Herscha Wind Energy Project
Phase 2
Road Construction and Transportation
February 2013
Project Design
Richard Gauld BSc(Hons)
IEng MInstMC Dip. DesInn Dip. GeoSci
Orkney Sustainable Energy Ltd
6 North End Road
Stromness
Orkney KW16 3AG
Telephone 01856 850054
Facsimile 01856 851239
Email [email protected]
Richard Gauld is a professional design engineer, a Member of the Institute of Measurement and Control and is registered as an Incorporated
Engineer with the Engineering Council of Great Britain.
Orkney Sustainable Energy Document OSE/3551 Chapter 5 24 February 2013
2
1 Summary
1.1 A locally-owned wind project is located on farmland between the communities of
Auchenblae and Glenbervie, to the south of Stonehaven in Kincardineshire. The project
extends the development by adding a further two medium sized wind turbines and an
upgraded access track.
1.2 The site and route of the access track have been subject to assessment, with ground
conditions noted and mapped. The project layout and access routes have evolved over
the assessment period, and as the project has been designed to have minimum ecological
impact, care has been taken to avoid areas of sensitive habitat.
1.3 Construction stone, concrete and all turbine components will be delivered to the
Herscha site along public roads. The turbine components will likely be delivered by sea
from the German factory to Peterhead then delivered by extended trailer along the A90
through Aberdeen then south past Portlethen and Stonehaven to Fordoun. Note that this
route was used for the first turbine delivery; no further road engineering works will be
necessary. Analysis of the transportation route identified difficulty with the right turn off
the A90 at Fordoun, and at Auchenblae, where vehicles will travel through the village.
1.4 Construction stone and concrete will come from existing Aberdeenshire quarries, and
the stone transport vehicles will access the site from the north of Newlands Farm,
largely avoiding the village of Auchenblae. A nearby sand and gravel quarry has been
identified and was used to provide roads and hardstandings for the first phase of the
development.
1.5 Assessment of the volume of materials required, the total weights and traffic numbers
has been calculated, and a method statement of the track, foundation and hardstanding
construction has been completed. Carbon balance calculations have been completed,
comparing the volume of carbon emissions from concrete production and the possible
loss of carbon from displaced soil during the road construction programme, against the
carbon dioxide emission avoidance of renewable energy production from the wind
turbines.
1.6 This report has been broken down into three parts; track and foundation construction,
analysis of the public road network for delivery and transportation of turbine
components and possible environmental risks are considered for all aspects of the
construction process, with mitigation considered where required.
Orkney Sustainable Energy Document OSE/3551 Chapter 5 24 February 2013
3
2 Track, Foundation and Hardstanding construction
2.1 The site is at Newlands Farm, on Herscha Hill, north of the community of Auchenblae,
to the south of Stonehaven. The project will consist of two further 80m high wind
turbines and an access track. The turbine location has been established following
detailed environmental assessment, and is an area which is least sensitive in ecological
and social terms. The location is well drained, mature, managed farmland, with an
existing track established for the first project.
2.2 The substation is located next to the existing turbine, north of the farm buildings and
near to the existing line of underground cables. The new turbine access track will be
levelled and made 4m wide to accommodate the large delivery vehicles, and the general
construction technique will be to remove vegetation then create a 4m wide track by
filling with as-dug stone then laying 10cm of Type 1 sub base stone, rollered flat.
2.3 The hardstanding areas will have a layered construction; geotextile will be placed on the
rocky sub-surface, with as-dug crushed rock aggregate placed on top of the geotextile,
followed by a sub-base layer. To mitigate any surface run-off problems the new track
will only be constructed in dry conditions. Construction will follow the general SUDS
guidelines published by SEPA, with a porous construction and a free-draining sub
layer[1]. The access track will have filter strips at the edges to ensure that any run-off
water is routed to the upper layers of the adjacent soil.
2.4 All soil extracted during excavation work will be used to in-fill depressions in existing
fields, and to create bunds and soak-away barriers. Turbine foundations and
hardstandings will be created, consisting of a layer of free-draining crushed stone 30m x
20m, with a nominal excavation of 10m by 10m for the foundations.
2.5 The total volume of concrete required for the foundations will be 100m3 for each site,
and the stone requirement will be approximately 900m3
for the track and hardstanding.
The requirement for the track will vary according to ground conditions; however the
maximum predicted quantities are as follows, table 1. It has further been presumed that
all of this stone shall be brought into the area, but it is likely that there will be
opportunities to recover rocky glacial till and a proportion of fractured rock during roads
and foundation excavation.
Orkney Sustainable Energy Document OSE/3551 Chapter 5 24 February 2013
4
Section Sub-base Bottoming
Access track 800m x 4m x 100mm; 320m3 -
Hardstanding 2(30m x 20m x 100mm); 120m3 2(30m x 20m x 400mm); 480m
3
Corner widening Approx 10m x 10m x 100mm; 103
Totals 450 m3,
or 900T 480 m3 or 960T
Table 1; Maximum predicted stone quantities
2.6 It is intended that as before a local quarry will be used to source the stone. The
estimated volume of stone required from Table 1 is 930m3, and although stone will be
produced during the levelling and excavation of the road and foundations, this
represents the maximum volume that could be delivered to site. Allowing for medium
size vehicles with 28T per load, this is equivalent to 66 loads for all construction work.
2.7 Concrete will be delivered to site as drybatch, to be mixed with water at the foundation
hardstanding. Each turbine location will require 100 m3 of concrete, with a limit of 8m
3
per load. The concrete mixer will carry water, with no need for local abstraction. This
volume of concrete is equivalent to 12.5 loads, although in practice it may be more
appropriate to deliver larger batches to the area. This will depend upon which civil
contractor is finally chosen for the project.
2.8 Summary construction method statement:
a. Remove any vegetation on the existing track verges, widen to 4m and fill tracks
with 100mm of sub-base stone.
b. Used crushed stone to provide hard standing, graded to match existing slopes.
c. Site office, mess, toilets and any materials storage to be sited on permanent hard
standing at the existing turbine.
d. Any soil extracted during the construction of the tracks and hard standings should
be stored on dry ground prior to distribution around the farm.
e. No bridges, culverts or other water crossings are required.
f. The turbine hardstanding is to be constructed with crushed rock from suitable
excavated foundation material, with sub-base and bottoming layers of quarried
stone as required.
g. Excavate soil and sub-surface rock till then cast foundation block on hard strata
and bedrock.
h. Roadways and hardstanding are to be unsurfaced and porous with adjacent bunds
and filter strips; active drainage is not required.
i. Reinstatement of site track; no side slopes, tracks to be flush with existing ground.
j. Topsoil fill - finished to merge with existing slopes and reseeded to match
adjacent land. Use extracted soil to fill land depressions on the farm.
Orkney Sustainable Energy Document OSE/3551 Chapter 5 24 February 2013
5
3 Access Route
3.1 The route to the site has been considered taking into account the transport requirements
of an Enercon E48 wind turbine, and analysis of the main route between Peterhead
Harbour and the site has been undertaken.
3.2 The Road Vehicles (Authorisation of Special Types)(General) Order 2003 – (STGO).
STGO permits certain types of vehicles to be used on roads notwithstanding that they do
not fully comply with the requirements that generally apply to vehicles permitted on
roads.
3.3 The Construction and Use Regulations 1986 (C&U) apply to loads which are wide or
long but not heavy. Vehicle and load lengths can be up to 27.4m long and weigh a
maximum of 44T under C&U, up to 30m under STGO and vehicles or loads in excess
of 30m require a Special Order. Widths above 2.9m and less than 4.3m are permitted
under C&U, widths between 4.3m and 5.0m are permitted under STGO and widths
between 5.0m and 6.1m require a Highways Agency Special Order [2].
3.4 The Enercon E48 turbine has a 24m long blade, while the largest tower section is less
than 30m long, and no wider than 4m. Maximum weight is 30T for the bottom tower
section, 47T for the nacelle, and the blades and hub together weigh a total of 30T.
3.5 The dimensions of the Enercon E48 turbine are within the requirements of the
Construction and Use Regulations; a Highways Agency Special Order is not necessary.
The turbine components are Abnormal Indivisible Loads as defined under STGO, and
accordingly a BE16 permit from the Scottish Executive will be required.
3.6 The turbine components will be delivered by sea from the Enercon factory in Germany
then transported by extended trailer along the A90 from Peterhead Harbour, on to the
A90 before travelling through Aberdeen then south past Stonehaven to the Auchenblae
area. The manufacturer is experienced in transportation of their wind turbines, and do
not foresee any difficulties in the transportation of the turbine components from
Peterhead to Auchenblae; the route was used to deliver the first turbine.
Orkney Sustainable Energy Document OSE/3551 Chapter 5 24 February 2013
6
3.7 Analysis of the transportation route has identified the following potentially difficult
locations:
a. The right turn at the Fordoun junction off the A90. Although this is a dual
carriageway, traffic travelling northwards should be halted by police before the
long vehicles traverse the carriageway;
b. Auchenblae, where all delivery vehicles will have to travel through the village.
It would be prudent to have the road cleared of any parked vehicles on
narrower stretches and bends to reduce collision risk;
c. The farm entrance after Burnmouth Bridge to the north of Auchenblae, where
road widening has already been completed at Newlands farm to allow access
for long transport vehicles to make a left turn to the farm.
3.8 The corners of the road junction off the minor road north of Auchenblae shall require
temporary modification to allow access to the longer loads. This will entail laying down
sub-base stone over an area around 5m back from corner of the junctions at a radius of
30m, and the temporary removal of any fencings. This stone could be removed after
construction, however it may be prudent to leave in place in the event of future blade
replacement or refurbishment.
3.9 The access route for all components follows the main A90 from Peterhead Harbour
south through Aberdeen to Tullos, before re-joining the A90 southwards on the outskirts
of Aberdeen. The vehicles will then travel southwards along the A90, bypassing
Stonehaven then turning westwards at the Fordoun junction. The vehicles will skirt
around Fordoun, travelling over the main railway bridge to the north of the village,
before travelling westwards to Auchenblae, then through the village and onwards to
Burnmouth Bridge then Newlands Farm.
3.10 The site access follows the route through the farm to the existing turbine, with a new
track then travelling eastwards along the northern boundary of Newlands Farm,
connecting to the sites of the new turbines.
Orkney Sustainable Energy Document OSE/3551 Chapter 5 24 February 2013
7
4 Delivery of components
4.1 A transport route has been determined by travelling the route from Aberdeen Harbour to
the turbine site. With the exception of the above locations, there should be no difficulty
in transporting components of an Enercon wind turbine along the public roads.
4.2 There will be five large loads per turbine, consisting of a bottom tower section,
approximately 30m by 4m diameter, a narrower upper tower section 19m long, a nacelle
which weighs 47T, a set of blades 25m long, 4m high and 2m wide and a load
consisting of the hub and internal fittings. In addition a crane will be required for the
final assembly, which is delivered as a permitted load under C&U regulations.
4.3 In addition there will be transformers delivered to site, along with high voltage
switchgear and cabling. The detailed turbine construction programme will be issued at
the time of construction, but can be summarised as follows. Cranes will be needed to
offload from the transporters and to lift and assemble the components, and a large 350T
telescopic crane will be required for assembly:
1 Deliver and install the transformers onto the foundations.
2 Erect the lower tower sections directly off the trailer onto the foundation;
3 Deliver the upper tower sections and nacelles to the site;
4 Erect the upper tower section and nacelle;
5 Deliver sets of blades to the site and assemble on a hub into a rotor;
6 Install the rotor assemblies.
4.4 The delivery of long loads through Auchenblae has the greatest potential for disruption,
with traffic management required. The first turbine was delivered at Midday, when the
village is at its quietest; there was little in the way of disruption. Although there are
alternative routes for other vehicles, the most appropriate time to deliver these
components through Auchenblae was found to be during the daytime and midweek,
when the roads are at their quietest. Before any wind turbine components are
transported to site, the project owners and designers will consult with Aberdeenshire
Council Roads Department and the Police to ensure acceptability of the route to site.
Existing public road culverts, bridges, verges and street furniture will be surveyed by the
project developers in conjunction with the Roads Department. A schedule of loads and
a timetable will be prepared and circulated prior to delivery.
Orkney Sustainable Energy Document OSE/3551 Chapter 5 24 February 2013
8
5 Environmental impact and mitigation
5.1 A carbon balance calculation has been completed, based on recommendations from the
Carbon Trust. It should be noted that carbon loss was considered when examining the
soils, and CO2 emissions were considered when examining concrete manufacture.
5.2 The maximum volume of topsoil that could be disturbed is approximately 180m3,
consisting of an 800m long track widening by 1.5m and a hardstanding 20m x 30m, a
total area of 1,800m2 of construction work at an average depth of 0.1m. The carbon
content of soils has been discussed by Chapman et al[3] and for the Herscha assessment a
figure of 0.069 tonnes of carbon per cubic metre of soil has been used; the carbon
content of the soil is estimated to be 12T.
5.3 The carbon emission factor of grid electricity is 0.117 T/MWh [4] and assuming a mean
windspeed of 7.8m/s, two Enercon E48 wind turbines will produce an annual energy
yield of approximately 3600 MWh at a capacity factor of 31%. An average production
of 10 MWh per day gives a positive carbon balance of 1.2 T per day, assuming a
mixture of conventional generation is displaced; 11 days of generation are required to
compensate for the potential carbon released from the soil. It should be noted that the
construction process will endeavour to retain the integrity of the soil systems to avoid
release of carbon, and all soil will be reused in other parts of the farm.
5.4 It is recognised that concrete production results in the emission of CO2 from both the
energy required and from the calcining of limestone when producing cement. A cubic
metre of concrete is made from 2T of aggregate and 450kg of cement and the project
will require approximately 200m3 of concrete. 200 m
3 of concrete requires 90T of
cement, and assuming 0.75T of CO2 per tonne for the energy requirement, and 0.5T of
CO2 per tonne from the calcining of limestone[5], the total CO2 emissions during
concrete manufacture for the project is 110 T. Using a CO2 avoidance factor of 0.43T
CO2/MWh, the wind turbines provides a positive CO2 balance of 4T per day; 26 days of
generation are required to compensate for the carbon dioxide released during concrete
manufacture.
5.5 The construction activities during mobilisation and installation of the turbines represent
a pollution risk. This may be through operational discharges or as the result of an
unplanned or accidental event. Measures will be taken to protect against the release of
any material with the potential to leach into the soil or water courses.
Orkney Sustainable Energy Document OSE/3551 Chapter 5 24 February 2013
9
5.6 The construction of the access track and the area of hardstanding have a potential
pollution risk, and SEPA’s Pollution Prevention Guidelines PPG1, PPG5, PPG6, PPG8
and PPG21 have been adopted by the project[6]: To combat the potential risk of run-off
from these areas, it is proposed that some of the mechanisms used to construct
Sustainable Urban Drainage systems be adopted, using of a permeable surface on the
access track to allow water to pass through the upper layer, along with filter strips and
bunds of vegetated soil to providing filtering and flow attenuation of water run-off.
5.7 The construction of the wind turbine foundations involves pouring fresh concrete, and
has the greatest risk of pollution impact. The nearest watercourse is around 900m from a
turbine location, reducing the risk of pollution run-off and it is proposed that all
concrete be brought onto site in a dry batch form to minimise the risk of spills.
Cleaning of shutters and the washing of equipment will only be done away from site.
To minimise risk of pollution from oils and fuels during project construction, all work
will be to COSHH regulations[7] and any machinery, equipment or construction material
will be located on areas of hardstanding away from water courses. Any waste will be
transported away from the work area and disposed of using standard waste handling
procedures.
5.8 Silt run-off both direct and indirect to watercourses can cause problems to burns and
rivers. Silt can access watercourses both by uncontrolled overland flow and directly by
percolation into field drains and rock fractures. It is proposed that the access track and
the hardstanding area will be graded and a grass swale or filter drain be installed at one
side to collect surface run-off. The surface run off from the filter drain will discharge to
permeable areas adjacent to the access from the public road, and will be controlled by
using a series of filter strips and soil bunds next to the access track.
5.9 Fuel or oil pollution from the construction vehicles would have a serious impact on
water quality should it enter any water courses, and accordingly fuels will be managed at
the farmyard, well away from any water courses, and good site management will be
established. Refuelling activities for construction vehicles and equipment will be
restricted to contained areas of hardstanding at the fuel storage area, and to minimise
the potential for contamination of land, any spills would be contained during fuel
transfer, and a store of absorbent material will be provided on site.
Orkney Sustainable Energy Document OSE/3551 Chapter 5 24 February 2013
10
References, web links and bibliography
1 SEPA recommendations on drainage systems in Scotland - Sustainable Urban Drainage
Systems (SUDS). http://www.sepa.org.uk/publications/leaflets/suds/?lang=_e
2 The Road Vehicles (Authorisation of Special Types)(General) Order 2003.
http://www.dft.gov.uk/stellent/groups/dft_rdsafety/documents/page/dft_rdsafety_023695-
01.hcsp
3 Chapman, S.J., Towers, W., Williams, B.L., Coull, M.C., Paterson, E. (2001) Review of the
Contribution to Climate Change of Organic Soils Under Different Land Uses. Scottish
Executive Central Research Unit.
4 The Carbon Trust. Guidelines on measuring carbon and CO2 emissions from electricity.
http://www.thecarbontrust.co.uk/carbontrust/low_carbon_tech/dlct2_1_6.html
5 Boden, T.A., G. Marland, R.J. Andres, (1995). Estimates of global, regional, and national
annual CO2 emissions from fossil-fuel burning, hydraulic cement production, and gas flaring:
1950-1992, Oak Ridge National Laboratory. Report ORNL/CDIAC-90, NDP-030/R6.
6 SEPA pollution prevention guidelines http://www.sepa.org.uk/guidance/ppg/
7 Control of Substances Hazardous to Health COSHH Regulations http://www.hse.gov.uk/coshh/
Orkney Sustainable Energy Document OSE/3551 Chapter 5 24 February 2013
11
Appendix 1
Transport Route Maps and Photographs
Stage 1:
Fordoun Junction
Transport route is the A90 from Peterhead
until the Fordoun turn off is reached, south
of Stonehaven. Turn right off the A90 then
veer around Fordoun, taking the minor road
over the railway bridge.
Traffic management may be required to
allow long vehicles turn off the A90.
Stage 2:
South Auchenblae
Travel northwards from Fordoun to
Auchenblae along the minor road. Continue
into the village, taking the route through the
High Street.
These roads are single carriageway and
traffic management will be required in the
village centre. Care is required to avoid
collision with buildings, walls and road
verges.
Herscha Wind Energy Project: Transportation Route Details.
30m radius
30m radius
Stage 3:
North Auchenblae
Travel along the High Street, on to
Inverurie Street then out of the village on
Glenfarquhar Road.
These roads are single carriageway and
traffic management will be required in the
village centre.
Stage 5:
Newlands
Follow improved access track to the west
of Newlands, travelling directly to the
turbine site.
Stage 4:
Burnmouth Bridge
Continue northwards out of Auchenblae,
cross Burnmouth Bridge then travel north-
eastwards towards Newlands Farm.
Junction widening has been completed at
the Newlands Farm site access.
Herscha Wind Energy Project: Transportation Route Details.
Herscha Wind Energy Project: Transportation Route Photographs
Stage 1A:
Fordoun Junction
Stage 1B:
Former Fordoun Lorry Park
Stage 1C:
Fordoun Railway Bridge