+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing...

Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing...

Date post: 23-Jun-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
47
Free Trade Agreements – a global perspective March 2015 www.pwc.com/ch
Transcript
Page 1: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

Free Trade Agreements – a global perspective

March 2015

www.pwc.com/ch

Page 2: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Agenda

Part 1 Introduction by Ambassador Thomas Kupfer

Part 2 European Overview

Part 3 Free Trade Agreement – an overview

Part 4 Practical and operational challenges in Free Trade Agreements

Part 5 Future Free Trade Agreements

Part 6 Q&A - Closing

2

Page 3: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Introduction by Ambassador Thomas Kupfer

3

3 March 2015 Free Trade Agreements

Page 4: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

European Overview

4

3 March 2015 Free Trade Agreements

Page 5: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Estonia

France

Germany

Greece

Italy

Luxembourg

Portugal

Spain

Switzerland

US

-

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

2000

2001

2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

2012

% o

f G

DP

Austria Belgium Cyprus

Estonia Finland France

Germany Greece Ireland

Italy Luxembourg Malta

Netherlands Portugal Slovak Republic

Slovenia Spain Switzerland

US

Public debt as % of GDP

Source: IMF

Evolution of the Euro crisis

s

tim

ula

tio

n

Public debt as % of GDP Late 2009: Increasing government debt

Early 2010: Intensified concerns in certain European countries

May-2010: 1st Greece bail-out package (€ 100bn)

Creation of European Financial Stability Facility (EFSF)

Nov-2010: Ireland bail-out package (€67.5bn)

Jan- 2011: Created European Financial Stability Mechanism (EFSM)

May-2011: Portugal bail-out package (€70bn)

Oct-2011: 2nd Greece bail-out package (€130bn 50% write-off Greek debt €100bn)

Jun-2012: Spain bail-out package (€100bn)

Mid-2013: Replace EFSF & EFSM with European Stability Mechanism (EFM)

Free Trade Agreements 3 March 2015

5

Page 6: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

-1.0

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

2000 - 05 2006 - 09 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017

% GDP Growth

EU

UK

US

EU Growth forecast

Sources: European Commission, IMF, World Bank, Oanda, Bloomberg, Reuters,Scotiabank, PwC Analysis

European Union % GDP Growth, 2000 - 17 2014 Slow recovery: Unfinished macroeconomic adjustment Slow implementation of reforms Failure in recovery of investments

2015 – 17 Brighter outlook: Sharp decline in oil prices Depreciation of the Euro ECB’s QE easing and EU Investment Plan

Stimulating Growth Restricting Growth Key Risks

• Decreasing costs for input factors

(e.g. oil, metals)

• Weakened Euro increasing

competitiveness of EU products and

services

• Increasing consumers purchasing power

stimulating private consumption

• ECB quantitative easing and EU

economic programs stimulating

investments and demand

• Lack of economic and social reforms of

EU member states weakens

competitiveness

• Uncertainty with outcome Ukraine /

Russia crisis (Sanctions)

• Countries debts and cost cutting

programs negatively impact domestic

growth

• Unemployment rate and high economic

uncertainty cause social unrests and

prevent long-term investments

• Greek’s EURO exit and bankruptcy

• UK’s EU exit and cancellation of

agreements

• Economic sanctions and energy supply

disruptions relating to the Ukraine /

Russia conflict

• Armed conflicts between EU/US and

Russia

• Increasing nationalisms in the member

states with negative impacts on workforce

mobility and availability

3 March 2015

6

Page 7: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Over the next 3 years the EUR is expected to meet the USD value

Sources: European Commission, IMF, World Bank, Oanda, Bloomberg, Reuters,Scotiabank, PwC Analysis

US$/Euro Exchange Rate, 2010 - 17

0.70 0.75 0.78 0.75 0.73 0.86

0.95 1.00

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

1.2

Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12 Jan-13 Jan-14 Jan-15 Jan-16 Jan-17

Euro

2014 - 15 18% depreciation against US$ Deviation of US monetary policy from EU

2015 – 17 Brighter outlook: Improve price competitiveness of European companies Further hike inflation in 2016

3 March 2015

7

Page 8: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

The impact of a Grexit on the EU growth significantly decreased in the last two years

-10

-8

-6

-4

-2

0

2

4

6

20

00

-05

20

06

-09

20

10

20

11

20

12

20

13

20

14

20

15

20

16

20

17

% GDP Growth

EU Greece

Sources: European Commission, IMF, World Bank, IEA, ING, Bloomberg, Reuters, Independent UK, PwC Analysis

Greece

148.3

171.3

156.9

174.9 176.3

170.2

159.2 152.0

0.020.040.060.080.0

100.0120.0140.0160.0180.0200.0

20

10

20

11

20

12

20

13

20

14

20

15

20

16

20

17

% of GDP

Govt Gross Debt Total Govt Revenue

2014 Rebound to growth: Rising private consumption Strong growth in exports, tourism & shipping

2015 - 17: Implementation of agreed structural reforms Exports growth due to euro depreciation

Assessment of Grexit:

• 20 – 25% chance of Grexit in 2015

• EU: Minimal impact - 2% share of EU 2014 GDP

• Greece:

• Restore wealth level by mid 2020s without Grexit

• Huge growth in inward investments with Grexit

3 March 2015

8

Page 9: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

The UK is significantly contributing to the EU growth, however an exit would reduce the UK’s ability to influence and serve EU markets

Sources: European Commission, IMF, World Bank, IEA, ING, Bloomberg, Reuters, Independent UK, PwC Analysis

United Kingdom

-1.0

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

20

00

-05

20

06

-09

20

10

20

11

20

12

20

13

20

14

20

15

20

16

20

17

% GDP Growth

UK EU

2014 Solid growth: Strong domestic demand Formation of gross fixed capital

2015 - 17: Reduction in oil prices Buoyant private consumption Continued growth in investment

-1.0

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

20

00

-05

20

06

-09

20

10

20

11

20

12

20

13

20

14

20

15

20

16

20

17

20

18

20

19

% GDP Growth

UK leaves EU EUAssessment of Brexit:

• EU: Significant impact - 9% of EU 2014 GDP

• UK:

• Spike in inflation, 2.8% by 2018

• Cuts in economic growth

• Quicken formation of FTA agreements

Impact of Brexit

3 March 2015

9

Page 10: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook

Severely impacted by global decline in oil prices

80% depreciation of Rouble against US$

Retaliatory sanctions hike inflation

Dependent on geopolitical tensions & sanctions

If low oil prices continue:

• Huge pressure on the budget, limiting GDP growth • Large foreign currency reserve funds tides it through the short-term if sanctions are

removed

79.0

104.0 105.0 104.1

53.2 56.9 60.8 65.0 69.4 74.1

96.2

56.7 63.9 68.0

70.9 72.1 72.6

0.0

20.0

40.0

60.0

80.0

100.0

120.0

2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020

US$/barrel

Historical World Bank IMF

Russia sharp slowdown spills over to CIS

Sources: IMF, World Bank, OPEC, Oanda, Bloomberg, Reuters, Forbes, Scotiabank, PwC analysis

CIS, Ukraine & Russia % GDP Growth, 2000 - 17

-10.0

-5.0

0.0

5.0

10.0

2000 - 05 2006 - 09 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017

% GDP Growth

Russia

Ukraine

CIS

2014 Sharp deceleration: Geopolitcal tensions – Russia & Ukraine Spillovers from weakness in Russia & Europe

2015 – 17 Moderate recovery: Russia & Ukraine: Oct 14 Ceasefire agreement Modest recovery in Euro area demand Ukraine: Uncertain outlook, 2016-17 recovery dependent on relief of geopolitical tensions

29.9 29.2 29.8 30.2 35.2

63.5 63.0

60.0

0.0

10.0

20.0

30.0

40.0

50.0

60.0

70.0

Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12 Jan-13 Jan-14 Jan-15 Jan-16 Jan-17

Rouble

World Crude Oil Prices, 2010 - 20 US$/ Rouble Exchange Rate, 2010 - 17

Russia

3 March 2015

10

Page 11: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Risks to consider when investing in EU

Key Countries

Trend / Topic

Consequences PwC Publications

GREXIT

• Recession in Greece and possibly Eurozone • Increased spread for other Mediterranean countries, leading

to more austerity measures and a decrease in governmental spending

• Interview with Andreas Riris, PwC Greece Partner

BREXIT • UK loses access to EU markets, making it more difficult for

UK firms to sell goods to continental Europe

• 2015 Predictions for UK economy

• UK Economic Outlook, Nov 2014

EUR/USD • Investments in Europe would become less valuable in home

currency, however, could pay off as companies

Ukraine crisis

• EU and US trade embargo against Russia renders investments in Russia less valuable and hits companies exporting to Russia hard

• Exports to and production in Ukraine difficult due to ‚civil war‘

• Meeting the challenges of crisis in Ukraine

Surge in popularity of nationalist parties

• Danger of reinstatement of border controls and limits to freedom of movement or residence can be the result of nationalist movements in EU countries

Free Trade Agreements 3 March 2015

11

Page 12: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

What does that all mean to your business?

Free Trade Agreements 3 March 2015

12

Page 13: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

CEOs are more optimistic about mature markets this year

Q: Which countries, excluding the one in which you are based, do you consider most important for your overall growth prospects over the next 12 months? Source: PwC 18th Annual Global CEO Survey

2015 2014 2015 2014

Free Trade Agreements 3 March 2015

13

Page 14: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Country analysis should be reviewed regularly to avoid surprises

Average real wages % change p.a. Average wage per month (US = 100)

“Five years ago, if you asked me the best place to set up a factory, first would be China, second would be China, and third would be China”, he says. “Today it’s very different.”

Harry Lee, Chief Executive Officer, Tal Apparel, Hong Kong garment maker

Source: The Economist Source: PwC, ‘Global wage projections to 2030’ (September 2013

“The utopia for one-stop sourcing for quality and low price has been China … but utopias never last”

Matt Rubel, Chief Executive Officer, Collective Brands

Philippines India

Mexico

China

Poland

South Africa

Turkey Spain

UK US

0

20

40

60

80

100

2013 2030

-6

-4

-2

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013

China India Indonesia Malaysia Philippines Thailand Vietnam

Free Trade Agreements 3 March 2015

14

Page 15: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Europe is the largest and most accessible market

Private consumption at current market exchange rates

Source: Oxford Economics, PwC the 15th annual global CEO survey 2012

European is perceived to be the easiest market for export

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%

Sub-Saharan Africa

China

Russia and other CIS

Middle East and North Africa

Japan

Australia and other Oceania

Latin America

Rest of Asia

US

EU

Very difficult Somewhat difficult Not difficult at all

Source: Oxford Economics

Free Trade Agreements 3 March 2015

15

Page 16: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Europe’s attractiveness to Chinese companies …..

• Global and luxury brands and advanced technology

• Improve manufacturing competences and capabilities

• Deliver value for money - quality output offset start-up costs

Chinese FDI in EU-27 Chinese direct investments in EU-27 vs. US

Chinese direct investments in EU-27 by industry

Automotive12%

Chemicals17%

Communica-tions6%

Natural resources

8%Electronics

6%

Machinery5%

Other18%

Transportation6%

Metal mining & processing

6%

Utilities16%

Are European brands a steal?

• Set up operations in regions with large and strong domestic demand

• Stability and transparency of political, legal and regulatory environment

• Quality and diversity of the labour force

Free Trade Agreements 3 March 2015

16

Page 17: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

European brands are a steal!

Eurozone confidence heat map

Source: PwC Global Economy Watch

“The kind of assets that Chinese companies look for overseas has also begun to shift, from natural resources and energy, to an emerging appetite for consumer brands”

Squire Sanders

Opportunities in brand and innovation base acquisitions as well as market access

Free Trade Agreements 3 March 2015

17

Page 18: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Europe – a truly diversified continent

Eurozone & EU countries

EU countries

Other European countries

2011 average annual salary in constant USD

Note: China average wage in 2010 Source: OCED, Romania National Institute of Statistics, State Statistics Services of Ukraine, Turkish Statistical Institute

Average wage of selected Asian countries

20,273

United Kingdom

Spain Portugal

France

Germany

Italy Hungary

Sweden

Poland

50,366

53,069

46,984

22,549

37,583

39,112

47,704

13,811

14,177

Czech Republic

16,922

54,459

81,475

Norway

Finland

Ireland

66,822

Estonia

14,955

Greece

28,434

7,912

3,838

23,671

8,775

Russia

Ukraine

Bulgaria

Romania

Turkey

China 5'747

Malaysia 5'824

Philippines 2'246

Vietnam 1'152

Indonesia 1'089

India 943

3 March 2015

18

Page 19: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Germany 2'131

United Kingdom

1'756

France1'506

Italy1'151

Spain717

Netherlands 446

Switzerland 301

Belgium272

Poland 262

Austria 231

Denmark171 Finland

150

Greece143

Portugal 123

Ireland 123

Czech Republic

83

Hungary 57

15'000

20'000

25'000

30'000

35'000

40'000

0.0% 0.5% 1.0% 1.5% 2.0% 2.5% 3.0% 3.5% 4.0% 4.5%

20

11 G

DP

pe

r c

ap

ita

GDP CAGR% (2000 - 2011)

High potential markets

Eurozone average GDP CAGR 1.2%

Different characteristics of individual countries, driving different value propositions

Mercedes-Benz C-Class EUR 35,000

Dacia Sandero EUR 9,000

Source: Eurostat

Switzerland as a pilot market for Europe

• Diverse cultures

• Diverse languages

• High purchasing power

• Brand awareness

Free Trade Agreements 3 March 2015

19

Page 20: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

10

00

km

Switzerland’s relevance to your European strategy

London 1:40

Paris1:15

Berlin 1:25

Rome 1:30

Barcelona 1:40

Vienna 1:20

Warsaw 1:40

Prague 1:15

• Three languages and cultures in one country: a multi-cultural segmented consumer market for product research, providing pilot markets for the 3 largest EU neighbour markets (jointly account for 67% GDP of Eurozone and nearly 50% GDP of EU)

• EU‘s biggest trading partner

• Heart of Europe – allowing efficient business travels to visit your customers and business partners

From Zurich From Dublin

Paris 1:15 1:45

Berlin 1:25 2:15

Rome 1:30 3:00

London 1:40 1:25

Barcelona 1:40 3:25

Prague 1:15 2:40

Warsaw 1:40 3:00

Comparison of flight time

50

0k

m

Free Trade Agreements 3 March 2015

20

Page 21: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Free Trade Agreements – An Overview

21

3 March 2015 Free Trade Agreements

Page 22: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

What does a Free Trade Agreement cover?

• Fostering Trade in Goods

- Primary focus in duty reductions

• Trade related aspects

- Reduction of non-tariff barriers to trade (e.g. procedures)

- Geographical origin and intellectual property rights

• Other topics

- Trade in services, environment protection, etc.

22

3 March 2015 Free Trade Agreements

Different topics included to cover individual needs of

contracting parties

Page 23: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Free Trade Agreements: The Spaghetti Bowl Effect

23

3 March 2015 Free Trade Agreements

Quelle: WTO Discussion Papers No. 12 “The Changing Landscape of Regional Trade Agreements: 2006 Update”, via www.wcoomd.org

Page 24: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Free Trade Agreement – an overview

24

3 March 2015 Free Trade Agreements

Figures according to World Trade Organization as of 8 January 2015

446

259

Agreements notified

Agreements in force

Are they the same?

Bilateral and multilateral agreements

Asymmetric rules possible (e.g. different duty reduction on each side)

Different rules in each agreement possible

Page 25: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Implications of a FTA for a production company

25

3 March 2015 Free Trade Agreements

Business model alignment to build up presence in new markets and to gain customer base and to benefit from the geographic location, competencies, regulatory environment and other aspects.

In addition to the customs benefits provided in the FTA, a tax-optimized business model can be implemented taking into account the entire value chain which allows you to build an operationally robust business set-up that simultaneously allows you to manage your tax burden properly and in a suitable manner

Page 26: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Value Chain Transformation

26

3 March 2015 Free Trade Agreements

Chinese Manufacturer

EU Customer

Swiss Trader

No duties under the Free Trade Agreement

Standard duty rates

Textiles and textile articles: between 0,0% and 12,0%

Footwear and the like: between 3,0% and 17,0%

Chinese Manufacturer

EU Customer

Swiss Manufacturer

No duties under the China – Swiss Free Trade Agreement

No duties under the EU – Swiss Free Trade Agreement

Semi-finished goods

Finished goods

Transforming the Value Chain

Page 27: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Customs Tariff Classification Important aspect for the customs handling

Example: Coffee Machine

• For domestic use: 8516.7100

• Usually commercial deployment: 8419.8100

• Parts thereof?

- Water heater / immersion heaters: 8516.10..

27

3 March 2015 Free Trade Agreements

Imports China under the FTA with Switzerland

Page 28: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Impacts of currency exchange fluctuations on qualification

Exchange rate 1.20 Exchange rate 1.00

Raw Material EU (in EUR) 4’500 4’500

Raw Material EU (in CHF) 5’400 4’500

Raw material CH & value add 2’600 2’600

Profit 2’000 2’000

Ex-works price 10’000 9’100

No Swiss Origin Swiss Origin

Freight costs 1’000 1’000

Customs duties China 32.0% / 3’520 19.2% / 1’939

Total costs procurement 14’520 12’039

Advantage 2’481 (17.1%)

28

Free Trade Agreements 3 March 2015

Coffee machine / Rule of Origin Swiss China FTA: Non originating material <50%

Page 29: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

How can a company prepare?

Building up know-how to be familiarised to apply the different rules

Creating awareness amongst different departments

Customs responsible or FTA champion

Including free trade topic in the development of new products or in the purchasing and sales department

Customs tariff classification

Automated issuing of origin confirmations

Origin calculation

Regular updates (e.g. new agreements, changed rules

People IT Processes

29

3 March 2015 Free Trade Agreements

Page 30: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Practical and operational challenges in FTAs

30

3 March 2015 Free Trade Agreements

Page 31: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

It’s all about interpretation… part 1

• Company X gets a Certificate of Origin (Form D) under ATIGA stamped by Department of Foreign Trade in Province A in Thailand to certify preferential origin for goods shipped to Indonesia to its client Company Y.

• The port of loading of the goods is located in Province B in Thailand.

• Indonesia Customs Authority requests a retroactive verification to the Thailand Authorities.

Reason obtained: The Certificate of Origin has not been stamped by the Authority located in the same Province as the port of loading.

• Thailand Authorities never responded to the request.

As a consequence, Indonesia Authority rejects Certificate of Origin and the preferential treatment of the goods at importation.

Company Y had to pay duty.

31

Free Trade Agreements 3 March 2015

Page 32: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Multiple party transactions - Back-to-Back (B2B)

32

• Invoicing flow is different than physical flow of goods • To suit current business model: Usually manufacturing entity in one location (cost-effectiveness as location consideration) and HQ in another (tax- optimisation as location consideration)

• Reason? Price-Masking: End-customers should not know the actual cost of manufacturing (HQ usually charge a mark-up)

• Rules of Origin: FTAs are based on archaic business model where the seller and manufacturer are the same, or at least located in the same country

• What are the practical issues?

Free Trade Agreements 3 March 2015

Page 33: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Third Party Customer

Third Party Manufacturer /

Supplier

Third Party Invoicing

33

Flow of goods

Flow of invoices

China

Singapore

Company B Regional HQ

USD $100

Certificate of Origin

Malaysia

USD $300

Trade Agreement:

ASEAN – China FTA

Free Trade Agreements 3 March 2015

Page 34: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

ACFTA – FORM E

34

Free Trade Agreements 3 March 2015

Page 35: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Third Party Customer

Third Party Manufacturer /

Supplier

Third Party Invoicing – Back-to-Back CoO (MC)

Flow of goods

Flow of invoices

China

Singapore

Company B Regional HQ USD $100

Certificate of Origin

Malaysia

USD $300

Trade Agreement:

ASEAN – China FTA

CoO Movement Certificate

35

(d) The product which is to be re-exported using MC shall be under control of the Customs Authority of the intermediate Party. The products shall not undergo any further processing in the intermediate Party, except for repacking and logistics activities consistent with Rule 8 of the Rules of Origin for the ACFTA

Extracted from Rule 12 of the Revised OCP for the

rules of origin of the ACFTA

Free Trade Agreements 3 March 2015

Page 36: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

ACFTA – FORM E

36

Free Trade Agreements 3 March 2015

Page 37: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Last but not least, it’s all about interpretation… part 2

• Third party invoicing

• Does it mean it is limited to 3 parties?

• Or does it refer to multiple invoicing parties as a technical term?

Some of the importing countries in ASEAN do understand under third party invoicing that only 3 parties can be involved in the value chain. If there is a fourth party involved, or more, questions might be raised by the importing Authority and as a consequence, an interruption of the supply chain.

In a worst case scenario, Certificate of Origin may be rejected.

37

Free Trade Agreements 3 March 2015

Page 38: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Future Free Trade Agreements

38

3 March 2015 Free Trade Agreements

Page 39: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Global Trends

• From local to regional to worldwide

- “Distance” between trading partners becomes bigger, through FTAs it becomes closer

• Regional Blocks

- E.g. ASEAN, AEC, EU, NAFTA, MERCOSUR

• Race to establish template for future trade agreements

39

3 March 2015 Free Trade Agreements

Page 40: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP)

• Proposed regional regulatory and investment treaty

• Market access

• Recognising development of production and supply chains among TPP members

• Intellectual property provision

• Investor-state arbitration

• Postponed from March to April 2015

40

3 March 2015 Free Trade Agreements

Members

2005: Brunei, Chile, New Zealand, Singapore

2008: United States, Australia, Peru, Vietnam

Malaysia (2010); Mexico, Canada (2012); Japan (2013)

Potential members: China, Korea (announced interest in 2013), Taiwan, Philippines, Laos, India, Colombia, Indonesia, Cambodia, Bangladesh

Page 41: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP)

• Market access

• Including Trade in Service, Investment and E-Commerce

• Technical Barriers to Trade

• Specific sectoral agreements (e.g. textiles, chemicals, cars)

• Broader rules (e.g. public procurement, intellectual property, competition policy)

41

3 March 2015 Free Trade Agreements

Members

European Union and United States

Potential members: Albania, Iceland, The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, Montenegro, Serbia, Turkey (EU accession candidates)

TTIP indicated to be open for other members once in force

Page 42: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP)

• Broaden and deepen ASEAN+1 pacts

• Minimization of FTAs “spaghetti bowl” problems thanks to harmonization of Rules of Origin and faciliation

• RCEP may conflict with TPP

• 7 rounds of negotiation, outcome less optimistic

• Issues:

India, South Korea and China to open only 40% of their tariff lines for benefits

India suggested that concessions may vary depending the member country

42

3 March 2015 Free Trade Agreements

Members

ASEAN +6 (Australia, China, India, Japan, Korea, New Zealand)

Page 43: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

ASEAN Economic Community (AEC)

• 4 pillars: (1) Single Market & Production base, (2) Competitive Economic Region, (3) Equitable Economic development, (4) Integration into the global Economy

• Gradual harmonisation of certain policies and gradual removal of restrictive policies

• It is not an EU – no customs union, no common external tariff, not a political union, customs borders will remain

43

3 March 2015 Free Trade Agreements

Members

ASEAN

“Implementation date” 31 December 2015

Page 44: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Looking ahead

• More Free Trade Agreements

• Spanning global network

• Utilising benefits in global supply chains

- Interplay between purchase, production and sales

• Holistic approach

- Duty benefits vs. administrative burden

- Extended costs and savings opportunities

44

3 March 2015 Free Trade Agreements

Page 45: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Q&A - Closing

45

3 March 2015 Free Trade Agreements

Page 46: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Q&A - Closing

March 2015 46

Felix Sutter

Partner Risk Assurance Services, Head Asia Desk PricewaterhouseCoopers AG, Zurich Phone: +41 58 792 28 20 [email protected]

Simeon L. Probst

Director Customs & VAT PricewaterhouseCoopers AG, Basel Phone: ++41 58 792 5351 [email protected]

Michel Anliker

Manager Customs PwC WMS Asia, Singapore Phone: ++65 6236 7307 [email protected]

Page 47: Free Trade Agreements a global perspective · (e.g. oil, metals) •Weakened Euro increasing competitiveness of EU products and ... 2014 - 15 2015 – 17 Outlook Severely impacted

PwC

Customs & International Trade Compliance in Asia Pacific - doing the groundwork

Why should you attend?

Any professional involved in the cross –border buying or selling of goods is touched by trade compliance considerations. Whether employed in supply chain operations, planning, procurement, or finance, the failure to understand and plan around import/export regulatory requirements can lead to unanticipated costs and a lot of wasted time. Product delays, stock-outs, emergency shipments, additional warehousing costs, and customs penalties are all common consequences of compliance failures. Many businesses operating in Asia Pacific choose to have their logistics service provider (“LSP”) handle customs formalities at overseas borders; relying on their operational knowledge and relationships with customs officials. However LSPs often lack technical training and the legal responsibility for customs compliance remains with the owner of the goods. Most customs authorities expect informed oversight over LSPs and customs brokers. To equip Singapore based business professionals with the ability to take a more informed and pro-active role in the management of customs and trade risk in Asia Pacific, we will cover the following topics during this two-day workshop:

• Recognising and monitoring customs and trade “hot spots” throughout the supply chain

• Introduction to customs valuation, classification, and FTA compliance

• Understanding the trade compliance roles and responsibilities of the various business functions, LSP, and customs authorities

• Essentials of customs rules and procedures in Asia Pacific

• Identifying opportunities for duty savings and cash-flow improvement across the region

Expand your horizons with customs and international trade know-how

Workshop details

Date: 25 & 26 March 2015 Time: 9.00am to 5.00pm Venue: 8 Cross Street, PWC Building, Level 17, Singapore 048424

Fees

PwC Clients, Alumni & Public: S$980 Fees includes 7% GST, refreshments and workshop kit.

Who should attend?

Sales, procurement, logistics, supply chain

planners, and legal and finance professionals

who wish to build their knowledge of cross-

border trade compliance to better manage

business risk and identify trade savings

opportunities

PwC’s Academy


Recommended