7/31/2019 Fredrick Toben Reviews "Holocaust Denial and Operation Reinhard"

1/20

4

B}jg}nlf Wmjk ]jrnjy|?

SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

Mjhjl( \cmnmc}( W}jmhnkfd

Achcldz|w Gjkndh dkg Cuj}dwnck ]jnkad}g

D L}nwntzj cb waj Bdh|jaccg| cb @dwwcikc( I}db dkg Fzj|

D Achcldz|w Lckw}crj}|nj| Yanwj Uduj}( Bn}|w Jgnwnck Gjlj`mj} =544

awwu?##achcldz|wlckw}crj}|nj|+mhci|ucw+lc`

Ockdwadk Ad}}n|ck( ]cmj}wc @zjahjkfd`u( Od|ck @~j}|(

\j}ij~ ]c`dkcr( Knlachd| Wj}}~Jktzn}j| ldk mj gn}jlwjg wc tzj|wnck|+alEi`dnh+lc`

SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

U]CHCIZJ wc ]jrnjyWankf ck waj|j wanki| b}c`?

Mj}w}dkg ]z||jhh? Waj N`udlw cb \lnjklj ck \clnjw~( 4>:=

Iccihj Mccf| awwu?##mccf|+iccihj+lc`+dz#mccf|

-Bc} |c j }jd|ck yanla N adrj bdnhjg wc zkgj}|wdkg( `dk~ ujcuhj hnfj waj |~|wj` V|lnjkwnbnl

wcwdhnwd}ndkn| P yajk nw n| ]z||ndk mzw gn|hnfjg waj rj}~ |d`j |~|wj` yajk nw yd| Ij}`dk+ N d`

lc`ujhhjg wc wankf wadw wan| n| gzj wc waj ucyj} cb hdmjh|6 waj|j ujcuhj hnfj yadwjrj} n| hdmjhhjg

Hjbw ynwaczw jqd`nknki yajwaj} waj hdmjh ad| dk~ oz|wnbnldwnck+-

VBW lc``jkw|? Waj bc}`j} yd| nkwj}kdwnckdhn|w dkg }zk m~ d Wdh`zgnl wacziaw udwwj}k wadw cuuc|jg

kdwz}j( yanhj waj hdwwj} yd| kdwnckdhn|w dkg }zk m~ d Ij} dknl wacziaw udwwj}k wadw yc}fjg ynwakdwz}j+P

-Waj lc`uhjwjkj|| cb waj }j|zhwnki lckw}ch crj} cunknck gjujkg| nk rd}ncz| yd~| zuck |lnjkwnbnl

wjlakntzj+ Yaj}j dhh lanhg}jk ic wc |lacch( dkg dhh |lacch| d}j lckw}chhjg m~ waj icrj}k`jkw( waj

dzwac}nwnj| ldk lhc|j waj `nkg| cb waj ~czki wc jrj}~wanki lckw}d}~ wc cbbnlndh c}wacgcq~+ U}nkwnki n|

n`uc||nmhj ynwaczw uduj}( dkg dhh uduj} mjhcki| wc waj \wdwj+ M}cdgld|wnki dkg waj lnkj`d d}j

jtzdhh~ uzmhnl `ckcuchnj|+-

-Dhh wan| n| kcw n`dinkd}~( nw n| gdnh~ dkg acz}h~ }jdhnw~+ Kc}( inrjk chnid}la~( n| waj}j waj |hniawj|w

}jd|ck wc jqujlw dk~wanki jh|j+-

-Waj}j d}j wa}jj yd~| cb |jlz}nki d |clnjw~ wadw |adhh mj |wdmhj d| }jid}g| ucuzhdwnck+ Waj bn}|w n|

wadw cb mn}wa lckw}ch( waj |jlckg n| wadw cb nkbdkwnlngj c} }jdhh~ gj|w}zlwnrj yd}|( dkg waj wan}g wadw

cb ijkj}dh `n|j}~ jqljuw bc} d ucyj}bzh `nkc}nw~+ Dhh waj|j `jwacg| adrj mjjk u}dlwn|jg? waj bn}|w(bc} jqd`uhj( m~ waj Dz|w}dhndk dmc}ninkj|6 waj |jlckg m~ Dwjl|( waj \ud}wdk| dkg waj }zhj}| cb

Uhdwc)| ]juzmhnl6 waj wan}g nk waj yc}hg d| |c`j Yj|wj}k nkwj}kdwnckdhn|w| acuj wc `dfj nw dkg nk

\crnjw ]z||nd+-

-I}dgzdhh~( m~ |jhjlwnrj m}jjgnki( waj lckijknwdh gnbbj}jklj| mjwyjjk }zhj}| dkg }zhjg ynhh nkl}jd|j

zkwnh waj~ mjlc`j dh`c|w gnbbj}jkw |ujlnj|+ D }jrchw cb waj uhjm| yczhg mjlc`j d| zkwankfdmhj d|

dk c}idknjg nk|z}}jlwnck cb |ajju didnk|w waj u}dlwnlj cb jdwnki `zwwck+ !Waj Dwjl| fjuw d

gc`j|wnldwjg dhnjk w}nmj bc} waj uz}uc|j| cb ldkknmdhn|`+ Wajn} }jin`j yd| wcwdhnwd}ndk.- u2< V45P

-Gnjw( nkojlwnck|( dkg nkozklwnck| ynhh lc`mnkj( b}c` d rj}~ jd}h~ dij( wc u}cgzlj waj |c}w cb

lad}dlwj} dkg waj |c}w cb mjhnjb| wadw waj dzwac}nwnj| lck|ngj} gj|n}dmhj( dkg dk~ |j}ncz| l}nwnln|` cb

waj ucyj}| wadw mj ynhh mjlc`j u|~lachcinldhh~ n`uc||nmhj+ Jrjk nb dhh d}j `n|j}dmhj( dhh ynhh mjhnjrj

waj`|jhrj| aduu~( mjldz|j waj icrj}k`jkw ynhh wjhh waj` wadw waj~ d}j |c+-

///

7/31/2019 Fredrick Toben Reviews "Holocaust Denial and Operation Reinhard"

2/20

=

4+ M~ yd~ cb dk Nkw}cgzlwnck |c`j mdlfi}czkg d|ujlw| cb `~ yc}hg rnjy wadw |aduj

`~ `c}dh dkg nkwjhhjlwzdh rdhzj|~|wj`( dkg }jrjdh `~ mhnkg |ucw|+

Yajkjrj} waj ngjdh cb w}zwa d| d oz|wnbnldwnck cb d yc}hg rnjy n| gjj`jg wc mj n`uc}wdkw( dhh wcc

cbwjk cm|j||nrj l}jgjkwndhn|` `dfj| nw kjlj||d}~ wc udnkw d rdhngdwnck unlwz}j cb cbbj}jg

lc``jkwd}~ wadw cziaw wc mj |jhbjrngjkw d| nk `~ }j|uck|j wc wan| :95udij yc}f cb `nkzwj

gjwdnh uz}uc}wjgh~ u}crnki waj Achcldz|w\acda wc mj dk an|wc}nldh bdlw+

@~ yc}hg rnjy }j|w| ck waj Fdkwndk Ldwjic}nldh N`uj}dwnrj Fdwjic}n|laj N`uj}dwnr dkg nw|

}jbhjlwnrj bc}`zhdwnck nk waj 4911 y}nwwjk yc}f? L}nwntzj cb U}dlwnldh ]jd|ck+

/

_yjn Gnkij j}bhhjk gd| Ij`w `nw n``j} kjzj} zkja`jkgj} Mjyzkgj}zki zkg

Ja}bz}law oj bwj} zkg dkadhwjkgj} |nla gd| Kdlagjkfjk gd`nw mj|labwniw? Gj} ij|wn}kwj

An``jh mj} `n} zkg gd| `c}dhn|laj Ij|jw nk `n}+

Wyc wanki| bnhh waj `nkg ynwa jrj} kjy dkg nkl}jd|nki dg n}dwnck dkg dyj( waj `c}j

cbwjk dkg uj}|n|wjkw nw wankf| dmczw waj`? waj |wd}}~ ajdrjk dmcrj `j dkg waj `c}dh

hdy ynwank `j+

/

Waj bn}|w |niknbnj| |lnjkwnbnl jktzn}~ dkg waj |jlckg uj}|ckdh `c}dhnw~+ Wajk( bc} waj }jlc}g( hjw `j

dgg wa}jj uc|nwnrj lc``jkw| `dgj nk =55= dmczw `~ uj}|ck?

B}jg}nlf Wmjk n| d `dk cb lck|ngj}dmhj lcz}dij+ Yadwjrj} ckj wankf| cb an| rnjy|( ckj

ldk }j|ujlw d gn||ngjkw yac |wnlf| wc an| jqw}j`jh~ zkucuzhd} cunknck| oz|w mjldz|j aj

mjhnjrj| nk waj` N|}djh \ad`n}( OdbbdWjh Drnr( Udhj|wnkj+

Waj dgrdkwdij cb lc``zkn|w ljk|c}|anu yd| nw| w}dk|ud}jkw zihnkj|| dkg nw| cujk

hzkdl~+ Waj gn|dgrdkwdij cb waj |cldhhjg Yj|wj}k hnmj}dh gj`cl}dl~ n| nw| bjnikjg

b}jjgc`( dkg nw| lcch hzkdl~+ Lc``zkn|` z|jg wc fnhh waj mcg~ mzw nw |ud}jg waj |czh+

Waj hnmj}dh gj`cl}dl~ fnhh| waj |czh yanhj hjdrnki waj mcg~ cb d c`mnj+ Waj }jrn|nckn|wB}jg}nlf Wmjk c} yj `niaw mjwwj} ldhh an` d kcklckbc}`n|w c} d hdwwj}gd~ gn||ngjkw

n| yjhh dyd}j cb waj `jkgdlnw~ cb waj gj`cl}dwnl gn|lcz}|j dkg gjhn}ncz| `~wa| yanla

|aduj cz} `cgj}k yc}hg? mcwa d}j jkbc}ljg m~ l}n`nkdh lcgj| dhh crj} waj ihc}ncz| Yj|w+

Aj }jojlw| waj` ynwa u}jln|nck dkg dhh gzj nkln|nck+ Waj}j n| kc bhniaw bc} Wmjk dkg

cwaj} b}jj wankfj}| hnfj an` ckh~ d hcki bniaw+ D| Knjw|laj z|jg wc |d~( d b}jj `dk n| d

bniawj}+ G} Wc`n|hdr \zknl_di}jm( L}cdwnd+

Wc cunkj ck d|ujlw| cb Ojyn|a u}cudidkgd n| lcz}dijcz|6 wc ic uzmhnl ynwa |zla ackj|w

cunknck| n| |znlngdh+ D| |zla( N mjhnjrj B}jg}nlf Wmjk ad| la}cknl hnwj}d}~ |znlngdh

wjkgjklnj|+ @cad``jg Ajidn( @jhmcz}kj( Dz|w}dhnd+

Cb lcz}|j( ~cz ldk Iccihj `~ kd`j dkg bnkg kz`j}cz| lckw}d}~ lc``jkw| dmczw `~ uj}|ck(|c`jwanki wadw gcj| kcw mcwaj} `j nk waj |hniawj|w( dkg N |adhh lj}wdnkh~ kcw j`uhc~ |c`jckj yac

lad}ij| '4555( d `ckwa wc `dknuzhdwj Iccihj |wdwn|wnl| |c wadw ckh~ bdrcz}dmhj lc``jkw| duujd}

nk waj |jd}la jkinkj+ Waj bc}`j} Bjgj}dh Lcz}w cb Dz|w}dhnd ozgij @d}lz| Jnkbjhg n| dhhjijgh~

j`uhc~nki |zla d uj}|ck+

Wan| bngghnki cb |wdwn|wnldh nkbc}`dwnck n| dk n`uc}wdkw ucnkw mjldz|j waj Nkwj}kjw n| }nbj ynwa

`dknuzhdwjg gdwd wadw gcj| kcw dllc}g ynwa waj w}zwa cb d `dwwj}+ Waj}j d}j hnd}|( mhccg~ hnd}| dkg

|wdwn|wnlndk|+ Ajklj waj tzj|w bc} ucuzhd}nw~( uj}|ckdh c} |zmojlw wa}czia Nkwj}kjw |wdwn|wnl|(

u}cgzlj| kcwanki mzw bdh|j lck|lncz|kj||( gjhz|nck| dkg bdkwd|nj|( dkg czw}niaw bnlwnck wadw

nkgnrngzdh| dwwj`uw wc ud|| cbb d| bdlw| i}czkgjg nk waj ua~|nldh yc}hg+

Waj Nkwj}kjw |clndh `jgnd l}dj ad| mjlc`j d `~wanl `dfj} j|ujlndhh~ yajk ~czki|wj}| ljhjm}dwj

wajn} wacz|dkg & dkg yadwjrj} kz`mj} b}njkg ck Wynwwj} c} Bdljmccf+ \zla b}njkg|anu| d}j kcw uzw

7/31/2019 Fredrick Toben Reviews "Holocaust Denial and Operation Reinhard"

3/20

DML| Iccg @c}knki D`j}nld d|fjg ]c|jkmhdww ya~ aj hnjg dmczw wadw duuhj

an| bzwz}j ynbj gdnh~ wa}jy wc an` crj} waj bjklj nkwc waj lckljkw}dwnck ld`u?

/

]c|d ]c|jkmhdw? N z|jg wc lc`j m~ jrj}~ gd~( m}nki waj duuhj N adg nk `~ odlfjw dkg unjlj cb

m}jdg( dkg |d~? Nhh |jj ~cz wc`c}}cy+

I@D? Ya~ gng ~cz gc nw3 Ya~ gng ~cz wjhh |zla d mni hnj wc |c `dk~ ujcuhj bc} |c hcki3

]c|jkmhdw? Nw yd| kc hnj+ Nw yd| `~ n`dinkdwnck( dkg nk `~ n`dinkdwnck( nk `~ `nkg( N mjhnjrjg nw+

Jrjk kcy N mjhnjrj nw wadw |aj yd| waj}j dkg wadw |aj wa}jy waj duuhj wc `j+

I@D? Acy ldk ~cz |d~ nw yd|kw d hnj( nw yd|kw w}zj dkg ~cz fkcy nw| kcw w}zj3

]c|jkmhdw? ^j|( nw| kcw w}zj mzw nk `~ n`dinkdwnck nw yd| w}zj+

I@D? Aj}`dk dkg ]c|d ]c|jkmhdw wchg wajn} bdh|j |wc}~ uzmhnlh~ bc} `c}j wadk d gjldgj mzw nw dhh

bjhh dud}w dmczw |nq yjjf| dic dbwj} Achcldz|w |lachd}| u}crjg wadw nw yd| ua~|nldhh~ n`uc||nmhj bc}

u}n|ckj}| wc duu}cdla waj bjklj dw waj lckljkw}dwnck ld`u yaj}j Aj}`dk ]c|jkmhdw yd| fjuw dkg

wadw ]c`d| bd`nh~ yd| wyc azkg}jg `nhj| dyd~ dw waj wn`j+

Ya~ gng ~cz} ynbj di}jj wc ic dhcki ynwa wan|+ Gng |aj jrj} jqu}j|| dk~ }j|j}rdwnck|3

]c|jkmhdw? Mjldz|j |aj hcrj| `j+

I@D? Ya~| |aj kcw aj}j wcgd~3

]c|jkmhdw? Mjldz|j N gckw ydkw aj} wc mj aj}j wcgd~+ Nw| wcc `zla wcc `zla icnki ck+

I@D? Yd| nw gnbbnlzhw bc} ~cz} ynbj wc adrj ic czw rj}~ uzmhnlh~ dkg wjhh d |wc}~ wadw |aj fkjy

yd|kw w}zj3

]c|jkmhdw? Nw yd|( nw yd|( mzw |aj hcrj| `j |c `zla wadw nb |aj wankf| wadw| iccg bc} `j |ajhh ic

dhcki ynwa nw+

I@D? ]c|jkmhdw n| }j`d}fdmh~ zk}jujkwdkw dmczw an| ~jd}| cb h~nki+

]c|jkmhdw? N u}ckczklj `~ hcrj bc} ~cz( bc}jrj}+

/

Nw n| |zla kck|jk|j wadw jkdmhjg `j wc bc}`zhdwj d wnwhj bc} waj uduj} N gjhnrj}jg dw waj =552

Wjaj}dk Achcldz|w Lckbj}jklj? Waj Achcldz|w ad| kc }jdhnw~ nk |udlj dkg wn`j( ckh~ nk`j`c}~+

7/31/2019 Fredrick Toben Reviews "Holocaust Denial and Operation Reinhard"

4/20

7

Mzw cb lcz}|j waj}j n| `zla `c}j wc wan| bnlwnck wadw dllz|j| Ij}`dk| cb d `c|w ajnkcz| l}n`j

mjldz|j rj}mdh }ju}j|jkwdwnck| d}j lhjd}h~ bczkg nk Chg Wj|wd`jkw y}nwnki| yaj}j nw n| |wdwjg waj

Ajm}jy Icg gn}jlw| waj |hdziawj} cb yc`jk dkg lanhg}jk( bc} jqd`uhj( cb yanla |nklj 4>7: Ojy|

dkg wajn} u}cqnj| dllz|j Ij}`dk| cb adrnki uj}ujw}dwjg ck yc}hg Ojy}~+ Waj Achcldz|w\acda|

`~wanldh `nkg|jw lhjd}h~ ad| Chg Wj|wd`jkw u}jljgjkw| mznhw nkwc nw( d| yjhh d| ac`nlngdh wacziaw

udwwj}k| wadw d}j lhjd}h~ jrngjkw nk gjwdnhjg Wdh`zgnl y}nwnki|( yanla `dfj zu waj jwanldh

|wdkgd}g| dkg `c}dh izngj cb `c|w C}wacgcq Ojy|+

Yajk D`j}nldk u}j|ngjkw| zkd|ad`jgh~ hnj dmczw wajn} uj}|ckdh hnrj| dkg u}c`cwj `dwwj}|

Achcldz|w\acda( c} j`m}dlj waj =55< Yjduck| cb @d|| Gj|w}zlwnck Y@G hnj( c} yc}|j |wnhh(

rnic}cz|h~ lckgckj| waj >?44 hnj|( dkg wajk waj ]c|jkmhdw hnj| d}j `j}jh~ dkcwaj} jqd`uhj cb d

`nkg|jw wadw ynwank cz} Yj|wj}k gj`cl}dlnj| jrjk dldgj nl| dkg hdy`dfj}|#uchnwnlndk|

zkd|ad`jgh~ j`m}dljg dkg lckwnkzj wc j`m}dlj+

Waj w}zwa cb d `dwwj} ad| mjlc`j n}}jhjrdkw dkg wan| n| waj lc}j cb yadw n| ldz|nki waj gjlhnkj cb

waj Yj|w dkg waj dgcuwnck cb Achcldz|w\acda d| d |zm|wnwzwj }jhninck mjkjbnlndh( d`cki cwaj}|( wc

Ojy| dkg N|}djh dw waj jqujk|j cb Ij}`dk|#kdwnckdhn|w| dkg @z|hn`|#Udhj|wnkndk|#N}dkndk|? waj

dgcuwnck cb waj Wdh`zgnl @d}qn|w dwajn|wnl gjdwa gndhjlwnl lc`mnkjg ynwa Uad}n|dnl z|z}~ u}nklnuhj|+

Bc} wan| fnkg cb gndhjlwnl ynkhc|j `nkg|jw w}zwa n| gjj`jg wc mj d `j}j |clndh lck|w}zlw w}zwa n|

yadw ~cz ydkw nw wc mj }dwaj} wadk w}zwa mjnki waj bczkgdwnck( waj mjg}clf cb cz} lnrnhn|dwnck+

Oz|w }j`j`mj}( yajkjrj} jkinkjj}| mjink wc bngghj waj mccf| ynwa wajn} ldhlzhdwnck| dkg

`jd|z}j`jkw|( nk jbbjlw l}jdwnki d ua~|nldh |w}zlwz}j mznhw ck hnj|( wajk waj |w}zlwz}j waj~ mznhg

ynhh lchhdu|j+ \c( wcc( nw n| ynwa dk~ `jkwdh |w}zlwz}j wadw d h~nki `nkg|jw lck|w}zlw|( bc} jqd`uhj(

waj @d}qn|w ngjchci~ c} waj Achcldz|w\acda `~wa |chg d| d ua~|nldh bdlw mzw u}cwjlwjg hjidhh~

b}c` d wac}czia jqd`nkdwnck+ Ij} dk| d}j dllz|jg cb adrnki lc``nwwjg dw}clncz| l}n j| ~jw

waj~ d}j kcw uj}`nwwjg wc `czkw d gjbjklj didnk|w |zla dhhjidwnck| mjldz|j |zla d gjbjklj yczhg

az}w waj bjjhnki| cb wac|j yac mjhnjrj nk waj Achcldz|w\acda `~wa|+ Waj ]c|jkmhdw Uajkc`jkck

ad| mjjk jklcz}dijg wc mhc||c` nk |cldhhjg yj|wj}k gj`cl}dlnj| dkg Ij}`dk| hdlf waj `c}dhdkg nkwjhhjlwzdh lcz}dij wc cuuc|j nw mjldz|j cb md|nl l}jdwz}j lc`bc}w|+ Ajklj waj bjy nkgnrngzdh|

yac j`m}dlj ]jrn|nckn|` fkcy bzhh yjhh wadw nw ynhh `jdk nk `c|w nk|wdklj| d |clndh dkg

u}cbj||nckdh gjdwa |jkwjklj+

Mzw bc}wzkdwjh~ |zla knanhn|wnl `nkg|jw wadw u}cudidwj| |zla Achcldz|w\acda hnj| dh|c lckwdnk| nw|

cyk |jhbgj|w}zlwnrj nkwj}kdh hcinl( d| waj ]c|jkmhdw jqd`uhj jqj`uhnbnj|+ ]jrn|nckn|w| gngkw jrjk

adrj wc jquc|j ]c|jkmhdw| hnj|+ Waj}j d}j kz`j}cz| |zla ld|j| ck }jlc}g yaj}j ]jrn|nckn|w|

`j}jh~ |`nhjg dw |zla b}dzg|wj}| }ngnki ck waj Achcldz|w\acda `~wa i}dr~w}dnk+ Ajklj( yaj}j

hnj| d}j wchg uj}|ckdh }jhdwnck|anu| m}jdf gcyk dkg d |clnjw~ mjink| wc }cw( dkg nw n| ckh~ bc} |c`j

wn`j wadw hjidh lck|w}dnkw| achg wcijwaj} waj }cwwnki |clndh bdm}nl+ An|wc}~ wjdlaj| z| acy zkgj} waj

yjniaw cb cbbnlndh hnj| waj `c}dh( |clndh dkg hjidh gzwnj| ynwa yanla `c|w lnwnjk| d}j n`mzjg d}j

l}z|ajg+ Ajklj nk c}gj} wc gjbhjlw b}c` waj nkjrnwdmhj |clndh gn|nkwji}dwnck waj ihcmdh w}jkg n| wcl}d|| lck|z`j} ajgckn|`( yanla acyjrj} gn}jlwh~ }j|zhw| nk u}cgzlnki d l~knldhknanhn|wnl yc}hg

rnjy yaj}j waj ckh~ b}jjgc` lnwnjk| jkoc~ n| waj b}jjgc` wc ic |acuunki kjrj} `nkg nb ~cz d}j

ckj cb waj `nhhnck| zkj`uhc~jg dkg adrj kc `ckj~ wc |ujkg$

D| G} ]cmj}w Bdz}n||ck }j`nkgjg z| yajk waj =55< Y@G yd| jquc|jg d| d hnj dkg z|jg d| d

u}jwjqw bc} waj Z\ wc nkrdgj N}dt( waj kjqw ihcmdh hnj cb }jljkw wn`j| wc m}jdf gcyk ynhh mj waj

>?44 yd| gckj m~ d mzkla cb @z|hn` wj}}c}n|w| hnj+ Dk~ckj ynwa |c`j zkgj}|wdkgnki cb bn}j| dkg

jquhc|nrj| fkcy| wadw mznhgnki| gckw lchhdu|j waj yd~ yj adrj mjjk wchg waj Yc}hg W}dgj Ljkw}j

Wynk Wcyj}| yj}j m}cziaw gcyk kcw m~ uhdkj| mzw m~ lckw}chhjg gj`chnwnck6 dkg yj kjjg kcw

jrjk `jkwnck acy Mznhgnki 9 lchhdu|jg nk waj dm|jklj cb dk~ uhdkj| anwwnki nw mjldz|j Hd}}~

\nhrj}|wjnk dg`nwwjg wadw aj gjlngjg wc uzhh nw+

7/31/2019 Fredrick Toben Reviews "Holocaust Denial and Operation Reinhard"

5/20

Ajklj( waj cbbnlndh lck|un}dl~ w

wadw d hnj wchg wc oz|wnb~ D

l}z`mhnki ihcmdh jlckc`nl ucy

Ck 2 Clwcmj} =544 Wmjk l

awwu?##y

dkg kcwj ]ck Udzh| uchnwn

awwu?##yyy+~czwzmj+lc`#

Wan| kcy ihcmdh hnj wadw uc|wzhd

waj ngjchcinldh rdlzz` hjbw dbw

waj jkg cb 4>1> dkg nkwc wa

D`j}nldk_nckn|w u}jgdwc}~ ldun

Waj `c|w lc`u}jajk|nrjh~ gjr

wadw gz}nki Yc}hg Yd} Wyc Ij}

lad`mj}| |wnhh |wdkg| mjldz|

|jj Ij}`dk| d| d wa}jdw wc wa

mjidk gz}nki waj hdwj 4>95| d

dkg wadw n| wadkf| wc nkgnrngzHjzlawj}( Ynhhn| Ld}wc( J}k|w _

kcwdmhj Achcldz|w\acda |lach

dwwdlf nk waj hdwj|w yc}f| m~ Ac

Ck =5 Du}nh 4>11 Waj Hjzlaw

w}ndh( }clfjg waj lc`uhdljkw A

id| yd| kcw bczkg nk waj dhhji

Mn}fjkdz+ Wyc ~jd}| hdwj} waj

gjdwa| kz`mj} yj}j }j`crjg

yj}j `z}gj}jg+ Kcwj wadw waj |

Wajk yj adrj wc mjd} nk `nkg w

dbwj} waj Kdwnckdh \clndhn|w| wc

jc}~( waczia |chngnbnjg wa}czia wyc azij nk|z}

ihcD`j}nldk_nckn|w ihcmdh yd} `ckij}nki

} |w}zlwz}j+

``jkw| ck u}j||wr+lc` kjy yc}hg c}gj

y+~czwzmj+lc`#ydwla3r0~]5z}2i@NdT

dh lc``jkw| dw

dwla3r0g4w7C>Ll_T5+

jg wj}}c}n|` d| dk jrnh g}nrnki bc}lj kjjgjg w

} waj \crnjw Zknck dkg nw| gjujkgjklnj| |wd}w

j 4>>5|( waj}jm~ |jlz}nki waj ihcmdh |zu}j

nwdhn|wnl yc}hg rnjy bc} |c`j gjldgj| wc lc`j+

jhcujg }jljkw an|wc}nldh hnj waj Achcldz|w\a

`dk| |~|wj`dwnldhh~ jqwj}`nkdwjg Jz}cujdk Oj

nw n| |jw nk hjidh lckl}jwj dkg nw |j}rj| yjhh w

jn} jlckc`nl jqn|wjklj+ Acyjrj}( |nklj nw| bc}

g jd}h~ 4>15| `d||nrj l}dlf| adrj duujd}jg

dh| |zla d| D}waz} Mzw( ]cmj}w Bdz}n||ck(gjh( @nladjh Acbb`dk( d`cki cwaj}|+ Cb lcz}|

}| Ld}hc @dwwcikc( O}ijk I}db dkg Wac`d| F

hcldz|w mjhnjrj}|+

} ]juc}w( d| ud}w cb waj J}k|w _kgjh Wc}ckwc

hcldz|w\acda mjhnjrj}| ynwa waj |lnjkwnbnl jrn

jg ac`nlngdh id| lad`mj}|( nk ud}wnlzhd}( dw

yc}hg yd| nkbc}`jg wadw Waj =5 uhdtzj| ld

dkg |zm|jtzjkwh~ }juhdljg ynwa uhdtzj| lhdn`n

nq `nhhnck bniz}j yd| kcw }jgzljg+

adw dllc}gnki wc Waj Yc}hg Dh`dkdl dkg Mc

cf ucyj} nk Ij}`dk~ waj}j yj}j 4:( 2

7/31/2019 Fredrick Toben Reviews "Holocaust Denial and Operation Reinhard"

6/20

2

Dbwj} waj yd}( nk 4>7:( waj }jbj}jklj mccf hn|w| :1(555& `c}j Ojy|+ Wankf dmczw nw dkg lck|ngj}

wadw wan| n| d Ojyn|a |cz}lj+

Waj yachj kz`mj}| kck|jk|j n| nkgnldwnrj cb waj Achcldz|w\acda |wc}~| md|nl kd}}dwnrj? Nw

dgoz|w| wc ]jrn|nckn|w| jquc|nki waj mjhnjrj}| czw}niaw hnj| m~ bdm}nldwnki kjy bniz}j|+

Ockdwadk Ad}}n|ck( ]cmj}wc @zjahjkfd`u( Od|ck @~j}|( \j}ij~ ]c`dkcr dkg Knlachd| Wj}}~ adrj

u}cgzljg d lc` nwwjj mccf wadw nk `nkzwj gjwdnh dwwj`uw| wc uj}|zdgj waj gn|mjhnjrj} wadw waj

Achcldz|w\acda nkgjjg ad| d }jdhnw~ nk |udlj dkg wn`j dkg jqn|w| kcw ckh~ nk waj `j`c}~ cb waj

|z}rnrc}| yac adrj dhh wcc cbwjk mjjk u}crjk wc mj bdm}nldwc}|( nb kcw czw}niaw hnd}| d| ]c|jkmhdw

u}crjg wc mj+

Wajk waj}j n| waj md|nl bdlwzdh |wz`mhnki mhclf dmczw Achcldz|w\acda dzwajkwnlnw~+ Nw n| d

}jlc}gjg bdlw wadw nk waj |cldhhjg Yj|wj}k b}jjdkggj`cl}dwnl lczkw}nj| wc gczmw dkg tzj|wnck

dk Achcldz|w j~jynwkj||| |wc}~ n| |dl}nhjij dk dkwn|j`nwnl dlw$ Waj uzmhnl `jgnd }jdlwnck wc waj

N|hd`nl ]juzmhnl cb N}dk achgnki d Achcldz|w lckbj}jklj nk Wjaj}dk nk Gjlj`mj} =552 yd| kcwanki

mzw |ujlwdlzhd}h~ nk|w}zlwnrj ck acy dk cujk gjmdwj ck waj wcunl n| bjd}jg( |c `zla |c wadw waj

yj|wj}k `jgnd `n||jg waj |zmwhjw~ cb waj lckbj}jklj| nkwjkwnck|+ Nw cbbj}jg d }jrnjy cb waj

Achcldz|w dkg kcw d tzj|wncknki cb waj Achcldz|w\acda mzw jrjk wadw yd| jkczia wc adrj waj

N}dkndk U}j|ngjkw( G} @da`czg Da`dgnkjodg hdmjhhjg d Achcldz|w gjknj}+

Hdy| nk Ij} dk~ dkg cwaj} Jz}cujdk lczkw}nj| |jkg czw |w}cki `j||dij| wc dk~ckj yac gd}j|

tzj|wnck waj Achcldz|w\acda c}wacgcq~+ Waj~ l}n nkdhn|j dk~ckj yac ldk mj bczkg wc mj

gjbd`nki waj `j`c}~ cb waj gjdg c} wc mj gczmwnki waj Achcldz|w\acda| wa}jj unhhd}| ck yanla

waj kd}}dwnrj }j|w|? |nq `nhhnck Ojy| gnjg6 |~|wj`dwnl |wdwj jqwj}`nkdwnck6 ac`nlngdh id| lad`mj}|

d| waj `z}gj} yjduck+

\zla hdy| dn` wc u}cwjlw j|ujlndhh~ |cldhhjg Ojy|( |ujlnbnldhh~ Achcldz|w rnlwn`|( b}c` adrnki wc

oz|wnb~nki wajn} uj}|ckdh kd}}dwnrj dkg wajn} lckwnkzcz| lc`ujk|dwnck lhdn`|+ Waj}j d}j jrjk

gj`dkg| dbccw wc adrj bn}|w dkg |jlckg( nb kcw wan}g ijkj}dwnck Achcldz|w |z}rnrc}| lc`ujk|dwjg$Dldgj`nl| adrj mjjk dwwdlfjg m~ zknrj}|nw~ lc``nwwjj| wadw dmac} dk~ gjrndwnck b}c` waj cbbnlndh

gci`dwnl rj}|nck cb waj Achcldz|w\acda kd}}dwnrj+ Gz}nki 4>1< waj Zknrj}|nw~ cb Iwwnkijk

|w}nuujg Ozgij Ynhajh` \wihnla cb an| gclwc}dwj nk hdy mjldz|j aj adg y}nwwjk Waj Dz|laynw

@~wa( yanla nklc}uc}dwjg an| `j`c}~ cb wn`j |ujkw d| d |chgnj} dw Dz|laynw Lckljkw}dwnck Ld`u+

Kjy _jdhdkg dldgj`nl( G} \wzd}w Ocjh Ad~yd}g( }jldkwjg dkg yd| |zm|jtzjkwh~ dyd}gjg ynwa dk

dldgj`nl uc|w nk Jkihdkg mzw kcw mjbc}j dh|c |zbbj}nki d `jkwdh m}jdfgcyk ck dllczkw cb adrnki

an| hnbj dkg wadw cb an| ynbj dkg lanhg}jk wa}jdwjkjg+ Waj|j d}j oz|w wyc jqd`uhj| cb dldgj`nl|

u}clj||jg hjidhh~ mjldz|j waj~ }jbz|jg wc mjhnjrj zktzj|wncknkih~ `dwwj}| Achcldz|w\acda

czw|ngj cb waj gj|nikdwjg ud}d`jwj}| yaj}j waj wa}jj unhhd}| |wdkg d| |jkwnkjh| izd}gnki waj

cbbnlndh Achcldz|w\acda kd}}dwnrj+

Yajk dk~ckj z|j| waj kck|jk|j lckljuw dkwn|j`nwj nw }j nkg| `j cb waj bdlw wadw yajk wajMch|ajrnf| j|wdmhn|ajg waj \crnjw Zknck ckj cb waj bn}|w lckljuw| wadw yd| l}n`nkdhnjg yd|

dkwn|j`nwn|`+ Dbwj} dhh( wc `c|w ]z||ndk| dw waj wn`j nw yd| cmrncz| wadw wan| |cldhhjg }jrchzwnck

yd| Ojylckw}chhjg+ Nb d uj}|ck yd| dllz|jg cb mjnki dk dkwn|j`nwj( wajk wan| dww}dlwjg waj gjdwa

|jkwjklj+ Nb d uj}|ck yd| dllz|jg cb mjnki d ]jrn|nckn|w( nw dww}dlwjg d hnbjwn`j IzHdi

mdkn|a`jkw+

Waj z|j cb waj lckljuw dkwn|j`nwj wc bz}waj} dk d}iz`jkw| rj}dlnw~ n| nkgnldwnrj cb adrnki hc|w

waj uhcw dkg zkdmhj( cmojlwnrjh~( wc `jjw dk cuuckjkw| d}iz`jkw+ Waj z|j cb waj wj}` nk waj wjqw

mjbc}j `j nkgnldwj| waj y}nwj}| bdnh waj cmojlwnrnw~ wj|w mjldz|j m~ z|nki waj wj}` waj~ gc wyc

wanki|?

4+ Wan| n| d kck|jk|j lckljuw mjldz|j nw n| d hdkizdij gj|nikdwnck+ Waz| wc hdmjh dk~ckj dkdkwn|j`nwj dh|c `jdk| mjnki didnk|w waj D}dmnl|ujdfnki ujcuhj| yac|j hdkizdij n| d \j`nwnl

7/31/2019 Fredrick Toben Reviews "Holocaust Denial and Operation Reinhard"

7/20

9

hdkizdij( d| n| Ajm}jy+ Waz| waj z|zdh }j|uck|j wc mjnki hdmjhhjg dk dkwn|j`nwj dww}dlw| waj

lc}}jlw }j|uck|j? N d` kcw didnk|w waj D}dmnl dkg Ajm}jy|ujdfnki ujcuhj|6

=+ Waj lhdn` wadw Ojy| d}j }dlndhh~ \j`nwj|( dkg ajklj dk~ckj cuuc|nki Ojy|( bc} yadwjrj}

}jd|ck( n| dk dkwn|j`nwj( ad| mjjk hjidhh~ jk|a}nkjg nk Yj|wj}k hnmj}dh gj`cl}dlnj| wa}czia }dlndh

gn|l}n`nkdwnck hdy|+ Nkwj}j|wnkih~( nb D}dmnl|ujdfnki @z|hn`| `dfj z|j cb waj|j }dlndh

gn|l}n`nkdwnck hdy| wajn} `dwwj} z|zdhh~ gcj| kcw u}cljjg wc ozgi`jkw+

Waj hdwj|w l}n nkdh ld|j nk Dz|w}dhnd nkrchrnki }dlndh gn|l}n nkdwnck hdy| n| M}jkgck CLckkjhh nk

Yj|wj}k Dz|w}dhnd yac adg dk dhwj}ldwnck ynwa d ~czki Ojy dw d u}cUdhj|wnkj u}cwj|w `jjwnki nk

Uj}wa yaj}j dh|c d kz`mj} cb nkgnrngzdh| u}cwj|wjg didnk|w N|}djhn b}znw n`uc}w| wc Dz|w}dhnd+ Ck

dllczkw cb wan| rj}mdh dhwj}ldwnck dkg waj uc|wnki cb |d`j ck ^czWzmj( CLckkjhh yd| lckrnlwjg

dkg |jkwjkljg wc wa}jj ~jd}| odnh d `d||nrj nkoz|wnlj+

]jljkwh~( dkg hnfj Odlf rdk Wckij}jk mjbc}j an`( CLckkjhh yd| cbbj}jg mdkn|a`jkw b}c` Yj|wj}k

Dz|w}dhnd bc} jd}h~ }jhjd|j( waj}jm~ aniahniawnki acy gjjuh~ jkw}jklajg nk Wdh zgnl hjidhj|j

Yj|wj}k Dz|w}dhnd ad| mjlc`j yaj}j Dz|w}dhndk| d}j |jkw nkwc nkwj}kdh jqnhj( |c`jwanki

}j`nkn|ljkw cb Wdh`zgnl@d}qn|w u}dlwnlj| nk \crnjw ]z||nd+

Dh|c }j`j`mj} nk wan| lckwjqw wadw d gd~ dbwj} an| mn}wagd~( ck =4 Du}nh 4>7?

dbwj} d 49~jd} hjidh mdwwhj nkrchrnki Dz|w}dhnd| Ojy| wadw |dy `j |ujkg wn`j nk Ij}`dk( Jkihn|a

dkg Dz|w}dhndk u}n|ck|+ Nk Ozh~ =544 N gjbjdwjg wajn} bnkdh dlw cb ljk|c}|anu wadw dn`jg wc |wcu `j

b}c` bzklwncknki mdkf}zuwl~+

7/31/2019 Fredrick Toben Reviews "Holocaust Denial and Operation Reinhard"

8/20

1

N d` nk waj u}nrnhjijg uc|nwnck wc lhdn` Ojy| w}njg wc ad}` `j( lck|un}jg didnk|w `j+ Hjw `j

}jujdw? Ojy| |jw czw wc ldz|j `j ad}`( wc gj|w}c~ `~ hnrjhnaccg mjldz|j N tzj|wnck wajn} n`uc|jg

Achcldz|w\acda kd}}dwnrj+ N d` bc}wzkdwj nk wadw N ldk jrjk |wdwj wadw N |z}rnrjg wan| Ojy

lck|un}dl~ m~ }jljnrnki ajhu b}c` waj `c|w zkhnfjh~ tzd}wj}| cb |clnjw~( waj}jm~ gjbjdwnki Ojy

nknwndwjg hjidh dlwnck |ujlnbnldhh~ gj|nikjg wc wdfj `dwwj}| Achcldz|w\acda czw cb uzmhnl gn|lcz}|j+

Dkg |wnhh N achg wc `~ `dqn ? Gckw mhd`j waj Ojy|6 mhd`j wac|j wadw mjkg wc wajn} u}j||z}j+

Dbwj} dhh( nk cz} m}njb jd}wah~ jqn|wjklj waj mdwwhj cb waj ynhh| n| waj `c|w kdwz}dh uajkc`jkck

dkg d| d `nkc}nw~ i}czu cb nkgnrngzdh| Ojy| adrj dhyd~| zkgj}|wccg acy wc `dknuzhdwj waj

`doc}nw~ d| wajn} u}cq~ |j}rj}|+

Ajklj( N }jbz|j wc bdhh nkwc waj `nkg|jw wadw wa}nrj| ck uzhhnki czw waj rnlwn` ld}g( yanla jkdmhj|

Ojy| dkg wajn} u}cqnj| wc lczkwj} m~ z|nki waj z|zdh |azwzu yc}g|( wac|j gn|lz||nck |wcuuj}|

]jrn|nckn|w| ckh~ fkcy wcc yjhh? adwj}( Achcldz|w gjknj}( dkwn\j nwj( }dln|w( Kdn(

qjkcuacmj( wj}}c}n|w+

Nk wan| lckwjqw( cb nkwj}j|w n| wadw dbwj} gjbjdwnki wan| mdkf}zuwl~ dlwnck( dkg dhh }czkg ud~nki czw

'9:(555( `~ bcz}~jd} ^czWzmj dllczkw yd| gjhjwjg+ Waj }jd|ck inrjk yd| wadw N cbbjkgjg

lc``zknw~ |wdkgd}g m~ zuhcdgnki d lhnu gjdhnki ynwa waj Mch|ajrnf Achcldz|w+ N adg gcykhcdgjg d

lhnu b}c` ^czWzmj dkg }jkd`jg nw? Wdh`zgnl nk|un}jg uchnwnldh dlwnck hjdg| wc Achcldz|w nk

Lc``zkn|w lczkw}nj|+

Aj}j n| waj nwj` N |jkw wa}czia `~ j`dnh hn|w dkg uc|wjg ck `~ yjm|nwj yyy+wcmjk+mn

----------------------------------------------------

B}c`? ^czWzmj \j}rnlj V`dnhwc?|j}rnljE~czwzmj+lc`P

\jkw? Kckj

Wc? wcmjkEwcmjk+mn

\zmojlw? ^czWzmj Rngjc Kcwnbnldwnck

-^czWzmj x M}cdgld|w ^cz}|jhb]jid}gnki ~cz} dllczkw? B}jg}nlfWcmjkWaj ^czWzmj Lc``zknw~ ad| bhdiijg ckj c} `c}j cb ~cz} rngjc| d| nkduu}cu}ndwj+ Cklj d rngjc n|bhdiijg( nw n| }jrnjyjg m~ waj ^czWzmj Wjd` didnk|w cz} Lc``zknw~ Izngjhnkj|+ Zuck }jrnjy( yjadrj gjwj}`nkjg wadw waj bchhcynki rngjc!|. lckwdnk lckwjkw nk rnchdwnck cb waj|j izngjhnkj|( dkgadrj mjjk gn|dmhjg?

Wdh zgnl nk|un}jg uchnwnldh dlwnck hjdg| wc Achcldz|w nk Lc``zkn|w lczkw}nj|

!B}jg}nlfWcmjk.Mjldz|j wan| n| waj wan}g rnchdwnck cb waj Lc``zknw~ Izngjhnkj| nk |nq `ckwa| dkg ~cz adrj}jljnrjg u}jrncz| yd}knki|( ~cz} dllczkw ad| kcy mjjk wj}`nkdwjg+ Uhjd|j mj dyd}j wadw ~cz d}ju}canmnwjg b}c` dllj||nki( uc||j||nki c} l}jdwnki dk~ cwaj} ^czWzmj dllczkw|+Bc} `c}j nkbc}`dwnck ck ^czWzmj)| Lc``zknw~ Izngjhnkj| dkg acy waj~ d}j jkbc}ljg( uhjd|j rn|nwwaj Ajhu Ljkw}j+\nklj}jh~(Waj ^czWzmj Wjd`Lcu~}niaw =544 ^czWzmj( HHL

------------------------------------------

B}c`? B}jg}nlf Wcmjk 8wcmjkEwcmjk+mn;Gdwj? \dw( Dzi =9( =544 dw

7/31/2019 Fredrick Toben Reviews "Holocaust Denial and Operation Reinhard"

9/20

>

Gng ~cz kcwnlj waj `dwwj} dmczw wadw wj}}nmhj Knij}ndk mc`mnki dkg acy wan| n| dn`jg wc gnrngjKnij}nd nkwc |czwaj}k La}n|wndk dkg kc}waj}k @z|hn` |wdwj|3 Dkg izj|| yadw uchnwnldh ucyj} ad|mjlc`j dlwnrj nk }j|cz}lj}nla Knij}nd3/ Knij}nd? Jkj}i~ \jlwc} N|}djhn( Dz|w}ndk Nkrj|wc}| Jquhc}j Cuuc}wzknwnj| /

Nkrj|wc}| dkg }ju}j|jkwdwnrj| cb icrj}k`jkw| cb N|}djh dkg Dz|w}nd}jljkwh~ idwaj}jg nk Hdic| wc jquhc}j cuuc}wzknwnj| nk Knij}nd)|

jkj}i~ dkg di}nlzhwz}dh |jlwc}( dw waj nk|wdklj cb waj Nkwj}kdwnckdh

\w}dwjinl Dhhndklj Lc``nwwjj !N\DL.( d i}czu cb Knij}ndk u}cbj||nckdh|nk Gnd|uc}d+ awwu?##dhhdb}nld+lc`#|wc}nj|#=54451=74==9+aw`h

Wajk gc |c`j }j|jd}la dkg bnkg czw yajk N|}djh dkg Knij}nd |nikjg d |jlz}nw~ udlw N |jk|jdkcwaj} Hnm~d lc`nki ck$Lajj}|B}jg}nlf Wmjk

///

Ckj j`dnh }j|uck|j ck wan| `dwwj} |jkw wc `j nkgnldwj| waj}j d}j gn||jkwj}| jrj}~yaj}j

yac tzj|wnck cbbnlndh lck|un}dl~ wajc}nj|?

B}c`? M}ndk J}nk m}ndk+j}nkEacw`dnh+lc`

\jkw? \zkgd~( =1 Dziz|w =544 45?44Ei`dnh+lc + Nk Dziz|w =544 N y}cwj?

N |jk|j Dkwack~ Hdy|ck n| d `dk cb nkwji}nw~( d b}jj wankfj} yac ad| |wz`mhjg ck wcgjljuwnrj |w}zlwz}j| wadw }j nkg `j |c `zla cb waj Achcldz|w\acda kd}}dwnrj? waj

nkgnrngzdh| yac mjhnjrj nk waj cbbnlndh lck|un}dl~ ldhhjg waj Achcldz|w\acda c} >#44(

9#9( Kc}yd~( jwl d}j jnwaj} nikc}dkw cb waj ua~|nldh bdlw|( h~nki( c} yadw n| yc}|j

mcwa+

///

Wajk( bc} waj }jlc}g( hjw `j |wdwj wadw wa}jj nkgnrngzdh| ynwa yac` N adg yc}fjg bc} |c`j wn`j

dkg yac dhh adg Ojyn|a `cwaj}|( mjidk wc dwwdlf `~ `c}dh dkg nkwjhhjlwzdh nkwji}nw~+ Ckj cb waj|j

yd| bz}ncz| dmczw `~ |jwwhnki waj lcz}w lc|w| bc} nki waj md|n| cb waj mdkf}zuwl~ u}cljjgnki|+

^cz}j inrnki waj Ojy| `ckj~( aj lhdn`jg+ Nw yczhg adrj mjjk mjwwj} wc gjlhd}j ~cz}|jhb

mdkf}zuw$ Hnwwhj gng aj }jdhnj wadw N yczhg adrj hc|w `~ ac`j cb =: ~jd}| dkg mj nklckrjknjkljg

nk |c `dk~ gnbbj}jkw yd~| wadw yczhg adrj kcw `dgj nw uc||nmhj bc} `j wc y}nwj wan| }j|uck|j+

Bnkdhh~( nw n| ck waj uzmhnl lcz}w }jlc}g wadw U}n`j Zih~ Ojy( \wjrjk Hjyn|( yac nk =545 l}cyjg dw d

uchnwnldh idwaj}nki wadw aj yd| dmczw wc mdkf}zuw `j( gngkw ydkw waj `ckj~ N cbbj}jg an` nk

|jwwhj`jkw mzw nk|wjdg ydkwjg `j wc mj gjlhd}jg d mdkf}zuw+ Wac|j yac ck =4 Ozkj =544 |dy an`

|wdkgnki dw waj md} wdmhj ynwa `j nk waj \~gkj~ Bjgj}dh @din|w}dwj| Lcz}w mjbc}j ]jin|w}d} Ajgij

kcwnljg wadw |aj hnwj}dhh~ adg wc c}gj} an` czw cb waj lcz}w}cc` |c d| wc |jwwhj ynwa `j+ Hjyn|

|wccg waj}j b}cjk( }jbz|nki wc `crj czw mjldz|j aj ydkwjg waj ]jin|w}d} wc dlwnrdwj an| L}jgnwc}|

Ujwnwnck( yanla yd| |zm|jtzjkwh~ |w}zlf czw dkg gn|`n||jg m~ aj} ck dllczkw cb waj gjmw adrnki

mjjk |jwwhjg+

Ynwa wan| dmcrj mdlfi}czkg nkbc}`dwnck wc adkg N ldk kcy }jrnjy `~ bn}|w jhjlw}cknl mccf z|nki

waj wn`jhj|| lckljuw| cb BC]@ dkg LCKWJKW+

SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

7/31/2019 Fredrick Toben Reviews "Holocaust Denial and Operation Reinhard"

10/20

45

=+ BC]@

Ck

7/31/2019 Fredrick Toben Reviews "Holocaust Denial and Operation Reinhard"

11/20

44

2+ Gjdwa Ld`u Ynwkj||j|

9+ @d|| I}drj|

1+ Mz}knki cb waj Lc}u|j|

Waj lckwjkw| cb wan| 44udij Lcklhz|nck ynhh mj }jbj}}jg wc hdwj}+

D ckjdkgdadhb udij Dbwj}yc}g? D \ujlndh Kcwj m~ Od|ck @~j}| n| duujkgjg wc waj mcg~ cb

waj mccf+ Nw |niknbnj| wadw waj}j n| kc `ckj~ wc mj `dgj nb ~cz gjlngj wc mjlc`j d ]jrn|nckn|w

|lachd} dkg wadw nw n| uz}j ngjdhn|` waj |jd}la bc} w}zwa wadw fjju| ]jrn|nckn|w| icnki( mzw `c}j

ck wan| hdwj}+

Waj n`u}j||nrjh~ jqwjk|nrj dkg lc`u}jajk|nrj Mnmhnci}dua~ |jlwnck n| gnrngjg nkwc

Zkuzmhn|ajg \cz}lj| dkg Uzmhn|ajg \cz}lj|( dkg ckh~ d lhc|j} hccf }jrjdh| bz}waj}

gnrn|nck|+

D+ Zkuzmhn|ajg \cz}lj| hn|w| lcz}w ld|j| dkg w}dk|l}nuw| b}c` lczkw}nj| wadw dbwj} waj

jkg cb Yc}hg Yd} Wyc |wccg nk ozgi`jkw cb waj Dqn| Ucyj}|? Ij}`dk~ Uchdkg

]z||ndk Bjgj}dwnck Mjhd}z| Zf}dnkj Hdwrnd Ljla ]juzmhnl Kjwaj}hdkg| B}dklj

Zknwjg \wdwj| Zknwjg Fnkigc` Kz}j`mj}i Gclz`jkw| W}ndh cb Dgchb Jnla`dkk(

Gclz`jkw|+

M+ Uzmhn|ajg \cz}lj| bz}waj} gnrngj| nkwc?

4+ Uzmhn|ajg U}n`d}~ \cz}lj|( yanla hn|w| 1: mccf|( bc} jqd`uhj? Dzijkjzijkmj}nlaw z gjk

@d||jkrj}id|zkijk( Rb_ =( 4>:76 Jnkj \lazhg( gnj knlaw j}hn|law+ Gcfz`jkwj mj}

gjzw|laj F}nji|rj}m}jlajk nk gj} \cyojwzknck+ Lchcikj? Udzh ]zijk|wjnk Rj}hdi( 4>196 Fhd}|bjhg(

\j}ij( Rnla~ Dz|laynw+ Gnj _z|d``jkd}mjnw gj} gjzw|lajk zkg b}dk|n|lajk Mja}gjk mjn gj}

Jkgh|zki gj} Ozgjkb}dij nk B}dkf}jnla+ K}ghnkijk( 4>1>6 Fzhfd( Cwwc Gcr dkg Jmj}ad}g Olfjh

!jg|.( Gnj Ozgjk nk gjk ijajn`jk K\-\wn `zki|mj}nlawjk 4>-4>77+ Ad`mz}i( 4>>:6 Ynwwj( Ujwj} jw dh !jg|.( Gj}

Gnjk|wfdhjkgd} Ajnk}nla An``hj}| 4>74#7=+ Ad`mz}i( 4>>>+

=+ @j`cn}|( dw udij :1:6 Ynhhjkmj}i( \d`zjh(

]jrchw nk W}jmhnkfd+ Yd}|dy( 4>>= !Ajm}jy c}ninkdh? 4>12.+

726 N@W( Waj W}ndh didnk|wwaj @dnk Yd} L}n`nkdh| mjbc}j waj Nkwj}kdwnckdh @nhnwd}~ W}nmzkdh( Kz}j`mj}i( 4>7:4>726 N|}djh(\wdwj cb( @nkn|w}~ cb Oz|wnlj( Waj W}ndh cb Dgchb Jnla`dkk+ ]jlc}g cb U}cljjgnki| nk waj Gn|w}nlwLcz}w cb Oj}z|dhj`( Oj}z|dhj` 4>>724>79+ 44 rch|+

7+ Lckwj`uc}d}~ Uzmhnldwnck| |z}u}n|nkih~ hn|w| ckh~ jniaw mccf|( bc} jqd`uhj?

Dujk|hdf( Odlcm !jg.( Waj Mhdlf Mccf cb Uchn|a Ojy}~+ Dk Dllczkw cb waj @d}w~}gc` cb Uchn|a

Ojy}~ zkgj} waj Kdn Cllzudwnck+ Kjy ^c}f( 4>7776

:+ \jlckgd}~ Hnwj}dwz}j( dw udij| :

7/31/2019 Fredrick Toben Reviews "Holocaust Denial and Operation Reinhard"

12/20

4=

Dhmj}wn( @nladjh( Gnj Rj}bchizki zkg Rj}knlawzki gj} Ozgjk n` ]jnla|idz Yd}wajhdkg 4>-4>7:+

Ynj|mdgjk( =5526 Dki}nlf( Dkg}jo dkg Ynwwj( Ujwj}( Waj -bnkdh |chzwnck- nk ]nid? jquhcnwdwnck dkg

dkknanhdwnck( 4>744>77+ Cqbc}g? Mj}iadak( =55>6 Dki}nlf( Dkg}jo( Dkknanhdwnck dkg Hdmc}? Ojy|

dkg Wac}cziabd}j NR nk Ljkw}dh Zf}dnkj nk ]d~ M}dkgck dkg Yjkg~ Hcyj} !jg|.( Waj \acda nk

Zf}dnkj( Nkgndkduchn|? Nkgndkd Zknrj}|nw~ U}j||( =5526 Dki}nlf( Dkg}jo( Ijc}i @nladjh|jk

Adkghzki|}jn|jkgj} gj} Jkgh|zki nk @dhh`dkk#Udzh !jg|.( Fd}}nj}jk gj} Ijydhw( uu+4:242:6

Dki}nlf( Dkg}jo( Mj|dwzki|uchnwnf zkg @d||jk`c}g+ Gnj Jnk|dwi}zuuj G nk gj} |ghnlajk

\cyojwzknck 4>74-4>716 M}cyknki( La}n|wcuaj} ]+(

Jrngjklj bc} waj N`uhj`jkwdwnck cb waj Bnkdh \chzwnck( gjbjklj |zm`n||nck( N}rnki r Hnu|wdgw(

=5556 Luuj}|( @d}wnk( Yjimj}jnwj} gj} \acda+ Gnj Ydbbjk-\\( gj} Fc``dkgc|wdm ]jnla|ba}j}-

\\ zkg gnj Ozgjkrj}knlawzki 4>-4>7:+ Gd}`|wdgw? Yn||jk|ladbwhnlaj Mzlaij|jhh|ladbw( =55:6

Gj|mcn|( Udw}nlf( Waj Achcldz|w m~ Mzhhjw|( Kjy ^c}f? Udhi}drj @dl`nhhdk( =5516 Hckij}nla( Ujwj}(

Anwhj})| ]chj nk waj Uj}|jlzwnck cb waj Ojy| m~ waj Kdn ]jin j? Jhjlw}cknl Rj}|nck( gjbjklj

gclz`jkw nk N}rnki r+ Hnu|wdgw( =5556 Hckij}nla( Ujwj}( Waj Zky}nwwjk C}gj}? Anwhj}| ]chj nk waj

Bnkdh \chzwnck+ \w}czg? Wj`uz|( =5546 Ujhw( ]cmj}w Odk rdk( Waj Ld|j bc} Dz|laynw+ Jrngjklj

b}c` waj N}rnki W}ndh+ Mhcc`nkiwck? Nkgndkd Zknrj}|nw~ U}j||( =55=6 Yjbnki( Ajnk}nla( Gj} Bdhh

Gj`odkozf? gj} hjwwj i}c||j K\-U}cj||+ Gd| Hjmjk( gj} U}cj||( gd| Z}wjnh+ Mj}hnk? Mjlf( =544+

2+ ]jrn|nckn|w Hnwj}dwz}j( hn|w| >1 mccf| lckwdnknki waj `doc} ]jrn|nckn|w yc}f|+

Waj bnkdh udij cb wan| mccf( :95( hn|w| waj D}lanrdh dkg Ocz}kdh Dmm}jrndwnck| z|jg nk

waj wjqw( Ocz}kdh| }jbj}jkljg dkg B}jtzjkwh~ Lnwjg mccf|+

Zkbc}wzkdwjh~ waj}j n| kc Nkgjq cb jnwaj} Kd`j| c} \zmojlw|( yanla |j}ncz|h~ hn`nw| wajz|jbzhkj|| cb wan| mccf d| d |cz}lj bc} }j|jd}la+ Dhwaczia waj}j n| d wjkgjkl~ bc}

ucuzhd} bdlwzdh mccf| wc mj uzmhn|ajg ynwaczw dk Nkgjq( nk d wc`j cb :95 udij| nw |aczhg

|wnhh mj cmhnidwc}~ wc adrj dk nkgjq+ N d` wankfnki cb lc`uzwj} u}ci}d`| wadw gc nw

|ynbwh~( mzw wajk }jldhh acy `~ jgnwc} |wnhh }jhnj| ck uhczianki wa}czia d mccf( udijm~

udij( wc d||j`mhj dk Nkgjq wadw d||n|w| waj }jdgj} wc idnk dk jrjk i}jdwj} gjwdnhjg

crj}rnjy cb yadw ad| mjjk y}nwwjk( nk wan| nk|wdklj( b}c` udij 4 wc udij :95+ Dk Nkgjq

yczhg nk wan| dij cb nkbc}`dwnck crj}hcdg d||n|w nk lhd}nb~nki |c`jwn`j lckbz|nki(

lckw}dgnlwc}~( }jujwnwncz|( n}}jhjrdkw dkg gjljuwnrj `dwj}ndh+

Waj mccf lckwdnk| =74@d}la 4>7=++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++>7

Jrchzwnck cb Jz}cujYngj Bnkdh \chzwnck( \juwj`mj} Gjlj`mj} 4>74++++++++++++++++++++++++++45>Hcldh Jqwj}`nkdwnck|? Lajh`kc( \j}mnd dkg ]jnla Ojy| nk ]F C|whdkg ++++++++++++++++++++++++++4=5

7/31/2019 Fredrick Toben Reviews "Holocaust Denial and Operation Reinhard"

13/20

47= @d}la 4>7< ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++47=++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++4

Lcklhz|nck++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++47?44 hnj ad| kcy

hd|wjg wjk ~jd}|+ \zla lz}}jkw hnj| d}j dh`c|w ld}mck lcunj| cb waj Achcldz|w\acda

kd}}dwnrj d ua~|nldh jrjkw n| jquhdnkjg ynwa dk crj}d}lanki mcg~ cb hnj|+ Dk~ckj yac

fkcy| oz|w d hnwwhj dmczw ua~|nl| dkg laj`n|w}~ fkcy| wadw waj Yc}hg W}dgj Ljkw}j Wynk

Wcyj}| yj}j m}cziaw gcyk m~ lckw}chhjg gj`chnwnck( kcw m~ waj bn}j ldz|jg m~ waj uhdkj|

l}d|anki nkwc waj` dkg wadw Mznhgnki 9 hnfjyn|j yd| m}cziaw gcyk( d| Hd}}~ \nhrj}|wjnk(

waj cykj} cb waj wcyj}| dkg waj mjkjbnlnd}~ cb wyc azij wj}}c}n|w jrjkw| nk|z}dklj

ud~czw|( nkbc}`jg waj yc}hg? Yj gjlngjg wc uzhh nw+

D| wc @~j}| }jbj}jklj wadw aj ldk |~`udwanj ynwa OjdkLhdzgj U}j||dl( nw lckbn}`| `~

rnjy wadw ]jrn|nckn|w| d}j waj wankfj}| yanhj waj Achcldz|w\acda mjhnjrj}| d}j kck

l}nwnldh nk bdlw( }j`dnk mjhnjrj}| cb d kd}}dwnrj wadw ldkkcw m j |z|wdnkjg dk~`c}j+ N

rn|nwjg U}j||dl dw an| uad}`dl~ dkg wajk dw an| ac`j nk 4>>9+ Aj |dng wadw an|

]jrn|nckn|w |wdklj |wnhh |wccg dkg wadw aj }ji}jwwjg waj b}dlwz}j mjwyjjk an`|jhb dkg

Bdz}n||ck+ Dhwaczia aj yd| |wnhh lc``zknldwnki ynwa cwaj} kcwdmhj ]jrn|nckn|w|( nw

mjld`j `c}j gnbbnlzhw mjldz|j aj kjjgjg wc `dfj d hnrnki dkg Ojyn|a ucyj} nk B}dklj

yd| wcc i}jdw bc} an wc cuuc|j+ Aj }jlczkwjg acy Fhd}|bjhg |udw wa}czia waj

wjhjuackj dw an` bc} }jbz|nki wc dlljuw dhh cb waj wa}jj unhhd}| cb waj Achcldz|w\acda

kd}}dwnrj+

U}j||dl| Dz|laynw nkrj|wnidwnck( aj lhdn`jg( nkgnldwjg wadw waj `dkzbdlwz}j}| cb waj

l}j`dwc}nd crjk|( Wcub " \akj( adg waj ldudlnw~ wc `dfj ac`nlngdh id| lad`mj}|+

U}j||dl adg cmwdnkjg dkg nk an| uc||j||nck waj lc`uhjwj Wcub " \akj lc`udk~ bnhj|+ N

yckgj} yadw aduujkjg wc wan| `dwj}ndh+ Nw }j`nkg| `j yajk waj @zbwn cb Oj}z|dhj` gnjg(

waj `dk yac gz}nki waj yd} |ujkw wn`j nk Mj}hnk+ ]cmj}w Bn|f lhdn`| wadw dbwj} an| gjdwa

|c`jckj lchhjlwjg an| hnm}d}~ dkg wccf nw wc N|}djh+ D bjy ~jd}| dic waj}j duujd}jg dlc``jkw nk |c`j uduj} wadw waj @zbwn adg mjjk dyd}j cb waj Achcldz|w id||nki|( c}

yc}g| wc wadw jbbjlw+ Wadw| waj `doc} u}cmhj` j`j}inki czw cb d |wzg~ cb waj Achcldz|w

\acda kd}}dwnrj mjldz|j wcc `dk~ u}canmnwnck| adrj mjjk uhdljg ck cujk dkg b}jj

}j|jd}la+ Waj kd}}dwnrj n| d lck|w}zlwjg oz|wnbnldwnck ynwaczw dk~ }jbj}jklj wc waj w}zwa cb

waj `dwwj} nw aduujkjg dkg dk~ckj yac gczmw| nw ynhh mj uzkn|ajg+

Nk j||jklj nw n| @~j}| |nhh~ kcwnck| dmczw ]jrn|nckn|` wadw n`udlw gn}jlwh~ ck an| tzdhnw~

cb }j|jd}la+ Wc waj ~czkij} ijkj}dwnck cb ]jrn|nckn|w wankfj}| nw kjjg| wc mj |w}j||jg

wadw waj}j n| kc `ckj~ wc mj `dgj b}c` mjlc`nki d gn||jkwj}( d Achcldz|w tzj|wnckj}( d

|cldhhjg Achcldz|w gjknj} yac mhnkgh~ }jbz|j| wc mjhnjrj nk d kd}}dwnrj wadw n| gjjuh~

bhdyjg `jwacgchcinldhh~ dkg nkwjhhjlwzdhh~+ Nk bdlw( nb dk nkgnrngzdh |jjf| waj w}zwa cb dkan|wc}nldh `dwwj}( j|ujlndhh~ lcklj}knki yadw aduujkjg gz}nki Yc}hg Yd} Wyc( wajk

7/31/2019 Fredrick Toben Reviews "Holocaust Denial and Operation Reinhard"

17/20

49

mjyd}j dkg jk|z}j ~cz d}j bnkdklndhh~ |jlz}j dkg |dbjizd}gjg d| wc adrnki d ac`j+

]jrn|nckn|w| d}j gn|`dkwhnki d `zhwnmnhhnck gchhd} nkgz|w}~ cb hnj| dkg gjljnw( dkg nw n| ckh~

kdwz}dh cb wac|j yac adrj u}cbnwjg dkg `dgj d hnrnki czw cb nw wadw waj~ ynhh `dfj z|j cb

dk~ nk|w}z`jkw wadw jkdmhj| waj` wc achg ck wc wajn} |cz}lj cb nklc`j+ \zla nkgnrngzdh|

gckw ld}j dmczw w}zwawjhhnki mjldz|j bc} waj` w}zwa n| d |clndh lck|w}zlw dkg dk~wanki

wadw ldk mj oz|wnbnjg wc mj waj w}zwa ynhh mj dgcuwjg+

Waj}j d}j kc |l}zuhj| |z}}czkgnki wac|j `nkg| wadw mjhnjrj nk dkg lckwnkzj wc lck|w}zlw

dkg j`mjhhn|a waj Achcldz|w\acda kd}}dwnrj+ Bd} b}c` nw( waj~ d}j jquj}w| nk gjbd`nki

dk~ckj yac gn|di}jj| ynwa waj`( dkg waj z|zdh |azwzu yc}g| c} gn|lz||nck |wcuuj}|

d}j z|jg mjldz|j waj~rj hc|w waj d}iz`jkw? adwj}( Achcldz|w gjknj}( dkwn\j`nwj(

}dln|w( qjkcuacmj( dkg kcy jrjk wj}}c}n|w+ ]jrn|nckn|w| adrj yck waj d}iz`jkw ck

uduj} mzw waj~ hdlf waj ucyj} wc m}jdf wa}czia waj hjidh |a}czg wadw |wnhh u}cwjlw| waj

cbbnlndh Achcldz|w\acda kd}}dwnrj+

95| lck|n|wjg cb bdklnbzh kck|jk|j+ Kcw zkwnh Ynhhn| Ld}wc

j|wdmhn|ajg waj Nk|wnwzwj bc} An|wc}nldh ]jrnjy NA] yd| waj}j d lcklj}wjg jbbc}w `dgj m~

dk~ckj |~|wj`dwnldhh~ wc }jbzwj waj }zmmn|a wadw `dgj zu waj Achcldz|w\acda kd}}dwnrj+Bc}wzkdwjh~( ]jrn|nckn|w| adrj hjbw d gjwdnhjg }jlc}g cb yadw Achcldz|w\acda mjhnjrj}| adg wc

ladkij nk }j|uck|j wc waj jqdlwnwzgj cb ]jrn|nckn|w| }j|jd}la+ Yac |wnhh }j`j`mj}| wadw waj |cdu

|wc}~ dw ckj wn`j yd| mjhnjrjg wc mj d bdlw Ij}`dk| wz}kjg Ojy| nkwc |cdu$

D| wc Dz|laynw nw yd| waj mjhnjrj}| u}ngjdkgoc~ zkwnh waj ]jrn|nckn|w| |~|wj`dwnldhh~

gj`chn|ajg nw( yanla yd| gckj m~ J}k|w _kgjh nk an| Wc}ckwc w}ndh|( j|ujlndhh~ waj 4>11 }jw}ndh

yaj}j bc} waj hd|w wn`j d Achcldz|w\acda ynwkj|| dkg `dwwj}| cb bdlw yj}j cujkh~ ldkrd||jg nk

lcz}w+ Waj }jdlwnck wc Waj Hjzlawj} ]juc}w dkg hdwj} wc Waj ]zgchb ]juc}w mjidk waj |anbw

dyd~ b}c` Dz|laynw mjldz|j ]jrn|nckn|w }j|jd}la adg gj`chn|ajg wan| ld`u d| dk jqwj}`nkdwnck

ld`u+ Yc}f| wadw lhdn` wc adrj }jbzwjg waj |lnjkwnbnl d}iz`jkw d}j bchhcynki waj udwwj}k kcy

dgcuwjg m~ wac|j yac yn|a wc u}crj wadw Lhn dwj Ladkij#Ihcmdh Yd}`nki n| }jdh+ Waj}j n| d

b}jk~ ynwank waj |lnjkwnbnl lc``zknw~ dkg wac|j yac d}j |ljuwnldh dkg }jh~ ck waj |lnjkwnbnl`jwacg yanla kjrj} u}cgzlj| d 455 uj} ljkw u}ccb cb d wajc}~ d}j kcy hdmjhhjg lhn`dwj

ladkij gjknj}|( oz|w d hnwwhj |a~ cb wac|j g}jdgjg Achcldz|w gjknj}|$

Wc wan| gd~ kcckj ad| bzhbnhhjg waj Bdz}n||ck ladhhjkij? \acy `j c} g}dy `j waj ac`nlngdh id|

lad`mj}| dw Dz|laynw+ Yadwjrj} ]cmj}wc @zjahjkfd`u y}nwj| dmczw wan| ladhhjkij n| `j}j

yc}g|( azbbdkguzbbdkgmhzbb yc}g| dw wadw+ N adrj d lcz}w c}gj} wadw jrjk u}jrjkw| `~

tzj|wncknki waj jqn|wjklj cb ac`nlngdh id| lad`mj}| dw Dz|laynw$ Nw n| yc}|j nk Ij}`dk~( Dz|w}nd

dkg cwaj} Jz}cujdk lczkw}nj|+ W}zwa gcj| kcw }jtzn}j hjidh u}cwjlwnck mzw hnj| lj}wdnkh~ gc+

Nk 4>>2 nw yd| ]cmj}wOdk rdk Ujhw dkg Gjmc}da Gyc}f nk wajn}? Dz|laynw+ 4=95 wc waj

u}j|jkw( yaj}jnk F}j`d N yd| gjlc``n||nckjg( dkg F}j`d NN dw Dz|laynwMn}fjkdz mjld`j waj

bcldh ucnkw+

7/31/2019 Fredrick Toben Reviews "Holocaust Denial and Operation Reinhard"

18/20

41

Nk =55= B}nwocb @j~j} gd}jg uhdlj waj `z}gj} `dlankj nk wyc kckjqn|wjkw bd}` acz|j|+ Aj

j|ldujg hjidh u}c|jlzwnck nk Ij}`dk~ mjldz|j aj lhdn`jg wadw an| dkdh~|n| gng kcw gczmw waj

Achcldz|w\acda( wadw nw }j`dnk| dk an|wc}nldh bdlw+

Nk J}}ch @c}}n| bnh`? @} Gjdwa+ Waj ]n|j dkg Bdhh cb B}jg D+ Hjzlawj}( O}( 4= @d~ 4>>>( nw n|

]cmj}wOdk Rdk Ujhw yac `dfj| waj bchhcynki lhdn`|?

Hjzlawj} n| d rnlwn` cb waj `~wa cb \aj}hclf Ach`j|+ D l}n`j ad| mjjk lc``nwwjg+ ^cz ic wc waj |nwj

cb waj l}n`j dkg ynwa d `diknb~nki ihd|| ~cz bnkg d adn}( c} ~cz bnkg d |ujlf cb gz|w ck waj |acj+

Hjzlawj} wankf| wadw n| waj yd~ }jdhnw~ ldk mj }jlck|w}zlwjg+ Mzw aj n| kc \aj}hclf Ach j|+ Aj

gcj|k)w adrj waj w}dnknki+ Nw yd| kcw wadw aj m}cziaw dk~ jquj}njklj( waj |ujlnbnl jquj}njklj

kjjgjg wc hccf dw }znkjg mznhgnki|+ Waj ckh~ jquj}njklj aj adg yd| gj|nik `cgnbnldwnck| bc} waj

@n||cz}n id| lad`mj}| nk Odlf|ckrnhhj+

/

Dz|laynw n| hnfj waj ach~ cb achnj|+ N u}jud}jg ~jd}| wc ic waj}j dkg wc adrj d bcch lc`j nk( lc`j nk

lc`uhjwjh~ zku}jud}jg( nw)| |dl}nhjij+ \c`jmcg~ yac ydhf| nkwc waj ach~ cb achnj| dkg gcj|k)w inrj

d gd`k+

\c( kcy |lnjkwnbnl }j|jd}la ad| mjlc`j d `dwwj} cb cm|j}rnki |c`j fnkg cb }jhnincz| }nwzdh$

B}jg Hjzlawj}| }j|uck|j n| |lnjkwnbnl? N jqujlwjg wc |jj bdlnhnwnj| wadw lczhg adrj mjjk z|jg d| id|lad`mj}|+ N jqujlwjg wc |jj d}jd| wadw yj}j jquhc|ncku}ccb+ N jqujlwjg wc |jj d}jd| wadw yj}j

hjdfu}ccb+ Waj}j adrj wc mj achj| nk ydhh| c} d}jd| yaj}j waj~ adg jqadz|w bdk| dkg unuj|+ Waj}j

ad| wc mj |c`jwanki wc }j`crj waj id| dbwj} nw ad| mjjk uzw nkwc waj }cc`+ Waj}j ad| wc mj |c`j

fnkg cb d gjrnlj wc ajdw waj ladhf ujhhjw| dkg |zmhn`dwj waj id| wc ijw nw wc ic nkwc waj dn}+ Waj|j

wanki| gngk)w jqn|w+

Rdk Ujhw lckwnkzj| |jwwnki waj |ljkj mzw aj bc}ijw| wadw ua~|nldh bdlw| |ujdf bc} waj`|jhrj| dkg gc

kcw kjjg wc mj nkwj}u}jwjg( zkhj|| waj}j n| d gjljuwnrj hcinl mjankg waj }j|jd}la d|( jqn|w| bc}

jqd`uhj( waj >?44 kd}}dwnrj lhdn`nki wadw uhdkj| ldz|jg waj YWL Wynk Wcyj}| wc mz}|w nkwc bhd`j|

dkg lchhdu|j( oz|w hnfj d lckw}chhjg gj`chnwnck+

Dz|laynw n| rj}~( rj}~ gnbbj}jkw b}c` waj uhdlj nw yd| gz}nki waj yd}+ Jrj}~wanki ad| ladkijg

wa}jj c} bcz} wn`j| |nklj wadw ld`u cuj}dwjg d| dk jqwj}`nkdwnck ld`u+ Waj md}}dlf| d}j bnbw~ ~jd}|

chg( waj~)}j `chg~( waj~ |`jhh mdg+ Nw)| kcw waj |`jhh cb waj yd} nw)| waj |`jhh cb gjld~( cb bnbw~

~jd}| cb mjnki jquc|jg wc waj jhj`jkw|+ Waj}j)| kc yd~ wadw yajk ~cz ic wc waj l}j`dwc}nd ~cz

}jdhh~ ldk zkgj}|wdkg yadw nw yd| wc mj hjg waj}j d| d rnlwn`( wc adrj wc zkg}j|| dkg mj hjg nk waj

id| lad`mj}+ Mzw yajk ~cz d}j nk waj mznhgnki d}lanrj nw n| uc||nmhj wc }jn`dinkj yadw waj uhdlj

yd| hnfj gz}nki waj yd}+

Waj bn}|w wn`j N ld`j nkwc waj d}lanrj N yd| |wzkkjg+ N adg bczkg d `n||nck( N adg bczkg d wd|f( N)g

bczkg d rcldwnck+ Yajk ~cz ic wc Mn}fjkdz waj}j n| rj}~ hnwwhj hjbw dkg wc |zggjkh~ adrj nk wadw

}cc` wadw lckljkw}dwnck cb jrngjklj+ Waj}j n| d wdlwnhj }jdhnw~( dk nkl}jgnmhj wjqwz}j( waj wjqwz}j cb

`dfnki wadw ld`u+

Nb Hjzlawj} adg ickj wc waj d}lanrj|( nb aj adg |ujkw wn`j nk waj d}lanrj|( aj yczhg)rj bczkg

jrngjklj dmczw rjkwnhdwnck |~|wj |( jrngjklj dmczw yd~| wc nkw}cgzlj _~fhck M nkwc waj|jmznhgnki|( jrngjklj cb id| lad`mj}|( zkg}j||nki }cc`|+ Mzw wajk cb lcz}|j( N gck)w wankf aj fkcy|

Ij}`dk( |c nw yczhgk)w adrj ajhujg rj}~ `zla+

Kcwj Rdk Ujhw| |wdwj`jkw? Mzw yajk ~cz d}j nk waj mznhgnki d}lanrj nw n| uc||nmhj wc }jn`dinkjyadw waj uhdlj yd| hnfj gz}nki waj yd}+

Wan| n| jqdlwh~ waj |zmojlwnrj |wdwj cb `nkg wadw d |lnjkwn|w dwwj`uw| wc drcng bdhhnki nkwc

yajk jkidijg nk }j|jd}la+ Nw n| }j`nkn|ljkw cb waj ]c|jkmhdw `nkg|jw? Nw yd| kcw d hnj+

Nk `~ `nkg nw yd| w}zj$

Wajk( cb lcz}|j( waj Achcldz|w\acda mjhnjrj}| dhyd~| lhdn` `c|w ]jrn|nckn|w| d}j

lck|un}dl~ kzwwj}|+ Aj}j n| Rdk Ujhw jquhdnknki d u}cmhj`?

7/31/2019 Fredrick Toben Reviews "Holocaust Denial and Operation Reinhard"

19/20

4>

Waj}j yd| d lcgj+ Waj Ij}`dk| adg d lcgjg hdkizdij+ ^cz kjrj} wdhf dmczw jqwj}`nkdwnck( ~cz

dhyd~| wdhf dmczw -|ujlndh dlwnck(- c} -|ujlndh w}jdw`jkw+- Waj}j yd| d rj}~ lhjd} uchnl~6 yc}g| hnfj

id| lad`mj} yczhg kcw mj z|jg+ Waj hjwwj} cb Mn|lacbb cb waj =>wa cb Odkzd}~( n| d fnkg cb jqljuwnck

nk wan|( mjldz|j nw n| d hjwwj} yanla n| y}nwwjk m~ d uj}|ck yac `dkdij| waj yachj cuj}dwnck( dkg

yac an`|jhb adg j|wdmhn|ajg d uchnl~ wadw ~cz yczhg kjrj} z|j waj yc}g )id| lad`mj}+) \c`jmcg~

nk waj d}lanwjlwz}j cbbnlj zkgj}hnkjg waj yc}g rj}id|zki|fjhhj}( hnwj}dhh~ id||nki md|j`jkw( dkg

uzw ck wcu d kcwj? -\\ Zkwj}|wz}`bza}j} Fn}|lakjlf+ Yanla `jdk|( Fn}|lakjlf |aczhg mj nkbc}`jgdmczw wan| |hnu+ Dkg nw gcj|k)w cllz} dbwj} wadw+ Waj Kdn| yj}j waj bn}|w Achcldz|w gjknj}|+ Mjldz|j

waj~ gjknjg wc waj`|jhrj| wadw nw)| aduujknki+

Wan| n| waj `nkg|jw wadw waj dzwac}| cb waj lz}}jkw rchz`j adrj bzhh~ j`m}dljg+ Nw n|

wajn} nkwj}u}jwnrj ucyj}|( |c waj~ dhhjij dkg wadw ]jrn|nckn|w| gc kcw uc||j||( yanla

jkdmhj| waj` wc u}crj waj Achcldz|w\acda wc mj w}zj+

Wajk hdwj} nk waj Nkw}cgzlwnck waj dzwac}| w}cw czw waj z|zdh |z|ujlw| d| }jhndmhj

ynwkj||j|( |c`jwanki ]jrn|nckn|w| dkg jrjk Mjhnjrj}| adrj |acyk wc mj zk}jhndmhj+ Odk

Fd}|fn }j`dnk| d b}dzg nk waj ]c|jkmhdw `czhg jqljuw wadw Fd}|fn| jrngjklj ad| mjjk

nklc}uc}dwjg nk |c `dk~ Achcldz|w\acda kd}}dwnrj| wadw nw ad| mjlc`j dk

j`md}}d||`jkw wc jrjk kcwj an| kd`j nk wan| mccf+

D bz}waj} l}zlndh }juc}w( lc`mnknki nkbc}`dwnck lc`unhjg m~ Ckji \admj| ynwa Uchn|a zkgj}i}czkg

|cz}lj|( yd| m}cziaw czw m~ waj Uchn|a zkgj}i}czkg lcz}nj} Odk Fd}|fn nk Kcrj`mj} 4>7=+

Nk waj |jlckg ud}di}dua cb waj Nkw}cgzlwnck waj gjljuwnck lckwnkzj| ynwa waj lhdn`

wadw nw n| ]jrn|nckn|w| yac |anbwjg dyd~ b}c` Dz|laynw( j|ujlndhh~ dbwj} waj N}rnki r

Hnu|wdgw Hckgck =555 w}ndh+ Nw n| lhdn`jg wadw ]jrn|nckn|w| hc|w waj d}iz`jkw nk cujk

lcz}w+

\zla d |wdwj`jkw n| uz}j }zmmn|a+ N}rnki cbbj}jg wc ljd|j hjidh dlwnck dkg `dfj d

gckdwnck wc lad}nw~ nb waj lcz}w yczhg rn|nw Dz|laynw F}j`d NN dw Mn}fjkdz+ Aj |w}j||jg

wadw an| bclz| yczhg mj ck waj id||nki u}cljgz}j mcwwhjkjlf ldz|jg m~ rnlwn`| ydnwnkink waj zkg}j||nki }cc`( mcgnj| ydnwnki wc mj wdfjk wc waj |`dhh hnbw wadw wccf waj` wc waj

l}j`dwnck crjk|( dkg waj dlwzdh l}j`dwnck cb mcgnj|+ Wan| ua~|nldh u}clj||? d}}nrdh

zkg}j|| id| l}j`dwj gn|uc|j cb d|a ldk mj yc}fjg czw( ldk mj ldhlzhdwjg nk }jdh

wn`j+

@~ Gjlj`mj} =552 Wjaj}dk Achcldz|w Lckbj}jklj u}j|jkwdwnck bclz|jg ck waj W}jmhnkfd

u}clj|| yaj}j dggnwnckdh |wju| yj}j m}cziaw nk? d}}nrdh zkg}j|| id| mz}}~

jqaz`j l}j`dwj dkg wadw 155(555 mcgnj|$ Wadw| dllc}gnki wc waj cbbnlndh

an|wc}nci}dua~ cb waj ld`u+

Mzw dk~ ]jrn|nckn|w| cb kcwj yac gd}j| `dfj |zla |wdwj`jkw| nk cujk lcz}w nk d lczkw}~yaj}j waj Achcldz|w\acda kd}}dwnrj n| hjidhh~ u}cwjlwjg ynhh bdlj dggnwnckdh odnhwn j

mjldz|j cynki wc an| `nkg|jw aj ldkkcw mj }jadmnhnwdwjg yanhj nk u}n|ck dkg |c `z|w

|j}rj czw waj bzhh |jkwjklj( d| adrj \~hrnd \wch( Ij}`d} ]zgchb dkg J}k|w _kgjh cb

}jljkw gdwj+

Ajklj waj bdh|j lhdn` `dgj m~ waj dzwac}| cb wan| lc``nwwjj mccf?

\zla d bdnhz}j lj}wdnkh~ uzw| waj hnj wc waj cbwajd}g gj`dkg m~ ]jrn|nckn|w| wadw waj~ ydkw cujk

gjmdwj ck waj Achcldz|w+

Nw n| kcw uc||nmhj wc gn|lz|| nk cujk bc}z` `dwwj}| Achcldz|w\acda yajk hdy| adrj

mjjk jkdlwjg dkg( bc} jqd`uhj zkgj} waj Jz}cujdk D}}j|w Yd}}dkw( waj~ d}j lhd||nbnjgzkgj} }dln|` dkg qjkcuacmnd+

7/31/2019 Fredrick Toben Reviews "Holocaust Denial and Operation Reinhard"

20/20

=5

Mzw waj wckj dgcuwjg m~ waj dzwac} lchhjlwnrj ijw| `c}j gj|uj}dwj dkg dmz|nrj( d| ldk

mj jqujlwjg yaj}j mzhh~mc~ @zjahjkfd`u n| dlwnrj?

Nw yd| dh|c d ladklj wc jkoc~ waj |dwn|bdlwnck cb jquc|nki |acgg~ dkg gjljnwbzh an|wc}~+ Yj bjjh

wadw( gj|unwj waj lhdn`| cb |c`j lc``jkwdwc}| wadw }jbzwnki Achcldz|w gjkndh n| d yd|wj cb jbbc}w(

waj cuuc}wzknw~ wc gjmzkf waj czwuzw cb u|jzgc|lachd}| n| ckj wadw |aczhg mj wdfjk bc} nw| cyk

|dfj+ Nw gcj| kcw `jdk wadw yj }jid}g gjknj}| d| jtzdh gjmdwnki ud}wkj}| ck dk nkwjhhjlwzdh c}jwanldh hjrjh6 nk|wjdg( yj u}cljjg nk waj fkcyhjgij wadw gjknj}| cuj}dwj nk nikc}dklj dkg mdg bdnwa+

Waj dmcrj wa}jj |jkwjklj| |ujdf bc} waj`|jhrj| dkg wan| fnkg cb wckj( yanla uj}rdgj|

wa}cziaczw waj :95udij rchz`j nkgnldwj| wc `j wadw waj dzwac}| d}j dlwzdhh~

crj}lc`ujk|dwnki mjldz|j waj~ d}j jnwaj} nikc}dkw cb waj ua~|nldh bdlw|( h~nki c} mcwa+

Dk~ckj |jlz}j nk waj fkcyhjgij cb d bdlwzdh `dwwj} gcj| kcw adrj wc dgcuw |zla

dii}j||nrj |wdklj( dkg wan| nkgnldwj| wc `j waj}j n| |c`jwanki |j}ncz|h~ y}cki ynwa

waj|j nkgnrngzdh| rdhzj |~|wj`+ Ya~ n| lnrnhnjg gn|lcz}|j kcw uc||nmhj3 Nw n| waj mzhh~

mc~ yac ad| hjidh u}cwjlwnck dkg kcy |jjf| wc ad``j} ac`j an| rnjy cb wanki| mjldz|j

aj fkcy| waj ]jrn|nckn|w| adrj wajn} adkg| hjidhh~ wnjg+

Dh|c waj lhdn` wc ucuzhd}nw~( cb }jljnrnki |c `dk~ anw| ck wajn} yjm|nwj }j`nkg| `j cb

waj `dwwj} wadw Ic}gck Gzbb }dn|jg yajk aj lhdn`jg aj yd| `c}j ucuzhd} wa}czia waj

Iccihj |jd}la }j|zhw| wadk N yd| d| nb N ld}jg dmczw ucuzhd}nw~ }dwnki|$ dkg d| wyc

hdgnj| adrj mj}dwjg `~ wjhhnki d wd|wjhj|| |wc}~( N |adhh kcw }jujdw `~ hnwwhj |wc}~ dmczw

waj u}n|ckj} yac mj`cdkjg waj bdlw wadw kc `dwwj} yadw aj gng aj lczhg kcw idnk

ucuzhd}nw~ d`cki an| nk`dwj|+ N` |z}u}n|jg wadw wan| dzwac} lchhjlwnrj kjjgjg wc |w}j||

|zla `dwwj}| mjldz|j W}zwa |wdkg| ck nw| cyk dkg gcj| kcw kjjg dk~ ucuzhd}nw~ lckwj|w(

lj}wdnkh~ kcw d uj}|ckdhnw~ ucuzhd}nw~ lckwj|w+

Wadw I}dbb( @dwwcikc dkg Fzj| d}j l}nwnln|jg bc} hdlf cb l}jgjkwndh| }j`nkg| `j cb L \

Ujn}lj ck yac|j wajc}~ cb bdhhnmnhn|` N y}cwj `~ waj|n|+ Ujn}lj( waj gjrjhcuj} cb waj

hcinldh bc}` cb dmgzlwnck wajc}~ bc}`dwnck dh|c yd| l}nwnln|jg bc} kcw mjnki dm|chzwjh~

lj}wdnk cb |c`j bdlw|( yanla aj lck|ngj}jg wc mj u}dn|j `jdkw d| mhd`j$ Nk |lnjklj

kcwanki n| dm|chzwj dkg wan| n| yaj}j waj lhn`dwj ladkij u}cuckjkw| d}j bdnhnki wajn}

l}jgnmnhnzw~ wj|w( j|ujlndhh~ yajk waj~ lhdn` wadw waj |lnjklj cb lhn`dwj ladkij n|

|jwwhjg+

Ajklj( waj bchhcynki lc``jkw n| d kck|jk|j?

bc} kckj cb waj wa}jj adrj |zm`nwwjg dk~wanki bc} d ujj}}jrnjyjg ocz}kdh !kc gjknj} yc}f n|

ujj}}jrnjyjg d| waj}j |n uh~ d}j kc ujj}| bc} waj`.( kc} gc dk~ cb waj` adrj zknrj}|nw~

l}jgjkwndh|+ Waz|( waj}j n| kc oz|wnbnldwnck wadw lc`ujh| dldgj`nl| wc dzwc`dwnldhh~ wdfj waj`

|j}ncz|h~+ Nkgjjg( wan| l}nwntzj |acy| ya~ ]jrn|nckn|w d}iz`jkw| d}j dk~wanki mzw+

Wan| }j`nkg| `j cb wac|j yac( hnfj U}cb Hnu|wdgw( dllz|j dk~ckj yac gn|di}jj| dkg

}jbz|j| mhnkgh~ wc mjhnjrj aj} }zmmn|a ldhhjg Achcldz|w\acda wc mj d ADWJ]+ \aj n|

dlwzdhh~ gj|l}nmnki aj} cyk `nkg|jw mzw gj|uj}dwjh~ w}~nki wc gjbhjlw b}c` nw( dkg nw n| d

w~unldh mzhh~ wdlwnl cb azbbdkguzbbdkgmhzbb+

DKG KCY I]DB ynwa an| j`dnh cb \dwz}gd~( 9 Odkzd}~ =54= 1?:> U@ lc`j| wc waj

}j|lzj dkg N ldk ljd|j lckwnkznki wc ydgj wa}czia waj }j`dnknki :55& udij|+

SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS