Date post: | 28-Mar-2015 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | landon-kearney |
View: | 218 times |
Download: | 2 times |
Experimental DesignExperimental DesignExperimental DesignExperimental Design
Christian RuffChristian Ruff
With thanks to: Rik Henson
Daniel Glaser
Christian RuffChristian Ruff
With thanks to: Rik Henson
Daniel Glaser
RealignmentRealignment SmoothingSmoothing
NormalisationNormalisation
General linear modelGeneral linear model
Statistical parametric map (SPM)Statistical parametric map (SPM)Image time-seriesImage time-series
Parameter estimatesParameter estimates
Design matrixDesign matrix
TemplateTemplate
KernelKernel
Gaussian Gaussian field theoryfield theory
p <0.05p <0.05
StatisticalStatisticalinferenceinference
OverviewOverviewOverviewOverview
• Categorical designsCategorical designsSubtraction Subtraction - Pure insertion, evoked / differential - Pure insertion, evoked / differential
responsesresponses
Conjunction Conjunction - Testing multiple hypotheses- Testing multiple hypotheses
• Parametric designsParametric designsLinear Linear - Adaptation, cognitive dimensions- Adaptation, cognitive dimensions
NonlinearNonlinear - Polynomial expansions, neurometric - Polynomial expansions, neurometric functionsfunctions
• Factorial designsFactorial designsCategoricalCategorical - Interactions and pure insertion- Interactions and pure insertion
ParametricParametric - Linear and nonlinear interactions- Linear and nonlinear interactions
- Psychophysiological Interactions- Psychophysiological Interactions
• Categorical designsCategorical designsSubtraction Subtraction - Pure insertion, evoked / differential - Pure insertion, evoked / differential
responsesresponses
Conjunction Conjunction - Testing multiple hypotheses- Testing multiple hypotheses
• Parametric designsParametric designsLinear Linear - Adaptation, cognitive dimensions- Adaptation, cognitive dimensions
NonlinearNonlinear - Polynomial expansions, neurometric - Polynomial expansions, neurometric functionsfunctions
• Factorial designsFactorial designsCategoricalCategorical - Interactions and pure insertion- Interactions and pure insertion
ParametricParametric - Linear and nonlinear interactions- Linear and nonlinear interactions
- Psychophysiological Interactions- Psychophysiological Interactions
• Aim: Aim: – Neuronal structures underlying process Neuronal structures underlying process PP? ?
• Procedure: Procedure: – Contrast: [Task with Contrast: [Task with PP] – [control task without ] – [control task without P P ] = ] = PP the critical assumption of „pure insertion“the critical assumption of „pure insertion“
• Aim: Aim: – Neuronal structures underlying process Neuronal structures underlying process PP? ?
• Procedure: Procedure: – Contrast: [Task with Contrast: [Task with PP] – [control task without ] – [control task without P P ] = ] = PP the critical assumption of „pure insertion“the critical assumption of „pure insertion“
Cognitive SubtractionCognitive SubtractionCognitive SubtractionCognitive Subtraction
- - Neuronal structures Neuronal structures computing face recognition? computing face recognition?
- - Neuronal structures Neuronal structures computing face recognition? computing face recognition?
• ExampleExample: : – Neuronal structures underlying Neuronal structures underlying face recognitionface recognition? ?
• ExampleExample: : – Neuronal structures underlying Neuronal structures underlying face recognitionface recognition? ?
Cognitive Subtraction: Baseline-Cognitive Subtraction: Baseline-problemsproblems
Cognitive Subtraction: Baseline-Cognitive Subtraction: Baseline-problemsproblems
-- PP implicit in control task ? implicit in control task ?-- PP implicit in control task ? implicit in control task ?
„ „Queen!“ „Aunt Jenny?“Queen!“ „Aunt Jenny?“ „ „Queen!“ „Aunt Jenny?“Queen!“ „Aunt Jenny?“
• „ „Related“ stimuliRelated“ stimuli• „ „Related“ stimuliRelated“ stimuli
-- Several components differ !Several components differ ! -- Several components differ !Several components differ !
• „ „Distant“ stimuli Distant“ stimuli • „ „Distant“ stimuli Distant“ stimuli
Name Person! Name Gender!Name Person! Name Gender!Name Person! Name Gender!Name Person! Name Gender!
-- Interaction of process and taskInteraction of process and task ?? -- Interaction of process and taskInteraction of process and task ??
• Same stimuli, different taskSame stimuli, different task• Same stimuli, different taskSame stimuli, different task
Differential event-related fMRIDifferential event-related fMRIDifferential event-related fMRIDifferential event-related fMRI
Parahippocampal responses to wordsParahippocampal
responses to words
BOLD EPI fMRI at 2T, BOLD EPI fMRI at 2T, TR 3.2sec. Words TR 3.2sec. Words presented every 16 presented every 16
secs; (i) studied words secs; (i) studied words or (ii) new wordsor (ii) new words
BOLD EPI fMRI at 2T, BOLD EPI fMRI at 2T, TR 3.2sec. Words TR 3.2sec. Words presented every 16 presented every 16
secs; (i) studied words secs; (i) studied words or (ii) new wordsor (ii) new words
SPM{F} testing for SPM{F} testing for evoked responsesevoked responsesSPM{F} testing for SPM{F} testing for evoked responsesevoked responses
Evoked responsesEvoked responsesEvoked responsesEvoked responses
• “ “Baseline” here corresponds to session mean Baseline” here corresponds to session mean (and thus processing during “rest”) (and thus processing during “rest”)
• Null events or long SOAs essential for estimationNull events or long SOAs essential for estimation
• “ “Cognitive” interpretation hardly possible, Cognitive” interpretation hardly possible, but useful to define regions generally involved in the but useful to define regions generally involved in the tasktask
• “ “Baseline” here corresponds to session mean Baseline” here corresponds to session mean (and thus processing during “rest”) (and thus processing during “rest”)
• Null events or long SOAs essential for estimationNull events or long SOAs essential for estimation
• “ “Cognitive” interpretation hardly possible, Cognitive” interpretation hardly possible, but useful to define regions generally involved in the but useful to define regions generally involved in the tasktask
Differential event-related fMRIDifferential event-related fMRIDifferential event-related fMRIDifferential event-related fMRI
Parahippocampal responses to wordsParahippocampal
responses to words
BOLD EPI fMRI at 2T, BOLD EPI fMRI at 2T, TR 3.2sec. Words TR 3.2sec. Words presented every 16 presented every 16
secs; (i) studied words secs; (i) studied words or (ii) new wordsor (ii) new words
BOLD EPI fMRI at 2T, BOLD EPI fMRI at 2T, TR 3.2sec. Words TR 3.2sec. Words presented every 16 presented every 16
secs; (i) studied words secs; (i) studied words or (ii) new wordsor (ii) new words
SPM{F} testing for SPM{F} testing for evoked responsesevoked responsesSPM{F} testing for SPM{F} testing for evoked responsesevoked responses
Differential responsesDifferential responsesDifferential responsesDifferential responses
Peri-stimulus time {secs}Peri-stimulus time {secs}Peri-stimulus time {secs}Peri-stimulus time {secs}
SPM{F} testing SPM{F} testing for differencesfor differences
SPM{F} testing SPM{F} testing for differencesfor differences
studied wordsstudied wordsstudied wordsstudied words
new wordsnew wordsnew wordsnew words
Experimental designExperimental design
Word generationWord generation GGWord repetitionWord repetition RR
R G R G R G R G R G R GR G R G R G R G R G R G
Experimental designExperimental design
Word generationWord generation GGWord repetitionWord repetition RR
R G R G R G R G R G R GR G R G R G R G R G R G
G - R = Intrinsic word generationG - R = Intrinsic word generation
……under assumption of under assumption of pure insertionpure insertion
G - R = Intrinsic word generationG - R = Intrinsic word generation
……under assumption of under assumption of pure insertionpure insertion
A categorical analysisA categorical analysisA categorical analysisA categorical analysis
OverviewOverviewOverviewOverview
• Categorical designsCategorical designsSubtraction Subtraction - Pure insertion, evoked / differential - Pure insertion, evoked / differential
responsesresponses
Conjunction Conjunction - Testing multiple hypotheses- Testing multiple hypotheses
• Parametric designsParametric designsLinear Linear - Adaptation, cognitive dimensions- Adaptation, cognitive dimensions
NonlinearNonlinear - Polynomial expansions, neurometric - Polynomial expansions, neurometric functionsfunctions
• Factorial designsFactorial designsCategoricalCategorical - Interactions and pure insertion- Interactions and pure insertion
ParametricParametric - Linear and nonlinear interactions- Linear and nonlinear interactions
- Psychophysiological Interactions- Psychophysiological Interactions
• Categorical designsCategorical designsSubtraction Subtraction - Pure insertion, evoked / differential - Pure insertion, evoked / differential
responsesresponses
Conjunction Conjunction - Testing multiple hypotheses- Testing multiple hypotheses
• Parametric designsParametric designsLinear Linear - Adaptation, cognitive dimensions- Adaptation, cognitive dimensions
NonlinearNonlinear - Polynomial expansions, neurometric - Polynomial expansions, neurometric functionsfunctions
• Factorial designsFactorial designsCategoricalCategorical - Interactions and pure insertion- Interactions and pure insertion
ParametricParametric - Linear and nonlinear interactions- Linear and nonlinear interactions
- Psychophysiological Interactions- Psychophysiological Interactions
• One way to minimise the baseline/pure insertion problem is to isolate the One way to minimise the baseline/pure insertion problem is to isolate the same process by two or more separate comparisons, and inspect the same process by two or more separate comparisons, and inspect the resulting simple effects for commonalitiesresulting simple effects for commonalities
• A test for such activation common to several independent contrasts is A test for such activation common to several independent contrasts is called “called “Conjunction”Conjunction”
• Conjunctions can be conducted across a whole variety of different Conjunctions can be conducted across a whole variety of different contexts:contexts:
• taskstasks• stimulistimuli• senses (vision, audition)senses (vision, audition)• etc.etc.
• But the contrasts entering a conjunction have to be truly independent!But the contrasts entering a conjunction have to be truly independent!
• One way to minimise the baseline/pure insertion problem is to isolate the One way to minimise the baseline/pure insertion problem is to isolate the same process by two or more separate comparisons, and inspect the same process by two or more separate comparisons, and inspect the resulting simple effects for commonalitiesresulting simple effects for commonalities
• A test for such activation common to several independent contrasts is A test for such activation common to several independent contrasts is called “called “Conjunction”Conjunction”
• Conjunctions can be conducted across a whole variety of different Conjunctions can be conducted across a whole variety of different contexts:contexts:
• taskstasks• stimulistimuli• senses (vision, audition)senses (vision, audition)• etc.etc.
• But the contrasts entering a conjunction have to be truly independent!But the contrasts entering a conjunction have to be truly independent!
ConjunctionsConjunctionsConjunctionsConjunctions
Example: Example:
Which neural structures support object recognition, Which neural structures support object recognition,
independent of task (naming vs viewing)?independent of task (naming vs viewing)?
Example: Example:
Which neural structures support object recognition, Which neural structures support object recognition,
independent of task (naming vs viewing)?independent of task (naming vs viewing)? A1A1A1A1 A2A2A2A2
B2B2B2B2B1B1B1B1
Task (1/2)Task (1/2)Task (1/2)Task (1/2)
NamingNaming ViewingViewingNamingNaming ViewingViewing
Stim
uli (
A/B
)S
timul
i (A
/B)
Stim
uli (
A/B
)S
timul
i (A
/B)
Col
ours
O
bjec
tsC
olou
rs
Obj
ects
C
olou
rs
Obj
ects
Col
ours
O
bjec
ts
Visual Processing Visual Processing V V Object Recognition Object Recognition RRPhonological Retrieval Phonological Retrieval PP
(Object - Colour viewing) & (Object - Colour naming)(Object - Colour viewing) & (Object - Colour naming)
[1 -1 0 0] & [0 0 1 -1][1 -1 0 0] & [0 0 1 -1]
[ R,V - V ] & [ P,R,V - P,V ][ R,V - V ] & [ P,R,V - P,V ]
= = R & R R & R = R= R
(assuming no interaction (assuming no interaction RxPRxP; see later); see later)
Visual Processing Visual Processing V V Object Recognition Object Recognition RRPhonological Retrieval Phonological Retrieval PP
(Object - Colour viewing) & (Object - Colour naming)(Object - Colour viewing) & (Object - Colour naming)
[1 -1 0 0] & [0 0 1 -1][1 -1 0 0] & [0 0 1 -1]
[ R,V - V ] & [ P,R,V - P,V ][ R,V - V ] & [ P,R,V - P,V ]
= = R & R R & R = R= R
(assuming no interaction (assuming no interaction RxPRxP; see later); see later)
ConjunctionsConjunctionsConjunctionsConjunctions
Price et al, 1997Price et al, 1997Common object Common object
recognition response (Rrecognition response (R))Common object Common object
recognition response (Rrecognition response (R))
ConjunctionsConjunctionsConjunctionsConjunctions
SPM8 offers two general ways to test the SPM8 offers two general ways to test the significance of conjunctions: significance of conjunctions:
• Test of global null hypothesis: Test of global null hypothesis: Significant set of consistent effectsSignificant set of consistent effects
“ “which voxels show effects of similar which voxels show effects of similar direction (but not necessarily direction (but not necessarily individual significance) across contrasts?” individual significance) across contrasts?”
• Test of conjunction null hypothesis: Test of conjunction null hypothesis: Set of consistently significant effectsSet of consistently significant effects
“ “which voxels show, for each specified which voxels show, for each specified contrast, effects > threshold?” contrast, effects > threshold?”
• Choice of test depends on hypothesis and Choice of test depends on hypothesis and congruence of contrasts; the global null test congruence of contrasts; the global null test is more sensitive (i.e., when direction of is more sensitive (i.e., when direction of effects hypothesised)effects hypothesised)
SPM8 offers two general ways to test the SPM8 offers two general ways to test the significance of conjunctions: significance of conjunctions:
• Test of global null hypothesis: Test of global null hypothesis: Significant set of consistent effectsSignificant set of consistent effects
“ “which voxels show effects of similar which voxels show effects of similar direction (but not necessarily direction (but not necessarily individual significance) across contrasts?” individual significance) across contrasts?”
• Test of conjunction null hypothesis: Test of conjunction null hypothesis: Set of consistently significant effectsSet of consistently significant effects
“ “which voxels show, for each specified which voxels show, for each specified contrast, effects > threshold?” contrast, effects > threshold?”
• Choice of test depends on hypothesis and Choice of test depends on hypothesis and congruence of contrasts; the global null test congruence of contrasts; the global null test is more sensitive (i.e., when direction of is more sensitive (i.e., when direction of effects hypothesised)effects hypothesised)
Two flavours of inference about Two flavours of inference about conjunctionsconjunctions
Two flavours of inference about Two flavours of inference about conjunctionsconjunctions
A1-A2 A1-A2
B
1-B
2
B1-
B2 p(A1=A2)<pp(A1=A2)<p
++p(B1=B2)<pp(B1=B2)<p
++
Friston et al.Friston et al. (2005). Neuroimage, Neuroimage, 25:661-7.25:661-7.
Nichols et al. (2005). Nichols et al. (2005). Neuroimage, Neuroimage, 25:653-60.25:653-60.
Friston et al.Friston et al. (2005). Neuroimage, Neuroimage, 25:661-7.25:661-7.
Nichols et al. (2005). Nichols et al. (2005). Neuroimage, Neuroimage, 25:653-60.25:653-60.
OverviewOverviewOverviewOverview
• Categorical designsCategorical designsSubtraction Subtraction - Pure insertion, evoked / differential - Pure insertion, evoked / differential
responsesresponses
Conjunction Conjunction - Testing multiple hypotheses- Testing multiple hypotheses
• Parametric designsParametric designsLinear Linear - Adaptation, cognitive dimensions- Adaptation, cognitive dimensions
NonlinearNonlinear - Polynomial expansions, neurometric - Polynomial expansions, neurometric functionsfunctions
• Factorial designsFactorial designsCategoricalCategorical - Interactions and pure insertion- Interactions and pure insertion
ParametricParametric - Linear and nonlinear interactions- Linear and nonlinear interactions
- Psychophysiological Interactions- Psychophysiological Interactions
• Categorical designsCategorical designsSubtraction Subtraction - Pure insertion, evoked / differential - Pure insertion, evoked / differential
responsesresponses
Conjunction Conjunction - Testing multiple hypotheses- Testing multiple hypotheses
• Parametric designsParametric designsLinear Linear - Adaptation, cognitive dimensions- Adaptation, cognitive dimensions
NonlinearNonlinear - Polynomial expansions, neurometric - Polynomial expansions, neurometric functionsfunctions
• Factorial designsFactorial designsCategoricalCategorical - Interactions and pure insertion- Interactions and pure insertion
ParametricParametric - Linear and nonlinear interactions- Linear and nonlinear interactions
- Psychophysiological Interactions- Psychophysiological Interactions
Parametric Designs: General Parametric Designs: General ApproachApproach
Parametric Designs: General Parametric Designs: General ApproachApproach
• Parametric designs approach the baseline problem by:Parametric designs approach the baseline problem by:
– Varying a stimulus-parameter of interest on a continuum, Varying a stimulus-parameter of interest on a continuum, in multiple (n>2) steps...in multiple (n>2) steps...
– ... and relating blood-flow to this parameter... and relating blood-flow to this parameter
• Flexible choice of tests for such relations :Flexible choice of tests for such relations :• LinearLinear• Nonlinear: Quadratic/cubic/etc.Nonlinear: Quadratic/cubic/etc.• „„Data-driven“ (e.g., neurometric functions)Data-driven“ (e.g., neurometric functions)• Model-basedModel-based
Linear effect Linear effect of time of time
Linear effect Linear effect of time of time
A linear parametric contrastA linear parametric contrastA linear parametric contrastA linear parametric contrast
The nonlinear effect of time The nonlinear effect of time assessed with the SPM{T}assessed with the SPM{T}
The nonlinear effect of time The nonlinear effect of time assessed with the SPM{T}assessed with the SPM{T}
A nonlinear parametric contrastA nonlinear parametric contrastA nonlinear parametric contrastA nonlinear parametric contrast
Inverted ‘U’ response toInverted ‘U’ response toincreasing word presentationincreasing word presentation
rate in the DLPFCrate in the DLPFC
Inverted ‘U’ response toInverted ‘U’ response toincreasing word presentationincreasing word presentation
rate in the DLPFCrate in the DLPFCSPM{F}SPM{F}SPM{F}SPM{F}
Polynomial expansion:Polynomial expansion:f(x) ~ f(x) ~ b1 x + b2 x2 + ...
…up to (N-1)th order for N levels
Polynomial expansion:Polynomial expansion:f(x) ~ f(x) ~ b1 x + b2 x2 + ...
…up to (N-1)th order for N levels
Lin
ear
Lin
ear
Qu
adr
atic
Qu
adr
atic
E.g, F-contrast [0 1 0] on E.g, F-contrast [0 1 0] on Quadratic Parameter =>Quadratic Parameter =>E.g, F-contrast [0 1 0] on E.g, F-contrast [0 1 0] on Quadratic Parameter =>Quadratic Parameter =>
Nonlinear parametric design matrixNonlinear parametric design matrixNonlinear parametric design matrixNonlinear parametric design matrix
(SPM8 GUI offers polynomial (SPM8 GUI offers polynomial expansion as option during creation expansion as option during creation of parametric modulation regressors)of parametric modulation regressors)
(SPM8 GUI offers polynomial (SPM8 GUI offers polynomial expansion as option during creation expansion as option during creation of parametric modulation regressors)of parametric modulation regressors)
Parametric Designs: Neurometric Parametric Designs: Neurometric functionsfunctions
Parametric Designs: Neurometric Parametric Designs: Neurometric functionsfunctions
Rees, G., et al. (1997). Rees, G., et al. (1997). Neuroimage, 6Neuroimage, 6: 27-78: 27-78Rees, G., et al. (1997). Rees, G., et al. (1997). Neuroimage, 6Neuroimage, 6: 27-78: 27-78
versusversusversusversus
Inverted ‘U’ response toInverted ‘U’ response toincreasing word presentationincreasing word presentation
rate in the DLPFCrate in the DLPFC
Inverted ‘U’ response toInverted ‘U’ response toincreasing word presentationincreasing word presentation
rate in the DLPFCrate in the DLPFCRees, G., et al. (1997). Rees, G., et al. (1997). Neuroimage, 6Neuroimage, 6: 27-78: 27-78Rees, G., et al. (1997). Rees, G., et al. (1997). Neuroimage, 6Neuroimage, 6: 27-78: 27-78
Parametric Designs: Neurometric Parametric Designs: Neurometric functionsfunctions
Parametric Designs: Neurometric Parametric Designs: Neurometric functionsfunctions
Coding of tactile stimuli in Anterior Cingulate Cortex:Stimulus (a) presence, (b) intensity, and (c) pain intensity
– Variation of intensity of a heat stimulus applied to the right hand(300, 400, 500, and 600 mJ)
Büchel et al. (2002). Büchel et al. (2002). The Journal of Neuroscience, 22The Journal of Neuroscience, 22: 970-6: 970-6
– Assumptions::
Parametric Designs: Neurometric Parametric Designs: Neurometric functionsfunctions
Parametric Designs: Neurometric Parametric Designs: Neurometric functionsfunctions
Büchel et al. (2002). Büchel et al. (2002). The Journal of Neuroscience, 22The Journal of Neuroscience, 22: 970-6: 970-6Büchel et al. (2002). Büchel et al. (2002). The Journal of Neuroscience, 22The Journal of Neuroscience, 22: 970-6: 970-6
Stimulus presenceStimulus presence Stimulus presenceStimulus presence
Pain intensityPain intensity Pain intensityPain intensity
Stimulus intensityStimulus intensity Stimulus intensityStimulus intensity
Parametric Designs: Model-based Parametric Designs: Model-based regressorsregressors
Parametric Designs: Model-based Parametric Designs: Model-based regressorsregressors
Seymour, O‘Doherty, et al. (2004). Seymour, O‘Doherty, et al. (2004). Nature.Nature.Seymour, O‘Doherty, et al. (2004). Seymour, O‘Doherty, et al. (2004). Nature.Nature.
OverviewOverviewOverviewOverview
• Categorical designsCategorical designsSubtraction Subtraction - Pure insertion, evoked / differential - Pure insertion, evoked / differential
responsesresponses
Conjunction Conjunction - Testing multiple hypotheses- Testing multiple hypotheses
• Parametric designsParametric designsLinear Linear - Adaptation, cognitive dimensions- Adaptation, cognitive dimensions
NonlinearNonlinear - Polynomial expansions, neurometric - Polynomial expansions, neurometric functionsfunctions
• Factorial designsFactorial designsCategoricalCategorical - Interactions and pure insertion- Interactions and pure insertion
ParametricParametric - Linear and nonlinear interactions- Linear and nonlinear interactions
- Psychophysiological Interactions- Psychophysiological Interactions
• Categorical designsCategorical designsSubtraction Subtraction - Pure insertion, evoked / differential - Pure insertion, evoked / differential
responsesresponses
Conjunction Conjunction - Testing multiple hypotheses- Testing multiple hypotheses
• Parametric designsParametric designsLinear Linear - Adaptation, cognitive dimensions- Adaptation, cognitive dimensions
NonlinearNonlinear - Polynomial expansions, neurometric - Polynomial expansions, neurometric functionsfunctions
• Factorial designsFactorial designsCategoricalCategorical - Interactions and pure insertion- Interactions and pure insertion
ParametricParametric - Linear and nonlinear interactions- Linear and nonlinear interactions
- Psychophysiological Interactions- Psychophysiological Interactions
A1A1A1A1 A2A2A2A2
B2B2B2B2B1B1B1B1
Task (1/2)Task (1/2)Task (1/2)Task (1/2)
NamingNaming Viewing Viewing NamingNaming Viewing Viewing
Stim
uli (
A/B
)S
timul
i (A
/B)
Stim
uli (
A/B
)S
timul
i (A
/B)
Col
ours
C
olou
rs O
bjec
tsO
bjec
ts
Col
ours
C
olou
rs O
bjec
tsO
bjec
ts
Colours Objects Colours ObjectsColours Objects Colours Objects Colours Objects Colours ObjectsColours Objects Colours Objects
interaction effectinteraction effect (Task x Stimuli)(Task x Stimuli)interaction effectinteraction effect (Task x Stimuli)(Task x Stimuli)
ViewingViewingViewingViewing NamingNamingNamingNaming
Factorial designs: Main effects and Factorial designs: Main effects and InteractionsInteractions
Factorial designs: Main effects and Factorial designs: Main effects and InteractionsInteractions
• Main effect of task:Main effect of task: (A1 + B1) – (A2 + (A1 + B1) – (A2 + B2)B2)
• Main effect of stimuli: Main effect of stimuli: (A1 + A2) – (B1 + (A1 + A2) – (B1 + B2)B2)
• Interaction of task and stimuli: Interaction of task and stimuli: Can show a failure of pure insertionCan show a failure of pure insertion
(A1 – B1) – (A2 – (A1 – B1) – (A2 – B2)B2)
• Main effect of task:Main effect of task: (A1 + B1) – (A2 + (A1 + B1) – (A2 + B2)B2)
• Main effect of stimuli: Main effect of stimuli: (A1 + A2) – (B1 + (A1 + A2) – (B1 + B2)B2)
• Interaction of task and stimuli: Interaction of task and stimuli: Can show a failure of pure insertionCan show a failure of pure insertion
(A1 – B1) – (A2 – (A1 – B1) – (A2 – B2)B2)
Interactions and pure insertionInteractions and pure insertionInteractions and pure insertionInteractions and pure insertion
Object-naming-specific activationsObject-naming-specific activationsObject-naming-specific activationsObject-naming-specific activations
Context: Context: no naming namingno naming namingContext: Context: no naming namingno naming namingad
just
ed r
CB
Fad
just
ed r
CB
Fad
just
ed r
CB
Fad
just
ed r
CB
F
ComponentsComponentsVisual processingVisual processing VVObject recognition Object recognition RRPhonological retrievalPhonological retrieval PPInteractionInteraction RxPRxP
InteractionInteraction(name object - colour) - (view object - colour)(name object - colour) - (view object - colour)
[1 -1 0 0] [1 -1 0 0] - - [0 0 1 -1] [0 0 1 -1]
= = [ P,R,V + RxP[ P,R,V + RxP - P,V ] - [ R,V - V ] - P,V ] - [ R,V - V ]
= = RxPRxP
ComponentsComponentsVisual processingVisual processing VVObject recognition Object recognition RRPhonological retrievalPhonological retrieval PPInteractionInteraction RxPRxP
InteractionInteraction(name object - colour) - (view object - colour)(name object - colour) - (view object - colour)
[1 -1 0 0] [1 -1 0 0] - - [0 0 1 -1] [0 0 1 -1]
= = [ P,R,V + RxP[ P,R,V + RxP - P,V ] - [ R,V - V ] - P,V ] - [ R,V - V ]
= = RxPRxP
Interactions and pure insertionInteractions and pure insertionInteractions and pure insertionInteractions and pure insertion
Interactions: Interactions:
cross-over cross-over
and and
simplesimple
We can selectively We can selectively inspect our data for one inspect our data for one or the other by masking or the other by masking during inferenceduring inference
Interactions: Interactions:
cross-over cross-over
and and
simplesimple
We can selectively We can selectively inspect our data for one inspect our data for one or the other by masking or the other by masking during inferenceduring inference
A1 A2A1 A2 B1 B2B1 B2
A1 A2A1 A2 B1 B2B1 B2
OverviewOverviewOverviewOverview
• Categorical designsCategorical designsSubtraction Subtraction - Pure insertion, evoked / differential - Pure insertion, evoked / differential
responsesresponses
Conjunction Conjunction - Testing multiple hypotheses- Testing multiple hypotheses
• Parametric designsParametric designsLinear Linear - Adaptation, cognitive dimensions- Adaptation, cognitive dimensions
NonlinearNonlinear - Polynomial expansions, neurometric - Polynomial expansions, neurometric functionsfunctions
• Factorial designsFactorial designsCategoricalCategorical - Interactions and pure insertion- Interactions and pure insertion
ParametricParametric - Linear and nonlinear interactions- Linear and nonlinear interactions
- Psychophysiological Interactions- Psychophysiological Interactions
• Categorical designsCategorical designsSubtraction Subtraction - Pure insertion, evoked / differential - Pure insertion, evoked / differential
responsesresponses
Conjunction Conjunction - Testing multiple hypotheses- Testing multiple hypotheses
• Parametric designsParametric designsLinear Linear - Adaptation, cognitive dimensions- Adaptation, cognitive dimensions
NonlinearNonlinear - Polynomial expansions, neurometric - Polynomial expansions, neurometric functionsfunctions
• Factorial designsFactorial designsCategoricalCategorical - Interactions and pure insertion- Interactions and pure insertion
ParametricParametric - Linear and nonlinear interactions- Linear and nonlinear interactions
- Psychophysiological Interactions- Psychophysiological Interactions
A (Linear) A (Linear) Time-by-ConditionTime-by-Condition
InteractionInteraction(“Generation strategy”?) (“Generation strategy”?)
A (Linear) A (Linear) Time-by-ConditionTime-by-Condition
InteractionInteraction(“Generation strategy”?) (“Generation strategy”?)
Contrast: Contrast:
[5 3 1 -1 -3 -5][5 3 1 -1 -3 -5] [-1 1][-1 1]
= [-5 5 -3 3 -1 1 1 -1 3 -3 5 -5]= [-5 5 -3 3 -1 1 1 -1 3 -3 5 -5]
Contrast: Contrast:
[5 3 1 -1 -3 -5][5 3 1 -1 -3 -5] [-1 1][-1 1]
= [-5 5 -3 3 -1 1 1 -1 3 -3 5 -5]= [-5 5 -3 3 -1 1 1 -1 3 -3 5 -5]
Linear Parametric InteractionLinear Parametric InteractionLinear Parametric InteractionLinear Parametric Interaction
Factorial Design with 2 factors:Factorial Design with 2 factors:
1.1. Gen/Rep (Categorical, 2 levels)Gen/Rep (Categorical, 2 levels)2.2. Time (Parametric, 6 levels)Time (Parametric, 6 levels)
Time effects modelled with both linear Time effects modelled with both linear and quadratic components…and quadratic components…
Factorial Design with 2 factors:Factorial Design with 2 factors:
1.1. Gen/Rep (Categorical, 2 levels)Gen/Rep (Categorical, 2 levels)2.2. Time (Parametric, 6 levels)Time (Parametric, 6 levels)
Time effects modelled with both linear Time effects modelled with both linear and quadratic components…and quadratic components…
G-RG-R TimeLin
TimeLin
G x TLin
G x TLin
TimeQuadTimeQuad
G x TQuadG x TQuad
F-contrast tests for nonlinearF-contrast tests for nonlinearGeneration-by-Time interactionGeneration-by-Time interaction
(including both linear and (including both linear and Quadratic components)Quadratic components)
F-contrast tests for nonlinearF-contrast tests for nonlinearGeneration-by-Time interactionGeneration-by-Time interaction
(including both linear and (including both linear and Quadratic components)Quadratic components)
Nonlinear Parametric InteractionNonlinear Parametric InteractionNonlinear Parametric InteractionNonlinear Parametric Interaction
OverviewOverviewOverviewOverview
• Categorical designsCategorical designsSubtraction Subtraction - Pure insertion, evoked / differential - Pure insertion, evoked / differential
responsesresponses
Conjunction Conjunction - Testing multiple hypotheses- Testing multiple hypotheses
• Parametric designsParametric designsLinear Linear - Adaptation, cognitive dimensions- Adaptation, cognitive dimensions
NonlinearNonlinear - Polynomial expansions, neurometric - Polynomial expansions, neurometric functionsfunctions
• Factorial designsFactorial designsCategoricalCategorical - Interactions and pure insertion- Interactions and pure insertion
ParametricParametric - Linear and nonlinear interactions- Linear and nonlinear interactions
- Psychophysiological Interactions- Psychophysiological Interactions
• Categorical designsCategorical designsSubtraction Subtraction - Pure insertion, evoked / differential - Pure insertion, evoked / differential
responsesresponses
Conjunction Conjunction - Testing multiple hypotheses- Testing multiple hypotheses
• Parametric designsParametric designsLinear Linear - Adaptation, cognitive dimensions- Adaptation, cognitive dimensions
NonlinearNonlinear - Polynomial expansions, neurometric - Polynomial expansions, neurometric functionsfunctions
• Factorial designsFactorial designsCategoricalCategorical - Interactions and pure insertion- Interactions and pure insertion
ParametricParametric - Linear and nonlinear interactions- Linear and nonlinear interactions
- Psychophysiological Interactions- Psychophysiological Interactions
ContextContextContextContext
sourcesourcesourcesource
targettargettargettarget
XXXX
Parametric, factorial design, in which one factor is a psychological context …
...and the other is a physiological source (activity extracted from a brain region of interest)
Parametric, factorial design, in which one factor is a psychological context …
...and the other is a physiological source (activity extracted from a brain region of interest)
Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)
stimulistimulistimulistimuli
Modulation of Modulation of stimulus-specific stimulus-specific
responsesresponses
Modulation of Modulation of stimulus-specific stimulus-specific
responsesresponses
sourcesourcesourcesource
targettargettargettarget
SetSetSetSet
Context-sensitiveContext-sensitiveconnectivityconnectivity
Context-sensitiveContext-sensitiveconnectivityconnectivity
sourcesourcesourcesource
targettargettargettarget
Parametric, factorial design, in which one factor is a psychological context …
...and the other is a physiological source (activity extracted from a brain region of interest)
Parametric, factorial design, in which one factor is a psychological context …
...and the other is a physiological source (activity extracted from a brain region of interest)
Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)
SPM{Z}SPM{Z}
Attentional modulation ofAttentional modulation ofV1 - V5 contributionV1 - V5 contribution
Attentional modulation ofAttentional modulation ofV1 - V5 contributionV1 - V5 contribution
AttentionAttentionAttentionAttention
V1V1V1V1
V5V5V5V5
attention
no attention
V1 activityV1 activity
V5
activ
ity
timetime
V1
activ
ity
Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)
SPM{Z}SPM{Z}
attention
no attention
V1 activityV1 activity
V5
activ
ity
timetime
V1
activ
ity
V1V1 AttAtt V1 x AttV1 x Att
0 0 1 0 0 1
Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)
adju
sted
rC
BF
adju
sted
rC
BF
adju
sted
rC
BF
adju
sted
rC
BF
medial parietal activitymedial parietal activitymedial parietal activitymedial parietal activity
FacesFacesFacesFaces
ObjectsObjectsObjectsObjects
Stimuli:Stimuli:Faces or objectsFaces or objects
Stimuli:Stimuli:Faces or objectsFaces or objects
PPCPPCPPCPPC
ITITITIT
SPM{Z}SPM{Z}SPM{Z}SPM{Z}
Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)
• PPIs tested by a GLM with form:PPIs tested by a GLM with form:
yy = ( = (V1V1AA).b).b11 + + V1V1.b.b22 + + AA.b.b33 + + ee c = [1 0 0]c = [1 0 0]
• However, the interaction term of interest, However, the interaction term of interest, V1V1AA, is the product of V1 activity and , is the product of V1 activity and Attention block AFTER convolution with HRFAttention block AFTER convolution with HRF
• We are really interested in interaction at neural level, but:We are really interested in interaction at neural level, but:
(HRF (HRF V1) V1) (HRF (HRF A) A) HRF HRF (V1 (V1 A A) )
(unless A low frequency, e.g., blocked; mainly problem for event-related PPIs)(unless A low frequency, e.g., blocked; mainly problem for event-related PPIs)
• SPM5 can effect a SPM5 can effect a deconvolutiondeconvolution of physiological regressors (V1), before of physiological regressors (V1), before calculating interaction term and reconvolving with the HRF – the “PPI button”calculating interaction term and reconvolving with the HRF – the “PPI button”
• PPIs tested by a GLM with form:PPIs tested by a GLM with form:
yy = ( = (V1V1AA).b).b11 + + V1V1.b.b22 + + AA.b.b33 + + ee c = [1 0 0]c = [1 0 0]
• However, the interaction term of interest, However, the interaction term of interest, V1V1AA, is the product of V1 activity and , is the product of V1 activity and Attention block AFTER convolution with HRFAttention block AFTER convolution with HRF
• We are really interested in interaction at neural level, but:We are really interested in interaction at neural level, but:
(HRF (HRF V1) V1) (HRF (HRF A) A) HRF HRF (V1 (V1 A A) )
(unless A low frequency, e.g., blocked; mainly problem for event-related PPIs)(unless A low frequency, e.g., blocked; mainly problem for event-related PPIs)
• SPM5 can effect a SPM5 can effect a deconvolutiondeconvolution of physiological regressors (V1), before of physiological regressors (V1), before calculating interaction term and reconvolving with the HRF – the “PPI button”calculating interaction term and reconvolving with the HRF – the “PPI button”
Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)Psycho-physiological Interaction (PPI)
OverviewOverviewOverviewOverview
• Categorical designsCategorical designsSubtraction Subtraction - Pure insertion, evoked / differential - Pure insertion, evoked / differential
responsesresponses
Conjunction Conjunction - Testing multiple hypotheses- Testing multiple hypotheses
• Parametric designsParametric designsLinear Linear - Adaptation, cognitive dimensions- Adaptation, cognitive dimensions
NonlinearNonlinear - Polynomial expansions, neurometric - Polynomial expansions, neurometric functionsfunctions
• Factorial designsFactorial designsCategoricalCategorical - Interactions and pure insertion- Interactions and pure insertion
ParametricParametric - Linear and nonlinear interactions- Linear and nonlinear interactions
- Psychophysiological Interactions- Psychophysiological Interactions
• Categorical designsCategorical designsSubtraction Subtraction - Pure insertion, evoked / differential - Pure insertion, evoked / differential
responsesresponses
Conjunction Conjunction - Testing multiple hypotheses- Testing multiple hypotheses
• Parametric designsParametric designsLinear Linear - Adaptation, cognitive dimensions- Adaptation, cognitive dimensions
NonlinearNonlinear - Polynomial expansions, neurometric - Polynomial expansions, neurometric functionsfunctions
• Factorial designsFactorial designsCategoricalCategorical - Interactions and pure insertion- Interactions and pure insertion
ParametricParametric - Linear and nonlinear interactions- Linear and nonlinear interactions
- Psychophysiological Interactions- Psychophysiological Interactions