7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

1/41

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

2/41

June

2,

2010

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

3/41

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

4/41

Fitzgerald

Marine

Reserve

Oct.

18,

2012

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

5/41

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

6/41

1/4miletrail Oct. 18,2012

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

7/41

June

2,

2010

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

8/41

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

9/41

June

2,

2010

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

10/41

ConstructioncouldhavebeenrestrictedtouseofaBobcatorothersmallequipmentinthebid

packageandCountyParksplannerscouldhave

reducedtheareatobedisturbedwhentheCounty

PlanningCommissionreducedthetrailwidth.Instead

Parks

contracted

with

a

local

paving

companythatoperatesheavyroadgrading/

pavingequipmenttodevelopthetrail/bridge.

FitzgeraldMarineReserve

DardenelleTrailProject

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

11/41

Oct.

18,

2012

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

12/41

June

2,

2010

3-4wide

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

13/41

Oct.

18,

2012

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

14/41

Theextensivegradingmobilizationbegan

thisfall,thetimingpairedupperfectlywith

therainyseason,andleftmassiveareasof

exposed

soil

to

wash

into

San

Vicente

Creek.Thisalreadyimpairedcreekshouldbeprotectedfrominappropriatelytimed

grading

projects.

Whyweren'tseasonalweatherconditionsfactoredintotheconstructionschedule?

FitzgeraldMarineReserve

DardenelleTrailProject

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

15/41

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

16/41

June

2,

2010

Theproximityofthepondtothetrail

wasnotconsideredbytheCounty,

andthereforenotconsideredbythe

Commissionstafeither.

DardenelleTrail

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

17/41

TheFitzgeraldMarineReserveishome

totheCaliforniaRed-leggedFrog

Oct

31,

2012

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

18/41

During

grading

a

California

Red-legged

frog

was

identifiedattheFMR. Itappearsthatendangeredwildlifemayhavebeendisplacedbythefrogandsnake

exclusion

fencing

along

the

perimeter

oftheDardenelleTrailconstructionzone. The

fencingisstillinplacealthoughworkonthe

projecthasstopped.

WrittenconcernsabouttheCRLFhavebeen

emailedtotheCounty. To-datenoreplyhas

beenprovided.

FitzgeraldMarineReserve

DardenelleTrailProject

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

19/41

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

20/41

June

2,

2010

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

21/41

Theextensivegradingmobilizationbegan

thisfall,thetimingpairedupperfectlywith

therainyseason,andleftmassiveareasof

exposed

soil

to

wash

into

San

Vicente

Creek.Thisalreadyimpairedcreekshouldbeprotectedfrominappropriatelytimed

grading

projects.

Whyweren'tseasonalweatherconditionsfactoredintotheconstructionschedule?

FitzgeraldMarineReserve

DardenelleTrailProject

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

22/41

Oct.

18,

2012

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

23/41

June

2,

2010

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

24/41

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

25/41

DARDENELLE

FITZGERALDMARINERESERVE

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

26/41

June

2,

20103-4

wide

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

27/41

Oct.

18,

2012

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

28/41

Oct.

25,

2012

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

29/41

Nov.

25,

2012

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

30/41

Dec.

2,

2012Failed

exclusion

netting

and

erosion

fencing.

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

31/41

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

32/41

Dec.

2,

2012

Failedexclusionnettinganderosionfencing.

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

33/41

TheDardenelleTrail/Bridgeprojectplansdidnot

adequatelyaddresshydrology,andthesegmentof

theDardenelleTrailthatcrossestheseasonalcreek(nearthebridge)willcontinuetohaveerosionproblems. Thephotosoffailederosionfencing

documentrunofcarryingdebrisintothecreek.

Writtenconcernsaboutrainyseasongrading,

seasonalcreekrunof,andhydrologyhavebeenemailedtotheCounty.

FitzgeraldMarineReserve

DardenelleTrailProject

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

34/41

SanMateoCountyProjectPlans

DrainageisnotdiscussedinExhibit

No.

2,

detail

3

of

the

DardenelleTrailProjectPlans(page8of8)

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

35/41

Dec.

2,

2012

Failedexclusionnetting

anderosionfencing.

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

36/41

Failedexclusionnettinganderosionfencing.

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

37/41

Followingrecentwinterstormsthetide-poolareaonthenorthsideandadjacenttothe

mouthofSanVicenteCreekhadextremelymurkydarkbrownturbidwater,thatlookstobeinveryfinesuspension(claysize,finerthan

sand/silt).

WhydidSanMateoCountyParksplanners

allowcontractorstoleavethesiteunfinished

forweeksfollowingtheinitialmobilization?

FitzgeraldMarineReserve

DardenelleTrailProject

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

38/41

Oct.

25,

2012San

Vicente

Creek

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

39/41

Dec.

2,

2012San

Vicente

Creek

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

40/41

The2002FitzgeraldMarineReserveMasterPlan

recognizedthearea'srichnaturalresources

throughitsguidingprinciples:

"Thefundamentalconceptunderlyingthe

MasterPlanisthatprotectionofthe

outstandingnaturalresourcesoftheFitzgerald

MarineReserve

will

require

a

new

approach

to

managementofecologicalsystemsandvisitors

infutureyears,andthebestwaytoaccomplish

thisgoalistoemphasizethesensitivityofthe

resource,toenhancetheeducationalvalueof

theReserve,tomanagevisitation,andtolimit

useoftheReserveasarecreationdestination."

7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail

41/41

Thankyou

www.PelicansEye.comSabrinaBrennan

Dec. 13,2012

AppealA-2-SMC-11-010

http://www.pelicanseye.com/http://www.pelicanseye.com/http://www.pelicanseye.com/http://www.pelicanseye.com/http://www.pelicanseye.com/http://www.pelicanseye.com/http://www.pelicanseye.com/http://www.pelicanseye.com/http://www.pelicanseye.com/http://www.pelicanseye.com/