- -Ll-

ti q?TT/I/104

dr*,q8TTIt 3TfEN,

ffl 3Tpr, Ir fflrfuffi 3TfaHer ±

ffro:24.07.2020

fa":Combined Graduate level (CGL) Examination, 2016-regarding conditions of

the outcome of the court case OA No. 2964/2017 -Rohit Kumar and Ors

(WP 3457/2018) to the appointment.

ri±±rd±!A£±±±!82Q±±2±§sQ±BQQ±±£A!±d£±Q±_2Qi6£jjfiE-3qtr fardfa atF a 3Fa edife " (± giv) al FTaPr rm

edanrJr (al fat CGLE-2016 Batch 3Tat fry gT a) aT rfu # ffli ffl q5EE #i

wi:-qanl

qfanj€3Tfen7

ap 3T=rm,(Ech)

-gil.-aFT 3Tfen (q3IT)

PCDA (swc) jPr website qT Upload ed a5l

a"hEL`(q3IT)

::...-:-i:;...;:--:-;:-:.i-;`-:.

it o Hog mjLfa3 `

_ar£T=,EEL-11001',,{Admin-RR &Estt. 3rTTTiT}

qI9:rmL Oi 1-2567548O, 25665708, fro- 01 1-256748o6, ap-

!±ga±!min8_.dad@LhrdifriQ

No, AN/VIIl/8201/2/SSC/Rectt/Auditor-2016/11 (Through Email)

To

All PCsDA/PCA (Fys.)/CsDA

Sub:

Ref:

Dt: 09/07/2020

Combined Graduate level (CGL) Examination,2016-regarding co`nditions of the outcomeof the court case OA No. 2964/2017 -Rohit Kumar and Ors fwp 3457/2018) to theappointment I

HQrsofficeletterNo.AN/VIII/8201/SSC/Auditors/CGLE-2016daredl6.03.2018

Reference is invited to HQrs offlce letter cited above regarding recruitment of Auditor in

Defence Accounts Department through CGLE-2016 under which it was intimated that the appointment

letter Issued to candidat-es will contain the first condition that :"Tfre appoi.;Cmenf o/these candJ.dates

shall be subject to the final outcome of the Writ Petition to be filed by the corl`imission before the Honble

High Court of Delhi against the order dated 23.10.2017 passed by the Ld. CAT ,Principal Bench, New Delhi

ln OA no. 2964/2017 filed by Shri Rohlt Kumar and Ors /any other litigation (OAs/WPs/SLPs) as the case

may be ."

3. Now it has been intimated byssc (Staffselection commission ) that Hon'ble supreme court of

India vide its order dated 22.11.2019 had dismissed the plea 6f Union of India in the special Leave

petition (C) 18743/2018 (Union of India vs Sumit Kumar ). A copy of tl`ieir letter bearing No. N-

11011/1/2017/NOM/NWR dated 26.05.2020 is enclosed.

I

4 Accordingly, the appointment of all nominated candidates ofcGLE 2016, which have been made

subject to l-he final outcome of WP 3457/2018 filed by the commission before the High Court of Delhi

against the CAT order dated 23.10.2017 in the matter of OA no. 2967/2017 (Rohit Kumar & Ors) or any

other litigation (OAs/WPs/SLPs), as the case may be, may now be made uncoliditional.

5. This is foryour information and necessaryaction.`-;.:i::,

(Amit Gupta)Sr. Dy, CGDA (Admin.)

q5l`: . . I) ,___ .---.----- ' -----(Ear qF9=uTT dr-I)

tf5Tife, dr RTtma 3\xt¥ froifflen'

an FT, Stfee-9qqudrg-160009.

IgEijlgiJ2iz2:

To

Kavita Garg,SF`. DY. CGDA (AN),Controller General Of Defense Account,Ullan Battr Road, Palam,Delh.I Cantt -110010

L) Examination, 2

Court Case OA NO. 2964/2017 -Rohit Kumar anSub: - Combined Graduate Level (CG

Madam/Sir,

The Comniission had declared the Final ResulExamination, 2016 on 26.09.2017. Results cif these ExaOrders in OA No. 2964/2017 fHed by Rohit Kumar & Ors. b

2 Hon'ble supreme court of vide its order dated 22_.£1I I `,' I _' - _ _ r

lndia Hi the special (eave petition (C) 18743/2018 (unlon ofthis Hon'ble Court of Delhi in WP 3457/2018 filed by theCAT dated 23.10.2017 in OA 2964/2017, has` disposed owlth the dlrection to comply the Order dated 23.10.2010 of

3` Pursuantto the abovejudgement, the appointmen2016, wh.ich have been made subject to the fl

16

File No, N-11011/1/2017/MOM/NWR

Dated: 26/05/2020.

Government of IndiaStciff Selection C()mmission

(North West Region)Ministry of Personnel, Public

Grievances & Pensions,

Ken.~d!'iva Sadan, Sector 9-A,

ch`'andigarb -160009.

regarding conditions of outcome of6-rs (Vip 3457/2018) to tliie appointment.

:e::;

in

r

Combined Gracluate Level (CGl.)ons were declared subject to the final

rt of India.ford the Hon'ble Supreme Cou

19 had dism``ssed the plea. of Union oflndi!a vs. Sumit Kumar) and consequent tonio,n c)f |ndia against the Order of Hc>n'blethe said WP vide order dated 06.02.?.020on'Pie CAT (PB) New DeihL

of :all the nominated cand'idates of OGLEof WP 3457/2018 filed by the commissionated 23.10.2017 in the matter of OA no,/WPs/SLPs), as the case may be, may now

nal outcome-\/ I \,' ,'' .```. . ' `_ -_ _ _

before the High Court of Delhi against the CAT Order2967/2017 (Rohit Kumar & Ors.) or any other litigatlon (OAbe made u nconditional

Ericl. As stated above.`. „_`.F~

--,`--.-_

_--.--

Yours faithfuHy

ii,"13-..-,`!...,,.;

(WREN MISHRA).` i.Dy. Regional Director.

'/ ByspEEDPor.ifeap ned±i;'*£-'4.pry

mst \\F;I:t::}i##::c`hT2%-2`t' ;¥~?`\,1`:``,/\he*.L/(.\1``.,

\ \` „ ffiananRE©in, '\\ '~€---.`---=`=f----f====.`t.''fan-ii0003I

:¥~:°;'tL%cDs;::e:I:£(£gRIo:in:mM#E:£nMp;\K¥AVRaeRe:,on '\\,Subject:-CombinedGraduateLevelExamination216-'iregaTding conditions of outcome--.-~~~~ofcourtcaseoANo.2984/2017.RohitKuarandors(WP3457/2018)tothe

appointment.I

Madam/Sir,where,:t::ads'rreec:::stt:dr:ieartt::!Su:e°rnTDme';:L°:':n:#:I;'beeeardi,:teeddt::s°stue2::::;:%t:ne:'t(sFothenominatedcandidate(s)OfCGLE,2016containinghefpwowingconditio""theappointmentofthesecandidatesshanbeubjbcttothefinaloutcomeoftVvritPetitiontobefiledbytheCommissionbefoetheHori'bleHighCourtofDe;ge:|is}tnt:eA°Nr:e2rgg:/t:odt?3;,1:a2g{,7sphar;8Re:h:tyK:{rd;Cn£Ta:§r,i:nc;P:}thBe:n,:t:{:,a¥{OASAVPs/SLPs),asthecasemaybe".,2lnthisconnectio"Hon'blesupremecourtvideitsorerdated22.11.2019haddismispleaofUmonofIndiaintheSpecialLeavePetition(C)18"/2018{umonofIndiaVsSumlt:;:i;dtnetsh:e:d;eerr::e:tt°:f;i:S:;¥:#htd:ae::d::°c:t,;:e'iho;;;Ln:;i:::gr;dfe:rl8::,::h:as%l:Shgeo2S:e;:;°o:fitosed)letterhelhiewit?r,sedthKumaoflndihesaHon'b

CAT (PB),New Delhi.

3. PursuanHothe abovejudgemenHhe appointmento2016,whichhavebeenmadesubjecttothefinaloutcomeofbefore the High Court Of Delhi against the CAT Order date_iL--I:,;^~+i^n /nAfbeTC)re Lr`c riitjil vvt* ,.., _ _ _

2964/20„ (Rohit Kumar & Ors.) or any other litigation (OAsnow be made

4. Keeping inviewtheabove, alltheRDs/DDsarerequuser M.inistries/Department to this effect.

Er!c!:.: .A.s ebr'..J€ ....-........,.. _„ ;-

~,yr

au[henomina{edcar\didatesofcGLEi_ _:_-I,,I,' ._ .

P '3457/2018 filed by the Commission23\.10.2017 in the matter of O.A. No.

Ps/SLPs), as i(ie ca?e may be. may

I

Und

Copy to. Shri George L).Toppo, Under Secretaryt CS.I(A),Khan market, Nevt Delhi w.r.t. DOPT.s letter no.7r7/2018-Cancl necessary action, if any.

{o issue necessary advisory to the

Yoursf€%hi:=ll},\~

(s La(ha)

rS¢cretarytotheGovernmentoflnd.\a

Odr, 2nd Floor, Lok Nayak Bhawan,I(A)dated25.112019forij{odga;O`~n

-_-