Date post: | 08-Apr-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | maria-javed |
View: | 219 times |
Download: | 0 times |
of 30
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
1/29
Probability & their application in Business
1
ALLAMA IQBAL OPEN UNIVERSITY(Department Of Business Administration)
SEMESTER: AUTUMN 2010
BUSINESS MAHEMATICS & STATISTICS
Code no 523
SIDRA MUDASSERAH 525501
ASSIGNMENT # 2
Probability & their application in Business
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
2/29
Probability & their application in Business
2
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Isincerely feel that the credit of this project work could not be narrowed to
only one individual as the whole work is outcome of integrated efforts of my
instructors and their hand outs and their cooperation which results into
completion of this project.
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
3/29
Probability & their application in Business
3
ABSTRACT
Integration of MS office has been designed to simplify the use ofthe various
Microsoft Officetools while still offering users the optionto continue working with
what is familiarto them. Previously set uptemplates and forms can continueto be
used by organizations enablingthemto seamlessly integratetheirexistingprocesses
into new ones with Integration of MS office. This factalone willpromote user
adoption substantially and demonstrate Integration of MS officeease of use.
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
4/29
Probability & their application in Business
4
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Probability..5Types of Probability...5Microsoft Excel...10-11Microsoft PowerPoint ..12Microsoft Access .13MS office Integration ..14Benefits of Integration .15Share Point Integration ...15-18MS Access & MS excel Integration ...19-23Case Study of SPO..23-33Conclusion ...35
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
5/29
Probability & their application in Business
5
1. PROBABILITY
Probability theory is an importantpart of statisticaltheory that bridges descriptiveand
inferential statistics. It is the science of uncertainty or chance, or likelihood. A
probability valueranges between 0 and 1 inclusiveand represents thelikelihoodthata
particularevent will happen. A probability value of 0 means there is no chance that
and will happenand a value of 1 means there is 100 percent chancethattheevent will
happen.
Understandingprobability is helpful for decision-making. Conductinganexperiment
or sampletestprovides an outcomethat can be used to computethe chance ofevents
occurring inthe future.
An experiment is the observation of some activity or the act of taking some
measurement. Whereas, an outcome is a particular result of an experiment. The
collection of one ormore outcomes ofanexperiment is knownas anevent.
Forexample,amarkettesting ofa sample ofnew breakfast cereal,new beer,new
wine,new magazine,etc.gives theDirectorof Production orDirectorof Marketinga
company apreliminary idea(outcome) whetherconsumers would liketheproduct if it
is produced and distributed in bulk.
2. TYPES OF PROBABILITIES
There are three definitions of probability. The first one is known as classical
probability. The classical definitionapplies whentherearenequally likely outcomes
to anexperiment. It is obtained by dividingthenumberof favorable outcomes by the
totalnumberofpossible outcomes.
The second one is Empirical probability that is based onpast experience. This is
determined dividing the number of times an event happens by the total number of
observations. Forexample:
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
6/29
Probability & their application in Business
6
Theprobability that your income tax return will beaudited if thereare two million
mailed to yourdistrict officeand 2,400 areto beaudited is 2,400/2,000,000 = 0.0012
or0.12%.
The third is asubjective probability. Subjectiveprobability is aprobability assigned
to anevent based on whateverevidence is available. It is aneducated guess.Unlike
empiricalprobability, it is not based onpastexperience.
Subjective probability is obtained by evaluating the available options and by
assigning the probability. Examples of events that require computing subjective
probability:
(1)Estimatingtheprobability thataperson wins a jackpotlottery.(2)Estimatingtheprobability thatthe GM willlose its firstranking in carsales.
3.BASIC RULES OF PROBABILITY
No
.
EVENTS FEATURES KEY
CONNECTING
WORDS
APPLICABL
E RULE
FORMUL
A
1 Mutually
exclusive
No overlapping
events - if one
event happens the
otherone cant
occuratthe same
time
Theprobability
ofA occurringor
theprobability of
B occurring
SpecialRule of
Addition
P(AorB) =
P(A)+P(B)
2 Not
mutually
exclusive
(Joint/
Compound)
Overlapping/
Concurrentevents
two ormore
events happenat
the sametime
Theprobability
thateitherA
may occurorB
may occur
followed by the
possibility that
bothAandB
GeneralRule
of Addition
P(AorB) =
P(A)+P(B)
P(Aand
B)
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
7/29
Probabilit
& t ir appli ation inB
iness
7
may occur.
Independent The occurrence of
eventA has no
effect on the
occurrence of
another eventB
The probability
thatAandB will
occur
SpecialRule of
Multiplication
P(A and B)
= P(A)P(B)
Conditional Dependent events
the probability of
a particular event
occurring given
that another event
has occurred
P(B|A)
probability that
eventB will
occurgiv n that
eventA has
already occurred
GeneralRule
of
Multiplication
P(A and B)
=
P(A)P(B|A)
5 Complemen
t
All events in the
sample space that
are not part ofthe
specified event
determined by
subtracting the
probability of an
event not
happening from
the probability of
happening
Event Not
occurring
or
Neither/nor will
happen
Complement
Rule
P(A) = 1
P (~ A)
3.DISCRETE PROB BILIT DISTRIB TIONS
Probabilities values for experiments whose outcomes are numerical are known as
randomvar
iable
s. Random variables can be discrete (have a finite number of samplespace) or continuous (have an infinite number of sample space). An example of
discrete probability distributions is binomial distribution.
Properties ofBinomial distribution:
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
8/29
Probability & their application in Business
8
y Each trial(X)may be selected from infinitepopulation withoutreplacement orfroma finitepopulation(N) with replacement.
y Each trial(X) is mutually exclusiveand collectively exhaustivey Each trial(X) has two possible outcomes, success orfailure.y Each trial has a fixedprobability of success orfailure().
5. THE PRINCIPLES OF COUNTING
Ifthenumberofpossible outcomes inanexperiment is small, it is relatively easy to
count them. If, however, therearea largenumber ofpossible outcomes, it would be
tedious to countall thepossibilities. To facilitate counting, three counting formulas
will be examined: the multiplication formula, the permutation formula, and the
combination formula.
A) The Multiplication Formula is:
Totalnumber of arrangements = (m)(n).
Example: If a salesperson has seven shirts and 5 ties to display, 35 outfits are
possible. This means he or she has 35 different ways displayingthe outfits.This can
beextended to more than two events. For threeeventsm, n, and o: Totalnumber of
arrangements _(m)(n)(o).
B)The Permutation Formula
The permutation formula is applied to find thepossible number of arrangements
whenthere is only one group of objects. Orderis very important inpermutation. Note
thearrangements a b c and b a c are differentpermutations. The formulato countthe
totalnumberof differentpermutations is:
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
9/29
Probability & their application in Business
9
where:
n is thetotalnumberof objects (pool).
ris thenumberof objects selected atatime.
Before we solve the two problems illustrated, note that permutations and
combinations useanotation called n factorial.It is writtenn! and means theproduct
ofn(n-1),(n-2),(n-3),(n-4),(n-5),etc. For instance, 5! Means 5 x4x3x 2 x 1 =
120.
By definition, zero factorial, written 0!, is 1. That is, 0! = 1.
Example: A flag with three stripes of3 colors can useany of six colors. How many
flags arepossible? This is apermutationproblemand the orderofarrangingthe flags
is important.
nPr= 6P3 = 6! = 120
(6-3)!
C)The Combination Formula
Ifthe orderofthe selected objects is not important,any selection is called a
combination.The formula
to countthenumberofrobject combinations froma set ofn objects is:
Example: You have6 colors to choose fromand you wish to choose3 fora flag. How
many choices arepossible? This is a combinationproblemthe orderofarranging
colors innot important.
nCr = 6C3 = 6! = 20
3!(6-3)!
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
10/29
Probability & their application in Business
10
6. APPLICATION IN THE BUSINESSIn the quest to achieve a sustainablemaximum level ofprofit and profitability in
business,analyticaltools are oftenput into play thataddress thequantitative
Methods of business.
The use of these tools helps to determine theeffectiveness of givenprograms of
operation and can help demonstrate which areas of business need to be subject to
refinement oradaptationto oncemoreminimizeloss and maximizeprofit.
Through addressing the quantitativemethods of business, those inmanagementand
cost- reassessmentprograms can betterunderstand the forces thatareat work intheir
respective departments and within the business environmentas a whole, essentially
accomplishingagreaterdegree of controloverallareas of business.
This paper three investigate many of the commonly- used analytical tools and
concepts thatare used to helpeffectuatedecisions ina business environment.
This paper shall break down the investigation of these analytical tools into three
different
areas of study to better limit the discussion: The first area is that of the localized
department, wheretheanalyticalmethods can beapplied to a specific area of business
such as shipping & receiving ororderprocessing.
The second area is that ofthe business as anentity, wherethe business is examined as
a separateand wholeentity, orthe sum of its localized departments. Finally,thethird
area shall bethe overall business environment in which a specific business is located,
where for example a law firm would be examined according to its position and
business strategies withintheentirelaw industry.
Thetypes ofanalyticalmodels that shall be investigated inthispaperareprobability
theory and statistics, utility theory and gametheory. Through investigatingthesetools
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
11/29
Probability & their application in Business
11
in this three- tired framework, the readerwill haveagreatercomprehension of how
analytical tools can be used to accomplish various reforms withina business or the
business sectoras a whole.
7. PROBABILITY THEORY AND STATISTICS
This section shall explore the use ofthemodel forprobability theory and how this
theory functions withina business environment. Probability theory is almostalways
used inrespectto statistical figures as this theory is useless without statistics through
which to supportthe initialassessment.
Introduction to Probability Theory
Therole ofprobability theory inanalyticalmethodology has been called thecommon
sense approach to investigating specific areas of study, for probability theory
suggests that the best way of investigating a problem is to combine a previous
knowledge ofevents with thelikelihood ofevents manifestingagain.
The overallassumptions that can be drawn fromprobability theory havea significant
margin oferror (inmost circumstances) but the single solution that can be drawn is
what is mostlikely the situationthat will occurgivenapredetermined set of variables.
Essentially, thenature ofprobability theory has been traced to standard Aristotelian
logic, which reduces a situation to be applicable to deductive according to the
assumptionthata situation can be defined aseithertrue or false.
When a given situation is presented, a researcher can then address the scenarioaccording to true or false qualities (as shall be explored ata laterpoint in this
section). This method 2011 119 therefore allows for various generalizations to be
made based upontheavailable data frompre- existing situations,and is a usefultool
forcreatingthemostlikely outcomes foragiven scenario.
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
12/29
Probability & their application in Business
12
Take the following citation as a means of getting a better overview of the
methodology and functionality ofprobability theory in respect to related events, for
this is thearea in which probability theory is most frequently utilized in business.
Inthe followingexamples,throwing dice is used to illustratethenature ofprobability
theory in respect to statistics, where theprobability of rolling a specific number is
manifestaccordingto thenumberof dice used and thetimes takento rollthe dice.
Independent or related e ents?
One of the important steps you need to make when considering the probability of two
or more events occurring. Is to decide whether they are independent or related events.
Examples:
Independent or Mutually exclusive events
Theprobability ofthrowinga doublethreewith two dice is theresult ofthrowing
three with the first dieand three with the second die. Thetotalpossibilities are, one
from six outcomes forthe firsteventand one from six outcomes forthe second,
therefore(1/6) *
(1/6) = 1/36th or 2.77%.
Thetwo events are independent, sincewhateverhappens to the first die cannotaffect
thethrow ofthe second; theprobabilities arethereforemultiplied,and remain 1/36th.
Related or Mutually inclusive events
1. What happens if we wantto throw 1 and 6 inany order? This now means that we
do notmind ifthe first die is either1 or6,as weare still in with a chance. But with
the first die, if 1 falls uppermost, clearly It rules out the possibility of 6 being
uppermost, so thetwo Outcomes, 1 and 6,aremutually inclusive, Oneresult directly
affects the other.
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
13/29
Probability & their application in Business
13
Inthis case,theprobability ofthrowing 1 or6 with the first die is the sum ofthetwo
probabilities, 1/6 + 1/6 = 1/3.
2. Theprobability of the second die being favorable is still 1/6as the second die can
only be one specific number,a6 ifthe first die is 1,and vice versa.
3. Therefore theprobability ofthrowing 1 and 6 inany orderwith two dice is 1/3x
1/6 = 1/18. From theabove citation, it can be seen that givenapredefined set of
variables inthe context of what willmostlikely occur inagiven scenario (whereall
potentialexternal variables remain constant),a specific answerto the situation can be
assessed.
Becauseoftheselimitations,probability theory inbusiness is doneaccordingto past
variablesand existing business situations and is notfrequently used to predictearth-
shatteringbusiness decisions but rather is more limited in its scope, for it is not a
method of businessassessmentthat is infallible.
It must be stressed that the existence of problems corresponding to the
overgeneralization of a specific scenario tends to create complications in certain
situations,where onearticlenotes that:
Probability theory and its offspring, inferentialstatistics, constitute perhaps the most
frustrating branch of human knowledge.The abstractness of formalmethods scares
many people, andleads to frequent errors in the choice of procedures.(Simon &
Bruce: 1993)
Indeed,the overwhelminguse ofprobability theory is a usefultoolonly in scenarios
wheregeneralizations arepossible:
No one would build a space shuttlebased upon theresults ofprobability theory,but
one could theoretically predict ordering a preset number ofproducts for a given
monthbased uponthis method.
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
14/29
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
15/29
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
16/29
Probability & their application in Business
16
of smallpox, where the mathematician DAlembert attempted to determine the risk
assessment found within inoculationto smallpox.
This source notes: One urgent social issue which prompted much argument about
probability [] was inoculationagainst smallpox. Theprocedure was notrisk free. It
involved impregnatingthe skin with live smallpoxpustules and could lead to death.
At the same time, however, over 10 percent of thepopulations of Londonand Paris
were beingkilled by the disease. ForDAlembert the choice was approximately as
follows:a 1 in 7 longer term chance of dying of smallpox versus a 1 in 200 short-
term chance of dying fromthe inoculation.
Complicatingthe issue was thegenerally smallaveragelifeexpectancy in Paris. In
addition, conservative opinion inFrance, includingthe Faculty of Medicineand the
Faculty of Theology atthe University of Paris, had come out strongly against
inoculation.
Daniel Bernoulli [another mathematician] applied his probability formulae for
lotteries to theproblem of smallpox. He calculated thenumberofpersons likely to be
killed by smallpox in a given time. Then, he calculated the gain in life expectancy
from inoculation forany givenage. His formulas were necessarily rather crudeand
the statistics ofmortality inadequate, but his results definitely favored inoculation.
This risk- versus- gain stillexists inthemodern business environment, where
companies that do business that contains acertainelement ofriskneed to beaware of
thelikelihood of injury to a customer,eitherindependently (insurance) oras aresult
ofproduct use(carmanufacturing).
The end result of this assessment helps to create theparameters around which the
business can be conducted with the maximum amount ofprofit according to the
minimum amount of inherent risk. To enumerate this concept further through a
quantitativemethod,theresearcheruses theexample of stocks ofa company Genco.
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
17/29
Probability & their application in Business
17
Supposea broker buy shares of GencoCorporationataprice of $100 per shareand
intend to keep it on hold forone yearfora dividend yield of3%.
Totalrate ofreturn ofthe share can beestimated by the formula: Supposetheprice of
the stock changes by 7% while its yield remains at 3% in one week, then the total
return is R= 3 + 7 % = 10%. Gencos stockprice may yield 10% or it may yield
differently butthe yield will bearound 10% inthe shortrun.
The change in Gencos stocks price is basically based onthe volatility theory. Fora
short term theprobability of the returns is easy to gaugebut in the long run, the
volatility rate is quite different.
It is based onarange of deviation orprobability distributionrange.Forexample ifthe
possibility ofnotgainingreturn is zero thentheprobability ratio of 10% return can be
assigned as one. To determine the long term return, the broker will estimate
probabilities of Gencos stockina weak,a strongand normaleconomy andobtains
the following figures:
State ofGenco Probability
Strong30% 0.20
Normal 10% 0.60
Weak-10% 0.20
Usingtheaboveprobability returns thebrokercan furthercalculatetheexpected
returns:
Expected Returns = Sum of(Probability ofReturn)x(PossibleReturn)
Fromthetable ER= 0.20 X30% + 0.6x
10% +0.2 x -10% = 10%
Thus,themostlikely returnthata brokerwillgain is 10% forGencos stock. The
utility ofprobability theory canextended furtherifthe brokerdecides to comparethe
price of Gencos stockand that of its competitors. The outcome willgive himan idea
as to which stockis a betterinvestmentand which oneposes a higherriskforreturns.
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
18/29
Probability & their application in Business
18
Utility Theory
Far easier to understand than probability theory and arguably the method of
quantitative assessment that is most frequently used in business is that of utility
theory. This section shall define utility theory and how advances in technologyhave
created an environment in which this method of assessment is most effective in
predicting consumerresponses.
Introduction to Utility Theory
The functionality of utility theory is best found inmeasuring thepreferences ofan
individual or a target group of individuals and measuring the impact of these
preferences on behaviors and beliefs. This practice should sound familiar to any
student in business, for the study of utility theory is the study of consumer buying
behaviors.
In utility theory, the individual that is targeted for assessment is believed to be a
rational individual who determines his orherbehaviors accordingto obvious needsor
desires. The scale against which these behaviors are measured is called a utility
scale, and the ranking placed upon this scale helps in the overall assessment of
behaviors.
The study of utility theory is by no means anew area, but it has becomea science
overthepast five decades. Theearliestmethods of utility theory ineconomic practice
can be traced to a mathematician who suggested that consumer behavior was
essentially predefined according to setpatterns of behavior,and that these behaviors
could be slightly altered orexploited:
In his book The Theory of Value, author Debreu (1959) suggested that consumer
behaviors could be understood in the sense that these behaviors created an
equilibrium forconsumers,where if someoneneeded aproducttheywould seekout
thatproduct.
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
19/29
Probability & their application in Business
19
Those seekingto encourage consumers to changetheirbehaviors would notgetthem
to altertheirneed but could instead altertheirdesires.Forexample, if someoneneeds
drain cleaner,this need cannot be changed buttheirdecision of which drain cleanerto
buy can bealtered accordingtoknowledge ofthe utility theory.
Utility Theory in the LocalizedEnvironment
The use of utility theory in specific sections of a specific business is not overly
functional: Utility theory helps predict behavior ona larger level, which in turn can
impact the localized environment. However, there is very little direct interaction
between utility theory and thelocalized environment.
Utility Theory and the BusinessEnvironment
Utility theory inthe business environment is one ofthemost widely- used assessment
tools forquantitativeanalysis. Thepurchasing behavior of consumers is what drives
businesses,and those businesses that fully understand theirtarget consumeraudience
and how to bestappealto themare farmorelikely to succeed than companies that do
notrecognizethis basic area of commerce.
Companies that wish to succeed haveevengone so faras to utilizenewmethods of
technology to keep track oftheirconsumerspurchasing behaviors in order to better
tailor their businesses and therefore draw ingreater consumer interest. Perhaps the
bestexample ofthis use ofnew technology is inthe supermarket:
It is a common feature in supermarkets to find atype ofmembership discount, where
customers that are part of the supermarkets community are offered discounted
savings whenthey runtheirmembership card.
However, inadditionto offering savings,themembership card also creates atally of
the customers purchasing behaviors, includingthetype ofproductpurchased andits
size, cost,and thetime ofmonth it waspurchased.
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
20/29
Probability & their application in Business
20
The supermarket can therefore use these membership cards to either offer the
customer increased savings or provide incentive for the customer to return, or to
simply chartthetypes of buying behaviors displayed by theircustomers.
Utility Theory and the RespectiveIndustries
Those familiarwith business willrecognizethatentire industries have been compiled
around utility theory Advertising is a multi- billion dollar industry that all
companies tend to rely uponto some degree,and the use ofadvertising suggests that
all companies areaware oftheneed to assess consumerbehaviors.
According to the use of utility theory and other methods of statistical assessment,
companies determine all manner of business strategies including releasing new
productlines, changingexistingproducts,and adaptingexisting strategies to better fit
the demands of consumers.
Yet despitethetraditionalreliance on utility theory in industries such as advertising
as wellas the businesses that benefit fromthe use of utility theory thereare inherent
flaws withinthis type ofmethod that cannotbe overlooked.
One article from the renown industry digest Quirks Marketing Research Review
(Lawson & Glowa: 2000) suggests that therearefour limitations in utility theory,
wherethis method is lacking inthe following:
a. Forecasting demand fornew, orcategory- revolutionizingproducts.
b. Forecasting demand forproducts in categories in which new and differentattributes
which werenotpreviously a consideration in choiceare introduced.
c. Forecasting demand for products in categories in which attribute ranges are
stretched well beyond those inpresentmarkets.
d. Forecasting demand inmarkets in which serious multicollinearity is presentamong
thepredictorvariables.
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
21/29
Probability & their application in Business
21
Also,this source suggests thata wholesalereliance onadvertisingas a solutionto all
problems in business is a flawed perspective, because utility theory is based uponthe
belief that customers can be manipulated according to their choices made when
buyingaproduct. Theauthors notethat:
Real customers who make choices inrealmarkets frequently decidenotto choose.
That is, forwhateverreason, some customers chooseto delaypurchases orchooseno
products offered inaparticularcategory.
Examples of the former customers include millions ofpotential customers for PCs
who know they eventually wantto haveoneat home, butare waitingeitherforprices
to drop further, or functionality to increase, orboth. Examples ofthelattercustomers
include those who are allergic to chocolate, and hence, will not buy chocolate
products regardless ofthe category in which they are offered.
Reliance on advertising inan industry can therefore be concluded as a science, but
perhaps not the most exact science necessary to predict all aspects of consumer
behaviors.
This is apparently why markets constantly emergethat wereeitherunderestimated or
unpredicted,and markets that were seenaspotential booms collapsewithout warning.
Game Theory
Unliketheassessmentmodels ofprobability theory and utility theory,gametheory is
best utilized according to human created conditions within a specific working
environment. Gametheory is extremely diverse in its scope yet can begeneralizedashow human beings or larger entities such as organizations interact within certain
conditions.
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
22/29
Probability & their application in Business
22
AnIntroduction to Game Theory
The study of game theory is the study of human behavior within a specific
environment. When applied to business, the use ofgame theory helps to determine
how an individual ora business willreact withinthatenvironment.
In terms ofqualitativeassessment,gametheory is unique because italso brings into
play elements of humanpsychology that arenot generally found within standard
assessmenttechniques, such as philosophy andaltruism.
For example, one of the best- known elements of game theory is the prisoners
dilemma: Simply put, the matter of game theory in the prisoners dilemma
suggested that in a prison setting where two individuals were being questioned
separately and the one who talked first was (theoretically) offered freedom, either
both parties could benefit slightly, one party could benefit significantly, or both
parties could sufferseverelosses.
Theresponse ofthe otheris dependent uponnot only theirown desires,butalso upon
thequestionable benefits thatthey mightreceive ifthey remain silent. This aspect of
gametheory is summarized fromanarticlepublished intheJournal ofthe History of
Economic Thought. AuthorRoth (1993) writes. InJanuary of 1950, MelvinDresher
and Merrill Flood conducted attheRand Corporationanexperiment which has had an
enormous if indirect influence, since it introduced the game that has subsequently
cometo beknownas the Prisoners Dilemma.
The game they studied was the hundred- fold repetition of the matrix game given
below, betweena fixed pairof subjects who communicated only theirchoices ofrow
(1 or2) orcolumn(1 or2).(-1,2) (1/2, 1)(0, 1/2) (1, -1) Payoffs were inpennies, with
each playerreceivingthe sum, overtheone hundred plays ofthegame, of hispayoffs
ineach play.
The unique Nash equilibriumprediction is that theplayers should choose (2,1) - the
second row and the first column - ateach ofthe hundred repetitions. Thus the
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
23/29
Probability & their application in Business
23
predicted earnings of theplayers are 0 for the row player (henceforth Row) and
$0.50 forthe columnplayer(henceforth Column).
Of coursethis is inefficient, since iftheplayers instead played (1,2)ateveryperiod,
forexample,theirearnings would be $0.50 forRow and $1.00 forColumn i.e.they
would both earnmore.
But this is not equilibrium behavior. That equilibrium play is substantially less
profitable than cooperativeplay madeDresherand Flood anticipate correctly that
this game would presenta demandingtest oftheequilibriumpredictions.
The observed payoffs, forapairofplayers [] were $0.40 forRow and $0.65 for
Column. This outcome is far from the equilibrium outcome, although it also falls
considerably short ofperfect cooperation.
(This observation has since been replicated many times.) Dresher and Flood
interpreted this as evidenceagainstthegeneral hypothesis thatplayers tend to choose
Nash equilibrium strategies,and in favor of the hypothesis thata cooperative split
the difference principle would bemorepowerful in organizingthe data fromgames
ofthis kind.
Yet in a business setting, the welfare of a single company is weighed against the
potential benefits or losses that might be incurred from interaction with another
company. Gametheory is one way in which to bestpredictthe outcome ofencounters
between individuals and between organizations,as shallnow be clarified:
Game Theory in the LocalizedEnvironment
Game theory in a localized environment is most often utilized as part of the team
buildingprocess, wheremembers ofa specific departmentarerequired toparticipate
inteachingtools that utilizegametheory as ameans of betterunderstandingtheirrole
in business. Forexample, intheaforementioned Randolph Glassworks thereseems to
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
24/29
Probability & their application in Business
24
bea competition betweentwo men inthe design department fortheattentions oftheir
manager.
Themanagerrecognizes this competitionas unhealthy only when one ofthemen
seeks to sabotagethe others labor.Evenafterseveralmeetings designed to solvethe
problem,themanageris ableto tellthattheproblempersists and is afraid that it will
againerupt ina way that will harmthe workof one ofthemen.
Themanagerdetermines thata day ofteam building is the best way to rectify this
situationand he determines thatgametheory is the bestmethod ofteambuildingto be
used: Not only is themanagerableto bring his department closerthrough interaction
but he canalso taketheresults ofthe survey assessments provided to thedepartment
and see if he can usetheresults to alleviatethepressurethatexists betweenthetwo
men.
Game Theory in a BusinessEnvironment
Therole ofgametheory ina business environment is remarkably likethat found
withinthelocalized environment, wheretheuse ofgametheory can be doneto
determinethe interactions of various departments and individuals,and theresults of
thetesting canthen beevaluated to see how team- building can beaccomplished.
Inaddition,gametheory is occasionally used on customers fora specific business to
evaluate how the customersperceivethemselves withintheirrelationshipto the
business: Surveys andphone interviews are often used to facilitatethis type of
quantitativeassessment.
Game Theory in the RespectiveIndustries
Gametheory is so widely varied interms of its use, its features,and its impactthat it
is rarethatanencounterbetweentwo businesses cannot beexplored viaa function of
gametheory.
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
25/29
Probability & their application in Business
25
For example, imagine a situation where two businesses were planning to merge:
These businesses thenneed to assess their relationship to each otherand the use of
gametheory can help inpredicting how one business willreactto themerger. Game
theory cantherefore serveas ameans of understandingthepositionofthe otherentity
and willthereafterhelpencouragea facilitated relationship betweenthetwo.
7. CASE STUDYAbout enterprise Attock Petroleum limited, Ltd.
AttockPetroleum Limited (APL) is anassociate company ofthe AttockOil Group of
Companies, which is the only fully vertically integrated Group inthe Oil & Gas sector
of Pakistan involved in Exploration & Production, Refining & Marketing. APL's
corporate head office is registered in Islamabad.
Groups of goods Attock Petroleum limited, Ltd.
Automobile oils, Automotive gear oils, Oils for automatic gearboxes, Oils for
automatic transmissions (automatic), Oils forautomotive torque converters, Oils for
passengerautomobiles, Oils fortrucks and heavy machinery.
Attock Petroleum limited, Ltd. Address: 6, Faisal Avenue, F-7/1, Islamabad,
Pakistan http://1959.pk.all-biz.info
Applying Probability to Impro e Business Performance Helping
Company to Look Forward
Today,enterprise softwareprofessionals continue to mull overwhat capabilities they
canadd to theirproducts both to createmore value fortheircustomers and to identify
unique differentiators that allow them to compete more effectively versus their
competition.
IfThe Graduate was recreated inthe year2009and the workingprofessional had deep
experience inenterprise softwareapplications to help improve business performance,
it is likely thatthe one word that would haveagreat future would beprobability.
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
26/29
Probability & their application in Business
26
Theapplication ofprobabilistic models to helpaddress business problems is nothing
new, but the breadth of understanding of these models, and the ability fornon-
mathematicians to apply them to help tune both financial and operationalperformance, is coming ofage.
ProfessorJames Smith ofDuke Universitys Fuqua School of Business says, From
anacademic perspective,predictivemodels haveadvanced both interms ofaccuracy
and flexibility, and these technologies can now be applied to a wide variety of
business forecastingproblems. It is clearthatthesetechnologies havethepotentialto
haveatremendous impact on day-to-day financialand operational decisionmaking.
Severalperformancemanagement vendors have been touting theapplication of this
type of mathematics in their applications with varying degrees of success. In its
simplest form,predictiveanalytics provideaplatform fora business userto help him
feed historical informationand key business drivers into a financial model and use
thatmodelto help definearange of futureperformance with aprobabilistic degree of
certainty.
Although notthe crystal ballthatmany execs would dreamto have,this approach has
significantadvantages over the traditionalreview of historic financials and applying
x% growth when considering future business forecasts and budgets.
On an operational level, companies are applying this type of analytics in both the
sales and marketing department, as well as with human resources. In the cellular
communications and credit industries, customer churn has always beena topic that
executives recognizeas the driverforsuccess.
The companies that could better identify potential customers who were consideringdefecting to a competitor could have the opportunity to take steps to ward off that
defection. Several banks and cellphone carriers apply sophisticated models to help
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
27/29
Probability & their application in Business
27
identify early signals of waning customer satisfaction or cost sensitivity and take
proactive steps to retainthose clients.
Forward-thinking human resource departments are also using these predictive
capabilities to identify valuableemployees who may beatrisk. Assumingthere is aninterest inretainingan atrisk employee,managers cantakeproactive steps interms
ofenhanced communications, compensationand/orpromotionto helpassurethatthe
employee stays focused onthe jobat hand.
In summary,predictive capabilities continue to evolve, and there are technologies
now available that do not require an advanced degree in mathematics to apply to
pressing business issues. For companies that are ready to proactively embrace this
next stage ofperformance management, they will likely find themselves with an
advantage over their competitors who rely on the more traditional approach to
financialand operationalplanning.
y The HR Manager of the company is responsible for market trend analysis,services developmentand technology vendorrelationships atthe company,the
leading independent authority on business performance management (BPM)
solutions.
y Prior to BPM Partners, John was Senior Director, Product Marketing atHyperion Software, responsible for directing Hyperion's OLAP Business
Analysis financial softwareproducts.
y Earlier in his career, John was an end user of performance managementsolutions while aproduct manager atRaychem Corporation, a Fortune 500
company that has since beenacquired by TycoHRManagerhas contributed to
many publications including the New York Times, BPM Magazine,
Information Week, Business Financeand eWeek,and he is aregularpresenter
atperformancemanagementrelated conferences and web seminars.
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
28/29
8/7/2019 FINALprob[1]
29/29
Probabilit
& t eir appli ation inB siness
RE ERENCES
y Aumann, R. J. & S. Hart. (1994) Handbook of Game Theory with EconomicApplications. Amsterdam: North- Holland.
y Axelrod, R. (1984) The Evolution ofCooperation. New York:Basic Books.Baird, D. G., GertnerR. H. & Picker, R. C. (1994) Game Theory and the Law.
Cambridge Mass.: Harvard University Press.
y Bandura, A. (1977) Social Learning Theory. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall.Carroll, J. S. & Johnson, E. J. (1990) Decision Research: A Field Guide.
(Applied SocialResearch Methods Series: Volume 22).
y Joyce, J. M (1999) The Foundations ofCausal Decision Theory. CambridgeStudies in Probability, Induction, and Decision Theory. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
y Lawson, S. & Glowa, T. (2000) Discrete Choice Experiments and TraditionalConjoint Analysis. Quirks Marketing