8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

1/31

OONO A ANALI

   

TORONTO

STAR ANALYSIS: 4/23/2015 CAS / CROWN WARD DATA

This document shares the findings of a Toronto Star analysis

of 4th Quarter Reports (2008/09 – 2012/13) and Crown

Ward Reviews (2013) for Ontario Children’s Aid Societies.

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

2/31

OONO A ANALI

   

TORONTO STAR ANALYSIS:C A S / C R O W N W A R D D A T A

SUMMARY

M C

. (2008/9 2012/13)

.

I ,

.

. O A C A

,

.

OACA,

.

A OACA,

..

A : D , 0 5

. . A,

, .

, O

hildren's aid society (CAS)  . A A , . M, 30 , ,

2013. N M , ,

18 . I C A 11

7 D C F , .

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

3/31

OONO A ANALI

   

L,

; .

, .

F ,

J CA 33

; , 2 .

,

, . I CA

.

.

I C , CA ( 8 J/H B;

3 ), (13 ; 3.6

). B , CA 100

C ; BGC, 65 .

.

(AD)

. CA

. B , CA

. .

.

5/ 5 CA , , O .

.

C, L M J

A B H N. I

, J 4168694431,  @..

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

4/31

OONO A ANALI

   

SECTION I: QUARTERLY REPORTS

1) KINSHIP AND CUSTOMARY CARE:

, 2008/2009

2012/2013. I ,

( .. C . ) C C,

A .

L , ,

( ) . .

, . (A

. E,

.) K

.

TABLE 1: KINSHIP AND CUSTOMARY CARE

CA

F I. 68.1% 1

C F I. 64.6% 2

A A F 54.8% 3

D A F C 35.0% 4

CK I C' 31.3% 5

N C F 15.6% 39

F, C M 15.2% 40

H C A 15.1% 41

C C' A 13.8% 42

J F C G 12.0% 43

C' A 11.6% 44

C E C' A 9.4% 45

D C F 6.5% 46

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

5/31

OONO A ANALI

   

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

6/31

OONO A ANALI

   

2) GROUP HOME CARE . I

/ .

.

D , J CA G 33.2

, C CA 21.9 . 2

CA.

20

. N 10

.

TABLE 2: GROUP HOME CARE

CA

J F C G 33.2% 1

: J H B F 27.2% 2

C C' A 21.9% 3

CA M 21.1% 4

E C' A 20.5% 5

C' A C C L I. 20.4% 6

CA C G& C 5.4% 41C' A B 5.4% 42

D A F C 4.6% 43

C' A HN 4.6% 44

F I. 4.5% 45

C A 1.9% 46

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

7/31

OONO A ANALI

   

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

8/31

OONO A ANALI

   

3) ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION (ADR)

, / .

AD

. AD . AD .

F , B, 11 , AD. 

O, . F N

. B, E, B ,

.

, O, , 6

.

TABLE 3: ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION

CA

C

AD

C' A D B 11:1 1

C E C' A 15:1 2

F & C' C 18:1 3

C' A B 20:1 4

K H C' A 22:1 5

C' A A 22:1 6

55F C' L, L G 205:1 37

09 C' A D 220:1 38

14H C' A 404:1 39

52E C' A 792:1 40

01A A F N/A

08D C F N/A

33: J H B F N/A

44 C F I. N/A50 F I. N/A

51CA C G & C N/A

N/A EO AD

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

9/31

OONO A ANALI

   

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

10/31

OONO A ANALI

   

4) NEW PROTECTION APPLICATIONS , ,

. . ,

.

TABLE 4: NEW PROTECTION APPLICATIONS

CA

F & C' C 55.2% 1

C' A D N 41.3% 2

F C F, L A 34.7% 3

CA L M 27.0% 4

CA C . C E 26.5% 5C' A O 25.8% 6

C' A 7.0% 41

D A F C 5.9% 42

H C' A 5.5% 43

A A F 5.4% 44

C F I. 0.1% 45

F I. 0.0% 46

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

11/31

OONO A ANALI

   

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

12/31

OONO A ANALI

   

5) INVESTIGATIONS CA . I

, .

5a) Investigations – Completed versus Ongoing 

, .

,

.

.

D, G J, H . A ,

, HN, N E F N

.

TABLE 5A: INVESTIGATIONS - COMPLETED VS ONGOING

CA CO

C F 7.2:1 1

H C' A 6.5:1 2

J F C G 6:1 3

C' A D 6:1 4

D C F 5.8:1 5

4.3:1N E O F C 3:1 41

C' A HN 2.9:1 42

A A F 2.9:1 43

C A 2.8:1 44

C F I. 2.2:1 45

F I. 2.2:1 46

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

13/31

OONO A ANALI

   

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

14/31

OONO A ANALI

   

5b) Investigations – Cases Reopened 

. , .

CA , , C, D,

O, .

G J CA 16

. F N A

.

M .

TABLE 5B: INVESTIGATIONS - CASES REOPENED

CA O

J F C G 16:1 1

C F I. 7:1 2

A A F 6.9:1 3

K D C F 5.4:1 4

F I. 5.3:1 5

C' A 5.2:1 6

C' A 0.9:1 37

H C A 0.9:1 38

C C' A 0.9:1 39

K H C' A 0.9:1 40

C' A A 0.8:1 41

C' A O 0.8:1 42

C' A D 0.7:1 43

CA M 0.6:1 44

C' A D B 0.6:1 45

C' A D M 0.5:1 46

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

15/31

OONO A ANALI

   

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

16/31

OONO A ANALI

   

6) CROWN WARDS WITH AND WITHOUT PARENTAL ACCESS C , C

, CA . ,

. , .

I D, C 8 1. I CK

G/ CA O, 1 1. I CA ,

2 1 . I C CA, C CA

C .

TABLE 6: RATIO OF CROWN WARDS WITH PARENTAL ACCESS TO THOSE WITHOUT

CA A:NA

F I. A 1

C F I. 61:1 2

AA F 57:1 3

C' A D 8:1 4

H C' A 5:1 5

F C' L, L G 5:1 6

C' A O 1.0:1 43

CK I C' 0.98:1 44

N C F 0.95:1 45

CA C G & C 0.94:1 46

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

17/31

OONO A ANALI

   

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

18/31

OONO A ANALI

   

SECTION II: CROWN WARD REVIEWS

C CA 2009

2013. 2012, .

CA 2013 .

.

1) AVERAGE NUMBER OF PLACEMENTS PER CHILD/YOUTH SINCEMOST RECENT ADMISSION 2.6 8.6 J & H

B. A 6.6, E, N E

5 .

TABLE CW1: AVERAGE NUMBER OF PLACEMENTS

CA

A

/

EEL 2.6 1

KENOA AIN IE 2.8 2

ENFE 2.9 3

NAIE 3.0 4

HNDE BA 3.0 4

ALOI ECO 5.5 41

ELGIN 5.6 42

NOH EAEN 5.7 43

IKINAGAN 6.6 44

JAME AND HDON BA 8.6 45

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

19/31

OONO A ANALI

   

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

20/31

OONO A ANALI

   

2) AVERAGE NUMBER OF CASEWORKERS SINCE CHILD’S ADMISSIONTO CARE 2.7 CA 12.8 CA.

CA .

TABLE CW2: AVERAGE NUMBER OF CASEWORKERS

CA

A

'

EECHIIEIN 2.7 1

NAIE CHILD (OONO) 3.2 2

ANIA LAMBON 3.6 3

ELLINGON 3.6 3

DHAM 3.7 5

IMCOE 3.7 5

BCE GE 7.1 41

DFFEIN 7.3 42

ANIHINAABE ABINOOJII 7.6 43

JAME AND HDON BA 8.2 44

IKINAGAN 12.8 45

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

21/31

OONO A ANALI

   

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

22/31

OONO A ANALI

   

3) AAR/ONLAC USED TO DEVELOP PLANS OF CAREA CA . B

G 21.8 , 36.8 , E 40 .

CA 50 , .

O CA A, H 100 .

TABLE CW3: PERCENTAGE OF PLANS USING AAR/ONLAC

CA

AA/ONLAC

ALGOMA 100.0% 1

HALON 100.0% 1

EECHIIEIN 100.0% 1

ALOI ECO 95.5% 4

NIAGAA 91.7% 5

CHAHAM KEN 91.1% 6

64.8%

ENFE 44.9% 39

MKOKA 44.4% 40

ELLINGON 44.4% 40

ELGIN 40.0% 42

JAME AND HDON BA 38.2% 43

IMCOE 36.8% 44

BCE GE 21.8% 45

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

23/31

OONO A ANALI

   

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

24/31

OONO A ANALI

   

4) ANNUAL MEDICALO CA 100 C

. B G 65 .

TABLE CW4: PERCENTAGE OF CROWN WARDS THAT RECEIVE ANNUAL MEDICALS

CA

A

DFFEIN 100.00% 1

HALON 100.00% 1

JAME AND HDON BA 100.00% 1

MKOKA 100.00% 1

ALOI ECO 100.00% 1

EECHIIEIN 100.00% 1

HAMILON ENOH CCA 86.30% 41

ENFE 85.70% 42

HIGHLAND HOE 85.40% 43

ANIHINAABE ABINOOJII 81.60% 44

BCE GE 65.50% 45

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

25/31

OONO A ANALI

   

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

26/31

OONO A ANALI

   

5) ANNUAL DENTALO CA 100 C

. 56.6 , B G 69 .

CA 70 80 .

TABLE CW5: PERCENTAGE OF CROWN WARDS THAT RECEIVE ANNUAL DENTAL CARE

CA A

ALGOMA 100.00% 1

ELGIN 100.00% 1

JEIH FAMIL 100.00% 1

MKOKA 100.00% 1

EECHIIEIN 100.00% 1

LONDON 74.10% 41

DILICO ANIHINABEK 73.90% 42

DFFEIN 72.70% 43

BCE GE 69.10% 44

IKINAGAN 56.60% 45

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

27/31

OONO A ANALI

   

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

28/31

OONO A ANALI

   

6) AVERAGE NUMBER OF FACE-TO-FACE CONTACTS IN PAST 12MONTHS 23 A 6 . CA

.

TABLE CW6: AVERAGE NUMBER OF FACE-TO-FACE CONTACTS

CA

A

12

ALGOMA 23.5 1

NOH EAEN 19.4 2

NIAGAA 16.6 3

LANAK LEED AND GENILLE 15.0 4

FONENAC KINGON ADDINGON 14.7 5

KAAHA HALIBON 14.7 5

MKOKA 9.9 40

JAME AND HDON BA 9.8 41

ENFE 9.5 42

NAIE 8.8 43

NIIING A OND 8.3 44

EECHIIEIN 5.9 45

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

29/31

OONO A ANALI

   

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

30/31

OONO A ANALI

   

7) OVERALL COMPLIANCE C . CA 13

100 ( 100

) (

75 99 ) .

TABLE CW7: OVERALL COMPLIANCE

CA % F % H

%

=F & H

C

ALGOMA 68.4% 31.6% 100.0% 1

ELGIN 81.2% 18.8% 100.0% 1

HALON 68.4% 31.6% 100.0% 1

HAMILON ENOH 45.5% 54.5% 100.0% 1

HON EH 57.9% 42.1% 100.0% 1

JAME AND HDON BA 42.1% 57.9% 100.0% 1

MKOKA 68.8% 31.2% 100.0% 1

NIAGAA 47.6% 52.4% 100.0% 1

OAA 33.3% 66.7% 100.0% 1

OMON DNDA & GLENGA 33.3% 66.7% 100.0% 1

OONO CA 36.4% 63.6% 100.0% 1

AELOO 16.7% 83.3% 100.0% 1

OK 45.0% 55.0% 100.0% 1

HAMILON ENOH CCA 30.0% 40.0% 70.0% 40

ANIA LAMBON 30.0% 40.0% 70.0% 40

IKINAGAN 21.1% 47.4% 68.5% 42

DB MANIOLIN 16.7% 50.0% 66.7% 43

EEL 22.2% 44.4% 66.6% 44

BCE GE 20.0% 40.0% 60.0% 45

8/9/2019 Findings Package for CAS

31/31

OONO A ANALI