20
Excelsior / Mission Terrace / Cayuga Parking Management Community Meeting November 21, 2019
Excelsior / Mission Terrace / Cayuga Parking Management
Community Meeting
November 21, 2019
Agenda
• Welcome • Background—how we arrived to today• Research findings
• Neighborhood parking survey • Survey results by sub-area• Parking utilization study
• Options and choices for RPP• Questions & answers• Possible next steps
www.sfmta.com/D11parking 2
www.sfmta.com/D11parking 3
Background
SFMTA parking related work in District 11:
• Assessed feasibility of increasing supply. Found insufficient street width to accommodate angled or perpendicular parking
• Held open houses/office hours and conducted survey on parking issues
• Prepared alternative options for Residential Permit Parking • November 2018 Parking Town Hall • March 2019 parking occupancy survey• March 2019 household survey
www.sfmta.com/D11parking 4
www.sfmta.com/D11parking
Survey study area
5
Survey statistics
• Administered March 7 to April 2• Net mailed surveys: 8,962• Completed surveys: 1,879• Response rate: 21%
• Non-English responses: 8%• Chinese 83• Spanish 58• Filipino 9
www.sfmta.com/D11parking 6
Survey results v. census data
Survey respondents have more vehicles than District 11 as a whole.
www.sfmta.com/D11parking
Persons/ Census Data Household Households Percent Percent
1 268 16% 17%2 510 30% 28%3 325 19% 19%4 or more 615 36% 36%Source: SFMTA, D11 Parking Survey, 2019; U.S. Census
Number of Households by Size of Household
2019 SFMTA Survey
AvailableVehicles 2011 2015 2010 2015
No Vehicle 5% 12% 14% 30% 30%1 Vehicle 25% 38% 37% 41% 41%2 Vehicles 39% 33% 32% 21% 21%3 Vehicles 18% 12% 12% 6% 5%4 or more 13% 5% 5% 2% 2%Source: SFMTA, D11 Parking Survey, 2019; U.S. Census
Households by Number of Vehicles AvailableSFMTA 2019
Parking Survey
U.S. Census DataDistrict 11 City of San Francisco
7
Vehicles parked on-street
No Cars, 29%
1 Car, 39%
2 Cars, 20%
3 Cars, 7%
4 Cars, 3% 5+ Cars, 1%
1,823 Households
Percent of Households Responding
www.sfmta.com/D11parking 8
www.sfmta.com/D11parking
RPP support: all responses
Level of support for RPP varies across study area
Support appears to be influenced by:
• Proximity to Mission St
• Proximity to BART/Muni
• Difficulty finding parking/ occupancy rates
752, 41%
127, 7%
960, 52%
Yes Unsure No
1,839 households
9
www.sfmta.com/D11parking 10
www.sfmta.com/D11parking 11
www.sfmta.com/D11parking
Q3. Reasons for not wanting RPP*
• Permit too expensive• No parking problem/have a garage• More than two drivers• Do not own a vehicle• Other [See optional written comments]
* From drop-down menu of choices
12
Q3. Optional comments
Reasons Against RPPNumber of Comments
Visitor parking needs 37
Night-time enforcement needed 25
Won’t solve the problem/no commuters
16
Other residents fault 12
Other 63
www.sfmta.com/D11parking 13
www.sfmta.com/D11parking 14
www.sfmta.com/D11parking 15
www.sfmta.com/D11parking
Who’s parking here?
< 1/4 mile1/4 to 1/2
mile1/2 to 2.0
miles> 2 miles
5:00 AM 32% 13% 13% 41%11:00 AM 28% 11% 13% 48%
2:00 PM 28% 11% 13% 47%8:00 PM 32% 12% 14% 41%
Source: SFMTA; Kittelson & Associates, 2019
Share of parked vehicles by distance from survey route to registered address
16
lp_observations (1)
AreaDate Time< 0.25 mi0.25-0.5 mi0.5-2mi> 2miTotal Obersvations
Bernal3/12/19 5:00009213
Bernal3/12/19 10:00007617
Bernal3/12/19 20:00005314
Bernal3/13/19 5:0000217
Bernal3/13/19 10:00005413
Bernal3/13/19 20:00005717
Bernal3/19/19 5:009893163303
Bernal3/19/19 10:0081132291272
Bernal3/19/19 14:0078122993283
Bernal3/19/19 20:001201234126391
Bernal4/3/19 5:00137154297380
Bernal4/3/19 10:0084123790297
Bernal4/3/19 14:00931540114343
Bernal4/3/19 20:001181745102398
BVW12/5/18 5:00108302171278
BVW12/5/18 11:00842220100272
BVW12/5/18 14:00791821106266
BVW12/5/18 20:00109191875262
BVW12/10/18 5:001042913103299
BVW12/10/18 11:00762213128277
BVW12/10/18 14:00742120137285
BVW12/10/18 20:0099271596279
Dogpatch3/7/19 5:009334121264
Dogpatch3/7/19 10:0059115274447
Dogpatch3/7/19 14:0055315254401
Dogpatch3/7/19 20:007937141279
Dogpatch3/14/19 5:009046149304
Dogpatch3/14/19 10:0061616314462
Dogpatch3/14/19 14:006649279426
Dogpatch3/14/19 20:008099146300
Dogpatch4/23/19 5:00370971169
Dogpatch4/23/19 10:001905141251
Dogpatch4/23/19 14:002113133235
Dogpatch4/23/19 20:00250384164
Excel/MT12/5/18 5:001010620
Excel/MT12/5/18 11:00810819
Excel/MT12/5/18 14:00611817
Excel/MT12/5/18 20:00620618
Excel/MT12/10/18 5:00710719
Excel/MT12/10/18 11:004021120
Excel/MT12/10/18 14:003031323
Excel/MT12/10/18 20:001002719
Excel/MT3/21/19 5:00683634146377
Excel/MT3/21/19 11:00522737140324
Excel/MT3/21/19 14:00472230147314
Excel/MT3/21/19 20:00722233138349
Excel/MT4/2/19 5:00814236148385
Excel/MT4/2/19 11:00603839132329
Excel/MT4/2/19 14:00653728133333
Excel/MT4/2/19 20:00854641139391
Excel/MT4/4/19 5:001283625134437
Excel/MT4/4/19 11:001132330116380
Excel/MT4/4/19 14:001183934116395
Excel/MT4/4/19 20:001324334125431
Excel/MT4/9/19 5:00693957113328
Excel/MT4/9/19 11:00432836111253
Excel/MT4/9/19 14:00512945115268
Excel/MT4/9/19 20:00623564113314
Excel/MT4/10/19 5:00814665115344
Excel/MT4/10/19 11:00512337115251
Excel/MT4/10/19 14:00462243111253
Excel/MT4/10/19 20:00753451107294
Excel/MT4/11/19 5:001855132121441
Excel/MT4/11/19 11:001152831131361
Excel/MT4/11/19 14:001253330132372
Excel/MT4/11/19 20:001664636124422
HVNA12/5/18 5:007001127
HVNA12/5/18 11:005012028
HVNA12/5/18 14:004012129
HVNA12/5/18 20:0010011226
HVNA12/10/18 5:0016001030
HVNA12/10/18 11:0012031228
HVNA12/10/18 14:0012041330
HVNA12/10/18 20:0012001228
HVNA3/12/19 5:0028363793268
HVNA3/12/19 10:00161925111239
HVNA3/12/19 20:00223028115301
HVNA3/13/19 5:0038373985264
HVNA3/13/19 10:00232825119257
HVNA3/13/19 20:00223337148331
SOMA0000-00-00 00:00:00834480248665
SOMA4/16/19 10:00462251225487
SOMA4/16/19 14:00371639203482
SOMA4/16/19 20:00472047166446
SOMA5/30/19 10:00452538259497
SOMA5/30/19 14:00412244267531
SOMA5/30/19 20:00522445204441
Bernal
AreaDate Time< 0.25 mi0.25-0.5 mi0.5-2mi> 2miTotal Obersvations
Bernal3/12/19 5:00009213
Bernal3/12/19 10:00007617
Bernal3/12/19 20:00005314
Bernal3/13/19 5:0000217
Bernal3/13/19 10:00005413
Bernal3/13/19 20:00005717
Bernal3/19/19 5:009893163303
Bernal3/19/19 10:0081132291272
Bernal3/19/19 14:0078122993283
Bernal3/19/19 20:001201234126391
Bernal4/3/19 5:00137154297380
Bernal4/3/19 10:0084123790297
Bernal4/3/19 14:00931540114343
Bernal4/3/19 20:001181745102398
BuenaVistaW
AreaDate Time< 0.25 mi0.25-0.5 mi0.5-2mi> 2miTotal Obersvations
BVW12/5/18 5:00108302171278
BVW12/5/18 11:00842220100272
BVW12/5/18 14:00791821106266
BVW12/5/18 20:00109191875262
BVW12/10/18 5:001042913103299
BVW12/10/18 11:00762213128277
BVW12/10/18 14:00742120137285
BVW12/10/18 20:0099271596279
Dogpatch
AreaDate Time< 0.25 mi0.25-0.5 mi0.5-2mi> 2miTotal Obersvations
Dogpatch3/7/19 5:009334121264
Dogpatch3/7/19 10:0059115274447
Dogpatch3/7/19 14:0055315254401
Dogpatch3/7/19 20:007937141279
Dogpatch3/14/19 5:009046149304
Dogpatch3/14/19 10:0061616314462
Dogpatch3/14/19 14:006649279426
Dogpatch3/14/19 20:008099146300
Dogpatch4/23/19 5:00370971169
Dogpatch4/23/19 10:001905141251
Dogpatch4/23/19 14:002113133235
Dogpatch4/23/19 20:00250384164
Excel_MT
AreaDate TimeTotal Obersva-tions< 0.25 mi0.25-0.5 mi0.5-2mi> 2miCalifornia Plates < 0.25 mi0.25-0.5 mi0.5-2mi> 2miTotal CA Plates< 0.25 mi0.25-0.5 mi0.5-2mi> 2miTotal Obersva-tions
Excel/MT12/5/18 5:0020101060.500.050.000.301.000.440.050.000.331.00
Excel/MT12/5/18 11:001981080.420.050.000.421.000.310.030.050.491.00
Excel/MT12/5/18 14:001761180.350.060.060.471.000.230.030.100.531.00
Excel/MT12/5/18 20:001862060.330.110.000.331.000.430.050.050.351.00
Excel/MT12/10/18 5:001971070.370.050.000.371.00
Excel/MT12/10/18 11:0020402110.200.000.100.551.00
Excel/MT12/10/18 14:0023303130.130.000.130.571.00
Excel/MT12/10/18 20:0019100270.530.000.110.371.00
Route 1
Total Obersva-tions< 0.25 mi0.25-0.5 mi0.5-2mi> 2miCalifornia Plates < 0.25 mi0.25-0.5 mi0.5-2mi> 2miTotal CA Plates< 0.25 mi0.25-0.5 mi0.5-2mi> 2miTotal CA Plates
Route 1
Excel/MT3/21/19 5:003776836341462840.240.130.120.511.005:000.250.130.120.501.00
Excel/MT3/21/19 11:003245227371402560.200.110.140.551.0011:000.210.120.140.521.00
Excel/MT3/21/19 14:003144722301472460.190.090.120.601.0014:000.220.120.110.551.00
Excel/MT3/21/19 20:003497222331382650.270.080.120.521.0020:000.270.120.130.481.00
Excel/MT4/2/19 5:003858142361483070.260.140.120.481.00
Excel/MT4/2/19 11:003296038391322690.220.140.140.491.00
Excel/MT4/2/19 14:003336537281332630.250.140.110.511.00
Excel/MT4/2/19 20:003918546411393110.270.150.130.451.00
Route 2
Total Obersva-tions< 0.25 mi0.25-0.5 mi0.5-2mi> 2miCalifornia Plates < 0.25 mi0.25-0.5 mi0.5-2mi> 2miTotal CA Plates
Route 2
Excel/MT4/4/19 5:0043712836251343230.400.110.080.411.005:000.440.120.080.361.00
Excel/MT4/4/19 11:0038011323301162820.400.080.110.411.0011:000.390.090.100.421.00
Excel/MT4/4/19 14:0039511839341163070.380.130.110.381.0014:000.390.110.100.401.00
Excel/MT4/4/19 20:0043113243341253340.400.130.100.371.0020:000.420.130.100.351.00
Excel/MT4/11/19 5:0044118551321213890.480.130.080.311.00
Excel/MT4/11/19 11:0036111528311313050.380.090.100.431.00
Excel/MT4/11/19 14:0037212533301323200.390.100.090.411.00
Excel/MT4/11/19 20:0042216646361243720.450.120.100.331.00
Route 3
Total Obersva-tions< 0.25 mi0.25-0.5 mi0.5-2mi> 2miCalifornia Plates < 0.25 mi0.25-0.5 mi0.5-2mi> 2miTotal CA Plates
Route 3
Excel/MT4/9/19 5:003286939571132780.250.140.210.411.005:000.260.150.210.391.00
Excel/MT4/9/19 11:002534328361112180.200.130.170.511.0011:000.210.110.160.511.00
Excel/MT4/9/19 14:002685129451152400.210.120.190.481.0014:000.210.110.190.491.00
Excel/MT4/9/19 20:003146235641132740.230.130.230.411.0020:000.250.130.210.411.00
Excel/MT4/10/19 5:003448146651153070.260.150.210.371.00
Excel/MT4/10/19 11:002515123371152260.230.100.160.511.00
Excel/MT4/10/19 14:002534622431112220.210.100.190.501.00
Share of parked vehicles by distance from survey route to registered address
Excel/MT4/10/19 20:002947534511072670.280.130.190.401.00
< 1/4 mile1/4 to 1/2 mile1/2 to 2.0 miles> 2 milesTotal CA Plates
5:00 AM32%13%13%41%
11:00 AM28%11%13%48%1.00
2:00 PM28%11%13%47%1.00
8:00 PM32%12%14%41%1.00
Source: SFMTA; Kittelson & Associates, 20191.00
HVNA
AreaDate Time< 0.25 mi0.25-0.5 mi0.5-2mi> 2miTotal Obersvations
HVNA12/5/18 5:007001127
HVNA12/5/18 11:005012028
HVNA12/5/18 14:004012129
HVNA12/5/18 20:0010011226
HVNA12/10/18 5:0016001030
HVNA12/10/18 11:0012031228
HVNA12/10/18 14:0012041330
HVNA12/10/18 20:0012001228
HVNA3/12/19 5:0028363793268
HVNA3/12/19 10:00161925111239
HVNA3/12/19 20:00223028115301
HVNA3/13/19 5:0038373985264
HVNA3/13/19 10:00232825119257
HVNA3/13/19 20:00223337148331
SOMA
AreaDate Time< 0.25 mi0.25-0.5 mi0.5-2mi> 2miTotal Obersvations
SOMA0000-00-00 00:00:00834480248665
SOMA4/16/19 10:00462251225487
SOMA4/16/19 14:00371639203482
SOMA4/16/19 20:00472047166446
SOMA5/30/19 10:00452538259497
SOMA5/30/19 14:00412244267531
SOMA5/30/19 20:00522445204441
www.sfmta.com/D11parking 17
www.sfmta.com/D11parking 18
www.sfmta.com/D11parking
Residential permit parking options
• Boundaries• Based on where there is support for RPP
• Days of the week• Monday – Friday• Monday – Saturday
• Hours• 8 AM – 6 PM• 8 AM – 9 PM• 4 PM – 9 PM
19
www.sfmta.com/D11parking
Thank you
20
Excelsior / Mission Terrace / Cayuga Parking ManagementAgendaSlide Number 3BackgroundSurvey study areaSurvey statisticsSurvey results v. census dataVehicles parked on-streetRPP support: all responsesSlide Number 10Slide Number 11Q3. Reasons for not wanting RPP*Q3. Optional commentsSlide Number 14Slide Number 15Who’s parking here?Slide Number 17Slide Number 18Residential permit parking optionsThank you
