Internal
From Steady-State to Dynamic Simulation: Benefits and Use Cases of Modern Process Simulation Tools
Aveva World Conference North America 2019, Andrea Milioni (BASF SE), Chloe Smith (AVEVA)
Internal
14.11.20192
• Introduction of the APC Team and challenges of the digital transformation
Advanced Process Control at BASF SE
• Use of Steady-State/Dynamic Models in different phases
Process Simulation During the Plant Lifecycle
• Use Cases of Dynamic Simulation by APC
Dynamic Simulation Using SimCentral
• Benefits from the use of a modern Process Simulator
Summary
Structure of the presentation
Internal
14.11.20193
• Introduction of the APC Team and challenges of the digital transformation
Advanced Process Control at BASF SE
• Use of Steady-State/Dynamic Models in different phases
Process Simulation During the Plant Lifecycle
• Use Cases of Dynamic Simulation by APC
Dynamic Simulation Using SimCentral
• Benefits from the use of a modern Process Simulator
Summary
Structure of the presentation
Internal
14.11.20194
APC for continuous processes
• Multivariable Predictive Control (MPC)
• Real-time Optimization (RTO)
• Operator Training Simulators (OTS)
• Scenario Simulation
Advanced Data Analytics
• Online-monitoring and optimization
with empirical and grey-box models
• Offline Data-Analysis
APC for batch processes
• Multivariable monitoring and control
• Recipe Optimization
• Sequence optimization
Base Layer Control
• Controller Performance Management
• Advanced Regulatory Control
• Sequence/Procedure Automation
• Softsensors / Inferentials
• Process Analytical Technology
Innovation and Strategic Activities
Advanced Process Control (APC) at BASF SE
Internal
14.11.20195
Plant
Automation
actuatorssensors
Engineering Documentation and Modelling
RTO
Manual interface, characteristic for “Industry 3.0”
Research
Development
Engineering
ConstructionProcess Simulation
Construction
Design
Real World
Propan
Benzol
K200W205
W210
P205
B215
B100
W100
C100
K300
W310
V300
P315
B315
W305
P305P010
AbgasAbgas
Abgas
Diisopropyl- benzol
Cumol
P215
Engineering doc.
Dynamic Model
Challenges of the Digital Transformation
Status Quo:
often modelling activities from
“scratch”
Internal
14.11.20196
Plant
Automation
actuatorssensors
Digital Twin
RTO
Research
Development
Engineering
ConstructionProcess Simulation
Construction
Design
Real World
Propan
Benzol
K200W205
W210
P205
B215
B100
W100
C100
K300
W310
V300
P315
B315
W305
P305P010
AbgasAbgas
Abgas
Diisopropyl- benzol
Cumol
P215
Engineering doc.
Dynamic Model
Digital Twin of Process BehaviorIntegrated Digital Technology for Engineering, Operation and Maintenance
Vision: Manual interfaces are eliminated
→ All islands are connected (seamless & bidirectional)
Modelling integration in lifecycle
(“Digital Twin”)
RTO
Internal
14.11.20197
Plant
Automation
actuatorssensors
Digital Twin
Research
Development
Engineering
ConstructionProcess Simulation
Construction
Design
Real World
Propan
Benzol
K200W205
W210
P205
B215
B100
W100
C100
K300
W310
V300
P315
B315
W305
P305P010
AbgasAbgas
Abgas
Diisopropyl- benzol
Cumol
P215
Dynamic Model
Digital Twin of Process BehaviorIntegrated Digital Technology for Engineering, Operation and Maintenance
Vision: Manual interfaces are eliminated
→ All islands are connected (seamless & bidirectional)
Modelling integration in lifecycle
(“Digital Twin”)
Process Simulation
plays a crucial role to enable the use of an integrated Digital
Technology
RTO
Engineering doc.
Internal
14.11.20198
• Introduction of the APC Team and challenges of the digital transformation
Advanced Process Control at BASF SE
• Use of Steady-State/Dynamic Models in different phases
Process Simulation During the Plant Lifecycle
• Use Cases of Dynamic Simulation by APC
Dynamic Simulation Using SimCentral
• Benefits from the use of a modern Process Simulator
Summary
Structure of the presentation
Internal
14.11.20199
ProcessSimulation
Initial Design
Initial Design – Process Engineering
(Steady-State Model)
• Conceptual Design
• Steady-State Simulation (H&M
Balance)
• Equipment Design
• Steady-State Detailed Simulation
Process Simulation during the plant Lifecycle
Initial DesignControl Concept
SelectionOperabilityAnalysis Operators Training Simulator (OTS)
Engineering & Construction Phase Operations Phase
Operations Support
Real Time Optimization (RTO)
Internal
14.11.201910
Process Simulation during the plant Lifecycle
Initial DesignControl Concept
SelectionOperabilityAnalysis Operators Training Simulator (OTS)
Engineering & Construction Phase Operations Phase
Operations Support
Real Time Optimization (RTO)
ProcessSimulation
Initial Design
Control Concept Selection
Control Concept Selection – Control
Engineering
• Overall Control Scheme
Development
• Evaluation of the Optimal Set-point
• Open Loop Step-test
• Closed Loop Step-test and
Controllers Tuning
Steady-State
Simulation
Dynamic
Simulation
Internal
14.11.201911
Process Simulation during the plant Lifecycle
Initial DesignControl Concept
SelectionOperabilityAnalysis Operators Training Simulator (OTS)
Engineering & Construction Phase Operations Phase
Operations Support
Real Time Optimization (RTO)
ProcessSimulation
Initial Design
Control Concept Selection
OperabilityAnalysis
Operability Analysis
• Scenario Simulation: Changes in
Process Operating Conditions
• Disturbance rejection
• Start-up and Shutdown
• Early Detection of Operational
Challenges and Bottlenecks
Internal
14.11.201912
Process Simulation during the plant Lifecycle
Initial DesignControl Concept
SelectionOperabilityAnalysis Operators Training Simulator (OTS)
Engineering & Construction Phase Operations Phase
Real Time Optimization (RTO)
ProcessSimulation
Initial Design
Control Concept Selection
OperabilityAnalysis
OperationsSupport
Operations Support
• Control Concept
Evaluation/Improvement
• What if? Analysis
• Troubleshooting
• Incident Scenario Reproduction
Operations Support
Internal
14.11.201913
Process Simulation during the plant Lifecycle
Initial DesignControl Concept
SelectionOperabilityAnalysis Operators Training Simulator (OTS)
Engineering & Construction Phase Operations Phase
Operations Support
Real Time Optimization (RTO)
ProcessSimulation
Initial Design
Control Concept Selection
OperabilityAnalysis
OperationsSupport
OTS
Operators Training Simulator
• Control Room Operator Training
• Simulation/Validation of the main
operating procedures
• Validating DCS Control and Logic
Checkout
Internal
14.11.201914
Process Simulation during the plant Lifecycle
Initial DesignControl Concept
SelectionOperabilityAnalysis Operators Training Simulator (OTS)
Engineering & Construction Phase Operations Phase
Operations Support
Real Time Optimization (RTO)
ProcessSimulation
Initial Design
Control Concept
Evaluation
OperabilityAnalysis
OperationsSupport
OTS
RTO
Real Time Optimization (Online)
• Frequent changes to the plant (e.g.
feed composition)
• Steady-State Set-point Optimization
in presence of unconstraint non-linear optimum
• Data reconciliation to estimate
unmeasured process parameters
• Model can still be used for offline
analyses/studies
Internal
14.11.201915
Process Simulation during the plant Lifecycle
Initial DesignControl Concept
SelectionOperabilityAnalysis Operators Training Simulator (OTS)
Engineering & Construction Phase Operations Phase
Operations Support
Real Time Optimization (RTO)
ProcessSimulation
Initial Design
ControlConcept
Evaluation
OperabilityAnalysis
OperationsSupport
OTS
RTO
Main challenges:
• From Steady-State to Dynamic models
• Reuse of Models
Status Quo:
• Process Simulation is„standard“ only for Initial Design (Steady State)
• Dynamic Simulation limited to specific cases due to high
engineering effort (non-optimal tools)
Internal
14.11.201916
Process Simulation during the plant Lifecycle
Initial DesignControl Concept
SelectionOperabilityAnalysis Operators Training Simulator (OTS)
Engineering & Construction Phase Operations Phase
Operations Support
Real Time Optimization (RTO)
ProcessSimulation
Initial Design
ControlConcept
Evaluation
OperabilityAnalysis
OperationsSupport
OTS
RTO
Simulation Tool Requirements
• Easy to use (even for non expert
users)
• Fluid transition between Steady-State
and Dynamics in one Simulation tool
• Open Model Equations (easy to
identify the important parameters)
• Support of the complete lifecycle
Internal
14.11.201917
• Introduction of the APC Team and challenges of the digital transformation
Advanced Process Control at BASF SE
• Use of Steady-State/Dynamic Models in different phases
Process Simulation During the Plant Lifecycle
• Use Cases of Dynamic Simulation by APC
Dynamic Simulation Using SimCentral
• Benefits from the use of a modern Process Simulator
Summary
Structure of the presentation
Internal
18
Project 1: green field project, steady state simulation already present with “in -house” process simulation tool
◼ Main goal: evaluation of different control schemes with different dynamic scenarios (e.g. compositional change, flowrate change, disturbances etc.)
Dynamic Simulation using SimCentralUse Cases of Dynamic Simulation by APC
Feed
Distillate
Bottom product
Steam
Condensate
Of f gas
Cooling Water
Reboiler
Condenser
LIC
-
FIC
-
LIC
-
K1
FIC
-
PIC
-
TIC
-
Off gas
Condenser
Feed from Hydrogenation
Bottom
FIC
-
TIC
-
Nitrogen
Distillate
Condensate
Steam
Reboiler
Steady State model
(in-house tool)
Steady State model
(SimCentral)
Dynamic model
(SimCentral)
Control Concept Evaluation
Flowsheet Model in SimCentralControl concept scheme
Internal
19
Dynamic Simulation using SimCentralUse Cases of Dynamic Simulation by APC
LIC
-
FIC
-
LIC
-
K1
FIC
-
PIC
-
TIC
-
Off gas
Condenser
Feed from Hydrogenation
Bottom
FIC
-
TIC
-
Nitrogen
Distillate
Condensate
Steam
Reboiler
Feed composition change: open loop response
Project 1: green field project, steady state simulation already present with “in -house” process simulation tool
◼ Main goal: evaluation of different control schemes with different dynamic scenarios (e.g. compositional change, flowrate change, disturbances etc.)
Steady State model
(in-house tool)
Steady State model
(SimCentral)
Dynamic model
(SimCentral)
Control Concept Evaluation
Control concept scheme
Internal
20
Dynamic Simulation using SimCentralUse Cases of Dynamic Simulation by APC
LIC
-
FIC
-
LIC
-
K1
FIC
-
PIC
-
TIC
-
Off gas
Condenser
Feed from Hydrogenation
Bottom
FIC
-
TIC
-
Nitrogen
Distillate
Condensate
Steam
Reboiler
AC
Feed composition change: distillate online analyzer controller response
Project 1: green field project, steady state simulation already present with “in -house” process simulation tool
◼ Main goal: evaluation of different control schemes with different dynamic scenarios (e.g. compositional change, flowrate change, disturbances etc.)
Steady State model
(in-house tool)
Steady State model
(SimCentral)
Dynamic model
(SimCentral)
Control Concept Evaluation
Control concept scheme
Internal
21
Dynamic Simulation using SimCentralUse Cases of Dynamic Simulation by APC
LIC
-
FIC
-
LIC
-
K1
FIC
-
PIC
-
TIC
-
Off gas
Condenser
Feed from Hydrogenation
Bottom
FIC
-
TIC
-
Nitrogen
Distillate
Condensate
Steam
Reboiler
AC
AC
Feed composition change: inlet feed online analyzer controller response
Project 1: green field project, steady state simulation already present with “in -house” process simulation tool
◼ Main goal: evaluation of different control schemes with different dynamic scenarios (e.g. compositional change, flowrate change, disturbances etc.)
Steady State model
(in-house tool)
Steady State model
(SimCentral)
Dynamic model
(SimCentral)
Control Concept Evaluation
Control concept scheme
Internal
Steady State model
(SimCentral)
Dynamic model
(SimCentral)
Model Validation
(PIMS)
Scenario Reproduction
Control Loop Evaluation
22
Project 2: dynamic simulation of an existing Plant
▪ Main goal: to reproduce a Plant upset scenario in order to better identify the root causes / control loops evaluation
Dynamic Simulation using SimCentralUse Cases of Dynamic Simulation by APC
Flowsheet Model in SimCentralControl concept scheme
Internal
23
Dynamic Simulation using SimCentralUse Cases of Dynamic Simulation by APC
Plant upset scenario reproduction
Steady State model
(SimCentral)
Dynamic model
(SimCentral)
Model Validation
(PIMS)
Scenario Reproduction
Control Loop Evaluation
Project 2: dynamic simulation of an existing Plant
▪ Main goal: to reproduce a Plant upset scenario in order to better identify the root causes / control loops evaluation
Real Data from PIMS
Internal
24
Dynamic Simulation using SimCentralUse Cases of Dynamic Simulation by APC
Subsequent start-up reproduction
Steady State model
(SimCentral)
Dynamic model
(SimCentral)
Model Validation
(PIMS)
Scenario Reproduction
Control Loop Evaluation
Project 2: dynamic simulation of an existing Plant
▪ Main goal: to reproduce a Plant upset scenario in order to better identify the root causes / control loops evaluation
Control concept scheme
Internal
14.11.201925
Process Simulation during the plant Lifecycle
Initial DesignControl Concept
SelectionOperabilityAnalysis Operators Training Simulator (OTS)
Engineering & Construction Phase Operations Phase
Operations Support
Real Time Optimization (RTO)
ProcessSimulation
Initial Design
Control Concept
Evaluation
OperabilityAnalysis
OperationsSupport
OTS
RTO
Positive elements from the use of
SimCentral
✓ Easy to use (even for non expert users)
✓ Fluid transition between Steady-State and Dynamics
✓ Open Model Equations (easy to identify the important parameters)
✓ Robust and efficient Equation Oriented solver
✓ “Library” approach
✓ Interactive simulation with visualization of the results as “real time” data
SimCentral is an enabler to
address use cases for dynamic simulation
Internal
14.11.201926
• Introduction of the APC Team and challenges of the digital transformation
Advanced Process Control at BASF SE
• Use of Steady-State/Dynamic Models in different phases
Process Simulation During the Plant Lifecycle
• Use Cases of Dynamic Simulation by APC
Dynamic Simulation Using SimCentral
• Benefits from the use of a modern Process Simulator
Summary
Structure of the presentation
Internal
◼ Digital transformation: demand for models will increase
◼ Integrated Steady-State and Dynamic Simulation can enable the use of models during the whole plant Lifecycle
◼ Main benefits from a modern Process Simulation tool:
➢ Cross-functionality use of models: integrate competencies and enhance collaboration
➢ Model-based methods accessible for other domain experts (e.g. APC)
➢ Improvement of communication between technical departments and production management → generate trust into simulation models
14.11.201927
Summary
Internal