Heat Pump Implementation Scenarios

until 2030

Key Results & Methodology

Leonardo Energy Webinar, 17 April 2014

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhäuser

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

Key Research Question

How can heat pumps contribute to the

long-term EU energy and climate targets?

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 2

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

Agenda

Part I - Overview

> Objective & Key Messages

Part II - Details

> Methodology

> Scenario Definitions

> Results > Individual Building Level

> Scenarios

> Conclusion

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 3

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014 Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 4

Part I

Overview

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

Objective

> Scope

> Study for

> Scenarios for 8 countries (AT, BE, FR, DE, IT, ES, SE, UK)

> Impact of increasing heat pump

implementations

> Scope of heating, hot water,

cooling, auxiliary energy

> 3 scenarios

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 5

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

Objective

> Scenario Definition

> 3 scenarios

> All with (very) high energy efficiency standard related to the

building shell

> Differentiation of heating system mix

> Scenario “Current Policy Implementation - CPI”

with moderate increasing HP share

> Scenario “HP+”

with high HP shares (30%4

for retrofits and 50%4

for new

builds)

> Scenario “HP++”

with very high HP shares (50%4

for retrofits and 100%4

for new

builds)

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 6

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

Key Message I

> GHG Emissions

Building sector

target corridor*

Total CO2 emissions

reduction by 46% in

the “HP++” scenario

2012-2030

* Building sector specific targets 2005, 2020 and 2050 based on the “European Roadmap for moving to a competitive low carbon economy in 2050”

Impact of heat pump shares within the total building sector:

CO2-emissions for the focus countries

Scenarios:

Heat pumps can play an essential

role in the future supply mix.

without any

heat pumps

CO2-eq emissions

from heat pump

F-gas leakages:

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 7

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014 Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 8

Key Message II

> Final Energy

The overall final energy for space heating, hot water,

cooling and auxiliary purposes with increasing shares of

heat pumps can be reduced by 2030 (compared to 2012):

> by 19% in “CPI”,

> by 25% in “HP+” and

> by 31% in “HP++”.

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014 Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 9

Key Message III

> Costs

The total annual costs (annuities from investments and

energy costs) increase by 2030 related to “CPI”.

> by 0.7% in the

scenario “HP+” and

> by 2.7% in the

scenario “HP++”.

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

RES-shares from heat pumps by 2020 can be higher than

required by the RES-Directive

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 10

Key Message IV

> RES shares

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014 Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 11

Part II

Details

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

Methodology

> The Ecofys BEAM² Model

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 12

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

Methodology

> The Ecofys BEAM² Model

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 13

1

2

3

4

5

6

8

7

Calculation Steps BEAM² (Source: Dissertation Bettgenhaeuser)

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

Methodology

> The Ecofys BEAM² Model

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 14

Schematic illustration of the scope for the Built-Environment-Analysis-Model BEAM² (Source: Dissertation Bettgenhaeuser, CEN/TR 15615)

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

Scenario Definition

> Number of buildings in key markets

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 15

Number of buildings

Conditioned floor area per country and building type

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

Scenario Definition

> Reference buildings

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 16

Geometries

Source: Klauß, S.,Maas, A. (2010). Entw icklung einer Datenbank mit Modellgebäuden für energiebezogene Untersuchungen, insbesondere der Wirtschaftlichkeit Verfügbar: <http://w w w .irbnet.de/daten/baufo/20118035234/Endbericht.pdf> (Letzter Zugriff: 2012-02-23). Zentrum für Umw eltbew usstes Bauen e.V., Kassel, Germany. Klauß, S.,Maas, A. (2010). Entw icklung einer Datenbank mit Modellgebäuden für energiebezogene Untersuchungen, insbesondere der Wirtschaftlichkeit Verfügbar: <http://w w w .irbnet.de/daten/baufo/20118035234/Endbericht.pdf> (Letzter Zugriff: 2012-02-23). Zentrum für Umw eltbew usstes Bauen e.V., Kassel, Germany. Klauß, S.,Maas, A. (2010). Entw icklung einer Datenbank mit Modellgebäuden für energiebezogene Untersuchungen, insbesondere der Wirtschaftlichkeit Verfügbar: <http://w w w .irbnet.de/daten/baufo/20118035234/Endbericht.pdf> (Letzter Zugriff: 2012-02-23). Zentrum für Umw eltbew usstes Bauen e.V., Kassel, Germany. Klauß, S.,Maas, A. (2010). Entw icklung einer Datenbank mit Modellgebäuden für energiebezogene Untersuchungen, insbesondere der Wirtschaftlichkeit Verfügbar: <http://w w w .irbnet.de/daten/baufo/20118035234/Endbericht.pdf> (Letzter Zugriff: 2012-02-23). Zentrum für Umw eltbew usstes Bauen e.V., Kassel, Germany. Klauß, S.,Maas, A. (2010). Entw icklung einer Datenbank mit Modellgebäuden für energiebezogene Untersuchungen, insbesondere der Wirtschaftlichkeit Verfügbar: <http://w w w .irbnet.de/daten/baufo/20118035234/Endbericht.pdf> (Letzter Zugriff: 2012-02-23). Zentrum für Umw eltbew usstes Bauen e.V., Kassel, Germany. Klauß, S.,Maas, A. (2010). Entw icklung einer Datenbank mit Modellgebäuden für energiebezogene Untersuchungen, insbesondere der Wirtschaftlichkeit Verfügbar: <http://w w w .irbnet.de/daten/baufo/20118035234/Endbericht.pdf> (Letzter Zugriff: 2012-02-23). Zentrum für Umw eltbew usstes Bauen e.V., Kassel, Germany. Klauß, S.,Maas, A. (2010). Entw icklung einer Datenbank mit Modellgebäuden für energiebezogene Untersuchungen, insbesondere der Wirtschaftlichkeit Verfügbar: <http://w w w .irbnet.de/daten/baufo/20118035234/Endbericht.pdf> (Letzter Zugriff: 2012-02-23). Zentrum für Umw eltbew usstes Bauen e.V., Kassel, Germany. OpenEnergyInfo: http://en.openei.org/datasets/node/443

Comment: For further information, please see sheet "reference building source"For further information, please see sheet "reference building source"For further information, please see sheet "reference building source"For further information, please see sheet "reference building source"For further information, please see sheet "reference building source"For further information, please see sheet "reference building source"For further information, please see sheet "reference building source"For further information, please see sheet "reference building source"

Residential Non-residential

Sweden, France, Italy

Germany, Spain,

Belgium, Austria, UK All regions All regions All regions All regions All regions All regions

Single-family house

(detached)

Single-family house

(Row-end house)Multi-family house Office Education Trade / retail Touristic Health

Floor area [m²] 110,7 120,0 335,0 1972,0 11725,0 620,0 1050,0 22.422,2

Ambient w all [m²] 152,0 130,0 270,0 1595,6 7597,0 510,6 1351,8 5184,3

North [m²] 40,0 0,0 15,0 576,0 1846,0 155,3 161,9 1501,8

East [m²] 36,0 30,0 120,0 234,1 1950,0 100,0 513,0 1086,7

South [m²] 40,0 70,0 15,0 597,6 1847,0 155,3 164,4 1444,4

West [m²] 36,0 30,0 120,0 187,9 1954,0 100,0 512,5 1151,4

Window s 26,6 24,4 96,1 611,0 2825,8 46,8 207,2 845,4

North [m²] 5,7 0,0 6,3 207,9 721,9 0,0 0,0 186,2

East [m²] 5,8 3,9 26,0 181,5 787,0 46,2 105,6 144,9

South [m²] 5,3 8,6 6,3 208,2 891,9 0,0 10,0 220,7

West [m²] 9,7 9,2 57,5 13,4 425,0 0,6 91,6 293,7

Roof w indow East [m²] 0,0 0,7 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0

Roof w indow West [m²] 0,0 2,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0

Ground plate [m²] cellar existent Cellar existent 188,5 591,0 4267,0 620,0 564,1 Cellar existent

Cellar ceiling [m²] 99,2 85,5 no cellar no cellar no cellar no cellar no cellar 3.739,1

Roof [m²] 77,0 52,3 188,5 591,0 4267,0 620,0 564,0 3.739,1

East [m²] 38,5 26,8 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0

West [m²] 38,5 25,5 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0

Story height [m²] 2.75 (average) 2.75 (average) 2.75 (average) 3,7 4,5 4,7 2.8 / 3.5 4,3

Building volume [m³] 465 (w ithout cellar) 517 (w ithout cellar) 1480,0 7473,7 53941,9 3100,0 6879,0 88.864,2

Ratio m² f loor to cellar or ground 1,1 1,4 1,8 3,3 1,0 1,9 6,0

Source: Klauß, Maas (2010)

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

Scenario Definition

> Retrofits, new buildings and demolitions

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 17

Renovation, new construction and demolition rates

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

Scenario Definition

> Shares of heat pumps

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 18

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

Scenario Definition

> Definition of heat pump increase rates

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 19

Leverage factors for heat pump implementation in the “CPI” scenario

Illustration of “Implementations gained from competing technologies” in the HP+ and HP++ scenarios

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

Scenario Definition

> Heat pump market saturations

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 20

Market saturation curve (S-curve)

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

Scenario Definition

> Heat pump implementations

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 21

Heat pump implementations per scenario

Relation of heat pump implementations per scenario in 2020 related to 2012

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

Results

> SPFs and CO2-emissions for individual buildings

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 22

SPF values for heat pumps in single-family houses per country

Austria: CO2-emissions per year for heating (floor heating system)

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

Results

> GHG Emissions

Building sector

target corridor*

Total CO2 emissions

reduction by 46% in

the “HP++” scenario

2012-2030

* Building sector specific targets 2005, 2020 and 2050 based on the “European Roadmap for moving to a competitive low carbon economy in 2050”

Impact of heat pump shares within the total building sector:

CO2-emissions for the focus countries

Scenarios:

Heat pumps can play an essential

role in the future supply mix.

without any

heat pumps

CO2-eq emissions

from heat pump

F-gas leakages:

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 23

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

Results

> Overview

* Building sector specific targets 2005, 2020 and 2050 based on the “European Roadmap for moving to a competitive low carbon economy in 2050”

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 24

Overview on main results per scenario

© ECOFYS | | 17.04.2014

Conclusion

High implementation of heat pumps can:

contribute significantly to the mitigation of CO2-

emissions, energy savings and to an increasing

share of renewable energies

be realised at moderate additional overall costs

be an important puzzle piece for reaching long term

targets (by 2050)

play an essential role in the future supply mix.

Additional policy actions for heat pumps are

required in the HP+ and HP++ scenario.

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 25

© ECOFYS | |

Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhäuser

T: +49 221 270 70 157

E: k.bettgenhaeuser@ecofys.com

Ecofys Germany

Am Wassermann 36

50829 Cologne

Germany

www.ecofys.com

26 17.04.2014 Dr.-Ing. Kjell Bettgenhaeuser - Leonardo Energy Webinar 26

Thank you!