Date post: | 31-Dec-2015 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | hanae-french |
View: | 21 times |
Download: | 0 times |
Farmer Preference for CAPS Workshop and Analysis
January 2012
Brinton Foy ReedDr. Catherine Chan-Halbrendt
Natural Resources and Environmental
Management
Presentation Outline
I. Introduction to analytic hierarchy process
II. Goal, objectives, and CAPS
III. Survey instructions
IV. Survey
V. Discussion of Results
What is analytic hierarchy process (AHP)?• A multi-criteria, multi-level decision-making method• Breaks down complex decisions into a series of simple questions reflecting an optimal goal,
objectives, and various options • Provides a structured technique for organizing and analyzing differing preferences for CAPS
options
I. Introduction to analytic hierarchy process
AHP HierarchyImproved Income
Profit Labor Saving Yield Soil Quality
GOAL:
OBJECTIVES:
FP(Full Till, Millet)
CAPS 1(Full Till, Cowpea)
CAPS 2(Full Till, Millet/Cowpea
Intercrop)
CAPS 3(Strip Tillage,
Millet/Cowpea Intercrop)
OPTIONS:
II. Goal, objectives, and CAPS
• GOAL: Improved Income
• OBJECTIVES:• Profit
• Labor Saving
• Yield
• Soil Quality
• CAPS –Maize Based Systems• FP(Full Till / Millet), CAPS 1(Full Till / Cowpea), CAPS
2(Full Till / CP+M), CAPS 3(Strip Till / CP+M)
For each comparison, we will follow two steps:1. State which element is most important or
preferred to meeting the goal or objective2. Show the level of importance or preference
compared to the other option using the scale and candies provided.
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
Scale of Importance
III. Survey instructions
1. For the goal or objective presented, tell your recorder which option you feel is best for meeting the goal or objective.
Which CAPS are more important to meeting the goal of increased Profit?
For example…
FP OR CAPS 2
2. Using the scale and the candies provided, show how much more important the best option is compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
Which objective is more important to meeting the goal of Improved Income?
O1: Increased Profit OR O2: Increased Labor Saving
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
• How much more important is the objective you chose compared to the other?
Which objective is more important to meeting the goal of Improved Income?
01: Increased Profit OR 03: Increased Yield
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
• How much more important is the objective you chose compared to the other?
Which objective is more important to meeting the goal of Improved Income?
01: Increased Profit
OR 04: Improved Soil Quality
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
• How much more important is the objective you chose compared to the other?
Which objective is more important to meeting the goal of Improved Income?
02: Increased Labor Saving
OR 03: Increased Yield
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
• How much more important is the objective you chose compared to the other?
Which objective is more important to meeting the goal of Improved Income?
02: Increased Labor Saving
OR 04: Improved Soil Quality
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
• How much more important is the objective you chose compared to the other?
Which objective is more important to meeting the goal of Improved Income?
03: Increased Yield OR 04: Improved Soil Quality
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
• How much more important is the objective you chose compared to the other?
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of increased Profit?
FP(Full Till / Millet)
OR
CAPS 1(Full Till / Cowpea)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of increased Profit?
FP(Full Till / Millet)
OR
CAPS 2(Full Till / Millet-Cowpea Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of increased Profit?
FP(Full Till / Millet)
OR
CAPS 3(Strip Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of increased Profit?
CAPS 1(Full Till / Cowpea)
OR
CAPS 2(Full Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of increased Profit?
CAPS 1(Full Till / Cowpea)
OR
CAPS 3(Strip Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the goal of increased Profit?
CAPS 2(Full Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
OR
CAPS 3(Strip Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of increased Labor Saving?
FP(Full Till / Millet)
OR
CAPS 1(Full Till / Cowpea)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of increased Labor Saving?
FP(Full Till / Millet)
OR
CAPS 2(Full Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of increased Labor Saving?
FP(Full Till / Millet)
OR
CAPS 3(Strip Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of increased Labor Saving?
CAPS 1(Full Tillage / Cowpea)
OR
CAPS 2(Full Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of increased Labor Saving?
CAPS 1(Full Till / Cowpea)
OR
CAPS 3(Strip Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of increased Labor Saving?
CAPS 2(Full Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
OR
CAPS 3(Strip Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of increased Yield?FP
(Full Till / Millage)
OR
CAPS 1(Full Till / Cowpea)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of increased Yield?
FP(Full Till / Millet)
OR
CAPS 2(Full Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of increased Yield?
FP(Full Till / Millet)
OR
CAPS 3(Strip Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of increased Yield?
CAPS 1(Full Till / Cowpea)
OR
CAPS 2(Full Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of increased Yield?
CAPS 1(Full Tillage / Cowpea)
OR
CAPS 3(Strip Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of increased Yield?
CAPS 2(Full Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
OR
CAPS 3(Strip Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of improved Soil Quality?
FP(Full Till / Millet)
OR
CAPS 1(Full Till / Cowpea)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of improved Soil Quality?
FP(Full Till / Millet)
OR
CAPS 2(Full Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of improved Soil Quality?
FP(Full Till / Millet)
OR
CAPS 3(Strip Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of improved Soil Quality?
CAPS 1(Full Till / Cowpea)
OR
CAPS 2(Full Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of improved Soil Quality?
CAPS 1(Full Till / Cowpea)
OR
CAPS 3(Strip Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5
Which CAPS is preferred to meeting the objective of improved Soil Quality?CAPS 2
(Full Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
OR
CAPS 3(Strip Till / Cowpea-Millet Intercrop)
• How much more important is the CAPS you chose compared to the other?
Equal Moderate Strong Very Strong Extreme
1
2
3
4
5