7/29/2019 Evaluating Form

1/6

Date: 15/11/2011

SL

No

Nobletec Eng Pvt

Ltd

Naveen Cons.

Corporation Gryphons India Sri. Dominic Sri. Kannan Remarks

1 Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted

2 Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted

a)

MSBI 2639861818

Dt: 09/11/2011

MSBI 2640815296

Dt: 11/11/2011

MUBI 2640505618

Dt: 10/11/2011

MSBI 2640858369

Dt: 11/11/2011

MSBI 2640658370

Dt: 11/11/2011

3 Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted

2.0.0

2.1.0 OK OK OK OK OK

2.1.1 NO NO NO NO NO

2.1.2 NO NO NO NO NO

2.2.1 NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL

2.3.0

2.3.1

Balance sheet for 3

Years (2008-2009-

2010) submitted

Networh - OK

Balance sheet for 3

Years (2008-2009-

2010) submitted

Networh - OK

Balance sheet for

3 Years (2008-

2009-2010)

submitted

Networh - OK

Balance sheet for

3 Years (2009-

2010-2011)

submitted

Networh - OK

Balance sheet for

3 Years (2008-

2009-2010)

submitted

Networh - OK

OK OK OK OK OK

1

2

3

4

2.3.2

62.39 +

55.90 +

216.32

39.275066 +

60.048935 +

75.433177

78.846099 +

190.816515+

269.114366

20.698891 +

26.304221+

25.845785

20.218016 +

134.087918+

141.369321

Joint Venture 334.61/3 174.75/3 538.78/3 72.85/3 295.67/3

All partner combained Each partner 58.25 Million

One partner 111.50 Million

JV-- 19.8+2.03+

19.07 = 40.9/3

13.63million

(65.29%) 179.59 Million 24.28 Million 98.55 Million

Preliminary agreement

Period of Completion : 12Months

Qualification

Kerala Water AuthorityPH Circle, Kozhikode.

Tender Evaluation

Name of Work: UIDSSMT-- for Kalpetta Municipality- Design,construction,testing and commissioning of 10mld output capacityWater Treatment Plant at Swargamkunnu

Tender No: 26/2011-2012 PAC : LS Tender

Requirements

Letter of Technical Bid

Bid Security---- 3 Lakhs

Bid Security may be in the form of DD/ Call deposite from a

scheduled bank drawn in favour of SC KWA, PH Circle,

Kozhikode

All pending littigation shall be treated as resolved againist the

applicant and so shall in total not represent more than 50% of

the applicant networthF nancal S tuat on

Form FIN 1

Requirement

Historical Financial Performance:Submission of audited

balance sheets and income statements, for the last three (3)

years to demonstrate the current soundness of the applicants

financial position. As a minimum, a Bidder's net worth

calculated as the difference between total assets and total

liabilities should be positive.

Conditions

All such documents reflect the financial situation of the Bidder

or partner to a JV, and not sister or parent companies

Historic financial statements must be audited by a certified

accountant

Eligibility

Conflicts of interest

Govt -- owened Entity

LIT Pending Litigation

Requirement

Historic financial statements must be complete, including all

notes to the financial statements.

Historic financial statements must correspond to accounting

periods already completed and audited (no statements for

partial periods shall be requested or accepted).

Average Annuak Construction Turnover--Minimum average

annual construction turnover of Rupees 20.88 million withinthe last three years.

7/29/2019 Evaluating Form

2/6

Must meet 40% of the

requirements

Must meet 25% of the

requirements Sufficient Sufficient Sufficient Sufficient Sufficient

2.3.3

OK OK OK OK OK

OK OK OK OK OK

2.4.0

2.4.1

OK OK OK OK OK

Joint Venture

All Partners Combined Each partner

Each Partner Must meet requirement OK OK OK OK OK

Joint Partner requirement

Each partner of the JV should

have a minimum stipulated

experience

Submission Requirements Form EXP -1

2.4.2

OK OK OK OK OK

2.5.0 PER-- 1 Proposed personal

Requirement

1OK Not Furnished OK OK OK

2OK Not Furnished OK OK OK

3OK Not Furnished OK OK OK

2.6.0 Equipment

Form experience

General Construction Experience

Requirement- Experince under construction contracts in the

roll of contractor, subcontractor , or management contractor,

for atleast the last 5 years in watersupply and sewerage

project. Prior to the applications submissions deadlines

Specific Construction Experience

requirement

FIN 3

Financial resources

(Bidding Forms) the Bidder must demonstrate access to, or

availability of, financial resources such as liquid assets,

unencumbered real assets, lines of credit, and other financial

means, other than any contractual advance payments, to

meet the financial requirements of the contract in the

amount of his Bid. As a minimum the Bidder must show that

his resources, in terms of at least his latest years working

capital and lines of credit, will be adequate to cover his Bid

Form Fin 4 Current Contract Commitment / And work in ProgressBidders and each partner to a JV should provide information

on their current commitments on all contracts that have been

awarded, or for which a letter of intent or acceptance hasbeen received, or for contracts approaching completion, but

for which an unqualified, full completion certificate has yet to

Participation as contractor, management contractor, or

subcontractor, in at least one contracts within the last 5 (Five)

years, each with a value of at least Rs.13.92 million that have

been successfully or are substantially completed and that are

similar to the proposed works. The similarity shall be based on

the physical size, complexity, methods, technology or other

characteristics as described in Section 5, Works Requirements.

The Tenderer should have experience planning, designing and

construction of Rapid sand filter conventional water Treatment

Plant of at least 5.00MLD output capacity

Graduate civil Engineer 1 No Total Work Experience 3 years,

experience in similar work 2 years.

Sub Engineer (Diploma in civil Engineering) 2 Nos Total Work

Experience 5 years, experience in similar work 3 years.

Supervisor (ITI Certificate holder in civil Engineering) 3 Nos

Total Work Experience 5 years, experience in similar work 3

7/29/2019 Evaluating Form

3/6

Requirement

1 OK OK OK OK OK

2 OK OK OK OK OK

3 OK OK OK OK OK

4 OK OK OK OK OK

5 OK OK OK OK OK

6 OK OK OK OK OK

7 OK OK OK OK OK

2.5 Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted

Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted

Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted

Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted

Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted

Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted

Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted

Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted

Concrete vibrators 5 Nos

Dewatering pump sets (5HP) 5 Nos The bidder shall provide

bucher details (such as registration number Make and

capacity) of proposed item of equipments

Site Organiasation

Truck of 10T Capacity 2Nos.

Truck of 5T Capacity 2Nos.

Tractors with Jack Hammers 1No

Concrete Mixing machine medium capacity 2 Nos

Excavators medium duty 1 No

copy of the agreemnt entered in to by

Method of statement

Mobilization Schedule

Consttuction Schedule

Declaration form for standared SpecificationThe PAN No of incometax with Xerox copy of the PAN card

or equalent document for foreign bidder

One copy of bidding document and addendum issued duly

signed by authorised representative

7/29/2019 Evaluating Form

4/6

Date: 15/11/2011

SL

No

Cochin Steel

Ind Complex

Shriram EPC

Ltd

Shahul Hameed-

Omega

Reena Engi &

Contractors

BESL Infra

project Ltd

Sri. MV

Vishwanathan

Mega Engi &

Infrastructure Remarks

1 Submitted Submitted Not Furnished Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted

2 Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted

a)MSBI 2640271722

Dt: 10/11/2011

2440788126

Dt: 11/11/2011

MSBI 2640843533

Dt: 11/11/2011

MSBI 2639347939

Dt: 27/07/2011

MSBI 2639541487

Dt: 8/11/2011

MSBI 2640218808

Dt: 10/11/2011

MSBT 2640242345

Dt: 10/11/2011

3 Submitted Submitted Not Furnished Submitted Not Furnished Submitted Not Furnished

2.0.0

2.1.0 OK OK OK OK OK OK OK

2.1.1 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO

2.1.2 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO

2.2.1 NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL NIL

2.3.0

2.3.1

Balance sheet

for 3 Years

(2008-2009-

2010) submitted

Networh - OK

Balance sheet for

3 Years (2008-

2009-2010)

submitted

Networh - OK

Balance sheet for 3

Years (2008-2009-

2010) submittedNetworh - OK

Balance sheet

for 3 Years

(2008-2009-

2010) submitted

Networh - OK

Balance sheet for

3 Years (2008-

2009-2010)

submitted

Networh - OK

Balance sheet for

3 Years (2008-

2009-2010)

submitted

Networh - OK

Balance sheet for

3 Years (2008-

2009-2010)

submitted

Networh - OK

1

2

3

4

2.3.2

221.951075+

65.921800 +

59.925600

9239.54 +

11217.32 +

13252.30

omega- 332.0 Ave +

Popular-613.0 Ave +

K Gowda 370.0 Ave

79.68+

1154.67 +

574.53

205.505 +

182.8+

230.983

175.566971 +

125.719795 +

88.479031

23193.5+

23452.2 +

29027.1

Joint Venture 347.798475/3 33709.16 /3 1808.88/3 619.28/3 389.77/3 75672.8/3

All partner combained Each partner

All such documents reflect the financial situation of the Bidder

or partner to a JV, and not sister or parent companies

Historic financial statements must be audited by a certified

accountant

Historic financial statements must be complete, including all

notes to the financial statements.

Historic financial statements must correspond to accountingperiods already completed and audited (no statements for

partial periods shall be requested or accepted).

Average Annual Construction Turnover--Minimum average

annual construction turnover of Rupees 115 million within the

last three years.

Requirements

Bid Security may be in the form of DD/ Call deposite from a

scheduled bank drawn in favour of SC KWA, PH Circle,Kozhikode

LIT Pending Litigation

Govt -- owened Entity

Eligibility

Qualification

Conflicts of interest

Historical Financial Performance:Submission of audited

balance sheets and income statements, for the last three (3)

years to demonstrate the current soundness of the applicants

financial position. As a minimum, a Bidder's net worthcalculated as the difference between total assets and total

liabilities should be positive.

Kerala Water AuthorityPH Circle, Kozhikode.

Tender Evaluation

Bid Security---- 3 lakhs

Letter of Technical Bid

Preliminary agreement

Requirement

F nanc al S tuat on

Form FIN 1

All pending littigation shall be treated as resolved againist the

applicant and so shall in total not represent more than 50% of

the applicant networth

Requirement

Conditions

Name of Work: UDISSMT-- for Kalpetta Municipality- Supplying,Laying,Testing and Commissioning Raw Water Pumping main and Clear water transmission main

Tender No: 27/2011-12 PAC : Period of Completion : 6 Months

7/29/2019 Evaluating Form

5/6

One partner 115.93 Million 1123.63 Million 131.57 Million 602.96 Million 206.43 Million 129.92 Million 25224.26 Million

Must meet 40% of the

requirements

Must meet 25% of the

requirements Sufficient Sufficient Sufficient Sufficient Sufficient Sufficient Sufficient

2.3.3 Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted

OK OK OK OK OK OK OK

FIN 4 Submitted

NIL

FIN 4 Submitted

OK

FIN 4 Submitted

NIL

FIN 4 Submitted

OK

FIN 4 Submitted

OK

FIN 4 Submitted

OK

FIN 4 Submitted

OK

2.4.0

2.4.1

Joint Venture

OK OK OK OK OK OK OK

All Partners Combined Each partner

Each Partner Must meet requirement

Joint Partner requirement

Each partner of the JV should

have a minimum stipulated

experience

Submission Requirements Form EXP -1

2.4.2

OK OK OK OK OK OK OK

2.5.0 PER-- 1 Proposed personal

Requirement

Participation as contractor, management contractor, or

subcontractor, in at least one contracts within the last 5 (Five)

years, each with a value of at least Rs.77 million that have

been successfully or are substantially completed and that are

similar to the proposed works. The similarity shall be based onthe physical size, complexity, methods, technology or other

characteristics as described in Section 5, Works Requirements.

D.I. pipe line of diameter not less than 300 mm for a

minimum length of 5800 m for the last five years. If the length

of pipe line in a single work is less than 500 m such works will

not be considered for experience.

requirement

General Construction Experience

Requirement- Experince under construction contracts in the

roll of contractor, subcontractor , or management contractor,for atleast the last 5 years in watersupply and sewerage

project. Prior to the applications submissions deadlines

Form Fin 4 Current Contract Commitment / And work in Progress

(Bidding Forms) the Bidder must demonstrate access to, oravailability of, financial resources such as liquid assets,

unencumbered real assets, lines of credit, and other financial

means, other than any contractual advance payments, to

meet the financial requirements of the contract in the

amount of his Bid. As a minimum the Bidder must show that

his resources, in terms of at least his latest years working

capital and lines of credit, will be adequate to cover his Bid

Form experience

FIN 3

Financial resources

Specific Construction Experience

on their current commitments on all contracts that have been

awarded, or for which a letter of intent or acceptance has

been received, or for contracts approaching completion, but

for which an unqualified, full completion certificate has yet to

be issued.

7/29/2019 Evaluating Form

6/6

1OK OK OK OK OK Not Mensioned OK

2 1 NoOK OK OK OK Not Mensioned OK

3

Qualification not

mensioned forsite supervisor

1 No OK OK OK Not Mensioned OK

2.6.0 Equipment

Requirement

1 OK OK OK OK OK OK OK

2 OK OK OK OK OK OK OK

3 OK OK OK OK OK OK OK

4 OK OK OK OK OK OK OK

5 OK OK OK OK OK OK OK

6 OK OK OK OK OK OK OK

7 OK OK OK OK OK OK OK

2.5 Submitted Not furnished Submitted Submitted Not furnished Submitted Submitted

Submitted Submitted Submitted Not furnished Submitted Submitted Submitted

Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted

Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted SubmittedSubmitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted

Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Not furnished

Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Submitted Not furnished

Submitted Submitted Not furnished Submitted Not furnished Submitted Not furnished

Superintending Engineer

Tractors with Jack Hammers 1No

Truck of 5T Capacity 2Nos.

Truck of 10T Capacity 2Nos.

Concrete Mixing machine medium capacity 2 Nos

Excavators medium duty 1 No

Consttuction Schedule

Declaration form for standared Specification

The PAN No of incometax with Xerox copy of the PAN card

or equalent document for foreign bidder

One copy of bidding document and addendum issued duly

signed by authorised representative

copy of the agreemnt entered in to by

Concrete vibrators 5 Nos

Dewatering pump sets (5HP) 5 Nos The bidder shall provide

bucher details (such as registration number Make and

capacity) of proposed item of equipments

Site Organiasation

Method of statement

Mobilization Schedule

Supervisor (ITI Certificate holder in civil Engineering) 3 Nos

Total Work Experience 5 years, experience in similar work 3years.

Sub Engineer (Diploma in civil Engineering) 2 Nos Total Work

Experience 5 years, experience in similar work 3 years.

Graduate civil Engineer 1 No Total Work Experience 3 years,

experience in similar work 2 years.