CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010
Experimental procedures for efficient after-treatment model calibration
Maria E. Kalogirou Exothermia SA Laboratory of Applied Thermodynamics, Aristotle University Thessaloniki Greece
Matyáš Schejbal Laboratory of Applied Thermodynamics, Aristotle University Thessaloniki Greece
Grigorios C. Koltsakis Exothermia SA Laboratory of Applied Thermodynamics, Aristotle University Thessaloniki Greece
21 April 2010 CLEERS Workshop 2010
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 2
Background - motivation
simulation software + user interface
balance equations
reaction kinetics
numerical
methods
! Advanced after-treatment simulations tools are available.
! Knowledge of accurate reaction kinetics remains the main challenge.
! Target of this work is to derive realistic reaction rates for soot oxidation with emphasis on CRT (DOC+DPF) operation (only uncat DPF soot oxidation will be shown).
! Experimental methodology – real diesel soot – calibration with synthetic gas tests – validation on engine bench
in combination with axisuite® model platform.
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010
Uncatalyzed soot oxidation reactions review
Calibration targets of soot oxidation with O2 and NO2: - set of reactions (how many and which reactions?) - kinetic parameters (activation energies, pre-exponential factors)
3
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 4
Methodology
model based validation valid kinetic parameters
small-scale experiments + controlable & cheaper - soot properties ?
model based calibration
engine experiments - hard to control & expensive + realistic
full-scale simulations
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 21 April 2010 CLEERS Workshop 2010 5
Methodology
model based validation valid kinetic parameters
small-scale experiments - controlable & cheaper + soot properties ?
model based calibration
engine experiments - hard to control & expensive + realistic
full-scale simulations
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 6
Small-scale soot loading methodology
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 7
Soot oxidation measurements Small-scale DPF apparatus for synthetic gas bench
8
test piece (+6 thermocouples)
synthetic gases
gas mixer furnace
H2O HC
by-pass line flow meter
exhaust line (can be connected to engine) AVL AMA i60 analyzer
(CO, CO2, HC, NO/NOx) + pressure & temperature sensors
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 8
Similar experiments were done at 380, 460, 470 and 540 °C.
NOx
NOx – O2 mixture
soot burn off in O2
heat up in N2
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 9
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 10
Reaction with O2 Activation energy
Two discrete regions are observed: there appears to be a necessity to use 2 reactions with O2 (one with higher and one with lower activation energy).
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 11
Reaction with O2 Activation energy
E ~ 100 kJ/mol R2 = 0.9594
Two discrete regions are observed: there appears to be a necessity to use 2 reactions with O2 (one with higher and one with lower activation energy).
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 12
Reaction with O2 Activation energy
Range: 550 – 650 °C E ~ 153 kJ/mol R2 = 0.9956
Range: 400 – 530 °C E ~ 67 kJ/mol R2 = 0.9752
Two discrete regions are observed: there appears to be a necessity to use 2 reactions with O2 (one with higher and one with lower activation energy).
E ~ 100 kJ/mol R2 = 0.9594
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010
Cooperative reactions in mixture of NO2-O2 Are they necessary to explain our results?
13
A set of independent reactions was used to describe soot oxidation with NO2 and O2.
Within experimental uncertainty, the sum of the reaction rates of the reactions with O2 and NO2 seems to be equal with the experimental reaction rate measured when both species are present.
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 14
Methodology
model based validation valid kinetic parameters
small-scale experiments - controlable & cheaper + soot properties ?
model based calibration
engine experiments - hard to control & expensive + realistic
full-scale simulations
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 15
Modeling and rate expressions axitrap (3d + 1d DPF modeling)
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010
Uncatalyzed soot oxidation reactions
Calibration targets of soot oxidation with O2 and NO2: - set of reactions (how many and which reactions?) - kinetic parameters (activation energies, pre-exponential factors)
16
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 17
Characteristic simulation results Experiment at 460 °C
ENO2 = 45 kJ/mol, EO2,low = 64 kJ/mol, EO2,high = 155 kJ/mol
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 18
Characteristic simulation results Experiment at 380 °C
ENO2 = 45 kJ/mol, EO2,low = 64 kJ/mol, EO2,high = 155 kJ/mol
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 19
Methodology
model based validation valid kinetic parameters
small-scale experiments - controlable & cheaper + soot properties ?
model based calibration
engine experiments - hard to control & expensive + realistic
full-scale simulations
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 20
• Steady-state regeneration experiments at 3 temperatures (400 – 450 – 500 °C). • The filter was weighed before and after each test. • Target soot loading 7–9 g/L. • A cDPF was used upstream in order to increase NO2 concentration and to avoid loading of the tested filter.
Engine test protocol for full-scale tests
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 21
Methodology
model based validation valid kinetic parameters
small-scale experiments - controlable & cheaper + soot properties ?
model based calibration
engine experiments - hard to control & expensive + realistic
full-scale simulations
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 22
Model validation in full-scale system Experiment at 400 °C
Δm EXP: 1.5g Δm SIM: 1.6g
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 21 April 2010 Cleers 2010 23
Model validation in full-scale system Experiment at 450 °C
Δm EXP: 3.4g Δm SIM: 2.5g
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 24
Model validation in full-scale system Experiment at 500 °C
Δm EXP: 4.8g Δm SIM: 3.9g
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010
Model validation in full-scale system Experiment at 500 °C
25
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010
Conclusions
! A novel experimental procedure was used to evaluate uncatalyzed soot oxidation kinetics with NO2 and O2.
! The experimental results suggested that: • soot oxidation with O2 and NO2 take place independently • a low temperature direct reaction with O2 is necessary to
describe soot oxidation at CRT-relevant temperature range
! With the help of model-based calibration, it was possible to obtain rate parameters, activation enrgies and reaction selectivities
! The calibrated model was succesfully applied to full-scale engine operation under passive regeneration conditions.
26
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010 21 April 2010 CLEERS Workshop 2010 27
Future work
! Further research is needed to optimize the experimental setup and protocols and to understand and validate:
– effects of water, ammonia, … – the transient soot oxidation effects: Can they be predicted with the
assumption of a more reactive part of soot? – etc. (G.B. Shaw: “Science... never solves a problem without creating ten more.”)
Transient areas were commonly observed in the beginning of each step.
CLEERS Workshop 2010 April 21st, 2010
Thank you for your attention!
Matyáš Schejbal
http://lat.eng.auth.gr
28