Heavy-Ion Physics with Heavy-Ion Physics with Compact Muon SolenoidCompact Muon Solenoidat Large Hadron Colliderat Large Hadron Collider
Bolek WyslouchMassachusetts Institute of
Technology
Los Alamos25 October 2007
CMS
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 2
Quark Gluon PlasmaQuark Gluon PlasmaData from SPS & RHIC show new and unexpected properties of hot nuclear matter
Jet quenching, strong elliptical flow, d+Au- control data indicate that we have produced strongly interacting color liquid
LHC will significantly increase energy density New properties of the plasma
Continuation of strong coupling regime? Weakly interacting Plasma?
New tools to study to hot and dense state Hard probes Access to very low-x
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 3
Summary of physics opportunitiesSummary of physics opportunities
LHC will accelerate and collide heavy ions at energies far exceeding the range of existing accelerators The increase of beam energy will result in:
Extended kinematic reach for pp, pA, AA New properties of initial state, saturation at mid-rapidity A hotter and longer lived partonic phase Increased cross sections and availability of new hard probes
New energy regime will open a new window on hot and dense matter physics: another large energy jump!
AGS SPS RHIC LHC
sNN[GeV] 5 20 200 5500
E increase x4 x10 x28
y range 1.6 3.0 5.3 8.6
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 4
Large Hadron ColliderLarge Hadron Collider
LHC is about to start operations:
2008: proton-proton collisions
at ~14 TeV 2008:
p+p at 14 TeV Pb+Pb at 5.5 TeV per
nucleon pair
Heavy Ions Expect ~1 month of
heavy ion collisions each year
Beam
Energ
y
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 5
Rapidity Density600 1200
PHOBOS Central Au+Au (200 GeV)
Compilation by K. EskolaColor Glass
Kharzeev & Levin, Phys. Lett. B523 (2001) 79
Data: PHOBOS,Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 102303 (2001)
From Eskola, QM 2000
First RHIC Surprise: Multiplicities Are “Low”First RHIC Surprise: Multiplicities Are “Low”
Low, that is, compared to pre-data predictions of “cascading partons”
Consistent with predictions based on gluon saturation :
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 6
LHC?
Extrapolated to LHC:dN/d~1000-2000
LHC multiplicity is likely to be lowLHC multiplicity is likely to be low
?
Note: this is an important experimental issue!
Is it saturation that makes it so low?Will it increase at higher energies?
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 7
RHIC’s Two RHIC’s Two MajorMajor Discoveries Discoveries
Discovery of strong “elliptic” flow:
Elliptic flow in Au + Au collisions at √sNN= 130 GeV, STAR Collaboration, (K.H. Ackermann et al.). Phys.Rev.Lett.86:402-407,2001
307 citations
Discovery of “jet quenching”
Suppression of hadrons with large transverse momentum in central Au+Au collisions at √sNN = 130 GeV, PHENIX Collaboration (K. Adcox et al.), Phys.Rev.Lett.88:022301,2002
357 citationsF
low
str
en
gth
Su
pp
res
ion
Fac
tor
Strongly interacting liquid with very lowviscosity
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 8
Elliptic Flow at RHICElliptic Flow at RHIC
Flow (asymmetry in pT) is near to hydrodynamic limit,LHC: can it grow even more ?
STAR
HYDRODYNAMICS
Flow
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 9
““Jet Quenching” at high pJet Quenching” at high pTT: will it continue at LHC ?: will it continue at LHC ?
p+p
Au+Au
Energy loss of partons in hot and dense matterE.g. charged particle RAA for multi-100 GeV/c pT
Parton Energy loss
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 10
Quarkonia in Heavy IonsQuarkonia in Heavy Ions
•J/ suppression in heavy ion collisions has been heralded as a discovery of Quark Gluon Plasma at CERN SPS circa 2000: there are fewer J/’s produced as energy density is increasing•There is a lot of detailed experimental data from SPS. RHIC is now releasing new information, it is consistent with SPS•Theoretical interpretation is difficult: we possibly need to look towards LHC: family can provide important hints, there are three states with differing binding energy
SPS
Suppression ?
Regeneration ?
RHICLHC
Energy Density
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 11
Post-RHIC Dream heavy-ion detectorPost-RHIC Dream heavy-ion detector
Large acceptance for charged and neutral hadrons, muons, photons, electrons covering wide pT range hermeticity
Good resolution for high pT probes (jets, J/, family) resolution
Good trigger to allow selection of rare events speed Good particle identification 0, b-, c-quarks, muons,
electrons, photons, , Ks, , K , p particle ID
Most likely it does NOT have to handle extreme multiplicities
Relatively low luminosity of LHC as a heavy-ion accelerator
CMS
““High density QCD with heavy-ions”High density QCD with heavy-ions”
D.d'E (ed.) CERN-LHCC-2007-009; J.Phys.G. to appear.
170 pages10 chapters~90 figures, ~20 tables
~20 CMS-AN-Notes
Athens, Auckland, Budapest, CERN,
Chongbuk, Colorado, Cukurova, Ioannina,
Iowa, Kansas, Korea, Lisbon, Los Alamos,
Lyon, Maryland, Minnesota, MIT, Moscow,
Mumbai, Seoul, Vanderbilt, UC Davis, UI
Chicago, Vilnius, Zagreb
~25 CMS-HI institutions~100 collaborators
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 13
Calorimeters: high resolution and segmentation
Hermetic coverage up to ||<5 (||<6.6 with the proposed CASTOR)Zero Degree Calorimeter
Muon tracking: from Z0, J/, Wide rapidity coverage: ||<2.4
σm 50 MeV at the mass in the barrel Silicon Tracker
Good efficiency and purity for pT~>0.3 GeV
Pixel occupancy: <2% at dNch/d 3500
p/p 1-2% for 1<pT <100 GeV
Good low pT reach using pixels
Functional at the highest expected multiplicities: studied in detail at dNch/d 3000-5000 and cross-checked at 7000-8000
• DAQ and Trigger– High rate capability for A+A, p+A, p+p– High Level Trigger: real time HI event
reconstruction
CASTORCASTOR
(5.2 < |η| < 6.6)
ZDCZDC
(z = 140 m, |η| > 8.2 neutrals)
CMS, as a heavy ion experimentCMS, as a heavy ion experiment
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 14
CMS coverageCMS coverage
HCAL (Barrel+Endcap+Forward)
| | < 3.0ECAL + HCAL
3 .0< | | < 5.2Forward HCAL
8.2 < ||ZDC (neutrals)
5.2 < | | < 6.6CASTOR
| | < 2.4Tracker, muons
CoverageSub detector
Q2
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 15
Silicon Tracker
CMS under constructionCMS under construction
Hadron Calorimeter
Electromagnetic Calorimeter
Si tracker &Pixels
Muon Absorber
DAQ
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 16
Centrality and forward detectorsCentrality and forward detectors
Energy in the forward hadronic calorimeter
Zero Degree Calorimeter
Tungsten-quartz fibre structure electromagnetic section: 19X
0
hadronic section 5.6λ0
Rad. hard to ~20 Grad (AA, pp low lum.) Energy resolution (n,): E~E·10%
Position resolution: ~2 mm (EM sect.)~140 meters from CMS IP
Centrality (impact parameter) determination is needed for most physics analyses
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 17
Zero Degree CalorimeterZero Degree Calorimeter
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 18
CASTOR: Tungsten-Quartz
5.2 < η < 6.6
T2 Tracker TOTEM
5.2 < η < 6.6
CASTORCASTOR
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 19
Charged particle multiplicityCharged particle multiplicity
Will be one of the first results, important for initial energy density, saturation, detector performance etc.
ch
Muon detection, tracking, jet finding performance checked up or larger than dNch/d=5000
high granularity pixel detectors pulse height measurement in each pixel
reduces background Very low pT reach, pT>26 MeV (counting
hits)
W. Busza, CMS Workshop, June 2004
Simple extrapolation from RHIC data
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 20
Elliptic Flow measurements in CMSElliptic Flow measurements in CMS
• Use calorimeters and tracker
•Event plane reconstruction•v2 measurements
•Very large acceptance v2() tracker
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 21
Jets at RHICJets at RHIC
nucleon nucleonparton
jet
Find this……….in this
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 22
Production of QCD jetsProduction of QCD jets
c
d
ab
c
d
ab
Proton-proton Ion-ion“Clean” Jet Quenched, absorbed, modified jet
2008-> 2009->
““Hard QCD”Hard QCD”““Soft QCD”Soft QCD”
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 23
nhit > 12pchi2 > 0.01dca <3
• Efficiencyo Fake Rate
High-pHigh-pTT (leading) charged hadrons (leading) charged hadrons
Excellent tracking performances (PbPb, dNch
/d = 3500):
Momentum resolution
Impact parameter resolution
Expected dN/dpT
reach pT~300 GeV/c
(high ET HLT)
C.Roland, CMS-AN06-001
Displaced vertexes from heavy-Q decays measurable
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 24
Pixel Tracking, low pPixel Tracking, low pT T reach of CMSreach of CMS
Pixel tracking All tracker fitting
800 MeV
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 25
Pixel trackingPixel tracking
Track finding efficiency vs pT and for p+p and central Pb+Pb
Fakes are controlled using pixel hit shapeF. Sikler
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 26
High-pHigh-pTT (leading) charged hadrons (leading) charged hadrons
Nuclear modification factor (= AA-yield / pp-yield) at the LHC:
×5 suppr.
Strong discrimination power for parton energy loss models:
- Initial parton medium density: dNg/dy~O(2-4·103)
- Medium transport coefficient: <q>~O(10-100) GeV2/fm
extended reach ~300 GeV/cw/ high-E
T (jet)trigger
PbPb (PYQUEN) 0.5 nb-1
C.Roland et al., CMS-AN06-110
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 27
Pb-Pb full jet reconstructionPb-Pb full jet reconstruction
Iterative-cone + backgd subtraction. [New developments (fast-KT)
under study] 1. Subtract average soft background 2. Find jets: iterative cone algorithm 3. Recalculate pileup outside cone 4. Recalculate jet energy
jet energy: reco vs. MC efficiency, purity energy resolution
I. Vardanyan et al. CMS-Note-2006-50
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 28
Pb-Pb full jet reconstructionPb-Pb full jet reconstruction
Jet spectra up to ET~ 0.5 TeV (PbPb, 0.5 nb-1, HLT-
triggered). Detailed studies of medium-modified (quenched) jet FF possible.
min.bias
HLT
C.Roland et al., CMS-AN06-110
I. Lokhtin et al., PLB567 (03)39
Gluon radiation:large-angle (out-of-cone) vs. small-angle emission
Njets
~6·106
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 29
- , - , *- , Z- jet tagging (CMS)*- , Z- jet tagging (CMS)
Possibility to calibrate jet-energy loss (and Fragmentation Functions) with back-to-back gauge boson (large cross-sections, good detection capabilities):
Dominant (heavy-Q) dimuon backgd. “removable” via secondary-vtx. cut
Dimuon trigger
Associated Hadrons
q/g Z0 / *
Away side
C.Mironov et al.
NZ-jet
~103
pT
>25 GeV/c
r=50 m
=20 m3 vtx. cut
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 30
ETo - ET
Jet (GeV)
Eve
nts/
5 G
eV
ETjet, > 120GeV in Barrel, 1 month at 1027 cm-2s-1 Pb+Pb
, Z0
Jet
Balancing Balancing or Z or Z00//** vs Jets vs Jets Jet quenching with calibrated
energy On average Z/ ET and jet ET
should balance (unquenched jets) Z -> and can be reconstructed
with very good ET resolution Dominated by quark jets
q + g -> q + Z0/
-Jet: Need to control the background
from leading 0 in QCD dijets Reject 0 by cluster isolation cuts
in the calorimeters Quenching will help
Lower Thresholds Z0 - Jet
Cleaner but lower rates
dN/dy ~7000, unquenched Jetsnew studies to appear shortly
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 31
Quarkonia: probe of high-density QCD mediaQuarkonia: probe of high-density QCD media
Dissociation (color screening) = hot QCD matter thermometer
Probe of low-x gluon structure/evolution:
Lattice QQ free energy vs T:Spectral function vs T:
Suppression pattern vs
[H.Satz, hep-ph/0512217]
production via gg fusion: x~10-3 (10-5)Q2~10 GeV2
gluon saturation,non-linear QCD
_
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 32
Heavy Ion MC Event in CMSHeavy Ion MC Event in CMS
Pb+Pb event display: Produced in CMS software framework (simulation, data structures, visualization)
Pb+Pb event (dN/dy = 3500) with -> -
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 33
J/J/ψψ suppression suppression
J/ acceptance Best mass resolution @ LHC
pT reach (0.5 nb-1)
SPS
suppression ?
regeneration ?
RHICLHC
Energy Density
= 35 MeV/c2
J/ ' S/BO.Kodolova, M. Bedjidian, CMS-AN06-116
NJ/~1.8·105
|y|<1
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 34
suppressionsuppression
acceptance
’/ stat. reach (HLT)
= 54 MeV/c2’
’’
family S/B Best mass resolution @ LHC
pT reach (0.5 nb-1) spectroscopy (seq. suppr.)
O.Kodolova, M. Bedjidian, CMS-AN06-116
Strong models constraint
N~2.5·104 Gunion&R.Vogt
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 35Bolek Wyslouch
Ultra-Peripheral collisions Ultra-Peripheral collisions Pb Pb Quarkonia
photoproduction
Probes nuclear PDF in unexplored (x,M2) range
Uses ZDC to trigger on forward emitted neutrons
Measurement --> +-, e+e- in the central detector
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 36
CMS Trigger and DAQ in p+pCMS Trigger and DAQ in p+p
Level-1 p+p
Collision rate 1GHz
Event rate 32MHz
Output bandwidth 100 GByte/sec
Rejection 99.7%
Level 1 trigger- Uses custom hardware- Muon tracks + calorimeter information- Decision after ~ 3μsec
High Level Trigger p+p
Input event rate 100kHz
Output bandwidth 225 MByte/sec
Output rate 150Hz
Rejection 99.85%
High level Trigger- ~1500 Linux servers (~10k CPU cores) - Full event information available- Runs “offline” algorithms
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 37
High Level Trigger Pb+Pb p+p
Input event rate 3kHz (8kHz peak) 100kHz
Output bandwidth 225 MByte/sec 225 MByte/sec
Output rate 10-100Hz 150Hz
Rejection 97-99.7% 99.85%
Level-1 Pb+Pb p+p
Collision rate 3kHz (8kHz peak) 1GHz
Event rate 3kHz (8kHz peak) 32MHz
Output bandwidth 100 GByte/sec 100 GByte/sec
Rejection none 99.7%
CMS Trigger+DAQ in Pb+Pb vs p+pCMS Trigger+DAQ in Pb+Pb vs p+p
Level 1 trigger- Uses custom hardware- Muon tracks + calorimeter information- Decision after ~ 3μsec
High level Trigger- ~1500 Linux servers (~10k CPU cores) - Full event information available- Runs “offline” algorithms
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 38
Trigger/DAQ ArchitectureTrigger/DAQ Architecture
Standard rack serversDual CPU - dual core2008/09: quad/8 core
~1500 “Filter Unit” servers~12000 1.8GHz Opteron equivalent
8 “DAQ slices”modular
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 39
High Level Trigger SimulationsHigh Level Trigger Simulations
Production
X-sections
Luminosity Ncoll Acc(y,pT) Eff(y,pT)
Acceptance, BR Efficiency
1 + Bkg/Sig(y,pT)
Trigger Table x
DAQ rateSignal rate
d2/dydpT
Trigger rate(signal + bkg)Rate to tape
Productionrate
Acceptance, efficiency, backgroundsmeasured and parametrized from full offline simulation + algorithms
Output Rates to tape
Timing of offline algorithms and event sizebias measured on full simulations
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 40
Minimum bias vs HLTMinimum bias vs HLT
Rates to tape
Significance(106 sec @ design lumi)
HLT CPU time Budget ~ 8 CPUsecper event(1.8GHz Opteron)
Strawman triggertable for design lumi
with HLT
Min bias
with HLT
Min bias
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 41
Activities of HI physicistsActivities of HI physicistsExploration of the capabilities of CMS as a heavy ion detector and preparations for data taking
Development of analysis tools and reconstruction algorithms
Development of generators Reconstruction algorithms
Development of trigger algorithms HLT Farm operations Trigger algorithms
Simulation studies Studies of detector behavior in HI collisions
Design and construction of “HI motivated” detectors
Zero Degree Calorimeter CASTOR
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 42
Heavy Ion Physicists within CMS CollaborationHeavy Ion Physicists within CMS Collaboration
Overall CMS Collaboration 38 Countries, 181 Institutions, ~2500 Scientists
Heavy Ion Institutions Athens, Auckland, Budapest, CERN, Chongbuk,
Colorado, Cukurova, Ioannina, Iowa, Kansas, Korea, Lisbon, Los Alamos, Lyon, Maryland, Minnesota, MIT, Moscow, Mumbai, Seoul, Vanderbilt, UC Davis, UI Chicago, Vilnius, Zagreb
Total of about 65 PhDs, 35 Students, 50% from the US
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 43
Physics PlanPhysics Plan Comprehensive heavy ion physics program with emphasis on hard probes Program follows increasing luminosity
Continuously extend pT range New probes Increase level of precision and detail Tighten and optimize trigger
Pb+Pb for the first few years, expect other ions and p+Pb later, in close coordination with ALICE
Detailed studies of rare channels
Extensive studies of rare channels, centrality, event plane dependence of quarkonia, tagged jets, heavy quarks
Detailed jet fragmentation studies, multi-jets, quarkonia physics, first tagged jet studies, detailed open b,c studies
Centrality and event plane dependence of global obs., charged particle spectra to 200 GeV, multi-100 GeV jets, open b,c, first quarkonia
Reference p+p, global observables, jets ET<200 GeV, charged particle spectra, first dimuon events,
Preparations: HLT, Reconstruction, first p+p physics at low energy
Physics (known physics)
55k2013
35k2012
15k2011
3k2010
0.3 k2009
02008
Total on tape
Calendar Year
October 25, 2007 Los Alamos Bolek Wyslouch 44
ConclusionsConclusions
LHC will extend energy range and in particular high pT reach of heavy-ion physics
CMS is preparing to take advantage of its capabilities Excellent rapidity and azimuthal coverage and high resolution
Quarkonia Jets
Centrality, Multiplicity, Energy Flow reaching very low pT
Essentially no modification to the detector hardware New High Level Trigger algorithms specific for A+A Zero Degree Calorimeter, CASTOR and TOTEM will be important
additions extending forward coverage Heavy-Ion program is well integrated into the overall CMS
Physics Program The knowledge gained at RHIC will be extended to the
new energy domain