Gatherings 2012

7/31/2019 Gatherings 2012

1/113

Ghg

the heidegger circle annual

volume 2, 2012

Gatherings: The Heidegger Circle Annual ubl

h Hgg Cl, gu hl wh hv bg ull Nh A 1966 u

h w M Hgg. I h Sg 2010,

h bu g h Hgg Cl, h

b h g v u

ul ubl h h hugh w-

g M Hgg l h. Th

u h ul w ublh h Sg 2011.

issn 2165-3275 print / issn 2165-3283 online


2/113

Gatherings: The Heidegger Circle Annual

editor

Dl O. Dhl, Boston University

associate editors

Aw J. Mhll,Emory University;Rh Pl,Xavier University

editorialboard

Bb Bbh,Fordham University;Rb B,Pennsylvania State University;

Wl Bg, Villanova University;Pg Bgh, DePaul University;Rh

Cb, Stonehill College;Rb C, Stony Brook University; B Dv,

Loyola University Maryland;Chl Gug, University o South Florida;C

Hl, Loyola University Maryland; Lw Hb, Old Dominion University;

Jul Il, Whitman College;Th Kl, North Illinois University;Wll

MNll, DePaul University;Dv Pgw, Southern Connecticut State University;

F Rul,Louisiana State University;Rb Sh, University o New Hamp-

shire;Th Shh, Stanord University;Pl Vvl,Marquette University

submissionguidelines

Th g ub ubl hul lu h l h

, h uh , l ( lbl). All h g h ub-

hul b ub. All ubqu g, h g, hul

b ub bl vwg, g h uh h u-

h ubl; h ubl, h uh

ubl vu w b b h l . P hul

7,500 w, lug , hul b ub gl ,

T Nw R , 12 , u h llwg l : pd, rt,

doc , docx . A G w hul b U h.P hul h The Chicago Manual o Style, 16h ; Ch 14:

Du I: N Bblgh. Th b ub

h ul g h Hgg Cl Gatherings. All hul

b h [email protected], g Ghg h ubj.

designby ajm


3/113

G A T H R I N G Svolume2, 2012

Tg Bg: v, Cl, A 1Krzyszto Ziarek

F Destruktion h H Bg 24

Will McNeill

Th A Fugu: Hgg Rhh 41David Nowell-Smith

Th Pl Ovg Wll 65 Kg Hgg

Adam Buben

bookreview

Th v S: 89Aw J. Mhll, Heidegger Among the Sculptors

Franois Raoul

T Hgg h bbv 107


4/113


5/113

Gatherings: The Heidegger Circle Annual, 2 (2012): 1-23.

Tg Bg:

v, Cl, A

Krzyszto Ziarek

Whl h lb h h v L, Fuul, D l h hugh M Hgg, u wh ll h vu ul hg u wh h v b Hgg g hg h v (Das Ereignis), -g b h 1930. Wh h glg Hgg fu bu h bl h Hgg das

Ereignis ll h l g h v,g b h uu b g lv- l hlgl w l.

Th v Ereignis g l uu hlgl, whh wul u v h l, gu-l hw v, l blg u g u g. Th h v Hgg l l-wh, h l wh h g w -wh gg ll w, .. b w-.

theevent

Hgg l h bl h - wh h - w hlgl h l l D-, h , wh


6/113

2

krzyszto ziarek

bg l vg lhl

h g u h qu bg:this g vl lgv l D-, bu h uh b-g [Seyn], whh b u, wll bg hg h h h g ulg be-ing itsel. A h hvhg h h wlw hll l b-g u b b , bu h- b b-g l, whh -

w g gug bg.

F Hgg, hEreignis l bu h uug h hlg-l hugh bvul uh uu l- u wh h v h bu h g u h- whh hgbu bg h v w bg. Whu gg uh l bu h vbul Hgg l Contributions to Philosophy g vl h bl bg h lgl bw bg bg, I wul l l h lg Hgg u h h h h -, whh u wh hEreignis. F wh ul g bu Hgg - v h v l qu w l: h, u, lul, l, g . Wh Hgg Con-tributions to Philosophy h - h l v l w.

A vlv hugh h l 1930 l 1940, Hgg

u bu hEreignis l vl h w, u, h, ll u-g gulg W h. I b h lu bg whh u ulu Machenschat, h ,


7/113

3

Trading in Being

h, ulv w, whh h Whugh hg h ulbl- bg: , bg ulbl, lulbl, , l, bl. Hgg l h l G machen, u, whMacht, w, g hh h u g ll l h -h w. Th Machenschat hu l lluh l bw g w, whh u bhW hugh h W ulu. Iv h bl u b ulu h w. T, h

g ul hg h ug,u, l bg . O hu lbu l w, h l g ul h glbl l v h wl .

Hgg vl h qu g h b Nhwll w, h bg h hugh bg v(Ereignis) h w, l, vl. H hwhw bg h b l w h ul Gewalt(vl), Herrschat(, , g),Ma-chen (g u), , ll,Macht(w). I h, W h b w, h, b bl, lulbl, llbl, whh ,, vlu, l, . Th h wh Hggu h v u vlv lv hgbg, v h u g w, w ulg l (Gelassenheit) h wg w. Th whl u h h 1930 40 b b h h bg v

h w-. L llu h wh w qu h 1938/39 Besinnung(Mindulness).


8/113

4

krzyszto ziarek

B-g hpowerless [das Machtlose] beyond powerand lack o power b, wh u w l w, ull ul uh.

Th w-l [das Macht-lose] h wh whu-w whh whl v w l w vhl l -l w.Hw u h -less? F ureusal.

Th u -less (-los) machtlos (lll, w-l) hv, Hgg l, h l b: wl h h l w, , -w. Rh h G u los l g. Thu b b das Machtlose glh h w-, Hgg hl ugg, wh hul machtlos wh machtrei.

A v, bg l l g (Machen) w (Macht): h w hgh bl, bh g w h G Gemchtes. Rh, v b hugh

g-: Sg- h -v Dasein uh w h -v whw h /h [Da] ( h gu hu uu) whh hu l u. Sg- whwl blg b-g v. Thu hg u whh h bg. B-g -g; bu with bg uh h h v h lg wh -, w , h u l u hw u b-g. Th v l wh , b, bu ul h -l h - h bl.

Th v h bg h h qu h

bl. B-g bl, wh v hugh-v lw wh g u -gg. Rhgbg das Mgliche L Hu, Hgg h h h bl w b hll lgll


9/113

5

Trading in Being

v bl ul. Wh I hqu h bl I hpossible l -possibilitas, potentia h essentia actus existentia;h, I Bg l, whh vg [mgen, blg] v hg h v h hu, h v l Bg. T bl hg h v , l. Th l bg h b Hgg h das Mgliche: hwhh bh has h g bl ul as this pos-sible, whh h bg bh h whh bl wh hu bl.

Wh l ug Hgg h hbg, h l whh bl, h hl(Nichten, Nichtung), h h u h h bl hl. O , bl Contributions to Philosophy,Hgg b h h g u h l bg bg ul, whwl b-g, hu , , bjv, . H h,hugh, lg h h ul hg gv, h, , the oremost and utmost giting o be-ing, nay even its inceptualunolding[Wug] itsel. Th ul b hugh l, b, ul bg, bg whh hul b h, h, b , bu whh u l. Rh, h ul h eigen, h w, h w bg b: hw bgubl gv l w ul. Th ul gl h h bg h l ull, bu h vfw h hg/hlg v wh bg. I l h w whh hl h l bg vfw bhv gv, g g g bl. Thhg h u bg the overow o pure reusal. The

richer the nothing, the simpler the be-ing.

A Hgg , w h hlg w h w hg (ugvl) gv h (Krat, Macht) g hb (Ab-grund) bg. Nhl, h, h h bg


10/113

6

krzyszto ziarek

h h b, b-gu: l, h h bl hbl l b vg, g, g u hugh h uul l -.

Wh llw bg hv bl h lg -u h l -. Rlg g bg h , , bjv, , h h bl bl h b: l h b l h h bg h h bl, , whh g: h g- hl h g , -gg [ab-setzt] bg uh. Th ,hlg gg bu h hul b ll

h jugl g bg uh, wh -gg. Hwv, hlg l -gg l, whb b-g g- w l v h lg h w /h [Da]. I h gh (Krat) h -h (Nicht-hatigkeit) (hgh, -h)h bg g g bl bg: ul h llg. I gg, hl h h h g, lg bg h bl bg.Th hg h hg gv gl; h h l quvg b-g l h more-beingh bg.

Pw fw hugh bg uh w h h -, g h gbl ulbl . I hl- h qu h bl h gg bg bgw lulbl ul. Th g -u hl, whh Hgg h vb whh u h v b, gv: , l, lg b. I h w, hl h b h u los machtlos (w-l/w-

). L h g g b bu l g h hl. Nhl, w, vh (Machenschat), h , w, whh, fwg bg,u h v, -l h -, h


11/113

7

Trading in Being

g h. I h h hl l gv ( g) bu u bg g h -l bl, h w-- g b bg l. Nhl u h -l h - l power-ree. A l h -l - h h vg [g u, be-wahren] l v h whh ll bg h h lg.

capital

A h h h v l b, l llw vhg, h l bl, b bg.Sl u, bg l lw l l bg, h bg l h h h bg. Th h l-g Hgg b Alles-gelten-lassen, lg b h llwvhg b hu b vl, vl bg, , vlu. Th w v lg b f. [W]h hg Bg hub bg bj, ull wh bjv h vlu. v vlug, v wh vlu vl, ubjvg.

I l bg: b. Rh, vlug l bg: b vl ll h bj g. Wh lg b h llwghg b vl, h buh hlg g u bl. I h w, h h bl h , h g, vl bg, , ubqul, h vlu g whhbg qu. N lg hugh hl bu , Gelten bl h bg whu, w, hg h bg bg, h , bg uul h h bl, h uu h -.

I hu bl l hg bg vl hvg vlu bu l ubl bl vlu(). Ih w, lgl l l bl,


12/113

8

krzyszto ziarek

bu l l ll lul hg b llwgu h bg hugh h w bg.

Th h h Gelten l , bl, whh hlg v bg. I wh bg bg, hu hl u b quvl bg, h , h bg bg, h vu w whh bg . Bu h wh bg, w, b bg, h lw l b hl, h , l h u l b bg g, vl, vlu. T h vl h , ul h bgare , h h hl u bg, bu l h, whh

h h h h bl, wh -hl g, vl, vlu h h llw hv bg. Wh bg llw b, h v b () bg, bu h h hl-: h g bg lw l hl, v, u uu bl. A h h, wh l b,bg bg bu h h hl, h v b vl bl hvg vlu. Ol wh h v hl g, wh bg lg h qu h bl, bg b l vl vlu. Wh Gelten llw hl, v g, l hl bg bl hvg vlu, whh h b-g lbl.

A h h bg , bjv, vlu, hl b - g. Bu geltenlassen hw bg llw b vl uh bg hg g, v, hl l h g wh vl, -

v, , . I h l h Gelassenheit,bg bl, bu g,, vl, ju bu b g. Rh, Gelassenheit h ll h bl l


13/113

9

Trading in Being

h , h l -. I , l wh h -g, h b, h b bl bg wh. S vlu , h v g hg bg, gvh bg v, uh v v vh g blg hl, qu h bg, lw l , b g, h, h , g bg, b l, v, -vl. Bu h g b bl l h h h l bl b hl, h , b bg h bl. I h , lg b vl gl h h bl vl, v, v-

. A h b ull v whgelten lassen, lgb vl, l h hlg bl lbg b bu hl h h g , vl, vlubl bj u. Lg bg b vl, bg lg bl h b h h bl l g h. I uh , lg b vl lg wh lg b, u lg hl.

I g b h wl , glbl u, l l hg l-v - h w g vlu, whh g,g, g. S fuu u h - ul l, whl l g bgu h h h h glbl - h l gl . Th u l wh , uv, bl ug u g h. Y, whl , ll, ulul l - glbl l l l, hbvu vv h l -bl -

vl f wh bg w hg g, h, wh bg -bl, u l bl. Wh bg h g bl, h ubl,


14/113

10

krzyszto ziarek

uul l h -? A, ll, wh , bg bg, h b , g hg g? T u l, wh lgl -hv l h l-hlglvlg bg glbl bl?

Whl gh ll b h h ul l Hgg h h wl , hhg h hlg l h vbbl h u f h lg-l whh h - bg -bl.Hgg h vvl h h-

bg , h l Machenschat h-1930, h f h hlg, hlglvlg, h Gestell, ggg wh h hl-lglg bg, ll wh bl v g (Gestell), whh h l l bl.Thugh Hgg u lgh l l-, vlv hl ulul qu, h hg v g b h l b h w whhbg, vlg l l h, l l bu ll h wh h I h l bg. Bg b vhugh bg, h , b l h h h arebg ll, h bg h in being, bg hll hll , , vlu,, l, u . I l h bg vl l hugh bg b-g, h w g h g h vl , h l bg. Th lvllw lg bg ju h h l bg,

-, hg wh, vlu, hu hg h b l.

I l g Hgg lgl hg l. Ag wh h ll h g


15/113

11

Trading in Being

hg bg Hgg, h , h hg bg bg (Sein Seiendheit), Ch Mlbu hbLe change Heideggerw bu l l lgqu, lgl l, Hgg hugh: Olgl l h u b h g hg l. A bg g bg v h u ., bg, b h u whh b-g gv l bh b b hugh. Th b h -lgl , h hl gl , whh hugh,, h hlhl g bg bl. Thhg bg bg h ubu -

h bg bg l h l. Bg w vlg l g v, v u l, h h bg. I l l h l v b l - bu l bg l, whh h h hghg bg h h Gestell g.

Hgg l h h l qug Wh A PF?, h 1946 lu Rl ublh Holzwege:

I l h, whh h h wl-u gv l l, h bj-h h-lgl l v h h v qul, uhll, ll. N l blh [stellt....au] ll hg ubl [Her-stellbares] h u; l lv[stellt...zu] h u u b h. I l-v u [des sich durch-setzendes Herstellens], h hu hhg hg lv h lul

vlu whh l h whl h wl , bu l, h wll wll, h Bg [im Wesen des Seins marktet] hu ubj ll bg h lul


16/113


17/113

13

Trading in Being

vb markten. I u ll, h vb markten l w-g. C l g hugh h vbhandeln eilschen: , h bg hggl.Th G , hwv, leilschen, gh wh handeln, , l h uh - l h -g markten. Th l markten gg h - g, llg, ., h (als hndler den marktbeziehen, handelschat au dem markte betreiben: markten, kauen, kra-

men, nundinari). Th gg g hugh g (durch solchen handel einnehmen, in der ormel geldmarkten; viel, wenig markten.). Th h g h kauen,

l bug, llg, qug. I h uh, markten l bgg hgglg wh . ub v g ul wh bugh l, whlh l h markten gg lw , bg, -g, qubblg, g h vlu bj.

I h gu, Hgg u h vb markten hvbl h u , h whhh wl , , h bg. I h l h , h g -hg h l l h , bu, , lwh h wl wl . Ju lwh Hgg wg h wl wl, vblg h u welth v welten, h h u h h markten h vb h u Markt(). O ul h , llg hl Hgg h der Weltmarkt marktet, h hwl . Th g bvul h g g hg h vg , bu h whh, hugh h g, h wl vl b , vl b h

bg wl . Rvlg h wl b wl , h vl bg , whhl l. T b h wl vl h wl b . b u


18/113

14

krzyszto ziarek

l . I h, markten blghll h bg, h , h w whhbg ul b. Wh h g Wh AP F? h w, b bl h h vbmarkten b h whh h wl lg wl,h , lg vl wl, bu , , h , b wl .

Th wh h u markten v h wgWh A P F? 1946 b v h whh h g bg l l, bugh h, llwg l l

l h h bl hugh h-lgl - h v bg. Ju hvb markten l u, h v v h wl bg-bl l g hg. A wh , hqu wh ll bg h h wl bl bg .

I h Gestell, blg g bl, bg -vl l b h whh , , u vhg h bg b u vlu: bj, u,, l, , . Suh u wh -ll lulbl, hu bg b h vlu gl , b h l h -hg. Rh h lg b (sein lassen), h gv bg hu gelten, h b w b v bg, hv h u wh bg, bg whbg b vlu. I h, b lg b h qu h bl bu h b vlu-bl. A qu, bg h h uull bl bu b h lulbl

vlu: h b vlu-bl, bl hvg vlu bglulbl vlu. Wh bg vlu, wh b vl bg, h bg hg ll bg u


19/113

15

Trading in Being

l llwg bu llg lul. Lg b vlhu bg u, h g v, H-gg ll Th Qu Cg Thlg: vwhvhg [bestellt] b, b l h, h ju h b ll uh g.Whv bu h w h w g. W ll h g-v [Bestand].

A v h g h bl b lul vlu. Wh hg h g h bl vlu, h vlu l b l hl . I b u b

gl, , l. Th l bg, whhI h bgg , h wh lgb b lg b vl, h vl gv bg gwhh v v h hlg u h -bl. I h , uh l h lu h qub bg h g l, wh wh , v wh ll , h bg vlu vl l. Cl b hu u hvl bg h g-v, wh bg bh g lulbl ubl bg. Th G Geltungf h l vl, h , h bg vl, gg h g vlu wh.A bg vl hughgelten lassen, bg are h h hbg vlu, h wh vl. Th h bg bg, hu ul l, l hvg h g vlu, bg hg wh. A qu, h bg, wh vl=vlu=wh, b bl bg l lul l. T u l, h bg bg h vl g as l.

Th l, wh bg qu h gwhh ll lbl, l h whh wl b bl b . Cl h wl-bl, whh h wh h wl h b


20/113

16

krzyszto ziarek

h g vl l. Hvg h g h bl b l, bg b l-ulbl hgbl. Th hv vlu lul hg h bg b -bl, h h b bugh h , , . Thu g bl wh h l b -bl vl qu h h bg: bw lg b lg b vl, bw sein/nichtenlassen gelten lassen. Th bl u, -l, hlg, .

A l, hwv, h hw bg

l b, bh lg b lg b vl. Th u, h, l l, h g, v h wl-bl, bu h gg lg b hlg h bl. Cl b bll wh h lg b vl, h l bg, u vlg lg b, wh , bg h qu h bl. Y, h bl h, bu bg gvl hugh ul, uh vl lg b h lwl h. Th ul h g lg bghv hl, whh llwg h b vl l h vl vlu whhbg g b vu bg, h , bg .

theothertime-spaceoftheartwork

Th g whh Hgg u wl g bg, whh h v h u u, h lu Wh A P F? whh f h l h hlgl wl glbl l. Phlhll ll h u, l g Hgg

h h j h hg -1930 w, h wl glbl , bu h h wl -bl, h , h w whh h wl lg b wl uull - hl bu ul


21/113

17

Trading in Being

wl . I uh wl vhg h hv h hlg - bu l vul , h h l -, h h l , h glbl fw , h , l , h u hlul , h lh h vlu l bg. Wh h , , v gll, , h g wl ? N g , ll , qu l ,ll, ulul , bu, ll, l h vw hlhl hg, vg qu

h l bg h g bg vlu, l, g u . Th h h qu h g (Marktung) bg vl (Geltung), whh bg bg h , bhg h v g h v , h , hgg bg, wh lbl g vlu. Th g h, h hl vlg bg, -bl h l. Wh b vl h u Hgg hugh h qu h l bg h lgl lvl, qu h l h,g lg b lg b vl, h l , l, ulul u.

I Pl w bh ll h ul ll u hhlhl, l, , ull, h ug h l, wl bh v vl, whu ll . I ugh u h -l -bl hg , whh , lu,, hg. A h l w h b -bl hw h qu vlu , h, ,

l h vlu: l, ulul, ll, lgu,lgl, hu, h , vlu whh ul b u uvl, l, vlu gu u u u hlg. Bu, Hgg l , vlu l h h


22/113

18

krzyszto ziarek

v wh whh h v -g hll b vlu , lu, , gll, . F vlu, whh l, ulul, l, l h . Th h ul w h hw l uh h h bg ... h wh h hl l vlu.

Wh u , hu , l wh h h h g wh ; h , hg g, w ggg wh l-g u lgug, h vl vlu u-, , . P, h ,

llw lgug b h vlu bu l lgug hl. I h w, ,hugh wh wh , h hlg g whh bg, h h bl, l b. Th wh g, g , v vu -, gubl h h bg, h , h llwg bg hl h bl. Thg hllg h ulul ll vlu , l wh h vlu l gv bu l -l gv. A ul , h -bl lu, u hl bg, h hg bg l bl.I h wg wh lgug, llw l- G, ul nicht gelten lassen hl-lg g h hg hl b hg hl b bg.

Y h qu h l wh w b v bg g h ulul bj.Hgg ugg h h qu h w bu wh

h vg h h ululwh vg bg wh bjvlbl. Ovg h g ul l h hl u wh h uh.Ovg


23/113

19

Trading in Being

h g h h qu h uh bg h l, ul, l l-l l bg. T b h-ll ulull, h w h b bj, bj bl bg , , h ulull u hg bj .Culu bu ul h l bj, buh l h w v. I , Hgg, u g, hugh bu bj, h b Kunst-losigkeit, l b l , h , v, bu b l, g h h ulul

w bj. Ah ulul g l g h w hl , h h Hgg w lv bh h gu h v-g h g wlg : Ih h h wg, h l l ulu; vll h l v b-g. I l wh Kunst-losigkeit, , h , h ulul , h h w vl l v hu v g wh w ,l ug h uh b-g Wh Hgg lg h g , h ulul ,bu l l bg v g u hhlg -l h -.

Wh ul h, hlg blgg ulu, h w vl bl u bg . Bu wh , h , , whh llu bg h , w wh u hg v? I h h w l h bw w

-. O h h, h hl -, gu-l v b h w, bMachenschat, whll b bl vlbl u lulbl ulbl; u, h , glbl


24/113

20

krzyszto ziarek

l l, g, h, -b, vl-bl l ul ubl h-, , lul, hu . O h h h, h - h bl, ulg w-, bw wl, ll ul w uh. I h l, h - bw h w vl - h b h v .

Aw v g h bw h - h w h l-l glbl - l h - h w-, whbg llw -gg h u g -

, , vlu, . I h bw h- w l h - h w-h gv h ul h v l h w. O h ul h h - l g h - bl h g bg, , l l. Wh w w wh - h bl h -, b h gl h w-, h l w h l bg. F h - l h - w wul l llw l, l h uv v h w lv ul ll l w l wh h ug h glbl wul ll wl.Pw bg lw l h w, u h g wul, gl l w, hu lulbl wh lg h g v w. Th l h w h whhg h g w, g ll h h h b w. T h h v, h

w g bg bg g , h , h bw h l w, h h, h w-, h h, b vl l - w. Wh gg


25/113

21

Trading in Being

h ulul bj, w b u v h w-, hwg bg - ul w wl, w-l h - h bl. Th w hwl l l l, l b w -l -l bg h ll h w-.Plg h w g l, v gg w, g hw bg v ll lulbl u-bl vlu. A v vlu-, h uh u wh h gbl vlu, wll llubl . A v b l

h ulul , lw l g wh h w l. I w u ug h , l b bgg h -, whh bg ll v g h l w w, h v h bgg h-.


26/113

22

krzyszto ziarek

N

1 Contributions to Philosophy, 334; .2 Mindulness, 166.3 Contributions to Philosophy, 339; .4 Contributions to Philosophy, 335.5 Contributions to Philosophy, 335; .6 Basic Writings, 220; .7 Contributions to Philosophy, 170.8 Contributions to Philosophy, 176.9 Contributions to Philosophy, 173.

10 Contributions to Philosophy, 173.11 Contributions to Philosophy, 340.12 Contributions to Philosophy, 170.13 Contributions to Philosophy, 187-188.14 Th bw g hl h b

hugh h llwg w. Nhl h v gv, h das Mgliche, hwhh h h , h bl, , lw uull, hl bl. Ng l, , wh

h l l h bl, ll h - wh wh bl llw b vl. Ng b- bl wh bg bg, hu hv vlu ( b) h vl bg.

15 Contributions to Philosophy, 336; .16 Basic Writings, 251.17 L l lgqu g l qu

uv lhg g l ll-.L l v l l. Ch Ml-

bu, Le change Heidegger: Du antastique en philosophie (P:L Sh, 2004), 98.

18 Holzwege 270 = O the Beaten Track, 219; . A Sll -, w gwh Wlghl u h vh,


27/113

23

Trading in Being

hb h hll, hl u vllg Ggg hh Hh b . Sll h u ll S l Hllb P Pu u, ll Pu Puuh M u. D Mhlh Mh u Dgh Dg l h hlb h uhHll gh Mw M u, h u l Wl u, l Wll u Wll W S u ll S- Hl Rh bg, hhh, w Zhl h b.

19 Holzwege, 289 = O the Beaten Track, 235.20 markten, vb. fg, b

marken, h mark markt (. 1644) h gbl hu l hh, j h ulh, u; hwh uh mrten, vgl. u 4. C Deutsches Wrterbuch von Jacob und Wilhelm Grimm h I-. Th wb : h://g.u-./Pj/WBB/wbuh/wb ( 2/13/2012).

21 Basic Writings, 322.22 Holzwege, 267 = O the Beaten Track, 217; .23 Contributions to Philosophy, 354.24 Contributions to Philosophy, 355; .25 Contributions to Philosophy, 355.


28/113

Gatherings: The Heidegger Circle Annual, 2 (2012): 24-40

F Destruktion h H Bg

William McNeill

I h l, 1962 lu T Bg, Hgg - bw h Du, whh w l h ul lg h 1920, h l

hugh h h Bg. I h uug Being andTime, Du w v lg (Abbau) hl whh, h h lg, h v v hl, G h g Bg . I T Bg, Hgg h llwg:

Ol lg [Abbau] h l h wh b Du h-g u gh wh h vl l h g Bg. Bu l vwh

g h g Bg l h h l hg, h v uh hg wh Being and Time bu h hl D ( Bg). B , h l blw hg h l hugh hg Bg g Being and Time h hugh wh Being and Timeg h Du h lgl

h Bg bg.

O u Hgg h ul h, wh h u vw w h hl D w h -lu Bg l wh h v Du Being


29/113

25

From Destruktion to the History o Being

and Time. A , h v , g h lv h h Bg, vl wh h hl D, ul l l wh ug h h hl D h h Bg. F wh Hgg h 1962l h ul h u h hl D h Du, hg h hll h Being and Time. Th, h h Du ull h hl D: Igh h -l hl D h h qu Bg bl D l h b hl,

h ulg h qu Bg u qu w h (h h lg) b l bg hlg-l, lh v w ull w bl qug. I h hlgl qu h h Du, gu u u hhl D l.

I h bw Du h h-l D h I wul l uu h , wh vw b ug ju hw h ul lg D wh wul l b ll h h- Bg. M ulg h , I h hw, uvl b ghwl: Hgg lhg h h Bg h g Bg(Geschick des Seins) hg h h w hg wh, Being and Time, v h qu h bl (die stille Krat des Mglichen).

T bg wh, l u u b uv hw Du u b h l Hgg h lu h

Being and Time. Fllwg h, I hll u Being and Time l, ll h L Hu.

Hgg vl h Du wll b Be-ing and Time. Alhugh h h Du


30/113

26

iiam mcnei

h h u Basic Problems o Phenomenol-ogy w 1919-20, h h l hvu , h u Phenomenological and Transcenden-tal Philosophy o Values (SS 1919), wh Hgg h -l hlg. Th hlgl qu,whh wul b u Du, w, hwv, b gv , Hgg . Alhugh Hggh h hlgl qu Hul h v ug lv -, lvg l h -h wh lgl u, wh hll

, bu h wh hl qu v (Herkunt) v. B h u 1920, h u

Phenomenology o Intuition and Expression, h h-lgl qu h b wh Hgg ll ll h hlgl-l Du. A ul l, h Phenomenological Interpretations with Respect to Aristotle(1922), Hgg uh l h hl qu - hlg h qu h: Cqu h lw l qu h . []H g g bu l, bu bu ll v h whu, hwv, bg bl b uh-ll . Th hlgl hu , Hgg h , u l h h Du; h l v ll gv, deconstructive regress (abbauenden Rckgang) h wll h gl vl u ulg h l g u l l. Du hlwg h l h ; hlh u-v [destruktive] wh w h. A uh,

u h , bu h uh h u whh h u l w b v.

I h u 1923 u Ontology (Hermeneuticso Facticity), hwv, h Hgg v h ull l


31/113

27


wh l b Du. Phlg v hw h h h bj, D l , u b h l gv bj,whh b ul l, gg bj [Sacherassung] h l. Thl h lu h h h l l. Th hlhl qug, w Hgg, u buu b h gl u [Sachquellen]. Th ub l [abgebaut]. F h gg b, h gv v- (Rckgang) l g bg hlh b hv u. Th hlh hlg u b gv

h u u hl qu (historische Kritik) ul , h hl l v vh h Hul hlg. I u u h (das Heute), h -w . N v hv g , Hgg. Th l lg h , ll, g G hlh, Al, hw hw g h ll l l, l whh w ll ulv . Th lg u v ul w h gl , hu vl hg h . Hu hlg h u b : h h g h h ( ), l-u gu g h v b, b w lg ll l. I ul bg Bg l h, hw l.

Whl h 1923 u l, Hgg v Ab-bau, lg, l h h h hg hg l hwh wul vull b Du Being and Time. Th h h h vlu, whh

l , qu l g Du: Hu- Du! l Hgg, u hb vg, gu g h lu hlhl . Th uv u


32/113

28

iiam mcnei

u lg v v: lg Du. Wh g, Hgg , hg h , bu - l, g qul ull v, , bj, ull b u- u, h , h b l.

Th h Du h 1923 u u-l ul h l j u vl l Being and Time. I 6 h Iu h guu, Hgg g h Du g h gl u whh h g lg w w, gg b h u h

l h h lg h l l l h . Th D v wll vl wl w l, wl llg h D ug Bg: h h, D h h w Bg h Bg h bg h , l, h --h --h; h h h, gh wh h (in einsdamit), D ll , whh w D w v, qug, h. Alhugh h bh w D ug Bg, h w l, H-gg l, v hugh h g gh, h :h ll u lgl uu DBg gl, wul b hg h ul b v: wul b l, h, vbl b wh hv v (h llg, h , ull h -uh h-l) D Bg; whl h , whh u h , v , hg hvhl bh u b u lv (v h-lgl Du u u D uh h-

l). Th , I hll l ugg, ul g ug h Du l.

S qug g Bg gl h gug Being and Time bl D,


33/113

29


D Bg ll u b l h-l, uh hl l h v ulg h qu g Bg v . Thu, H-gg , h qu Bg u qu w h[Geschichte], h , b hlgl [historisch] u w bl qug hugh v - h . Hgg qu Bg l , , h h lg b h G ul b Al. Nw h h h, Hgg ugg,

h h whh - [l, ug Bg] ll bl h l . I lvwh h b h u l-v bl h gl u [Quellen] whh h l g w w, gu . Th - v bg uh v [Herkunt] gl blv. I gv b u h v uh g

[Rckgang].

A qu, Bg l h b g, h l l qubl, l l qu uh h - whh h j Being and Time ul bg.I G lg l h hu bl such l,Hgg : G lg h, whh, hughl w u [Filiationen und Verbiegungen] ll h ul hlh, h hD u l Bg gl h wl

[.., --h wh h wl], h h lgh h hu [verllt] h u . Glg h Bg bg wl u,v h whh l l


34/113

30

iiam mcnei

b u, hu u h g Bg , parousia ousia, hu ul , h -. G lg, Hgg h l, l qu D llg.

I G lg hg, h, h hl Du. Hgg w:

I gg w h b - h qu Bg l, h wh lg u h gl lb h l h bughbu. W u h h Du h lg, -lh b w h gug h h qu Bg, v h gl whhh l ubqul lg Bg w qu.

Th gl h, Hgg ul, gg hh h qu Bg l. Y h h -h, h qu Bg h b ll quv h G bgg: h g Bg, h, h bu, ll u h wh l b u; h -h h h h vg-v whh wulb h ul D u l h wl, u h b : h,

parousia ousia h h l wul w, llwg hDu, b wh ll w.

Suh , ul, h w Du Being and Time, j h wll b lv h w , u h 1927 Basic Problems o

Phenomenology 1928Metaphysical Foundations o Logic. A ,h hg v bu h v j. Hgg hll uh l uh. I h Zhg 1973, h h llwg :


35/113

31


I Being and Time, hwv, h w gu- g h h Bg, hh h , l -g, h v, h lgl Du. Sh, h uvbl v wh g wh h b h gv w gh.

Th v Du, Hgg ,l lu g h h Bg. A, Hgg ugg T Bg, Du l h v : only h Du- hg u gh wh h vl l h g Bg, h , h h h Bg l g. Wh, h, h h h l hDu u gh h g Bg? Thh, I w ugg, l b l h j Du l, bu u l f u h gh h gv gu h Du: h hl D l, hw h hl v Being and Time.Th f h, I wul , u 76 Beingand Time. Th , l Th l Og Hl-

g F Ou h Hl D, h h l g ug l h hlglDu h h hlh.

Th l qu h wh l uuh hlg wh b h. S hlg bl gu h hl D, u-g uh hl, authentic hlgl qu Dw h u vl b gu uh hl -l, h , h hl ulg D bl uh-. A h D l, bg--h-wl l hvg

b h, hugh : hl ,u, , u, h l. Auh hlglqu u h h bj, D h h b h, D w bl h ,


36/113

32

iiam mcnei

D l bl. I u hv bj hg hh h bl, bl l. Hgg hu w: Bu h l ll hw, hlg wlll h qu h bl ll h vl, h ghwl l u l hvg-b--h-wl bl. Auh h-lg hu gu h uh hl D,lg l u D w bl Bg, h uh bl bj h: whuh bl l. Suh hlgl qu u u hl , h u lg wh w

w bl h , bu w vl bl . A Hgg u , uh hlg lh h h h b h uh w h h vl, h h bl l , h , h uul h.

Wh l h, I h, Hgg wlg (Krat) h bl, g h -bl l, h D j, bu l, h hu h b h h D wjv v. F wh b h h D j l j w Bg bl h ugg h ( u h huhlg Being and Time) l hlgllu lg, bu vbl bu D ubjv: h ll ubjv , b u,bu ll ubjv h bu uh w h v D u Bg, gvg bh l( hl). Th j gug bl blg,h Bg l uh, hg whh D ( h

Bg h hu bg) v hg v (Ereignis) h Bg h hhl . Th h Bg h h wh hhu b ( -ll, -ul ) h


37/113

33


lgug h h hlh h hl Bg. Th hu bg lw -l v: v wh hll b Bg( uh g h v g : . Th QuCg Thlg). Th g Bg h hlulg h qu h bl.

Th g h gh wh Being and Time l - b Hgg w vl l h h b hw l h qu h bl h bgg wh gubl h h 1940, h L Hu (1946). Wh I h qu h bl,

Hgg h w, I hpossibile l -possibilitas, potentia h essentia actus existentia;h, I Bg l. Pbl w hugh hb D jv v, bu h qu h bl h Bg l, h l h bl (er-mglicht) hg hg h g h hlh b h G bgg. F h v hL Hu, w w h h l, u whh h hl Du h h hl-h l , h w uv uhhugh h l D Being and Time. I h L, h h bl v blg (Vermgen)h , h bl lh hg, h blblgg D Subj, bu g b-g, lvg, bwl, vg hu h hlu gvg g, h gv h bl,h u v g:

Thg h : Bg h b [..,hg] l h .

T b hg h lv h, v h. Thugh gl w, uh vg h bwl h g. Suh vg [Mgen] h


38/113

34

iiam mcnei

blg [Vermgen], whh l hv h h, bu l l hg -ll ul -v [Her-kunt], h , l b. I b [krat] uh blg b vgh hg l bl b. Th blg wh l bl [das Mgliche], wh - vg. F h vg Bg -bl hg. Th bl [ermglicht]h l. Bg h blg-vg, h -b[das Mg-liche]. A h l, Bg h qu h vg-blg, h , h bl.

H, h qu h bl hugh h v Bg h, l , l hg l b, h , l v v g, v. Hgg h hhh G w v, Her-kunt, gh h g (Kunt), h gv h, Being and Time, w hugh h h uul whh D w l. H, h L,hwv, h g hugh h vl Bg l h l h bl. Hgg u h qu

h bl vg, b, bwl h, -v, ul wh, Being and Time, lvl uvlwh h v qu gl : l, h hw Krat, whh G h v vlh h glh ugg, b u hl l, w, g, bu h gl gh uul h h h v Bg.

Wh, Being and Time, h qu hbl h w, h hu D

uul h h , h uul h h h bl l hu, Hgg hl l l, h-g h h h h Bg l, ul hg l h. Y


39/113

35


h h l h Bg b l hugh j uh hlg huh hl D. D uul h, gw l, , gll v, h l Bgl, uh l hg l hugh hhlgl h, Being and Time, v h Du h h hlh. O h h, hl h gh h l h Bg , h-, bu v f h j Du l, bul hw Du, hlgl j, gu h hl D. O h h h, l

h h l hugh h h Bg l l bhugh whu hlgl h h hl-h, h l b D h h b h.

T u, b w lu, l qu: Wh Hgg wh h l h v h lglDu? I wh uh v l? I - b h Being and Time, h Du h h- hlh w ull lh, bu l b h G bgg ubqu, j P Tw h vg. I j ug (Ablsung) h l h h g h G bgg h u b hubqu h h h hlhh h bgg. Th lg uh l-, hwv, wh Being and Time ugg, l u b gl u gl whh h G ug Bg v, whh wulw b ull vl, w, b ll l. N l ul D ll ,

l , bu h wl u w Bg Bg gl u uh ug w vbl l, b llhl . I l, h, gh D


40/113

36

iiam mcnei

l g h h h - h G bgg, hb gh h h-l l h , h h Bgl h l g . Th Du lh lg h l Bg h h h- hlh; h, w b h lu, hlg h whh h l [sich zuschickt] Bg h bgg h uu qu h h h hlh . Th l Bgh u h h hlh, h w, merel. Rh, l, h h h

l w whh Bg h l vl, b-, bu hugh v whwl, l-l. Ihwg h h h u ug Bg hh h w v h G bgg,Hgg h L Th 1969, h l Dbl u l h g Bg -hl. Wh h, h , h Du h gl. Buw, h u,

b vbl h h vu l h

[annglich] g Bg l l h whh h l. Th h- h hb v ull g. I v ul hh b u vl qu v w h g, h blg gh h u gul h h Bg g h h Bg.

I h w, w b h h qu lh u h h hlh ul hg hlh: h ul h h hlh, bu bl gv h v h, h l


41/113

37


b hugh h h blgg h h Bgl. N h l h ul D llg, lu uh h D. N l h,hwv: Th h Bg l b hugh hbll b vu h Bg l-l h l h h hlh b vu, h , h blv Bg h ll h h gl j Du. Bgblv, w, h bgg, v h blv: lw w, lw wll hv b, h qu h bl.


42/113

38

iiam mcnei

N

1 I lv h Destruktion ul h , l h ull g u l h .

2 Zur Sache des Denkens, 9.3 sz 20-21. Pg Sein und Zeitllw h h

(Hll . . S.: N, 1927).4 O Du h l Hgg Luh g

ul Bj D. Cw, Heideggers Religious Ori-gins: Destruction and Authenticity. Blg: I Uv-

P, 2006.5 a 58: 139.6 a 56/57: 119-203.7 a 56/57: 125-26. S, ul, b., 126: Phlgl

qu ug, bgg h ; h,h b u where v , g wh g. Cqu v hg-u gu v. N-guv v ll, b u

-gu l h gu. Wh h-lgll gu l uh, uh (hl) .

8 a 59: 29.9 Phlgh I u Al (Ag

huh Su). Dilthey Jahrbuch r Philoso-phie und Geschichte der Geisteswissenschaten 6 (1989): 239. C pia. Tl b Jh v Bu Supplements: From the

Earliest Essays to Bg T and Beyond, b Jhv Bu. (Alb: S Uv Nw Y P, 2002),

114.10 pia 245/124.11 a 63: 75.12 a 63: 76.


43/113

39


13 a 63: 105.14 a 63: 108-09.15 sz 21.16 sz 20-21.17 sz 21.18 sz 21-22.19 sz 25.20 sz 22.21 Vier Seminare, 133 =Four Seminars, 78, .22 sz 392.23 sz 394.

24 sz 395.25 F h hu bg b h

blg h l g.... F h l -g h h bg vlg h. DieTechnik und die Kehre, 24-25.

26 a 9: 316-17.27 a 9: 316.28 I h hg h bl

l 1931 lgu wh Al, Hgg hh w Krat l Al dunamis w ul. S a 33.

29 Th h b vgl gu b Rb B h v h l Hgg h Bg.S h D h H Bg: Ah BNvl? I: Heidegger in Question: The Art o Existing(Nw J-: Hu P, 1993), h 9.

30 sz 21.31 sz 22.32 I h h lu l llw-

g h ubl Being and Time, The Basic Problems oPhenomenology The Metaphysical Foundations o Logic, hl l uul b. Th b Rb B h R


44/113

40

i mcnei

T: Hgg Duug h D Bw Basic Problems o Phenomenology. S

Reading Heidegger From the Start: Essays in His Earliest Thought,. Kl & v Bu (Alb: SUNY, 1994), h 7, 8.

33 Vier Seminare, 133 =Four Seminars, 77-78, .34 Vier Seminare, 77 =Four Seminars, 43, .


45/113

Gatherings: The Heidegger Circle Annual, 2 (2012): 41-64

Th A Fugu: Hgg Rhh

David Nowell-Smith

Dug h h lu S Gg D W, Hggu h Gg g, I ll uh. A gh lu, h h llwg h :

Th hh h g vllu l.I ugh ugg wh h . Rhh,rhuthmos, fu fwg, bu huu [Fgung]. Rhh wh , whuu [gt] h v [Be-wegung] g, hu l wh l. Rhhbw . I h g w ju h, h uuhw l w h h ugu [Fuge]whh g u, h , h : -

u ul u gh, , hll.

Rhh, v bh l l ug hhlhl h h fu, wul, hugh l wg h g gen, h v b-g. Bu h ul hh hugh whh h v bbl h ugu [Fuge] h l. Th v hqu hw h hh h u h v bg wh hh bl?

Th h qu h h u wll ; g wll u h v u Hgg g l. Th hh Hgg ul h u Gg v hh l wul vg : h


46/113

42

daid noe-smit

g h ugl h (whh, u bgu, I wll hh ). I, h u- h hh lgl vl, uul hll; wh l wul ll hh -l b. lwh h l h g. Th u Gg Tl Wb bg wh h l :M h b ul g hh , bu uh h lv u b h lgug h h vl hu .Th l g h u lgug l h lgug hugh

uu , wh Hgg wul gu vbl lgug ug h u- l. A h 1953 lu Lgug h P, g Tl, h h h h [Gedicht], h u h g wv [bewegendeWoge], hl wh h vl wh hl-h b hh. Rhh(.. ) hl-h v h gwv h lgug l .

Hgg h Fuge b Gg ullgug: wll-w ul , bu l llu wh hlwh h h ju bg . I bw h l l l l h h h g bg whl. Th llwgg wll bFuge l u h ul -l bg h g, bu l b h w w h h ug l b whh vbl lgug h lv ghg bu gh h g [Sage] lgug. P b v b Hgg hhl bw w hh: h ll bw

g bg h h, h h. Ih l I wll hw h w hh j, v Hgg g .


47/113

43

The Art o Fugue

fuge :jointureandfugue

I h Being and Time, Hgg lh bg l, bu h is bg. Bu ub hl qu h w v bh bg (whh lg l ub, bg Bg, bu h h h bglg hlv h bg) . T h b b hlh Al Hgl w. F Hgg h v hugh whh wh w g u , whw , h ubl b hvg-b [Gewesenheit] uu [Zukntigkeit].

Wh Hgg urhuthmos

l, h 1939 lu AlPhysics, h h h l h bg l-lu. Hgg l rhuthmos ul-g, g, g, g: Gliederung, Prgung, Fgung,und Verassung. Og ul bl l llh u lgug Being and Time, wh u hul llgbl: gu b gh llgbl whl h, bh synthesis diairesis. I lg rhuthmos Fgung(l b Shh g), Hgg h u hh w w h

u Gg I ll uh.Th l h u rhuthmos h Al

lu Ah l h hproton arruthmiston, h whh uuh b h l , wh bg(v , l h , wh bg wll v - ). Al, Hgg gu, v h: rhuthmos b h ll, bu h hl uu b whh h wh bu b h b -bg. I l rhuthmos h b-g ul l, h , l l wh uu, llgbl hu b b. F Ah,wh bg hg , h wulu g h bg l; b , h wh -bg u ull b


48/113

44

daid noe-smit

v bg.Rhuthmos fu, bl,bu h h whh uu bg wh , hwhh llw llgbl uh--uhh w u g.

Hgg g hg l h gl dike A Sg. I l h l dike l g, Hgg u h g gen:dike, hugh u bg g, h g, ju-gvg [ugend-gende Fug]. I bg ,h u b j uh w h h llgbl , Hgg, h ju gll l, jg ll

h bw wl b (vl u). Allju, Hgg ul, ju h whl.

H Hgg bulg Being and Time h h l . Ju h g bg b u w, Hgg guh hwhl u. Hwv, Hgg A- g g bw h w . A , l lg wh h h hg h -ju [in der Un-Fuge]: whu g hju h whl. I -ju, lg whlbu b ubl b, bu h u: wh wll lb ul b Pl . Th h-l g , h, ll A g; bu A, Hgggu, -ju b h whh h bg gvju. I h w, h bg l ub h hugh whh hb bg.

I h gl bh rhuthmos dike, h, Hgg

u hw bg u hlv ll hughh gg wh b; bh u wh h whh wh bg h b . Cl h gu h l h h v


49/113

45

The Art o Fugue

u h b h w uh u-lu ll uublg; h llgbl h wl u u j. Th gu- u hughu Hgg w, l u l bu l gg b h gulb w . I Being and Time h: Ill w v h l u, bu hg wg, h l. W h h lu h h,h h w, h w g, h lg . I The

Principle o Reason, h l, h v h gu: Ou w h Bh ugu wh u , bu w lv wh

h l h, wh wh h u u wv,h w v h Bh ugu. Ju Bh ugu b b w u h wh , h ugl ju bg wh h whl b v w.

Gv Hgg l h Fuge ju h 1930 w, qu g h h hul hv h ugu h l gul u ubl gu- u . Th v h wh w h h The Principle o Reason h wll b I ll uh ugu. I h Gg lu, Fuge ul Fuge ju qu ll lg, Gg ugu j hh hh u. Whu lg lg-l u, I wul l uu l wh g lwh Hgg lg h ju bg wh h ul .

I ugu, (h ubj) vl lhll,ugg v ul, hg g b, bu lw gu bu b w -

. h h ubj u w l ( v),ugg v ul, l v h v wh h lh; v,h v, h ugu lh b, v


50/113


51/113

47

The Art o Fugue

wh hu bg h u h ,hugh whh u h , h ,u h l h uul. Th w h ll h w h w u hg uh. I,l b hbg uh ll u u whbg (, Hgg lg, u wl). F bh hg I ll uh Og, h , u-g h b , g[Bewegtheit]. I Og h g b v, h wl h, h u-v lg ulg, bg g.

I h g ll h w uu h u , bu h ll bw g bg hugh whh v uh b bl.

Y Hgg, h w h h wl h uh instigate . Th hhugh h w h h w-l(h , u). A g-h lg v, hh u l h h u, g hw h u wh h wl hl -. A h w h u h l u, h h h h lg , wh h l h u l-lu ( g-h) . F lg h w w, h h h h-wl lu h, ull bhg gug wl, wh h l bg l-lu uh. Thgg wh h l h lg v hg h u Hgg ull l-ug gh-g; h llu w h vl u logos l h l h w Hgg wh . Ag

uh--uh wh h w (hugh , ), g l uh--uh (l, h w h ), h w h h v -uu h .


52/113

48

daid noe-smit

I h, Hgg uv wh logos l:h w bl gh -g h bu h l. Th w, logos,ull v g h whh h w-lu whh h, gh bg .

Th vl h u h w Gestalt: gu gul l.A h w h u h l w-l, h h, whh, bg g u, v v l, w h wl whh wul whw. Th wl h l hw gg wh u u

l, wh h hqu h l u h wll h hqu. Ah w h l u, f h u, h u h l. Th uh w h l v qu Fl- g, whh ull b qu w lluhqu, M lg v hugh -l guu l l gu, C v h hugh hg u h h hugh l; uh u h ulg lg u h ghh llbl h l 18h u glh v, h ghl l Mll Un coup de ds. I h, h g v ghg l-ug hl gh ul ; h h gu u l.

I h whh h h l u gul h, wh Hgg ll h -g (Ri), b h -g h w h w hw l gulgu h -g: Gestalt. I h wl

h l h Gestalt, u b bl wlll -h h w wll b w. I l hw h l whu ubjg h Hgg : Wh h ll gu [Gestalt]


53/113

49

The Art o Fugue

h uu [Gege] whh h j l [der Ri sich gt].Th j [gegte Ri] h ju [Fuge] h hg uh. A h w whh h wl h ull , hb b gh h hg [Scheinen] uh, v v, hul ul. Ag h w whh h -w u b h v wll llw u h v h uh, f h g bg h b ll b h h u u wh h bg, wh Shh ul h llgbl.

T hw h v g [Bewegtheit] f hw Gestalt l, l hl. I C

Portrait du jardinier Vallier, h hg h g hul h hl l ww buh bl gh u h w v g wgh. S l h h , h wghv gg l h g, wg hvu h ul v w l . I bg l u, h wgh l h h h g ubj. A h l h l Vll h hul, w h hul gu; h u h g l wgh, h w wh h g u gh. Bu wh ullg hw, h whh h uv buh- h, Vll hl b ul still , hll h hg h wh uh w. I wul wh wh Hgg h whh , h hgh g.

I l h h Hgg, h bu h Vll w 1970, -h Gestalt:


54/113

50

daid noe-smit

D h Gl, gSll Gl l GVll

Th fv l, h g-whSll h gu l gVll

Th g / Sll Gl v ll b , bb, v, whh h v l gu, b gu.I wh g h h Gestalth w wh Hggu h w. I h b h l h w whl, , ul gu wh hw h , wh h gu h Vll hl.Th h hg h bh u Gestalt: v h whh h w g g v u j gh. I h vh, h h g-wh ll, h whhuu v. I h h, v, whh uh w ju h hg uh.

theway-makingmovement

I bh Th Og h W A A Sg,h Fuge l ju hugh whh h l bg h bg h bg . F bh, Fuge h v, -h b hugh h h wl h u whl whh bg l hlv ll bu ; bh, v u huv bw g bg. Bh, ll,

lg h jg Fuge wh logos. Th w gg wh w-l w b l-ug ghg, whl A Sg Hgg lbwFuge h logos h gh g .


55/113

51

The Art o Fugue

Bh h ju h ghg logos ul: bgg l-lgbl whl hugh g h. Bu ju logos l v, h l logos w wh lguvl. I h , I wh b h v whHgg wh lgug l.

Th g lgg Hgg hg logos ll wh lgug - . I Being andTime h h existential u l logos,h G hvg w lgug. L h u hu u existential, u lgug v

h h g lgu ;

h1939 Al lu ( h h logos ghg) h : O llegein h hg wh g wh lgug, bu h b h gl u-l l bg. I h, Hgg l whh lv u logos, h w u.

Hwv, w l u h lbw vbl lgug logos ug hughu h w. IBeing and Time, lg h v h v h wl lgu g (Bedeutungen), h : Th -gul whl llgbl put into words [Wrter]. T g,w u [Den Bedeutungen wachsen Worte zu]. Bu w-hg g ul wh g. Wh g h l hh u gu ul gwh [wachsen zu] b -g u, bu h h gwh h wh h w h-lv, gu ll , Wrter, gw h Worte gul vbl . A l Hgg wllgu h u w Dasein -

- hugh h , ul, h l, h, h l w. I bh , vbl lgug h v: h h gwh g, h h h h h (


56/113

52

daid noe-smit

ul) l l (). Bu h bl, l hw h v whh l u g. I , v, h w bl lgug w Be-ing and Time, whh uh hghl vg . W hg l h l wg wh h h vbllgug hul b u ug w, h bw u . Th b h l h ju uh lgug u g vb, hv bl, h w lgug g. N l h h u vbl

lgug b l h ghg logos; l h h v lgug h ghg v h bg bg .

Hw h w v ? T h w hul u h v b whh Hgg h lgug:h Swb h Be-wgung, h v h lgug w. Th W Lgug g u h guw: bg lgug lgug lgug. A , Hgg - h hllg hg: hw w hg bulgug wh u hlv lgu? A hw w bu lgug lgu bgg l-gug lgug as language h h hu v (b , , u), h hlg hg hlv hu v? Hgg wh wh -hu lgu gh b, h h h h l bw g Sg [Sagan], whhu -vbl g llgbl, hu vbl [Sprechen]. I h wul h uu lgl , w hul h Hgg h

ug l hugh whh h w l l bu gh ; g bg h ub h, h w wh lgug, whh wh, h u guw h , lgug .


57/113

53

The Art o Fugue

Th w h h bg lgug lgug l-gug wh g: h bgg b whh g h gh h wh lgug l . Buh qu h h b ug l h j gh hg ul g wh hu h. Th wll jgh h wh bh h bl h blg h, h u h bu . I h g h ugl, h h h j [Gege] hwg whh j [verugt] h h g, h u u h -b-. A wh l, H-gg v h u ubl b. Th j

wll h wh h ubqul Sage: h l whhu bh h g g hu h u l-gug. Bu h j l -gu h l l bu hwlgug w. Sage l u g h h w , bl b, h. Hhu lu: Ereignis gh gh h g g [Sage] ul h uu [Gege] l hwg.

Ereignis, w-g v, gh lgug uwhl [Sage], h gh gh bg . Wh lv h guw: Th w-g v [Be-wgung]bg lgug (lgu ) lgug (Sage) lgug(h ug w). Th w-g v l ki-netic, bu, Th Shh h bv, dynamic.

Wh l h w-g v b h v h? I ug h Tl h1953 lu, Hgg h . Th bwh Tl [das Gedicht], h whh b ll Tl gh gul uv, h vul [Dichtungen] h u h uu,

h bw g h. Nh vull l h Dichtungen ul h ll hlv; h, w u wh h hu u whh h , u whh ull v


58/113

54

daid noe-smit

h , w whh h ull gl, v l blqul. H I u ull h g ll h u.

F h h h h wv h h v h Sg [Sagen] . Buh wv, lvg h bh, u ll h v Sg [Bewegen der Sage] fw b v h u. Th h , h u h g wv, hlwh h vl wh hl-h b hh.

T h g u whh h qu hw g h ulg h ; l h wv uwhh h fw, bu h u h wv wh wh wh h . Th v g h h h w Th W Lgug. Th Sage h -vbl Sagen h vbl Sprechen h .Y h ll hh vl: wh hhwul vl h v ul h l wh Sage.

Bu h l Hgg gu (wh hh hh) wh bguu. I h l h , Dv Fll Kll h h g wv h ul bg w lgug, w whh l bh lg llbl, v w hg, b-g w b bh g g. Kll hu u-: Rhh h ll hg wh h w lgug h u v. I hv wh h - lgug uh. Bu h w b l ?

Th , h u h g wv b hh hl-h , h g h lgug wh h h h-, w hul h hh. Thughu h w Tl


59/113


60/113

56

daid noe-smit

w- v-uu [das Bewegungsgesetz derWort- und Versgung], ju h chorei v 336 l h wh h [Versma] h.

A w u l, Hgg h h lu h G, h h u wul hv h h l h hlv.I l g h h h l h qul h g, hgh u v wh , h ; h, hg qu ullh g h w chorei. I h g l, chorei gv kreuzt( b Pl F u), bu g l , Hgg u:

[M] gv u h l, h h u vu - h u w h ll f. Th w l ll h u h v.

L ll, h w u h wgh llh uu . Th bl h l Th Og h W A (whh h w wg h ), whl-ub l g h h uuh l u , g. I bh, w u

whh, g b v,u l . Th h h l h w choreigh v l l u, bu ubqulh b ll l u h lw gvg h whl. Th wh H-gg Og h w Gestalt: hwh h w uv j gh gll. Th , wul , u h - g w v.

I h g Shl , Hgg l l

u bu wh bu h h llw h g h h whl. Wh h u I ll uh, h qu hh ju bh h l, bu g h u hh


61/113

57

The Art o Fugue

b ubl b h h . I ll uh l b hl bw v, u b b gh whh / Wh u / Tubl h u ul.

I ll uhB gBh jh blD uh hD h l

S w u hhD

Sl gl gU h uIh b u b bug:

S w M gll luM wl llNh l lgVl uhl .

I ll O ug Sul b gh whhWh u Tubl h u ul

A wh h hghTh l Tw l A h l

B h gu:


62/113

58

daid noe-smit

A wh h Wh hll Wh wl hO g h lgAb hll hu

Gg Hgg h v bluh ll . F Gg, h u ll wul v h vulbl wh u; Hgg, h uull b g-wh-l. Wgh b , Pul M Hgg Hllg, h Gg says exactly the opposite o what Heidegger makeshim say. Y Hgg l bv bu h -l uu u wh h h wulu h . Th l h h w h A wh b h . A ul,h , b h gu h b h h , b h h , wh h hu uhbl v h whh ll h lg b- hll. Th h , Hgg gu, h g h wl (wh Dasein lv Being

and Time) whh h ull . Wh hgu Hgg g, h h ul: h h g wll h u h Gg, DW, h .

Bu wh h hh h ? I h uI h ug h hh lgl v b g h l-l g ;bu b l u. Hgg u h gu hu: Sichre Seele,jher Blick, Stamm und Sturm,Meerund Muschel; h w llbl b

u , v , h hlg hughwhh h bh u w b l. I, h , Hgg u h jher jh, u vb bg


63/113

59

The Art o Fugue

h b jv bg gh. Hgg h h v wul gl v-; gjherjh gh u h gul h bu, g vb jv, uh gl . I g b h hugh h h wl, h u h gul v bg g .

Th w h ul g l l bg llg exegesisoh , bu g llg en-counter with h . A v, h u wh h

prosodic. Th u h g hugh ,

Hgg lu, ul l bu h h g h l l g gl h u-bl Sg [die Wandlung des Sagens in den ast verborgen rauschendenliedhaten Widerklang einer unsgliche Sage]. Th h bhg l h llg h v h -vblSagen h h; hh ju, ublh Sage h j h w gh. Ju h g u- Tl , h v h hh bu h h b l Hgg whh. l w hw Hgg wg h h bb fw Gg -u ; h, b , w -u - uul jv, ulg l l g h rauschenden liedhatenWiderklang einer unsglichen Sage wh vfw l l h h h bul u. A h uljuu, Hgg wg bl unlike Gg . Th kinesis, h, jg , l l u hugh h u- Gg l Hgg l vfw.

Hgg g Gg ugl hh vlv h

ugl bw h v h wh Sagen Sprechen h v h h u whh . I Og Hgg gu h, h w w qu h h w b u b v, wh


64/113

60

daid noe-smit

wh h bg h h h w. I l uh v h g l Hgg - u wh I ll uh, h gl h l l g gl h ublSg, h l h u l u hh ju bg h w. Bu h l h, Hgg wh l -, h g hugh whh l v hhb l u gg h g v h Gg wul g. P , l h b h g llbl, bu l h

whh Hgg l dynamis: hg w.


65/113

61

The Art o Fugue

N

1 Unterwegs zur Sprache, 230-1 = On the Way to Language, 149; .2 Unterwegs zur Sprache, 18-19 =Poetry Language Thought,193.3 S h u Al De Interpretatione Th

Nu Lgug Th W Lgug, Unterwegszur Sprache, 205 = On the Way to Language, 98; Unterwegs zurSprache, 244-5 = On the Way to Language, 115.

4 Unterwegs zur Sprache, 38 = On the Way to Language, 160; .5 I h, I bl llwg h g h Hgg

h b Th Shh; Th Shh,

O Mv h Du Olg, Man andWorld, 64:4 (O 1981): 534-542, l, Ahg!Thg M S! Gatherings: The Heidegger Circle An-nual, I (2011): 1-25.

6 Sein und Zeit, 420-427 = Being and Time (. Mqu Rb), 473-480.

7 a 9: 337 =Pathmarks, 204.8 Sein und Zeit, 159 = Being and Time, 201.9 Holzwege, 329 = O the Beaten Track,269.

10 Holzwege, 339 = O the Beaten Track,277.11 Holzwege, 328-329 = O the Beaten Track, 268-269.12 Sein und Zeit, 163 = Being and Time, 207.13 Der Satz vom Grund, 87 = The Principle o Reason, 47.14 Holzwege, 37 = O the Beaten Track, 26.15 Holzwege, 54 = O the Beaten Track, 40.16 Holzwege, 37-8 = O the Beaten Track, 26-7.17 Holzwege, 35 = O the Beaten Track, 24.18 Holzwege, 37-8 = O the Beaten Track, 26-7.19 I h b h l Rh Pl Mg,

, v, Gatherings: The Heidegger Circle Annual,I (2011): 26-53.


66/113

62

daid noe-smit

20 I h Al lu h l, Hgg wll Gestalt l eidos; a 9: 344-346 =Pathmarks,210-211.

21 Holzwege, 51 = O the Beaten Track, 38.22 Holzwege, 51 = O the Beaten Track, 38.23 Shh, O Mv h Du Olg, 538.24 C Vll vl l h l.

Jul Yug h g qu b h v, whh h b lgh lu lugh wh w wh uh qul ( w h l g h l b h h

h ) bl h wlu h h l; Jul Yug, Heideggers Philosophy o Art (C-bg: Cbg Uv P, 2001), 153. Hwv, hl g Vll, whh 1902 h whh w bg w v lg u ulh h, u h w Vll b bv. M g Hgg h ubl: l, bu h g wh Hgg , h - h u V Ggh h; l,bu h h g wh -g llll b u.

25 Holzwege, 38 = O the Beaten Track, 27.26 a 13: 223. I wul ll l g b w;

h lu h l h h ll g-wh, whh ul h ll h h w Og w.

27 Holzwege, 340 = O the Beaten Track, 278. I, ju b hb h g dike, Hgg h h u-

l w dike, tisis, adikia, u b u logos, aletheia, phusis, w whh hugh u h g (Holzwege, 325 = Othe Beaten Track, 265).


67/113

63

The Art o Fugue

28 Sein und Zeit, 165 = Being and Time, 209.29 Unterwegs zur Sprache, 14 =Poetry Language Thought, 190.30 a 9: 350 =Pathmarks, 213-4.31 Sein und Zeit, 161 = Being and Time, 204; .32 Bh J Al Chl Gug wul u

h Hgg u lgug; J Al,Hgg lgug Being and Time M- (.),Martin Heidegger: Critical Assessments, vl.4 (L:Rulg, 1992), 28, Chl Gug, Heidegger and the

Problem o Knowledge (Il: H, 1983), 116.33 Sein und Zeit, 162 = Being and Time, 205.

34 Unterwegs zur Sprache, 205 = On the Way to Language, 98.35 Unterwegs zur Sprache, 242 = On the Way to Language, 112 (I hv

hg H l llw Hgg ul- ll).

36 Unterwegs zur Sprache, 252 = On the Way to Language, 121.37 Unterwegs zur Sprache, 259 = On the Way to Language, 128.38 Unterwegs zur Sprache, 261 = On the Way to Language, 130.39 Th Shh, O h W Ereignis: Hgg I-

Physis, Hugh J. Slv, Jh Sll, Th M. Sbh (.), Continental Philosophy in America(Pbugh: Duqu Uv P, 1983), 131-164.

40 Dv Fll Kll, Th Su h Wv: Rhh hLgug P Thg, Lunar Voices: O Tragedy,

Poetry, Fiction, and Thought(Uv Chg P, 1995),65.

41 Kll, Th Su h Wv, 60.42 Einhrung in die Metaphysik, 118 =Introduction to Metaphysics,

164; .43 Einhrung in die Metaphysik, 112 =Introduction to Metaphysics,

156.44 Einhrung in die Metaphysik, 112 =Introduction to Metaphysics,

156.


68/113

64

daid noe-smit

45 Einhrung in die Metaphysik, 118 =Introduction to Metaphysics,164.

46 Unterwegs zur Sprache, 229-30 = O the Way to Language, 148;.

47 Pul M, Hgg g Hll, Blindnessand Insight: Essays in the Rhetoric o Contemporary Criticism, - b Wl Gh, , (L: Mhu, 1983),254-5. D M u: l j hv hv, lgu h , h w lu g h hg.

48 Unterwegs zur Sprache, 231 = On the Way to Language, 149.

49 Swh uul, h glh l u ghjher Blick v llv .

50 Unterwegs zur Sprache, 231 = On the Way to Language, 150.51 Kll, ug g Wh P? (Unheil also Unheil

spurt uns das Heile. Heiles er winkt ruend das Heilige. Heiliges

bindet das Gttliche. Gttliches nhert den Gott), H-gg gl hhl l, whh b -l (Th Su h Wv, 72).

52 Holzwege, 55 = O the Beaten Track, 41.


69/113

Th Pl Ovg Wll

Kg Hgg

Adam Buben

I ug S Kg v w (tilbagevirkendeKrat) h, Gg Cll l h v l Hgg uh lu h h. WhCll h bu Kg u h w whh vul h, h h l hlg h vull, gull h l whl ll bg lv. H-gg, l Kg b h, v -u -u whh u h l :

h h v v D l towards

h , l g g wh h hw h h hg whh D ull l . ID, bg w h, w u- h l b lu.

Whu gg h ll u u Hgg ul b Kg wg, h h w hv uh wh h l h h w.D h h, h hv b uu bh h

Kg Hgg hl guhhl h h h. Whl Hgg vl -wh g bu Kg v, bv (bh vw Kg, h ju g Hgg) l wh h D wul , v hul

Gatherings: The Heidegger Circle Annual, 2 (2012): 65-88.


70/113

66

adam en

, b uug Hgg j. A b h lgl h hlh h, I wul l wh I b h g l h ugg u ug h lh.

theexistential philosophyofdeath

Th h l bw Kg h j hl h Being and Time l wh ggb v w ll. Bu l ll h l h Hgg h bh ul wh Kg, l u vg h u vw ugg ll w wh h. I Kg ,h gl h g h wl l b Ch, b h l (.g. R.6:6-8; 2 C. 4:10-12, 5:14-19), w, (ll) l uhll, b Ch h-. I ul l h Hgg vlv vlg ul v h Ch g h wl. ITh b h Being and Time v whhw u w h wl, v ulv, h u b h wl, wl w w w, wh h hv b .

Fllwg Pul , g wll w -bl bh h bg wh w w vwg .

Hub L. Du ul hg wh, ug hKg g , h , Hggbg-u-h, h, g all. Ju Kg l ll w lg l h b huug h wl, h g v gulhul lh wh Ch, Hgg vg h h hv b uqugl v h h v, bu h v

gg wh uhll . O u h gw g h ju h hv ll u u u wh l w. BhKg Hgg b h h w b


71/113

67

The Perils o Overcoming Worldliness

h v wl l l (Dh: tilldige,G: zullige) h h h hg h v h v h blul l .

Wh h wl u what b lh ul gv hlgl (whh u v b gu, g ll ul l -l), Kg Hgg h h h lgl (Dh: jeblikket, G:Augenblick; bh lll h bl )how l h bl (gl hhlgl vlbl) wh ll . Bh h w u u, Kg b h w

h Ch u h whwll l h l h ll wh h lv u w. F -l, h u Hu h h ull h h l, h l l h uu h . T u h w: v h l h , l, lg (h u) hb vh h h uu. Wh v- vg-l w h v - lgg . Th l l g b l hg l l hghl g l wll.

D Hgg l v l h Kgul h l l h ul hhlgl vw h h l, h -hl-g u h Hgg v hw g bg Kg w h . Hgg l hg l lv h D uu D

jg h l b l h ll ( bhw) . I wg u h bl h vlbl gv h u, bl hg g h whh uu (h lu g h bl


72/113


73/113

69


h w ug l h wl;h g h l bu h b w w h l lub hughl (.g. l ulul Ch, h-l) h ll l h. Th wll g h h b gv u w h, lg h l h w wg h b g h w u lb g h wl. Bu wh , h u wh -g h wh hl ugg gl , ull wh wll v ug. Gv h uul l

l u h j, lh, gl h h v wl .Whu uh , bh Kg Hgg blv h bl g l h lgh g, l ulull-u, u.

heideggers atheism andthetheology ofkierkegaard

Alhugh h hv uh h-l u, H-gg ll h h hlgl h h

Kg u g h wl. A l ug h w lg u hugh h wg Being and Time, Hgghl h h ul h gu hlh.Th h guh hlh h hlg: hlh bb lg, whh qu Bg gl, whl hlg l bgl bu h u ( bg) G , g H-gg, h u h Ch G qu g wh . I hlh u h l, gl, u -

qu, llw l b b hlgl .Bu Hgg gg wh ul lg Beingand Time, h u hlgl h hughu h h l u.


74/113

70

adam en

F Hgg, Kg hlg bu h l hu v h Ch G, h - h ul lg h G. H g hlgbu, ul h, h j M Luh hgh l h ul, bu w g g h lh, h lu lu hlg h l l w ul. I wul b h h u Hgg Kg hlg-l gv h Kg hl , I hv vb wh Ch h w bl hl w, I h l lv l vhg

, u .

Bu h hlg , h Kg hlgl hu gul, , , v h v h l lgl ug h hHgg Being and Time. Thu, g Hgg, K-g w l ju g l l h ghv hlul g g vg wh ul h vv h lgu .Whl Hgg l h g qu hvl,ull h h, h l v vl Kg w h hlgl g, uh h uh ul h b bl lv(.. h -lgu).

F l, A Gv, wh Kg - h hg bu h whu llg u h b lg v uh hw hlg. D lv l h , hugh G v u. Aug h h Hgg b h u h w vw

h,

h wul ll ll l h ul h hlgl. I ju u G, hwv, h H-gg j; ull, h v Kg l l-gu u h l b l v b lg


75/113


76/113

72

adam en

b gu g . B uh v uh g h Hgg .

I g bw Hgg h l- h qubl l, bh Bhl-B Hugb h vlu lu. F l, Bhl-B , h w hw b - uh whh l, b, h h -b h uw h wl qu bl. Hug, lg Bhl-B, l h Hgg b u uhlv, bu , v l ll -

.

Bu Kg g u h w vh uh h h l, g Bhl-B, h hl, g Hug, h h h v h gh ul u hgl bh h N . Wh Bhl-B Hug- l w u hu gh v l bhv w h h h.

O Bhl-B vw, Hgg h g u- h uh v uh l Kgug h h l whh hg ul l ug v h. Whl bh h h vluw wh g l u , Bhl-B u h g vl Kg l u,h h b g vg hgh h , bu bl u wlgh. I h bl, whh hv b v h h h, h bl h u - uh hl lgu . Bu Hgg

v l u, bu h v gg , h l uh wh v -bl h ul b - h l uh h b. Thu, Bhl-B , Kg h h


77/113

73


ubl h h hugh uh w lv h b l h Hgg hl-g uh bg.

Th b w bl wh Bhl-B u,hwv. F, wh g Kg l llCh wg, I wh g h l bwKg Hgg g h wl, ll lh h h ug h h h Bhl-Bl . I h g l hvl wh l u hv wh -g Kg Hgg, h Bhl-B u wh

h w gh b ll qu. S, I blv hBhl-B l h hbl h Hggb u l bl. WhlHgg ul l h u u (whh h - wh h l l h h), h gh ul bl h vlbl u b hw u (v ug h h ). I -hg, Hgg gh b h bl u, uhll , h Kg wul b l Ch v. Bhl-B l wlgh Hgg llw v h wl - w b h [h] l b b h . Y h u lu , h blv h h wh Hgg u b ugu h wh Kg u-l h h h bl.

Whu jg Bhl-B u, Hug lghl h. H gu l u bw Kg Hgg v h l

l v. Kg uh vul j hhughl w h w uh u-, bu h- hl l l l, ul u h bl u u vul.


78/113

74

adam en

Suh u wul b whu blu-g h whu lg h-l u.Hgg, h h h, l guh bw uh v l l , whh bl h uh vul l h ubl wl . I h w, Hgg l - l v wh h v h b v( bl), hb l uh wh uh v. I hb h ul h , h v b h lv h , g hhg, vlv Nl Sl.

Gv h h h g Kg qu Hgg qu l, hul u h I hvughl h w bl wh Hug u h I hwh Bhl-B. Th u h h h ll h ll Ch Kg l w-g, wh lll wh Hgg v g h wl. Whu h , Hug l Kg l l h u-hl vw hb at least wh h lhugh. Cg h h l l h l wh Kg h Hgg l, uh h h w qubl. Bu v h w h, I wul ll ugg h h l h h Hgg v -l . Th Hgg h h l vull- j ul hl l-h. I , h qu l Kg gug h hvulg g h wl h qu h uh -g ul lh h -

v h wh u.

Alhugh uh lh v , , Hgg ll, h blh guh h u w Kg.


79/113

75


Whl I g wh uh wh Bhl-B Hug- hv , h h I wul lu. I h Kg wul j h l b Hgg -lu, bu lgu ll Ch gu hh h hl gu. Alhugh Kg -ll h h l how Ch ,whh h l v l Hgg, wul b Christian whu whatCh what . I l uh what h v h h Hgg u

l. Wh Kg g h wl h u- lg Ch bh, Hgg g h wll - l- h l ul l v g h gh lu l bl uh N . I , vbl h Hgg vw gh v wh h h gv u ugh ll h u u. Th l- whv gh b h b h g -bu g g Hgg, buKg wul ll bu g g uh b ll w. I lhugh hg l h lh wh hv h l g v hl hl bu.

amutualunderstanding

Wh h Kg h g h wlu Hgg, h b h h h b . Whl

Kg ll w Hgg, Hgg b b Kg. Bu h h hw u wh b ul g? Iblv h h uh ug l h ul w


80/113

76

adam en

h Kg l h vl h l-h wh h v.

I h h uu Practice in Christianity,Kg, h l , h h qu hulb h h I gh l l grace bu l h u grace. H blv h h qu,whh ugh b , l , wh h g w wll g g h wl, ul h hu h h w. I h hg b hu h w h wl ll u l

wh v g. A Jh D. Cu u , u qu hllu h hl whl b h w w, h hlg w whu v. Hu G, hvg h ; G hu u uh bg, h h l lgu -g whh Kg g Ch h ulb g. Th G v , bu vu w bl lvl Ch g h wl h ul h v g h v h wul bbl whu h S wg wh u.

Th bl wh l v h -bug g h l wh -bl g h b vbl ugw l. Th vw h b ll llg wh h vu l Ch g bg l lh u h lgh hlglv. Kg u h guh g ub wh h bjv Ch- hul hv ll gul vg Ch wh

ulv ubjv lh wh Ch.

Hgg, hh h, h h h h g h u. Rh h ug lgu v- g h wl, h ugg v g h


81/113

77

h bl lgu u. Hgg b h g l b g w ll h gh l hvg ll h wl, bulg w g b ll g v wh vlbl hw. Thu, MCh u, Hgg l h l Plgu Kg Augu.

I wl whh Ch blu lg bl,hwv, h g h Hgg gv hl g h v Kg h gv D l- hg . I b h whu h blu, h l gg b h ,

lb wh g , whh Hgg uugg. Alhugh g h uh Bhl-B Hug, h b v g h , bu l wll-w h h wh bl hbw. Whl h h l b h wl , h h l h gv vh llw h v g h v. A h gh ju b h b h lgu wl h w g ulh ugl g h bl.

Th ug h l hlh h whhh gl g v h g ( bg b h g h wl h b hw ), h hugh A (wh G hl ul) B (whu uh hl lu),ugg gg g. Bh Kg H-gg w h ul h vul u g h h g h h wh u.Igl, h g bw h v

h ul I hv l h u l lll ThMl w Kg Nh. Ov h l w g h , Ml b Kg h hl u h ubl vbl g h Nh



82/113

78

adam en

h bl. Nh gu g hlbu, l Hgg, u lgu h v - v uh . Whl Kg wul b h wh h ul Nh , Ml luh h u h h h h vw bl ul u. Alhugh Ch h b , , ujubl , u uh ju h l Nh . Alhugh Nh l- (l Hgg u)h l, l vlu hlv l h. I wul ugg h

l u ull b h g hwl g Kg Hgg.

I , vl h vw bh Kg Hgg ugg h h u g uh -. I h Kg l hw bl, u, gu u Ch b. A ll, h uh h l uhh g h l l. Al-hugh h h h hul u g v lu, h w wh h Luh .

H, h u h g g uh h l- h w b wll b l lg h wl. I bu g u vul vg h Kg v bu h Practice h I qu bv. Whu wll-g wll w, whh lu g lu , hv h gh w g.

Hgg, h h h, l h Plg hughu h l w. Cu h Hgg l - h h uh uh

hg by bu h hg in b vg g. Alhugh h h h Hgg h ll Ch g , h vl,


83/113

79


llg , whh u Cu gl . F -l, vw l h h, Hgg ul:

Phlh wll b bl bg bu hg h h wl. Th u l hlh bu ll l hu - v. Ol g ll v u. I hh l bl lv l u , hugh hg , h - h g h b h g ug hl; h w , l u, glh, bu h wh w l, w l h h b g.

Th u u h v h v h, bu h g bf ugg hwhl Kg u h wb lg g gv l g, ll wh -Ch v, Hgg gh vull h wb g g hugh w v.Thu, h w h l hlh h ulull u wh g uul ug h h h h ll bl.


84/113

80

adam en

abbreviationsofkierkegaardsworks

ca The Concept o Anxiety. Tl b R Th llb- wh Alb B. A. P, NJ: P Uv- P, 1980.

cd Christian Discourses and The Crisis and a Crisis in the Lie oan Actress. Tl b Hw V. Hg H. Hg.P, NJ: P Uv P, 1997.

se For Sel-Examination and Judge or Yoursel!Tl b Hw- V. Hg H. Hg. P, NJ: P U-

v P, 1990.p Sren Kierkegaards Journals and Papers, 7 vlu. Tlb Hw V. Hg H. Hg, b Gg Ml-hu. Blg: I Uv P, 19671978.

na The Moment and Late Writings (Nw Al). Tlb Hw V. Hg H. Hg. P, NJ: PUv P, 1998.

p Philosophical Fragments; Johannes Climacus. Tl b Hw- V. Hg H. Hg. P, NJ: P Uv- P, 1985.

p The Point o View. Tl b Hw V. Hg H.Hg. P, NJ: P Uv P, 1998.

pc Practice in Christianity. Tl b Hw V. Hg H. Hg. P, NJ: P Uv P, 1991.

sd Sickness unto Death. Tl b Hw V. Hg H.Hg. P, NJ: P Uv P, 1980.

sks Sren Kierkegaards Skriter, 28 vlu (lu g vlu). b Nl Jg Cl l.Chg: G Flg, 1997-2013.

tdio Three Discourses on Imagined Occasions. Tl b HwV. Hg H. Hg. P, NJ: P UvP, 1993.

Works o Love. Tl b Hw V. Hg H. Hg.P, NJ: P Uv P, 1995.


85/113

81


N

1 tdio, 97 / sk s 5: 465. I h b lu h w, l-h Dh uh Kg w (sks) bu h l glh l v wh l Dh . Th -lu wll u b bl vlu h ll h ubl.

2 Gg Cll, Fu Ful: Th T b hS h Gv, International Kierkegaard Commentary,vl. 10, . Rb L. P (M, GA: M Uv

P, 2006), 436.3 tdio, 75 / sk s 5: 446.4 sz 259. Th Mqu Rb l h b

llw hughu.5 Ag Hgg w, I u l h l g-

u u vl ; h w g , , h h v vl h , , , h Kg fuw ll lg ubl.

6 uu ul b h h wh h l hh ghg b hg, hg u; whw , h , wh h , hw (The Epicurus Reader, . B Iw L.P. G [Il: H Publhg C, 1994], 29).

7 O h ug g h wl, , l, cd,17, 72, 172, 184, 208, 242-43 / sks 10: 29, 81, 183, 194-95, 216-17, 248-49; se, 76-85 / sks 13: 98-105. O h vw h v h g Ch h l v, , l, p 1: 71-72; 2: 354, 368; 3: 82, 101,

467 / sks 23: 323; 24: 491; 25: 400-01, 432-33; 26: 44.8 I Th, Hgg P Phlh u-

Being and Time, Continental Philosophy Review, 37, . 4(2004): 456. C. Jh v Bu, The Young Heidegger: Rumor o


86/113

82

adam en

the Hidden King(Blg: I Uv P, 1994),158-67, 174-76, 186-89; Mhl Thu, Th Ubulg h Thugh Dh: Tl l, Ivv I, Uhu Pbl Kg A Gv,. Gg P, International Kierkegaard Commen-tary, vl. 10, . Rb L. P (M, GA: M UvP, 2006), 338-39, 343-46.

9 Hub L. Du, Being-in-the World (Cbg, MA: ThMIT P, 1991), 312.

10 sz 262-67.11 C. V MCh, M Hgg: Kg Ifu-

H I Full Vw, Kierkegaard Research: Sources,Reception and Resources, vl. 9, . J Sw (Su, gl:Ahg, 2011), 108-11; v Bu, 177-82. v llg uh g l h wl (l llg Kg vw) uvbl D (sz 51).

12 S, l, tdio, 75, 96 / sks 5: 446, 464. Hgg bg h g l [Zullig-keiten] wh whh bu u vg l (sz 310).C. sz 384, 388, wh Hgg u l h Kg lgug h l vl wh- bu uu.

13 C. Du 1991, 321-22; Th Kl, The Genesis o Hei-deggers Being and Time (Bl: Uv ClP, 1993), 437-38; v Bu, 190-202.

14 C. D Mguh, Th C A: Th K h Kg-Hgg Rlh, International Kier-kegaard Commentary, vl. 8, . Rb L. P (M, GA:M Uv P, 1985), 180.

15 ca, 90 / sk s 4: 393.16 V Bu, 192-93.17 sz 338.


87/113

83


83

18 Ag v Bu, hugh g Kg (lgwh h Ch h, uh Pul Augu) hHgg vl h h ll -wl u uh l -uh ll l ll l gul, whh u bh u uul bl (v Bu,185). C. l v Bu, 192-95.

19 sz 338.20 sz 391. C. l sz 384-85.21 S v Bu, 191, 194-95. C. Hu l h h -

, l ul. H wh

lv l h b h l (ca,92-93 / sks 4: 395-96).

22 Bf, l wh h h g h hg l bu hlh uggv h u gl.

23 Th h wul g b h hugh h Works o Love (.g. , 353 / sks 9: 347) A Gv (tdio, 76, 81-83 / sks 5: 447, 451-54). I h l l-u, bl w 1920-21, Hgg h wul h Nw T (l hw b Augu, Luh, Pl Kg) h u lw b v h hl wll gh, wh wul ju b ll l gl u l bu h llg wh Ch wll u (. M. 25: 13, 26: 40-45).Thu, wul ll bu l wh h u h, bu l wh h lgl v-vgl. S v Bu, 175, 178, 188-91, 193, 195, 202.

24 tdio, 75, 95 / sks 5: 446, 463; sz 250-51, 262-64.

25 tdio, 95-96, 99 / sks 5: 463-64, 467; sz 258, 265-66.26 Kl, 80.27 S Being and Time 1927 Hgg h, -

lgll g, h-lg : h G, bu


88/113

84

adam en

84

ull, what is given or theology (its positum) is Christianness hlg h h (Pathmarks, 43, 45, 48). A h: Luh , Fh g ulv b b h hg w h vl- h -u h Ch u Faith is thebelieving-understanding mode o existing in the history revealed,

i.e., occurring, with the Crucifed (Pathmarks, 44-45).28 sz 8-11, 34-35.29 sz 247-48.30 S, l, sd, 13-17 / sks 11: 129-33; l Mguh,

193. O Hgg vw Kg hlgl

sz 190; O the Beaten Track, 186; The Piety o Thinking,195-96.

31 C. sz 10. F l h Kg, p,1:71-72 / sk s 25: 432-33; se, 68 / sk s 13: 90.

32 p, 80.33 S, l, sz 338.34 Ag h llg b, Thu ull ugg h h

ll l l u hlgl A Gv gh hv Hgg h-lgl lu uh h w h h(Thu, 347).

35 tdio, 78 / sk s 5: 448. C. Cll, 436.36 .g. Chl Gug, Hgg Kg Dh:

Th ll h l, Kierkegaard and Death,. P S A Bub (Blg: I U-v P, 2011), 200-01.

37 Alhugh wlgg h Hgg l l- (sz 188) l h blh lgu l- hlh, Dl Bhl-B

h lll h wh h C j gg wlb ubg ; Dl Bhl-B, A Kg- Cqu Hgg C Auh, Manand World, 24 (1991): 126-27. Whl h u Hgg


89/113

85


l-ug g bl h g w , D w -hl-lgl u.

38 Bhl-B, 128.39 P J. Hug, Hgg Rg Kg

Rv: F Olgl Ab hl C, Kierkegaard in Post/Modernity, . M J. Mu Ml Whl (Blg: I Uv P, 1995),56.

40 Bl-B, 128-29; Hug, 47, 59.41 Bl-B, 133-37.

42 Ib., 138.43 sz 173.44 Bl-B, 130-31.45 Ib., 137.46 Hug, 49.47 Ib., 51.48 Ib., 50.49 Ib., 56.50 .g. p 3: 301-02.51 Hug, 53, 59.52 C. Jul Yug, Dh Auh, Death and Phi-

losophy, . J Ml Rb C. Sl (Nw Y: Ru-lg, 1998), 192.

53 C. Ml Whl l h h f -uh bg-wh-h h bl uh l l h l ll h hgh hu hv. I b h lll bu h hl-w hu qu h h v- ll gu gh (God, Guilt, and Death

[Blg: I Uv P, 1987], 98). Chl Gu-g v ll u hw Hgg h b v, v h ulg v ul h Hug Bhl-B


90/113

86

adam en

; Chl Gug, Hgg C F, 1927-1930, Interpreting Heidegger, . DlO. Dhl (Cbg: Cbg Uv P, 2011),97-99.

54 Hug , v hl b h j h v h h w I b (Hug, 51). Alhugh h hl - Kg g h, uh ju v Hgg . Th l l ul , bu vg h ull h h .

55 MCh h uul j (MCh, 108) w Kg uu w wh h bjv u (hwhat) gv ll u h ubjv u (h how). F l, h b-jv u Ch Concluding Unscientifc Postscriptto Philosophical Fragments l wh ughl 50 gwhl h ubjv u u h g 550 g.Sll, whl gh uh, h u b l l g what ubjv Ch b (. p, 104 / sks 4: 300). Wh l Kg w-l h h bjv u h h wlh u l l h Ch what(whh u ) g h ubjv.

56 pc, 7 / sks 12: 15. Th w h u b wh h . Th h -g h l h qu g. Bu g ulg h ul Ch hul uu bg Ch (na, 69 / sks 14: 213),

u l l Ch ul v g gv v h hvg l g b ulg h w h l. Th h u u h . I u b


91/113

87


h Kg h g u Practice hblh huh l h Dh l Zl,h Bh Jb P M (na, 69-70 / sks 14: 213). Whlh h llg v qu hg h A-Clu u h g-u qu, I blv h Kg l h -l b lbl wh wh Ch.I h b h g h I u h.

57 S .g. se, 76-77, 81/sks 13: 97-99, 102.58 Jh D. Cu, Kg, Hgg, h Fug

Mh, International Kierkegaard Commentary, vl.

6, . Rb L. P (M, GA: M Uv P,1993), 217.

59 C. Th Ml, Dv Hu: Kg Hu R, Fh, h h Phlh, Kierkegaard Re-search: Sources, Reception and Resources, vl. 5, 1, . JSw (Su, gl: Ahg, 2009), 23-27.

60 I l ugg h Hgg h Be-ing and Time j l h , bu I h b bh u hlul ug hlh wh Kg.

61 MCh, 113.62 Du, 313.63 Gug, Hgg C F, 97-99.64 I h ug uh lll J Whl

u h h v b ugg h Hgg -qu h wl Nh wh h lg Kg h wl Kg wh h lg Nh(Philosophies o Existence, . F. M. L [L: Rulg Kg Pul, 1969], 103). Ju b g h ,

Whl h g qu bu HggBeing and Time j: wh wul h w l hvl h lgug uu Ch wh h ll gg lgu v? Th w h qu


92/113


93/113


94/113

90

ranois rao

w h hg bg h l h h h lh wh h h wl, hb g ug h l h g ll; , , Mhll , b l, gh b hb l , uh h b h wl w b v g l . Th b v bl l, h , - ll. Th wul vl gh h b, h l g hg ghBlh g wh Hgg b bg wh ll h uubl u bg

h h Hlg h g u huw, h h ulu gu hvbl (Th wg h ghg h vbl),hpoiesis ulu bgg-h [her-vor-bringen] h vbl, Ah gg h l h l ghg w, h gh h l ll .

M bl, ul h g doxa g llg gl b Hgg l, l, l ( wll g llg g -l v Hgg w), Aw Mhll b -vl h h Hgg hg , l b . A Mhll u , wh Hgg lu ulu, g v h u h u ul l b qul hugh l v b lg hg l h Being and Time.B vlg vl ll-w b Hgg ul h , Mhll l bg ll j lu h hl-h Hgg h hg b, bul h ug . F, Mhll , lhugh h

ubl u w Hgg , v Hgg , h u ll h ulu Hgg f , h h A Sh b vlbl glh 1973, Hgg R


95/113

91

Review: Heidegger Among the Sculptors

A-Sulu-S 1996 G. Mhll bu h l h .

space, place, event

Wh l ulu gg h qu , h, Hgg u , h qu wh gull (das

Eigentmliche) ? Hgg ll u h 1969 A S, h hb h Sh Bqu ulu Chll, h qug bu wh , h , h qu wh . Th qu, u, h , w, l!Wh , Hgg w, u hw l l. I, g v hh, llgl l, h Hgg h hul b h blgg h g h(Urphnomene), h , h h bh whh h hg whh ul b b. Fuh, b h hugh h v whh hu vb w, h [Angst], h h l h hg bh , bu l bu, , h

v hg l bl.

Sulu wul llw u gg h qu, gv u

h , Hgg gg h rom sculpture. Hgg u wh ul vh u h qu , h whh w, -gl, l wh vv wh wl -l Being and Time. Sulu conrontation wh : Hgg l R A-Sulu-S (h whh w gv b M Hgg h g hBh Hlg ulu Ob 3, 1964 h -

Gl S. Gll, Swl): Nw qu u h l , h bv ll ulu, g l Th l h h h l


96/113

92

ranois rao

l , h b u g wh .

A l b uul h u. I A SHgg w: Th ulul b b [verkrpert] -hg. D b hl b? N. A h, , hl b [Krper] qu wh , bu h bl h [Leibphnomen], h b h g hg bg--h-wl. Thu, wh ul l h, h h l g h vbl u, uh h h h l vbl, l h w whh h hl h wl, hw b h , h b

h hu hg h.

Th ulu h hhl b bu h bg (Leiben) bg--h-wl, whh, w hul , invisible. Sculpture brings into view the invisible. Th wh Hgg : Th bg h ll vbl gu , wh h h h , h llw hg vw h ul h w v .

Th ulul b hu b hl b bu hbg bg--h-wl. D h ulul b b? I , , Hgg l h ulu -b , bu places: A ulu: ug .Sulu wul b wh . I, ul-u wul b h b l [Orten]. I whK , wh vu l l bl h b h a priori gv gu, hHgg wh h h l Bulg Dwll-g Thg, l h spaces receive their being rom locations[O] and not rom space. Hgg l h l l -gv , h hl-hlgl. Th l ul l l hugh h gg l

g.

S h wh hgu ,h b whh Hgg h h hg-u h bl l.Mhll hw v wll hw, h hgu


97/113

93


whh hughu h b l, l l [ h l u] h , Hlg ulu, , b qul h heterogeneous, h h ulu - exteriority, wh h hwg whg. I, h gu ugh u l. Th u h u , uu, . N l , uluh , gh gh w h lhughu uug.

Rug h vl l, Hgg -

u b g h l g h hghlv l l blg l. A l- Bulg Dwllg Thg, Hgg h hw hl hg that is itsel a location . Thelocation is not already there beore the bridge is. Wh l h ? Cl hg-l Mhll ghl ( l h wul b hg, hg h wul b l), bul h l h wh takes place, h lwul w wh hg hg, g l, whh g l. Hgg g h-g, h g, hg [ein Geschehen] l l, h h gg l h [ge-schieht] h h h h hg [Geschehens] uh gg. A wh h h happening o space, wh h h (Raum) h v g (Rumen) , Bulg Dwllg Thg Hgg ll u h hg h h b , [Ein Raumist etwas Eingerumtes] w v w h Ereignis? Hgg ull ugg h ll

g On Time and Being, g gl g h A S. S, h w, hul b hugh hb Ereignis: S wll bg l b hugh

Ereignis h g Ereignis, h l Ereignis u


98/113

94

ranois rao

l b lgu w, whh l l qug h g h gul bg l.

Ereignis l h R A-Sulu-S, ul wh Hgg l wh .S qu wul b: hul lb uh h v, l g-l, h l Er-eignis h hugh? A, Mhll g bl,hw wul h h bg h b (Leib) Ereignis?

emptinessandmateriality

Mhll h u b u h material-ity o bodies:S u b u hg, l b b b. S u b u ll, h, lg ll b. A vv g l, bu whh b l whwh Hgg bu l b h 1969 A S: l, h h hl hh lw hugh b (lhugh, b u, h b h Krper, Leib), whhHgg w . (O qu g h,

h h. Mhll w hughu h b b, hw v b hugh whu b. Buhw b h, gv h bw KrperLeib? I h , h blu h b? I, Hgg h h lv bl , b, h . Thu, wh Mhll b h h h lul?)Wh h l bw b , Hgg w:D ll h h hg bw G hugh, u h same w, bod-

ies. S h-l , extensio. I , h b h v hv h j, h , h blh , whh h u h u , w. I wh h , Hgg h qu bu h


99/113

95


l: Bu w wh l w [in seinemEigenen]? A h h h ll g l:Wh thought without consideration to bodies?Th g g h g wh Mhll hw, h bbl wh h l ll w h - Hgg gh gv u h , v b. Nw h b b h , bu h h Hgg g b! A hw ul b hw h g h , g whh lg u, g, g (reigeben ein Freies), h g h l

(Oenes)?

Shul h g b -hg ( ll h hw K, h R h Ahbl h C Rf h Critique o Pure Reason, lu h bl h Nhg u whu b-j). Hgg l uh h h h: h h qu , hg h (b), buromitsel: wh hugh whu hlb? Th w h qu l, h ll u, bu hv , h u, l h ul. Wh? Bu h l hl hg b l [gklrt] wh l [klrt] h b something else, in the present case,space in relation to physical bodies. O h, hg h h h, u l w [in ihrem Eigenen] wh w u l l g g hg b hg l. I, bg h vwpurely rom itsel, just as it shows itsel.Hgg g wh , h : independently o bodies. T h , h , w wll , h v g, h v, I ugg

bv, Ereignis.Hw l h g wh h l gg

Mhll l bl ? Sll, hw l h h l


100/113


101/113


102/113

98

ranois rao

Spatiality belongs to the clearing[Lhug]. I blg h whh w ju g [hu] bg. Y Mhll - h D l , w, vv, h , v bg--h-wl: D h bg-- l h b Bg--h-wl gl. Th lu h hhw Hgg bg--h-wl ul b whu ,ll h Mhll bl l.

Mhll b u qu h h v wl b Hgg l wg. Hwv, u h h l Hgg hbl bw wl , g

h 1964R A-Sulu-S, wh Hgg hwhw w, bl, wl: Th hu bu b h u h u b. Wh I h,h I l h hu I ulul hb h ww , l, u h w,briey put: I am in a world. A wh Hgg h hbg h b Leib, h h l uu D bg--h-wl: Th bodying[Leiben] o the body b h w bg. Th bg h b, h, w D- bg. A ull: Bodying uh blg bg--h-wl.

Mhll vl h qu g ul D- The Metaphysical Foundations o Logic, lg h ulD l . Ag, ul -u h b hwg h h essentialbw ul D l D, bu Mhll h h h ll b Hgg lw ulu. A Mhll u : I h l w ulu,h hlgl b h h b

u l, u l, hugh l/l v, hwv u b. I wll uu hqu uh, ll Mhll g w bw Hgg l wg h l w, l h


103/113

99


g uv g Being and Time u h . A g, h: gl, hul b bl ju hgl Hgg l wg whu g ju hl wg.

Mhll l h h wl , h things u u ul lg: h ll D b uv ul h wl uh ull w - h v h b u Hggl w. Y Mhll h w h Being and Time l v bj, h gh

hv qu l. O gh gu h bg--h-wl, l h -h---whh Mhll , l h D w bg--l h hg wh whh vlv ull. Mhllgv h l h h uhg h wll, lu h Hgg h hg hlv , llug h Hgg l (I wllu h ). Hwv, gh h h h gl bj, h uh bl wh h , a space or spacing, wh wl u hg gv hlv , hu wh h g- g.

Wh h qu h wl, llg h- Hgg l, Mhll l h Beingand Time D w h : F, l u h D , , h h , hv l g h u w . I hugh h qu g h j u ll u qu u D l ul

u, wh D u. I h w, wul b u D h Being and Time l Mhll , h g h bg l h lg vwhlg


104/113

100

ranois rao

. A qu h u: wh vwhlg h, gv h l h l g, h whhhg gh w? A lgh wh H-gg bu l Bulg Dwllg Thg,l h hg h h b , hg h l , namely within a boundary,Gperas, Hgg h g h l l hl lug h ll lu h horismos, hh, h bu, h h whh h b , that which is let into its bounds? Th bh l h: h vwhlg , whh

l g l, g l h l; h h l h whh gh w; h, h l l u g ll (hll hughu Mhll b u - J-Lu N w l, u, ll).Wh h l bw h h ? Wh h lbw h h l Mhll hb b? Wh, , h l bw Nhugh h l, u ll, Hgg w ? S ulg h qu wul hv b hlul,ll h h ul qu l h u: h g u, /h g l. Fll, h vwhlg , h , w wh l bg l, bg u l,whu l? Hgg , w bv, h bg u , g g 40Being and Time, wh Hgg h nowhere. Th h wh hg nowhere

h wh bu.

Wh u wh, l l. I ulu ul gu h vbl,ul l gu uh wh, uh bg u l? Wh


105/113

101


l gv h u--l h Lv Hgg h wllg, h g?

thehumanbeing intheeventofspace

Mhll b uu b wh l bw l, h Hgg, l w hwul h h. Bu h l b -vg. L ugg h h l lb Hgg h h h l wb h v l h hu bg hv . Wh h , I wul h h u-g Being and Time h- w ulS h l ug Hgg, -ug h Hgg v h L Hu. I , w l 1929 h Hgg w h hg, O h Gu.H l vlg, vlv h -. A g h h h- Being and Time, Hgg , wh g l b h [D g h , h ]

h l u entire solely hwg hh essence D h h h , ..,excentric? I h w, D h , bu l h bg, outside-l, ,ll g, wll , h hv hg wh ,ll Hgg, Spacing = l g h lg [der Instndigkeit in der Lichtung], . I hub bl h, hcentrism, -ll D h h hlgl bg,D bg bu h Da- Sein.

Nw, wh hg h g b h- h l w ( h h v hv!), I wll l u h Hgg h vl h hu h v h b bg.


106/113

102

ranois rao

I , Hgg l h h blu lw wh h b u human g, h, bg-human D-. Mhll w bw hugh h hu h l w hg hg b l wg. Bu l u l h ll. W l w Hgg g b h l. Wh h ? Th ! Wh w [Eigenste] h .Wh, h, ? Aw: S [der Raumrumt]. Sg clearing out, makingree, h g [reigeben ein Freies], [Oenes]. I

, l gv , h wh h h bl g, , bu, h bl gu. A h?Th hu vlv , , required byh g,Hgg g h llwg: , hvg h whg hw h human , h w h hu bg l hl b, bu uh w h h g [den Raum einrumt], h h hv hl b hl b [Krper]. Rh, h hu lv hb [lebt seinen Leib]. H h w: B : (l u), l gv h g l h. Bu l l insoar as hhu g , h gvg, l hl , blhg hl h hg , h w . Th, Hgg u, as space, h hu bg, Hgg vg h h u l h l h uh l h l bw h hu bg , bul h l bg h hu bg, h h

: Ereignis. Ereignis hu h wh Hgg ll h bgg h h l bw , h wh gl u, h - hu wh


107/113

103


Ereignis. O gl h - h h l hu bg .

Wul h l h bg ll -h? Pbbl , I g, Mhll hw -vgl g 83 86, h v l l, Hgg u h v vlgl h hu bg h gv gl (Hggg h gg v h hu) h u/l ll hg. I h ll h b hugh b Hgg h bg h hubg? Th llwg g ugg uh: Th hu

lv h h b [leiben] hu h h , hugh h l- [Sicheinlassen] h uh l l h llw hu hg. Ih Zll , Hgg g v uh h v, Jul 6, 1964, l h hg(hg ), h h whu h hubg, h l hu hv , h h hu bg blg h h, h h l - as space. I R A-Sulu-S h h l h h hu bg uh lg, l l noh . Hw w u h , hw w l h wh Mhll l h Hgg l hughv h vlg D gl llg whv? Qu h v hw uhMhll b gv u h, wh Hgg lg h 1964 lu ulu, l h hl-hl h gu, .., h hg .


108/113

104

ranois rao

N

1 D Ku u Ru (1969) Aus der Erahrung des Den-kens, 1910-76, a 13: 203-211. Tl b Chl H. Sb A S,Man and World6 (1973): 3-8, whh l The Heidegger Reader, b G Fgl(Blg, IN: I Uv P, 2007), 305. glhg as, llw b g ub The Hei-degger Reader. I wh h llgu J Cgbu hllg h .

2 Heidegger Among the Sculptors (h h), 14.

3 s, 1.4 s, 2.5 s, 1, 52.6 s, 81.7 s, 22.8 s, 47.9 s, 60.10 s, 8.11 S Bemerkungen zu Kunst Plastik Raum (h

kpr). I hv gll llw Aw Mhll l h , wh l , wll -ul h v Jh Mhg, SuhCu S Uv Mqu Uv.

12 a 13: 205 / as, 306.13 a 13: 205 / as, 306.14 a 13: 205 / as, 306.15 a 13: 205 / as, 306; .16 kpr , 6.17 a 13: 205 / as, 306.

18 kpr , 14.19 kpr , 14.20 kpr , 14.21 a 13: 205 / as, 306.


109/113

105


22 a 13: 208 / as, 308.23 a 7: 156 / pt, 152.24 a 13: 208 / as, 308.25 a 13: 205 / as, 306.26 s, 39.27 s, 44.28 s, 93.29 a 13: 208 / as, 308.30 a 7: 156 / pt, 151, h.31 a 13: 207 / as, 307-308.32 a 7: 156 / pt 152.

33 Z u S, Zur Sache des Denkens (1927-1968), a 14: 28-29 = On Time and Being23; .

34 kpr , 15.35 s, 1-2.36 zs 113/86.37 kpr , 11.38 kpr, 12, h.39 s, 90.40 kpr , 13.41 Iul K, Critique o Pure Reason, l

b Pul Gu All W. W (Cbg: Cbg U-v P, 1998), a 292/ 348, . 383.

42 kpr, 12-13, h; .43 a 13: 209 / as, 309.44 s, 24.45 C s, 69, h.46 a 13: 209 / as, 309; .47 a 13: 209 / as, 309.48 s, 14.

49 s, 3.50 zs 283/225, h.51 s, 5.52 kpr, 13-14, h.

7/31/2

Date post:	05-Apr-2018
Category:	Documents
Upload:	malcolm-winder
View:	221 times
Download:	0 times

Gatherings 2012

Documents