DI Energy storage Conference Copenhagen, 24. August 2017
Global Drivers and Perspectives on Chemical Energy Storageon Chemical Energy StorageMaximilian FleischerCorporate Technology
siemens.com/innovationUnrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
Our milestones –Over 170 years
1866Dynamo
1816-1892Company founder, visionary and inventor
2012Field testing of the world's largest rotor at an offshore wind farm
1983Magnetic resonance tomograph
1959SIMATIC controller
1847 1925 1975 2010 2016
Werner von Siemens Siemens innovations over 170 years
Pointer telegraph Electrificationof Ireland with hydropower
High-voltage direct-current (HVDC) transmission
TIA Portal for automation
MindSphere introduced as the digitalization platform for all industries
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 2 Corporate Technology
World Finite and Renewable Energy Resources
The planetary energy reserves
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 3 Corporate Technology
Source: http://asrc.albany.edu/people/faculty/perez/Kit/pdf/a-fundamental-look-at%20the-planetary-energy-reserves.pdf
Photovoltaics Used to be Driven by Enthusiasm & SubsidiesNow: Industrial Solar Parks driven by Business Models
The five largest PV plants.E h 500 MW
Desert Sunlight Solar Farm, CA, 550 MW
© Time Magazine March 2016Private Solar Farm in Germany
Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum Solar Park,Dubai, 1000 MW, (planned 5000 MW by 2030)
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 4 Corporate Technology
Each >500 MWpeak All built in last two years Built in China and US, Germany (# 18,25) South Germany 7 Ct/kWh, middle east <3 Ct/kWh
Global Generation Capacity Additions of Wind and PV Power Plants
Note: overall installed global power generation capacity approaching 1TW = 1000 GWpeak
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 5 Corporate Technology
Source: http://www.ren21.net/GSR2015-Renewables-2015-Global-Status-Report-Figures-EN (Abbildungen) und IHS (PV-Zubau in 2015)
g p g p y pp g peak
From system to market integration via decentrally managed grids towards a completely decoupled generation and consumption
Energiewende 2.0
<10% 20+% 40+% 60+% 80+%
– Efficiency – Decreasing spot market prices – Power2Heat CHP increasing – Regional plants cellular grids – Complete integration of
– Fossil (coal, gas, oil)– Nuclear– Renewables (mainly hydro)
– Fossil (coal, gas, oil)– Renewables (wind, PV, hydro)
– Capacity markets etc. – Predictable regional “area generation” (topological plants)
– Interaction of all energy carriers
Traditional mix System integration Market integration Regionalself sustaining systems
Decoupled generation and consumption
Past Today Mid-term Long-term
– Efficiency– LCC reduction– Availability / reliability / security
– Decreasing spot market prices– Subsidized economy– Increasing redispatch1) operation
– Power2Heat, CHP increasing– Demand side management– First storage solutions– HVDC/AC overlay
– Regional plants, cellular grids– HVDC overlay and meshed
AC/DC systems– Power2Chem / CO2toValue– Stability challenge
– Complete integration of decentralized power generation
– Storage systems/Power2X– Return of gas power plants?
• Integration of large scale renewable generation becomes system challenge with regard to grid design and system stability
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 6 Corporate Technology
Integration of large scale renewable generation becomes system challenge with regard to grid design and system stability• Interdependencies of renewable generation, prosumers and storage systems require huge competence in system management• Core Technologies for future energy systems are Power Electronics, Storage Solutions, and IC Technologies
1) Corrective action to avoid bottlenecks in power grid
Increasing Share of Renewables: Germany in Front, Others Started to Follow
Volatile renewables with increasing share on total electrical energy production
Production of electrical energy in Germany, 8. July: Volatile renewables are close to the limit! (Double in 10 years acc. to German government) …
S l ti f i l f l t i l f bl d d
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 7 Corporate Technology
Solutions for economical usage of excess electrical energy from renewables needed
Source: eex-transparency.com, sma.de/unternehmen/pv-leistung-in-deutschland
Example: Increasing Share of Renewables: Germany in Front, Others Started to Follow
Volatile renewables with increasing share on total electrical energy production
Left: Production of electrical energy in Germany, 10. July (Sunday): less demand from industry, trading prices decline
Right: Similar situation during a windy winter night: 22. February (Wednesday)
S l ti f i l f l t i l f bl d d
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 8 Corporate Technology
Sources: eex-transparency.com, sma.de/unternehmen/pv-leistung-in-deutschland
Solutions for economical usage of excess electrical energy from renewables needed
Storage of Volatile Renewables?
9 pumped Hydro Power Plants in Germany can store 40 GWh
40 GWh
16 m: Diesel16 m: Diesel20 m: Methanol18 m: Ethanol166 m: (Methane, 1 bar)230 m: (Hydrogen, 1 bar)40 m: (Hydrogen, 200 bar)
50 m: Lithium ion batt.96 m: Lead acid batt.
19 m: Lithium19 m: Calcium0 ( yd oge , 00 ba )
23 m: (Ammonia, liquid)19 m: Calcium16.3m: Magnesium
4.500 and 40.000 GWh excess renewable energy expected in Germany in 2020 * • Europe‘s largest Li Battery plant BMZ Batterie-Montage-Zentrum GmbH, Karlstein: 5 GWh planned in 2020• 0.4 GWh = 400 MWh storage by Southern California Edison in Long Beach / LA Los Angeles (1.000.000 Li-Ion cells)• Limberg II (Austrian large pumped hydro storage) annual balancing is 207 GWh
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 9 Corporate Technology
Only chemical storage for seasonal / transportable energy storage
• Limberg II (Austrian large pumped hydro storage) annual balancing is 207 GWh
* Source EM TI
Storage- & Power-to-X-Technologies are required to balance consumption vs. renewable generation and support sector coupling
Segmentation(use cases) Chemicals/Hydrogen/MethaneW
eeks
Flow-Batteries Pumped
Hydro
Thermo-mechanicalstorage
Hou
rsD
ays
T h l
ETES1)CAES2) ACAES3)
Flywheel storage(< 1MW Flywheel, up to 100 MW Turbines)
Super
Min
utes
H
Li-Ion
NaS, Lead AcidNaNiCl
Batteries Technology
MechanicalElectrical
Electrochemical
ChemicalThermal
Super capacitor
Seco
nds
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 10 Corporate Technology
1) Electro-Thermal Energy Storage 2) Compressed Air Energy Storage
1 kW Power 100 kW 1 MW 10 MW 100 MW 1,000 MW
3) Adiabatic Compressed Air Energy Storage
System & Markets Competence is essential to reduce the uncertainty regarding the development of future energy systems
Fossiland renewablegeneration
Infrastructuredevelopment
Storage systemsand prosumers
– What is the technical need for thermal l t iti i f t
– What is the need for transmission and di t ib ti id i f f t
– What is the system impact of a large t ti f l t i l t i thpower plant capacities in future energy
system scenarios? What is the impact of international power exchange?
– How are thermal power plants operated in future energy system scenarios? Are
distribution grid expansions for future energy system scenarios?
– How does a “cell approach” impact the need for transmission grid expansion?
Wh t id i /i t lli t id
penetration of electrical storage in the future energy system?
– What is the need and the system impact of different power-to-heat and thermal storage options in future energy
they profitable?
– Can a substitution of lignite power plants by CCGT1) plants enable a more competitive “Energiewende”?
– What grid expansion/intelligent grid management are needed in the distribution grids to integrate distributed energy resources?
g gysystems?
– Will industrial-size power-to-chemical plants significantly influence the need for infrastructure expansion?
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 11 Corporate Technology
1) Combined Cycle Gas Turbine
Storage solutions –Selected Siemens activities
High temperature heat pump Hydrogen CO2toValueSiestorage
‒ Heat as the largest part of‒ World‘s largest PEM ‒ Siemens demonstrator‒ High-capacity lithium-ion Heat as the largest part of final energy consumption (47%)
‒ 10kW demonstrator operating at >140°C available
World s largest PEM electrolysis systemin Mainz, Germany
‒ Goal: convert electricity to hydrogen (>6MW)
‒ Highly dynamic PEM high-
Siemens demonstrator using to convert carbon dioxide into carbon compounds for industry
‒ 1. step: chemical feedstock (Ethylene ~1000 €/t,
High capacity lithium ion storage system
‒ Modular concept with four standard components
‒ Siestorage system with an output of 1 MW at a
‒ Pilot application in MW range in production
g y y gpressure electrolysis
‒ Next generation with higher performance
( y ,carbon monoxide ~600 €/t)
‒ 2. step: energy carrier (Methane)
O St t D i i li ti f b tt t t i d t i l h t l PEM
output of 1 MW at a capacity of more than 1.4 megawatt-hours in Schwäbisch Hall, Germany
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 12 Corporate Technology
Our Strategy: Drive commercialization of battery storage systems, industrial heat pumps, scale PEM electrolyzer business, push frontier research in CO2toValue
To meet the decarbonization targets, all industry sectors will become more electr(on)ic – Siemens key applications in mobility
Taxibot: Innovative aircraft towing truck
eHighway: Electric road freight transport
eAir: Hybrid electric airliner
eBus: Sustainable public transportation
eFerry: CO2-free shipping
– Pilot-controlled taxiing without aircraft engines running
– Major fuel savings, emission & noise
– Hybrid trucks supplied with electricity from overhead contact lines at up to 90km/h
– Increased system
– Fuel consumption ~51% of aircraft operating costs
– Electric propulsion: >25% fuel, emission
– DC charging post, off-board and on-board pantographs
– Flexible, fast-charging system mounted on
– World’s 1st all-electric car ferry developed with Fjellstrandshipyard (Norway)
– Powered by three reduction, foreign object damage
– Certification granted, three Taxibotsoperating in Frankfurt
yefficiency and energy savings
– Cooperation with Scania, demonstration projects in Sweden and
and noise reduction
– Development of hybrid electric airliner in research cooperation with Airbus
ymast or roof of a bus stop
– Implemented by the Hamburger HochbahnAG
ybattery packs
– 1st ferry (360 passen-gers, 120 vehicles) in operation since 2015
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 13 Corporate Technology
operating in Frankfurt projects in Sweden and California
with Airbus AG
Option already available: Water to HydrogenTechnical Principle of a Proton Exchange Membran (PEM) Electrolysis System
-+
-+
Stacking of > 100 cells to get to high power
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 14 Corporate Technology
Energiepark MainzElektrolyzer SystemElektrolyzer System
3 SILYZER 200 PEM-electrolyzer skids
3.75 MW rated power / 6.0 MW peak3.75 MW rated power / 6.0 MW peak power (limited in time)
High dynamic: load changes in seconds, capable for partial load in a wide range
35 bar outlet pressure35 bar outlet pressure World largest PEM electrolyser
installation
15
„Energiepark Mainz“ –PEM-Electrolyzer in the MW range
ElectricityProject scope‒ Three high performance PEM electrolyzer
Wind power
cityHydrogen
Electricity
with max. performance of 6 MW‒ Connected to wind farm (10 MW)‒ 1.000 kg storage (33 MWh)‒ Goal: annual production of 200 t
(filling station and feed in to public gas
Research Elec
tric
Hydrogen
„Energiepark Mainz“Production and storage
of hydrogen
Hydrogen (filling station and feed-in to public gas grid)
First results
Gas orcombinedheat and
power plant
H
Public gas gridHouseholds
Filling station
‒ Operating from Sept. 2015 – April 2016‒ Peak power exceeded: 6.7 MW‒ Achieved efficiency of 60 %‒ 1.200 MWh absorbed
Industry
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 16 Corporate Technology
p pFilling station ‒ 20 t of produced hydrogen
How much Fuel can be Made with the Energy of a Windpark?
Air traffic
Energy balance for Power-to-Liquid scenarios
Renewables (on-grid / off-grid)
Power-to-Gas/Liquids Plant Liquid fuelinfrastructure
Airbus A3208.7 mil. km air mileage fleet
with 6 planesOR
trafficgrid) infrastructure
Road transport
Scania G410
85 mil. km road mileagefleet with 2000 trucks
OR
Private transport
520 mil km road mileage fleet200 MW i df 560 380 GWh H2
Electrolysis Chemical synthesis
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 17 Corporate Technology
520 mil. km road mileage fleetwith 50,000 cars
200 MW windfarm 560GWhel
380 GWh H2
280 GWh fuel 280 GWh fuel
Courtesy Dr. Alex Tremel, Siemens Corporate Technology
Several potential markets exist for Green Ammonia: it is a carbon-free flexible asset
Generation
Hydrogen Storage Transport Fuel for
Synthesis Use
Solar Power
Storage Transport Fuel for Fuel Cell Vehicles
Electrolysis
Air Separation Unit
Ammonia Cracking
Feedstock (Fertiliser or other Industry)
Agile Ammonia Synthesis
Wind Power
Gas Turbine
N2
Ammonia Shipment
or other Industry)
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 18 Corporate Technology
Ammonia Storage
Gas Turbine Power Generation
Grid IncreasingDSR / Grid
balancing services
product valueCT
Confidential © Siemens AG 2017
Seite 5 April 2017
Siemens is building a Green Ammonia energy storage demonstrationsystem in the UK - at Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, near Oxford, UK.
• Proof-of-principle for Agile H-B, and ammonia energy storage.
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 19 Corporate Technology
• Development platform for future demonstration: cracker,refuelling station; electrochemical ammonia synthesis; plant optimisation etc.
Direct electrochemical CO2 reduction –A novel process for feedstocks
Carbon Dioxide (CO2)– 10 giga tons carbon dioxide (CO2)
Market penetration in 3 stagesElectro-catalyticalreduction V 1. Advanced Biogas Process –2
emitted by power plants in 2013
– Example: Germany's biggest power station Niederaussem emitted 30 million tons in 20131)
CO2
COC2H4
MeOH, CH4,
O2
1. Advanced Biogas Process demonstrator market
2. Chemical feedstocks – market entry
Liquid petroleum gas LPG
Renewable Electricity– Climate targets only achievable
via flexible use and mass storage systems Technical req irements
Ethylene (C2H4)
Carbon monoxide (CO)
Formic acid (HCOOH)
Ethanol (C2H5OH)
Butanol(C H OH)systems
– Due to power system congestions,excess energy of 4-40 TWh p.a. to be expected
Technical requirements– High faradic efficiencies: Current efficiency >90%– Low power consumption: System efficiency >50%– High turnover rates: Current densities >0.3A/cm²– Long lifetime: >4,000h (service business!)
3. Fuels as mass market
Methanol (CH3OH)
(C4H9OH)
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 20 Corporate Technology
Source: 1) http://www.wwf.de/fileadmin/fm-wwf/Publikationen-PDF/Studie-Dirty-Thirty-2014.pdf
Upscaling for CO / Syngas generation out of CO2 into kW and x000h range
Tasks of “CO2toV lab demonstrator building” – Characterization of catalyst materials – Definition of optimized process parameters for CO– Evaluation of scale-up and long-term tests– Support transfer to pilot-scale
Liquid Handling in 300 cm2 cell
Lab-scale demonstrator
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 21 Corporate Technology
Also Liquid Products can be made out of CO2Using a Cu-catalysed Electrochemical Reduction (research stage)
• Ethylene formation is accompanied by C1 to C3 liquid components
• Quantitative liquid phase analytics established
Main
Ethanol
Formate
• Faraday efficiency gaps are fully closed on absolute scale
• Products were observed time resolved
no doubt, that they come from CO2 electrolysis
Minor Acetate
Mono-Ethylene-Glycol
n Propanoln-PropanolAllylic Alcohol
Trace Methanol
A
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 22 Corporate Technology
Acetone
Quantitative NMR spectrum with water suppression
The decarbonization will transform the entire energy value chain –with strong growth rates and a complete electr(on)ification
Massive trendStrong demand Digitalization as Energy storage Electrification ofMassive trend towards distributed generation and
Strong demand for highly efficient power plants, flexibility
Digitalization as new driver for technology progress and
Energy storage innovation shaping the future power
Electrification of applications, especially in the transport sector
renewables and lower emissions
new business models
industry landscape
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 23 Corporate Technology
Siemens Corporate Technology –Contact and further information
Prof. Dr. Maximilian FleischerChief Expert Energy Technologies
Siemens AGCorporate Technology, Research in Energy and Electronics Otto-Hahn-Ring 681739 MunichGermany
Internetsiemens.com/corporate-technology
Unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017
7Page 24 Corporate Technology