1
GRI’s Fibrous Filler Technology
G.R. International
April 5th, 2006
Presented by: Dr. Vijay Mathur, GR International
32918 6th Avenue SW, Federal Way, WA 98023 Ph: 253-924-6070
A Paper Technology Vision Company©
2
AGENDA April 5th, 2006
1. Background and Acknowledgements 2. Statement of Problem 3. GRI Technology Solutions and Innovation 4. Project Objective and Schedule 5. Status of Milestones / Key Issues 6. Project Output / Key Accomplishments 7. Commercialization Barriers / Economics 8. Commercialization Plan and Strategy 9. Energy Efficiency
G.R. International
10. Current Status
A Paper Technology Vision Company©
3
Background and Acknowledgements
� Project Title: Fibrous Fillers to Manufacture
� Project Number: DE-FC07-0131D14439
� Principal Investigator:
� Industrial Partners:
G.R. International
Ultra-High Ash / Performance Paper
Dr. Vijay K. Mathur
– Weyerhaeuser Company – Grays Harbor Paper Company – Lawrence Livermore National
Laboratories – Pennsylvania State University – University of Washington
A Paper Technology Vision Company©
4
Statement of Problem
G.R. International A Paper Technology Vision Company©
5
Statement of Problem
� The Paper Industry currently uses fillers to reduce manufacturing cost and energy consumption
� The problem is that the current fillers causes a Loss in Paper Strength
•This is due to their size, shape, and aspect ratio
� This strength loss limits the amount of filler added into paper to ~15% to 18%
G.R. International A Paper Technology Vision Company©
6
GRI Technology Solutions and Innovations
G.R. International A Paper Technology Vision Company©
7
I.
• pigment
• pigment
•
(intrinsic stiffness)
II.
III. Chemical Pretreatment for Fillers (Licensed from Weyerhaeuser)
GRI Technology SolutionsG.R. International
“Fibrous Fillers:” Patented Calcium Silicate Products
Silicate nano-fibers (SNF / Tech-8) - ultra-high opaque
Silicate macro-particle (SMP / Tech-4) - ultra-high bulk
Silicate macro-particle low-drying demand (SMF-LDD / Tech-6) – lower drying demand and ultra-high stiffness
“Super” PCC / Tech-2: Patented High Pressure Process
A Paper Technology Vision Company©
8
Products Tech-8 SEMs
G.R. International
10 µm 1 µm
10 µm
Silicate Nano-Fibers (SNF)
Confidential Proprietary
A Paper Technology Vision Company©
9
Products Tech-4 SEMs
G.R. International
)
10 µm 1 µm
10 µmConfidential Proprietary
A Paper Technology Vision Company©
Silicate Macro-Particle (SMP
10
Scalenohedral
GRI’s Technology“Fibrous Fillers”
Nano-Clustered PCC
“Super” PCC for Fillers
11Calendared
G.R. International
i
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
0% 10% 40%
Fi (%)
( )
li(
80
82
84
86
88
90
92
94
96
0% 20%
(%)
( )
GRI Technology SolutionsA Paper Technology Vision Company©
Br ghtness
20% 30% 50%
ller
IS O
PCC HO SNF SMP
Norma zed Opacity to 74 gsm)
10% 30% 40% 50%
Filler
IS O
PCC HO SNF SMP
12Calendared
G.R. International
Bulk
1.5
1.7
1.9
2.1
2.3
2.5
0% 20% 40%
(%)
m 3 / g
)
lt-Side)
50
75
100
125
150
175
200
225
250
275
0%
Fill (%)
f i i
( )
GRI Technology SolutionsA Paper Technology Vision Company©
10% 30% 50%
Filler
PCC (HO SNF SMP
Smoothness (Fe
10% 20% 30% 40% 50%
er
S h ef
el d
U n
t s
PCC HO SNF SMP
G.R. International A Paper Technology Vision Company©
Tensile Index
25
30
35
Stiffness (Gurley)
145
170
195
GRI Technology Solutions/ g 120 U
n it s
20
N* m
95
Gu r
l e y
5
10
15
20
45
70
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50%
Filler (%) Filler (%)
PCC (HO) SNF SMP PCC (HO) SNF SMP
13Calendared
14Calendared
G.R. International
Cali
Bulk
i
Sti
il
i
i
i i
Fill i i
PCC
GRI Technology SolutionsA Paper Technology Vision Company©
Multifunctionality of SNF
0.0%
25.0%
50.0%
75.0%
100.0% per
Poros ty
ffness
Tens e Index
ISO Br ghtness
ISO Opac ty
Sheet Scatter ng Coeffic ent
er Scatter ng Coeffic ent
Sheffield Smoothness
15Calendared
G.R. International
Cali
Bulk
i
Sti
il
i
i
i i
Fill i i
iO2
GRI Technology SolutionsA Paper Technology Vision Company©
Multifunctionality of SNF
0.0%
25.0%
50.0%
75.0%
100.0% per
Poros ty
ffness
Tens e Index
ISO Br ghtness
ISO Opac ty
Sheet Scatter ng Coeffic ent
er Scatter ng Coeffic ent
Sheffield Smoothness
PCC PCC + 7% T
16Calendared
G.R. International
Cali
Bulk
i
Sti
il
i
i
i i
Fill i i
PCC i
GRI Technology SolutionsA Paper Technology Vision Company©
Multifunctionality of SNF
0.0%
25.0%
50.0%
75.0%
100.0% per
Poros ty
ffness
Tens e Index
ISO Br ghtness
ISO Opac ty
Sheet Scatter ng Coeffic ent
er Scatter ng Coeffic ent
Sheffield Smoothness
PCC + 7% T O2 SNF
17
GRI Technology SolutionsG.R. International
i i i
$0
$10
$20
$30
$40
$50
$60
i (lb/ )
)
/ /
A Paper Technology Vision Company©
Basis We ght Reduct on Econom cs
18.0 18.5 19.0 19.5 20.0
Basis We ght 3300ft2
Fille
r Sa
ving
s Pe
r To
n (O
D
12% PCC 0% SMP 7% PCC 13% SMP
18
GRI Technology SolutionsG.R. International A Paper Technology Vision Company©
19
The Key Innovations are: �
and Silica) • US Patent #: 6,726,807B1
� Multifunctional Performance of “Fibrous Fillers” • Improves Sheet Bulk, Porosity, Smoothness, Optical, and Strength Properties Simultaneously
�
Rates • US Patent #: 6,251,356
�
Calcium Carbonates, From a Common Reactor • US Patent Allowed, Serial # 09/797,173
InnovationG.R. International
Fiberous Crystals from Inorganic Materials (Calcium Oxide
Pressure Carbonation System to Produce Super Precipitated Calcium Carbonate at 400% to 600% Higher Reaction
Producing Multiple Pigments, “Fibrous Fillers” and
A Paper Technology Vision Company©
20
Project Objectives and Schedule
G.R. International A Paper Technology Vision Company©
21
Project Objectives and Schedule
� Objectives: •Techno-Economic Viability of Manufacturing
•Low Cost Super Precipitated Calcium Carbonates (SPCC) or Tech-2
•Technology
� Schedule •Initiation Date: •Original Expected Completion Date: •Revised Expected Completion Date:
G.R. International
“Fiberous Filler”
Protoytpe Plant for Scale-Up of Fiberous Filler
4/14/03 9/30/06 4/13/06
A Paper Technology Vision Company©
22
Status of Milestones / Key Issues
G.R. International A Paper Technology Vision Company©
23
Status of Milestones / Key Issues
The Key Issues are: � Could Not Complete the Work on Interfacial
Interaction, Paper Structure, and Paper Properties • Task I: University of Washington
� Partially Completed the Mechanism of Formation of
• Task II: Lawrence Livermore National Laboratories
�
in Surface Treatment Formulations • Task V: Western Michigan University
G.R. International
“Fiberous Fillers”
Partial Completion of Application of “Fiberous Filler”
A Paper Technology Vision Company©
24
Projects Output / Key Accomplishments
G.R. International A Paper Technology Vision Company©
25
Project Output / Key Accomplishments
�
• •
–Silicate Nano-Fibers (SNF) or Tech-8 –Silicate Micro-Fibers (SMF-LDD) or Tech-6 –Silicate Micro-Particles (SMP) or Tech-4
� Objective II Accomplishments: •
� Objective III Accomplishments: • Designed, Engineered, and Erected the Prototype Plant to Produce Multiple Pigments
–Tech-6, Tech-4, and Tech-2
G.R. International
Objective I Accomplisments: Development and Validation of Techno-Economic Viaility Techno-Economic Viability Manufacturing Demonstration of:
Development and Validation of S-PCC or Tech-2
A Paper Technology Vision Company©
26
Commercialization Barriers / Economics
G.R. International A Paper Technology Vision Company©
27
Commercialization Barriers / Economics
Barriers to Commercialization � Market Resistance to New Silicate Technology � 1st Commercial Validation of Technology
G.R. International
Economics of a Typical Multiple Pigment Plant Capital (millions): ~7.0 Revenue (millions): ROI(%): ~31.0
A Paper Technology Vision Company©
~13.5
28
Commercialization Plan and Strategy
G.R. International A Paper Technology Vision Company©
29
Commercialization PlanG.R. International
1997 2000 2001 2002 2003 2005 2006 2007 2011
Concept
Lab
Pilot
Commercial Scale-up
DOE Funding
Plant
First Commercial Plant
R&D Stage Commercialization
A Paper Technology Vision Company©
Commercialization
Bench Reactor
Reactor
Prototype Commercialization
30
Financing StrategyG.R. International
GRI
Strategic Partners/ Customers
Pigment/Chemical Manufacturers
Debt/Equity Partners
Debt Equity
Licensing
A Paper Technology Vision Company©
31
Energy Efficiency
G.R. International A Paper Technology Vision Company©
32
Energy EfficiencyG.R. International
55%
()
ional
/
A Paper Technology Vision Company©
Caliper
3.8
4.0
4.2
4.4
4.6
4.8
5.0
5.2
5.4
35% 40% 45% 50% 60% 65%
Press Solids
Cal
iper
mils
ConventPCC GRI's Micro PCC SMP
33
Energy Efficiency G.R. International A Paper Technology Vision Company©
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
30 35 40 45 50 55
Press Solids (%)
BTU
/Ton
Pap
er (1
06 )
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
4000
4500
lb D
ryer
Ste
am/T
on P
aper
ionPapermachine Dryer Steam Consumption As A FunctOf Press Solids
*Steam Temperature 230 - 266 °F
Range for 230 - 266 °F (steam 21- 39 psia)
34
Energy EfficiencyG.R. International
Energy Savings (Trillions BTU/yr)
Pulp Mill* 31.5
Paper Mill** 11.5
Total 43.0
*: 1000 ton pulp mill vs. 600 ton pulp mill and 400 ton
**: Press Solids increased from 45% to 55%
A Paper Technology Vision Company©
“Fiberous Filler” mill
35
Potential Savings To U.S. IndustryG.R. International
Attainable Industry Total Attainable Product SNF $900 90,000 $81 million (Ti02 Reduction) SMP $15 20,000,000 $300 million (Bulk, Stiffness, Basis Weight Reduction) Energy Savings $12 20,000,000 $240 million
Incremental Pulp Profits $200 1,000,000 $200 million (10% Filler Increase) PCC $20 1,000,000 $20 million (Lower Cost) Total $841 million / Year
A Paper Technology Vision Company©
Savings $/ton Usage (tons) Savings (per year)
(Paper Mill)
36
Current Status
• Building The Prototype / Commercial Plant
G.R. International A Paper Technology Vision Company©
37
“Fibrous Fillers”
Lime Slaking
CO2 Boiler
•Power
Paper
Mill
Precipitated Calcium Carbonate
Pigment Mill Pulp Mill Paper Mill
SNF SMP
SPCCCa(OH)
Ca(OH)
SiO2
Ca(OH)2 + CO2 CaCO3 + H2O
Ca(OH)2 + SiO2 CaSiO3 .H2O
Multiple Pigments From a Single Plant
Fibrous Fillers
• Recovery (Lime Kiln)
38
G.R. International A Paper Technology Vision Company©
39
G.R. International 50# GH Offset HiBright SM PM#1
ial
)
l
Trial
A Paper Technology Vision Company©
Grays Harbor Paper - March 28th, 2006
91.45
91.50
91.55
91.60
91.65
91.70
91.75
91.80
91.85
Pretr Trial
Brig
htne
ss (I
SO
Pre-Tria
40
G.R. International
Pretrial
(
ial
Trial
A Paper Technology Vision Company© 50# GH Offset HiBright SM PM#1
Grays Harbor Paper Trial - March 28th, 2006
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
Trial
Smoo
thne
ss F
elt S
ide
Shef
field
)
Pre-Tr
41
G.R. International
50# GH Offset HiBright SM PM#1
ial
Trial
A Paper Technology Vision Company©
Grays Harbor Paper Trial - March 28th, 2006
100.00
110.00
120.00
130.00
140.00
150.00
160.00
Pretr Trial
HST
Pre-Trial
42
G.R. International
29
29.5
30
30.5
31
31.5
32
32.5
33
33.5
34
Pretrial
Trial
A Paper Technology Vision Company© 50# GH Offset HiBright SM PM#1
Grays Harbor Paper Trial - March 28th, 2006
Trial
Stea
m P
ress
ure
(Mai
n D
ryer
Sec
tion)
Pre-Trial
43
Apri
i
ll ii th
i i (i i ) i
ines ( l i i ). i l
i i l ine tuniFurther tri i l
i i l i i
rd
98550Date: l 4, 2006
From: Bob Brennand
To: Operations
Subject: Prelim nary GRI S-PCC Trial Results
Summary Though we have not trialed the S-PCC on a wide variety of products yet, the fo ow ng properties improved on both mach nes during the second (March 28 ) trial: Steam Usage, Brightness, HST, and Sheff eld Smoothness. Several other propert es CD Stretch, CD & MD Tensile Energy Absorpt on, Burst, and Poros ty improved on one of the two mach nes, and some properties deteriorated on one of the two mach Caliper/Bu k, Poros ty, and MD & CD St ffnessConsidering the short t me the GRI reactor has been operating, the resu ts to date are very encourag ng, and I th nk there is room eft for f ng the S-PCC manufacturing process.
als n the future shou d be performed on a wider variety of paper products, but the data so far ind cates the S-PCC s very c ose to be ng “qualif ed” at GHP.
801 23 Street Hoquiam, WAPhone: 360-538-5742 Cell: 360-310-0747 [email protected]
44
Path Forward GRI and our industry partners are requesting an
extension of the project by one year, so that we can:
G.R. International
1. run extended trials 2. continue research on energy savings 3. continue research on cost reduction 4. meet original program objectives
A Paper Technology Vision Company©