Date post: | 06-Jul-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | odormicchi |
View: | 217 times |
Download: | 0 times |
of 202
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
1/202
,
CO
Oi
CO
Q
JTD-MT-2^1-133-71
FOREIGN
TECHNOLOGY
DIVISION
HEAT
CONDUCTIVITY
OP OASES
AND
LIQUIDS
by
N . B .
Vargaftlk,
L .
P.
Plllppov,
A .
A.
Tarzlmanov,
and
R.
P .
Yurchak
D
u j
E
B
s
m
c
Approved
for
public
release;
Distribution
unlimited.
i
Reproduced y
NATIONAL TECHNICAL
INFORMATION SERVICE
Springfi«M. *. 21151
W l
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
2/202
.
THIS DOCUMENT
IS BEST
QUALITY
AVAILABLE
THE
COPY
FURNISHED
TO DTIC CONTAINED
A
SIGNIFICANT NUMBER OF
PAGES
WHICH
DO
NOT
REPRODUCE LEGI LYo
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
3/202
mm»»
FTP'MT-2^-133-71
EDITED
MACHINE RANSLATION
THERMAL
CONDUCTIVITY
OP GASES
AND
LIQUIDS
By: N . B . Vargaftlk, L .
P .
Pilippov,
A .
A . Tarzlmanov,
and R . P . Yurchak
English
pages:
84
Source:
eploprovodnost' Gazov
. 1
Zhldkostey,
Moscow, 1970, pp. 1^-155.
This
document Is
a SYSTRAN machine aided
translation,
post-edited for
technical
accuracy
b y:
ohn
R.
Sechovlcz.
UR/0000-70-000-000
Approved
for public
release;
distribution unlimited.
TMII
RANSLATION
S
A
MNMTIOH
OP
TNf
OHM».
NAL
PORIMN
TIKT
WTNOUT AN Y
ANAtYTICAL
M
lO iTOKIAL OMMINT. STATIMfNT S
O B
THIOMIS
AOVOCAT IOOR IMPLIf0
AMI
TNOS I O P TNI SOURC I
ANOOO
NO T
NIC SUMLY
RIPLICT TNI POSIT ION
00 PINION P
NI
ONI ION I CNNOLOOV .
PMPARIO
IYI
TRANSLATION I V I SMN
POR I ION I CNNOLOOY
DIVISION
•P.APR.
ONIO.
FTP-MT- H-m~7i
PHI
12
Nov.
If 71
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
4/202
EMM**
Translator's
note:
n
several
occasions,
symbols
found in
formulae
and calculations appear
to
have
been
rendered
incorrectly
in
the
original
document.
They will be shown
exactly
as they appear
in
the original.
ä
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
5/202
T A B L E P
O N T E N T S
U . S. Board n
Geographic
ames Transliteration ystem
^
Designations f he Trigonometric unctions
V
Foreword
i
Chapter . Questions
of
he Measurement
Procedure
of
Thermal
Conductivity
Natural Convection
Temperature
um p
T he
ole
f he
rocess
f
Heat
Transfer
y
adiation
....
Concerning ew Methods
for
Measuring
he
eat
Conductivity
f Gases
and iquids 0
Chapter I.
Analysis
f he
xperimental
Data.
Recommended
Values
f Thermal Conductivity
5
Helium 5
Neon 1
Argon
8
Krypton
5
Xenon
9
Hydrogen 2
Nitrogen
8
Oxygen
4
Air 9
Carbon Dioxide
6
Ammonia 04
V a p o r s
o f . Hydrocarbons
o f
t h e
Methane Series
a t
Atmospheric
Pressure
10
M e t h a n e
2 2
f
Ethane
2 6
Propane 31
Butane
34
P e n t a n e
36
Hexane 37
Heptane 40
^0-^- 24 -1 3 3 -71
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
6/202
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
7/202
U .
S .
BOARD
ON GEOGRAPHIC NAMES
TRANSLITERATION SYSTEM
B l o c k talic ransliteration Block t a l i c ransliteration
Ai
A
a A ,
a
9 P p
, r
B
6
B
6
B, b
C
c
C e S,
8
B
B
B
V,
v
T
T
T
m
T,
t
r
r
0,
g
y
y
y
y
U,
u
fl
>
n
9
D, d
< t >
#
0
*
P,
f
E
•
E
$
Ye, ye;
,
e*
X
X
X
X
Kh,
kh
) K
w H I
OK
Zh, 2h
u
u
a
H
Ts,
ts
3 •
3
1
Z,
z
M
•1
V
H
Ch,
h
H
N
H
u
I,
i
I I I
t u
lü
m
Sh,
sh
n
t
R
a
Y,
1 1 1
U l
m
> H
Shch,
shch
K
K
K
K
K ,
k
• b
%
z >
»
ji
i
JI
A
L, 1
bl
u
hi
M
Y,
M
M
M
M
M, m
b
b
b
k
•
H
H
H
H
N,
3
»
9
1
E,
e
0 o
0
0
0« o
10
»
J O
1 0
Yu, yu
n n
n
n
P,
a
n
fl
n
Ya, ya
W F e
*
̂£
Initially,
after
owels,
and
fter , b;
elsewhere,
len
written s n
Russian,
transliterate
s
8
r
.
T he se
f
diacritical marks
s
referred, but
uch marks
m ay
e mitted
hen xpediency dictates.
PTD-MT-24-133-71
ü
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
8/202
n
'OUXHÜiQ RE H E .
O R t t E S P O N D I H G USSIAN H O
M G L I S H
DESICMATIONS
? " K L
HIOOIIOMEIKIC
UNCTIOMS
Russian
s i n
e o s
t g
ctg
SSO
cosec
• h
e h
t h
e t h
« e h
csch
a r e
s i n
a r c
e o s
a r c
t g
a r c
c t g
a r e
SS O
are
cosse
a r e
s h
a r e
o h
a r e
t h
a r e
c t h
a r e s c h
a r e
eseh
rot
If
English
sin
cos
tan
oot
B SC
esc
sinh
cosh
tanh
coth
sseh
eseh
oln- ̂
eos"
1
tan-1
oof
1
sse
esc
-1
-1
sinh
1
eosh-
1
tanh-
1
coth-
1
sseh-
1
eseh-
1
earl
log
FTD-' T-2'
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
9/202
This
eference
ook
epresents
ystem-
atized nd ritical urvey
f
he
asic
xper-
imental
ata or he
ost
widely
tudied
substances
n
iquid nd
aseous
tates (for
helium,
eon,
rgon, krypton, xenon, ydrogen,
nitrogen,
xygen,
ir,
arbon
ioxide,
mmonia,
ten ydrocarbons, arbon
etrachlorlde,
thyl
alcohol nd
water).
Tables
f
he
most
eliable
alues
f
he
thermal onductivity
of
all he
ited
ubstances
in wide
ange
f emperatures nd
pressures
have
been
ompiled.
There
re 0
ables,
61 llustrations,
and
56
ibliography
ntries.
T he ook
s ntended or wide
ircle
of engineers nd
cientific
workers
f various
branches
f
echnolopry,
nd
lso
or
tudents
and
graduate ssistants.
PrD-MT-24-133-71
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
10/202
f
MMMnHMHHBHMHaBMHBMHMnHHHHMRS^'
1
'
1
'' '
POREWORD
In
he
most lvarse ranches f modern cience nd echnology
data
n
heat
conductivity
of
many
ases
and
iquids
re
mployed.
In
connection
with
his here xists he eed or
he
ompilation
of
ables
f he
ecommended
eference
alues f he hermal
conductivity
ased n
areful
nalysis
of
he
xisting
experimental
results.
This
work hould e iewed
s
part f he
rogram
of he
State
ureau
of Standard
nd
Reference
Data
Q S S S D )
for he
ublica-
tion
f undamental
manuals
n
he roperties
of
ubstances,
hich
are
idely sed n
modern
echnology nd
re
ecessary or
he
successful
evelopment
f
ew
cientific-research
works.
Recently n
he
S A
n ommission f he
National
Bureau
of
Standards
he
am e
ork w as artially carried ut t he Thermo-
ohyslcal
roperties
esearch
enter Purdue
University.
A s
esult
there
as ublished
n
966-1968 book
n
wo
parts
[1],
/hlch
ives
the ecommended
alues
f he
hermal onductivity of 0
olid
substances
nd
2
ubstances n he
iquid
nd gaseous
tates.
In
his
ublication f he B S he
emperature ependence
f he
thermal onductivity
as
stablished nly or are ases (with 1
atm),
nd
or
iquids
he values
f he
hermal
onductivity
as
given nly
n
he
aturation
ine. T he ependence f he hermal
conductivity
n
he ressure
as
ot stablished. It
s
atural hat
such ata annot satisfy he emands of modern cience nd
echnology.
It
hould
e oted
hat
for
many
ubstances,
presented
n
he
ables
.
:rr-2'j-i33-7i i
.
.,
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
11/202
of
he
B S ,
here
xists
In he
iterature
xperimental
ata
n
he
thermal
onductivity
t
sufficiently
igh
pressures.
It
s
lso
ignificant
hat n umber
of ases he alues f
the hermal
onductivity
f
gases nd
iquids ecommended
n
1] re
based n veraged
urves
constructed ccording o he
ata
f arious
authors
without
he
necessary
nalysis
f he methods
f
measurement
employed
or
he
egree of ccuracy f he nitial xperimental
results. T he
ethods
f btaining
eferenced
ata y
eans
f
simple
veraging
f existing experimental alues, ithout onsideration
of
heir qualities as
ed
o he act
hat
n he
ables
f he
National
ureau
of
Standards
f
he
S A
1]
he
alues
of
he
thermal
onductivity
f water vapor t levated
emperatures
significantly
iffer
rom
hose
dopted n he nternational ables
In
9 64 2,
3]
nd
o beyond he imit
f
olerances
stablished n
these ables.
W e
uggest hat he
eferenced
ecommendations
must e
ompiled
by eans
of areful
election
f he ost
eliable nitial
ata
for
ignificant
umber
of ubstances.
For iquids nd ases.
In
hose
ases
here
t
Is
ossible.
It
s
ssential
o
epresent
he
dependence
f he hermal conductivity
n
he
emperature nd
pressure.
Such
ork n he ompilation f
ables f
ecommended
alues f
the
hermal onductivity
s ery
aborious.
It
can e
one
sufficiently
well
nly
y ersons
aving
experience n
xperimental
research
n
his
rea. A s
a
result,
a
eries
f
books
ust
e
published.
T he
resent
ook
s
he first
f
his
eries. It
Includes ata n
he
hermal onductivity f 5
ubstances
n he
liquid
nd
as
hases,
most
widely
tudied
n
n
xperimental
espect
in
wide ange
f
emperatures
and
ressures.
T he
uthors
hought t ecessary
hat
he
ompilation f
he
tables
e receeded
y
erious analysis
f
certain
principal
problems
f
he
methodical haracter nd y
discussion
f ew
methods,
which
re being
eveloped nd sed t
he
resent
ime
or
the
measurement
f
he hermal
onductivity
f
ases
nd
iquids.
PTD-MT-24-133-71
il
-
.
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
12/202
Therefore,
pecial
ttention was
iven
o he
ole
f
he
processes
f
eat
ransfer y adiation f medium proton eat
conductivity).
The mportance
f
his
roblem
has
ecently
een
clarified
n
onnection with he arrying
ut of
number
f
theoretical
nd
xperimental
nvestigations,
from which, n
particular, it
as
concluded
hat
hese rocesses can
oticeably
Influence
he esults of measurements f
hermal
onductivity
f
liquids
nd
ompressed ases
ven
t
ow
emperatures.
Work
n
the
ompilation
f
eference ables
and
specially
he
election
f
the ample
ubstances
make his roblem n rgent ne.
T he
corresponding material
xpounded
n
Chapter
as
een written
y
L.
P.
FllloDOV.
T he uthors also xamine he
roblem
f atural onvection,
since
ecently
here
ave
ppeared ew nteresting
esults
on
he
Investigation
f
natural
onvection
n
arrow learances.
O f reat
ignificance s he
rincipal of electing
material
for he
ompilation
f ables f
eference ata
n hermal onduc-
tivity.
A t
he resent
ime,
nfortunately,
here re
s
et
o
generally
ccepted riteria nd enets
which
might erve s he
basis
or
orresponding
nalysis.
T he asic material must
e
ompiled rom
he
esults
f ystematic
experimental nvestigations,
onducted
n
wide
ange f tates
by
well
orked ut methods.
T he ecessary
onditions
re horough
consideration
y he author
f ll
he
ossible ources f rror
of he xperiments and
proven stimate f
he
ccuracy.
Besides
this
material,
it
s
advisable
o se he
ata
f
uthors, hich
refer o
arrow
ange
f
states,
f
he
nvestigations
f
each
f
them
ncompass
arge
umber
of
ubstances. T he
esults
f
nonsystematlc
easurements,
onducted
n
arrow
ange
f
emper-
atures nd pressures, can
e
xamined
nly
n
he
ase
where
here
is
detailed
description
f
he
xperiment,
he
method
f
ntroduc-
tion
f
orrections
is
described, nd
o
rror stimates
hich
suggest
oubt
ave
een iven. O ne
hould
ot
use he
ata f
investigations carried ut
y
hose
uthors
hose
esults
differ
PTD-MT-2i»-133-7i
iii
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
13/202
anomalously without isible easons
r om
he
otality
f
he
mos t
reliable
data
v en If nly
n ne
substance, specially If he
experiment
wa s
escribed
with
nsufficient
detail.
he
formulated
criteria ave,
f
ourse,
a
general haracter;
during heir
practical
mployment
t oes
without
aying
hat he ompilers
will
a v e xperience
n
arrying
ut xperimental
esearch
n he
given ield, nd
horough
amiliarity
with
he
riginal orks
a nd
with
heir
riticism.
Even or e
omplicated s the
roblem f
valuating
he esults
used, nd of he
election
f
weights,
which
hould
e prescribed
for
hose
data
u r i n g
he
processing
f
he
material
or
a m p l e
liquids.
Here
t
s
specially
esirable
o
a v e
or e
r
ess
objective ethods f uch n
valuation.
O n e f
he
possible
methods
s described n w ork 43,
where
he
weights
f
data,
belonging
to
ndividual authors, ave been
escribed
y he omputation f
divergences
from
he
otality
f
he
o st
eliable
alues
,
stablished
during he averaging of he ata f ll he uthors.
S u c h method
allowed
s to
haracterize
he
esults f
a ch
uthor
y
a
oncrete
number .
A
imilar device
a s
sed
n
ombination 5],
here he
data of
all
he uthors a s broken
own nto
hree roups
depending
on
he
ivergence
r om
he
esults,
selected
s the
m o s t
reliable.
In everal
nstances
he stimates of he degree
f
reliability
by
he
or k ethod
4] er e
s ed
n
his
eference
ook
also,
primarily
he n he uthors* evaluations f he rror
w e r e
clearly
contradictory with he ariation of
he
orresponding
data
r om
the
veraged
values
f he whole. However , he
s e
f this
ethod
for
all
he
data
wa s
ot
thought dvisable,
ven
f nly because
there
rises
he
roblem
f
he
possible ifference n he
weighting
factors
or
arious
emperatures. In
onnection
with
his.
In
he
processing
f
he
data
or
a m p l e
iquids
-
oluene,
carbon
tetrachlorlde, nd also or benzoyl
nd
thyl
lcohol
he
os t
simple method
f
valuation
wa s mployed: the elected ata were
broken
own
Into
wo r o u p s epending n whether he
probable
rror
of he
xperiment
a s
within
%
r
whether
t
xceeded
this value.
In valuating he
o u n d a r y
imit f rror or his irst g r o u p
we
PTD-riT- -̂lSa-Tl x
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
14/202
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
15/202
For all ubstances
xamined
n
his ook he ependence f he
excess hermal
onductivity s unique
unction
f he
ensity n
those
egions
f
he
arameters
f
state.
In
which
eneralization
f
the xperimental ata
has
een arried
ut. A n
xception
s
water
vapor,
for
which n
ertain
nterval
f
densities
the
stratification
of
X
with
espect
o sotherms is bserved.
With
espect
o orrelations (1 )
nd
2) ables
ave
een ompiled
for
he moothed ata or
hose
ubstances epresented
n
he
ook
t
equal ntervals f
emperatures
nd
pressures.
N ot
iven
re
he
alues
of he hermal
onductivity
for egions close
o
ritical, lthough
recently
here
has een
arge
umber of orresponding nvestigations.
Here
here
as
etected
ery
trong
ependence
f
he
hermal
conductivity
n
he
emperature nd pressure, owever here re still
no ufficiently
eliable
ata
o
e
ecommended.
Therefore,
n
he
book
here
re o abulated
alues
f
or
he
egion
.9
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
16/202
r ^
I
The
otality
f e comme n de d ubstances
ncompasses
a
wide
range
f
alues of hermal onductivity r om .005 o
.5
W/(m.deg).
The
ook
ives
he
ange
of
emperatures,
n
which
ach
of
he
cited ubstances ca n
be
mployed
s
a
ample
ubstance,
/e
lso
estimated he
possible olerances
for
he alues
of he hermal
conductivity for
hese ubstances.
O n
he
basis
f
n
nalysis f
arge body f xperimental
ata
on
hermal onductivity
of
mixtures
a nd
olutions
f
arious ypes
It Is
possible
o
onclude
hat
he effect
f
mixtures n
he
thermal onductivity f
ases
nd
iquids
s
omparatively mall.
The
content
of mixtures
In enths
of raction of
percent,
s
a
ule,
does
ot
oticeably
hange
he
hermal
onductivity.
Requirements for
he
purity
of ubstances,
therefore,
are ot
overly
strict.
FT
D-MT-2H-133-71
xll
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
17/202
CHAPTERI
QUESTIONS
OP HE MEASUREMENT ROCEDURE
OP
HERMAL
ONDUCTIVITY
Natural Convection
The xclusion f he
effect
f
onnective eat ransfer
s
one
of
he
most
essential questions
n
he practice
f
measurements
of
he
hermal onductivity f iquids
a nd ases.
Fo r he escription of natural
onvection n
he o r m of
connection n lmenslonless
criteria
e sually se elationship
Nu~f(Or,Pr)-f(Ra)
3)
or
,=4i-/(/fc).
T"'
1
" 4)
where
T."
Ra'Gf'Pr
Raylelgh
umber;
X
1
effective
hermal onductivity,
which
ncludes molecular
hermal onductivity X nd
onvectlve eat
transmission;
e
he
oefficient f onvection.
PTD-:::
,
-2i«-i33-7i
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
18/202
In
1934 Kraussol^, [11] generalized
the
experimental
data
available
at
that
time
about
natural
convection
in a
limited
space,
using relationship
(4). As
the determining dimenpion
d
he
selected
the thickness of
the liquid layer 6
;
then Ra - '̂f
6
'
For
horizontal
and vertical layers, regardless of their configuration
Kraussold-,
obtained
a
single curve
(Fig.
1) . In
this
case
the beginning
of
convection (e >
1.00)
occurs when R a > 1000. During
measurement of
X
all
the
authors were
usually guided by this Kraussold curve for
the
selection
of
dimension
6
of
the
measuring
cell
and
the
difference,
of
temperatures in
the
investigated
layer
of
liquid.
In
certain
cases
corrections
were inserted
into
measured
values
of X,
by using
this curve. [Translator's
note:
unable to find exact spelling of
foreign names in
text. hen English spelling
is common,
I
will
use
it,
otherwise
I
will
transliterate
the
names.]
• ̂ f
Ü - v*
*
» • < , - « •
Fig. 1 .
The
relationship of
the
coefficient
of convection
to
Or
and Pr criteria according
to
data
of: I
- Kraussold
[11]; II -
Shlngarev fl^] for Saratov
gas
(1);
for C0
2
C2).
In the last 10
years a
number
of new experimental investigations
of
natural
convection has been
conducted,
mainly
in
liquids,
which
are located in the space between coaxial cylinders.
he
results
of
these
investigations
were
presented by
t h e 3rd International
Conference on Heat Exchange (1966) in three
reports:
ees,
Sherrif,
Grigul'
and Gauf [12].
Qrigul'-
and Ga uf studied
local
and average
coefficients of
heat em i s si on
during
natural convection
in
a
horizontal annular clearance.
They
applied optical methods of
investigation
of
convection,
determining
the
distribution
of
temper-
atures and heat
flows
with the aid of an
interferometer.
Generally
FTD-MT-24-133-71
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
19/202
the
reatest
quantity
f xperimental ata
s obtained
or
horizontal
a n n u l a r learances
nd
considerably
ess
or
ertical. In
om e
works,
or
x a m p l e
[13]*
he Kraussold u r v e as ee n
efined,
some ifferences a v e
been
evealed n he
alue
f or
horizontal
a nd
ertical
learances.
v
However ,
all hese
nvestigations,
s
he
esults
f earlier
experiments,
generalized
y
Kraussold
11],
ave
een
btained
n
comparatively
wide
learances:
6
7-300 m . A t he
a m e
ime,
when
f
iquids nd ases
s
etermined
at igh
pressures,
6
0.2-0.5
m , and he
length
f
m e a s u r i n g
ylinders
I
100
a m v
Therefore,
he
nvestigation
f
natural
onvection
t
u ch
omparatively
small
alues
of
nd
l* ^ a s
f nterest.
• '
v
."
;
R. V.
Shlngarev IM ]
ur ing
nvestigation f
he
hwmal
conductivity
f
O -
y
he ethod
f
heated ilament d «0.1 m ;
6
r
4 m ;
1*
00 m ) conduc ted xperiments at arious
t nd
extrapolated
he
e a s u r e d
alues of
'
to t • •
or
he purpose f
obtaining rue alues
f
. The nstallation wa s
ocated
n
vertical position. Measurements ndicated hat u r v e
= f
Ra),
constructed
r om xperimental
ata,
ies noticeably
ower han
he
K r a u s s o l d urve,
s
s vident
r om
Fig. 1.
From
xperiments
It
lso
ollowed
hat
the beginning
f
onvection
e
.00)
takes
place
t
Ra
500.
Th e u t h o r
ffered wo
quations
or
etermination
of
he oefficient
f
onvection
:
when
500
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
20/202
A . A .
Berkenhelm
tudied natural onvection
n
narrow
nnular
clearances
t
arious
alues
f
from
.5
o
m
nd
100
m .
A s
n
nternal
ylinder
here
erved
latinum
ilament
(d
0.1
m),
external
glass ube, he
iameter f
which
aried.
Experiments
were onducted with water and thyl lcohol with
ertical
nd orizontal
position f
he
measuring
ube. Results f experiments Fig. 2)
showed
hat
atural
onvection
with
ertical
nd
horizontal
position
of
he
measuring ube
s escribed
y
arious urves.
They
both
lie
elow
he
Kraussold urve. With
ertical
osition
of
ylinders
the
uthor
proposed equations:
for
egion
2JOO
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
21/202
•
Y u. L .
Rastorguyev
nd
.
Z. eller
15]
n
n
nstallation,
based
n
he
eated
ilament method
a
0.1
m ; .6? mm;
I
100
m ),
rranged ertically,
etermined
he alues
f
nd
on he
asis
f
experiments with arious
liquids
(Pig. 3).
for his uantity
n
egion
400
a 000 roposed
quation
• -0,402 (Pa)W».
(9)
T he
xamination
f
all
he
ew works,
n which
natural
onvection
w as tudied
n arrow
nnular
learances
on nstallations
y
he
heated
ilament
method,
llows
making
he
ollowing
onclusions:
1 .
curve.
Curves e
-
f
(Ra) are
located
lower
than
the
Kraussold
2 .
he
beginning of convection
(e >
1.00)
is
observed
at
number
Ra
>
2000,
i .e .,
greater
than
Kraussold (e
>
1.00
when
R a
> 1000).
he
Initial
sec t i on of
curves
e
f
(Ra) is
considerably
flater
than
for
the
Kraussold curve.
3 .
ith horizontal
pos i t i on
of the
clearance
the value
of
e
is
higher than
with
vertical, but lower than according to Kraussold
curve.
£
m
w
tmmA tti mf
j
^
a 4-«S'»"
«
0
0 '
/C *
W*
W*
trPr
Pig.
3.
Relationship
f o r nd
Pr 15]: I
-
ccording o
Kraussold-
Mlkheyev
equation; I ccording
o
data
of Berkenheim;
II
ccording
to
data of Rastorguyev nd
Heller
or
carbon
etrachlorlde
1),
exane 2),o
toluene 3) nd benzene (H).
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
22/202
It
hould
e
ndicated
hat eometric imensions
(6
nd
) n
[13-15]
re
ery
lose
o
he
imensions,
sually
tilized
n
he
heated ilament method
uring
measurement f
hermal
onductivity.
In his
ase
he
learances
re
sually laced
ertically.
O n
he
basis
f
esults f 13-15] or vertical learances t
s ossible
to
raw n
veraged
urve
or
f Ra).
T he
urve onstructed
by
s
p
o
a
30,000
s iven
n
ig. 4.
T he
eginning
of
convection
s
elected
t
a
2000.
Experimental
alues
of
e,
obtained
n
13-15],
are eflected
rom his curve
within
% .
T he
curve
an e
ecommended
for evaluation
f
natural
onvection
during
he
measurement
f
hermal
onductivity
f
iquids
and
gases y he ethod f
ertical
eated ilament.
1 .20
1 , 1 0
1.00
/
1
W 45
4, 0
* .S
gR a
i
10' tWs Ŵ*
2 1 0 *
JHfto-GrPr
Fig.
4 .
Generalized
relation-
ship
of
th« coefficient
of
convection to
Rayleigh
criter-
ion
(experiments
with
vertical
heated
filament).
Natural
convection
in a
narrow
annular clearance
(6-1
mm)
with
cylinder
diameter
d
10 mm and I
10 0
mm was studied by
Yu.
L .
lastorguyev
and
A. A .
Nemzer [16].
he cylinders were
placed
vertically.
On
the
basis
of experiments,
conducted
up
to
values
R a
5000,
the authors proposed equation
«-0.402
( / ? a )
0
. »
(10)
for region
1700
1.00)
is
when R a
> 1700.
This
equation can
be
used
for
vertical
coaxial
cylinders
at
R a
numbers
up
to 5000.
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
23/202
Temperature um p
T he ffect f
emperature
um p s ubstantial uring measurement
of
he
hermal onduotlvlty f ases.
During
xperimental
etermination f he
hermal
onductivities
of
gases
e
sually
measure
he
wall
emperature f
n nstrument.
B ut
t
s
known
hat etween olid
nd
as,
hich
re
located
at
istance
f mean ree
ath, there
xists emperature
um p 6t
This
henomenon as
xperimentally
tudied
y any nvestigators:
Smolukhovskly, nudsen,
lmiryazev,
azarev nd thers.
T he
question s described
n
detail n iterature, for
example, n
he
books
f
ennard
17]»
evlen
[18]
nd Clark
nd McChesney 19].
As
Is established,
h '̂
t
emperatüre.JuW p t or moderately
rarefied
ae
s roportional
o
he emperature radient
dt/dn
along
he ormal o he
wall urface fit*
dt/dn),
nd he
proportionality
actor
.
s
nversely
proportional
o
he
as
pressure
(Y A/P), Usually, y
measuring
he.thermal
onductivity
of ases at
low
pressures (when
f e
tm), uantity 6t
s
aken
into
ccount
y
onducting ests
at
arious
ressures;
Mum
~ /,,,-)-—-.
T he
consideration
f
his
correction s specially
ssential
for ases
with
omparatively
ow
molecular
weight nd t igh
temperatures.
A s
pplied
p
oaxial
ylinders
he
method
f
ccount
of
he
orrection
s ubstantiated n
20],
and
or
heated
ilament
In 21]. T he measured alues f hermal onductivity ot llowing
for
he orrection
re lways ower
han
rue alues f .
•:
*
.-
•
•
Thie,neglect
f
his
ffect
t
igh
emperatures can
ead o
•
substantial
rrors,
specially
for gases
with
omparatively
ow
i..5,
t
'.V
-
'.
"
. '.
'
:
- .,
•«..»
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
24/202
molecular
weight,
s,
for xample,
ook
place
n
he ase
f
-nitrogen. Figure
,
aken
rom 30],
hows
he
esults f measure-
ments
f he
hermal
onductivity
f itrogen, btained y arious
authors.
A t
levated emperatures
he
iscrepancies ere
very
noticeable
hey
eached
2 % .
Ueglect
f
he
emperature
Jump
specially
ppeared n
he esults f
experiments
f
Schäfer
and
Reuter 31], nasmuch, s heir
ata
efer o he
egion
f
high emperatures p
o
400
o
K .
tu
43
.̂
»U
O
• ? s o
m
isx
e
1
1
- <
I
I S O
ftß
S C O
—
•
\.
Q
1
V
*
»
J
L
of
A 1
|-
i
ob
•
> •
•
0
o
- J
1
•
:rp
'
S
.._
_
. . . j
*
•
1
1 _
,
e
iCO
e:j
«is
mo
i*c
Pig. 5. Experimental
ata
of
arious
authors
n
he
hermal
onductivity f
nitrogen: 1 rank 22]; 2
Natell,
Jennings
[23];
3
hotki
21»] ; » .
Geier,
chäfer
25];
5- lays,
l
ann
[26];
Weiss 27];
Stops
[28],;
8 ibland, arton 29].
After he
ntroduction
f
orrection
or emperature um p he
corrected
experimental
ata
ay
well
n ne
urve, s s
vident
from Pig.
6,
taken rom £30]. T he eviations of experimental
atja.,
obtained
y
arious
methods,
ie
within
% .
.'_
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
25/202
• . v ; fc
Pig.
6.
The
elationship
of
thermal
onductivity of
nitrogen
o emperature ccord-
ing o arious
ata,
orrected
taking
nto ccount
he
emper-
ature ump. Designations re
the
a m e s n Fig. .
.
A n
nalogous
ituation
ook
place
with
xperimental ata
n
the
hermal
onductivity
f rgon
[32], lthough
n ess
clearly
expressed
form.
nasmuch s
he
molecular
weight
f
argon s
higher
han
itrogen.
The
Role
of
he Process
f
Heat
Transfer
by Radiation
There
Is very reason o
believe
hat
eat
ransfer
aused y
the ohoton" echanism n
u m b e r f practically
mportant
ases
plays
a
ery ignificant
ole
n
he
process
f
nergy
ransfer,
especially
at
elatively
igh
emperatures. In
particular, here
are heoretical nd
xperimental
rguments
o
he
effect
that
he
process
of
he
adiation
ransfer
a y
oticeably
distort
the
sual,
molecular heat onductivity
of
iquids, beginning with
emperatures
of
he
rder
f
0
o
S.
A t
he
a m e
time,
he
nformation
which
e
have ow
vailable o
s
is
ery mall, a nd he roblem equires
thorough
tudy.
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
26/202
f.-.-
Tanlng
his into ccount,
he
authors
thought
t ossible to
thoroughly
analyze
the
rocess
f
adiant
ransfer. To
ignificant
degree he material
resented here is riginal.
1
T he
xistence
f processes f
adiation
nd
bsorption
of
radiant
nergy
leads
o
he
ppearance
of
upplementary mechanism
for heat
transfer.
This
radiation
echanism oexists
with
he
r.oleoular
heat
conductivity
nd n eneral
complicates
considerably
the otal rocess
of heat
transfer.
T he
implest s
he
rocess
in
media, hich
ay
e xamined
s
almost ransparent In
he
egion
of
requencies
close
o
he
maximum
f
lanck function.
It
takes
place, for example,
n
ases
f elatively low
ensity,
here eat
transfer
y radiation
eads
o heat xchange
etween he
oundary
surfaces
and
he
resulting
heat
flow
s
a
imple
otal f molecular
and
adiant
heat. What
s
ore omplex
s the
ransfer
f heat in
partially
ransparent media.
T;ie
ssential
ole f he
rocess
of
adiation
f edium w as
first
nderstood nd
iscussed,
pparently,
y
.
G .
Guton,
ho
as
occupied with he tudy f he hermal
onductivity
f
molten lass
B^].
Then
his
roblem
w as xamined n
pproximation
for lat ayer,
-ithout
consideration f he iffusion
ature f
he adiation) by
L .
?.
Filippov
35]
n
onnection
with
ebate
etween
.
B .
Vargaftik
[36,
37], on
he
one
and, and
eys and
andell
[38]
on
he
ther,
;n
he problem f
hermal
conductivity
of water
apor, n
he
course
of which
he merican
uthors
advanced
he
roposition
hat
the
hen xisting ifference n he esults could e ttributed
o
the
ole
f
heat transfer
y
adiation [38, 39]. T he
mathematical
formulation
f he roblem n he
eneral form as
ut
ogether y
Y u.
A .
ourinov
40]. Later,
recognition
as
iven
o
he
orks
of
Kelett
fkl] and Genzel
[42]. In he first f hese n
pproximate
examination
as
made for he ase
f
flat layer n
he
assumption
of
ndependence f
he oefficient
of bsorption
rom
he
frequency
ôr
more
detail, see
he onograph
of
.
?.
Pilipcov
T he
study
of heat onductivity of iquids" [33].
NO T EPRODUC IBLE
10
i
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
27/202
("gray
edium")
and without
consideration f
he
iffusion ature
f
the
adiation.
In
he
econd
work
he
distribution
f
ntensity
with
respect o
ngles
as aken
nto ccount nd
umber
f
mportant
particular
ases
ere
xamined-.for. transfer n lat
ayer transfer
by
adiation
n he
bsence
f molecular hermal
onductivity,
he
general
ase
f ransfer
n
medium
with trong
bsorption,
nd
he
general ase f
ransfer
n
gray"
edium). In
.
P.
Pilippov's
work
[̂ 3]
he eneral
roblem
or
lat
layer as
xamined
nd
an
nalysis as given
or wo imiting
cases:
strong nd weak bsorp-
tion. A eneralization of hese
esults
as
ade n he
ork
f
E .
A .
Sidorov
M].
T he ase f
ransfer
n lat layer of
"gray"
edium
as
xamined
f
ate
n
he
orks
f
oltz
^S-̂ S]
nd
Hohler 49],
T he
esults
f he development
f
work ^3] re
presented
elow.
T he nitial elationship or n nalysis ay
e
he quation f
transfer f
adiant
nergy,
written
n
he
ssumption
of he
existence
f
ocal
hermodynamic
quilibrium,
COJ» -̂«« -«/. 11)
This equation expresses
the
fact
that
the change
in the
intensity
of radiation I in a direction which
comprises
angle
u with
the
axis
x is
caused by the
natural radiation
of an
element
of the
volume
of
tne
medium
(the
first
term o f the
right
side) and
by
the
attenuation
of
intensity as a result
of absorption
(the
second
member
of
the
right side).
Equation
(11)
obeys
Kirchhofs
law,
expressing
the coefficient
of
volumetric radiation
of
the
medium
through the
intensity of the equilibrium
radiation
in a
vacuum
e,
the
coefficient
of
absorption
a
and
the
index
of
refraction n
(the
process
of
dispersion in this case
is
not taken
into
account).
Integration
of equation
(11)
for
a
flat
layer
o f width L with
the
temperature gradient,
perpendicular
to
the walls (axis s),
s ; i v e s the formulas for
the
intensity of radiation in a positive
(I
and negative
(I~)
direction
of
the axis:
U
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
28/202
t
I
cot d ,
/+-/M0)«
c , , ,
4 -
J
-rl
CO»»
. )
1
'
M*J
To
find
the
values
of
the
intensity on
the
boundaries
I
( 0 )
a n d I~(L) we use the
relationships
for
the
mirror
reflection:
'
+
(0 -H
* , /
O ) .
'-(*)-•. +
* , / ♦ ( * .
where
R a nd
^
re
he
oefficients
of
eflection.
For
he
+
differences in
intensities
I
a nd
w e
btain he xpression
/._/-
« p i l l -ä/̂ J^J U n ' O
-Ä.)/^*
+
t --4L
x(l-/^.)+-^
^
J
«« •*
•
r f i +
jr
where
ß
s
the factor f
he
ecurrence
f
eflections;
12
•
•
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
29/202
The
otal hermal flow s ade p
of
he
flow
f nergy
of
radiation
nd
he flow f molecular hermal onductivity:
Q
« ;j(/+_/-)co$
Mw/v-X^-,
12)
(here
u s he
lementary
solid
angle;
v
s
the
frequency). In
he
stationary tate
I.e.,
JU^jQcosOrf-rf»».
—ii^-.
13)
tf^
r fx
x
äx
J/
Expression (13)
s
a
omplex Integral-differential quation.
T(x)
HT )
n(T , v ) .
Th r ough he gency f
T(x)
o n
hese a m e
values
lso epends he
heat flow. It
s
significant
hat n eneral
both
erms n
expression
12) for
heat
flow
re nterdependent;
the
ntegral
radiation
er m
hrough
he agency
f
T(x)
depends
on , he econd
term or
he a m e reasons depends po n
he optical haracteristics.
The
radiation
nd molecular
contributions)
to
he
hermal
low
prove o e
onadditive,
dlspite he ssumption
bout
he additivity
of
ransfer
mechanisms.
determining
he function T(x)
-
he
distribution
of
emperature in
the layer.
It s clear
hat n he eneral
ase
he istribution
of
emperature t
fixed
emperatures of he
urfaces epends
simultaneously n
he
functions
13
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
30/202
To
nalytically nvestigate he
eneral
ase,
etermined y
formulas
(11)-(13), without
additional
ssumptions
s too omplex.
Therefore,
e
will
henceforth
imit
urselves
o he
following
special
assumptions:
1.
e will
xamine
ases
f
mall
ifferences
n emperature
o n boundaries, hich will
llow
s o imit
urselves o he
irst
two
terms
of
he
xpansion f he
unction
nto series.
2. e will s s u m e that t is
possible o isregard he ependence
of
he
coefficients
f bsorption
nd efraction
n he emperature.
3.
or
he
a ke
f
implicity
e
will
ssume
hat
i R ?
*
The
numerated
ssumptions
simplify
he
nvestigation,
but
hey
do
ot
deprive t
f sufficient
enerality nd o ot
impose ny
significant limit
n
he
applicability
f ts
esults
to ctual
systems.
Equation 13) n his case
can
e
ransformed
o
he
fo rm
L
£=jVd.
x),
Wdl
(14)
where
y
**'
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
31/202
Prom formula
(
i
»)-(8)
It is
clear
that
K
0
when
\~
*
0
and
the
distribution
of
temperatures
In
the
layer
approaches
a
linear
one.
n
correspondence
with
this
the
s o l ut i o n
for
the
temperature
can be found
In the form:
AT
7--ir
i
4r . j c
+
-|-9(xl
►
... .
20)
disregarding
he higher erms
f he
xpansion
o eries
with
respect o a nd
xamining hereby
only
the conditions, nder
which
ivergences
f
he
e m p e r a t u r e
ield
r om
inear
ne
re
sufficiently
mall
n
o m p a r i s o n
with T.
Physically, his
eans
the
xamination
f
he
processes
under
which
he
ecisive
factor
Is
he
molecular heat ransfer, while adiation plays he
ole
of
distortion
actor.
In he
pproximation f 20)
the
olution
f quation
(15)
ha s
the
or m
r-r.-iTir+ *(*)-( -^.)*(
0
) i .
2D
where
-
«-'-11
^
/?«-»*
-'>-) ]ds. 22)
A n
analysis
f
o r m u l a s (21),
(22) allows
u s
o
establish
that
he
emperature istribution
urve a s
a ending point
in
he
middle
f
he
layer
L/2)
nd
s
onvex n
he
wall
with
he esser
t e m p e r a t u r e
nd
s concave
n
he pposite
wall. It s also
possible
to
emonst ra te
a
umber
f
particular
peculiarities
f
he
emperature
distribution
n
hese
r
ther
oncrete
nstances
[33].
The
istribution of emperature, escribed
y
o r m u l a s
(21),
(22), llows
u s
o
lso btain
general
ormula
or he
otal eat
flow n
he
xamined
pproximat ion
15
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
32/202
L L
^
(1+«/?-*'•)»»
(23)
For ow-absorbing media
he
ormula ssumes he
orm
Q-_
xir
r̂ .
j T j
l+R *
d $
+
+
2̂«
•••
(24)
T he first
erm
of his ormula expresses
he
eat lo w ue
o
molecular
heat
onductivity, he
econd
describes
he
ffect
f
radiation
f
he walls, nd
he
hird - he
ought or hange
n
the eat
lo w s
result
f
he
processes f
adiation
nd
absorption
f adiant nergy y
he medium.
T he
aximum
value
f
this erm s qual
o
2i7=£
r ^ - r f » .
JdT
For
he
alue
f
he
elative
hange
n
heat flow
s
he
pper
limit
(for
n
bsolutely
lack
ody)
e
btain
he
xpression
0 3
k
dTi
(25)
A Q
In
practical
stimate
he
alue
^
or gases
hich
re
ow-
absorbing
media
he
ntegral
f
ormula
25)
can
e onveniently
replaced y xpression
J
..*-*A
(26)
where s he as ressure; s he imit
f
he
elati'onahip
f
the
degree
f
blackness f he lat ayer f gas o
he product.
. 'iJL,
with he
atter
ending
oward ero;
nd
s
he onstant f
the
tefan-Boltzmann
aw
or
hemispherical
adiation.
1 6
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
33/202
In
he
evaluation
of
26)
he
emperature
ependence
of can
h
be
isregarded
n
omparison
with
A s
esult
e
btain
£ ••i£t3t
t
27 )
Th is ormula
an
e
sed
or
valuating
he nfluence f
boundaries
f he nvestigated
effect. Thus, for carbon ioxide
gas
at
oom
emperature
nd pressure
of
ar
2.«lO"
l
I
,
f
• « ~
,
,
I.e.,
he
change n he
eat
low s esult of
adiation
f
he edium
ca n
n his case
ecome
oticeable t istance f
everal
centimeters. A t
a pressure f 000 ar
his
ffect
s ald
o
e
(at
istances
far emoved
rom
ritical oint)
lready
t
istance
of
everal
millimeters.
W e
will
lso
btain
imilar
order f
alues
for
water
apors.
T he
ole
of adiation
ncreases with
extraordinary
Intensity with he ncrease n
emperature.
In he
other imiting
case, for trongly-absorbing
media
formula
23)
assumes he orm
*-¥-TIH*T- « )
T he ffective
oefficient
f heat
onductivity
s
omposed
of w o erms which re ndependent one
rom
he
ther
he coefficient
of
molecular
eat conductivity nd he oefficient
f adiant
(radlatlonal) heat
onductivity.
n
which he
atter lso haracterizes
only
he
edium
s uch
nd oes
ot
epend n
he onditions
n
the
walls nd he onfiguration
of
he
ystem.
T he
oefficient
f
radiation
heat
onductivity s xpressed
y he formula
3
J
«if
-JT
(the
erivation
of
his
ormula s
also iven n ork
50], hich
w as specially eserved
or
he
problem
f
onditions f pplicability
of he
oncept f he
coefficient of
adiation heat
onductivity
in
onnection
with
ttempts t he
distribution f
ormulas
of
uch
type,
xisting
n
he
literature,
for cases
f
media
with
oor
absorption).
17
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
34/202
•
■
I
It
hould be oted hat
t
s
precisely the otal effective
heat
onductivity,
xpressed y ormula 28),
which u s t
be
igured
In
he Prandtl
nd
Nusselt criteria
or
hese ases, hen he
thickness
f
he
thermal
limiting
ayer
s
considerably
reater
*
than
he
pposite
alue of he effective
oefficient
f
bsorption
V)f
he
ed ium.
Let
s
urn
o
ormula 23),
which
escribes he eat
low
n
the
eneral
ase.
Effective
adiation
eat
conductivity
ay. be
represented s
'-Tj«'fr
( « .
D*.
(30)
where,
•'••''-4-±h^*}
In
he
eneral
ase
he
effective adiation
eat
onductivity
and ts ependence n
parameters
nd
,
being
unctional
of
o(v),
will
e
different
or arious
media.
Only
for
he
ypothetical
"ej ray" edium, for
which
const, an
e write
i«
VmS,*fiP*(*,l).
(32)
F o r m u l a
32) is he
basic
esult
of
he
o r k
f Poltz
46].
The
function
was
btained y
im
n
o m e w h a t
ifferent
but
similar
o r m :
*-i[.-£
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
35/202
T he
et
f curves—(»I,/?)
Is epicted
n
Pig.
.
rom
he orm
of his ependence
t
s ossible
o
ra w he
ollowing
ignificant
conclusions:
1. he
adiation
heat conductivity
f
he walls
with
evel
of blackness
f
1
)
8/18/2019 Heat Conductivity of Gases and Liquids Vargaftik Filippov, Tarzimanov, Yurchak
36/202
SV
may
e
sed
for evaluation f
he pper imit of he possible nfluence
of
adiation
ransfer
n lat
ayer.
1
It s
orth
emphasizing
he
strong
nature f he
emperature
ependence f
his
riterion
(vr
J
)
nder
onditions
typical
or
hanges
n
eat
onductivity
f
boundary fluids ( X ̂ .1-0.3
W/(m-deg);
^
m).
A t oom
temperatures
he
ercentage
f heat
xchange y
adiation
hould
not
xceed
ew
ercent. However, at
igher
emperatures. In
narticular
t
emperatures
lose o he ritical points, he ole
of
adiation
an
e
onsiderably
ore
ubstantial, specially
because he onditions of
he
ransparency n his
rea
passing
from
he as to
he iquid
tate,
can e
specially nfavorable
(aL
̂1).
It
s
nown
hat n
mportant
ole can
e
played
y
radiation
or
high
emperatures melts (glasses, lags). It
can
be
Just
s
reat
n
solid
onm