of 14
7/31/2019 Guidelines concept and causal mapping
1/14
* Lwwhfids < *Oxdihkdfhu @bq Elxulk*"Ebfehwy*Jlwwdfo
Ahelxuh wh clph akxqqhi ych abxfilqt ahywhhf elxulk* lfi ebfehy*jldfo df
ycdu abbm+ wh wdkk qh`hq yb abyc yhecfd|xhu at l jbqh ohfhqde klahk> E"E*jlwwdfo&
L Ady B Ychbqt
E"E*jldfo du l jhycbi `bq qhqhuhfydfo df`bqjlydbf lfi dfyhqleydbfu lu l
fhywbqmhi uyqxeyxqh+ wdycbxy ych iduyqleydbf b` uhfyhfehu bq lqloqlcu& Ychqh
lqh uhphqlk abbmu xakduchi bf abyc yhecfd|xhu+ lu whkk lu lhqu lfi jlyhqdlk
bf ych dfyhqfhy&
Ych liplfylohu b` E"E*jldfo lqh>
Dy qhixehu ych qhkdlfeh bf wbqiu lfi qhqhuhfyu ych jlyhqdlk jbqh pduxlkkt&
Dy du jbqh ohfhqde"`khsdakh yclf l cdhqlqecdelk `bqjly ahelxuh ychqh du fbehfyqlk dihl ycly du djbuhi xbf ych jlyhqdlk `qbj ych ahodffdfo&
Dy hjcluduhu lfi qhuheyu ych fhywbqm"utuyhjde uyqxeyxqh b` df`bqjlydbf&
Df l jl b` l kbodelk lqoxjhfy+ dy elf>
qhqhuhfy ych lyyhqf bq uyqxeyxqh b` ych df`bqjlydbf=
qhqhuhfy ych `kbw bq uh|xhfeh b` df`hqhfehu df l kbodelk lqoxjhfy&
Ych qhqhuhfylydbf b` `kbw jhlfu dy elf lkub qhqhuhfy itfljde bq ydjh*
ihhfihfy hphfyu df l ihphkbdfo udyxlydbf&
Dy elf qhqhuhfy jbqh ebjkhs dfyhqleydbfu+ uxec lu utuyhju wdyc `hhialemkbbu&
Dy elf qhphlk ebfyqlideydbfu+ dfebfuduyhfedhu+ lfi olu df ych jlyhqdlk bq ych
kbode b` ych lqoxjhfy& Ycdu khliu yb jbqh ebfuyqxeydph |xhuydbfdfo&
_h ibf/y xuh jdfi*jlu #udihq idloqlju$ bq yhsy*bxykdfhu
ahelxuh>
ycht qhuxjh bfh ehfyqlk ebfehy=
ycht qhuxjh lfi djbuh l cdhqlqecdelk uyqxeyxqh=
ycht ibf/y qhqhuhfy ych `kbw bq uh|xhfeh b` dihlu wcdec duqh|xdqhi `bq jldfo bxy kbodelk qhlubfdfo=
ycht elf/y qhqhuhfy ych ihphkbjhfy bphq ydjh&
7/31/2019 Guidelines concept and causal mapping
2/14
Umdkku @bq Jlsdjdudfo Tbxq Oqlixlyh Hswhqdhfeh
Iqldfo E"E*Jlwu
Fbihu Fbihu lqh ytdelkkt qhqhuhfyhi lu ekbuhi `doxqhu+ uxec lu hkkduhu+
qheylfokhu+ edqekhu bq u|xlqhu&
Fbihu elf ebfyldf>
lf lohfybq hfydyt lftycdfo ycly elf ylmh leydbf b` ubjh mdfi&
lf leydbf bq ylumycly fhhiu yb ah hq`bqjhi& Ycdu jlmhu ych jl jbqh
kdmh l WHQY idloqlj&
lf luuhqydbf bq ekldj+ wchf ycht lqh xuhi yb qhqhuhfy ych kbode b` lf
lqoxjhfy&
l |xhuydbf
l ebfehy bq dihl
l jhluxqlakh bq |xlkdylydph luhey b` ubjhycdfo+ uxec lu Adqyc Qlyh bq
\xlkdyt b` Kd`h&
l ebfidydbf bq lf hphfy
Fbihu clph fhxyqlkklahku&
Hsljkhu b` fhxyqlk klahku wbxki ah>
!Loh b` Wbxklydbf!
!Hshqeduh! bq d` qhkhplfy+ l uhed`de yth uxec lu !Elqidbpluexklq
Hshqeduh!=
!Whbkh bf Udemfhuu Ahfh`dy!
Hsljkhu b` klahku ycly lqhf/y fhxyqlk ahelxuh ycht dfidelyh l idqheydbf bq
l eclfoh wbxki ah>
!Dfeqhludfo Loh b` Wbxklydbf!
!Khuu Hshqeduh!
Ibf/y xuh linheydphu"liphqau uxec lu jbqh+khuu+`luyhq+ukbhq+tbxfohq+
bkihq&&&
_chf qhiqlwdfo l jl+ dy elf djqbph ych eklqdyt b` ych jl d` tbx oqbx
qhklyhi fbihu ekbuhq ybohychq lfi jdfdjduh ych fxjahq b` eqbuudfo lqqbwu&
_chf jldfo l kbodelk lqoxjhfy+ tbx elf lii l fbyh `bq ych ubxqeh b`
hlec dheh b` hpdihfeh+ `bq hsljkh Ylakh
7/31/2019 Guidelines concept and causal mapping
3/14
Oxdihkdfhu @bq Elxulk*"Ebfehwy*Jlwwdfo
Ych ywb hfiu b` lf lqqbw ebxki clph ych `bkkbwdfo buudakh
jhlfdfou"dfyhqqhylydbfu>
Wqhehihu &&&
ebjhu ah`bqh &&&
@bkkbwu l`yhq"`qbj &&& Ydjh
Khliu yb &&& @bkkbwu l`yhq"`qbj &&& Elxulydbf
Elxuhu &&&
ebfyqdaxyhu yb &&&
Qhuxkyu `qbj &&& bq
Du lf h``hey b` &&&Elxulydbf
Uydjxklyhu &&&
dfdydlyhu &&&Du ych qhubfuh yb &&& Elxulydbf
UhfiuDu ych ubxqeh b` &&&
QhehdphuDu ych udfm `bq &&&
@kbw bqYqlfu`hq
Du l qhebfidydbf yb &&&
Du l qhqh|xdudyh yb &&&Du l ebfuh|xhfeh b` &&& Kbode
&&& du yqlfu`bqjhi &&& Dfyb &&& Wqbehuu
@hhk `qhh yb ihphkb liidydbflk wltu b` dfidelydfo lftycdfo djbqylfy
#h&o& luheyu+ eclqleyhqduydeu bq qhklydbfucdu$ at xudfo ebkbxq+ kdfh uytkh bq
ych uclh b` fbihu&
@bq hsljkh+ wh xuh>
udfokh*chlihi ycdem iluchi kdfhu # {{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{ $ yb dfidelyh ycly
fbih L djwkdhu fbih A= lfi
ibxakh*chlihi ycdem iluchi kdfhu # {{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{ $ yb dfidelyh l
ebjwlqdubf ahywhhf ywb fbihu&
D` tbx uclqh tbxq E"E*jlu wdyc bychqu+ ychf jlmh uxqh tbx qbpdih ychj
wdyc l khohfi `bq ych utjabku tbx xuh+ huhedlkkt d` tbxq utjabkduj jdocy
ah fbf*uylfilqi&
Lqqbchliu Ych lqqbwchliu elf ah klahkkhi wdyc wbqiu bq utjabku yb ih`dfh ych flyxqh
b` ych dfyhqleydbf& @bq hsljkh>
D` l eclfoh df bfh fbih eclfohu lfbychq fbih df ych uljh idqheydbf+ ychf
ycdu qhklydbfucd du dfidelyhi at l kxu #-$ udof bq !u! `bq uljh idqheydbf>
d` fbih
7/31/2019 Guidelines concept and causal mapping
4/14
Umdkku @bq Jlsdjdudfo Tbxq Oqlixlyh Hswhqdhfeh
D` l eclfoh df bfh fbih eclfohu lfbychq fbih df ych bbudyh idqheydbf
#dfphquh"qhedqbelk$ jlffhq+ ychf ycdu qhklydbfucd du dfidelyhi at l jdfxu
#$ udof bq !b! `bq bwwbudyh idqheydbf>
d` fbih
_cly jxuy ebjh ah`bqh ycdu2
Ycdu du wbqmdfo alemwlqiu df ydjh lfi Yhi elkku ycdu wbqmdfo xwuyqhlj+
kdmh obdfo x l qdphq ybwlqiu dyu ubxqeh& Whbkh `qbj hfodfhhqdfo
alemoqbxfiu lkub qh`hq yb ycdu lu qhphquh ihudof&
_bqmdfo xwuyqhlj ih`dfhu ych fhehuulqt lfi"bq ux``dedhfy qhebfidydbfu+
qhqh|xdudyhu bq elxuhu `bq l odphf ebfidydbf"uylyh&
Lu lf hsljkh+ khy/u djlodfh ych qhphquh ihudof qbehuu wchf hfodfhhqu `dquy cli
ych dihl b` jlmdfo l bqylakh EI klthq df ych klyh
7/31/2019 Guidelines concept and causal mapping
5/14
Oxdihkdfhu @bq Elxulk*"Ebfehwy*Jlwwdfo
wbxki ah Ebjwhydydph wqdeh+ Kdocy hdocy+ Ujlkk ud~h+ Xuh`xk alyyhqt kd`h lfi
Wkltu EIu& Ychf wcly hkuh wbxki clph yb ah yqxh df bqihq `bq ychuh yb ah ych
qhuxky2 Fbydeh ycly lu wh wbqm xuyqhlj+ wh elf uhh ycly xudfo uhlmhqu du obdfo
yb ah dfebfuduyhfy wdyc ych ihudqhi kbw whdocy+ ujlkk ud~h lfi kbfo alyyhqt*kd`h&
Chlicbfhu lqh ebfuduyhfy wdyc kdocy whdocy+ ujlkk ud~h lfi kbw bwhqebfuxjydbf+ wcdec du wct ycht whqh ecbuhf df qhlkdyt& Udjdklqkt+ kbw whdocy lfi
ebjhydydph qdeh wbxki ah `lpbxqhi at ych xuh b` lu jlft kluyde lqyu lu
buudakh&
7/31/2019 Guidelines concept and causal mapping
6/14
Umdkku @bq Jlsdjdudfo Tbxq Oqlixlyh Hswhqdhfeh
_bqmdfo Ibfuyqhlj
Ych |xhuydbf wcdec ytdelkkt dfidelyhu wbqmdfo `bqwlqiu df ydjh du ubjhycdfo kdmh>
_cly wbxki ah ych ebfuh|xhfehu d` &&& clhfu2
Ycdu du wbqmdfo `bqwlqiu df ydjh ybwlqiu wcly ebxki ebjh l`yhq& Yhi elkkuycdu wbqmdfo ibfuyqhlj&
_bqmdfo ibfuyqhlj ih`dfhu buudakh ebfuh|xhfehu bq h``heyu b` l odphf
leydbf&
_chf tbx iqlw ych `dquy iql`y b` ych jl+ ibf/y wbqqt labxy cbw
!qhyyt! dy kbbmu& @bexu bf ohyydfo ych fbihu lfi lqqbwu ebqqhey&
Ychf tbx elf qhiqlw dy yb jlmh dy fhlyhq& Jlft b` ych idloqlju dfycdu abbm ybbm 19 qhiqlwu&
_cdkh qhiqlwdfo dy+ tbx wdkk lkub clph ych eclfeh yb ycdfm labxy
ych jlyhqdlk `xqychq&
_h qhebjjhfi iqldfo ych `dquy phqudbf at clfi& Ychf `bq
klyhq iql`yu ychqh lqh uhphqlk `qhhwlqh bq bhf*ubxqeh qboqlju
ycly elf ah xuhi+ uxec lu Idl+Pxh lfi EJlw& Yhi xuhi Idl yb
iqlw ych E"E*jlu `bq ycdu abbm&
Lft qboqlj ycly elf iqlw l `kbweclqy elf ah xuhi wdycbxy
id``dexkyt& Jbuy iqlwdfo lemlohu wdkk lkub uhqph hq`heykt
lih|xlyhkt `bq iqlwdfo E"E*jlu&
D` tbx lqh iqlwdfo l E"E*jl yb chk tbx xfihquylfi l lhq bq qhbqy lfi tbx
`dfi dy id``dexky#bq djbuudakh$ yb ebfuyqxey ych E"E*jl+ ychf ychqh lqh uhphqlk
buudadkdydhu>
dy clu fb kbodelk uyqxeyxqh=
dy clu bbq"whlm uyqxeyxqh=
ych uyqxeyxqh du bauexqhi at l bbq wqdydfo uytkh&
7/31/2019 Guidelines concept and causal mapping
7/14
Oxdihkdfhu @bq Elxulk*"Ebfehwy*Jlwwdfo
D` ych qhuxkydfo ebfehy*jl du jhuut+ ychf ych lhq du hdychq>
bbqkt uyqxeyxqhi lfi du kdyykh jbqh yclf l ebkkheydbf b` `leyu+ edylydbfu lfi
uxbudydbfu= bq
bphqkt ebjkdelyhi&
Ycdfou Yb Kbbm @bq Df Lft E"E*Jlw
Ixqdfo ych iqlwdfo b` tbxq E"E*jl+ tbx wdkk clph lkqhlit ahhf kbbmdfo `bq>
jduudfo fbihu bq lqqbwu=
uheydbfu ycly lqh xfehqyldf=
dfebfuduyhfedhu&
Dy du wbqycwcdkh yb ebfydfxh kbbmdfo `bq ych labph hphf wchf tbxq E"E*jl du
`dfduchi& Df liidydbf+ dy du lkub xuh`xk yb kbbm `bq>
`hhialem kbbu=
ihkltu"ydjh*klou=
hfyqt #uylqy$ lfi hsdy #`dfduc$ bdfyu&
@hhialem Kbbwu _chf tbx lqh wbqmdfo wdyc ebjkhs jlu+ bfh ycdfo yb kbbm `bq du `hhialem
kbbwu& L `hhialem kbb du wchqh l ekbuhi kbb bq lyc elf ah yqlehi lqbxfi
l edqexdy b` fbihu&
@hhialem Kbbw Fby L @hhialem Kbbw
L A E L `bqju l ekbuhi kbb& Ycdu du ywb lycwltu `qbj L yb A>
L A lfi L E A
L A E I L `bqju l kbb& Ywb lycu `qbj L yb A&
7/31/2019 Guidelines concept and causal mapping
8/14
Umdkku @bq Jlsdjdudfo Tbxq Oqlixlyh Hswhqdhfeh
L A E I H L `bqju l kbb& Ywb lycu `qbj L yb E&
Klqohq jlu elf clph jbqh yclf bfh `hhialem kbb lfi ych kbbu jlt hphf
ah dfyhqebffheyhi"dfyhqleydfo&
_chf tbx lqh wbqmdfo wdyc l elxulk jl #udofu bf ych lqqbwchliu$ lfi
ychqh lqh `hhialem kbbu+ ychf dy du xuh`xk yb ebfudihq ych h``hey#u$ b` ych
`hhialem kbb#u$& @hhialem kbbu elf ah hdychq fholydph bqwbudydph&
Ych ywb `bkkbwdfo hsljkhu dkkxuyqlyh ych ohfhqlk qxkh `bq ihyhqjdfdfo
wchychq l `hhialem kbb duwbudydph bq fholydph& Df ychuh hsljkhu wh clph
klahkkhi ych lqqbwchliu wdyc #l$+ #a$+ #e$ lfi #i$ wcdec qhqhuhfy ych udof bf
ych qhuheydph lqqbwchli&
D` #l$ du &&& D` #a$ du &&& D` #e$ du &&& ychf@hhialem
du &&&
- - - -
- -
- -
- -
- -
- -
- -
7/31/2019 Guidelines concept and causal mapping
9/14
Oxdihkdfhu @bq Elxulk*"Ebfehwy*Jlwwdfo
D` #l$ du &&& D` #a$ du &&& D` #e$ du &&& D` #i$ du &&& ychf@hhialem
du &&&
- - - - -
-
- - -
- - -
- - -
-
D` ych qbixey b` ych udofu lqbxfi ych kbb du ychf dy du l fholydph `hhialem
kbb& Lf lkyhqflydph wlt b` ih`dfdfo ycdu du d` ych fxjahq b` udofu lqbxfi ych
kbb du bii ychf ych `hhialem kbb du fholydph&
D` ych qbixey b` ych udofu lqbxfi ych kbb du -+ ychf dy du lwbudydph `hhialem
kbb& Lf lkyhqflydph wlt b` ih`dfdfo ycdu du d` ych fxjahq b` udofu lqbxfi ychkbb du hphf ychf ych `hhialem kbb duwbudydph&
Fholydph `hhialemelf lkub ah elkkhi alklfedfo bq qhuyqldfdfo `hhialem
ahelxuh ych fholydph `hhialem kbb lxybjlydelkkt qhuyqldfu bq qhuduyu lft eclfoh
yb ych fbihu wdycdf ych kbb& Dy wdkk ah uylakh df ych uhfuh ycly d` ubjhycdfo yqdhu
yb eclfoh bfh fbih ychf ych kbb lu l wcbkh wdkk lxybjlydelkkt qhlinxuy df l wlt
yb jdfdjduh ycly eclfoh& Ych idloqlj ahkbw ucbwu l fholydph `hhialem kbb&
Khy/u djlodfh ycly ubjhycdfo `qbj bxyudih ych kbb dfeqhluhu fbih L&
D` wh `bkkbw ych h``heyu b` ycdu dfeqhluh df fbih L lqbxfi ych kbb ychf wh uhh
ycly>
d` L dfeqhluhu ychf A wdkk dfeqhluh lkub=
d` A dfeqhluhu ychf E wdkk dfeqhluh=
d` E dfeqhluhu ychf I wdkk iheqhluh= lfi
7/31/2019 Guidelines concept and causal mapping
10/14
Umdkku @bq Jlsdjdudfo Tbxq Oqlixlyh Hswhqdhfeh
d` I iheqhluhu ychf L wdkk iheqhluh lu whkk&
Ych `hhialem kbb clu qhubfihi df ych bwwbudyh idqheydbf yb ych dfdydlk eclfoh ly
L& Khy/u kbbm ly lf hsljkh& Df flyxqh+ bxklydbfu fbqjlkkt uyladkduh ly l
fxjahq ycly du uxdyhi yb ych uleh lfi `bbi lpldklakh& Cbw ibhu ycly clhf2
Ycqbxoc ych leydbf b` plqdbxu fholydph `hhialem kbbu+ bfh b` wcdec du ucbwfahkbw&
D` Wbxklydbf dfeqhluhu+ ychf ub wdkk Eqbwidfo lfi lu l qhuxky b` dfeqhluhiEqbwidfo ychqh wdkk ah lf dfeqhluh df Iduhluh lfi @ljdfh& Dfeqhluhi Iduhluh
lfi @ljdfh wdkk dfeqhluh Ihlycu wcdec wdkk iheqhluh ych Wbxklydbf&
Wbudydph `hhialemelf lkub ah elkkhi xfalklfedfo bq qhdf`bqedfo `hhialem
ahelxuh ych budydph `hhialem kbb wdkk lxybjlydelkkt qhdf`bqeh bq leehfyxlyh lft
eclfoh yb ych fbihu wdycdf ych kbb& Dy wdkk ah xfuylakh bq ihuyladkdudfo df ych
uhfuh ycly d` ubjhycdfo yqdhu yb eclfoh bfh fbih ychf ych kbb lu l wcbkh wdkk
lxybjlydelkkt qhley df l wlt ycly ljkd`dhu ych eclfoh& Ych idloqlj ahkbw ucbwu
l budydph `hhialem kbb& Khy/u djlodfh ycly ubjhycdfo `qbj bxyudih ych kbb
dfeqhluhu fbih L&
D` wh `bkkbw ych h``heyu b` ycdu dfeqhluh df fbih L lqbxfi ych kbb ychf wh uhh
ycly>
d` L dfeqhluhu ychf A wdkk iheqhluh=
d` A iheqhluhu ychf E wdkk iheqhluh lu whkk=
d` E iheqhluhu ychf I wdkk dfeqhluh= lfi
d` I dfeqhluhu ychf L wdkk dfeqhluh `xqychq&
Ych `hhialem kbb clu qhubfihi df ych uljh idqheydbf yb ych dfdydlk eclfoh ly
L lfi clu qhdf`bqehi bq ljkd`dhi ych eclfoh&
Wbudydph lfi fholydph `hhialem kbbu lqh fhdychq obbi fbq ali& _chychq ycht lqh
chk`xk bq clqj`xk ihhfiu xbf ych edqexjuylfehu lfi ych ihudqhi bxyebjh&
Df udyxlydbfu wchqh tbx wlfy ycdfou yb qhjldf uylakh lfi ebfuylfy+ ychf
fholydph `hhialem kbbu wdkk ah xuh`xk lfi budydph `hhialem kbbu wdkkelxuh qbakhju ahelxuh ycht wdkk ihuyladkduh jlyyhqu&
7/31/2019 Guidelines concept and causal mapping
11/14
Oxdihkdfhu @bq Elxulk*"Ebfehwy*Jlwwdfo
Df udyxlydbfu wchqh tbx wlfy l eclfoh yb clhf+ ychf budydph `hhialem
kbbu wdkk ah xuh`xk lfi fholydph `hhialem kbbu wdkk lxybjlydelkkt
qhuyqldf"qhuduy lft eclfohu&
Khy/u qhpdudy lf hsljkh `qbj Eclwyhq 0+ wchqh l bkdydedlf cli jlih l ploxh
uylyhjhfy ycly ych dfeqhludfo fxjahq b` Whbwkh bf Udemfhuu Ahfh`dy wluliphquhkt l``heydfo ych Flydbflk Hebfbjt& Ycdu E"E*jl clu bfh budydph #-$
`hhialem kbb wcdec clu ahhf cdockdocyhi df oqht>
Iduwbulakh DfebjhEbfuxjhq IhjlfiAxudfhuu_bqm`bqehIduwbulakh
Dfebjh
Ych budydph `hhialem kbb jhlfu ycly dy du l qhdf`bqedfo kbb& Ychqh lqh ywb
buudakh idqheydbfu b` qhdf`bqehjhfy>
ych fbihu lqbxfi ych kbb elf dfeqhluh bq djqbph=
ych fbihu lqbxfi ych kbb elf iheqhluh bq ihyhqdbqlyh&
Cbw ib tbx mfbw wcdec wlt dy wdkk ob2 Ych fbih Whbwkh bf Udemfhuu Ahfh`dy
l``heyu abyc _bqm`bqeh lfi Iduwbulakh Dfebjh& Ych fbih Ylshu wdkk l``hey
abyc Axudfhuu lfi Iduwbulakh Dfebjh& Ych fbihu Whbwkh bf Udemfhuu Ahfh`dy
lfi Ylshu wdkk ley kdmh ywb uhlqlyh uwdyechu ycly df`kxhfeh ych idqheydbf b` ych
budydph `hhialem kbb&
D` hdychq Whbwkh bf Udemfhuu Ahfh`dy lfi"bq Ylshu dfeqhluh+ ychf ych
`hhialem kbb wdkk ah iqdphf dfyb l iheqhludfo udqlk+ jlmdfo ych hebfbjde
udyxlydbf wbquh&
D` hdychq Whbwkh bf Udemfhuu Ahfh`dy lfi"bq Ylshu iheqhluh+ ychf ych
`hhialem kbb wdkk ah iqdphf dfyb l dfeqhludfo udqlk+ jlmdfo ych hebfbjde
udyxlydbf ahyyhq&
7/31/2019 Guidelines concept and causal mapping
12/14
Umdkku @bq Jlsdjdudfo Tbxq Oqlixlyh Hswhqdhfeh
D` Whbwkh bf Udemfhuu Ahfh`dy lfi Ylshu eclfoh df bbudyh idqheydbfu yb
hlec bychq+ ychf ych h``hey bf ych `hhialem kbb wdkk ah jbqh id``dexky yb
qhidey udfeh ych ywb |xlfydydhu wdkk ah clpdfo bbudfo df`kxhfehu xbf ych
`hhialem kbb&
D` Whbwkh bf Udemfhuu Ahfh`dy lfi Ylshu qhjldf ebfuylfy+ ychf ych`hhialem kbb wdkk ebfydfxh df wcdechphq idqheydbf dy wlu lkqhlit obdfo&
Ihkltu"Ydjh*KlouLfbychq duuxh b` djbqylfeh df E"E*jlu du ydjh*klou bq ihkltu lfi ychuh elf
beexq hdychq lkbfo l ecldf b` hphfyu bq wdycdf `hhialem kbbu& _cly ycdu jhlfu du
ycly ych qhuxky du lkwltu ihklthi wdyc qhuhey yb ych leydbf bq hphfy ycly
yqdoohqhi dy&
Df ych ecldf b` fbihu labph+ L dfdydlyhu l uh|xhfeh b` hphfyu ycly hphfyxlkkt
qhuxkyu df @& Qholqikhuu b` cbw `luy hlec lqqbw du+ ych qhubfuh ly fbih @ wdkk
beexq klyhq+ wcdec du yb ult dy wdkk ah ihklthi& Ychqh wdkk fby ah lf dfuylfylfhbxu
qhubfuh&
Ych uljh wdkk lkt yb `hhialem kbbu wchqh ych `hhialem wdkk ah ihklthi yb
ubjh ihoqhh ahelxuh dy jxuy yqlphk lqbxfi ych kbb& @hhialem wdkk fby ah
dfuylfylfhbxu&
Khy/u luuxjh ycly lkk lqqbwu lqh h|xlkkt `luy lfi qhpdudy ych hsljkhu `qbj
hlqkdhq&
@hhialem Kbbw Ydjh*Klo @bq @hhialem
D` fbih L ibhu ubjhycdfo yb fbih A+
ychf L wbf/y `hhk ych h``heyu b` dyu
leydbfu xfydk A clu leyhi bf E lfi
ychf E clu leyhi bf L&
D` fbih L ibhu ubjhycdfo yb fbih A+ychf L wbf/y `hhk ych h``heyu b` dyu
leydbfu xfydk A clu leyhi bf E lfi
ychf E clu leyhi bf I lfi ychf I
clu leyhi bf L& Ych `hhialem ihklt wdkk
ah oqhlyhq `bq ycdu kbb ebjlqhi yb ych
qhpdbxu kbb&
7/31/2019 Guidelines concept and causal mapping
13/14
Oxdihkdfhu @bq Elxulk*"Ebfehwy*Jlwwdfo
@bq ycdu eluh+ ych `hhialem ihklt wdkk ah
hphf oqhlyhq&
Qholqikhuu b` ych uhhi b` ych qbehuuhu qhqhuhfyhi at lqydexklq lqqbwu+ ych
`hhialem wdkk ah ihklthi yb ubjh ihoqhh& Df ohfhqlk+ ych jbqh fbihu ycly lqh
qhuhfy df l `hhialem kbb+ ych ukbwhq ych `hhialem kbb wdkk ah&
D` wh qhpdudy ych jl bf Whbwkh Bf Udemfhuu Ahfh`dy labph+ wh elf uhh ycly
hphf d` Axudfhuu cdqhu hbkh lfi ych _bqm`bqeh dfeqhluhu+ ychqh wdkk ah l
ihklt ah`bqh ych hsyql Iduwbulakh Dfebjh b` hjkbthi hbkh l``heyu
Ebfuxjhq Ihjlfi&
Hfyqt Lfi Hsdy WbdfyuBfeh tbxq E"E*jl du ebjkhyhi tbx jlt `dfi ycly dy clu hfyqt lfi"bq hsdy
bdfyu&
Fbihu ycly clph bfkt khlpdfo lqqbwu lqh elkkhi hfyqt#uylqy$ bdfyu `bq ych
jl&
Fbihu ycly clph bfkt hfyhqdfo lqqbwu lqh elkkhi hsdy#`dfduc$ bdfyu `bq ych
jl&
Df ych hsljkh bf loh
7/31/2019 Guidelines concept and causal mapping
14/14
Umdkku @bq Jlsdjdudfo Tbxq Oqlixlyh Hswhqdhfeh
_cly du qhuxbuhi at ych jl lfi dyu hkhjhfyu2
D` bfh ycdfo du yqxh+ ychf wcly hkuh jxuylkub ah kbodelkkt yqxh bq kbodelkkt
`lkuh2
D` ych jl du lf leexqlyh qhqhuhfylydbf+ ychf lqh ychqh lft
ebfuh|xhfehu bq djkdelydbfu ycly `bkkbw `qbj dy2
Cbw ibhu ycdu jl `dy wdyc bychq ycdfou tbx mfbw2
Dy du wbqyc qhjhjahqdfo ycly lft fbih df l ebjkhyhi E"E*jl
jdocy dfyhqley wdyc hsyhqflk hfpdqbfjhfylk `leybqu ycly clphf/y
ahhf qhqhuhfyhi wdycdf ych jl& Ychqh du lkwltu l buudadkdyt ycly
ubjhycdfo wcdec cluf/y ahhf qhqhuhfyhi ebxki ah djbqylfy&
Hsehqyhi wdyc hqjduudbf b` ych lxycbqu lfi xakduchq `qbj ych abbm>
Umdkku @bq Jlsdjdudfo Tbxq Oqlixlyh Hswhqdhfeh
_qdyyhf at Yhi PlfihqFbby+ Wc&I& lfi Pdeybqdl PlfihqFbby Wc&I&
Wxakduchi df ych Xfdyhi Mdfoibj at Ebofdyqds Kyi&
Yb `dfi bxy jbqh labxy ycdu abbm+ khluh pdudy &ebofdyqds&ebj&
Hshqeduh*aluhi wbqmucbu ycly qhdf`bqeh ych jlyhqdlk df ych abbm elf ah
abbmhi `qbj Ebofdyqds Kyi& Ychuh wbqmucbu lqh uxdylakh `bq oqlixlyh uyxihfyu
lfi buyibeybqlk qhuhlqechqu& Wkhluh pdudy ych whaudyh `bq jbqh df`bqjlydbf&