Experience from Landfill Developments in New
England
Andrew Reed
Borrego Solar
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
Generating Change Since 1980
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
EBC Rhode Island Chapter Program Renewable Energy at Closed Landfills
December 3, 2012
Andrew Reed
Director of Project Development
Borrego Solar
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
1. Overview of Borrego Solar
2. Considerations for landfill development
3. Long term operation and maintenance
4. Case Study: Easthampton landfill in MA
5. Conclusions and discussion
Agenda and Discussion Topics
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
Borrego Solar overview
Our installations meet the highest quality and reliability standards in the industry
‣ Established 1980
‣Nearly 100 employees in offices on both
coasts
‣ Leading provider of turnkey solar
photovoltaic systems
‣ Fully integrated PPA provider with nearly
$100m to deploy
‣Commercial, Government, and Utility
‣ ~10 MW of landfills completed or under
construction
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
‣ Additional revenue from land with limited uses
• For private and municipal sites
• Methane extraction tapers off after closure
• Low demand for other types of development
‣ Available financing
• Labeled “stable” by investors
‣ Large expanses of space
• EPA estimates over 15 million acres in US
‣ Good transmission
• Close proximity to existing grid and point of interconnection
‣ Environmental stewardship/leadership
Landfills & Brownfields
Why landfills should go solar…
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
‣ Buy the system
• Hire Engineering, Procurement and Construction (EPC)
Services for the installation
• Optional O&M for system operations
• Upfront cost would be paid back through power savings
• No ability for municipalities to take advantage of tax incentives
‣ Utilize third party ownership structure
• No upfront capital requirements
• PPA provider would monetize tax attributes and own, operate,
& maintain the system
• Municipality would enter into a long-term fixed contract to
hedge on electricity rates
• Net metering regulations often require on-site load
‣ Collect a lease payment
• Provider would enter into a PPA with the utility
• Provider would own, operate, and maintain the system
Financing options
Pay or be paid
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
‣ Only about a dozen known solar landfill projects are complete in the US
‣ Specific standards for landfill solar installations are still being developed
‣ Landfill solution considerations:
• Waste Composition – municipal solid waste; gases omitted
• Cover Materials – no cap v. cap; membrane v. membrane plus soil; vegetation
• Landfill Age – impacts settling expectations
• Construction – Slope angle, drainage, loading requirements
• Location – wetlands, conservation, species, wind speeds, marine environments
‣ Designs incorporate ground-mounted ballasted racking & fencing to minimize disturbance
Project planning
Landfill considerations
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
TYPICAL MAX
SLOPE 5°
DECOMPOSITION CAUSES
SETTLING
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
Project planning
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
‣ Permitting
• Landfill sites have challenging permitting hurdles
• Process can be lengthy
• Concept is new to most AHJ’s including environmental
regulators
• Proper planning is essential
• Construction oversight may be required
‣ Load on landfill
• Consider construction & long term gravity loads
• Limits based on specific landfill construction
• Easthampton = 10 psi/1440 psf
• May restrict location of inverter/transformer
Project planning
Engineering challenges
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
‣ Steep side grades
• Up to 5° top surfaces ok for ballast, minimal preparation
• Up to 13° side surfaces more challenging
• Flexible solution can be used on exposed caps and is best
when applied during closure process
‣ Settling
• Depends on depth, content, placement and age
• Could be 10-20’ over the life of the landfill
• Likely greater than 1' per year in first few years
• Generally reduced effect with age
• Differential settling is an issue
• Voids in fill - depressions / sinkholes
Project planning
Engineering challenges
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
MAINTAIN
CLEARANCE
DURING SETTLING
Project planning
Engineering challenges
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
‣ Drainage
• Must be maintained
• changing surface changes drainage characteristics
• Interrupted by digging or placing crushed stone
• Situation will aggravate if not remediated
‣ Interconnection
• No landfill specific issues
• Often little or no onsite load for net-metering
• Potentially long runs to three phase
• Competing for interconnection with wind power/landfill gas
to energy
Project planning
Engineering challenges
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
‣ Staging areas off the landfill are critical
• Space constraints
• Weight limits
‣ Low ground pressure equipment
• Cap limited to 5-10psi
• Heavy equipment is limited to Low Ground Pressure
machinery
‣ Protect the cap!!!!
• Don’t plan on digging
• Work with the land – react to how the land is reacting to
our work
• Use contractors that build landfills to work on the landfill
Project planning
Construction
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
‣ Current maintenance requirements of landfills
• Annual or semi-annual inspections for compliance
• Ground water monitoring/sampling
• Gas extraction and monitoring
• Cap inspection
• Vegetation management
• Man hole lock maintenance
‣ Long-term O&M
• Electrical inspection and system check
• System washing
• Mowing
• Fence maintenance
• Settlement surveys
• Erosion Inspections - storm water control
Project planning
Operations and maintenance
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
Case Study: Town of Easthampton
Easthampton landfill
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
‣ 2.3 MW array
‣ 16 acre landfill
‣ 10,000 modules
‣ 10 year PPA under 7 cents
‣ 2,828,000 kWh annually
‣ 3,606,146 lbs of CO2 offset annually
‣ Town will save $110,000 in the first year
‣ Nothing down, no operational expenses or
additional responsibility
Case Study: Town of Easthampton
Project Overview
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
Construction Sequencing
Construction – Site Prep
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
Construction Sequencing
Construction - Access Roads
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
Construction Sequencing
Construction – Drainage and Culverts
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
Construction Sequencing
Construction - Ballasts: Pre-cast
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
Construction Sequencing
Construction - Racks
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
Construction Sequencing
Construction - Modules
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
Construction Sequencing
Construction – Conduit and Wiring
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
Construction Sequencing
Construction – Electrical Equipment
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
Conclusions and discussion
‣ Rhode Island has many factors that support good solar economics
‣ Not all landfills are perfect candidates for solar
‣ Consider the characteristics of your own facility
‣ What other properties might you have that could also host a system?
‣ What kind of contract fits with your goals?
‣ Be considerate of who you partner with
Is this right for me?
www.borregosolar.com © Borrego Solar Systems, Inc. Private & Confidential
Andrew Reed
Phone 978-513-2607
1115 Westford Street, 2nd floor
Lowell, MA 01851
www.borregosolar.com
Phone (888) 898-6273
Fax (888) 843-6778
Borrego Solar Systems, Inc.