning.”
- Catherine Aird
Ethical Leadership/December 2008 27
Ethical Leadership Summary
Demonstrate that you understand your role
and responsibilities
Comply with all laws, and rules and policies
Clearly communicate and model
expectations for staff
Consult with Human Resources early and
often!
Expect Ambiguity, Change and Paradox
Discussion? Questions?
Thank you.