+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Final Report (Volume 1)

Final Report (Volume 1)

Date post: 17-Feb-2018
Category:
Upload: jaspreet-singh-sahni
View: 214 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
155
7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1) http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 1/155 THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE GETTING OFF THE MARK Cricket is a national sport that connects the people of India in a unique way The !oard of Control for Cricket in India "#!CCI$% which ad&inisters the 'a&e in the nation( howe)er( continues to *e &ired in one contro)ersy after another These include serious inaction re'ardin'  *ettin' and &atch+fi,in'( frequent a&end&ents to the rules to ena*le persons in power to perpetuate their control and pro&ote their financial interests( per&ittin' or ena*lin' its office *earers( e&ployees and players to do acts which clearly 'i)e rise to conflicts of interest which ha)e no resolution &echanis&( lack of transparency and accounta*ility( failure to pro)ide effecti)e 'rie)ance redressal &echanis&s and a 'eneral apathy towards wron'doin' In addition( althou'h the !CCI dischar'es pu*lic functions( its workin' is percei)ed as a closed door and *ack+roo& affair( not accounta*le to those who are affected *y its decisions nor to those who &atter &ost - the cricket fans  .t stake therefore are the faith( lo)e and passion for the 'a&e of hundreds of &illions of people The task at hand The Supre&e Court has left us in no dou*t a*out its 'ra)e concern a*out the place at which Indian cricket finds itself today The /cloud o)er the workin' of the !CCI0 has left followers of the 'a&e /worried and ~ 1 ~
Transcript
Page 1: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 1/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

GETTING OFF THE MARK 

Cricket is a national sport that connects the people of India in a

unique way The !oard of Control for Cricket in India "#!CCI$% which

ad&inisters the 'a&e in the nation( howe)er( continues to *e &ired in

one contro)ersy after another These include serious inaction re'ardin'

 *ettin' and &atch+fi,in'( frequent a&end&ents to the rules to ena*le

persons in power to perpetuate their control and pro&ote their financial

interests( per&ittin' or ena*lin' its office *earers( e&ployees and

players to do acts which clearly 'i)e rise to conflicts of interest which

ha)e no resolution &echanis&( lack of transparency and accounta*ility(

failure to pro)ide effecti)e 'rie)ance redressal &echanis&s and a 'eneral

apathy towards wron'doin' In addition( althou'h the !CCI dischar'es

pu*lic functions( its workin' is percei)ed as a closed door and *ack+roo&

affair( not accounta*le to those who are affected *y its decisions nor to

those who &atter &ost - the cricket fans

 .t stake therefore are the faith( lo)e and passion for the 'a&e of 

hundreds of &illions of people

The task at hand

The Supre&e Court has left us in no dou*t a*out its 'ra)e concern

a*out the place at which Indian cricket finds itself today The /cloud o)er

the workin' of the !CCI0 has left followers of the 'a&e /worried and

~ 1 ~

Page 2: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 2/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

deeply suspicious a*out what 'oes on in the na&e of the 'a&e0 says the

Court( *efore indicatin' the way forward for a sport that is not only a

passion *ut a 'reat unifyin' force( *y adoptin' a /1ero tolerance

approach0( which can alone satisfy the cry for cleansin' It cannot also 'o

unnoticed that while re+e&phasi1in' that !CCI dischar'es pu*lic

functions( the Court has referred to the tacit concurrence and support of 

the Central and State 2o)ern&ents in acti)ities which create a &onopoly 

o)er cricket

The Supre&e Court appointed Co&&ittee co&prisin' of 3ustice

RM4odha( for&er Chief 3ustice of India( 3ustice .shok !han( for&er

3ud'e of the Supre&e Court and 3ustice R5Ra)eendran( for&er 3ud'e

of the Supre&e Court was &andated inter alia to e,a&ine and &ake

suita*le reco&&endations to the !CCI for refor&s in its practices and

procedures and necessary a&end&ents in the Me&orandu& of 

 .ssociation and Rules 6 Re'ulations on the &atters set out in Para'raph

789 of the :ud'&ent dated ;;nd 3anuary ;87<7 The Co&&ittee appointed

1  /109. The proposed Co&&ittee can also( in our opinion( *e requested to e,a&ine and &ake

suita*le reco&&endations on the followin' aspects= "i% .&end&ents considered necessary to the

&e&orandu& of association of the !CCI and the pre)alent rules and re'ulations for strea&linin' the

conduct of elections to different posts>officers in the !CCI includin' conditions of eli'i*ility and

disqualifications( if any( for candidates wantin' to contest the election for such posts includin' the office of 

the President of the !CCI

"ii% .&end&ents to the &e&orandu& of association( and rules and re'ulation considered necessary topro)ide a &echanis& for resol)in' conflict of interest should such a conflict arise despite Rule ?;@prohi*itin' creation or holdin' of any co&&ercial interest *y the ad&inistrators( with particular referenceto persons( who *y )irtue of their proficiency in the 'a&e of Cricket( were to necessarily play so&e role asCoaches( Mana'ers( Co&&entators etc"iii% .&end&ent( if any( to the Me&orandu& of .ssociation and the Rules and Re'ulations of !CCI to

carry out the reco&&endations of the Pro*e Co&&ittee headed *y 3ustice Mud'al( su*:ect to suchreco&&endations *ein' found accepta*le *y the newly appointed Co&&ittee

~ 2 ~

Page 3: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 3/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

Mr2opal Sankaranarayanan( .d)ocate of the Supre&e Court to act as its

Secretary

The task assi'ned to the Co&&ittee is clear= reco&&end those

chan'es in the Rules and Re'ulations of !CCI that will further the

interest of the pu*lic at lar'e in the sport of cricket( i&pro)e the ethical

standards and discipline in the 'a&e( strea&line and create efficiency in

the &ana'e&ent of the !CCI( pro)ide accessi*ility and transparency(

pre)ent conflicts of interest situations and eradicate political and

co&&ercial interference and a*use and create &echanis&s for

resolution of disputes and 'rie)ances .s the Supre&e Court has

reiterated that the !CCI is carryin' out pu*lic functions - functions that

'o)ern the interests of the pu*lic - the necessary corollary is that !CCI is

su*:ect to the ri'ours of pu*lic law This would &andate that it acts in

line with the 'eneral principles of reasona*leness and fairness( and also

that it adheres to the *asic principles of accounta*ility and transparency

In carryin' out the assi'ned task( the Co&&ittee took the followin'

steps=

"i)% .ny other reco&&endation with or without suita*le a&end&ent of the rele)ant Rules andRe'ulations( which the Co&&ittee &ay consider necessary to &ake with a )iew to pre)entin' sportin'frauds( conflict of interests( strea&linin' the workin' of !CCI to &ake it &ore responsi)e to thee,pectations of the pu*lic at lar'e and to *rin' transparency in practices and procedures followed *y 

!CCI0

~ 3 ~

Page 4: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 4/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

"a% Prepared and circulated a detailed Auestionnaire " Appendix-1% to

 )arious key stakeholders( aficionados and patrons of the 'a&e This

 was prepared after a detailed perusal of the Supre&e Court$s

 :ud'&ent( the e,istin' Rules and Re'ulations of the !CCI and

 )arious &edia articles and news reports which indicated to the

Co&&ittee the flaws and loopholes in the ad&inistration of the

nation$s fore&ost sport The Auestionnaire contained 7B< questions

'rouped under distinct heads of concern areas for cricket

ad&inistration=a Or'ani1ation( structure and relationship

 * Source and e,tent of :urisdictionc Offices( co&&ittees and electionsd Co&&ercial en'a'e&ents( contracts and ser)icese .udit( accounts and financesf Player welfare and dispute resolution

' Conflict of interesth O)ersi'ht and transparency 

 "*% Conducted o)er B< days of sittin's in Mu&*ai( !an'alore( Chennai(

Dolkata( Hydera*ad and ew Felhi These allowed the Co&&ittee to

'et )aried perspecti)es fro& ? pri&ary Test Centres as well as to

afford ease of access to the respecti)e representati)es fro& the

 )arious Gones The Co&&ittee also interacted with @ persons

around India includin' or&er Captains( International and irst

Class Players( Coaches( Mana'ers( .d&inistrators( 3ournalists(

Talent scouts( .uthors( 4awyers( Clu* Owners( Selectors and a

or&er Chief 3ustice of a Hi'h Court . 4ist of these persons is at

~ 4 ~

Page 5: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 5/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

 Appendix-2 to this Report . su&&ary of the rele)ant su''estions

&ade *y persons who responded to the Auestionnaire and those

 who interacted with the Co&&ittee is 'i)en in  Appendix-3 to this

report"c% E,tensi)ely researched &edia reports( docu&entaries( pu*lished

&aterial( draft le'islation( *ooks and articles( apart fro& se)eral

unsolicited "*ut always welco&e% &issi)es fro& cricket fans( local

e,perts and ad&inistrators a*out how &alad&inistration is rife in

all parts of the country . select list of these &aterials is at

 Appendix-  to this Report Co&plaints of defalcation and

siphonin' of funds( opaqueness in ad&inistration( *latant

fa)ouritis& and political interference unfortunately see& to e,ist in

al&ost all State associations( )aryin' only in de'ree fro& place to

place"d% Co&&issioned a co&parati)e analysis of international sports *odies

"*oth cricket and otherwise% and how they are structured( their

constitution( electoral process and o)erall &ana'e&ent and how 

&easures e,ist to check conflict of interest and &ana'e ethics This

co&parati)e report secured *y the Co&&ittee fro& The Sports 4aw 

6 Policy Centre is at Appendix-! to this Report

The interactions ha)e *een e,tre&ely insi'htful and infor&ati)e as

they ha)e allowed the Co&&ittee a close e,a&ination of not only what is

e)ident and e,pressed( *ut also the layers of the politics of the cricket

~ 5 ~

Page 6: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 6/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

esta*lish&ent( *oth at the national and local le)els The Co&&ittee was

'ratified and o)erwhel&ed *y the stren'th and content of the responses

recei)ed fro& )arious other quarters Stran'ers ha)e walked up to the

&e&*ers on &ornin' walks and e)en called at odd hours to put in their

two *its on what the way forward ou'ht to *e for Indian cricket Dnowin'

the stron' feelin's the sport e)okes in the 'eneral populace( these

o)ertures ha)e *een i&portant - to understand the a)id cricket fan$s

&ind as well as those( who once de)oted( ha)e *eco&e cynical Most of 

those the Co&&ittee interacted with( were ea'er that the 'a&e of cricket

 *e 'o)erned and ad&inistered confor&in' to the hi'hest standards of 

&ana'e&ent( ethics( accounta*ility and transparency worthy of the

'a&e( and that efficient decision &akin' process should *e

institutionalised Se)eral others declined to interact with the Co&&ittee

due to prior confidentiality o*li'ations to the !CCI The interactions(

responses to questionnaire and Co&&itteeJs research relatin' to sports

syste&s in 'eneral and cricket in particular( ha)e ena*led the Co&&ittee

to identify the pro*le& areas in the functionin' of !CCI

The B Me&*er Pro*e Co&&ittee headed *y 3ustice Mukul Mud'al

earlier entrusted with the task of e,a&inin' the alle'ations of *ettin'

and spot fi,in'( in their Report dated 9;;87@ su*&itted to the Supre&e

Court( &ade se)eral reco&&endations to pre)ent and to effecti)ely deal

 with *ettin' and &atch>spot+fi,in' This Co&&ittee has carefully 

~ 6 ~

Page 7: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 7/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

considered the said reco&&endations and( where)er found accepta*le

and feasi*le( incorporated the& in this Report The reco&&endations of 

the 3ustice Mud'al Pro*e Co&&ittee are at Appendix-" to this Report

It *eca&e clear that &any ills had *eco&e ende&ic due to the

apathy or in)ol)e&ent of those who were at the hel& of the !oard$s

ad&inistrationK that &any of these were hi'h functionaries in the Central

and State 2o)ern&ents further co&pounded the pro*le&( as did the fact

that se)eral incu&*ents had re&ained in char'e of State associations for

se)eral decades Many officials of the )arious State .ssociations hold

power without adherin' to the *asic principles of accounta*ility and

transparency *y con)ertin' the& into re'ional fiefdo&s Unfortunately(

the &ana'e&ent of other Indian sports *odies re)eals the sa&e sorry 

trend

The Co&&ittee also found inequities writ lar'e at the hi'h ta*le(

 with so&e States o)er+represented in )otes( tourna&ent participation

and central fundin' while others ha)e to wait in the win's for indefinite

periods until fa)oured Policies ha)e *een for&ulated and altered to suit

the needs of a few powerful indi)iduals( and coteries ha)e for&ed around

the& which has polari1ed and co&pro&ised independent leadership

 .l&ost without e,ception( those who ha)e no such a'endas ha)e

~ 7 ~

Page 8: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 8/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

re&ained quiet( their silence e&*oldenin' further &alfeasance In the

&ind of the cricketin' pu*lic( they are as &uch to *la&e

Close o*ser)ers of the 'a&e ha)e infor&ed the Co&&ittee how the

pu*lic 'ets only a s&all percenta'e of seats in &atches and how the 5IP

culture has o)ertaken a no*le pasti&e The con)enience of the )iewers in

the stadiu& 'enerally( and wo&en( children and differently a*led in

particular( are not catered to There is neither access to quality food and

 water at a reasona*le price( nor adequate washroo& facilities are &ade

a)aila*le E)en in re'ard to tele)ision ri'hts( the atte&pt has *een to

&a,i&ise re)enue *y insertin' ad)ertise&ents at crucial parts of the

'a&e( and to &u11le dissentin' )oices at all le)els

Surprisin'ly( the players who are the sport$s *i''est draw are not

spared fro& the apathy of the !CCI They are treated less like assets and

&ore as the e&ployees and su*ordinates of those 'o)ernin' the 'a&e

The Co&&ittee has *een infor&ed that often( the players are left to

deter&ine the acco&&odation and transport arran'e&ents for their

fa&ilies( that requisitions for 'enuine pay&ents are not cleared and

delayed( and that counsellors and nutritionists are not included in the

support staff In the affairs of the sport that they are the dri)ers of( they 

ha)e no )oice and no independence

~ 8 ~

Page 9: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 9/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

The IP4 has o*)iously *een the &ost )isi*le( re&unerati)e and

'la&ouri1ed co&ponent of cricket in India o)er the last years( *ut with

 *i' &oney and attention( there has not *een the necessary caution to

protect the sport and its players fro& the or'y of e,cess that quickly 

 *e'an to en)elope the e)ent .s e)ents unfolded o)er the last few years(

it was clear that unsa)oury interferences had reached the hi'hest

echelons of cricket and o)erlappin' and conflictin' interests were not

only condoned( *ut those in 'o)ernance of the !oard had &ade e,+post

facto a&end&ents to facilitate the sa&e .s persons in 'o)ernance

interfered with the &ana'e&ent of the 'a&e and the rest re&ained &ute

spectators( 'enerations of players ha)e *een forced to *uckle( &i'rate or

 worse( 'i)e up

 Le hasten to add a word of caution lest there *e a ne'ati)e

i&pression created a*out the !CCI Furin' our interactions( one fact

that e&er'ed unifor&ly concerned the way the &anpower of the !CCI

or'ani1es the actual 'a&e and its co&petitions across the country The

or'anisation has still &ana'ed to har)est talent and ensure that the

national tea&s perfor& re&arka*ly on the world sta'e Talented players

fro& )irtually any corner of this )ast nation are in a position to co&pete

and reach the hi'hest le)els( e)en if they co&e fro& relati)ely &odest

 *ack'rounds Recent years ha)e *orne e)idence with India winnin' the

~ 9 ~

Page 10: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 10/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

 Lorld Cup in T+;8 and One Fay Internationals( while also reachin' the

top of the Test rankin's

The !CCI staff &e&*ers ha)e ensured that hundreds of &atches

alon' with &atch officials are or'ani1ed annually at all le)els( and that

updates are pro)ided so that the !CCI re&ains fully infor&ed The

&ana'e&ent of the 'a&e is also self+sufficient without any 'o)ern&ental

'rants Le notice the !CCI also conducts charity &atches for national

causes and hu&anitarian assistance is also 'i)en to the for&er cricketers

and their fa&ilies

The Co&&ittee has therefore consciously ensured that no

&easures are reco&&ended that would interfere or li&it the 'ood work 

 *ein' done on *ehalf of the !CCI

Inte#a$ti%ns &ith the '((Iro& the outset( the Co&&ittee has reached out to the

ad&inistration of the !CCI to offer its co&&ents and inter)entions on

the issues that were *ein' considered Meetin's were arran'ed with all

the office+*earers( and fro& the first week of .pril( the Auestionnaire

 was sent to all of the& The then President Mr3a'&ohan Fal&iya and

Secretary Mr.nura' Thakur e)en sent identical responses to it Le are

'lad to note that ha)in' o*tained a *road picture fro& the Auestionnaire

a*out how the Co&&ittee intended to proceed( !CCI started takin'

so&e action( or at least &ade so&e announce&ents touchin' upon the

~ 10 ~

Page 11: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 11/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

contents of the questions These include state&ents concernin'

co&&ittees to represent States where associations were in dispute or not

for&ed An7?N( a'ent accreditation Ans?78 6 ?7BN and conflict of 

interest Ans7 - BN Unfortunately( a closer e,a&ination shows that

these &easures ca&e without any structural &odifications( and were

done &ore in an effort to assua'e the pu*licOn the B8th of Septe&*er ;87<( the Co&&ittee interacted in ew 

Felhi with MrShashank Manohar( who had *een the President of the

!CCI when a&end&ents were carried out to per&it a conflict of interest(

 which action was e)entually quashed *y the Hon$*le Supre&e Court On

the day of the &eetin'( MrManohar was widely tipped to *e the

consensus candidate to a'ain *e the President of the !CCI in elections to

 *e held on the weekend Furin' the e,tensi)e discussions( the

Co&&ittee put to MrManohar the )arious concerns hi'hli'hted in the

Auestionnaire( particularly re'ardin' the wide+ran'in' powers of the

President( the lack of financial o)ersi'ht o)er State *odies( the lack of 

transparency as far as !CCI re'ulations and processes were concerned(

the lack of a Conflict of Interest policy and the need for an O&*uds&an

MrManohar fairly conceded that these needed to *e addressed Le are

a'ain happy to note that that on *ein' elected as President of !CCI

 within @ days thereafter( MrManohar( e)en without waitin' for the

Co&&ittee$s report( adopted and pro:ected the Co&&ittee$s )iews as his

~ 11 ~

Page 12: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 12/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

road&ap for i&pro)in' the functionin' of the !CCI He also

i&ple&ented so&e of the&( ie uploadin' of the Constitution and !ye+

4aws on the !CCI we*site( creatin' a policy for Conflicts of Interest and

appoint&ent of an O&*uds&an Lhile we *elie)e that these proposals

are in the ri'ht direction( we find that they are not co&prehensi)e and

su*stanti)eThe need of the hour is not cos&etic *ut funda&ental chan'e(

 which will lay the proper foundations on which the !CCI can function in

a professional and transparent &anner and will *rin' the 'a&e of cricket

 *ack to its pristine for& and restore the confidence of the people It is

precisely this that the Co&&ittee has proposed

O)# App#%a$h

 Le understand that the cricket fan is e&otionally wedded to the

'a&e( and is willin' to sacrifice &uch for a &ere taste of what cricket has

to offer The Indian fan( youn' or old( fit or differently a*led( deser)es

 *etter fro& the richest cricket *ody in the world( *oth in ter&s of access

and ad&inistration Lhile &assi)e funds flow into the coffers of the

!CCI and the IP4 throu'h the sale of tele)ision and &edia ri'hts and

sponsorship deals( little co&&ensurate ad)anta'e finds its way to the

&e&*ers of pu*lic who stand in snakin' lon' queues( often una*le to

o*tain tickets( and if lucky( to stu&*le into stadia without access to *asic

a&enities This trustin' soul *elie)es in the purity of the 'a&e and his

~ 12 ~

Page 13: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 13/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

passion dri)es his faith that all aspects of cricket are ethical and clean

The fact that forces fro& politics and *usiness see cricket ad&inistration

as a steppin' stone to reco'nition and pu*licity is irrele)ant to the

cricket fan( until he reali1es( as &any e&*ittered souls recently ha)e(

that the 'a&e is not really *ein' played on the cricket pitch The

Co&&ittee has therefore approached each issue( keepin' in )iew the

directions and o*ser)ations of the Supre&e Court and atte&pted to find

the solutions *y applyin' two tests + /Lhether this will *enefit the 'a&e

of cricket0 and /Lhat does the Indian cricket fan want0

In an effort to &ake this Report as reada*le as possi*le( the

Co&&ittee has shorn it of le'al :ar'on and unnecessary details Le ha)e

also sou'ht to &aintain the confidentiality reposed in us fro& )arious

quarters *y not referrin' to indi)iduals or institutions which ha)e shared

infor&ation or su''estions with us( and li&ited the contents of this

report to the *are &ini&u& so that the Model Me&orandu& of 

 .ssociation and Re'ulations &ay speak for the&sel)es alon' with the

Codes set out in the .nne,ures

 .t a ti&e when the nation$s hi'hest court has *een co&pelled to

find that the 'a&e has fallen into disrepute( only e,traordinary steps will

 *rin' it *ack fro& this chas& Le are conscious that so&e of our

proposals &ay e)oke )aried responses( *ut the collecti)e conscience of 

~ 13 ~

Page 14: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 14/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

this Co&&ittee is clear that tou'h &easures are called for to restore

Indian cricket to its pinnacle of 'lory Indi)idual interest will ha)e to *e

sacrificed for the sake of the institution( and no e,i'ency of con)enience

or con)ention shall stand in the way of a whole scale structural o)erhaul

The current 'o)ernance structure of the !CCI and its Me&*er

 .ssociations is far fro& satisfactory and it needs to *e suita*ly 

restructured Strict ter&s and tenures ha)e to *e i&posed on

ad&inistrators( o)ersi'ht and audit of &e&*er associations need to *e

carried out( professional &ana'e&ent deser)es to *e introduced in the

ad&inistration of the 'a&e( all States require an equal say in the affairs

of the !CCI( financial prudence has to *e e,ercised( independent )iews

in 2o)ernance are i&perati)e and cricketers ha)e to *e protected and

'i)en a free hand in cricketin' affairs There also ou'ht to *e an

O&*uds&an( an Ethics Officer and an Electoral Officer who can pro)ide

institutional resolution while principles of transparency and conflict of 

interest need to *e infused without further delay

The report that follows is the Co&&itteeJs effort to restore Indian

cricket to its deser)ed status *y puttin' in place 'ood 'o)ernance

structures and *est practices

~ 14 ~

Page 15: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 15/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

(hapte# One* The +t#)$t)#e and (%nstit)ti%n

It was nearly ;88 years after the !ritish first *rou'ht cricket to

India that its 'o)ernin' *ody was created .t a ti&e of co&&unal

2y&khanas and the occasional tourin' tea& fro& En'land( the princely 

fa&ilies and other cricket patrons ca&e to'ether to create the !oard of 

Control for Cricket in India( which was re'istered as a not+for+profit

society in Madras "now Chennai% The !CCI has 'rown fro& its ori'inal

co&position of less than half a do1en pro)incial &e&*ers to ha)e fi)e

ti&es that nu&*er representin' )arious 'roups and territorial di)isions

The Structure

The !CCI at the &o&ent consists of B8 ull Me&*ers so&e of 

 who& do not field tea&s( while others do not represent any territory

Twenty States and one Union Territory are included and ten States and

si, Union Territories re&ain either e,cluded or disenfranchised In

addition( officially there are .ssociate and .ffiliate Me&*ers as well as

so+called uture Me&*ers

The Ser)ices Sports Control !oard( the Railways Sport Pro&otion

!oard and .ll India Uni)ersities represent particular national ser)ice

'roups( who traditionally constituted the lar'est e&ployers of Indian

sports&en *efore the ad)ent of li*eral pri)ate enterprise .part fro&

~ 15 ~

Page 16: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 16/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

these( two Clu*s - the Cricket Clu* of India at Mu&*ai and the ational

Cricket Clu* at Dolkata also en:oy full &e&*ership of the !CCI

 Problems

 .n e,a&ination of the e,istin' structure re)ealed the followin'

ano&alies=

a ot all States are represented on the !CCIOne old State "!ihar% and two new states "Chhattis'arh and

Uttarakhand% and si, orth+Eastern States "Sikki&( Manipur(

Me'halaya( a'aland( .runachal Pradesh and Mi1ora&% are

unrepresented on the !oard Of course( the &ost si'nificant

o&ission was !ihar( which( *ein' the third &ost populous State in

the nation required the cricket representati)es of its 788 &illion

populace to &i'rate to other States to ply their trade .part fro&

Tripura( the other si, sister+States of the north+east had *een

rele'ated to )arious cate'ories of &e&*ership ".ssociate( .ffiliate

and uture% which really ha)e no )oice on the !oard

 * So&e States are o)er+representedMainly attri*uta*le to their historic le'acy( *oth Maharashtra and

2u:arat ha)e B ull Me&*ers( each representin' parts of their

respecti)e States Maharashtra therefore e,ercises )otes throu'h

the .ssociations of Mu&*ai( 5idar*ha and Maharashtra while

2u:arat fields the .ssociations of !aroda( 2u:arat and Saurashtra

~ 16 ~

Page 17: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 17/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

c So&e &e&*ers do not represent territoriesThe Ser)ices Sports Control !oard( the Railways Sport Pro&otion

!oard and .ll India Uni)ersities show that territorial di)isions

 were not the consistent criteria to deter&ine &e&*ership of the

!CCI Howe)er( these &e&*ers were represented *y tea&s that

played co&petiti)e cricket

d So&e &e&*ers neither play &atches nor represent territories!oth the ational Cricket Clu* "CC% at Dolkata and the Cricket

Clu* of India "CCI% at Mu&*ai were &ore in the nature of 

recreation clu*s which neither fielded tea&s for tourna&ents nor

had a 'eo'raphical *asis for *ein' ull Me&*ers of the !CCI In

fact( *y )irtue of CCI *ein' 'ranted full &e&*ership( Maharashtra

has 'arnered as &any as four out of the total B8 )otes on the

!oard

e Union Territories are unrepresented on the !oardE,cept for Felhi which en:oys a special position under the

Constitution as well( none of the other si, Union Territories are

ull Me&*ers of the !CCI In fact( there ha)e *een repeated

representations *y the Cricket .ssociation of Pondicherry that :ust

as Felhi( it is also a Union Territory with a Chief Minister and

ou'ht to *e &ade a ull Me&*er This issue is sub judice *efore the

Madras Hi'h Court *ut nonetheless( there see&s that so&e

~ 17 ~

Page 18: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 18/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

artificial distinction e,ists in the e,tant rules *etween Felhi and

Puducherry

f .d+hoc creation of Me&*ership cate'oriesThe Re'ulations of the !CCI only speak of three cate'ories of 

Me&*ers - ull( .ssociate and .ffiliate Howe)er( we find that

there is a list of si, /uture Me&*ers0( a cate'ory that does not

ha)e a le'al *asis This consists of Uttarakhand( Mi1ora&(

Telan'ana( Chandi'arh( Puducherry and .nda&an 6 ico*ar

Such a classification see&s a half+way house with no real purpose

e,cept to 'i)e the association an illusion that it will *e pro&oted at

so&e )a'ue point in the future

' .r*itrary addition and re&o)al of associationsor reasons *est known to the !CCI( despite *ein' a ull Me&*er(

the Ra:asthan Cricket .ssociation has *een treated as

disenfranchised( resultin' in the players of the State *ein' forced

to &o)e elsewhere to co&pete The non+addition of the !ihar

Cricket .ssociation or an equi)alent has also led to such a denial to

the players fro& !ihar

 Solutions

 .l&ost uni)ersally( apart fro& those who represented the

associations in 2u:arat and Maharashtra( the pre)alent )iew was that

that the State is a fair unit of representation on the !CCI On a

~ 18 ~

Page 19: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 19/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

consideration of the entire issue( the Co&&ittee is of the )iew that it is

not proper for only one or two States to ha)e &ultiple &e&*ers when all

other States ha)e sin'le &e&*erships "in fact( while &any States ha)e no

representation% Fe&ocratic nor&s require each State should ha)e equal

representation( and therefore the Co&&ittee proposes the policy of #One

State - One Me&*er - One 5ote$ In fact( this is the policy followed *y 

other national sports associations "IH 6 .I%( each of whose &e&*ers

ha)e an equal )ote re'ardless of si1e or population E)en at the

international le)el "IOC 6 I.%( this is the position Cricket ou'ht to *e

no different

It was howe)er also stated that as far as dis*urse&ent of funds *y 

!CCI for cricket de)elop&ent( it need not *e unifor&( *ut can depend on

the need( infrastructure and other rele)ant criteria( for&alised as a clear

and equita*le policy to incenti)i1e Me&*ers to de)elop the sport

In keepin' with the a*o)e principle( and notwithstandin' any 

sense of senti&ent( there would also *e no place for &ultiple

associations fro& a sin'le State The Co&&ittee is of the )iew that it *e

left to the !CCI to decide which of the B associations fro& 2u:arat and

Maharashtra would *e taken to represent the entire State( and the

re&ainin' ; associations fro& each State would *eco&e .ssociate

Me&*ers( who would howe)er continue to field tea&s for co&petitions

~ 19 ~

Page 20: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 20/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

as they ha)e done in the past Equally( in States where there are disputes

concernin' the appropriate 'o)ernin' *ody 3a&&u 6 Dash&ir( !ihar(

Ra:asthan( etcN( it is *est left to the !CCI or the Court "as &ay *e the

case% to decide which association would represent the State

 .s the Ser)ices( Railways and Uni)ersities ha)e hitherto en:oyed

ull Me&*er ri'hts althou'h they do not represent a particular State( the

Co&&ittee reco&&ends that they *e accorded the status of .ssociate

Me&*er so that their )iews &ay still *e considered while they will not

ha)e )otin' ri'hts The sa&e principle would apply to the Clu*s "CCI and

CC%( which do not field cricket tea&s and ha)e no cause to *e treated as

ull Me&*ers

Those e,istin' Me&*ers who are affected *y the chan'es su''ested

 *y the Co&&ittee &ust appreciate that the chan'es are *ein' su''ested

in the interest of the 'a&e as a whole and also ha)in' re'ard to !CCI$s

role as a national *ody to pro&ote and control cricket in India

2o)ernance of cricket *ein' the central the&e( the chan'es in

&e&*ership in the !CCI are ine)ita*le and &ust *e seen *y all

concerned in the ri'ht spirit of fair representation and for the *etter&ent

of cricket ad&inistration

 Lhile there are se)en Union Territories( it was found that only 

Felhi and Puducherry ha)e a Chief Minister and are treated as

~ 20 ~

Page 21: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 21/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

su*stantially independent 'o)ernin' entities .t first 'lance( there see&s

no rationale for a distinction *etween the two( *ut what cannot *e denied

is the fact that Felhi( apart fro& *ein' the national capital( is also a

&a:or Test Centre with an international stadiu& and has nearly ;8 ti&es

the population of Puducherry There &ay thus *e so&e &erit for

Puducherry not i&&ediately *ein' included as a ull Me&*er( especially 

 when the issue is sub judice .&on' the Union Territories( it would

howe)er *e appropriate for Puducherry to *e now inducted *y the !CCI

as an .ssociate Me&*er which will retain ri'hts to field a tea& and

co&pete

The consequence of the a*o)e reali'n&ents would also ha)e an

effect on how the Gones are constituted The Gones would consist of 

Me&*ers in such a &anner that each of the& would *e reasona*ly 

 *alanced as far as co&petition for the )arious 1onal tourna&ents is

concerned Howe)er( this reconstitution is *est left to the !CCI for the

purposes of con)enience and co&petition It is also left to the discretion

of the !CCI whether the Union Territories would field indi)idual or

co&*ined tea&s for tourna&ents and whether( for the purposes of 

e,pediency and con)enience( the tea&s representin' the States of the

orth+East *e co&*ined as well

~ 21 ~

Page 22: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 22/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

The cate'ories of .ffiliate and uture Me&*ers are therefore to *e

re&o)ed( and only ull Me&*ers and .ssociate Me&*ers will re&ain(

the for&er with )otin' ri'hts and the latter without The @ associations

fro& the States of Maharashtra and 2u:arat which would *e rele'ated to

the cate'ory of .ssociate Me&*ers shall( howe)er( continue to recei)e

'rants for cricket de)elop&ent( as &ay *e assessed *y the !CCI

dependin' on infrastructure and rele)ant criteria They will also field

tea&s in the do&estic tourna&ents and host international &atches

It is i&perati)e that all players across the country ha)e

opportunities to represent their States and Gones and then the national

tea& To punish the innocent residents and players of a State for the real

or percei)ed shortco&in' of the Me&*er .ssociation is illo'ical and

unaccepta*le E)en if an alternate .ssociation is not readily a)aila*le(

!CCI should function as the  parens patriae of Indian cricket and

continue to pro)ide equal and alternate a)enues for that particular State

The Model Me&orandu& of .ssociation and Rules 6 Re'ulations

of !CCI are at ANNE,RE-A 

~ 22 ~

Page 23: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 23/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

(hapte# T&%* G%e#nan$e

O)er the last two decades( and especially with the ad)ent of the

IP4( the co&ple,ion of the office *earers of the !CCI has su*stantially 

chan'ed Those who hel& the 'a&e co&e fro& &i,ed &ilieu - so&e are

patrons seekin' to pro&ote the sport( while others seek to pro&ote

the&sel)es( with no particular attention *ein' paid to cricket itself

There can *e no two )iews that cricket( with its popularity and its

finances ou'ht to *e run professionally Towards this end( it is

i&perati)e that a stron' 'o)ernance structure is put in place( which will

 *e at ar&$s len'th fro& the actual day+to+day &ana'e&ent of the

association and the 'a&e

The reins of cricket$s richest and ar'ua*ly &ost powerful national

 *ody re&ains &ired in contro)ersy Lith an indi)idual+centric

constitution and old power centres that ha)e re&ained relati)ely 

unaltered for years( the !CCI see&s to ha)e strayed fro& its chosen path

It has found it difficult to control and &ana'e the IP4( and its &ost

successful )enture threatens its e,istence in its present for& There

see&s to *e no collecti)e interest in the 'a&e *ein' pro&oted( and

cricket stands without a custodian for its protection and propa'ation in

its &ost passionately followed nation

~ 23 ~

Page 24: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 24/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

 Problems

a Concentration of powerro& o)erall superintendence of the !oard and its affairs to

takin' action a'ainst players and e)en appro)in' the co&position

of the tea& chosen *y the Selectors( the President is all+powerful

In practice( this power was e)en a*used with the e,ercise of )eto

o)er the chan'es in captaincy and selection of ICC

representati)es Incu&*ents were also known to turn a *lind eye

 when issues of corruption and &is&ana'e&ent were *rou'ht to

their notice( e)en 'oin' as far as per&ittin' retrospecti)e

a&end&ents to the *ye+laws to fa)our particular interests * 4ack of co&petence

The runnin' of an or'anisation like the !CCI requires a clear

functionin' structure with well defined ideas to *e e,ecuted The

present Lorkin' Co&&ittee of the !CCI consistin' of the )arious

office *earers elected *y the !CCI and other representati)es of the

Me&*ers do not ha)e any &ana'erial e,pertise and requisite

e,perience to run !CCI in a professional &anner Specialists and

professionals are usually en'a'ed in an ad+hoc &anner without

any ter&s and tenures as would *e e,pected with any *illion

dollar entity

c O)erlap of di)erse functionsTo *orrow an analo'y fro& political 'o)ernance( it is necessary 

that the &akin' of laws and re'ulations "le'islati)e functions% are

~ 24 ~

Page 25: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 25/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

di)orced fro& i&ple&entation thereof "e,ecuti)e functions% and

those that re)iew their )alidity or i&ple&entation ":udicial

functions% .s far as the !CCI is concerned( the Lorkin'

Co&&ittee not only lays down the rele)ant rules( re'ulations and

 *ye+laws that 'o)ern the !CCI( *ut also o)ersee their

i&ple&entation and takes final decisions when a Me&*er or third

party challen'es either the rule or the &anner of its

i&ple&entation These o)erlaps pro)ide for e,tre&ely 

co&plicated and &essy functionin'd Gonal considerations

There see&s to *e no rational *asis for the Presidency to *e

rotated as per Gones( which has the effect of forsakin' &erit . 

person who has the support of as few as two or three &e&*ers in

his Gone &ay end up as the President( if it is the turn of that Gone

for election of President Recent a&end&ents to the rules ha)e

per&itted indi)iduals who are not e)en fro& the 1one in question

to *e no&inated to the post or the sa&e reason( the 5ice+

Presidents who are elected fro& each of the fi)e 1ones see& to *e

&erely orna&ental without any specific functionse o representation to players

It is only *y accident that players are elected to the Lorkin'

Co&&ittee of the !CCI Their )iews are( &ore often than not(

i'nored( and the lack of an assured position at the 'o)ernance

ta*le lea)es the players 'ra)ely ha&strun' Lith ar*itrary 

~ 25 ~

Page 26: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 26/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

contracts and salaries that are dwarfed *y those playin' for

franchises( it is full credit to the national players that they 

continue with enthusias& and patriotic fer)our to do their *est

for the country when they ha)e no say in the affairs of the )ery 

 *ody towards which they are the pri&ary contri*utorsf o representation to wo&en

The !CCI has ne)er seen a wo&an in the Lorkin' Co&&ittee(

and for a *ody that runs the sport in the country( the !CCI ou'ht

to ha)e *estowed 'reater attention to the wo&en$s 'a&e

 .ustralia( ew Gealand( En'land and e)en Pakistan are seen to

re'ularly play the wo&en$s 'a&e with only 'o)ernance apathy 

responsi*le for the Indian wo&en$s tea& playin' few and far

 *etween in all for&s of the 'a&e 2reater support and pro&otion

is required so that youn'sters &ay also *e attracted to it' o independent )oice

The !CCI has not e&*raced the &odern principles of open

'o)ernance( which is all the &ore necessary when dischar'in'

such far reachin' pu*lic functions The Lorkin' Co&&ittee

consists entirely of representati)es of the ull Me&*ers( there*y 

&akin' it$s functionin' a closed+door affair with no

representation of players or audit e,perts to act as checks on

'o)ernanceh Unli&ited ter&s and tenures

Many indi)iduals occupy )arious posts in the !CCI for &ultiple

ter&s and on &ultiple occasions( without any ceilin' li&it There

~ 26 ~

Page 27: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 27/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

has e)en *een an instance of a for&er President later *eco&in'

the Treasureri o disqualifications

There appears to *e no 'round on which an office *earer has to

de&it office o principles of conflict of interest( of a'e( of 

con)iction *y a cri&inal court or of holdin' an office under the

2o)ern&ent has *een laid down to disqualify an office *earer

 Solutions

The 'o)ernance of the !CCI &ust *e decentralised o indi)idual

is &ore i&portant than the institution( and so all crucial powers and

functions hitherto *estowed e,clusi)ely on the President will ha)e to *e

di)ided across the 'o)ernin' *ody( which is to *e known as the .pe,

Council "with a special and separate 'o)ernin' *ody for IP4( known as

IP4 2o)ernin' Council%

The issue of co&petence re'ardin' those &ana'in' the 'a&e has

to *e addressed *y *rin'in' in professional &ana'ers and area e,perts( a

the&e which is discussed in detail in Chapter B

 .s the 1onal rotation policy is without any rational *asis( and as it

has *een decided to keep the State as the unit to *eco&e a ull Me&*er(

it is consistent to ha)e a president who is elected fro& a&on' the ull

Me&*ers( so that the *est and &ost co&petent person is selected The

pro)ision for fi)e 5ice+Presidents is detri&ental to efficiency and efficacy 

~ 27 ~

Page 28: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 28/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

and so only one 5ice+President shall *e elected to the .pe, Council in

the sa&e &anner as the Secretary( 3oint Secretary and Treasurer

The .pe, Council should ha)e a fair &i, of elected representati)es

and independent &e&*ers It is reco&&ended that it shall *e a nine+

&e&*er *ody The fi)e elected Office !earers of !CCI "President( 5ice+

President( Secretary( 3oint Secretary and Treasurer% shall *e the

&e&*ers of the .pe, Council In addition( the .pe, Council shall ha)e

four other #Councillors$ - two "one &ale( one fe&ale% to *e no&inated *y 

the Players$ .ssociation which is to *e for&ed( one to *e elected *y the

ull Me&*ers of !CCI fro& a&on'st the&sel)es and one to *e

no&inated *y the Co&ptroller 6 .uditor 2eneral of India These

&easures address the followin' concerns=

a Transparency is *rou'ht in( and independent )oices are heard

in the 'o)ernance of the !CCI for the first ti&eK

 * The pu*lic are the pri&ary stakeholders in the 'a&e while its

players for& its )ery core Their in)ol)e&ent throu'h these

representati)es is &ost deser)in' and lon' awaited

c .s wo&en are nearly half the population of the country( the

ano&alous fact that they do not ha)e a )oice in the 'o)ernance

of the sport that has a #*illion hearts$ *eatin' for it is now 

rectified

~ 28 ~

Page 29: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 29/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

d The no&inee of the C6.2 also *rin's financial and audit

e,perience which would *rin' in &uch required o)ersi'ht into

&onitorin' the finances of the !CCI

e It continues to ensure a stron' say for the ull Me&*ers( as it

pro)ides that two+thirds$ stren'th on the Council is &ade up of 

their representati)es

In order to ensure that the posts are not treated as per&anent

positions of power( each ter& should *e for three years The total period

for which a person can *e a &e&*er of the .pe, Council shall *e nine

 years re'ardless of the capacity in which such position was or is

occupied Howe)er( in order to ensure that there is an appropriate

coolin'+off period( no person shall *e a &e&*er of the .pe, Council for

two consecuti)e ter&s  .ny elected Councillor shall stand auto&atically 

disqualified after nine years as an office *earer( and shall also *e

disqualified fro& contestin' or holdin' the post if he has co&pleted the

a'e of 8 years( is char'ed under the penal law( is declared to *e of 

unsound &ind( is a Minister or 'o)ern&ent ser)ant or holds any post of 

another sports *ody in the country .ny no&inated Councillor howe)er(

 would not ha)e &ore than one ter& in office The endea)our in this

re'ard is to filter those who are a*le and enthusiastic to 'o)ern the 'a&e

that is the national passion

~ 29 ~

Page 30: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 30/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

~ 30 ~

Page 31: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 31/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

(hapte# Th#ee* Mana/eent

Uni)ersally( all co&petent sports or'anisations thri)e on ha)in'

professionals in char'e of the actual ad&inistration of the 'a&e(

 *rin'in' to it the )ery skills that are so positi)ely utili1ed for *i'

corporations and *usinesses .spects of operations( &arketin'( hu&an

resources( re'ulatory( strate'y and finances are looked at keepin' the

preser)ation and de)elop&ent of the sport as the pri&ary consideration

Thus( 'o)ernance and policy direction are kept separate fro& the actual

i&ple&entation of that )ision

These &ultiple tiers e,ist internationally in the oot*all

 .ssociation ".% of the United Din'do&( the ederation Internationale

de oot*all .ssociation "I.% and the ederation Internationale de

Hockey sur 2a1on "IH% Si&ilar structures e,ist in the do&estic lea'ues

for *ase*all( *asket*all and .&erican foot*all in the United States

"M4!( !. and 4 respecti)ely% Such a co&position has also *een

proposed in the Carter 6 Crawford Report on Cricket .ustralia

 .s the .pe, Council of the !CCI is not equipped to deal with issues

of cricketin' and non+cricketin' &ana'e&ent( it is felt that a separate

run' for day+to+day &ana'e&ent and 'uidance *e created The purpose

of this is to &o)e fro& ad+hocis& to institutionalisation The !CCI and

its Me&*ers will ha)e to now run as co&panies do( with specific

~ 31 ~

Page 32: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 32/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

responsi*ilities placed on full+ti&e professionals with esta*lished skill+

sets( with reportin' syste&s( hi'h+le)el IT solutions and no interference

fro& the 'o)ernors

 Lhile the non+cricketin' &ana'e&ent will ha)e to *e *y 

professional &ana'ers headed *y a CEO "who will act as a nodal officer%(

the pure cricketin' &atters "selection( coachin' and perfor&ance

e)aluation% deser)e to *e left e,clusi)ely to the e,+players who ha)e the

'reater do&ain knowled'e( e,cept for u&pirin' which should si&ilarly 

 *e handled e,clusi)ely *y u&pires .s also the CEO( these Cricket and

U&pires Co&&ittees would *e accounta*le directly to the .pe, Council

The IP4$s 2o)ernin' Council would howe)er report directly to the

'eneral *ody of the !CCI

There would also *e two Co&&ittees that would *e ad)isory in

nature - the Tours( i,tures 6 Technical Co&&ittee and the

Tourna&ents Co&&ittee Their ad)ice would 'uide the CEO and the

Mana'ers in &ana'in' the affairs of the !CCI( *ut it would *e the CEO

 who would *e accounta*le to the .pe, Council

The CEO would ideally *e a person with &ana'erial e,perience for

fi)e years as the MF>CEO of a corporation with an annual turno)er of at

least Rs788 crore There would *e a &a,i&u& of si, &ana'ers to assist

the CEO who would ha)e e,pertise pri&arily in the strea&s of 

~ 32 ~

Page 33: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 33/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

Operations( inance( Technical( Co&pliance "le'al%( Hu&an Resources

and Media The CEO would *e on contract with the !CCI and ha)e a

fi,ed tenure of fi)e years "unless the contract is ter&inated *y &utual

a'ree&ent or *y a B &onths$ notice *y either party%( whereas the

Mana'ers will *e career e&ployees The functions of the CEO would

for& the core of the or'ani1ational dealin's of the !CCI( and he &ay 

distri*ute or dele'ate the& in any &anner he chooses a&on' the

Mana'ers It will *e his pri&ary &andate to cater to the two &ain

contri*utors to the 'a&e of cricket - the fans and the players - and to

take all &easures to acco&&odate their needs It will also *e the duty of 

the CEO to ensure that all non+cricketin' and lo'istical concerns of the

Players are duly addressed throu'h dedicated personnel so that the tea&

can concentrate sin'le+&indedly on what they do *est= playin' cricket

Inno)ation in cricket ad&inistration is the need of the hour The

ourth Test of the India+South .frica reedo& Series that recently 

concluded in ew Felhi has de&onstrated how inno)ati)e thinkin' in

fillin' up the otherwise e&pty stands *y per&ittin' school children to

 )iew the &atch free or at no&inal prices has created 'reater interest in

the 'a&e

The Cricket Co&&ittees would *e se)en in nu&*er dealin' with

selection( coachin'( perfor&ance e)aluation and talent resource

~ 33 ~

Page 34: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 34/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

de)elop&ent of Men( Lo&en( 3unior( Gonal and Fifferently+.*led

tea&s Each of these Co&&ittees would co&prise only for&er players In

accordance with su*stantial feed*ack and reco&&endations in )arious

other real&s as well( a three &e&*er co&&ittee for selection is thou'ht

to *e ideal These Co&&ittees would answer directly to the .pe, Council

althou'h their quarterly reports would *e routed to the Council )ia the

CEO

Ordinarily( spottin' talent at the hi'hest le)el is a continuous

e,ercise for the national selection co&&ittee !ut now since the Cricket

Talent Co&&ittee has *een separately constituted( restrictin' the

selectors to B &e&*ers will also *e &ore co&pact( and increase the

authority of the selection co&&ittee and &ake it accounta*le for tea&

perfor&ance

 . &ost unfortunate fact that was &ade known to the Co&&ittee

 was that the Indian wo&en$s cricket tea& had last played a Test Match

 years a'o Coupled with 'eneral chau)inis&( the wo&en players recei)e

paltry earnin's and ha)e only a one &onth lon' do&estic season Unlike

other countries includin' nei'h*ours Sri 4anka and Pakistan( no central

contracts are 'i)en to wo&en players( and not e)en s&all &easures like

co&pli&entary tickets for &atches are pro)ided to the& The Lo&en$s

Cricket Co&&ittee is to *e therefore for&ed to e,clusi)ely pay attention

~ 34 ~

Page 35: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 35/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

to this &uch i'nored depart&ent in addition to the Lo&en$s Selection

Co&&ittee

 Lhile the !CCI is the parent *ody 'o)ernin' cricket in India(

neither the Constitutional docu&ents of the !CCI nor the we*site and

other &aterial a)aila*le su''est any pro&otion or association with

cricket for the differently+a*led( which is a si'nificant o&ission In a

nation such as ours( with its passion for cricket( it is all the &ore

i&portant to take alon' all sections in an endea)our to pro&ote the

sport( and &ake Indian cricket truly inclusi)e . fine e,a&ple of this is

the En'land Fisa*ility Cricket Pathway produced *y the En'land 6

 Lales Cricket !oard( which shows how this section of society can *e

sensiti)ely dealt with The Fifferently+.*led Cricket Co&&ittee will

hopefully take 'uidance fro& the En'lish effort in *rin'in' the )arious

disa*led tea&s under a sin'le u&*rella in order to &ake a concerted

effort to i&pro)e Indian cricket

The U&pires Co&&ittee is another Co&&ittee co&prisin' only 

U&pires( which conducts tests( considers confidential reports and selects

and classifies u&pires for officiatin' 'a&es under the auspices of the

!CCI This Co&&ittee would also report directly to the .pe, Council

The structure that should *e put in place is illustrated *y the

followin' chart=

~ 35 ~

Page 36: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 36/155

H

 

E

E

A

 

O

 Y

F

H

 

C

I

H

 

E

E

A

 

O

 Y

F

H

 

C

I

T

H

E

 A

P

E

X

 

C

O

U

N

C

I

T

H

E

 A

P

E

X

 

C

O

U

N

C

I

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

 .part fro&  the 7B /Standin' Co&&ittees0 that find &ention in the

Constitution of the !CCI( there are se)eral do1en other Co&&ittees that

are created fro& ti&e to ti&e( usually *ased on the ad+hoc decision of 

the President of the ti&e These include the )ery speciali1ed #5i11y 

Trophy Co&&ittee$( #the T5 Production Co&&ittee$( #the 2round 6

Pitches Co&&ittee$( #the Museu& Co&&ittee$ and se)eral &ore

Representati)es of the ull Me&*ers are distri*uted across the

Co&&ittees( althou'h their &eetin's( work done( 'oals &et and 'eneral

purpose are not considered So&eti&es( as was the case with the recently 

~ 36 ~

Page 37: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 37/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

constituted #Cricket .d)isory Co&&ittee$( the &e&*ers the&sel)es find

no roles assi'ned( nor instructions 'i)en as to what is to *e done

The present Mana'e&ent structure does away with the need for

such Co&&ittees that e)entually ser)e no purpose other than to e,pend

the !CCI$s resources Howe)er( two Standin' Co&&ittees are retained in

&odified for&s for the purpose of pro)idin' 'uidance and ad)ice to the

CEO and his Mana'ers( especially as they will *e new to the functionin'

of the !CCI These are the Senior Tourna&ents Co&&ittee( and the

Tours( i,tures 6 Technical Co&&ittee

~ 37 ~

Page 38: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 38/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

(hapte# F%)#* I

The phrase /cash cow0 has *een e&ployed to descri*e the T+;8

lea'ue that has captured the i&a'ination of a 'eneration !i' &oney(

!ollywood stars( e,patriate cheerleaders( *larin' &usic and a 'lo*al

audience ca&e to'ether to create this 'rand carni)al in ;88( which

looks set to continue una*ated as it readies to enter its ninth season

True to its na&e( it has *eco&e a #pre&ier lea'ue$

The fact that the IP4 is the sin'le lar'est re)enue 'enerator for the

!CCI cannot *e lost si'ht of Lithout the IP4( &uch of the &edia

attention and international interest would *e lost Howe)er( the

'o)ernance of the IP4 has left &uch to *e desired( run as it is *y a

Co&&ittee of twel)e which denies any role to the franchisee co&panies

 who are responsi*le for fosterin' co&petition and &akin' re)enue Once

a'ain( there is no independent )oice( with ten of the &e&*ers

representin' the ull Me&*ers and two *ein' for&er cricketers hand+

picked *y the !oard The IP4 2o)ernin' Council needs to *e

reconstituted with &ore autono&y( co&prisin' not only of 

representati)es of the ull Me&*ers( *ut also of ranchisees( Players and

an independent auditor

The Co&&ittee proposes a 2o)ernin' Council with only nine

&e&*ers( co&prisin' of three e,+officio &e&*ers "the Secretary( the

~ 38 ~

Page 39: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 39/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

Treasurer and the CEO of !CCI%( two representati)es of the &e&*ers of 

!CCI to *e elected *y the 2eneral !ody( two no&inees of the

ranchisees( one no&inee *ein' the C6.2$s Councillor on the .pe,

Council and one *ein' a no&inee of the Players$ .ssociation .s per this

arran'e&ent( four out of nine &e&*ers of the IP4 2o)ernin' Council

 will *e independent of !CCI( there*y pro)idin' a &uch+needed

autono&y and *alance in &ana'e&ent of the &ost lucrati)e enterprise

of the !oard One of the two representati)es of the Me&*ers of !CCI

elected *y the 2eneral !ody shall *e the Chairperson of the 2o)ernin'

Council It is clarified that the no&inees of the ranchisees shall rotate

on an annual *asis and no ranchisee shall *e represented a'ain until all

others ha)e had a turn

This Co&&ittee also reco&&ends that the Co&&ittees >

Co&&issions to *e appointed under the IP4 Re'ulations ".nti+

Corruption Code( Code of Conduct( Operational Rules( etc(% ou'ht to

consist of &e&*ers selected *y a panel of the O&*uds&an( the Ethics

Officer and the CEO which shall *e presided o)er *y the O&*uds&an

This will ensure independence fro& the !CCI

The fact that IP4 players( &any with &odest credentials( are richly 

re&unerated *y the ranchisees while those who don India colours and

 *rin' laurels to the nation are re&unerated less is also a &atter of 

~ 39 ~

Page 40: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 40/155

Page 41: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 41/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

(hapte# Fie* a4e#s5 Ass%$iati%n 6 A/ent Re/ist#ati%n

Two of the necessary initiati)es that the Co&&ittee reco&&ends

concern an association for Players and a strict set of procedures to

'o)ern players$ .'ents Lhile al&ost all Test playin' nations ha)e a

Players$ .ssociation( there see&s to ha)e *een reluctance on the part of 

the !CCI to initiate such a &o)e( ostensi*ly due to the apprehension of 

unionisation !oth En'land and .ustralia ha)e a'ents$ accreditation

syste&s in place to ensure that only those professionals who qualify 

throu'h a ri'orous knowled'e and ethics selection process can alone

represent the players These syste&s are ad&inistered *y the national

 *oard in con:unction with the respecti)e players$ associations

!.1 a4e#s5 Ass%$iati%n

To *e one a&on' the select few that &akes up the Indian national

cricket tea& is no easy task The stiffness of co&petition and the wei'ht

of pu*lic e,pectation fro& national players are e,tre&ely de&andin'(

and that &akes their *urden hea)ier

 . )ery i&portant step towards i&pro)in' the lot of the players is to

'i)e the& a )oice to raise their concerns and ha)e the& discussed with

the !CCI .part fro& this( in cricketin' &atters( the e,+cricketersJ skill(

e,pertise and e,perience deser)e to *e utilised for the *etter&ent of the

'a&e .s e)ery other Test Playin' nation has a Players$ .ssociation( and

~ 41 ~

Page 42: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 42/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

e)en the Players$ representati)e at the ICC is an Indian( it is only fittin'

that an independent Players$ .ssociation is esta*lished This .ssociation

shall *e co&prised only of Players who ha)e retired fro& co&petiti)e

cricket in all for&s of the 'a&e It will *e for such .ssociation to

no&inate representati)es fro& a&on'st its &e&*ers to the 2o)ernin'

!ody and .pe, Council In order that the .ssociation is esta*lished and

functions in a reasona*le &anner( the financial needs should *e &et *y 

the !CCI

It would *e &ost appropriate that this .ssociation is esta*lished *y 

the players the&sel)es and *rou'ht into effect *y an Honorary 

Co&&ittee of @ &e&*ers( which shall *e the Steerin' Co&&ittee The

&e&*ers of this Steerin' Co&&ittee shall *e=

a Mr2DPillai( or&er Union Ho&e Secretary "Chairperson% * MrMohinder .&arnath( or&er ational Cricketerc MsFiana Edul:i( or&er ational Cricketerd Mr.nil Du&*le( or&er ational Cricketer

It shall *e the task of the Steerin' Co&&ittee( as early as possi*le(

 with the assistance of the !CCI( to identify and in)ite all eli'i*le E,+

Cricketers to *e &e&*ers of the .ssociation( to open *ank accounts(

recei)e funds fro& the !CCI( conduct the first elections for office

 *earers( co&&unicate the na&es of !CCI player no&inees to the !oard

and take all necessary steps in this re'ard The &odel code for the

Cricket Players$ .ssociation is at ANNE,RE-'

~ 42 ~

Page 43: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 43/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

!.2 A/ents5 Re/ist#ati%n

There e,ist 'ra)e concerns a*out those who act as a'ents of 

players Their *ack'rounds are nor&ally unknown( as are the

co&&ercial arran'e&ents entered into *y and on *ehalf of the players

The conduct of players in the last few years has also shown that they 

ha)e not *een properly infor&ed and instructed a*out the applica*le

principles and ethics 'o)ernin' the !CCI( the IP4 and the 'a&e

It is the o*li'ation of the Players$ .'ent to ensure proper

infor&ation and adherence to all nor&s *y his client and also to protect

the player fro& any suspicious contact or questiona*le o)ertures

The nor&s for .'ents$ Re'istration are 'i)en in ANNE,RE-(

and this will *e ad&inistered *y the !CCI in consultation with the

Cricket Players$ .ssociation

~ 43 ~

Page 44: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 44/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

(hapte# +ix* (%n7i$t %7 Inte#est

The e)ents that ha)e led up to this Report re)ol)e around one oft+

quoted and little understood concept= Conflict of Interest The fact that

indi)iduals in positions of trust( ad:udication and 'o)ernance &ust

conduct the&sel)es in a &anner not re&otely su''esti)e of co&pro&ise

has *een an underpinnin' of all 'o)ernance in the ci)ili1ed world In the

courts( an oft+quoted precept is /:ustice &ust not only *e done( *ut &ust

also *e seen to *e done0 Howe)er( the last few years of 'o)ernance at the

!CCI has re)ealed that there is( at *est( an e,tre&ely casual

understandin' of the concept of Conflict of Interest

In our interactions with )arious stakeholders( it *eca&e apparent

that the understandin' of the concept of Conflict of Interest *y a Player

or Official is )ery different fro& that of a le'al professional who is

attuned to conflict &echanis&s and their a)oidance on a daily *asis

Se)eral cricketers of i&pecca*le repute were surprised when queried

a*out what were o*)iously potential conflict situations( needin' to *e

con)inced that no wron'doin' was necessary for a conflict to e,ist The

Co&&ittee had to point out to the& that the )ery holdin' of a position

 which could *e a*used to under&ine the inte'rity of the 'a&e renders

the occupant )ulnera*le to such a char'e

~ 44 ~

Page 45: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 45/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

Furin' the course of the last few &onths( the Co&&ittee has co&e

to learn of se)eral instances of o*)ious conflict where contracts ha)e

 *een entered into *y the !CCI( where the contractor or )endor includes

fa&ily &e&*ers of an Office !earer The fact that there was no )oluntary 

disclosure &akes &atters worse( raisin' a presu&ption of wron'doin'

and su*terfu'e a'ainst the indi)iduals in question

Understanda*ly( &uch of this is left to the su*:ecti)e assess&ent of 

the person concerned In consonance with the practice internationally(

either undertakin's or declarations are furnished as so&e for& of 

inde&nity( or in &ore o*)ious situations( sanctions are i&posed !efore

the IP4( it could well ha)e *een ar'ued that the !CCI felt no cause to

take steps in this re'ard( *ut with its ad)ent( the conduct of the !CCI has

 *een to acco&&odate the conflict rather than to pre)ent it

Unfortunately( &atters needed to reach the hi'hest court of the land

 *efore the !CCI decided to take tentati)e steps towards settin' its house

in order

The seriousness of conflict of interest affectin' sport cannot *e

underesti&ated Lhile it &ay see& surprisin' to the indi)idual

ad&inistrator or player that their position could *e capa*le of such an

interpretation( it is out of a*undant caution in the interests of the game(

that its re'ulation is &andated In &ost( if not all cases( there is no

~ 45 ~

Page 46: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 46/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

question *ein' raised a*out the inte'rity of the indi)idual( *ut it is out of 

concern that the occupation of a particular post should not allow 

reasona*le presu&ptions or inferences to *e drawn a*out the

co&pro&ise which could ensue( that would in turn lower the di'nity of 

the 'a&e

 . 'lance at the )arious international sports *odies such as I.(

ICC( IH and .C that are considered in the appendi, to this Report

 would show that conflict of interest issues are central to the re'ulation of 

ethical conduct in sport This is why the ad&inistration of these

principles is coupled with the appoint&ent of a responsi*le and

independent indi)idual who assists the or'anisation in the

ad&inistration of the policy

E)en as this report is *ein' prepared( two further IP4 franchises

ha)e *een added( and questions re'ardin' conflict of interest are raised(

 which cannot *e satisfactorily addressed *y the policy in place

The Co&&ittee has therefore spelt out specific types of Conflict of 

Interest( and applied the& to indi)iduals e&ployed with( or connected to

the !CCI E)ery Office !earer( Player( Councillor( E&ployee(

 .d&inistrator( Tea& Official( U&pire or other person connected to the

!CCI( its Me&*ers or the IP4 and its ranchisees is &andated to a)oid

any act or o&ission which is( or is percei)ed to *e( likely to *rin' the

~ 46 ~

Page 47: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 47/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

interest of the indi)idual in conflict with the interest of the 'a&e of 

cricket In order to pro)ide clarity( the conflicts ha)e *een *roadly 

classified as tracta*le and intracta*le( with separate solutions or

sanctions as the case &ay *e .n Ethics Officer is also to *e appointed

 who would ad&inister the policy for the !CCI

 

~ 47 ~

Page 48: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 48/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

(hapte# +een* O8)dsan Ethi$s 6 Ee$t%#a O77i$e#s

The functionin' of the !CCI cannot *e truly transparent and

independent without the creation of B new authorities essential to its

functionin' in its new a)atar One to resol)e  internal conflicts

independent of the !CCI( another to ad&inister the principles 'o)ernin'

conflict of interest ( and a third to ensure that the  process of selectin'

office *earers is clean and transparent

:.1 The O8)dsan

 .s the 'enesis of this Co&&ittee has shown( there are se)eral disputes

that e,ist within the !CCI( *orn out of years of apathy in 'o)ernance and

'ross &is&ana'e&ent The co&pact entered into *etween the State

 .ssociations on the one hand and the !CCI on the other has rarely *een

equita*le and *alanced( with the latter e,ercisin' its he'e&ony o)er the

constituents The Co&&ittee feels that as with any quasi+federal

structure( the relationship &ust *e carefully &oderated in an o*:ecti)e

&anner Thus far( it is the !oard that has *een e,ercisin' this function(

i&&ediately *eco&in' a :ud'e in its own cause The fact that certain

associations ha)e *een reco'ni1ed as the le'iti&ate representati)es of 

their States has led to dis'runtle&ent and liti'ation( not least fro&

!ihar Ra:asthan tells a different tale( with the election of an apparently 

unpalata*le fi'ure &akin' the entire association( and thus the State(

~ 48 ~

Page 49: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 49/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

 persona non grata In *oth 3a&&u 6 Dash&ir and Felhi &eanwhile(

ri)al factions ha)e atte&pted to field alternate tea&s( &uch to the

dis'ust of the players who are used as pawns in the political 'a&e

Such instances are &ere illustrations of a lar'er &alaise - the

a*sence of a suita*le dispute resolution process E)en an ar*itration

syste& as hitherto e,isted is insufficient( and palpa*ly inappropriate as it

often pitted two unequals a'ainst each other( with the State association

 *eholden to the !oard for &atches( 'rants and re)enues The challen'es

under the auspices of the .r*itration 6 Conciliation .ct( 799? ine)ita*ly 

dra''ed on in the courts with an ad)ersarial process and its attendant

 *itterness( when an independent entity was the ideal option

In order to reduce the :udicial role and the *urdenin' of the courts

and to e,pedite dispute resolution( the Co&&ittee therefore

reco&&ends the appoint&ent of a retired :ud'e of the Supre&e Court or

a for&er Chief 3ustice of a Hi'h Court as the O&*uds&an of the !CCI(

to *e appointed once a year at the .nnual 2eneral Meetin' This

O&*uds&an shall( either on a reference *y the .pe, Council or on a

co&plaint *y a Me&*er>ranchisee>Gone>Players$ .ssociation> Player>

Tea& Official> .d&inistrator or suo motu "on its own%( in)esti'ate and

resol)e any dispute *etween the !oard and any of the a*o)e entities or

~ 49 ~

Page 50: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 50/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

a&on' the&sel)es *y followin' due principles of natural :ustice(

production of e)idence and fair hearin'

The O&*uds&an &ay also entertain and redress any 'rie)ance or

co&plaint *y &e&*ers of the pu*lic if they concern ticketin'( access and

facilities at stadia( and lack of transparency in the award of contracts for

'oods and ser)ices

:.2 The Ethi$s O77i$e#

The &onitorin' of the principles of Conflict of Interest alon' with

the Code of !eha)iour of the !CCI and any other such rules shall *e done

 *y an Ethics Officer His powers include the layin' down of additional

'uidelines or *ye+laws on ethics( the initiation of in)esti'ation or

ad:udicatory proceedin's and the award of warnin's( fines( repri&ands(

suspensions or other action as &ay *e reco&&ended to the !CCI

In addition( the !CCI and the IP4 ha)e codes of conduct and

 *eha)iour for .d&inistrators( Tea& Officials( U&pires and Players *oth

on and off the field( includin' in relation to &atch fi,in'( *ettin'( non+

reportin' of suspicious approaches( dopin'( etc The approach of the

!CCI in recent years in ad&inisterin' these Codes has not *een

encoura'in'( especially when powerful fi'ures in the sport were

in)ol)ed

~ 50 ~

Page 51: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 51/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

The Co&&ittee has referred to the role of Ethics Officer in

constitutin' Co&&ittees>Co&&issions under the IP4 Re'ulations while

dealin' with IP4 in Chapter @

 .s far as all non+IP4 ethics issues are concerned( the sa&e shall *e

ad&inistered and ad:udicated *y the Ethics Officer who shall *e a for&er

3ustice of a Hi'h Court to *e appointed *y the !oard

The ull Me&*er associations shall also adopt and o*ser)e all the a*o)e

ethical principles includin' those concernin' Conflict of Interest They 

shall also appoint an Ethics Officer( *ut howe)er( dependin' on

 workload and e,pediency( the O&*uds&an to *e appointed &ay also

dischar'e the functions of an Ethics Officer in an association

 .dditionally( &ultiple States &ay ha)e a co&&on Ethics Officer for the

sake of con)enience and econo&y

:.3 The Ee$t%#a O77i$e#

The e,perience of se)eral elections at the !CCI has shown that while the

'o)ernin' law needs to *e seriously re)isited( it is not sufficient for the

process of elections to *e internally &onitored Especially with the

 )arious disqualifications fro& holdin' office laid down a*o)e( there are

 *ound to *e questions raised ri'ht fro& the )ery inception of the election

process

~ 51 ~

Page 52: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 52/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

The Co&&ittee is of the )iew that whene)er elections are to *e

held( an independent authority needs to *e )ested with the powers of 

scrutini1in' no&inations and clearin' the&( of drawin' up and )erifyin'

the electoral roll after identifyin' appropriate representati)es of the ull

Me&*ers( of ensurin' that no candidate falls foul of the Rules( and for

declaration of results The Electoral Officer will also *e responsi*le for

conductin' elections to the Co&&ittees under the Rules In order to

ensure co&petence and to distance the entity fro& any suspicion or *ias(

the Co&&ittee is of the )iew that a for&er Election Co&&issioner for

India *e appointed as the Electoral Officer for the !CCI( and that his or

her decision would *e final and conclusi)e

~ 52 ~

Page 53: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 53/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

(hapte# Ei/ht* T#anspa#en$4 and Oe#si/ht

Shortly after this Co&&ittee was constituted( an effort was &ade

to )iew the pre)ailin' Constitution and *ye+laws of the !CCI fro& its

 we*site( which pro)ed to *e futile( as the we*site did not carry these

 *asic docu&ents Many stakeholders( in the course of interactions with

the Co&&ittee stated that )ery little of the functionin' of the !CCI is

done in a fair and transparent &anner and that those who seek 'reater

infor&ation are either re*uffed *y the !oard or won o)er *y 

entice&ents Those whose professional li)elihoods depend on cricket

acknowled'e the !CCI$s total sway o)er the sport( and choose to re&ain

silent rather than upset the apple cart

E)en in re'ard to cricket co&&entary( 'a&es or'ani1ed *y the

!CCI ha)e a contractual condition that there can *e no criticis& of the

!CCI or its selection process( there*y curtailin' an e,ercise of free

speech O*:ecti)e co&&entary ou'ht to *e per&itted a*out e)erythin'

connected to the &atch( allowin' the co&&entators to e,press

the&sel)es freely and o*:ecti)ely

 .s the &ediu& is )ery i&portant( it is necessary that to ser)e *oth

Players$ and the pu*lic( all Rules( Re'ulations( Codes and Instructions of 

the !CCI *e translated into Hindi and *oth )ersions *e uploaded onto

the official we*site *y the !CCI and its Me&*ers It is also necessary that

~ 53 ~

Page 54: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 54/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

the !CCI use the latest and updated tools of Infor&ation Technolo'y in

'o)ernance( &ana'e&ent and 'eneral decision &akin'

Co&&erce has also o)ertaken the en:oy&ent of the sport( with

ad)ertise&ents continuin' &any a ti&e( e)en after the first *all and

a'ain co&&encin' e)en *efore the last *all of the o)er is played( there*y 

interruptin' the full and proper *roadcast of the 'a&e Re'ardless of the

 wicket that has fallen( century ha)in' *een hit or other &o&entous

e)ent( full li*erty is 'ranted to &a,i&ise the *roadcaster$s inco&e *y 

cuttin' away to a co&&ercial( there*y ro**in' sport of its &ost

attracti)e attri*ute - e&otion It is reco&&ended that all e,istin'

contracts for international Test 6 One+Fay &atches *e re)ised and new 

ones ensure that only *reaks taken *y *oth tea&s for drinks( lunch and

tea will per&it the *roadcast to *e interrupted with ad)ertise&ents( as is

the practice internationally .lso( the entire space of the screen durin'

the *roadcast will *e dedicated to the display of the 'a&e( sa)e for a

s&all sponsor lo'o or si'n

 . perusal of the e,penses of the !CCI( particularly with reference

to the attendance of &eetin's of the )arious su*+co&&ittees as well as

the e,penses on professional ser)ices su''ests that there ou'ht to *e

 *etter financial &ana'e&ent Deepin' in &ind that the !CCI is not for

~ 54 ~

Page 55: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 55/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

profit( resources &ust *e used for the de)elop&ent of the 'a&e( and

financial prudence &ust *e e,ercised to a)oid unnecessary e,penditure

There appear to *e no standard nor&s and o*:ecti)e criteria for the

selection and e&panel&ent of professionals in the fields of law( audit(

etc Si&ilarly( e)en as far as infrastructure contracts( &edia

en'a'e&ents( tele)ision ri'hts and equip&ent supply( no nor&s or

procedures e,ist to select or en'a'e contractors in a fair and transparent

&anner

In the li'ht of all this( the Co&&ittee proposes that clear principles

of transparency *e laid down( and the !CCI we*site and office will carry 

all rules( re'ulations and office orders of the !CCI( the constitution of the

 )arious co&&ittees( their resolutions( the e,penditures under )arious

heads( the reports of the O&*uds&an>.uditor>Electoral Officer>Ethics

Officer and the annual reports and *alance sheets In addition( nor&s

and procedures shall *e laid down for the en'a'e&ent of ser)ice

professionals and contractors( and there shall *e full transparency of all

tenders floated and *ids in)ited *y or on *ehalf of the !CCI The we*site

shall also ha)e links to the )arious stadia with seatin' capacities and

transparent direct ticketin' facilities

The Ri'ht to Infor&ation .ct( ;88< "#RTI .ct$% enacts that pu*lic

authorities shall &ake known the particulars of the facilities a)aila*le to

~ 55 ~

Page 56: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 56/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

citi1ens Lhile the issue of the !CCI *ein' a&ena*le to the RTI .ct is

sub judice  *efore the Hi'h Court of Madras in LPo;8;;9>;87B(

&any respondents who appeared and interacted with the Co&&ittee

 were of the )iew that !CCI$s acti)ities &ust co&e under the RTI .ct

Ha)in' re'ard to the e&phasis laid *y the Hon$*le Supre&e Court that

!CCI dischar'es pu*lic functions and also the Court$s reference to

indirect appro)al of the Central and State 2o)ern&ents in acti)ities

 which has created a &onopoly in the hands of the !CCI o)er cricket( the

Co&&ittee feels that the people of the country ha)e a ri'ht to know the

details a*out the !CCI$s functions and acti)ities It is therefore

reco&&ended that the le'islature &ust seriously consider *rin'in' !CCI

 within the pur)iew of the RTI .ct

The Co&&ittee also *elie)es that the .uditor *e tasked not only 

 with a financial analysis( *ut also specifically carry out a perfor&ance

audit "Co&pliance Report% to deter&ine whether the State associations

ha)e actually e,pended their 'rants towards the de)elop&ent of the

'a&e and &ark the& on a report card which will *e utili1ed to deter&ine

the due they deser)e the followin' year This o)ersi'ht also needs to

consider the hi'h and unreasona*le e,penditures *y the !oard on

 )arious heads( which would ha)e to *e li&ited and strea&lined

~ 56 ~

Page 57: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 57/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

(hapte# Nine* Mat$h-Fixin/ and 'ettin/

or those fro& an earlier era( cricket was the typical 'entle&an$s

'a&e Clad in whites( 'rown &en would chase after a red leather *all on

sunny 'reens of the En'lish countryside Lith its ad)ent to the su*+

continent and the Cari**ean( cricket saw an uphea)al ow it was an

opiate to the &asses( and it heralded its arri)al with colour( noise and

passion Lhen tele)ision ca&e( it *rou'ht with it an unparalleled reach(

now &akin' the 'a&e a)aila*le to 'lo*al audiences of *illions E)en in

the United States( where it has not attained the pro&inence of the local

sports( international 'a&es are a)aila*le for pay+per+)iew and throu'h

online strea&in'

The re)enue 'enerated *y international cricket( and particularly 

&atches featurin' the Indian tea& are now the su*:ect of endorse&ents(

co&&ercials( pre and post &atch pro'ra&&es and )arious )i'nettes

&easured to e,tract e)ery penny possi*le as re)enue It is not surprisin'

therefore( that it has also attracted the interest of the wa'erin'

co&&unity Lith only horse+racin' le'ally per&issi*le in India( those

interested in *ettin' ha)e 'one under'round( with ille'al *ookies

&ana'in' affairs .s is ine)ita*le( the hawala syste& has awakened to

these channels and &oney launderin' has also *eco&e an ine)ita*le

outco&e

~ 57 ~

Page 58: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 58/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

The last couple of decades ha)e shown a far &urkier side of cricket

- that of &atch fi,in' ro& South .frica to Pakistan( instances of 

players in)ol)ed in influencin' the outco&e of a 'a&e for profit has

caused se)ere da&a'e to the fa*ric of the 'a&e There ha)e *een

alle'ations in India of such nefarious acti)ities( especially when cricket

&o)ed to Shar:ah( and &ore so after the introduction of the cash+rich

IP4 This is pro*a*ly why the ICC decided to take the lead to check such

&alfeasance and instil a definite re'ulatory code a&on' players and

ad&inistrators alike

There is a funda&ental difference *etween *ettin' and

&atch>spot+fi,in' The latter interferes with the inte'rity of the 'a&e

and atte&pts to chan'e the course of the &atch It is ta&perin' the 'a&e

 *y the cricket players to *enefit a few On the other hand( *ettin' is a

'eneral &alaise indul'ed *y different sections of society( not only with

reference to cricket *ut other 'a&es also Lhile the issue of *ettin' can

 *e effecti)ely dealt with *y pro)idin' a le'al fra&ework( &atch>spot+

fi,in' is neither pardona*le nor a &atter for re'ulation The only way to

deal with it is *y &akin' it a cri&inal offence punisha*le *y law The

Co&&ittee reco&&ends appropriate a&end&ents *y the le'islature

 . perusal of the rele)ant !CCI and IP4 re'ulations relatin' to .nti+

Corruption show that the offences are classified under Corruption(

~ 58 ~

Page 59: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 59/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

!ettin' and Misuse of inside infor&ation( and detail the standard of 

proof( the in)esti'ation and sanctions to *e i&posed *y a disciplinary 

co&&ittee !y and lar'e( these pro)isions see& to *e satisfactory to

'o)ern the !CCI( *ut it would *e necessary for the Fisciplinary 

Co&&ittee referred to therein to *e appointed *y a Co&&ittee of the

O&*uds&an( the Ethics Officer and the CEO so that there is so&e

independence in the 'rie)ance redressal process Rele)ant a&end&ents

 would therefore *e necessary to the !CCI and IP4 re'ulations in this

re'ard

 .s far as !ettin' alone is concerned( &any of the respondents

 *efore the Co&&ittee were of the )iew that it would ser)e *oth the 'a&e

and econo&y if it were le'ali1ed as has *een done in the United

Din'do& It cannot *e o)erlooked that the worldwide le'al sports *ettin'

&arket is worth o)er @88 *illion dollars Howe)er( with the interest of 

cricket *ein' fore&ost in our &inds( it would always *e necessary to

protect and in)oke transparency fro& those in)ol)ed in the 'a&e

 Lhile it is our reco&&endation that the le'islatures ou'ht to

le'ali1e *ettin' in cricket( these &ust *e with the followin' safe'uards=

a Re'ulatory watchdo's would *e necessary to ensure that the

 *ettin' houses as well as those transactin' there are strictly 

~ 59 ~

Page 60: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 60/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

&onitored( failin' which their re'istrations would *e

suscepti*le to cancellation * The Players( .d&inistrators and others closely associated

 with the sport would *e required to furnish the details of 

their inco&es and assets for the sake of transparencyc 4icenses would ha)e to *e issued to those placin' the *ets as

 well( with a'e and identification details recordedd Strict penal sanctions would ha)e to *e i&posed on those

trans'ressin' the license and other require&ents

eedless to say( *ettin' *y .d&inistrators( Players( Match Officials(

Tea& Officials( Owners( etc( shall continue to *e an offence under the

!CCI and IP4 Rules 6 Re'ulations

The need to educate and sensiti1e youn' players and de*utants

a*out 'a&e ethics( the need to inculcate discipline and inte'rity a&on'

players( and the need to spread awareness a*out the ills of *ettin'(

&atch>spot+fi,in' and other 'a&e related &alpractices is well accepted

and reco'ni1ed In fact( !CCI has already introduced the .CSU

education &odule in)ol)in' lectures *y ICC instructors !ut this is

inadequate It is therefore necessary for !CCI to take the followin'

additional &easures to ensure that cricket players in particular(

 youn'sters understand( appreciate and practise the ethics relatin' to the

'a&e=

~ 60 ~

Page 61: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 61/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

i Prepare a Cricketers Hand*ook for youn' players( on the lines

of .thletes$ Hand*ook( ;87B "prepared *y 2o Sports

oundation% containin' the Fo$s and Fon$ts and .Asii .rran'e for 4ectures "prefera*ly in local lan'ua'es apart fro&

En'lish% and frequent interactions with cricket players and

sport persons of uni&peacha*le inte'rity in re'ard to 'a&e

ethicsiii Create an Inte'rity Unit consistin' of for&er cricket players of 

repute( co&&itted to the cause of cricket( to act as &entors and

'uides( who& youn' players can &eet on desi'nated dates to

discuss their dou*ts( pro*le&s and 'rie)ances related to the

'a&e

inancial insecurity( short professional career and hu'e disparity in the

contract &oney paid to different classes of players are so&e of the

factors which te&pt players towards &alpractices Lhile

reputed>'la&orous players( particularly those with international

e,posure ha)e hu'e inco&es( the position of other national players( let

alone frin'e players( is not )ery rosy Equally distur*in' is the trend of 

 youn' players suddenly e,posed to riches *y way of IP4 not *ein'

suita*ly 'uided on responsi*le conduct( with the result that in order to

&aintain their e,tra)a'ant lifestyles( they are lured into &isad)entures

in the for& of *ettin' and &atch>spot+fi,in' .ttention should *e

 *estowed *y !CCI to 'i)e education a*out ethics and financial

~ 61 ~

Page 62: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 62/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

&ana'e&ent to youn'sters and to secure the post+cricket life of all

players

E,perience has shown that when a *ettin' or &atch>spot+fi,in'

incident occurs( !CCI is ill+prepared to deal with the sa&e !CCI should

therefore coordinate with State &achinery so as to create a dedicated

special in)esti'ation win' in the police to *e acti)ated whene)er there

are co&plaints( and also to ensure that such e)ents do not occur This

can *e done *y !CCI a'reein' to *ear the e,penditure of such special

 win' It has *een *rou'ht to the notice of the Co&&ittee that the official

post+&atch parties of the IP4 which &andate player presence ha)e not

 *een conduci)e to the 'a&e and the conduct of the players The

Co&&ittee also learns that this has now *een discontinued !CCI should

 *e careful not to offer any a)enues which &ay affect the 'a&e and the

conduct of the players

 . data*ase of undesira*le ele&ents "*ookies( fi,ers( etc(% thou'h

&aintained *y !CCI+.CU( is not shared with the Players and Tea&

Officials( with the result that they re&ain in the dark and &i'ht deal with

the& unwittin'ly Such non+sharin' &ay e)en ena*le a technical defence

of i'norance when such incidents surface The sharin' of such

infor&ation should *e in 'ood faith to protect the interest of the person

to who& such co&&unication is &ade and for the pu*lic 'ood of the

~ 62 ~

Page 63: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 63/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

'a&e Such a caution should clarify that it does not seek to cast any 

aspersion on the person re'ardin' who& any infor&ation is shared

 .ny person associated with the 'o)ernance or &ana'e&ent( or

e&ployed or en'a'ed *y the !CCI has a duty to infor& the .pe, Council

or the CEO of any undesira*le acti)ity or approaches which ha)e a

 *earin' on the 'a&e or the functionin' of the !CCI

In addition to this( when conductin' franchise auctions( the !CCI

shall )erify and ascertain whether the person controllin' the prospecti)e

franchisee has cri&inal antecedents These are so&e of the &easures

 which &ay help in pre)entin' ille'alities in re'ard to the 'a&e

~ 63 ~

Page 64: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 64/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

(hapte# Ten* (%nstit)ti%n 6 F)n$ti%nin/ %7 Me8e#s

 .part fro& the !CCI( a &a:ority of the re'ional &e&*ers of the

!CCI are societies re'istered either under the Societies Re'istration .ct(

7?8 or the respecti)e State acts . handful ha)e recently *een re'istered

as co&panies under the pro)isions of the Co&panies .ct( 79<?

"Haryana( Pun:a*( Felhi( Hi&achal Pradesh( Uttar Pradesh and

Maharashtra% The Cricket Clu* of India "CCI% and the ational Cricket

Clu* "CC% are also pu*lic co&panies li&ited *y 'uarantee Thus( the

e,istin' Me&*ers of the !CCI ha)e different structures Unifor&ity in

the constitution and functionin' of the Me&*er .ssociations is

necessary for the proper 'o)ernance of the 'a&e The different

structures in Me&*er .ssociations ha)e *rou'ht a*out &uch disquiet in

Indian cricket

 Problems

a Me&*ership 6 Pri)ile'esSo&e Me&*er .ssociations ha)e clu*s and indi)iduals as

&e&*ers( so&e ha)e only clu*s as &e&*ers and others ha)e

indi)iduals and patrons as &e&*ers There does not see& to *e

any 'uideline or *asis for &e&*ership( and these see& to *e ad+

hoc( often at the pleasure of the incu&*ents Lhere clu*s are

&e&*ers( a few powerful interests control se)eral cricket clu*s(

~ 64 ~

Page 65: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 65/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

there*y positionin' the&sel)es for easy election with a si1ea*le

chunk of the con)enient electorate ew entrants are discoura'ed

or &u11led out of contention So&e associations e,clude e)en

for&er Indian cricketers fro& &e&*ership "includin' le'endary 

perfor&ers%( without any *asis( and ensure that the association

functions &ore as a social clu* controlled *y a few fa&ilies The

priority often see&s to *e to ha)e an e,clusi)e )enue with *ar and

dinin' facilities with other recreational a)enues for the &e&*ers(

and not the pro&otion of cricket Tickets to 'a&es are also

distri*uted as lar'esse a&on' &e&*ers as entitle&ent( there*y 

shrinkin' their a)aila*ility to the pu*lic at lar'e In *oth Chennai

and Dolkata for e,a&ple( it is learnt that the respecti)e stadia at

Chepauk and Eden 2ardens had *een constructed on land which

had *een leased to the Madras Cricket Clu* "MCC% and ational

Cricket Clu* "CC% respecti)ely( *ut now( e)en with the chan'e in

structure( the respecti)e Clu*s continue to *e housed at the

pre&ises Lhile at CC( the &e&*ers ha)e ticket and other

entitle&ents( the sa&e is not so for the MCC * Posts 6 Tenures

There is &uch rancour concernin' the ad&inistration of these

 .ssociations Posts either e,ist without any specified ter&s( or sans

any restriction on the nu&*er of ter&s which can *e held .s a

result( in so&e .ssociations( the incu&*ents ha)e continued at the

~ 65 ~

Page 66: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 66/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

hel& for o)er three decades( creatin' personal and hereditary 

&onopolies which ha)e no place in sport Unfortunately( a 'lance

at se)eral other Indian sports *odies re)eal the sa&e &alaise( with

indi)iduals re&ainin' at the hel& for years to'ether So&e

 .ssociations ha)e also &ade a&end&ents to their re'ulations to

per&it certain indi)iduals to effecti)ely ha)e posts for life( and to

allow unre'ulated tenures The lack of any qualifications or

disqualifications also ensures that those with full ti&e occupations

superficially in)ol)e the&sel)es( there*y co&pro&isin' their

co&&it&ent to the association and the 'a&e of cricket Se)eral

pu*lic ser)ants hold lead positions in State .ssociations which take

a su*stantial toll on *oth sets of their respecti)e o*li'ations to the

pu*licc 5otin'

Pro,y )otin' see&s to *e the *ane of se)eral associations which

ha)e indi)idual &e&*ers E)en the continuin' e,istence of the

&e&*ers is not confir&ed( *ut coteries are pro&oted and

candidates elected on the *asis of se)eral si'ned pro,y )otes 'i)en(

 )ery often with the na&e of the pro,y left *lank to *e filled in later

This has 'i)en rise to unscrupulous practices that ha)e e)en *een

 *rou'ht to the attention of the courtsd Co&pliance

Co&panies and Societies ha)e funda&entally different

constitutions and o*:ects( apart fro& different reportin' and

~ 66 ~

Page 67: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 67/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

co&pliance &echanis&s Lhile the associations that are

co&panies ha)e *een re'istered as not+for+profit "earlier under

Section ;< of the Co&panies .ct( 79<? and now under Section of 

the Co&panies .ct( ;87B%( there is little to show that there has

 *een co&pliance as le'ally &andated .s far as .ssociations

re'istered as societies( the rele)ant statutes pro)ide for a

co&parati)ely lesser de'ree of transparencye E,penditure 6 Infrastructure

One of the &a:or criticis&s of the functionin' of the !CCI has *een

the fact that there has *een no accounta*ility *y Me&*er

 .ssociations of the 'rants 'i)en to the& *y the !CCI for the

#de)elop&ent of cricket$ o detailed account are &aintained( no

o)ersi'ht or audit is carried out( and on the rare occasion where a

particular .ssociation has *een found wantin'( there is no follow 

up action The funds are alle'edly utili1ed for winnin' )otes *y 

apportionin' a&ounts to constituents "clu*s( district associations(

etc(% and quite frequently *ein' siphoned away without any 

accounta*ility State infrastructure re&ains poorly de)eloped with

 )ery few turf wickets or cricket 'rounds outside of the e,istin'

stadiu& The stadia "e)en new ones% do not pro)ide *asic facilities

to the pu*lic( nor offer food and water at a reasona*le price or of 

an accepta*le quality More i&portantly( the lack of hy'ienic toilets

and access to the differently+a*led discoura'e &any patrons The

~ 67 ~

Page 68: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 68/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

ad+hoc and irre'ular &anner of creatin' stands or refur*ishin' the

pre&ises without proper &unicipal per&issions has led to a stand+

off with at least two State 2o)ern&ents "Felhi and Ta&il adu%

The e)entual )icti& is of course the cricket fan who loses out on a

chance to watch a ho&e &atch

f 4ack of professionalis&There is no distinction *etween 'o)ernance and &ana'e&ent in

the Me&*er .ssociations( and no steps ha)e *een taken to create

&odern and professional syste&s to take cricket ad&inistration

forward The accountin' syste&s for e,a&ple( are unifor&ly 

capa*le of alterations without a trace( there*y openin' up the

possi*ility of a*use There is no incenti)e to create re)enue

strea&s( and it is ti&e to rouse the Me&*er .ssociations fro&

their co&forta*le couches where they rest upon !CCI$s lar'esseThe one nota*le e,ception to this are the detailed &odules

created at the *ehest of the ad&inistration of the Darnataka State

Cricket .ssociation in ;87; which sou'ht to o)erhaul the policies

and processes that were ha&perin' the functionin' of the

 .ssociation The report prepared *y an e,ternal consultant see&s

to fairly reflect the )ery issues that concern all other State

 .ssociations as well This report is at  Appendix-: IT solutions

 would 'o a lon' way to ensure that hu&an interference is reduced

and that the association functions transparently . reluctance to

~ 68 ~

Page 69: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 69/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

adopt such a)enues "e)en *y the Darnataka .ssociation% would

raise 'ra)e dou*ts a*out the actual intentions of the

ad&inistrators

' Fual postsStran'ely( while conflict of interest issues ha)e *een at the heart of 

recent contro)ersies( )irtually all office *earers of the !CCI

continue to *e office *earers in their respecti)e State .ssociations

at the same time Presidents and Secretaries of State .ssociations

are to dischar'e functions with the pri&ary interest of the State in

&ind( *ut as !CCI office *earers( these interests would ha)e to *e

su*ordinated to that of national interest Often( with powers

centred on an office *earer( that indi)idual has *een found to

appoint his State associates to critical posts in the !CCI( there*y 

creatin' an i&*alance

h Interference in selectionO)er the last two decades( there ha)e *een distur*in' accounts of 

so&e of the country$s leadin' players *ein' forced to &i'rate and

play for other States *ecause the ho&e state$s ad&inistration looks

to suppress their a)enues and *rook no independent action *y the

Selection Co&&ittees 4ar'e a&ounts of influence( in all possi*le

unsa)oury for&s ha)e *een utili1ed in order to ha)e one player or

other selected( with &erit *ein' wholly i'nored The pro*le& is so

~ 69 ~

Page 70: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 70/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

deep+rooted( that &any feel that the States are not inductin' or

fieldin' their *est a)aila*le talent

i Transparency  Lhile quite a few associations ha)e we*sites( the rele)ant and

critical details includin' their constitution( *ye+laws( accounts(

e,penditure( ethics 'uidelines and player statistics are rarely 

a)aila*le or up to date There are &any others who do not e)en

ha)e or &aintain we*sites( nor do their offices respond to requests

fro& :ournalists and others for sharin' such &aterial Infor&ation

Technolo'y solutions( as referred to earlier( would *e useful to

ensure that such transparency is achie)ed

 Solutions

There was a consistent )iew a&on' respondents to the queries that

&any of the ills *efallin' Indian cricket find their roots in the State

 .ssociations and their lack of ad&inistration The root cause for the

pro*le& is that the !CCI is &akin' su*stantial annual 'rants re'ardin'

 which there is no o)ersi'ht( and so the status quo re&ained as it was(

 with little effort *y the pro)incial ad&inistrators

Therefore( it is necessary that there is unifor&ity in the

constitution and functionin' of the )arious associations "without any 

office *ein' created for life%( that &e&*ership of social clu*s *e di)orced

~ 70 ~

Page 71: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 71/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

fro& the ad&inistration of cricket which is a so&*re task( that cricketers

 *e &ade &e&*ers and ha)e a say in 'o)ernance and that &ana'e&ent

 *e &ade professional The State .ssociations &ust also create a)enues to

'enerate re)enue( i&pro)e infrastructure and de)elop the sport( all of 

 which will *e &arked throu'h a detailed report card There also has to *e

an audit and independent o)ersi'ht of how resources are allocated and

spent It is necessary that all State .ssociations i&&ediately transition to

the use of ta&per+proof accountin' software which either does not

per&it alterations or which records all alterations &ade

The conflicts that arise *y holdin' office *oth at the !CCI and in

the State .ssociations ou'ht to *e *rou'ht to an end *y auto&atic

 )acation of post at the local le)el when elected to the !CCI .lso( certain

disqualifications ha)e to *e laid down that apply to those who seek office

in the State .ssociations( alon' with li&its on their tenures and ter&s

Correcti)e &easures are to *e *rou'ht into place so that professional

&ana'ers will interface with the State 2o)ern&ents and atte&pt to

rectify any pre)ailin' shortfalls or draw*acks as far as infrastructure and

per&issions are concerned

The electoral process will ha)e to *e transparent and independent(

for which an Electoral Officer "a retired Central or respecti)e State

Election Co&&issioner% will ha)e *e appointed In the e)ent that no

~ 71 ~

Page 72: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 72/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

such person is a)aila*le( any other for&er State Election Co&&issioner(

prefera*ly fro& a nei'h*ourin' State &ay *e appointed This officer

 would conduct and super)ise the entire process of elections fro& the

filin' of no&inations to the declaration of results and the resolution of 

any disputes and o*:ections durin' the election

It is also necessary to ha)e an independent selection co&&ittee in

 which the 2o)ernin' *ody of the State .ssociation will ha)e no say( and

also for the cricket co&&ittees &anned only *y for&er players to ha)e

an independent say on coachin' and e)aluation of tea& perfor&ance(

apart fro& the selection of players

The policies of !CCI re'ardin' dispute resolution and Conflict of 

Interest( as well as the nor&s for .'ents$ Re'istration will ha)e to apply 

to the State .ssociations as well In order to ad&inister this( the

associations &ay also appoint an O&*uds&an+cu&+Ethics Officer It

 would *e open to &ultiple States to ha)e a sin'le O&*uds&an > Ethics

Officer so as to reduce e,penditure The person so appointed shall *e an

e&inent person well )ersed in ad:udicatory processes and it will *e

his>her task to decide all disputes *etween the .ssociation and any of its

constituents "Fistricts( Clu*s( etc%( or *etween the constituents( or

co&plaints of any player or &e&*er of the pu*lic( *y followin' the

principles of natural :ustice *efore renderin' a decision

~ 72 ~

Page 73: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 73/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

 .s Ethics Officer( it shall *e his duty to ad&inister the principles of 

Conflict of Interest and reco&&end such action as &ay *e dee&ed fit as

far as an Office !earer( E&ployee( Player( Tea& Official or other

indi)idual connected to the State .ssociation is concerned eedless to

say( if it is an issue that concerns the !CCI as well( the Ethics Officer of 

the !CCI shall proceed to decide the issue The Ethics Officer shall also

decide all issues concernin' the )iolation of the .'ents$ Re'istration

nor&s as far as players of the State are concerned

Each State .ssociation will necessarily ha)e a we*site that carries

the followin' &ini&u& details=

a The Constitution( Me&orandu& of .ssociation and Rules 6

Re'ulations( !ye+4aws and Office Orders and directions that

'o)ern the functionin' of the .ssociation( its Co&&ittees(

the O&*uds&an and the Ethics Officer

 * The list of Me&*ers of the .ssociation as well as those who

are defaulters

c The annual accounts 6 audited *alance sheets and head+wise

inco&e and e,penditure details

~ 73 ~

Page 74: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 74/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

d Fetails of &ale( fe&ale and differently a*led players

representin' the State at all a'e 'roups with their na&es(

a'es and detailed playin' statistics

e .d)ertise&ents and in)itations for tenders when the

 .ssociation is seekin' supply of any 'oods or ser)ices

"e,ceedin' a &ini&u& prescri*ed )alue%( or notices

re'ardin' recruit&ent( as also the detailed process for

awardin' such contracts or &akin' such recruit&ents

f Fetails of all 'oals and &ilestones for de)elopin' cricket in

the State alon' with ti&elines and the &easures undertaken

to achie)e each of the&

' Fetails of all office *earers and other &ana'erial staff 

"includin' CEO( COO( CO( etc%

h Fetails of directi)es fro& the !CCI and their co&pliances

These we*sites will ha)e to *e &aintained and updated at least on a

quarterly *asis .ll the a*o)e infor&ation will ha)e to *e &aintained at

the re'istered office of the State .ssociation and when sou'ht( the sa&e

shall *e shared with the applicant on the pay&ent of a reasona*le fee( as

&ay *e prescri*ed *y the .ssociation

~ 74 ~

Page 75: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 75/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

The cost of construction of a stadiu& runs into hundreds of crores

On the other hand( for&ation of a cricket playin' 'round costs a s&all

fraction of the cost of a stadiu& It &akes &ore sense to ha)e cricket

playin' 'rounds in each Fistrict( rather than ha)in' one or two stadia in

a State In fact( the Co&&ittee learns that so&e &e&*ers are &erely 

collectin' the 'rants fro& !CCI and depositin' the& in a !ank so as to

accu&ulate sufficient funds necessary for takin' up construction of a

stadiu& The result is so&e s&aller States ha)e neither a stadiu& nor

 well de)eloped cricket playin' 'rounds !CCI should therefore

encoura'e the State .ssociations to=

a Ha)e as &any cricket playin' 'rounds and fields instead of 

&ultiple stadia( which will ena*le 'reater usa'e and access to

'reater nu&*er of players * Con)ert e,istin' 'rounds and fields into turf wickets so that

international standard facilities are &ade a)aila*le e)en fro& a

 youn' a'ec To &ake the e,istin' stadia a&ena*le to other sports *y 

pro)idin' for alternate surfaces to *e laid ".stroturf for hockey(

Carpet for tennis( etc% so that inco&e &ay *e 'enerated and

there would *e all round de)elop&ent of sport( care *ein' taken

not to da&a'e the pitch !ut they should not *e used for pu*lic

functions where thousands will sto&p on the 'round

~ 75 ~

Page 76: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 76/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

The a*o)e reco&&endations relatin' to State .ssociations "ull

Me&*ers% will also *e applica*le to the @ associations rele'ated to the

cate'ory of .ssociate Me&*ers and who are entitled to dis*urse&ent of 

the 'rant fro& the !CCI

~ 76 ~

Page 77: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 77/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

EN; OF THE INNING+

If there has *een one unifyin' factor in India( it has *een cricket

ro& CDayudu to 5irat Dohli( the B; captains of India and the &en

they ha)e led ha)e *een equally deified and )ilified *y the &asses( for

such is the a*ility of the 'a&e to infla&e passions It is on *ehalf of these

de)otees of willow and leather that this Co&&ittee su*&its this effort to

edify the !CCI

In an effort to present the reco&&endations &ade *y the

Co&&ittee in *rief( the followin' synopsis of our proposals are set out=

7 Me&*ership‘One State, One Vote’ 

Only cricket .ssociations representin' the States would ha)e

 )otin' ri'hts as ull Me&*ers of the !oard( there*y ensurin'

equality a&on' the territorial di)isions .ny other e,istin'

&e&*ers would *e .ssociate Me&*ers; Gones

‘Zones for Tournaments alone’ 

The Gones would *e rele)ant only for the purpose of the

tourna&ents conducted a&on'st the&sel)es( *ut not for

no&ination to the 'o)ernance of the !oard or to the )arious

Standin' Co&&ittees

B State .ssociations‘State Associations - niformit! in Structure’  

~ 77 ~

Page 78: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 78/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

The .ssociations that are the Me&*ers would necessarily ha)e

to restrict the tenures of office *earers and prescri*e

disqualifications( do away with pro,y )otin'( pro)ide

transparency in functionin'( *e open to scrutiny and audit *y 

the !CCI and include players in &e&*ership and &ana'e&ent

They would also ha)e to a*ide *y the conflict of interest policy 

prescri*ed *y the !oard( and di)orce the .ssociation fro& the

social clu*( if any@ Office !earers

‘"imited Tenures # $ooling Off’ 

 Lhile all the e,istin' office *earers "President( 5ice+President(

Secretary( Treasurer and 3oint Secretary% are retained in

honorary positions( the nu&*er of 5ice Presidents is pruned

fro& fi)e to one Their duties ha)e *een reali'ned The

President is shorn of his say in selections The additional )ote

for the President at &eetin's is deleted The ter&s of these

Office !earers continue to *e of B years( *ut with a &a,i&u& of 

B such ter&s re'ardless of the post held( with a coolin' off 

period after each such ter&

< 2o)ernance‘%o&ernance separated from management’ 

The 7@ &e&*er Lorkin' Co&&ittee is replaced *y a 9 &e&*er

 .pe, Council "with one+third independent &e&*ers% consistin'

of the Office !earers of the !CCI( an elected representati)e of 

~ 78 ~

Page 79: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 79/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

the 2eneral !ody( two representati)es of the Players .ssociation

"one &an and one wo&an% and one no&inee fro& the C6.2$s

office Ter&s of eli'i*ility and disqualification are specified with

a *ar on Ministers and 'o)ern&ent ser)ants

? Mana'e&ent‘'rofessionalism in management’ 

Professionalis& is *rou'ht in *y introducin' a CEO with stron'

credentials assisted *y a tea& of &ana'ers to handle non+

cricketin' affairs The lar'e nu&*er of Standin' Co&&ittees

and Su*+Co&&ittees created *y the !CCI has *een reduced to

two essential ones that would ad)ice the CEO with reference to

tours( technical aspects and tourna&ents

The selection( coachin'( perfor&ance e)aluation and

u&pirin' are to *e handled *y Cricket Co&&ittees &anned only 

 *y for&er professionals Specific pro)isions ha)e *een &ade to

encoura'e cricket for wo&en and the differently+a*led

The IP4‘"imited Autonom! for ('"’ 

The 2o)ernin' Council of the IP4 is reduced to 9( *ut includes ;

representati)es of the ranchisees and no&inees of the Players$

 .ssociation and the C6.2$s office Players

~ 79 ~

Page 80: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 80/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

‘A &oice for 'la!ers’ 

There shall *e a Cricket Players$ .ssociation affordin'

&e&*ership to all international and &ost first class &en and

 wo&en retired cricketers This .ssociation shall dischar'e

assi'ned functions with the financial support of the !CCI It

shall *e *rou'ht into e,istence *y an independent steerin'

co&&ittee9 .'ents

‘Arms length for agents’ 

Players$ interests are protected *y ensurin' that their .'ents are

re'istered under the prescri*ed nor&s ad&inistered *y the

!CCI and the Players$ Cricket .ssociation78 Conflict of Interest

‘A&oidance of conflicts’  

Fetailed nor&s ha)e *een laid down to ensure there is no direct

or indirect( pecuniary or other conflict or appearance thereof in

the dischar'e of the functions of those persons associated or

e&ployed *y the !CCI( its Co&&ittees( its Me&*ers or the IP4

ranchisees These nor&s shall *e ad&inistered *y an Ethics

Officer77 The O&*uds&an and the Electoral Officer

‘(ndependent monitors’ 

Pro)ision has *een &ade to ha)e an independent o&*uds&an

to resol)e 'rie)ances of Me&*ers( .d&inistrators( Players and

e)en &e&*ers of the pu*lic as per the procedures laid down

~ 80 ~

Page 81: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 81/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

Si&ilarly( an independent Electoral Officer to o)ersee the entire

electoral process is also &andated7; unctionin'

‘Transparenc!’ 

The !CCI &ust pro)ide the rele)ant infor&ation in dischar'e of 

its pu*lic functions .ll rules and re'ulations( nor&s( details of 

&eetin's( e,penditures( *alance sheets( reports and orders of 

authorities are to *e uploaded on the we*site as well7B O)ersi'ht

‘Accountabilit!’ 

 .n independent auditor to )erify how the ull Me&*ers ha)e

e,pended the 'rants 'i)en to the& *y the !CCI( to record their

tar'ets and &ilestones( and to su*&it a separate co&pliance

report in this re'ard7@ !ettin' 6 Match+fi,in'

‘"egali)ation for betting and $riminali)ation for match-fi*ing’  

 . reco&&endation is &ade to le'ali1e *ettin' "with stron'

safe'uards%( e,cept for those co)ered *y the !CCI and IP4

re'ulations .lso a reco&&endation for &atch>spot+fi,in' to *e

&ade a cri&inal offence7< Ethics for Players

‘Awareness and sensiti)ation’ 

Pro)isions to *e &ade for lectures( classes( hand*ooks and

&entorin' of youn' players

The Co&&ittee fer)ently hopes that this report will *rin' cricket

fans *ack to the fold and put an end to re'ional e,cesses and i&*alances(

~ 81 ~

Page 82: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 82/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

rei'n *y cliques( corruption and red tape( all of which ha)e har&ed the

'a&e and the youn'sters lookin' for nothin' &ore than to take the field

in flannels

~ 82 ~

Page 83: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 83/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

THE .EURES

~ 83 ~

Page 84: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 84/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

 ANNE,RE-A 

MEMORANDUM OF ASSOCIATION

1. The name of the Association is “THE BOA! O" #O$TO% "O

#&#'ET &$ &$!&A( an) it sha** he+eafte+ ,e +efe++e) to as the

“Boa+)(.

2. The o,-ects an) /+oses of the B##& a+e

a To cont+o* an) im+oe /a*it an) stan)a+)s of the ame of 

#+icet in &n)ia *a )on o*icies +oa)mas /i)e*ines an)

mae +/*es an) +e/*ations an) amen) o+ a*te+ them in a**

matte+s +e*atin to the ame of #+icet +econi:in that the

+ima+ staeho*)e+s a+e the *ae+s an) #+icet fans in &n)ia

an) that acco/nta,i*it t+ansa+enc an) /+it of the ;ame

a+e the co+e a*/es<

, To +oi)e fo+ meas/+es necessa+ fo+ +omotion an)

)ee*oment of the ame of #+icet e*fa+e an) inte+est of 

#+icete+s an) e*imination of /nethica* an) /nfai+ +actices in

the ;ame of c+icet< an) fo+ that /+ose o+ani:e coachin

schemes esta,*ish coachin aca)emies ho*) to/+naments

e=hi,ition matches Test >atches O!&s Tent?20 an) an

othe+ matches an) tae a** othe+ +e/i+e) stes<

c To st+ie fo+ so+tsmanshi an) +ofessiona*ism in the ame of 

#+icet an) its oe+nance an) a)minist+ation< inc/*cate

+inci*es of t+ansa+enc an) ethica* stan)a+)s in *ae+s

team o@cia*s /mi+es an) a)minist+ato+s< an) to ,an )oin

ae f+a/) se=/a* ha+assment an) a** othe+ fo+ms of ine/it

an) )isc+imination<

) To enco/+ae the fo+mation of tate eiona* o+ othe+ #+icet

~ 84 ~

Page 85: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 85/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

Associations an) the o+ani:ation of &nte+tate an) othe+

 To/+naments< to *a )on no+ms fo+ +econition hich achiee

/nifo+mit in the st+/ct/+e f/nctionin an) +ocesses of the

>em,e+ Associations<

e To a++ane cont+o* +e/*ate an) if necessa+ Cnance isits of 

 Teams that a+e >em,e+s of the &nte+nationa* #+icet #o/nci*

an) teams of othe+ #o/nt+ies to &n)ia<

f To a++ane cont+o* +e/*ate an) Cnance isits of &n)ian

#+icet Teams to to/+ co/nt+ies that a+e mem,e+s of the

&nte+nationa* #+icet #o/nci* o+ e*sehe+e in con-/nction ith

the ,o)ies oe+nin c+icet in the co/nt+ies to ,e isite)<

To se*ect teams to +e+esent &n)ia in Test >atches One !a

&nte+nationa*s Tent?20 matches an) in an othe+ fo+mat in

&n)ia o+ a,+oa) as the Boa+) ma )eci)e f+om time to time<

h To foste+ the si+it of so+tsmanshi an) the i)ea*s of c+icet

amonst schoo* co**ee an) /nie+sit st/)ents an) othe+s

an) to e)/cate them +ea+)in the same<

i To aoint &n)iaDs +e+esentatie?s on the &nte+nationa* #+icet

#o/nci* as a*so to #onfe+ences an) emina+s connecte) ith

the ame of #+icet<

- To aoint >anae+s an)?o+ othe+ team o@cia*s fo+ the &n)ian

 Teams<

To em*o an) aoint #EOs +ofessiona* manae+s a/)ito+s

e=ec/tie sec+eta+ies a)minist+atie o@ce+s assistant

sec+eta+ies manae+s c*e+s team s/o+t sta *ae+s an)

othe+ se+ice e+sonne* an) sta< an) to +em/ne+ate them fo+thei+ se+ices , a of sa*a+ies aes +at/ities ensions

~ 85 ~

Page 86: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 86/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

hono+a+ia e=+atia aments an)?o+ +oi)ent f/n)< an) to

+emoe?te+minate o+ )ismiss s/ch em*oees o+ e+sonne*<

* To ens/+e that ticets to c+icet matches a+e i)e* aai*a,*e

e** in a)ance of the matches to mem,e+s of the /,*ic at

+easona,*e +ates an) to +eent )ist+i,/tion of the same as

*a+esse< an) a*so to oe+ seats gratis o+ at nomina* +ates to

st/)ents<

m To *a o/t c+icet +o/n)s an) to +oi)e ai*ion canteen an)

othe+ faci*ities an) amenities fo+ the conenience an) ,eneCt

of the mem,e+s *ae+s an) the #+icet fans inc*/)in the

omen an) the )isa,*e) an) to ens/+e the aai*a,i*it of 

#+icet ea+ an) amenities to #+icet *ae+s<

n To constit/te #ommittees f+om time to time an) ent+/st o+

)e*eate its f/nctions an) )/ties to s/ch #ommittees fo+

achiein the o,-ects of the Boa+)<

o To est immoa,*e +oe+ties an) f/n)s of the B##& in

 T+/stees aointe) , it fo+ ca++in o/t the o,-ects of the

Boa+)<

To se** manae mo+tae *ease e=chane )isose of o+

othe+ise )ea* ith a** o+ an +oe+t of the B##&<

To ac/i+e o+ /+chase +oe+ties F moa,*e an) immoa,*e

an) assets F tani,*e an) intani,*e an) to a* the caita*

an) income the+ef+om an) the +ocee)s of the sa*e o+ t+ansfe+

the+eof fo+ o+ toa+)s a** o+ an of the o,-ects of the B##&<

+ To co**ect f/n)s an) he+ee+ necessa+ ,o++o ith o+

itho/t sec/+it an) to /+chase +e)eem o+ a o an s/ch

sec/+ities<

~ 86 ~

Page 87: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 87/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

s To ca++ o/t an othe+ actiit hich ma seem to the Boa+)

caa,*e of ,ein conenient* ca++ie) on in connection ith

the a,oe o+ ca*c/*ate) )i+ect* o+ in)i+ect* to enhance the

a*/e o+ +en)e+ +oCta,*e o+ ene+ate ,ette+ income?+een/ef+om an of the +oe+ties assets an) +ihts of the B##&<

t To +omote +otect an) assist the G*ae+s ho a+e the +ima+

aents of the ame ,

i #+eatin a G*ae+s Association to ,e f/n)e) , the B##&<

ii Bein sensitie to G*ae+s ,efo+e inte+nationa* ca*en)a+s

a+e )+an / so that s/@cient time is +oi)e) fo+ +est an)

+ecoe+<

iii Tain stes a+tic/*a+* on *one+ to/+s so the emotiona*

e**,ein an) fami* ,on)s of the G*ae+s a+e st+enthene)<

i #om/*so+i* hain /a*iCe) Ghsiothe+aists >enta*

#on)itionin #oaches ? #o/nse**o+s an) $/t+itionists amon

the Teams s/o+t sta<

Hain a sin*e oint of contact on the *oistics an)

manae+ia* si)e so that G*ae+s can f/** concent+ate on the

ame<

i eiste+in a** )/* /a*iCe) aents to ens/+e the+e is

oe+siht an) t+ansa+enc in *ae+ +e+esentation<

ii Oe+in a+o+iate +em/ne+ation of an inte+nationa*

stan)a+) hen +e+esentin the co/nt+ on the inte+nationa*

stae an) a*as +eca**in that nationa* +e+esentation has

+io+it oe+ c*/, o+ f+anchise<

/ To +ant?)onate s/ch s/m?s fo+

~ 87 ~

Page 88: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 88/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

i /ch ca/ses as o/*) ,e )eeme) Ct , the Boa+)

con)/cie to the +omotion of the ame of #+icet<

ii The ,eneCt of #+icete+s o+ thei+ so/ses an) chi*)+en ,

int+o)/cin ,eneo*ent f/n) schemes o+ othe+ ,eneCt

schemes as the Boa+) )eems Ct s/,-ect to its +/*es an)

+e/*ations<

iii The ,eneCt of an othe+ e+sons ho hae se+e) #+icet

o+ thei+ so/ses an) chi*)+en as the Boa+) ma consi)e+ Ct<

i To aa+) sonso+shis to so+tse+sons in ames othe+

than #+icet fo+ )ee*oment of thei+ in)ii)/a* si**s< an)

To )onate to an cha+ita,*e ca/se<

To sta+t o+ sonso+ an)?o+ to s/,sc+i,e to f/n)s o+ stae

matches fo+ the ,eneCt of the #+icete+s o+ e+sons ho ma

hae +en)e+e) se+ice to the ame of #+icet o+ fo+ thei+

fami*ies o+ to )onate toa+)s the )ee*oment o+ +omotion

of the ame an) to o+ani:e matches in ai) of G/,*ic

#ha+ita,*e an) e*ief "/n)s<

To ima+t hsica* e)/cation th+o/h the me)i/m of #+icet<

= To coo+)inate the actiities of mem,e+s an) instit/tions in

+e*ation to the Boa+) an) amonst themse*es<

To c+eate an) maintain a cent+a* +eosito+ an) )ata,ase of a**

#+icete+s a*on ith thei+ ame statistics<

: To int+o)/ce a scheme of +ofessiona*ism an) to im*ement

the same<

~ 88 ~

Page 89: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 89/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

aa To +oi)e a fai+ an) t+ansa+ent +ieance +e)+essa*

mechanism to *ae+s s/o+t e+sonne* an) othe+ entities

associate) ith #+icet<

,, ;ene+a** to )o a** s/ch othe+ acts an) thins as ma seem to

the Boa+) to ,e conenient an)?o+ con)/cie to the ca++in

o/t of the o,-ects of the B##&.

3. The income f/n)s an) +oe+ties of the B##& hoee+ ac/i+e)

sha** ,e /ti*i:e) an) a*ie) so*e* fo+ the +omotion of the o,-ects

of the B##& as set fo+th a,oe to ai) an) assist Cnancia** o+

othe+ise an) to +omote enco/+ae a)ance an) )ee*o an)

ene+a** to assist the ame of c+icet o+ an othe+ so+t th+o/ho/t

&n)ia.

4. The B##& sha** not ,e )isso*e) /n*ess the )isso*/tion is )eci)e)

/on , a +eso*/tion asse) at a ;ene+a* >eetin of the Boa+)

conene) fo+ the /+ose , a ma-o+it of 3?4th of the >em,e+s

+esent an) entit*e) to ote. The /o+/m fo+ s/ch meetin sha** ,e

2?3+)  of the >em,e+s ho hae a +iht to ote. &n the case of 

)isso*/tion of the Boa+) if the+e sha** +emain afte+ satisfaction of a**

)e,ts an) *ia,i*ities an +oe+t hatsoee+ it sha** ,e ien o+

t+ansfe++e) to some othe+ instit/tion o+ instit/tions hain o,-ects

simi*a+ to those of the B##& an) not +/nnin fo+ +oCt.

~ 89 ~

Page 90: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 90/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

RULES AND REGULATIONS

CHAPTER ONE: SCOPE

1. (A) DEFINITIONS

&n these /*es an) e/*ations /n*ess the conte=t othe+ise +e/i+es

(a) “A!>&$&TATO( sha** mean an) inc*/)e +esent an) fo+me+

G+esi)ents Iice G+esi)ents Hono+a+ ec+eta+ies Hono+a+

 T+eas/+e+s Hono+a+ Joint ec+eta+ies of the Boa+) of #ont+o* fo+

#+icet in &n)ia “B##&( ast an) +esent G+esi)ents an)

ec+eta+ies of >em,e+s a@*iate) to the Boa+) a +e+esentatie of a

>em,e+ of the Boa+) an) an e+son connecte) ith the

;oe+nance an) >anaement of the aai+s of the Boa+) o+ of its

#ommittees.

,“A;E$T E;&TE( is the +eiste+ maintaine) , the B##& /n)e+

the e/*ations fo+ eist+ation of G*ae+s Aents.

c“AGEK #OL$#&%( is the +incia* ,o) of the Boa+) tase) ith its

oe+nance as set o/t in /*e 14.

)“AL!&TO( is the a/)ito+ of the Boa+) aointe) , the Ae=

#o/nci* of the Boa+) to )ischa+e the f/nctions set o/t in /*e 34.

e“B##&( o+ “BOA!( is the Boa+) of #ont+o* fo+ #+icet in &n)ia

+eiste+e) /n)e+ Act KK& of 1860 at #hennai >a)+as on 2811

1940.

f “#EO( is the #hief E=ec/tie O@ce+ of the B##& aointe) , the

Ae= #o/nci* as set o/t in /*e 23.

“#O$"%&#T O" &$TEET( +efe+s to sit/ations he+e an in)ii)/a*

associate) ith the B##& in an caacit acts o+ omits to act in a

manne+ that ,+ins o+ is e+ceie) to ,+in the inte+est of the

in)ii)/a* in conMict ith the inte+est of the ame of c+icet an) that

~ 90 ~

Page 91: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 91/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

ma ie +ise to a+ehensions of o+ act/a* fao/+itism *ac of 

o,-ectiit ,ias ,eneCts moneta+ o+ othe+ise o+ *inaes as set

o/t in /*e 38.

h“#OL$#&%%O( a+e the mem,e+s of the Ae= #o/nci*.

i “#&#'ET #O>>&TTEE( a+e the #ommittees as set / in /*e 26

hich consist on* of fo+me+ G*ae+s an) a+e cha+e) ith se*ection

coachin an) ea*/ation of team e+fo+mance.

- “#&#'ET G%ANE AO#&AT&O$( +efe+s to the association of 

G*ae+s so constit/te) an) oe+ne) , the #o)e fo+ the #+icet

G*ae+s Association.

“E%E#TOA% O""&#E( is the e+son aointe) to con)/ct

s/e+ise an) )ea* ith iss/es conce+nin e*ections as set o/t in

/*e 33.

* “ETH&# O""&#E( is the e+son aointe) to a)ministe+ the

#onMict of &nte+est +inci*es as set o/t in /*e 39.

m “EK&T&$; >E>BE( is an association o+ othe+ ,o) co+o+ate

that as a >em,e+ of the Boa+) imme)iate* ,efo+e the Eectie

!ate.

n“"A$#H&EE( a+e the a+io/s comme+cia* entities ho hae

ente+e) into f+anchise a+eements ith the B##& fo+ a+ticiation in

the &n)ian G+emie+ %ea/e.

o“;E$EA% BO!N( is the s/+eme ,o) of the B##& hich isconstit/te) , its >em,e+s.

“;OIE$&$; #OL$#&%( is the tan)in #ommittee constit/te) ,

the Boa+) hich sha** ,e in cha+e of an) con)/ct the &n)ian

G+emie+ %ea/e.

“&G%( +efe+s to the &n)ian G+emie+ %ea/e hich is the f+anchise

,ase) Tent?20 to/+nament con)/cte) , the B##& fo+ a ma=im/m

~ 91 ~

Page 92: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 92/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

e+io) of 7 ees.

+ “JO&$T E#ETAN( is the Hono+a+ Joint ec+eta+ of the B##& as

set o/t in /*e 74.

s “JL$&O TOL$A>E$T( sha** mean an ae +o/ to/+naments

con)/cte) , the B##& f+om time to time.

t i “>E>BE( is a “"/** >em,e+( an) an “Associate >em,e+( of 

the Boa+).

ii “"L%% >E>BE( is a tate #+icet Association hain

otin +ihts an) as en/me+ate) in /*e 3aii of these /*es<

 iii “AO#&ATE >E>BE( is a >em,e+ of the Boa+) not hain

otin +ihts an) as en/me+ate) in /*e 3aiii of these /*es.

/“>AT#H O""&#&A%( inc*/)es Lmi+es >atch efe+ees O,se+e+s

tatisticians ;+o/n) ta an) co+e+s so aointe) , the Boa+) o+

a "/** >em,e+ f+om time to time.

“O""&#E BEAE( means the G+esi)ent IiceG+esi)ent ec+eta+

 Joint ec+eta+ an) T+eas/+e+.

“O>BL!>A$( is the in)een)ent +ieance +e)+essa*

a/tho+it set / /n)e+ /*e 40.

=“G%ANE( is an #+icete+ ast o+ +esent +eiste+e) ith B##& o+

an of its >em,e+s as a *ae+ an) sha** inc*/)e an e+son

se*ecte) in an s/a) to +e+esent &n)ia in a Test >atch O!& to/+match Tent?20 o+ J/nio+ To/+nament >atch in &n)ia o+ A,+oa).

“GE&!E$T is the Hono+a+ G+esi)ent of the B##& an) of the Ae=

#o/nci* as set o/t in /*e 71.

: “EGEE$TAT&IE( of a >em,e+ means a e+son )/* nominate)

as s/ch , the +esectie "/** >em,e+ o+ Associate >em,e+ as the

case ma ,e.

~ 92 ~

Page 93: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 93/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

aa “L%E( shall refer to any rule or su*+rule in these Rules and Re'ulations(

an) “L%E( +efe+ to these /*es an) e/*ations.

a, “E#ETAN( is the Hono+a+ ec+eta+ of the B##& as set o/t

in /*e 73.

ac “TEA> O""&#&A%( +efe+s to the s/o+t sta aointe) , the

B##& inc*/)in coaches manae+s hsiothe+aists n/t+itionists

t+aine+s ana*sts co/nse**o+s an) me)ics.

a) “TOL$A>E$T L%E( means the +/*es oe+nin the

con)/ct of a+io/s )omestic to/+naments o+ani:e) , the B##&

inc*/)in the &G% an) s/ch othe+ to/+naments as ma ,e con)/cte)

, the B##& f+om time to time.

ae “TEALE( is the T+eas/+e+ of the B##& as set o/t in /*e

75.

af “I&#E GE&!E$T( is the Iice G+esi)ent of the B##& as set o/t

in /*e 72.

a “NEA( means Cnancia* ea+ commencin f+om the1st )a of 

A+i* an) en)in on the 31st )a of >a+ch of the fo**oin ea+.

ah “O$E( means an of the 5 :ones name* $o+th one o/th

one East one Pest one an) #ent+a* one com+isin s/ch

teams as ma ,e )eci)e) , the B##& f+om time to time an)

s/,-ect to the fo**oin

i On* "/** an) Associate >em,e+s a+e entit*e) to Ce*) teams fo+

ona* to/+naments.

ii The B##& ma )eci)e on +ea*inin the ones in acco+)ance

ith +inci*es of e=e)ienc an) cometition.

iii The B##& ma if it is e=e)ient com,ine teams fo+ the $o+th

East an) Lnion Te++ito+ies.

B. INTERPRETATION

~ 93 ~

Page 94: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 94/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

i &n these /*es a** +efe+ences to G*ae+s >atch O@cia*s an)

A)minist+ato+s sha** ,e )eeme) to inc*/)e G*ae+s >atch

O@cia*s an) A)minist+ato+s of the &G% an) its "+anchisees as

e**.

ii The E""E#T&IE !ATE sha** ,e the )ate on hich these /*es

come into fo+ce.

2. HEADQUARTERS:

 The Hea)/a+te+s of the Boa+) sha** ,e *ocate) at >/m,ai.

3. MEMBERSHIP AND JURISDICTION OF MEMBERS:

a >em,e+shi

i >em,e+shi of the Boa+) sha** ,e conCne) to

a "/** >em,e+s< an)

, Associate >em,e+s<

ii "/** >em,e+s

A. Each tate sha** ,e +e+esente) , a state c+icet

association )/* +econi:e) , the B##& an) s/ch

associations sha** ,e "/** >em,e+s. $o tate sha**

hae mo+e than one "/** >em,e+.B. The associations ho a+e the cont+o**in ,o)ies fo+

c+icet in the fo**oin tates sha** ,e the "/**

>em,e+s of the B##&1. An)h+a G+a)esh2. A+/nacha* G+a)esh

3. Assam4. Biha+5. #hhattisa+h6. !e*hi7. ;oa8. ;/-a+at9. Ha+ana10. Himacha* G+a)esh11. Jamm/ Q 'ashmi+12. Jha+han)13. 'a+nataa

14. 'e+a*a15. >a)ha G+a)esh

~ 94 ~

Page 95: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 95/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

16. >aha+asht+a17. >ani/+18. >eha*aa19. >i:o+am20. $aa*an)

21. O+issa22. G/n-a,23. a-asthan24. iim25. Tami* $a)/26. Te*anana27. T+i/+a28. Ltta+ G+a)esh29. Ltta+ahan)30. Pest Bena*

#. &n tates ith m/*ti*e E=istin >em,e+s the B##&

sha** +econi:e one of them to +e+esent the tate

hi*e the +emainin sha** ,ecome Associate

>em,e+s.!. Phe+e )is/tes a+e en)in +ea+)in the )/*

+econi:e) association to +e+esent a a+tic/*a+

tate the tate sha** ,e +e+esente) , the

+econi:e) association s/,-ect to an o+)e+ of the

#o/+t o+ +eso*/tion of the B##& as the case ma ,e.

iii Associate >em,e+s

A. An E=istin >em,e+ ho )oes not fa** ithin the

)eCnition of a "/** >em,e+ sha** ,e an Associate

>em,e+ of the Boa+).

B. The Boa+) ma in)/ct an othe+ entit as anAssociate >em,e+ s/,-ect to a** the con)itions an)

)is/a*iCcations *ai) )on in /*e 3, ,e*o.

, ;+o/n)s fo+ sanction Q )e+econition of a "/** >em,e+

1 $o >em,e+ sha** ,e entit*e) to an +ant f+om the B##& if its

#onstit/tion fai*s to +oi)e fo+ o+ com* ith the fo**oin

ithin One Nea+ afte+ the Eectie !ate

~ 95 ~

Page 96: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 96/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

i The Association sha** not hae an +oision fo+ an ost

to ,e he*) fo+ mo+e than 9 ea+s.ii The oe+nin ,o) of the Association sha** inc*/)e

+e+esentaties of *ae+s an) omen an) a nominee of 

the Acco/ntant ;ene+a* of the tate.iii The Association sha** +ant a/tomatic mem,e+shi to

fo+me+ inte+nationa* *ae+s hai*in f+om the tate.i The Association sha** not hae +o= otin. The+e sha** ,e a +oision he+e, the O@ce Bea+e+s of 

the Association stan) )is/a*iCe) /n)e+ an of the

+o/n)s *ai) )on in /*e 143 ,e*o.i The Association sha** aoint an E*ecto+a* O@ce+ an

Ethics O@ce+ an) an Om,/)sman.ii The Association sha** a,i)e , the +inci*es of 

 T+ansa+enc *ai) )on in #hate+ 8 of these /*es.

2 &n the eent of the +ant ,ein )enie) to an >em,e+ /n)e+

1 a,oe the B##& sha** )i+ect* sen) the +ant in +esect of 

the tate conce+ne) in its caacit as parens patria.

3 &f an Association contin/es to ,e )isentit*e) fo+ a +ant /n)e+

1 a,oe fo+ a contin/o/s e+io) of 2 ea+s the B##& ma

)e+econi:e the Association as a >em,e+ an) if it is a "/**

>em,e+ in its *ace +econi:e an othe+ Association f+om

that tate hich com*ies ith the +e/i+ements of 1 a,oe.

c Ann/a* L)ates

A** >em,e+s sha** on o+ ,efo+e 15th $oem,e+ of each ea+

info+m an) /)ate the Boa+) as to the names of thei+ O@ce

Bea+e+s an) the mem,e+s of thei+ E=ec/tie #ommittees thei+

+esectie ten/+es the A/)ite) statement of Acco/nts an) the

Ba*ance heets.

) J/+is)iction

 The te++ito+ia* -/+is)iction of the "/** >em,e+s c*assiCe) /n)e+

/*e 3aii sha** ,e of the a)minist+atie tate so )eCne)

~ 96 ~

Page 97: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 97/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

/n)e+ the #onstit/tion. &f a tate e+e to ,e ,if/+cate) the

ne* c+eate) tate o/*) ,e entit*e) to an in)een)ent "/**

>em,e+shi an) sha** ,e so in)/cte) ithin 3 months of s/ch

tatehoo) comin into fo+ce.

. !OTE " ACCOUNTS OF TOURNAMENTS

1 Each "/** >em,e+ sha** hae one ote to ,e e=e+cise) th+o/h

its a/tho+i:e) e+esentatie.

2 An Associate >em,e+ sha** ,e entit*e) to a+ticiate in the

;ene+a* Bo) >eetins ,/t sha** not ,e entit*e) eithe+ to ote o+

hae its +e+esentatie e*ecte) to the Ae= #o/nci*.

3 A >em,e+ +e/i+e) to s/,mit the ann/a* o+ othe+ acco/nts

,a*ance sheets o+ statements of e=en)it/+e eithe+ /n)e+ these

/*es o+ /n)e+ the /*es of the to/+nament?match o+ /n)e+ the

+eso*/tions o+ )ecisions of the B##& +e*atin to an +ant fai*s to

s/,mit the acco/nts o+ the statements of e=en)it/+e +e*atin to

s/ch +ant to/+nament match o+ othe+ise ithin the e+io)

sti/*ate) the+e/n)e+ sha** not ,e entit*e) to an f/+the+

Cnancia* +ants f+om the B##& ti** the +e/i+ement is com*ie)

ith.

G+oi)e) that notithstan)in anthin state) a,oe

nothin sha** +eent the Ae= #o/nci* fo+ oo) +eason f+om

e=ten)in fo+ a ma=im/m e+io) of 6 months the time fo+

s/,mittin of acco/nts an) statements ,eon) the e+io)

+efe++e) to a,oe.

~ 97 ~

Page 98: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 98/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

CHAPTER T#O: THE GENERAL BODY AND OFFICE BEARERS

AND THEIR PO#ERS " FUNCTIONS

$. CONSTITUTION AND FUNCTIONS OF THE BOARD

1 The ;ene+a* Bo) is constit/te) of a** the >em,e+s of the

B##&.

2 The a/tho+i:e) e+esentaties of the a+io/s "/** >em,e+s

sha** cast thei+ otes on ,eha*f of thei+ +esectie "/** >em,e+.

 The Associate >em,e+s sha** hae no +iht to ote.

3 A** oe+s of oe+nance manaement an) )ecisionmain

sha** est in the ;ene+a* Bo). &n a))ition to the oe+s

a*+ea) ien to the Ae= #o/nci* the ;oe+nin #o/nci* an)

the #EO /n)e+ these /*es the ;ene+a* Bo) ma )e*eate

s/ch oe+s as it )eems Ct to an of them.

4 &n a))ition to an) itho/t +e-/)ice to the ene+a*it of 

oe+s este) in it the ;ene+a* Bo) sha** hae the oe+

aTo co**ect f/n)s an) he+ee+ necessa+ ,o++o ith o+

itho/t sec/+it fo+ /+oses of the Boa+) an) to +aise

*oans ith o+ itho/t sec/+it an) to /+chase +e)eem o+

a o an s/ch sec/+it.

,To f+ame the %as of #+icet in &n)ia an) to mae

a*te+ations amen)ments o+ a))itions to the %as of 

#+icet in &n)ia henee+ )esi+a,*e o+ necessa+.

c To )i+ect an) cont+o* the ;oe+nin #o/nci* to *en)

oe+siht an) assistance to the &G% con)/cte) , the

#o/nci* an) to ens/+e that the inte+ests of the f+anchises

an) the *ae+s a+e +otecte).

)To +eie an )ecision of the Ae= #o/nci* o+ the

;oe+nin #o/nci*.

~ 98 ~

Page 99: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 99/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

e;ene+a** to )o a** s/ch othe+ acts an) thins as ma

aea+ to the ;ene+a* Bo) to ,e e=e)ient conenient

an)?o+ con)/cie to the ca++in o/t of the a,oe

f/nctions of the Boa+).

%. ELECTION " TERM OF OFFICE BEARERS

1 The fo**oin O@ce Bea+e+s of the B##& sha** ,e e*ecte) ,

the "/** >em,e+s of the Boa+) f+om amonst thei+

+e+esentaties at an Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin

a The G+esi)ent

, The IiceG+esi)ent

c The ec+eta+

) The Joint ec+eta+

e The T+eas/+e+

2 The Te+m of o@ce of an O@ce Bea+e+ sha** ,e 3 ea+s. Thei+

osition sha** ,e Hono+a+.

3 $o e+son sha** ,e an O@ce Bea+e+ fo+ mo+e than 3 te+ms in

a**.

4 $o O@ce Bea+e+ sha** ,e e*ii,*e to contest a s/ccee)in

e*ection i.e. no O@ce Bea+e+ sha** hae a consec/tie te+m as

an O@ce Bea+e+.

5A e+son sha** ,e )is/a*iCe) f+om ,ein an O@ce Bea+e+ if he

o+ shea&s not a citi:en of &n)ia<,Has attaine) the ae of 70 ea+s<c &s )ec*a+e) to ,e inso*ent o+ of /nso/n) min)<)&s a >iniste+ o+ ;oe+nment e+ant<eHo*)s an o@ce o+ ost in a so+ts o+ ath*etic

association o+ fe)e+ation aa+t f+om c+icet<

f Has ,een an O@ce Bea+e+ of the B##& fo+ ac/m/*atie e+io) of 9 ea+s<

~ 99 ~

Page 100: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 100/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

&. PO#ERS AND DUTIES OF OFFICE'BEARERS:

1 THE GE&!E$T

a The G+esi)ent sha** +esi)e at a** meetins of the

;ene+a* Bo) an) the Ae= #o/nci*., The G+esi)ent sha** a*so e=e+cise s/ch f/nctions an)

)/ties as he ma ,e emoe+e) ith , the ;ene+a*

Bo) o+ the Ae= #o/nci*.

c The G+esi)ent sha** in the eent of a acanc o+

in)isosition of an O@ce Bea+e+ )e*eate the f/nctions

to anothe+ O@ce Bea+e+ /nti* the acanc is )/* C**e)

/ o+ the in)isosition ceases.

2 THE I&#E GE&!E$T

aThe Iice G+esi)ent sha** o@ciate in the G+esi)ents

a,sence hen the G+esi)ent is /naai*a,*e.,The Iice G+esi)ent sha** a*so e=e+cise s/ch f/nctions an)

)/ties as he ma ,e emoe+e) ith , the ;ene+a*

Bo) o+ the Ae= #o/nci*.

3 THE E#ETAN

 The ec+eta+ sha**

a 'ee an) maintain the min/tes of Ann/a* ;ene+a* an)

ecia* ;ene+a* >eetins of the ;ene+a* Bo) the

>eetins of the Ae= #o/nci* an) of the #ommittees

aointe) , the ;ene+a* Bo) in a+o+iate ,oos an)

sha** ca/se them to ,e +oe+* an) co++ect* +eco+)e)an) conC+me).

, in a** cont+acts fo+ an) on ,eha*f of the B##& an) ca++

on a** co++eson)ence in the name of the B##& sae as

othe+ise )i+ecte) , the Ae= #o/nci*.

c Be in cha+e of the +eco+)s of the ;ene+a* Bo) the

Ae= #o/nci* the ;oe+nin #o/nci* an) a**

#ommittees an) s/ch +oe+ties as ma ,e ent+/ste)to his ca+e , the Boa+) the Ae= #o/nci* o+ the

~ 100 ~

Page 101: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 101/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

;oe+nin #o/nci* as the case ma ,e.

) #onene the Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin the ecia*

;ene+a* >eetin an) the >eetins of the Ae= #o/nci*

an) ;oe+nin #o/nci* ith the conc/++ence of theG+esi)ent.

e #i+c/*ate to a** >em,e+s of the B##& the statement of 

acco/nts +ea+e) , the T+eas/+e+.

f Hae the oe+ to )e*eate an o+ to the Hono+a+

 Joint ec+eta+.

4 THE JO&$T E#ETAN

 The Joint ec+eta+ sha**

a #onene an) ee min/tes of the #ommittees that ma

,e *ace) in his cha+e at the Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin

o+ , the ec+eta+.

, Assist the ec+eta+ in a** matte+s e+tainin to the

aai+s of the Boa+).

5 THE TEALE

 The T+eas/+e+ sha**

aeceie a** s/,sc+itions an) )onations an) the monies

aa,*e an) ? o+ +eceia,*e , the B##&<

, >ae aments an) inc/+ e=en)it/+e o/t of the f/n)s

of the B##& in acco+)ance ith the )ecisions of the B##&

the Ae= #o/nci* o+ an #ommittee aointe) , the

Boa+) +oi)e) that a** t+ansfe+s o+ aments m/st ,e

ith the sinat/+es of to e*ecte) O@ce Bea+e+s of 

hich the T+eas/+e+ sha** ,e one.

c 'ee acco/nts of a** monies +eceie) an) e=en)e) ,

the B##& in +esect of assets c+e)its an) *ia,i*ities of 

the B##&.

~ 101 ~

Page 102: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 102/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

) G+ea+e statement of acco/nts.

 e G*ace ,efo+e the Ae= #o/nci*

i Ann/a* Ba*ance heet<

ii tatement of Acco/nts of the B##&<

iii Ann/a* B/)et<

f G*ace ,efo+e the Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin )/* a/)ite)

i Ann/a* Ba*ance heet<

ii tatement of Acco/nts of the B##&<

&nest an)?o+ )is,/+se the f/n)s of the B##& to

ith)+a an o+ a** of the e=istin C=e) )eosits ,efo+e

the )ate of mat/+it in acco+)ance ith an ene+a* o+

secia* )i+ections of the ;ene+a* Bo) o+ the Ae=

#o/nci*.

h G+ea+e ,/)ets to ,e +esente) at the Ann/a* ;ene+a*

>eetin ecia* ;ene+a* >eetins an) >eetins of the

Ae= #o/nci*.

i %iaise ith the A/)ito+ an) the "inance #ommittee to

o,tain oe+siht on ho the "/** >em,e+s a+e /ti*i:in

f/n)s a**otte) to them , the B##&.

~ 102 ~

Page 103: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 103/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

CHAPTER THREE: MEETINGS OF THE GENERAL BODY 

. ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING

1The Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin of the ;ene+a* Bo) sha** ,e he*)

ee+ ea+ not *ate+ than 30th etem,e+ at s/ch *ace an)

time as the G+esi)ent ma C=.

2E*ections an) $ominations to the Ae= #o/nci* sha** tae *ace

ee+ 3 ea+s at the Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin.

3The fo**oin ,/siness sha** ,e t+ansacte) at ee+ Ann/a*

;ene+a* >eetin of the ;ene+a* Bo)

a #onC+mation of the min/tes of the +eio/s ;ene+a*

>eetins.

, A)otion of the eo+t of the ec+eta+ fo+ the ea+

/n)e+ +eie.

c A)otion of the T+eas/+e+s eo+t an) the a/)ite)

acco/nts fo+ the ea+ /n)e+ +eie.

) A)otion of the Ann/a* B/)et.

e Aointment of A/)ito+ o+ A/)ito+s fo+ the ea+ an) C=

thei+ +em/ne+ation.

f Aointment of the Om,/)sman an) Ethics O@ce+.

Aointment of the #+icet #ommittees an) tan)in

#ommittees as mentione) in /*es 26 an) 25

+esectie*.

h i #onsi)e+ation of the eo+t an) +ecommen)ations of 

the Ae= #o/nci* the #EO an) the #ommittees an) to+oose o*ic )i+ections to the Ae= #o/nci*.

ii #onsi)e+ation of the eo+t an) +ecommen)ations

of the ;oe+nin #o/nci* an) to +oose o*ic

)i+ections to the Ae= #o/nci*.

iii #onsi)e+ation of an amen)ments to the /*es

an) e/*ations of the B##& +oi)e) no amen)ment to

the /*es an) e/*ations of the B##& +oose) , a "/**>em,e+ sha** ,e consi)e+e) /n*ess the +oosa*s fo+

~ 103 ~

Page 104: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 104/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

amen)ments a+e +eceie) , the ec+eta+ ,efo+e 31st

 J/*.

i #onsi)e+ation of the eo+ts of the Om,/)sman

an) Ethics O@ce+ an) an +ecommen)ations ma)ethe+ein.

i #onsi)e+ation of an motion notice he+eof is ien ,

a "/** >em,e+ to the ec+eta+ tentone )as ,efo+e

the meetin. /ch a motion sha** ,e ci+c/*ate) in

a)ance to a** mem,e+s.

- To aoint the B##&s e+esentatie o+ e+esentaties

on the &nte+nationa* #+icet #onfe+ence o+ simi*a+

#onfe+ences.

i #onsi)e+ation of an othe+ ,/siness hich the

G+esi)ent ma consi)e+ necessa+ to ,e inc*/)e) in the

aen)a.

ii T+ansaction of an othe+ ,/siness of an info+ma*

cha+acte+ as ma ,e e+mitte) , the #hai+e+son.

4 The +eco+) of the +ocee)ins of the Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetins

an) ecia* ;ene+a* >eetins sha** afte+ the a+oa* of the

#hai+e+son of the >eetin ,e ci+c/*ate) ithin to months of 

the >eetin to the >em,e+s of the B##& an) then ente+e) in the

>in/tes Boo. The min/tes sha** ,e )/* conC+me) afte+

co++ection if an an) sine) , the #hai+e+son at the

s/,se/ent Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin.

5 The ec+eta+ sha** at *east Tent One 21 )as +io+ to the

)ate C=e) fo+ the Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin fo+a+) to each

mem,e+ a notice settin o/t the aen)a of ,/siness to ,e

t+ansacte) at the Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin a*on ith

a#oies of the >in/tes of the +eio/s meetin o+

meetins to ,e conC+me) at the Ann/a* ;ene+a* meetin<,#oies of a/)ite) tatement of Acco/nts to ,e a)ote)

an) to ,e asse) at the Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin<

c#oies of the a/)ite) tatement of Acco/nts of an to/+o+ to/+s<

~ 104 ~

Page 105: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 105/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

)T+eas/+e+s eo+ts an) the Ann/a* B/)et<eeo+t of the Om,/)sman< an)f #oies of a** )oc/ments an) ae+s hain a +efe+ence to

an item on the Aen)a of the ;ene+a* >eetin<

6 An >em,e+ )esi+in to +aise an oint +e*atin to the Aen)a o+

Acco/nts at the Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin sha** ie seen )as

notice the+eof to the ec+eta+. The ec+eta+ sha** ci+c/*ate s/ch

notice to a** >em,e+s ,efo+e the )ate C=e) fo+ the meetin.

. SPECIAL GENERAL MEETING

1 A ecia* ;ene+a* >eetin of the ;ene+a* Bo) ma ,e conene)

, the ec+eta+

a on a )i+ectie of the G+esi)ent

, on a +eso*/tion of the Ae= #o/nci* o+

c on a +e/isition sine) , not *ess than 10 "/** >em,e+s

secia** statin the ,/siness to ,e t+ansacte) at s/ch >eetin.

$o ,/siness othe+ than the one fo+ hich the ecia* ;ene+a*

>eetin is ca**e) i** ,e t+ansacte) at s/ch meetin.

2 &n the eent of the ec+eta+ fai*in to conene a ecia* ;ene+a*

>eetin ithin thi+t )as of the +eceit of a +e/isition the

+e/isitionists ma themse*es conene a >eetin fo+ the

/+ose seciCe) in the +e/isition at s/ch *ace an) time as

ma ,e )eci)e) , the +e/isitionists.

3 The G+esi)ent ma at his )isc+etion )i+ect the ec+eta+ to

conene a ecia* ;ene+a* >eetin at sho+te+ notice in hich

case a notice of at *east 10 )as sha** ,e ien.

4 "o+ an ecia* ;ene+a* >eetin the ec+eta+ sha** ie Tent

One )as notice secifin the ,/siness to ,e t+ansacte) at that

meetin.

~ 105 ~

Page 106: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 106/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

5 &n the eent of the ec+eta+ fai*in to conene a ecia* ;ene+a*

>eetin at the )i+ection of the G+esi)ent o+ on a +eso*/tion of the

Ae= #o/nci* ithin Ten )as the G+esi)ent ma conene a

meetin /n)e+ his on sinat/+e.

1*. QUORUM AT ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING " SPECIAL GENERAL

MEETING

1 Ten "/** >em,e+s +esent an) entit*e) to ote sha** ,e a /o+/m

fo+ an Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin. $o ,/siness sha** ,e t+ansacte)

at the Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin /n*ess the /o+/m +e/isite is

+esent at the commencement of the ,/siness of the meetin. &f 

ithin an ho/+ f+om the time aointe) fo+ the Ann/a* ;ene+a*

>eetin a /o+/m is not +esent the meetin sha** stan)

a)-o/+ne) to the same )ate of the fo**oin month an) at the

same *ace an) time. &f at the a)-o/+ne) meetin the /o+/m is

not +esent ithin an ho/+ f+om the time of the meetin the "/**

>em,e+s +esent sha** fo+m the /o+/m.

2 "o+ a ecia* ;ene+a* >eetin ten "/** >em,e+s +esent an)

entit*e) to ote sha** ,e /o+/m. &f no /o+/m is +esent at the

aointe) time of the meetin the meetin sha** stan)

a)-o/+ne) fo+ an ho/+. &f at the a)-o/+ne) meetin the /o+/m is

not +esent the "/** >em,e+s +esent sha** fo+m the /o+/m.

11. CHAIRPERSON AT MEETINGS

 The G+esi)ent sha** +esi)e as #hai+e+son at the Ann/a* ;ene+a*

>eetin o+ the ecia* ;ene+a* >eetin of the ;ene+a* Bo) an) in his

a,sence the IiceG+esi)ent sha** +esi)e. &n the eent of the Iice

G+esi)ent a*so ,ein a,sent the >eetin sha** e*ect one amonst them

as the #hai+e+son of the >eetin.

~ 106 ~

Page 107: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 107/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

12. !OTING AT ANNUAL GENERAL MEETINGS + SPECIAL GENERAL

MEETINGS

1 At the Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin ? ecia* ;ene+a* >eetineach "/** >em,e+ sha** hae one ote. The Associate >em,e+s

sha** hae no ote.

2 At an Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin ? ecia* ;ene+a* >eetin a

+eso*/tion *ace) ,efo+e the >eetin )/* moe) an)

secon)e) sha** ,e /t to ote an) sha** ,e )eci)e) eithe+ on a

sho of han)s o+ , a sec+et ,a**ot as the #hai+e+son ma

)eci)e.

13. CASTING !OTE OR DRA#ING LOTS

ae as +oi)e) othe+ise , these /*es /estions a+isin at an

meetin sha** ,e )eci)e) , a ma-o+it of otes an) in the eent of 

a tie the #hai+e+son sha** hae a castin ote. &f the #hai+e+son of 

the >eetin )ec*ines to e=e+cise his castin ote the iss/e sha** ,e

)eci)e) , )+ain *ots.

~ 107 ~

Page 108: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 108/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

CHAPTER FOUR: GO!ERNANCE

1. THE APEX COUNCIL

1 The+e sha** ,e an Ae= #o/nci* fo+ the B##& hich sha** ,e+ima+i* +esonsi,*e fo+ the oe+nance of the aai+s of the

Boa+).2 The Ae= #o/nci* sha** com+ise of 9 #o/nci**o+s of hom 5

sha** ,e the e*ecte) O@ce Bea+e+s as e+ /*e 6 an) the

+emainin 4 sha** ,eaOne to ,e e*ecte) , the "/** >em,e+s of the B##&

f+om amon thei+ +e+esentaties<

,To to ,e nominate) , the G*ae+s Associationf+om amonst themse*es one ma*e an) one

fema*e<c One to ,e nominate) , the #omt+o**e+ an)

A/)ito+ ;ene+a* of &n)ia f+om amon the se+in

senio+ f/nctiona+ies of the #QA;s o@ce co

te+min/s ith the nominees ten/+e<3 A e+son sha** ,e )is/a*iCe) f+om ,ein a #o/nci**o+ if he o+

shea&s not a citi:en of &n)ia<,Has attaine) the ae of 70 ea+s<c &s )ec*a+e) to ,e inso*ent o+ of /nso/n) min)<)&s a >iniste+ o+ a oe+nment se+ant Re=cet fo+

the nominee /n)e+ /*e 142cS<eHo*)s an o@ce o+ ost in a so+ts o+ ath*etic

association o+ fe)e+ation aa+t f+om c+icet<f Has ,een an O@ce Bea+e+ of the B##& fo+ a

c/m/*atie e+io) of 9 ea+s<4 Each of the e*ecte) #o/nci**o+s sha** hae a te+m of 3 ea+s in

o@ce s/,-ect to a ma=im/m of 3 Te+ms on the Ae= #o/nci*.

$o e*ecte) #o/nci**o+ sha** ho*) to consec/tie Te+ms on the

Ae= #o/nci*.5 $o in)ii)/a* inc*/)in one C**in / a acanc /n)e+ /,

/*e 9 ,e*o sha** ,e a #o/nci**o+ fo+ mo+e than 9 ea+s. &n

the eent of a #o/nci**o+ com*etin 9 ea+s ,efo+e the e=i+

of his te+m he sha** cease to ho*) o@ce on com*etion of 9

~ 108 ~

Page 109: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 109/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

ea+s.6 $o nominate) #o/nci**o+ sha** hae mo+e than one te+m of 3

ea+s.7 A fo+me+ G+esi)ent of the B##& sha** not ,e entit*e) to ,e

e*ecte) o+ nominate) to the Ae= #o/nci* in an caacit

e=cet fo+ a secon) an) Cna* te+m as G+esi)ent s/,-ect to

s/,/*es 4 an) 5 a,oe.8 $o #o/nci**o+ once e*ecte) sha** ho*) an o@ce in a "/**

>em,e+ Association. The "/** >em,e+ sha** tae stes to C** /

the acanc so c+eate) imme)iate*.9 An acanc in the Ae= #o/nci* )/e to )eath +esination

inso*enc /nso/n)ness of min) nomination to the &## o+

othe+ )is/a*iCcation sha** ,e C**e) / fo+ the +emainin

e+io)a. &n the case of an e*ecte) #o/nci**o+ , e*ections at a

ecia* ;ene+a* Bo) meetin of the B##& conene) , the

ec+eta+ fo+ that /+ose ithin 45 )as<,. &n the case of a nominate) #o/nci**o+ in the same manne+

as +esc+i,e) fo+ the +esectie nominee in /*e 142

a,oe<10 "o+ the /+oses of the ocieties eist+ation Act the

oe+nin ,o) of the B##& sha** ,e the Ae= #o/nci*.

1$. PO#ERS AND FUNCTIONS OF THE APEX COUNCIL

1The aai+s of the Boa+) sha** ,e oe+ne) , the Ae= #o/nci*

an) its f+ameo+ of oe+nance sha**i. Ena,*e st+ateic /i)ance of the entit<

ii. Ens/+e e@cient monito+in of manaement<iii. #*a+if the +esectie +o*es +esonsi,i*ities an) oe+s

of the #EO >anae+s #+icet #ommittees an) tan)in

#ommittees e=cet the ;oe+nin #o/nci*<i. Ens/+e a )ist+i,/tion an) ,a*ance of a/tho+it so that no

sin*e in)ii)/a* has /nfette+e) oe+s<

2The Ae= #o/nci* sha** hae a** the oe+s of the ;ene+a*

Bo) an) a/tho+it an) )isc+etion to )o a** acts an) thins

e=cet s/ch acts as , these +/*es a+e e=+ess* )i+ecte) o+

~ 109 ~

Page 110: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 110/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

+e/i+e) to ,e )one , the ;ene+a* Bo). E=e+cise of s/ch

oe+s a/tho+ities an) )isc+etion sha** ,e s/,-ect to the

cont+o* an) +e/*ation of the ;ene+a* Bo). $o +e/*ation sha**

+et+osectie* ina*i)ate an act of the Ae= #o/nci* hichas othe+ise a*i).

3The Ae= #o/nci* sha** e=e+cise s/e+inten)ence oe+ the

#EO the #+icet #ommittees an) the tan)in #ommittees in

the )ischa+e of thei+ )/ties ene+a** an) in a+tic/*a+ in

acco+)ance ith an ene+a* o+ secia* )i+ection of the

;ene+a* Bo) e=cet fo+ the ;oe+nin #o/nci* of the &G%

hich is )i+ect* acco/nta,*e to the ;ene+a* Bo).

4&n a))ition to an) itho/t +e-/)ice to the ene+a*it of 

oe+s confe++e) )i+ect* o+ , necessa+ im*ication /n)e+

these /*es an) +e/*ations an) the >emo+an)/m of 

Association the Ae= #o/nci* sha** e=e+cise the oe+s an)

e+fo+m the )/ties he+eafte+ mentione)a. To cont+o* e+mit an) +e/*ate a** asects +ea+)in the

isits of fo+ein c+icet teams to &n)ia an) isits of &n)ianteams to fo+ein co/nt+ies an) to sett*e the te+ms on

hich s/ch isits sha** ,e con)/cte).,. To *a )on con)itions on hich G*ae+s sha** tae a+t in

a to/+ to an fo+ein co/nt+ an) , hich s/ch G*ae+s

sha** ,e oe+ne) inc*/)in te+ms of aments to s/ch

G*ae+s.c. To cont+o* e=an) an) +e/*ate the Cnances of the B##&.

). To instit/te o+ )efen) an action o+ +ocee)ins fo+ o+aainst the B##& o+ aainst an O@ceBea+e+ o+ em*oee

of the B##&.e. To me)iate in +ea+) to iss/es ,eteen >em,e+s fai*in

+eso*/tion of hich a +efe+ence ma ,e ma)e to the

Om,/)sman<f. To inte+act an) cons/*t ith the #+icet G*ae+s

Association +ea+)in +e+esentations ma)e on thei+

,eha*f.. To /+chase se** an)?o+ mo+tae e=chane an)?o+

~ 110 ~

Page 111: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 111/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

othe+ise )isose of immoa,*e +oe+t he+ee+

sit/ate) in o+)e+ to +omote the o,-ects of the B##&.h. To co**ect f/n)s an) henee+ necessa+ ,o++o not

e=cee)in 25 of the ;ene+a* "/n) ith o+ itho/t

sec/+it fo+ /+oses of the B##& an) to +aise *oans ith

o+ itho/t sec/+it an) to /+chase +e)eem o+ a o 

an s/ch sec/+it.i. To C** / ti** the fo**oin Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin an

acanc occ/++in of a mem,e+ of a committee , +eason

of )eath o+ ,ein a)-/)e) inso*ent o+ ,ein of /nso/n)

min) o+ ,ein conicte) of a c+imina* oence ino*in

mo+a* t/+it/)e o+ , +esination o+ an othe+

)is/a*iCcation. -. To f+ame +/*es an) *a )on con)itions inc*/)in those of 

t+ae* accommo)ation an) a**oances /n)e+ hich

&n)ian G*ae+s sha** tae a+t in c+icet

to/+naments?matches o+ E=hi,ition "estia* an) #ha+it

matches o+ani:e) , the B##& o+ , a >em,e+ /n)e+ the

a/tho+it of the B##& in the co/+se of a isit o+ to/+ of a

fo+ein c+icet team to &n)ia.. To f+ame +/*es fo+ the $ationa* #hamionshi of &n)ia fo+

the an-i T+oh matches o+ fo+ Lnie+sit choo*s o+

othe+ to/+naments o+ fo+ an E=hi,ition matches ,eteen

mem,e+s an) ? o+ ,eteen the Lnie+sities in &n)ia.*. To f+ame +/*es +ea+)in the aointment se+ice

con)itions an) )isci*ina+ action conce+nin em*oees

an) o@ce+s of the B##&.m. To mae the To/+nament /*es fo+ a+io/s )omestic

to/+naments an) e=hi,ition matches ino*in >em,e+s

Lnie+sities an) othe+ entities.n. To f+ame in cons/*tation ith the #EO +/*es fo+ the

aointment of >anae+s ec+eta+ies A)minist+atie

O@ce+s Geons an) othe+ se+ice e+sonne* an) sta an)

fo+ ament to them an) othe+ e+sons in +et/+n fo+ thei+

se+ices +en)e+e) to the B##& sa*a+ies aes +at/ities

~ 111 ~

Page 112: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 112/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

ensions hono+a+i/ms comensations an e=+atia

ament an)?o+ +oi)ent f/n) an) to +e/*ate )isci*ine

, s/sen)in Cnin +emoin o+ )ismissin s/ch

em*oees.o. To mae +/*es ene+a** fo+ the manaement of the aai+s

of the B##&.. To sta+t o+ sonso+ an)?o+ to s/,sc+i,e to f/n)s o+ stae a

match fo+ the ,eneCt of c+icete+s o+ e+sons ho ma

hae +en)e+e) se+ice to the ame of c+icet o+ fo+ thei+

fami*ies o+ to )onate fo+ the )ee*oment o+ +omotion of 

the ame to ,e +e/*ate) , +/*es f+ame) in this +ea+)

f+om time to time.. To aoint B##&s +e+esentatie o+ +e+esentaties on the

&nte+nationa* #+icet #o/nci* Asian #+icet #o/nci* o+

simi*a+ confe+ence.+. To eithe+ on its on of th+o/h its )e*eate ente+tain

hea+ an) )eci)e a)minist+atie aea*s , em*oees o+

othe+ )i+ect* aecte) a+ties aainst the o+)e+s of the

#EO o+ the #+icet #ommittees as the case ma ,e.

s. ;ene+a** to )o a** s/ch othe+ acts an) thins hich a+e)e*eate) to it , the Boa+) an) a** othe+ f/nctions to ,e

e=e)ient conenient an)?o+ con)/cie to the ca++in

o/t of the a,oe f/nctions of the Ae= #o/nci*.

G+oi)e) that the e=e+cise of oe+s /n)e+ #*a/ses -

* m n an) o sha** ,e s/,-ect to +atiCcation , the Boa+)

at its ne=t meetin fai*in hich the +/*es sha** *ase.

5The Ae= #o/nci* sha** meet at *east once ee+ 3 months at

s/ch time an) *ace an) sha** con)/ct +ocee)ins in s/ch

manne+ as it ma f+om time to time )eci)e.

6A ecia* >eetin of the Ae= #o/nci* ma ,e conene) at

an time , the G+esi)ent an) sha** ,e conene) on a

+e/isition to that eect ,ein ma)e in +itin , not *ess

than th+ee #o/nci**o+s. An s/ch +e/isition sha** e=+ess theo,-ect of the meetin +oose) to ,e ca**e) an) sha** ,e sent

~ 112 ~

Page 113: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 113/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

to the ec+eta+.

7"o/+teen )as c*ea+ notice of the >eetin of the Ae= #o/nci*

toethe+ ith the Aen)a sha** ,e ien to the #o/nci**o+s. "o+

a ecia* >eetin of the Ae= #o/nci* conene) fo+ the

/+oses state) in /,/*e5 a,oe een )as c*ea+

notice sha** ,e ien. An Eme+ent meetin of the Ae=

#o/nci* ma ,e conene) ith To )as notice.

8"ie mem,e+s of the Ae= #o/nci* sha** fo+m a /o+/m fo+ its

meetins. The G+esi)ent o+ in his a,sence a mem,e+ e*ecte)

, those +esent at the meetin sha** ,e the #hai+e+son. &n

the eent of a tie the #hai+e+son sha** hae a castin ote.

9A +eso*/tion , ci+c/*ation , a** mem,e+s of the Ae= #o/nci*

sha** ,e as a*i) an) eectie as if it ha) ,een asse) at a

meetin of the Ae= #o/nci*. /ch a +eso*/tion sha** ,e +atiCe)

at the ne=t meetin of the Ae= #o/nci*.

10 The ec+eta+ sha** ee the min/tes of ee+ >eetin

in a ,oo hich sha** ,e sine) , the #hai+e+son hena+oe).

1%. BCCI JURISDICTION O!ER PLAYERS, MATCH OFFICIALS "

TEAM OFFICIALS OF MEMBERS

 The B##& sha** hae conc/++ent -/+is)iction an) cont+o* oe+ G*ae+s

>atch O@cia*s an) Team O@cia*s ithin the -/+is)iction of a

>em,e+. /ch in)ii)/a*s a+ticiatin in c+icet /n)e+ the aeis of a >em,e+ sha** ,e )eeme) iso facto to s/,mit to the -/+is)iction of 

the B##&.

1&. CONDUCT OF PLAYERS

 The Ae= #o/nci* sha** hae the oe+ to en/i+e into the con)/ct

of an G*ae+ ithin its -/+is)iction an) ma tae s/ch )isci*ina+

action aainst the G*ae+ as the Ae= #o/nci* ma )eem Ct hich

)ecision sha** ,e Cna*.

~ 113 ~

Page 114: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 114/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

1. ENQUIRY INTO CONDUCT OF PLAYERS, MATCH OFFICIALS,

ADMINISTRATORS, ETC.

&n the eent of the B##& en/i+in into the con)/ct of a G*ae+>atch O@cia* A)minist+ato+ etc. the B##& sha** +ocee) in the

manne+ +esc+i,e) in /*e 41.

~ 114 ~

Page 115: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 115/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

CHAPTER FI!E: MANAGEMENT

1. ADMINISTRATION OF THE BCCI

1>/m,ai sha** ,e the a)minist+atie hea)/a+te+s he+e theo@ce of the B##& sha** ,e e+manent* sit/ate). &t sha** ,e the

#ent+a* ec+eta+iat of the B##&.2The )ato)a manaement of the B##& sha** ,e con)/cte)

, +ofessiona*s in ,oth c+icetin an) nonc+icetin matte+s.3The ;oe+nin #o/nci* of the &G% sha** ,e acco/nta,*e )i+ect*

to the ;ene+a* Bo) an) not to the #EO o+ the Ae= #o/nci*.

2*. NON'CRIC-ETING MATTERS1 The )a to )a manaement of nonc+icetin matte+s

inc*/)in oe+ations technica* h/man +eso/+ces Cnance an)

me)ia sha** ,e con)/cte) , the #EO /n)e+ the s/e+ision of 

the Ae= #o/nci* ai)e) , the a)ice of the tan)in

#ommittees as set o/t in /*e 24.

2 The #EO sha** ,e assiste) , >anae+s as ma ,e aointe)

/n)e+ /*e 23.

21. CRIC-ETING MATTERS

1 The manaement of c+icetin matte+s s/ch as se*ections

coachin an) ea*/ation of team e+fo+mance sha** ,e

e=c*/sie* han)*e) , the #+icet #ommittees com+isin

on* of G*ae+s as set o/t in /*e 26.

2 The manaement ea*/ation an) se*ection of /mi+es sha**,e )one , the Lmi+es #ommittee com+isin on* of 

Lmi+es as set o/t in /*e 27.

3 The +eo+ts of the #+icet an) Lmi+es #ommittees sha** ,e

sent to the #EO fo+ ,ein fo+a+)e) to the Ae= #o/nci* ,/t

the #EO sha** not in an a ,e ino*e) in the +ea+ation

a+oa* o+ amen)ment of the same.

22. EFFICIENCY IN FUNCTIONING1 The ,ane+s *ae+s an) othe+s oe+in +ofessiona* se+ices

~ 115 ~

Page 116: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 116/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

to the B##& sha** ,e aointe) in a fai+ an) t+ansa+ent

manne+ an) ma ,e chane) f+om time to time as the B##&

ma )eem e=e)ient.

2 The ,an acco/nt of the B##& sha** ,e oe+ate) , the T+eas/+e+ a*on ith the Joint ec+eta+ an) in the a,sence of 

the Joint ec+eta+ , the ec+eta+.

3 The #EO an) the #+icet Q Lmi+es #ommittees sha** f/nction

in)een)ent* in thei+ +esectie )omains itho/t an

inte+fe+ence o+ a+oa* f+om each othe+.

23. THE CEO

1The )ato)a manaement of the aai+s of the B##& sha** est

in a f/** time #EO to ,e aointe) , the Ae= #o/nci* ho sha**

,e a manaement +ofessiona* ith manaement e=e+ience of 

at *east 5 ea+s as the #EO?>! of a coman ith a t/+noe+ of 

at *east s.100 c+o+e.2The #EO sha** ,e assiste) , not mo+e than 6 f/**time

+ofessiona*s >anae+s ho sha** ,e aointe) , the Ae=

#o/nci* in cons/*tation ith the #EO essentia** to oe+n the

st+eams of Cnance technica* inf+ast+/ct/+e *a me)ia an)

h/man +eso/+ces. The #EO ma hoee+ +ea*in o+ +ea**ot these

st+eams as he )eems Ct.3The e*ii,i*it c+ite+ia fo+ the #EO an) >anae+s sha** ,e *ai)

)on , the Ae= #o/nci* eein in min) the fo**oin

/i)e*inesa. 'no*e)e an) fami*ia+it ith c+icet o+ othe+ so+ts<,. Ln)e+stan)in of Cnancia* osition an) Csca* )i+ection of 

the B##&<c. 'no*e)e of oe+ations of c+icet a)minist+ation an)

oe+a** o*ic<). #*a+it on +o*e )iision of +esonsi,i*ities an) hie+a+ch<e. "ami*ia+it ith +e/*ato+ an) *ea* +esonsi,i*ities as e**

as atten)ant +iss<4The+e sha** ,e an a+o+iate in)/ction +ocess *ai) )on , the

Ae= #o/nci* fo+ the #EO an) the >anae+s hich sha** inc*/)e afai+ an) t+ansa+ent +ocess of aointment.

~ 116 ~

Page 117: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 117/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

2. THE FUNCTIONS OF THE CEO

 The #EO sha** hae the fo**oin f/nctions on ,eha*f of the B##&

1To im*ement a** the /*es an) e/*ations ma)e , the

;oe+nin Bo) an) the Ae= #o/nci* in +ea+) to nonc+icetin

matte+s<2To iss/e /i)e*ines in +esect of t+ae* accommo)ation

a**oances etc. to ,e ai) to *ae+s s/o+t sta an) o@cia*s

a+ticiatin in matches othe+ than inte+nationa* matches<3To *ease an) manae immoa,*e +oe+t of the B##& he+ee+

sit/ate) in o+)e+ to +omote the o,-ects of the B##&.4To *a )on a+amete+s fo+ the *ain of +o/n)s fo+ *ain the

ame an) to +oi)e ai*ion canteen an) othe+ coneniences

an) amenities in connection the+eith.5To aoint Team O@cia*s fo+ the &n)ian teams hich sha**

com/*so+i* inc*/)e /a*iCe) coaches manae+s

hsiothe+aists n/t+itionists t+aine+s ana*sts co/nse**o+s an)

me)ics.6To sec/+e G*ae+s e*fa+e to ens/+e that the *oistics manae+

i** a++ane fo+ accommo)ation an) t+ae* to ens/+e that ticets

ien to G*ae+s fo+ matches i** ,e on a+ ith those ien to the

>em,e+s an) to a*so ens/+e that no e=en)it/+es toa+)s the

ame ,aae han)*in in-/+ +e*ate) etc. i** ,e /n)e+taen

, the G*ae+ fai*in hich s/ch e=enses i** ,e +eim,/+se) to

the G*ae+ ithin 30 o+in )as of the +e/isition ,ein ma)e.

A*so to +ocess +e/ests ma)e , G*ae+s to mae a++anements

fo+ the accommo)ation an) t+ae* of thei+ +esectie ies ?

a+tne+s ? fami* mem,e+s he+ee+ e+mitte).7To ens/+e that a** meas/+es a+e a)ote) to e*iminate an fo+m of 

+acia* comm/na* casteist o+ othe+ hat+e) f+om the ame ith

st+inent action taen aainst the oen)e+s inc*/)in the

initiation of c+imina* +ocee)ins.8To sta+t an) maintain a *i,+a+ of ,oos e+io)ica*s !I!s an)

othe+ )ata,ases on o+ts in ene+a* an) #+icet in a+tic/*a+ an)

to /,*ish -o/+na*s ,oos an) othe+ mate+ia* as e** as the o@cia*

e,site of the B##&.

~ 117 ~

Page 118: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 118/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

9To +o)/ce , itse*f the #+icet content fo+ te*ecast of c+icet

matches an)?o+ ce+emonies , hi+in o+ onin e/iment an)

hi+in necessa+ c+e technicians etc.10 To /,*ici:e the sta)i/m caacit of a** sta)ia ac+oss the

co/nt+ ith com/*so+ seat n/m,e+s to +oi)e t+ansa+ent

on*ine an) oUine ticet ,ooin se+ices ith +easona,* +ice)

ticets an) ma=imi:e the access of the /,*ic to the ames.11 To +oi)e at sta)i/ms ho*esome an) hienic foo) an)

,ee+aes at ao+)a,*e +ates c*ean an) hienic +est+ooms fo+ a**

en)e+s an) fo+ the )ie+ent*a,*e) a)e/ate C+e an)

eme+enc ent+ies an) co++i)o+s s/@cient access aen/es an)

hee*chai+s fo+ the )ie+ent*a,*e) +oe+ sinae a+in an)

t+anso+t faci*ities as e** as e@cient sec/+it sstems.12 To a++ane an) o+ani:e the $ationa* #hamionshi of &n)ia

fo+ the an-i T+oh matches o+ fo+ Lnie+sit choo*s o+ othe+

to/+naments o+ fo+ an E=hi,ition matches ,eteen mem,e+s an)

? o+ ,eteen the Lnie+sities in &n)ia inc*/)in +e/*ations an)

,e*as in +esect of t+ae* accommo)ation a**oances to ,e

ai) to *ae+s an) o@cia*s a+ticiatin in s/ch matches.13 To f+ame /i)e*ines ene+a** fo+ the conenience an) ease of 

)ato)a manaement of aai+s of the B##&.14 To +esc+i,e /i)e*ines to *a o/t o+ cone+t an +o/n) into

hih /a*it t/+f icets at a** *ee*s in a** a+eas of the co/nt+ an)

to +oi)e Gai*ions #anteens G/,*ic #oneniences an) othe+

amenities ith )isa,*e) access an) s/ita,*e sinae esecia** to

ino*e mo+e &n)ians in the ame of c+icet an) to enco/+ae

a+ticiation of a** sections of societ.15 To assist the #+icet #ommittees an) faci*itate the

im*ementation of thei+ tass an) +ecommen)ations.16 To co**ate month* +eo+ts conce+nin the f/nctionin of the

a+io/s #ommittees to c+eate action *ans in a)ance an) /*oa)

the same on the e,site of the B##&.17 To c+eate a )ata,ase of a** c+icete+s at a** *ee*s maintain

+eco+)s an) statistics t+ac e+fo+mances an) ce+tif ae an)

i)entit of a+ticiants.18 To tae stes to c+eate o+*) c*ass inf+ast+/ct/+e at a** *ee*s

~ 118 ~

Page 119: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 119/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

in a** a+eas ac+oss the co/nt+. To coo+)inate ith tate

associations to con)/ct to/+naments to +oi)e ,ette+ access to

the /,*ic ith a+tic/*a+ +efe+ence to omen an) the )isa,*e).19 To /t in *ace mechanisms to enco/+ae &n)ian c+icete+s to

*a inte+nationa** an) hone thei+ si**s so that a i)e+ ta*ent

oo* is aai*a,*e to +e+esent the co/nt+.20 To ente+ t+ansa+ent* into cont+acts ith thi+) a+ties an)

en)o+s fo+ the /+oses of the a+io/s #ommittees of the B##&

an) to ens/+e that in a** cont+acts fo+ te*eision an) me)ia +ihts

the inte+ests of the /,*ic +emain /ncom+omise) an) f/**

/nhin)e+e) ,+oa)casts of a** )e*ie+ies an) thei+ +e*as a+e

shon ith the sc+een oe+in a f/** an) com*ete ie itho/t

a)e+tisement ,anne+s o+ ma+ins an) to +est+ict comme+cia*

time on* to the +ef+eshment an) othe+ team ,+eas )/+in an)

,eteen innins.21 To +eo+t to the Ae= #o/nci* ee+ /a+te+ o+ as often as

+e/i+e) , the Ae= #o/nci* on the f/nctionin of the

manaement an) the +o+ess ma)e in )ee*oin c+icet in

&n)ia.22 To consi)e+ the +eo+ts of the A/)ito+ to e+if hethe+ "/**

>em,e+s a+e meetin thei+ o,-ecties an) to assess hethe+

c+icet is ,ein s/ita,* )ee*oe) an) +omote) ac+oss the

co/nt+.23 To consi)e+ a** a*ications fo+ Cnancia* ai) o+ an othe+

,eneo*ence to c+icete+s Lmi+es an) a)minist+ato+s as e+ the

+/*es f+ame) , the ;ene+a* Bo) in this ,eha*f f+om time to time

an) +ecommen) the same to the Ae= #o/nci* fo+ thei+ a+oa*.24 To e=amine a** the e=en)it/+e e=cee)in the B/)et an) to

cont+o* s/ch o/t*as as a+e +e/i+e) fo+ the +oe+ a)minist+ation

of the B##&.25 To a)ise the B##& +ea+)in inestments.26 To +ocess +e/ests ma)e fo+ inc+ease in a** tes of 

a**oances s/,entions?s/,si)ies to ,e ai) to the Associations

ta+i fo+ #oachin #ams #oachin /,si)ies to the Associations

a**oance to the *ae+s fo+ matches of )ie+ent T+ohies an)hen *ain aainst fo+ein si)es ,oth at home an) aa an) to

~ 119 ~

Page 120: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 120/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

+ecommen) the same to the Ae= #o/nci*.27 To )o a** acts an) thins hich a+e )e*eate) , the Boa+) an)

Ae= #o/nci* to him an) a** othe+ f/nctions as a+e necessa+ an)

e=e)ient to ca++ o/t the o,-ects of the B##& as afo+esai).

2$. THE STANDING COMMITTEES

1 The tan)in #ommittees a+e the #ommittees that +oi)e

/i)ance an) a)ice on ,eha*f of the >em,e+s to the #EO.

2 The tan)in #ommittees a+e

A. The enio+ To/+nament #ommittee

i The enio+ To/+nament #ommittee sha** consist of "&IE

e+sons aointe) , the Boa+) at the Ann/a* ;ene+a*

>eetin one f+om each one.

ii The #ommittee sha** a)ice the #EO on the con)/ct of the

fo**oin To/+naments in acco+)ance ith thei+ +esectie

+/*es as f+ame) , the Boa+)

a. $ationa* #hamionshi of &n)ia fo+ the an-i T+oh<

,. >atch ,eteen the $ationa* #hamions an) the est

of &n)ia fo+ the &+ani T+oh<

c. $ationa* ona* #hamionshi fo+ the !/*eeT+oh<

). %imite) Oe+s ona* To/+nament fo+ G+of.!.B.!eo)ha+

 T+oh<

e. %imite) Oe+s One !a &nte+ tate To/+nament fo+

Ii-a Ha:a+e T+oh<

f. The Ii:: T+oh fo+ Lnie+sities<

B. The To/+s "i=t/+es Q Technica* #ommittee

i The To/+s "i=t/+es Q Technica* #ommittee sha** consist of 

"&IE e+sons aointe) , the Boa+) at the Ann/a* ;ene+a*

>eetin one f+om each one. At *east th+ee of these Ce

~ 120 ~

Page 121: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 121/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

e+sons o/ht to hae *ae) a minim/m of 25 "i+st #*ass

ames.ii The #ommittee sha** s/,-ect to an )i+ections of the

Boa+) a)ice the #EO on the main of )+as an) C=in

of )ates an) en/es in +esect of the fo**oin

a. To/+s of &n)ian Team isitin a,+oa)<

,. To/+s of fo+ein teams isitin &n)ia<

G+oi)e) that a** Test #ente+s sha** ,e aa+)e)

 Tests on a +otationa* ,asis itho/t an +eetition /nti*

the enti+e cc*e is com*ete an) a** One !a

&nte+nationa*s an) Tent?20 matches sha** ,e simi*a+*

+otate) amon a** &nte+nationa* #ente+s in s/ch a

manne+ that no tate sha** host mo+e than one match

+ea+)*ess of fo+mat on a sin*e to/+.

c. A** matches an) To/+naments con)/cte)?o+ani:e)

, the B##&.

iiiThe #ommittee sha** s/,-ect to an )i+ections of the

;ene+a* Bo) o+ the Ae= #o/nci* a)ice the #EO on the

fo**oin

a. Aointment of O,se+e+s fo+ Tests an) othe+

matches )/+in the to/+s of fo+ein teams in &n)ia<

,. #onsi)e+in the *as of the ame an) amen)ments

the+eto e=e+imenta* *as technica* matte+s that

ma ,e +efe++e) to it , the ;ene+a* Bo) an)

matte+s +ea+)in the %as of the ame to ,e

)isc/sse) at the &nte+nationa* #+icet #o/nci*.

c. "+amin an) Cna*i:in the *ain con)itions fo+ a**

to/+s to an) f+om &n)ia.

2%. THE CRIC-ET COMMITTEES

1The #+icet #ommittees a+e the #ommittees com+ise) e=c*/sie*

of fo+me+ G*ae+s ho a+e tase) ith the e*ection #oachin an)

~ 121 ~

Page 122: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 122/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

Ea*/ation of Team Ge+fo+mances.

2The #+icet #ommittees a+eA.  The >ens e*ection #ommittee

i The >ens e*ection #ommittee sha** se*ect the enio+

$ationa* Team fo+ +e+esentation in Tests One !a

&nte+nationa*s Tent?20 an) an othe+ fo+mat. This

#ommittee sha** a*so ,e +esonsi,*e fo+ ettin an)

se*ectin #oaches an) /o+t ta hsiothe+aists

t+aine+s the+aists ana*sts an) me)ics fo+ the

+esectie teams as e** as +oi)in ea*/ation

+eo+ts of the +esectie team e+fo+mances to the Ae=

#o/nci* on a /a+te+* ,asis.ii The >ens e*ection #ommittee sha** consist of THEE

e+sons to ,e aointe) , the Boa+) at the Ann/a*

;ene+a* >eetin on s/ch te+ms an) con)itions as ma

,e )eci)e) , the Ae= #o/nci* f+om time to time. On*

fo+me+ G*ae+s ho hae +e+esente) the enio+

$ationa* Team in Test >atches sha** ,e e*ii,*e to ,e

aointe) to this #ommittee +oi)e) that the hae+eti+e) f+om the ame at *east 5 ea+s +eio/s*. The

senio+ most Test ca amon the mem,e+s of the

#ommittee sha** ,e aointe) as the #hai+e+son.iii The >ens e*ection #ommittee sha** aoint a #atain

fo+ the team in each fo+mat ho sha** ,e an e=O@cio

mem,e+ of the #ommittee. The #atain hoee+ sha**

not ,e entit*e) to ote. &n the eent of the+e ,ein an

e/a*it of otes fo+ the aointment of a #atain the

#hai+e+son sha** hae a castin ote. &n the eent of 

the+e ,ein no ma-o+it a+eement oe+ the se*ection of 

the *ae+s the #atains ishes in that +ea+) sha**

+eai*.i On an oe+seas to/+ the #+icet >anae+?#oach

#atain an) Iice#atain sha** constit/te the e*ection

#ommittee. The A)minist+atie >anae+ sha** conene

~ 122 ~

Page 123: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 123/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

the meetin an) ee a +eco+) of the +ocee)ins.

B.  The J/nio+ #+icet #ommitteei The J/nio+ #+icet #ommittee sha** consist of THEE

e+sons to ,e aointe) , the Boa+) at the Ann/a*;ene+a* >eetin on s/ch te+ms an) con)itions as ma

,e )eci)e) , the Ae= #o/nci* f+om time to time. On*

fo+me+ G*ae+s ho hae *ae) a minim/m of 25 "i+st

#*ass ames sha** ,e e*ii,*e to ,e aointe) to this

#ommittee +oi)e) that the hae +eti+e) f+om the

ame at *east 5 ea+s +eio/s*. The senio+ most

amonst the mem,e+s of the #ommittee sha** ,e

aointe) as the #hai+e+son.ii The J/nio+ #+icet #ommittee sha**

a. e*ect a** ae +o/ teams /to Ln)e+22 ea+s

fo+ the /+ose of coachin cams o+ fo+ *ain

aainst *oca* o+ fo+ein teams ithin &n)ia o+

a,+oa) in an fo+mat of the ame.,. Aoint a #atain fo+ the team in each fo+mat

ho sha** ,e an e=O@cio mem,e+ of the

#ommittee. The #atain hoee+ sha** not ,e

entit*e) to ote. &n the eent of the+e ,ein an

e/a*it of otes fo+ the aointment of a

#atain the #hai+e+son sha** hae a castin

ote. &n the eent of the+e ,ein no ma-o+it

a+eement oe+ the se*ection of the *ae+s the

#atains ishes in that +ea+) sha** +eai*. On

an oe+seas to/+ the #+icet >anae+?#oach

#atain an) Iice#atain sha** constit/te the

e*ection #ommittee. The A)minist+atie >anae+

sha** conene the meetin an) ee a +eco+) of 

the +ocee)ins.c. Iet an) se*ect #oaches an) /o+t ta 

hsiothe+aists t+aine+s the+aists ana*sts

an) me)ics fo+ the +esectie teams as e** as

~ 123 ~

Page 124: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 124/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

+oi)in ea*/ation +eo+ts of the +esectie

team e+fo+mances to the Ae= #o/nci* on a

/a+te+* ,asis.). O+ani:e an) con)/ct -/nio+ to/+naments of the

B##&<e. O+ani:e -/nio+ to/+s of fo+ein co/nt+ies<f. !eci)e an )is/te in +ea+) to -/nio+

to/+naments<. &nc/*cate +oe+ ethics in the o/th a+tic/*a+*

th+o/h inte+actions ith senio+ an) fo+me+

G*ae+s on iss/es s/ch as )+/s ,ettin match

C=in etc.

#.  The Pomens e*ection #ommitteei The Pomens e*ection #ommittee sha** se*ect the

$ationa* Team ac+oss a** ae +o/s fo+ +e+esentation in

 Tests One !a &nte+nationa*s Tent?20 an) an othe+

fo+mat. This #ommittee sha** a*so ,e +esonsi,*e fo+

ettin an) se*ectin #oaches an) /o+t ta 

hsiothe+aists t+aine+s the+aists ana*sts an)

me)ics fo+ the +esectie teams as e** as +oi)in

ea*/ation +eo+ts of the +esectie team e+fo+mances

to the Ae= #o/nci* on a month* ,asis.ii The Pomens e*ection #ommittee sha** consist of 

 THEE e+sons to ,e aointe) , the Boa+) at the

Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin on s/ch te+ms an) con)itions

as ma ,e )eci)e) , the Ae= #o/nci* f+om time to

time. On* fo+me+ G*ae+s ho hae +e+esente) thePomens $ationa* Team sha** ,e e*ii,*e to ,e aointe)

to this #ommittee +oi)e) that the hae +eti+e) f+om

the ame at *east 5 ea+s +eio/s*. The senio+ most

inte+nationa* amonst the mem,e+s of the #ommittee

sha** ,e aointe) as the #hai+e+son.iii The Pomens e*ection #ommittee sha** aoint a

#atain fo+ the team in each fo+mat ho sha** ,e an e=

O@cio mem,e+ of the #ommittee. The #atain

~ 124 ~

Page 125: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 125/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

hoee+ sha** not ,e entit*e) to ote. &n the eent of 

the+e ,ein an e/a*it of otes fo+ the aointment of a

#atain the #hai+e+son sha** hae a castin ote. &n

the eent of the+e ,ein no ma-o+it a+eement oe+ these*ection of the *ae+s the #atains ishes in that

+ea+) sha** +eai*.i On an oe+seas to/+ the #+icet >anae+?#oach

#atain an) Iice#atain sha** constit/te the e*ection

#ommittee. The A)minist+atie >anae+ sha** conene

the meetin an) ee a +eco+) of the +ocee)ins.

!.  The Pomens #+icet #ommittee

i The Pomens #+icet #ommittee sha** consist of THEE

fo+me+ omen G*ae+s ho hae *ae) at *east "i+st

#*ass c+icet. One G*ae+ sha** ,e nominate) f+om each

one at the Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin of the Boa+) the

senio+ most of hom sha** ,e the #hai+e+son.

ii The #ommittee sha**

a!+a / +o+ammes of coachin at :ona* an)nationa* *ee*s.

,G*an an) con)/ct Pomens J/nio+ an) enio+

)omestic to/+naments.cO+ani:e to/+s to fo+ein co/nt+ies o+ to/+s of othe+s

co/nt+ies to &n)ia.)!eci)e an )is/te in +ea+) to Pomens

 To/+naments.e;ene+a** hae cont+o* oe+ Pomens #+icet

actiities o/tsi)e of those coe+e) , the Pomens

e*ection #ommittee.

E.  The ona* e*ection #ommitteei The ona* e*ection #ommittee sha** se*ect the

+esectie ona* Team fo+ inte+:ona* cometitions an)

t+ohies. This #ommittee sha** a*so ,e +esonsi,*e fo+

ettin an) se*ectin #oaches an) /o+t ta 

hsiothe+aists t+aine+s the+aists ana*sts an)

~ 125 ~

Page 126: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 126/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

me)ics fo+ the +esectie teams.ii The ona* e*ection #ommittee sha** consist of O$E

e*ecto+ f+om each one as *ai) )on in /*e 1Ahh

ho sha** ,e nominate) , the +esectie Associations

at the Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin of the Boa+). On* fo+me+

G*ae+s ho hae *ae) at *east 10 "i+st #*ass ames

a+e e*ii,*e to ,e aointe) to this #ommittee +oi)e)

that the hae +eti+e) f+om the ame at *east 5 ea+s

+eio/s*. The senio+ most amonst the mem,e+s of 

each ona* #ommittee sha** ,e aointe) as the

#hai+e+son fo+ the +esectie #ommittee.

iii The ona* e*ection #ommittee sha** aoint a #atain

fo+ the team ho sha** ,e an e=O@cio mem,e+ of the

#ommittee. The #atain hoee+ sha** not ,e entit*e)

to ote. &n the eent of the+e ,ein an e/a*it of otes

fo+ the aointment of a #atain the #hai+e+son sha**

hae a castin ote. &n the eent of the+e ,ein no

ma-o+it a+eement oe+ the se*ection of the *ae+s

the #atains ishes in that +ea+) sha** +eai*.

".  The !ie+ent*A,*e) #+icet #ommittee

i The !ie+ent*A,*e) #+icet #ommittee sha** consist of 

 THEE e+sons to ,e aointe) , the Boa+) at the

Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin on s/ch te+ms an) con)itions

as ma ,e )eci)e) , the Ae= #o/nci* f+om time to

time. On* fo+me+ !ie+ent*A,*e) G*ae+s ho hae

+e+esente) the co/nt+ in an fo+mat of the ame sha**

,e e*ii,*e to aointe) to this #ommittee. &t is

+efe+a,*e that )ie+ent cateo+ies of imai+ment

is/a* hsica* etc. ,e +e+esente) amon the

mem,e+s of the #ommittee. The senio+ most amon the

G*ae+s sha** ,e the #hai+e+son.

ii The !ie+ent*A,*e) #+icet #ommittee sha** in

se*ection ith the #+icet Ta*ent #ommittee se*ect the

~ 126 ~

Page 127: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 127/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

$ationa* Team ac+oss a** ae +o/s fo+ +e+esentation

in Tests One !a &nte+nationa*s Tent?20 an) an

othe+ fo+mat. &n a))ition this #ommittee sha** a*so

+oose to the #EO the ,est +actices to ,e inc/*cate)inc*/)in coachin co/nse**in an) secia* e/iment.

 This #ommittee sha** a*so en)eao/+ to ,+in the

a+io/s e=istin c+icet associations fo+ a+io/s tes of 

imai+ment /n)e+ the common /m,+e**a of the B##& an)

eo*e t+ainin +o+ammes an) +aise aa+eness.

iii This #ommittee sha** aoint a #atain fo+ the team in

each fo+mat ho sha** ,e an e=O@cio mem,e+ of the

#ommittee. The #atain hoee+ sha** not ,e entit*e)

to ote. &n the eent of the+e ,ein an e/a*it of otes

fo+ the aointment of a #atain the #hai+e+son sha**

hae a castin ote. &n the eent of the+e ,ein no

ma-o+it a+eement oe+ the se*ection of the *ae+s

the #atains ishes in that +ea+) sha** +eai*. On an

oe+seas to/+ the #+icet >anae+?#oach #atain an)

Iice#atain sha** constit/te the e*ection #ommittee.

 The A)minist+atie >anae+ sha** conene the meetin

an) ee a +eco+) of the +ocee)ins.

;. The #+icet Ta*ent #ommittee

i The #+icet Ta*ent #ommittee sha** consist of THEE

e+sons to ,e aointe) , the Boa+) at the Ann/a*

;ene+a* >eetin on s/ch te+ms an) con)itions as ma

,e )eci)e) , the Ae= #o/nci* f+om time to time. On*

fo+me+ G*ae+s ho hae *ae) at *east 20 "i+st #*ass

ames an) hae the hihest *ee* of coachin

ce+tiCcation sha** ,e e*ii,*e to aointe) to this

#ommittee. The senio+most amon the G*ae+s sha** ,e

the #hai+e+son.ii This #ommittee sha**

a. Be +esonsi,*e fo+ sco/tin fo+ ta*ent in men -/nio+ omen an) )isa,*e) c+icet.

~ 127 ~

Page 128: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 128/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

,. O+ani:e the f+ameo+ ithin hich the $ationa*

#+icet Aca)em an) the a+io/s

tate?!ist+ict?ona* #+icet Aca)emies i** ,e

esta,*ishe) an) e+fo+m.c. #+eate the +o+ammes an) coachin cente+s fo+

coachin at +eiona* an) nationa* *ee*s<). &m+oe inf+ast+/ct/+e in a** a+eas of the co/nt+<e. >ae +oisions fo+ main the ame of c+icet

accessi,*e to the ene+a* /,*ic , c+eatin t/+f 

icets aan)*a faci*ities an) cone+tin

e=istin Ce*)s an) +o/n)s into hih /a*it

itches<f. Enco/+ae the o/th to tae / c+icet , settin

/ +omotiona* cams an) othe+ aen/es of 

enaement ith the ame<. G+oi)e ea*/ation +eo+ts of the ta+ets set an)

achiee) an) the )etai*s of its +o+ammes to the

Ae= #o/nci* on a /a+te+* ,asis<

3$o e+son ho has ,een a mem,e+ of a #+icet #ommittee fo+ atota* of 5 ea+s sha** ,e e*ii,*e to ,e a mem,e+ of a #+icet

#ommittee.

4$o e+son ho has ,een a mem,e+ of a #+icet #ommittee sha**

+ite comment o+ /,*ici:e an )isc/ssions o+ )ecisions of the

e*ections ma)e e=cet he+e so a/tho+i:e) , the Boa+) o+ the

Ae= #o/nci*. An io*ation of this conC)entia*it +oision i** inite

+emoa* an) s/,stit/tion , the Ae= #o/nci*.

5The #hai+e+sons of the +esectie #+icet #ommittees sha** s/,mit

a /a+te+* +eo+t to the #EO hich sha** then ,e fo+a+)e) , him

to the Ae= #o/nci* fo+ assessment an) action if an.

6The Ae= #o/nci* is emoe+e) to a)) an f/+the+ #+icet

#ommittees as ma ,e +e/i+e) a+tic/*a+* to cate+ to eae+

sections of societ.

~ 128 ~

Page 129: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 129/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

2&. THE UMPIRES COMMITTEE

1 The Lmi+es #ommittee sha** consist of THEE e+sons aointe)

, the Boa+) at the Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin each of hom sha**hae ,een a fo+me+ &nte+nationa* /mi+e f+om &n)ia. &n the eent

of s/ch a e+son not ,ein aai*a,*e an /mi+e ho has

o@ciate) in at *east 25 "i+st #*ass matches sha** ,e e*ii,*e to ,e

aointe). $o e+son ma ,e a mem,e+ of this #ommittee fo+

mo+e than 5 ea+s. The senio+ most /mi+e sha** ,e the

#hai+e+son of the #ommittee.2 The f/nction of the Lmi+es #ommittee sha** ,e to stan)a+)i:e

/mi+in th+o/ho/t &n)ia an) to )+a / an) maintain a ane* of 

Lmi+es to o@ciate matches in &n)ia an) c*assif them into E*ite

Gane* A** &n)ia Gane* an) an-i T+oh Gane* of Lmi+es acco+)in

to the me+its of the Lmi+es s/,-ect to +ec*assiCcation as e+

c+ite+ia o+e) o/t , the #ommittee. The #ommittee sha** ho*)

e=aminations f+om time to time fo+ this /+ose.3 The #ommittee sha** aoint /mi+es fo+ a** $ationa* an)

&nte+nationa* matches an) sha** assist >em,e+s in the fo+mationof the ane*s of Lmi+es in thei+ +esectie a+eas. The #ommittee

sha** en)eao/+ to +omote /mi+in , con)/ctin cams an)

+o+ammes.4 The #ommittee sha** )+a a fo+mat to o,tain conC)entia* +eo+ts

f+om catains on /mi+es match +efe+ees o+ an othe+ )esinate)

e+sons to assess the me+its ? )eme+its of the Lmi+es.5 The #ommittee ma ho*) o+ani:e an) a++ane semina+s an)

conentions of /mi+es to )isc/ss the *as of the ame

e=e+imenta* +/*es an) s/estions of &nte+nationa* #+icet

#o/nci* in +ea+) to amen)ments a*te+ations an) a))itions to the

*as of the ame.

2. THE GO!ERNING COUNCIL

1 The ;oe+nin #o/nci* of the &G% sha** consist of $&$E mem,e+s

ho sha** ,e in)/cte) at ee+ Ann/a* ;ene+a* Bo) >eetin of 

~ 129 ~

Page 130: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 130/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

the Boa+). The te+m of the mem,e+s of the ;oe+nin #o/nci*

othe+ than the ec+eta+ T+eas/+e+ #QA; nominee an) #EO

sha** ,e one ea+.2 The comosition of the ;oe+nin #o/nci* sha** ,e as fo**os

i. "o/+ +e+esentaties of the ;ene+a* Bo)< of hich to

sha** ,e the ec+eta+ an) T+eas/+e+ an) to othe+s to ,e

e*ecte) , the ;ene+a* Bo)<ii. To +e+esentaties of the &G% "+anchisees<iii. One +e+esentatie of the #+icet G*ae+s Association

othe+ than the +e+esentaties on the Ae= #o/nci*<i. The #o/nci**o+ ho is the nominee of the #omt+o**e+ Q

A/)ito+ ;ene+a* on the Ae= #o/nci*<. The #EO of the B##&<

3 One of the to e*ecte) >em,e+ +e+esentaties sha** ,e the

#hai+e+son of the ;oe+nin #o/nci*.4 The nominees of the &G% "+anchisees sha** ,e +otate) ann/a** so

that no "+anchisee is +e+esente) aain /nti* a** "+anchisees hae

,een +e+esente) at *east once.5 A** )ecisions +e*atin to the &G% o/*) ,e taen , the ;oe+nin

#o/nci* , ma-o+it an) in case of e/a*it of otes the

#hai+e+son sha** hae a castin ote.6 The ;oe+nin #o/nci* sha** maintain a sea+ate Ban Acco/nt

hich sha** ,e oe+ate) , the T+eas/+e+ an) the #EO.7 The ;oe+nin #o/nci* sha** at the fo**oin >eetin of the

;ene+a* Bo) s/,mit a +eo+t a*on ith a** )ecisions taen ,

it.

2. ACCIDENTAL OMISSION TO GI!E NOTICE OF MEETING

Acci)enta* omission to ie notice of an Ann/a* ;ene+a* o+ ecia*

;ene+a* >eetin o+ >eetins of the Ae= #o/nci* o+ of an of the

#ommittees to an mem,e+ entit*e) the+eto o+ the non+eceit

the+eof , s/ch in)ii)/a* sha** not ina*i)ate the +ocee)ins of 

s/ch meetins.

3*. PERMISSION TO CONDUCT TOURNAMENTS

1$o #*/, a@*iate) to a mem,e+ sha** con)/ct o+ o+ani:e an

~ 130 ~

Page 131: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 131/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

to/+nament o+ an matches in hich *ae+s?teams f+om the

+eion ithin the -/+is)iction of a mem,e+ a+e a+ticiatin o+

a+e *ie* to a+ticiate itho/t the +eio/s e+mission of the

mem,e+ a@*iate) to the B##&.

2$o mem,e+ o+ a #*/, a@*iate) to a mem,e+ sha** con)/ct o+

o+ani:e an to/+nament o+ an match?matches in hich

*ae+s?teams f+om +eions o/tsi)e thei+ -/+is)iction a+e

a+ticiatin o+ a+e *ie* to a+ticiate itho/t the +eio/s

e+mission of the B##&.

3Ge+mission fo+ con)/ctin o+ o+ani:in an to/+nament o+

match?matches i** ,e acco+)e) on* to the mem,e+s of the

B##& an) i** ,e in acco+)ance ith the +/*es f+ame) , the B##&

in this +ea+) f+om time to time.

4$o mem,e+ o+ a #*/, a@*iate) to a mem,e+ sha** con)/ct o+

o+ani:e an inte+nationa* To/+nament o+ &nte+nationa*

match?matches in hich fo+ein *ae+s?teams a+e a+ticiatin

o+ a+e *ie* to a+ticiate itho/t the +eio/s e+mission of the

B##&. Ge+mission fo+ con)/ctin o+ o+ani:in an &nte+nationa*

 To/+naments o+ &nte+nationa* match?matches i** on* ,e

acco+)e) to the >em,e+s of the B##& on secia* occasions.

5>em,e+s o+ thei+ a@*iates )esi+o/s of /n)e+tain to/+s a,+oa)

o+ initin fo+ein teams sha** o,tain the +eio/s e+mission of the B##& hich ma ,e +ante) in acco+)ance ith the /*es

f+ame) , the B##&.

31. BAN ON PARTICIPATION IN UNAPPRO!ED TOURNAMENTS

1$o >em,e+ sha** a+ticiate o+ e=ten) he* of an in) to an

/na+oe) To/+nament.

2$o G*ae+ Lmi+e co+e+ O@cia* o+ othe+ e+son associate)

~ 131 ~

Page 132: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 132/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

ith the B##& sha** a+ticiate in an /na+oe) to/+nament.3The Ae= #o/nci* sha** tae a+o+iate action inc*/)in

s/sension an) stoae of Cnancia* ,eneCts an) an othe+

action aainst in)ii)/a*s ? >em,e+s cont+aenin the a,oe.

~ 132 ~

Page 133: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 133/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

CHAPTER SIX: ELECTIONS

32. PROCEDURE FOR ELECTIONS

 The ;ene+a* Bo) sha** f+om time to time f+ame +/*es of +oce)/+efo+ the e*ections. An amen)ments to the +oce)/+e a)ote) sha**

,e ma)e at *east 3 months +io+ to the e*ections.

33. THE ELECTORAL OFFICER

1 At *east to ees +io+ to the Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin at hich

an e*ection is to ,e he*) the Ae= #o/nci* sha** aoint anE*ecto+a* O@ce+ ho sha** ,e a fo+me+ mem,e+ of the E*ection

#ommission of &n)ia.2 The E*ecto+a* O@ce+ sha** oe+see an) s/e+ise the enti+e

e*ection +ocess fo+ #o/nci**o+s an) the G*ae+s #+icet

Association hich sha** inc*/)e a** nominations an) can)i)at/+es

,ein s/,-ect to his sc+/tin in acco+)ance ith the /*es.3 &n case of an )is/te o+ o,-ection as to can)i)ac

)is/a*iCcation e*ii,i*it to ote o+ the a)mission o+ +e-ection

of a ote in the e*ections to the Ae= #o/nci* the G*ae+s

#+icet Association o+ an of the #ommittees the E*ecto+a*

O@ce+ sha** )eci)e the same an) s/ch )ecision sha** ,e Cna* an)

conc*/sie.

~ 133 ~

Page 134: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 134/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

CHAPTER SE!EN: AUDIT " ACCOUNTS

3. AUDITOR(S):

1 The ;ene+a* Bo) sha** at ee+ Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin aoint

one o+ mo+e a/)ito+s to ho*) o@ce fo+ a 1 ea+ e+io) an) sha**

C= thei+ +em/ne+ation. The A/)ito+ sha** ,e e*ii,*e fo+

+eaointment , the ;ene+a* Bo).2 The A/)ito+s of the B##& sha** hae the +iht of access at a**

times to the Boos of Acco/nts Io/che+s an) an othe+

)oc/ments +e*atin to the acco/nts of the B##& an) sha** ,e

entit*e) to o,tain f+om the O@ce,ea+e+s an) #ommittees s/ch

info+mation an) e=*anation as ma ,e necessa+ in the

)ischa+e of his?thei+ )/ties.3 The A/)ito+s sha** +oi)e an oinion on the Cnancia*

statements of the B##& an) +ecommen)ations on the Cnancia*

cont+o*s ithin the sstem hich sha** ,e containe) in a

"inancia* eo+t.4 The A/)ito+s sha** a*so asce+tain ho the f/n)s of the B##& a+e

,ein /ti*i:e) , the +esectie >em,e+s. &t i** ,e the

+esonsi,i*it of the A/)ito+s to e+if the statements ma)e ,

the >em,e+ associations in this +ea+) an) to ie Cn)ins

hich sha** ,e containe) in a #om*iance eo+t.5 Both the "inancia* eo+t an) the #om*iance eo+t of the

A/)ito+s sha** ,e consi)e+e) at the Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin.

3$. ACCOUNTS

 T+/e acco/nts sha** ,e et , the T+eas/+e+ of a** mones +eceie)

an) e=en)e) , the B##& an) the matte+s in +esect of hich

s/ch +eceits an) e=en)it/+e tae *ace an) of a** assets c+e)its

an) *ia,i*ities of the B##&. This sha** inc*/)e the sea+ate acco/nt

maintaine) fo+ the &G% as e**.

~ 134 ~

Page 135: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 135/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

3%. SETTLEMENT OF ACCOUNTS " BALANCE SHEET

 The acco/nts sha** /n*ess the ;ene+a* Bo) C=es an othe+ )ate

the+e fo+ ,e sett*e) , the T+eas/+e+ on the 31st of >a+ch in each

ea+ an) a ,a*ance sheet of the assets an) *ia,i*ities of the B##& on

that )a sha** ,e ma)e o/t , him. The Ba*ance heet )/* a/)ite)

ith the A/)ito+s +ema+s sha** ,e *ai) ,efo+e the ;ene+a* Bo) at

the Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin.

~ 135 ~

Page 136: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 136/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

CHAPTER EIGHT: TRANSPARENCY " CONFLICT OF INTEREST

3&. TRANSPARENCY 

i The >emo+an)/m of Association /*es an) e/*ations an)

a** othe+ +eso*/tions o+)e+s an) memo+an)a of the B##&

inc*/)in the Ae= #o/nci* an) the ;ene+a* Bo) sha** ,e

f+ee* aai*a,*e to the ene+a* /,*ic at a +easona,*e +ice.

 The same sha** a*so ,e aai*a,*e on the Pe,site of the B##&.

ii The comosition of the a+io/s #ommittees inc*/)in the

;oe+nin #o/nci* thei+ +eo+ts of o+ )one Cnancia* o/t*a

an) e=en)it/+e sha** ,e /*oa)e) on the Pe,site of the B##&

on a /a+te+* ,asis at )istinct *ins )e)icate) to each

#ommittee. &t sha** ,e the +esonsi,i*it of the #EO to ens/+e

that this is )one.

iii A** aments an) e=en)it/+es ma)e , the B##& hich is in

e=cess of s.25 *ah sha** ,e en/me+ate) an) /*oa)e) on the

e,site.

i A** +ocee)ins an) conc*/sions of the Om,/)sman an) the

E*ecto+a* O@ce+ sha** ,e /*oa)e) on the Pe,site of the B##&

ann/a**.

The a/)ite) acco/nts ,a*ance sheets +oCt Q *oss acco/nts

an) ann/a* +eo+ts sha** ,e /*oa)e) on the Pe,site of the

B##& ann/a**.

i The "inancia* an) #om*iance eo+ts of the A/)ito+ sha** ,e

*ace) on the /*oa)e) on the Pe,site of the B##& ann/a**.

ii A** notices on o+ ,eha*f of the B##& inc*/)in ten)e+s fo+ oo)s

an) se+ices fo+ cont+act/a* a++anements an) the *ie sha**

,e +omt* /*oa)e) on the Pe,site of the B##&.

iii The e,site of the B##& sha** hae )e)icate) *ins to a** the

sta)ia in the co/nt+ hich host inte+nationa* matches a*on

~ 136 ~

Page 137: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 137/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

ith thei+ com*ete seatin caacit +icin an) t+ansa+ent

,ooin +oce)/+es fo+ a** to/+naments hethe+ inte+nationa*

)omestic o+ &G%. A** sonso+ an) othe+ f+ee a**otments sha**

a*so ,e )isc*ose) in no eent ,ein mo+e than 10 of theenti+e seatin caacit in an a+tic/*a+ cateo+.

3. CONFLICT OF INTEREST

1A #onMict Of &nte+est ma tae an of the fo**oin fo+ms as fa+

as an in)ii)/a* associate) ith the B##& is conce+ne)

i Direct or Indirect Interest  Phen the B##& a >em,e+ the

&G% o+ a "+anchisee ente+ into cont+act/a* a++anements

ith entities in hich the in)ii)/a* conce+ne) o+ his?he+

+e*atie a+tne+ o+ c*ose associate has an inte+est. This is

to inc*/)e cases he+e fami* mem,e+s a+tne+s o+ c*ose

associates a+e in ositions that ma o+ ma ,e seen to

com+omise an in)ii)/a*s a+ticiation e+fo+mance an)

)ischa+e of +o*es.

&**/st+ation 1 A is an O@ce Bea+e+ of the B##& hen it ente+s

into a ,+oa)cast cont+act ith a coman he+e As son B is

em*oe). A is hit , !i+ect #onMict of &nte+est.

&**/st+ation 2 # is a >em,e+ of the &G% ;oe+nin #o/nci*. The

&G% ente+s into a cont+act ith a ne f+anchisee the

>anain !i+ecto+ of hich is #s a+tne+ in an in)een)ent

comme+cia* ent/+e. # is hit , &n)i+ect #onMict of &nte+est.

&**/st+ation 3 ! is the O@ce Bea+e+ of a tate Association. !s

ife E has sha+es in an &G% "+anchisee hich ente+s into a

sta)i/m cont+act ith the tate Association. ! is hit ,

&n)i+ect #onMict of &nte+est.

&**/st+ation 4 " is G+esi)ent of the B##&. His sonin*a is a

 Team O@cia* of a "+anchisee. " is hit , #onMict of &nte+est.

&**/st+ation 5 ; is an em*oee of the B##&. His ife +/ns a

cate+in aenc that is enae) , the B##&. ; is hit ,#onMict of &nte+est.

~ 137 ~

Page 138: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 138/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

ii Roles compromised Phen the in)ii)/a* ho*)s to

sea+ate o+ )istinct osts o+ ositions /n)e+ the B##& a

>em,e+ the &G% o+ the "+anchisee the f/nctions of hich

o/*) +e/i+e the one to ,e ,eho*)en to the othe+ o+ inoosition the+eof.

&**/st+ation 1 A is the #oach of a team. He is a*so #oach of an

&G% "+anchisee. A is hit , #onMict of &nte+est.

&**/st+ation 2 B is ec+eta+ of the B##&. He is a*so G+esi)ent

of a tate Association. B is hit , #onMict of &nte+est.

&**/st+ation 3 # is the Iice G+esi)ent of the B##&. He is a*so

G+esi)ent of a tate Association an) mem,e+ of a tan)in#ommittee. # is hit , #onMict of &nte+est.

&**/st+ation 4 ! is a e*ecto+. He is a*so coach of an &G%

f+anchisee. ! is hit , #onMict of &nte+est.

iii Commercial conficts Phen the in)ii)/a* ente+s into

en)o+sement cont+acts o+ othe+ +ofessiona* enaements

ith thi+) a+ties the )ischa+e of hich o/*)

com+omise the in)ii)/a*s +ima+ o,*iation to the

ame o+ a**o fo+ a e+cetion that the /+it of the ame

stan)s com+omise).

&**/st+ation 1 A +/ns a c+icet aca)em. He is aointe) as a

se*ecto+. A is hit , #onMict of &nte+est.

&**/st+ation 2 B is a B##& commentato+. He a*so +/ns a so+ts

manaement coman hich cont+acts mem,e+s of the

team. B is hit , #onMict of &nte+est.

&**/st+ation 3 # is a se*ecto+. He is cont+acte) to +ite a

co*/mn on a to/+ that the nationa* team is on. # is hit ,

#onMict of &nte+est.

&**/st+ation 4 ! is a team catain. He is a*so coone+ of a

so+ts manaement aenc hich is cont+acte) to manae

othe+ team mem,e+s. ! is hit , #onMict of &nte+est.

~ 138 ~

Page 139: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 139/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

&**/st+ation 5 E is a mem,e+ of the &G% ;oe+nin #o/nci*. He

is enae) , a c+icet ,+oa)caste+ to act as an &G%

commentato+. E is hit , #onMict of &nte+est.

iPrior relationship Phen the in)ii)/a* has a )i+ect o+

in)i+ect in)een)ent comme+cia* enaement ith a

en)o+ o+ se+ice +oi)e+ in the ast hich is no to ,e

enae) , o+ on ,eha*f of the B##& its >em,e+ the &G%

o+ the "+anchisee.

&**/st+ation 1 A is G+esi)ent of the B##&. G+io+ to his tain

o@ce he has ,een enae) +ofessiona** fo+ his se+ices ,

a C+m B. Afte+ A ,ecomes G+esi)ent B is aointe) as the

o@cia* cons/*tants of the B##&. A is hit , #onMict of &nte+est.

&**/st+ation 2 B is the ec+eta+ of a tate Association. G+io+

to his e*ection he +an a C+m # secia*i:in in e*ect+onic

,o/n)a+ hoa+)ins. Lon ,ecomin ec+eta+ the cont+act

fo+ the Associations sta)i/m hoa+)ins is +ante) to #. B is

hit , #onMict of &nte+est.

&**/st+ation 3 ! is the #ommissione+ of the &G%. Befo+e he

came into this o@ce he /se) to enae E as his a/)ito+ fo+

his ,/siness. Afte+ ,ecomin #ommissione+ E is aointe) asa/)ito+ to the &G%. ! is hit , #onMict of &nte+est.

&**/st+ation 4 " is the #atain of an &G% team an) ; is the

teams manae+. Phen " is ma)e #atain of the nationa*

team ; is aointe) as the nationa* teams manae+. " is hit

, #onMict of &nte+est.

Position o infuence Phen the in)ii)/a* occ/ies a ost

that ca**s fo+ )ecisions of oe+nance manaement o+

se*ection to ,e ma)e an) he+e a f+ien) +e*atie o+ c*ose

a@*iate is in the :one of consi)e+ation o+ s/,-ect to s/ch

)ecisionmain cont+o* o+ manaement. A*so hen the

in)ii)/a* ho*)s an stae otin +ihts o+ oe+ to

inM/ence the )ecisions of a f+anchisee ? c*/, ? team that

a+ticiates in the comme+cia* *ea/es /n)e+ B##&<

&**/st+ation 1 A is a se*ecto+. His son is in the :one of consi)e+ation fo+ se*ection. A is hit , #onMict of &nte+est.

~ 139 ~

Page 140: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 140/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

&**/st+ation 2 B is the ec+eta+ of a tate Association. He

a*so +/ns a c+icet aca)em in the tate. B is hit , #onMict of 

&nte+est.

&**/st+ation 3 # is an /mi+e. His )a/hte+ ! is a mem,e+ of a

team hich is *ain a match in hich # o@ciates. # is hit, #onMict of &nte+est.

&**/st+ation 4 E is the G+esi)ent of a tate Association an) his

coman " ons 12 c+icet c*/,s in the tate f+om hich

+o,a,*es a+e se*ecte) fo+ the tate team. E is hit , #onMict

of &nte+est.

EKG%A$AT&O$ The &**/st+ations hich +efe+ to a G+esi)ent ?

ec+eta+ ? IiceG+esi)ent ma ,e +ea) as i**/st+ations +efe++in to

an othe+ O@ce Bea+e+ an) a*so to the mem,e+s of the Ae=#o/nci* the ;oe+nin #o/nci* an) the #ommittees.

2Pithin a e+io) of 15 )as of tain an o@ce /n)e+ the B##&

ee+ in)ii)/a* sha** )isc*ose in +itin to the Ae= #o/nci* an

e=istin o+ otentia* eent that ma ,e )eeme) to ca/se a

#onMict of &nte+est an) the same sha** ,e /*oa)e) on the

e,site of the B##&. The fai*/+e to iss/e a com*ete )isc*os/+e

o+ an a+tia* o+ tota* s/+ession the+eof o/*) +en)e+ the

in)ii)/a* oen to )isci*ina+ action hich ma inc*/)e

te+mination an) +emoa* itho/t ,eneCts. &t is c*a+iCe) that a

)ec*a+ation )oes not *ea) to a +es/mtion that in fact a

/estiona,*e sit/ation e=ists ,/t is me+e* fo+ info+mation an)

t+ansa+enc.

3A #onMict of &nte+est ma ,e eithe+ T+acta,*e o+ &nt+acta,*e.

a. T+acta,*e conMicts a+e those that a+e +eso*a,*e o+

e+missi,*e o+ e=c/sa,*e th+o/h +ec/sa* of the in)ii)/a*

conce+ne) an)?o+ ith f/** )isc*os/+e of the inte+est ino*e)<

,. &nt+acta,*e conMicts a+e those that cannot ,e +eso*e)

th+o/h )isc*os/+e an) +ec/sa* an) o/*) necessitate the

~ 140 ~

Page 141: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 141/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

+emoa* of the in)ii)/a* f+om a ost o+ osition occ/ie) so

that the conMict can cease to e=ist<

E=*anation &n &**/st+ation iii of /*e 381i if the ife he*)

51 sha+es the conMict i** ,e t+eate) as int+acta,*e. &f theife ho*)s 3 sha+es hethe+ the conMict is t+acta,*e o+

int+acta,*e i** hae to ,e )eci)e) , the Ethics O@ce+ on

the facts of the case. &f the ife ho*)s on* 100 sha+es o/t of 

1 c+o+e sha+es a )isc*os/+e of the same ma ,e s/@cient.

5 &t is c*a+iCe) that no in)ii)/a* ma occ/ mo+e than one of the

fo**oin osts at a sin*e oint of time e=cet he+e +esc+i,e)

/n)e+ these /*es

a. G*ae+ #/++ent,. e*ecto+ ? >em,e+ of #+icet #ommitteec. Team O@cia*). #ommentato+e. >atch O@cia*f. A)minist+ato+ ? O@ceBea+e+. E*ecto+a* O@ce+h. Om,/)smanQ Ethics O@ce+i. A/)ito+ -. An e+son ho is in oe+nance manaement o+ em*oment of a

"+anchisee. >em,e+ of a tan)in #ommittee*. #EO Q >anae+sm. O@ce Bea+e+ of a >em,e+n. e+ice G+oi)e+ %ea* "inancia* etc.o. #ont+act/a* entit B+oa)cast ec/+it #ont+acto+ etc.. One+ of a #+icet Aca)em

6 As fa+ as inc/m,ents a+e conce+ne) ee+ )isc*os/+e man)ate)

/n)e+ /,/*e 3 ma ,e ma)e ithin 90 )as of the Eectie

!ate.

3. THE ETHICS OFFICER

1 The Boa+) sha** aoint an Ethics O@ce+ at the Ann/a* ;ene+a*

>eetin fo+ the /+ose of /i)ance an) +eso*/tion in instances

of conMict of inte+est. The Ethics O@ce+ sha** ,e a +eti+e) J/)e

of a Hih #o/+t so aointe) , the Boa+) afte+ o,tainin his?he+

consent an) on te+ms as )ete+mine) , the B##& in eein ith

~ 141 ~

Page 142: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 142/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

the )init an) stat/+e of the o@ce. The te+m of an Ethics O@ce+

sha** ,e one ea+ s/,-ect to a ma=im/m of 3 te+ms in [email protected] An instance of #onMict of &nte+est ma ,e taen coni:ance of 

, the Ethics O@ce+

a. /o >ot/<

,. B a of a com*aint in +itin to the o@cia* osta* o+

emai* a))+ess< o+

c. On a +efe+ence , the Ae= #o/nci*<

3 Afte+ consi)e+in the +e*eant facto+s an) fo**oin the +inci*es

of nat/+a* -/stice the Ethics O@ce+ ma )o an of the fo**oin

a. !ec*a+e the conMict as T+acta,*e an) )i+ect that

i. The e+son )ec*a+e the #onMict of &nte+est as e+

/,/*e 3< o+

ii. The inte+est that ca/ses the conMict ,e

+e*in/ishe)< o+

iii. The e+son +ec/se f+om )ischa+in the o,*iation

o+ )/t so este) in him o+ he+<

,. !ec*a+e the conMict as &nt+acta,*e an) )i+ect that

i. The e+son ,e s/sen)e) o+ +emoe) f+om his o+ he+

ost< an)

ii. An s/ita,*e moneta+ o+ othe+ ena*t ,e imose)< an)

iii. The e+son ,e ,a++e) fo+ a seciCe) e+io) o+ fo+ *ife

f+om ino*ement ith the ame of c+icet<

 The Ethics O@ce+ is ho** emoe+e) to a*so )i+ect an a))itiona*

meas/+es o+ +estit/tion as is )eeme) Ct in the ci+c/mstances.

~ 142 ~

Page 143: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 143/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

CHAPTER NINE: THE OMBUDSMAN

*. THE OMBUDSMAN

1 The Boa+) sha** aoint an Om,/)sman at the Ann/a* ;ene+a*>eetin fo+ the /+ose of +oi)in an in)een)ent )is/te

+eso*/tion mechanism. The Om,/)sman sha** ,e a +eti+e)

 J/)e of the /+eme #o/+t o+ a +eti+e) #hief J/stice of a Hih

#o/+t so aointe) , the Boa+) afte+ o,tainin his?he+

consent an) on te+ms as )ete+mine) , the B##& in eein

ith the )init an) stat/+e of the o@ce. The te+m of the

Om,/)sman sha** ,e one ea+ s/,-ect to a ma=im/m of 3te+ms in o@ce.

2 The Boa+) sha** in cons/*tation ith the #EO f+ame

e/*ations +ea+)in the )isci*ine an) con)/ct of the

G*ae+s >atch O@cia*s Team O@cia*s A)minist+ato+s

#ommittee >em,e+s an) othe+s associate) ith the B##&.

1. GRIE!ANCE REDRESSAL

1 The tes of )is/tes?)ie+ences that fo+m the Om,/)smans

am,it an) the +oce)/+es fo+ +e)+essa* a+e

a.  >em,e+ Association Q "+anchisee !is/tesAn )is/tes ,eteen o+ amon the B##& its >em,e+s &G%

"+anchisees ones an) the #+icet G*ae+s Association sha**

,e a/tomatica** +efe++e) to the Om,/)sman.Procedure Both a+ties o/*) s/,mit thei+ a+/ments

an) a hea+in o/*) ,e con)/cte) fo**oin the

+inci*es of nat/+a* -/stice an) e=e+cisin a** oe+s of 

en/i+ an) hea+in as the Om,/)sman )eems Ct

,efo+e a+o+iate o+)e+s a+e asse).

,.  !et+iment ca/se) , >em,e+ o+ A)minist+ato+&f an >em,e+ o+ an A)minist+ato+ of the B##& commits an

act of in)isci*ine o+ miscon)/ct o+ acts in an manne+ hich

ma o+ *ie* to ,e )et+imenta* to the inte+est of the B##& o+

~ 143 ~

Page 144: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 144/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

the ame of c+icet o+ en)ane+ the ha+mon o+ aect the

+e/tation o+ inte+est of the B##& o+ +ef/ses o+ ne*ects to

com* ith an of the +oisions of the >emo+an)/m an)?o+

the /*es an) e/*ations of the B##& an)?o+ the /*es of con)/ct f+ame) , the Boa+) the Ae= #o/nci* on +eceit of 

an com*aint sha** iss/e a ho #a/se $otice ca**in fo+

e=*anation an) on +eceit of the same an)?o+ in case of no

ca/se o+ ins/@cient ca/se ,ein shon +efe+ the same to the

Om,/)sman.Procedure:  The Om,/)sman sha** afte+ +oi)in

oo+t/nit of hea+in to the a+ties conce+ne) ass an

a+o+iate o+)e+.

c.  >iscon)/ct o+ B+each , Othe+s

&n the eent of an com*aint ,ein +eceie) f+om an /a+te+

o+ ,ase) on an +eo+t /,*ishe) o+ ci+c/*ate) o+ on its on

motion of an act of in)isci*ine o+ miscon)/ct o+ io*ation of 

an of the /*es an) e/*ations , an G*ae+ Lmi+e Team

O@cia* e*ecto+ o+ an e+son associate) ith the B##& the

Ae= #o/nci* sha** +efe+ the same ithin 48 ho/+s to the #EO

to mae a +e*imina+ en/i+.

Procedure The #EO sha** fo+thith mae a +e*imina+

in/i+ an) ca** fo+ e=*anations f+om the conce+ne)

e+sons an) s/,mit his +eo+t to the Ae= #o/nci* not

*ate+ than 15 )as f+om the )ate of +efe+ence ,ein

ma)e , the Ae= #o/nci*. On +eceit of the +eo+t the

Ae= #o/nci* sha** fo+a+) the same to the

Om,/)sman ho sha** ca** fo+ a** a+tic/*a+s an) /n*ess

it )eci)es that the+e is no +ima facie case an)

acco+)in* )+os the cha+e hea+in sha** commence

on the case an) the same sha** ,e com*ete) as

e=e)itio/s* as ossi,*e , +oi)in a +easona,*e

oo+t/nit to the a+ties of ,ein hea+). &f )esite )/e

notice an a+t fai*s to s/,mit an ca/se o+ s/,mits

~ 144 ~

Page 145: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 145/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

ins/@cient ca/se the Om,/)sman sha** afte+ +oi)in

+easona,*e oo+t/nit of hea+in to the a+ties

conce+ne) ass a+o+iate o+)e+. &n the eent an

a+t +ef/ses an) o+ fai*s to aea+ )esite notice theOm,/)sman sha** ,e at *i,e+t to +ocee) e=a+te on

the ,asis of the aai*a,*e +eco+)s an) ei)ence.

).  B the G/,*ic aainst the B##&Phe+e a mem,e+ of the /,*ic is a+iee) conce+nin

ticetin an) access an) faci*ities at sta)ia the same ma

,e ,+o/ht in the fo+m of a com*aint to the Om,/)sman.

Procedure The Om,/)sman o/*) a)ot the same

+oce)/+e as *ai) )on in c a,oe afte+ +efe++in the

com*aint to the #EO to so*icit a +eo+t on the

com*aint.

3 The G*ace of hea+in sha** ,e )eci)e) , the Om,/)sman

f+om time to time. The Om,/)sman sha** hae the oe+ to

imose ena*ties as +oi)e) in the e/*ations fo+ G*ae+s Team O@cia*s A)minist+ato+s >anae+s an) >atch O@cia*s

of the B##&.4 The )ecision of the Om,/)sman sha** ,e Cna* an) ,in)in an)

sha** come into fo+ce fo+thith on ,ein +ono/nce) an)

)e*ie+e).5 An A)minist+ato+ G*ae+ >atch O@cia* Team O@cia*

e*ecto+ o+ othe+ in)ii)/a* associate) ith the B##& on ,ein

fo/n) /i*t an) e=e**e) , the Boa+) sha** fo+feit a** thei+

+ihts an) +ii*ees. He o+ she sha** not in f/t/+e ,e entit*e)

to ho*) an osition o+ o@ce o+ ,e a)mitte) in an committee

o+ an +o*e on the B##&.6 A >em,e+ o+ "+anchise once e=e**e) ma on a*ication

ma)e afte+ e=i+ of th+ee ea+s since e=/*sion ,e

+ea)mitte) , the Boa+) +oi)e) the same is accete) at a

;ene+a* Bo) meetin , 3?4th mem,e+s +esent an) otin.7 Gen)in in/i+ an) +ocee)in into com*aints o+ cha+es of 

~ 145 ~

Page 146: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 146/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

miscon)/ct o+ an act of in)isci*ine o+ io*ation of an /*es

an) e/*ations the conce+ne) >em,e+ A)minist+ato+

G*ae+ >atch O@cia* Team O@cia* o+ othe+ in)ii)/a*

associate) ith the B##& a*on ith thei+ +esectie+ii*ees an) ,eneCts ma ,e s/sen)e) , the Ae=

#o/nci* /nti* Cna* a)-/)ication. Hoee+ the sai) a)-/)ication

o/ht to ,e com*ete) ithin si= months fai*in hich the

s/sension sha** cease.

~ 146 ~

Page 147: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 147/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

CHAPTER TEN: MISCELLANEOUS

2. NOTICE

1 An notice +e/i+e) to ,e se+e) on an >em,e+ of the B##&o+ an A)minist+ato+ o+ othe+ entit sha** ,e a))+esse) to thei+

+eiste+e) a))+esses.

2 A** notices sha** ,e se+e) , a of e*ect+onic mai* to the

o@cia* emai* a))+esses as a+e f/+nishe) to the B##&.

3 An notice sent ia ost o+ emai* sha** ,e )eeme) to hae

,een se+e) at the time hen the same as sent an) it sha**

,e s/@cient to +oe eithe+ that the *ette+ containin thenotice as +oe+* a))+esse) an) oste) o+ that the emai*

as sent to the co++ect emai* a))+ess.

3. INDEMNITY 

Ee+ O@ce,ea+e+ #o/nci**o+ #EO >anae+ o+ a >em,e+ of a

#ommittee of the B##& sha** ,e in)emniCe) o/t of the B##&s f/n)s

aainst a** *osses an) e=enses inc/++e) in the )ischa+e of his o+ he+)/ties e=cet those hich hae occ/++e) th+o/h i*f/* act o+ )efa/*t

an) if so each one sha** ,e cha+ea,*e on* fo+ so m/ch mones o+

+oe+ties as the sha** act/a** +eceie fo+ o+ in the )ischa+e of the

,/siness of the B##& an) sha** ,e anse+a,*e on* fo+ thei+ on act

ne*ect o+ )efa/*t an) not fo+ those of an othe+ e+son.

. SUITS BY OR AGAINST THE BCCI

 The B##& sha** s/e o+ ,e s/e) in the name of the ec+eta+.

$. AMENDMENT AND REPEAL

 These /*es an) e/*ations of the B##& sha** not ,e +eea*e)

a))e) to amen)e) o+ a*te+e) e=cet hen asse) an) a)ote) ,

a 3?4th ma-o+it of the mem,e+s +esent an) entit*e) to ote at a

~ 147 ~

Page 148: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 148/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

ecia* ;ene+a* >eetin of the ;ene+a* Bo) conene) fo+ the

/+ose o+ at the Ann/a* ;ene+a* >eetin.

~ 148 ~

Page 149: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 149/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

 ANNE,RE-'

THE (O;E FOR THE (RI(KET A<ER+5 A++O(IATION =(A>

7 .ME

The na&e of the association shall *e the Cricket Players$ .ssociation "/CP.0%

; O!3ECTS

The o*:ects of the CP. shall *e as follows=

"a% To conser)e( pro&ote and ad)ance the welfare and interests of the

&e&*ersK"*% To pro)ide insurance and other &edical and other *enefits for PlayersK

"c% To ne'otiate with the !oard of Control for Cricket in India "/!CCI0%(

securin' *est co&&ercial and other ter&s to Players( and welfare

&easures and *enefits( for *oth current and for&er players "It is

clarified that CP. will not *e and act as a Trade Union%

B FEIITIOS

"a% or the purpose of this Code( the followin' capitali1ed ter&s shall ha)e the

followin' &eanin's=

"i% /.ssociation0 shall &ean the CP.

"ii% /E,+Cricketer0 shall &ean any Player who has retired fro& co&petiti)e

cricket in all for&s of the 'a&e

"iii% /E,ecuti)e Co&&ittee0 shall &ean the co&&ittee &ana'in' the affairs

of the CP. and as constituted under these rules

"i)% /Me&*er0 shall &ean a person who has *een 'ranted &e&*ership into

the CP.

")% /Me&*ership0 shall &ean the ri'hts( pri)ile'es( and *enefits 'ranted to a

&e&*er *y the CP.

")i% /Rules0 &eans the re'ulations in this Code

~ 149 ~

Page 150: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 150/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

"*% Ter&s for which &eanin's are defined in this re'ulation shall apply equally to

sin'ular and plural for&s and also &asculine>fe&inine 'ender

@ MEM!ERSHIP

The &e&*ership of the CP. shall co&prise=

"a% Male and fe&ale E,+cricketers( who ha)e played at least one International

Cricket Match in any for&at of the 'a&e at the senior le)elK

"*% Male e,+cricketers( who ha)e played at least Ten irst Class Matches in any 

for&at of the 'a&e at the senior le)elK

"c% e&ale e,+cricketers( who ha)e played at least i)e irst Class Matches in

any for&at of the 'a&e at the senior le)elK

"d% Fifferently+a*led e,+cricketers( who ha)e played either International

Cricket or first class cricket in any for&at of the 'a&e at the senior le)elK

< . PP4IC.TIO OR  MEM!ERSHIP

"a% E)ery application for &e&*ership shall *e &ade in writin' to the

E,ecuti)e Co&&ittee > Steerin' Co&&ittee as per a for& prescri*ed *y the

Co&&itteeK

"*% o application shall *e re:ected on any 'round if the player satisfies any of 

the eli'i*ility criteria laid down in re'ulation @

? FUTIES>O!4I2.TIOS O MEM!ERS 

"a% Me&*ers shall not for& a trade union of any sort and player"s% in)ol)ed in

any such &easure will 'et auto&atically disqualified to continue as

&e&*ers of this .ssociationK

"*% Me&*ers shall strictly adhere to all pro)isions of the !CCI Re'ulations

includin' the Code of Conduct and all other Re'ulations &ade *y !CCI or

IP4( as the case &ay *e( with special e&phasis on Conflict of Interest and

!CCI Code of !eha)iourK

~ 150 ~

Page 151: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 151/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

TERMI.TIO O MEM!ERSHIP

"a% . &e&*er &ay resi'n fro& the association *y=7 2i)in' notice( in writin'( to the E,ecuti)e Co&&ittee to that effectK and; Payin' any outstandin' le)ies due at the date of such noticeK

and upon receipt of such written notice and such pay&ent( the E,ecuti)eCo&&ittee shall re&o)e the &e&*er fro& the .ssociation

"*% The E,ecuti)e Co&&ittee &ay *y resolution( and *y followin' a process

consistent with the principles of natural :ustice( re&o)e any Me&*er fro&

the association in the e)ent of con)iction for the co&&ission of a cri&inal

offence or for *reachin' the o*li'ations laid down in Re'ulation ?

THE EECUTI5E COMMITTEE

"a% The E,ecuti)e Co&&ittee shall *e the 'o)ernin' *ody of this association

co&prisin' a President( a Secretary( a Treasurer and two Me&*ersK

"*% .t least one of the &e&*ers of the E,ecuti)e Co&&ittee shall *e a wo&anK

"c% The E,ecuti)e Co&&ittee shall ha)e the power to do all such acts( deeds(

&atters as &ay *e necessary for the furtherance of the o*:ecti)es of this

association

9 E4I2I!I4ITQ 

"a% Me&*ers of the E,ecuti)e Co&&ittee shall *e elected *y a si&ple

&a:ority throu'h elections conducted *y the Electoral Officer of the !CCIK

"*% Such &e&*er elected &ust ha)e either played at least fi)e

International Test Matches for India( or a &ini&u& nu&*er of twenty+

fi)e ";<% irst Class &atches( if it is a &ale or a &ini&u& nu&*er of ten

"78% irst Class &atches( if it is a fe&ale

78TERM

"a% The ter& of the E,ecuti)e Co&&ittee shall *e ; years

"*% Each Me&*er of the E,ecuti)e Co&&ittee shall *e eli'i*le to hold office

for a &a,i&u& of ; ter&s( after which he or she shall *e ineli'i*le to

stand for office

~ 151 ~

Page 152: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 152/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

77 FUTIES O THE EECUTI5E COMMITTEE 

"a% The E,ecuti)e Co&&ittee shall ensure that the funds pro)ided *y the !CCI

are utili1ed e,clusi)ely for the purpose of this association and for no other

purposeK"*% . report and audited *alance sheet and state&ent of accounts for the

precedin' financial year shall *e furnished to the !CCI for the funds

assi'ned *y the !CCIK"c% The E,ecuti)e Co&&ittee shall *e responsi*le for o*ser)ance of &easures

&andated for the constitution of the .pe, Council of the !CCI or for any of 

its Co&&ittees or under any Re'ulations of the !CCI or IP4K"d% The E,ecuti)e Co&&ittee shall elect>no&inate two of the &e&*ers for

 *ein' appointed as Me&*ers of the .pe, Council of !CCI( and one &e&*er

to the IP4 2o)ernin' Council

7; . MEFMET > MOFIIC.TIO

 The CP. &ay add( &odify or delete any of the pro)isions of this Code in

consultation with the !CCI

~ 152 ~

Page 153: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 153/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

 ANNE,RE-(

THE REGATION+ FOR REGI+TRATION OF A<ER+5 AGENT+

7 . PP4IC.!I4ITQ  O R E2U4.TIOS 

o person "other than a Player representin' hi&self% shall *e per&itted to

conduct indi)idual contract ne'otiations on *ehalf of a Player and>or assist in or

ad)ise with respect to such ne'otiations after the Effecti)e Fate unless he is

re'istered>certified as a Player .'ent pursuant to these Re'ulations

; . FMIISTERI2 . UTHORITQ  OR  THE . 2ETS 

"a% . Co&&ittee on .'ent Re'ulation "/Co&&ittee0% shall *e constituted *y the

!CCI to ad&inister &atters relatin' to re'istration of Player .'ents

"*% This Co&&ittee shall consist of < &e&*ers( of which ; shall *e no&inees of 

the Players$ .ssociation and B "includin' the Chairperson% shall *e no&inees

of the !CCI

"c% In addition to perfor&in' the function of re)iewin' and actin' upon all

applications for Re'istration( the Co&&ittee on .'ent Re'ulation also ser)es

as the Fisciplinary Co&&ittee In the latter capacity( it shall ha)e the

authority and responsi*ility of initiatin' and then presentin' disciplinary 

proceedin's a'ainst Player .'ents who )iolate disciplinary pro)isions and>or

en'a'e in prohi*ited conduct

B PREREAUISITES OR  R E2ISTR.TIO

"a% The .pplicant &ust necessarily *e a natural person= .ll applications &ust

 *e si'ned *y and filed on *ehalf of a sin'le indi)idual applicant The

Co&&ittee shall not accept any .pplication filed *y( nor will it certify as a

Player .'ent( any co&pany( partnership( corporation( or other artificial

le'al entity

"*% Each applicant( who shall not *e less than ;< years of a'e( &ust pass a written e,a&ination which will *e followed *y a personal inter)iew= . test

~ 153 ~

Page 154: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 154/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

and personal inter)iew shall *e conducted *y !CCI to ena*le the co&&ittee

to ascertain whether the applicant is capa*le and suita*le to *e a Player

a'ent and has adequate knowled'e of cricket re'ulations( includin' the

rele)ant disciplinary and ethics re'ulations laid down *y the !CCI and>or

the IP4 as also knowled'e in the fields of le'al( accountin' and *usiness

&ana'e&ent

"c% Clearance Certificate fro& .nti+Corruption and Security Unit ".CSU%= The

applicant &ust su*&it a clearance certificate issued *y the .nti+Corruption

and Security Unit ".CSU% of the International Cricket Council "ICC% which

ensures that strict anti+corruption protocols are followed *y all

stakeholders

"d% o Cri&inal Record= The applicant will *e required to satisfy the co&&ittee

of his 'ood character and reputation( on ter&s that shall *e stipulated *y 

the co&&ittee fro& ti&e to ti&e This shall include( *ut not *e li&ited to(

consideration of the .pplicantJs cri&inal record and financial history

"e% Fisclosure State&ent= The applicant shall disclose on his application and

thereafter upon request of the Co&&ittee all infor&ation rele)ant to his or

her qualifications to ser)e as a Player a'ent He>she shall also authori1e the

Co&&ittee to perfor& a *ack'round in)esti'ation

"f% on+refunda*le .pplication fee and .nnual ee= .part fro& the pay&ent of 

a non+refunda*le .pplication ee( in order to retain his or her re'istration(

the Player .'ent will ha)e to pay to the !CCI an annual ad&inistrati)e fee

 which shall *e deter&ined *y the Co&&ittee

"'% Ma,i&u& a'ent fee= The applicant shall furnish an undertakin' that he

shall char'e no &ore than a &a,i&u& a'ent fee of ; of the total annual

re)enue earned

@ . FHERECE  .F FISCIP4I.RQ   .CTIO

"a% The a'ent shall strictly adhere to all pro)isions of the !CCI Re'ulations

includin' the Code of Conduct and all other Re'ulations &ade *y !CCI or

IP4( as the case &ay *e( with e&phasis on=

~ 154 ~

Page 155: Final Report (Volume 1)

7/23/2019 Final Report (Volume 1)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-report-volume-1 155/155

THE SUPREME COURT COMMITTEE

o Conflict of Interesto o Fual Representation "Representin' *oth an indi)idual and a

clu*>franchise%o o *orrowin' of &oney fro& Playerso

ailure to disclose Rele)ant Infor&ationo !reach of Confidentiality 

"*% The Co&&ittee shall ha)e the authority to initiate disciplinary procedures

a'ainst Player .'ents who )iolate any of the rele)ant pro)isions and

Re'ulations &ade *y the !CCI or the IP4 as the case &ay *e The principles

of natural :ustice shall *e followed *efore the re'istration of the a'ent is

either suspended or cancelled

"c% Lithout reference to the .'ent concerned( if relia*le infor&ation isrecei)ed fro& the .CSU or any other in)esti'ati)e *ody of the 2o)ern&ent

concernin' the actions of an a'ent( the Co&&ittee &ay in its discretion take

any action it dee&s fit

< M .ITE.CE O R E2ISTER 

The Co&&ittee shall &aintain an up to date re'ister of all the re'istered a'ents


Recommended