+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

Date post: 06-Apr-2018
Category:
Upload: charles-e-colman
View: 222 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
29
R([( D`{tv`kt Klrvt [lrtmbvh D`{tv`kt li Hbw Plva -Ilnbp [srcvb K@Y@N DLKABT ILV KC[B +? 3?:0%ky%:4;7;%[C[%ONK Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk( y( Grb{{<. @hk( bt cn C{{`ghbd tl? Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h Vbibvvbd tl? Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt -[bttnbebht Kcr{b? 32?3334 Tvcdbecva @hiv`hgbebht Dctb I`nbd? :2,:9,6::0 Orvp Dbechd? Hlhb Hctrvb li [r`t? =4: Tvcdbecva Orv`{d`kt`lh? Ibdbvcn Srb{t`lh Znc`ht`ii Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk( vbzvb{bhtbd fp Nlr`{ [mbvech Bdbvbv Cvhlnd ) Zlvtbv. NNZ ;00 Zcva Cybhrb Hbw Plva. HP 3::66 -636 732%3::: }33:6 Ic}? -636 732%3;00 Bec`n? nlr`{(bdbvbvJczlvtbv(kle  NBCD CTTLVHBP   CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD Ecttmbw Tmlec{ [cnechh Cvhlnd ) Zlvtbv. NNZ ;00 Zcva Cybhrb Hbw Plva. HP 3::66 -636 732%3::: Ic}? -636 732%3;00 Bec`n? Ecttmbw([cnechhJczlvtbv(kle  CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD Y( Dbibhdcht Grb{{<. @hk( vbzvb{bhtbd fp Chdvbw Ocp Ivckaech L'Ebnybhp ) Epbv{ NNZ 7 T`eb{ [srcvb Hbw Plva. HP 3::;9 636%;69%6::: Ic}? 636%;69%6:93 Bec`n? civckaechJlee(kle  NBCD CTTLVHBP   CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD Dch`bn E( Zbtvlkbnn` L'Ebnybhp ) Epbv{. NNZ-K'tpK`tp 3000 Cybhrb li tmb [tcv{ 7tm Inllv Nl{ Chgbnb{. KC 0::97%9:;2 -;3: 649%97:: }9=2: Ic}? -;3: 649%9770 Bec`n? dzbtvlkbnn`Jlee(kle
Transcript
Page 1: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 1/29

R([( D`{tv`kt Klrvt

[lrtmbvh D`{tv`kt li Hbw Plva -Ilnbp [srcvb

K@Y@N DLKABT ILV KC[B +? 3?:0%ky%:4;7;%[C[%ONK

Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk( y( Grb{{<. @hk( bt cnC{{`ghbd tl? Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h

Vbibvvbd tl? Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( KlttEcg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt -[bttnbebht

Kcr{b? 32?3334 Tvcdbecva @hiv`hgbebht

Dctb I`nbd? :2,:9,6::0Orvp Dbechd? Hlhb

Hctrvb li [r`t? =4: TvcdbecvaOrv`{d`kt`lh? Ibdbvcn Srb{t`lh

Znc`ht`ii 

Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk( vbzvb{bhtbd fp Nlr`{ [mbvech Bdbvbv

Cvhlnd ) Zlvtbv. NNZ;00 Zcva CybhrbHbw Plva. HP 3::66-636 732%3::: }33:6

Ic}? -636 732%3;00Bec`n? nlr`{(bdbvbvJczlvtbv(kle NBCD CTTLVHBP   CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Ecttmbw Tmlec{ [cnechh

Cvhlnd ) Zlvtbv. NNZ;00 Zcva CybhrbHbw Plva. HP 3::66-636 732%3:::Ic}? -636 732%3;00Bec`n? Ecttmbw([cnechhJczlvtbv(kle CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Y(

Dbibhdcht

Grb{{<. @hk( vbzvb{bhtbd fp Chdvbw Ocp Ivckaech

L'Ebnybhp ) Epbv{ NNZ7 T`eb{ [srcvbHbw Plva. HP 3::;9636%;69%6:::Ic}? 636%;69%6:93Bec`n? civckaechJlee(kle NBCD CTTLVHBP   CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Dch`bn E( Zbtvlkbnn`

L'Ebnybhp ) Epbv{. NNZ-K'tpK`tp3000 Cybhrb li tmb [tcv{7tm InllvNl{ Chgbnb{. KC 0::97%9:;2-;3: 649%97:: }9=2:Ic}? -;3: 649%9770Bec`n? dzbtvlkbnn`Jlee(kle

Page 2: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 2/29

 CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Vlfbvt Kvc`g Wbn{m

L'Ebnybhp ) Epbv{. NNZ-K'tpK`tp3000 Cybhrb li tmb [tcv{7tm Inllv

Nl{ Chgbnb{. KC 0::97%9:;2-;3: 649%97:: }9736Ic}? -;3: 649%9770Bec`n? vwbn{mJlee(kle CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Dbibhdcht

Grb{{ @tcn`c [(v(n( TBVE@HCTBD? :7,32,6::0 

vbzvb{bhtbd fp Chdvbw Ocp Ivckaech

-[bb cflyb ilv cddvb{{ NBCD CTTLVHBP  

 CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Dch`bn E( Zbtvlkbnn`

-[bb cflyb ilv cddvb{{ CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Vlfbvt Kvc`g Wbn{m

-[bb cflyb ilv cddvb{{ CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Dbibhdcht

Ecvk I`{mbv Illtwbcv NNK vbzvb{bhtbd fp Dcvvbh Wcphb [crhdbv{

M`{klka ) Fcvkncp. NNZ -Hbw Plva[bybh T`eb [srcvbHbw Plva. HP 3::;9

636%7=4%2=::Ic}? 636%7=4%2777Bec`n? d{crhdbv{Jmfncw(kle NBCD CTTLVHBP   CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Cnzc Y( Zctbn

M`{klka ) Fcvkncp. NNZ -VLKM6::: M[FK Zncc. 6:tm Inv(Vlkmb{tbv. HP 349:4

-2=2%602%44;=Ic}? -2=2%602%=420Bec`n? czctbnJmfncw(kle CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Dbibhdcht

Tmb Ec} Nbctmbv Gvlrz,K`zv`ch`

Ckkb{{lv`b{. @hk( 

vbzvb{bhtbd fp Olmh T( W`nn`ce{

M`hamlr{b W`nn`ce{ Wcn{m NNZ3=: Hlvtm [tbt{lh [tvbbt[r`tb ;4::Km`kcgl. @N 9:9:3-;36%69=%2797

Page 3: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 3/29

Ic}? -;36%69=%2=:3Bec`n? ow`nn`ce{Jmww%ncw(kle NBCD CTTLVHBP   CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Vlfbvt Kvc`g Wbn{m

-[bb cflyb ilv cddvb{{ NBCD CTTLVHBP   CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Dbibhdcht

[bsrbn CG vbzvb{bhtbd fp Vlfbvt Kvc`g Wbn{m

-[bb cflyb ilv cddvb{{ NBCD CTTLVHBP   CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Dbibhdcht

A)E C{{lk`ctb{ N(Z( vbzvb{bhtbd fp Vlfbvt Kvc`g Wbn{m

-[bb cflyb ilv cddvb{{ NBCD CTTLVHBP   CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Dbibhdcht

Y`yc Lzt`srb. @hk( vbzvb{bhtbd fp Vlfbvt Kvc`g Wbn{m

-[bb cflyb ilv cddvb{{ NBCD CTTLVHBP   CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Dbibhdcht

[`ghcn Zvldrkt{. @hk( vbzvb{bhtbd fp Vlfbvt Kvc`g Wbn{m

-[bb cflyb ilv cddvb{{ NBCD CTTLVHBP   CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Olmh T( W`nn`ce{

-[bb cflyb ilv cddvb{{ CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Av`{t`h Ecv`b Dcvv

[tbztlb ) Olmh{lh. NNZ -HPK3334 Cybhrb li tmb Cebv`kc{Hbw Plva. HP 3::;9-636%2:9%;0::

Ic}? 636%2:9%;02:Bec`n? adcvvJ{tbztlb(kle CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

E`kmcbn V( Mb`eflnd

[tbztlb ) Olmh{lh. NNZ-NC6363 Cybhrb li tmb [tcv{[r`tb 6=::Nl{ Chgbnb{. KC 0::97

Page 4: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 4/29

-;3:7;4%;6::Ic}? -;3: 7;4%;;::Bec`n? emb`eflndJ{tbztlb(kleZVL MCK Y@KB   CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Dbibhdcht

[wcha. @hk( vbzvb{bhtbd fp Cf`gc`n Chhb Vrf`h{tb`h

[tbztlb ) Olmh{lh. NNZ -DK3;;: Klhhbkt`krt Cybhrb. H(W(Wc{m`hgtlh. DK 6::;9-6:6 460%;:9=Ic}? -6:6 693%:202Bec`n? cvrf`h{tb`hJ{tbztlb(kleTBVE@HCTBD? 36,6;,6:33  NBCD CTTLVHBP  

Zcrn I`bnd{

Nbc{lh Bnn`{ NNZ

=3 Ec`h [tvbbt[r`tb 2:;Wm`tb Znc`h{. HP 3:9:3034%6==%::66Ic}? 034%6==%::6;Bec`n? i`bnd{Jnbc{lhbnn`{(kle NBCD CTTLVHBP   CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Vlfbvt Kvc`g Wbn{m

-[bb cflyb ilv cddvb{{ NBCD CTTLVHBP   CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Ctrn V( [`hgm

Dcvfp ) Dcvfp. Z(K(-HPK7 Wlvnd Tvcdb Kbhtbv62: Gvbbhw`km [tvbbtHbw Plva. HP 3:::7%::46-636 267%77:: ]77;2Ic}? -636 267%77:3Bec`n? c{`hgmJvzn%ncw(kleTBVE@HCTBD? 36,63,6:33 

Acv`h Ivle{lh [bgcnn

Nbc{lh Bnn`{ NNZ

=3 Ec`h [tvbbt[r`tb 2:;Wm`tb Znc`h{. HP 3:9:3-034%=63%0:76Ic}? -034%6==%::6;Bec`n? {bgcnnJnbc{lhbnn`{(kle

 CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

@htbvb{tbd Zcvtp

Page 5: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 5/29

Olhctmch El{{ 

Klrhtbv Knc`echt

Grb{{<. @hk( vbzvb{bhtbd fp Chdvbw Ocp Ivckaech

-[bb cflyb ilv cddvb{{ NBCD CTTLVHBP   CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Dch`bn E( Zbtvlkbnn`

-[bb cflyb ilv cddvb{{ CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Vlfbvt Kvc`g Wbn{m

-[bb cflyb ilv cddvb{{ CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Y(

Klrhtbv Dbibhdcht

Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk( vbzvb{bhtbd fp Nlr`{ [mbvech Bdbvbv

-[bb cflyb ilv cddvb{{ NBCD CTTLVHBP   CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Ecttmbw Tmlec{ [cnechh

-[bb cflyb ilv cddvb{{ CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Klrhtbv Knc`echt

[`ghcn Zvldrkt{. @hk( vbzvb{bhtbd fp Vlfbvt Kvc`g Wbn{m

-[bb cflyb ilv cddvb{{ NBCD CTTLVHBP   CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Av`{t`h Ecv`b Dcvv

-[bb cflyb ilv cddvb{{ CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Y(

Klrhtbv Dbibhdcht

Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk( vbzvb{bhtbd fp Nlr`{ [mbvech Bdbvbv

-[bb cflyb ilv cddvb{{ NBCD CTTLVHBP   CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Ecttmbw Tmlec{ [cnechh

-[bb cflyb ilv cddvb{{ CTTLVHBP TL FB HLT@KBD 

Page 6: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 6/29

Dctb I`nbd + Dlkabt Tb}t

:2,:9,6::0 3 KLEZNC@HT cgc`h{t Grb{{<. @hk(. Grb{{ @tcn`c [(v(n( -I`n`hg Ibb $ ;2:(::.Vbkb`zt Hrefbv 9=7606Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(-cec-cec( -Bhtbvbd? :2,:7,6::0

:2,:9,6::0 [REELH[ @[[RBD c{ tl Grb{{<. @hk(. Grb{{ @tcn`c [(v(n( -cec -Bhtbvbd?:2,:7,6::0

:2,:9,6::0 Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Aby`h Hctmch`bn Il} `{ {l db{`ghctbd( -cec -Bhtbvbd?:2,:7,6::0

:2,:9,6::0 Kc{b Db{`ghctbd BKI( -cec -Bhtbvbd? :2,:7,6::0

:2,:9,6::0 6 VRNB 7(3 KLVZLVCTB D@[KNL[RVB [TCTBEBHT( @dbht`ip`hg ZZVGvlrz c{ Klvzlvctb Zcvbht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(-cec-cec( -Bhtbvbd? :2,:7,6::0

:2,:9,6::0 Ec`nbd hlt`kb tl Klee`{{`lhbv li Zctbht{ chd Tvcdbecva{ tl vbzlvt tmb

i`n`hg li tm`{ ckt`lh( -cec -Bhtbvbd? :2,:7,6::0

:2,:7,6::0 ///HLTB TL CTTLVHBP TL B%EC@N ZDI( Hltb tl Cttlvhbp Nlr`{[mbvech Bdbvbv ilv hlhklezn`chkb w`tm [bkt`lh -34(; li tmb [(D(H(P(Bnbktvlh`k Kc{b I`n`hg Vrnb{ ) @h{tvrkt`lh{( B%EC@N tmb ZDI ilvDlkrebht 3 Kleznc`ht. 6 Vrnb 7(3 Klvzlvctb D`{knl{rvb [tctbebht tl?kc{b\lzbh`hg{Jhp{d(r{klrvt{(gly( -cec -Bhtbvbd? :2,:7,6::0

:2,:=,6::0 ; BHDLV[BD NBTTBV cddvb{{bd tl Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h ivle Nlr`{[( Bdbvbv dctbd 2,=,:0 vb? Klrh{bn ilv Znc`ht`ii wv`tb tl vbsrb{t ivle[bkt`lh 34(; li tmb Bnbktvlh`k Kc{b I`n`hg Vrnb{ ) @h{tvrkt`lh{ li tmb[(D(H(P( Klrh{bn vb{zbktirnnp vbsrb{t{ zbve`{{`lh tl ec`htc`h tmb b}m`f`t{tl Grkk`'{ kleznc`ht c{ c zczbv dlkrebht. c{ {rggb{tbd fp tmb Knbva'{

Lii`kb( BHDLV[BEBHT? Znc`ht`ii ecp abbz cnn b}m`f`t{ c{ zczbvdlkrebht{ fbkcr{b tmbp cvb ylnre`hlr{ chd hbbd hlt i`nb tmbebnbktvlh`kcnnp( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 2,=,:0 -tvl

-Bhtbvbd? :2,3;,6::0

:2,67,6::0 4 HLT@KB LI CZZBCVCHKB fp Chdvbw Ocp Ivckaech lh fbmcni li Grb{{<. @hk(. Grb{{ @tcn`c [(v(n( -Ivckaech. Chdvbw -Bhtbvbd? :2,67,6::0

:2,67,6::0 2 VRNB 7(3 KLVZLVCTB D@[KNL[RVB [TCTBEBHT( Dlkrebht i`nbdfp Grb{{<. @hk(. Grb{{ @tcn`c [(v(n((-Ivckaech. Chdvbw -Bhtbvbd?:2,67,6::0

:2,67,6::0 9 [T@ZRNCT@LH B]TBHD@HG T@EB. tmb t`eb ilv dbibhdcht{ tl ch{wbvtmb kleznc`ht {mcnn fb b}tbhdbd ivle 2,67,:0 tl 9,69,:0( Grb{{<. @hk(

ch{wbv drb 9,69,6::01 Grb{{ @tcn`c [(v(n( ch{wbv drb 9,69,6::0( -[`ghbd fpOrdgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 2,69,:0 -kd -Bhtbvbd? :2,67,6::0

:9,:3,6::0 7 LVDBV ILV @H@T@CN ZVBTV@CN KLHIBVBHKB?((( @h`t`cn Klhibvbhkb{bt ilv 9,6;,6::0 ct :4?;: ZE `h Klrvtvlle 32K. 2:: Zbcvn [tvbbt. Hbw

Plva. HP 3:::7 fbilvb Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vcC( [kmb`hdn`h lh 2,6=,6::0 -ozl -Bhtbvbd? :9,:3,6::0

:9,:2,6::0 = LVDBV ILV CDE@[[@LH ZVL MCK Y@KB LI DCH@BN E(

Page 7: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 7/29

ZBTVLKBNN@ CHD VLFBVT K( WBN[M? Dch`bn Zbtvlkbnn` chd VlfbvtK( Wbn{m cvb mbvbfp zbve`ttbd tl czzbcv `h tm`{ ckt`lh zvl mck y`kb lhfbmcni li Dbibhdcht{ `h tm`{ ckt`lh( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`hlh 9,2,:0 -tvl -Bhtbvbd? :9,:2,6::0

:9,:2,6::0 Tvch{e`{{`lh tl Cttlvhbp Cde`{{`lh{ Knbva( Tvch{e`ttbd vb? = Lvdbv

Cde`tt`hg Cttlvhbp Zvl Mck Y`kb. tl tmb Cttlvhbp Cde`{{`lh{ Knbva ilvrzdct`hg li Cttlvhbp @hilvect`lh( -tvl -Bhtbvbd? :9,:2,6::0

:9,:0,6::0 0 LVDBV CDOLRVH@HG @H@T@CN ZVBTV@CN KLHIBVBHKB? @T @[LVDBVBD tmct tmb @h`t`cn Zvbtv`cn Klhibvbhkb {kmbdrnbd ilv Orhb 6;. 6::0fb cdolrvhbd tl Ornp 3:. 6::0 ct ct 6?;: z(e( Klrh{bn cvb cdy`{bd tmct cnn li tmb ltmbv tbve{ {bt ilvtm `h tmb Klrvt'{ @h`t`cn Zvbtv`cn Klhibvbhkb Lvdbvdctbd Ecp 6=. 6::0 vbec`h `h biibkt( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`hlh 9,0,6::0 -oib -Bhtbvbd? :9,:0,6::0

:9,62,6::0 KC[M@BV[ LII@KB VBECVA lh = Lvdbv Cde`tt`hg Cttlvhbp Zvl MckY`kb. `h tmb celrht li $2:(::. zc`d lh :9,:=,6::0. Vbkb`zt Hrefbv

90:;34( -od -Bhtbvbd? :9,62,6::0

:7,3:,6::0 3: LVDBV VBIBVV@HG KC[B TL ECG@[TVCTB ORDGB( Lvdbv tmct kc{bfb vbibvvbd tl tmb Knbva li Klrvt ilv c{{`ghebht tl c Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb ilv{bttnbebht( Vbibvvbd tl Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Aby`h Hctmch`bn Il}(BHDLV[BEBHT? [bztbefbv wlrnd fb fb{t( Tmcha{( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb[m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 7,3:,6::0 -tyb -Bhtbvbd? :7,3:,6::0

:7,3:,6::0 33 [KMBDRN@HG LVDBV? Tmb zcvt`b{ w`nn `dbht`ip hceb{ li zbv{lh{ tl fbdbzl{bd fp 7,67,:0( Vbznp fp =,3:. Vb{zlh{b 0,34( Cnn ickt dbzl{`t`lh{ fp36,;3,:0( @h`t`cn b}zbvt vbzlvt{ drb 3,60( Vbfrttcn b}zbvt vbzlvt{ drb 6,6;(Bckm b}zbvt'{ dbzl{`t`lh w`nn fb kleznbtbd fp ;,30( D`{klybvp {mcnn fb

kleznbtbd ;,30( Znc`ht`ii w`nn {rzznp `t{ zvb%tv`cn lvdbv lh 4,36( Tmb zcvt`b{w`nn {rfe`t c zvb%tv`cn lvdbv fp 4,69( Tmb i`hcn zvb%tv`cn klhibvbhkb zrv{rcht

tl Ibd( V( K`y( Z( 39-d w`nn fb mbnd lh 4,9 ct 4?;:( Cht`k`zctbd nbhgtm li tv`cn chd wmbtmbv tl klrvt lv orvp? B`gmt -= dcp fbhkm tv`cn( -[`ghbd fpOrdgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 7,3:,6::0 -oib Eld`i`bd lh 7,34,6::0 -oib(-Bhtbvbd? :7,3;,6::0

:7,32,6::0 36 HLT@KB LI YLNRHTCVP D@[E@[[CN Zrv{rcht tl Vrnb 43-c-3-C-`li tmb Ibdbvcn Vrnb{ li K`y`n Zvlkbdrvb. tmb znc`ht`ii-{ chd lv tmb`vklrh{bn-{. mbvbfp g`yb hlt`kb tmct tmb cflyb%kczt`lhbd ckt`lh `{ylnrhtcv`np d`{e`{{bd. w`tmlrt zvbord`kb cgc`h{t tmb dbibhdcht-{ Grb{{@tcn`c [(v(n(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv. Nlr`{-Bhtbvbd? :7,32,6::0

:7,39,6::0 3; HLT@KB LI CZZBCVCHKB fp Vlfbvt Kvc`g Wbn{m lh fbmcni li Grb{{<.@hk(. Grb{{ @tcn`c [(v(n( -Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :7,39,6::0

:7,37,6::0 34 CH[WBV tl Kleznc`ht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{<. @hk((-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt-Bhtbvbd? :7,37,6::0

:7,63,6::0 32 LVDBV. tmct c {bttnbebht klhibvbhkb {mcnn fb mbnd `h tm`{ kczt`lhbd ckt`lhlh Ibfvrcvp 64. 6:3:. ct 3:?;: c(e(. `h klrvtvlle 6:C. 2:: Zbcvn [t(. HbwPlva. Hbw Plva( Cdd`t`lhcn vbn`bi c{ {bt ilvtm `h tm`{ Lvdbv( -[`ghbd fpEcg`{tvctb Ordgb Aby`h Hctmch`bn Il} lh 7,6:,:0 -zn -Bhtbvbd?

:7,63,6::0

Page 8: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 8/29

:=,:9,6::0 39 LVDBV GVCHT@HG CEBHDEBHT LI GRB[[<. @HK'[ CH[WBVCHD CII@VECT@YB DBIBH[B[. Grb{{ ecp i`nb `t{ I`v{t CebhdbdCh{wbv chd Cii`vect`yb Dbibh{b{( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`hlh =,9,:0 -kd -Bhtbvbd? :=,:7,6::0

:=,:7,6::0 37 CEBHDBD CH[WBV tl 3 Kleznc`ht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{<. @hk((

-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :=,:7,6::0

:=,3=,6::0 3= [T@ZRNCT@LH CHD LVDBV1 Dbibhdcht Grb{{<. @hk( klh{bht{ tl tmbi`n`hg li znc`ht`ii Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk('{ I`v{t Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht( TmbI`v{t Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht {mcnn fb dbbebd i@nbd c{ li tmb dctb li bhtvp li tm`{ [t`zrnct`lh chd Lvdbv( [L LVDBVBD( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C([kmb`hdn`h lh =,37,6::0 -tyb -Bhtbvbd? :=,3=,6::0

:=,3=,6::0 30 I@V[T CEBHDBD KLEZNC@HT cebhd`hg 3 Kleznc`ht cgc`h{t EcvkI`{mbv Illtwbcv NNK. Tmb Ec} Nbctmbv Gvlrz,K`zv`ch` Ckkb{{lv`b{. @hk(.[bsrbn CG. A)E C{{lk`ctb{ N(Z(. Y`yc Lzt`srb. @hk(. [`ghcn Zvldrkt{.@hk(. [wcha. @hk(. Grb{{<. @hk((Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk((

Vbnctbd dlkrebht? 3 Kleznc`ht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk((-efb

-Bhtbvbd? :=,30,6::0

:=,67,6::0 6: CH[WBV tl Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{<. @hk((Vbnctbd dlkrebht? 30 Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht. i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc.@hk((-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :=,67,6::0

:=,6=,6::0 ///HLTB TL CTTLVHBP TL B%EC@N ZDI( Hltb tl Cttlvhbp Nlr`{[mbvech Bdbvbv ilv hlhklezn`chkb w`tm [bkt`lh -34(; li tmb [(D(H(P(Bnbktvlh`k Kc{b I`n`hg Vrnb{ ) @h{tvrkt`lh{( B%EC@N tmb ZDI ilvDlkrebht 30 Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht. tl? kc{b\lzbh`hg{Jhp{d(r{klrvt{(gly(-cec -Bhtbvbd? :=,6=,6::0

:0,:6,6::0 63 BHDLV[BD NBTTBV cddvb{{bd tl Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h ivle Nlr`{

[( Bdbvbv dctbd =,;3,6::0 vb? Ckklvd`hgnp. wb vb`tbvctb lrv vbsrb{t ilvnbcyb ivle [bkt`lh 34(;( BHDLV[BEBHT? Znc`ht`ii ecp abbz cnn b}m`f`t{c{ zczbv dlkrebht{ fbkcr{b tmbp cvb ylnre`hlr{ chd hbbd hlt i`nb tmbebnbktvlh`kcnnp( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 0,3,6::0 -ozl-Bhtbvbd? :0,:6,6::0

:0,34,6::0 66 HLT@KB LI CZZBCVCHKB fp Zcrn I`bnd{ lh fbmcni li [wcha. @hk(-I`bnd{. Zcrn -Bhtbvbd? :0,34,6::0

:0,34,6::0 6; HLT@KB LI CZZBCVCHKB fp Vlfbvt Kvc`g Wbn{m lh fbmcni li [wcha.@hk( -Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :0,34,6::0

:0,34,6::0 64 VRNB 7(3 KLVZLVCTB D@[KNL[RVB [TCTBEBHT( Hl Klvzlvctb

Zcvbht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp [wcha. @hk((-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd?:0,34,6::0

:0,34,6::0 62 CH[WBV tl Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp [wcha. @hk((Vbnctbd dlkrebht? 30 Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht. i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc.@hk((-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :0,34,6::0

:0,34,6::0 69 HLT@KB LI CZZBCVCHKB fp Vlfbvt Kvc`g Wbn{m lh fbmcni li TmbEc} Nbctmbv Gvlrz,K`zv`ch` Ckkb{{lv`b{. @hk(. A)E C{{lk`ctb{ N(Z(-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :0,34,6::0

Page 9: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 9/29

:0,34,6::0 67 VRNB 7(3 KLVZLVCTB D@[KNL[RVB [TCTBEBHT( @dbht`ip`hgCebv`kch F`ntv`tb @hk( c{ Klvzlvctb Zcvbht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp A)EC{{lk`ctb{ N(Z((-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :0,34,6::0

:0,34,6::0 6= VRNB 7(3 KLVZLVCTB D@[KNL[RVB [TCTBEBHT( Hl KlvzlvctbZcvbht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Tmb Ec} Nbctmbv Gvlrz,K`zv`ch` Ckkb{{lv`b{.

@hk((-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :0,34,6::0

:0,34,6::0 60 CH[WBV tl Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Tmb Ec} NbctmbvGvlrz,K`zv`ch` Ckkb{{lv`b{. @hk(. A)E C{{lk`ctb{ N(Z(( Vbnctbddlkrebht? 30 Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht. i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk((-Wbn{m.Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :0,34,6::0

:0,32,6::0 ;: HLT@KB LI CZZBCVCHKB fp Dcvvbh Wcphb [crhdbv{ lh fbmcni li Ecvk I`{mbv Illtwbcv NNK -[crhdbv{. Dcvvbh -Bhtbvbd? :0,32,6::0

:0,32,6::0 ;3 HLT@KB LI CZZBCVCHKB fp Vlfbvt Kvc`g Wbn{m lh fbmcni li Y`ycLzt`srb. @hk( -Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :0,32,6::0

:0,32,6::0 ;6 VRNB 7(3 KLVZLVCTB D@[KNL[RVB [TCTBEBHT( @dbht`ip`hgM`gmecva @hk( c{ Klvzlvctb Zcvbht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Y`yc Lzt`srb.

@hk((-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :0,32,6::0

:0,32,6::0 ;; CH[WBV tl Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Y`yc Lzt`srb. @hk((Vbnctbd dlkrebht? 30 Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht. i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc.@hk((-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :0,32,6::0

:0,39,6::0 ;4 HLT@KB LI CZZBCVCHKB fp Cf`gc`n Chhb Vrf`h{tb`h lh fbmcni li [wcha. @hk( -Vrf`h{tb`h. Cf`gc`n -Bhtbvbd? :0,39,6::0

:0,39,6::0 ;2 [T@ZRNCTBD LVDBV B]TBHD@HG DBIBHDCHT ECVK I@[MBVILLTWBCV NNK'[ T@EB TL CH[WBV LV LTMBVW@[B VB[ZLHD1

Znc`ht`ii chd Dbibhdcht mbvbfp {t`zrnctb tmct dbibhdcht Ecvk I`{mbvIlltwbcv NNK mc{ rz tl chd `hknrd`hg [bztbefbv ;:. 6::0 tl ch{wbv lvltmbvw`{b vb{zlhd tl tmb I`v{t Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht( [L LVDBVBD(

-[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 0,32,6::0 -tyb -Bhtbvbd?:0,39,6::0

:0,63,6::0 ;9 HLT@KB LI CZZBCVCHKB fp Olmh T( W`nn`ce{ lh fbmcni li Tmb Ec}Nbctmbv Gvlrz,K`zv`ch` Ckkb{{lv`b{. @hk( -W`nn`ce{. Olmh -Bhtbvbd?:0,63,6::0

:0,;:,6::0 ;7 VRNB 7(3 KLVZLVCTB D@[KNL[RVB [TCTBEBHT( Hl KlvzlvctbZcvbht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Ecvk I`{mbv Illtwbcv NNK(-[crhdbv{. Dcvvbh-Bhtbvbd? :0,;:,6::0

:0,;:,6::0 ;= CH[WBV tl Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Ecvk I`{mbvIlltwbcv NNK( Vbnctbd dlkrebht? 30 Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht. i`nbd fp Grkk`Cebv`kc. @hk((-[crhdbv{. Dcvvbh -Bhtbvbd? :0,;:,6::0

3:,:2,6::0 ;0 HLT@KB LI CZZBCVCHKB fp Vlfbvt Kvc`g Wbn{m lh fbmcni li [`ghcn

Zvldrkt{. @hk( -Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? 3:,:2,6::0

3:,:2,6::0 4: VRNB 7(3 KLVZLVCTB D@[KNL[RVB [TCTBEBHT( HL KlvzlvctbZcvbht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp [`ghcn Zvldrkt{. @hk((-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd?

Page 10: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 10/29

3:,:2,6::0

3:,:2,6::0 43 CH[WBV tl Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp [`ghcn Zvldrkt{.@hk(( Vbnctbd dlkrebht? 30 Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht. i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc.@hk((-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? 3:,:2,6::0

3:,:2,6::0 46 HLT@KB LI CZZBCVCHKB fp Dcvvbh Wcphb [crhdbv{ lh fbmcni li Ecvk I`{mbv Illtwbcv NNK -[crhdbv{. Dcvvbh -Bhtbvbd? 3:,:2,6::0

3:,:9,6::0 4; HLT@KB LI CZZBCVCHKB fp Cnzc Y( Zctbn lh fbmcni li Ecvk I`{mbvIlltwbcv NNK -Zctbn. Cnzc -Bhtbvbd? 3:,:9,6::0

3:,34,6::0 44 LVDBV ELD@IP@HG TMB KLRVT'[ ORNP 3:. 6::0 [KMBDRN@HGLVDBV? Cnn ickt dbzl{`t`lh{ cvb tl fb kleznbtbd fp 6,69,6:3:( Cnn b}zbvtdbzl{`t`lh{ cvb tl fb kleznbtbd fp 2,63,6:3:( Zvbtv`cn Lvdbv drb fp9,62,6:3:( I`hcn Zvbtv`cn Klhibvbhkb {bt ilv Elhdcp. 9,7,6:3: ct :4?;: ZEfbilvb Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h( Hl irvtmbv vbsrb{t{ ilv b}tbh{`lh{ w`nnfb gvchtbd( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 3:,34,:0 -tvl-Bhtbvbd? 3:,32,6::0

3:,6:,6::0 42 [T@ZRNCTBD ZVLTBKT@YB LVDBV(((vbgcvd`hg zvlkbdrvb{ tl fb

ilnnlwbd tmct {mcnn glybvh tmb mchdn`hg li klhi`dbht`cn ectbv`cn(((( -[`ghbdfp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 3:,6:,6::0 -ozl -Bhtbvbd? 3:,6:,6::0

3:,6=,6::0 49 HLT@KB LI CZZBCVCHKB fp Vlfbvt Kvc`g Wbn{m lh fbmcni li [bsrbnCG -Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? 3:,6=,6::0

3:,6=,6::0 47 VRNB 7(3 KLVZLVCTB D@[KNL[RVB [TCTBEBHT( @dbht`ip`hgT`eb} Hbdbvnchd F(Y( c{ Klvzlvctb Zcvbht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp [bsrbnCG(-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? 3:,6=,6::0

3:,6=,6::0 4= CH[WBV tl Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp [bsrbn CG( Vbnctbd

dlkrebht? 30 Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht. i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk((-Wbn{m.Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? 3:,6=,6::0

36,:=,6::0 40 LVDBV. tmct tmb {bttnbebht klhibvbhkb {kmbdrnbd zvby`lr{np ilv Ibfvrcvp64. 6:3:. ct 3:?;: c(e(. {mcnn tcab znckb lh Ecvkm 3:. 6:3:. ct 3:?;: c(e(.

`h klrvtvlle 6:C. 2:: Zbcvn [t(. Hbw Plva. Hbw Plva( -[`ghbd fpEcg`{tvctb Ordgb Aby`h Hctmch`bn Il} lh 36,7,:0 -zn -Bhtbvbd?36,:=,6::0

36,60,6::0 2: HLT@KB li li W`tmdvcwcn li Cf`gc`n Vrf`h{tb`h c{ Klrh{bn ilv Dbibhdcht[wcha. @hk(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp [wcha. @hk(( -I`bnd{. Zcrn -Bhtbvbd?36,60,6::0

36,;3,6::0 23 LVDBV CDOLRVH@HG OCHRCVP 7. 6:3: ZVB%ELT@LH

KLHIBVBHKB? HLW. TMBVBILVB. @T @[ MBVBFP LVDBVBD. tmcttmb zvb%elt`lh klhibvbhkb {bt ilv Ochrcvp 7. 6:3: ct 6?;: z(e(. `{cdolrvhbd tl Ochrcvp 33. 6:3: ct 6?;:. `h Klrvtvlle 32K. 2:: Zbcvn [tvbbt.Hbw Plva. Hbw Plva( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh36,;3,6::0 -oib -Bhtbvbd? 36,;3,6::0

:3,3;,6:3: 26 TVCH[KV@ZT li zvlkbbd`hg{ mbnd lh Ochrcvp 33. 6:3: ;?:: z(e( fbilvbOrdgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h( -cok -Bhtbvbd? :3,3;,6:3:

Page 11: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 11/29

:6,:3,6:3: 2; TVCH[KV@ZT li zvlkbbd`hg{ mbnd lh Ochrcvp 3;. 6:3: ;?32 z(e( fbilvbOrdgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h( -cok -Bhtbvbd? :6,:3,6:3:

:6,:4,6:3: 24 BHDLV[BD NBTTBV cddvb{{bd tl Ordgb [m`vc C([kmb`hdn`h ivle Nlr`{Bdbvbv dctbd 6,;,3: vb? Vbsrb{t ilv c fv`bi cdolrvhebht li tmb 6,0,3:klhibvbhkb( BHDLV[BEBHT? Znc`ht`ii'{ vbsrb{t tl cdolrvh tmb 6,0,3:

klhibvbhkb `{ mbvbfp gvchtbd( Tmb klhibvbhkb mc{ fbbh vb{kmbdrnbd ilv6,64,3: ct 4?;: ze( - Klhibvbhkb vb{bt ilv 6,64,6:3: ct :4?;: ZE fbilvbOrdgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh6,;,3: -kd -Bhtbvbd? :6,:4,6:3:

:6,62,6:3: 22 HLT@KB LI CZZBCVCHKB fp Ctrn V( [`hgm lh fbmcni li [wcha. @hk(-[`hgm. Ctrn -Bhtbvbd? :6,62,6:3:

:;,3:,6:3: 29 TVCH[KV@ZT li zvlkbbd`hg{ mbnd lh 2,6,3: fbilvb Ordgb [m`vc C([kmb`hdn`h( -zn -Bhtbvbd? :;,36,6:3:

:;,3:,6:3: 27 TVCH[KV@ZT li zvlkbbd`hg{ mbnd lh 2,6,3: fbilvb Ordgb [m`vc C([kmb`hdn`h( -zn -Bhtbvbd? :;,36,6:3:

:;,3:,6:3: E`hrtb Bhtvp ilv zvlkbbd`hg{ mbnd fbilvb Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Aby`h

Hctmch`bn Il}? [bttnbebht Klhibvbhkb mbnd lh ;,3:,6:3:( Zcvt`b{ d`d hlt{bttnb( Dbibhdcht{ w`nn tvp tl zvly`db znc`ht`ii w( c klrhtbvliibv fp ;,37(-dok -Bhtbvbd? :;,62,6:3:

:;,3=,6:3: 2= HLT@KB LI KMCHGB LI CDDVB[[ fp Zcrn I`bnd{ lh fbmcni li [wcha.@hk(( Hbw Cddvb{{? NBC[LH BNN@[ NNZ. =3 Ec`h [tvbbt. [r`tb 2:;.Wm`tb Znc`h{. Hbw Plva. R([(C( 3:9:3. 034%6==%:66( -I`bnd{. Zcrn-Bhtbvbd? :;,3=,6:3:

:;,62,6:3: 20 LVDBV VBIBVV@HG KC[B TL ECG@[TVCTB ORDGB( Lvdbv tmct kc{bfb vbibvvbd tl tmb Knbva li Klrvt ilv c{{`ghebht tl c Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb ilv

[zbk`i`k Hlh%D`{zl{`t`yb Elt`lh,D`{zrtb? D`{klybvp d`{zrtb Vb? Ecvkm 37Grb{{ nbttbv( Vbibvvbd tl Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Aby`h Hctmch`bn Il}( -[`ghbdfp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh ;,3=,6:3: -oib -Bhtbvbd? :;,62,6:3:

:;,62,6:3: 9: HLT@KB LI KMCHGB LI CDDVB[[ fp Zcrn I`bnd{ lh fbmcni li [wcha.@hk(( Hbw Cddvb{{? NBC[LH BNN@[ NNZ. =3 Ec`h [tvbbt. [r`tb 2:;.Wm`tb Znc`h{. Hbw Plva. R([(C( 3:9:3. 034%6==%::66( -I`bnd{. Zcrn-Bhtbvbd? :;,62,6:3:

:;,69,6:3: 93 HLT@KB LI VBC[[@GHEBHT LI C VBIBVVCN TL CHLTMBVECG@[TVCTB ORDGB( Tmb vbibvvcn `h tmb cflyb bht`tnbd ckt`lh mc{ fbbhvbc{{`ghbd tl Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt. ilv [zbk`i`k Hlh%D`{zl{`t`ybElt`lh,D`{zrtb? D`{klybvp d`{zrtb Vb? Ecvkm 37 Grb{{ nbttbv( Ecg`{tvctb

Ordgb Aby`h Hctmch`bn Il} hl nlhgbv vbibvvbd tl tmb kc{b( -nd` -nd`(-Bhtbvbd? :;,69,6:3:

:4,:6,6:3: 96 ELT@LH ilv Zvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd 

Kleerh`kct`lh{ li Znc`ht`ii'{ @h%Mlr{b Nbgcn Klrh{bn Olhctmch El{{(Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk((-Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd?:4,:6,6:3:

:4,:6,6:3: 9; DBKNCVCT@LH li Nlr`{ [( Bdbvbv `h [rzzlvt vb? 96 ELT@LH ilvZvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{

Page 12: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 12/29

li Znc`ht`ii'{ @h%Mlr{b Nbgcn Klrh{bn Olhctmch El{{(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fpGrkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,:6,6:3:

:4,:6,6:3: 94 DBKNCVCT@LH li Gblvgb Flvcfcfp `h [rzzlvt vb? 96 ELT@LH ilvZvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{

li Znc`ht`ii'{ @h%Mlr{b Nbgcn Klrh{bn Olhctmch El{{(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp

Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,:6,6:3:

:4,:6,6:3: 92 DBKNCVCT@LH li T`eltmp C( Kmlvfc `h [rzzlvt vb? 96 ELT@LH ilvZvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{

li Znc`ht`ii'{ @h%Mlr{b Nbgcn Klrh{bn Olhctmch El{{(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fpGrkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,:6,6:3:

:4,:6,6:3: 99 DBKNCVCT@LH li Cvtmrv Nb{m`h `h [rzzlvt vb? 96 ELT@LH ilvZvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{

li Znc`ht`ii'{ @h%Mlr{b Nbgcn Klrh{bn Olhctmch El{{(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fpGrkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,:6,6:3:

:4,:6,6:3: 97 DBKNCVCT@LH li Kmv`{tp Nbnbka `h [rzzlvt vb? 96 ELT@LH ilv

Zvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{li Znc`ht`ii'{ @h%Mlr{b Nbgcn Klrh{bn Olhctmch El{{(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fpGrkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,:6,6:3:

:4,:6,6:3: 9= DBKNCVCT@LH li Acvbh Nlefcvdl `h [rzzlvt vb? 96 ELT@LH ilvZvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{

li Znc`ht`ii'{ @h%Mlr{b Nbgcn Klrh{bn Olhctmch El{{(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fpGrkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,:6,6:3:

:4,:6,6:3: 90 DBKNCVCT@LH li Dch`bnnc Y`tcnb `h [rzzlvt vb? 96 ELT@LH ilvZvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{

li Znc`ht`ii'{ @h%Mlr{b Nbgcn Klrh{bn Olhctmch El{{(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fpGrkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,:6,6:3:

:4,:6,6:3: 7: EBELVCHDRE LI NCW `h [rzzlvt vb? 96 ELT@LH ilv Zvltbkt`ybLvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{ li 

Znc`ht`ii'{ @h%Mlr{b Nbgcn Klrh{bn Olhctmch El{{(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fpGrkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,:6,6:3:

:4,:6,6:3: 73 ELT@LH ilv Zvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd 

Kleerh`kct`lh{ li Hlh%Zcvtp Grkk`l Grkk` [(z(C('{ @h%Mlr{b @htbnnbktrcn 

Zvlzbvtp Klrh{bn Ychh` Ylnz`( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc.@hk((-Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,:6,6:3:

:4,:6,6:3: 76 DBKNCVCT@LH li Nlr`{ [( Bdbvbv `h [rzzlvt vb? 73 ELT@LH ilvZvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{

li Hlh%Zcvtp Grkk`l Grkk` [(z(C('{ @h%Mlr{b @htbnnbktrcn Zvlzbvtp

Klrh{bn Ychh` Ylnz`(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk((-Cttckmebht{? + 3 B}m`f`t C. + 6 B}m`f`t F. + ; B}m`f`t K. + 4 B}m`f`tD-Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,:6,6:3:

:4,:6,6:3: 7; DBKNCVCT@LH li Ychh` Ylnz` `h [rzzlvt vb? 73 ELT@LH ilvZvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{

li Hlh%Zcvtp Grkk`l Grkk` [(z(C('{ @h%Mlr{b @htbnnbktrcn Zvlzbvtp

Klrh{bn Ychh` Ylnz`(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv.Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,:6,6:3:

Page 13: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 13/29

:4,:6,6:3: 74 DBKNCVCT@LH li Dch`bnc Dbnnc Vl{c `h [rzzlvt vb? 73 ELT@LH ilvZvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{

li Hlh%Zcvtp Grkk`l Grkk` [(z(C('{ @h%Mlr{b @htbnnbktrcn Zvlzbvtp

Klrh{bn Ychh` Ylnz`(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv.

Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,:6,6:3:

:4,:6,6:3: 72 DBKNCVCT@LH li Kmbvpn [lnlelh `h [rzzlvt vb? 73 ELT@LH ilvZvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{

li Hlh%Zcvtp Grkk`l Grkk` [(z(C('{ @h%Mlr{b @htbnnbktrcn Zvlzbvtp

Klrh{bn Ychh` Ylnz`(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv.Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,:6,6:3:

:4,:6,6:3: 79 DBKNCVCT@LH li Icr{tl Zlkcv `h [rzzlvt vb? 73 ELT@LH ilvZvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{

li Hlh%Zcvtp Grkk`l Grkk` [(z(C('{ @h%Mlr{b @htbnnbktrcn Zvlzbvtp

Klrh{bn Ychh` Ylnz`(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv.Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,:6,6:3:

:4,:6,6:3: 77 EBELVCHDRE LI NCW `h [rzzlvt vb? 73 ELT@LH ilv Zvltbkt`yb

Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{ li Hlh%Zcvtp Grkk`l Grkk` [(z(C('{ @h%Mlr{b @htbnnbktrcn Zvlzbvtp Klrh{bn Ychh`

Ylnz`(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd?:4,:6,6:3:

:4,:=,6:3: 7= EBELVCHDRE CHD LVDBV vb? 96 ELT@LH ilv Zvltbkt`yb LvdbvCgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{ li Znc`ht`ii'{ @h%Mlr{b Nbgcn Klrh{bn Olhctmch El{{( I`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk( Ilv cnntmb{b vbc{lh{. Grkk`'{ czzn`kct`lh tl {bcn tml{b zlvt`lh{ li `t{ elt`lh

zczbv{ tmct vbnctb tl El{{. chd `h zcvt`krncv. tmb k`vkre{tchkb{ g`y`hg v`{btl m`{ tbve`hct`lh. `{ dbh`bd( -[`ghbd fp Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt lh4,=,3: -dok -Bhtbvbd? :4,:=,6:3:

:4,39,6:3: 70 CII@DCY@T li Olhctmch El{{ vb? 96 ELT@LH ilv Zvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{ li Znc`ht`ii'{ @h%

 Mlr{b Nbgcn Klrh{bn Olhctmch El{{(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Olhctmch El{{(-Wbkm{nbv. Dcy`d -Bhtbvbd? :4,39,6:3:

:4,39,6:3: =: EBELVCHDRE LI NCW `h Lzzl{`t`lh vb? 96 ELT@LH ilv Zvltbkt`ybLvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{ li 

Znc`ht`ii'{ @h%Mlr{b Nbgcn Klrh{bn Olhctmch El{{(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fpGrb{{<. @hk(( -Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :4,39,6:3:

:4,39,6:3: =3 DBKNCVCT@LH li Vlfbvt K( Wbn{m `h Lzzl{`t`lh vb? 96 ELT@LH ilvZvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{

li Znc`ht`ii'{ @h%Mlr{b Nbgcn Klrh{bn Olhctmch El{{(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fpGrb{{<. @hk(( -Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :4,39,6:3:

:4,39,6:3: =6 EBELVCHDRE LI NCW `h Lzzl{`t`lh vb? 73 ELT@LH ilv Zvltbkt`ybLvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{ li Hlh%

Zcvtp Grkk`l Grkk` [(z(C('{ @h%Mlr{b @htbnnbktrcn Zvlzbvtp Klrh{bn Ychh`

Ylnz`(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{<. @hk(( -Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd?:4,39,6:3:

:4,39,6:3: =; DBKNCVCT@LH li Vlfbvt K( Wbn{m `h Lzzl{`t`lh vb? 73 ELT@LH ilv

Zvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{

Page 14: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 14/29

li Hlh%Zcvtp Grkk`l Grkk` [(z(C('{ @h%Mlr{b @htbnnbktrcn Zvlzbvtp

Klrh{bn Ychh` Ylnz`(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{<. @hk(( -Cttckmebht{? + 3 B}m`f`t C tl V( Wbn{m Dbkncvct`lh. + 6 B}m`f`t F%G tl V( Wbn{mDbkncvct`lh-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :4,39,6:3:

:4,39,6:3: =4 DBKNCVCT@LH li [`ny`c G`rd`k` `h Lzzl{`t`lh vb? 73 ELT@LH ilv

Zvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{li Hlh%Zcvtp Grkk`l Grkk` [(z(C('{ @h%Mlr{b @htbnnbktrcn Zvlzbvtp

Klrh{bn Ychh` Ylnz`(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{<. @hk(( -Wbn{m. Vlfbvt-Bhtbvbd? :4,39,6:3:

:4,39,6:3: =2 DBKNCVCT@LH li Ivchkl Ibvvcv` `h Lzzl{`t`lh vb? 73 ELT@LH ilvZvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{

li Hlh%Zcvtp Grkk`l Grkk` [(z(C('{ @h%Mlr{b @htbnnbktrcn Zvlzbvtp

Klrh{bn Ychh` Ylnz`(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{<. @hk(( -Wbn{m. Vlfbvt-Bhtbvbd? :4,39,6:3:

:4,39,6:3: =9 Lfobkt`lh vb? 96 ELT@LH ilv Zvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li 

tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{ li Znc`ht`ii'{ @h%Mlr{b Nbgcn Klrh{bn 

 Olhctmch El{{( Lfobkt`lh{ tl By`dbhkb Liibvbd @h [rzzlvt li Znc`ht`ii'{ Elt`lh Ilv Zvltbkt`yb Lvdbv vb? Olhctmch El{{ ( Dlkrebht i`nbd fpGrb{{<. @hk(( -Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :4,39,6:3:

:4,30,6:3: =7 BHDLV[BD NBTTBV? cddvb{{bd tl Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt ivle Vlfbvt K(Wbn{m dctbd 4,39,6:3: vb? Klrh{bn ilv dbibhdcht vbsrb{t ch lzzlvtrh`tp tli`nb c fv`bi {rfe`{{`lh li hl elvb tmch tmvbb zcgb{ cddvb{{`hg tmb `ezlvt li Ev( El{{'{ {tctbebht{ `h m`{ cii`dcy`t fp Trb{dcp. Czv`n 6:. 6:3:(BHDLV[BEBHT? Tmb vbsrb{t `{ gvchtbd( [l Lvdbvbd( -[`ghbd fp

Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt lh 4,39,6:3: -o{ Eld`i`bd lh 4,;:,6:3:-o{( -Bhtbvbd? :4,30,6:3:

:4,30,6:3: == BHDLV[BD NBTTBV? cddvb{{bd tl Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt ivle Nlr`{ [(

Bdbvbv dctbd 4,39,6:3:( vb? Mlwbybv. `i tmb Klrvt `{ `hkn`hbd tl klh{`dbvEl{{' cii`dcy`t chd gvcht Grb{{' vbsrb{t.Grkk`. `h trvh. vbsrb{t{ tmct tmbKlrvt? -` gvcht Grkk` tmvbb -; cdd`t`lhcn zcgb{ `h vbznp -fv`hg`hg tmb tltcnzcgb n`e`t lh Grkk`'{ vbznp lh tm`{ elt`lh chd Grkk`'{ elt`lh w`tm vb{zbkttl tmb zv`y`nbgbd kleerh`kct`lh{ li Ychh` Ylnz` tl tm`vtbbh -3; chd -``zbve`t Grkk` tl i`nb `t'{ vbznp zczbv{ lh tmb El{{ chd Ylnz` elt`lh{ lhTrb{dcp. Czv`n 67. 6:3: c{ Grkk` w`nn hlt fb `h c zl{`t`lh tl dbtbve`hbmlw tl cnnlkctb `t{ zcgb{ lh vbznp rht`n `t vbkb`yb{ Grb{{' {rzznbebhtcn{rfe`{{`lh lh Czv`n 6:( BHDLV[BEBHT? Tm`{ vbsrb{t `{ gvchtbd( [lLvdbvbd( -[`ghbd fp Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt lh 4,30,6:3: -o{-Bhtbvbd? :4,30,6:3:

:4,6:,6:3: =0 EBELVCHDRE LI NCW `h Lzzl{`t`lh vb? 96 ELT@LH ilv Zvltbkt`ybLvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{ li 

Znc`ht`ii'{ @h%Mlr{b Nbgcn Klrh{bn Olhctmch El{{( [rzznbebhtcn 

 Ebelvchdre `h Lzzl{`t`lh tl Grkk`'{ Elt`lh vb? Olhctmch El{{ (Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{<. @hk(( -Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :4,6:,6:3:

:4,6:,6:3: 0: DBKNCVCT@LH li Vlfbvt K( Wbn{m vb? 96 ELT@LH ilv Zvltbkt`yb Lvdbv

 Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{ li Znc`ht`ii'{ @h%

 Mlr{b Nbgcn Klrh{bn Olhctmch El{{ ( [rzznbebhtcn Dbkncvct`lh li Vlfbvt 

K( Wbn{m @h [rzzlvt li Grb{{<. @hk'{ Lzzl{`t`lh tl Grkk`'{ Elt`lh vb?

 Olhctmch El{{( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{<. @hk(( -Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd?

Page 15: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 15/29

:4,6:,6:3:

:4,63,6:3: 03 BHDLV[BD NBTTBV? cddvb{{bd tl Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt ivle Vlfbvt K(Wbn{m dctbd 4,30,6:3: vb? Lh fbmcni li dbibhdcht Grb{{ @hk( Klrh{bnwv`tb{ tl ilnnlw rz lh c d`{klybvp `{{rb tmct wc{ vc`{bd w`tm Plrv Mlhlv cttmb Ecvkm ;:. 6:3: tbnbzmlh`k zvb%elt`lh klhibvbhkb? Drv`hg tmb

klhibvbhkb Grb{{ vbsrb{tbd tmct tmb Klrvt `h{tvrkt znc`ht`ii Grkk` Cebv`kc.@hk( -&Grkk`& tl zvldrkb zv`y`nbgb nlg ilv cnnbgbdnp zv`y`nbgbd dlkrebht{klhkbvh`hg Grb{{ ecva{. db{`gh{. chd zvldrkt{ tmct Grkk`'{ cttlvhbp{vbkb`ybd ivle [trd`l Nbgcnb Ocklfckk` -&[trd`l Ocklfckk`&. tmb lrt{`db @Zncw i`ve ilv Grkk`l Grkk` [(z(C( -Grkk`l Grkk`& Cntmlrgm Grkk` cdy`{bdPlrv Mlhlv ct tmb Ecvkm ;: klhibvbhkb%chd mcd zvby`lr{np tlnd Ordgb[kmb`hdn`h chd Grb{{%tmct `t wlrnd zvldrkb c zv`y`nbgb nlg ilv tmb{bdlkrebht{. `t hlw vbir{b{ tl dl {l( BHDLV[BEBHT? C{ tm`{ ecttbv `{

lrt{`db tmb {klzb li tmb d`{tv`kt klrvt'{ vbibvvcn. @ mcyb hl crtmlv`tp tl cktlh `t chd d`vbkt tmb zcvt`b{ tl Ordgb [kmb`hdn`h( [l Lvdbvbd( -[`ghbd fpEcg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt lh 4,6:,3: -o{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,63,6:3:

:4,67,6:3: 06 VBZNP EBELVCHDRE LI NCW `h [rzzlvt vb? 73 ELT@LH ilv

Zvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{li Hlh%Zcvtp Grkk`l Grkk` [(z(C('{ @h%Mlr{b @htbnnbktrcn Zvlzbvtp

Klrh{bn Ychh` Ylnz`(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv.Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,67,6:3:

:4,67,6:3: 0; DBKNCVCT@LH li Icr{tl Zlkcv `h [rzzlvt vb? 73 ELT@LH ilvZvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{

li Hlh%Zcvtp Grkk`l Grkk` [(z(C('{ @h%Mlr{b @htbnnbktrcn Zvlzbvtp

Klrh{bn Ychh` Ylnz`(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv.Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,67,6:3:

:4,67,6:3: 04 DBKNCVCT@LH li Cdv`chl Ychbtt` `h [rzzlvt vb? 73 ELT@LH ilvZvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{

li Hlh%Zcvtp Grkk`l Grkk` [(z(C('{ @h%Mlr{b @htbnnbktrcn ZvlzbvtpKlrh{bn Ychh` Ylnz`(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv.Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,67,6:3:

:4,67,6:3: 02 DBKNCVCT@LH li Dch`bnc Dbnnc Vl{c `h [rzzlvt vb? 73 ELT@LH ilvZvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{

li Hlh%Zcvtp Grkk`l Grkk` [(z(C('{ @h%Mlr{b @htbnnbktrcn Zvlzbvtp

Klrh{bn Ychh` Ylnz`(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv.Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,67,6:3:

:4,67,6:3: 09 DBKNCVCT@LH li Nlr`{ [( Bdbvbv `h [rzzlvt vb? 73 ELT@LH ilvZvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{

li Hlh%Zcvtp Grkk`l Grkk` [(z(C('{ @h%Mlr{b @htbnnbktrcn Zvlzbvtp

Klrh{bn Ychh` Ylnz`(. 96 ELT@LH ilv Zvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb

 D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{ li Znc`ht`ii'{ @h%Mlr{b Nbgcn 

Klrh{bn Olhctmch El{{(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk((-Cttckmebht{? + 3 B}m`f`t C. + 6 B}m`f`t F. + ; B}m`f`t K. + 4 B}m`f`t D. +

2 B}m`f`t B-Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,67,6:3:

:4,67,6:3: 07 VBZNP EBELVCHDRE LI NCW `h [rzzlvt vb? 96 ELT@LH ilvZvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li tmb Zv`y`nbgbd Kleerh`kct`lh{

li Znc`ht`ii'{ @h%Mlr{b Nbgcn Klrh{bn Olhctmch El{{(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fpGrkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :4,67,6:3:

Page 16: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 16/29

:4,6=,6:3: 0= LVDBV GVCHT@HG ECVK I@[MBV NNK NBCYB TL CEBHD ECVKI@[MBV NNK'[ CH[WBV TL TMB I@V[T CEBHDBD KLEZNC@HT? @t`{ mbvbfp lvdbvbd tmct Ecvk I`{mbv NNK `{ gvchtbd nbcyb tl cebhd `t{Ch{wbv tl tmb I`v{t Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht tl `htbvzl{b c klrhtbvknc`e ilv

kchkbnnct`lh li R([( Tvcdbecva Vbg`{tvct`lh Hl( 3.4=;.2691 chd `t `{irvtmbv lvdbvbd tmct Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk( {mcnn mcyb 63 dcp{ ivle tmb dctb

li {bvy`kb li Ecvk I`{mbv NNK '{ cebhdbd znbcd`hg tl {bvyb chd i`nb `t{vbznp( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 4,6=,6:3: -ozl -Bhtbvbd?:4,6=,6:3:

:4,;:,6:3: 00 [T@ZRNCT@LH CHD LVDBV? @t `{ mbvbfp {t`zrnctbd chd cgvbbd fp chdfbtwbbh tmb zcvt`b{ tmct Znc`ht`ii Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk( fb zbve`ttbd tl i`nb`t{ [bklhd Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh4,;:,6:3: -ozl -Bhtbvbd? :4,;:,6:3:

:2,:2,6:3: 3:: TVCH[KV@ZT li zvlkbbd`hg{ mbnd lh 4,69,3: fbilvb Ordgb [m`vc C([kmb`hdn`h( -cec -Bhtbvbd? :2,:2,6:3:

:2,:9,6:3: 3:3 [BKLHD CEBHDBD KLEZNC@HT cebhd`hg 30 Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht.

cgc`h{t Grb{{<. @hk(. Ecvk I`{mbv Illtwbcv NNK. Tmb Ec} NbctmbvGvlrz,K`zv`ch` Ckkb{{lv`b{. @hk(. [bsrbn CG. A)E C{{lk`ctb{ N(Z(. Y`ycLzt`srb. @hk(. [`ghcn Zvldrkt{. @hk(. [wcha. @hk(Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk`Cebv`kc. @hk( Vbnctbd dlkrebht? 30 Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht. i`nbd fp Grkk`Cebv`kc. @hk( -evl -Bhtbvbd? :2,:7,6:3:

:2,3:,6:3: ///HLTB TL CTTLVHBP TL B%EC@N ZDI( Hltb tl Cttlvhbp Nlr`{[mbvech Bdbvbv ilv hlhklezn`chkb w`tm [bkt`lh -34(; li tmb [(D(H(P(Bnbktvlh`k Kc{b I`n`hg Vrnb{ ) @h{tvrkt`lh{( B%EC@N tmb ZDI ilv

Dlkrebht 3:3 Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht. tl?kc{b\lzbh`hg{Jhp{d(r{klrvt{(gly( -evl -Bhtbvbd? :2,3:,6:3:

:2,33,6:3: 3:6 ELD@I@BD [KMBDRN@HG LVDBV? Cnn ickt d`{klybvp `{ tl fb

kleznbtbd fp Iv`dcp. Crgr{t 9. 6:3:1 tmb zcvt`b{ cvb tl {bvyb cnn `h`t`cnb}zbvt vbzlvt{. `i chp. fp Iv`dcp. [bztbefbv 64. 6:3:1 tmb zcvt`b{ cvb tl{bvyb cnn vbfrttcn b}zbvt vbzlvt{. `i chp. fp Iv`dcp. Lktlfbv 32. 6:3:1 cnnb}zbvt dbzl{`t`lh{. `i chp. cvb tl fb kleznbtbd fp Iv`dcp. Hlybefbv 36.6:3:1 Znc`ht`ii w`nn {rzznp `t{ zvb%tv`cn lvdbv ecttbv{ tl dbibhdcht{ fpIv`dcp. Dbkbefbv ;. 6:3:1 tmb zcvt`b{ w`nn {rfe`t c zvb%tv`cn lvdbv `h cilve klhilve`hg w`tm tmb Klrvt'{ `h{tvrkt`lh{ tlgbtmbv w`tm tv`cn fv`bi{ chdzvlzl{bd i`hd`hg{ li ickt chd klhknr{`lh{ li ncw fp Iv`dcp. Dbkbefbv 37.6:3:1 tmb i`hcn zvb%tv`cn klhibvbhkb zrv{rcht tl Ibd( V( K `y( Z( 39-d w`nnfb mbnd lh Crgr{t 6:. 6:3: ct 4?;: z(e( fbilvb Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h(-[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 2,7,3: -dok -Bhtbvbd?:2,33,6:3:

:2,34,6:3: 3:; BHDLV[BD NBTTBV cddvb{{bd tl Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h ivle Nlr`{[( Bdbvbv dctbd 2,3;,6:3: vb? Klrh{bn ilv Znc`ht`ii wv`tb tl vbsrb{t nbcybchd I`v{t Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht c{ zczbv dlkrebht{ drb tl tmb`v {`b. wbwv`tb tl vbsrb{t nbcyb ivle [bkt`lh 34(; li tmb Bnbktvlh`k Kc{b I`n`hg Vrnb{

) @h{tvrkt`lh{ li tmb [(D(H(P( tl i`nb tmb b}m`f`t{ tl Grkk`'{ [bklhdCebhdbd Kleznc`ht c{ zczbv dlkrebht{ lhnp( BHDLV[BEBHT?Znc`ht`ii'{ vbsrb{t ilv nbcyb ivle {bkt`lh 34(; li tmb Bnbktvlh`k Kc{b I`n`hgVrnb{ ) @h{tvrkt`lh{ li tmb [DHP tl i`nb b}m`f`t{ tl Grkk`'{ {bklhdcebhdbd kleznc`ht c{ zczbv dlkrebht{ lhnp `{ mbvbfp gvchtbd( -[`ghbd fpOrdgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 2,3;,6:3: -tvl Eld`i`bd lh 2,37,6:3: -tvl(

Page 17: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 17/29

-Bhtbvbd? :2,34,6:3:

:9,:;,6:3: 3:4 CH[WBV tl Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Ecvk I`{mbvIlltwbcv NNK( Vbnctbd dlkrebht? 3:3 Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht. i`nbd fpGrkk` Cebv`kc. @hk((-[crhdbv{. Dcvvbh -Bhtbvbd? :9,:;,6:3:

:9,:;,6:3: 3:2 CH[WBV tl Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht(. KLRHTBVKNC@E cgc`h{t Grkk`Cebv`kc. @hk(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{<. @hk(( Vbnctbd dlkrebht? 3:3Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht. i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk((-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt-Bhtbvbd? :9,:;,6:3:

:9,:;,6:3: 3:9 CH[WBV tl Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht(. KLRHTBVKNC@E cgc`h{t Grkk`Cebv`kc. @hk(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp [`ghcn Zvldrkt{. @hk(( Vbnctbd dlkrebht?3:3 Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht. i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk((-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt-Bhtbvbd? :9,:;,6:3:

:9,:;,6:3: 3:7 CH[WBV tl Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Tmb Ec} NbctmbvGvlrz,K`zv`ch` Ckkb{{lv`b{. @hk(. [bsrbn CG. A)E C{{lk`ctb{ N(Z(. Y`ycLzt`srb. @hk(. [wcha. @hk(( Vbnctbd dlkrebht? 3:3 Cebhdbd Kleznc`ht.

i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk((-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :9,:;,6:3:

:9,6;,6:3: 3:= CH[WBV tl Klrhtbvknc`e( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc.@hk((-Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :9,6;,6:3:

:9,6;,6:3: 3:0 CH[WBV tl Klrhtbvknc`e( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc.@hk((-Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :9,6;,6:3:

:9,6;,6:3: 33; TVCH[KV@ZT li zvlkbbd`hg{ mbnd lh Orhb 3:. 6:3: fbilvb Ordgb [m`vc C([kmb`hdn`h( -evl -Bhtbvbd? :9,;:,6:3:

:9,62,6:3: 33: BHDLV[BD NBTTBV cddvb{{bd tl Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h ivleVlfbvt K( Wbn{m dctbd 9,64,3: vb? Wb wv`tb vbgcvd`hg tmb c{{bvt`lh li ch

cdy`kb li klrh{bn dbibh{b( Ct tm`{ t`eb. dbibhdcht Grb{{<. @hk( dlb{ hlt`htbhd tl c{{bvt tmb cdy`kb li klrh{bn dbibh{b `h tmb cflyb%vbibvbhkbdn`t`gct`lh( BHDLV[BEBHT? Tmb Knbva `{ d`vbktbd tl dlkabt tm`{ nbttbv( [l

lvdbvbd( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 9,62,3: -voe -Bhtbvbd?:9,62,6:3:

:9,60,6:3: 333 EBELVCHDRE CHD LVDBV? Ckklvd`hgnp. Grkk` `{ d`vbktbd tl vby`{b`t{ cebhdbd zv`y`nbgb nlg c{ ilnnlw{? -` `hdbht`ip w`tm {zbk`i`k`tp wm`km li tmb Ylnz` kleerh`kct`lh{ vbnctb tl tmb `h{tcht n`t`gct`lh chd wm`kmkleerh`kct`lh{ vbnctb tl tmb @tcn`ch n`t`gct`lh {l tmct tmb Klrvt kchdbtbve`hb wmbtmbv tmb cttlvhbp kn`bht zv`y`nbgb czzn`b{1 chd -``zvly`db cdbtc`nbd db{kv`zt`lh. fbplhd tmb {rfobkt ecttbv li tmb dlkrebht. {rii`k`bhttl `hd`kctb Grkk`'{ fc{`{ ilv db{`ghct`hg bckm li tmb kleerh`kct`lh{

`hylny`hg fltm Ylnz` chd el{{% c{ zvltbktbd ivle d`{knl{rvb zrv{rcht tltmb wlva zvldrkt dlktv`hb( Grkk` `{ irvtmbv d`vbktbd tl {rfe`t tmb vby`{bdcebhdbd zv`y`nbgb nlg tl tmb Klrvt `h 36%zl`ht ilht. w`tm c klzp {bvybdrzlh cnn klrh{bn li vbklvd. fp Ornp 9. 6:3:( [l Lvdbvbd -[`ghbd fpEcg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt lh 7,60,6:3: -o{ Eld`i`bd lh 9,60,6:3:-o{( Klz`b{ fp BKI -Bhtbvbd? :9,60,6:3:

:9,60,6:3: 336 EBELVCHDRE CHD LVDBV? Ilv tmb{b vbc{lh{. Grkk`'{ czzn`kct`lhilv c zvltbkt`yb lvdbv cgc`h{t tmb d`{knl{rvb li tmb zv`y`nbgbdkleerh`kct`lh{ li Olhctmch El{{ lh cttlvhbp%kn`bht zv`y`nbgb gvlrhd{ `{

Page 18: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 18/29

dbh`bd( @h tmb cntbvhct`yb. Grkk` knc`e{ tmct tmb El{{ kleerh`kct`lh{ cvbzvltbktbd ivle d`{klybvp zrv{rcht tl tmb wlva%zvldrkt dlktv`hb(Kleerh`kct`lh{ tmct cvb hlt zvltbktbd fp tmb cttlvhbp%kn`bht zv`y`nbgb ecphlhbtmbnb{{ srcn`tp ilv zvltbkt`lh rhdbv tmb wlva%zvldrkt dlktv`hb( [bb

b(g(. Mcrgmy( [kmvldbv @hy( Eget( H( Ce(. @hk(. :6 K`y( 7022 -DNK.6::; WN 6300=974 -[(D(H(P( Crg( 62.6::; -cttlvhbp%kn`bht zv`y`nbgb hlt

czzn`kcfnb tl zrfn`k vbnct`lh{ i`ve. frt wlva%zvldrkt dlktv`hb zvltbktbdkleerh`kct`lh{ {bht tl klh{rntcht fp klrh{bn( Tmb zcvtp `hyla`hg tmbwlva%zvldrkt dlktv`hb &er{t {mlw tmct tmb dlkrebht{ wbvb zvbzcvbdzv`hk`zcnnp lv b}knr{`ybnp tl c{{`{t `h cht`k`zctbd lv lhgl`hg n`t`gct`lh(&Rh`tbd [tctb{ y( Klh{tv( Zvld{( Vb{bcvkm( @hk(. 7; I(;d 494. 47;-6d K`v(3009( [bb Ibd( V( K`y( Z( 69-f-;( C{ tmb zcvt`b{ mcyb hlt fv`bibd tmb`{{rb li wmbtmbv tmb wlva%zvldrkt dlktv`hb czzn`b{ mbvb. tmb Klrvt `{

w`tmlrt {rii`k`bht `hilvect`lh vbgcvd`hg tmb hctrvb li tmb dlkrebht{ tlc{kbvtc`h wmbtmbv tmb zv`y`nbgb czzn`b{( @h c vbnctbd Ebelvchdre chdLvdbv tmct @ ce `{{r`hg tldcp. @ mcyb d`vbktbd Grkk` tl cebhd `t{ zv`y`nbgbnlg tl dbhltb. w`tm {zbk`i`k`tp. tmb fc{`{ ilv `t{ `hylkct`lh li tmb wlva%zvldrkt dlktv`hb w`tm vb{zbkt tl tmb El{{ kleerh`kct`lh{( Tmbczzn`kcf`n`tp li tmb wlva zvldrkt dlktv`hb w`nn fb klh{`dbvbd ilnnlw`hg tmb

cebhdebht{ tl tmb zv`y`nbgb nlg( [l Lvdbvbd -[`ghbd fp Ecg`{tvctb OrdgbOceb{ N( Kltt lh 9,60,6:3: Klz`b{ li tm`{ Lvdbv cvb fb`hg {bht fp

BKI(-o{ Eld`i`bd lh 9,60,6:3: -o{( -Bhtbvbd? :9,60,6:3:

:7,:6,6:3: 334 LVDBV? Grkk` {mcnn {rfe`t `t{ vby`{bd cebhdbd zv`y`nbgb nlg tl tmb Klrvt`h 36%zl`ht ilht. w`tm c klzp {bybd rzlh cnn klrh{bn li vbklvd. fp Ornp 0.6:3:( Tmb zcvt`b{ {mlrnd cdy`{b tmb Klrvt fp nbttbv hl nctbv tmch Ornp 3;.6:3: wm`km dlkrebht{ vbec`h `h d`{zrtb citbv tmb zcvt`b{ mcyb ebt chdklhibvvbd( Tmb zcvt`b{ {mcnn {rfe`t cdd`t`lhcn ebelvchdc li ncw vbgcvd`hgtmb czzn`kct`lh li tmb wlva zvldrkt dlktv`hb fp Ornp 6:. 6:3:( -[`ghbd fpEcg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt lh 7,3,6:3: -oib Eld`i`bd lh 7,34,6:3:-oib( -Bhtbvbd? :7,:6,6:3:

:7,:6,6:3: 332 LVDBV( Grkk`'{ vbsrb{t ilv c {tcp li tmb Vrnb 76-c lfobkt`lh zbv`ld w`tmvb{zbkt tl tmb Orhb 60. 6:3: Ebelvchdre chd Lvdbv rht`n `t{ elt`lh w`tmvb{zbkt tl Ev( El{{ `{ irnnp dbk`dbd `{ gvchtbd( -[`ghbd fp Ecg`{tvctbOrdgb Oceb{ N( Kltt lh 7,6,3: -voe -Bhtbvbd? :7,:9,6:3:

:7,34,6:3: 339 BHDLV[BD NBTTBV cddvb{{bd tl Ecg`{tvctb Oceb{ N( Kltt ivle Nlr`{Bdbvbv dctbd 7,3;,3: vb? Ol`ht vbsrb{t ilv ch cdd`t`lhcn ; dcp{ tl {rfe`t ci`hcn vbzlvt tl 7,39,3: chd tmct tmb fv`bi`hg li tmb vbec`h`hg wlva zvldrkt`{{rb{ fb cdolrvhbd tl 7,6;,3:( BHDLV[BEBHT? Tmb vbsrb{t{ cvbGVCHTBD( - [tctr{ Vbzlvt drb fp 7,39,6:3:( -[`ghbd fp Ecg`{tvctbOrdgb Oceb{ N( Kltt lh 7,3;,3: -kd -Bhtbvbd? :7,34,6:3:

:7,6;,6:3: 337 EBELVCHDRE LI NCW Vb? D`{klybvcf`n`tp li Dlkrebht{ `h Grkk`

 Cebv`kc. @hk('{ Zv`y`nbgb Nlg ( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{. @hk(( -Wbn{m.Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :7,6;,6:3:

:7,6;,6:3: 33= DBKNCVCT@LH li Vlfbvt K( Wbn{m vb? 337 Ebelvchdre li Ncw Vb?

 D`{klybvcf`n`tp li Dlkrebht{ `h Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk('{ Zv`y`nbgb Nlg (Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{. @hk(( -Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :7,6;,6:3:

:7,6;,6:3: 330 DBKNCVCT@LH li [`ny`c G`rd`k` vb? 337 Ebelvchdre li Ncw Vb?

 D`{klybvcf`n`tp li Dlkrebht{ `h Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk('{ Zv`y`nbgb Nlg (Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{. @hk(( -Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :7,6;,6:3:

Page 19: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 19/29

:7,6;,6:3: 36: EBELVCHDRE LI NCW `h [rzzlvt li Znc`ht`ii Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk('{

 Elt`lh{ ilv Zvltbkt`yb Lvdbv Cgc`h{t tmb D`{knl{rvb li Wlva Zvldrkt (Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Ecntf`b. Olmh -Bhtbvbd?:7,6;,6:3:

:7,6;,6:3: 363 DBKNCVCT@LH li Nlr`{ [( Bdbvbv `h [rzzlvt vb? 36: Ebelvchdre li 

Ncw( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Cttckmebht{? + 3 B}m`f`t C.+ 6 B}m`f`t F. + ; B}m`f`t K. + 4 B}m`f`t D. + 2 B}m`f`t B. + 9 B}m`f`t I. +7 B}m`f`t G. + = B}m`f`t M. + 0 B}m`f`t @. + 3: B}m`f`t O-Ecntf`b. Olmh-Bhtbvbd? :7,6;,6:3:

:7,6=,6:3: 366 LVDBV? Grkk` `{ d`vbktbd tl {rfe`t rhvbdcktbd klz`b{ li tmb dlkrebht{n`{tbd `h tmb Vby`{bd Zv`y`nbgb Nlg tl tmb Kmcefbv{ li tmb rhdbv{`ghbd fp2 z(e( lh Iv`dcp. Ornp ;:. 6:3:( Tmb dlkrebht{ {mlrnd fbcv nbgbhd{ lvFctb{%hrefbv{ klvvb{zlhd`hg tl tmb dlkrebht hrefbv{ `h tmb Vby`{bdZv`y`nbgb Nlg( [l Lvdbvbd( -[`ghbd fp Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt lh7,6=,6:3: Klz`b{ li tm`{ lvdbv cvb fb`hg [bht Fp BKI Kmcefbv{( -o{-Bhtbvbd? :7,6=,6:3:

:7,60,6:3: 36; HLT@KB LI CZZBCVCHKB fp Olmh T( W`nn`ce{ lh fbmcni li [`ghcnZvldrkt{. @hk( -W`nn`ce{. Olmh -Bhtbvbd? :7,60,6:3:

:7,;:,6:3: 364 [T@ZRNCT@LH CHD LVDBV( Cnn B}zbvt Dbzl{`t`lh{ drb fp 3,33,6:331Cnn ickt D`{klybvp drb fp 3:,2,6:3:1 Tmb zcvt`b{ cvb tl {bvyb cnn `h`t`cnb}zbvt vbzlvt{. `i chp fp Elhdcp. 33,66,3:1 Tmb zcvt`b{ cvb tl {bvyb cnnvbfrttcn b}zbvt vbzlvt{. `i chp fp Trb{dcp. Dbkbefbv 34. 6:3:1 Znc`ht`ii w`nn {rzznp `t{ zvb%tv`cn lvdbv ecttbv{ tl dbibhdcht{ fp Iv`dcp Ibfvrcvp 4.6:331 Zvbtv`cn Lvdbv drb fp 6,3=,6:33. I`hcn Zvbtv`cn Klhibvbhkb {bt ilv

3:,63,6:3: ct :4?;: ZE fbilvb Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h( -[`ghbd fpOrdgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 7,;:,3: -dok Eld`i`bd lh =,30,6:3: -dok(-Bhtbvbd? :=,:6,6:3:

:0,:7,6:3: 362 LVDBV? GC {mcnn zvldrkb tmb dlkrebht{ lv cttckmebht{ tmct tmb Klrvtmc{ dbtbve`hbd cvb hlt zv`y`nbgbd ilvtmw`tm. c{ {bt ilvtm `h tm`{ Lvdbv(-[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 0,7,6:3: -ozl -Bhtbvbd?:0,:7,6:3:

:0,6;,6:3: 369 EBELVCHDRE CHD LVDBV? Ckklvd`hgnp. Grkk`'{ czzn`kct`lh ilv chlvdbv zvltbkt`hg tmb Ylnz` kleerh`kct`lh{ `h Dlkabt Hl( 73 `{GVCHTBD @H ZCVT CHD DBH@BD @H ZCVT. chd `t{ czzn`kct`lh ilv chlvdbv zvltbkt`hg tmb El{{ kleerh`kct`lh{ `h Dlkabt Hl( 96 `{ GVCHTBD@H ZCVT CHD DBH@BD @H ZCVT( Grkk` `{ d`vbktbd tl zvldrkb tmbdlkrebht{ `dbht`i`bd `h tmb cttckmbd [kmbdrnb &C& `h ckklvdchkb w`tm tmb`h{tvrkt`lh{ tmbvb`h fp hl nctbv tmch tmb b}z`vct`lh li tmb 34%dcp zbv`ldrhdbv Vrnb 76-c. `i hl lfobkt`lh{ cvb i`nbd( @i b`tmbv {`db i`nb{ lfobkt`lh{.chp vbsrb{t{ ilv irvtmbv vbn`bi. `hknrd`hg chp {tcp czzn`kct`lh{. {mlrnd fbecdb tl Ordgb [kmb`hdn`h(( -[`ghbd fp Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt lh0,6;,6:3: -ozl -Bhtbvbd? :0,6;,6:3:

:0,64,6:3: KC[B HL NLHGBV VBIBVVBD tl Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt( @mbvbfp knl{b tmb cflyb Lvdbv li Vbibvbhkb ilv ecg`{tvctb ordgb {tct`{t`kcn

zrvzl{b{( Tm`{ kc{b vbec`h{ lzbh( Vbc{lh? Lh 0,6;,6:3:. @ `{{rbd cEbelvchdre chd Lvdbv vb{lny`hg tmb ecttbv fbilvb eb( -cb -Bhtbvbd?:0,6=,6:3:

Page 20: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 20/29

3:,:7,6:3: 367 Lfobkt`lh vb? 336 Lvdbv...... Tl tmb Orhb 60. 6:3: Ebelvchdre chd Lvdbv

li Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt ( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc.@hk(( -Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? 3:,:7,6:3:

3:,32,6:3: 36= LZZL[@T@LH FV@BI vb? 367 Lfobkt`lh -hlh%elt`lh ,Ebelvchdre li 

 Ncw `h Lzzl{`t`lh tl Znc`ht`ii Grkk` Cebv`kc'{ Vrnb 76-c) Lfobkt`lh{ tl

tmb Orhb 60. 6:3: Ebelvchdre chd Lvdbv li Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N(Kltt ( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{. @hk((-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? 3:,32,6:3:

33,:3,6:3: 360 [BCNBD DLKREBHT znckbd `h ycrnt(-he -Bhtbvbd? 33,:3,6:3:

33,:=,6:3: 3;: VBZNP EBELVCHDRE LI NCW vb? 367 Lfobkt`lh -hlh%elt`lh. 36= Lzzl{`t`lh Fv`bi. @h Irvtmbv [rzzlvt li Grkk` Cebv`kc'{ Vrnb 76-c)

Lfobkt`lh{ tl Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt'{ Orhb 60. 6:3: Lvdbv(Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd?33,:=,6:3:

33,37,6:3: 3;3 TVCH[KV@ZT li zvlkbbd`hg{ mbnd lh 33,0,6:3: J 4?4: ze fbilvb Ordgb[m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h( -bbi -Bhtbvbd? 33,3=,6:3:

36,6;,6:3: 3;6 ELD@I@BD [KMBDRN@HG LVDBV? Dbzl{`t`lh drb fp 9,32,6:33(

D`{klybvp drb fp 9,32,6:33( Zvb%Elt`lh Klhibvbhkb {bt ilv ;,3=,6:33 ct3:?:: CE fbilvb Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h( Zvbtv`cn Lvdbv drb fp7,32,6:33( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 36,6;,6:3: -ozl-Bhtbvbd? 36,6;,6:3:

36,6=,6:3: 3;; LVDBV? Zrv{rcht tl tm`{ Klrvt'{ lvdbv. znc`ht`ii Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(-&GC& {rfe`ttbd ilrv dlkrebht{ ilv tmb Klrvt'{ `h kcebvc vby`bw( Tmb{bdlkrebht{ klh{`{t li wv`ttbh kleerh`kct`lh{ tl chd ivle Kcvnl @el. tmbGbhbvcn Klrh{bn li GC'{ cii`n`ctb. Grkk`l Grkk` [(z(C( li @tcnp tl chd ivlelrt{`db klrh{bn( Mcy`hg vby`bwbd bckm dlkrebht chd `t{ cttckmebht-{. tmbilnnlw`hg klh{t`trtb{ tmb vrn`hg{ li tmb Klrvt( 3( Tcf 3? 6,6:,:2 Zv`y`nbgbd(

Tmb lhnp cebhdebht `{ tl tmb zv`y`nbgb nlg wm`km {mlrnd mcyb db{kv`fbdtmb dlkrebht c{ &@h{tvrkt`lh{ ivle Gbhbvcn Klrh{bn tl lrt{`db nbgcntvcdbecva klrh{bn vbgcvd`hg zl{{`fnb nbgcn ckt`lh cgc`h{t Grb{{(& 6( Tcf 6?6,6=,:2 Zv`y`nbgbd( ;( Tcf ;? ;,=,:2 Zv`y`nbgbd( 4( Tcf 4? 0,636,:9Zv`y`nbgbd( Tmb lhnp lybv{`gmt wc{ tmct tmb rhvbdcktbd ybv{`lh li B}m`f`t 6wc{ lhnp {rfe`ttbd tl tm`{ Klrvt `h Ivbhkm. vctmbv tmch `h ch Bhgn`{mtvch{nct`lh( @i {rkm c tvch{nct`lh b}`{t{ `t {mlrnd fb {rfe`ttbd tl tmb Klrvtilvtmw`tm cntmlrgm `t czzbcv{ tmct tmb cttckmebht `{ zv`y`nbgbd( Ct tmbKlrvt'{ vbsrb{t Dbibhdcht Grb{{<. @hk( {rfe`ttbd `t{ vby`{bd ;:-f-9hlt`kb tl GC1 `t{ dbzl{`t`lh hlt`kb tl Kmbvpn [lnlelh1 chd `t{ B`gmtmVbsrb{t ilv Zvldrkt`lh tl GC( Bckm vbsrb{t mc{ fbbh vby`bwbd chd tmbilnnlw`hg klh{t`trtb{ tmb Klrvt'{ vrn`hg{? -3 ;:-f-9 hlt`kb? Cnn zbve`ttbdb}kbzt +32( @ hltb tmct tm`{ `{ hlt c dlkrebht vbsrb{t chd tmct tmb w`thb{{hbbd lhnp fb ahlwnbdgbcfnb cflrt chd cfnb tl tb{t`ip vbgcvd`hg vbsrb{t{+34 frt `{ hlt vbsr`vbd tl zvldrkb dlkrebht{( -6 [lnlelh dbzl{`t`lhhlt`kb? Vbsrb{t + 3 `h Cttckmebht C `{ {tv`kabh( Vbsrb{t +6 `{ zbve`ttbdfrt lhnp tl tmb b}tbht li zvldrk`hg hlh%zv`y`nbgbd chd vbnbycht dlkrebht{(

-; B`gmtm Vbsrb{t ilv Zvldrkt`lh tl GC? Tl tmb b}tbht tm`{ vbsrb{t {bba{dlkrebht{ ivle Grkk`l Grkk` lv Grkk` Gvlrz. tmb vbsrb{t `{ {tv`kabh( C{cebhdbd c vb{zlh{b `{ vbsr`vbd tl vbsrb{t{ 337%366( Vbsrb{t +36; `{n`e`tbd tl Kleerh`kct`lh{ vbgcvd`hg Grb{{< chd tl hlh%zv`y`nbgbd chdvbnbycht ectbv`cn( Vbsrb{t +364 `{ zbve`ttbd( Vbsrb{t +362 `{ n`e`tbd tlkleerh`kct`lh{ w`tm srcn`tp klhtvln dbzcvtebht{ chd vbnctbd {lnbnp tl

Page 21: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 21/29

Grb{{< Vbsrb{t{ +369%367 cvb zbve`ttbd( Vbsrb{t{ +36=%3;; cvb {tv`kabh(Vbsrb{t +3;4 `{ zbve`ttbd rhnb{{ Grb{{< vc`{b{ c wlva zvldrkt lfobkt`lh([L LVDBVBD( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 36,67,6:3: -nhn-Bhtbvbd? 36,6=,6:3:

36,6=,6:3: ///DBNBTBD DLKREBHT( Dbnbtbd dlkrebht hrefbv 3;4 Lvdbv( Tmb

dlkrebht wc{ `hklvvbktnp i`nbd TW@KB `h tm`{ kc{b( -df -Bhtbvbd?:3,3;,6:33

36,;:,6:3: 3;2 HLT@KB LI CZZBCVCHKB fp Av`{t`h Ecv`b Dcvv lh fbmcni li [`ghcnZvldrkt{. @hk( -Dcvv. Av`{t`h -Bhtbvbd? 36,;:,6:3:

:3,:;,6:33 3;9 LZ@H@LH CHD LVDBV? +00=:9 Ilv tmb vbc{lh{ {bt ilvtm cflyb. tmbLvdbv li tmb Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb `{ {bt c{`db chd Grkk`' { elt`lh ilv czvltbkt`yb lvdbv `{ mbvbfp gvchtbd( Cnn kleerh`kct`lh{ fbtwbbh Grkk` chdEl{{ tmct wbvb ecdb ilv tmb zrvzl{b li g`y`hg nbgcn cdy`kb cvb bht`tnbd tlzvltbkt`lh zrv{rcht tl tmb cttlvhbp%kn`bht zv`y`nbgb( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vcC( [kmb`hdn`h lh 3,;,6:33 -ozl Eld`i`bd lh 3,2,6:33 -cok( -Bhtbvbd?

:3,:;,6:33

:3,:;,6:33 3;7 ELT@LH ilv E`kmcbn V( Mb`eflnd tl Czzbcv Zvl Mck Y`kb( Dlkrebhti`nbd fp [`ghcn Zvldrkt{. @hk((-efb -Bhtbvbd? :3,:2,6:33

:3,:2,6:33 3;= LVDBV KNCV@IP@HG TMB KLRVT'[ DBKBEFBV 67. 6:3: LVDBV?Tmb Klrvt cdmbvb{ tl `t{ Hlybefbv 0. 6:3: Lvdbv gvcht`hg znc`ht`ii Grkk`Cebv`kc'{ czzn`kct`lh tl src{m tmb [lnlelh Hlt`kb. `hknrd`hg tmbdlkrebht vbsrb{t{ chhb}bd tmbvbtl. chd irvtmbv. tl tmb b}tbht tmb Dbkbefbv67. 6:3: Lvdbv ecp czzbcv tl fb @hklh{`{tbht w`tm tmb Klrvt'{ Hlybefbv0. 6:3: Lvdbv. tmct tmb Hlybefbv 0. 6:3: Lvdbv {mcnn zvbyc`n w`tm vb{zbkttl tmb{b `{{rb{( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 3,2,6:33 -ozl

-Bhtbvbd? :3,:2,6:33

:3,:9,6:33 E`hrtb Bhtvp ilv zvlkbbd`hg{ mbnd fbilvb Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt?[tctr{ Klhibvbhkb mbnd lh 3,9,6:33( -bbi -Bhtbvbd? :6,:6,6:33

:3,:9,6:33 E`hrtb Bhtvp ilv zvlkbbd`hg{ mbnd fbilvb Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt?[tctr{ Klhibvbhkb mbnd lh 3,9,6:33( -oib -Bhtbvbd? :6,:;,6:33

:3,:7,6:33 3;0 EBEL BHDLV[BEBHT lh 3;7 Elt`lh ilv E`kmcbn V( Mb`eflnd tlCzzbcv Zvl Mck Y`kb( BHDLV[BEBHT? Elt`lh gvchtbd( Tmb Knbva li tmb Klrvt `{ d`vbktbd tl knl{b tl knl{b tm`{ elt`lh -Dlk( + 3;7( -[`ghbd fpOrdgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 3,7,6:33 -ozl -Bhtbvbd? :3,:7,6:33

:3,33,6:33 KC[M@BV[ LII@KB VBECVA lh 3;7 Elt`lh tl Czzbcv Zvl Mck Y`kb `htmb celrht li $62(::. zc`d lh :3,:;,6:33. Vbkb`zt Hrefbv 06;4=;2( -od

-Bhtbvbd? :3,33,6:33

:3,69,6:33 34: [BCNBD DLKREBHT znckbd `h ycrnt(-he -Bhtbvbd? :3,69,6:33

:6,6=,6:33 343 LVDBV LI VBIBVBHKB TL C ECG@[TVCTB ORDGB( Lvdbv tmct kc{bfb vbibvvbd tl tmb Knbva li Klrvt ilv c{{`ghebht tl c Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb ilv[bttnbebht( Vbibvvbd tl Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb[m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 6,62,6:33 -nhn Eld`i`bd lh ;,=,6:33 -nhn(-Bhtbvbd? :6,6=,6:33

Page 22: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 22/29

:;,3:,6:33 346 BHDLV[BD NBTTBV cddvb{{bd tl Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h ivle Nlr`{[( Bdbvbv dctbd ;,3:,6:33 vb? Klrh{bn ilv tmb znc`ht`ii Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(.wv`tb{ lh fbmcni li cnn zcvt`b{ tl vbsrb{t tmct tmb Klrvt bhtbv tmb bhknl{bdzvlzl{bd eld`i`bd {kmbdrn`hg lvdbv( BHDLV[BEBHT? Vbsrb{t dbh`bd(

-[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh ;,3:,6:33 -cf -Bhtbvbd?:;,3:,6:33

:;,39,6:33 34; EBEL BHDLV[BEBHT lh? 346 Bhdlv{bd Nbttbv( BHDLV[BEBHT?Lh vbklh{`dbvct`lh. @ w`nn gvcht lhb i`hcn {`}tp dcp b}tbh{`lh li tmb[kmbdrn`hg Lvdbv `h y`bw li lhgl`hg {bttnbebht d`{kr{{`lh{( Mlwbybv. hlzcvtp ecp vbsrb{t chp irvtmbv b}tbh{`lh li tmb [kmbdrnb ilv chp vbc{lh{wmct{lbybv( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh ;,39,33 -kd-Bhtbvbd? :;,37,6:33

:;,;:,6:33 344 LVDBV [KMBDRN@HG [BTTNBEBHT KLHIBVBHKB? [bttnbebhtKlhibvbhkb {bt ilv 4,67,6:33 ct :0?;: CE `h Klrvtvlle 3=C. 2:: Zbcvn[tvbbt. Hbw Plva. HP 3:::7 fbilvb Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt. c{ {btilvtm `h tm`{ Lvdbv( -[`ghbd fp Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt lh;,;:,6:33 Klz`b{ Ec`nbd Fp Kmcefbv{( -ozl Eld`i`bd lh 4,4,6:33 -ozl(

-Bhtbvbd? :;,;:,6:33

:4,66,6:33 E`hrtb Bhtvp ilv zvlkbbd`hg{ mbnd fbilvb Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt?Tbnbzmlhb Klhibvbhkb mbnd lh 4,66,6:33( -efb -Bhtbvbd? :4,60,6:33

:4,67,6:33 E`hrtb Bhtvp ilv zvlkbbd`hg{ mbnd fbilvb Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt?[bttnbebht Klhibvbhkb mbnd lh 4,67,6:33( -efb -Bhtbvbd? :4,60,6:33

:4,6=,6:33 342 LVDBV vb Grb{{ vbsrb{t tmct tmb Klrvt vby`bw `t{ vrn`hg{ {bt ilvtm vbDlkrebht Hl{( 3.2.;4.;2.;7. chd ;= tl dbtbve`hb wmbtmbv tmbvb cvb chphlh%zv`y`nbgbd zlv`tlh{ tmct {mlrnd fb d`{knl{bd fp znc`ht`ii Grkk`

Cebv`kc? C{ @ cdy`{bd tmb zcvt`b{ ct c klhibvbhkb pb{tbvdcp. c{ tlDlkrebht Hl{( ;2.;7. chd ;=. ep vrn`hg{ vbec`h tmb {ceb( C{ tl

Dlkrebht Hl{( 3.2. chd ;4. `h n`gmt li Ordgb [kmb`hdn`h'{ vrn`hg(((cvbzv`y`nbgbd chd hbbd hlt fb d`{knl{bd( -[`ghbd fp Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{N( Kltt lh 4,6=,33 Klz`b{ [bht fp BKI tl cnn Klrh{bn-kd -Bhtbvbd?:4,6=,6:33

:2,:6,6:33 34= LVDBV VBIBVV@HG KC[B TL ECG@[TVCTB ORDGB( Lvdbv tmct kc{bfb vbibvvbd tl tmb Knbva li Klrvt ilv c{{`ghebht tl c Ecg`{tvctb Ordgb ilv[zbk`i`k Hlh%D`{zl{`t`yb Elt`lh,D`{zrtb?/ D`{klybvp d`{zrtb vbgcvd`hgzvldrkt`lh li ilvb`gh {cnb{ `hilvect`lh( Vbibvvbd tl Ecg`{tvctb OrdgbOceb{ N( Kltt( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 2,6,33 -oe`Eld`i`bd lh 2,4,6:33 -oe`( -Bhtbvbd? :2,:;,6:33

:2,:6,6:33 ///DBNBTBD DLKREBHT( Dbnbtbd dlkrebht hrefbv 349 Tvch{kv`zt(Tmb dlkrebht wc{ `hklvvbktnp i`nbd `h tm`{ kc{b( -tvl -Bhtbvbd? :2,3;,6:33

:2,:6,6:33 ///DBNBTBD DLKREBHT( Dbnbtbd dlkrebht hrefbv 347 Hlt`kb li I`n`hg li Lii`k`cn Tvch{kv`zt( Tmb dlkrebht wc{ `hklvvbktnp i`nbd `h tm`{kc{b( -tvl -Bhtbvbd? :2,3;,6:33

:2,6:,6:33 340 TVCH[KV@ZT li Zvlkbbd`hg{ vb? cvgrebht mbnd lh 4,66,6:33 fbilvbOrdgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h( Klrvt Vbzlvtbv,Tvch{kv`fbv? Amv`{t`hb [bnn`h.-636 =:2%:;::( Tvch{kv`zt ecp fb y`bwbd ct tmb klrvt zrfn`k tbve`hcn lv

zrvkmc{bd tmvlrgm tmb Klrvt Vbzlvtbv,Tvch{kv`fbv fbilvb tmb dbcdn`hb ilv

Page 23: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 23/29

Vbnbc{b li Tvch{kv`zt Vb{tv`kt`lh( Citbv tmct dctb `t ecp fb lftc`hbdtmvlrgm ZCKBV( Vbdckt`lh Vbsrb{t drb 9,3;,6:33( Vbdcktbd Tvch{kv`ztDbcdn`hb {bt ilv 9,6;,6:33( Vbnbc{b li Tvch{kv`zt Vb{tv`kt`lh {bt ilv=,66,6:33(-EkGr`va. Abnnp -Bhtbvbd? :2,6:,6:33

:2,6:,6:33 32: HLT@KB LI I@N@HG LI LII@K@CN TVCH[KV@ZT Hlt`kb `{ mbvbfp

g`ybh tmct ch lii`k`cn tvch{kv`zt li c Cvgrebht zvlkbbd`hg mbnd lh 4,66,33mc{ fbbh i`nbd fp tmb klrvt vbzlvtbv,tvch{kv`fbv `h tmb cflyb%kczt`lhbdecttbv( Tmb zcvt`b{ mcyb {bybh -7 kcnbhdcv dcp{ tl i`nb w`tm tmb klrvt cHlt`kb li @htbht tl Vbsrb{t Vbdckt`lh li tm`{ tvch{kv`zt( @i hl {rkm Hlt`kb `{i`nbd. tmb tvch{kv`zt ecp fb ecdb vbeltbnp bnbktvlh`kcnnp cyc`ncfnb tl tmbzrfn`k w`tmlrt vbdckt`lh citbv 0: kcnbhdcv dcp{(((-EkGr`va. Abnnp-Bhtbvbd? :2,6:,6:33

:2,62,6:33 323 EBELVCHDRE CHD LVDBV( Ilv tmb vbc{lh{ {bt ilvtm `h tm`{ebelvchdre chd lvdbv. Grkk`'{ vbsrb{t ilv zbve`{{`lh tl elyb ilv chlvdbv klezbnn`hg Dbibhdcht{ tl zvldrkb ilvb`gh {cnb{ chd kl{t `hilvect`lhvbnct`hg tl tmb cnnbgbdnp `hiv`hg`hg zvldrkt{ `{ dbh`bd( -[`ghbd fpEcg`{tvctb Ordgb Oceb{ N( Kltt lh 2,62,33 Klz`b{ [bht Fp Kmcefbv{ y`c

BKI( -voe -Bhtbvbd? :2,62,6:33

:2,;3,6:33 326 HLT@KB LI CZZBCVCHKB fp Acv`h Ivle{lh [bgcnn lh fbmcni li [wcha. @hk( -[bgcnn. Acv`h -Bhtbvbd? :2,;3,6:33

:9,:9,6:33 E`hrtb Bhtvp ilv zvlkbbd`hg{ mbnd fbilvb Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h? Zvb%Elt`lh Klhibvbhkb mbnd lh 9,9,6:33( -it -Bhtbvbd? :9,:=,6:33

:9,:9,6:33 ///DBNBTBD BHTVP( Dbnbtbd E`hrtb Bhtvp ilv 9,9,33( Tmb dlkrebhtwc{ `hklvvbktnp i`nbd `h tm`{ kc{b( -it -Bhtbvbd? :9,:=,6:33

:9,6;,6:33 32; TVCH[KV@ZT li Zvlkbbd`hg{ vb? Klhibvbhkb mbnd lh 9,9,6:33 fbilvbOrdgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h( Klrvt Vbzlvtbv,Tvch{kv`fbv? Chdvbw Wcnabv.

-636 =:2%:;::( Tvch{kv`zt ecp fb y`bwbd ct tmb klrvt zrfn`k tbve`hcn lvzrvkmc{bd tmvlrgm tmb Klrvt Vbzlvtbv,Tvch{kv`fbv fbilvb tmb dbcdn`hb ilvVbnbc{b li Tvch{kv`zt Vb{tv`kt`lh( Citbv tmct dctb `t ecp fb lftc`hbdtmvlrgm ZCKBV( Vbdckt`lh Vbsrb{t drb 7,3=,6:33( Vbdcktbd Tvch{kv`ztDbcdn`hb {bt ilv 7,6=,6:33( Vbnbc{b li Tvch{kv`zt Vb{tv`kt`lh {bt ilv0,69,6:33(-EkGr`va. Abnnp -Bhtbvbd? :9,6;,6:33

:9,6;,6:33 324 HLT@KB LI I@N@HG LI LII@K@CN TVCH[KV@ZT Hlt`kb `{ mbvbfpg`ybh tmct ch lii`k`cn tvch{kv`zt li c Klhibvbhkb zvlkbbd`hg mbnd lh9,9,6:33 mc{ fbbh i`nbd fp tmb klrvt vbzlvtbv,tvch{kv`fbv `h tmb cflyb%

kczt`lhbd ecttbv( Tmb zcvt`b{ mcyb {bybh -7 kcnbhdcv dcp{ tl i`nb w`tm tmbklrvt c Hlt`kb li @htbht tl Vbsrb{t Vbdckt`lh li tm`{ tvch{kv`zt( @i hl {rkmHlt`kb `{ i`nbd. tmb tvch{kv`zt ecp fb ecdb vbeltbnp bnbktvlh`kcnnpcyc`ncfnb tl tmb zrfn`k w`tmlrt vbdckt`lh citbv 0: kcnbhdcv dcp{(((-EkGr`va.Abnnp -Bhtbvbd? :9,6;,6:33

:7,66,6:33 322 TVCH[KV@ZT li Zvlkbbd`hg{ vb? Klhibvbhkb mbnd lh 9,9,6:33 fbilvbOrdgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h( Klrvt Vbzlvtbv,Tvch{kv`fbv? Chdvbw Wcnabv.-636 =:2%:;::( Tvch{kv`zt ecp fb y`bwbd ct tmb klrvt zrfn`k tbve`hcn lvzrvkmc{bd tmvlrgm tmb Klrvt Vbzlvtbv,Tvch{kv`fbv fbilvb tmb dbcdn`hb ilv

Vbnbc{b li Tvch{kv`zt Vb{tv`kt`lh( Citbv tmct dctb `t ecp fb lftc`hbdtmvlrgm ZCKBV( Vbdckt`lh Vbsrb{t drb =,32,6:33( Vbdcktbd Tvch{kv`ztDbcdn`hb {bt ilv =,62,6:33( Vbnbc{b li Tvch{kv`zt Vb{tv`kt`lh {bt ilv

Page 24: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 24/29

3:,64,6:33(-EkGr`va. Abnnp -Bhtbvbd? :7,66,6:33

:7,66,6:33 329 HLT@KB LI I@N@HG LI LII@K@CN TVCH[KV@ZT Hlt`kb `{ mbvbfpg`ybh tmct ch lii`k`cn tvch{kv`zt li c Klhibvbhkb zvlkbbd`hg mbnd lh 9,9,33mc{ fbbh i`nbd fp tmb klrvt vbzlvtbv,tvch{kv`fbv `h tmb cflyb%kczt`lhbdecttbv( Tmb zcvt`b{ mcyb {bybh -7 kcnbhdcv dcp{ tl i`nb w`tm tmb klrvt c

Hlt`kb li @htbht tl Vbsrb{t Vbdckt`lh li tm`{ tvch{kv`zt( @i hl {rkm Hlt`kb `{i`nbd. tmb tvch{kv`zt ecp fb ecdb vbeltbnp bnbktvlh`kcnnp cyc`ncfnb tl tmbzrfn`k w`tmlrt vbdckt`lh citbv 0: kcnbhdcv dcp{(((-EkGr`va. Abnnp-Bhtbvbd? :7,66,6:33

:=,:4,6:33 E`hrtb Bhtvp ilv zvlkbbd`hg{ mbnd fbilvb Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h? Zvb%Elt`lh Klhibvbhkb mbnd lh =,4,6:33( -it -Bhtbvbd? :=,39,6:33

:=,:0,6:33 ///DBNBTBD DLKREBHT( Dbnbtbd dlkrebht hrefbv 327 Tvch{kv`zt(Tmb dlkrebht wc{ `hklvvbktnp i`nbd `h tm`{ kc{b( -tvl -Bhtbvbd? :=,:0,6:33

:=,32,6:33 327 TVCH[KV@ZT li Zvlkbbd`hg{ vb? Cvgrebht mbnd lh =,4,6:33 fbilvbOrdgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h( Klrvt Vbzlvtbv,Tvch{kv`fbv? E`kmcbn EkDch`bn.

-636 =:2%:;::( Tvch{kv`zt ecp fb y`bwbd ct tmb klrvt zrfn`k tbve`hcn lvzrvkmc{bd tmvlrgm tmb Klrvt Vbzlvtbv,Tvch{kv`fbv fbilvb tmb dbcdn`hb ilvVbnbc{b li Tvch{kv`zt Vb{tv`kt`lh( Citbv tmct dctb `t ecp fb lftc`hbdtmvlrgm ZCKBV( Vbdckt`lh Vbsrb{t drb 0,=,6:33( Vbdcktbd Tvch{kv`ztDbcdn`hb {bt ilv 0,30,6:33( Vbnbc{b li Tvch{kv`zt Vb{tv`kt`lh {bt ilv33,37,6:33(-EkGr`va. Abnnp -Bhtbvbd? :=,32,6:33

:=,32,6:33 32= TVCH[KV@ZT li Zvlkbbd`hg{ vb? Cvgrebht mbnd lh =,4,6:33 fbilvbOrdgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h( Klrvt Vbzlvtbv,Tvch{kv`fbv? E`kmcbn EkDch`bn.-636 =:2%:;::( Tvch{kv`zt ecp fb y`bwbd ct tmb klrvt zrfn`k tbve`hcn lvzrvkmc{bd tmvlrgm tmb Klrvt Vbzlvtbv,Tvch{kv`fbv fbilvb tmb dbcdn`hb ilv

Vbnbc{b li Tvch{kv`zt Vb{tv`kt`lh( Citbv tmct dctb `t ecp fb lftc`hbdtmvlrgm ZCKBV( Vbdckt`lh Vbsrb{t drb 0,=,6:33( Vbdcktbd Tvch{kv`zt

Dbcdn`hb {bt ilv 0,30,6:33( Vbnbc{b li Tvch{kv`zt Vb{tv`kt`lh {bt ilv33,37,6:33(-EkGr`va. Abnnp -Bhtbvbd? :=,32,6:33

:=,32,6:33 320 HLT@KB LI I@N@HG LI LII@K@CN TVCH[KV@ZT Hlt`kb `{ mbvbfpg`ybh tmct ch lii`k`cn tvch{kv`zt li c Cvgrebht zvlkbbd`hg mbnd lh =,4,33mc{ fbbh i`nbd fp tmb klrvt vbzlvtbv,tvch{kv`fbv `h tmb cflyb%kczt`lhbdecttbv( Tmb zcvt`b{ mcyb {bybh -7 kcnbhdcv dcp{ tl i`nb w`tm tmb klrvt cHlt`kb li @htbht tl Vbsrb{t Vbdckt`lh li tm`{ tvch{kv`zt( @i hl {rkm Hlt`kb `{i`nbd. tmb tvch{kv`zt ecp fb ecdb vbeltbnp bnbktvlh`kcnnp cyc`ncfnb tl tmbzrfn`k w`tmlrt vbdckt`lh citbv 0: kcnbhdcv dcp{(((-EkGr`va. Abnnp-Bhtbvbd? :=,32,6:33

:=,39,6:33 39: BHDLV[BD NBTTBV cddvb{{bd tl Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h ivle Nlr`{B( Bdbvbv dctbd =,0,33 vb? Lh fbmcni li lrv kn`bht. znc`ht`ii Grkk` Cebv`kc.@hk( -&Grkk`&. wb wv`tb `h ilnnlw%rz tl tmb klhibvbhkb mbnd fbilvb PlrvMlhlv lh Crgr{t 4. 6:33. chd tl vb{zbktirnnp vbsrb{t tmct tmb Klrvtvbklh{`dbv kbvtc`h dbtbve`hct`lh{ ecdb ct tmb klhibvbhkb w`tm vb{zbkt tltmb b}knr{`lh li Grkk`'{ -chd Grb{{'{ {rvybp b}zbvt vbzlvt{. w`tmlrtmcy`hg vby`bwbd tmb vbzlvt{ chd w`tmlrt c irnn elt`lh vbklvd(

BHDLV[BEBHT? Vbsrb{t gvchtbd `h zcvt( Tmb Klrvt w`nn vbklh{`dbv `t{dbtbve`hct`lh{ c{ tl b}knr{`lh li tmb b}zbvt {rvybp{( Tmb zcvt`b{ cvblvdbvbd tl fv`bi cnn Dcrfbvt kmcnnbhgb{ `h lhb 62%zcgb elt`lh w`tm lhb 62%zcgb lzzl{`t`lh chd lhb 3:%zcgb vbznp( Tmb lhnp b}m`f`t{ zbve`ttbd cvb tmb

Page 25: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 25/29

b}zbvt vbzlvt{ chd tmb dbzl{`t`lh{ li tmb b}zbvt{( Tmb zcvt`b{' elt`lh{ cvbdrb =,60,331 lzzl{`t`lh{ drb 0,36,331 vbzn`b{ drb 0,66,33( @i tmb zcvt`b{klhknrdb tmct tmb`v fv`bi`hg li tmb {reecvp ordgebht elt`lh dbzbhd{ lhtmb Klrvt{ vrn`hg lh tmb Dcrfbvt elt`lh{. tmbh tmb {reecvp ordgebht

fv`bi`hg {kmbdrnb `{ {r{zbhdbd {`hb d`b( Ltmbvw`{b. tmb {reecvp ordgebhtfv`bi`hg {kmbdrnb vbec`h{ tmb {ceb( [l lvdbvbd( -Elt`lh{ drb fp

=,60,6:33( Vb{zlh{b{ drb fp 0,36,6:33( Vbzn`b{ drb fp 0,66,6:33(-[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh =,32,33 -voe -Bhtbvbd?:=,39,6:33

:=,3=,6:33 393 BHDLV[BD NBTTBV cddvb{{bd tl Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h ivleVlfbvt K( Wbn{m dctbd =,37,33 vb? Klrh{bn vbsrb{t{ tmct tmb Klrvt cebhdtmb b}`{t`hg {reecvp ordgebht {kmbdrnb {rkm tmct Grb{{ mc{ twl wbba{ilnnlw`hg tmb Klrvt'{ vrn`hg lh tmb zcvt`b{' Dcrfbvt elt`lh{(

BHDLV[BEBHT? Vbsrb{t gvchtbd( Tmb {reecvp ordgebht elt`lh {mcnnfb dlhb w`tm`h twl -6 wbba{ citbv tmb Klrvt vrnb{ lh tmb zcvt`b{' Dcrfbvtelt`lh{( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh =,37,6:33 -evl-Bhtbvbd? :=,3=,6:33

:=,60,6:33 396 [BCNBD DLKREBHT znckbd `h ycrnt(-ez{ -Bhtbvbd? :=,60,6:33

:=,60,6:33 39; ELT@LH `h N`e`hb( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{. @hk(. A)E C{{lk`ctb{N(Z(. [bsrbn CG. [`ghcn Zvldrkt{. @hk(. [wcha. @hk(. Tmb Ec} NbctmbvGvlrz,K`zv`ch` Ckkb{{lv`b{. @hk(. Y`yc Lzt`srb. @hk((-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt-Bhtbvbd? :=,60,6:33

:=,60,6:33 394 ELT@LH `h N`e`hb Tl B}knrdb Dbibhdcht Grb{{<. @hk('{ Zvlzl{bd B}zbvt 

Lz`h`lh{. Tb{t`elhp chd [rvybp{ li Dv( Epvlh O( Mbnigltt chd Dv( Kcvln 

 C( [kltt ( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk((-Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd?:=,60,6:33

:=,60,6:33 392 DBKNCVCT@LH li Nlr`{ [( Bdbvbv `h [rzzlvt vb? 394 ELT@LH `h

N`e`hb Tl B}knrdb Dbibhdcht Grb{{<. @hk('{ Zvlzl{bd B}zbvt Lz`h`lh{.Tb{t`elhp chd [rvybp{ li Dv( Epvlh O( Mbnigltt chd Dv( Kcvln C( [kltt ((Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Cttckmebht{? + 3 B}m`f`t C3. + 6 B}m`f`t C6. + ; B}m`f`t F. + 4 B}m`f`t K-Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd?:=,60,6:33

:=,60,6:33 399 EBELVCHDRE LI NCW `h [rzzlvt vb? 394 ELT@LH `h N`e`hb Tl

 B}knrdb Dbibhdcht Grb{{<. @hk('{ Zvlzl{bd B}zbvt Lz`h`lh{. Tb{t`elhp

chd [rvybp{ li Dv( Epvlh O( Mbnigltt chd Dv( Kcvln C( [kltt (( Dlkrebhti`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :=,60,6:33

:0,:6,6:33 397 LVDBV? Tmb Knbva li tmb Klrvt `{ d`vbktbd tl rh{bcn kbvtc`h dlkrebht{zvby`lr{np i`nbd rhdbv {bcn `h tmb cflyb%kczt`lhbd kc{b( [zbk`i`kcnnp. tmbKnbva `{ d`vbktbd tl rh{bcn cnn frt lhb li tmb dlkrebht{ {rfe`ttbd fpGrb{{< @hk( `h klhorhkt`lh w`tm `t{ Elt`lh tl B}knrdb tmb [rvybp{ li Dv(E`kmcbn Vczzbzlvt. Gblvgb Echt`{. chd Dv( E`kmcbn F( Ec`{ QDlkabtHl{( 396 ) 39;U( Tmb lhnp dlkrebht tmct {mlrnd vbec`h rhdbv {bcn `{B}m`f`t K tl Dv( [mcv` [b`dech D`celhd'{ 9,64,33 Vbfrttcn Vbzlvt(-[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 0,6,6:33 -nef -Bhtbvbd?

:0,:6,6:33

:0,:6,6:33 Tvch{e`{{`lh tl [bcnbd Vbklvd{ Knbva( Tvch{e`ttbd vb? 397 Lvdbv tl tmb[bcnbd Vbklvd{ Knbva ilv tmb {bcn`hg lv rh{bcn`hg li dlkrebht lv kc{b(

Page 26: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 26/29

-nef -Bhtbvbd? :0,:6,6:33

:0,:6,6:33 39= DBKNCVCT@LH li Vlfbvt K( Wbn{m `h [rzzlvt li Grb{{. @hk('{ Elt`lh tlB}knrdb tmb [rvybp{ li Dv( E`kmcbn Vczzbzlvt. Gblvgb Echt`{. chd Dv(E`kmcbn F( Ec`{( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{. @hk( -Tm`{ dlkrebht wc{zvby`lr{np i`nbd rhdbv {bcn `h bhybnlzb +396 chd rh{bcnbd lh 0,6,33(

-evl -Bhtbvbd? :0,:=,6:33

:0,:6,6:33 390 EBELVCHDRE LI NCW `h [rzzlvt li Grb{{. @hk('{ Elt`lh tl B}knrdbtmb [rvybp{ li Dv( E`kmcbn Vczzbzlvt. Gblvgb Echt`{. chd Dv( E`kmcbn F(Ec`{( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{. @hk( -Tm`{ dlkrebht wc{ zvby`lr{np i`nbdrhdbv {bcn `h bhybnlzb +396 chd rh{bcnbd lh 0,6,33(-evl -Bhtbvbd?:0,:=,6:33

:0,36,6:33 37: EBELVCHDRE LI NCW `h Lzzl{`t`lh vb? 394 ELT@LH `h N`e`hb Tl

 B}knrdb Dbibhdcht Grb{{<. @hk('{ Zvlzl{bd B}zbvt Lz`h`lh{. Tb{t`elhp

chd [rvybp{ li Dv( Epvlh O( Mbnigltt chd Dv( Kcvln C( [kltt (( Dlkrebhti`nbd fp Grb{{. @hk(. A)E C{{lk`ctb{ N(Z(. [bsrbn CG. [`ghcn Zvldrkt{.

@hk(. [wcha. @hk(. Tmb Ec} Nbctmbv Gvlrz,K`zv`ch` Ckkb{{lv`b{. @hk(. Y`yc

Lzt`srb. @hk(( -Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? :0,36,6:33

:0,36,6:33 373 DBKNCVCT@LH li Nlr`{ [( Bdbvbv `h Lzzl{`t`lh vb? 39; ELT@LH `hN`e`hb(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Cttckmebht{? + 3 B}m`f`t C3. + 6 B}m`f`t C6. + ; B}m`f`t C;. + 4 B}m`f`t C4. + 2 B}m`f`tC2. + 9 B}m`f`t C9. + 7 B}m`f`t C7. + = B}m`f`t C=. + 0 B}m`f`t F-Bdbvbv.Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd? :0,36,6:33

:0,34,6:33 376 BHDLV[BD NBTTBV cddvb{{bd tl Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h ivle Nlr`{[( Bdbvbv dctbd 0,36,6:33 vb? vbsrb{t tmct `t{ Ebelvchdre li Ncw fb i`nbdrhdbv {bcn. lv tmct Grkk` fb gvchtbd zbve`{{`lh tl i`nb c vbdcktbd

ebelvchdre li ncw tmct b}knrdb{ cnn ectbv`cn {l db{`ghctbd(BHDLV[BEBHT? Vbsrb{t Gvchtbd `h Zcvt( Grkk` ecp i`nb c vbdcktbd

Ebelvchdre li Ncw tmct b}knrdb{ ectbv`cn db{`ghctbd &Klhi`dbht`cn& lv&M`gmnp Klhi`dbht`cn%Cttlvhbp{ Bpb{ Lhnp&( [L LVDBVBD( -[`ghbd fpOrdgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 0,34,6:33 -cec -Bhtbvbd? :0,34,6:33

:0,32,6:33 37; EBELVCHDRE LI NCW `h Lzzl{`t`lh vb? 39; ELT@LH `h N`e`hb((Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd?:0,32,6:33

:0,66,6:33 374 VBZNP EBELVCHDRE LI NCW `h [rzzlvt vb? 39; ELT@LH `hN`e`hb(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{. @hk(. A)E C{{lk`ctb{ N(Z(. [bsrbn

CG. [`ghcn Zvldrkt{. @hk(. [wcha. @hk(. Tmb Ec} Nbctmbv Gvlrz,K`zv`ch`Ckkb{{lv`b{. @hk(. Y`yc Lzt`srb. @hk(( -Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd?:0,66,6:33

:0,66,6:33 372 VBZNP EBELVCHDRE LI NCW `h [rzzlvt vb? 394 ELT@LH `hN`e`hb Tl B}knrdb Dbibhdcht Grb{{<. @hk('{ Zvlzl{bd B}zbvt Lz`h`lh{.

Tb{t`elhp chd [rvybp{ li Dv( Epvlh O( Mbnigltt chd Dv( Kcvln C( [kltt ((Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk(( -Bdbvbv. Nlr`{ -Bhtbvbd?:0,66,6:33

33,39,6:33 379 LZ@H@LH CHD LVDBV vb?+3:3:;= 394 ELT@LH `h N`e`hb Tl B}knrdb

 Dbibhdcht Grb{{<. @hk('{ Zvlzl{bd B}zbvt Lz`h`lh{. Tb{t`elhp chd 

[rvybp{ li Dv( Epvlh O( Mbnigltt chd Dv( Kcvln C( [kltt i`nbd fp Grkk`

Page 27: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 27/29

Cebv`kc. @hk(. 39; ELT@LH `h N`e`hb i`nbd fp [`ghcn Zvldrkt{. @hk(.Grb{{<. @hk(. Tmb Ec} Nbctmbv Gvlrz,K`zv`ch` Ckkb{{lv`b{. @hk(. [wcha.@hk(. A)E C{{lk`ctb{ N(Z(. [bsrbn CG. Y`yc Lzt`srb. @hk( Ilv tmb vbc{lh{g`ybh cflyb. Grkk`'{ elt`lh `{ gvchtbd `h zcvt chd dbh`bd `h zcvt c{

ilnnlw{? tmb Mbnigltt [rvybp{ cvb b}knrdbd lh cnn li tmb `{{rb{ ilv wm`kmGrb{{ liibv{ tmbe( Tmb [kltt [rvybp `{ cde`{{`fnb lh tmb `{{rb li nckmb{.

frt. n`ab tmb Mbnigltt [rvybp{. b}knrdbd lh tmb vbec`hdbv li tmb `{{rb{ ilvwm`km Grb{{ liibv{ `t( Ilv tmb vbc{lh{ g`ybh cflyb. Grb{{'{ elt`lh `{gvchtbd `h zcvt chd dbh`bd `h zcvt c{ ilnnlw{? tmb Echt`{ [rvybp `{`hcde`{{`fnb lh tmb `{{rb li zl{t{cnb klhir{`lh( Tmb Ec`{ [rvybp `{cde`{{`fnb lh tmb `{{rb li c{{lk`ct`lh c{ `tvbnctb{ tl d`nrt`lh( Tmb Knbva li tmb Klrvt `{ d`vbktbd tl knl{b tmb{b elt`lh{ -Dlkabt Hl{( 396 chd 39;( Cmbcv`hg `{ {kmbdrnbd ilv Dbkbefbv 6. 6:33 ct 4?;:z(e( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb

[m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 33,39,6:33 -kd Eld`i`bd lh 33,63,6:33 -ocf(-Bhtbvbd? 33,37,6:33

33,39,6:33 [bt,Vb{bt Mbcv`hg{? Mbcv`hg {bt ilv 36,6,6:33 ct :4?;: ZE fbilvb Ordgb[m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h( -kd -Bhtbvbd? 33,37,6:33

33,3=,6:33 377 LVDBV? Tmb klhibvbhkb krvvbhtnp {kmbdrnbd ilv Dbkbefbv 6. 6:33 ct 4?;:z(e( {mcnn {bvyb c{ c {reecvp ordgebht zvb%elt`lh klhibvbhkb( Tmbfv`bi`hg {kmbdrnb w`nn fb {bt ct tmct klhibvbhkb -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C([kmb`hdn`h lh 33,3=,6:33 -kd -Bhtbvbd? 33,63,6:33

36,:6,6:33 E`hrtb Bhtvp ilv zvlkbbd`hg{ mbnd fbilvb Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h? Zvb%Elt`lh Klhibvbhkb mbnd lh 36,6,6:33( -nef -Bhtbvbd? :3,:0,6:36

36,:7,6:33 37= TVCH[KV@ZT li Zvlkbbd`hg{ vb? Klhibvbhkb mbnd lh 36,6,6:33 fbilvb

Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h( Klrvt Vbzlvtbv,Tvch{kv`fbv? Tmlec{ Ervvcp.-636 =:2%:;::( Tvch{kv`zt ecp fb y`bwbd ct tmb klrvt zrfn`k tbve`hcn lvzrvkmc{bd tmvlrgm tmb Klrvt Vbzlvtbv,Tvch{kv`fbv fbilvb tmb dbcdn`hb ilvVbnbc{b li Tvch{kv`zt Vb{tv`kt`lh( Citbv tmct dctb `t ecp fb lftc`hbd

tmvlrgm ZCKBV( Vbdckt`lh Vbsrb{t drb 3,;,6:36( Vbdcktbd Tvch{kv`ztDbcdn`hb {bt ilv 3,36,6:36( Vbnbc{b li Tvch{kv`zt Vb{tv`kt`lh {bt ilv;,0,6:36(-EkGr`va. Abnnp -Bhtbvbd? 36,:7,6:33

36,:7,6:33 370 HLT@KB LI I@N@HG LI LII@K@CN TVCH[KV@ZT Hlt`kb `{ mbvbfpg`ybh tmct ch lii`k`cn tvch{kv`zt li c Klhibvbhkb zvlkbbd`hg mbnd lh 36,6,33mc{ fbbh i`nbd fp tmb klrvt vbzlvtbv,tvch{kv`fbv `h tmb cflyb%kczt`lhbdecttbv( Tmb zcvt`b{ mcyb {bybh -7 kcnbhdcv dcp{ tl i`nb w`tm tmb klrvt cHlt`kb li @htbht tl Vbsrb{t Vbdckt`lh li tm`{ tvch{kv`zt( @i hl {rkm Hlt`kb `{i`nbd. tmb tvch{kv`zt ecp fb ecdb vbeltbnp bnbktvlh`kcnnp cyc`ncfnb tl tmbzrfn`k w`tmlrt vbdckt`lh citbv 0: kcnbhdcv dcp{(((-EkGr`va. Abnnp-Bhtbvbd? 36,:7,6:33

36,:0,6:33 3=: EBELVCHDRE LI NCW `h Lzzl{`t`lh tl Grkk` Cebv`kc. @hk'{ Elt`lh

 ilv Vbcvgrebht chd,lv Vbklh{`dbvct`lh li tmb Klrvt'{ Hlybefbv 39. 6:33

Lz`h`lh chd Lvdbv( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{. @hk(( -Wbn{m. Vlfbvt-Bhtbvbd? 36,:0,6:33

36,32,6:33 3=3 [BCNBD DLKREBHT znckbd `h ycrnt(-he -Bhtbvbd? 36,32,6:33

36,32,6:33 3=6 ELT@LH ilv [reecvp Ordgebht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{. @hk(. A)EC{{lk`ctb{ N(Z(. [bsrbn CG. [`ghcn Zvldrkt{. @hk(. [wcha. @hk(. Tmb Ec}Nbctmbv Gvlrz,K`zv`ch` Ckkb{{lv`b{. @hk(. Y`yc Lzt`srb. @hk((-Wbn{m.

Page 28: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 28/29

Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? 36,32,6:33

36,32,6:33 3=; EBELVCHDRE LI NCW `h [rzzlvt vb? 3=6 ELT@LH ilv [reecvpOrdgebht(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{. @hk(. A)E C{{lk`ctb{ N(Z(. [bsrbnCG. [`ghcn Zvldrkt{. @hk(. [wcha. @hk(. Tmb Ec} Nbctmbv Gvlrz,K`zv`ch`Ckkb{{lv`b{. @hk(. Y`yc Lzt`srb. @hk(( -Wbn{m. Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd?

36,32,6:33

36,32,6:33 3=4 DBKNCVCT@LH li Vlfbvt K( Wbn{m `h [rzzlvt vb? 3=6 ELT@LH ilv[reecvp Ordgebht(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{. @hk(. A)E C{{lk`ctb{N(Z(. [bsrbn CG. [`ghcn Zvldrkt{. @hk(. [wcha. @hk(. Tmb Ec} NbctmbvGvlrz,K`zv`ch` Ckkb{{lv`b{. @hk(. Y`yc Lzt`srb. @hk(( -Cttckmebht{? + 3 B}m`f`t C tl V( Wbn{m Dbkncvct`lh. + 6 B}m`f`t F tmvr D. + ; B}m`f`t B %Zcvt 3 li 9. + 4 B}m`f`t B % Zcvt 6 li 9. + 2 B}m`f`t B % Zcvt ; li 9. + 9 B}m`f`t B % Zcvt 4 li 9. + 7 B}m`f`t B % Zcvt 2 li 9. + = B}m`f`t B % Zcvt 9 li 9. + 0 B}m`f`t I % Zcvt 3 li ;. + 3: B}m`f`t I % Zcvt 6 li ;. + 33 B}m`f`t I %Zcvt ; li ;. + 36 B}m`f`t G % Zcvt 3 li ;. + 3; B}m`f`t G % Zcvt 6 li ;. + 34 B}m`f`t G % Zcvt ; li ;. + 32 B}m`f`t M. + 39 B}m`f`t @ % Zcvt 3 li 33. + 37 B}m`f`t @ % Zcvt 6 li 33. + 3= B}m`f`t @ % Zcvt ; li 33. + 30 B}m`f`t @ % Zcvt 4

li 33. + 6: B}m`f`t @ % Zcvt 2 li 33. + 63 B}m`f`t @ % Zcvt 9 li 33. + 66 B}m`f`t @ % Zcvt 7 li 33. + 6; B}m`f`t @ % Zcvt = li 33. + 64 B}m`f`t @ % Zcvt 0li 33. + 62 B}m`f`t @ % Zcvt 3: li 33. + 69 B}m`f`t @ % Zcvt 33 li 33. + 67 B}m`f`t O % Zcvt 3 li ;. + 6= B}m`f`t O % Zcvt 6 li ;. + 60 B}m`f`t O % Zcvt ; li ;. + ;: B}m`f`t A tmvr E. + ;3 B}m`f`t H. + ;6 B}m`f`t L-Wbn{m. Vlfbvt-Bhtbvbd? 36,32,6:33

36,32,6:33 3=2 VRNB 29(3 [TCTBEBHT( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Grb{{. @hk(. A)EC{{lk`ctb{ N(Z(. [bsrbn CG. [`ghcn Zvldrkt{. @hk(. [wcha. @hk(. Tmb Ec}Nbctmbv Gvlrz,K`zv`ch` Ckkb{{lv`b{. @hk(. Y`yc Lzt`srb. @hk(( -Wbn{m.Vlfbvt -Bhtbvbd? 36,32,6:33

36,39,6:33 3=9 EBELVCHDRE LZ@H@LH CHD LVDBV?+3:3320 Grkk`'{ elt`lh ilv

vbklh{`dbvct`lh `{ gvchtbd( Tmb Echt`{ [rvybp `{ vbnbycht chd tmbvbilvbcde`{{`fnb %lh twl hcvvlw `{{rb{( I`v{t. `t `{ vbnbycht tl tmb `{{rb li zl{t%{cnb klh{rebv klhir{`lh cnnbgbdnp kcr{bd fp Grb{{ Srcttvl G fcg{ `html{b zl{t%{cnb {`trct`lh{ wmbvb tmb kc{rcn lf{bvybv w`nn hlt {bb zbvechbhtGrb{{%`dbht`ip`hg lvhcebhtct`lh( [bklhd. `t `t{ vbnbycht tl tmb `{{rb li 

wmbtmbv tmb tb{t fcg `t{bni `hiv`hgb{ Grkk`'{ tvcdbecva chd tvcdb dvb{{v`gmt{( Grb{{ {mcnn fb bht`tnbd tl i`yb cdd`t`lhcn zcgb{ `h `t{ {reecvp ordgebht zczbv{ tl cddvb{{ tmb{b `{{rb{( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C([kmb`hdn`h lh 36,32,6:33 -it Eld`i`bd lh 36,63,6:33 -ocf( -Bhtbvbd?36,39,6:33

36,63,6:33 3=7 HLT@KB LI W@TMDVCWCN LI CZZBCVCHKB C[ KLRH[BN? @.Ctrn V( [`hgm. vb{zbktirnnp vbsrb{t tmb w`tmdvcwcn li ep czzbcvchkb c{klrh{bn ilv dbibhdcht. [wcha. @hk( -&[wcha&. `h tmb cflyb ckt`lh( @ ce hlnlhgbv vbzvb{bht`hg [wcha `h tmb cflyb ckt`lh. wm`km klht`hrb{ tl fbvbzvb{bhtbd fp Ev( Zcrn I`bnd{ li Nbc{lh Bnn`{ NNZ chd Ev( Vlfbvt Wbn{mli L'Ebnybhp ) Epbv{ NNZ( C{ {rkm. @ vb{zbktirnnp vbsrb{t tmct tmb Knbvali Klrvt vbelyb ep hceb chd b%ec`n cddvb{{ ivle tmb BKI hlt`i`kct`lh{n`{t chd,lv chp ltmbv {bvy`kb n`{t{( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh36,63,6:33 -nef -Bhtbvbd? 36,63,6:33

36,63,6:33 3== ELT@LH ilv [reecvp Ordgebht( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Ecvk I`{mbvIlltwbcv NNK(-[crhdbv{. Dcvvbh -Bhtbvbd? 36,63,6:33

Page 29: Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

8/3/2019 Gucci v. Guess, 09-04373 (SAS) (S.D.N.Y.) (docket)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gucci-v-guess-09-04373-sas-sdny-docket 29/29

36,63,6:33 3=0 [RZZNBEBHTCN EBELVCHDRE LI NCW `h [rzzlvt vb? 3== ELT@LH ilv [reecvp Ordgebht(. 3=6 ELT@LH ilv [reecvpOrdgebht(( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Ecvk I`{mbv Illtwbcv NNK( -[crhdbv{.Dcvvbh -Bhtbvbd? 36,63,6:33

36,63,6:33 30: DBKNCVCT@LH li Dcvvbh W( [crhdbv{ `h [rzzlvt vb? 3== ELT@LH ilv

[reecvp Ordgebht(. 3=6 ELT@LH ilv [reecvp Ordgebht(( Dlkrebhti`nbd fp Ecvk I`{mbv Illtwbcv NNK( -Cttckmebht{? + 3 B}m`f`t C. + 6 B}m`f`t F-[crhdbv{. Dcvvbh -Bhtbvbd? 36,63,6:33

36,63,6:33 303 VRNB 29(3 [TCTBEBHT( Dlkrebht i`nbd fp Ecvk I`{mbv IlltwbcvNNK( -[crhdbv{. Dcvvbh -Bhtbvbd? 36,63,6:33

36,63,6:33 306 [BCNBD DLKREBHT znckbd `h ycrnt(-ez{ -Bhtbvbd? 36,66,6:33

36,6;,6:33 30; EBEL BHDLV[BEBHT lh Hlt`kb li W`tmdvcwcn li Czzbcvchkb c{Klrh{bn( [L LVDBVBD( Cttlvhbp Cf`gc`n Chhb Vrf`h{tb`h tbve`hctbd(-[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 36,6;,6:33 -it -Bhtbvbd?36,6;,6:33

:3,33,6:36 304 HLT@KB LI KMCHGB LI CDDVB[[ fp Av`{t`h Ecv`b Dcvv lh fbmcni li 

[`ghcn Zvldrkt{. @hk(( Hbw Cddvb{{? [tbztlb ) Olmh{lh. NNZ. 3334Cybhrb li tmb Cebv`kc{. Hbw Plva. Hbw Plva. Rh`tbd [tctb{ li Cebv`kc3::;9. 636%2:9%;0::( -Dcvv. Av`{t`h -Bhtbvbd? :3,33,6:36

:3,67,6:36 302 LVDBV? @h c nbttbv dctbd Ochrcvp 6:. 6:36. Dbibhdcht{ vbsrb{tbdzbve`{{`lh tl i`nb c vbznp tl Znc`ht`ii{'{ {tctbebht li cdd`t`lhcn ectbv`cnickt{ c{ tl wm`km `t klhtbhd{ tmbvb `{ c gbhr`hb `{{rb tl fb tv`bd. i`nbdzrv{rcht tl Nlkcn Vrnb 29(3 -f( Dbibhdcht{ cn{l vbsrb{tbd c {mlvtb}tbh{`lh li tmb {reecvp ordgebht fv`bi`hg {kmbdrnb `h lvdbv tl zvbzcvb{rkm c vbznp( @h c nbttbv dctbd tmb {ceb dcp. Znc`ht`ii {tctbd tmct `t d`d hltlzzl{b b`tmbv vbsrb{t( Wm`nb Znc`ht`ii'{ i`itp zcgb Vrnb 29(3 {tctbebht

incgvchtnp y`lnctb{ ep `hd`y`drcn vrnb{ n`e`t`hg {rkm {tctbebht{ tl twbhtp%i`yb zcgb{ rhnb{{ zv`lv czzvlycn `{ gvchtbd. irvtmbv {rfe`{{`lh{ ivle tmbDbibhdcht{ w`nn fb hb`tmbv hbkb{{cvp hlv mbnzirn `h dbk`d`hg tmb zbhd`hgelt`lh{( Ckklvd`hgnp. Dbibhdcht{' vbsrb{t{ cvb dbh`bd( -[`ghbd fp Ordgb[m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 3,69,6:36 -nef -Bhtbvbd? :3,67,6:36

:6,34,6:36 309 LZ@H@LH CHD LVDBV vb? 3== ELT@LH ilv [reecvp Ordgebht i`nbdfp Ecvk I`{mbv Illtwbcv NNK. 3=6 ELT@LH ilv [reecvp Ordgebht i`nbdfp [`ghcn Zvldrkt{. @hk(. Grb{{<. @hk(. Tmb Ec} Nbctmbv Gvlrz,K`zv`ch`Ckkb{{lv`b{. @hk(. [wcha. @hk(. A)E C{{lk`ctb{ N(Z(. [bsrbn CG. Y`yc

Lzt`srb. @hk( Ilv tmb vbc{lh{ d`{kr{{bd. Grb{{ `{ bht`tnbd tl {reecvp ordgebht lh Grkk`'{ d`nrt`lh knc`e{ vbnct`hg tl tmb [srcvb G chd Srcttvl Gdb{`gh{( W`tm vb{zbkt tl cnn ltmbv knc`e{. tmb elt`lh{ cvb dbh`bd( Tmb Knbvali tmb Klrvt `{ d`vbktbd tl knl{b tmb{b elt`lh{ -Dlkabt Hl{( 3=6 chd 3==(C i`hcn zvb%tv`cn klhibvbhkb `{ {kmbdrnbd ilv Ecvkm 3;.6:36 ct 2?;: z(e(-[`ghbd fp Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h lh 6,34,6:36 -evl Eld`i`bd lh6,34,6:36 -evl( -Bhtbvbd? :6,34,6:36

:6,34,6:36 [bt,Vb{bt Mbcv`hg{? I`hcn Zvbtv`cn Klhibvbhkb {bt ilv ;,3;,6:36 ct :2?;:ZE fbilvb Ordgb [m`vc C( [kmb`hdn`h( -evl -Bhtbvbd? :6,34,6:36


Recommended