of 115
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
1/115
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
2/115
u()*)* (+'*(: o (:' &+'3)ou '+(: (o (y l)-'.
L* o+ (:' L*l' ) lo* (:( u*'+3o+' (:' 3u(' )
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
3/115
@@7, o(:'+;)' =*o;* (:' Co&+':'*)-' A++)* R'o+ L; o 1988, ;:)3:+')'*( Au)*o )*' o* Ju*' 10, 1988. T:) l;, ;:)l' 3o*)'+
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
4/115
Ao3)()o* o R)3' * Co+* +ou3'+ o (:' :)l)&&)*', I*3. -. T:' N()o*l L*R'o+ Cou*3)l. 9 T:' '('+)*()o* o u( 3o&'*()o*
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
5/115
;'l(: +'3')-' (:+ou: (:' +')'*()l Co))o* o* Goo Go-'+*'*( *u3: o(:'+ ou+3' o-'+*'*( y '' &&+o&+)('. T:' ou*( 3oll'3('* 33+u)* (o (:) &'3)l u* :ll
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
6/115
*'3')(y o+ (:' '&+o&+)()o* '&l)*' )* (:' ;:'+' 3lu' o (:'+o3l()o* * u
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
7/115
K2 T:' ) ''3u()-' o+'+ +' -)ol()-' o (:' 3o*()(u()o*l &+o-))o* (:( *o&+)-(' &+o&'+(y :ll
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
8/115
No ('**(+'+ )* +)3ul(u+l l* &+)+)ly '-o(' (o +)3' * 3o+* :ll
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
9/115
'+*'( (u)' ;'+' '
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
10/115
) )* (+u(: ll (:( ) )*-ol-' )* ;:( ) ('+' u)3)l u&+'3y ;:)3: &+o&'+ly) (:' &o;'+ o u)3)l +'-)'; u*'+ (:' Co*()(u()o*. 1@
T:' 3'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
11/115
T:' +u'*( o o' o (:' &'()()o*'+ (:( +o3. No. 1/1 * E.O. No. 229 :oul
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
12/115
I (:' u(y ) &u+'ly )3+'()o*+y, (:' 3ou+(
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
13/115
'&+o&+)()o*, +o. Jo:* J. Co(o*) o (:' !*)-'+)(y o Ill)*o) Coll'' o L;K+''++)* (o (:' '+l)'+ 3' o Eu3l) -. A
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
14/115
*'):
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
15/115
'l
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
16/115
+'o+ )*(' o )')('ly )(u+
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
17/115
&+o*ou*3'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
18/115
To
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
19/115
* o(:'+ )*('+'(' &+()' +' *'-'+(:'l' llo;' * o&&o+(u*)(y (o u
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
20/115
K
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
21/115
3o&'*()o* (o ;:)3: (:' o;*'+ o 3o*'*' &+o&'+(y ) '*()(l', (:' +='(-lu'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
22/115
(:' ou*( o 0
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
23/115
(:' o(:'+ (:)* o -lu' 3o*()(u()* (:' (o(l &y'*(, '('+)*' o* (:'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
24/115
(:' ()(l' (o (:' &+o&'+(y )* (:' S((' l
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
25/115
D'3+'' No. 27 :ll
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
26/115
27 :ll '*oy (:' +'('*()o* +):( +*('
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
27/115
2. Roxas v. CA GR#12787 12!17!"" EN BANCUG.R. No. 12787@. D'3'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
28/115
(:) y'+ u*'+ (:' Co&+':'*)-' A++)* R'o+ +o+.U4V
O* O3(o((o u*ul()* K08 lo&' * 3(ully o33u&)' * 3ul()-(' ( (o u*ul()*&&+o)('ly //9 :'3(+' u*'+ T D'3l+()o* No. 02/4 ;:)3: lo : '-'+l3(ul o33u&*( * ()ll'+ o u+3*'U@V ;:)l' )* (:' (:)+ R'&o+(, (:' MAROou* &&+o)('ly 7 :'3(+' u*'+ T D'3l+()o* No. 0/4 >( (ou*ul()* ;)(: // 3(ul o33u&*( * ()ll'+ lo o u+3*'.U7V
O* O3(o
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
29/115
3u))()o* o (:' (;o H3)'*. T:' LB (+u( 33ou*( 3o&'*()o* o+H3)'* l)3o ;'+' +'&l3'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
30/115
M=(), M'(+o M*)l.U2VR'&o*'*( DAR o'+' &'()()o*'+ 3o&'*()o* o 1,108,99.2 o+ 729.4190:'3(+' * 4,428,[email protected] o+ 2/4.@498 :'3(+'.U2@V
O* S'&('
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
31/115
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
32/115
ADMINISTRATI#E REMEDIES IN #IEW OF THE ATENT ILLEGALIT$ OF THERESONDENTS ACTS, THE IRREARABLE DAMAGE CA!SED B$ SAID ILLEGAL ACTS,AND THE ABSENCE OF A LAIN, SEED$ AND ADE!ATE REMED$ IN THE ORDINAR$CO!RSE OF LAWALL OF WHICH ARE E6CETIONS TO THE SAID DOCTRINE.
B. RESONDENT CO!RT OF AEALS GRA#EL$ ERRED IN HOLDING THATETITIONERS LANDHOLDINGS ARE S!BJECT TO CO#ERAGE !NDER THECOMREHENSI#E AGRARIAN REFORM LAW, IN #IEW OF THE !NDIS!TED FACT THATETITIONERS LANDHOLDINGS HA#E BEEN CON#ERTED TO NONAGRIC!LT!RAL!SES B$ RESIDENTIAL ROCLAMATION NO. 120 WHICH DECLARED THEM!NICIALIT$ OF NAS!GB!, BATANGAS AS A TO!RIST "ONE, AND THE "ONINGORDINANCE OF THE M!NICIALIT$ OF NAS!GB! RECLASSIF$ING CERTAINORTIONS OF ETITIONERS LANDHOLDINGS AS NONAGRIC!LT!RAL, BOTH OFWHICH LACE SAID LANDHOLDINGS O!TSIDE THE SCOE OF AGRARIAN REFORM,OR AT THE #ER$ LEAST ENTITLE ETITIONER TO AL$ FOR CON#ERSION ASCONCEDED B$ RESONDENT DAR.
C. RESONDENT CO!RT OF AEALS GRA#EL$ ERRED WHEN IT FAILED TO DECLARE THE ROCEEDINGS BEFORE RESONDENT DAR #OID FOR FAIL!RE TO OBSER#E D!EROCESS, CONSIDERING THAT RESONDENTS BLATANTL$ DISREGARDED THEROCED!RE FOR THE AC!ISITION OF RI#ATE LANDS !NDER R.A. @@7, MOREARTIC!LARL$, IN FAILING TO GI#E D!E NOTICE TO THE ETITIONER AND TOROERL$ IDENTIF$ THE SECIFIC AREAS SO!GHT TO BE AC!IRED.
D. RESONDENT CO!RT OF AEALS GRA#EL$ ERRED WHEN IT FAILED TORECOGNI"E THAT ETITIONER WAS BRA"ENL$ AND ILLEGALL$ DERI#ED OF ITSROERT$ WITHO!T J!ST COMENSATION, CONSIDERING THAT ETITIONER WASNOT AID J!ST COMENSATION BEFORE IT WAS !NCEREMONIO!SL$ STRIED OFITS LANDHOLDINGS THRO!GH THE ISS!ANCE OF CLOAS TO ALLEGED FARMERBENEFICIARIES, IN #IOLATION OF R.A. @@7.U41V
T:' )*' '++o+ )*-ol-' (:+'' K/ &+)*3)&l )u' K1 ;:'(:'+ (:) Cou+( 3*(=' 3o*)?*3' o (:) &'()()o* '&)(' &'()()o*'+ )lu+' (o ':u( )*)(+()-'+'')' K2 ;:'(:'+ (:' 3u))()o* &+o3'')* o-'+ (:' (:+'' :3)'* ;'+'-l) * )* 33o+*3' ;)(: l; * K/ u)* (:' :3)'* y
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
33/115
3o*(+o-'+y ) &+)-(' l* * K11 )* uo ;++*(o &+o3'')*.U42V
'()()o*'+ +):(ly ou:( )')(' +'+' )* (:' 3ou+(. T:'+' ; -)ol()o* o )(+):( * (o +'u)+' )( (o ':u( )*)(+()-' +'')'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
34/115
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
35/115
T:' DAR : ' 3o&ulo+y 3u))()o* (:' &+)o+)(y o' o l* 3u))()o* (o:('* (:' )&l''*(()o* o (:' Co&+':'*)-' A++)* R'o+ +o+ KCAR.U4@V !*'+ S'3()o* 1@ o (:' CARL, (:' +( ('& )* 3o&ulo+y 3u))()o* ) (:')'*()3()o* o (:' l*, (:' l*o;*'+ * (:'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
36/115
2. I')('ly u&o* +'3')&( o 3' ol'+, 3o&u(' (:' -lu()o* o (:' l* )*33o+*3' ;)(: A.O. No. @, S'+)' o 1988.U47V T:' -lu()o* ;o+=:''( * (:'+'l(' CACF -lu()o* o+ :ll
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
37/115
B+*y A++)* R'o+ Co)(('' KBARC, (:' L* B*= o (:' :)l)&&)*'KLB * o(:'+ )*('+'(' &+()' (o )3u (:' )*&u( (o (:' -lu()o* o (:'&+o&'+(y * ol)3)( -)';, u'()o*, o
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
38/115
2. G(:'+
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
39/115
.
DAR A. O. No. 9, S'+)' o 1990 ly o;* (:' +ul' o*
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
40/115
LG! o3' 3o*3'+*' *o()' DAR
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
41/115
(:' *u
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
42/115
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
43/115
+'&o*)
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
44/115
&'()()o*'+, :o;'-'+, (:' '3( +' o (:' l*:ol)* ;'+' *o( &+o&'+ly'+'(' * 'l)*'('. !&o* +'3')&( o (:) *o()3', (:'+'o+', &'()()o*'+3o+&o+()o* : *o )' ;:)3: &o+()o* o )( '((' ;'+' u
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
45/115
S'3. 9. #olu*(+y O'+ (o S'll. T:' o-'+*'*( :ll &u+3:' ll +)3ul(u+l l*)( '' &+ou3()-' * u)(
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
46/115
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
47/115
33o&*y)* o+)**3' &' u&o* * &&+o-'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
48/115
'('+)*' ;:'(:'+ H3)'* l)3o, B*)l * Cyl;y +' *o*+)3ul(u+l,:'*3', ''&( +o (:' 3o-'+' o (:' CARL l)' ;)(: (:' DAR, *o( ;)(: (:) Cou+(.
F)*lly, ;' (+' (:( (:' )lu+' o +'&o*'*( DAR (o 3o&ly ;)(: (:' +'u))(' o u' &+o3' )* (:' 3u))()o* &+o3'')* o' *o( )-' (:) Cou+( (:' &o;'+ (o*ull)y (:' CLOA l+'y )u' (o (:' +'+
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
49/115
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
50/115
FWB OF @,29@ THE !NSENT OR !N!SED BALANCE OF THE ROCEEDS OF THESALE OF THE 00 HECTARES AND 80.1 HECTARES OF THE HLI LAND, BECA!SE
K1 THE ROCEEDS OF THE SALE BELONG TO THE CORORATION, HLI, ASCORORATE CAITAL AND ASSETS IN S!BSTIT!TION FOR THE ORTIONS OF ITSLAND ASSET WHICH WERE SOLD TO THIRD ART$
K2 TO DISTRIB!TE THE CASH SALES ROCEEDS OF THE ORTIONS OF THE LANDASSET TO THE FWB, WHO ARE STOC5HOLDERS OF HLI, IS TO DISSOL#E THECORORATION AND DISTRIB!TE THE ROCEEDS AS LI!IDATING DI#IDENDSWITHO!T E#EN A$ING THE CREDITORS OF THE CORORATION
K/ THE DOING OF SAID ACTS WO!LD #IOLATE THE STRINGENT RO#ISIONS OF THECORORATION CODE AND CORORATE RACTICE.
B
IT IS NOT ROER, EITHER IN LAW OR IN E!IT$, TO REC5ON THE A$MENT OF J!STCOMENSATION FROM NO#EMBER 21, 1989 WHEN THE ARC, THEN !NDER THECHAIRMANSHI OF DAR SECRETAR$ MIRIAM DEFENSORSANTIAGO, ARO#ED THESTOC5 DISTRIB!TION LAN KSD ROOSED B$ TADECOHLI, BECA!SE
K1 THAT ARC RESOL!TION NO. 89122 DATED NO#EMBER 21, 1989 WAS NOT THEACT!AL TA5ING OF THE TADECOHLI AGRIC!LT!RAL LAND
K2 THE RECALL OR RE#OCATION !NDER RESOL!TION NO. 200/201 OF THAT SDB$ THE NEW ARC !NDER THE CHAIRMANSHI OF DAR SECRETAR$ NASSERANGANDAMAN ON DECEMBER 22, 200 OR 1@ $EARS EARLIER WHEN THE SDWAS ARO#ED DID NOT RES!LT IN ACT!AL TA5ING ON NO#EMBER 21, 1989
K/ TO A$ THE J!ST COMENSATION AS OF NO#EMBER 21, 1989 OR 22 $EARSBAC5 WO!LD BE ARBITRAR$, !NJ!ST, AND ORESSI#E, CONSIDERING THEIMRO#EMENTS, E6ENSES IN THE MAINTENANCE AND RESER#ATION OF THELAND, AND RISE IN LAND RICES OR #AL!E OF THE ROERT$.
O* (:' o(:'+ :*, ARC * DAR, (:+ou: (:' O3' o (:' Sol)3)(o+ G'*'+l KOSG,+)' (:' ollo;)* )u' )* (:')+ Mo()o* o+ +()l R'3o*)'+()o* (' July 20,2011
THE DOCTRINE OF OERATI#E FACT DOES NOT AL$ TO THIS CASE FOR THEFOLLOWING REASONS
I
THERE IS NO LAW OR R!LE WHICH HAS BEEN IN#ALIDATED ON THE GRO!ND OF!NCONSTIT!TIONALIT$ AND
II
THIS DOCTRINE IS A R!LE OF E!IT$ WHICH MA$ BE ALIED ONL$ IN THEABSENCE OF A LAW. IN THIS CASE, THERE IS A OSITI#E LAW WHICH MANDATES
THE DISTRIB!TION OF THE LAND AS A RES!LT OF THE RE#OCATION OF THE STOC5 DISTRIB!TION LAN KSD.
ELS Su'+ 201@ A++)* L; * So3)l L')l()o* Full C' T;'*(y19 0
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
51/115
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
52/115
ollo;)* )u'
I
THE HONORABLE S!REME CO!RT SHO!LD HA#E STR!C5 DOWN SECTION /1 OFURA @@7V FOR BEING !NCONSTIT!TIONAL. THE CONSTIT!TIONALIT$ ISS!E THATWAS RAISED B$ THE RESONDENTSINTER#ENORS IS THE LIS MOTA OF THE CASE.
II
THE HONORABLE S!REME CO!RT SHO!LD NOT HA#E ALIED THE DOCTRINE OFOERATI#E FACT TO THE CASE. THE OTION GI#EN TO THE FARMERS TO REMAIN ASSTOC5HOLDERS OF HACIENDA L!ISITA IS E!I#ALENT TO AN OTION FORHACIENDA L!ISITA TO RETAIN LAND IN DIRECT #IOLATION OF THE COMREHENSI#EAGRARIAN REFORM LAW. THE DECETI#E STOC5 DISTRIB!TION OTION STOC5 DISTRIB!TION LAN CANNOT J!STIF$ S!CH RES!LT, ESECIALL$ AFTER THES!REME CO!RT HAS AFFIRMED ITS RE#OCATION.
III
THE HONORABLE S!REME CO!RT SHO!LD NOT HA#E CONSIDERED ULICOV ANDURCBCV AS INNOCENT !RCHASERS FOR #AL!E IN THE INSTANT CASE.
Mll+), '( l., o* (:' o(:'+ :*, -*3' (:' ollo;)* +ou* )* u&&o+( o (:')+Mo()o* o+ R'3o*)'+()o* (' July 21, 2011
K1 THE HOMELOTS RE!IRED TO BE DISTRIB!TED HA#E ALL BEEN DISTRIB!TED!RS!ANT TO THE MEMORAND!M OF AGREEMENT. WHAT REMAINS MEREL$ IS THERELEASE OF TITLE FROM THE REGISTER OF DEEDS.
K2 THERE HAS BEEN NO DIL!TION OF SHARES. CORORATE RECORDS WO!LDSHOW THAT IF E#ER NOT ALL OF THE 18,804./2 SHARES WERE GI#EN TO THEACT!AL ORIGINAL FARMWOR5ER BENEFICIAR$, THE RECIIENT OF THE DIFFERENCEIS THE NE6T OF 5IN OR CHILDREN OF SAID ORIGINAL UFWBV. HENCE, WERESECTF!LL$ S!BMIT THAT SINCE THE SHARES WERE GI#EN TO THE SAME FAMIL$BENEFICIAR$, THIS SHO!LD BE DEEMED AS S!BSTANTIAL COMLIANCE WITH THERO#ISIONS OF SECTION 4 OF DAO 10.
K/ THERE HAS BEEN NO #IOLATION OF THE /MONTH ERIOD TO IMLEMENT THEUSDV AS RO#IDED FOR B$ SECTION 11 OF DAO 10 AS THIS RO#ISION M!ST BEREAD IN LIGHT OF SECTION 10 OF E6EC!TI#E ORDER NO. 229, THE ERTINENTORTION OF WHICH READS, THE ARO#AL B$ THE ARC OF A LAN FOR S!CHSTOC5 DISTRIB!TION, AND ITS INITIAL IMLEMENTATION, SHALL BE DEEMEDCOMLIANCE WITH THE LAND DISTRIB!TION RE!IREMENT OF THE CAR.
K4 THE #AL!ATION OF THE LAND CANNOT BE BASED AS OF NO#EMBER 21, 1989, THE DATE OF ARO#AL OF THE STOC5 DISTRIB!TION OTION. INSTEAD, WERESECTF!LL$ S!BMIT THAT THE TIME OF TA5ING FOR #AL!ATION !ROSES IS AFACT!AL ISS!E BEST LEFT FOR THE TRIAL CO!RTS TO DECIDE.
K TO THOSE WHO WILL CHOOSE LAND, THE$ M!ST RET!RN WHAT WAS GI#EN TO THEM !NDER THE SD. IT WO!LD BE !NFAIR IF THE$ ARE ALLOWED TO GET THELAND AND AT THE SAME TIME HOLD ON TO THE BENEFITS THE$ RECEI#ED
ELS Su'+ 201@ A++)* L; * So3)l L')l()o* Full C' T;'*(y19 2
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
53/115
!RS!ANT TO THE SD IN THE SAME WA$ AS THOSE WHO WILL CHOOSE TO STA$WITH THE SDO.
L(ly, R'*' Gl* * AMBALA, (:+ou: (:' u
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
54/115
(o +')* (o3=:ol'+ o HLI o+ (o o&( o+ l* )(+)
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
55/115
No. @0, )u'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
56/115
)u'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
57/115
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
58/115
3)+3u(*3', )( ) -+)ouly '&+''
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
59/115
(:' +)3ul(u+l l* o H3)'* Lu))( )* -)'; o HLI -)ol()o* o (:' SD *DAO 10. By &&ly)* (:' o&'+()-' 3( o3(+)*', (:) Cou+( '+'ly -' (:'ul)' FWB (:' o&()o* (o +')* (o3=:ol'+ o HLI * +ul' (:( (:'y ;)ll+'()* (:' :o'lo( * o(:'+
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
60/115
u'()o*)* (:' 3o*()(u()o*l)(y o S'3. /1 o RA @@7. T:' '3o* +'u)+''*((:( (:' 3o*()(u()o*l u'()o* :oul
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
61/115
III. Co-'+' o Co&ulo+y A3u))()o*
FARM +u' (:( (:) Cou+( )*o+' 3'+()* ('+)l 3( ;:'* )( l))(' (:')u +' (o
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
62/115
Co*(++y (o (:' lo( &+ll'l (*3' o (:' +'&o*'*(, =''&)* H3)'* Lu))(u*+'*(' ) lo *o( o* (:' )&'+()-' )&o)()o*
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
63/115
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
64/115
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
65/115
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
66/115
A &+'-)ouly '*()o*', W' +ul' )* Ou+ July , 2011 D'3))o* (:( )*3' (:' Cou+('3lu' (:' 00:'3(+' lo( u
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
67/115
(:' +):(, o
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
68/115
O* (:) *o(', DAR 3l) (:( (:' UlV')()(' 3o+&o+(' '&'*' :oul *o(
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
69/115
'*('+&+)' * (:' +)*'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
70/115
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
71/115
3o-'+'. E-)'*(ly, (:' &&+o-l o (:' SD (oo= (:' &l3' o *o()3' o 3o-'+')u' u*'+ 3o&ulo+y 3u))()o*.
Alo, )( ) u+&+))* (:( ;:)l' (:' )*o+)(y o&)*' (:( u*'+ (:' (o3= )(+)
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
72/115
Co)(('' KARCCOM, :'+')* &+o-)', :ll, )* (u+*,
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
73/115
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
74/115
&+o&o'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
75/115
Co*(++y (o (:' '+()o* o AMBALA * FARM, *o;:'+' )* (:' SD, RA @@7 *DAO 10 3* )(
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
76/115
S)*)3*(ly, HLI +; &+()3ul+ (('*()o* (o )( :-)* &) )( FWB, u+)* (:'+')' o (:' SD K1989200, o' : /
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
77/115
) (:' +'l'' o ()(l' +o (:' R')('+ o D''.U7@V T:'y u+(:'+ '+( (:( (:'+':
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
78/115
Mo+' (:* )(''* K1@ y'+ :-' 'l&' +o (:' ()' (:' SD ; &&+o-'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
79/115
T:'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
80/115
(:' +'+ ( (:( ()' (:( *u
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
81/115
)()o*l +;o+='+.
Go)* )*(o *o(:'+
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
82/115
&y (:' o-'+*'*(. To
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
83/115
:* o (:' +'+, W' +'3o*)'+ ou+ +ul)* (:( (:' ul)' FWB :oul
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
84/115
WHEREFORE, (:' Mo()o* o+ +()l R'3o*)'+()o* (' July 20, 2011 l'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
85/115
\ : 70,000,000 \ : 80,11,00 Z : 1,//0,11,00 :ll
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
86/115
/. E'3()* +o (:' l* (:' o3ll' ('**(, *'ly G
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
87/115
T:' &)-o(l )u' ) ;:'(:'+ o+ *o( l* o
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
88/115
UG.R. No. 10//02. Auu( 12, 199/.VNATALIA REALT$, INC., * ESTATE DE#ELOERS AND IN#ESTORS COR., &'()()o*'+,-. DEARTMENT OF AGRARIAN REFORM, SEC. BENJAMIN T. LEONG * DIR.WILFREDO LEANO, DARREGION I#, +'&o*'*(.Lo*) M. (o o+ &'()()o*'+.
T:' Sol)3)(o+ G'*'+l o+ +'&o*'*(. S$LLAB!S1. OLITICAL LAW STAT!TOR$ CONSTR!CTION A SECIAL LAW RE#AILSO#ER A GENERAL LAW. P T:' )&l''*()* S(*+, Rul' * R'ul()o* o .D. 97 &&l)' (o ll u
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
89/115
'*3y, +' *o( ''' X+)3ul(u+l l*X ;)(:)* (:' '*)* * )*('*( o S'3()o* / K3 o R.A. No. @@7. No(
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
90/115
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
91/115
DAR &&+o-l. W' *o; '('+)*' ;:'(:'+ u3: l* +' 3o-'+'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
92/115
WHEREFORE, (:' '()()o* o+ C'+()o++) ) GRANTED. T:' No()3' o Co-'+' o 22 No-'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
93/115
&oul(+y
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
94/115
* /2 o R.A. No. @@7 K(:' Co&+':'*)-' A++)* R'o+ L; o 1988, )*o+ (:' ) l; )*3lu' (:' +))* o l)-'(o3=, &oul(+y * ;)*' )* )( 3o-'+' ;'ll (:' I&l''*()* Rul' * Gu)'l)*' &+oul(' )* 33o+*3'(:'+';)(:.
T:' 3o*()(u()o*l &+o-))o* u*'+ 3o*)'+()o* +' ollo;
ARTICLE 6III AGRARIAN AND NAT!RAL RESO!RCES REFORMS'3()o* 4. T:' S((' :ll,
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
95/115
T:' &'()()o* ) )&+'' ;)(: '+)(.
T:' u'()o* +)' ) o*' o 3o*()(u()o*l 3o*(+u3()o*. T:' &+)+y (= )*3o*()(u()o*l 3o*(+u3()o* ) (o 3'+()* * (:'+'('+ u+' (:' +'l)?()o* o (:' &u+&o' o (:' +'+ )* (:' o&()o* o (:' Co*()(u()o* KJ.M. Tu?o* % Co. -.L* T'*u+' A)*)(+()o*, /1 SCRA 41/ U1970V.
A3'+()*'*( o (:' '*)* o (:' &+o-))o* o Co*()(u()o*
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
96/115
I ; ;o*'+)* ;:'(:'+ I ;+o* )* y &&+'3)()o* (:( ) o'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
97/115
T:u, ;:'+' (:' l')l(u+' o+ (:' ''3u()-' 3(
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
98/115
&u+&o' o (:' l;, ).'., (:' ;'l+' o (:' l*l' +'+ * +;o+='+ )* (:'&+oo()o* o o3)l u()3',
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
99/115
Eu()* l)-'(o3= * &oul(+y +)* ;)(: o(:'+ +)3ul(u+l 3()-)()' ) loll3)ou )* (:' '*' (:( l)=' (:' *u3(u+)* '3(o+, )( ) +='( o+, +(:'+(:* ou+3' o +)3ul(u+l ou(&u(. A( l'( @0 o (:' '*()+' o'()3 u&&ly o 3o+* )
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
100/115
(:' Co&+':'*)-' A++)* R'o+ L; KCARL o 1988, (oo= ''3(. I( )*3lu' )*)( 3o-'+' + u' o+ +))* l)-'(o3=, &oul(+y * ;)*'. O* D'3'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
101/115
Lu? F+ 3' (:' A.O. &+o-)' (:' u)'l)*' (o '('+)*' ;:'(:'+ 3'+()*&+3'l o l* )
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
102/115
* &oul(+y +))*. T:' Cou+( 3l+)' )* (:' Lu? F+ 3' (:( l)-'(o3=, ;)*'* &oul(+y+))* +' )*u(+)l 3()-)()' * o *o( ll ;)(:)* (:' '*)()o* o +)3ul(u+' o+ +)3ul(u+l 3()-)(y. T:' +))* o l)-'(o3=, ;)*' * &oul(+y ))'+'*( +o 3+o& o+ (+'' +)*. I( ) * )*u(+)l, *o( * +)3ul(u+l, 3()-)(y. A+'( &o+()o* o (:' )*-'('*( )* (:) '*('+&+)' ) )* (:' o+ o )*u(+)l ''(, u3: *)l :ou)* (+u3(u+' * 3)l)()', +)*', ;('+'+ *
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
103/115
U21V W)(: (:) )*)3*( o)3()o*, Co*+' 3l'+ly ou:( (o l)* (:'&+o-))o* o ou+ ++)* l; ;)(: (:' )*('*( o (:' 1987 Co*()(u()o*lCo))o* (o '3lu' l)-'(o3= + +o (:' 3o-'+' o ++)* +'o+. I* u, )( ) o3(+)*l (:( +ul' o )*)(+()-'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
104/115
3u)+' l*
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
105/115
T:' Sou(:'+* )*uy F+'+ Mul()u+&o' Coo&'+()-', I*3. K)*uy F+'+,+'&+''*('
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
106/115
/. 8 :'3(+' o+ (:' 8 :o+' 4. 0./809 u+' '('+ o )*+(+u3(u+' o+ (:' 8 :o+' U*V . 1/8.9@7 :'3(+' o+ (:' ,@78 :' o ;)*'.U1V '()()o*'+ l' Mo()o* o+ R'3o*)'+()o*,U1@V u
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
107/115
(:'+' ) &o)
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
108/115
1 Co*-'+)o* O+'+U29V (' No-'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
109/115
33o+' (:' *)* o MARO El * MARO C'l) (:' &+'u&()o* o +'ul+)(y )*(:' &'+o+*3' o o3)l u*3()o* )* (:'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
110/115
I* D'3'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
111/115
III. IN AN$ CASE, THE CO!RT OF AEALS GRA#EL$ ERRED AND COMMITTED GRA#EAB!SE OF DISCRETION WHEN IT HELD THAT THE ROERT$ IN DIS!TE IS NOLONGER BEING !SED FOR LI#ESTOC5 FARMING.U49V
'()()o*'+ '-'+(' (:( l* '-o(' (o l)-'(o3= +)* o Ju*' 1, 1988+' 3l)' )*u(+)l l*, :'*3', ou()' (:'
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
112/115
'3l+()o* o DAR A.O. No. 9 u*3o*()(u()o*l o' *o( ( ll ))*): (:'*(' u(y o (:' DAR, (:' l' '*3y o (:' Go-'+*'*(, (o )&l''*((:' CARL (:( (:' DAR, -'(' ;)(: (:' &o;'+ (o )'*()y l* u
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
113/115
L'( )(
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
114/115
8/17/2019 Full Cases Batch1
115/115
* ol 3ou+' u' o *'+ly o*':l o (:' '*()+' +' o+))*lly 3l)' ''&( +o CAR 3o-'+'