Confidential
FORD WINDSTARCASE ANALYSIS
PREPARED BY:
FAIZATUL AMRAH
AISHAH
WAN HAMIZA
WAN HAZIRA
Confidential
SUMMARY
Minivan history and development
Minivans designed for families, for people with two or more children and who were tired of cramming into sedans for long and short-hour trips.
Minivan is divided into 2 categories: LWB and SWB.
It was first introduced by Dodge Caravan on 1983 and then followed by General Motors and Ford.
Confidential
SUMMARY
Ford Windstar
o Ford Windstar was introduced in Canada in 1991.
o Windstar was the first to be given 5 stars rating by NHTSA
o Windstar is way back behind when it comes to introducing product innovations.
sliding fourth door
flip-fold seat
o Quality problems and product recall.
o Limited choice
Confidential
Ford Windstar
Confidential
Pontiac Montana
Honda Odyssey
Chevrolet Venture
Grand Caravan
Toyota Previa
Confidential
SUMMARY
Below Table 1 show % of market share in LWB
segment in 1999 and 2001
1999 2001
Windstar 44% 30%
Pontiac Montana 9% 14%
Grand Cadavan 19% 27.4%
Honda 3.3% 11%
Confidential
Highlight of the case
Confidential
Question 1:Assess the various promotional tactics available to Brian. Which one(s) make financial sense. Why?
Ford Windstar
Confidential
Brian Tafler had considered the followings:-
• Direct Mail Campaign• Repositioning Through Advertising
• Value Pricing• Sales Incentives
• Leasing• Cash Offers
Confidential
Direct Mail Campaign
Lease Renewal Customers
• Targeted to about 5000 customers
• Highlighted the new features i.e Safety System and Family Entertainment System
• Current Lease renewal Rate : 40%
• Expected : 45 to 50% returning lease customers
• Offered: $500 loyalty discount
Confidential
Direct Mail Campaign (cont..)
Potential New Customer
• Focus – the customer who leased a minivan from other manufacturer
• Offered - $500 switching incentive
• Expected – 2 to 3% customer switched to Ford
Confidential
Repositioning Through Advertisement
Tier 1
• Manufacturer paid and control the advertising
• Focused- Building brand image
• Impact- can be seen after few years
Tier 2
• The dealer and manufacturer associates for the advertising
• Focused- promoting particular brands within region and for short time.
Tier 3
• The dealer paid for the advertising
• Focused- To attract customers with price,
promotion and incentives
Confidential
Repositioning Through Advertisement (cont)
Shortcoming of Tier1, 2 and 3• Manufacturer focused on building brands,
dealers interested in immediate sales• Cost of advertising/promotion of minivan
increased i.e 10% since 1998• Advertisement spending in Tier 1 and 2.• Tier 2- Price of LX model to fight the SWB
market
• Brian need to target customers by price oriented strategy or by image advertising.
Confidential
Value Pricing
o Tier 1 Advertising
o Bundled attractive features
o No charge for Family Entertainment Systems worth $1500 in its Sport, SEL and Limited
o Rivals- offered the features for top-of-line models
o Improve the selling of vehicle mixed.
Confidential
Sales Incentives
To trigger sales
Benefits the buyer of subvented lease or financing rates, cash-backs and other discounts.
Incentives offered by domestic manufacturers were higher than imports.
Confidential
Leasing
• In 2002- 55% sales of Windstar in Canada were lease.
• Ford offered 24 to 36 months rates• Windstar offered 48 to 60 months rates• Rivals-GM & Chrysler offered 24, 36 and 48
months rate. Imports – none.• General Motor Acceptance and Ford Credit
provides attractive lease and financing options
• Interest rate charged to customers – 0 to 2%
Confidential
Leasing (cont)
• Longer lease- lower monthly outlay
• Shortcoming- customers will not be back almost 12 to 24 months.
• Customer satisfaction was lower after 3 or 4 years
• Benefits – sales mix would be larger proportion to lease.
Confidential
Cash Offers
Cash discount offered to buyer and salespersonCash $2000 on Windstar purchasedRed Carpet Lease Cash- $500 cash on Windstar leaseRenewal Offer - $1000 cash on returning leaseChristmas Bonus- $500 cash to purchase and lease in DecemberSales person incentive-$100 for every vehicle sold in 30 daysPeriod Golf Vacation- for top salesperson in each regionProduced- 2% of volume in next 3 months
Confidential
Financial Sense
Brian should considered :
• Repositioning Trough Advertisement by using structure Tier 2.
• Value pricing
• Leasing
• Cash Offers
Confidential
Repositioning Trough Advertisement by using structure Tier 2
Associated manufacturer and dealers, cost will be shared by them
Promoting Windstar and price promotionAttacking region by region and also
globally.
Confidential
Value Pricing
Create excitement by creating the value package
Also can be swap in Tier 2 advertising instead of Tier 1.
Improve sales mix
Confidential
Leasing
55 % Windstar in Canada were leases Offered longer lease rate . Up to 60
months Will lower customer monthly outlay Lower interest rate- 2% Sales mix will be larger in proportion
Confidential
Cash Offers
Cash discount to buyer/salesperson
Increased in volume in next 3 months
70% of non-leased vehicles were financed.
Each $1000- will produce additional 2% in volume.
Confidential
Ford Windstar
Question 2:
Assess the alternatives in terms of their attractiveness to target consumers and the effect on the Ford Windstar brand?
Confidential
Windstar and Safety
• SAFETY• Important element of the Windstar
5-star rating by NHTSA
Led the industry
Personal Safety System (PSS)
• Important consideration for families
Confidential
0.45
0.42
0.39
0.350.34
0.31
0.31
0.3
0.3
0.28
0.270.23
0.23
0.18
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5
Proud to own
Meets the needs of you and your family
Good value for money
Provide peace of mind
Dependable
Superior ride
One of the safest minivan
Full of innovative ideas
Power to keep you out of harm's way
Easy to convert for people or cargo
Are versatile
Distinctive styling
Drive like a car
Have luxurious interior finish
Att
rib
ute
s
Correlation score
Purchase Consideration14 Important Attributes*
*change over time
Confidential
Seating Capacity
Fuel Economy
OEM's Reputation
SafetyOverall Quality
Price / Deal
Value for Money
Reliability
Windstar 34% 25% 28%
Venture 23% 42% 30%
Montana 22% 29% 28%
Caravan 27% 28% 28%
Odyssey 39% 21% 50%
Sienna 33% 28% 44%
MPV 30% 30% 32%
Top 3 Reasons For Purchase
Confidential
Performance of WindstarNot Translated into Higher Market Share
Value for moneyWindstar – 40%
Leader’s score – 50%
Windstar performance is far behind the market leader in term of the price & value for money
Confidential
Performance of WindstarNot Translated into Higher Market Share
Leading: Lacking:
1. Proud to own
2. Meets the needs of you & your family
3. Provide peace of mind
4. Dependable
5. Superior ride
6. Safety7. Power to keep you out of harm’s
way
8. Versatile
9. Distinctive styling
10. Drive like a car
1. Value for money
2. Innovative Ideas3. Easy to convert for people or
cargo
4. Have luxurious interior finish
Confidential
Buying Process
Consideration Phase Image and brand perception
Active Shopping Phase Image and Features
Buying Phase Features and Price
Confidential
Consumer Behavior
• Definition:• The study on how individuals, groups, and
organizations select, buy, use, and dispose of goods, services, ideas, or experience to satisfy their needs and wants.
Confidential
Consumer BehaviorWhat Influences Consumer Behavior?
Cultural factorsSocial factors
Reference groups Family Roles and statuses
Personal Factors Age Occupation Personality Lifestyle
Confidential
Analyzing Consumer MarketsThe Aim of Marketing
Meet and satisfy target customer’s needs and wants
Understand important attributes in making purchase decision
Confidential
Minivan Buyers
Age Group 1998 2001
35 - 49 47% 40%
> 65 12% 19%
Confidential
Reasons of PurchasePrice / Deal / Value
Age Group 1998 2001
< 35 55% 57%
> 65 40% 43%
Confidential
Target Market vs PopulationDecline in The Minivan Sales
Population: 35-49 age group >> 65+
YEAR 1998
35-4947%
>6512%
Others41%
YEAR 2001
35-4940%
>6519%
Others41%
Confidential
Question 3:Develop a promotional plan for the Windstar to carry the brand to the introduction in the fall of 2003
Ford Windstar
Confidential
Brand
• Brand is name, sign, and symbol design to identify goods services of seller and differentiate from competitors.
• A brand is the marketers promise to deliver predictable product/service performance
• To create brand value convince the customer of meaningful differences among brands (related to attributes of product).
Confidential
Brand Asset Valuator (BAV)
• Provides comparative measures of the brand equity of thousands of brands across hundreds of different categories.
• Based (BAV), there are 4 components of brand equity • Differentiation –the degree to which a brand
is seen as different from others.
Confidential
Brand Asset Evaluator (BAV)
• Relevance -the breadth of a brand’s appeal.
• Esteem –how well the brand is regarded and respected.
• Knowledge –how familiar and intimate consumers are with the brand
Confidential
• Differentiation + Relevance = Brand Strength
(Point to brand’s future value, rather than reflecting its past)
• Esteem + Knowledge = Brand Stature(More to a ‘report card’ on past
performance)
Brand Asset Valuator (BAV)
Confidential
Components Windstar’s performance
Differentiation There are many newcomers entering
into the competition offering customers
various options.
LOW
Relevance Windstar is popular with safety
features but safety is not the most
important feature that customers seek
for.
LOW
Esteem Windstar is respected as it is a major player in minivan industry however, recently, it is regarded as a low quality minivan.
LOW
Knowledge High percentage of minivans buyers are aware with this brand since it is an old player in the industry.
HIGH
Confidential
Differentiation Relevance Esteem Knowledge
New Brands
Low Low Low Low
Strong New
Brands
High Low Low Low
Leadership High High High High
Declining Brands
Low Low Low High
Confidential
Brand Revitalization
• Changes in consumer tastes and preferences, the emergence of new competitors could affect the fortune of a brand.
• In Ford Windstar case have fallen on hard times because of emergence of various competitors.
• What Ford can do whether to retain the same positioning or to create a new positioning.
• Ford Windstar has to really understand what its sources of brand equity were
Confidential
What Windstar can do?
i) Expand depth, breadth of brand awareness by improving brand recall and recognition
in purchase or consumption.
ii) Improve strength, favourability and uniqueness of brand associations
Confidential
• Brand elements the devices that identify and differentiate brand.
Safety- one of the safest minivansValue- good value for money
• Brand Promise the marketer’s vision of what the brand must be and do for consumers.
Alert today: Alive tomorrow.
Confidential
Promotional Plan
• Objectives:i) Reverse a decline and put Windstar on the path to
regain market share and restoring its brand image.
ii) To carry Ford Windstar’s brand image as the safest minivan with good values
• promotional plan divisions:• public relations • advertising • direct marketing• Promotion & optional feature pricing
Confidential
Public Relation
• Public relations are very believable and seem more real to readers than ads do.
• The activities :• Media relation campaign on safety
• Auto show with concentrations on Alert today. Alive tomorrow
Confidential
Public Relation (contd)
• Publication, such as newsletters, trade journals and books about safety
• Public speaking and conference
• Sponsorship for special event/ sponsor to produce road safety advertisement.
• Organize fairs (eg: safety first fair)
Confidential
Advertising
• Advertising can reach masses of geographically dispersed buyers at a low cost per exposure
• Advertising is also very expressive as it allows the company to dramatize its products
Confidential
Advertising (contd)
• Tier 1 advertising which the manufacture paid for and controlled all the advertising.
• The advertising was focused on building brand image.
• The advertisements will be divided into various types:
• Broadcast on radio and TV• Outdoor advertising- billboards• Print in magazines and newspaper.
Confidential
Direct Marketing• A message that is normally directed to a specific person
• Direct mail to specific customers:
• lease renewal customers
• potential new customers
• customers who have road accident’s experience This is to approach road accident victims which we
assume to be more safety conscious.
• Send to potential customers:
Flyers
Newsletter
Posters
Brochure
Confidential
Value For Money
• Safety Insufficient
• Improve ‘value for money’ attribute
• Customer value product by• Features
• Quality
• Price
Confidential
Ford Windstar must…
1. Enhance the manufacturing process
2. Add new features for the new model
i) Offering various models of Windstar
Eg: LWB, SWB, limited edition, sports edition and etc.
ii) Offering new features• flip-fold back seat
• back-seat video entertainment system
• seatback grocery hooks added to rear bench
Confidential
Ford Windstar must…(contd)
2. Add new features for the new model (contd)
iii) Offering new safety features• low tyre pressure warning
• censors deployed the dashboard airbags according to crash severity and the front occupants
• A strobe light in the driver’s outside mirror to warn approaching traffic that the left-slide sliding door was open
• A rear- brake and reduced engine power to enhance control in turns
Confidential
Ford Windstar must…(contd)
3. Adopt optional feature pricing- offer optional products, features and services along with main product
i) Second-row bucket seats with a rear-seat video entertainment system
ii) Removable back-seat video entertainment system
iii) Extended warrantyiv) Electric window controlv) Light dimmers vi) Antiskid system (safety feature)
Confidential
Conclusion
• Ford Windstar should take more aggressive actions in order to regain its market share and improve their brand image.
• Ford should educate their customers on the importance of safety in a way to increase their favorability towards safety attribute
• Ford also should improve their quality problems and innovative features in order to compete with the emergence of wild competitors.
Confidential
THANK YOU!!
AMRA AISHAHHAZIRA
HAMIZA