1CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
Operations Summary of a Commercial Biomass Gasifier Generating a Clean, Combustible Gas for Industrial Heat or Repowering an Existing Power Boiler
Frontline GasifierBenson, MN
Jerod Smeenk2011 TAPPI IBBC Conference
March 15, 2011
CVEC Ethanol Plant – Benson, MN
CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
Chippewa Valley Ethanol Company
• Located in Benson, MN• 48 MMGY corn ethanol plant• Innovative farmer co-op
– Produce alcohol for two different vodkas– Largest organic alcohol producer in the US
A Strategic Decision in 2005 Driven by:
• Concern about natural gas price trend vs potential biomass energy lying in co-op members’ fields (keep $13M/yr energy costs ‘at-home’)
• Interest in improving fossil energy balance of the plant– Probability of carbon monetization in the US– Make the ethanol more “renewable”
• Desire to participate in cellulosic biofuel technology
CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
CVEC Design Considerations• Displace 90% of natural gas with renewable biomass
– Disruption free operation of existing ethanol plant– ~ 280 ton/day biomass required
• Enable biomass feedstock flexibility– wood, cobs, stover, grass, oil or glycerin (liquid injection)
• Utilize existing energy assets– Retrofit existing “Gas Fired” appliances– Distributed gas integration network required to fire TO/HRSG,
ICM drum dryer, Barr-Rosin ring dryer, package boilers– Natural gas & propane backup required
• Platform suitable for future BTL efforts– Syngas-to-ethanol platform– Low tars
5CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
Frontline’s Gasifier Systemat Chippewa Valley Ethanol Company
• Phase 1: – 75 ton/day (40 MMBH)– high efficiency particulate
removal before combustion– retrofit existing gas-fired boiler
• Phase 2: – add CLEANGAS™ system to
eliminate tars– distribute gas to multiple
burners
• Phase 3: – Upgrade system to achieve
280 ton/day (> 90% NG displacement)
6CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
What is Gasification?
7
CO H2
Also,CH4, CO2,H2O
Direct Gasification (Air or Oxygen)Indirect Gasification (Heat Exchange)
CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
8
Gasification is a Thermochemical Process• CombustionFuel + Excess Air → Heat + Hot Exhaust Gas + Ash
• Direct GasificationFuel + Limited Air→ “Producer Gas” + Heat + Char-ash + “Tar”Fuel + Limited Oxygen→ “Syngas” + Heat + Char-ash + “Tar”
• Indirect Gasification and PyrolysisFuel + Heat → “Syngas” or “Pyrolysis Gas” + Char-ash + “Tar”
CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
Gasification & Combustion(Gas Integration vs. Steam Integration)
• Gasification allows piping of combustible gas to multiple locations for integration with existing appliances– Change natural gas burner to a multi-fuel burner on boilers, dryers,
and TO’s– Avoid stranded capital, retrofit existing appliances
• Gasification allows gas independent interface, not steam dependent– Instant, robust natural gas or LP backup– Decouples plant reliability from energy system avail.– Protects and values your on-line production time
CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
Gas Integration cont’d
10
• Gasification allows gas conditioning and cleanup before firing gas appliance (boiler, dryer, etc.)– Gas conditioning (emissions control) done at one location, not each
individual appliance– Protect equipment from particulate and alkali– Smaller filtration system (pre-combustion gases)
• Bridge to ligno-cellulosic ethanol & products– Builds a biomass market– Convert from air blown (producer gas) to oxygen blown (syngas)
CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
CVEC Gasification System
11
BIOMASS DG DRYER
BAGHOUSEFILTER
AIR
CHAR-ASHCOOLING,DEDUSTING,…LOAD-OUT
PRODUCER GAS(H2, CO, CH4, H2O, CO2, CXHY, N2)
GA
SIF
IER COOLING
(steam generation)
BOILER
CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
METERINGVESSEL
LOCK HOPPERVESSEL
BIOMASSSTORAGE
SILO
One Gasifier Many Multi-fuel Burners
DRYER #1
DRYER #2
T.O./HRSG #1
Etc….
MULTIGAS BURNERSFRONTLINE GASIFIER
COEN MULTIGAS BURNER
• Deliver CLEANGAS® to the burners– Cleaner boiler means less production down-time
• Downstream PM control not required– pre-combustion filter is >99.9% efficient
• Avoids new boiler capital & complexity– Expensive solid fuel boilers, steam appliances not required
CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
NAT GAS BACKUP
Gasifier System
CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
BiomassSilo
Char/AshLoad-Out
GasifierBuilding
Gas Product Pipe LineMCC
Air Blower
CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
Gasifier
Filter
Boiler
Flare Test
Feedstock Unloading
Gasifier
Gasifier System Design
• Pressurized (up to 60 psig)• Bubbling Fluidized Bed• Scalable – units > 1000 tpd• Fuel flexible – omnivorous• Simple, robust, and stable
operation• Minimizes footprint • Up to 10 : 1 turndown
15CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
Advanced Gas Cleanup
PMFree Gas™ – high efficiency hot gas filtrationCommercial demo at CVEC
Removes bad actors from producer gas prior to combustion
>99.999% particulate matter (PM) down to < 2 mg/Nm3
including alkali metals and alkali chlorides
~95% capture of chloride (HCl)
~90% sulfur capture
16CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
CVEC Operations Cost atPhase 1 Capacity
CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
$‐
$1.00
$2.00
$3.00
$4.00
$5.00
$6.00
Natural Gas Wood Cobs RDF
$5.00
$5.91 $5.80
$4.02
Cost per million Btu
Includes:•Fuel•Labor•Electricity•Maintenance
CVEC Operations Costs Ex Capital
CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
$‐
$1.00
$2.00
$3.00
$4.00
$5.00
$6.00
Natural Gas
Wood Cobs RDF
$5.00
$5.91 $5.80
$4.02
$4.72 $4.61
$2.83
Cost per million Btu
40 MMBH
160 MMBH
Operating, Feedstock, & Amortized Capital Costs
CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
$‐
$1.00
$2.00
$3.00
$4.00
$5.00
$6.00
$7.00
Natural Gas RDF Wood
Cost per million Btu
Fuel
Opex
Capex
$5.15
$4.22
$6.29
400 MMBH$5/MMBtu nat gas$30/bd‐ton RDF$70/bd‐ton wood
Lessons learned by CVEC
• Feedstock– Biomass is not always a commodity - requires
proactive sourcing and solid supplier relationships– Wood is not wood is not wood– Increased moisture = decreased efficiency– Bubbling fluidized bed has proven its flexibility - wood,
corn cobs, glycerin and corn oil feedstocks– Should have permitted the gasifier for a wide range of
feedstocks
CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
Lessons learned by CVEC
• Gasifier Operation– Process has worked per design intent– Component reliability issues have caused the most
headaches - valve selection is critical– Thermal cycling destroys refractory– Fouling of the Producer Gas Cooler with certain
feedstocks & operating conditions– Multi-fuel burner has worked well
CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
Lessons learned by CVEC
• Char-ash– Residual ash and unconverted carbon– Must establish proper handling techniques – it is a
combustible dust!– Obtained beneficial use permit that authorizes land
application as a soil amendment
CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
CVEC Gasifier Status• Have logged thousands of operating hours –
but displacement of natural gas with wood gas not economical
• Working to permit the system to use lower cost waste feedstocks
• Anticipate emissions testing on engineered fuel (sorted MSW) this summer
CAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
Summary• Natural gas and feedstock prices dictate plant
economics• Biomass is uniquely suited among renewables
for providing low carbon gaseous fuels• True gasification provides the opportunity to
utilize existing gas appliances (gas integration) and provide instant natural gas backup to protect plant operation
• Energy dollars directed to local economy instead of foreign countries
• Biorefinery optionality for biofuels productionCAPTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only
Frontline BioEnergy, LLC
1421 S. Bell Avenue, Suite 105Ames, IA 50010
515-292-1200www.frontlinebioenergy.com
25APTURE THE ENERGY | RELEASE THE POTENTIAL
Copyright Protected—Use by Permission Only