Finding Quality:Finding Quality:Getting a 2Getting a 2ndnd Opinion Opinion
(or (or How To Use the S&P Quality How To Use the S&P Quality Ranking)Ranking)
By Kevin GilloglyBy Kevin Gillogly
For Happy Destiny Investment For Happy Destiny Investment ClubClub
July 2005July 2005
22
Measuring Managerial Measuring Managerial AbilityAbility
– – Benjamin Graham and David DoddBenjamin Graham and David DoddSecurity AnalysisSecurity Analysis
“A statement of actual earnings, over a period of years, with a reasonable expectation of that these will be approximated in the future. The record must cover a number of years, first because a continued or repeat performance is always more impressive than a single occurrence, and secondly because the average of a fairly long period will tend to absorb and equalize, the distorting influences of the business cycle.”
33
What is Quality?What is Quality?
As long-term investors, we look for As long-term investors, we look for quality growth companiesquality growth companies
What does quality looks like?What does quality looks like? On the SSG it is consistency of Sales, On the SSG it is consistency of Sales,
Pre-Tax Profit (PTP) margins, and EPSPre-Tax Profit (PTP) margins, and EPS Is it well managed?Is it well managed?
On the SSG it is the trends on the On the SSG it is the trends on the graph and in Sec. 2 (Evaluating graph and in Sec. 2 (Evaluating Management)Management)
Want a 2Want a 2ndnd opinion? opinion? Where do you turn?Where do you turn?
44
Finding QualityFinding QualityMyriad ways to find quality without doing a Myriad ways to find quality without doing a
SSG. Not one is perfect. All have some SSG. Not one is perfect. All have some limitations.limitations.
The Stock Check List The Stock Check List SSG on training wheelsSSG on training wheels Looks at a sample of the past 7 yearsLooks at a sample of the past 7 years Quick cut; “Quick cut; “Wrong” years can lead to Wrong” years can lead to
misinterpretationmisinterpretation Take Stock softwareTake Stock software
Shows the Better Investing concepts in 4 clicksShows the Better Investing concepts in 4 clicks Goes through quality points found on the SSGGoes through quality points found on the SSG Can be conservative; Can miss some good Can be conservative; Can miss some good
choiceschoices
55
Other Forms of QualityOther Forms of QualityNon Better Investing forms:Non Better Investing forms: Kausch Meisheri’s Quick AnalysisKausch Meisheri’s Quick Analysis
Looks at the trends of the past 10 years Looks at the trends of the past 10 years worth of Value Line (VL) dataworth of Value Line (VL) data
Quick cut; but can’t tell if the price is rightQuick cut; but can’t tell if the price is right Mark Robertson’s 60 Second Equity Mark Robertson’s 60 Second Equity
AnalysisAnalysis Also uses VL dataAlso uses VL data A Quality Ranking that can be compared A Quality Ranking that can be compared
across industries and uses projections in the across industries and uses projections in the calculationscalculations
66
How Strong Are These How Strong Are These Companies?Companies?
Most of the previous metrics look at Most of the previous metrics look at sales, EPS and margins. sales, EPS and margins. What about financial stability? What about financial stability? How strong is management? How strong is management? Can a company survive a financial hit?Can a company survive a financial hit? Where do we turn?Where do we turn?
metric n., a system of measurement
77
Looking For Independent^ Looking For Independent^ Quality Ratings*Quality Ratings*Sources:Sources:
Morningstar Stock InvestorMorningstar Stock Investor Newest on blockNewest on block Uses “Stewardship” grade & Star RatingUses “Stewardship” grade & Star Rating
Value LineValue Line Peter Lynch “like hiring your own analyst”Peter Lynch “like hiring your own analyst” Financial Strength & Earnings Financial Strength & Earnings
PredictabilityPredictability Standard & Poor’s Standard & Poor’s
Used by founders of Better Investing Used by founders of Better Investing Quality RankingQuality Ranking
^ = reputable w/ no brokerage business* = no price component
88
S&P Quality RankingS&P Quality Ranking Formally known as S&P Earnings and Formally known as S&P Earnings and
Dividend RankingDividend Ranking Proprietary measure started in 1956Proprietary measure started in 1956 Attempts to measure Graham & Attempts to measure Graham &
Dodd’s sustainable earnings powerDodd’s sustainable earnings power See quote on page 2See quote on page 2
Measures long-term growth and Measures long-term growth and stability of earnings and dividends.stability of earnings and dividends. Focus is on the last 10 years worth of Focus is on the last 10 years worth of
datadata Covers over 3,500 US based Covers over 3,500 US based
companiescompanies
99
Why Use It?Why Use It?According to back-testing by S&P when According to back-testing by S&P when
compared to lower ranked companies, compared to lower ranked companies, high quality rankings have:high quality rankings have:
Less risk;Less risk; Lower debt levels, higher profit margins Lower debt levels, higher profit margins
and higher return on equity;and higher return on equity; Less likely to engage in accounting Less likely to engage in accounting
manipulations;manipulations;AndAnd Outperformed the S&P 500 indexOutperformed the S&P 500 index
1010
How To Use ItHow To Use It
Simple and quick way to determine if Simple and quick way to determine if company is worth studyingcompany is worth studying Screening ShorthandScreening Shorthand
Simple and quick way to determine if Simple and quick way to determine if company is worth keepingcompany is worth keeping Portfolio Management ShorthandPortfolio Management Shorthand
Uses letter gradesUses letter grades 8 in total8 in total
Remember to do your own research!
1111
Where To Find ItWhere To Find It
Two places:Two places: S&P Company Report (aka S&P Company Report (aka
“tearsheet”)“tearsheet”) On-line Premium Service (OPS)On-line Premium Service (OPS)
Can drop straight into Toolkit (TK5), Can drop straight into Toolkit (TK5), Stock Analyst (SA 3.1), and Stock Analyst (SA 3.1), and Prospector (NSP 2.6)Prospector (NSP 2.6)
Not available in Classic (NCP 2.3)Not available in Classic (NCP 2.3) Can also be used in MS ExcelCan also be used in MS Excel
1212
S&P “Tearsheet” For Most S&P “Tearsheet” For Most CompaniesCompanies
1313
S&P “Tearsheet” For Smaller S&P “Tearsheet” For Smaller CompaniesCompanies
1414
S&P Quality in Stock AnalystS&P Quality in Stock Analyst
1515
S&P Quality in Toolkit 5S&P Quality in Toolkit 5
1616
Translating the Grades *Translating the Grades * A+A+ Highest Highest ( 2%; 81 ( 2%; 81
companies)companies) AA High High ( 6%; 204)( 6%; 204) A-A- Above Ave. Above Ave. ( 6%; 233)( 6%; 233) B+B+ Average Average (16%; 576)(16%; 576) BB Below Ave. Below Ave. (19%; 702)(19%; 702) B-B- Lower Lower (26%; 966)(26%; 966) CC Lowest Lowest (24%; 872)(24%; 872) DD In reorg. In reorg. ( 1%; 36)( 1%; 36) LIQ LiquidationLIQ Liquidation NRNR Not Ranked Not Ranked (3670 companies)(3670 companies)
* Source: OPS 3705 cos. w/ Quality Rank Jun 05
1717
Translating into NSP *Translating into NSP * A+A+ Highest Highest 88 AA High High 77 A-A- Above Ave. Above Ave. 66 B+B+ Average Average 55 BB Below Ave. Below Ave. 44 B-B- Lower Lower 33 CC Lowest Lowest 22 DD In reorg. In reorg.
11 NRNR Not Ranked Not Ranked 00
* NAIC Stock Prospector
1818
S&P Quality as a Cross CheckS&P Quality as a Cross Check
Can Be FoundCan Be Found In screening of In screening of
ProspectorProspector
1919
S&P Quality as a Cross CheckS&P Quality as a Cross Check
Can Be FoundCan Be Found In the Portfolio In the Portfolio
Portion of Stock Portion of Stock AnalystAnalyst
2020
Benefit of S&P Quality Benefit of S&P Quality RatingRating
Combines some key Combines some key aspects of the SSGaspects of the SSG
Growth and Growth and stability of stability of earningsearnings
Growth and Growth and stability of stability of dividendsdividends
2121
Limitations of S&P Quality Limitations of S&P Quality RatingRating
Misses key aspects of the SSGMisses key aspects of the SSG No forecast of future Sales No forecast of future Sales
& EPS growth rates& EPS growth rates Does not help determine Does not help determine
future valuefuture value
Misses key aspects of the SCGMisses key aspects of the SCG Measuring to its peersMeasuring to its peers Measuring the better returnMeasuring the better return
2222
From Quality to From Quality to PerformancePerformance
Top Return to Risk Was Top Return to Risk Was NotNot Found in Found in stocks with the highest ranking, “A+”stocks with the highest ranking, “A+”
Two notches below, “A-”, preformed best.Two notches below, “A-”, preformed best. Price Premium of top rankingPrice Premium of top ranking
That’s still leaves over That’s still leaves over 200 companies (with 200 companies (with a ranking of A-) to a ranking of A-) to examine that could be examine that could be potential purchasespotential purchases
2323
Quality to Quality to PerformancePerformance
S&P Quality Ranking will S&P Quality Ranking will notnot help finding help finding undiscovered “gems” of the stock market:undiscovered “gems” of the stock market:
Penalizes companies not paying a dividendPenalizes companies not paying a dividend Highest they earn is a “A-”Highest they earn is a “A-”
Also favors companies paying a dividendAlso favors companies paying a dividend Lowest they earn is a “B-”Lowest they earn is a “B-”
Penalizes young small companiesPenalizes young small companies Good companies > 10 years may Good companies > 10 years may notnot be ranked be ranked
No ranking of foreign companiesNo ranking of foreign companies Used only on US based companiesUsed only on US based companies
2424
Final ThoughtsFinal ThoughtsS&P Quality Ranking has …S&P Quality Ranking has … No price componentNo price component
Therefore no “buy” or “sell” aspect as Therefore no “buy” or “sell” aspect as found in other S&P proprietary found in other S&P proprietary measures (STAR & Fair Value/Outlook)measures (STAR & Fair Value/Outlook)
No projected return No projected return As in Sec. 5c of the SSGAs in Sec. 5c of the SSG
Which is our reason for studying Which is our reason for studying stocksstocks
Use as your starting pointUse as your starting point First cutFirst cut Remember it’s limitationsRemember it’s limitations
2525
Final ThoughtsFinal ThoughtsUse the S&P Quality Ranking …Use the S&P Quality Ranking … Like a pilot use your instrumentsLike a pilot use your instruments
Several different gauges to tell the Several different gauges to tell the same thing same thing
Use in conjunction with other metricsUse in conjunction with other metrics VL Financial StrengthVL Financial Strength Quick AnalysisQuick Analysis 60 Second Equity Analysis60 Second Equity Analysis It is ok to have overlapIt is ok to have overlap
Cross-check your work on the SSGCross-check your work on the SSG The visual analysisThe visual analysis Evaluating ManagementEvaluating Management
2626
What We LearnedWhat We Learned
The Value of a simple The Value of a simple quality metricquality metric
How To Eliminate Stocks How To Eliminate Stocks Before Doing a SSGBefore Doing a SSG
How To Monitor Existing How To Monitor Existing StocksStocks
Another use for OPSAnother use for OPS Another Benefit of using Another Benefit of using
NAIC SoftwareNAIC Software
2727
Questions?Questions?
2828
Further ReadingFurther Reading Brain Lewis articlesBrain Lewis articles
Sept. 04 Better Investing (BI)Sept. 04 Better Investing (BI) Aug. 04 BITS (expanded article)Aug. 04 BITS (expanded article)
ICL list (NAIC Chat room – free to ICL list (NAIC Chat room – free to anyone)anyone) August 12 to 23, 2004August 12 to 23, 2004
www.standardandpoors.comwww.standardandpoors.com Equity Research (near top)Equity Research (near top) Analytical Methodology (left side)Analytical Methodology (left side)