What Drives Resistance to Change?

A Leader’s Perspective

Sponsor: Assentire Ltd www.assentire.net Researcher: Rod Willis rod.willis@assentire.net

© Assentire Limited 2012

Is this research Important?

70% of all change initiatives fail (HBR).http://hbr.org/product/hbr-s-10-must-reads-on-change-management-with-feat/an/12599-PBK-ENG

Resistance to Change is often cited as the number one reason why a change program has not delivered to the level that was anticipated.

Organisations need to respond to turbulent market conditions. Needing to achieve more with fewer resources is a common theme we hear daily in the media, be this public, private or non-profit sectors.

The Prime Research context

Sixteen change leaders (past and present) via semi-structured interviews created the prime data.

Combined experiences spanning > 55 organisations.

Operating within Oil and Gas, Professional and Financial Services, Public sector, including two District Councils and a Police Collaboration Programme.

© Assentire Limited 2012

It’s not new after all!Just some of the articles

How to Deal with Resistance to Change (Lawrence, 1954)

A person-centred approach to dealing with resistance to change (Coghlan, 1993)

7 Transformations of Leadership (Rooke and Torbert, 2005)

Beyond talk: creating autonomous motivation through self-determination theory (Stone et al., 2009)

Reframing resistance to organizational change (Thomas and Hardy, 2011)

© Assentire Limited 2012

The Problem of Change

© Assentire Limited 2012

“Change is occurring at an ever increasing pace in all phases of man’s life. People fear change because it upsets their way of doing things and threatens their security. This feeling is balanced by a desire for new experiences and for the benefits that come as a result of change” (BURNS, J. E. 1966. THE PROBLEM OF CHANGE. Industrial Management, 8, 1.)

Resistance to Change Symptoms by Theme

Top 5 by number of references identified with “*”

© Assentire Limited 2012

Resistance to Change Symptoms by Leaders Perception

© Assentire Limited 2012

Top 5 by number of references identified with “*”

Is Resistance in the Eye of the Beholder?

As I reflected on the 1/3rd of quotes not directly responding to Resistance to Change I became curious, wondering if there was a link between “Leadership Transformational Levels” and the success of change programs? To answer this question is beyond the scope of this work, but to investigate a little more, I made direct contact with David Rooke, who provided the following paper “Organizational Transformation as a Function of CEOs’ Developmental Stage1” (Rooke and Torbert, 1998), as well as the following statement:

“You are definitely onto something that I think is really significant. I have Attached an article written by Bill Torbert and myself some years ago that doesindeed point to the link between the action logic of the senior leader and the degree of change and the shorter version of this that appeared in Systems Thinker. The sample size is of course too small for any substantial claims to be made”. (email Rooke April 2012)

© Assentire Limited 2012

Implications for Change Programs

© Assentire Limited 2012

Top 5 by number of references identified with “*”

Change Programs under-performingCould this be why?

© Assentire Limited 2012

Top 5 by number of references identified with “*”

Resistance to Change Symptoms and the “Grow Through Change”

Framework

© Assentire Limited 2012

Thoughts for the day

Resistance to Change, has our view actually changed since 1954?

“New research finds 'reality gap’ in the capability of UK plc's 8 million managers, undermining attempts to boost

economic growth” (CIPD 3rd of May 2012)

“Insanity is doing the same thing, over and over again, but expecting different results” (Albert Einstein)

Thank you for your time

© Assentire Limited 2012

It’s not new after all!Books for consideration

Leading and Managing Change 1: Purpose (Heron, 1999, Pink, 2011, Jung, 1995, Sinek, 2011)

3: Communication (Patterson, 2002, Wright, 2009, Gallwey, 1986)

4: Change Dynamic (Black, 2008, Conner, 2006, Hurst, 2002, *Kim and Mauborgne, 2003)

Ensure a safe environment to enable learning and change 2: Relationship Health (Covey, 2006, Kotter and Cohen, 2002, *Welsh NHS Confederation, 2008, Schutz, 1994)

Leading and Managing Individual and Group Transition 6: Group Dynamic (Jaques and Salmon, 2008, Senge, 1994, Senge, 2006, Thornton, 2010)

5: Personal Dynamic (Argyris, 2008, Cartwright, 2004, Deci, 1997, Hawkins and Smith, 2006, Lawrence and Nohria, 2002)

Transformational LeadershipFrameworks (*Rooke and Torbert, 2005, *Jr., 2006, Collins, 2005, Barrett, 2011, *Michael J. Zickar, 2008)

A link for the books available from Amazon is available at http://www.assentire.net/Resources.aspx

References prefixed with an * are Papers, please contact me for more details if you would like the full reference.

© Assentire Limited 2012

References for Journals introduced at the start of the presentation

COGHLAN, D. 1993. A person-centred approach to dealing with resistance to change. Leadership & Organization Development Journal, 14, 10.

LAWRENCE, P. R. 1954. How to Deal with Resistance to Change. Harvard Business Review, 32, 49-57.

ROOKE, D. & TORBERT, W. R. 2005. 7 Transformations of Leadership. Harvard Business Review, 83, 66-66.

STONE, D. N., DECI, E. L. & RYAN, R. M. 2009. Beyond talk: creating autonomous motivation through self-determination theory. Journal of General Management, 34, 75-91.

THOMAS, R. & HARDY, C. 2011. Reframing resistance to organizational change. Scandinavian Journal of Management, 27, 322-331.

© Assentire Limited 2012