FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA …M.S. Mumbai is directed as follows: (a) Call for and...

FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET

IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD

ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.36/2019

(Dr. Sulbha Bapusaheb Mule V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

CORAM : JUSTICE A.H.JOSHI, CHAIRMAN

DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri P.B.Salunke learned Advocate holding

for Shri V.G.Salgare learned Advocate for the applicant

and Shri D.R.Patil learned Presenting Officer for the

respondents.

2. Learned P.O. has tendered the record for perusal.

It is perused and returned.

3. The Secretary, Higher & Technical Education,

M.S. Mumbai is directed as follows:

(a) Call for and peruse record himself.

(b) File own affidavit answering each and every

averment contained in O.A., before next date.

4. S.O. to 22-03-2019.

5. Steno copy and hamdust is allowed.

6. Learned P.O. is directed to communicate this

order to the concerned respondent/s.

CHAIRMAN

YUK ORAL ORDERS 08-03-2019 AHJ



M.A.ST.NO.511/2019 IN O.A.NO.300/2015

(Santosh Namdas V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



AND

ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A)

DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri V.S.Tanwade learned Advocate for the

applicant and Smt. Sanjivani Ghate learned Presenting

Officer for the respondents.

2. At the request of learned Advocate for the

applicant, S.O. to 20-03-2019.

MEMBER (A) CHAIRMAN



IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,

AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD

T.A. 11/1999 (W.P. 3251/1993) T.A. 12/1999 (W.P. 653/1994)

T.A. 19/1999 (W.P. 2311/1994) T.A. 26/1999 (W.P. 2772/1993) T.A. 47/1999 (W.P. 776/1993)

T.A. 07/1999 (W.P. 3765/1997) T.A. 06/2006 (W.P. 4261/1995)

T.A. 36/2002 (W.P. 3007/1991) M.A. 311/2008 in T.A. 42/1999 (W.P. 1274/1991)

T.A. 01/2005 (W.P. 812/1993)

T.A. 17/1999 (W.P. 2791/1994) T.A. 35/1998 (W.P. 296/1998)

M.A. 312/2008 in T.A. 35/1999 (W.P. 1259/1991)

T.A. 22/1999 (W.P. 3344/1997) T.A. 27/1999 (W.P. 3871/1995)

M.A. 367/2008 in T.A. 25/1999 (W.P. 3569/1993) M.A. 309/2008 in T.A. 24/1999 (W.P. 3607/1993) M.A. 306/2008 in T.A. 36/1999 (W.P. 652/1994)

T.A. 28/1999 (W.P. 1253/1991) T.A. 30/1999 (W.P. 617/1994) T.A. 33/1999 (W.P. 3796/1997)

T.A. 34/1999 (W.P. 3620/1997) T.A. 37/1999 (W.P. 1382/1994)

T.A. 14/1999 (W.P. 3770/1997) T.A. 16/1999 (W.P. 1226/1991) T.A. 09/1999 (W.P. 3345/1997)

T.A. 08/1999 (W.P. 1364/1992) T.A. 13/1999 (W.P. 777/1995)

T.A. 10/1999 (W.P. 5254/1995) T.A. 20/1999 (W.P. 882/1991) T.A. 38/1999 (W.P. 329/1992)

(Marathwada Serva Shramik Sanghatana through its Joint Secretary M.S. Sonwane & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


CORAM : JUSTICE A.H.JOSHI, CHAIRMAN AND


DATE : 08.03.2019 ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri A.S.Shelke learned Advocate holding for

Shri S.K.Shelke learned Advocate for the applicant and

=2=

Shri M.S.Mahajan learned Chief Presenting Officer for the

respondents.


applicants as well as the learned Chief Presenting Officer,

S.O. to 29-03-2019.

MEMBER (A) CHAIRMAN





(V.B.Malve V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



AND


DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri R.D.Khadap learned Advocate holding

for Shri S.S.Thombre learned Advocate for the

applicant and Shri M.S.Mahajan learned Chief

Presenting Officer for the respondents.


applicant, S.O. to 22-03-2019.

MEMBER (A) CHAIRMAN





(Rahul Thaware V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



AND


DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri A.A.Nimbalkar learned Advocate for

the applicant and Shri N.U.Yadav learned Presenting



applicant as well as the learned Presenting Officer,

S.O. to 20-03-2019.

MEMBER (A) CHAIRMAN





(Sayeeda Begum w/o Syed Mohamed Ali

V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


AND


DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Smt. Pathan learned Advocate holding for

Shri U.T.Pathan learned Advocate for the applicant

and Shri S.K.Shirse learned Presenting Officer for the

respondents.



S.O. to 25-03-2019.

MEMBER (A) CHAIRMAN




O.A.NO.30/2018 WITH O.A.NO.107/2019

(Mrs. Rohini Deokar & Anr. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



AND


DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri V.B.Wagh (for resp. no.5 in

O.A.No.107/19) & S.D.Joshi learned Advocates for the

applicants in respective O.As. and Shri M.S.Mahajan

learned Chief Presenting Officer for the respondents.

2. At the request of learned Advocates for the

applicants, S.O. to 27-03-2019.

MEMBER (A) CHAIRMAN




O.A.NO.160/2018 WITH O.A.NO.844/2018

(Nilesh Bansode & Anr. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



AND


DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri S.S.Dambe learned Advocate holding

for Shri S.S.Panale learned Advocate for the applicant

(O.A.No.160/18), Shri A.S.Kulkarni learned Advocate

for applicant in O.A.No.844/18 and Shri B.S.Deokar

learned Presenting Officer for the respondents.



S.O. to 22-03-2019.

MEMBER (A) CHAIRMAN





(Dr. Vaishali P. Deshpande V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



AND


DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri R.A.Tambe learned Advocate for the

applicant and Shri M.S.Mahajan learned Chief


2. At the request of learned Chief Presenting Officer,

S.O. to 02-04-2019.

MEMBER (A) CHAIRMAN




O.A.NOS. 125/2018 WITH M.A. 28/2018 IN O.A.NO. 519/2017 WITH M.A.NO. 29/2018 IN O.A.NO. 520/2017 WITH M.A.NO. 30/2018 IN

O.A.NO. 949/2017 WITH O.A.NO. 521/2017 WITH O.A.NO. 480/2017

(Shri Dnyaneshwar T. Sakhare & Ors. Vs. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

CORAM : JUSTICE A.H. JOSHI, CHAIRMAN

AND

ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Shri S.B. Sontakke, learned Advocate holding for

S/Shri B.R. Kedar, Abhishek C. Deshpande, S.S. Deve

& G.K. Kshirsagar, learned Advocates for the

respective applicants in respective cases is absent.

Mrs. Priya R. Bharaswadkar, learned Presenting

Officer for the respondents in all these cases is

present.

2. Since none is present for the applicants,

S.O. to 22.03.2019.

MEMBER (A) CHAIRMAN


FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRA TIVE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI,

BENCH AT AURANGABAD

ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 207 OF 2019 (Shri Brijesh Premlala Patil V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

CORAM : JUSTICE A.H. JOSHI, CHAIRMAN.

DATE : 08.03.2019.

O R D E R

Heard Ms. Preeti R. Wankhade, learned Advocate for

the applicant and Smt. Priya R. Bharaswadkar, learned

Presenting Officer for respondents.

2. Issue notices to the respondents, returnable on

02.05.2019.

3. Tribunal may take the case for final disposal at once

and separate notice for final disposal shall not be.

4. Applicant is authorized and directed to serve on

respondent/s intimation/notice of date of hearing duly

authenticated by Registry, along with complete paper book

of the case. Respondents are put to notice that the case

would be taken up for final disposal at the stage of

admission hearing.

5. This intimation/notice is ordered under Rule 11 of

the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal (Procedure)

Rules, 1988, and the questions such as limitation and

alternate remedy are kept open.

6. The service may be done by hand delivery, speed

post, courier and acknowledgment be obtained and

produced along with affidavit of compliance in the

Registry before due date. Applicant is directed to file

affidavit of compliance and notice.

//2// O.A. No. 207/2019

7. If notice is not collected within 7 days or proof of

service is not produced before 3 days of the next date, case

shall automatically stand dismissed without further

reference to the Tribunal.

8. Heard both sides on the point of interim relief.

9. The applicant has challenged the transfer effected

through the order dated 20.02.2019. Applicant’s previous

posting and present posting reads as follows:-

v-dz- vf/kdk&;kaps uko o inuke cnyhuarjps inLFkkiusps in o fBdk.k

15- Jh- fczts’k ikVhy

mfoHkkxh; vf/kdkjh ijrwj

ft- tkyuk

mifoHkkxh; vf/kdkjh] ukansM

¼Jh- izfni dqyd.khZ ;kaP;k cnyhus fjDr gks.kk&;k

inkoj½

(Quoted from page No. 24 of pager book of O.A.)

10. Perusal of O.A. reveals that inter alia, applicant has

challenged on the grounds viz. :-

“II) The impugned order dated 20/02/2019 of

applicant‟s transfer is issued before completion of statutory tenure of 3 years on the said post, hence is bad & untenable in the eye of law as it has been issued by Resp. No. 1 in violation of the provisions contained in Sections 3 (1), 4 (4) (2) & 5 of the said Act.

VI) It needs to be further taken into consideration

that applicant‟s case does not fall in any of the contingencies laid down in Clause 3(i) as Jalna is not his Home district nor in Clause 3(ii) of the notification dated 16/01/2019 because he has not completed 3 years on the said post. And hence on this count also the impugned order is deserving to be quashed and set aside.

//3// O.A. No. 207/2019

VII) It needs to be further taken into consideration that applicant‟s case does not even fall in the contingency laid down in Clause 4 of the notification dated 16/01/2019 as there were no Bye elections held at Partur in Jalna prior to 31/05/2017.”

(Quoted from page Nos. 9 & 10 of paper book of O.A.)

11. The question as to whether the special reasons and

exceptional circumstances are recorded the crux of matter,

and it is a matter of record of the Government. Therefore,

this Tribunal directed the learned Presenting Officer to

produce perusal record viz. :-

(i) Copy of the proposal sent by the Divisional Commissioner, Aurangabad proposing the

transfer.

(ii) Copy of the Civil Services Board along with approved transfer.

12. Learned Presenting Officer produced the same, and it

is perused.

13. The text of proposal sent by the Divisional

Commissioner, Aurangabad in so far as it relates to the

applicant, reads as follows:-

v-

dz-

vf/kdk&;kps

ukao

dk;Zjr in

o ftYgk

Cknyh

izLrkfor

dj.;kps

dkj.k

izLrkfor cnyhps

in o ftYgk

‘ksjk

31- Jh fczts’k

ikVhy

mifoHkkxh;

vf/kdkjh

ijrwj ft-

tkyuk

iz'kkldh;

dkj.kkLro

mifoHkkxh;

vf/kdkjh ukansM

¼Jh iznhi

dqyd.khZ ;kaps

izLrkfor cnyhP;k

v/khu jkgwu½

Lk| inkojhy 3 o”ksZ

dkyko/kh iw.kZ u

>kY;kus ‘kklu

Lrjkojhy ukxjh

lsok eaMGkP;k

f’kQkj’khP;k v/khu

jkgwu-

(Quoted from proposal of Divisional Commissioner, Aurangabad)

//4// O.A. No. 207/2019

14. Copy of the minutes of the Civil Services Board

contains applicant’s name at Sr. No. 15. The text of

minutes of Civil Services Board reads as follows:-

v-

dz-

vf/kdk&;kps

ukao o

inuke

LoftYgk 10 o”kkZpk

lsokri’khy

fo-pkS-@

QkS-

[kVyk

cnyhps dkj.k

@ foHkkxkps

vfHkizk;

ukxjh lsok

eaMGkph

f’kQkjl

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

15- Jh- fczts’k

ikVhy

mifoHkkxh;

vf/kdkjh

ijrwj ft-

tkyuk

22-09-

2016

tGxko miftYgkf/kdkjh

¼jksg;ks½]

ijHk.kh

10-6-2011 rs

7-6-2012

mifoHkkxh;

vf/kdkjh]

fduoV] ijHk.kh

8-6-2012 rs

23-8-2013

mifoHkkxh;

vf/kdkjh ikFkjh

ft- ijHk.kh

28-8-2013 rs

21-9-2016

ukgh Lk{ke

izkf/kdk&;kauh

Jh- fczts’k

ikVhy ;kaph

mifoHkkxh;

vf/kdkjh]

ukansM ;k

inkoj

inLFkkiuk

ns.;kph

;kiwohZp

ekU;rk fnyh

vkgs-

mifoHkkxh;

vf/kdkjh]

ukansM ;k

fuoM.kwd

dkedktk’kh

lacaf/kr Jh-

izfni

dqyd.khZ

;kaP;k

izLrkfor

cnyhus

fjDr

gks.kk&;k

inkoj

inLFkkiuk-

(Quoted from minutes of Civil Services Board, Aurangabad Division)

15. It is seen that the Civil Services Board has in toto

accepted the recommendation of the office of Divisional

Commissioner, Aurangabad, in so far as transfer of the

applicant in place of Shri Pradeep Kulkarni as Sub

Divisional Officer, Nanded, is concerned.

16. The reasons recorded in column No. 7 by the Civil

Services Board are replica of contents of the text narrated

in column No. 5 of the proposal sent by the Divisional

Commissioner, Aurangabad.

17. Endorsement of the competent authority i.e. Hon’ble

Minister and Hon’ble Chief Minister does not reveal reasons

consisting of even one line, in order to comply with the

statutory requirement of existing and recording of ‘special

//5// O.A. No. 207/2019

reasons’ and ‘exceptional circumstances’, for effecting mid-

term and mid-tenure transfer.

18. In the result, applicant has made out prima-facie

strong case for grant of interim relief by way of stay to the

impugned order dated 20.02.2019, in so far as applicant

relates and hence, ex-parte ad-interim relief by way of stay

to the impugned order is granted in favour of applicant in

terms of para 12(F) is granted, with notice to respondents

to show cause as to why the I.R. should not be made

absolute.

19. S.O. to 02.05.2019.

20. Steno copy and Hamdast is allowed to both parties.

CHAIRMAN kpb ORAL ORDER 08.03.2019 C.

FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI,

BENCH AT AURANGABAD

ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 775 OF 2018

(Smt. Ashwini P. Kankute V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CORAM : JUSTICE A.H. JOSHI, CHAIRMAN.

DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

Shri M.P. Tripathi, learned Advocate for the applicant

(Leave Note). Smt. Sanjivani K. Deshmukh-Ghate, learned

Presenting Officer for respondents, present.

2. In view of leave note filed by learned Advocate for the

applicant, S.O. to 27.03.2019.

CHAIRMAN

kpb ORAL ORDER 08.03.2019 C.


BENCH AT AURANGABAD


(Shri Vikas B. Kamble V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri S.P. Salgar, learned Advocate for the

applicant and Smt. Sanjivani K. Deshmukh-Ghate, learned


2. At the request of learned Presenting Officer, S.O. to

20.04.2019.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD


(Shri Ramesh D. Chaudhari V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri N.L Choudhari, learned Advocate for the

applicant and Shri M.S. Mahajan, learned Chief Presenting

Officer for respondents.

2. At the request of learned Chief Presenting Officer,

S.O. to 20.03.2019.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD

O.A. No. 02/2019 with M.A. No. 58/2019

(Shri Tukaram R. Bhojane V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri P.P. Deshmukh, learned Advocate holding

for Shri V.M. Maney, learned Advocate for the applicant

and Smt. Priya R. Bharaswadkar, learned Presenting

Officer for respondents, present.


27.03.2019.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD

M.A. No. 467/2018 in C.P. No. 78/2018 in O.A. No. 417/2018 (Shri Chhagan B. Chavan V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri V.R. Bhumkar, learned Presenting Officer

for the applicants in M.A. No. 467/2018 and Shri Ashish

Rajkar, learned Advocate holding for Shri S.D. Joshi,

learned Advocate for applicants in C.P. No. 78/2018.


08.04.2019.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD


(Shri Kaniram M. Jadhav V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri D.T. Devane, learned Advocate for the

applicant and Smt. M.S. Patni, learned Presenting Officer

for respondents.

2. At the request of learned Advocate for the applicant,

S.O. to 15.04.2019 for producing copy of charge sheet in

Criminal Case.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD


(Smt. Mangal S. Kathar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri D.T. Devane, learned Advocate for the

applicant and Shri D.R. Patil, learned Presenting Officer for

respondents.

2. Learned Advocate for the applicant prays for time to

collect information to plead discrimination. Time granted.

3. S.O. to 15.04.2019.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD

O.A. No. 345/2018 with Caveat 41/2018 with M.A. No. 184/2018

(Dr. Shivaji J. Rathod V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri S.D. Joshi, learned Advocate for the

applicant, Shri V.R. Bhumkar, learned Presenting

Officer for respondent Nos. 1 and 2, Shri S.B. Bhosle,

learned advocate for respondent No. 5 (applicant in

M.A.) and A.S. Savale, learned Advocate for respondent

Nos. 3 & 4.

2. Learned Presenting Officer has placed on record

a copy of order dated 02.03.2019. Same is taken on

record and marked as document-‘X’ for the purposes

of identification.

3. Learned Presenting Officer states that impugned

order transferring the applicant passed on 07.07.2018

has been revoked.

4. Learned Presenting Officer states on instructions

that suitable decision as regards the posting of

Respondent No. 5 and even the transfer of applicant

when due would be passed in due course.

5. Hence, O.A. is disposed of without any order as

to costs.

//2// O.A. No. 345/2018 with Caveat

41/2018 with M.A. No. 184/2018

6. Since O.A. itself stood disposed of, nothing

survives in M.A. No. 184/2018 and the same also

stands disposed of.

7. Parties are directed to bear their own costs.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD


(Shri Parshuram S. Bramhne & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

Shri Sudhir Patil, learned Advocate for the applicant

and Shri M.P. Gude, learned Presenting Officer for

respondents.

2. Learned Advocate for the applicant prays for leave to

delete the name of applicant No. 1 from the array of

applicants.

3. Leave as prayed for is granted to the learned

Advocate for the applicant.

4. Heard both sides.

5. The present matter is reserved for orders.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD

M.A. No. 366/2018 in M.A. St. No. 1591/2018 in O.A. St. No. 1592/2018

(Dr. Ravindra A. Daware & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri S.G. Kulkarni, learned Advocate holding

for Shri Ajay Deshpande, learned Advocate for the

applicant and Smt. Priya R. Bharaswadkar, learned


2. At the request of learned Presenting Officer for the

respondents, S.O. to 29.03.2019 for filing affidavit in reply

in M.A.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD

M.A. No. 386/2018 in O.A. St. 1620/2018

(Shri Ashok B. Sonwane V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri Prashant Kawde, learned Advocate

holding for Shri Y.V. Kakde, learned Advocate for the

applicant and Shri M.P. Gude, learned Presenting Officer

for respondents.


S.O. to 08.04.2019.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD

M.A. No. 480/2018 in O.A. St. No. 1939/2018

(Shri Paraji G. Jorule V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri S.D. Munde, learned Advocate for the

applicant, Shri N.U. Yadav, learned Presenting Officer for

respondent Nos. 1 to 3 and Shri R.M. Lone, learned

Advocate for respondent No. 4.

2. At the request of learned Presenting Officer, S.O. to.

02.04.2019 for filing affidavit in reply in M.A.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD

M.A. NO. 17/2019 in O.A. St. No. 55/2019

(Shri Natharao R. Dodabe V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri M.B. Bharaswadkar, learned Advocate for

the applicant and Shri S.K. Shirse, learned Presenting




in M.A.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD

M.A. NO. 18/2019 in O.A. St. No. 57/2019

(Shri Ankush L. Jadhav V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :


the applicant and Shri D.R. Patil, learned Presenting




in M.A.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD

M.A. NO. 19/2019 in O.A. St. No. 59/2019

(Shri Mohan F. Jadhav V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :


the applicant and Shri B.S. Deokar, learned Presenting




in M.A.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD

M.A. NO. 20/2019 in O.A. St. No. 61/2019

(Shri Mubasaroddin S. Siddiqui V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :


the applicant and Shri M.P. Gude, learned Presenting




in M.A.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD


(Shri Dilip K. Mankeshwar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Smt. Suchita A. Dhongde, learned Advocate for

the applicant, Smt. M.S. Patni, learned Presenting Officer

for respondent No. 1 and Shri Shamsundar B. Patil,

learned Advocate for respondent No. 2.

2. S.O. to 20.03.2019.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD


(Shri Namdeo P. Gawali V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

Shri Prashant Deshmukh, learned Advocate for the

applicant (Leave Note). Shri M.P. Gude, learned Presenting

Officer for respondents, present.

2. In view of leave note filed by the learned Advocate for

the applicant, S.O. to 08.04.2019.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD

M.A. No. 63/2019 in M.A. No. 61/2019 in O.A. St. No.219/2019 (Shri Chandrakant P. Patange V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)



DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri V.B. Wagh, learned Advocate for the

applicant and Shri B.S. Deokar, learned Presenting Officer

for respondents.

2. This is an application preferred by the applicants

seeking leave to sue jointly.

3. For the reasons stated in the application, and since

the cause and the prayers are identical and since the

applicants have prayed for same relief, and to avoid the

multiplicity, leave to sue jointly granted, subject to payment

of court fee stamps, if not paid.

4. Accompanying O.A. be registered and numbered,

after removal of office objections, if any. The present M.A.

stands disposed of accordingly without any order as to

costs.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD

M.A. No. 61/2019 in O.A. St. No.219/2019 (Shri Chandrakant P. Patange V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)



DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :


applicant and Shri B.S. Deokar, learned Presenting Officer

for respondents.

2. This is an application preferred by the applicants for

condonation of delay of about 180 days caused in filing

accompanying O.A.

3. For the reasons stated in the M.A., the same is

allowed and disposed of without any order as to costs. The

delay of about 180 days caused in filing accompanying O.A.

is hereby condoned.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD

ORIGINAL APPLICATION ST. NO. 219 OF 2019 (Shri Chandrakant P. Patange & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)


CORAM : JUSTICE A.H. JOSHI, CHAIRMAN. DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :


applicants and Shri B.S. Deokar, learned Presenting Officer

for respondents.


02.05.2019.








admission hearing.










//2// O.A. St. 219/2019





8. S.O. to 02.05.2019.




BENCH AT AURANGABAD


(Shri Ramniwas R. Khandelwal V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :


the applicant and Smt. Deepali S. Deshpande, learned



20.03.2019 for filing affidavit in reply.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD


(Shri Shivaji R. Tidke V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :


the applicant, Shri S.K. Shirse, learned Presenting Officer

for respondent Nos. 1 and 2 and Shri S.B. Mene, learned

Advocate for respondent No. 3.

2. Learned Presenting Officer prays for time on the

ground that respondent No. 2 shall look into the matter

and would study and decide the course of action before

next date. Time granted.

3. S.O. to 20.03.2019.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD


(Shri Sainath J. Korpakwad & Anr. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :


applicant and Shri S.B. Mene, learned Advocate for

respondent No. 1.

2. Learned Advocate Shri S.B. Mene has filed affidavit

in reply on behalf of respondent. Same is taken on record

and the copy thereof has been served on the other side.

3. S.O. to 02.04.2019.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD


(Dr. Usha N. Bholane V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

Shri K.A. Ingle, learned Advocate for the applicant

(Absent). Shri M.P. Gude, learned Presenting Officer for

respondent Nos. 1 to 4, present. Shri B.S. Deshmukh,

learned Advocate for respondent No. 5, absent.

2. As none present for the applicant, S.O. to

12.04.2019.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD


(Shri Rajaram S. Shendge V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri A.S. Deshmukh, learned Advocate for the

applicant and Shri S.K. Shirse, learned Presenting Officer

for respondents.


S.O. to 05.04.2019.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD

ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 216 OF 2019 (Shri Bharat Prabhakar Rathod V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)



DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :


applicant and Shri M.S. Mahajan, learned Chief


2. Learned Advocate for the applicant prays for leave to

amend the O.A.

3. Leave as prayed for is granted. The applicant shall

amend the O.A. forthwith.


20.03.2019.








admission hearing.





//2// O.A. No. 216/2019










10. Parties are put to notice that in case applicant is

relieved, in the event applicant succeeds applicant would be

restored the charge.

11. S.O. to 20.03.2019.




BENCH AT AURANGABAD


(Smt. Sulbha B. Khanale V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS


DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

1. Heard Shri Ajit Kadethankar, learned Advocate for

the applicant and Smt. Sanjivani K. Deshmukh-Ghate,

learned Presenting Officer for respondents.

2. Learned Presenting Officer has tendered purshis

dated 08.03.2019 as below :-

“ The R. No. 3 Deputy Director of Education, Aurangabad Division, Aurangabad submits that the orders and decisions cited at pages 45, 47, 53 and 54 of the present Original Application reducing pay scale of the Applicant and re-fixing the same at lower scale are withdrawn.

That the prayer clause „D‟ in the Original Application shall be complied and processed thereby granting 2nd benefit to the applicant under Assured Career Progress Scheme w.e.f. 9.11.2005 holding Applicant‟s 1st entitlement for higher pay scale w.e.f. 9.11.1993. Applicant‟s pay shall be fixed accordingly and the pension proposal be processed accordingly within three months from today. Hence, this purshis”

3. Learned Advocate for the applicant states that the

applicant is satisfied.

4. In view of the foregoing, the O.A. is disposed of in

terms of purshis quoted in foregoing paragraph No. 2.

5. There shall be no order as to costs.

CHAIRMAN



BENCH AT AURANGABAD

ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 129 OF 2019 (Shri Tejrao B. Gadekar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)


CORAM : JUSTICE A.H. JOSHI, CHAIRMAN. DATE : 08.03.2019.

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri S.B. Jadhav, learned Advocate for the

applicant and Shri M.S. Mahajan, learned Chief Presenting



20.03.2019.








admission hearing.










//2// O.A. No. 129/2019





8. S.O. to 20.03.2019.





ORIGINAL APPLICATION ST. NO.111/2019

(Kailas S. Mogale V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri Suresh D. Dhongde, learned Advocate

for the Applicant and Shri V.R. Bhumkar, learned

Presenting Officer for the Respondents.

2. Issue notice returnable on 15-04-2019.

3. Tribunal may take the case for final disposal at

once and separate notice for final disposal shall not be

issued.



authenticated by Registry, along with complete paper

book of the case. Respondents are put to notice that

the case would be taken up for final disposal at the

stage of admission hearing.

5. This intimation/notice is ordered under Rule 11

of the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal

(Procedure) Rules, 1988, and the questions such as

limitation and alternate remedy are kept open.


post, courier and acknowledgment be obtained

//2// O.A.St.No.111/19

and produced along with affidavit of compliance in

the Registry before due date. Applicant is directed to

file affidavit of compliance and notice.


service is not produced before 3 days of the next date,

case shall automatically stand dismissed without

further reference to the Tribunal.

8. In the meanwhile let the Divisional Commissioner

secure guidance from the Government about taking

review of suspension.

9. S.O. to 15.04.2019.

CHAIRMAN

SAS ORAL ORDER 08.03.2019




(Sudhir A. Khiradkar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri Vishwas B. Wagh, learned Advocate

for the Applicant and Shri M.S. Mahajan, learned

Chief Presenting Officer for the Respondents.




issued.













//2// O.A.No.201/19








8. Learned C.P.O. for the Respondents has

produced for perusal certain documents. It transpires

that Departmental Enquiry is contemplated against the

Applicant. In this background let these facts and

details come on record by way of affidavit. However it

is evident that prima-facie there exists ground for

transfer.

9. Hence, order of status-quo is vacated.

10. Issue of interim relief is still kept open.

11. S.O. to 22.03.2019.

CHAIRMAN




C.A.NO.43/2018 IN O.A.NO.838/2015

(Ramdas T. Patil V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri R.P. Bhumkar, learned Advocate for

the Applicant and Shri N.U. Yadav, learned Presenting

Officer for the Respondents.

2. At the request of the learned P.O. for the

Respondents, S.O. to 20.03.2019.

CHAIRMAN





(Ramdas T. Patil V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri R.P. Bhumkar, learned Advocate for




Respondents, S.O. to 20.03.2019.

CHAIRMAN





(Dilip B. Rajput V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri K.B. Jadhav, learned Advocate for the

Applicant and Shri M.S. Mahajan, learned Chief


2. Learned Advocate for the Applicant states that

the Respondents have granted the deemed date sought

for by Applicant and payment of arrears is pending.

3. It is hoped that remaining part of compliance

would be done expeditiously.

4. With foregoing observations, Original Application

is disposed of with no order as to costs.

CHAIRMAN




M.A.No.116/2018 IN O.A.ST.NO.443/2018

(Dagdu B. Raut V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Shri Anant D. Gadekar, learned Advocate for the

Applicant has filed a leave note.

Heard Shri N.U. Yadav, learned Presenting


2. In view of leave note of Advocate for the

Applicant, S.O. to 26.04.2019.

CHAIRMAN




M.A.No.43/2018 IN O.A.ST.NO.54/2018

(Gangadhar K. Salve V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :



Heard Shri M.P. Gude, learned Presenting Officer

for the Respondents.



CHAIRMAN




M.A.No.508/2017 IN O.A.ST.NO.1873/2017

(Vasant J. Joshi V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :



Heard Smt. M.S. Patni, learned Presenting Officer




CHAIRMAN




M.A.No.479/2017 IN O.A.ST.NO.1742/2017

(Gunabai M. Pethe V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :



Heard Shri D.R. Patil, learned Presenting Officer




CHAIRMAN




M.A.No.478/2017 IN O.A.ST.NO.1740/2017

(Bhimrao S. Ingle V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :



Heard Shri Sanjivani K. Deshmukh-Ghate,

learned Presenting Officer for the Respondents.



CHAIRMAN




M.A.No.477/2017 IN O.A.ST.NO.1736/2017

(Dagdu B. Raut V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :



Heard Smt. Deepali S. Deshpande, learned




CHAIRMAN




M.A.No.476/2017 IN O.A.ST.NO.1738/2017

(Maruti S. Tambe V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :



Heard Smt.M.S. Patni, learned Presenting Officer




CHAIRMAN




M.A.No.435/2017 IN O.A.ST.NO.1550/2017

(Bapurao S. Dumnar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :



Heard Shri D.R. Patil, learned Presenting Officer




CHAIRMAN




M.A.No.427/2017 IN O.A.ST.NO.1525/2017

(Rama N. Bhuktar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :



Heard Smt. Sanjivani K. Deshmukh-Ghate,




CHAIRMAN





(Madhukar K. Sapdhare V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri D.R. Irale Patil, learned Advocate for

the Applicant, Smt. Deepali S. Deshpande, learned

Presenting Officer for the Respondent Nos. 1 to 4 and

Shri S.B. Bhosale, learned Advocate for the

Respondent No.5.

2. At the request of learned P.O. for the

Respondents, S.O. to 11.04.2019 for filing affidavit in

reply.

CHAIRMAN





(Namdeo S. Rathod V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri A.P. Gunge, learned Advocate for the

Applicant and Smt. Priya R. Bharaswadkar, learned



Respondents, S.O. to 02.04.2019 for filing affidavit in

reply.

CHAIRMAN





(Shaikh Hakim Shaikh Abdulla V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri K.B. Jadhav, learned Advocate for the

Applicant and Shri M.P. Gude, learned Presenting




CHAIRMAN




M.A.NO.100/2019 in O.A.St.No.352/2019

(Vishal N. Jogdand V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri I.D. Maniyar, learned Advocate

holding for Shri Vilas S. Panpatte, learned Advocate for

the Applicant and Smt. Priya R. Bharaswadkar,


2. At the request of the learned Advocate for the


CHAIRMAN




M.A.NO.101/2019 in O.A.St.No.348/2019

(Devidas M. Chandane V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :



the Applicant and Smt. Deepali S. Deshpande, learned




CHAIRMAN




M.A.NO.102/2019 in O.A.St.No.356/2019

(Sham S. Thorat V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :



the Applicant and Shri D.R. Patil, learned Presenting




CHAIRMAN




M.A.NO.103/2019 in O.A.St.No.354/2019

(Amol S. Kamble V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :







CHAIRMAN




M.A.NO.104/2019 in O.A.St.No.350/2019

(Govind N. Londhe V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :



the Applicant and Smt. Sanjivai K. Deshmukh-Ghate,




CHAIRMAN





(Pradip S. Dhale V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Smt. Suchita A. Dhongde, learned

Advocate for the Applicant and Smt. Deepali S.

Deshpande, learned Presenting Officer for the

Respondents.


Respondents, S.O. to 20.03.2019 for filing affidavit-in-

reply.

CHAIRMAN




M.A.NO.437/2017 WITH M.A.St.No.1563/2017 in O.A.No.201/2006 (Govind D. Chavan V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri Ravindra B. Ade, learned Advocate for

the Applicant and Shri V.R. Bhumkar, learned




CHAIRMAN




M.A.NO.9/2018 in O.A.No.929/1999 (Narayan N. Wakchaure V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri S.N. Suryawanshi, learned Advocate

for the Applicant and Smt. M.S. Patni, learned




CHAIRMAN




ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.197/2019 (Vijaykumar P. Narwade V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri Vijaykumar P. Narwade, party in

person and Smt. Priya R. Bharaswadkar, learned


2. By consent adjourned to 22.03.2019.

CHAIRMAN




ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.765/2017 (Ravindra P. Patel V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Smt. S.A. Dhongde, learned Advocate for

the Applicant, Shri M.S. Patni, learned Presenting

Officer for the Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 and Shri S.B.

Mene, learned Advocate for the Respondent No.4.



CHAIRMAN




ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.764/2017 (Vijaykumar B. Raut V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Smt. Suchita A. Dhongde, learned

Advocate for the Applicant, Smt. M.S. Patni, learned

Presenting Officer for the Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 and

Shri S.B. Mene, learned Advocate for the Respondent

No.4.



CHAIRMAN




ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.576/2017 (Ulhas N. Suryawanshi V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Smt. S.A. Dhongde, learned Advocate for

the Applicant and Smt. Deepali S. Deshpande, learned



Respondents, S.O. to 20.03.2019 for filing affidavit-in-

reply.

CHAIRMAN




M.A.NO.111/2019 in O.A.NO.717/2018 (Vidya P. Shinde V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Smt. Amruta Paranjape-Menezes, learned

Advocate for the Applicant and Smt. Priya R.

Bharaswadkar, learned Presenting Officer for the

Respondents.

2. Learned Advocate for the Applicant prays for

leave to amend the memo. Leave as prayed for is

granted.

3. Amendment is carried out.

4. Accepting the reasons contained in M.A. to be

good and sufficient, Misc. Application for restoration is

allowed. O.A. be restored to its original stage.

CHAIRMAN




ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.717/2018 (Vidya P. Shinde V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Smt. Amruta Paranjape-Menezes, learned

Advocate for the Applicant and Smt. Priya R.


Respondents.




issued.













//2// O.A.No.717/18








8. S.O. to 28.03.2019.

CHAIRMAN




ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.276/2017 (Shri Prashant R. Bibrale V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri P.H. Sukale, learned Advocate holding

for Shri K.J. Suryawanshi, learned Advocate for the

Applicant and Shri B.S. Deokar, learned Presenting




CHAIRMAN




ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 215/2019

(Shahaji N. Narsude V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A)

DATE : 8.3.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri Ajay T. Kanwade, learned Advocate

for the applicant and Shri V.R. Bhumkar, learned


2. Issue notice to respondents, returnable on

27.4.2019.



issued.











::-2-::

O.A. NO. 215/2019










8. Interim relief granted in terms of prayer

clause (B) of the O.A. In the circumstances the

respondents are directed to take a decision on the

proposal dtd. 5.9.2018 forwarded by the res. no. 4

by the next date and submit compliance report in

that regard.

9. S.O. to 24.4.2019.

10. Steno copy and Hamdast is allowed to both

parties.

MEMBER (A) ARJ ORAL ORDERS 8-3-2019




(Balasaheb K. Jadhav V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

AND


(Rameshwar E. Chadidar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


DATE : 8.3.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri P.A. Kulkarni, learned Advocate for

the applicants in respective the cases and S/shri M.S.

Mahajan & N.U. Yadav, learned Chief Presenting

Officer / Presenting Officer for the respondents in

respective cases.

2. Learned C.P.O. / P.O. is directed to produce the

copy of G.R. of 2017 in which the G.A.D. has made a

essential condition of graduation for promotion from

Class-IV to Class-III post for proper adjudication of the

present case. In the circumstances, S.O. to 11.3.2019

for above compliance from the side of respondents.




C.P. 7/2019 IN O.A. 161/2017

(Dr. Saheb P. Kapure V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 8.3.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri V.G. Pingle, learned Advocate for the

applicant and Smt. Deepali S. Deshpande, learned

Presenting Officer for the respondent.

2. Issue notice to the respondent in the present

contempt petition, returnable on 18.4.2019.



issued.











::-2-::

CP 7/2019 IN

OA 161/2017










8. S.O. to 18.4.2019.


parties.




M.A. 113/2019 IN O.A. ST. 399/2019

(Maruti T. Kamble & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 8.3.2019

ORAL ORDER :


applicants and Smt. Priya R. Bharaswadkar, learned


2. This is an application preferred by the applicants

seeking leave to sue jointly.

3. For the reasons stated in the application, and

since the cause and the prayers are identical and since

the applicants have prayed for same relief, and to avoid

the multiplicity, leave to sue jointly granted, subject to

payment of court fee stamps, if not paid.

4. Accompanying O.A. be registered and numbered,

after removal of office objections, if any. The present

M.A. stands disposed of accordingly without any order

as to costs.

MEMBER (A)

ARJ ORAL ORDERS 8-3-2019



O.A. ST. 399/2019

(Maruti T. Kamble & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 8.3.2019

ORAL ORDER :


applicants and Smt. Priya R. Bharaswadkar, learned



22.4.2019.



issued.











::-2-::

O.A. St. NO. 399/2019










8. S.O. to 22.4.2019.


parties.





(Shamrao G. Wagatkar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 8.3.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Smt. Suchita Dhongde, learned Advocate

holding for Shri S.D. Dhongde, learned Advocate for

the applicant and Shri V.R. Bhumkar, learned


2. Learned P.O. submits that grant of selection

grade to the applicant is now finalized, though order in

that regard is yet to be passed. In the circumstances,

at the request of learned P.O., S.O. to 20.3.2019 for

placing on record copy of order granting selection

grade to the present applicant.

3. Steno copy allowed for the use of learned P.O.

MEMBER (A)




C.P. 6/2018 IN O.A. 166/2016

(Gautam P. Padghane & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 8.3.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri P.V. Suryawanshi, learned Advocate

for the applicant and Shri B.S. Deokar, learned


2. Learned P.O. files on record copy of

communication dtd. 7.3.2019 received to him from the

concerned respondent, which is taken on record and

marked as document ‘X’ for the purpose of

identification. He seeks time for reporting compliance

on the line of order dtd. 6.2.2019. At his request, S.O.

to 29.3.2019 for above compliance.

MEMBER (A)




T.A. 10/2018 (W.P. 1439/2018)

(Nirmala T. Ragh V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 8.3.2019

ORAL ORDER :

None appears for the applicant. Smt. Priya R.


respondents, is present.

2. At the request of learned P.O., S.O. to 18.4.2019

for filing affidavit in reply of the respondents.




M.A. 112/2019 IN O.A. 958/2018

(Ramprasad S. Lahoti V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 8.3.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri H.A. Joshi, learned Advocate for the



2. Present misc. application has been filed by the

applicant seeking leave of the Tribunal to amend the

O.A. as per draft amendment at Annex. A. 1 of M.A.

3. For the reasons stated in the present M.A. it is

allowed and disposed of without any order as to costs

and the applicant is permitted to amend O.A. as per

draft amendment at Annex. A. 1.

4. The O.A. be amended accordingly within a period

of one week and amended copy be supplied to the

learned C.P.O.




O.A. 958/2018

(Ramprasad S. Lahoti V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 8.3.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri H.A. Joshi, learned Advocate for the



2. At the request of learned C.P.O., S.O. to

29.3.2019 for filing affidavit in reply of the respondents

to the amended O.A..

MEMBER (A)





(Dr. Rekha G. Gaikwad V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 8.3.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri Shamsunder B. Patil, learned

Advocate for the applicant and Smt. Priya R.


respondents.


22.3.2019.



issued.











::-2-::

O.A. NO. 230/2019










8. S.O. to 22.3.2019.

9. Applicant is at liberty to ask for circulation for

considering the case for grant of interim relief, if such

an exigency arises in the meanwhile.


parties.





(Dr. Shankarrao B. Wadikar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 8.3.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri J.S. Deshmukh, learned Advocate for

the applicant and Shri M.S. Mahajan, learned Chief

Presenting Officer for the respondent nos. 1 to 3.

2. Today Shri Ashish Shinde, learned Advocate

appears and files his V.P. for res. no. 4. He seeks time

to file affidavit in reply of res. no. 4.

3. Learned C.P.O. also seeks time to file affidavit in

reply of res. nos. 1 to 3.

4. In the circumstances, S.O. to 12.3.2019 for filing

affidavit in reply of all the respondents.





(Vinod S. Muley V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 8.3.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri M.B. Bharaswadkar, learned

Advocate for the applicant and Shri M.S. Mahajan,

learned Chief Presenting Officer for the respondents.

2. Learned C.P.O., on instructions from Shri (Dr.)

Aakash Ashokrao Deshmukh, Dist. Malaria Officer,

Nanded, who is present in the court hall, submits that

pension / provisional pension of the applicant will be

released positively, within next 15 days. The said

statement is accepted and taken on record. Only on

this assurance, the present case is adjourned to

10.4.2019.

3. In the circumstances, S.O. to 10.4.2019 for filing

affidavit of compliance and also written apology. The

point of imposition of costs is kept open.

4. Steno copy allowed for the use of learned C.P.O.





(Shri Vyankat S. More & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 8.3.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri T.B. Bhosale, learned Advocate for the

applicants and Shri S.K. Shirse, learned Presenting


2. With the consent of both the sides, S.O. to

22.3.2019.

CHAIRMAN ARJ ORAL ORDERS 8-3-2019




(Shri Baban D. Gadekar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 8.3.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri P.P. Deshmukh, learned Advocate

holding for Shri V.M. Maney, learned Advocate for the

applicant and Shri S.K. Shirse, learned Presenting








(Shri Pandurang R. Chinchoale V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 8.3.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri A.S. Deshmukh, learned Advocate for

the applicant, Shri N.U. Yadav, learned Presenting

Officer for the respondent nos. 1 & 4 and Shri D.T.

Devane, learned Advocate for respondent nos. 2 & 3.







(Shri Bhagwat T. Kadam V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 8.3.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri K.G. Salunke, learned Advocate for

the applicant and Shri B.S. Deokar, learned Presenting







ORIGINAL APPLICATION NOS. 476, 477, 478 & 485/2017

(Shri Balasaheb M. Ghadge & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 8.3.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri Sanjay A. Wakure, learned Advocate

for the applicants in all these cases and Smt. Deepali

S. Deshpande, Smt. Sanjivani Deshmukh Ghate, Smt.

M.S. Patni and Shri D.R. Patil, learned Presenting

Officers for the respective respondents in respective

cases.

2. With the consent of both the sides, S.O. to

11.4.2019.





(Shri Bansilal Chiranjilal Jaiswal V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 8.3.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri Ashok D. Raut, learned Advocate for

the applicant, Smt. M.S. Patni, learned Presenting

Officer for the respondent nos. 1 & 2 and Ms. Rebekah

Daniel, learned Advocate holding for Shri S.B. Talekar,

learned Advocate for respondent no. 3.

2. Learned Advocate for the res. no. 3 has tendered

short additional affidavit. It is taken on record with

copy thereof to other sides.

3. Learned Advocate for the applicant has also

tendered certain documents and those are also taken

on record.

4. In the circumstances, the matter is closed for

orders.




ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.247/2017 (Dr. Mohammed Fazalul Haq V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



DATE : 08.03.2019

ORAL ORDER :

Heard Shri Asif Ali, learned Advocate for the

Applicant and Shri M.P. Gude, learned Presenting

Officer for the Respondent Nos. 1 to 6. Shri Sachin

Deshmukh, learned Advocate for the Respondent No. 7

is absent.

2. Dr. (Shri) Anup Kumar Yadav, (IAS), Director of

Health Services, Mumbai, is present. He has tendered

explanation and apology. Explanation and apology is

accepted and show cause notice issued to Dr. (Shri)

Anup Kumar Yadav, (IAS), Director of Health Services,

Mumbai, is recalled and dropped.

3. S.O. to 22.03.2019.

CHAIRMAN


Date post:	17-Jul-2020
Category:	Documents
Upload:	others
View:	1 times
Download:	0 times

FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA …M.S. Mumbai is directed as follows: (a) Call for and...

Documents