+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some...

Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some...

Date post: 05-Jul-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
44
Transcript
Page 1: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

University of Applied Sciences and Arts Dortmund

Faculty of Applied Social Studies

Final Report

A practical term in Orissa, India

Nicole Suchanek

April 4, 2009

Supervisor: Prof. Dr. Evemarie Knust-Potter

Winterterm 2007/ 2008

Page 2: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

Contents

1 Introduction 4

2 Destination: India 5

2.1 Facts about Orissa . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5

2.2 The journey to India . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6

2.3 The living situation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6

3 Chetana Institute for the Mentally Handicapped 8

3.1 The school . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8

3.2 Daily schedule . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9

3.3 Intended duties within the institution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9

3.4 Working experience at Chetana . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10

3.5 Review of the work at Chetana . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11

3.5.1 Facing problems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11

3.5.2 Language barrier . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12

3.5.3 Health care of children . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12

3.5.4 Positive aspects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13

3.5.5 Achievements after the internship . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13

3.5.6 General conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14

4 Working at NYSASDRI 15

4.1 General information about NYSASDRI . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15

4.2 Working experience . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15

4.3 Review . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16

5 Bakul Foundation 17

5.1 Bakul Foundation- A small introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17

5.2 Working duties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18

5.3 Working at Bakul . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19

2

Page 3: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

5.4 Review of the work at Bakul . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21

5.4.1 Exploitation of the library . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21

5.4.2 Childrens Theater Workshop . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21

5.4.3 Teaching English to the Khelaghara School Children . . . . . . . 22

5.4.4 Mobilizing volunteers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23

6 General Conclusion 25

I Pictures, Articles and Information 27

A Pictures of Chetana Institute 28

B Pictures of NYSASDRI 31

C Pictures of Bakul 33

D Criticism, Articles etc. 37

D.1 Criticism on the musical production . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37

D.1.1 Mail of 15 January 2008: Some criticism of Bakul . . . . . . . . . 37

D.1.2 Mail of 16 January 2008: Re: [Bakul] Some Criticism of Bakul . 41

D.1.3 Article in: The Telegraph, Calcutta, India . . . . . . . . . . . . . 43

E Map of Orissa 44

F Collection of websites related to in the report 44

3

Page 4: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

1 Introduction

The following paper is the �nal report of my practical term in 2007/2008 in India. The

duration was from Sep 17th 2007 till Feb 3rd 2008. While I stayed in India I spent

most of my time with two di�erent non-pro�t organizations based in Bhubaneswar, the

capital city of Orissa.

In the beginning of this report you will �nd some information about the state of

Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working and living circumstances in the

area. Adjacent there will be a discription of Chetana, a school for mentally challenged

children. In that school I spend about 2 months of my internship. A re�exion of the

work at Chetana will complete that chapter.

A short period I spent with an organization called Nysasdri to have an excursion to

di�erent �elds of social work in Orissa. Few information will be given about that period,

including a review.

After all, the focus lies mainly on an organization named Bakul Foundation. I

spend two and a half months with that organization and take it as the core part of my

working experiences.

An overall review of the practical semester is given in the end of this assignment.

Unlike most other reports, you will also �nd a section about living in India and how I

got my job. I think the living experience is a fundamental part in this practical semester

and must not be ignored.

In the appendix you will �nd all weekly reports for a further insight knowledge con-

cerning the work. Also an excerpt of newspaper articles, pictures and criticisms is

attached.

4

Page 5: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

2 Destination: India

As you know, my whole internship took place in India. I experienced it as a very

di�erent country, not only regarding culture and climate. Therefore I will give you a short

introduction to the state of Orissa, which is very unlike other Indian states. Subsequently

you may �nd a brief summary of how I found my placement in Bhubaneswar and how

things got started.

2.1 Facts about Orissa

Since my work was placed in Orissa, here are some information about the state.

Orissa is placed in the East of Central India with its capital Bhubaneswar. The main

spoken language is Oriya. It had a population of 36,804,660 in 20011 and still growing,

more than 1 million people live in Bhubaneswar today. �Out of the total population,

85.01% live in rural areas and depends mostly on agriculture for their livelihood. Urban

population constitutes 14.99%.�2

But despite �being endowed with vast natural resources such as long coastal line,

fertile green coastal plains, rivers, forest resources, and mineral resources such as iron

ore, bauxite ore, limestone, the state continues to be a backward state. A comparative

analysis of interstate poverty ratio shows that 47.2 per cent of the state's population lives

below the poverty line in 2001-02�.3 Malnutrition of children is one big issue amongst

others in Orissa. More than 50% of all children below the age of 3 are underweight.4The

illiteracy rate in Orissa is one of the highest in the country, especially amongst female.

Only 64% of the population are literate in 2001.5

Nevertheless Orissa has more to o�er. Such as a beautiful landside with hills and

forests, three main temple cities of the hindu religion and a rich culture. Also �Orissa

1[6]http://www.orissa.gov.in/health_portal/healthpro�le/demography.html, 14 October 2008.2[6]ibid.3[3]Jena; Rath, 2006.4[7]http://122.160.10.83/unicef_website/Mapping%20Indias%20Children/, 28.Jul 2008.5[1]Census of India, 2001.

5

Page 6: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

has 62 distinct tribal groups,making it the largest collection of tribal people in a single

state in the country.�6

This description should be a good enough survey of circumstances as a preparation

for the following report.

2.2 The journey to India

This is a brief summary of how I was placed.

In 2006, an Indian professor, called Dr. Pati came to our university. He gave a lecture

about his organization, back in Bhubaneswar. This story was very inspiring for me.

As soon as I had a chance, I would ask Dr. Pati and his wife, if it was possible to

have an internship at their school for mentally challenged children. Both of them were

enthusiastic about me coming to Orissa. Subsequently, one year later, I met them both

at the university again and settled things for visiting India four months later.

While I planned my trip to India, I found three other people joining, to explore that

fascinating country. One of them was from my faculty, another a physiotherapist and

the third one just �nished high school in Germany. Except for the physiotherapist all of

us would share a room in a hostel at Chetana. Hence I was living at my workplace.

The secretary of that institution was responsible for me while I stayed there and with

him I made all arrangements before I left for Bhubaneswar. Our agreement was that I

would visit three di�erent organizations during my stay to have best practice experience

in di�erent institutions. Narayan, the secretary, as far as I knew was in contact with

the other organizations. This fact made me conclude that things were settled.

On the 15th September in 2007 my friends and me reached the place and we got

welcomed by all students of the school. Since it was a special holiday, they started

with a pooja, which is the hindu way to worship god. We took some lunch with the

authorities before we got to our room.

Two days later I was about to start my work at the school, like you will acknowledge

in the next chapter.

2.3 The living situation

This paraghraph gives you a small idea about my placement in Bhubaneswar.

6[5]http://www.indiaplaces.com/india-states/orissa.html, 28. Jul 2008.

6

Page 7: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

The living situation in Bhubaneswar was such that I shared a room with two other

German interns. We had an own bathroom attached to our room. Luckily the hosting

organization provided this room for us, free of cost. The building complex we were

placed in had a hostel for about 150 people. Since we did not have a kitchen in our

room, we could eat in the dining hall of the students hostel. Lunch and dinner were

served for about 0,25¿ each. I took my breakfast in our room.

As the food in the hostel was not very various (though tasty), due to the low price, I

did not take both meals everyday in the hostel. Also the times were �xed. Depending

on my work schedule I could not attend dinner. In that case it was easy to eat in the

surrounding area.

Living costs in India are mostly lower than in Germany. But this only applies, if one

can reduce the living standards in certain ways (e.g. in general in Orissa you will not

�nd wallpaper, heater, often no glass windows or toilet paper, which cannot be �ushed

in many toilets).

In Bhubaneswar itself the public transport system is not very good. Due to that the

community found a way to provide public transport with shared auto rickshaws. Those

autorickshaws would always drive on the same street. On all junctions the rickshaw can

be switched, so that every place can be reached. This system works very well and is

comparatively cheap.

The access to the internet is very limited in many cases. In our building we did not

have internet connection. Hence we had to use internet cafes in a 15 min. walk distance.

This was no problem as long as it was not dark outside one could go alone. If it is dark

already it is not very safe to be by yourself as a woman. In that case we mostly walked

at least with two people.

Food is also easy available in many local markets. Especially the vegetables and fruits

are fresh and can be bought at many places. Since many people do not have a car, small

markets come up more frequent on the streets.

I would consider those aspects as the main issues of my placement in Bhubaneswar.

7

Page 8: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

3 Chetana Institute for the Mentally

Handicapped

This chapter deals with the main features of one of the biggest schools for mentally

handicapped children in Orissa. After a description of the institution, I explain my

work duties and give a re�exion.

3.1 The school

Chetana is a school, including a hostel, for mentally challenged children from all over

Orissa. It is situated in Bhubaneswar. In 2007 about 75 students are enrolled, of

which approximately 17 are female (number of enrolled students is changing). All of

those students stay at the school and most of them visit their parents during summer

vacation.

Mostly the school has �ve di�erent classes such as: Primary, Secondary, Vocational

I, Vocational II and the Girls Class. School hours are from 10.00-17.00h, Mondays till

Saturdays, including lunch break of one hour.

Each class has about 12 students and almost every class has one teacher and an

assistant teacher. But in the girls class for instance is no teacher but a female care taker

to teach the students.

My work was in Primary Class, therefore I will make some more depictions about this

particular class.

The primary class had 12 male students with the average age of 8 years. One teacher

was in charge of the curriculum and one assistant teacher helped to take care of the

students. In the afternoon, one caretaker would most probably come over to do some

cultural program with the children. To take part in the daily process, every other day

students from local colleges came to the class for an internship at the institution.

The disabilities among the children in Primary Class are as follows: Two of the boys

had autism spectrum disorders and four boys were born with downsyndrom. Most other

8

Page 9: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

boys had mental retardation in di�erent severities.1 Additional to the disabilities most

children su�ered from scabies and all of them had lice. This fact also had an in�uence

on their learning impact.

But Chetana is not only a school for mentally challenged children, but a college for

special education. That way more than 100 students from Orissa come there to become

special educators. Regarding the principal, this is the only college for special education

in Orissa.

3.2 Daily schedule

When the children came to school in the morning, they assembled in the yard and

did some prayer, before they proceeded to their classrooms. In general the day would

start with either grooming (e.g. combing hair, oiling, applying powder) or some yoga

exercises. One particular boy would show the exercises to the other students.

After some time the assistant teacher might give exercisebooks to some of the students

to do writing exercises, such as writing their names. The other children, which would

not get an assignment, would wait in the back of the classroom. About one hour or half

an hour before lunch, everyone would store their papers away and sit down to wait for

lunch.

Lunch brake is from 1PM till 2PM. During that time, the students get lunch on the

upper �oor of the hostel building and all college students can go to the dining hall.

After lunch brake some students would be allowed to play a board game, called Car-

rom. The others sit in the back of the classroom and watch the games. Mostly one

of the care takers would visit the classroom one or two hours after lunchbrake. Then

she would do some Indian dancing with the children, play some music or sing songs.

Eventually at around 4.45PM the children would leave school and go back to the hostel.

3.3 Intended duties within the institution

When I came to Chetana �rst, the principal had a short talk with me and on my �rst

working day I got introduced to Mrs. Sabita, who is the teacher of Primary class. On

the 17th September I started my work. It was said that I should do individual training

with 6 boys of the class. First I should do some assessment to �nd about about their

mental age and intelligence quotient. Then I would have to decide which individual

1see pictures of the children in appendix A on page 28

9

Page 10: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

training is best for them. Generally it would be a three months teaching plan with short

term and long term goals. Three months later one would have to do another assessment

and check if the child has made the planned progress. After consulting Mrs. Sabita, I

would start with my teaching plan.

Considering my work experience in theater pedagogics, the secretary of Chetana sug-

gested me to start a little play with some children for the annual day of the school.

Those were supposed to be the main aspects of my work at Chetana. In the following

section you will �nd a summary of my working experience. For more details see the

weekly reports in the appendix.

3.4 Working experience at Chetana

When I came to school that Monday morning, I got introduced to Mrs. Sabita, my

supervisor while I worked at Chetana. On that day and on many following days I was

observing the children. The main exercise was writing names in exercisebooks. In the

afternoon mostly we spend time with traditional Indian dance.

In the second week I got an assessment sheet for mentally handicapped children. In

the end of the week I was doing this assessment with Ashok. He was my focus child with

whom I would do the individual training. On some days I got help from other college

students, because I was not able to ask questions in Oriya myself to �nish the test. The

students helped me to translate the questions for Ashok.

Eventually in the third week I was able to start the individual training with Ashok.

In the fourth and �fth week I was working for NYSASDRI. That part will just be left

out for now and covered in the next chapter.

When I got back to the classroom after my excursion trip, some things had changed

at Chetana. For example children did not get beaten anymore (at least while I was

around). To take a bit more action I tried di�erent things now. Therefore one afternoon

I brought balloons for all children and they could play and learn about colours and how a

balloon �ies etc. On this afternoon the teacher was also in the classroom (in the reports

you will read that she could not be there most of the time) and supported me with my

little afternoon exercise.

The next few weeks I mostly concentrated on writing exercises with the children and

doing little assignments if no teacher came to the classroom. Eventually the scabies

in�uenced the children a lot during this period. They had open wounds and were

scratching their skin. The itching skin and wounds made it very hard for them to

10

Page 11: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

concentrate on exercises. Nevertheless I proceeded in the individual training with Ashok.

Overall we would practice for few minutes every day. Ashok could not concentrate for

more than few minutes. Then he would need a break.

Sometimes I would visit the other classrooms to see, what they were doing. One day

I could also witness how a �lm about Chetana got shot. That gave me the opportunity

of experiencing di�erent ways of vocational training, too.

During week 9 I decided to look for a new job and eventually found something. I

wanted to collect some other working experiences.

3.5 Review of the work at Chetana

In total I can say that I did learn certain things at Chetana, but I did not learn as much

as I wanted to. That is why I �nally decided to look for another organization to join.

Here I will give you an impression of my main issues.

3.5.1 Facing problems

When I �rst came to the school I had to observe the children for many days, till I could

do anything else. I realized that one has to be very patient in a country like India.

Furthermore I was not sure, if it is appropriate to bother people with what you want

or not. I asked the teacher about the assessment sheet for Ashok many times. At that

place it is a big deal, to take a paper out of the locker.

The biggest challenge for me though, was that very few things happened most of

the time. Even though most of the reports I have written describe things which have

happened, it does not mean that it endured during most of the time. Indians have a

di�erent perception of time, but time was very precious for me, because I knew I would

be around only for a limited period.

A lot of time was spend only with waiting. Either for lunch or for the end of the

school hours. Sometimes the children would have to sit for more than an hour. If they

fell asleep, because they got bored, they would be beaten to wake up and sit straight.

Till date this does not make much sense to me and I cannot understand the approach

of this. For some time I thought it was only me thinking that very less happened. But

when I talked to the other college students, I realized that they were feeling the same

way. I do not have a real answer on how to change those things, on how to activate

teachers to do more lessons. Especially with every child and not only few of them.

11

Page 12: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

Sometimes Rebecca, who was also working there, and me, we tried to do some exercises

if no teacher was there. But as soon as the assistant teacher entered the room, everyone

had to take seats again and wait.

I always thought it would be easier to change such conditions but I was proved wrong.

Chetana has a special system, working like this for many years. It is not enough just to

go up to people and talk to them to change their behaviour. And then also I ask myself,

if my way of handling situations is the right solution. Moreover my approach was not,

to change the world, but to learn from it and help to develop new methods of resolution.

At that point I might have been too overwhelmed by things to know what to do and put

it into action. So probably it is better to be much more aware of issues like a di�erent

perception of time, before going to another country. Even though I considered myself

being prepared well enough, it shows me that you can still undergo big surprises. And

funnily I expected a di�erent handling of time in India, but I never expected it to be

this di�erent.

3.5.2 Language barrier

Another problem I was facing, was the language barrier. Before I came to India I was

aware of the fact that not everyone would speak English. But I never imagined that very

few sta� members in the school would be able to talk to me. It made me sad at some

point, because I would have liked to get to know the local people better. I think that

if you speak the local language, people will receive you very di�erent and you can get

involved much more. But the way it was, I had hard times �nding someone to translate

even little words for me. It made the work very di�cult sometimes. That way for the

next time I would at least try to take a Hindi crash course which allows the people at

least to understand me, even though they might not speak Hindi themselves (many do

though). It is almost impossible to take Oriya classes in Germany.

3.5.3 Health care of children

Something I really would like to refer to, is the health condition of the children. It

shocks me till date that the children sometimes get very bad medical treatment, even

for diseases which can be cured easily and with government funding. Out of the 75

children at the school more than 50 had scabies. �Human scabies is an intensely pruritic

skin infestation caused by the host-speci�c mite.�2 Scabies is contagious in case of close

2[2]Cordoro, 2008.

12

Page 13: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

contact and can lead to secondary bacterial invasion, sepsis, rheumatic fever and other

preexisting dermatoses.3

First I did not know what this disease, the children had, was. I only saw them

scratching their skin all the time. Eventually I found out that it was scabies and I was

very surprised nobody did anything to heal it. After I asked few people about it, I got

to know that some teachers wanted to take the children to the doctor, but the principal

gave no permission. One day I even had a talk with the principal and she told me that

she does not want to support allopathic medicine and tries to cure the scabies with

homeopathic medicine. At the same time she told me, someone would be interested in

taking the children to the doctor and if that person paid himself, that would be �ne

with her.

What has happened was that the teachers collected money and we took all infected

children to the doctor on the next day. But this e�ort could not remedy the disease. It

occurs from unhygienic living-circumstances and in the hostel there was not even any

soap for the children available. This made things very complicated and later on I decided

to buy soap and laundry detergent for the hostel. But still this is no sustainable solution

to the problem and till date I do not know how to convince people of certain things such

as treating scabies.

3.5.4 Positive aspects

Something which is very important for me to relate to is my relationship to the children.

Actually this is what made it hard for me at �rst to decide to work somewhere else. They

bring a lot of happiness, which makes my day. I think we had a very good relationship

and the children felt safe around me. We had great moments and played together. After

I left I assessed this as the main bene�t for the children. Even though I probably could

not teach them much, they could share nice moments and keep them in a good memory.

I hope it gives them faith and strength in the future.

3.5.5 Achievements after the internship

After I started my work at Bakul, I would still go to the classroom sometimes and spend

some time with the children. I was able to get some funds from Germany to buy soap

for several months, laundry detergent, new T-Shirts, teaching materials, etc.

3ibid.

13

Page 14: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

This could improve the work in the classroom a lot, because now there were enough

materials available to teach every child. Earlier it was troublesome to ask the authorities

for paper or pencils for the students. In general the school was not willing to give out

teaching materials. Now they could at least each have their own exercisebook to write

into.

Even though this is no longterm solution, I think it is better than no solution at all.

Only for the future I wish to �nd a better approach for sustainable support.

3.5.6 General conclusion

Generally speaking I would say that it was good to understand such an institution and

its problems in a developing country. Also it was good to collect positive and negative

experiences. At the same time I am glad that I decided to collect di�erent experiences

somewhere else, too. Otherwise my comprehension of India might have been very partial

today.

14

Page 15: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

4 Working at NYSASDRI

Since I did not spend much time with NYSASDRI, I will just give a small introduction

about the organization, before I describe my experiences.

4.1 General information about NYSASDRI

Nysasdri was established in the 1980s and means National Youth Service Action and

Social Development Research Institute. Since the inception NYASDRI was working in

several �elds of social work such as education, disabilites, health care, old age etc. 1 At

the moment the main focus is on eyecare and health.

A special eye hospital (Kalinga Eye Hospital and Research Center) is based in Dhenkanal,

a small town in the west of Bhubaneswar. It makes eyecare more accessible to those

who live in remote areas around Dhenkanal district. Patients can go for checkup to

the hospital right away and get treated. Also they can visit an eyecamp in the villages

(especially for cataract patients) and get diagnosis. If they have cataract, they will be

taken to the hospital, get surgery and be brought back to their homes on the next day.

This service is free of cost for those, who cannot a�ord any treatment.

In the sector of health care, NYSASDRI tries to emend the situation of two primary

health care centers through public private partnership (PPP). This PPP means it is a

corporation of the government of Orissa and local NGO's for the bene�t of the residents

in the concerned areas.

4.2 Working experience

While I stayed with this NGO for about two weeks, I had the advantage of joining three

di�erent areas such as the work in the main o�ce, the eye hospital and the headquarters

for some workshop.

1see: www.nysasdri.org/program.html, 30 Jul 2008.

15

Page 16: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

When I �rst joined, I got introduced to the work of NYSASDRI. For a few days I got

to read reports of other interns and �nd out more about publications and researches.

Also I helped with developing the website of NYSASDRI. In the same week, together

with my friend, I went to visit the eye hospital in Dhenkanal.2 It lies about about 3

hours away from Bhubaneswar. The next two days I was exploring the hospital. After

that observation I joined some sta� members on an eye camp.3 This eye camp was in a

village in Dhenkanal district. The eye hospital has an own bus to take the sta� members

and patients across the area. Hence we went to the village and did small checkups on the

patients. Those who had cataract, we took to Kalinga Eye Hospital to provide surgery

on the next day.4

After that trip, my friend and I went further, to the headquarters of NYSASDRI, in a

small village called Santhasara. There we attended a three days workshop on advocacy.

Additional to that I stayed for another program on gender equality, before I went back

to Bhubaneswar.

4.3 Review

During my two weeks with NYSASDRI I had the chance to get a wider image of Orissa.

It was very interesting for me, to visit a small town, Dhenkanal, and even a village (for

the eye camp). Those places were much di�erent from Bhubaneswar and gave me a

greater impression of life in Orissa. At the same time it was enriching to have di�erent

experiences like o�ce work, �eld work and a workshop.

Although I think if I had spend more time with NYSASDRI, I would have been bored.

Especially in the eye hospital. After all I was not allowed to do any nurse jobs and I

could mostly only observe what was happening. That was good enough for the time I

spend there.

2see map in the appendix E on page 443see appendix ?? on page ??4see pictures in appendix B on page 32

16

Page 17: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

5 Bakul Foundation

Like mentioned earlier, I consider the work with Bakul foundation, as the main part of

my internship. Not only because I spend most of my time with this organization, but

also because it gave me most opportunities to develop my skills. Initially I will describe

the small organization, before I proceed with my work duties, the work I did and the

review. In this paper I will only refer to my responsibilities linked to social work, though

In the appendix you will �nd di�erent newspaper articles and emails from the members

of Bakul Foundation. The online discussion group is very important and till date we

(Bakul members) exchange our ideas and information in this group.

5.1 Bakul Foundation- A small introduction

Bakul foundation was launched in 2006 to promote volunteerism and pull together indi-

vidual contributions for community development.1 It is a young non-pro�t organization

to mobilize people who are interested in social change. It started o� with a pledge cam-

paign2 to collect at least 1,000 individual contributions to set up a library. Finally the

inauguration of this library happened on April 1st 2007. The library is open everyday

from 2PM-9 PM. It is free of cost for everyone and open to any group. Till date it

consists of three rooms. When you enter you will �nd a computer room on the left hand

side. Further a room looking like a jungle, keeps books for reading beginners3 and the

last room contains literature for advanced readers and a screen for presentations and

�lm screenings. Bakul does not have tables or chairs in the reading rooms. Mats are

lying on the �oor. That way an open space is provided and everyone can move freely

and has access to every side in the room.

Since the inauguration di�erent activities got launched by Bakul Foundation. One

big e�ort was putting up a library booth with books and activities about reading on

an exhibition ground for the National Children's Day on November 14th-15th. For the

1see article at http://www.indiatogether.org/2008/jan/edu-bakul.htm2visit: http://www.pledgebank.com/Bakul-Library3see picture in the appendix C.1 on page 34

17

Page 18: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

same event 14 local schools from Bhubaneswar did a wall painting in front of Bakul

Children's Library.4 In the end of the same year a �lm festival on contemporary art has

happened in the backyard of the library. In 2008 Bakul started o� with a talk of the

American Professor Ellen Handler Spitz entitled `The impact of imagery in picture books

for young children', followed by a children's musical in the same month. Furthermore

several workshops such as art for children and a leadership workshop for youths take

place at the library.

One could say that the members of Bakul are sparkling with motivation and gather

people together from all over the place to achieve a change.

5.2 Working duties

While I was placed at Bakul, I had four main work duties.

� One core challenge was getting children of di�erent backgrounds over to the library

and giving them the opportunity to explore it. This includes slum children, boys

from a tribal hostel placed in Bhubaneswar, children of prisoners and children from

all schools in Bhubaneswar. After Bakul works on the inclusion of all social groups,

it aims to be open for all children whatsoever. The way I approached the children

was for example talking to principals, inviting classes for library tours and picking

up children from places in a walkable distance. When I began working at Bakul,

the library wasn't even a year old and the word about it still had to spread. That

is why I tried to reach out to as many places as possible.

� My personal interest and part of my education is in applied drama. Hence I

planned a children's play; by children for children. Especially in Bhubaneswar

this was a totally new method to be used with children. This made it even more

ambitious for me to start a theater project.

� The third duty of my work was connected to a group of slum children. A slum

school is situated only 2 minutes away of Bakul. With children of this school

(Khelaghara Elementary School) I planned regular sessions in the library. Since

their access to English classes in school is very limited, Bakul tries to provide

additional facilities to improve their English language skills. This was about to be

done in a playful way such as story telling and role plays.

4see pictures in the appendix C.3 on page 35

18

Page 19: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

� And because Bakul was still very new, another main objective of my work was

mobilizing volunteers. The whole concept of the organization is volunteerism.

Therefore only with volunteers, innovative ideas can be implemented. My target

groups were college students and university students of Bhubaneswar. The idea

was to inform them during classes about Bakul and motivate them to volunteer.

In the next part you will read about the work which had been put into e�ect in a

chronological order.

5.3 Working at Bakul

On December 1st 2007 I started working at Bakul. The �rst day I got introduced to the

story of Bakul and learned more about the latest happenings. Also the musical for the

children's drama was chosen. It was to become �Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs�,

after an adaptation by Roald Dahl.

The next day I started with picking up boys from a tribal hostel and took them to

Bakul. This was connected to my main objective of exploiting the library.

During the following days I proceeded with settling things for the theater workshop. I

went to schools to distribute �yers and talked in front of a whole school at the morning

assembly. Also a draft for the concept note was developed.

All Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays I would pick up the slum children in their

school to work with them at the library. Those children could not come by themselves.

Therefore I talked to the principal to get permission to take groups of children during

school hours to Bakul.

On the weekend of the �rst week, I started the theater workshop with 12 children.

Most of my work time was dedicated to the musical now.

Basically I was preparing the workshop, conducting it and re�ecting for the next unit.

Also I frequently worked with the Khelaghara children.

After Christmas break I proceeded with the musical production. Many things had to

be arranged and many people came in to o�er their help. Also rehearsals took place on

7 days in a row, to complete the play before Jan 13th. As a treat for the children, we

arranged a little New Years Lunch Party.

In the following week, apart of arranging things for the play, I started working with

the Khelaghara children again (they had winter holidays in between). Further Bakul had

to make preparations for the talk of an American professor in the following week. Only

few days were left to the premiere, too. What worried me, was that we still did not have

19

Page 20: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

any booking for an auditorium and had not distributed any posters. Therefore there

was a lot of work on my front. But many volunteers came to help out. Some of them

helped to prepare props and others were practicing songs with the children. We were an

international group working on the project consisting of two Germans, a Canadian and

several Indians.

On Monday, Jan 7th, Ellen Spitz had her talk about �The impact of imagery in picture

books for young children�. Members of di�erent organizations, professors and interested

people came to the talk.

The rest of that week was dedicated to the musical. Before the musical was performed I

had to organize many things, such as picking up costumes, distributing �yers and posters

and preparing the program for the weekend. The last rehearsal with the children was

on Saturday.5 After that things got packed to go to the venue on the next day.

Finally we had the performance. The children came to Bakul in the morning and

accordingly we took the children to the auditorium, which was at the local school of

drama. Every volunteer had a certain job and after a last rehearsal the children prepared

their costumes and makeup.

Finally the play took place and in the evening everything was brought back to Bakul.

About 300 visitors came to see the play.6 The children were very satis�ed and we planned

a �nal party for the following Sunday.

In the next week I spend some time with the follow up of the workshop, e.g. writing

the concept note and responding to criticisms concerning the play. On Sunday most

children showed up for the party. First we did a small evaluation of the workshop. Then

we had some lunch, cake and dances. The children enjoyed playing games a lot.

In the following days, things around Bakul became quiet. Less people came in and less

events were happening. After winding up some work concerning the musical, I started

a small art workshop with the slum children. For that project I got help from an Indian

lady who is working on arts. She gave her ideas for an art workshop with the children.

As a follow up of this project, the children were introduced into using a camera. With

the help of other volunteers, such as an Indian professional photographer, we started a

photograph workshop.7 The aim was that children could show their living environment

from their perspective. For instance did we go to their houses and they took pictures

from their families and residential quarters, if they liked. The children did not get any

guidelines but were allowed to feel free to use the camera as they wanted.

5see in the appendix C on page 356Criticism see in the appendix D.1 on page 377see in the appendix C.5 on page 36

20

Page 21: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

My last few days at Bakul were spend with winding up work, like �nishing the concept

note.

5.4 Review of the work at Bakul

In this section I will re�ect the main issues of my work at Bakul Children's Library. A

lot of interaction happened in the online discussion forum. A selection of this you will

�nd in the appendix.

At Bakul I learned many things, not only as a social worker, but for life. What really

stays in my memory till today is the strong cohesion we had among all members. My

experience was that everyone, whoever started volunteering at Bakul, felt associated

with it very easily. The working climate was very good. It is not comparable to what

I experienced earlier. The environment encouraged me to create new ideas. The orga-

nization itself is much open minded. One main reason might be that it is still growing.

Also most members have not worked in such facilities as a library yet. Therefore own

ideas must be developed to run the institution.

Concnerning my initial work objectives, I mainly realized three of them.

5.4.1 Exploitation of the library

It was rendered possible to exploit the library by more children. Even though the tribal

hostel boys could visit very seldom (the superintendent of the hostel did not approve

much of the library and would not give any further permission for the boys to visit),

the slum children from Khelaghara school at least keep coming in, till today. Also those

children started using the library in after-school hours and brought their siblings with

them. Due to the tight schedule I could not get into contact with the children of the

prisoners. Additional to that I tried to convince the authorities of schools for disabled

children to send their students. I did not succeed in this case so far.

5.4.2 Childrens Theater Workshop

My second prospective was to use applied drama in the work with children. As a main

part of my work at Bakul I directed a musical, performed by elementary school children.

Altogether I would say that the project was bigger than what I expected and gave me

many opportunities to acquire di�erent skills. One main aspect was organizing things.

Never before I had the task to coordinate so many people (18 children and about 8

21

Page 22: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

volunteers) in such a project. In some ways it was di�cult to arrange times which �t

most people's schedules, especially the children's. They came from several schools and

had very di�erent timings altogether. Still I can claim that we balanced to get them

together.

Another challenge among organizing things was that I did not know the place for very

long. I did not know where to buy certain things. We had to get Styrofoam, beads,

fabrics and so forth. In Germany I would know right away, in which stores the things

would be available. But in Bhubaneswar I had no clue about where to get Styrofoam.

It took a lot of resources calling up people and inquiring about shops and prices (if you

have no idea about prices, sellers might cheat on you very easily). Or I even had to ask

people to take me to a shop, if it was in di�erent parts of Bhubaneswar. At the same

time, I was very lucky that the volunteers at Bakul were so patient with me.

The work with the children was an awesome experience. In certain ways they were

di�erent from German children. I think, due to the Indian school system, the children

were more disciplined in some ways. Of course they would also play or be loud while

others rehearse their scenes. But they were always practicing till the end, trying to

concentrate on what they were doing. Also what impressed me very much was that the

children learned to give very constructive criticism. We could re�ect our ideas and the

rehearsals, without people feeling o�ended. In my opinion the good constellation of the

group was most important for this development.

And last but not least I have to name the people which supported me with my plans.

I really have to thank the whole team for being so cooperative and patient. Also for

spending day after day at the library, preparing things for the play. I never experienced

such a supporting group of volunteers. If it was not them, we never would have pulled

of such a successful performance.

In summary, the theater workshop was a lot of hard work and not always easy to

manage. Nevertheless it gave me a great learning experience, which will help me in my

further work.

For more details about the workshop, please read the concept note at:

http://www.scribd.com/doc/4325259/Musical-Production-with-Children.

5.4.3 Teaching English to the Khelaghara School Children

The third aim of my work had two components. One was to help the slum children

of Khelaghara school to improve their English. The other was to have regular sessions

with them at the library. This way they would have the opportunity to make use of the

22

Page 23: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

library as much as possible.

I planned to pick them up at the school, three times a week. A group of about 10-15

children and me would walk to the library. With a small group of about 4-6 children I

would read an early readers book. Subsequent to that the children would draw a picture

or have a role play of the story. This would show me, if they understood the story and

for them it would be more fun to read the stories and create an understanding.

Actually on some days this worked out much better than I expected. The children

loved to visit the library and every time I went to the school, even more students wanted

to come. But then, not having a �xed group turned out be a problem in some way.

Reading the stories and working on them would not happen on a regular basis with

most children. Therefore there was barely any routine to learn English. On the other

hand, this way many children got access to the library. Some of them started visiting in

their leisure time and even brought their siblings with them.

My conclusion is that I did succeed in introducing the library to the children. Also

some children began coming on a regular basis. But also, their English language skills

did not improve as much as I wished. Still it did improve somehow, since some children

started reading more di�cult books after few weeks.

In my opinion it is important to continue the regular visits within school hours. If

Bakul had a volunteer to continue picking up the students, even if it is not three times

a week, I think the children could bene�t a lot in the long term.

5.4.4 Mobilizing volunteers

This achievement, mobilizing volunteers, was not totally ful�lled. Not mentioned in this

short summary, but in the appendix is that one volunteer from England started working

at Bakul after I consulted her. Even though it is a start, I was not satis�ed with the

outcome at that time. Since I had very limited time after the play, it was di�cult to �nd

more volunteers for Bakul to be with them for a longer period. But at least while I was

there many people volunteered however for a short time, e.g. for the theater workshop. I

think this organization needs both, people who volunteer frequently and some volunteers

who can o�er help for certain projects. That way the everyday business is taken care of

and in times of a bigger need of personal (e.g. for a big event), some people can give a

hand.

Till date I tell people about Orissa and encourage students to become volunteers.

Latest development is that some youth from Singapore might start volunteering at Bakul

in the end of the year. Also some students from our university showed interest in it

23

Page 24: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

recently. Therefore I am hopeful to motivate more students to volunteer and take it as

a long term resolution.

To get back to the idea of approaching college and university students to become

volunteers, I think it can be an e�ective way to mobilize people. While I stayed in

Delhi, after my internship, I visited an organization working with street children. This

organization, called Khoj, is also based on volunteerism. Their approach is exactly what

we planned to do at Bakul. They go to universities and colleges to have short talks

about their organization. According to that they mobilize people to become volunteers.

Hence I think we could use a similar strategy at Bakul. Also it would be a new scheme

in Bhubaneswar and could set a small movement among youth (in other parts of Asia

it is common to volunteer for few hours a week, if you are a student, e.g. in Malaysia,

Korea).

24

Page 25: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

6 General Conclusion

In general I can say that it was worth going to India for my internship. I experienced a

lot of di�erent things in various �elds of social work. Not only that I had the opportunity

to visit as many organizations, but also the way of getting introduced to their work was

most enriching.

For me it is interesting to become part of a foreign culture. To meet people and learn

how they solve social issues in their community is a very important part of studying

social work. I think that we can bene�t a lot if we study foreign cultures and use best

practice experiences in our own work in Germany. At the same time we can share our

own ideas with the organizations abroad.

Of course experiences are not always good. While I stayed in Orissa I witnessed

a lot of bad circumstances. Either they happen to be amongst people or within the

organizations. But then, these incidents kept me going and forced me to reconsider my

own work. Also it taught me not to take things for granted but to appreciate the good

things and work hard to eradicate the bad.

After all I like the place that much that I will go back to Bakul next year. We start an

educational theater project, which will be the topic of my thesis. It is very motivating

to work with people who are enthusiastic about what they do. My observation is that

a lot can be done, if people are inspired by their work. Very less will be done if people

only do their jobs.

After I came back from India, many fellow students inquired, if it is worth going.

They were wondering about all the things one might not have in India, like you might

have them here. But I always have and always would again, recommend to take the

step. There is not much to lose, but a lot to win.

25

Page 26: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

Bibliography

[1] Census of India. O�ce of the Registrar General & Census Commissioner. India, 2001.

[2] Cordoro, Kelly M.: Scabies. University of California, San Francisco, 2008.

http://www.emedicine.com/DERM/topic382.htm , 14 October 2008.

[3] Jena, Pradyot Ranjan; Rath, Binayak: Growth Determinants of Orissa and their

Implications for Future Development of the State. 2006.

[4] Pati, Narayan C.: Intellectual Disability. Jewels International. Bhubaneswar, 2003.

[5] http://www.indiaplaces.com/india-states/orissa.html, 28. Jul 2008.

[6] Government of Orissa: http://www.orissa.gov.in/health_portal/healthpro�le/demography.html,

28 Jul 2008.

[7] UNICEF: http://122.160.10.83/unicef_website/Mapping%20Indias%20Children/,

28.Jul 2008.

26

Page 27: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

Part I

Pictures, Articles and Information

27

Page 28: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

A Pictures of Chetana Institute

28

Page 29: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

Figure A.1: Main building of Chetana Institute

Figure A.2: Primary Class

29

Page 30: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

Figure A.3: Writing lesson

Figure A.4: Writing lesson II

30

Page 31: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

B Pictures of NYSASDRI

31

Page 32: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

Figure B.1: A hospital in a village used for an eye camp. Dhenkanal District, Orissa

Figure B.2: Eye camp in a village. Dhenkanal District, Orissa

32

Page 33: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

C Pictures of Bakul

33

Page 34: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

Figure C.1: The jungle room

Figure C.2: Reading room for older children

34

Page 35: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

Figure C.3: Art Wall

Figure C.4: The group of the Snow White Musical

35

Page 36: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

Figure C.5: Photograph Workshop

Figure C.6: Photograph Workshop II

36

Page 37: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

D Criticism, Articles etc.

D.1 Criticism on the musical production

D.1.1 Mail of 15 January 2008: Some criticism of Bakul

Dear friends

This mail continues what I had mentioned in my last mail about the

reservations some people had about our staging Snow White and the

Seven Dwarfs. But before I take up the serious criticism that has come

about Bakul, let me give you an update on the Musical that was staged

on 13th December.

We hardly advertised the event because we feared a more than capacity

audience from just among the parents, relatives and friends of the

participants. The Auditorium we booked had 210 seats and there were

300 odd people who had come. Many people were standing and many left

after some time because they could not see anything. We should have

the images of the event up soon.

Now about the criticism that has come our way. I am sorry this mail

has taken epical proportions but then criticism excites me. :)

1. Why was the Musical done in English and not in Oriya? Are we

promoting an Anglicization that is anyway already taking place? Now,

�rst and foremost, let me remind the group that we have been

committed to children's theatre from the beginning. Art and Theatre

were always two key dimensions through which we have tried to promote

the creativity in children as well as develop an interest in books

and readng through these activities. We had advertised a Summer

Theatre Workshop this summer for children in Oriya, but it happened

late after the schools were closed but most importantly our chief

resource person went missing for some reason just after we advertised

37

Page 38: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

it, and we had to cancel the workshop.

In the Sishu Prativa Utsav that happened, one of our key activities

was "Kahanira Rangamancha" where the Theatre Directors Choudhury Jay

Prakash Das and Mihir Swain helped children dramatize the stories they

had read. This was in Oriya. And the coming Summer, we intend to have

a Summer Theatre Workshop for children in Oriya again. So, doing this

Musical in English does not mean that we want to do theatre only in

English.

2. Why did we do the Snow White story, which is racist?

We did Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs in English for three reasons.

A) We had the advantage of the presence of Nicole Suchanek,

who is trained in theatre pedagogic and she had the assistance of

Melanie and Melissa (who was trained in dance). They could work with

children of course only in English. And we did not want to lose the

opportunity of exploiting their presence at Bakul. Let me EMPHASIZE

here the speci�c advantage of having Nicole here for the workshop.

Nicole does not have a degree in Dramatics. Her training is in Social

Work. She specializes in theatre as part of social work. Hence, her

emphasis has been on how the children develop, the process of their

development rather than on the end result that the audience gets to

appreciate. The Musical was for the children and not for the audience.

And by that token, let me boast that the Musical was a GRAND SUCCESS.

Someone came into Bakul yesterday drunk, and said that he felt the

organizers were more excited about the event than the audience. he

thought it was some advertisement for Bakul we were doing. Even after

seeing that the library does not charge children anything, he held his

views. He has a right to his views but I have a right to my opinion

that his views were ridiculous because he still wants his kids to come

to the library though he says he does not believe in what we are

doing. but then coming back to his comment, of course, the Musical was

for the kids not for him. And we feel the kids had a ball, and so we

are very happy.

Nicole, Melanie and Melissa were very clear from the beginning that it

was the kids Musical not theirs and they involved the kids in every

aspect of the production. Many of the dances were choreographed by the

38

Page 39: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

kids themselves, the props were designed by them etc etc. Our

volunteers merely acted as facilitators asking them questions like how

would you express frustration rather than showing them how to express

frustration.

B) The second reason for doing the Snow White Musical was

that we had got hold of a wonderful Musical adaptation of the Snow

White story by the famous children's writer Roald Dahl. It came with a

Musical track which I think was out of the world.

ABOUT RACISM, I would like to say that if our critic had followed the

adaptation carefully, in Roald Dahl's version the racism had been much

cut out from the original. No Prince gets the fairest lady here. Snow

White just helps the Jockeys (standing in for the Dwarfs here) make

lots of money. Let me also mention that we had tried to INdianize the

script and Purabi had worked on it. It was quite a task to match upto

Roald Dahl and to ensure the revised text had the same rhyme and

rhythm. Purabi had donea good job but we realized that the Musical

soundtrack which bound us needed us to follow the script. For

instnace, we could not change horseracing and betting on horses to

cricket and betting on matches. THe Music for horses did not go with

cricket.

C) the staging of Snow White, moreover, is part of a larger

project of staging performances by children on the classic fairytales

and folktales from around the world. We started with Snow White. We

will move to a dramatization of folktales from India and Africa this

year. In fact, we are also working on the idea of having all these

folktales from around the world performed in Odissi dance as well.

3. The 3rd criticism is that we have been besotted with the media.

Well, well, well. Here we go again. if you remember, we had kept a

moratorium on the media for a good 6 initial months. There was only

one story in The Telegraph because the News Bureau Chief asked his

Principal Correspondent to do it after he visited the library. this

Principal Correspondent had been an active member of Bakul all the

time. He, however, did the story not because he wanted to but because

he was asked to. After the �rst six months, however, when we did not

�nd the response of kids as encouraging as we would have wanted and

39

Page 40: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

many people commented that they were not aware of teh library, we

decided to lift the moratorium. Even then, members would remember my

mentioning how the story on Bakul came out in The Times of India under

pressure from a freelancer who had visited Bakul though Sandeep

Mishra, Principal Correspondent in the TOI is a member of Bakul and

had wanted that we do not publicize our work.

We lifted teh Moratorium also when people said that they had been

looking for Bakul for many months and it was only after a story, that

they could get the location of the library.

If there have been quite a few reports on Bakul the last few months,

it is because there has been quite a bit happening all the time.

Within one week now for instance, we had 2 big events. And it must be

mentioned here that the only time, we sent a press invite or a release

was for the Art Wall. Never again, has there been a press release. the

story on the Musical by the Telegraph happened after the reporter got

a general invite to the event. the person who reported Ellen's visit

to Bakul in The HIndu remembers well that he had been asked not to

write the Bakul story in the paper even though he had come for the

Inauguration.

In fact, because we do not want to be seen as publicity hungry, we did

not go the way to ensure that the event is reported in the newspapers.

No e�ort from our side.

MY COMMENTS ON THE CRITICS

Although I �nd the comments of our drunk friend (I mentinoed)

ridiculous, his criticism is important because it gives us a window to

public perception. It does matter because we want to make this into a

movement. I also admire the fact that he made his comment upfront.

What I am upset about is that one of us, a member of the yahoogroup,

who I am glad to say, really appreciates the idea of Bakul and

believes in it, had to share her criticism of Bakul and the direction

it is taking with another member (who relayed it to me). I would

expect that all members of the group (by being members I expect them

to be interested in the good of the group) would make their

dissensions public through the yahoogroup. It is easy to criticize. It

is tougher to come forward and come together to ensure that no one

40

Page 41: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

else can make the criticism we are making. but if we consider

ourselves a part of this group and believe in the idea, we should do

it.

I do not know if I did not right thing by being very defensive. I am

not sure we haev been doing the right things always but de�nitely we

are trying and we want your support to ensure we do things we can

defend.

I have broken my New Year resolution of writing shorter mails. Sorry for that :)

Sujit

D.1.2 Mail of 16 January 2008: Re: [Bakul] Some Criticism of

Bakul

Dear Sujit;

Being a member of this yahoo group as well as the

parent of a participating member of the play recently

staged by Bakul, let me put in my 2 cents for whatever

that they may be worth.

I think Bakul and you along with few of your close

associates are doing a fabulous service. It need to be

lauded continuouly and as Shambhu is doing at XIMB,

should be highlighted as a case study for others to

follow. Hats o� to all of you who were involved with

the production.

Yes, you should listen to the criticisms, but over the

years I have learnt to ignore most of them as long as

I am clear in what I am trying to do and doing my best

to communicate that clearly to all stakeholders. At

the end of the day, there is very little you can do

about the minority that will always be unhappy no

matter what you do.

Have you heard about the story where a father and a

son were walking with a horse. First the father was

sitting on the horse and the so was walking beside.

The villagers said look at that - what a heartless

41

Page 42: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

father making his young son walk. Hearing this, the

father got o� and the son rode the horse. As they

came to the next village people started saying look

what a cruel thing for the young son to make his old

father walk. Hearing this both father and son started

riding the horse together and as they came to the next

village - some people started saying look at the cruel

fellows who have no pity for the poor animal. So, you

can't please all people all the time.

Keep up the good work. All I can say is that being

also involved with pratham in Orissa, my o�er to

Bakul to work closely with us remains open. In

particular, do consider joining our summer campaign to

boost reading across all government schools. I think

it will be a win-win.

Regards,

Dhanada

42

Page 43: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

D.1.3 Article in: The Telegraph, Calcutta, India

Snow White in temple city

PRIYA ABRAHAMBhubaneswar, Jan. 11: A fair maiden, a poisoned apple and a princely kiss � the storyof Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs, by brothers Grimm, would soon come alive onOrissa's stage � thanks to volunteers from Canada and Germany, along with the city'sown Bakul Foundation.Nichole Suhanek, Melanie Eidecker and Mellissa Cornacchia, are the three social workstudents of Dortmund University, who have put their talents together for a (slightlytampered) version of the popular fairy tale as a grand �nale to a theatre workshop beingorganised by Bakul Foundation.This is the �rst-ever theatre workshop for children here.With the show a few days away, preparations are on at a furious pace at an innocuousaddress in the dusty lane of Satyanagar. Nichole, has donned the director's hat for themusical, and is being assisted by Melanie and Mellissa � also doubling up as lyricists,trainers, art directors, prop and costume designers and musicians for the production.�This show is about fun and laughter. The musical is going to be a real treat,� promisesNichole.Her actors are all ready and con�dent and the rest would be done by �amboyant andwacky costumes along with the music and dance, the director assures.The workshop, which began on December 6, 2007, with 20 Bhubaneswar schoolchildren,focussed on basics of emoting.�We started with general exercises and then went on to expressions and �nally a story.Then we taught them about props, how to make them and the costume selection, too,�said Melanie.�It's great to watch the kids in action. Nichole, Melanie and Mellisa also double up asenergetic and warm friends for them. Despite not knowing our language, it is amazinghow the three have managed to make this workshop a success,� said Sujit Mahapatra,secretary of the foundation.�It's not about the performance only, but also about development. There were some shykids, who outgrew all their shyness and that is the biggest achievement,� he added.�We'll sing and look great in the costumes. We are looking forward for our day,� saidAnish Mishra, a little student of Class III of Loyola School. Anish would be the narratorfor the musical. The signi�cant seven dwarfs are to be played by Loyola and St Xavier'sstudents.

43

Page 44: Final Report A practical term in Orissa, India · In the beginning of this report you will nd some information about the state of Orissa. It might be helpfull to understand the working

E Map of Orissa

Figure E.1: http://www.indiaplaces.com/india-maps/orissa.html, 14 October 2008.

F Collection of websites related to

in the report

� www.bakulfoundation.org

� http://www.indiatogether.org/2008/jan/edu-bakul.htm

� www.nysasdri.org/program.html

� http://www.pledgebank.com/Bakul-Library

� http://www.scribd.com/doc/4325259/Musical-Production-with-Children

44


Recommended