Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 1
Higgs Searches at the Tevatron (Run I)
• Introduction• SM Higgs
– ZH & WH with H bb (CDF & D)
• MSSM Higgs – bb with =H0,h0,A0 (CDF)– H+ (CDF & D)
• Fermiophobic Higgs – H CDF & D)
• Conclusions
Lorenzo MonetaUniversity of Geneva
on behalf of CDF and D collaboration
¯
¯
Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 2
Introduction
• Electroweak Symmetry breaking in the SM predicts existence of an Higgs boson but with unspecified mass– Higgs mass constraints scale where SM might break down
• if = MPlank then 130 < M(H) < 180
Current Status of Higgs searches • SM fit to Electroweak data indicates a light Higgs
– M(H) < ~ 200 GeV @ 95 % CL
• Direct searches from LEP2– 95 % CL limit is ~ 113 GeV– Indication of Higgs-like events in the last year data:
excess ~ 3 at M(H) 115 GeV
Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 3
Tevatron (Run I)
Run I (Oct. 92 Feb. 96)
total integrated luminosity~ 120-1 pb / detector
Tevatron proton-antiproton collision @ s = 1.8 TeV
Expected ~ 2 fb-1 in Run IIa !
Silicon Vertex Detector
CDF DØ
Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 4
tt
LEP
SM H0 production @ Tevatron
• Gluon Fusion
– too difficult (QCD background)• Higgsstrahlung
– SM cross section is very small • 1/20 (t-tbar) • 1/500 (Z/W + 2 jets)
– possible with Run II luminosity !– larger with new physics ??
for M(H) = 120 Gev/c2
with QCD NLO correction
• Vector Boson fusion• radiation off heavy quark
• very small in the SM
0Hgg
= 0.70 pb
ZH: = 0.10 pb
WH: = 0.16 pb
0VHqq
0Hqqqq 0Httqq
Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 5
• M(H) < 130 GeV– dominant decay is
– final states are for W/ZH
– need lepton ID/MET + b-tags
• M(H) > 130 GeV– dominant decay is
–
final state with 2 leptons
– but smaller cross-section •
interesting at RunII !
SM Higgs decays
LEP
bbH
bbbbbbbbqq , , ,
WWH
jjZWWWWWVHWWHgg
**
*
/ For M(H) = 120 GeV/c2
%7 )(%70 )(
HBR
bbHBR
Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 6
Tevatron Run I channels : (W/Z + H with M(H) < 130 GeV)
•
– BG: QCD multijets
•
– BG:
•
– BG: QCD,
•
– BG:
SM H signatures (W /Z + H)
bbqq
bb
bb
bb
tbqbtWZttbWb , , , ,
btZZttbZb , , ,
btZZttbZb , , ,Essential for these analyses:
• b tagging• good di-jet mass resolution
( 50% of W/Z H )
( 9% )
( 5.4%)
( 1.8%)
Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 7
b tagging at the Tevatron
Techniques developed for top analyses. Two algorithms: – Soft Lepton Tagging (SLT) (CDF & DØ)
• semileptonic b decays:
• DØ: ( pT > 4 GeV) CDF: & e (pT > 2 GeV)
– Secondary Vertex Tagging (SVX) (CDF)• reconstruct a displaced vertex in the jet • b lifetime ~ 1.5 ps decay length ~ few mm• use capability of Silicon vertex detectors
secondary vertexprimary vertex
b jet(b-tag) ~ 20%/b-jet(mistag) ~ 0.2%/jet
(decay-length) ~ 100 m
b e,µ (in jets)
(b-tag) ~ 7%/b-jet(mistag) ~ 0.5%/jet
%20 ),(
%20 ),(
BReXcb
BReXb
Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 8
bbWH 0 Search for
• Final states are lepton (e/) + MET + b’s• Event selection:
– high pTlepton: pT(lep) > 20 GeV & <1
– MET>20
– 2 jets with ET(j)>15, <2
– b-tags (single OR double jet tag)
• Backgrounds: –
Results (CDF & D) 106 pb-1
~ 0.2 – 0.3 %63 12 b-tagsCDF
~ 0.6 - 0.9 %2725 31 b-tagD
~ 0.6 – 0.8 %3630 51 b-tagCDF
Br x accept. (90<m(H)<130)
databackgchannelExp.
CDF
mbb
1 b-tag
2 b-tags
bbWH 0
tbqbtWZttbWb , , , ,
95% CL Limit on BR: 26-28 pb for 90<MH<130 (CDF)40-19 pb for 90<MH<120 (D)
from fit to di-jets mass:
Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 9
bbWH 0 Search for
• Final states is MET + b’s• Event selection (CDF):
– MET>40 (trigger >35) + lepton veto
– 2 or 3 jets with ET(j)>15, <2
– (MET,j) > 60° for all jets (ET>8)
– (j1,j2) < 150°
– b-tags (single OR double)
• Backgrounds: – QCD and
Results (88 pb-1)
bbZH 0
btZZttbZb , , ,
95% CL Limit on BR: ~ 8 pb for 90<MH<130 ~ 0.4 – 0.5 %44 12 b-tagsCDF
~ 0.5 – 0.8 %4039 41 b-tagCDF
Br x accept.(90<m(H)<130)
databackgchannelExp.
Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 10
bbWH 0 Search for
• Final states is di-leptons + b’s• Event selection (CDF):
– pT(lep)>20,10 GeV
– 76<M(l,l)<106 GeV
– 2 or 3 jets with ET(j)>15, <2
– MET < 50 GeV (against top di-lepton evts)
– 1 b-tag
• Backgrounds: –
Results (106 pb-1)
bbZH 0
btZZttqZqbZb , , , ,
~ 0.2 %53 11 b-tagCDF
Br x accept.(90<m(H)<130)
databackgchannelExp.95% CL Limit on BR: 56-24 pb for 90<MH<130
mbb
Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 11
bbWH 0 Search for
• Multi-jet final state with b’s• Event selection (CDF):
– Multi-jets trigger 4 jets with ET>125 GeV & ET>15
– double b-tag – pT(bb)>50 GeV
• Backgrounds: – mainly QCD (b’s + fakes) – also top and Z + jets
Results (91 pb-1)
bbqqHZW 0/
~ 1.5 – 2.9 %589~ 6002 b-tagCDF
Br x accept.(90<m(H)<130)
databack.channelExp.
Need good Mbb resolution against background 95% CL Limit on BR: 30-16 pb for 90<MH<130
mbb
¯
Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 12
Combined limit for SM Higgs
CDF combination of
95 % CL limit on
bbbbbbbbqq , , , )(),( 0 bbHBRZHWHpp
• x 30 SM cross-section (mH = 115)
• Limit is dominated by bb• Expected best limits from:
– bb and lbb• poor lbb limit due to a small
excess in observed events• Need more luminosity
– RUN II
limit = 7.4-8.2 pb for mH = 90-130 GeV/c2
LEP
SM
¯ ¯
¯
¯
115
Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 13
MSSM Higgs Search
Two Higgs doublets in the MSSM – 5 Higgs particles
• two neutral CP-even: h0,H0
• One neutral CP odd: A0
• Two charged: H+,H-
– two free parameters: tan and mA
– Mass relations at tree level:• m(h0) < m(Z0) < m(H0); m (A0) < m(H0); m(H+) < m(W) • but after radiative corrections m(h0) < 130 GeV
– Couplings at large tan• enhanced to d-type quark and leptons • suppressed to u-type quark
Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 14
In general dominant Higgs’s Branching Ratio are to bb (90%) and (10%)
MSSM Higgs production
• Small tan– SM-like cross-sections
• Large tan– enhanced hbb coupling– hbb/Hbb/Abb can have
large cross-sections ( tan
tan = 3 tan = 30
p
b
p
b
h H
¯
hH
¯¯¯¯
Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 15
Search for
• Exploit enhanced Yukawa couplings looking for bb production ( = h,HA)
• large cross sections ( tan • 4-b’s jets final state • Event selection (CDF):
– Multi-jets trigger
• 4 jets with (ET)>125 GeV & ET>15
– ET(j) cuts depending on m() 3 b-tags – (bb) > 109° (against gbb)
• Backgrounds: – QCD (bb/cc), Z/Wjj, top
bbbbbbpp
0.28 % 23.5 1.10.28 %120
0.59 % 00.1 0.40.59 %300
0.16 %54.6 1.4 0.16 %70
Br x accept. databackgBR x acc. M() (GeV)
CDF results (91 pb-1)
¯
¯
¯
Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 16
Limit for
• Limit (95%CL for M = 100 GeV):• convert BR limit in tan vs Higgs mass
exclusion – No mixing & Maximal Mixing for the stop
bbbbAHhbbpp )//(
Tevatron complements LEP !
BR < 25.7 pb
tan vs m(h) tan vs m(A)
Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 17
Charged Higgs Searches
• Searches for t H+b when M(H+) < mt - mb
• decay t H+b can compete with SM decay t W+b• BR(t H+b) depends on tan
Direct Search (CDF): • look for H+ in t-tbar evts
– BR(H+ 1 for large tan– WHbb or HHbb channels in addition to WWbb – look for l + + MET + jj events (l = e,,)– use identifications via hadronic decays
(tracking + calorimeter) – backgrounds:
• Z + jj, W+3 jets, WW/WZ– acceptances for single and double H
production
Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 18
Charged Higgs Searches
Indirect Search (CDF + D) • look for lepton disappearance in t-tbar events
• suppression of dileptons and lepton + jets events • rate of the two depends on BR(t H+b) • t-tbar cross-section independent of m(H), tan• given measured x-section (when BR(t H+b) = 0)
exclusion regions in the m(H+)-tanplane
New Exclusion regions at low and high tan
LEP2 (ADLO)
D0
Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 19
Fermiophobic Higgs
• In some models Higgs couples only to vector bosons• BR(H ) dominant for light Higgs (m(H) < 100)
• Searches for W/Z + H jj– D search:
• di-photons + jets• Backgrounds from QCD
– fakes or real in jets
– CDF search • di-photons with e/ + MET or jj
• Limit For SM cross-section: M(H) > ~ 80 GeV (95% CL)
• LEP limit is ~ 105 GeV
D0
Lorenzo Moneta Moriond QCD 17-23 March 2001 20
Conclusions
• SM Higgs searches are luminosity limited in Run I – no sensitivity to SM cross sections– no excess seen and set limits at ~30 SM cross-section – provided experience for Run II – developed techniques for low mass Higgs searches
• b tagging and di-jet mass resolution are crucial !
– good expectations for Run II see next talk on Run II prospects
• Nice exclusion results for MSSM Higgs: – bb search with sensitivity for high tan region– charged Higgs from t H+b
– probed regions inaccessible to LEP– very interesting in Run II
report of the Tevatron Higgs Working Group (hep-ph/0010338)