of 65
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
1/65
Governance & State of DelhiPresentation by
CHETNA
Society for Protection of CultureHeritage, Environment, Traditions and
Promotion of National Awareness(Regd)
E-mail: [email protected]
Web site: www.chetnavk.com
India International Centre 14-07-06
mailto:[email protected]://www.chetnavk.com/http://www.chetnavk.com/mailto:[email protected]8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
2/65
Governments Efforts to Improve
Governance-Social AuditACCESS TO INFORMATION-GENESIS
GOOD GOVERNANCE RESULTS FROMTRANSPARENCY, ACCOUNTABILITY AND CITIZEN
FRIENDLINESS;SECRECY AND LACK OF OPENNESS IN
TRANSACTIONS IS CONTRARY TO THE SPIRIT OFAN ACCOUNTABLE AND DEMOCRATIC
GOVERNMENT;DEMAND FOR INTRODUCING GREATERTRANSPARENCY IN THE FUNCTIONING OFGOVERNMENT DEPARTMENTS AND PUBLICBODIES;
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
3/65
Governments Efforts to Improve
Governance-Tools CITIZENS CHARTERS
REDRESSAL OF PUBLIC GRIEVANCES
REVIEW OF LAWS, REGULATIONS ANDPROCEDURES
PEOPLES PARTICIPATION,DECENTRALIZATION AND DEVOLUTION
OF POWERS TRANSPARENCY AND RIGHT TO
INFORMATION
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
4/65
Governance-
Corruption in Judiciary
24-02-2004-Times of India-Chief Justice cries formore powers:-
Give some powers to the Chief Justice. Whatpowers does the Chief Justice of India Have?Despite repeated requests nothing has been done.How do I control the situation and how much can
be done to control such situations by passing theorders on judicial side. You (the Government) donot know with how much difficulty I secured theresignation of the two high court judges earlier
Contd
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
5/65
Governance-
Corruption in Judiciary Contd..There was complete nexus
between magistrate and lawyers in Gujarat
which lead to warrants being issued againstthe President, the Chief Justice of India, a
sitting Sc Judge and a leading lawyer
Such incidents are not taking place inGujarat alone it is happening all over the
Country.
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
6/65
Governance-
Corruption in Judiciary 24-02-2004- Letter addressed to the President of
India by CHETNA stating
The observations of the Honble Chief Justice ofIndia that appeared in all the News papers today
that there is a nexus between Judges and Lawyers
is nothing new. This nexus exists in the Apex
Court itself. The demand for more powers appearsto be an escape route
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
7/65
Governance-
Corruption in Judiciary20-04-2004- Punjab & Haryana High Court
Judges on Mass Leave;
20-04-2004Fax addressed to the President ofIndia- Whither the Indian Judiciary
21-04-2004-Presentation submitted before
President of India supported by the orders passed
by the Apex Court in one matter evidencing one
Senior Lawyer appearing on both sides of Law
before the same Bench.
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
8/65
MCD - Desilting of Drains
Reply ID No. 31 under RTI
Amount spent: - 2002-03 - Rs.23.91Crores
2003-04 - Rs.11.28 Crores
2004-05 - Rs. 11.56 Crores
Verification by:JE/AE/Officers/Councilor/MLA
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
9/65
MCDDe-silting of Drains
Still Delhi Roads get inundated with
slightest rain why?
Sewage connection in Storm water drains;
Most of the drains are settled;
De-silting only on papers.
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
10/65
MCD - Desilting of Drains
The Director in Chief-CSE MCD on 16-01-
2006 admits before Public Grievance
Commission, Delhi in our appeal no.Appeals (1585)/05/PGC/DRI/MCD/9458
that many drains in many areas are settled
and cannot be de-silted. Drain designs are wrong.
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
11/65
MCD - Desilting of Drains
Directed to put the system of de-silting the
drains on web site so that the general public
is involved with in one month.
Agreed.
Till date not complied.
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
12/65
Governance- State of Delhi
Failure of Power Reforms in Delhi
High T & D Losses continue to haunt
honest consumers;
No action by Government to establish 5
special Courts in the last 5 years.
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
13/65
PowerTheft- Facts
Out of total 24 Districts under BSES both
YPL and RPL in 12 Districts the power
theft ranges between 52% to 88%.
Source: Energy Audit Report under RTI
From DERC.
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
14/65
Power Theft- Facts
T & D Losses- BRPL, 04-05 & April 05 to Aug 05
District 04-05 4/05 to 08/05
Nazafgarh 58.90% 88.10%
Nangloi 56.90% 51.20%
Punjabi Bagh 47.00% 45.80%
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
15/65
Power Theft- FactsT & D Losses- BRPL, 04-05 & April 05 to Aug 05
District 04-05 4/05 to 08/05
Nizamudin 35% 54.20%
R.K.Puram 34.50% 21.70%
Janak Puri 39.10% 19.40%
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
16/65
Power Theft- Facts
T & D Losses- BRPL, 04-05 & April 05 to Aug 05
District 04-05 4/05 to 08/05
Vikaspuri 52.90% 55.30%
Palam 47.90% 69.70%
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
17/65
Power Theft- Facts
T & D Losses- BYPL, 04-05 & April 05 to Aug 05
District 04-05 4/05 to 08/05
Chandani
Chownk
38.60% 46.60%
Daryaganj 43.40% 54.70%
Pahar Ganj 45.60% 63.70%
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
18/65
Power Theft- Facts
T & D Losses- BYPL, 04-05 & April 05 to Aug 05
District 04-05 4/05 to 08/05
Shankar Road,
Central Circle
34.30% 57.20%
Jhilmil 44.90% 37.70%
Krishna Nagar 44.90% 54.60%
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
19/65
Power Theft- Facts
T & D Losses- BYPL, 04-05 & April 05 to Aug 05
District 04-05 4/05 to 08/05
Laxmi Nagar 58.00% 55.40%
Mayur Vihar 63.50% 66.60%
Yamuna Vihar 70.20% 69.50%
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
20/65
Power Theft- Facts
T & D Losses- BYPL, 04-05 & April 05 to Aug 05
District 04-05 4/05 to 08/05
Nand Nagri 63.90% 65.10%
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
21/65
PUBLIC TRANSPORT
No Policy Traffic congestion & Fuel Wastage
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
22/65
GovernanceState of Delhi
Annual Financial impact of traffic congestion at
each fly over :-
Annual Wastage of Fuel & Man hours Road width: 40 feet, length 1 KM Traffic Island
with four way crossing during peak hours: 8.30
am to 10.30 am & 5.30 to 7.30 pm
Fuel: Rs. 24 Crores;
Man Hours. Rs.1300 Crores
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
23/65
Governance-State of Delhi
Reason given by the governmentEverincreasing number of personal vehicles on
road? Question arises why commuters prefer
personal vehicles?
RTI answers this question and governmentstill does not react and takes correctivesteps.
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
24/65
Governance- State of Delhi
The roads of Delhi are over crowded due to
ever increasing number of private vehicles;
Reasons:
Lack of Public Transport ;
Intermediate Public Transport ,
Encroachments of carriageways & footpath,
Lack of sufficient parking space
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
25/65
Governance- State of Delhi
Route No Sanctioned
Busses
Busses Plying
66 C-9 Vasant Kunj to
JLN Stadium
4 (Four) 01 DTC
605- C-9 to Mori Gate 54(Fifty Four) 2 Pvt.
2 DTC
602 C-9 Vasant Kunj
to Red Fort06 01 DTC
02 Pvt.
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
26/65
Governance-State of Delhi
Except for lone DTC bus once in a while
either on Route no. 66 or on Route no. 605
other buses are not there for the last threeyears;
No action by Transport Department inspite
of having been put to notice as late as on02-11-2004.
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
27/65
Governance-State of Delhi
Route No. BussesSanctioned
Actual Variation
784 Nazafgarh
to Nehru Place
Nil 27 Pvt. & 2
DTC
29
737 Nazafgarh
to JLN Stadium
3 1 2
840 Extn
Source: RTI
5 2 3
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
28/65
Governance-State of Delhi
Route No STA Busses DTC Busses Total
615 JNU to NDLS
Rly
Station
14 03 17
680 CentralSecretariat
19 05 24
505 Kamla Market
to Mehrauli13 04 17
520 Super Bazar to
Malviya Nagar19 04 23
533 ISBT to Mehrauli 20 05 25
780 Super Bazaar to
IGI Airport04 03 07
Source: RTI
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
29/65
Governance-State of Delhi
The Joke:-
The Transport Department on 24-01-2006
before Public Grievance Commission,
Delhi, admits that it cannot ascertain how
many busses are actually plying on theseroutes.
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
30/65
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
31/65
Governance-State of Delhi
Heavy Goods Vehicles challaned for
overloading:
April 02Jan 03 : 3,703
April 03 to May 04 : 6,636
April 04 to March 05 : 2,656
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
32/65
Governance-State of Delhi
Financial Loss due to non enforcement of Law:
No. of Heavy Goods Vehicles Challaned from
April 02 to 31-12-02 for over loading: 3703.Every day nearly 25,000 trucks enter/pass through
Delhi and almost 80% are overloaded.
Total Trucks in Eight months: 25,000 x 8 x30 x
80% = 48,00,000
% of CHALANS- 0.0007715%
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
33/65
Governance-State of Delhi
Vehicles not challaned: 48,00,000-3703
Financial loss : 4796297 x 5,500.00
= Rs 263.79 Crores
Annualized : 263.79/8 x 1
= Rs. 396 Crores
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
34/65
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
35/65
Governance-State of Delhi
04-05 - Every day nearly 80,000 trucks enter/passthrough Delhi and almost 80% are overloaded.(Source Bhure Lal Committee affidavit in
Supreme Court)
Total Trucks in Eight months: 80,000 x 12 x30 x80% = 2,30,40,000
Total not challaned : 2,30,40,000-2,656
= 2,30,33,364 x 5,500
= Rs. 1267.05 Crores
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
36/65
Traffic Police- Statistics
Challans & Compounding Fee2004 39.65lac 43.08 Cr. Per
Challan
Rs. 85.19
Min.
Challan
Rs.100/-
31-10-
2005
3,395,47
2
28,92,65,
250
Per
ChallanRs.
108.65
Min.
ChallanRs.100/-
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
37/65
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
38/65
Governance- State of Delhi
Delhis Water Crisis
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
39/65
Governance- State of Delhi
10thPlanning Commission Report
Chapter 5.5- Page 601
In line with the National Agendafor Governance, safe drinkingwater is to be provided inaccordance with the stipulatednorms on a sustainable basis to allhabitations by March 2004
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
40/65
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
41/65
Governance- State of Delhi
31% of rural household had source ofwater within premises;
60% had to go about 0.20 Km to getwater;
Seasonal disruption of supply iscommon;
Dependence on supplementary sourceswhere tube well & hand pump is thesource;
Practice of filtering & Boiling of water
non existent;
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
42/65
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
43/65
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
44/65
Governance- State of Delhi
In many villages the villagers still have to travel more
than 3 Kms to get water;
Regular disruption is very common;
95% achievement only on papers;
Rain water harvesting and ground water charging-
embroiled in procedural formalities;
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
45/65
Governance- State of Delhi
Delhi:
Availability of Raw Water Much more than
any other European Country;
Most pampered city of India
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
46/65
Governance- State of Delhi
Reasons for shortage
Inequitable distribution;
NDMC Area- 6 to 12 hours;
Delhi Cantt Area- 4 to 6 hours;
East Delhi- 4 to 6 hours;
Luteyans Delhi- 24 hours
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
47/65
Governance- State of Delhi
DJB Responsibilities:-
Purchase, Produce Raw Water;
Filter Water through- WTP;
Supply of Filtered Water to colonies;
Maintain tube wells for supply of water to
areas not connected with filter water supply
network.
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
48/65
Governance- State of Delhi
WATER
Requirement : 950 MGD
Production : 650 MGDTransmission
& Distribution losses 40% : 260 MGD
Balance Water Supply : 390 MGDProduction figures cannot be relied upon as would
be demonstrated
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
49/65
Governance- State of Delhi
Which means substantial water is allowed
to go waste to feed:-
Illegal colonies;
Unauthorized connections; and
JJ Clusters
At the cost of Honest Tax payer
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
50/65
Governance- State of Delhi
Sanction letter No 4(205/FZ/CE/(P)-W-111/04/696-
700 dt. 4.9.1984
DDA shall make arrangement of water on its ownsources i.e. by sinking tube-wells of sufficient
yield or independent ranny wall etc. to meet the
water requirement prior to taking up any
development works in the area. No demand ofMunicipal Water for this area shall be raised by
DDA.
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
51/65
Governance- State of Delhi
Age of pumps
Wazirabad
Plant-1- 47 to 70 years- Loss of
efficiency -not known;
Plant-ll- 14 to 28 years- Loss of
efficiency - not known;
Source: Reply under RTI
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
52/65
Governance- State of Delhi
We became independent nation in-1947
Means 57 years ago
Thus some of the pumps were installed by
British prior to independence;
DDA was created in 1955- 49 years ago
Means some of the pumps were installed in
initial years;
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
53/65
Governance- State of Delhi
Chandrawal
Vertical pumpage 10 years- Loss of
efficiency- not known
High Lift Treated Clear Water Pump
age- 39 years- Loss of efficiency not
known;
Source- Reply under RTI
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
54/65
Governance- State of Delhi
Leak Detection Cell:
State of Art Equipment Purchased in 1979;
Could not be put to use because-
Pressure Chambers on pipeline were not
provided;
Status of equipment as of now not known.
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
55/65
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
56/65
Governance- State of Delhi
1989 Storage Water Tanks on loft in garage
1992- Tanks shifted on floor level of garage
1993- Tanks shifted outside garage on
Planters
1994- Tanks lowered under ground
1995- Online boosters installed
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
57/65
Governance- State of Delhi
Reasons:-
Inadequate Pressure caused by:-
Frequent change of Land use by DDA;
Commercialization of Residential areas;
Removal of Ferrules; and
Installation of heavy duty on line boosters
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
58/65
Governance- State of Delhi
Tampering-
Valves
Distribution Pipe line
Old & Outdated Pumps & Motors;
Mismatched Pumps & motors;
Lack of co-ordination
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
59/65
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
60/65
Governance- State of Delhi
How much app. 2000 flats spend to collect
& pump water to overhead tank:-
Fixed : Rs. 18,000,000
Once in 10 years
Re-occurring per annum : Rs.208,24,000
Total Exp in 10 years 1.80 Crores +
2.082x10 = Rs. 24.42 Crores
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
61/65
Governance- State of Delhi
How much 21 pockets have spent in 10
years
Capital Investment- 1.80 x 7 =12.60 Crores;
Reoccurring Expense:20.82 x 7 = Rs.145.74
Crores
Total= Rs. 158.34 Crores
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
62/65
Governance- State of Delhi
DJBS future action plan to meet the
shortfall in requirement;-
- Presently from Haiderpur WTP and in
ultimate setup of Sonia Vihar WTP
subject to availability of Raw Water
from respective states;
Source: Reply under RTI
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
63/65
Governance- State of Delhi
Causes of worry:-
Shopping Malls-
EIAS submitted by Shopping Malls:- DJBshall supply water;
DJB: As per letter
NoDJB/SE(P)W/2006/1260 dated 02-06-2006- DDA shall supply water throughBore wells.
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
64/65
Governance- State of Delhi
Vasant Kunj Phase-II (Part)
Condition No. 6 At present no drinking water isbeing supplied by this Deptt; in the area, as such
the developing agency shall not claim/ demandwater till such time the raw water is madeavailable to this Deptt. by the neighboring statesand construction of water treatment plant,transmission water lines, reservoirs etc. is
completed and the same are commissioned, for thearea.
Source: Reply under RTI
8/13/2019 Governance in Delhi-IIC 140706[1]
65/65
Governance- State of Delhi
Water Supply committed to shopping mall
from Sonia Vihar
Vasant Kunj on tail end of distributionsystem;
No restraint on new construction on the
basis of Sonia Vihar WTP;