Exploration of Novel Tunnel Barrier Materials for STT-RAM
Wei Chen
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/081
Wei Chen Advisor: Dr. Stuart Wolf
Department of PhysicsUniversity of Virginia
Funded by DARPA and DMEACollaborator: NIST, Freescale
Outline
• Introduction and Motivation• Background Theory• Experiment Setups
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/082
• Experiment Setups• Results & Discussion• Summary & Future Plan
Outline
• Introduction and Motivation• What is Magnetic Tunnel Junction (MTJ)?• MRAM: Major Application of MTJ• New Solution: Spin Torque Transfer!
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/083
• New Solution: Spin Torque Transfer!
• Background Theory• Experiment Setups• Results & Discussion• Summary & Future Plan
Magnetic Tunnel Junction
AFM
Pinned FM
Tunnel Barrier
Free FM
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/084
[Spintronics Class Lecture Notes, Stuart Wolf, Spring 2007]
Basic Structure of Exchange Biased MTJ
Free FM
Substrate
MRAM: Major Application of MTJ
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/085
[Spintronics Class Lecture Notes, Stuart Wolf, Spring 2007]
Potential Advantages:• Compatibility with CMOS• Density and speed of DRAM • Less power than FLASH
Main Challenges:
MRAM: Major Application of MTJ
Field Switching MRAM cannot be effectively scaled down (65nm node)!
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/086
• Less power than FLASH• Unlimited writing cycles• Truly Non-volatile
u
B
K V
k T
• 1T-1MTJ cell structure limited by the size of transistor!• Thermal Stability Factor:
down (65nm node)!
Spin Torque Transfer Switching
Key Advantage compared with conventional field switching: • Highly Scalablewriting
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/087
• A spin-polarized current injected into a ferromagnetic layer can induce a torque on its magnetization, hence rotate the magnetization.
• Highly Scalablewriting current scales down with cell size with constant Jc!
Key Advantages and Potentials of STTRAM
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/088
• Excellent write selectivity ~ localized spin-injection within cell
• Highly Scalable ~ write current scales down with cell size
• Low power ~ low write current
• Simpler Architecture ~ no write lines, no bypass line and no cladding
• High Speed ~ Few nanoseconds
=> Too high to be practical! ( )
Spin Torque Transfer Switching
ηπδα
h
MHeMJ ss
c
)2(2 +=
0.1) kA/m, 1420 ,5.2:(Co A/cm10~ 28 === αδ sc MnmJ
Model by Slonczewski:
26 /10 cmA
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/089
=> Too high to be practical! ( )26 /10 cmA
What we could engineer:•Ms Saturation Magnetization Decrease• α Gilbert damping parameter Decrease• η Spin Transfer Efficiency Increase
Novel Barrier Exploration
• Only ~70% with AlOx-MTJs.• TMR record with MgO barrier: Over 300%! MgO increases η (spin transfer efficiency) significantly!
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0810
significantly!
New Barriers Exploration Increase η :• Oxides: VOx, TiOx, TaOx• Nitrides: BN
• prevent the oxidation of under layer FM
• large gap provides robust tunneling
Smart Barrier for MTJsChallenge for SMT-MTJs:High Jc “Writing” voltage very close to junction break down voltage
VO2: • Structural phase transformation from Monoclinic to Rutile at ~340K • Current Driven transition
10-1
100
Monoclinic Rutile Read in high R phase for highest MR%
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0811
280 320 360 40010-4
10-3
10-2
10
ρρ ρρ (Ω
·cm
)
T (K)
Transition temperature: ~ 340 K
[Work by Kevin West]
for highest MR%
Write in low R phasefor lowest power!
Outline
• Introduction and Motivation• Background Theory
• Spin-dependent Transport• Spin Polarized Electron Tunneling: FM-I-FM
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0812
• Spin Polarized Electron Tunneling: FM-I-FM• AFM/FM Exchange Bias
• Experiment Setups• Results & Discussion• Summary & Future Plan
Spin-dependent Transport
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0813
Density of State diagram for ferromagnetic metal: g↑ > g↓
[Spintronics Class Lecture Notes, Stuart Wolf, Spring 2007][Mark Jonson, J. Phys. Chem. B (2005), 109, 14278-14291]
current through ferromagnetic metal
Spin Polarized Electron Tunneling: FM-I-FM
Julliere’s model:• spin conserved tunneling•
↑↓↓↑
↓↓↑↑
+=
+=
2121
2121
NNNNG
NNNNG
AP
p
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0814
21
21
1
2
PP
PP
G
GG
R
RR
R
RTMR
Ap
APp
P
PAP
P −=
−=−=∆=
↓↑
↓↑
↓↑
↓↑
+−
=
+−
=
22
222
11
111
NN
NNP
NN
NNP
Exchange Bias
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0815
[J.Nogues, Ivan Schuller, JMMM192(1999) 203-232]
FMFM
AFMFMexEB tMa
SSJH 2
2=
Outline
• Introduction and Motivation• Background Theory• Experiment Setups
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0816
• Experiment Setups• Reactive Biased Target Ion Beam Deposition• Lithographic patterning process• CIPTech Measurement
• Results & Discussion• Summary & Future Plan
Reactive Biased Target Ion Beam Deposition
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0817
• Low Energy Ion Source (5-50eV)
• High Temperature ~ 700 °C
• Smooth Surface/Interface Layer
• Control Phase Formation
• Combinatorial Growth Complex Oxides
Lithographic Patterning (I)
Unpatterned MTJ Film (Cross-section View)
• i) Apply mask, develop photo resister (PR)• ii) Dry etching to define junction structure; leave PR for next-step lift-off process
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0818
Cross-section View Plane View
lift-off process
i) ii)
Lithographic Patterning (II)
• iii) Deposition of ~ 300nm SiO2 by rf-sputtering as passivation layer• iv) Dissolve PR in Acetone to finish lift-off process• v) Apply and develop another
iii)
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0819
• v) Apply and develop another layer of mask, deposit and define Ti/Au contact layer by lift-off
iv)
v)
Cross-section View
Plane View
Top Contacts
Bottom Contacts
CIPTech Measurement
• Fast, nondestructive, and accurateway to measure TMR without patterning!• Collaboration with NIST
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0820
D. C. Worledge, etc. APL, 83, 84 (2003)
Outline
• Introduction and Motivation• Background Theory• Experiment Setups
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0821
• Experiment Setups• Results & Discussion• Summary & Future Plan
MTJ with AlOx Barrier (I)
15nm Ta
6nm CoFeB
~1nm AlOx
0
100
200
M(m
icro
em
u)
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0822
~1nm AlOx
5nm Ta3nm CoFeB
Si/SiO2 Substrate
-50 -40 -30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50
-200
-100M(m
icro
em
u)
H(Oe)
Black: 1SccmO2 5min Oxidation
Blue: 5SccmO2 2mins Oxidation
Red: 5SccmO2 4mins Oxidation
Better oxidized AlOx barrier provides better separated switching!
AlOx-MTJ Stack
MTJ with AlOx Barrier (II)
8.2279
8.2280
8.2281
8.2282
8.2283
Res
ista
nce
(oh
m)
TMR Measurement of MJT Unit @ 5K
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0823
Microscopic image of patterned MTJ cell (25x50 µm)
-200 -100 0 100 2008.2273
8.2274
8.2275
8.2276
8.2277
8.2278
Res
ista
nce
(oh
m)
Magnetic Field(Oe)
Ar/O2 Flow Rate (Sccm) Resistance (Ohm) Change
(RT->~100C)
5.5 200K->30K
• Growth condition: on top of sub/CoFeB(1nm)/V(0.5nm)• VOx thickness: ~50nm
VOx Recipe Development
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0824
5.5 200K->30K
6 680K->150K
6.5 2,500K->400K
7 Too insulating
6 (with enhanced ion energy~50eV)
57K Ohm->200 Ohm (Temperature:50K->250K )
IrMn/CoFeB Exchange Bias
50
100
Mo
men
t (m
icro
em
u)
15nm Ru
10nm IrMn(AFM)
5nm CoFeB (FM) Exchange Bias
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0825
-600 -400 -200 0 200 400 600
-100
-50
0
Mo
men
t (m
icro
em
u)
H(Oe)
20nm Ru
5nm Ta
Si/SiO2 Substrate
10nm IrMn(AFM) Exchange Bias
Hex ~ 250 Oe
MTJ with VOx Barrier (I)
50
100
150
M (
mic
ro e
mu
)
M vs H @ 305K
10nm Ru
5nm CoFeB (FM)
5nm CoFeB (FM)5nm Ta
1~2nm VOx
Pinned Layer
Free Layer Tunnel Barrier
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0826
-600 -400 -200 0 200 400 600-150
-100
-50
0
M (
mic
ro e
mu
)
H (Oe)
***The sample is measured after annealing in forming gas(95%Ar 5%H2) at 250C, 4kOe for 1hr
20nm Ru
5nm Ta
Si/SiO2 Substrate
10nm IrMn(AFM)
5nm CoFeB ( )Pinned Layer
VOx-MTJ Stack
Results Analysis and Improvement (I)
• Tunneling interfaces are crucial!• Over-oxidation of bottom FM layer • Alloy formation between FM and barrier material: pre-oxidation to form diffusion barrier
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0827
• Barrier needs to be further optimized!• Barrier Thickness: 1~2nm; Pinholes, uniformity problem with thin barrier• Oxidation approaches: natural oxidation, reactive sputtering, post-deposition plasma oxidation, etc.
• Annealing is also very important!
Results Analysis and Improvement (II)
Dry etching is crucial in defining MTJ unit, and it could be further optimization!Solutions:
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0828
Solutions:• Using tilted rotating stage• Reactive Etching Ar+Cl2
Utilizing more tools to facilitate the lithographic processing:AFM, SEM, EBL, etc.
Summary
• Growth of Prototype AlOx-MTJ
• Development of Basic Patterning Process
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0829
• Development of Basic Patterning Process
• VOx Material Exploration
• Preliminary VOx-MTJ Experiments
Future Work• Continuous exploration of VOx-MTJ; focusing on barrier growth and interface quality.• Re-visit of AlOx-MTJs to better understand
Wei Chen Condensed Matter Seminar 04/24/0830
• Re-visit of AlOx-MTJs to better understand the dependence of interface and barrier quality on TMR• New barrier materials exploration: Oxides like TiOx, TaOx, Nitrides like BN, etc. • Further optimization of lithographic patterning process.